Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Politics
of Educational
Decentralisation
in Indonesia
A Quest for Legitimacy
Irsyad Zamjani
Centre for Policy Research
Ministry of Education and Culture,
the Republic of Indonesia
Jakarta, Indonesia
© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer
Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2022
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the
Publisher, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights
of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on
microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and
retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology
now known or hereafter developed.
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc.
in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such
names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for
general use.
The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and informa-
tion in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither
the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, expressed or implied, with
respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been
made. The publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps
and institutional affiliations.
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature
Singapore Pte Ltd.
The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore
189721, Singapore
Acknowledgements
v
vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
work and provide backup in critical moments: Nur Berlian Venus Ali,
Lukman Solihin, Damardjati Kun Marjanto, Andry Rihardika, the late
Sugih Biantoro and other colleagues who also shared equal contribution,
but it is not possible to name everyone.
Finally, my heartfelt thanks go to my beloved wife, Irene Budi Prastiwi,
for her affection and encouragement throughout my intellectual journey.
I also want to thank my siblings, in-laws and their families who never give
up their care and love. This work is dedicated as the loving memory of
my parents, H. Jahdi and Hj. Rumiatun, who trusted me to embark on
a life of autonomy and self-responsibility since I was a 12-year-old boy.
Their exemplary ethics and love have been my lifetime inspiration.
Contents
1 Introduction 1
Localising the Global Problem 1
Why Does Legitimacy Matter? 5
The Role of the New Institutionalism 7
Institutional Environment 7
Decoupling 8
Structuration and Destructuration 9
Methods 10
The Logic of the Book 11
References 13
2 Institutional Change and Indonesian Education
Governance 17
Introduction 17
The Religious Construction of Education 18
Education and the Colonial State 21
The Mercantilist Era 21
The Ethical Policy 23
Education and Nation-State Building 28
The Organisational Arrangement of Education
Governance 28
Localising the Global Ideological Confrontation 34
Education and the Neoliberal Bureaucratic State 39
vii
viii CONTENTS
Conclusion 45
References 47
3 Why Legitimacy Matters: The Institutional Perspective
of Educational Decentralisation 51
Introduction 51
Decentralisation and Educational Decentralisation 53
Educational Decentralisation in Indonesian Literature 57
Assessing Theoretical Arguments on Globalisation and Its
Relevance to the Worldwide Expansion of Educational
Decentralisation 61
The Institutional Perspective of Educational Decentralisation 64
Isomorphic Pressure 66
The Duality of External and Internal Pressures 70
Decoupling 73
Organisational Fields: Structuration and Destructuration 78
Conclusion 81
References 82
4 Managing Global and Local Institutional Pressures:
Decentralisation and the Legitimacy Project
in Indonesia 91
Introduction 91
Educational Decentralisation and the Duality of Local
and Global Pressures 92
The Legitimacy Crisis: From Local to Global
Delegitimation of the Centralist Governance 92
Isomorphic Pressures: Global Institutionalisation and Its
Actors 94
The Duality of Pressure in Indonesian Educational
Decentralisation Reform 100
The Global Pressure: From Normative to Coercive 100
From the National Crisis of Legitimacy to International
Delegitimation 109
Decentralisation and the Central Government Response
to the Pressure 112
Decentralisation as a Compensatory Legitimation 112
The Task Force for Education Reform 115
Managing the Institutional Contradiction 117
Decentralisation and the Rise of Local States 117
CONTENTS ix
Bibliography 269
Index 299
List of Figures
xiii
xiv LIST OF FIGURES
xv
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
Some parts of this chapter have been published in Zamjani, I., (2020),
“Ringkasan Disertasi (Dissertation Summary): Dancing with Legitimacy:
Globalization, Educational Decentralization, and The State in Indonesia,”
Masyarakat Indonesia, 46(1): 93–108. I thank the Journal editor for the
republication permission.
big bang (Bünte, 2004; Fealy & Aspinall, 2003). The post-2001 decen-
tralisation was one of the major institutional reforms that ended the
dictatorial Suharto’s New Order regime in the late 1990s. Before the
reform, Indonesian education was highly centralised and fragmented. The
management of education was shared between the Ministry of Education
and Culture (MoEC) and the Ministry of Home Affairs (MoHA). The
MoEC was responsible for the curriculum of all primary and secondary
schools and the personnel of secondary schools: the MoHA was respon-
sible for the personnel of primary and junior secondary schools. Both
departments had their provincial and district or municipal offices, and this
made management highly bureaucratic. The 2001 decentralisation reform
dissolved both departments’ organisational structures in the regions,
which gave the district and municipal governments greater autonomy
in running most public service sectors, including education. Adopting
common decentralisation practices, some policy reforms were also enacted
to give schools a degree of managerial autonomy and to provide the
community with a participatory role in policymaking.
Governance fragmentation and inefficiency were the problems that
most concerned Indonesian reformers when they firstly discussed and
formulated the reform program (Jalal & Supriadi, 2001). By removing
4 I. ZAMJANI
Institutional Environment
Scott defines the institutional environment as particular arrangements of
regulative, normative and cultural cognitive structures that provide coher-
ence, meaning and stability to organisational action (Scott, 2013). The
institutional environment emerges from the shared historical processes
of socialisation that then become taken for granted and possess rule-
like status (Scott, 1987). These processes define what is and what is
not an organisation, either by means of individuals’ perceptions of how
it is supposed to look like (cognitive), their shared values on what are
the ideal goals it should achieve (normative), or restrictive rules on
what function does each individual have within the structure (regu-
lative). Arnove (2012) argues that nowadays education policy is the
product of a global–local dialectic. The global policy is adopted by
some nation-states, either through the internalisation of the discourse or
through the agency of global actors. The global nature of decentralisation
campaigns in the 1980s developed the strong institutional environment
that influences its adoption in many countries. As such, strong local aspi-
rations for democratisation would increasingly render obsolete the current
centralised structure.
