Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4th - Alternative Practices & Ideas
4th - Alternative Practices & Ideas
4th - Alternative Practices & Ideas
& IDEAS
Critical regionalism
An approach to architecture that strives to counter the
placelessness and lack of meaning in Modern Architecture by
using contextual forces to give a sense of place and meaning.
(In the 1980s a few architects and theorists were disappointed
with the direction that architecture was taking under the
influence of postmodernism. Rather than unveiling the
historicity of style in their designs, postmodern architects
became another avant garde that produced designs that
mimicked classical style. )
The term critical regionalism was first used by Alexander
Tzonis and Liane Lefaivre and later more famously and
pretentiously by Kenneth Frampton in "Towards a Critical
Regionalism: Six points of an architecture of resistance."
According to Frampton, critical regionalism should adopt
modern architecture critically for its universal progressive
qualities but at the same time should value responses
particular to the context. Emphasis should be on topography,
climate, light, tectonic form rather than scenography and the
tactile sense rather than the visual
As put forth by Tzonis and Lefaivre, critical regionalism need
not directly draw from the context, rather elements can be
stripped of their context and used in strange rather than
familiar ways.
Critical regionalism is different from regionalism which tries
to achieve a one-to-one correspondence with vernacular
architecture in a conscious way without consciously partaking
in the universal.
Säynatsalo Town Hall
Advantages
Energy saving & Eco-Friendly
Jack Arch compressive roofing.
Decorative & Highly
Economical
Maintenance free
•Masonry Dome
Advantages
•Energy saving eco-friendly compressive roof.
•Decorative & Highly Economical for larges spans.
•Maintenance free
Funnicular shell
Advantages
•Energy saving eco-friendly compressive roof.
•Decorative & Economical
•Maintenance free
• Masonry Arches
Advantages
•Traditional spanning sytem.
•Highly decorative & economical
•Less energy requirement.
This is Baker's home in Trivandrum.
This is remarkable and unique house built on a plot of land along the slope of a rocky
hill, with limited access to water:
However Baker's genius has created a wonderful home for his family
Material used from unconventional sources
Family eats in kitchen
Electricity wiring is not concealed
Drawings
GROUND FLOOR
FIRST FLOOR
STEPS LEADING UP TO A VIEW FROM THE OPPOSITE
FRONT DOOR SIDE
STEPS DIRECTLY CUT IN ROCK ENTRANCE HAS SMALL SITTING
AREA FOR GUESTS
THE WALL IS DECORATED
FROM BROKEN POTTERY,
PENS, GLASS
Design strategies
1. Exposed brickwork and
structure
2. Sloped concrete roof
3. Openness in design and
individual units offset each
other Continuous latticework
in the exposed walls
Low sloped roofs and courts serve as wind catchers
Open walls function to dispel it
Long row of housing replaced by even staggering
Fronting courts catch the breeze and also get view of sea
Little private rectangle of land in between houses for drying nets , kids play,
Provides sleeping lofts within and adequate space outside for mending nets and
cleaning and drying fish
PLAN
H Egyptian architect – 1900 – 1989
Designed 160 separate projects from modest country
A retreats to fully planned communities, markets,
S schools, theatres, places for worship and for
recreation.
S
ARCHITECTURAL PERSPECTIVES
A 1. Ancient design methods and
N materials
2. Utilizing a knowledge of rural
Egyptian economic situation
3. Space design suitable to
F surrounding environment
A 4. Low cost construction without
using R.C.C and steel
T 5. Training locals to build ones
own house
H
Y
Design Phillosophy
• Low cost construction
• Usage of local materials and vernacular architecture
• Training of local people in construction to reduce
labor cost
• Against western techniques and ‘Matcbox houses’
• Design development with energy conservation
technique, Study of temperature and wind patterns.
• Passive cooling
Design elements
Pla
n
An
d
Sec
tio
nal
ele
vat
ion
Vaulted roof at Gourna Theatre
Ventilation system - Kharga Market
• Mud brick – Low heat radiation, low cost, availability
• Thick wall – high insulation
• Small windows not facing the sun.
• Windcatcher – Air circulation, a pressure gradient used to get
away with the hot air.
• Qanat – Used with windcatcher to cool the interior air by deep
cut canal in the floor filled with water.
• Screens – Restrict glare of light
• No use of R.C.C and Steel for high heat radiation
• Courtyard with partial greenery to screen dust and sand in the
prevailing wind.
