Article Citation What is the What larger What methods What are the What What makes How

re the What What makes How does this How does this
At the bottom of author’s conversation is does the author author’s main conclusions this a credible & article compare article differ
the page looks purpose for the research use to collect and supporting does the author relevant source to other articles from other
better than writing this part of? What and analyze arguments? draw? What is for my I’m using? What sources? What
when squished piece? What literature or data? What What data are the significance research? What terms, new information
in the box. need or gap is authors does seem to be used to support of their are the author’s information, does this article
this research the author cite? important data them? How do findings? Do qualifications & methods, provide?
filling? How What are some points? How are these support they call for motivations? and/or
does the author key topics or the data the main action or further How does this arguments are
introduce the ideas in analyzed? argument? research? contribute similar?
topic and its discussion insight into my
relevance? among these line of inquiry?
sources?
Article #1 The purpose of The larger The author The main The conclusion This article is This article This article
(INCLUDE this piece is to conversation mentions an argument is that the author credible compares to differs from
CITATION) show the this article idea then space utilization makes is to because it is other articles I other sources in
benefits of contributes elaborates on has many “emphasize this published by the am using my research
Is peer-reviewed space displays a lot of the idea and economic potential and Proceedings of because it keeps because it
exploration. The already then they give benefits and highlight the the National terms simple mentions many
gap this mentioned the reference sustainability. need for Academy of and easy to things I would
research is filling information in a number they The supporting informed policy- Sciences which follow. It also not have
is connecting connected pulled the arguments are making and is a very credible mentions the considered
the history of pattern. The information the details international source. The technological when
space author uses from. Important mentioned cooperation.” author's improvements researching.
exploration to work from over data points about the The significance qualifications discovered in This includes the
its benefits for 50 authors. The seem to be most benefit to the of the findings is are that they space. The mention of the
today. The key topics of the economy. The to try to inspire have published argument is like companies using
author discussed references data used to the increased several articles other articles space for
introduces the among these because they all support the use of space in the field, and because it is economic gain,
topic and sources are the lead to the main idea exploration. the motivation trying to history in better
relevance by vast benefits of bigger picture. comes in two They are calling is to get their persuade the detail, and the
mentioning how space The data is forms first in the for action on the message across. audience to feel economy in
space exploration with analyzed by text the expansion of This contributes that space great detail. This
exploration has a wide range. providing mentioning of space to my insight exploration is article provides
adapted and specific all the positive exploration due into my line of good for me with new
changed to examples and impacts, and to its many inquiry because mankind. information
become better mentioning second, the benefits and I can trust the about the many
overall for them in detail. graphs showing unprecedented information widespread
people. the expansion of ones. displayed. benefits of
space space
utilization. exploration.
Article #2 The author’s The large The author The author's The conclusion What makes this This article This article is
(INCLUDE purpose for conversation mentions a main arguments the author a credible compares to the different from
CITATION) writing this is to the research is a problem and are that makes is that source is that is other articles than other ones
display the part of is by how there has agriculture in space farming published by I’m using I used because
Not peer- many findings displaying been a space has will become NASA which is a because it this focuses
reviewed related to plant information that development or helped us on more important, very litigious mentions many primarily are
growth many would not fix to this Earth and that and that this organization. benefits in the just agricultural
discovered in already know problem we can keep importance will This contributes space benefits and
space that can and displaying it developed in solving lead to insight into my exploration field also takes it a
be used on positively to space. The problems in the innovations in line of inquiry and how they step further and
Earth. The need show it is important data future. The data agriculture here because it can help the goes into the
for this research helpful for the points seem to used to support on Earth. They creates support Earth. The expansion of
is to help future. The be whenever this argument is call for action to for the claims arguments are space
mention the article cites she mentions the listing of the improve made by the similar because exploration for
ways space other NASA specific benefits of agriculture author along this one tries to space not just
plant growth information technology these development in with me to trust persuade the here on Earth. It
has improved already because this developments in space and that it them and use audience to see is also different
and how it can published. The allows for the the article and will continue to them. the benefits of because it is not
benefit us. The key topic ideas naming of it and explaining each be important. space trying to force
author in these sources the explanation one. exploration. these ideas on
introduces the are that they all and helps create you it mentions
topic by display the a sense of them in a
mentioning that different importance with conversation-
food in space impacts on the reader. The type pattern not
has been agriculture data is analyzed just an
consumed resulting from by providing informative
which is an space. specific pattern.
important step examples and
for the future of then saying how
agriculture it fixed a
growth in space. problem.