8 I. ZAMJANI
Decoupling
The idea that legitimation can be achieved only by conforming to insti-
tutional pressure has given to these institutions a status of rationalised
myth. Given these myths’ powerful function to maintain the stability of
the organisational order, organisations adopt them ceremonially and with
ritual assertions of confidence and good faith (Meyer & Rowan, 1977).
However, the ceremonial adoption of myths leads to a contradiction,
which runs counter to the logic of technical efficiency. It is because the
myths can arise from a different environment that they cannot fit into
particular organisational settings (Meyer & Rowan, 1977). The contra-
diction between institutional and technical environments is then solved
by a mechanism called decoupling. The organisation keeps its institutional
legitimacy by making changes in its formal structure but at the same time
retaining some strategic practices unchanged. Habermas (1973) terms it
the separation of expressive symbols that influences a universal willingness
to follow from the instrumental function of administration.
At this stage, the concept of decoupling will be useful in explaining
how the institutionalisation of education decentralisation might result in
1 INTRODUCTION 9
Methods
The book is based on a qualitative research using two stages of case
study: one is a single case study (Creswell, 2007; Yin, 2003) to analyse
the Indonesian experience of decentralisation in the context of global–
national and central–local government relations, and the other is a
multiple second-level case study (Creswell, 2007; Yin, 2003) to analyse
the local practices of educational decentralisation in two municipalities:
Surabaya and Kupang. Sociologically, the selection of two localities for
the second-level case studies was based on differences in the possession of
symbolic capital (Bourdieu et al., 1994).
Surabaya, the capital city of East Java Province, has been the largest
municipal government in Indonesia, and its economic growth is among
the fastest in the country. Following decentralisation, the city has more
than 1500 schools, from elementary to secondary. Since 2010, the city has
been receiving much attention because of its immensely popular mayor,
Tri Rismaharini, whose social reform projects have been recognised with
numerous national and international awards. In contrast, Kupang, the
capital city of East Nusa Tenggara Province, is a small but growing
municipality. Its local government is responsible for fewer than 250
1 INTRODUCTION 11
schools. While Surabaya mostly relies on local revenue to fund its educa-
tional programs, Kupang relies mostly on central government subsidies.
Arguably, the economic capital of Surabaya’s government gives it symbolic
capital in terms of central–local government relations.
The research employed two data collection techniques: in-depth inter-
views and document study. The research participants were recruited
purposely using theoretical sampling of DiMaggio and Powell’s (1983)
organisation fields and the key informant technique (Marshall, 1996:
92). I interviewed 38 strategic informants consisting of central and local
government officials, national and local parliamentary members, teacher
associations, prominent academics, NGO leaders, school supervisors and
senior secondary school principals. The interviews took place during my
two rounds of fieldwork trip from 2013 up to 2015.
Moreover, as Yin (2003) contends, unless we are studying prelit-
erate societies, documents are an important source for data in every
case study research. Because the study deals with policy and organisa-
tional behaviour, documents issued by relevant organisations, such as
the literature of the previous studies, legislation, government regula-
tions, reports and proceedings, all served as primary sources. Included
here were World Bank reports, national legislations, MoEC regulations
and local government policy documents. In addition, the study relied on
secondary documents, which include newspaper articles, statistical figures
and demographic information.
References
Antaranews. (2011, November 28). Kemdikbud Kaji Ulang Pelaksanaan
Otonomi Pendidikan (MoEC reviews the educational decentralisation imple-
mentation). Antaranews.
Apple, M. W. (2006). Educating the “right” way: Markets, standards, god, and
inequality. Taylor & Francis.
Arnove, R. F. (2012). Reframing comparative education: The dialectic of the
global and the local. In R. F. Arnove, C. A. Torres, & S. Franz (Eds.),
Comparative education: The dialectic of the global and the local (pp. 1–26).
Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Ball, S. J., & Youdell, D. (2008). Hidden privatisation in public education.
Education International. Retrieved from https://www.right-to-education.
org/sites/right-to-education.org/files/resource-attachments/Education_Int
ernational_Hidden_Privatisation_in_Public_Education.pdf
Bodine, E. F. (2006). Institutional change in postsocialist education: The case
of Poland. In D. Baker & A. Wiseman (Eds.), The impact of comparative
education research on institutional theory (pp. 209–238). Elsevier.
Bourdieu, P., & Wacquant, L. J. (1992). An invitation to reflexive sociology.
University of Chicago Press.
Bourdieu, P., Wacquant, L. J., & Farage, S. (1994). Rethinking the state: Genesis
and structure of the bureaucratic field. Sociological Theory, 12(1), 1–18.
Bray, M. (1999). Control of education: Issues and tensions in centralization
and decentralization. In R. F. Arnove, C. A. Torres, & S. Franz (Eds.),
Comparative education: The dialectic of the global and the local (pp. 207–232).
Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Bromley, P., & Powell, W. W. (2012). From smoke and mirrors to walking
the talk: Decoupling in the contemporary world. Academy of Management
Annals, 6, 483–530.
Bünte, M. (2004). Indonesia’s decentralization: The big bang revisited. In M.
