Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Proposal
Proposal
On
Land use and land cover dynamics and its driving factors
in Hashenge Watershed, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia
September; 2020
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER ONE; INTRODUCTION..........................................................................................................1
1.1. Background of the study...................................................................................................................1
1.2 Statement of the Problem...................................................................................................................3
1.3 General objective of the study………………………………………………………………………………………………………4
i
CHAPTER ONE; INTRODUCTION
Ethiopia’s land resources are critical to the economic and social development of the country.The
sector is the main driver of economic growth, accounting for about 50% of GDP, 90% of export
revenues and 80% of employment. Most rural households directly depend on their local land
resources for their livelihoods. Annual crop production is the most important, contributing to
about 61% of household income. Small-scale low-input rain fed, primarily subsistence,
agriculture is the dominant form of production (Tesfaye, 2009). However, current levels of land
degradation have significant economic costs for the country particularly in the highlands. This
has been estimated at an annual cost of between 2-3% of Agricultural GDP. This is a
1
conservative estimate as it doesn’t take into account the off-site effects of land degradation. But,
the detailed economic assessment of land degradation in the Ethiopian Highlands suggested a
much higher figure, estimating that in 1990 the economic costs of land degradation were
equivalent to 8% of agricultural GDP, and that continuing soil erosion and leaching of nutrients
was contributing to an on-going annual decline of agricultural GDP of between 0.46 and 0.6%
per annum. Regardless of its diversified land resources, Ethiopia has been subjected to severe
land degradations (Tesfaye, 2009). In line with this, (Mastewal., 2006) states that Ethiopia is one
of the most environmentally. Degraded countries in the Sahel belt. Land degradation attracted
increasing awareness during the 1980s. A paradigm shift took place from projects dealing mainly
with physical and chemical aspects of degradation towards integration of a broader range of
disciplines. The pre-1980 period was largely dominated by a "technical-fix approach", where a
physical problem was identified and a physical solution prescribed (Stocking, 1992). There are
several interrelated factors that contribute adversely for degradation of lands in Africa in general
and Ethiopia in particular. For instance, (Mekuria, 2005) states that “Land degradation in
developing countries, mainly in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), is largely an outcome of the existing
agricultural production system, which is a “resource-poor” agriculture characterized by uncertain
Rainfall, low inherent land productivity, lack of capital, inadequate support services and
poverty”. Many studies carried out in Ethiopia to address natural resource degradation and
development needs; emphasizes mostly in the conservation based strategy. Since the 1960s,
different approaches were implemented to enhance the productive capacity and rehabilitation of
the degraded lands through natural resource management practices: such as soil and water
conservation, integrated natural resource management, sustainable land resource management at
landscape, basin,watershed and administrative levels (Luara and Jermias, 2012). A serious of
interventions which are not coordinated, integrated and low level of grass root participation in all
aspects of NRM practices especially; in the planning, appropriate technology selection and
control of the natural resource in their locality seriously affects the effectiveness of the
interventions (Tesfaye, 2009). Therefore, attempt will be made in this study to map out the status
of land use land cover of Hashenge watershed 1990 and 2020 with a view to detect the land
consumption rate and the changes that will be taken place using remote sensing and GIS and
establish the main drivers of land use/land cover change through household questionnaire and a
focus group discussion.
2
1.2 Statement of the Problem
The Ethiopian Highlands, once endowed with rich natural resources, are agriculturally used since
millennium and now heavily degraded. This environmental degradation replicated in the form of
land degradation and degradation of water resources as well as loss of biodiversity. With regard
to this, Pender and Birhanu (2007) state that “Low agricultural productivity, poverty and land
degradation are critical and closely related problems in the Ethiopian highlands. These problems
are particularly severe in the highlands “Several reports prevailed Ethiopian forest coverage
approximately 40% of the study carried out in the Chemoga watershed,in northwestern highland
Ethiopia, states the following:[Between 1960 and 1999, total annual stream flow decreased at a
rate of 1Ð7 mm year_1, whereas the annual rainfall decreased only at a rate of 0Ð29 mm year_1.
