Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- eBook PDF
Visit to download the full and correct content document:
https://ebooksecure.com/download/ise-fundamentals-of-corporate-finance-ebook-pdf/
Fundamentals of
Corporate Finance
Eleventh EDITION
THE MCGRAW-HILL EDUCATION SERIES IN FINANCE, INSURANCE, AND REAL ESTATE
Richard A. Brealey
London Business School
Stewart C. Myers
Sloan School of Management,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Alan J. Marcus
Carroll School of Management,
Boston College
Final PDF to printer
Published by McGraw Hill LLC, 1325 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10121. Copyright ©2023 by
McGraw Hill LLC. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. Previous editions ©2020, 2018,
and 2015. No part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in
a database or retrieval system, without the prior written consent of McGraw Hill LLC, including, but not limited
to, in any network or other electronic storage or transmission, or broadcast for distance learning.
Some ancillaries, including electronic and print components, may not be available to customers outside the
United States.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 LWI 27 26 25 24 23 22
ISBN 978-1-265-10259-3
MHID 1-265-10259-7
All credits appearing on page or at the end of the book are considered to be an extension of the copyright page.
The Internet addresses listed in the text were accurate at the time of publication. The inclusion of a website does
not indicate an endorsement by the authors or McGraw Hill LLC, and McGraw Hill LLC does not guarantee the
accuracy of the information presented at these sites.
mheducation.com/highered
Richard A. Brealey
Emeritus Professor of Finance at the London Business School
Professor Brealey is the former president of the European Finance Association and
a former director of the American Finance Association. He is a fellow of the British
Academy and has served as Special Adviser to the Governor of the Bank of England
and as director of a number of financial institutions. Professor Brealey is also the
author (with Stewart Myers, Franklin Allen, and Alex Edmans) of this book’s sister
text, Principles of Corporate Finance (McGraw Hill).
Stewart C. Myers
Robert C. Merton (1970) Professor of Financial Economics at MIT’s Sloan School of
Management
Dr. Myers is past president of the American Finance Association and a research
associate of the National Bureau of Economic Research. His research has focused on
financing decisions, valuation methods, the cost of capital, and financial aspects of
government regulation of business. Dr. Myers is a director of The Brattle Group, Inc.
and is active as a financial consultant. He is also the author (with Richard Brealey,
Franklin Allen, and Alex Edmans) of this book’s sister text, Principles of Corporate
Finance (McGraw Hill).
Alan J. Marcus
Mario Gabelli Professor of Finance in the Carroll School of Management at Boston
College
Professor Marcus’s main research interests are in derivatives and securities markets.
He is co-author (with Zvi Bodie and Alex Kane) of the texts Investments and
Essentials of Investments (McGraw Hill). Professor Marcus has served as a research
fellow at the National Bureau of Economic Research. Professor Marcus also spent
two years at Freddie Mac, where he helped to develop mortgage pricing and credit
risk models. He currently serves on the Research Foundation Advisory Board of the
CFA Institute.
vi
Preface
vii
viii Preface
Organizational Design
Fundamentals is organized in eight parts.
Chapter 5 also contains a short concluding section on inflation and the distinction
between real and nominal returns.
Chapters 6 and 7 introduce the basic features of bonds and stocks and give stu-
dents a chance to apply the ideas of Chapter 5 to the valuation of these securities.
We show how to find the value of a bond given its yield, and we show how prices
of bonds fluctuate as interest rates change. We look at what determines stock prices
and how stock valuation formulas can be used to infer the return that investors
expect. Finally, we see how investment opportunities are reflected in the stock price
and why analysts focus on the price-earnings multiple. Chapter 7 also introduces
the concept of market efficiency. This concept is crucial to interpreting a stock’s
valuation; it also provides a framework for the later treatment of the issues that
arise when firms issue securities or make decisions concerning dividends or capital
structure.
The remaining chapters of Part 2 are concerned with the company’s investment
decision. In Chapter 8, we introduce the concept of net present value and show how
to calculate the NPV of a simple investment project. We then consider more complex
investment proposals, including choices between alternative projects, machine replace-
ment decisions, and decisions of when to invest. We also look at other measures of an
investment’s attractiveness—its internal rate of return, profitability index, and payback
period. We show how the profitability index can be used to choose between invest-
ment projects when capital is scarce. The appendix to Chapter 8 shows how to sidestep
some of the pitfalls of the IRR rule.
The first step in any NPV calculation is to decide what to discount. Therefore, in
Chapter 9, we work through a realistic example of a capital budgeting analysis, show-
ing how the manager needs to recognize the investment in working capital and how
taxes and depreciation affect cash flows.
We start Chapter 10 by looking at how companies organize the investment
process and ensure everyone works toward a common goal. We discuss how positive-
NPV projects reflect a competitive advantage, and we go on to look at various tech-
niques such as sensitivity analysis, scenario analysis, and break-even analysis that
help managers identify the key assumptions in their estimates, We explain the dis-
tinction between accounting break-even and NPV break-even. We conclude the
chapter by describing how managers try to build future flexibility into projects so
that they can capitalize on good luck and mitigate the consequences of bad luck.
Part 3 (Risk) is concerned with the cost of capital. Chapter 11 starts with a historical
survey of returns on bonds and stocks and goes on to distinguish between the
diversifiable risk and market risk of individual stocks. Chapter 12 shows how to measure
market risk and discusses the relationship between risk and expected return. Chapter 13
introduces the weighted-average cost of capital and provides a practical illustration of
how to estimate it.
Part 4 (Financing) begins our discussion of the financing decision. Chapter 14 pro-
vides an overview of the securities that firms issue and their relative importance as
sources of finance. In Chapter 15, we look at how firms issue securities, and we follow
a firm from its first need for venture capital, through its initial public offering, to its
continuing need to raise debt or equity.
Part 5 (Debt and Payout Policy) focuses on the two classic long-term financ-
ing decisions. In Chapter 16, we ask how much the firm should borrow, and we
summarize bankruptcy procedures that occur when firms can’t pay their debts. In
Chapter 17, we study how firms should set dividend and payout policy. In each
x Preface
case, we start with Modigliani and Miller’s (MM’s) observation that in well-
functioning markets, the decision should not matter, but we use this initial obser-
vation to help the reader understand why financial managers in practice do pay
attention to these decisions.
Part 6 (Financial Analysis and Planning) starts with long-term financial plan-
ning in Chapter 18, where we look at how the financial manager considers the com-
bined effects of investment and financing decisions on the firm as a whole. We also
show how measures of internal and sustainable growth help managers check that
the firm’s planned growth is consistent with its financing plans. Chapter 19 is an
introduction to short-term financial planning. It shows how managers ensure that
the firm will have enough cash to pay its bills over the coming year. Chapter 20
addresses working capital management. It describes the basic steps of credit man-
agement, the principles of inventory management, and how firms handle payments
efficiently and put cash to work as quickly as possible. It also describes how firms
invest temporary surpluses of cash and how they can borrow to offset any temporary
deficiency. Chapter 20 is conceptually straightforward, but it contains a large dollop
of institutional material.
Part 7 (Special Topics) covers several important but somewhat more advanced
t opics—mergers (Chapter 21), international financial management (Chapter 22),
options (Chapter 23), and risk management (Chapter 24). Some of these topics
are touched on in earlier chapters. For example, we introduce the idea of options
in Chapter 10, when we show how companies build flexibility into capital proj-
ects. However, Chapter 23 generalizes this material, explains at an elementary
level how options are valued, and provides some examples of why the financial
manager needs to be concerned about options. International finance is also not
confined to Chapter 22. As one might expect from a book that is written by
an international group of authors, examples from different countries and finan-
cial systems are scattered throughout the book. However, Chapter 22 tackles
the specific problems that arise when a corporation is confronted by different
currencies.
many instructors prefer to reverse our order. There should be no difficulty in taking
Chapter 20 out of order.
When we discuss project valuation in Part 2, we stress that the opportunity cost of
capital depends on project risk. But we do not discuss how to measure risk or how
return and risk are linked until Part 3. This ordering can easily be modified. For exam-
ple, the chapters on risk and return can be introduced before, after, or midway through
the material on project valuation.
Improving the Flow A major part of our effort in revising this text was spent on
improving the flow. Often this has meant a word change here or a redrawn diagram
there, but sometimes we have made more substantial changes. For example, the dis-
cussions of forward and spot exchange rates in Chapter 22 are now integrated, which
makes the introduction to the material easier to understand. The material is substan-
tially unchanged, but we think that the flow is much improved.