H. Nelson (Ed.), Thai politics: Global and local perspectives (pp. 379–430).
King Prajadhipok’s Institute.
Burch, P. (2009). Hidden markets: The new education privatization. Routledge.
Calvert, R. (1995). The rational choice theory of social institutions: Cooper-
ation, coordination, and communication. In J. Banks & E. A. Hanushek
(Eds.), Modern political economy: Old topics, new directions (pp. 216–268).
Cambridge University Press.
Carnoy, M. (1995). Structural adjustment and the changing face of education.
International Labour Review, 134(6), 653–653.
Cerych, L. (1997). Educational reforms in Central and Eastern Europe: Processes
and outcomes. European Journal of Education, 32(1), 75–96.
Creswell, J. W. (2007). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among
five approaches (2nd ed.). Sage
14 I. ZAMJANI
Meyer, J. W., Boli, J., Thomas, G. M., & Ramirez, F. O. (1997). World society
and the nation-state. American Journal of Sociology, 103(1), 144–181.
Meyer, J. W., & Rowan, B. (1977). Institutionalized organizations: Formal
structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology, 83(2),
340–363.
Muta, H. (2000). Deregulation and decentralization of education in Japan.
Journal of Educational Administration, 38(5), 455–467.
Republika. (2011a, November 28). Banyak Masalah, Pelaksanaan Otonomi
Pendidikan Dikaji Ulang (Causing many problems, educational decentrali-
sation is reviewed). Republika.
Rhoten, D. (2000). Education decentralization in Argentina: A ‘global-local
conditions of possibility’ approach to state, market, and society change.
Journal of Education Policy, 15(6), 593–619.
Riddell, A. R. (1998). Reforms of educational efficiency and quality in developing
countries: An overview. Compare, 28(3), 277–291.
Robertson, P. J., & Tang, S.-Y. (1995). The role of commitment in collec-
tive action: Comparing the organizational behavior and rational choice
perspectives. Public Administration Review, 55(1), 67–80.
Robertson, S. L., & Dale, R. (2009). The World Bank, the IMF, and the
possibilities of critical education. In M. W. Apple, W. W. Au, & L. A.
Gandin (Eds.), The Routledge international handbook of critical education
(pp. 23–35). Routledge.
Scott, W. R. (1987). The adolescence of institutional theory. Administrative
Science Quarterly, 32(4), 493–511. https://doi.org/10.2307/2392880.
Scott, W. R. (2013). Institutions and organizations: Ideas, Interests, and identi-
ties. Sage.
Scott, W. R., Ruef, M., Mendel, P. J., & Caronna, C. A. (2000). Institutional
change and healthcare organizations: From professional dominance to managed
care. University of Chicago Press.
Weiler, H. N. (1990). Comparative perspectives on educational decentraliza-
tion: An exercise in contradiction? Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis,
12(4), 433–448.
World Bank. (1998). Education in Indonesia: From crisis to recovery. World Bank.
Yin, R. (2003). Case study research: Design and methods. Sage.
CHAPTER 2
Introduction
Since its inception, the organisation of Indonesia’s education has been
continuously transforming following the changes in its institutional envi-
ronment. Different environments brought different logics and gover-
nance systems, which affect the structure of respective organisational
fields. In this sense, the dynamic of global and local institutional envi-
ronments in influencing the shape of educational arrangements has been
present since the very beginning. In Indonesia, the earliest institution for
education was religion and it was taught by international travellers from
India, China, the Middle East and Europe (Azra, 2004; Penders, 1968;
Schmutzer, 1977). As such, the modern education system was intro-
duced through the global trend of colonial expansion from the sixteenth
to the twentieth centuries when European nations claimed territory in
Asia, Africa and the Americas as their colonies. This was the period when
state involvement in education was first introduced. During this colonial
period, any development that occurred in the mother countries caused
pressure for the colony to create its local arrangement. The early colonial
era, for instance, was marked by the rise of mercantilist policies so that
technical education was promoted to help strengthen mother country’s
economy. Yet, as the ideas from the French Revolution were spreading
and the ideology of liberal-humanism becoming very popular in Europe,
some adjustments were also made in colonial policies (Schmutzer, 1977).
the teachers, and the Church served as technical organiser. The regula-
tions arranged by the company did not touch upon the pedagogical and
were limited to three aspects: the subjects taught, the school hours and
the school holidays. The others were left for the clergymen (Kroeskamp,
1974).
With their European ideological assumptions, the initial Dutch reli-
gious education preoccupation was to eradicate the influence of the
Roman Catholic Church from Indonesian schools. It was easier to do this
in Java, which was not affected by European influence to the extent that
the eastern islands were, a result of their century-long connection with the
Portuguese and Spaniards. In these eastern islands, the Dutch schooling
requirements met resistance from local communities and the company had
few teachers because of its interdiction of Catholic preachers. A compul-
sory education system was then enacted with a pound of rice given as
compensation for those willing to teach children. The effort to introduce
Dutch as instructional language also failed in most islands. The native
peoples were accustomed to Portuguese and to Malay, which forced
teachers to use the latter language rather than the former (Govaars-Tjia,
2005; Penders, 1968).
Following the departure of the VOC in 1799, The Netherlands
kingdom that took over the colonial administration arranged more signif-
icant changes. Education was no longer a matter for the religious, and
therefore, the leadership role of the Church in education was supplanted.
