Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OPEN ACCESS articles distributed under Creative Commons Attribution University of Dar es Salaam
Licence [CC BY-ND] ISSN 1821-536X (print); ISSN 2619-8789 (electronic)
Websites: https://ajol.org/tjet; https://tjet.udsm.ac.tz https://doi.org/10.52339/tjet.v42i1.887
Special Issue – Seventh International Conference on Mechanical and Industrial Engineering (MIE) 2022
Conference, 20 – 21, October 2022, University of Dar es Salaam New Library, Dar es Salaam, TANZANIA
ABSTRACT
This paper presents the design and simulation of a hybrid ARTICLE INFO
renewable energy system utilizing solar and wind energy sources First submitted: June 29,
with a backup generator. The demand for reliable electric energy in 2022
support of investments in large social and economic development
activities such as airport operations has been an agenda worldwide. Revised: Sep. 29, 2022
In Tanzania, Mwanza International Airport (MIA) expects to
consume about 18 MVA of electric power annually to support its Presented: Oct. 21 - 22,
operations for the next 25 years. About 78-80% of the world's 2022
commercial energy comes from fossil fuels. Non-renewable fuels
and other negative effects contribute to global warming through Accepted: Dec. 27, 2022
greenhouse gas emissions and carbon dioxide emissions.
Additionally, most centralized conventional power generation Published: Feb. 25, 2023
methods require transmission systems, adding complexity and poor
power quality. Therefore, the proposal to use a mixed-coupled
hybrid renewable energy source to power the airport is necessary.
The energy mix considered is solar photovoltaic (PV), wind, diesel
generator and a battery. There is an average solar irradiation of
5.38 kWh/m2 and a wind speed average of 4.20 m/s that could be
converted to electricity by installing a 10-kW wind turbine (this is
enough to generate power for MIA). The diesel generator and the
battery designed at 140 kVA and 400 Ah, respectively, take the
intermittency. The project will be in operation for 25 years; hence
its costs are reasonable, and the justification is the potentiality of
harvesting that estimated energy output of 18 MVA, which will meet
the load for MIA. Some mathematical computations were
performed, and, in the end, simulation results displayed different
techno-economic Hybrid Renewable Energy Source (HRSE)
configurations. The selected system's complete design would include
a 78.48 kW PV system comprising 314 pieces of 200 W poly-
crystalline modules, 608 batteries of 83.4 Ah, 12 V rating, 140 kVA
diesel generator, and 41.64 kVA bidirectional converter. The net
present cost of the selected design is US$357,780.8, the energy cost
is 0.93US$/kW, and the minimum renewable fraction is 40.2%.
46 Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023
M. N. Minja & A. T. Mushi, (2023), doi: 10.52339/tjet.v42i1.887
provided with Auto Transfer Switch (ATS) The system consists of two buses such as
switchgear for the operation of essential AC and DC buses. The AC sources, such as
services. The DG provides power within 15 wind and diesel generators, feed to the AC
seconds of mains power failure from bus while the battery bank and solar PV
TANESCO. The current total load of MIA is systems are connected to the DC bus with a
350 kVA. bidirectional converter linking the two
buses. All loads are assumed to be AC loads
METHODS AND MATERIALS connected to the AC bus. This system has
higher loads than the DC loads (Juma et al.,
Design procedures of the HRES
2021a; Juma et al., 2021b). Compared with
Mixed Hybrid Renewable Energy System other MCHRES design topologies, mixed-
(MCHRES) can be designed based on coupled power system design maximizes
different technical topologies to harvest the diesel efficiency and has the possibility of a
available renewable and non-renewable decrease in diesel fuel utilisation and battery
energy potentials to meet the required load capacity (Kaabeche et al., 2010). It also
(Fungo et al., 2021; Marcel et al., 2021; offers optimal power generation and
Sterl et al., 2019). In this paper, the controllability (Bahta, 2013).
MCHRES shown in Figure 1 was designed.