Updating For many firms, a major focus of the past few years has been on the
impact of Covid. Not surprisingly, references to Covid crop up regularly in this new
edition in discussions of risk management, estimating beta, setting dividend policy,
and so on.
The dozens of real-firm examples in the text have been updated to reflect cur-
rent events in the last three years. These should offer greater name recognition and
salience to the typical reader.
Of course, in each new edition we also try to ensure that any statistics are as up to
date as possible. For example, since the previous edition, we have available an extra
two years of data on security returns. These show up in the figures in Chapter 11 of
the long-run returns on stocks, bonds, and bills. Accounting ratios, data on security
ownership, dividend payments, and stock repurchases are just a few of the other cases
where data have been brought up to date.
New Illustrative Boxes The text contains a number of boxes with illustrative real-
world examples. Many of these are new. Look, for example, at the box in Chapter 1
that raises the question whether managers should maximize the value of stakeholders
as a whole rather than that of the shareholders. Or look at the box in Chapter 15 that
shows how SPACS emerged in 2021 as an important alternative to a traditional IPO for
firms wishing to go public.
Chapter Summaries All chapter summaries have been reorganized into series of
easy-to-digest bullet points.
More Worked Examples We have added more worked examples in the text, many of
them taken from real companies.
Beyond the Page The Beyond the Page digital extensions and applications provide
additional examples, anecdotes, spreadsheet programs, and more thoroughgoing
xii Preface
explanations of some topics. In this edition, we have updated them and added a num-
ber of additional applications and made them easier to access. For example, the appli-
cations are seamlessly available with a click on the e-version of the book, but they are
also readily accessible in the traditional hard copy of the text using the shortcut URLs
provided in the margins of relevant pages.
Assurance of Learning
Assurance of learning is an important element of many accreditation standards.
Fundamentals of Corporate Finance, Eleventh Edition, is designed specifically to
support your assurance-of-learning initiatives. Each chapter in the book begins with a
list of numbered learning objectives, which are referred to in the end-of-chapter prob-
lems and exercises. Every test bank question is also linked to one of these objectives,
in addition to level of difficulty, topic area, Bloom’s Taxonomy level, and AACSB skill
area. Connect, McGraw-Hill’s online homework solution, and EZ Test, McGraw-Hill’s
easy-to-use test bank software, can search the test bank by these and other categories,
providing an engine for targeted assurance-of-learning analysis and assessment.
Preface xiii
AACSB Statement
McGraw-Hill Education is a proud corporate member of AACSB International.
Understanding the importance and value of AACSB accreditation, Fundamentals of
Corporate Finance, Eleventh Edition, has sought to recognize the curricula guidelines
detailed in the AACSB standards for business accreditation by connecting selected
questions in the test bank to the general knowledge and skill guidelines found in the
AACSB standards.
The statements contained in Fundamentals of Corporate Finance, Eleventh Edition,
are provided only as a guide for the users of this text. The AACSB leaves content cov-
erage and assessment within the purview of individual schools, the mission of the
school, and the faculty. While Fundamentals of Corporate Finance, Eleventh Edition,
and the teaching package make no claim of any specific AACSB qualification or eval-
uation, we have, within the test bank, labeled selected questions according to the six
general knowledge and skills areas.
Unique Features
What makes Fundamentals of Corporate Finance
such a powerful learning tool?
Integrated Examples
Numbered and titled examples are
integrated in each chapter. Students
can learn how to solve specific
problems step-by-step as well as gain
insight into general principles by
seeing how to approach and analyze
different problems.
Confirming Pages
spreadsheets when applying financial in functions to compute bond values and yields. They typi-
cally ask you to input both the date you buy the bond
in Excel:
=PRICE(DATE(2020,11,15), DATE(2024,11,15), .075, .03, 100, 1)
concepts. The boxes include questions
(called the settlement date) and the maturity date of the
bond. The DATE function in Excel, which we use for both the set-
The Excel function for bond value is:
that apply to the spreadsheet, and their
tlement and maturity dates, uses the format
=PRICE(settlement date, maturity date, annual coupon DATE(year,month,day). We assume the bond makes its cou-
pon payments on the 15th of each month, which is most com-
solutions are given at the end of the rate, yield to maturity, redemption value as percent of
face value, number of coupon payments per year) mon, and that it is also purchased and redeemed on the 15th.
Notice that the coupon rate and yield to maturity are
applicable chapter. These spreadsheets (If you can’t remember the formula, just remember that you
can go to the Formulas tab in Excel, and from the Financial
expressed as decimals, not percentages. In most cases,
redemption value will be 100 (i.e., 100% of face value), and
are available for download in Connect. tab pull down the PRICE function, which will prompt you for
the necessary inputs.) For our 7.5% coupon bond, we would
the resulting price will be expressed as a percent of face
value. Occasionally, however, you may encounter bonds that
enter the values shown in the spreadsheet below. pay off at a premium or discount to face value. One example
A B C D E F
1 7.5% annual 7.5% semiannual 6% annual
2 coupon bond, coupon bond, coupon bond,
3 maturing Nov 2024 Formula in column B maturing Nov 2024 30-year maturity
4
5 Settlement date 15-Nov-2020 =DATE(2020,11,15) 15-Nov-2020 15-Jan-2000
6 Maturity date 15-Nov-2024 =DATE(2024,11,15) 15-Nov 2024 15-Jan-2030
7 Annual coupon rate 0.075 0.075 0.06
8 Yield to maturity 0.03 0.03 0.04
9 Redemption value 100 100 100
(% of face value)
1,000
900
176
Finance in Practice Boxes
These are excerpts that appear in most
chapters, often from the financial
press, providing real-life illustrations
of the chapter’s topics, such as ethical
choices in finance, disputes about
stock valuation, financial planning,
and credit analysis.
Self-Test Questions
Provided in each chapter, these
helpful questions enable students to
check their understanding as they
read. Answers are worked out at the
end of each chapter.
“Beyond the Page” Interactive
Content and Applications
Additional resources and hands-on
applications are just a click away.
Students can tap or click the icons
in the e-version or use the direct
web links to learn more about key
concepts and try out calculations,
tables, and figures when they go
“Beyond the Page.”
Web Exercises
Select chapters include Web Exercises
that allow students to utilize the
Internet to apply their knowledge
and skills with real-world companies.
Minicases
Integrated minicases allow students
to apply their knowledge to relatively
complex, practical problems and
typical real-world scenarios.
Supplements
In addition to the overall refinement and improvement of the text material, considerable effort was put into develop-
ing an exceptional supplement package to provide students and instructors with an abundance of teaching and learn-
ing resources.
We take this opportunity to thank all of the individuals who helped us prepare this and previous editions. We want
to express our appreciation to those instructors whose insightful comments and suggestions were invaluable to us
during this revision.
