Republic of the Philippines

National Police Commission

Philippine National Police
Camarines Sur Police Provincial Office
CALABANGA MUNICIPAL POLICE OFFICE
Calabanga, Camarines Sur

Calabanga MPO-Inves

MEMORANDUM

FOR: Chief, Investigation Section

FROM: The Investigator-on-Case

SUBJECT: Initial Investigation Report, re – Parricide

DATE: February 26, 2024

I. AUTHORITY:

1. Verbal instruction of PCPT EDWARDO RANIREZ, Chief of Investigation

dated February 25, 2024 to investigate a reported incident recorded in Patrol Section
Incident Logbook, Entry No. 18-1128

II. DETAIL:

2. Upon receiving the report conducted by the investigator, herein

Investigator was dispatched by the Duty Desk Officer, Pat. Hazel S Ollita to conduct
investigation regarding on the stabbing incident that transpired at about 4:00 PM, at
the resident of the Enchande ‘s in zone 7,brgy Sabanga Calabanga Camarines sur.

III. FINDINGS:

3. There are some variety of physical evidence that was found at the crime
scene such as: blood stains from the victim, hairs, Knife that use kill the victim.

4. The area has a 2 Close-Circuit Television (CCTV), one is located inside the
house were in the stabbing incident happen and the other one is located outside of
the house. The incident was recorded on the CCTV and can be used as an evidence.

5.The witnesses recognized that his boss when it coming home he smells like
an alcohol after finishing his work.
6.Spot report to be followed.

III. RECOMMENDATION:

7. Taking all of these factors into consideration, the aforementioned

investigator hereby advises that the case be referred to the Chief of Police as soon
as possible, that an autopsy be performed to ascertain the victim's immediate and
proximate cause of death, Review the CCTV camera footage, and that field
interviews be conducted in zone 7 Barangay Sabang Calabanga Camarines Sur, and
interview the family of the victim.

HAZEL S OLLITA
Patrolwoman
 Republic of the Philippines
National Police Commission
Philippine National Police
Camarines Sur Police Provincial Office
CALABANGA MUNICIPAL POLICE OFFICE
Calabanga, Camarines Sur

Calabanga MPO

MEMORANDUM

FOR: Chief of Police

FROM: The Investigator-on-Case

SUBJECT: Spot Report, re – Parricide

DATE: February 28, 2024

1. Please be informed that on or about 04:00 PM of February 25, 2024 a

stabbing incident transpired along the resident of the Enchande’s, Zone 7 Barangay
Sabang, Calabanga Camarines Sur. The victim namely, Flore Amanda Enchande, 26
years old, House wife, Filipino, female, wife of the suspect, a resident of Zone 7 brgy.
Sabang, Calabanga Camarines Sur, who was stab by his Husband. A witness Ms.
Marga Morteza, 29 years old, single, Maid of Enchande’s Family, Filipino, female a
resident of Zone 5, Brgy. Sabang of Calabanga, Camarines Sur.

2. Initial Investigation and Blotter revealed that the victim is just inside of
their house and also the other maid and the suspect its come from work, and
according to the witness his boss is smells like an alcohol and after 10 to 15 minutes
she heard shout and she immediately go inside of the house and she saw when
suspect appeared and without apparent reason, stab his wife for 5 times. The
witness was afraid and could not move where she was when saw the incident and
heard that the victim begged to the suspect which is his husband not to kill her,
After the Stabbing incident , witness make a telephone call to the police station on
the above mentioned time and date. The victim sustained multiple stab wounds at
the back and front of the body and was immediately brought to the nearest hospital
at Bicol Medical Center, but she was pronounced dead on arrival.
 3. The motive of the incident is undetermined, the case still under
investigation and suspect is at large, pursuit operation is being conducted for the
arrest of suspect.

4. Progress report will follow as soon as possible.

5. Respectfully submitted for information and reference.

HAZEL S OLLITA
Patrolwoman
 Republic of the Philippines
National Police Commission
Philippine National Police
Camarines Sur Police Provincial Office
CALABANGA MUNICIPAL POLICE OFFICE
Calabanga, Camarines Sur

Calabanga MPO

MEMORANDUM

FOR: Chief of Police

FROM: The Investigator-on-Case

SUBJECT: Progress Report, re – Parricide

DATE: March 02, 2024

I. AUTHORITY:

1.The progress report to the investigation conducted on the stabbing incident

recorded in Patrol Section Incident Logbook, Entry No. 18-1128, dated February 28,
2024.

