Professional Documents
Culture Documents
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Styrene–butadiene–styrene (SBS) modified asphalt (PMA) was prepared by high shear method. Four
Received 10 December 2013 asphalts with different components and four types of SBS copolymers with different S/B ratio and types
Received in revised form 9 March 2014 were selected in this study. The influences of the asphalt components and SBS structure as well as SBS
Accepted 11 March 2014
contents on the particle size distribution of SBS and properties of the SBS modified asphalt were
Available online 10 April 2014
investigated. Fluorescence microscope and the Image-Pro Plus program were chosen to characterize
the microstructure and count the particle size distribution of SBS. The results show that the asphalt
Keywords:
components, SBS structure and content had significant impacts on the particle size distribution of SBS
Asphalt components
SBS structure
polymer in asphalt and the performance of SBS modified asphalt. The high aromatics content and the
Particle size distribution of SBS low asphaltenes content could improve the dispersion of SBS in asphalt. When the S/B ratio is 30/70,
Image-Pro Plus program the particle size distribution curve was the narrowest and the performance of modified asphalt was
SBS modified asphalt improved. With the content of SBS increasing, the particle size distribution curve became wide and the
softening point of the modified asphalt was increased, while the penetration and the ductility were
decreased. The viscosity at 135 °C of modified asphalt was increased with the range of the particle size
distribution curves becoming narrow.
Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2014.03.018
0950-0618/Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
2 F. Dong et al. / Construction and Building Materials 62 (2014) 1–7
analysis method of microstructure was established. However, the Items Unit Copolymer
microstructure was not analyzed quantitatively and the factors of 1201 1301 1401 4303
influencing on the SBS modified asphalt morphology have not been
Structure Linear Linear Linear Radial
investigated systematically. It is known that SBS is a block copoly- Styrene–butadiene ratio 20/80 30/70 40/60 30/70
mer of styrene and butadiene, which has different structures, block Average molecular weight 4
10 g/cm 3
10 10 9.5 28
S/B ratio, and molecule weights. Furthermore, asphalts are extre- Shore hardness A P58 70 92 82
mely complex and variable materials, the properties of which de- Tensile strength MPa 8 25 36.5 14
300% Tensile stress MPa 1.4 2.55 3.86 2.0
pend not only on the crude oil used to obtain the asphalt, but
Breaking elongation % 700 915 755 650
also on the refining process itself. Therefore, it is necessary to Volatile matter % 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7
investigate the influence of asphalt chemical composition and Ash content % 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
SBS structure on the morphology and properties of SBS modified Melt flow rate g/min 0.1–5 0.1–5 0.5–5 0–1.0
asphalt for understanding on the interaction of polymers with dif-
ferent asphalts better. 2.3.2. Rotational viscosity test
The objective of the current study was to investigate the effects The modified asphalt needs remain sufficiently fluid or workable at high
temperatures, so that the energy required during the plant mixing, laydown, and
of asphalt source/grade, the SBS content and structure on the
compaction phases is minimized. The rotational viscometer measures the viscosity
particle size distribution of SBS and properties of the SBS polymer of modified asphalt to evaluate the workability during mixing and compaction pro-
modified asphalt using conventional methods and fluorescence cesses. In this study, the Brookfield viscometer equipped with a thermo container
microscope observation. for control of sample temperature was used to measure the dynamic viscosity of
the prepared samples at 135 °C.
Table 1
Properties of four base asphalts.
Fig. 1a. Fluorescent images of SBS PMA samples with 400 magnifications (original).
It is known that the chemical composition of asphalt affects the weights, and so on. And PS block and PB block play the different
properties of SBS modified asphalt. Fig. 3 illustrates the influence of role in modification. As shown in Fig. 4, the S/B ratios have a signif-
asphalt components on the properties of SBS modified asphalt. SBS icant effect on the dispersion of SBS. On the contrary, radial and
modification caused increases in both softening point and ductility linear SBS with the same S/B display almost present the same par-
at low temperature, and reductions in penetration. Notably, there ticle size distribution curves. As the S/B ratio of linear SBS in-
are great differences in properties of SBS modified asphalt pre- creases, the range of curves becomes narrower, and then wider
pared by different types of asphalt [1,30]. As for the different grade again. It is found that the range of the particle size distribution is
of asphalt, the softening point of modified asphalt prepared by AH- wider than others when the S/B was 20/80, which is from 0 to
90 asphalt is lower than that of AH-70 asphalt. On the contrary, 6 lm, and the dispersion of SBS particles was heterogeneous.