xx
Benjamas Jirasakuldech Qianqiu Liu Steve Nenninger Thomas Rhee
Slippery Rock University of University of Hawaii–Manoa Sam Houston State University California State University–
Pennsylvania Long Beach
Sheen Liu Hazel Nguyen
Benjamas Jirasakuldech Washington State Southwestern University Jong Rhim
Slippery Rock University University–Vancouver University of Southern
Liem Nguyen
Wilson Liu Indiana
Mark Johnson Westfield State University
Loyola University Maryland James Madison University Joe Riotto
Srinivas Nippani
Scott W. Lowe New Jersey City University
Steve Johnson Texas A&M
Sam Houston State University James Madison University University–Commerce Scott Roark
Qingzhong Ma Boise State University
Daniel Jubinski Prasad Padmanabhan
Saint Joseph’s University Cornell University–Ithaca Saint Mary’s University Mukunthan Santhanakrishnan
Yulong Ma Idaho State University
Alan Jung Ohaness Paskelian
San Francisco State University California State University– University of George Sarraf
Long Beach Houston–Downtown University of California,
Ayala Kayhan
Brian Maris Riverside
Louisiana State University Jeffrey Phillips
Northern Arizona University Colby-Sawyer College Maria Schutte
Marvin Keene
Carol Mannino Michigan Technological
Coastal Carolina University Richard Ponarul
Milwaukee School of University
Eric Kelley California State
Engineering University–Chico Adam Schwartz
University of Arizona
David McGuire Washington & Lee University
Dong Man Kim Gary Porter
Central Michigan University Michael Seiler
California State University– John Carroll University
Jinghan Meng College of William & Mary
San Bernardino Eric Powers
University of North John Settle
Jullavut Kittiakarasakun University of South
Carolina–Chapel Hill Portland State University
University of Texas at San Carolina
Antonio Jose Mercardo Michael G. Sher
Ronald Prange
University of Central Metropolitan State
Ladd Kochman Western Michigan
Missouri University
Kennesaw State University University
Paulo Miranda Henry Silverman
David Kuipers Purdue University–Calumet Robert Puelz
University of Missouri– Southern Methodist Roosevelt University
Hammond
Kansas City University Elena Skouratova
Derek Mohr Concordia University Texas
Mark Lane State University of New York Sunder Raghavan
Hawaii Pacific at Buffalo Embry-Riddle University Richard Smith
University–Honolulu Vedpauri Raghavan University of California,
Helen Moser
Embry-Riddle University– Riverside
Linda Lange University of Minnesota–
Regis University Minneapolis Daytona Beach Ahmad Sohrabian
Ganas K. Rakes University of California,
Doug Letsch Tammie Mosley
Ohio University Irvine
Walden University California State University–
East Bay Mahdi Rastad Ron Spicer
Paul Lewandowski
Colorado Tech University
Saginaw Valley State David Murphy California Polytechnic State
University Saginaw Valley State University Roberto Stein
University Adam Reed Tulane University
Yuming Li
California State Vivian Nazar University of North Clifford Stephens
University–Fullerton Ferris State University Carolina–Chapel Hill Louisiana State University
xxi
Tom Strickland Michael Toyne Qiang Wu Athena Zhang
Middle Tennessee State Northeastern State Rensselaer Polytechnic California State
University University University University–Chico
Jan Strockis James Turner Patricia Wynn Shaorong Zhang
Santa Clara University Weber State University University of North Texas Marshall University
at Dallas
Mark Stohs Bonnie Van Ness Yilei Zhang
California State University University of Mississippi David Yamoah University of North Dakota
Fullerton Kean University
J. Douglas Van Ness Yiling Zhang
Joseph Tanimura Columbia University Fred Yeager University of Texas–
San Diego State University St. Louis University Arlington
Joe Walker
Steve Tokar University of Woongsun Yoo Zhong-Guo Zhou
University of Indianapolis Alabama–Birmingham Saginaw Valley State California State
University University–Northridge
Damir Tokic Kenneth Washer
University of Texas A&M Kevin Yost Zi Jia
Houston–Downtown University–Commerce Auburn University University of Arkansas at
Kudret Topyan Little Rock
K. Matthew Wong Emilio R. Zarruk
Manhattan College St. John’s University Florida Atlantic University
In addition, we would like to thank Nicholas Racculia, Ph.D., for his help with revisions and updates to our
instructor materials and online content in Connect. His efforts are much appreciated as they will help both students
and instructors. We also appreciate help from Aleijda de Cazenove Balsan and Malcolm Taylor.
We are grateful to the talented staff at McGraw Hill, especially Allison McCabe-Carroll, Senior Product
Developer; Chuck Synovec, Director, Finance; Kevin Moran, Director, Digital Content; Fran Simon and Bruce Gin,
Content Project Managers; Laurie Entringer, Designer; and Trina Mauer, Senior Marketing Manager.
Finally, as was the case with the last ten editions, we cannot overstate the thanks due to our families.
Richard A. Brealey
Stewart C. Myers
Alan J. Marcus
xxii
Contents in Brief
Part Three 11 Introduction to Risk, Return, and the Opportunity Cost of Capital 330
Risk 12 Risk, Return, and Capital Budgeting 360
13 The Weighted-Average Cost of Capital and Company Valuation 392
xxiii
Contents
Chapter 1 Chapter 3
Goals and Governance of the Corporation 2 Accounting and Finance 56
1.1 Investment and Financing Decisions 4 3.1 The Balance Sheet 58
The Investment (Capital Budgeting) Decision 6 Book Values and Market Values 61
The Financing Decision 6 3.2 The Income Statement 63
1.2 What Is a Corporation? 8 Income versus Cash Flow 64
Other Forms of Business Organization 9 3.3 The Statement of Cash Flows 67
1.3 Who Is the Financial Manager? 10 Free Cash Flow 69
1.4 Goals of the Corporation 12 3.4 Accounting Practice and Malpractice 70
Shareholders Want Managers to Maximize Market Value 12 3.5 Taxes 73
1.5 Agency Problems, Executive Compensation, Corporate Tax 73
and Corporate Governance 15 Personal Tax 74
Executive Compensation 16
Summary 75
Corporate Governance 17
Questions and Problems 76
1.6 The Ethics of Maximizing Value 18
1.7 Careers in Finance 20 Chapter 4
1.8 Preview of Coming Attractions 22 Measuring Corporate Performance 86
1.9 Snippets of Financial History 23 4.1 How Financial Ratios Relate to Shareholder
Summary 25 Value 88
Questions and Problems 26 4.2 Measuring Market Value and Market Value
Added 89
Chapter 2 4.3 Economic Value Added and Accounting
Rates of Return 91
Financial Markets and Institutions 32
Accounting Rates of Return 93
2.1 The Importance of Financial Markets
Problems with EVA and Accounting Rates of Return 95
and Institutions 34
2.2 The Flow of Savings to Corporations 35 4.4 Measuring Efficiency 96
Summary 51
Questions and Problems 52
xxv
xxvi Contents
Chapter 5 Chapter 7
The Time Value of Money 118 Valuing Stocks 192
5.1 Future Values and Compound Interest 120 7.1 Stocks and the Stock Market 194
5.2 Present Values 123 Reading Stock Market Listings 195
Finding the Interest Rate 127 7.2 Market Values, Book Values, and
5.3 Multiple Cash Flows 128 Liquidation Values 197
Future Value of Multiple Cash Flows 128 7.3 Valuing Common Stocks 199
Present Value of Multiple Cash Flows 129 Valuation by Comparables 199
5.4 Reducing the Chore of the Calculations: Part 1 131 Price and Intrinsic Value 200
Using Financial Calculators to Solve Simple The Dividend Discount Model 202
Time-Value-of-Money Problems 131 7.4 Simplifying the Dividend Discount Model 205
Using Spreadsheets to Solve Simple Case 1: The Dividend Discount Model with No Growth 205
Time-Value-of-Money Problems 132 Case 2: The Dividend Discount Model with Constant
5.5 Level Cash Flows: Perpetuities and Annuities 135 Growth 205
How to Value Perpetuities 135 Case 3: The Dividend Discount Model
How to Value Annuities 136 with Nonconstant Growth 210
Future Value of an Annuity 140 7.5 Valuing a Business by Discounted Cash Flow 214
Annuities Due 143 Valuing the Concatenator Business 214
5.6 Reducing the Chore of the Calculations: Part 2 144 Repurchases and the Dividend Discount Model 215
Using Financial Calculators to Solve Annuity Problems 144 7.6 There Are No Free Lunches on Wall Street 216
Using Spreadsheets to Solve Annuity Problems 145 Random Walks and Efficient Markets 217
5.7 Effective Annual Interest Rates 145 7.7 Market Anomalies and Behavioral Finance 220
5.8 Inflation and the Time Value of Money 147 Market Anomalies 220
Real versus Nominal Cash Flows 147 Bubbles and Market Efficiency 222
8.5 More Mutually Exclusive Projects 252 Calculating the NPV of Blooper’s Mine 283
Problem 1: The Investment Timing Decision 253 Further Notes and Wrinkles Arising from Blooper’s Project 284
Problem 2: The Choice between Long- and Short-Lived
Summary 289
Equipment 254
Questions and Problems 290
Problem 3: When to Replace an Old Machine 256
Minicase 298
8.6 A Last Look 257
Summary 258
Questions and Problems 259 Chapter 10
Minicase 266 Project Analysis 300
Appendix: More on the IRR Rule 267 10.1 The Capital Investment Process, Some Problems,
Using the IRR to Choose between Mutually Exclusive and Some Solutions 302
Projects 267
10.2 Some “What-If” Questions 304
Using the Modified Internal Rate of Return When
Sensitivity Analysis 305
There Are Multiple IRRs 267
Stress Tests and Scenario Analysis 308
10.3 Break-Even Analysis 309
Chapter 9
Accounting Break-Even Analysis 310
Using Discounted Cash-Flow Analysis to Make NPV Break-Even Analysis 311
Investment Decisions 270
Operating Leverage 314
