You are on page 1of 4

Page 283 Data-based question: Caenorhabditis Page 287 Data-based question: Mitotic index and

elegans development cancer survival rates


1. 1 → 2 → 4 → 8 → 16 → 32 → 64 → 128 → 256 → 1. Bar chart; percentage survival on y-axis with scale
512 → 1024 (almost enough) → 2048 (more than and legend; six groups on x-axis with clear labels;
enough); eleven synchronous divisions to produce grouped by tumour size or by mitotic index (two
enough cells. groups of three bars or three groups of two bars).
2. a) Not exactly synchronous; but there are 2. a) Negative relationship; the higher the mitotic
periods when many cells divide. index the lower the percentage survival.
b) Major division periods occur at about 93, b) Tumour growing faster; secondary tumours
118, 147 and 183 hours after fertilization; will also grow rapidly.
the intervals between these periods are 25, 3. Mitotic index is a better indicator; larger
29 and 36 hours so the intervals appear to be differences in survival percentage with variation
getting longer. in mitotic index than with tumour size.
3. a) Eight synchronous divisions would be 4. To check for secondary tumours; metastasis; to
needed to produce at least 182 cells. decide whether chemotherapy is needed.
b) If all cells had divided in each round of
division there would have been 256 cells; so Page 289 What is the consequence of tumour
not all cells have completed 8 divisions. cells moving?
4. 959 + 131 = 1090 cells. 1. Drug companies want to recoup the cost of
developing the treatment; new treatments are
Page 284 Data-based question: Aging and under patent so competition cannot drive down
telomere shortening the price; new treatments involve antibodies/
1. Telomeres become shorter with increasing age; proteins that are expensive to produce.
rate of decrease gets less over time. 2. Yes, because limits force drug companies to
2. Data in the graph supports the claim; telomeres restrict prices; limits make it possible for a
are shown to vary from more than 10 kb treatment to be made available to everyone/more
(kilobases) to fewer than 4 kb; length must be patients; money for health care is limited so
variable as it reduces during the lifetime and a without price limits for cancer therapy other
population consists of people at different stages in treatments will be restricted; cost-benefit
their life; graph shows that at any specific age analyses may show that the extra days/months of
there is a range in telomere length. life are not warranted if the costs of treatment are
3. Shorter/longer telomere at birth; faster/slower very high.
rate of decrease in telomere length per year; 3. Difficult to make it illegal to spend money on
variation in rates of cell division; possible enviro- relatives’ health care; doctors should give
nmental influence on the rate of cell division. guidance about whether the money will provide
4. a) Body growth; asexual reproduction/cloning; enough pain-free rewarding days of life to the
repair/replacement of damaged tissue; relative; perhaps not ethical for the very wealthy
growth of tumours. to monopolize resources/health care
b) Slower healing after injury; skin becoming professionals’ time if others then do not receive
thinner; slower/no body growth; slower hair adequate care; treatment providers should be
growth; slower/no asexual reproduction; regulated so to be prevented from making
slower growing tumours/cancer. promises of recovery that are not justified by
evidence.
Page 286 The mitotic index of a tumour
1. Five cells in mitosis. Page 290 What factors in the environment can
2. Upper left cell: telophase; cause normal body cells to change into tumour
middle left cell: telophase; cells?
middle centre cell: metaphase; 1. a) Nuclear bombs release radioactive fallout;
lower left cell: anaphase/telophase; beta particles/gamma rays; radiation causes
lower right cell: prophase. mutations; in oncogenes.
3. 171 cells in interphase (allow a wide range of b) Sun-beds emit UV radiation; UVA and UVB;
answers because accurate counting is difficult). causes mutations in skin cells; causes skin
4. (5/176) × 100%; = 2.8 cancer.

