You are on page 1of 5

2023 10th IEEE International Conference on Power Systems (ICPS)

13-15 December, Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh

Empowering Remote Islands and Unlocking


Sustainable Energy: A Hybrid Off-Grid DC System
Approach
Ellin Ankon Dewan1, Ayon Datta2, Waiz Ibn Sufian3, Tajek Ahmed4, Taskin Jamal5
2023 10th IEEE International Conference on Power Systems (ICPS) | 979-8-3503-1873-9/23/$31.00 ©2023 IEEE | DOI: 10.1109/ICPS60393.2023.10428809

Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering


Ahsanullah University of Science and Technology, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Email- ellinankondewan@gmail.com, ayon2k15@gmail.com, waiz4321@gmail.com, tajek086@gmail.com,
taskinjamal@gmail.com

Abstract—The interconnectedness of energy consumption sustainable electricity solutions for remote islands. Renewable
and human progress is evident, but environmental challenges energy sources emerge as the optimal choice for sustainable
stemming from global energy production persist. Remote energy production. Their costs are declining due to ongoing
islands rely heavily on fossil fuel imports for power, yet green research and technological advancements. Many islands are
energy and decarbonization advances offer solutions. transitioning, either implementing or planning solar panel
Overcoming nature's unpredictability and weather dependence farms and wind turbines, to boost renewable energy shares
through the precise integration of renewables and converters is while eliminating non-renewable reliance progressively.
crucial. This study proposes a hybrid off-grid DC System for a Furthermore, certain islands necessitate substantial thermal
remote site called 'Fuerteventura' in Spain, incorporating PV
energy for various needs such as space heating, hot water, and
panels, wind turbines, converters, batteries, and diesel
generators, addressing both electric and thermal loads.
industrial purposes. This demand can be fulfilled through
Simulation outcomes reveal its adaptability to the site climates, Combined Heat and power (CHP) systems, proficiently
potentially elevating renewable use and curbing CO2 emissions generating both electricity and thermal energy using advanced
to achieve sustainable energy. technologies and fuels. This approach minimizes losses and
reuses waste energy, channeling it towards facility needs like
Keywords—Renewable Energy, HRES, CHP, Off-Grid process heating, steam, or chilled water [2].
System.
Established technologies exist for seamlessly blending
I. INTRODUCTION renewable energy sources with CHP [3]. Moreover, the
concept of DC mini-grids, explored for decades and deployed
Global energy demand is rising, driven by the constant in various places, aims to enhance efficiency by minimizing
addition of new loads. This necessitates increased energy losses through a direct current (DC) system. Conventional
production. Various energy sources exist worldwide, electricity relies on AC systems, while researchers have
including renewables and non-renewables. Non-renewables explored DC mini-grids for decades. DC appliances and
mainly comprise oil, natural gas, coal, and nuclear energy [1]. systems have shown the potential to curtail electricity
The fossil fuel category includes oil, natural gas, and coal, consumption and costs. However, no islands have fully
while renewable sources encompass solar, wind, hydro, integrated an off-grid DC system with Hybrid Renewable
geothermal, tidal, and biomass energy. Widely used, fossil Energy Systems (HRES) for CHP. Introducing DC appliances
fuel-based electricity generation is unsustainable and and off-grid HRES for combined heat and power can address
environmentally harmful due to carbonization and greenhouse multiple issues, minimizing appliance electricity usage,
gas emissions. Nuclear energy, with pros and cons, is costly, addressing waste in electricity and heat generation, and
generates hazardous waste, and is not entirely green. In establishing a sustainable green energy generation system.
contrast, renewables are infinite and sustainable, with Therefore, this study examines the comprehensive evaluation
decreasing costs and improving efficiency through ongoing of combined heat and power generation viability using a
research. hybrid off-grid DC system on Fuerteventura, a remote Spanish
Islands, especially remote ones, face isolation and access island. The study utilized the Hybrid Optimization Model for
challenges, making extending the national grid uneconomical. Electric Renewables (HOMER) tool.
Despite this, the electricity demand grows. Often reliant on This study employs a techno-economic approach to assess
diesel generators and fossil fuels, they face sustainability the feasibility of employing a hybrid off-grid DC system to
issues, including carbonization and GHG emissions, fulfill electrical and thermal requirements in remote island
worsening global warming and climate change. settings. The primary aim is to identify the optimal
Environmentally and economically, fossil fuel transport raises configuration of an off-grid DC system integrated with HRES
energy costs. Geopolitical tensions further destabilize fossil for the region. The research objectives encompass examining
fuel supply chains. Ultimately, power sector development off-grid DC systems, a comparative analysis of HRES
goes in vain if it cannot meet SDG 7. Renewable fraction is viability in distinct global climates, and determining the most
increasing on the mainland, but it is always a challenge for efficient hybrid renewable energy system design for
remote islands. respective sites, considering factors like cost of energy, net
Energy security is becoming a global concern in the future. present cost, and renewable fraction.
These challenges demand resolution, particularly in finding