9.1 Identifying Cash Flows 272
10.4 Real Options and the Value of Flexibility 316
Discount Cash Flows, Not Profits 272
The Option to Expand 316
Discount Incremental Cash Flows 274
A Second Real Option: The Option to Abandon 318
Discount Nominal Cash Flows by the Nominal
Cost of Capital 277 A Third Real Option: The Timing Option 318
Separate Investment and Financing Decisions 278 A Fourth Real Option: Flexible Production Facilities 319
12.3 Risk and Return 371 The NPV of Geothermal’s Expansion 400
Why the CAPM Makes Sense 373 Checking Our Logic 401
The Security Market Line 374 13.3 Interpreting the Weighted-Average Cost of Capital 402
Using the CAPM to Estimate Expected Returns 375 When You Can and Can’t Use WACC 402
How Well Does the CAPM Work? 376 Some Common Mistakes 402
12.4 The CAPM and the Opportunity Cost of Capital 379 How Changing Capital Structure Affects Expected
The Company Cost of Capital 380 Returns 403
What Determines Project Risk? 381 What Happens When the Corporate Tax Rate Is
Not Zero 403
Don’t Add Fudge Factors to Discount Rates 381
13.4 Practical Problems: Measuring Capital Structure 403
Summary 382 13.5 More Practical Problems: Estimating
Questions and Problems 383 Expected Returns 405
The Expected Return on Bonds 405
Chapter 13 The Expected Return on Common Stock 406
The Weighted-Average Cost of Capital and The Expected Return on Preferred Stock 407
Company Valuation 392 Adding It All Up 408
13.1 Geothermal’s Cost of Capital 394 Real-Company WACCs 408
13.2 The Weighted-Average Cost of Capital 395 13.6 Valuing Entire Businesses 409
Calculating Company Cost of Capital Calculating the Value of the Deconstruction Business 410
as a Weighted Average 396
Use Market Weights, Not Book Weights 398 Summary 411
Taxes and the Weighted-Average Cost of Capital 398 Questions and Problems 412
What If There Are Three (or More) Minicase 417
Sources of Financing? 400
Chapter 14 Chapter 15
Introduction to Corporate Financing 420 How Corporations Raise Venture Capital
14.1 Creating Value with Financing Decisions 422 and Issue Securities 440
14.2 Patterns of Corporate Financing 422 15.1 Venture Capital 442
Are Firms Issuing Too Much Debt? 424 Venture Capital Companies 443
14.3 Common Stock 425 15.2 The Initial Public Offering 444
Stock Splits 427 Arranging a Public Issue 445
The Wall Street Walk 429 15.3 General Cash Offers by Public Companies 451
Classes of Stock 429 General Cash Offers and Shelf Registration 452
14.4 Preferred Stock 429 Costs of the General Cash Offer 452
Market Reaction to Stock Issues 453
14.5 Corporate Debt 431
Debt Comes in Many Forms 431 15.4 The Private Placement 454
Innovation in the Debt Market 434 Summary 454
14.6 Convertible Securities 435 Questions and Problems 455
Minicase 460
Summary 436
Appendix: Hotch Pot’s New-Issue Prospectus 461
Questions and Problems 437
Contents xxix
Summary 491
Questions and Problems 492
Chapter 18 Chapter 19
Long-Term Financial Planning 526 Short-Term Financial Planning 550
18.1 What Is Financial Planning? 528 19.1 Links between Long-Term and Short-Term Financing 552
Why Build Financial Plans? 528 Tax Strategies 553
18.2 Financial Planning Models 529 Reasons to Hold Cash 553
Components of a Financial Planning Model 529 19.2 Tracing Changes in Cash 554
18.3 A Long-Term Financial Planning Model 19.3 Cash Budgeting 556
for Dynamic Mattress 530 Preparing the Cash Budget 556
Pitfalls in Model Design 535 19.4 Dynamic’s Short-Term Financial Plan 559
Choosing a Plan 536 Dynamic Mattress’s Financing Plan 559
Valuing Dynamic Mattress 537 Evaluating the Plan 560
18.4 External Financing and Growth 538 A Note on Short-Term Financial Planning Models 561
Summary 682
Questions and Problems 683
Net Present Value (Chapter 5) 714 How Can We Explain Merger Waves? 719
Risk and Return (Chapters 11 and 12) 714 What Is the Value of Liquidity? 719
Efficient Capital Markets (Chapter 7) 715 Why Are Financial Systems Prone to Crisis? 720
MM’s Irrelevance Propositions (Chapters 16 and 17) 715 What Should Be the Goals of the Corporation? 720
Goals and
1 Governance of
the Corporation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
R E L AT E D W E B S I T E S F O R T H I S C H A P T E R C A N B E
F O U N D I N C O N N E C T.
2
PA R T O N E
Introduction
To grow from small beginnings to a major corporation, FedEx needed to make good investment and financing decisions.
Sundry Photography/Getty Images
T
o carry on business, a corporation needs an value. Financial managers add value whenever the cor-
almost endless variety of assets. Some assets are poration can invest to earn a higher return than its share-
tangible, for example, plant and machinery, office holders can earn for themselves.
buildings, and vehicles; others are intangible, for exam- But managers are human beings, not perfect servants
ple, brand names and patents. Corporations finance who always and everywhere maximize value. We will con-
these assets by borrowing, by reinvesting profits back sider the conflicts of interest that arise in large corpora-
into the firm, and by selling additional shares to the tions and how corporate governance helps to align the
firm’s shareholders. interests of managers and shareholders.
Financial managers, therefore, face two broad ques- If we ask managers to maximize value, can the corpo-
tions. First, what investments should the corporation ration also be a good citizen? Won’t the managers be
make? Second, how should it pay for these investments? tempted to try unethical or illegal financial tricks? They
Investment decisions spend money. Financing decisions sometimes may be tempted, but wise managers realize
raise money for investment. that such tricks are not just dishonest; they almost
We start this chapter with examples of recent invest- always destroy value, not increase it. More challeng-
ment and financing decisions by major U.S. and foreign ing for the financial manager are the gray areas where
corporations. We review what a corporation is and the line between ethical and unethical financial actions
describe the roles of its top financial managers. We then is hard to draw.
turn to the financial goal of the corporation, which is usu- Finally, we look ahead to the rest of this book and look
ally expressed as maximizing value, or at least adding back to some entertaining snippets of financial history.
3
4 Part One Introduction
1
Legend has it that Smith received a grade of C on this paper. In fact, he doesn’t remember the grade.
Chapter 1 Goals and Governance of the Corporation 5
How many operations hubs should it build? What computer and tracking systems were
necessary to keep up with the increasing package volume and geographic coverage?
Which companies should it acquire as it expanded its range of services?
FedEx also needed to make good financing decisions. For example, how should it
raise the money it needed for investment? In the beginning, these choices were limited
to family money and bank loans. As the company grew, its range of choices expanded.
Eventually it was able to attract funding from venture capitalists, but this posed new
questions. How much cash did the firm need to raise from the venture capitalists? How
big a share in the firm would the venture capitalists demand in return? The initial
public offering of stock prompted similar questions. How many shares should the
company try to sell? At what price? As the company grew, it raised more funds by bor-
rowing money from its banks and by selling publicly traded bonds to investors. At
each point, it needed to decide on the proper form and terms of financing as well as the
amounts to be raised.
In short, FedEx needed to be good at finance. It had a head start over potential com-
petitors, but a series of bad financial decisions would have sunk the company. No two
companies’ histories are the same, but, like FedEx, all successful companies must
make good investment and financing decisions. And, as with FedEx, those decisions
range from prosaic and obvious to difficult and strategically crucial.
Let’s widen our discussion. Table 1.1 gives an example of a recent investment and
financing decision for 10 corporations. Five are U.S. corporations and five are foreign.
We have chosen very large public corporations that you are likely to be familiar with.
You may have shopped at Walmart, posted a picture on Facebook, or bought a Lenovo
computer.
Take a look at the decisions now. We think you will agree that they appear sensible—
at least there is nothing obviously wrong with them. But if you are new to finance, it
may be difficult to think about why these companies made these decisions and not
others.
TABLE 1.1 Examples of recent investment and financing decisions by major public corporations.
2
LVMH (Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton) markets perfumes and cosmetics, wines and spirits, leather goods,
watches, and other luxury products. And, yes, we know what you are thinking, but “LVMH” really is short for
“Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton.”
6 Part One Introduction
the bank can force the firm into bankruptcy and stake a claim on its real assets. Finan-
cial assets that can be purchased and traded by investors in public markets are called
securities. The shares of stock issued by the public corporations in Table 1.1 are all
securities. Union Pacific’s 10-year bond in Table 1.1 also is a security. But a bank
loan from JPMorgan to Union Pacific would not be called a security.
