Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mega and Complex
Mega and Complex
Student’s ID
Page 0 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Executive Summary
Mega-projects entail various aspects that must be controlled rationally and organized. Several
aspects impact the entire operation, project completion, and fulfillment. This paper focuses
on the South-North Water Transfer Project, one of China's most significant construction
projects. The program's supply chain includes many downstream and upstream processes
involving numerous partners from the commercial and public sectors. Involving stakeholders
is critical to ensuring that the program is finished without significant disruptions or problems.
Below is a detailed assessment and critical review, program and project management
Page 1 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Table of Contents
Introduction 4
Projects/Programmes 4
Organizational Complexities 7
Structural Complexities 7
Legalities Complexities 8
Putting It Together 8
Optimum Bias 9
Over/Under Estimate 10
Page 2 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Procurement Method 10
Change Management 12
Gaps Analysis 14
Sustainability 15
Recommendation 16
Conclusion 17
References 18
Appendix 21
Page 3 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Introduction
Mega-projects are complicated and emerge in volatile political, social, and economic settings
remains a crucial obstacle. The reasons for substantial cost increases in massive projects arise
from humans' limited ability to approximate, strategy, or predict the effects of uncertainty.
The mega-project administration research field must address decision-making concerns and
productivity deficits that arise when traditional project management concepts are used in
of its sort ever attempted. The project entails extracting water from southern waterways and
delivering it to the arid north. This gigantic project already took fifty years from the idea to
2050 and would ultimately redirect massive amounts of water yearly to the arid north's
populated areas. Once completed, the project will connect China's four major waterways –
the Yellow River, the Yangtze, the Haihe, and the Huaihe – and will necessitate the building
of three diverting channels that will extend south-to-north across the country's western,
Page 4 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Projects/Programmes
The complexity of mega-projects raises the number of organizations engaged and the
expenses and expands the work area even more. Nonetheless, facing complexity in every
project, irrespective of scale is unavoidable, and it is immensely more so than in the event of
massive projects. As a result, knowing the idea of complexity is critical for avoiding errors
and meeting project objectives. According to this viewpoint, the strategy formulation of
complexity is critical to implementing mega-projects effectively. The plan has raised so many
environmental, economic, and ideological worries that state experts are pushing for it to be
postponed and scaled back, increasing the prospect that it will emerge to be a mega-project
too far for China. Tianjin, according to reports, intends to develop desalination facilities.
Worries about the economic and political costs of deflecting water from the Yangtze to the
Yellow, high mainly in the Tibet-Qinghai region, have caused the west portion to be halted
When a company does not achieve the maximum use of its existing resources and therefore
does not engage in investment or innovation, it may generate or operate more petite than its
idealized capacity. The most recent business strategy was developed around 2009. Even
though it had all of the information required by legislation at the time, it lacked the detail that
Page 5 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
the Legislature needed to make significant budgetary decisions. Because of the ambiguity, the
Legislature approved budget resolution language in 2010, requiring HSRA to provide this
information (McKenney et al. 2020). The folks who appear to be the most unhappy are those
from Han's middle reaches due to the diversion program. "Locals are concerned about the
effect on our ecosystem since we will lose a fifth of the freshwater," a Xiangfan City local
told The Guardian. "While we are worried, everyone must demonstrate their support." We
Mega-projects, including China's South-to-North Water Transfer Program, are often regarded
management evolve in response to the problems given by unique projects and domestic and
foreign settings. As a result, the starting point is there's no standardized project management
technique for coping with contexts, and they vary depending on the many problems imposed
by mega-projects. Utilizing Critical Success Variables, this thesis will focus on project
management techniques that might be used in the South-to-North Water Transfer Project in
logically related practices, processes, and processes that outline how to design, organize, and
Program management has evolved and will continue to grow as a management technique for
separate profession. The project will continue to encounter urgent demand for management,
Page 6 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
such as irrigation, commerce, and economy and considering the global financial catastrophe,
It is mainly based on clean water which is critical for sustainable development. In spite of the
value of water, reflecting that the difficulties of water deficiencies are partly because of the
geographical as well as temporal inequities in the source of water along with the demand for
water. The South-North Water Transfer Project associates with social concerns that are linked
Organizational Complexities
The South-North Water Transfer Project in China is mainly associated with extracting water
from the southern rivers as well as allocating it to the dry northern. In long run, it struggles to
carriage three-dimensional meters which is 44.8 billion of stream from the Yangtze River in
southern China to the dried along with profitable north through three detached canal roads.
Mao Zedong planned the perception of mass engineering creativity as a resolution to China's
Structural Complexities
In the case of structural complexities of the South-North Water Transfer Project in China, it
can be stated that hundreds of thousands of individuals were banished from the construction
of dams as well as reservoirs. Moreover, the entire process of generating the dams can have
Page 7 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
habitats. Most significantly, if the project can’t be a success, the farmers over the entire
North China Plain would probably fail to access the water obligatory for farming,
The construction of cost projections represents that fluctuating from USD 20 billion to USD
81 billion for Easterly Way as well as Central Way South-North Water Transmission Project
unaccompanied. The entire dimensions of water remote by the South-North Water Transfer
Project can puts a very bad impact on the Han River and the Yangtze Delta (Rogers et al.,
2016).