48 Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023
M. N. Minja & A. T. Mushi, (2023), doi: 10.52339/tjet.v42i1.887
use solar radiation databases to estimate the energy potential at the airport was estimated
solar PV energy potential at MIA depicted using data provided by Tanzania
in Figure 3. Then, one can determine the Meteorological Authority (TMA), as
wind speed data for the site from 10 m to 20 depicted in Figure 4.
m height from the ground of MIA. The wind
Figure 2: Map showing the location of MIA infrastructures (google maps, 2023)
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Months
Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023 49
Design of Mwanza International Airport Hybrid Renewable Energy System
900.0
800.0
Monthly Wind speed/Energy
700.0
600.0
500.0
400.0
300.0 Total monthly average wind speed (m/s)
200.0
100.0 Monthly total wind energy (kWh/m2)
0.0
Energy at wind speed time (kWh/m2)
Months
Mathematical model of solar PV system cell reference temperature [K], and t is the
Designing an efficient solar PV system to temperature coefficient of efficiency
enhance its performance for maximum ranging from 0.004 to 0.006/ºC for silicon
power production is very significant. A cells.
solar PV array can be modelled using ατ
different approaches. Several parameter Tc = Ta + Gt Tc = Ta + Gt (U1 )
data are required for modelling solar PV U1
system, such as incident solar radiation, (3)
NOCT − 20 ατ NOCT-20
areal ambient temperature, and = U1
= 800
manufacturer's PV module specifications. U1 800
Wang (2006) explained that PV output (4)
power could be determined by Equation (1). Further, Ta the ambient site temperature
PPV = g NAmGt Ppv = ηg NAm Gt
[K] are photovoltaic transmittance and
(1) absorptance coefficients, respectively.
where PPV Ppv is the solar PV power These parameters pt , t , and NOCT are
generator output [W], g ηg is the solar PV parameters that depend on module type and
generator efficiency [%], Am Am is the area can be obtained from the module
manufacturer’s datasheet (Equations (3) and
of a single module [m2], Gt is the global (4)).
radiation [W/m2], and N is the number of
solar modules assembled in the system. The Mathematical model of wind system
solar PV generator efficiency can be
The theoretical power available in the wind
presented in by Equation (2).
per 1 m2 of rotor swept area can be
g = r pt 1 − t (Tc − Tr ) ηg = mathematically expressed by Equation (5).
ηr ηpt [1-βt (Tc -Tr )] (2) 1 1
P = V 3 P = 2 ρV 3
where r is reference efficiency [%], pt 2
(5)
is solar tracking system efficiency [%], Tc The power density available in the wind is
is the PV cell temperature [K], Tr is the PV P [W/m2m2], wind speed is V [m/s], and
50 Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023
M. N. Minja & A. T. Mushi, (2023), doi: 10.52339/tjet.v42i1.887
is the air density [kg/m3]. Since air demand (Equation (9)) as per (Dufo-López
temperature and humidity are variable, the et al., 2021; Khan et al., 2021).
air density varies with altitude. Taking air N V Q (1 − qmin /100 ) 24 h
S D = B nom nom
density of 1.225 kg/m3 as a reference, the 1000 Wh day
specific air density of the site can be I prim − ave
kWh
determined by Equation (6) as given by 24hr
Nbatt ×Vnom ×Qnom ×(1-qmin/100 )×( )
(Bahta, 2013). day
SD = Wh
= 0 − 1.194 10−4 H m ρ = ρ0 -1.194 × Iprim,ave ×(1000
kWh
)
(9)
10-4 Hm (6)
where N B Nbatt is the number of batteries,
The H m is site elevation [m], and 0 is the
air density at sea level [1.225 kg/m3]. The Vnom Vnom is the single battery nominal
electrical power of the wind turbine is voltage [V], Qnom Qnom is the single battery
expressed mathematically by Equation (7).
nominal capacity [Ah], qmin is the battery
1 1
Pel = V 3C p gm Pel = 2 ρV 3 Cp ηg ηm bank minimum state of charge [%], and
2
(7) I prim− ave Iprim,ave is the average primary
where Pel is the wind turbine electrical electrical load [kWh/day].
power density [kW/m2], g is the electrical
Mathematical model of Converters
generator efficiency [%], m is the
The converters in this project were inverter
mechanical gearbox efficiency [%], and C p and rectifier. The mathematical models of
is the power coefficient of the wind turbine, these converters are as given by Johannesen
given as 0.4 and 0.5 for two blades rotor et al. (2021), Josue & Mushi (2022) and
and between 0.2 to 0.4 for more blades as Kumar Lal et al. (2011) as shown by
well as low-speed turbines (Wang, 2006). Equations (10) and (11).