Article #3 The purpose of The large The methods The author's The conclusions This article is This article This article is
(INCLUDE this piece is to conversation the author uses main argument the author credible compares to the different than
CITATION) go through the the research is a to collect and is the modern makes include because it is other articles I some of my
Peer reviewed major part of how analyze data is capabilities of stating that peer-reviewed am using other articles
categories of space can help by mentioning humankind can space and verified by because it is because it
improvement in more ways these ideas of allow exploration has many science shaped in a focuses on the
developed than one how it helps the humankind to produced an groups being it positive way future saying we
through space realizes. The overall of best use space impressive is published by towards space need to take
exploration author cites humanity and exploration for record of ISCEG which travel. The advantage and
from innovation sources from then providing a greater benefit benefits for contains a place information is move forward
and culture and different specific example to society. The humanity and where space generally similar and not just be
address global international of how it does data supporting that space articles can be by trying to compliant
challenges. The space countries this. The this is the listing exploration will published by keep it where where we are
need this ranging from important data of numerous have positive various most who read and that it is
 research is filling the U.S. to many seem to be ways space impacts on countries for all it could okay to want to
is to explain other countries mentioned in exploration has future other countries understand it. work forward to
these big in Europe and the section previously generations. to read. The inspire future
overarching Asian countries headers, the helped the The significance author's generations.
ideas and dive as well. This data is analyzed world. This of their findings qualifications
deeper into data is analyzed throughout the supports the is that with the are that it is a
them. The as a combining paragraph going main argument proven track group of authors
author of it mentioned from step to by providing record of space inside NASA
introduces the in the page step essentially evidence of it in exploration the which is a very
topic by naming working explaining why the past and future of it litigious
it and then towards getting the section is why it is should be a very organization.
going into the message titled what it is. important for simple decision This contributes
specific across for that the future to to make due to to my insight
advancements page and then continue using its highly because allows
in these presenting a and advancing positive nature. for a sense of
categories they solution of what in space The call for what I am
also ask some they have exploration. action is to reading to be
questions to to discovered. continue to verifiable and
help shape their push through true.
paper. what has been
done and to
help future
generations be
interested in the
idea of space
exploration.
Article #4 The author's The larger The method the The author's The conclusions This is a credible This article This article is
(INCLUDE purpose for conversation authors use to main argument the author source because compares to different than
CITATION) writing this the research is a collect data is to is that the ISS draws include, it was published others because others because
Not peer- piece is to show part of research mention and has helped that the ISS has by NASA which it is positively it calls for
reviewed that the is a part of is improve results humans on been a great would not allow shaped toward research to be
international that even with from space. The Earth in many place to test an incredible space done other
space station something that data is analyzed ways. The experiments on source to get utilization. The articles mention
has many is primarily by listing the supporting ideas for over published. After similar it but this article
benefits for focused on improvement arguments are 20 years and all, they want to arguments are sells the point
humans on space such as and how it has the actual ways that the ISS can maintain and that space is a that we must
Earth. The need the ISS helpful Earth has been continue to help keep the utmost great frontier work toward the
this research is *(Glossary) implications for helped, The citizens of Earth. respect for that can help us future of
filling is that still has an humans. The data is a listing The significance quality. The learn to adapt research. This
explains the impact on Earth important data of facts, they of the findings is author's and succeed article is
different strides and can help points including support the that they help qualifications here on Earth. different
and provides eliminate the the headings I main argument the audience are they work because it
specific problems we think more are by backing it up see that the ISS for NASA and focuses more
examples in have. The more important and providing does impact the motivation primarily just on
 different fields author cites than others real examples their everyday is to persuade the ISS whereas
of study. The many of the because they that can be seen lives. The call for the audience of others don’t
author past are more as positive. action and the benefits of mention the ISS.
introduces the experiments impactful on further the ISS. This
topic by NASA either a wider research, the contributes to
mentioning it in performed and range of people call for action is my insight
a header and how companies or just a more for the future affecting my line
then writes a have used them pressing generation to of inquiry
paragraph about to help citizens problem being get interested in because I can
it explaining it on Earth. The solved. The data the idea of trust the claims
and how it is key topics are is analyzed by space in the articles.
helpful. very significant explaining the exploration. After all, they
in the range benefits of it Their claim for provide specific
from ideas such and sometimes further research examples of the
as medical going further is to suggest to impacts of these
technology to into actually not stop pushing tests/experimen
lowering heat in naming the the boundaries ts done on the
cities. product. for space ISS.
research.