979-8-3503-1873-9/23/$31.00 ©2023 IEEE

Authorized licensed use limited to: M S RAMAIAH INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY. Downloaded on March 27,2024 at 09:10:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
II. LITERATURE REVIEW B. The rationale of the DC system
A. Renewable Energy In Remote Areas Many modern appliances, ranging from light bulbs and
fans to devices like televisions, mobile phones, and
In this era of industrialization, the energy demand is computers, primarily consume direct current (DC). However,
expanding globally, with fossil fuels being the primary source the conventional power system delivers alternating current
of global warming and climate change. To combat (AC). As a result, these appliances require converters to
environmental crises, a relationship between public opinion transform AC power into DC, leading to energy losses during
and policy is needed [4]. Europe has led the world to this conversion process. The situation becomes even more
transition to renewables since the 1990s [5]. Until 2017, only pronounced when renewable energy sources are integrated
26.5% of energy was produced by renewable sources, with into the system. For instance, photovoltaic (PV) panels
the rest coming from fossil fuels [6]. Research shows an initially produce DC power, which is then inverted into AC
overall 41.5% increase in renewable energy consumption before being supplied to the grid. When a DC load consumes
from a decade ago. It has been found from energy structure this electricity, it needs to convert it back to DC to match its
scenarios of 41 countries where 25 of them had less than 1% required voltage level. This multiple-stage conversion
of renewables [7]. process results in significant energy losses within the system,
especially when renewable energies are involved. In response
Research has revealed promising opportunities for to these challenges, engineers have begun considering the
reshaping energy systems in South America, Sweden, implementation of DC mini-grids. This approach makes use
Norway, Mexico, Spain, and Denmark, utilizing wind, wave, of DC loads and advanced power electronics equipment
readily available in the market. A 2019 study highlighted the
and solar energy resources in some underutilized areas such
potential energy savings associated with reducing conversion
as the Black Sea, South America, and South Korea [8].
stages [17]. For example, lighting appliances like LEDs could
Researchers have indicated that despite economic potential achieve a 73% reduction in energy consumption by utilizing
for renewables on islands such as the Philippines, feasibility DC-inherent technologies. In residential settings, a 14%
is sometimes hampered due to storage issues [8]. Integration energy savings could be realized by minimizing conversion
of Renewable Energy Systems (RES) with the grid also losses, and this figure could rise to 33% if DC-inherent
shows some concerns regarding quality issues such as voltage technologies were adopted [17]. Additionally, this transition
and frequency fluctuation and harmonics [9]. could reduce capital costs as the need for numerous inverters
Research in 2018 discussed the renewable energy current is eliminated.
states in Pacific Island Countries (PIC). Pacific Island
