You are on page 1of 144

VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM .

Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Lecturer: Renato Antonio Bertao
March 1st, 2024
CLASS 1/10
© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024
VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

WELCOME!
Let’s experience a design thinking
boot camp!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Before starting…
Let’s know each other!
I will start by introducing myself.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Ho Chi Min, Vietnam


6 PM

Curitiba, Brazil
8 AM

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Vietnam, Hanoi, July 2018

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Renato Antonio Bertão


• Ph.D. in [Smart Experience] Design (Kookmin University, Korea)
• MBA in International Business (Ajou University, Korea)
• Master’s in Information Science (UFPR, Brazil)
• Bachelor in Fine Arts (EMBAP, Brazil)
• Associate degree in Industrial Design (UTFPR, Brazil)

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Renato Antonio Bertão


Educator and researcher in the design and visual arts disciplines since 2001.
• ORCID
• Research Gate
• LinkedIn

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Renato Antonio Bertão


Independent design researcher
Research topics: DESIGN THINKING Experience design
Artificial intelligence Design methods
Innovation Information science
Business model innovation Fashion design
Visual communication design Media art

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Now it is your turn!


But let’s make it different with the help
of a spokesperson.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

You have 2 min to…


1. Find a colleague in the class to interview and be
interviewed.
Please choose someone you are not close to.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

You have 3 min to…


2. Get key information about your colleague.
For instance: name, educational and professional
background, knowledge about design thinking,
something you think we should know, etc.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Your colleague has 3 min to…


2. Get key information about you.
For instance: name, educational and professional
background, knowledge about design thinking,
something your colleague thinks we should know,
etc.
© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024
VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Each of you has 30 seconds to…


3. Prepare to be your colleague’s spokesperson.
You will introduce her/him in 30 seconds!
Be compelling to introduce this colleague to your
classmates!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Let’s start!
Who’s the first spokesperson?

[Estimated time: 15 min]

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Nice to meet you all!


Thank you for the opportunity to teach you!
I hope we have a great time in the next weeks.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Before starting, a few important


information.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

If there is any internet connection


issue, I will connect to VLU as soon as
possible.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Also, I will be in close contact with


professor the TA and Professor Thai to
manage the issue quickly.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

I will try to speak English slowly.


If needed, the TA will translate the
contents into the Vietnamese
language.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

How will the translation work?


1. I will present a couple of slides.
2. Then, I stop, and, if needed, the TA
translates the contents.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

If you cannot understand my English,


or you cannot follow my point, feel
free to ask me to repeat/clarify it.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

And now, the Design Thinking journey


begins!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Course description

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Course objectives
Provide students with:
• An understanding of design thinking logic and entire process;
• An opportunity for a hands-on experience with the design thinking
methodology;
• An applied context for using design thinking's creative problem-solving
tools;

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Course objectives
Provide students with:
• A training on design thinking based on current practices in the global
industry;
• Opportunities to deliver innovative and human-centered solutions for
wicked problems in the following contexts:
• Education (e.g., Vanlang University),
• Urban & Business (e.g., Ho Chi Minh City),
• Social (Vietnamese people's life).

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

What will you study and learn?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Course contents

• Wicked problems;
• Human-centered design;
• Design thinking process and methodology;
• Design thinking tools;
• d.school's design thinking model [Empathize, Define, Ideate, Prototype,
Test, Assess];

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Course contents

• Design thinking for non-designers;


• Design thinking boot camp [Training];
• Business design [Empathy & deep human understanding; Concept
visualization; Strategic business design];

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

What does your learning journey look


like?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Course map
Lecture # Topic
1 Introduction to Design Thinking
2 Pre-boot camp | Problem finding
3 Boot camp | Empathize
4 Boot camp | Define [A]
5 Boot camp | Define [B]
6 Boot camp | Ideate
7 Boot camp | Prototype and test
8 Boot camp | Iterate
9 Boot camp | Assess [Business Design]
10 Boot camp | Assess [Pitch]
© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024
VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Schedule [Class 3]

This is a tentative schedule for February 19th.