The way education was organised during this colonial period was influ-
enced by the institutional transformation within the state itself. The
period of the 1800s was marked by severe economic crises in The Nether-
lands Indies. Not only did the VOC leave a catastrophic economy behind,
but the new government itself was nearly bankrupted because of massive
spending for military campaigns against local uprisings, the most impor-
tant of which were the Java War and the Sumatran rebellion by puritanical
Muslims (Carey, 1976; Dobbin, 1977). The government imposed a culti-
vation system policy (cultuurstelsel ), causing villagers to spare 20% of their
lands for planting exportable, government-mandated commodities. If this
requirement was not met, they had to work in a government-owned plan-
tation for 60 days a year. Indonesian historians satirically named this policy
as ‘forced planting’ (tanam paksa) (Van Niel et al., 2003).
The vision of this, the nineteenth, century was to create an effective
colonial estate where all available resources were to serve the European
ascendancy. Hence, apart from supporting the economy, education was
2 INSTITUTIONAL CHANGE AND INDONESIAN EDUCATION GOVERNANCE 23
…. There was a subject that had never been taught even in the Dutch lower
school (i.e. ELS), which was the land survey (landmeten). The subject was
taught to prepare the implementation of government cultuurstelsel policy…
The drawing subject taught how to draw land maps. The math subject
must teach calculations of land tax (landrente) and coffee administration.
(Bradjanagara, 1956: 58)
This was three-year junior secondary system for those who had completed
ELS and HIS. The government then established schakelschool in 1920 for
pupils who had finished at the second-class schools and vervolgschool as a
transition before entering MULO. One year earlier, in 1919, a senior
secondary system was introduced for the indigenes, called algemeene
middelbare school (AMS). Graduates of AMS were equivalent to those of
the schools for Dutch families, hogere burgerschool (HBS) (Bradjanagara,
1956).
Despite the wide-ranging policy, this state-sponsored school system
failed to attain legitimacy. The problem was partly technical but mostly
institutional. The technical problem arose from the fact that the govern-
ment education campaign for natives was not allocated adequate funding.
A report in 1898 claimed that although the budgeted amount allocated
for each pupil of European descent was 122 guilders, the amount for
each native student was only 10 guilders (Djojonegoro, 1996). Another
report said that, in 1900, education spending was 4,109,000 guilders
and 65% of this was being disbursed to support European schools whose
pupils were less than 1% of the population (Zainu’ddin, 1970). However,
Schmutzer (1977) claimed that the problem was generally caused by the
lack of government funding. In 1907, it was calculated that the cost to
educate natives alone would come to 125 million guilders of less than
200 million guilders in total. Therefore, from the 186 new schools in
1909, only ten were acceptably funded (Schmutzer, 1977). After the great
depression in the 1920s, the central government had to tighten its budget
and some government schools, particularly volkschools, had to find their
own funding. As a result, parents had to pay more to send their children
to government schools, which caused them to opt out of sending their
children to school. Those who finished their primary education did not
continue to secondary (Suwignyo, 2013).
The greatest challenge to government education, however, came from
the nature of its system, which was less popular among the new genera-
tion of educated natives, who could see the importance of an independent
nation as well as identifying with the local culture. The technical and
vocational approach to education just did not fit a long-standing local
belief that education as the transmission of meaning rather than of skills.
In addition, the discriminative character of the school system also led
to a campaign against the colonial government. Rather than unifying
the population, the system otherwise promoted the spread of a nation-
alist spirit of resistance. This challenge resulted in the expansion of
26 I. ZAMJANI
Students and teachers were obliged to do physical exercises and take part
in the saluting ceremony for the Japanese Emperor every morning before
school activities began (Suwignyo, 2012). The Japanese government
also managed to convince prominent nationalist leaders to cooperate
under Japanese command. However, during the three years of Japanese
occupation, 1942–1945, schooling declined. Primary school enrolment
plunged by 30%, and secondary school numbers fell by nearly 90% (Bjork,
2005). All the people’s energies were forced to support Japanese mili-
tary campaigns. Thousands of youth were sent to join informal training
in a number of Japan-sponsored organisations, the most important of
which was PETA or Pembela Tanah Air (the Nation’s Defenders), which
provided military training (Tilaar, 1995).
When Indonesia gained its independence in 1945, the new govern-
ment inherited this institutional complexity: there was the unconsolidated
but institutionalised Dutch education legacy on the one hand, and a more
consolidated but short-lived and fragile Japanese system on the other. As
the nationalist leaders came to hold power, they made their hard-fought
nationalist ideals into the archetype of a new state-sponsored education.
Yet this had never been a simple one-night success. The raging nationalist
faction always wanted to break from the past nation-denigrating colonial
model, but no adequate blueprint was available to develop a new system.
idea, the law also stated that the education process should run based
on Indonesians’ own culture. The commentary part of the act further
elaborated the cultural foundation of the Indonesian education system as
follows:
That the foundation must be totally different from that of education and
instruction during the Dutch era, and (this is out of the question), no need
to be elaborated. (That is firstly) because the instruction during the Dutch
period was not deeply rooted in Indonesian society, our people did not feel
that those schools were their own. Despite any arguments, those schools
remained alien properties for Indonesian people. The second reason is that
the Dutch schools admitted only a small portion of Indonesian people,
predominantly the elites. Ordinary people generally did not get any chances
to obtain education and instruction in those schools. (GoI, 1950)
The burning desire to break free from the colonial past was mani-
fested in the government school reorganisation policy in June 1950. The
government abolished the current six types of primary school and seven
types of secondary school established by the Dutch, which were still using
Dutch nomenclature and being run on the basis of social class. These
organisations were merged to form a universal, age-based school cate-
gorisation: sekolah rakyat (elementary school), sekolah menengah pertama
(junior high school) and sekolah menengah atas (senior high school). In
addition, there were other secondary vocational and technical schools.