countries consist of numerous small islands with small Three case studies were presented in a previous work
done in 2013. The first case study is of a data center that saved
populations. Fossil fuel import costs a high amount of money
around 10-15% of energy consumption after switching to a
for them. Among PIC countries, Fiji and PNG respectively 380VDC architecture which was previously 480VAC
produce 50% and 25% of their electricity with hydropower architecture [18]. The second case study was on a commercial
[10]. Another research studied the case of the Pico and Faial space in NY, USA, where energy savings were 20% [18]. The
islands of the Portuguese Azores. It demonstrated that third case study was on a residential building that used a
considering an independent power system, Pico can 400VDC distribution system. With a DC distribution system,
potentially reach 100% RE penetration, but Faial can not conversion losses were decreased by 5680 KWh [18].
reach beyond 70%. However, establishing an interconnection
between these two islands can potentially eliminate the use of III. METHODOLOGY
fossil fuels [11]. Numerous studies have explored HRES for Diesel Generators are the primary means of electricity
power generation on Asian islands, such as Maldives, production in remote areas. Nevertheless, they are costly to
Thailand, and Indonesia. Studies show that hybrid systems operate and maintain. These networks can profit economically
with diesel generators have lower performance compared to and dependably from the combinations of PV systems and
100% renewable systems [12], [13]. A study in 2022 diesel generators. Due to their unpredictable fluctuating
analyzed 97 papers that discussed 100% RE systems on character, PV outputs must be conducted in parallel with the
islands [9]. Their study reflects that 100% renewable energy diesel generators. Our structural analysis starts with the final
is techno-economically possible. This has been demonstrated aim of defining previous study analysis, system modeling,
for some tiny and large islands, referring to several previous performance evaluation, and optimization. Fig. 1 shows the
studies and their results. PV and wind power were common methodology of the study.
in most cases [9].
From Fig.1, technical analysis dealt with system
An EU project demonstrated the reliability and reliability generation and demand meetup, solar irradiance, wind speed,
of an off-grid hybrid DC system in remote households in and temperature statistics. Inflation rate, fuel price, equipment
Greece, integrating CHP [14]. Another demand-side price, etc., were considered for the non-technical analysis part.
management algorithm was proposed to control unrequired In Fuerteventura, the yearly average solar irradiation is 5.58
capital costs [15]. Besides, a Bangladesh study designed a kWh/m2 /day, and the annual average wind speed is 7.42 m/s.
hybrid system with solar, wind, and tidal resources, showing
feasibility for Swandip Island [16]. It has been found that for A basic HRES may consist of PV, wind turbine,
a whole island, a study comprising an off-grid DC system with hydropower, geothermal energy, diesel generator, battery, and
HRES for CHP generation was not explored much in existing other options. However, in this case, based on favorable
pieces of literature. climatic conditions and the availability of resources, only PV