Article #5 The author’s The larger The method the The author's The conclusion This journal is This article is This article is
(INCLUDE purpose for conversation author uses to main argument the author credible similar because different than
CITATION) writing this the research is a collect data is to is that space makes is that because it is it mentions how the others
Peer Reviewed journal is to part of that list past displays exploration has although space peer-reviewed more countries because it
Journal show the space of the ideas many benefits travel has and is published are starting to mentions some
benefits and exploration may being displayed. but also some problems such in Procedia use space. This of the negatives
problems be viewed as The analysis of downsides and as pollution, which is a very journal also likes associated with
associated with negative, but this data is after costs. The there is a wider trustworthy to display the space use, it
space travel. the positives it is displayed supporting range of source that past of space also goes into
The need this outweigh these and then they arguments benefits to be covers many exploration. specific
research is filling negatives. In the give the range from reaped through types of examples of
explains that literature, the explanation of more countries space research being why space can't
space authors use the why it is having access to exploration. The published very be ruled by just
exploration is creation of important to space use, to significance of often and one country
very important clarity by consider. The the their findings is constantly being which the other
for the future of explaining the important data development of that it displays updated. The articles barely
citizens of Earth ideas presented points seem to new that although qualifications of touch on. The
and that it also that they be the headings technologies. space the author are article goes into
has drawbacks mentioned. The in the paper. The data is exploration may that the author some specifics
and protections. key topics in the The data is supported by a lead to some is publishing for about the future
The author discussion are analyzed by listing of negatives these this organization of space
introduces these brought up listing it and connections problems can be and that her exploration and
topics by through the explaining the between why solved and also work is always its potential
mentioning overall idea terms by these ideas lead to many done with impacts as well.
ideas that are being displayed defining them. were helpful in more research and
 more general and then the past and improvements intent. The
and they shift to explained how they can be with more space motivation is to
more specifics further with in the future. exploration. The get the general
related to the examples. This supports author calls for public to see
ideas. the main action that the more into the
argument world needs benefits and
because it can international costs associated
help lead to cooperation and with space
support for the global, long- exploration.
benefits of term thinking. They call for
space action on the
exploration. front of
improving
international
communication.
Article #6 The author's The large The methods The author's The conclusion This article is This article This article is
(INCLUDE purpose for conversation the author uses main argument the author credible compares to different from
CITATION) writing this the research is a to collect data is that public makes is that because it is other articles other sources
Peer Reviewed piece is to part of is how are by and private the space published in I’m using because it
display that the can space mentioning the sector space use economy is PNAS which is because it eases makes claims
expansion of utilization be major clusters is already going into one of the the concept and that have an
space used by used to benefit and giving present and it is uncharted leading scientific explains the impact saying
private a great examples of having an frontiers and journals in the difference that
companies can proportion of private and impact on what the benefits of world and is also between two corporations
be very the world's public entities. is developed/ technology and peer-reviewed. different sides should not be
beneficial for population. The The important researched. The economics are The author's of a piece. The able to hide
more of the literature the data points supporting very important qualifications arguments are information.
population if writers use is seem to be the argument is that it is up to the are that they are also similar This is different
proper actions the mentioning current progress this could be use of how trusted by this because they because the
are put in place. of ideas such as overhang positive or information is scientific journal mention that articles I
The need for that of the because it negative. The displayed/ to allow them to space use can previously used
this research is Tragedy of the shows what data that shared to more be published, help everyone. never went this
to help bridge Commons * and work is currently supports these than just those and their far in depth with
the gap and other terms being done in claims is the in private motivations are the difference
help create a related to how that field and listing of these corporations. that big between the
better more to better use a how it is groups already, The significance corporations public and
efficient picture resource. Some changing. The and also the of the findings is can't have space private sectors.
for the of the key topics data is analyzed explanation of that space is just to
companies using include focusing later in a what these going to be a themselves. This
space to see and on specific paragraph that groups are great economy contributes to
use. The author organizations explains the doing. it is just a my insight
introduces the and how they information question of who because allows
topic by plan and or further and with will have access me to see that
mentioning an currently use greater detail. and how will experts in the
 idea and then space for the they use it. They field realize that
providing benefit of call for action research hidden
examples of themselves and and how away from
how it has others. through people is not
worked with agreements very helpful for
other examples. with open the general goal
research these of space use.
companies'
discoveries will
be displayed for
all of humanity
to use.