The firm can issue an almost endless variety of financial assets. Suppose it decides
to borrow. It can issue debt to investors, or it can borrow from a bank. It can borrow for
1 year or 20 years. If it borrows for 20 years, it can reserve the right to pay off the debt
early. It can borrow in Paris, receiving and promising to repay euros, or it can borrow
dollars in New York. (As Table 1.1 shows, LVMH planned to borrow euros, but it
could have borrowed U.S. dollars or British pounds instead.)
In some ways, financing decisions are less important than investment decisions.
Financial managers say that “value comes mainly from the investment side of the bal-
ance sheet.” Also, the most successful corporations sometimes have the simplest
financing strategies. Take Microsoft as an example. It is one of the world’s most valu-
able corporations. In early 2021, Microsoft shares traded for $230 each. There were
7.56 billion shares outstanding. Therefore Microsoft’s market value—its market
capitalization or market cap—was $230 × 7.56 = $1,739 billion. Where did this market
value come from? It came from Microsoft’s products, from its brand name and world-
wide customer base, from its R&D, and from its ability to make profitable future
investments. It did not come from sophisticated financing. Microsoft’s financing
strategy is very simple: It finances almost all investment by retaining and reinvesting
operating cash flow.
Financing decisions may not add much value compared to good investment deci-
sions, but they can destroy value if they are stupid or ambushed by bad news. For
example, when a consortium of investment companies bought the energy giant TXU
in 2007, the company took on an additional $40 billion in debt. This may not have
been a stupid decision, but it did prove fatal. The consortium did not foresee the expan-
sion of shale gas production and the resulting sharp fall in natural gas and electricity
prices. By April 2014 the company (renamed Energy Future Holdings) was bankrupt.
1.1 Self-Test
Are the following capital budgeting or financing decisions? (Hint: In one case the
answer is “both.”)
a. Intel decides to spend $7 billion to develop a new microprocessor factory.
b. BMW borrows 350 million euros (€350 million) from Deutsche Bank.
c. Chevron constructs a pipeline to bring natural gas onshore from a production
platform in Australia.
d. Avon spends €200 million to launch a new range of cosmetics in European
markets.
e. Pfizer issues new shares to buy a small biotech company.
that its customers pay on time. Corporations that operate internationally must con-
stantly transfer cash from one currency to another. And the manager must keep an eye
on the risks that the firm runs and ensure that they don’t land the firm in a pickle.
1.2 Self-Test
Which of the following are financial assets, and which are real assets?
a. A patent.
b. A share of stock issued by Wells Fargo Bank.
c. A blast furnace in a steelmaking factory.
d. A mortgage loan taken out to help pay for a new home.
e. After a successful advertising campaign, potential customers trust FedEx to
deliver packages promptly and reliably.
f. An IOU (“I owe you”) from your brother-in-law.
3
In the United States, corporations are identified by the label “Corporation,” “Incorporated,” or “Inc.,” as in
Caterpillar Inc. The United Kingdom identifies public corporations by “plc” (short for “Public Limited Corpo-
ration”). French corporations have the suffix “SA” (“Société Anonyme”). The corresponding labels in Germany
are “GmbH” (“Gesellschaft mit beschränkter Haftung”) and “AG” (“Aktiengesellschaft”).
4
“Shareholder” and “stockholder” mean exactly the same thing and are used interchangeably.
Chapter 1 Goals and Governance of the Corporation 9
that you raise cash by selling other assets—your car or house, for example—in order to repay
the loan. But if you incorporate the restaurant business, and then the corporation borrows
from the bank, your other assets are shielded from the restaurant’s debts. Of course, incor-
poration also means that the bank will be more cautious in lending to you because it will
have no recourse to your other assets.5
Notice that if you incorporate your business, you exchange direct ownership of its real
assets (the building, kitchen equipment, etc.) for indirect ownership via financial assets (the
shares of the new corporation). ■
corporation if you want to take the trouble. But most corporations are larger businesses
or businesses that aspire to grow. Small “mom-and-pop” businesses are usually orga-
nized as sole proprietorships.
What about the middle ground? What about businesses that grow too large for sole
proprietorships but don’t want to reorganize as corporations? For example, suppose
you wish to pool money and expertise with some friends or business associates. You
can form a partnership and enter into a partnership agreement that sets out how deci-
sions are to be made and how profits are to be split up. Partners, like sole proprietors,
face unlimited liability. If the business runs into difficulties, each partner can be held
responsible for all the business’s debts. However, partnerships have a tax advantage.
Partnerships, unlike corporations, do not have to pay income taxes. The partners pay
personal income taxes on their shares of the profits.
Some businesses are hybrids that combine the tax advantage of a partnership with
the limited liability advantage of a corporation. In a limited partnership, partners are
classified as general or limited. General partners manage the business and have unlim-
ited personal liability for its debts. Limited partners are liable only for the money they
invest and do not participate in management.
Many states allow limited liability partnerships (LLPs) or limited liability compa-
nies (LLCs). These are partnerships in which all partners have limited liability. Another
variation on the theme is the professional corporation (PC), which is commonly used
by doctors, lawyers, and accountants. In this case, the business has limited liability,
but the professionals can still be sued personally, for example, for malpractice.
Most large investment banks such as Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs started
life as partnerships. But eventually these companies and their financing requirements
grew too large for them to continue as partnerships, and they reorganized as corpora-
tions. The partnership form of organization does not work well when ownership is
widespread and separation of ownership and management is essential.
Treasurer Controller
Responsible for: Responsible for:
Cash management Preparation of financial statements
Raising of capital Accounting
Banking relationships Taxes
Chapter 1 Goals and Governance of the Corporation 11
treasurer Below the CFO are usually a treasurer and a controller. The treasurer looks after
Responsible for financing, the firm’s cash, raises new capital, and maintains relationships with banks and investors
cash management, and that hold the firm’s securities. The controller prepares the financial statements, manages
relationships with banks the firm’s internal budgets and accounting, and looks after its tax affairs. Thus, the
and other financial
treasurer’s main function is to obtain and manage the firm’s capital, whereas the con-
institutions.
troller ensures that the money is used efficiently.
controller
Responsible for budgeting,
accounting, and taxes.
1.3 Self-Test
BEYOND THE PAGE Fritz and Frieda went to business school together 10 years ago. They have just
been hired by a midsize corporation that wants to bring in new financial manag-
The financial ers. Fritz studied finance, with an emphasis on financial markets and institutions.
managers Frieda majored in accounting and became a CPA five years ago. Who is more
suited to be treasurer and who controller? Briefly explain.
www.mhhe.com/brealey11e
In large corporations, financial managers are responsible for organizing and super-
vising the capital budgeting process. However, major capital investment projects are
so closely tied to plans for product development, production, and marketing that man-
agers from these other areas are inevitably drawn into planning and analyzing the proj-
ects. If the firm has staff members specializing in corporate planning, they are naturally
involved in capital budgeting too. For this reason, we will use the term financial man-
ager to refer to anyone responsible for an investment or financing decision. Often we
will use the term collectively for all the managers drawn into such decisions.
Now let’s go beyond job titles. What is the essential role of the financial manager?
Figure 1.2 gives one answer. The figure traces how money flows from investors to the
corporation and back again to investors. The flow starts when cash is raised from
investors (arrow 1 in the figure). The cash could come from banks or from securities
sold to investors in financial markets. The cash is then used to pay for the real assets
(investment projects) needed for the corporation’s business (arrow 2). Later, as the
business operates, the assets generate cash inflows (arrow 3). That cash is either rein-
vested (arrow 4a) or returned to the investors who furnished the money in the first
place (arrow 4b). Of course, the choice between arrows 4a and 4b is constrained by the
promises made when cash was raised at arrow 1. For example, if the firm borrows
money from a bank at arrow 1, it must repay this money plus interest at arrow 4b.
You can see examples of arrows 4a and 4b in Table 1.1. Glaxo partly financed its
investments in R&D by reinvesting earnings (arrow 4a). Procter & Gamble decided to
return cash to shareholders by buying back its stock (arrow 4b). It could have chosen
instead to pay the money out as additional cash dividends, also on arrow 4b.
Notice how the financial manager stands between the firm and outside investors. On
the one hand, the financial manager is involved in the firm’s operations, particularly by
helping to make good investment decisions. On the other hand, he or she deals with
financial institutions and other investors and with financial markets such as the New
York Stock Exchange. We say more about these financial institutions and markets in
the next chapter.
The same principles apply to the timing of a corporation’s cash flows, as the follow-
ing Self-Test illustrates.