EPVG−IN ( t ) = INV EPVG ( t ) EPVG-IN (t) =
Mathematical model of battery bank ηINV EPVG (t) (10)
system
EBAT ( t − 1) − ELOAD ( t )
The total capacity of the battery capable of EBAT − INV ( t ) =
supplying the full load demand can be INV DCHG
determined using Equation (8) (Kaabeche et EBAT (t-1)-ELOAD (t)
EBAT-INV (t) = [ ] (11)
al., 2010). ηINV ηDCHG
EL S D where EPVG−INV ( t ) EPVG-IN (t) is the energy
CB = CB =
VB DODmaxTcf B output from inverter [kWh], EPVG ( t )
EL SD
(8) EPVG (t) is the energy output from solar PV
VB ×DODmax ×Tcf ×ηB
generator [kWh], 𝜂𝐼𝑁𝑉 is the inverter
where C B CB is the capacity of battery [Ah], efficiency [%], EBAT −INV ( t ) is the energy
E L EL is the electrical load [Wh], S D SD is output from battery [kWh], ELOAD ( t ) is the
the battery autonomy [days], VB is the energy consumed by the load [kWh], DCHG
battery voltage [V], DODmax (DOD)max is is the battery discharging efficiency, and
the maximum allowed depth of discharge of EBAT ( t − 1) is energy stored in battery until
the battery, Tcf is the temperature correction time step t − 1 [kWh]. The rectifier is the
factor, and B ηB is the efficiency of battery converter used to convert the AC power
[%]. The autonomy period of a battery bank from the wind generator and diesel
is the ratio of battery bank size to the load generator to DC for battery charging. Its
Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023 51
Design of Mwanza International Airport Hybrid Renewable Energy System
demand dynamics and generation resource analyse the uncertainty about the power
fluctuations. Sensitivity parameters chosen system. Many sensitivity variables take
when modelling HRES tells how sensitive more HOMER computational time. Table 2
the power system is prior to the input depicts the sensitivity variables used in the
variables. These are load, maximum simulation.
capacity shortage, minimum renewable
fraction and diesel price. The advantage of
sensitivity variables in modelling is to
Table 2: Sensitivity variables used for HOMER simulations
Load Maximum Minimum renewable Diesel price
capacity shortage fraction [%] [US$/litre]
60 kWh/day, 115.34 kW 0, 5, 8, 10 40, 60 0.86, 0.95, 0.97, 1.01
peak
Note 1: The exchange rate is US$1 = TZS 2304.6541 on 11th August 2022 (BOT, 2022).
Note 2: Maximum capacity shortage is the ratio of the shortfall of the required capacity to the
actual operating/generating capacity. This ratio reflects how much the power generation
meets the load requirements.
Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023 53
Design of Mwanza International Airport Hybrid Renewable Energy System
$700,000.00
$623,333.80 $626,658.50
$600,000.00
$500,000.00
$400,000.00
$357,780.80 $359,150.10
$300,000.00
$200,000.00
$100,000.00
$-
Scheme A Scheme B Scheme C Scheme D
Figure 6: Simulation results based on total NPC for the four hybrid schemes.
5000
4401.89 4400.345
4500
4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0 0
0
Scheme A Scheme B Scheme C Scheme D
Figure 7: Simulation results based on total diesel consumption for the four hybrid schemes.
Referring to Figures 6 to 9, one realizes capacity for Scheme A was 78.48 kW,
which HRES scheme is the winner or which means 314 pieces of solar modules
technically feasible. Considering NPC and of 200 W each, a battery bank of up to 608
COE, scheme A is the winner. Scheme A batteries of 83.4 Ah each, a backup diesel
comprises the PV system, backup diesel generator of 140 kVA rating, a
generator and battery bank. The NPC of the bidirectional converter of 41.64 kVA with
scheme was recorded as US$357,780.80 an operating cost of US$ 11,578.51 per
and COE of 0.93 US$/kWh (Figure 6). year.