Article #7 The purpose of The large The method the The author's The conclusion This is credible This article This article
Nonpeer writing this conversation author uses to main argument the author because it compares to focuses on a
reviewed piece is to show the research is a collect data is by is that satellites draws is that for focuses on a others because more finite
the benefits of part of is the mentioning the are going to advancements neutral it shows me resource than a
increased use of use of space idea of why become cheaper in agriculture discussion and many positives lot of my other
high-quality technologies to satellites allowing for with a growing only provides with space and sources because
satellites and benefit haven’t been in more use of population the solid data it can help with it focuses on
how they can agriculture use before but them in the steps for provided by problems that freshwater and
eliminate production on then how they future for success may trustworthy are present on how its usage
problems Earth. The will be the data agriculture. The come from the sources and not Earth. can be improved
relating to water author cites starts to add up. supporting use of satellites just random where as my
usage and other information The data is argument is the and their many data without other articles
issues that will from the World analyzed by mention of how benefits. The proof. The didn’t go into
become more Health listing the these cheaper significance of qualifications of detail about this
prominent with Organization specific statistics options will their findings is the authors are finite resource.
time. The need and other major and how they create higher that they show they use high-
this research is organizations will become quality/ useable that quality statistics
filling is that is for the data more prominent information for improvements even if this is
helping show about the in the future. those who in technology in not the main
that even little future. The key The most participate in space can help subject they
impacts on topics are important data agriculture. The contribute specialize in
overall usage mentioned in point seems to data supports positively to they still put
can create the data be related to this by modern effort forward
major change in provided by the reduction of mentioning the problems on and make sure
the world. The listing all the water usage sharp decline in Earth. The the sources are
author ways satellites because it has the price of author calls for high quality.
introduces the can improve the the most expected further research This contributes
idea by talking agriculture that emphasis on it satellites over to be done to my insight by
to the reader the world so when the next decade. because these leading to me
about the much relies on. mentioned. This supports technologies are not trusting
concepts and the main not fully everything in
their relevance argument developed yet, this article, but
 by mentioning because it but when they more so trusting
the future. provides a real are they will the statistics.
% associated have many
with the benefits.
decrease in the
price of
satellites.
Article #8 The author's The large The method the The author's The conclusion This is a credible This article The article is
Peer-reviewed purpose for conversation author uses to main argument the author source because compares to different than
journal writing this the research is a collect data is to is that if Earth draws is that it is published by others because the others
piece is to part of is how mention the wants to Mining in space a scientific peer- it lists the many because it is
display that with can we as important ideas. become a is in its early reviewed benefits going more structured
decreases in humans The analysis of cleaner more stages but it is journal that I forward with like a plan on
minerals on continue to this data efficient planet going to be very have used space use and how to do
Earth turning to improve our happens in in the future it crucial going earlier in this expansion. something in
space could help lives with different ways it must turn to forward for the paper. The the future. It is
provide many limitations here could be space for improvement of motivations are also focused
benefits. The on Earth. The through a chart resources. The life on Earth. to get an idea solely on the
need for this author cites or a description data that The significance into leaders' space mining
research is to many sources in the text. The supports this is of their findings heads about idea which is
better explain for direct data important data the mention of is that they how mining in very important
what is being mentioned points seem to the plentiful display a general space is a for the future.
done and what about future be the major resources in plan for this worthy
can be done to usage and headings space and how resource can investment. This
improve space information that because they they are going help the human contributes to
mining. The has already help shape the to be needed population on my insight
author been paper. more than ever earth. The call because it
introduces the discovered. in the future. for further allows me to
topic by Some of the key research when realize it is not
explaining its topics are how relating to the directly
significance and can we use development of intended for me
then dives space resources mining in space. but I can use
further into to help with certain details
detail about it. clean energy from it.
and how can
this become
more prominent
in the future.
Article #9 The purpose of The larger The method the The author’s The conclusion This article is This article is This article is
Nonpeer this article is to conversation of author uses to main argument the author credible similar to other different from
reviewed display a need the research is a collect data is to is that increased makes is that because it is articles because others because
for more part of is that list an idea and spending in with increased published free it is a positive it focuses on
investment in space use is very then to list space is vital for spending there of opinion and it view on space policy and how
space spending important and a information economic can be many uses high- exploration and government
 and that it has valuable use of from a source benefit and positives quality sources that it takes intervention is
economic resources. The about that idea. improvement. generated for that I know are time to advance needed and
benefits. The authors this They analyze The supporting the economy. accurate and it. helpful.
need for this source cites are the data by arguments are The significance correct because
research is to from academic listing out how the listing of of their findings they are trusted
display the need journals. Some certain values increases in is that they sources. The
for more of the key topics with the data spending and hope to inspire author's
investment/bud in this article are are very jobs being the continued motivations are
get for space how space has important and created in the investment of to get the idea
exploration. The generated impactful. The space field. The resources and that investment
author revenue and important data data used to capital in space. is the best
introduces the how its funding seems to be the support the They call for option going
topic by giving a is needed to listing of the arguments action with the forward for
history and then improve. increase in verifies from increased space
expands and spending listing statistics spending in the exploration and
talks about the because that is to explanations space sector. use. This
future of that the main idea of the benefits contributes to
idea. displayed in the that are my insight
article. The data developed. because it
analyzed is These support creates a
analyzed by the main positive view of
defining the argument the data
information. because presented. After
increased jobs all, I can trust it
and increased and use what
spending lead to they mentioned.
more money
flowing around
an enemy.