1.4 Self-Test
Rhonda and Reggie Hotspur are working hard to save for their children’s college
education. They don’t need more cash for current consumption but will face big
tuition bills in 2031. Should they therefore avoid investing in stocks that pay
generous current cash dividends? (Hint: Are they required to spend the divi-
dends on current consumption?) Explain briefly.
Sometimes you hear managers speak as if the corporation has other goals. For
example, they may say that their job is to “maximize profits.” That sounds reasonable.
After all, don’t shareholders want their company to be profitable? But taken literally,
profit maximization is not a well-defined corporate objective. Here are two reasons:
1. Maximize profits? Which year’s profits? A corporation may be able to increase
current profits by cutting back on outlays for maintenance or staff training, but that
will not add value unless the outlays were wasteful in the first place. Shareholders
will not welcome higher short-term profits if long-term profits are damaged.
2. A company may be able to increase future profits by cutting this year’s dividend
and investing the freed-up cash in the firm. That is not in the shareholders’ best
interest if the company earns only a very low rate of return on the extra investment.
Maximizing—or at least maintaining—value is necessary for the long-run survival of
the corporation. Suppose, for example, that its managers forget about value and decide
that the only goal is to increase the market share of its products. So the managers cut
prices aggressively to attract new customers, even when this leads to continuing losses.
As losses mount, the corporation finds it more and more difficult to borrow money and
sooner or later cannot pay existing debts. Nor can it raise new equity financing if share-
holders see that new equity investment will follow previous investments down the drain.
This firm’s managers would probably pay the price for this business misjudgment.
For example, outside investors would see an opportunity for easy money. They could
buy the firm from its current shareholders, toss out the managers, and reemphasize
value rather than market share. The investors would profit from the increase in value
under new management.
Managers who pursue goals that destroy value often end in early retirement—another
reason that the natural financial goal of the corporation is to maximize market value.
We don’t want to leave the impression that value maximization justifies ruthless
and unethical behavior. It does not. Moreover, in most circumstances, ethical behavior
can be value maximizing because it serves to cement the firm’s reputation as both a
trustworthy purveyor of goods as well as a decent employer. We will return to this
issue later in the chapter.
The Investment Trade-Off Okay, let’s take the objective as maximizing market
value, or at least adding market value. But why do some investments increase market
value, while others reduce it? The answer is given by Figure 1.3, which sets out the
fundamental trade-off for corporate investment decisions. The corporation has a pro-
posed investment project (the purchase of a real asset). Suppose it has sufficient cash
on hand to finance the project. The financial manager is trying to decide whether to go
ahead. If he or she decides not to invest, the corporation can pay out the cash to share-
holders, say as an extra dividend. (The investment and dividend arrows in Figure 1.3
are arrows 2 and 4b in Figure 1.2.)
Assume that the financial manager is acting in the interests of the corporation’s
owners, its stockholders. What do these stockholders want the financial manager
14 Part One Introduction
to do? The answer depends on the rate of return on the investment project and on the
rate of return that stockholders can earn by investing in financial markets. If the return
offered by the investment project is higher than the rate of return that shareholders can
get by investing on their own, then the shareholders would vote for the investment
project. If the investment project offers a lower return than shareholders can achieve
on their own, the shareholders would vote to cancel the project and take the cash
instead.
Perhaps the investment project in Figure 1.3 is a proposal for Tesla to launch a new
electric car. Suppose Tesla has set aside cash to launch the new model in 2025. It could
go ahead with the launch, or it could cancel the investment and instead pay the cash
out to its stockholders.
Suppose that Tesla’s new project is just about as risky as the stock market and that
investment in the stock market offers a 10% expected rate of return. If the new project
offers a superior rate of return, say 20%, then the stockholders would be happy to let
the company keep the cash and invest it in the new model. If the project offers only a
5% return, then the stockholders are better off with the cash and without the new
project; in that case, the financial manager should turn down the project.
As long as a corporation’s proposed investments offer higher rates of return than its
shareholders can earn for themselves in the stock market (or in other financial markets),
its shareholders will applaud the investments and the market value of the firm will
increase. But if the company earns an inferior return, shareholders are despondent, the
stock price falls, and stockholders clamor to get their money back so that they can
invest on their own.
In our example, the minimum acceptable rate of return on Tesla’s new project is
opportunity cost of capital 10%. This minimum rate of return is called the hurdle rate or opportunity cost of
The minimum acceptable capital. It is called an opportunity cost of capital because it depends on the alternative
rate of return on capital investment opportunities available to shareholders in financial markets. Whenever a
investment set by the corporation invests cash in a new project, its shareholders lose the opportunity to
investment opportunities invest the cash on their own. Corporations increase value by accepting investment
available to shareholders
projects that earn more than the opportunity cost of capital.
in financial markets.
Figure 1.3, which compares rates of return on investment projects with the opportu-
nity cost of capital, illustrates a general principle: A corporation should direct cash to
investments that offer a higher return than shareholders could earn for themselves.7
7
We have mentioned 5% or 20% as possible future rates of return on Tesla’s project. We will see in Chapter 8
that future rates of return are sometimes difficult to calculate and interpret. The general principle always holds,
however. In Chapters 8 and 9 we show you how to apply the principle by calculating the net present value
(NPV) of investment projects.
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
we’ve got the right one, anyhow. This bird don’t look to me like a
feller who would do a girl a meanness.”
“Hmp! You always was soft in the head, Burt,” his companion
grunted.
But he left his prisoner in peace after that. Burt had said one true
word. Clint Reed would not want a half-dead hobo dragged to the
Diamond Bar K. He would prefer one that he could punish himself.
Tug plodded through the fine white dust that lay inches deep on the
road. A cloud of it moved with them, for the horses kicked it up at
every step until they ascended from the valley into the hills. The man
who walked did not have the reserve of strength that had been his
before he had gone to the hospital. There had been a time when he
could go all day and ask for more, but he could not do it now. He
stumbled as he dragged his feet along the trail.
They reached the summit of the pass and looked down on the
Diamond Bar K. Its fenced domain was a patchwork of green and
gold with a background of pineclad ridges. The green patches were
fields of alfalfa, the gold squares were grain ripe for the mower.
Downhill the going was easier. But by the time the horsemen and
their prisoner drew up to the ranch house, Tug was pretty well
exhausted.
While Dusty went in to get Reed, the tramp sat on the floor of the
porch and leaned against a pillar, his eyes closed. He had a
ridiculous feeling that if he let go of himself he would faint.
CHAPTER VI
“NOTHING BUT A GAY-CAT ANYHOW”
The advancing dust cloud rose from a little group of horses and men.
Some of the latter were riding. Others were afoot.
“Lon’s caught them,” said Betty. “I’m sorry.”
“Not so sorry as they’ll be,” returned the ragged youth grimly.
The foreman swung heavily from his horse. Though he was all
muscle and bone, he did not carry his two hundred pounds
gracefully.
“We got the birds all right, Miss Betty, even if they were hittin’ the trail
right lively,” he called to the girl, an ominous grin on his leathery
face. “I guess they’d figured out this wasn’t no healthy climate for
them.” He added, with a swift reversion to business, “Where’s yore
paw?”
“Not back yet. What’ll he do with them, Lon?” the girl asked, her
voice low and troubled.
Distressed in soul, she was looking for comfort. The big foreman
gave her none.
“He’ll do a plenty. You don’t need to worry about that. We aim to
keep this country safe for our womenfolks.”
“Oh, I wish he wouldn’t. I wish he’d let them go,” she said, almost in
a wail.
“He won’t. Clint ain’t that soft.” Forbes stared at the disreputable
vagrant standing beside Betty. “What’s he doing here?”
“Dusty dragged him back. That’s all the sense he has.”
Lon spoke just as though the vagrant were not present. “Lucky for
him he’s got an alibi this time.”
“Is it necessary to insult him after he protected me?” the girl
demanded, eyes flashing. “I’m ashamed of you, Lon.”
He was taken aback. “I reckon it takes more’n that to insult a hobo.”
“Is a man a hobo because he’s looking for work?”
The foreman’s hard gaze took in the man, his white face and soft
hands. “What would he do if he found it?” he asked bluntly.
“You’ve no right to say that,” she flung back. “I think it’s hateful the
way you’re all acting. I tell you he fought for me—after what Father
did to him.”
“Fought for you?” This was news to Lon. His assumption had been
that the young fellow had merely entered a formal protest in order to
clear himself in case retribution followed. “You mean with his fists?”
“Yes—against the thin-faced one. He thrashed him and put me on
my horse and started me home. Then Dusty ropes him and drags
him here on the ground and you come and insult him. He must think
we’re a grateful lot.”