These observed adverse changes in the stream flow have partly resulted from changes in land
cover/use and/or degradation of the watershed that involved destruction of natural vegetative
covers, expansion of croplands, overgrazing and increased area under eucalypt plantations. The
other contributory factor has been the increased dry-season water abstraction to be expected from
the increased human and livestock populations in the area.” (Weldeamlak and Grete, 2005).
Many studies carried out in Ethiopia to address natural resource degradation and development
needs; emphasizes mostly in the conservation based strategy . A serious of interventions which
are not coordinated, integrated and low level of grass root participation in all aspects of NRM
practices especially; in the planning, appropriate technology selection and control of the natural
resource in their locality seriously affects the effectiveness of the interventions (Tesfaye, 2009)
total land area century ago but now have shrunken to only 3% (Berry, 2003). The current
watershed management approach still mainly focuses on soil and water conservation, and the
integration and coordination of efforts and stakeholders are minimum and also the multi-
disciplinary approach and the focus on the natural resource conservation is greater (Adugna,
2O14).
In the other hand the different intervention implemented are not well address the issue of
sustainability and their effect in the LU/LC dynamics of the highland of Ethiopia is insignificant
due a different factors played socio-political, ecological and environmental: drought, population
pressure, civil war, land tuner, disease, settlement and resettlement (Robin et al, 2000). Most
researcher including Weldeamlake (2003), Amanueal and Mulugeta(2014), Weldeamlak and
3
Sterk(2005), use LULC change detection and NDVI method to analyze the rate of land use
change and level of rehabilitation or degradation of land resources, but Tessfaye (2011) analysis
the impact of IWS management approach through HHS, key informant interview, FGD and soil
analysis to assess the rehabilitation and livelihood improvement. Efrem (2009) use both LULC
dynamics and livelihood analysis.
There is still a research gaps in the analysis and assessments of the impact of different land
resource management interventions on the rehabilitation of degraded land at watershed level
specifically in the Hashenge watershed in the North Ethiopia. For current study different
combined methods will be used for instance: LULC change detection, biomass change response
(NDVI), slope DEM analysis, interview, and document analysis will be used to assess and
investigate the linkage in the land use/cover change, driving factors and drawbacks and
challenges of past interventions. The deficit on the soil nutrient include not only NPK but also
the micro nutrients which are very important for the productivity of crop land. Furthermore,
estimates of soil nutrient loss in Ethiopia show a net removal of 41 kg of nitrogen/ha of
agricultural land between 1982 and 1984, and losses projected to reach 47 kg/ha by the year
2000 (FOA, 1989) argued that soil fertility depletion may be a larger problem than erosion in the
Ethiopian highlands.
1.3 General and Specific Objectives
The general objective of this study is to assess the effect of past conservation interventions in the
land resource rehabilitation of the Hashenge watershed based on LULC change analysis over a
period of 40 year. Based on the above-stated general objectives, the following four specific
objectives are formulated in this study:
To identify and map the extent of LULC change over a period of 4 decades.
(1990-2020)
To assess land rehabilitation and/or degradation.
To identify the major driving factors of LULC change.
To determine the nature, rate and location of land use /land cover change.
4
1.4 Research Questions
This study is designed on the bases of the following guiding questions.
1. What are the major land use/cover changes of the study area?
3. What are the major driving factors for the change in LULC?
4. How was the LRM interventions carried out in the watershed? And what were their
achievements, drawbacks and challenges
5
CHAPTER TWO: REVIEW LITERATURE
Sustainable land management refers to the use of land resource for agriculture and other
purposes to meet individual and community needs while simultaneously maintaining the long
term productive potentials of the resource and the maintenance of environmental service through
6
systematic use of indigenous and scientific knowledge and technologies (World Bank, 2001).
(Gete and Hans, 2001) elaborated these concepts as, sustainable land resource management is
more than the use of soil and water conservation (SWC) practices it involves the use of practices
for soil fertility improvements and soil erosion minimization, water management, forestry and
agro-forestry through an integration manner to satisfy the present generation resource needs and
maintain the land resource to support the future generation (Gete and Hans, 2001).
