Page 1 of 1

Number of Comments Open - 3

Number of Comments Closed - 5
Number of Comments carried to next stage - 0

NOBLE INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL

DESIGN REVIEW SHEET
REVIEW DOCUMENT TITLE: NIS- STAGE CALCULATION A = Approved
DRS DATE : 7-Mar-24 2-Apr-24 Consent Classification : B = Approved w/ Comments
Consent Classification's C = Revise & Resubmit
Comments , D = Rejected
REVIEW DOCUMENT REFERENCE: NIS-CALC-STAGE-01.Rev.01 DRS VERSION : 1 2

COMMENT SHEET REFERENCE : NIS-DRS-STAGE-01-Rev.01 DRS RESPONSE: C B Document Status following review : B
COMMENT CODE LEGEND (for individual comments) : 1 = Action required for this issue , 2 = Advisory comment , 3 = To be addressed at next cc Response Code: 1 = Incorporated , 2 = Evaluated but
design phase not Incorporated

Doc Reference / Page Comment Response Status

No Entity Initial Comment Response Code Response
Rev Section Code By Open/Closed

In actual there is no finishes but only epoxy coating. The load 0.7kpa is
1 ZUH SAM 0 Genral 1 Provide finishes details by sketch and/or break down.
considered to be conservative only closed

1 Noted
Please refer to the revised report where the reactions are reduced by
adding additional columns. Therefore pinned supports are not required
2 ZUH SAM 0 Genral 1 The contractor/designer should utilize pinned connections with suitable bracing instead of fixed with bracings as it will also obstruct storage and access beneath the
closed
connections to prevent the occurrence of local stresses in the concrete. stage.

1
Noted
The contractor/designer should opt for chemical hilti anchor bolts instead of mechanical anchor
Please refer to the revised report where all the anchor designs are
3 ZUH SAM 0 Genral 1 bolts because of the effects of harmonic action.
updated to Hilti profis anchor
closed
1 Noted

The contractor/designer must validate the vibration analysis in light of harmonic action.

Where floors are likely to be subject to dancing and jumping activities characterised by
synchronised crowd movement, the floor must be designed for ultimate limit state
considerations in accordance with the requirements given in the National Annex to BS EN 1991-
1-1[4].
Revised model with footfall analysis has been checked and it has no
4 ZUH SAM 0 Genral 1 According to these Standards: closed
adverse effect on the framing.
The floor may be designed to have a fundamental frequency of at least 8.4 Hz vertically and at
least 4 Hz horizontally, in which case the resonant effects need not be evaluated.
or The floor should be designed to resist the anticipated dynamic loads due to rhythmic activity
which should be considered as an additional imposed load case.

The vertical natural frequency of the floor should be evaluated for the appropriate mode of
vibration for an empty structure.

1 Noted closed

The Contractor advised to ensure to prepare shop drawing which is in full compliance with the
5 ZUH SAM 0 Genral 1 Noted Open
general notes and comments of the approved design which will remain the reference for works
inspection and final approval.
6 ZUH SAM 0 Genral 2 To be coordinated with the latest approved MEP & Architectural design drawings Noted Open

The contractor is advised to guarantee that the existing rebar remains undamaged during the
7 ZUH SAM 0 Genral 3 Noted Open
drilling process for anchor bolts. Prior to drilling, a rebar scanning report must be submitted to
the Engineer of the supervising consultant for approval.

Comments Validated by: ___________________

Response Validated by: ___________________