It may be adjusted later by an agreement between the Professor and students.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Stay tuned!
There are two breaks (March 08 and 29) on the
course schedule to help teams to conduct fieldwork.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Class information | #1

2024 March
Day 01 (Fri)
Time (UTC+7) 6:00 ~ 9:00 PM [Class 3]
Class 1
Step Introduction
Topic DESIGN THINKING
Lecture Innovation; Wicked problems; Creative problem-solving; Human-centered design; Design
thinking
Group activity Self-introduction [spokesperson]
Assignment [Submission] -
Assignment [Next class] 1A: Identifying problems in daily life | Individual assignment: Field observation findings
[report submission]

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

How about the learning process


assessment?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Individual and team evaluation will


be adopted in this course.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Course evaluation
Assignments [Design thinking project] Class(es) Points
1A, 1B, 1C: Pre-boot camp [Individual + team assignment] | Reports 1~2 1
2A, 2B, 2C, 2D, 2E, 2F: Boot camp [Team assignment] | Design thinking project 3~9 5,5
4: Boot camp [Team outcomes and presentation] | Design thinking project 10 1,5
5: Pitiching scores [Team outcomes] | Design thinking project 10 2
TOTAL 10

Assignment [Midterm exam] Class Points


3: Midterm exam [Individual written assignment] | Critical essay 7 10
TOTAL 10

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Course evaluation
Assignments Points Weight FINAL GRADE
1A, 1B, 1C [Reports], 2A, 2B, 2C, 2D, 2E, 2F, 4, 5 [Design thinking project] 10 60%
10
3 [Midterm exam] 10 40%

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

And how about the course


references?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Core references

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
References
• d.school, and Hasso Pla.ner Ins2tute of Design at Stanford. 2016. 'Design Project Guide'. h.ps://dschool.stanford.edu/resources/design-
project-guide-1.
• d.school, and Hasso Pla.ner Ins2tute of Design at Stanford. 2013. 'Design Thinking Bootleg'. h.ps://dschool.stanford.edu/resources/the-
bootcamp-bootleg.
• d.school, and Hasso Pla.ner Ins2tute of Design at Stanford. 2019. ‘8 Core [Design] Abili2es'. h.ps://dschool.stanford.edu/about/#about-8-
core-abili2es.
• Design Council. n.d. 'Framework for Innova2on' Accessed 17 May 2023. h.ps://www.designcouncil.org.uk/our-resources/framework-for-
innova2on/.
• IDEO. 2015. 'The Field Guide to Human-Centered Design'. h.ps://www.designkit.org/resources/1.html.
• IDEO. n.d. 'IDEO Design Thinking'. Design Thinking Defined. h.ps://designthinking.ideo.com.
• IDEO.org. n.d. 'Design Kit | Methods'. IDEO.Org. h.ps://www.designkit.org/methods.html.
• Bertão, R. A.; Jung, C. H.; Chung, J.; Joo, J. (2023). “Design thinking: a customized blueprint to train R & D personnel in crea2ve problem-
solving.” Thinking Skills and Crea0vity Journal, 48, 101253. h.ps://doi.org/10.1016/j.tsc.2023.101253
• Bertão, R. A.; Jung, C. H.; Joo J. (2022). "Iden2fying Inconveniences in Daily Life: A Problem Finding Prompt to Foster Non-Designers'
Engagement in Design Thinking Training." In 13th Design Thinking Research Symposium, 345–68. Haifa: Technion - Israel Ins2tute of
Technology.
• Brown, T. 2009. Change by Design: How Design Thinking Transforms Organiza0ons and Inspires Innova0on. New York: Harvard Business
Press.
• Fraser, H. M. A. 2012. Design Works: How to Tackle Your Toughest Innova0on Challenges through Business Design. Toronto: University of
Toronto Press.
© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024
VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

If possible, please download all the


PDF files linked in the references.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
[Free download] References

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Other references (Books)

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Time to start!
But before delving into DESIGN
THINKING…

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

First, let’s learn some essential


concepts.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

CORE CONCEPTS
Related to design thinking
• Innovation
• Wicked problems
• Creative problem solving
• Human-centered design

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

What is innovation?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

INNOVATION
Definition [Oslo Manual]
“An innovation is a new or improved product or
process (or combination thereof) that differs
significantly from the unit’s previous products or
processes and that has been made available to
potential users (product) or brought into use by the
unit (process).”
(OECD, 2018)

OECD/Eurostat. (2018). Oslo Manual 2018 - Guidelines For Collecting, Reporting And Using Data On Innovation 4th Edition.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

INNOVATION
Types [Oslo Manual]
OLD EDITION NEW EDITION
• Product • Goods
• Services
• Goods and services include knowledge-capturing products, and
combinations thereof.
• Includes the design characteristics of goods and services.
• Process • Production
• Distribution and logistics
• Information and communication systems
• Organizational • Administration and management
• Marketing • Marketing, sales and aftersales support
• Product and business process development

OECD/Eurostat. (2018). Oslo Manual 2018 - Guidelines For Collecting, Reporting And Using Data On Innovation 4th Edition.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Applica?on Art Industry

Other perspectives about innovation…

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

INNOVATION
Approaches

Damanpour’s (1991) considers three pairs of innovation:


• administrative and technical,
• product and process,
• incremental and radical.