7
et al, 2003).While there is growing interest by farmers in planting eucalyptus trees and the areal
coverage increased rapidly due to the economic values of the specious.
As vegetation cover and quality of soil resources deteriorate, the quantity and quality of water
resources also deteriorates. Many perennial springs and streams had become seasonal. The
negative impact of sedimentation on irrigation projects in the absence of catchment treatment is
evident at the Borkena and Angereb water resources development projects in South Wollo and
North Gondar zones, respectively. And a worsening scenario is envisaged as increasing amounts
of forest, bush, grazing land and marshy areas are brought under intensive cultivation to meet the
increase in food demand due to increasing population pressure. Deforestation rate of the country
declined to 6% between 1995 and 2005 and the non-forest use declined. The reason for this is the
inaccessibility of the remaining forest resources, making their extraction difficult. In the same
period the net change shows a total increase of 8%. The overall forest area declined by 3% in this
period but the report of (FAO, 2000) estimates the forest cover of the country reaches around
15%.
Lambine, (2003) classify the land use land cover change perspective into:- Agent-Based
Perspective: the agent-based perspective is centered on the general nature and rules of land use
decision making by individuals. It represents the motivations behind decisions and the external
factors that influence decisions about land use. Systems Perspective: the systems/structures
8
perspective explains land-use change through the organization and institutions of society.
Institutions, such as governments, communities, or markets, operate interactively at different
spatial and temporal scales; the institutions link local conditions to global processes and vice
versa. The systems perspective highlights, for example, how communities are trapped in a
degradation pathway given complex mechanisms that may have their roots outside the area
subjected to degradation. Narrative Perspective: the narrative perspective seeks depth of
understanding through historical detail and interpretation. It tells a land-use/cover change story
for a specific locality. Historical analyses of landscape grasp all the complexity of events, in
particular stochastic or nonrandom but unpredictable events that significantly affect
land-use/land-cover changes. It includes changing political economies, environmental feedback
on land use, and external shocks. The narrative perspective recognizes the path dependence of
recent evolutions. It avoids the simplifications and erroneous interpretations that could result
from studies focused only on the present and immediate past, outside the context of longer
histories of human environment interactions (Lambine et.al, 2003)
9
2.4. Conservation intervention in Ethiopia
Soil and water conservation practices are long established tradition in Ethiopia: specifically
before 400 years in Konso area (Badege, 2001), According to Shiferaw and, after the realization
of the government the problem of land degradation, forest and wildlife conservation and
development policy was declared in 1980. Following this policy, the government initiated
various studies and capacity-building programs and massive SWC interventions (Badege, 2001),
stated in his study after 1989 soil and water conservation practices have mainly been undertaken
in a form of campaign and quite often farmers have not been involved in the planning process.
Between 1976 and 1990, 71,000 ha of soil and stone bunds 233,000 ha of hillside terraces for
afforestation, 12,000 km of check dams in gullied lands, 390,000 ha of closed areas for natural
regeneration 448,000 ha of land planted with different tree species, and 526,425 ha of bench
terrace interventions were completed mainly through food-for-work (FFW) program incentives
(USAID,2000).
10
and policies. The natural drivers include weather and climatic fluctuations, ecosystem and
geological dynamics, and others (Hurni et al., 2010). But (Lambin et al., 2003) categorized into
six classes which are natural variability, economic and technological factors, demographic,
institutional, and cultural and globalization. The natural drivers include weather and climatic
fluctuations, ecosystem and geological dynamics, and others .In this regard, remote sensing data
have been one of the most important data sources for studies of land cover spatial and temporal
changes
Multi temporal remote sensing data sets allow to map and identify landscape changes, giving an
effective effort to sustainable landscape planning and management. By means of integration of
remote sensing and GIS techniques, it is possible to analyses and to classify the changing pattern
of land cover during a long time period and as a result to understand the changes within the area
of interest (Fichera et al., 2012).Most researcher including Weldeamlake (2003), Amanueal and
Mulugeta (2014), Weldeamlak and Gret (2005), use LULC change detection and NDVI method
to analyze the rate of land use change and level of rehabilitation or degradation of land resources,
but Tessfaye (2009) analysis the impact of IWS management approach through HHS, key
informant interview, FGD and soil analysis to assess the rehabilitation and livelihood
improvement. (Efrem, 2009) use both LULC dynamics and livelihood analysis.