The government controlled the curricula in all schools and the Indone-
sian language as the medium of instruction was made compulsory. All
private schools, including those that catered for foreigners, had to have
the Indonesian language as one of their course subjects. The teaching
of Dutch was totally dropped from Indonesian public schools in 1950.
Dutch teachers who wanted to continue working in Indonesian schools
were selected according to stringent criteria and had to teach in Indone-
sian (Suwignyo, 2013).
Despite its success in gaining legitimacy in the anti-colonial campaign,
the nationalist education effort to embrace and define its own identity
became more complicated. Indonesia is a nation with over 400 hundred
ethnic languages (Nababan, 1985) and a great variety of belief systems
(McVey, 1993). To accommodate such differences, President Soekarno
had earlier formulated the Pancasila, which literally means five princi-
ples, and this was approved as the state ideology. These five principles
2 INSTITUTIONAL CHANGE AND INDONESIAN EDUCATION GOVERNANCE 31
The Act also allowed private schools to match the type of religion being
taught in their schools with their respective institutional foundation. This
meant, for example, that Muslim children in Catholic schools would
possibly receive Christian rather than Islamic instruction. Before being
ratified in 1950, the Act had caused massive protests across the country.
In early 1949, Masyumi, the biggest Islamic party, walked out during the
parliamentary session when the Bill was passed. In Sumatra, Mohammad
Sjafei, former Education Minister and respected politician, submitted a
statement called the Sumatra Memorandum to Minister Sastroamidjojo
urging the annulment of the Act (Suwignyo, 2013). On 16 October
32 I. ZAMJANI
1949, Daud Beureuh, the military governor of Aceh, issued his own state-
ment called the Aceh Memorandum. The memorandum demanded the
government to make religious teaching a compulsory subject in schools;
to acknowledge the education in religious schools equal to the training
in government schools; to convert the status of religious schools to
government-run schools; and to regulate the mixing of male and female
students so that local Islamic practices in Sumatera not be violated (Tilaar,
1995).
Soekarno showed a reluctance to ratify the Bill given such massive
controversy, but the acting president, Asaat, authorised the Act in April
1950. After it had been ratified, two prominent Islamist factions, Partai
Sarekat Islam Indonesia (PSII) and Partai Masyumi, moved refusal
motions in the parliament. The PSII labelled the regulation an ‘edu-
cational system which humiliates mankind’ (Suwignyo, 2013). Masyumi
also refused to comply with the Act and demanded the government make
religious instruction compulsory in school. The factions argued that ‘by
not making religious lessons a compulsory subject for schoolchildren, the
government is jeopardising the future life of the Indonesian people, in
particular, Muslims. The government has made a policy which diverges
from the first principle of the state ideology, the Pancasila’ (Suwignyo,
2013).
In September 1950, Masyumi took over the coalition government and
Prime Minister Natsir soon assigned an independent professional, Bahder
Djohan, as the new Education Minister. Because of the change of state
arrangement from a federal to a unitary system, the Act lost its legiti-
macy to integrate a national system. In 1954, another PNI government
was formed under the leadership of a former Education Minister, Ali
Sastroamidjojo, and the Act (Law No. 4 of 1950) was then declared
effective (GoI, 1954).
Despite the education system being centralised, the law provided the
room for a more decentralised administration. One year after the Educa-
tion Act was passed, in 1951, the government issued a regulation on this
decentralisation scheme. The regulation devolved the control of basic
education to the provincial governments. Such responsibility covered
administrative aspects such as school finance, school personnel, school
licences, student admissions and resource distribution. Other technical
matters such as curriculum content, the choice of textbooks, school
inspections, school holidays and international school affairs remained
under central government control (GoI, 1951). The decentralisation was
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
The Project Gutenberg eBook of Through India and
Burmah with pen and brush
This ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States
and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no
restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it
under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this
ebook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the
United States, you will have to check the laws of the country where
you are located before using this eBook.
Language: English
Credits: Al Haines
BY
A. HUGH FISHER
"The beauty of the world is simple like a looking-glass."
LONDON
T. WERNER LAURIE
CLIFFORD'S INN
TO MY FRIENDS IN ENGLAND
PREFACE
A. HUGH FISHER.
CONTENTS
CHAP.
I. RANGOON
II. HIS HIGHNESS THE SAWBWA OF HSIPAW
III. UP THE IRRAWADDY TO BHAMO
IV. THE DEAD HEART OF A KINGDOM
V. MANDALAY
VI. SOUTHERN INDIA, THE LAND OF HINDOO TEMPLES
VII. CALCUTTA
VIII. MY FIRST SIGHT OF THE HIMALAYAS
IX. BENARES
X. LUCKNOW
XI. CAWNPORE
XII. THE HOUSE OF DREAM
XIII. DELHI
XIV. DEHRA DUN AND LANDOUR
XV. AN EVENING OF GOLD
XVI. "GUARD YOUR SHOES"
XVII. "A GATE OF EMPIRE"
XVIII. THE CAPITAL OF THE PUNJAB
XIX. AT THE COURT OF HIS HIGHNESS THE RAJAH OF NABHA
XX. IN SIGHT OF AFGHANISTAN
XXI. RAJPUTANA
XXII. SIR PRATAP SINGH
XXIII. THE MOHARAM FESTIVAL
XXIV. RAKHYKASH
XXV. POLITICAL
INDEX
ILLUSTRATIONS
RANGOON
Down came the rain, sudden, heavy and terrible, seeming to quell even
the sea's rage and whelming those defenceless hundreds of dark-skinned
voyagers in new and more dreadful misery.
