PROJECT: TCGRE WORLD TRADE CENTRE, GURUGRAM, RETAIL BLOCK

COMPARISION OF HVAC SYSTEMS

# Description Unit VRF system Air cooled Split AC system

package units ( Ductable)

Total Air-conditioned area Sqft 6930 6930 6930

Calculated Refrigeration load TR 56 56 56
Dehumidefied Air Qty. CFM 26500 28000 28000
Proposed installed capacity TR 73 TR 70 TR 70 TR
based on dehumidefied air qty.
1.1 Input power (@ 100% load) kW/TR 1.15 1.3 1.3
1.2 Input power (NPLV) kW/TR 0.60 0.90 0.90
1.3 chilled water pumps kW/TR
1.4 Condenser water pump + cooling kW/TR
tower
1.6 Air side power requirement kW/TR Included Included Included
1.7 Total sub-system input power kW/TR 1.15 1.30 1.30
index (@ 100% load)

1.8 Total sub-system input power kW/TR 0.60 0.90 0.90

index (NPLV)
1.9 Total installed capacity TR 73 70 70

2.0 Plant input power (@100% load) kW 83.95 91 91

2.1 Plant input power (NPLV) kW 43.8 63 63

Plant input power 83.95 91 91

1.13 Input kVA kVA 104.9375 113.75 113.75

1.14 DG capacity kVA 123 134 134

A Capital investments

A-9 TOTAL Capital Investment (HVAC) Rs

(Up to AHU) 35,04,000.00 24,50,000.00 21,00,000.00
A-10 DG sets (@7500/kVA) Rs
9,25,919.12 10,03,676.47 10,03,676.47
A-11 Substation cost (@2750/kVA) Rs
2,88,578.13 3,12,812.50 3,12,812.50
A-12 Deposit to SEB (@Rs 3000/kVA) Rs
3,14,812.50 3,41,250.00 3,41,250.00
A-13 Tentative total capital
investments 50,33,309.7 41,07,738.97 37,57,738.97
4

MVAC CONSULTING ENGINEER: DEW POINT SERVICES CONSULTANTS LLP

AN ISO 9001-2008 CERTIFIED COMPANY
 PROJECT: TCGRE WORLD TRADE CENTRE, GURUGRAM, RETAIL BLOCK
COMPARISION OF HVAC SYSTEMS

B Operating cost

B-1 Power:

B-1.1 10 Hrs/day * 300 days /year @Rs Rs

10.00/kWH 13,14,000.00 18,90,000.00 18,90,000.00
B-2 Cooling water make-up Ltr/Hr

B-2.1 Water consumption per yr. Ltr/year

B-2.2 Cost / year .@ 10 paisa / ltr Rs

B-2.3 Total cost of water /year Rs

Total operating cost

13,14,000.0 18,90,000.00 18,90,000.00
0

Summary
C Total capital cost
50,33,309.7 41,07,738.97 37,57,738.97
4
D Annual Mintenance cost
(Tentative) @ 3.5% of HVAC 1,22,640.00 85,750.00 73,500.00
capital cost
E Total operating cost
14,36,640.0 19,75,750.00 19,63,500.00
0
F Conclusions
F-1 Difference in investment on Rs
baseline considered (VRF system) (9,25,570.77) (12,75,570.77)
F-2 Difference in operating cost over Rs/Yr
base-line considered (VRF 5,39,110.00 5,26,860.00
system)
F-3 ROI with respect to air cooled Approx.2.0
package unit Yr

F-4 ROI with respect to air cooled Approx 2.5

split AC unit Yr
Note: Assumption and exclusion

1 This analysis has been done for the feasibility of the systems considered, and in no way is the
indication of the total capital cost involved for the total HVAC services. Cost for ventilation
system, HRW unit for freh air, IAQ and air distribution etc. are not considered
2 Includes customs duty

MVAC CONSULTING ENGINEER: DEW POINT SERVICES CONSULTANTS LLP

AN ISO 9001-2008 CERTIFIED COMPANY
 PROJECT: TCGRE WORLD TRADE CENTRE, GURUGRAM, RETAIL BLOCK
COMPARISION OF HVAC SYSTEMS

MVAC CONSULTING ENGINEER: DEW POINT SERVICES CONSULTANTS LLP

AN ISO 9001-2008 CERTIFIED COMPANY
 PROJECT: TCGRE WORLD TRADE CENTRE, GURUGRAM, RETAIL BLOCK
COMPARISION OF HVAC SYSTEMS

Air cooled package Split AC units

# Desciption VRF
unit (Ductable)

All ceiling suspended / Hi-

Floor space on 2 # 3.5 x 2.5 m room All ceiling suspended
1 Wall / Cassette type unit
each floor required on each floor type unit shall be used
shall be used

Noise related
2 Less Less More
issues

Large no. of access door Floor mounted unit

Large no. of access
Access door in required in false ceiling if shall be used. No
3 door required in false
false ceiling ceiling suspended units acces door reqd. in
ceiling
installed false ceiling

4 Winter Heating Heating & Cooling Separately Required Separately Required

5 Compressors Inverter Type Scroll Fixed Scroll Fixed Scroll / Rotary

VFD on Outdoor
6 Yes No No
Fan Motor

MVAC CONSULTING ENGINEER: DEW POINT SERVICES CONSULTANTS LLP

AN ISO 9001-2008 CERTIFIED COMPANY