ETHICAL FALLACIES FALLACIES A fallacy is a mistaken belief, particularly FALLACY those based on invalid arguments.
WHAT ARE Flaws in ethical appeals that inhibit the flow of
01 ETHICAL meaningful, coherent discussion and argument FALLACIES? Unfairly advances the writer’s/speaker’s 02 (ETHOS) authority or character Example 1 GUILT BY You can’t hang with him; his friends are ASSOCIATION trouble
Example 2
Sara’s friend Amy robbed a bank;
therefore, Sara is a delinquent Example 3 Calls someone’s character into He is well on his way to becoming a thug, question by examining the because he has started hanging out with character of the person’s that thing, Robert AD Arguments attack a person’s character HOMINEM rather than that person’s reasoning.
EXAMPLE 1 EXAMPLE 2 EXAMPLE 3
Why should we Buy a car from Jack said Susan
think a candidate me, because the didn't cheat, but he who recently Ford dealer down is a thief, so she divorced will keep the street is an probably did her campaign idiot and a liar. cheat. promises? Example 1
FALSE My middle school teacher said it, so
AUTHORITY it must be true.
Asks audiences to agree with
Example 2 the writer based simply on his or her character or authority My uncle is a podiatrist, and he only even if that person may not be takes Sweet Valley daily chewable fully qualified to offer that vitamin C, and so should you. USING AUTHORITY Occurs when someone offers INSTEAD OF personal authority as proof. EVIDENCE EXAMPLE 1 EXAMPLE 2
Because I Trust me – my best
said so. friend wouldn't do that. Example 1
DOGMATISM I’m the teacher, so what I
say is the only right answer.
Shuts down decision by
asserting that the writer’s beliefs are the only acceptable ones. POISONING THE Attacks the person directly rather WELL than examining the logic of argument. EXAMPLE 1 EXAMPLE 2
We cannot believe the Everyone has a
Secretary of the right to their Treasury’s claims opinion, even a because he was fired liar like Ed. from his job. Example 1
STRAWMAN Students want it all: no work and
high grades. We should not take their evaluations seriously. Exaggerates a characteristic of a person or group of people and then uses the exaggeration to dismiss an argument. THANK YOU FOR LISTENING! :) GROUP 7 REFERENCES BSN 1-B https://slideplayer.com/slide/9091315/ AUSTRIA, ERICA JOY https://slideplayer.com/slide/4058890/ TANDOC, BENILDA MAE https://slideplayer.com/slide/4059017/
Extended Summary Of Daring Greatly: How The Courage To Be Vulnerable Transforms The Way We Live, Love, Parent, And Lead - Based On The Book By Brene Brown