Damanpour, F. (1991) ‘Organizational Innovation: a Meta-Analysis of Effects of Determinants and Moderators’, Academy of Management Journal, 34(3), pp. 555–590.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Applica?on Art Industry

INNOVATION
Approaches
Despite lacking [academic/industry] consensus, these two are often cited:

INCREMENTAL RADICAL
INOVATION INNOVATION

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

INNOVATION
Approaches

INCREMENTAL RADICAL
INOVATION INNOVATION

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Applica?on Art Industry

INNOVATION
Approaches

INCREMENTAL RADICAL
INOVATION INNOVATION
“R&D based” “Disruptive”

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

And how does innovation happen?


Let’s explore some tracks!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Applica?on Art Industry

INNOVATION TRACKS

• Businesses and corporations


• Governments and NGOs
• Organizations (for- and not-for-profit)

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

INNOVATION TRACKS
Businesses and corporations

Businesses and focus on to deliver better Profit is the


corporations customers’ needs products or ultimate
seeking INNOVATION and desires services. goal.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Applica?on Art Industry

INNOVATION TRACKS
Governments and NGOs

Governments and focus on citizens’ to deliver better Social welfare


NGOs seeking needs and [public] services. is the ultimate
INNOVATION desires goal.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

In summary:

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Applica?on Art Industry

INNOVATION TRACKS
Organizations (for- and not-for-profit)

Organizations focus on to deliver better Competitiveness


(for- and not-for- stakeholders’ structures and and efficiency are
profit) seeking INNOVATION needs and desires processes. the ultimate goals.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Let’s pay attention to the target


audiences.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Applica?on Art Industry

Businesses and focus on to deliver better Profit is the


corporations customers’ needs products or ultimate
seeking INNOVATION and desires services. goal.

Governments and focus on citizens’ to deliver better Social welfare


NGOs seeking needs and [public] services. is the ultimate
INNOVATION desires goal.

Organizations focus on to deliver better Competitiveness


(for- and not-for- stakeholders’ structures and and efficiency are
profit) seeking INNOVATION needs and desires processes. the ultimate goals.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Customers’ needs
and desires

Citizens’
INNOVATION needs and desires

Stakeholders’
needs and desires

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Customers’ needs
and desires

Citizens’
INNOVATION needs and desires

Stakeholders’
needs and desires

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Customers’ needs
and desires

Ci?zens’
INNOVATION needs and desires

Stakeholders’
needs and desires

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

ILL-DEFINED
INNOVATION PROBLEMS

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

WICKED
INNOVATION PROBLEMS

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

10 min break to stretch, get some


drink/food, relax, etc.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

10 min break!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

So, what is a wicked problem?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

WICKED PROBLEMS

”(…) refer to that class of social system problems


which are ill-formulated, where the information is
confusing, where there are many clients and decision
makers with conflicting values, and where the
ramifications in the whole system are thoroughly
confusing.”
(Churchman, 1967)

Churchman, C. W. (1967). Wicked Problems. Management Science, 14(4), 7.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

WICKED PROBLEMS

According to RiYel and Webber (1973), wicked problems


have ten proper^es:

Rittel, H., & Webber, M. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 155–169.
https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/facing-complexity-wicked-design-problems-ee8c71618966

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Rittel, H., & Webber, M. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 155–169.
https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/facing-complexity-wicked-design-problems-ee8c71618966

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Rittel, H., & Webber, M. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 155–169.
https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/facing-complexity-wicked-design-problems-ee8c71618966

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Rittel, H., & Webber, M. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 155–169.
https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/facing-complexity-wicked-design-problems-ee8c71618966

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Rittel, H., & Webber, M. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 155–169.
https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/facing-complexity-wicked-design-problems-ee8c71618966

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

WICKED PROBLEMS
Examples
Poverty
Natural hazards
Climate change

Waste
Public healthcare

Knowledge management
Business strategy
Education

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

WICKED PROBLEMS
Example

POVERTY

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

WICKED PROBLEMS
Interconnections

Education Nutri^on

POVERTY
Economy

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

WICKED PROBLEMS
InterconnecMons

Education Nutrition

POVERTY
Economy

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

How to solve a wicked problem?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