penetration at 25 °C and ductility at 5 °C of modified asphalt pre- When the S/B ratio increases to 30/70, the SBS particles were bro-
pared by AH-90 is higher than that of AH-70 asphalt. As for the ken into small pieces and the range is from 0 to 2.0 lm. However,
same grade asphalt, the soften point of SBS modified asphalt de- when the S/B ratio continues to increase, the range of the particle
crease as aromatics content increases. While the contents of aro- size distribution is becoming wider again. Polystyrene (PS) blocks
matics are similarly, the soften point and viscosity of SBS tend to clump with each other and clumped PS blocks are held to-
modified asphalt increase as asphaltenes content increases. The re- gether by poly-butadiene (PB) blocks, leading to a rubbery struc-
sults indicated that the high asphaltene content could improve the ture. While, PS blocks from the hard segment impart strength to
high temperature performance of modified asphalt. Evidently, to the resin, PB blocks from the soft segment increase the elasticity
produce a polymer modified binder with good compatibility, the of the copolymer [6,32]. Compared with the S/B ratio, the SBS type
content of aromatics of the base asphalt should be sufficiently high has a different effect on the dispersion of SBS. There has a little dif-
for the polymer to compete with asphaltenes. Therefore, it is rea- ference between the range of radial SBS and linear SBS. The molec-
sonable to expect that the compatibility of SBS modified asphalts ular weights of radial SBS is twice times than that of linear SBS, and
may be improved by the addition of aromatic oil [31]. However, the compatibility of radial SBS and asphalt is poorer, which have
an excessive content of aromatic or an insufficient content of bad effect on SBS dispersion.
asphaltenes in base asphalt may lead to modified binders with a The solubility parameter is an important measurement to pre-
single phase which show no significant improvement in mechani- dict compatibility between different materials, which has been
cal properties. Otherwise, the viscosity of modified asphalt is applied in polymer and relative fields. The approximate solubility
increasing with the range of the particle size distribution curves parameters of the asphalt components and that of the blocks of
narrowing, which is in accord with the influence of the asphaltene the copolymers are listed in Table 3 [33]. It is found that asphalt-
content. enes are the most polar components and the PB blocks are less po-
lar than the PS ones. PB blocks are less polar than all the maltenes
3.2. Influence of SBS structure on particle size distribution of SBS and constituents. Therefore, SBS is relatively miscible with maltenes,
the properties of SBS modified asphalt but almost completely immiscible with asphaltenes. The solubility
parameter of the blocks PB is 16.5–17.6, which are easily swollen
In order to investigate the effect of the structure of SBS includ- by saturates. However, the solubility parameter of the blocks PS
ing the types and block S/B ratios on the dispersion of SBS as well is 18.6–19.8, which have good compatibility with aromatics. So it
as the performance of modified asphalt, four kinds of SBS with ra- could be concluded that the asphalt components have a great effect
dial, linear and different S/B ratios were selected. In this part, four on the dispersion of SBS. Generally speaking, with the blocks S/B
kinds of SBS including 1201, 1301, 1401, and 4303 were used as increasing, the gathering energy of the blocks PS is more. There-
the modifiers. QHD AH-70 asphalt was chosen as the base asphalt. fore, more energy is needed to disperse SBS in asphalt.
The loading level of SBS was 3% by weight of modified asphalt. The The relationships between the SBS structure and the perfor-
modification parameters have been mentioned in Section 2.2. mance of SBS modified asphalt are shown in Fig. 5. As the block
SBS is a tri-block copolymer with poly-styrene (PS) which is the S/B ratio increases, the values of the performance of SBS modified
thermoplastic end block and poly-butadiene (PB) which is the rub- asphalt including the softening point, the penetration at 25 °C, and
bery midblock, linear and radial structure, different molecular the viscosity at 135 °C have a peak value. This suggests that the SBS
Fig. 3. Influence of asphalt types on the performance of SBS modified asphalt. Fig. 4. Influence of SBS structure on particle size distribution of SBS.