Authorized licensed use limited to: M S RAMAIAH INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY. Downloaded on March 27,2024 at 09:10:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
and wind turbines were considered among renewable sources.
Since the DFIG generator converts the wind turbine output
into AC at a desired level, the converter is required to convert
the AC output of the wind turbine into DC power.

Fig. 2. Schematic of System Architecture

445.39 kW with the same load factor of 0.26 and peak


load of 1703.96 kW.
• Controller: Load Following controller technique has
been chosen for the best optimization.
Fig. 1. Methodology of study.
In addition, a summary of the technical data of each
An understandable summary of the available resources of module is given in Table I.
our HRES model, including their features, can be stated
below: TABLE I. SYSTEM PARAMETER VALUES OF THE SYSTEM
System Parameter Value
• PV Module: A solar system Schneider Conext CoreXC PV System
generic flat plate PV panel with 1 kW capacity was Capital cost 2850 $/kW [14]
used. Replacement Cost 2400 $/kW
O&M Cost 10 $/kW/year
• Wind Turbine: A Leitwind 86 wind turbine with an Lifetime 25 years
86.3m rotor diameter for a lifecycle of 20 years was Derating Factor 96%
Wind Turbine
used with a rated capacity of 1500kW. Capital Cost 1,300,000.00 $/MW [19]
Replacement Cost 154,000.00 $/MW
• Electric Load: The annual peak occurs in September, O&M Cost 15,000.00 $/MW/year
estimated at around 115,979.00 kW. The yearly Lifetime 20 years
average load is estimated to be around 76213.59 kW Hub Height 90 meter
with a load factor of 0.66. The whole demand of the Diesel Generator
Capital Cost 1200 $/kW [20]
island has been scaled down into 25 small community Replacement Cost 1200 $/kW
levels to represent a single community and understand O&M Cost 0.030 ($/op. hour)
its operations. Adding up each such community would Fuel Price 1.9 $/L
give the total load of the island. So, each suburb Minimum Runtime 30 min
Lifetime 15,000 hours
represents the yearly average load of around 3048.5 Converter
kW with the same load factor of 0.66 and peak load of Capital Cost 450 $/kW
4639.16 kW. Replacement Cost 450 $/kW
O&M Cost 15 $/kW/year
• Diesel Generator: For optimization purposes, the Lifecycle 10 years
diesel generator has been given the flexibility to be Battery
Capital Cost 150 $/unit
designed at an appropriate required rating to adjust Replacement Cost 100 $/unit
with supply and demand. O&M Cost 10 $/year
Lifecycle 15 years
• Battery: Battery has been included for two major Project Lifetime 25 years
purposes: (a) as an ancillary service and (b) support Nominal Discount Rate 10%
whenever needed as an energy storage. Our chosen Inflation Rate 6%
model, 'Generic 1kWh Li-Ion', comes with a nominal
IV. RESULT & ANALYSIS
voltage of 6V, a nominal capacity of 167Ah, and a
maximum capacity of 2.7kWh. This study included PV and wind turbines as primary power
sources while the battery would act as an ancillary service
• Thermal Load: Annual peak occurs during December, provider and hence supply when primary sources are
which amounts to 851.98 kW. The yearly average load insufficient, such as night time. To increase reliability, a diesel
is around 222.7 kW with a load factor of 0.26. The generator has been included in the study. However, as the
peak load is 851.98 kW. After scaling like Electric system includes CHP processes, a thermal load controller
load, it represents a yearly average load of around (TLC) has been included to convert the excess electricity into
thermal power. For appropriate optimization of the system,

Authorized licensed use limited to: M S RAMAIAH INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY. Downloaded on March 27,2024 at 09:10:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
upper limit and lower limit for various resources have been fill in the demand by supplying noticeably much higher power
considered in between 500 to 3,000 kW for PV, 1,500 to 7,500 than at other times of the year, where it mostly performed
kW for wind turbine, 0 to 25,000 for Li-ion battery, and 2,000 minimal operation. Figure 5(c) explains the case properly. The
to 20,000 kW for TLC. Generator and converter sizing has battery remains sufficient for most of the year except for the
been varied in such a way as to determine an appropriate final quarter when it fails to keep sufficient charge; hence, DG
required capacity. is required to supply for the remaining fraction of demand.
Figure 5(b) portrays the monthly thermal production where
TLC converts the excess electricity into thermal power and
contributes 80.9%, and the boiler performs the remaining.
Excess thermal production of 227% can be handled by
manually scheduling the boiler off.
Based on the simulation results, the most suitable
architecture identified for the system consists of a hybrid
renewable energy system with a diesel generator serving as a
a) backup power source. This configuration comprises 3,000 kW
of photovoltaic (PV) panels, 7,500 kW of wind turbines,
47,916 batteries, a 5,654 kW converter, an 8,000 kW
Transient Load Controller (TLC), and a 4,900 kW backup
diesel generator. This combination results in a system with a
Cost of Energy (COE) of $0.125.
The simulation indicates that an initial capital investment
of $32.3 million is required, with a Net Present Cost (NPC) of
$67.5 million. Despite operating costs of $2.2 million, the
b) system's high solar irradiance and strong wind speeds on

c)

Fig. 4. Solar Irradiance (Blue) & Wind Speed (Green) Profile

a)
d)
Fig. 3. Annual (a) PV Power Output, (b) Wind Turbine Power Output, (c)
Generator Power Output, (d) Boiler Power Output