What trouble a Hindoo will take to keep his body from the rain!
Extremely cleanly and fond of unlimited ablutions he yet detests nothing so
much as a wetting from the sky, and now, wholly at the mercy of the
elements, do what they would, no human ingenuity availed to keep these
wretched people dry.
It was the season of the rice harvest, when South India coolies swarm
over to Burmah much as the peasantry of Mayo and Connemara used to
crowd to England every summer.
Somebody said that our ship was an unlucky one—that it ran down the
Mecca on her last trip and killed her third officer; but we got through safely
enough, though that crossing was one of the most disagreeable as well as the
most weird I ever made—disagreeable because of the bad weather, and
weird because of the passengers.
The deck and the lower deck were tanks of live humanity, and when it
began to get rough, as it did the morning after we left Madras, catching the
end of a strayed cyclone, it was worse than a Chinese puzzle to cross from
the saloon to the spar deck, and ten chances to one that even if you did
manage to avoid stepping on a body you slipped and shot into seven sick
Hindoo ladies and a family of children.
There were six first-class passengers, all Europeans, and 1700 deck
passengers, all Asiatics, and the latter paid twelve rupees each for the four
days' passage, bringing with them their own food.
After coffee the man next to me suddenly leapt from his chair with a
yell. He thought he had been bitten by a centipede. The centipede was there
right enough, but as the pain passed off the next day we supposed the brute
had only fastened his legs in and had not really bitten.
The nights were sultry and the ship rolled worse every watch. I think,
however, that I never saw people try harder than those natives did to keep
clean. They had all brought new palm-leaf mats to lie upon, but they could
not lie down without overlapping. I asked the captain what he did about
scrubbing decks, and he said it was always done at the end of the voyage!
Next morning the downpour, already referred to, began and did the business
with cruel effectiveness.
As we neared Burmah the sea grew calm again and the rain abated. The
sun dried sick bodies and cheered despondent hearts. I spoke to a woman
crouching by some sacks and tin cans, with an old yellow cloth round her
head and shoulders, and another cloth swathing her loins. She had very dark
brown eyes, and her fingernails were bright red and also the palms of her
hands from the "maradelli" tied round the nails at night. She was the wife of
a man the other side of fourteen people, some four yards away. I asked his
name, not knowing that a Hindoo woman may not pronounce her husband's
name. She called him "Veetkar," which means uncle or houseman: the man
was of the Palla caste, which is just a little higher than the Pariah, and they
had been married five years but had no children. This was the man's second
marriage, his first wife having died of some liver complaint he said. Like
most of the passengers they were going out for paddy-field work, but unlike
so many others, they were "on their own" not being taken over by a labour
contractor. The man said he should get work at Kisshoor village, about eight
miles from Rangoon. Every year for seven years he had been over.
Altogether, this man had saved, according to his own statement, two
hundred rupees in the seven years' work, and had invested this in bullocks
and a little field near his village, which was named Verloocooli. He had left
the son of his first wife to look after the house and the field.
About twenty people round one corner of the open hatch seemed to
belong to one another. They came from the Soutakar district and were
drinking rice-water—that is the water poured off when rice is boiled. A
Mohammedan with two sons was going to sell things. The boys would watch
the goods, he told me. He was returning to Upper Burmah, where he had
lived twenty-four years, and he had only been over to Madras to visit his
mother and father. He has "just a little shop" for the sale of such goods as
dal, chili, salt, onions, coconut oil, sweet oil, tamarind, matches and candles.
Then there was the Mongolian type of Mohammedan. He was very fat
and greasy, and had one of his dog teeth long like a tusk. He was a tin-
worker and made large cans in his shop in Rangoon.
I went down between decks and never saw people packed so closely
before except on Coronation Day. Even "marked" men discarded all clothing
but a small loin cloth: most of them could not move hand or foot without
their neighbours feeling the change of position; and as upon the deck above,
they often lay partly over each other. Yet in spite of the general
overcrowding, I noticed a woman of the Brahmin caste lying at her ease in a
small open space marked out by boxes and tin trunks. There was a large
lamp in a white reflector hanging by the companion-way, and some of those
lying nearest to it held leaf fans over their faces to keep the light from their
eyes.
The next day was brighter. There was a light wind and the whole sunlit
crowd was a babel of excited talk. A little naked Hindoo baby, just able to
walk, was playing mischievously with me. I had been nursing her for a while
and now she was laughing, and with palms up-turned was moving her hands
like a Nautch dancer as her eyes twinkled with merriment. She was called
Mutama, and the poor mite's ears had had a big cut made in them and the
lobes were already pulled out more than two inches by the bunches of metal
rings fastened in for this purpose.
A purple shawl, tied up to dry, bellied out in the wind over the side of the
ship in a patch of vivid colour. It had a border of gold thread and was of
native make. Not that the gold thread itself is made in Madras. It is curious
that English manufacturers have tried in vain to make these shawls so that
their gold thread shall not tarnish, whereas the gold thread obtained from
France does not do so.
The following morning we reached very turbid water, thick and yellow,
with blue reflections of the sky in the ripples. We could just see the coast of
Burmah and about noon caught sight of the pilot brig, and entering the wide
Rangoon river, passed a Chinese junk with all sails spread. Now the mats
began to go overboard and gulls swooped round the ship. We had passed the
obelisk at the mouth of the river when, above a green strip of coast on a little
blue hill, the sun shone upon something golden.