OR ?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

How do you tackle wicked problems


and innovate?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

A possible approach…

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

CREATIVE PROBLEM SOLVING


Designers’ approach

h`ps://medium.com/interacaon-service-design-concepts-principles/the-wicked-problem-could-we-solve-it-e5325e44f1bf

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

You are studying about creative


problem solving in the CREATIVE
METHODOLOGY course…

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

So, let’s briefly remind some key


concepts.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

CREATIVE PROBLEM SOLVING (CPS)


Definition
“(…) a proven method for approaching a problem or a challenge
in an imaginaBve and innovaBve way.
It helps people re-define the problems and opportuni^es they
face, come up with new, innova^ve responses and solu^ons, and
then take ac^on. The tools and techniques used make the process
fun, engaging, and collabora^ve.”
(Creacve Problem Solving Resource Guide, n.d.)

https://www.creativeeducationfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/CPS-Guide-6-3-web.pdf

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

CREATIVE PROBLEM SOLVING (CPS)


Definition
• “CREATIVE: elements of newness, innovation, and novelty.
• PROBLEM: any situation that presents a challenge, offers an
opportunity, or represents a troubling concern.
• SOLVING: devising ways to answer, to meet, or to satisfy a
situation by changing self or situation.”
(Noller, 1978)

Creative Problem Solving Resource Guide https://www.creativeeducationfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/CPS-Guide-6-3-web.pdf

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

CREATIVE PROBLEM SOLVING


Core principles
• “Divergent and convergent thinking must be balanced.
• Ask problems as ques^ons.
• Defer or suspend judgment.
• Focus on ‘Yes, and ...’ rather than ‘No, but.’ “
(Creacve Problem Solving Resource Guide, n.d.)

https://www.creativeeducationfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/CPS-Guide-6-3-web.pdf

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

CREATIVE PROBLEM SOLVING


Process
Osborn-Parnes model:

Buijs, J.A., & van der Meer, H. (2009). Towards a More Realistic Creative Problem Solving Approach. Wiley-Blackwell: Creativity & Innovation Management.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

CREATIVE PROBLEM SOLVING


Process
Mumford et al. model:

Mumford, M. D., & McIntosh, T. (2017). Creative thinking processes: The past and the future. The Journal of Creative Behavior, 51(4), 317–322.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

And how about Human-Centered


Design (HCD)?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
Definition
“Human-centered design is a creative approach to problem solving.”
(IDEO, n.d.)

https://designthinking.ideo.com/faq/whats-the-difference-between-human-centered-design-and-design-thinking

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
DefiniMon
“It’s a process that starts with the people you’re designing with and ends
with new solutions that are purpose-built to suit their needs.
Human-centered design is about cultivating deep empathy with the people
you’re designing with; generating ideas; building a bunch of prototypes;
sharing what you’ve made together; and eventually, putting your innovative
new solution out in the world.”
(IDEO, n.d.)

https://designthinking.ideo.com/faq/whats-the-difference-between-human-centered-design-and-design-thinking

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
Definition
“By [embedding human-centered design] innovation is powered by a thorough
understanding, through direct observation, of what people want and need in
their lives and what they like or dislike about the way particular products are
made, packaged, marketed, sold, and supported.”
(Brown, 2008)

Brown, Tim. 2008. 'Design Thinking'. Harvard Business Review, 2008.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
DefiniMon
“Human-centered design is a creative approach to problem solving.”
(IDEO, n.d.)

https://designthinking.ideo.com/faq/whats-the-difference-between-human-centered-design-and-design-thinking

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
Definition
“Human-centered design is a creative approach to problem solving.”
(IDEO, n.d.)

https://designthinking.ideo.com/faq/whats-the-difference-between-human-centered-design-and-design-thinking

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
DefiniMon
“Human-centered design is a creative approach to problem solving.”
(IDEO, n.d.)

https://designthinking.ideo.com/faq/whats-the-difference-between-human-centered-design-and-design-thinking

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
Principles

https://www.interaction-design.org/literature/topics/human-centered-design

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
Principles
Be people-centered (Norman, 2019)
“Focus on the people”

https://jnd.org/the-four-fundamental-principles-ofhuman-centered-design/

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
Principles
Understand and address the core problems (Norman, 2019)
“Solve the core, root issues, not just the problem as presented (which is often
the symptom, not the cause)”

https://jnd.org/the-four-fundamental-principles-ofhuman-centered-design/

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
Principles
Use an activity-centered systems approach (Norman, 2019)
“Take a systems point of view, realizing that most complications result from
the interdependencies of the multiple parts.”