F. Dong et al. / Construction and Building Materials 62 (2014) 1–7 5
Table 3 shear rate of 3000 rpm, shear time of 60 min, and shear tempera-
Solubility parameters of asphalt components and SBS polymer blocks. ture of 175 °C in Fig. 6.
Asphalt Solubility parameter Polymer Solubility parameter It is found that the SBS contents have the greatest effect on the
component (MPa)0.5 blocks (MPa)0.5 dispersion of SBS in asphalt presented in Fig. 6. The particle size
Saturates 17.4–20 PS 18.6–19.8 distribution curves shows great changes as the contents increase.
Aromatics 19–22.5 PB 16.5–17.6 The range of the curve at the SBS content of 1.0% is the narrowest
Resins 21.9–26.6 than others, which is 0–1.6 lm. Meanwhile, the SBS is dispersed
Asphaltenes 24.9–32.9
uniformly in asphalt and the particle size is small. At low polymer
content, the small polymer globules which are swollen by the base
asphalt compatible fractions are spread homogenously in a contin-
uous asphalt phase. That is to say, there is enough maltenes in as-
phalt to swell SBS and then make swollen SBS disperse into small
pieces uniformly. When the SBS content increases to 3.0%, the
curve have two peaks and the range of particle size distribution
is wider than that at content of 1.0%. However, when the content
of SBS continues to increase, particle size distribution curves of
SBS start to become complicated. Especially, when the content in-
creases to 5%, the range of the curve becomes wider than others,
which is 0–6 lm. At higher polymer concentrations, a larger quan-
tity of polar aromatics is subtracted from maltenes, and therefore,
the colloidal structure of asphaltene micelles or micellar aggre-
gates is no longer stabilized and tends to collapse. Meanwhile,
the maltenes in asphalt are limited [35]. SBS are not swollen suffi-
ciently as the content of SBS increases. Compared with the initial
composition of asphalt cement, the swelling of SBS cause an in-
crease in asphaltene content, and finally leads to a hard matrix.
So there is an optimum polymer content for the modified asphalt
which has good performance and superior dispersion of SBS.
Mohammad et al. [36] found that the phase morphology of two
Fig. 5. Influence of SBS structure on the performance of SBS modified asphalt. interlocked continuous phases was an ideal microstructure for
polymer modified road asphalt, and the optimum polymer content
was determined based on the formation of the critical network be-
structure has a great effect on the compatibility of modified as-
tween asphalt and polymer.
phalt and there is a moderate block S/B ratio for SBS. It has been
On the contrary, at the different polymer content, the effect of
reported that the glassy PS domains of SBS increase the stiffness
dispersion of SBS on the performance of modified asphalt is differ-
of asphalt for high temperature, whereas the rubbery PB midblocks
ent. As the content of polymer increases, the softening point of the
resist thermal cracking at low service temperatures [1]. In addition,
modified asphalt increases, while the penetration at 25 °C and the
the ductility at 5 °C decreases regularly with the increase of S/B ra-
ductility at 5 °C decreases shown in Figs. 7a and 7b. There is limited
tio. The PS is the hard segment and with the S/B ratio increasing,
increase in viscosity and softening point at a concentration of 1%
the hardness of SBS is growing, and so the tenacity of SBS becomes
because the SBS only acts as a dispersed polymer. As the penetra-
badly. Notably, whether the type of SBS is radial or linear, the soft-
tion and softening point results, the viscosities also give an indica-
ening point and the viscosity at 135 °C are higher than others while
tion of the stiffening effect of SBS modification. The viscosity values
the penetration at 25 °C is lower than others when the block S/B
and modification indices related to modified asphalt prepared by
ratio is 30/70, which are consistent with the effects of SBS structure
high content SBS are higher than that prepared by low content
on the dispersion of SBS. Meanwhile, the softening point and the
SBS. This may be due to that the higher content of SBS needs more
viscosity of radial SBS modified asphalt is higher than that of linear
one, which is due to the higher molecular weights and stereo-hin-
drance effect of radial SBS.
than others. However, the dispersion of SBS and the trends of per-
formance of modified asphalt prepared by radial and linear SBS at
the S/B of 30/70 have little difference.