© Oxford University Press 2017


1
c) Chemical mutagens in cigarette smoke; more Page 297 What evidence established the cause of
than 30 chemicals shown to be mutagenic; infectious diseases?
cause chemical changes in DNA; cancer if 1. Take blood sample from an infected and an
mutations are in oncogenes. uninfected cow; view the blood samples under a
d) X-rays are high energy/ionizing radiation; microscope to confirm the presence of anthrax
cause mutations. bacteria in the sample from the infected but not
2. Depends on the risk of cancer that they cause; and from the uninfected cow; culture the pathogen in
any benefits their use brings; there are ethical a tube; inoculate a healthy mouse with anthrax
questions over whether it is right to prevent an bacteria from the culture; confirm that the mouse
individual from causing harm to themselves; develops the disease; take a blood sample from
additional issues arise in jurisdictions where the diseased mouse; view the blood samples
there is publicly funded health care. under a microscope to confirm the presence of
anthrax bacteria in the sample; culture the
Page 291 Data-based question: Global pathogen in a tube.
distribution of air pollution 2. Mice may not contract the disease because the
1. Highest pollution levels in India/China/Middle pathogens are not adapted to them/because the
East; high levels in cities; higher levels in develop- mice already have immunity; death might be
ing countries/lower levels in developed countries. caused by other factors from the disease they are
2. Positive correlation with levels of air pollution; infected with.
the higher the level of air pollution the higher the 3. Viral diseases because they cannot be cultured on
incidence of asthma/emphysema/lung cancer/ acellular media; genetic/degenerative/mental
respiratory diseases; not directly proportional diseases.
because other factors influence these diseases. 4. Differences between animals; in physiology/
3. Negative correlation; lower lichen biodiversity metabolism/anatomy/immune system; so
with higher lung cancer mortality. findings in the model animal may not apply to
4. Lung cancer isn’t caused by low lichen bio- other animal species.
diversity; lung cancer mortality is positively 5. Possibly unethical to inoculate a healthy
correlated with concentration of air pollutants; mouse/animal with a pathogen; causes
lichen biodiversity is negatively correlated with suffering/could kill a healthy animal.
concentration of air pollutants; so there is a
negative correlation between concentration of air Page 298 Data-based question: MMR and DTP
pollutants and lung cancer mortality. vaccines
5. They might previously have lived in an area with a 1. Children don’t like vaccinations so the fewer the
different concentration of the air pollutants that better; cheaper to do one vaccination than three
cause cancer; lung cancer takes a long time to separate ones; more likely that a child will be fully
develop and be diagnosed. vaccinated against the three diseases.
6. Other factors affect lung cancer mortality; other 2. Increased between 1990-91 and 92-93; remained
factors affect lichen biodiversity. high (from 92-93 to 96-97); decreased (after
1998); decreased steeply (after 2000).
Page 293 Determining relatedness between 3. Somewhere in the range of 1996-1999.
organisms 4. Incidence of autism increased; increased from 88
1. Differences in base sequence: to 90 and from 92 to 94; decreased from 90 to
Adoxophyes honmai to Diatraea saccharalis 41 91/94 to 95.
Adoxophyes honmai to Ostrinia furnacalis 6 5. Claim not supported by the data; MMR
Adoxophyes honmai to Ostrinia nubilalis 13 vaccination rate dropped from over 70% to nearly
Diatraea saccharalis to Ostrinia furnacalis 35 0% in 1992; yet there was a larger increase in
Diatraea saccharalis to Ostrinia nubilalis 38 diagnosis of autism after that time; no sign of
Ostrinia furnacalis to Ostrinia nubilalis 17 drop in autism even four years later.
So Diatraea honmai is most dissimilar in base 6. Number of cases was high and fluctuating before
sequence to the other three species; and is not the use of DTP; cases dropped from over 300 per
closely related to any of them; the other three 100,000 to below 50 after the introduction of the
species are closely related to each other; as they vaccine; cases rose when the vaccine uptake
have many similarities in base sequence. dropped from 81% to 31%; but cases decreased
2. Adoxophyes honmai and Ostrinia furnacalis are again when vaccine uptake rose back to 93%;
most similar; Adoxophyes honmai is more similar clear link between vaccine uptake and cases of
to both Ostrinia species despite them being in the whooping cough.
same genus.