"The Pagoda!" I cried, and a pagoda it was, but only one at Siriam where
there is a garrison detachment. The Golden Pagoda—the Shwe Dagon—
appeared at first grey and more to the north. The water was now as thick and
muddy as the Thames at the Tower Bridge. It was full of undercurrents too,
and there was a poor chance for anyone who fell in.
Over went the mats, scores and scores and scores of them!
There is a bar a little further on called the Hastings, and it was a question
whether we'd get over it that afternoon. A line of yellow sand detached itself
from the green, and then the water became like shot silk, showing a pale
flood of cerulean slowly spreading over its turbid golden brown. On the low
bank were green bushes and undergrowth, and beyond—flat levels of tawny-
yellow and low tree-clad rising ground that reminded me of the Thames
above Godstow.
Beyond the green point of Siriam, just after the Pegu River branches off
to the right, the Rangoon River sweeps round in a great curve, at the far end
of which stretches the city. It was pale violet in the afternoon light, with
smoke streaming from vessels in the harbour, and on the highest point the
Shwe Dagon just showing on one edge that it was gold. Far to the right were
some twenty tall chimney-stacks of the Burmah Oil Works, but their colour,
instead of being sooty and unclean, was all blue and amethyst under a citron
sky.
The Customs Officer came out in a long boat, pulled by four men in red
turbans, and in his launch the medical officer of the port with a lady doctor.
There is a constant but ineffectual struggle to keep plague out of Burmah,
and every one of our 1700 deck passengers had to be thoroughly examined
—stripped to the waist with arms up, while the doctor passed his hands
down each side of the body.
The same night, on shore, I drove to the Shwe Dagon past the race-
ground, where a military tattoo was going on by torchlight.
Between great pillars, faced with plaster, red on the lower portion and
white above, I walked on while more dogs came yelping and snarling
angrily. I heard a low human wail which changed to a louder note and died
away—someone praying perhaps. Then all was quite still except for the
crickets. Now I was in a hall of larger columns and walked under a series of
carved screens—arches of wood set between pairs of them. Half-way up
these columns hung branches of strange temple offerings, things made in
coloured papers with gold sticks hanging from them.
At last I came out upon the upper platform on which stands the Pagoda
itself. Facing the top of the last flight of steps at the back of a large many-
pillared porch, reeking with the odour of burnt wax, I saw a cavernous
hollow, and set within it, behind lighted candles, dimly a golden Buddha in
the dusk. Outside, a strip of matting was laid over the flagged pavement all
round the platform, and in the stones little channels cut transversely for
drainage in the time of the rains lay in wait to trip careless feet.
Some years ago when the great "Hti" was brought down from the summit
of the Pagoda, after an earthquake, to be restored and further embellished,
people of all classes brought offerings of money and jewellery through the
turnstiles on to this platform. What a sight it must have been to see the lines
of Burmese people crowding up through these two turnstiles, one for silver
and one for gold—one woman giving two jewelled bracelets and the next a
bangle; a receipt would be given to each donor and then bangle and bracelets
thrown into the melting-pot after their jewels had been taken out for adding
to the "Hti."
HINDOO GIRL, SHOWING ELABORATE JEWELLERY.
Night had driven unscourged the money-changers from the temple, and
the magic light of the moon weaving silver threads through every garish tint
of paint had changed crude colours to ideal harmonies. Not colour alone but
form also was glorified. The grotesque had become dramatic, confusion had
changed to dignity, all surrounding detraction was subdued and the great
ascending curves of the Pagoda rose in simple, uncontested beauty. Nature
adored, acknowledging conquest, and the sound of those far wind-caught
bells was like that of the voices of angels and fairies singing about the cradle
of a child.
I had seen no building of such emotional appeal nor any that seems so
perfectly designed to wed the air and light that bathe it and caress it. But
imagine the Shwe Dagon transplanted to the cold light of some gargantuan
museum near the Cromwell Road; the nicest taste, the most steadfast
determination, could not unlock its charm. Here, upon easy hinge, the door
swings back at every raising of the eyes, and illumination is for all
beholders.
The following afternoon I was again at the Shwe Dagon, and to watch its
beauty under the glory of the setting sun was a further revelation. It seemed
to show fresh and delicate charm at each part of the day, and after burning at
sunset, like a man filled with impetuous passion, shone in the after-glow
with the diviner loveliness of the woman who gives her heart.
Building proceeds at such a rate that the big city seems to be growing
while you look at it, but there are plenty of open spaces. Government House,
in red brick and white stone, with an old bronze bell hung in front of the
portico between two brass cannon, stands in a goodly park with fine trees
and wide lawns and the Royal Lakes, across which there is a beautiful view
of the Shwe Dagon, are surrounded by large grounds with trim, well-kept
walks and drives. While I was painting by one of the lakes a water-snake
every now and then lifted its head above the surface, sometimes a foot and a
half out of the water like some long-necked bird.
I was driving back towards the hotel along the Calvert Road when I
noticed a temporary wood-framed structure, covered with coloured papers
and painted trellis-work. On inquiry I found it had been erected by a
Buddhist Society of that quarter of the city, and that the same night upon a
stage close to it in the open air a "Pwe" would be given, to which I was
bidden welcome about nine o'clock.
At my hotel two people had been poisoned by tinned food a few weeks
earlier, but whatever the table lacked in quality it made up in
pretentiousness. I quote that day's menu for comparison with the items of
another repast the same evening:—
It was after an early and somewhat abridged version of the above that I
drove in the cheerless discomfort of a "tikka gharry" through Rangoon again
in the moonlight. After twenty minutes I saw once more the paper temple.