Scheme A has a minimum renewable
fraction of 40.2%. The resulting PV system
54 Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023
M. N. Minja & A. T. Mushi, (2023), doi: 10.52339/tjet.v42i1.887
1.4
1.2
1 0.9320619 0.9356289
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
Scheme A Scheme B Scheme C Scheme D
Figure 8: Simulation results based on COE for the four hybrid schemes.
Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023 55
Design of Mwanza International Airport Hybrid Renewable Energy System
selected design was US$ 357,780.80; the Applied Sciences, 11(3): 1099.
cost of energy was 0.93 US$/kW; and the https://doi.org/10.3390/app11031099
minimum renewable fraction of 40.2%. EESI. (2021). Fossil Fuels. Environmental and
Some improvements should be made to Energy Study Institute.
generate energy efficiently at the minimum https://www.eesi.org/topics/fossil-
fuels/description
possible cost to meet energy demand for the Ferdous, R. Md., Reza, A. W., & Siddiqui, M.
future. Suggestions for future work can be F. (2016). Renewable energy harvesting
summarized as follows: for wireless sensors using passive RFID
• In this research, the efficiency of tag technology: A review. Renewable
components was not considered; thus, and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 58:
for optimal feasible design, this 1114–1128.
parameter could be included in the https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2015.12.332
future. Fungo, L. J., Mushi, A. T., & Msigwa, C. J.
• Accurate recording and measurement (2021, November 11). Grid Connected
PV-Wind Energy System for Luxmanda
of wind and solar potential of the area
Village in Tanzania. The Third Annual
should be done. Conference on Research and Inclusive
• The exact kW rating of appliances in Development.
the MIA cargo buildings should be ICAO. (2016). A Focus on the Production of
studied in detail. Renewable Energy at the Airport Site
• Accurate load consumption of specific ECO AIRPORT TOOLKIT.
appliances or equipment should be Irechukwu, M. E., & Mushi, A. T. (2020).
studied. Potential for Increased Rural
• Accurate and recent cost data of Electrification Rate in Sub-Saharan
Africa using SWER Power Distribution
components should be obtained.
Networks. Tanzania Journal of
• Considering increasing sensitivity Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J.
cases for more feasible solutions of Engrg. Technol.), 39(2):
the HRES designs. https://doi.org/10.52339/tjet.v39i2.707
Johannesen, N. J., Kolhe, M. L., & Goodwin,
REFERENCES M. (2021). Load prediction of rural area
Nordic holiday resorts for microgrid
Bahta, S. T. (2013). Design and Analyzing of an
development. In Residential Microgrids
Off-Grid Hybrid Renewable Energy
and Rural Electrifications (pp. 163–181).
System to Supply Electricity for Rural
Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-
Areas (Case study: Atsbi, North
323-90177-2.00005-0
Ethiopia)) [Master of Science]. KTH.
Josue, N., & Mushi, A. (2022). Renewable
BOT. (2022). Bank of Tanzania-Previous
Energy Microgrids to Improve
Exchange Rates.
Electrification Rate in Democratic
https://www.bot.go.tz/ExchangeRate/pre
Republic of Congo: Case of Hydro,
vious_rates?__RequestVerificationToken
Municipal Waste and Solar. Tanzania
=IUESAQGGnk2lcnniGdkL8i5vyH1g1B
Journal of Engineering and Technology,
N03BDRjml1mrhAj8qM29AeUOAKxg0
41(2): 82–97.
wZTaH1iJPyFWQOkLutG2D2UvxiYKe
https://doi.org/10.52339/tjet.v41i2.781
rh8me9lBtX60CTCpIeU1&exchangeDat
Juma, M. I., Mwinyiwiwa, B. M. M., Msigwa,
e=08%2F11%2F2022
C. J., & Mushi, A. T. (2021). Design of a
Chiras, D. (2010). Solar Electricity Basics. New
hybrid energy system with energy storage
Society Publishers.
for standalone DC microgrid application.
Dufo-López, R., Cortés-Arcos, T., Artal-Sevil,
Energies, 14(18).