The estimated cost of the project was $62 billion. In 2008, Construction prices for the
fundamental and eastern roads were decided at 254.6 billion. The administration had
accounted just 53.87 billion Yuan which is less than the planned cost. Most importantly,
more or less 30 billion Yuan had been paid to the development of the easterly as well as
central roads. Moreover $79 billion had been invested in 2014. It is quite obvious to note that,
the financial feasibility of the South-North Water Transfer Project stays controversial.
Legalities Complexities
There is a possibility for this project to develop the distribution of stream schistosomiasis
from southerly China. In the case of northern China, where schistosomiasis is relatively
infrequent the distribution is similar. The South-North Water Transfer Project has a key
influence on local populations. The project is associated with the repositioning of at least
330,000 individuals in middle of China. The experts assert that water withdrawal would
reason ecological harm, along with some villagers saying that establishments had pressured
Page 8 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Putting It Together
The entire project that named as South-North Water Transfer involves water rules and
divisions that were initially planned by river basin charges and local administrations in water
provision and water-receiving extents. There are several administration institutions along
with state-owned enterprises that regulate numerous aspects of the South-North Water
Transfer Project.
Project management helps the method of guiding the project to gain all the related goals
within a specific time limit. It helps to improve the initial work practices by identifying the
major drawbacks. The initial limitations of the South-North Water Transfer Project are
Program management is another important part that helps the London Crossrail project to link
with the method of organizing project-related actions by mapping the targets that progress
project performance rate. It involves strategic initiatives and observes all of the major and
minor project-related successes. It helps to link with the diligence of the circumstances
Optimum Bias
Priced, it is essential to note that, if the South-North Water Transfer Project fails then the
farmers over the entire North China Plain would probably fail to access the water obligatory
for farming. Most importantly, the experts assert that water withdrawal would reason
ecological harm, along with some villagers saying that establishments had pressured them to
Page 9 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Over/Under Estimate
There is a massive chance of the project being politically unsuccessful as it would involve
expanses and people who dump untreated water. China must endure to methodically present
as well as perform its demand approaches nationally to make sure that its uncommon
Procurement Method
The entire process of procurement method of the South-North Water Transfer Project helps to
offer a bedrock on which the whole functionality of the project can be adjusted. It offers
several prominences for all stakeholders inside the project that will help them to design
Page 10 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
According to the understanding of the mega projects overall, it can be mentioned that the
projects are liable to facing different strategic threats which have the credibility of creating
long term impact on the business value of the project partners, for example, a few potential
Environmental Issues: Wrong project task’s implementation or any wrong project decision
have the credibility of creating a direct impact on the ways managing project value can be
Dependency Risks: The threats related to improper physical space for managing equipment,
the number of required personal equipment exceeding, and poor data construction quality can
Regulatory Risks: Issues like the introduction o new regulatory requirements, changing
health and safety needs, and non-compliance sanction management can affect the result of the
project.
Communicating Risks: For example, improper contractor interference, language barrier, poor
communication, and poor designated time for meeting management can affect the business
External Risks: Threats such as local terrorism, wat, and property destruction have the
Page 11 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Change Management
In order to deal with the complexities, implementation of proper change management plays
an important role; in the case of the South-North Water Transfer Project of China, the change
management is adapted based on different steps and stages, which can help the project attain
all its desired outcomes in an accurate manner (Yang et al. 2020). In the following different
Step 1 in change management needs to define the need behind implementing the change as
with the help of this aspect, and the organizations are able to attain a better result. Moreover,
the change is an important part of any project, but before implementing that, understanding
Page 12 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
the forces that drive the change is very important as based on that, attainment of a detailed
Communication is the key to learning about the project process; in the case of the South-
North Water Transfer Project, China is dealing with environmental issues that need to be well
understood by communicating with fellow related partners. Another important step of the
change management requires the project to communicate about the change with fellow
stakeholders as based on that, the organization managing the project will be abler to attain a
Planning is another important step related to change management which is responsible for
guiding the project to understand the strategy that can be used by the South-North Water
Transfer Project of China to deal with mega project complexities (Rogers et al.2020). With
the help of this aspect, change management can be attained in an accurate manner.
The change plan decided in step 3 needs to be implemented properly in step 4, as based on
the change implementation South-North Water Transfer Project of China will be able to
deliver a better mega project value (Yang et al. 2020). Implementing the change plan needs
Evaluation of the change progress is responsible for guiding the project to understand the
areas that need to be managed to create a better value (Rogers et al.2020). The progress
Page 13 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
The lesson that has been learned from the project is related to the understanding of different
principles that need to be managed in megaprojects, and implementing these principles still
needs to be learned (Miao et al. 2018). Different lectures and seminars have helped to
understand the experience these principles' implementation has on other mega projects for
evaluating the importance and threats (Webber, Crow-Miller, and Rogers, 2017).