https://jnd.org/the-four-fundamental-principles-ofhuman-centered-design/

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
Principles
Use rapid iterations of prototyping and testing (Norman, 2019)
“Continually test and refine the proposed designs to ensure they truly meet
the needs of the concerns of the people for whom they are intended.”

https://jnd.org/the-four-fundamental-principles-ofhuman-centered-design/

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
IDEO’s approach

What is Human Centered Design? | IDEO video (2 min)

h`ps://vimeo.com/106505300

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
IDEO’s process

IDEO. (2015). The Field Guide to Human-Centered Design (p. 192). http://www.designkit.org/resources/1

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN
IDEO’s process

INSPIRATION IDEATION IMPLEMENTATION

IDEO. (2015). The Field Guide to Human-Centered Design (p. 192). http://www.designkit.org/resources/1

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

We will come back to the IDEO’s HCD


process soon.
Now, let’s talk about IDEO.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO

• A global design and innovation company


founded in 1978.
• Widely known for its human-centered,
interdisciplinary approach.
• Tim Brown and David Kelley, the early
leaders in the practice of design thinking. Tim Brown David Kelley

https://www.ideo.com/about/ideo-at-a-glance

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO
Innovation approach
ABC Nightline [TV show]
The shopping cart challenge

(1999)
Key moments (~9 min)

h`ps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M66ZU2PCIcM

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO
Innovation approach

(2009)
(2004)

https://www.ideo.com/post/the-power-of-design-in-businessweek
Brown, T. (2009). Change by Design: How design thinking transforms organizations and inspires innovation. Harvard Business Press.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO
Design thinking

Design thinking is
presented as an
innovation approach in
the Harvard Business
Review (2008).

Brown, T. (2008). Design Thinking. Harvard Business Review, 86(6), 84–92.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO
Design thinking

“Thinking like a designer


can transform the way
you develop products,
services, process — and
even strategy.”
(Brown, 2008)

Brown, T. (2008). Design Thinking. Harvard Business Review, 86(6), 84–92.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO
Design thinking origins

“IDEO is often credited with inventing the term “design thinking” and its
practice.
In fact, design thinking has deep roots in a global conversation that has been
unfolding for decades.”
(IDEO, n.d.)

https://designthinking.ideo.com/

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO
Design thinking origins

Design-driven innovation
practices have been developed at
Stanford University since 1957.

Auernhammer, J., & Roth, B. (2021). The origin and evolution of Stanford
University’s design thinking: From product design to design thinking in innovation
management. Journal of Product Innovation Management, 38(6), 623–644.
https://doi.org/10.1111/jpim.12594

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO
Design thinking origins

“At IDEO, we’ve been practicing human-centered design since our beginning
in 1978, and took up the phrase “DESIGN THINKING” to describe the
elements of the practice we found most learnable and teachable—empathy,
optimism, iteration, creative confidence, experimentation, and an embrace of
ambiguity and failure.”
(IDEO, n.d.)

https://designthinking.ideo.com/

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IDEO
Brief history

Tim Brown

(2005)

David Kelley
© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024
VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Now let’s focus on design thinking!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

DESIGN THINKING
Fundamentals

• Design thinking definition


• Design thinking models
• Design thinking attributes

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

So, what is design thinking?

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Actually, there are various types of


design thinking.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

And this is a bit confusing!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

I believe you are…

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

That’s all for today!

But let me explain your first


assignment!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Next class, the hands-on practice on


design thinking starts.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

From now on, we will focus on the


pre-boot camp. [Assignment 1A]

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

PRE-BOOT CAMP
Identifying inconveniences in daily life

“Identifying inconveniences in daily


life: a problem finding prompt to
foster non-designers’ engagement
in design thinking training”
Article published in the DTRS13
conference proceedings, 2022

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

PRE-BOOT CAMP
Identifying inconveniences in daily life

“Design thinking: a customized


blueprint to train R & D personnel in
creative problem-solving.”
Article published in the Thinking
Skills and Creativity Journal, 2023.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