J. S., & Bernal-Agustín, J. L. (2021).
https://doi.org/10.3390/en14185994
Comparison of Lead-Acid and Li-Ion
Juma, M., Mwinyiwiwa, B. M. M., Msigwa, C.
Batteries Lifetime Prediction Models in
J., & Mushi, A. T. (2021). Proposal
Stand-Alone Photovoltaic Systems.
Design of a Hybrid Solar PV-Wind-
56 Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023
M. N. Minja & A. T. Mushi, (2023), doi: 10.52339/tjet.v42i1.887
Battery Energy Storage for Standalone Minja, M. N., & Mushi, A. T. (2021, November
DC Microgrid Application. 11). Proposing Mixed Coupled Hybrid
https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202108. Renewable Energy Sources for Mwanza
0264.v1 International Airport. The Third Annual
Justo, J. J., & Mushi, A. T. (2020). Performance Conference on Research and Inclusive
Analysis of Renewable Energy Development.
Resources in Rural Areas: A Case Study Minja, M. N., & Mushi, A. T. (2022). Design
of Solar Energy. In Tanzania Journal of and simulation of hybrid renewable
Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. energy sources for Mwanza International
Engrg. Technol.) 39(1): Airport. 7th International Conference on
Kaabeche, A., Belhamel, M., & Ibtiouen, R. Mechanical and Industrial Engineering
(2010). Optimal sizing method for stand- (MIE’2022), 5.
alone hybrid PV/wind power generation Mushi, A. T. (2022). Recent Hydro Generation
system. Revue Des Energies Issues within Tanzania – A Closer Look.
Renouvelables (SMEE’10) Bou Ismail 2022 Zanzibar Water Conference, 69.
Tipaza, 205–213. Sekhar, P. C., Deshpande, R. A., & Sankar, V.
Khamharnphol, R., Kamdar, I., Waewsak, J., (2016). Evaluation and improvement of
Chaichan, W., Khunpetch, S., reliability indices of electrical power
Chiwamongkhonkarn, S., Kongruang, C., distribution system. 2016 National Power
& Gagnon, Y. (2023). Microgrid Hybrid Systems Conference (NPSC), 1–6.
Solar/Wind/Diesel and Battery Energy https://doi.org/10.1109/NPSC.2016.7858
Storage Power Generation System: 838
Application to Koh Samui, Southern Sterl, S., van Lipzig, N., van Griensven, A., &
Thailand. International Journal of Thiery, W. (2019). Flexible hydro-solar-
Renewable Energy Development, 12(2): wind mixes for reliable power supply in
216–226. West Africa. Geographical Research
https://doi.org/10.14710/ijred.2023.47761 Abstracts, 21.
Khan, F. A., Pal, N., & Saeed, S. H. (2021). Wang, C. (2006). Modelling and Control of
Stand-alone hybrid system of solar Hybrid Wind/Photovoltaic/Fuel Cell
photovoltaics/wind energy resources: an Distribution Generation Systems [PhD].
eco-friendly sustainable approach. In Montana State University.
Renewable Energy Systems (pp. 687–
705). Elsevier.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-
820004-9.00030-9
Kihwele, S., Hur, K., & Kyaruzi, A. (2012).
Visions, Scenarios and Action Plans
Towards Next Generation Tanzania
Power System. Energies, 5(10): 3908–
3927. https://doi.org/10.3390/en5103908
Kumar Lal, D., Bhusan Dash, B., & Akella, A.
K. (2011). Optimization of
PV/Wind/Micro-Hydro/Diesel Hybrid
Power System in HOMER for the Study
Area. International Journal on Electrical
Engineering and Informatics, 3(3): 307–
325.
https://doi.org/10.15676/ijeei.2011.3.3.4
Marcel, E. T., Mutale, J., & Mushi, A. T.
(2021). Optimal Design of Hybrid
Renewable Energy for Tanzania Rural
Communities. Tanzania Journal of
Science, 47(5): 1716–1727.
https://doi.org/10.4314/tjs.v47i5.19
Tanzania Journal of Engineering and Technology (Tanz. J. Engrg. Technol.), Vol. 42 (No. 1), Feb. 2023 57