As they looked at the slim, vital girl confronting him with such
passionate and feminine ferocity, the eyes of the foreman softened.
All her life she had been a part of his. He had held her on his knee, a
crowing baby, while her dimpled fingers clung to his rough coat or
explored his unshaven face. He had fished her out of an irrigation
ditch when she was three. He had driven her to school when for the
first time she started on that great adventure. It had been under his
direction that she had learned to ride, to fish, to shoot. He loved her
as though she had been flesh of his flesh and blood of his blood. It
was a delight to him to be bullied by her and to serve her whims.
“I renig,” he said. “Clint never told me the boy done that. I had it
doped out he was just savin’ his own hide. But I’ll take it all back if
it’s like you say. Shake, son.”
The tramp did not refuse to grip the big brown hand thrust at him.
Nor did he accept the proffered alliance. By a fraction of a second he
forestalled the foreman by stooping to knot a broken lace in one of
the gaping shoes.
Cig, who had been edging closer, gave Tug a rancorous look. “I ain’t
forgettin’ this,” he promised. “I’ll get youse good some day for rappin’
on me.”
“He didn’t tell on you. Some of my men brought him here in the
gather like we did you,” Forbes explained.
“Wot’ell youse givin’ me? He rapped. That’s wot he done, the big
stiff. An’ I’ll soitainly get him right for it.”
“That kind of talk ain’t helpin’ you any,” the foreman said. “If you got
any sense, you’ll shut yore trap an’ take what’s comin’.”
“I’ll take it. Don’t youse worry about that. You’d better kill me while
youse are on the job, for I’ll get you, too, sure as I’m a mont’ old.”
Reed drove up in the old car he used for a runabout. He killed the
engine, stepped down, and came up to the group by the porch.
“See you rounded ’em up, Lon.”
“Yep. Found ’em in the cottonwoods acrost the track at Wild Horse.”
The ranchman’s dominant eyes found Tug. “Howcome you here?” he
asked.
The gay-cat looked at him in sullen, resentful silence. The man’s
manner stirred up in the tramp a flare of opposition.
“Dusty brought him here. I want to tell you about that, Dad,” the girl
said.
“Later.” He turned to Tug. “I want a talk with you—got a proposition
to make you. See you later.”
“Not if I see you first,” the ragged nomad replied insolently. “I never
did like bullies.”
The ranchman flushed angrily, but he put a curb on his temper. He
could not afford to indulge it since he was so much in this youth’s
debt. Abruptly he turned away.
“Bring the other two to the barn,” he ordered Forbes. “We’ll have a
settlement there.”
York shuffled forward, in a torment of fear. “See here, mister. I ain’t
got a thing to do with this. Honest to Gawd, I ain’t. Ask Tug. Ask the
young lady. I got respeck for women, I have. You wouldn’t do dirt to
an old ’bo wot never done you no harm, would you, boss?”
His voice was a whine. The big gross man was on the verge of
blubbering. He seemed ready to fall on his knees.
“It’s true, Dad. He didn’t touch me,” Betty said in a low voice to her
father.
“Stood by, didn’t he? Never lifted a hand for you.”
“Yes, but—”
“You go into the house. Leave him to me,” ordered Reed. “Keep this
young man here till I come back.”
Betty knew when words were useless with her father. She turned
away and walked to the porch.
The cowpunchers with their prisoners moved toward the barn. York,
ululating woe, had to be dragged.
Left alone with the tramp called Tug, Betty turned to him a face of
dread. “Let’s go into the house,” she said drearily.
“You’d better go in. I’m taking the road now,” he said in answer.
“But Father wants to see you. If you’ll wait just a little—”
“I have no business with him. I don’t care to see him, now or any
time.” His voice was cold and hard. “Thank you for the lemonade,
Miss Reed. I’ll say good-bye.”
He did not offer his hand, but as he turned away he bowed.
There was nothing more for Betty to say except “Good-bye.”
In a small voice of distress she murmured it.
Her eyes followed him as far as the road. A sound from the barn
drove her into the house, to her room, where she could cover her
ears with the palms of her small brown hands.
She did not want to hear any echo of what was taking place there.
CHAPTER VIII
A RIFT IN THE LUTE
In the cool of the evening Justin Merrick drove down from the
Sweetwater Dam to the Diamond Bar K ranch. It was characteristic
of him that his runabout was up to date and in perfect condition. He
had an expensive taste in the accessories of life, and he either got
the best or did without.
Hands and face were tanned from exposure to the burning sun of the
Rockies, but he was smooth-shaven and immaculate in the
engineer’s suit which fitted his strong, heavy-set figure so snugly.
He drove with precision, as he did everything else in his well-ordered
life. There was in his strength no quality of impatience or turbulence.
He knew what he wanted and how to get it. That was why he had
traveled so far on the road to success and would go a great way
farther.
To-night he anticipated two pleasant hours with Betty Reed. He
would tell her about the work and how it was getting along, his
difficulties with the sand formation at the head gates and how he was
surmounting them. Even before she spoke, he would know from her
eager eyes that she was giving him the admiration due a successful
man from his sweetheart.
Afterward he would pass to more direct and personal love-making,
which she would evade if possible or accept shyly and reluctantly.
She was wearing his ring, but he doubted whether he had really
stormed the inner fortress of her heart. This uncertainty, and the
assurance that went with it of a precious gift not for the first chance
comer, appealed to his fastidious instinct, all the more that he was
sure she would some day come to him with shining eyes and
outstretched hands.
To-night Merrick found Betty distrait and troubled. Her attention to
the recital of his problems was perfunctory. He was conscious of a
slight annoyance. In spite of his force, Justin was a vain man, always
ready to talk of himself and his achievements in a modest way to an
interested and interesting young woman.
It appeared that her father had had a difficulty with some tramps,
which had eventuated in insolence that had brought upon the
vagrants summary physical punishment. From her account of it,
Justin judged that Reed had not handled the matter very wisely.
There was a way to do such things with a minimum of friction.
But he saw no need of worrying about it. The tramps had been given
what they deserved and the affair was closed. It was like a woman to
hold it heavily on her conscience because one of the ne’er-do-wells
chanced to be young and good-looking.
“If you’d seen him,” Betty protested. “A gentleman by the look of him,
or had been once, fine-grained, high-spirited, and yet so down-and-
out.”
“If he’s down-and-out, it’s his own fault. A man’s never that so long
as he holds to self-respect.”
This was incontrovertibly true, but Betty chose to be irritated. Justin
was so obviously successful. He might have had a little sympathy for
the underdog, she thought. Everybody did not have a square, salient
jaw like his. Weakness was not necessarily a crime.
“He looks as though life had mauled him,” she said. “It’s taken
something vital out of him. He doesn’t care what happens any more.”
“If he can only mooch his three meals a day and enough cash to
keep him supplied with bootleg poison,” the engineer added.
They were walking up to the Three Pines, a rocky bluff from which
they could in the daytime see far down the valley. She stopped
abruptly. If she did not stamp her foot, at least the girl’s manner gave
eloquently the effect of this indulgence.
“He’s not like that at all—not at all. Don’t you ever sympathize with
any one that’s in hard luck?” she cried out, her cheeks glowing with a
suffusion of underlying crimson.
“Not when he lies down under it.”
She flashed at him a look resentful of his complacency. It held, too,
for the first time a critical doubt. There was plenty to like about Justin
Merrick, and perhaps there was more to admire. He got things done
because he was so virile, so dominant. To look at the lines and
movements of his sturdy body, at the close-lipped mouth and
resolute eyes, was to know him a leader of men. But now a
treasonable thought had wirelessed itself into her brain. Had he a
mind that never ranged out of well-defined pastures, that was quite
content with the social and economic arrangement of the world? Did
there move in it only a tight little set of orthodox ideas?
“How do you know he lies down under it?” she asked with spirit.
“How do we know what he has to contend with? Or how he struggles
against it?”
If his open smile was not an apology, it refused, anyhow, to be at
variance with her. “Maybe so. As you say, I didn’t see him and you
did. We’ll let it go at that and hope he’s all you think he is.”
Betty, a little ashamed of her vagrant thoughts, tried to find a
common ground upon which they could stand. “Don’t you think that
men are often the victims of circumstance—that they get caught in
currents that kinda sweep them away?”
“‘I am the captain of my soul,’” he quoted sententiously.