The content of SBS also has great effect on the dispersion of SBS
and the performance of modified asphalt. However, the results are
contrary to that of the other factors. Lowering content of SBS is
conducive to improve the dispersion of SBS, but has bad effect on
the performance of modified asphalt; in other words, the particle
size distribution becomes wider and the softening point of the
modified asphalt increases, the penetration and the ductility
decreases, as the content of SBS increases.
Acknowledgements
References
[1] Shingo K, Shigeru T, Zhang XM, Dong DW, Inagaki N. Compatibilizer role of
styrene–butadiene–styrene tri-block copolymer in asphalt. Polym J
2001;33(3):209–13.
[2] Sengoz B, Isikyakar G. Evaluation of the properties and microstructure of SBS
and EVA polymer modified bitumen. Constr Build Mater 2007;22:1897–905.
[3] Navarro FJ, Martinezboza FJ, Partal P, Gallegos C. Effect of processing variables
on the linear viscoelastic properties of SBS–oil blends. Polym Eng Sci
2001;41(12):2216–25.
[4] Airey GD. Styrene butadiene styrene polymer modification of road bitumens. J
Mater Sci 2004;39:951–9.
[5] Becker IM, Muller AJ, Rodriguez Y. Use of rheological compatibility criteria to
study SBS modified asphalts. J Appl Polym Sci 2003;90:1772–82.
[6] Airey GD. Rheological properties of styrene butadiene styrene polymer
modified road bitumens. Fuel 2003;82:1709–19.
[7] Larsen Diego O, Alessandrini José Luis, Bosch Alejandra, Susana Cortizo M.
Micro-strutural and rheological characteristics of SBS-asphalt blends during
their manufacturing. Constr Build Mater 2009;23:2769–74.
[8] Ouyang CF, Wang SF, Zhang Y, Zhang YX. Preparation and properties of
styrene–butadiene–styrene copolymer/kaolinite clay compound and asphalt
Fig. 7b. Influence of SBS content on the performance of SBS modified asphalt. modified with the compound. Polym Degrad Stab 2005;87:309–17.
[9] Polacco G, Stastna J, Biondi L. Relation between polymer architecture and
nonlinear viscoelastic behavior of modified asphalt. Eur Polym J
maltenes at the same process condition. However, the maltenes in 2006;42:446–57.
asphalt are limited. It should be also mentioned that the perfor- [10] Mehmet Y, Muhammed E. Effects of SBS and different natural asphalts on the
mance of the modified asphalt is not only dependent on the properties of bituminous binders and mixtures. Constr Build Mater
2013;44:533–40.
polymer dispersion but also on the polymer content. This means
[11] Taner A, Mesude Y. Effects of different polymers on mechanical properties of
the high values of polymer dispersion does not always reflect the bituminous binders and hot mixtures. Constr Build Mater 2013;42:161–7.
continuous polymer phase. These results are consistent with the [12] Zhang F, Hu CB. The research for SBS and SBR compound modified asphalts
with polyphosphoric acid and sulfur. Constr Build Mater 2013;43:461–8.
effects of polymer content on the dispersion of SBS.
[13] Feng ZG, Yu JY, Xue LH, Sun YB. Rheological and aging properties of ultraviolet
absorber/styrene–butadiene–styrene-modified bitumens. J Appl Polym Sci
4. Conclusions 2013;128:2571–7.
[14] Sengoz B, Isikyakar G. Analysis of styrene–butadiene–styrene polymer
modified bitumen using fluorescent microscopy and conventional test
In this study, SBS copolymer was blended with asphalt to methods. J Hazard Mater 2008;150:424–32.
investigate the effect of SBS modification on asphalt binder proper- [15] Sengoz B, Topal A, Isikyakar G. Morphology and image analysis of polymer
modified bitumens. Constr Build Mater 2009;23:1986–92.
ties. The asphalt type, SBS structure and contents have significant [16] Xiao Y, Yuan Y, Zhang XN. Relationship between the micro disperse state of
impacts on the particle size distribution of SBS polymer and the SBS and the performance of modified asphalt. J South China Univ Technol
performance of SBS modified asphalt. 2005;33(8):83–6.
