COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

(CRS)

CONTRACT NUMBER LC19103100

CONTRACT TITLE: ECS FOR NEW LABORATORY BUILDING AT QP REFINERY, MESAIEED

QP EXTERNAL TRANSMITTAL REFERENCE, DATED: PID/LC19103100/EXT/TN/0976

DOCUMENT NUMBER, REV & TITLE: 4154-25-61-03-005, REV. 5, PROJECT FIRE & SAFETY PHILOSOPHY LAST REVISION STATUS: 2

PREVIOUS ISSUED DRAWING NUMBER MADE VOID (IF ANY) N/A

SR. QP COMMENTS CONTRACTOR'S RESPONSE REMARKS

NO
QP Engineer Section Comments
Ref id.
Kindly find our comments on the -4154-25-61-03-005_Rev.4 (Project
1 IFE/2M
Fire & Safety Philosophy)” as attached
1.It appears that information provided haphazardly in the subject
documents, which is not acceptable, Contractor to assimilate noted
technical info broadly into following topics:

1. General refer to chapter 02 OBJECTIVES

General 2. HSE deliverables refer to section 6.4.30 HSE PLAN
HSE deliverables 3. Fire & Gas Systems refer to Chapter 8.0 FIRE AND GAS DETECTION SYSTEMS
Life safety & signage way finding 4. Fire Protection system refer to Chapter 7.0 FIRE AND GAS DETECTION
Fire and gas system SYSTEMS
Fire protection system 5. Ventilation refer to Chapter 9.0 SMOKE MANAGEMENT SYSTE
Ventilation 6. Hazardous area classification refer to report with refrence number 4154-25-
Hazardous area classification 61-03-007
Safety shower and eye wash 7. Safety shower and eye wash refer to section 6.4.11 SAFETY SHOWERS &
Drainage 6.4.12 EYEWASH STATIONS
Emergency response 8. Drainage refer to Chapter
References (extracted) from national / international standards / 9. Emergency response refer to
codes 10. References (extracted) from national / international standards / codes
refer to section 4.2 CODES, STANDARDS, AND REGULATIONS

Information / requirements shall be consistent with what we

Confirmed
discussed and agreed during previous meetings
life safety report is part of the report and it was canceled based on QP
3. Life safety design report is missing requirment " The report is submitted for cancellation, as agreed in Minutes of
Meeting #15 held on 07th of June, Item 2.8."
4. Section 4.2 add NFPA 3, NFPA 4, NFPA170, NFPA 220, ANSI/ISEA
Incorporated reference for codes have been added
Z358.1, EI15/ 19

5. Section 5, add VdS, HAZID, MIC ERCC, HSSD, GWP. LEL, LPG, LPCB,
ODP, P&ID, PFD, ppm, PSR, SIL, TLV, STEL, TEL, TWA,UEL, UPS, ANSI, Incorporated, descriptions have been provided
BIS, API, CIA, OSHA, EI, ATEX, ISO, IEC, SHELL DEPs, SCBA

5. Section 6.2 is Irrelevant, codes/standards already covered in

section 6.2 is added as general statement
section 4.2

Doc. No.: 4154-25-61-03-005 CRS Page 1 of 3

 COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET
(CRS)

CONTRACT NUMBER LC19103100

CONTRACT TITLE: ECS FOR NEW LABORATORY BUILDING AT QP REFINERY, MESAIEED

QP EXTERNAL TRANSMITTAL REFERENCE, DATED: PID/LC19103100/EXT/TN/0976

DOCUMENT NUMBER, REV & TITLE: 4154-25-61-03-005, REV. 5, PROJECT FIRE & SAFETY PHILOSOPHY LAST REVISION STATUS: 2

PREVIOUS ISSUED DRAWING NUMBER MADE VOID (IF ANY) N/A

SR. QP COMMENTS CONTRACTOR'S RESPONSE REMARKS

NO
QP Engineer Section Comments
Ref id.

6. Section 6.3, and Section 6.3.5 along with type of construction of

Incorporated, table 4.1.1 for fire resistance rating has been added to show the
main building and utilities, provide fire rating for walls / protective
required fire rating for walls/ protective openings
openings, fire stopping system, refer NFPA 220 requirement

7. Section 6.3.1, update the building spaces section 6.3.1 for the main spaces "high hazard spaces" in the building only

8. Section 6.3.3, guard house missing Incorporated, description for guard house has been added
please refer to section 6.4.32 HAZARDOUS AREA CLASSIFICATION SCHEDULE for
9. Section 6.3.4 revisit this section, what does it mean by hazardous
more clarification & refer to report submitted for QP with reference no. 4154-
area, is this according to NFPA
25-61-03-007

1. Muster point is already covered in section 6.4.6 SAFETY SIGNS

10. Section 6.3.6.1, hard standing, muster points windsocks missing,
2. Wind Sock is already coved in section 6.4.8 WIND SOCK
what does it mean stairways on tank {6.3.6.1 (e) }, please clarify.
3. hard standing provided in section 6.4.37 FIRE HARDSTANDING
Clarify / elaborate section 6.3.6.1 (b) further
4. section 6.3.6.1 b has been elaborated

11. Section 6.4.2, all life safety design parameter shall be consistent
confirmed as per the approved life safety floor plans
with FLS plans/ FLS report, please verify and confirm

12. Section 6.3.6.4, not clear, as complying QP requirement is this as a general statement that the contractor has to obtain any approval will
perquisite for the construction phase be required by QP during the construction phase
13. section 6.3.4, please check and confirm if egress capacity
Confirmed that all egress capacity calculated for the FLS plans based on NFPA
calculations are in line with FLS plans.
14. section 6.4.4, Is this FLS plan or architectural plan? All
architectural drawing shall be consistent with FLS plans, please Confirmed
confirm
Section 6.4.11, Indicate that all safety showers and eye wash
Incorporated, note has been added
complying to ANSI/ ANSI/ISEA Z358.1

15. Section 6.4.26, Contractor shall conduct HAZID study and provide hazid study has been conducted please refer to document no. 4154-25-61-03-
action items required to be implemented during construction phase. 010

FIRE RISK ASSESSMENT (FRA) TERMS OF REFERENCE INCLUDING ASSUMPTION

16. Section 6.4.27 & 6.4.28, please check and confirm if FRA and FRA
REGISTER has been submitted and approved by QP with refer 4154-25-61-03-
conducted and reports are available.
009

17. Section 6.4.32, update based on the meeting held on 31/08/2021 Confirmed

Doc. No.: 4154-25-61-03-005 CRS Page 2 of 3

 COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET
(CRS)

CONTRACT NUMBER LC19103100

CONTRACT TITLE: ECS FOR NEW LABORATORY BUILDING AT QP REFINERY, MESAIEED

QP EXTERNAL TRANSMITTAL REFERENCE, DATED: PID/LC19103100/EXT/TN/0976

DOCUMENT NUMBER, REV & TITLE: 4154-25-61-03-005, REV. 5, PROJECT FIRE & SAFETY PHILOSOPHY LAST REVISION STATUS: 2

PREVIOUS ISSUED DRAWING NUMBER MADE VOID (IF ANY) N/A

SR. QP COMMENTS CONTRACTOR'S RESPONSE REMARKS

NO
QP Engineer Section Comments
Ref id.
18. please check and confirm if any Shelter-In-Place ( SIP) is
no SIP is provided in the project
envisaged for this protect

Noted and incorporated, kindly refer to the updated document (clause No.
19. Add NFPA-72
8.2.6.e & 8.2.7.f).

Doc. No.: 4154-25-61-03-005 CRS Page 3 of 3