A combined use of different methods LULC change detection, biomass change response
(NDVI), slope DEM analysis, key informant interview, and document analysis will be used to
assess and investigate the linkage in the land use/cover change, driving factors and drawbacks
and challenges of past interventions. A vegetation index is a common spectral index that
identifies the presence of chlorophyll. It is composed of reflectance in the red spectral region
(0.62 to 0.7µm) and a portion of the near infrared spectral region (0.7 to 1.1µm). Chlorophyll has
a relative low reflectance in the red part of the electromagnetic spectrum and a relative high
reflectance in the near infrared part. Vegetation indices are empirical formulae designed to
emphasize the spectral contrast between the red and near infrared regions of the electromagnetic
spectrum. They attempt to measure biomass and vegetative health, the higher the vegetation
index value, the higher the probability that the corresponding area on the ground has a dense
coverage of healthy green. Spectral vegetation indices permit clear discrimination between bare
soil surfaces, water bodies, and vegetation. NDVI = Near infrared - Visible red/Visible red +
11
Near infrared. In general, change detection involves the application of multi-temporal data sets
(mostly remotely sensed data) to quantitatively analyze the temporal effects of the phenomenon
and have two forms. The first one is bi-temporal change detection is a direct comparison, post-
analysis comparison and uniform modeling and it measures changes based on a simple ‘two-
epoch’ time scale comparison (Oettera et al., 2000). And the second one is temporal trajectory
analysis is a time series analysis and the changes based on a ‘continuous’ timescale, focusing
both changes between dates and the progress of the change over the period. Land cover accuracy
is commonly defined as the degree to which the derived classification agrees with reality and the
accuracy of the map in a larger part determines the usefulness of the map (Ashenafi, 2008)
Accuracy assessment is critical for a map generated from any remote sensing data.The accuracy
assessment will be done by comparing the classified image with the land cover classes on the
topographic maps and the ground control points on the field.using the formula of Rate of land
cover changes (ha/year)= (A-B)/C.
Where A-Recent land cover area size B- Previous land covers area size
12
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
13
3.2 Population
Based on the 2007 Census conducted by the Central Statistical Agency of Ethiopia (CSA),Ofla
wereda has a total population of 126,889, of whom 62,278 (49%) were male and 64,611 ( 51%)
female with a density of 116.8 peoples per square kilo meter. But the total population of the
wereda in 2012 increased to 144,027 of which 70,689 (49%) were male and 73,338(51%) were
female (http://www.csa.gov.et/index.php/2013-02-20-13-43-35/national-statistics-abstract/141-
population)
3.3 Climate
The climatic variables of the study area are highly governed by topography of the area (mainly
altitude). Mean annual temperature of the study area ranges from 5°C to 26°C(Fig.3.3 and 3.4).
The area is characterized by a bimodal rainfall pattern with a short rainy season “Belg” from
March to May and a long rainy season “Kiremt” from June to September with a peak in August.
During the long rainy season (Kiremt), mean monthly rainfall ranges from 40–240 mm and
between 40-60mm during short rainy season (Belg) as it is clearly indicated in figure 3.2. The
rainfall pattern in the area is relatively erratic and unpredictable (Misgina Gebrehiwot, 2012).
14
3.4.2 Secondary Data
Satellite images, Topo map, reports, manuals, evaluation documents and other resources in this
study will be used as secondary data sources. Checklists will be used as tools to prepare
secondary data for this purpose.
In order to substantiate the information obtained from the aerial photo and satellite image, the
socio-economic survey will be conducted with a total of 129 households’ i.e. 43 households from
The total household of the study area is 1289 which consists sample size of 129 households.