Article #10 The purpose of The large The methods The author's The conclusion This article is This article is This article is
Peer-reviewed this paper is to conversation the author uses main argument the author credible similar to others different
journal. examine the the research is a to collect data is is the tragedy of draws is that because it is I am using because
idea of the part of is how to list what is the commons is this tragedy of published in a because it keeps although it is
commons or can society use already known, present in outer the commons is peer-reviewed space about space it is
shared a shared then to analyze space. The a very important journal. The mentioned and more focused
resources of resource for the the data the supporting investigation author's the going on the
society. The greater good of author explains arguments are that needs to motivations are forward of breakdown of
need this gap is mankind. The the message in a that it must be take place in to break down a action with it. one's paper and
filling is author that is more personal governed, and outer space for complex paper how it can be
expanding upon cited and the way to the how to avoid better and be able to used in other
older ideas and work used is the reader. The this problem. development get their ideas fields as well.
making them to Nobel prize important data The data shows and use of it. out to more
where they are work winner points seem to that the idea of The significance people. This
easier to Elinor Ostrom. be the listing of the tragedy is of their findings contributes to
understand and The key the explanations present and is that they my line of
more accessible. topic/idea is the by the Nobel without display that inquiry because
The author tragedy of the prize winner. intervention there are I feel I
introduces the commons. The data is could get worse. problems with understand a
topic by analyzed by These support this concept and complex idea
connecting it giving accurate the main that it is very now in more
with the original explanations to argument important to simple terms.
artist allow for better because they correct and
mentioning the understanding. provide details change. They
paper then and call for further
explaining it. explanations as research and
to why they are explanation of
making their the paper and
claim. outer space.
Summary 2-4 is paragraph 1 of annotated bibliography. Asses 5-7 1st half of paragraph 2 of
annotated bibliography. Reflect 6-8 2nd half of paragraph 2 of annotated bibliography. Sorted
alphabetically
Article 1 citation-
Corrado, L., Cropper, M., & Rao, A. (2023). Space exploration and economic growth: New issues and horizons. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 120(43). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2221341120

Article 2 citation-
Space Farming Yields a Crop of Benefits for Earth - NASA. (2015, August 10). https://www.nasa.gov/technology/tech-transfer
spinoffs/space-farming-yields-a-crop-of-benefits-for-earth/

‌Article 3 citation-

NASA. (2013). Benefits Stemming from Space Exploration International Space Exploration Coordination Group.
https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/benefits-stemming-from-space-exploration-2013-tagged.pdf
Article 4 citation-
NASA. (2022, July 22). 15 Ways the International Space Station Benefits Humanity Back on Earth - NASA. NASA.
https://www.nasa.gov/missions/station/15-ways-the-international-space-station-benefits-humanity-back-on-earth/
Article 5 citation-
Konert, A., Balcerzak, T., Książek-Janik, E., & Yarushina, A. (2022). Legal Framework for Space Exploration. Benefits and Threats for
the Earth. Transportation Research Procedia, 65, 144–150. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trpro.2022.11.017
Article 6 citation-
Rausser, G. C., Choi, E.-H., & Bayen, A. M. (2023). Public–private partnerships in fostering outer space innovations. Proceedings of
the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 120(43). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2222013120
Article 7 citation-
Here’s how space technology can improve agriculture. (2023, May 10). World Economic Forum.
https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2023/05/space-tech-can-improve-agriculture/
Article 8 citation-
Fleming, M., Lange, I., Sayeh Shojaeinia, & Stuermer, M. (2023). Mining in space could spur sustainable growth. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 120(43). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2221345120
Article 9 citation-
Hicklin-Coorey, O. (2022). The Economic Benefits of Space Exploration: Why We Should Invest More in Space. Emory Economics
Review. https://emoryeconomicsreview.org/articles/2022/4/11/the-economic-benefits-of-space-exploration-why-we-should
invest-more-in-space
Article 10 citation-
Weeden, B. C., & Chow, T. (2012). Taking a common-pool resources approach to space sustainability: A framework and potential
policies. Space Policy, 28(3), 166–172. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spacepol.2012.06.004

‌
‌