There appear to be noticeable irregularities and


fluctuations in solar (Fig 3(a)) and wind power (Fig 3(b))
b)
output around the final quarter of the year. This is also evident
from Fig 4, which shows a decline in solar irradiance and wind
speed in this period. Consequentially, the battery cannot retain
high SOC (Fig 5(c)) during this time. Thus, the generator
increases its supply to meet the demand during this time (Fig
3(c)). Because less renewable power is produced in this
period, TLC gets less available excess electricity to convert
into thermal power. As a result, the boiler increased its output c)
during this time (Fig 3(d)).
Figure 5(a) shows the monthly electricity generation
where brown bars, orange bars, and green bars represent wind
power, solar power, and diesel generator supply, respectively.
According to the power production stats, 81.4% have been
produced by wind, whereas solar could contribute 15.7%, and
the rest (2.92%) have been supplied by the backup diesel
generator (DG). Since there appears to be reduced solar and Fig. 5. (a) Monthly Electric Power Generation, (b) Monthly Thermal Power
wind resources in winter, a diesel generator was required to Generation, (c) Battery SOC vs DG Output

Authorized licensed use limited to: M S RAMAIAH INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY. Downloaded on March 27,2024 at 09:10:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Fuerteventura enable it to generate 88.4% of its total power [4] A. Qazi, R. G. Raj, G. Hardaker and C. Standing, "A systematic
from renewable sources, making it a promising long-term literature review on opinion types and sentiment analysis techniques:
solution for the region. To further address the 26% excess Tasks and challenges," Emerald, vol. 27, no. 3, 2017.
electricity, future studies could focus on accurately identifying [5] L. Li, J. Lin, N. Wu, S. Xie, C. Meng, Y. Zheng, X. Wang and Y.
deferrable loads. Zhao, "Review and outlook on the international renewable energy
development," Energy and Built Environment, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 139-
From an economic perspective, the salvage value of the 157, 2022.
system remains at $4.75 million at the end of the 25th year. [6] A. Qazi, F. Hussain, N. A. Rahim, G. Hardaker and D. Alghazzawi,
Increasing the renewable fraction enhances the sustainability "Towards Sustainable Energy: A Systematic Review of Renewable
Energy Sources, Technologies, and Public Opinions," IEEE Access,
of this proposed HRES, significantly reducing fossil fuel vol. 7, pp. 63837 - 63851, 2022.
usage and CO2 emissions. The study indicates a daily fuel
[7] BP p.l.c., "Statistical Review of World Energy," 2020.
consumption of 1,642 liters, representing a remarkable 91%
reduction compared to using only a diesel generator for power [8] P. A. Østergaard, N. Duic, Y. Noorollahi, H. Mikulcic and S.
Kalogirou, "Sustainable development using renewable energy
supply. Similarly, establishing this HRES architecture can technology," Renewable Energy, vol. 146, pp. 2430-2437, 2020.
lead to a 91% reduction in CO2 emissions, contributing to a
[9] H. Meschede, P. Bertheau, S. Khalili and C. Breyer, "A review of
more environmentally friendly energy solution. 100% renewable energy scenarios on islands," WIREs Energy and
Environment, vol. 11, no. 6, 2022.
V. CONCLUSION
[10] T. Weir, "Renewable energy in the Pacific Islands: Its role and status,"
Extending the national grid to remote areas is often not Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 94, pp. 762-771,
cost-efficient and leads to power losses during conversion 2018.
stages. To address this challenge, renewable energy sources [11] M. Alves, R. Segurado and M. Costa, "On the road to 100% renewable
like wind and solar power offer a solution by reducing the energy systems in isolated islands," Energy, vol. 198, 2020.
need for centralized power generation and increasing the share [12] I. A. Aditya, S. Aisyah and A. A. Simaremare, "Optimal sizing and
of renewables. Additionally, utilizing a DC-based system sensitivity analysis of Hybrid Renewable Energy Systems: A case of