For data collection formal letter should be written from my host institution, to Ofla District
Administrative Office to get legal permit to conduct my data collection and sample size required
for research purpose.
15
Figure 3.2 Data collection methods and analysis
16
Reference
Ashenafi Burqa. Landuse/landcover dynamics in prosopis juliflora invaded area of Metehara and
the surrounding districts using remote sensing and GIS techniques. Unpubished MSc Thesis,
Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2008. 88
Adugnaw, B., Environmental Degradation and Management in Ethiopian Highlands: Review of
Lessons Learned. International Journal of Environmental Protection and Policy.2014,24-34.
Amanuel, A., Mulugeta, L,. Detecting and Quantifying Land Use/ Land Cover Dynamics in
NaddaAsendabo Watershed,South Western Ethiopia International Journal of Environmental
Sciences. 2014, 45-50
Aklilu A, de Graaff J., Determinants of Adoption and Continued Use Of Stone Terraces For Soil
And Water Conservation In An Ethiopian Highland Watershed. Ecological Economics, 2007;
294-302
Aklilu A,Leo S,Jan de G.,Long-Term Dynamics in Land Resource Use andthe Driving Forcesin
BeressaWatershed,Highlands ofEthiopia.Journal of Environmental Management, 2006 ; 13-32
Badege Bishaw. Deforestation and Land Degradation on the Ethiopian Highlands: A Strategy
for Physical Recovery. Paper Presented at an International Conference on Contemporary
Development Issues in Ethiopia, Kalamazoo, Michigan, U.S.A. August . 2001;16-18
Berry, L., Land Degradation in Ethiopia: its extent and impact. World Bank, Washington. 2003;
23.
Belay Tegene Processes and Causes of Accelerated Erosion on Cultivated Fields of South Wello,
Ethiopia Eastern Africa Social Science Research Review, 2000, 6.
Butt, A., Shabbir, R., Ahmad, S.S., Aziz, N., Land Use Change Mapping and Analysis using
Remote Sensing and GIS. A Case Study of Simly Watershed, Islamabad, Pakistan. The Egyptian
Journal of Remote Sensing and Space Sciences. 2015, 251-259.
CSA, Summary and statistical report of population and housing census ofEthiopia. Central
Statistical Agency, Addis Ababa. 2007.
Daniel, A. M., Remote sensing and GIS based Land use and land cover Change detection in the
upper Dijo river Catchment, Silite zone, Southern Ethiopia. Working papers on population and
land use change in central Ethiopia, nr. 17 NTNU and Addis Ababa University. 2008, 37.
Efrem G., Sandewa M., Ulf So¨D Bruce., M. Campbell Land-Use and Land-Cover Dynamics
in the Central Rift Valley of Ethiopia. Environmental Management 2009, 683–694.
FAO, The Highlands Reclamation Study Ethiopia. Food and Agriculture Organization of the
United Nations, Rome.FinalReport.1986; 2
FAO Land Cover Classification System (LCCS): Classification Concepts and User Manual.
http://www.fao.org/ 2000.
17
Fichera,C.R., Modica,G. and Pollino, M. Land cover classification and Change detection
analysis using multi temporal remote sensed imagery and landscape metrics. European Remote
sens.2012, 1-18.
Gete Z., Hans, H.Implications of Land Use and Land Cover Dynamics for Mountain Resource
Degradation in the Northwestern Ethiopian Highlands Mountain Research and Development.
2001; 184-191.
Haque, I.M., Basak, R.,. Land Cover Change Detection using GIS and Remote Sensing
Techniques: A Spatio-temporal Study on Tanguar Haor, Sunamganj, Bangladesh. The Egyptian
Journal of Remote Sensing and Space Sciences. 2017, 251-263.
Hurni H. Degradation and Conservation of Resources in the Ethiopian Highlands.Mountain
Research and Development. 1988; 123-130.
Hanse H.,Kebede, T., Gete, Z., The Implications of Changes in Population,Land Use, and
Management for Surface Runoff in the Upper Nile Basin Area of Ethiopia Mountain Research
and Development. 2005; 147-154.