II. DATAILS:

2. The investigation into the stabbing incident occurred on February 25, 2024,
in Zone 7 Barangay Sabang of Calabanga, Camarines Sur, is progressing. Here are
the latest development:

3. An Autopsy was conducted by Doc. Vincent Hidalgo as an pathologist to

the victim Flore Enchande. The autopsy revealed 5 wounds, two at the back at 3 at
front of her body. The stab wounds lead to several internal injuries, is the cause of
her death, and aside of that there were bruises found in the victim body, it could be
that she was hurting of her husband

4. As the investigation with the aid of the CCTV and other physical evidence,
the suspect namely Armando Enchande is arrested. While conduct an investigation
and interview in the place of crime scene mention in above, they found another
witnesses that she/he voluntary to give an information of happen to the victim’s
which is Rolinda Ranirez 26 years old, single, resident of Zone 1 Barangay salvacion
Baybay, Calabanga Camarines, Sur, bestfriend of the victim including
 5. The suspects are now at the custody of this station for further investigation
and proper disposition. The victim and weapons wear turned- over to PNP Crime
Laboratory office.

6. Possible Motives of incident:

a. Being obsessed to his wife
b. Being Violent to his wife

7. Further interviews with witnesses, Marga Morteza and Rolinda Ranirez,

including Marites Luparan are scheduled to gather additional information.

8. Armando Enchande will be interrogated to gather more information about

the motive and circumstances in killing his wife.

9. Final Investigation report will follow.

III. RECOMMENDATION:

10. To ensure justice is served, it is important to swiftly collaborate with the

legal team, confirm the admissibility of evidence, and meticulously prepare the case.
This involves careful attention to detail, thorough organization, and a focus on
upholding the principles of fairness and justice throughout the legal proceedings.

HAZEL S OLLITA
Patrolwoman
SWORN STATEMENT OF MARGA MORTEZA, TAKEN BY PATROLWOMAN HAZEL S.
OLLITA, INSIDE THE INVESTIGATION SECTION, CALABANGA MUNICIPAL POLICE
OFFICE, CALABANGA CAMARINES SUR, IN THE PRESENCE OF POLICE CAPTAIN
EDWARDO RANIREZ. THIS MARCH 06, 2024 AT AROUND 01:00 IN THE
AFTERNOON.
x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x

PRELIMINARY: MARGA MORTEZA, do you swear to tell the truth and nothing but the
truth?
ANSWER: Yes, ma’am.

Q1: Are you willing to give your free and willing statement?
A1: Yes, ma’am

Q2: Can you state your name and other personal circumstances?
A2: I am MARGA MORTEZA, 29 years old born on January 2, 1995, single, maid of
enchande’s family for 1 year, from Zone 5 Barangay Sabang Calabanga Camarines
Sur.

Q3: What is the reason you were here in our office and give a free and voluntary
statement?
A3: I was there when that tragedy happened and I saw with my two eyes how the
suspect kill the his wife. I want to complain against the suspect and I want to helped
the victim to get justice.

Q4: When and where such the incident occurred?

A4: It was occurred last February 25, 2024, at around 4:00 PM, at the house of
family Enchande, resident of Zone 5 Barangay Sabang Calabanga Camarines Sur.

Q5: What is your connection to the victim?

A5: I don’t have any connection to the victim ma’am but I’m one of their maid for 12
months.

Q6: Have your notice that he always hurt his wife?

A6: Yes Maam, many times.

Q7: Will you narrate the facts on how that incident happened?
A7: I was sweeping and watering the plants outside the house, when boss is
coming came from the work I open the gate and after that I continuously what I’m
doing, after a few minutes I heard noise inside the house and I saw may boss kill his
wife.

Q8: did you see What was used to the victim?

A8: Yes Maam, he used a knife.

Q9: What did you do after the victim was killed?

A9: I was afraid and could not move,
Q10: Do you know what are the motive of the suspects?
A10: No ma’am, I don’t know.

Q11: Is there anyone else who witnessed the incident, other than you?
A11: Yes, ma’am.

Q12: Who are they?

A12: Rolinda Alvarez and Marites Luparan maam.

Q13: For the meantime, I have nothing more to ask. Do you have any statement to
add?
A13: I Don’t have, ma’am.

Q14: Were you threatened, promised or bribed to do this confession?

A14: No, ma’am I made it voluntarily with my own free will.

Q15: Are you willing to sign this statement of yours and affirm under oath to the
truthfulness of the same?
A15: yes, ma’am

Marga Morteza
Affiant

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me, this 6th day of March 2024, at
Calabanga, Camarines Sur, Philippines.

Edwardo Ranirez
Police Captain
Chief of Investigation
Administering Officer

CERTIFICATION

I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have personally examined the herein affiant

under oath and that I am fully satisfied that she voluntarily executed and understood
her statement.

