Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ED 243
Task
Field Experience Write up ED 243
Step 1. Provide a Summary of what you experienced so the reader
knows what you did and what you experienced.
This Critical Reflection Assignment will walk you through the kind of
thought-process that allows a teacher to step outside of a thought-
provoking experience, to put it into perspective, and to react to it in
constructive ways. The “scaffolding”, or steps, provided to guide this
assignment will give you an opportunity to practice “deconstructing” an
experience—thinking about the situatedness of a particular critical incident
in the larger systems of power--and using that new framework to make a
thoughtful and purposeful response.
Your chosen event should be a moment from your Study Trip, a hallway
interaction with a student, an administrator, or a colleague, or a
parent/family member interaction. Choose an event that puzzles you, that
frustrates you, troubles you, excites you. As you reflect on this experience
through a series of different lenses, you will see more layers of meaning
and be able to bring more of what you know and believe to the task of
formulating significant questions about this critical incident and generating
personally relevant answers. In short, you will be practicing the kind of self-
directed learning that is essential to being a professional educator.
A. Description of the Critical Incident or Practice
Choose an incident that is complex and likely to draw you into an
exploration of ideas, beliefs, and dispositions you have learned about in
your teacher education classes. Completely describe the ONE critical
incident or practice that you have selected as the focus for this entry. Your
entry should include sufficient detail so that the reader can easily
understand your focus. This section should be purely descriptive.
Simply explain what you saw or experienced or the way something worked.
The description should be 1-3 well developed paragraphs in length.
The incident was our group in the MLL classroom which is the multi
language learners class. It is a extracurricular class which means that it
takes the place of either band or choir or a class outside of the general
education courses. The students that are in this class are either a level 1 or
2 english learner which means that they are below proficiency in english
speaking, writing, reading or hearing. The students on the particular day
that we were in the class were taking the speaking test to test their
vocabulary based on images that were on the test. Throughout the test,
there would be images provided and the students would answer prompts
based on the questions about those images. The directions and everything
on the test was strictly in english and the directions were only said once
and could not be repeated. Also, the students only had one attempt at their
responses and could not go back or try again on the recording for the
prompts.I felt mad seeing this and I felt upset. I also felt sad for the
students.
When I was in this classroom a wave of emotions hit me like a
ton of bricks. These students were connected to each other in a way
that was different than any other classroom environment and you
could tell through their body language that they felt comfortable in this
classroom environment with the other students that had the same
shared experiences. However, when the teacher started talking to
them she spoke strictly in english, the only language she knew, and
gave directions to these students in english. Luckily, there were
images that followed the instructions and sometimes other languages
were shown. However, when she talked about that the test would
only give the directions once, it made me very frustrated in the time.
When I get directions, especially in my foreign language classes I
need them multiple times to clearly understand what they are saying.
Also, in general education classes the directions are said more than
once so how is this helping the students to understand and do well on
this test? They also were not allowed to stop recording once they
started and restart their recording if they messed up. The whole test
seemed very against the students being able to succeed the best that
they can. Also, the results from this test are not available until april,
which means that the teacher has to guess their proficiency level
based on prior knowledge of the student and the entrance test that
they took. Instead she should be able to see the results and base
instruction on where the students are doing well What went well was
that these students had a safe place to be in the school with students
like them. These students body languages are completely different in
this specific classroom then outside and so therefore their learning is
different because they arent focused on safety or comfrotability inside
the classroom. The teacher also had multie language models for
instructions that would be hard to understand for the students and
had resources in the classroom that were in different languages to
provide resources for the students. What did not go so well was the
test structure and the way that the students take the test. It was not
formatted as equitable as it could be and will affect students scores
beyond their control. I want to see that classroom and observe the
lessons that occur in that classroom to see what I could do as a
teacher to help my multi-language learners better. I want to ask the
teachers of this classroom more questions and to “pick her brain”
more about why this school chose to implement this class when its
not mandatory and the affects it has on the students after the leave
Clay.
Rubric
ED 243 Field Experience Rubric
ED 243 Field Experience Rubric
Provide a summary of 1
what you experienced 5 pts 4.25 pts 3.75 pts 3.25 pts 0 pts pts
during your visit at the Exemplar Proficien Emergin Underdevelope Not
field experience using y t g d Demonstrated
the Critical Reflection
pieces.
Make at least one 1
connection to personal 1 pts 0.85 pts 0.75 pts 0.65 pts 0 pts pts
experience, other texts Exemplar Proficien Emergin Underdevelope Not
you’ve read, and/or y t g d Demonstrated
what you know about
schools.