Ur island in Indonesia," IOP Conference Series: Materials Science
helps mitigate power conversion losses, thereby improving and Engineering, vol. 1098, 2021.
overall efficiency.
[13] M. S. H. Lipu, M. G. Hafiz, M. Ullah and A. Hossain, "Design
Fuerteventura, the second-largest of the Canary Islands Optimization and Sensitivity Analysis of Hybrid Renewable Energy
and a popular tourist destination in Spain, presents an Systems: A case of Saint Martin Island in Bangladesh," RENEWABLE
ENERGY RESEARCH, vol. 7, 2017.
opportunity for renewable energy integration. The optimized
[14] E. Kalamaras, M. Belekoukia, Z. Lin, B. Xu, H. Wang and J. Xuan,
solution suggests a combination of PV panels, wind turbines, "Techno-economic Assessment of a Hybrid Off-grid DC System for
batteries, and a diesel generator to meet the island’s combined Combined Heat and Power Generation in Remote Islands,"
heat and power (CHP) demand. This configuration yields a Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, vol. 158, pp.
promising renewable energy fraction of 88.4%, significantly 6315-6320, 2019.
increasing from the current 22%. Moreover, the Cost of [15] F. Akram, F. Asghar, M. A. Majeed, W. Amjad, M. O. Manzoor and
Energy (COE) is remarkably low at 0.125 $/kWh, marking a A. Munir, "Techno-economic optimization analysis of stand-alone
substantial improvement in environmental impact. By renewable energy system for remote areas," Sustainable Energy
Technologies and Assessments, vol. 38, 2020.
transitioning to renewable energy, CO2 emissions on
Fuerteventura could be reduced by an impressive 91%, [16] N. A. Khan, A. K. Sikder and S. S. Saha, "Optimal planning of off-
grid solar-wind-tidal hybrid energy system for sandwip island of
making significant strides toward sustainable energy Bangladesh," in 2nd International Conference on Green Energy and
production on a remote island. However, some simulation tool Technology, IEEE, Dhaka, Bangladesh, 2014.
limitations need addressing for more precise findings and [17] N. N. Opiyo, "A comparison of DC- versus AC-based minigrids for
improved system efficiency. For instance, user-specified cost-effective electrification of rural developing communities,"
scheduling of the boiler could enhance system performance. Energy Reports, vol. 5, pp. 398-408, 2019.
[18] B. R. Blasi, "DC microgrids: review and applications," K-State
Spain is a global leader in increasing sustainable energy Electronic Theses, Dissertations, and Reports, 2013.
production, and this study aligns perfectly with Sustainable
[19] D. Blewett, "Wind turbine cost: Worth the million-Dollar price in
Development Goal 7 (SDG 7). It offers a techno-economic 2022?," Weather Guard Lightning Tech, 2023. [Online]. Available:
analysis to reduce fossil fuel dependency. The proposed https://weatherguardwind.com/how-much-does-wind-turbine-cost-
design addresses all three outcome targets of SDG 7: ensuring worth-it/.
universal access to energy, increasing the share of renewable [20] S. M. Islam, S. A. Ferdous, A. M. S. R. Bhuyan and S. M. Sultana, "A
energy, and improving energy efficiency. Techno-Economic Investigation on Hydrogen Utilization as a Long-
term Energy Storage Solution for Microgrids," in 6th International
Conference on Development in Renewable Energy Technology
VI. REFERENCES (ICDRET), IEEE, Dhaka, Bangladesh, 2021.

[1] N. Geographic, "Nonrenewable Resources," 2022. [Online].


Available:
https://education.nationalgeographic.org/resource/nonrenewable-
resources/.
[2] "What Is CHP?," United States Environmental Protection Agency,
[Online]. Available: https://www.epa.gov/chp/what-chp. [Accessed
2023].
[3] M. A. Bagherian and K. Mehranzamir, "A comprehensive review on
renewable energy integration for combined heat and power
production," Energy Conversion and Management, vol. 224, 220.

Authorized licensed use limited to: M S RAMAIAH INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY. Downloaded on March 27,2024 at 09:10:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like