Screens in Window
Difficulty of adjusting venetian blinds in summer: (a)
Schematic diagram of the modes the position for the optimal direction of the air
of heat gain and loss in a movement is undesirable with regard to sunshine; (b)
building. the optimal position for blocking sunlight is
undesirable with regard to the wind direction.
N
E
Byker Redevelopment
Location Newcastle-upon-Tyne, England, UK map
Date 1973 to 1978 timeline
Building Type multifamily housing
Construction System concrete, brick
Climate temperate
Context urban
Style Modern
Bykar wall
Erskine's Millennium Village
Innovation and sustainability are the
two key drivers for the new
Greenwich Millennium Village in
southeast London. It is an ambitious
mixed-use development being built
according to a master plan by
architect Ralph Erskine using the
latest sustainable methods and
materials.
These 450 apartments, set around modern versions of the classic London
"garden square" concept, lie on the northernmost part of the planned village
site beside the River Thames and a newly created lake.
Along with the extensive use of glass, materials include split bricks
contrasted with colored plaster, corrugated panels, wood cladding, and zinc
sheet. "The colors help break down the scale of the facade," says architect
Brendan Phelan, director at EPR.
The first phase of housing as seen
from the artificially created lake.
Diagrams of the
ecology.
The bathrooms reveal a
Scandinavian influence.
L
U Lucien Kroll (born Brussels, 13 March
1927) is a Belgian architect well known
C for this projects involving participation by
the future users of the buildings.
I
His most famous work is the Medical
E Faculty Housing, at the University
of Louvain, Belgium, from 1970-76.
N
The Belgian architect Lucien Kroll is
known internationally for his iconoclastic
K way of making architecture; his complex
and idiosyncratic forms delight some,
R enrage others, and intrigue many.
O
L
L
From the outset of his career Kroll aspired to a vernacular style which showed no
sign of "progressiveness" but which involved a constrained use of simple forms
and materials.
He created buildings that related to both the landscape and to the people using
them.
His medical faculty buildings for the University of Louvain outside of Brussels
aroused widespread controversy in the early 1970s, their fragmented and
improvisational appearance - the result of a deliberate participatory design process
- in stark contrast to the adjacent massive and repetitive hospital, the embodiment
of a centralized bureaucracy.
Ecological Architecture Of Lucien Kroll
The new Lycee at Caudry near Cambrai in north-east France involved the most
stringent design and construction ecological competition yet for a school in
France.
Kroll stresses the need for a holistic approach, drawing no hard lines between
physical and psychological issues, cultural and technical ones, or between the
well-being of the individual and that of the planet.
These concerns interact in complex ways, so stringent energy demands were not
allowed, for example, suddenly to dictate the whole design of the school as with
tile famous glass wall at Wallasey, or with a huge hemispherical form for minimal
surface area. Rather,
East-west alignment of both main
teaching blocks is perhaps the
strongest move, which gives them
north and south faces.
Roof strategy was to grow vegetation on all low-pitched or flat ones not paved for
access.
This increases insulation and avoids the need for surface treatment, while the
vegetation absorbs rain like a sponge, reducing or at least delaying run-off.
Most classrooms are conventionally rectangular and set in linear ranges conditioned
by day lighting.
Social spaces for larger groups such as the library, assembly hall and restaurant have
more complex polygonal forms with faceted roofs.
This differentiates them visually and spatially from the other parts, but they are also
more centralized in form.
Polygonal shapes allowed development of semi-separate bays - for example in the
library- which break down the scale of the whole into sub- appeared for electric
constituents being drawn from a spaces ‘owned’ by smaller groups.
Four views of the
“attics”. The top two
floors were divided
between students who
had activities in
common and who also
personally designed
their spaces and
furniture.
Japanese religion and style of life strongly influenced his architecture and design.
Tadao Ando's body of work is known for the creative use of natural light and for
architectures that follow the natural forms of the landscape (rather than disturbing the
landscape by making it conform to the constructed space of a building).
Ando's treatment of nature in the city is something else that distinguishes his work.
Confronted by the vulgar urban environment of downtown Osaka, he came to the
conclusion that coexistence with nature was funtamental to human life. He proposed
a new lifestyle in coexistence with nature, which is integrated into the dwelling.
It can get extremely cold in winter, on rainy days an umbrella is needed to go to the
tiolet.