Hurni H,Solomon A, Amare, B., Berhanu, D., Ludi E., Portner, B., Birru, Y., Gete, Z., Land
Degradation and Sustainable Land Management in the Highlands of Ethiopia. In: Hurni H,
Wiesmann U,editors; with an international group of co-editors. Global change and sustainable
development:A synthesis of regional experiences from research partnerships. Georaphica
Bernensia. 2010; 187-201.
Lambin, E.F., Helmut, J.G., Erika L,. Dynamics of Land-Use and Land-Cover Change in
Tropical Regions Annual Reviews www.annualreviews.org, 2003, 205-41.
Laura G.,Jeremias M., Integrated Natural Resource Management in the Highlands ofEastern
Africa:From Concept To Practice.International Development Research Center. Earth Scan, New
York. 2012.
Mastewal, Y., Kindeya, G.,Stein, M., Mekuria,W., Impact of Area Enclosures on Density,
Diversity, and Population Structure of Woody Species:the case of May Ba’ati-DougaTembien,
Tigray, Ethiopia. Impact of Area Enclosures on Woody Species Composition: 2006; 99-130.
Mueller-Dombois, D., Ellenberg, H., Aims and Methods of Vegetation Ecology.John Wiley
& Sons, Inc., New York. 1974, 547.
Misgina Gebrehiwot.(2006). An assesement of chanllenges of sustainable rural water supplay :
The case of Ofla wereda in Tigray region. Unpublished MA thesis, Addis Ababa University,
Addis Ababa,Ethiopia,125pp
Oettera, D. R., Cohenb, W. B., Berterretchea, M., Maierspergera, T. K., Kennedy, R. E. Land
Cover Mapping in an Agricultural Setting Using Multi Seasonal Thematic Mapper Data. Remote
Sensing of Environment. 2000, 139-155.
Pender, J., Berhanu, G., Determinants of Agricultural and Land Management Practices and
Impacts on Crop Production and Household Income in the Highlands of Tigray, African
Economies. 2007, 395-450.
18
Rawat, S.J., Kumar, M.,. Monitoring Land Use Cover Change using Remote Sensing and GIS
techniques: A Case Study of Hawalbagh Block, District Almora, Uttarakhand, India. The
Egyptian Journal of Remote Sensing and Space Sciences. 2015, 77- 84
Robin, S., Reid,R. Kruska, L., Nyawira, M., AndualemT.,Wotton S., Cathleen J.Wilson,
Woudyalew, M., Land-Use and Land-Cover Dynamics in Response to Changes in Climatic,
Biological and Socio-Political Forces: the case of South Western Ethiopia Landscape Ecology,©
2000Kluwer Academic Publishers 2000; 339–355.
Stocking, M., Land Degradation and Rehabilitation. Research in Africa Retrospect and Prospect.
Dry Land Networks Program.Issues Paper.International Institute for Environment and
Development. 1992 , 31.
Singh, A., 1989. Digital Change Detection Techniques using Remotely Sensed Data.
International Journal of Remote Sensing. 10, 989–1003
Weldeamlak, B., Integrated Watershed Management in Highland Ethiopia: The
ChemogaWatershed Case Study, PhD thesis,Wageningen University and Research Centre.2003,
210-124.
Woldeamlak, B., Geert, S,.Dynamics in Land Cover and its Effect on Stream Flow in the
Chemoga Watershed, Blue Nile Basin, Ethiopia, Hydrological Processes. Hydro l. Process 2005,
445–458.
Wubie, A. M., Assen, M., Nicolau, D. M., Patterns, Causes, and Consequences of Land
Use/Cover Dynamics in the Gumara Watershed of Lake Tana Basin, North Western Ethiopia.
Environ Syst Res. 2016, 5:8
World Bank,World Development Report:Conflict,Security and Development.
http://wdr2011.worldbank.org/sites/default/files/pdfs/%20WDR2011_Full_Text
Zubair, A,O. Change detection in landuse and landcover using remote sensing data and GIS: A
case study of Illorin and its enviros in Kwara state. University of Ibadan. 2006, 54.
19