Gaps Analysis
The project gap that needs to be evaluated is related to the ways of managing environmental
changers that can make proper value in the project result (Yang et al. 2020).
Page 14 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Effective Control, Monitoring, Transition, and Measurement such as defining proper roles
and responsibilities, creating shared goals short task creation, defining collaboration tools and
managing change can be used for managing project value and benefits (Miao et al. 2018).
Sustainability
Sustainability can be managed by PM, and PGM strategies like using accurate tools, diving
works, allocating proper resources, and this will help the project create monetary value
PRINCE2 is a process-based method that can be suggested for the selected method for
managing the project depending on project skills (Sheng and Webber, 2017).
Page 15 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Recommendation
Based on the selection of the South-North Water Transfer Project of China, it can be
mentioned that for managing mega projects like this, the implementation of accurate and
specific methods plays an important part. The selected mega project defines that the impact
created by it on the ecology is affecting its running needs. Therefore, to resolve the issue and
other project management system issues, utilization methods mentioned in the following play
● The creation of realistic and accurate project objectives from the perspective of
● The stakeholder engagement and their accountability towards the project need to be
al. 2018).
● In creating a revised schedule for the project, the project can be positioned in a more
● On the other hand, the project team, based on their credibility and role, needs to be
● The risk management strategy for the project needs to be created, which will analyze
any threats that have the possibility of affecting the objectives within tine (Crosby,
2017).
Page 16 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
● The budget needs to be improved, too, based on the understanding new project
management strategy.
● A newly created and improved schedule can produce an improved, changed direction
Conclusion
The project is owned by the South-to-North Water Transfer Project, including pre-project
development work completed by Hanjiang Water Resources and Hydroelectric power. The
State Policy and Management Council, the Ministries of Water Supplies, the Department of
Building, the State Protection Of the Environment Agency, and China Global Engineering
Consulting Company manage projects. The South-to-North Water Diversion Middle Route
Project would be critical in ensuring Beijing's long-term economic prosperity. Beijing suffers
from a severe scarcity of water sources and is primarily reliant on the overuse of subsurface
water to support its industrial procedure. Water resources have become a growing economic
burden for Beijing. The South-to-North Water Diversion Project will substantially impact
Page 17 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
References
Crosby, P., 2017. Shaping complex mega-projects: practical steps for success. Australian
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14488353.2017.1362806
Crow-Miller, B., 2015. Discourses of deflection: the politics of framing China's south-north
Jiang, J.J., Klein, G. and Fernandez, W.D., 2018. From project management to program
McKenney, M.J. and Handley, H.A., 2020. Using the DSRM to Develop a Skills Gaps
119.https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/9149577/
Miao, Z., Sheng, J., Webber, M., Baležentis, T., Geng, Y. and Zhou, W., 2018. Measuring
water use performance in the cities along China's South-North Water Transfer
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0143622818301565
Moore, S.M., 2014. Modernisation, authoritarianism, and the environment: the politics of
Pace, M., 2019. A correlational study on project management methodology and project
p.56.https://search.proquest.com/openview/048c1513e5a2c7347af2859ff4ff554b/1?pq-
origsite=gscholar&cbl=706377
Page 18 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Qiu, Y., Chen, H., Sheng, Z. and Cheng, S., 2019. Governance of institutional complexity in
443.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0263786318302564
Rahman, M.S., 2018. Risk management and measurement of risk management performance
http://jultika.oulu.fi/files/nbnfioulu-201808312690.pdf
Rogers, S., Barnett, J., Webber, M., Finlayson, B. and Wang, M., 2016. Governmentality and
the conduct of water: China's south–north water transfer project. Transactions of the Institute
Rogers, S., Chen, D., Jiang, H., Rutherfurd, I., Wang, M., Webber, M., Crow‐Miller, B.,
Barnett, J., Finlayson, B., Jiang, M. and Shi, C., 2020. An integrated assessment of China's
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1745-5871.12361
Rogers, S., Chen, D., Jiang, H., Rutherfurd, I., Wang, M., Webber, M., Crow‐Miller, B.,
Barnett, J., Finlayson, B., Jiang, M. and Shi, C., 2020. An integrated assessment of China's
Sheng, J. and Webber, M., 2017. Incentive-compatible payments for watershed services
along the Eastern Route of China’s South-North Water Transfer Project. Ecosystem
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2212041616305472
Webber, M., Crow-Miller, B. and Rogers, S., 2017. The South–North water transfer project:
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00343404.2016.1265647
Page 19 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Wilson, M.C., Li, X.Y., Ma, Y.J., Smith, A.T. and Wu, J., 2017. A review of the economic,
Yang, Y., Lei, X., Long, Y., Tian, Y., Zhang, Y., Yao, Y., Hou, X., Shi, M., Wang, P.,
Zhang, C. and Wang, H., 2020. A novel comprehensive risk assessment method for sudden
water accidents in the Middle Route of the South–North Water Transfer Project
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0048969719341440
Page 20 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Appendix
Page 21 of 23
MANAGEMENT OF MEGA AND COMPLEX PROJECTS: SOUTH-NORTH WATER
Page 22 of 23