Edwardo Ranirez
Police Captain
 Chief of Investigation
Administering Officer
SWORN STATEMENT OF ROLINDA ALVAREZ, TAKEN BY PATROLWOMAN HAZEL S
OLLITA, INSIDE THE INVESTIGATION SECTION, CALABANGA MUNICIPAL POLICE
OFFICE, CALABANGA CAMARINES SUR, IN THE PRESENCE OF POLICE CAPTAIN
EDWARDO RANIREZ. THIS MARCH 06, 2024 AT AROUND 02:30 IN THE
AFTERNOON.
x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -----x

PRELIMINARY: ROLINDA ALVAREZ, do you swear to tell the truth and nothing but
the truth?
ANSWER: Yes, ma’am.

Q1: Are you willing to give your free and willing statement?
A1: Yes, ma’am

Q2: Can you state your name and other personal circumstances?
A2: I am ROLINDA ALVAREZ, 26 years old born on April 19, 1998, married, from
Zone 1 Barangay Salvacion Baybay Calabanga Camarines Sur.

Q3: What is the reason you were here in our office and give a free and voluntary
statement?
A3: The reason is I want to testify against the suspect to help the victims’ family to
get justice.

Q4: Where were you when the crime is committed?

A4: I was in my home but before the crime happen I’m talking to the victim through
cellphone.

Q5: what is your connection to the victim?

A5: I’m the bestfriend of the victim since college

Q6: Do you know who the suspect is?

A6: yes, her husband

Q7: Can you narrate the facts on how that incident happened?
A7: Yes, ma’am, when I’m talking to my bestfriend she always says that she want to
leave the house but doesn’t want let him out because she experience the
maltreatment by his husband, so I decided that she go to my house in that day, so
in that day I’m waiting to her at that time I was nervous because it took her so long.
a few minutes ago one of the maids called me and said her husband killed flore.

Q8: What did you do after the killing incident happened?

A8: I immediately go to the house of my bestfriend but I was too late, I was seen
lying on the floor and bathed in her own blood held by yaya Marites

Q9: Is there anyone else who witnessed the incident, other than you?
A9: Yes, ma’am.
Q10: Who are they?
A10: Marites Luparan, the old maid of the family Enchande.

Q11: For the meantime, I have nothing more to ask. Do you have any statement to
add?
A11: I have nothing more to say, ma’am.

Q12: Were you threatened, promised or bribed to do this confession?

A12: No, ma’am I made it voluntarily with my own free will.

Q13: Are you willing to sign this statement of yours and affirm under oath to the
truthfulness of the same?
A13: yes, ma’am

Rolinda Alvarez
Affiant

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me, this 6th day of March 2024, at
Calabanga, Camarines Sur, Philippines.

Edwardo Ranirez
Police Captain
Chief of Investigation
Administering Officer

CERTIFICATION

I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have personally examined the herein affiant

under oath and that I am fully satisfied that she voluntarily executed and understood
her statement.

Edwardo Ranirez
Police Captain
 Chief of Investigation
Administering Office
Republic of the Philippines…………)
Province of Camarines Sur…………) S.S
Municipality of Calabanga ……)
x-------------------------------- -------x

AFFIDAVIT

I, Marites Luparan, Filipino, 35 years of age, married, have 3 child, and

resident of Barangay Liboton ng Naga City Camarines Sur, after having duly sworn to
accordance with the law, do hereby despose and say:

1. I personally know who the victim is, I’m her nanny when she was in high
school, until now she already married.

2. When I meet the guy, he been good that’s why I happy when I see my
daughter flore is also happy with Armando.

3. Until Armando see flore having fun with her friends with the boy that being
close to flore that can him jealous and angry and I was there and I was
shocked of he did.

4. When we go home Armando hurt flores, he slap for many times and I stop
him and take her in their room, and asking her if he always do that and she
said yes. I’m in the vocation to go my family in 1 month and I don’t that her
husband doing this to her.

5. Being his second mother I was concerned and I said I would call the police
and she stopped me, so I put him to sleep and I was surprised to see many
bruises on his body.

6. Before incident happen she called me and said she go to her bestfriend and
while fixing things we were both surprised and nervous armando screamed
and pulled flores down, I also stopped armando but he pushed me until I saw
he got a knife and was stabbing flores without hesitation.

7. That I am executing this affidavit to attest the veracity of the facts herein
declared to the best knowledge and belief.
 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand 7th day of March
2024, at Calabanga Camarines Sur, Philippines.

Marites Luparan
Affiant

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this 7th day of March 2024 at

Calabanga, Camarines Sur, Philippines. I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have personally
examined the herein affiant and I am satisfied that they voluntarily executed and
understood their given affidavit

Atty. Nathaniel Riego

Prosecutor