PRE-BOOT CAMP
Iden1fying inconveniences in daily life

Activity PRE-BOOT CAMP assignment

Empathetic observation (1A) Inconvenience identification (1C) Customer research

Team formation (1B) Sharing and connection

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

PRE-BOOT CAMP
Identifying inconveniences in daily life

Activity PRE-BOOT CAMP assignment

Empathetic observation (1A) Inconvenience identification (1C) Customer research

Team formation (1B) Sharing and connection

Fieldwork by March 4th

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

PRE-BOOT CAMP
Identifying inconveniences in daily life

Activity PRE-BOOT CAMP assignment

Empathetic observation (1A) Inconvenience identification (1C) Customer research

Team formation (1B) Sharing and connection

Fieldwork by
March 11th

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
Assignment 1A: Inconvenience identification

I. Select a person Choose a family member, friend, colleague, etc.


[user/customer]
II. Select a circumstance Choose one of the following contexts
A. Home
B. Work
C. University
D. City/country

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
CONTEXT EXAMPLE
A. Home Any situation frequently experienced in daily life: Cleaning, cooking, childcare
& education, storage & organization, sleeping, relaxation & hobby, etc.
B. Work Any situation frequently experienced in office life but excluding particular
company issues: Business meetings, internal communication, work
environment, using corporate systems, etc.
C. University Any situation frequently experienced as a student: Class enrollment, using
VLU online services [portal], issuing a certificate, visiting the library, etc.
D. City/country Any situation frequently experienced as a citizen: Grocery shopping, using
public transportation, visiting a hospital, issuing an official document, paying
taxes, etc.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
Assignment 1A: Inconvenience identification

III. Field observation Discover inconveniences the person encounters in daily life and
select one
IV. Prepare a problem Briefly describe the inconvenience following this format for a
statement statement
1. Who?
2. What situation?
3. What action?
4. Inconvenience experienced:
5. Negative emotion:

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
STATEMENT EXAMPLE 1
(HOME CONTEXT)
1. Who? A young man living alone
2. What situation? decides to rearrange the gaming desk in his bedroom.
3. What action? When he tries to put the furniture in a convenient area,
4. Inconvenience a power outlet gets in the way, and he has no choice but to keep the
experienced: current layout.
5. Negative emotion: Since the original plan failed, he has to live under stress.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
STATEMENT EXAMPLE 2
(WORK CONTEXT)
1. Who? My co-worker,
2. What situation? during a business trip,
3. What action? wanted to share project files and get quick feedback from our team.
4. Inconvenience But sending them via corporate systems was complicated for security
experienced: reasons.
5. Negative emotion: He got frustrated and decided to share the report when returning to the
company.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
STATEMENT EXAMPLE 3
(UNIVERSITY CONTEXT)
1. Who? A senior student in the Engineering major
2. What situation? needs an academic certificate to apply for an internship online.
3. What action? She issues the document via the Academic Portal.
4. Inconvenience However, she is also expected to print a hard copy of the certificate and
experienced: visit the Academic Affairs Office to get a stamp.
5. Negative emotion: The lack of an official digital version of the document annoys her.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
STATEMENT EXAMPLE 4
(CITY/URBAN CONTEXT)
1. Who? My husband.
2. What situation? In a mall’s parking lot.
3. What action? After parking the car, he has to take notes or memorize the floor and
zone.
4. Inconvenience But he always forgets to do so and, later, he spends a lot of time trying
experienced: to find the car.
5. Negative emotion: He is often in a bad mood after shopping.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
STATEMENT EXAMPLE FROM LAST YEAR COURSE
(UNIVERSITY CONTEXT)
1. Who? A male VLU student.
2. What situation? He looks at the clock, and now it is 3:30 PM. He has a class at 5 PM.
3. What action? He is considering whether he should go to school now or later. (It takes
him an hour to get to school).
4. Inconvenience YES: depart right now because the elevator and the parking lot are
experienced: always crowded during these hours. NO, depart later because he will
waste time waiting for class to start.
5. Negative emotion: He’s confused.

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

NEXT CLASS ASSIGNMENT


Identifying inconveniences in daily life
Assignment 1A: Inconvenience identification

V. Share your findings Upload your problem statement* to MS Teams

*Follow the template provided in advance


[MS Teams > Assignments folder > Assignment 1A]

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

IMPORTANT!
• Please share your problem statement at MS
Teams (Assignment 1A) by 11:59 PM on March
4th.
• Although you can prepare various problem
statements, upload only 1 (one) at MS Teams.
© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024
VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Thank you for joining the design


thinking journey!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024


VANLANG UNIVERSITY . Faculty of Art and Design | MASTER TRAINING PROGRAM . Application Art Industry

Have a great evening!


Please, take a good rest
and see you next Tuesday,
March 5th!

© Renato Antonio Bertao 2024

You might also like