“Yes, you are,” she admitted, after one swift glance that took in the
dogged, flinty quality of him. “But most of us aren’t. Take Dad. He’s
strong, and he’s four-square. But he wouldn’t have gone as far as he
did with these tramps if he hadn’t got carried away. Well, don’t you
think maybe this boy is a victim of ‘the bludgeonings of chance’? He
looked like it to me.”
“We make ourselves,” he insisted. “If the things we buck up against
break us, it’s because we’re weak.”
“Yes, but—” Betty’s protest died away. She was not convinced, and
she made another start. “It seems to me that when I read the new
novelists—Wells, Galsworthy, or Bennett, say—one of the things I
get out of them is that we are modified by our environment, not only
changed by it, but sometimes made the prey of it and destroyed by
it.”
“Depends on how solid on our feet we are,” answered the engineer.
“That’s the plea of the agitator, I know. He’s always wanting to do
impossible things by law or by a social upheaval. There’s nothing to
it. A man succeeds if he’s strong. He fails if he’s weak.”
This creed of the individualist was sometimes Betty’s own, but to-
night she was not ready to accept it. “That would be all very well if
we all started equal. But we don’t. What about a man who develops
tuberculosis, say, just when he is getting going? He’s weak, but it’s
no fault of his.”
“It may or may not be. Anyhow, it’s his misfortune. You can’t make
the world over because he’s come a cropper. Take this young tramp
of yours. I’d like to try him out and show you whether there’s
anything to him. I’d put him on the work and let him find his level.
Chances are he’d drift back to the road inside of a week. When a
man’s down-and-out, it isn’t because he doesn’t get a chance, but
because of some weakness in himself.”
Betty knew that in the case of many this was true. For a year or more
she had been an employer of labor herself. One of the things that
had impressed her among the young fellows who worked for her was
that they did find their level. The unskilled, shiftless, and less reliable
were dropped when work became slack. The intelligent and
energetic won promotion for themselves.
But she did not believe that it was by any means a universal truth.
Men were not machines, after all. They were human beings.
However, she dropped the subject.
“He’s gone, so you won’t have a chance to prove your case,” she
said. “Tell me about the work. How is it going?”
The Sweetwater Dam project had been initiated to water what was
known as the Flat Tops, a mesa that stretched from the edge of the
valley to the foothills. It had been and still was being bitterly opposed
by some of the cattlemen of Paradise Valley because its purpose
was to reclaim for farming a large territory over which cattle had
hitherto ranged at will. Their contention held nothing of novelty. It had
been argued all over the West ever since the first nesters came in to
dispute with the cattle barons the possession of the grazing lands. A
hundred districts in a dozen States had heard the claim that this was
a cattle country, unfit for farming and intensive settlement. Many of
them had seen it disproved.
The opposition of powerful ranching interests had not deterred Justin
Merrick. Threats did not disturb him. He set his square jaw and
pushed forward to the accomplishment of his purpose. As he rode or
drove through the valley, he knew that he was watched with hostile
eyes by reckless cowpunchers who knew that his success would put
a period to the occupation they followed. Two of them had tried to
pick a quarrel with him at Wild Horse on one occasion, and had
weakened before his cool and impassive fearlessness.
But he did not deceive himself. At any hour the anger of these men
might flare out against him in explosive action. For the first time in
his life he was carrying a revolver.
Clint Reed was a stockholder and a backer of the irrigation project.
He owned several thousand acres on the Flat Tops, and it was
largely on account of his energy that capital had undertaken the
reclamation of the dry mesa.
The head and front of the opposition was Jake Prowers, who had
brought down from early days an unsavory reputation that rumor
said he more than deserved. Strange stories were whispered about
this mild-mannered little man with the falsetto voice and the skim-
milk eyes. One of them was that he had murdered from ambush the
successful wooer of the girl he wanted, that the whole countryside
accepted the circumstantial evidence as true, and in spite of this he
had married the young widow within a year and buried her inside of
two. Nesters in the hills near his ranch had disappeared and never
been seen again. Word passed as on the breath of the winds that
Prowers had dry-gulched them. Old-timers still lived who had seen
him fight a duel with two desperadoes on the main street of Wild
Horse. He had been carried to the nearest house on a shutter with
three bullets in him, but the two bad men had been buried next day.
The two most important ranchmen in the valley were Clint Reed and
Jake Prowers. They never had been friendly. Usually they were
opposed to each other on any public question that arose. Each was
the leader of his faction. On politics they differed. Clint was a
Republican, Jake a Democrat. There had been times when they had
come close to open hostilities. The rivalry between them had
deepened to hatred on the part of Prowers. When Reed announced
through the local paper the inception of the Sweetwater Dam project,
his enemy had sworn that it should never go through while he was
alive.
Hitherto Prowers had made no move, but everybody in the district
knew that he was biding his time. Competent engineers of the
Government had passed adversely on this irrigation project. They
had decided water could not be brought down from the hills to the
Flat Tops. Jake had seen the surveys and believed them to be
correct. He was willing that Reed and the capitalists he had
interested should waste their money on a fool’s dream. If Justin
Merrick was right—if he could bring water through Elk Creek Cañon
to the Flat Tops—it would be time enough for Prowers to strike.
Knowing the man as he did, Clint Reed had no doubt that, if it
became necessary in order to defeat the project, his enemy would
move ruthlessly and without scruple. It was by his advice that Justin
Merrick kept the dam guarded at night and carried a revolver with
him when he drove over or tramped across the hills.
CHAPTER IX
UNDER FIRE
All day the faint far whir of the reaper could have been heard from
the house of the Diamond Bar K ranch. The last of the fields had
been cut. Much of the grain had been gathered and was ready for
the thresher.
The crop was good. Prices would be fair. Clint Reed rode over the
fields with the sense of satisfaction it always gave him to see
gathered the fruits of the earth. His pleasure in harvesting or in
rounding-up beef steers was not only that of the seller looking to his
profit. Back of this was the spiritual gratification of having been a
factor in supplying the world’s needs. To look at rippling wheat
ripening under the sun, to feed the thresher while the fan scattered a
cloud of chaff and the grain dropped into the sacks waiting for it,
ministered to his mental well-being by justifying his existence. He
had converted hundreds of acres of desert into fertile farm land. All
his life he had been a producer of essentials for mankind. He found
in this, as many farmers do, a source of content. He was paying his
way in the world.
To-day Reed found the need of vindication. He was fonder of Betty
than he was of anything or anybody else in the world, and he knew
that he was at the bar of her judgment. She did not approve of what
he had done. This would not have troubled him greatly if he had
been sure that he approved of it himself. But like many willful men he
sometimes had his bad quarter of an hour afterward.
It was easy enough to make excuses. The Diamond Bar K had been
troubled a good deal by vagrants on the transcontinental route. They
had robbed the smokehouse only a few weeks before. A gang of
them had raided the watermelon patch, cut open dozens of green
melons, and departed with such ripe ones as they could find.
Naturally he had been provoked against the whole breed of them.
But he had been too hasty in dealing with the young scamp he had
thrashed. Clint writhed under an intolerable sense of debt. The boy
had fought him as long as he could stand and take it. He had gone
away still defiant, and had rescued Betty from a dangerous situation.
Dragged back at a rope’s end to the ranch by the luckless Dusty, he
had scornfully departed before Reed had a chance to straighten out
with him this added indignity. The owner of the Diamond Bar K felt
frustrated, as though the vagabond had had the best of him.
He was not even sure that the severe punishment he had meted out
to the other tramps had been wise. The man Cig had endured the
ordeal unbroken in spirit. His last words before he crept away had
been a threat of reprisal. The fellow was dangerous. Clint read it in
his eyes. He had given orders to Betty not to leave the ranch for the
next day or two without an escort. Yet he still felt uneasy, as though
the end of the matter had not come.
It was now thirty hours since he had last seen the hoboes. No doubt
they were hundreds of miles away by this time and with every click of
the car wheels getting farther from the ranch.
He rode back to the stable, unsaddled, and walked to the house.
Betty was in the living-room at the piano. She finished the piece,
swung round on the stool, and smiled at him.
“Everything fine and dandy, Dad?”
His face cleared. It was her way of telling him that she was ready to
forgive and be forgiven.
“Yes.” Then, abruptly, “Reckon I get off wrong foot first sometimes,
honey.”
He was in a big armchair. She went over to him, sat down on his
knees, and kissed him. “’S all right, Dad,” she nodded with an effect
of boyish brusqueness. Betty, too, had a mental postscript and
expressed it. “It’s that boy. Nothing to do about it, of course. He
wouldn’t let me do a thing for him, but—Oh, well, I just can’t get him
off my mind. Kinda silly of me.”