[17] Xiao P, Kang AH, Liu BB. Quantitatively analysis on modified asphalt by
The contents of aromatics in asphalt play a significant role in fluorescent microscope. Pet Asphalt 2005;19(3):45–8.
compatibility between asphalt and polymer, and the higher [18] Yang Q, Yin W. Novel performance measurements of SBS modified asphalt
contents of aromatics was, the better the performance of modified based on microstructure pictures. J TongJi Univ 2012;40(8):1176–9.
[19] Zuguang Liu, Shifeng Wang, Dizhen Wang. Morphology and properties of SBS
asphalt. Meanwhile, asphaltenes content must be proper. The high modified asphalt of different S/B ratio. China Plast Ind 2005;33(4):50–3.
aromatics content and the low asphaltenes content could improve [20] GB/T 4507–2010. Standard test method for softening point of bitumen (ring-
the dispersion of SBS in asphalt. With the range of the particle size and-ball apparatus).
[21] GB/T 4509–2010. Standard test method for bitumen – determination of
distribution curves narrowing, the viscosity of modified asphalt
penetration.
increases. [22] GB/T 4508–2010. Standard test method for ductility of bitumen.
As the S/B ratio increases, there is a moderate S/B ratio for the [23] SH/T 0905–2010. Standard test method for separation of asphalt into four
dispersion of SBS and the performance of modified asphalt. When fractions.
[24] Zhang QQ, Fan WY, Wang TZ, Nan GZ, Jaka Sunarso. Influence of emulsification
the S/B ratio is 30/70, the particle size distribution curve is narrow- on the properties of styrene–butadiene–styrene chemically modified
est and the performance of modified asphalt is improved higher bitumens. Constr Build Mater 2012;29:97–101.
F. Dong et al. / Construction and Building Materials 62 (2014) 1–7 7
[25] Chen J, Liao M, Shiah M. Asphalt modified by SBS tri-block copolymer- [31] Wang T. Study on compatibility of waste plastic-modified asphalt. China Univ
morphology and model. J Mater Civil Eng 2002;14(3):224–9. Petrol 2010.
[26] Airey G. Rheological evaluation of ethylene vinyl acetate polymer modified [32] Isacsson U, Lu X. Testing and appraisal of polymer modified road bitumens:
bitumens. Constr Build Mater 2002;16:473–87. state of the art. Mater Struct 1995;28:139–59.
[27] Luo H, Deng WA, Gao JJ, Fan WY, Que GH. Dispersion of water-soluble catalyst [33] Ho RM, Adedeji A, Giles DW, Hajduk DA, Macosko CW, Bates FS. Microstructure
and its influence on the slurry-phase hydrocracking of residue. Energy Fuels of triblock copolymers in asphalt oligomers. J Polym Sci: Part B Polym Phys
2011;25:1161–7. 1997;35:2857–77.
[28] Cavaliere MG, Diani E, Dia MD. Dynamic mechanical characterization of binder [34] Chen JS, Liao MC, Tsai HH. Evaluation and optimization of the engineering
and asphalt concrete. In: Proceedings of the Euroasphalt and Eurobitumen properties of polymer-modified asphalt. Pract Fail Anal 2002;2(3):75–83.
Congress, No.5551, 1996. [35] Giovanni P, Antonio M, Dario B, Simona S. Effect of composition on the
[29] Chen JS, Huang CC. Fundamental characterization of SBS-modified asphalt properties of SEBS modified asphalts. Eur Polym J 2006;42:1113–21.
mixed with sulfur. J Appl Polym Sci 2007;103:2817–25. [36] Mohammad LN, Negulescul l, Wu Z, Daranga C, Daly WH, Abadie C.
[30] Yilmaz M, Çeloglu ME. Effects of SBS and different natural asphalts on the Investigation of the use of recycled polymer modified asphalt binder in
properties of bituminous binders and mixtures. Constr Build Mater asphalt concrete Pavements. J Assoc Asphalt Paving Technol 2003;72:551–94.
2013;44:533–40.