Ando gave priority, not to some facile notion of convenience, but to being able to
look up to sky and feel the wind.
The courtyard of the Row House is a secluded space cut off from the commotion of
the city; it is open only to the sky. It is a window, accepting light, wind and rain so
that nature is able to seep into the spirit of the observer.
The courtyard, made of concrete, glass and slate, reflects incident light and causes
complex shadows. Matter has a psychological effect on the observer precisely
because the absence of ornament invites extraordinary empathy.
Church of the Light
Church of the light (sometimes
called "Church with Light") is the
Ibaraki Kasugaoka Church's main
chapel. It was built in 1989, in the
city of Ibaraki, Osaka Prefecture.
This building is one of the most
famous designs
of Japanese architect Tadao Ando.
In 1999, the main building was
extended with the addition of a
Sunday School.
The Church of the Light is a small structure on the
corner of two streets at Ibaraki, a residential
neighborhood. It is located 25 km north-northeast of
Osaka in the western foothills of the Yodo valley
railway corridor.
F FAMILY: FATHER-LAWYER
MUSLIM-ENGLISH PARENTAGE;
R MOTHER- MIXED GERMAN-SCOTTISH
E DESCENT.
•His designs break down the barriers between inside and outside, between interior design
and landscape architecture.
•His ideas are providing a bridge between the past and the future, a mirror in which
ordinary people can obtain a clearer image of their own evolving culture.
Osmund and Ena de Silva House ,Columbo, 1960-62
Geoffrey Bawa
Views from the
entrance toward
the main courtyard
Most architects who do minimalistic architecture do not use color, but the ideas of forms
and spaces which Barragán pioneered are still there.
There have been several essays written by the Pritzker Prize recipient Alvaro Siza in
prefaces to books that make reference to the ideas of Barragán as well.
LUIS BARRAGÁN HOUSE AND STUDIO
The external façade is in keeping with the low-class neighborhood: it was highly
important for Barragán not to change the aspect of a street.
The entrance hall is quite small, forming as it were an emotional step before finally
encountering the house as Barragán designed it, which in his use of vivid color (as he
always did) starts to amaze every visitor with the first corridor, which is a quite vivid
pink, with yellow spaces.
One of the most important matters in the house is the light: as Barragán always hated
the use of ceiling illumination, the house is lit, if not by natural illumination, then only
with small lamps always placed on top of a small table.
The magnificent garden (not as big as it may look, but as Barragán wanted, with the
feeling of an enormous place) is a complicated puzzle of natural corridors and trees
(one of them is only decorative and not actually alive: the architect really wanted
another one and decided to bring one without planting it).
On the garden side, the building has a very different aspect compared with the
street side. The qualities of Barragán's architecture are expressed in the
treatment of the spaces inside the house, where he plays with strong non-
harmonic colour schemes (e.g. the sequence from the entrance); the raw
volcanic stone on the vestibule floor extends through a second door to the hall.
The garden was initially conceived as a large expanse of grass, but Barragán
later allowed it to grow more freely.
he Torres de Satélite ("Satélite Towers") are
located in Ciudad Satélite, in the northern Torres de Satélite
part of Naucalpan, Mexico.
Alvaro Siza has stated, "Architecture is increasingly a problem of use and reference to
models... My architecture does not have a pre-established language and does not
establish a language.
It is a response to a concrete problem, a situation in transformation in which I
participate."
The geographic and climatic contitions of the place of Alvaro Siza's architecture are of
profound importance to this thinking in addition to cultural and social concerns.
In Alvaro Siza's oeuvre sensitivity to context does not result in nostalgic historicism or
critical regionalism.
Since then, there have been several changes in its ownership but Siza has continued
to be the architect throughout and has been in charge of all its alterations, additions
and new furniture.
Now, due to external circumstances, the house fulfils all the requirements to be a
museum of the architect.
The writer Luisa Ferreira da Costa commissioned
the young Álvaro Siza in 1962 to design a house in a
dense neighbourhood of small plots.
It was as if Siza was marking his own evolution by adding new materials:
the new window openings were framed with white painted wood in white
marble cases.
Shortly afterwards, the house passed to Santos' son, an engineer who also
asked Siza to continue working with the house, but this time, by
designing all its furniture.
His commission was not to ask Siza for 'artistic' objects, but rather to
fulfil his practical requirements.
Iberê Camargo Foundation
Y
O
U