Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(1890–1945)
Topics
Imperialism: Debates
—------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Progressives
Postwar Diplomacy
Subject to Debate
● The Nature of American Imperialism
○ Critics often discuss the US as if it were a “colossus”, imposing its will on the
world - protecting democracy is an excuse for its economic exploitation
○ Others hold a “realpolitik” approach that America must expand if it wants to
maintain its current standard of living
○ A third view is the “international good guy” approach - that the US is truly driven
by altruism
● Progressivism and Progressive Historians
○ There are some questions to be raised about the movement - its assumptions, its
effectiveness, and its relationship to Jim Crow policies
● The Progressive Movement and the Business Community
○ Industry leaders initiated reform in the meat-packing industry to restore
confidence in their industry
○ Another critique of the Progressive movement was their attitude toward the
poor - trying to impose their idea of proper behavior on others
○ Ex. Prohibition - telling working class people they should not drink, this crusade
against immoral behavior raises the issue of elitism
● WWI in Public Memory
○ WWII is characterized as a good fight carried about by the greatest generation,
whereas WWI is tucked away into a corner
○ One of the reasons that WWI is ignored, is that there is no clearly identifiable
“evil” that the US was trying to defeat - this does not read like a morality play
○ As the war ended in 1919, America became violently conservative - the “Red
Scare” was paving the way for the resurgence of the KKK, restrictions on
immigration, and attacks on secularism
● Consensus Historians and Intolerance in the 1920s
○ According to them, Americans share a belief in democracy and individual
liberties, they believe that hard work leads to advancement, but do not try to
impose their beliefs on others - they are a tolerant people
○ They would argue that the labor battles of the Gilded Age was not a battle
between the high and low classes, but rather that they were strikers wanting a
greater share of the wealth that the economy was generating
○ They have a great deal of difficulty explaining the 1920s and the KKK - 3 million
Americans joined a violent, racist, intolerant, anti-Semitic organization - difficult
to fit into the traditional consensus model of American history
● Handling the Great Depression: Hoover vs. FDR
○ Hoover is not as incompetent as he is often portrayed
○ When the Depression hit, he implemented the Reconstruction Finance
Corporation, which provided needed funds to key sectors of the economy
○ Critics portray the New Deal as creeping socialism
● The New Deal - Successful or Ineffective?
○ Some historians noted that the New Deal did not solve the problems of the
Depression
○ Historians also note that the Depression only ended when the US began
producing materials for WWII
○ Others argue that the New Deal restored hope among the American people and
prevented more widespread suffering
○ Organized labor also made great strides because of New Deal legislation
● Mortality and Justice in the WWII Era
○ Some historians insist that the US could have done more to save European Jews,
such as allowing ships carrying refugees to dock
○ The debate over the use of the atomic bomb is also controversial, considering
that Japan was likely ready to surrender by the time the bomb was used.
Imperialism
Causes
1. Industrial Revolution Needed new resources, markets, places to invest surplus capital
5. White Man’s Burden Social Darwinism, American “duty” to help the weak
Platt ● Allowed US to intervene militarily in Cuba when they saw fit - so that
Amendment their economic interests could never be threatened
Philippine ● Philippinos rebelled because they thought the US would give them
Insurrection freedom
Involvement ● Intervened in China with the Open Door policy: allowed the US to
in Asia gain a foothold in trade; missionaries → Boxer Rebellion
Progressivism
Muckraking ● “Investigative journalism”: using the power of the mass media to shed
light on social ills
Segregation ● Du Bois called for full political equality, whereas Booker T. Washington
had a more conciliatory approach - confrontation would end badly for
blacks
WWI
British Blockade Britain’s Blockade on Germany was a cause of unrestricted sub warfare
Zimmerman Note Germany would help Mexico regain territory it lost to the US if Mexico
joined the war
Effects
1. Booming ● Munitions industry: US selling weapons to Britain and France
Industry ● War Industries Board: production and price regulations on industry
Mass Culture
Red ● Cause by the Bolshevik Revolution; Communist Party formed in the US
Scare ● Attorney General Palmer hunted down suspected communists and trampled
on people’s civil rights
● Labor union membership declined because of the correlation to communism
Great Depression
Causes
1. Overproduction ● Assembly line and scientific management increased industrial
and output
Underconsumption ● Consumption could not keep up with production
● Farmers increased production for WWI, but they were left in a
cycle of overproduction and falling commodity prices
2. Overspeculation ● Inflated stock market because people bought stocks with the
promise to pay the price later
● Because the stock market did not match up with the actual
valuation of the company, investors began panic selling
● Stock market crashed in 1929
New Deal
First ● National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA): Drew up a set of codes designed to
New shorten hours, establish min. wage, and promote fair business practices
Deal ○ This increased the popularity of unions
● Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA): paid farmers to grow fewer crops -
reduce production to bolster falling commodity prices and strengthen the
agricultural sector
● Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC): employed 2.75 million men in
infrastructure projects
Second ● Works Progress Administration (WPA): created millions of jobs for the
New unemployed
Deal ● Social Security Act: designed to help the unemployed, elderly, and disabled,
funded by taxes on workers and employees
WWII
British ● Lend-Lease Act: allowed the US to send arms to Britain in their own
Relations ships
● Atlantic Charter: solidified alliance between Britain and US
Wartime America
The Home ● Rationing policies gave ration books and stamps to families
Front ● Funded the war effort through war bonds and increase in taxes
● Unemployment of the 1930s ended because of arms manufacturing
Timeline
Island ● Avoided heavily fortified islands, only attacked key islands - naval
Hopping bases, airfields
● US cut off islands it had hopped over by blockading supply ships
Underbelly of ● ¼ million Allied troops landed in Sicily and tried to enter the Axis
the Axis through Italy
D-Day ● Allies stormed Normandy, France and pushed Hitler’s forces back to
Germany, liberating Paris from Nazi occupation
V-E Day ● Victory in Europe Day: After Hitler’s last attempt to stop the Allies at
the Battle of the Bulge failed, Germany surrendered
Effects
Yalta ● Divided Germany into zones controlled by the US, USSR, France, and
Conference Britain
● US and Britain allowed Stalin to remain in Eastern Europe
● FDR and Churchill were later criticized for abandoning Eastern Europe
to communist forces; however, they could not dislodge the Red Army
from Europe without starting a war