There were two long lines of lanterns high in the air in the shape of a
horizontal V, and under them a great crowd of people. The trellised temple
itself was also charmingly decorated with lanterns.
ALTAR TABLE AT A BUDDHIST SOCIETY'S CELEBRATION.
Four silver dishes were now brought to me on a lacquered box, and these
contained Burmah cheroots, betel leaves and areca nut, tobacco leaves and
chunam (lime). Chilis were also brought, which made me long in vain for a
cool drink.
Outside, beyond the walls of pale green trellis, glowed the lanterns, and
faces peered at us between the strips of wood. Cloth of red and white stripes
lined the roof, and countless flags, quite tiny ones, were fastened along the
outer green railing.
In front of the Buddha had now been placed some beautiful gold
chalices. The white alabaster figure of Gautama was half as high as a man,
and a band covered with gems glittered across its breast.
About ten o'clock I moved outside, where another arm-chair had been
placed for me, this time in the midst of a great crowd of people.
My interpreter had now gone to join some ladies, and I was left to make
the best I could of this, my first, Burmese "Pwe."
Two characters were dancing on the stage when I took my seat. Perhaps
they were a prince and princess—at any rate they were dressed in old
Burmese court style, in very narrow skirts similar to the "hobble," and
strange short jackets cut with curled bases like horned moons stretched and
held in shape by bamboo frames. There was much swaying and posturing of
the body, combined with quick, jerky movements, the arms were moved a
great deal with bent elbows and the hands with fingers straight and the palms
bent back sharply at the wrists. When these dancers left the stage two men
entered in long white gowns, with broad white bands tied round the head in
big bows. They turned their backs upon the audience at first, and then
turning round squatted upon the floor. Two more similarly dressed came in
in the same manner, and after they had squatted beside the others two quite
astounding figures came on the scene with long bare swords.
The music all this while kept up an accompaniment of jingle and clapper
and tum, tum, tum—jingle and clapper and tum, tum, tum, with a
particularly squeaky wind instrument going ahead at the same time like a
cork being drawn backward and forward over a pane of wet glass.
I discovered now that on turning their backs to the audience on first
entering, the performers made obeisance to a draped bench at the back of the
stage. Two more sword-bearing figures came in and two lance-bearers in
very lovely bejewelled dresses of old gold. There was a long shrill speech
now—then a loud bang, at which all the actors fell to the ground, and a
figure entered bearing a short-pointed mace and sat at once on the draped
bench.
Every now and then I turned my head to look up at the great V-shaped
line of lanterns hanging high in the air overhead from tall bamboo poles, and
the stars shining over all from the night sky. A number of the children were
sleeping, though their elders made a good deal of noise, laughing heartily at
the comic actor as the play went on and on and on. I should like to have
stayed longer, but an appointment with some elephants at an early hour the
next morning made me reluctantly leave the "Pwe" at midnight and hunt
among the back rows of the audience for the driver of that "tikka gharry."
Everyone has heard of the Burmese elephants piling timber. The largest
of the timber companies employing elephants is the Bombay Burmah
Trading Corporation, Limited. The logs, floated down the river from forest-
lands, eight hundred or a thousand miles upstream, are stranded at high rain-
tides at Poozoondoung, a tract of lowland to which I drove in the early
morning.
I reached there just after sunrise, before the dew of the night was yet
evaporated, and the logs, on which one had to walk to avoid the mud, were
very slippery and more difficult to negotiate with boots than without.
The work of the elephants is to push, drag or pile the teak logs, and on
the morning of my visit there were three of the great quadrupeds at work:—
Hpo Chem, aged fifty, a fine tusker who had been twenty years at the work,
and two female elephants, Mee Cyan, seventy years of age, and Mee Poo,
thirty. The male elephant has, of course, tremendous strength in his tusks and
uses them for carrying, holding the log firmly with his trunk as he gravely
walks up the pile of logs to place his burden on the top. Female elephants
can only pile by a combined lift and drag, and do not raise the log entirely
from the ground. Pushing with the head is called "ounging."
At Poozoondoung, not far from the timber-yards, the chief rice-mills are
situated. They were idle now, but when I saw them again after the harvest
their big chimneys were belching forth black smoke from the burning husk.
The husk obtained from the milled grain is not only sufficient for all fuel
requirements, but much has to be shot into the creek for waste.
Native boats called "Loungoes" brought such of the "paddy" from the
country as did not come by rail.
"Hulling" the rice is the operation of breaking off the husk. There were
rows of pairs of round flat stones, the under ones stationary, the upper ones
revolving, not grinding but merely breaking off the husk. Both grain and
husk fell from these stones together to the floor below, and were carried by
bucket-elevators to a fanning-room, where the husk was blown off. After
leaving the fans the grain had its remaining inner skin taken off in "cones"—
cement-faced stones made to press the grain against an outer jacket of
perforated wire. At the base of the cone a cloth hung round an opening in the
floor, through which the rice dropped, while the white skin fell upon the
floor outside to be called "bran," and shipped to Europe for use in the
manufacture of cattle cakes.
When the rice-mills are in full work the smoke of their chimneys hangs
above Rangoon, but overhead every evening the flying foxes pass as usual,
and the beautiful Pagoda is far enough away to remain untarnished upon its
little hill.
BOY SHOWING TATOOING CUSTOMARY WITH ALL BURMESE
MALES.
CHAPTER II