© Oxford University Press 2017


2
Summative assessment: Causes of disease
1. a) i) Asbestosis/Minamata disease.
ii) Influenza/malaria/syphilis/Athlete’s foot.
iii) Obesity/anorexia nervosa.

2. a) Spherical.
b) About 50 nuclei visible; but some are concealed behind others so this is
an underestimate; overall estimate is about 60/ is 50 – 70; not very
reliable.
c) 1 → 2 → 4 → 8 → 16 → 32 → 64; so 64 cells are produced by six rounds of
division.
d) Mitosis.
e) More mitochondria.
f) Some cells would have no mitochondria; could not carry out aerobic
respiration; would have no/too little energy for cell processes; would die.

3. a) Reduced to 18% of the level in 1972 = 82% reduction.


b) Blood cholesterol decreased most.
c) More smoking in women but less in men.
d) i) Actual reductions greater than the predictions; reduction to about
18% compared with prediction of about 44% in both men and
women.
ii) Factors that influence the incidence of CHD other than smoking,
blood pressure and cholesterol had improved during the study
period; better treatment for CHD lowered its incidence.

4. a) The increased chance is 8.8 – 3.1 = 5.7 more deaths per 100,000.
b) i) Passive smoking; non-smokers inhale in smoke exhaled by
smokers; containing carcinogens/mutagens; in places where non-
smokers and smokers are together.
ii) Prevent air pollution caused by burning coal; ban diesel vehicles
from cities/eliminate NOX from air that humans breathe; remove
asbestos; wear face masks if there is a danger of inhaling silica/
rock dust/nickel/arsenic/cadmium; remove radon gas from
homes/buildings.
c) With slow doubling rate there is likely to be a longer time before a
tumour is discovered because of its effects; with slow doubling rate there
is more chance of discovering a tumour before it becomes large by
routine screening programs; with slow doubling rate there is less chance
of secondary tumours causing rapid death; with slow doubling rate there
is less chance of chemotherapy working (because a smaller proportion of
cells is in mitosis and therefore vulnerable to chemotherapy drugs).

5. a) 390 deaths per 1,000.


b) Overall decrease in child mortality in all countries; all countries reach
mortality below 50 by the end of the study period; mortality in Chile and
Bangladesh rises during the middle of the study period to a level higher
than at the start before falling again whereas it never rises above the
initial level in Australia or Azerbaijan; decrease in mortality starts earlier
in Australia.
c) Decreases are due to improvements in medicine; such as vaccinations;
and public health measures/clean water; and better nutrition; earlier
decrease in Australia because these measures were introduced sooner.
d) Answers will depend on when the database is consulted.

3 © Oxford University Press 2017


6. A wide range of answers could be given here. One possible sequence of
answers is:
a) Compare and contrast changes in the incidence of malaria in two different
geographic regions.
b) For example compare equatorial Africa with Southern Africa: Congo, CAF
and Gabon versus Zambia, Mozambique and Zimbabwe.
c)

d) Pattern is variable though the highest rates are seen in Southern Africa
from 1999; the rates are very high at 40,000/100,000 in Zambia.

7. a) i) A chemical substance or form of radiation that causes cancer to


develop.
ii) In the uterus/before a baby has been born.
iii) Division of cells to produce many.
b) Award marks on a scale from 0 for an article that is without merit
because it is misleading, inaccurate or incomprehensible up to 8 marks
for a succinct article that presents all the information needed to convince
pregnant women that they should not smoke, written in an engaging and
comprehensible style.
c) Avoid inhaling vehicle exhaust fumes/emissions from power
plants/fumes from industry; avoid inhaling fumes from
fires/stoves/heaters used in the home; avoid smoked/grilled food/ avoid
all sources of radiation.

© Oxford University Press 2017


4

You might also like