Types of surveys: Advantages and Disadvantages Survey Research • Defined as "the collection of information from a sample of individuals through their responses to questions" • Allows for a variety of methods to recruit participants, collect data, and utilize various methods of instrumentation. • Can use quantitative research strategies (e.g., using questionnaires with numerically rated items), qualitative research strategies (e.g., using open-ended questions), or both strategies (i.e., mixed methods). • As it is often used to describe and explore human behaviour, surveys are therefore frequently used in social and psychological research • Information has been obtained from individuals and groups through the use of survey research for decades. • It can range from asking a few targeted questions of individuals on a street corner, to obtaining information related to behaviours and preferences, to a more rigorous study using multiple valid and reliable instruments. • Common examples of less rigorous surveys include marketing or political surveys of consumer patterns and public opinion polls. • Has historically included large population-based data collection. • The primary purpose of this type of survey research was to obtain information describing characteristics of a large sample of individuals of interest, relatively quickly. • Large census surveys, obtaining information reflecting demographic and personal characteristics and consumer feedback surveys are prime examples. • These surveys were often provided through the mail and were intended to describe demographic characteristics of individuals or obtain opinions on which to base programmes or products for a population or group. • More recently, survey research has developed into a rigorous approach to research, with scientifically tested strategies detailing who to include (representative sample), what and how to distribute (survey method), and when to initiate the survey and follow up with nonresponders (reducing nonresponse error), in order to ensure a high-quality research process and outcome. • Currently, the term "survey" can reflect a range of research aims, sampling and recruitment strategies, data collection instruments, and methods of survey administration. • Given this range of options in the conduct of survey research, it is imperative for the consumer/reader of survey research to understand the potential for bias in survey research as well as the tested techniques for reducing bias, in order to draw appropriate conclusions about the information reported in this manner. Data Collection Methods • Survey research may use a variety of data collection methods with the most common being questionnaires and interviews. • Questionnaires may be self-administered or administered by a professional, may be administered individually or in a group, and typically include a series of items reflecting the research aims. • Questionnaires may include demographic questions in addition to valid and reliable research instruments. • It is helpful to the reader when authors describe the contents of the survey questionnaire so that the reader can interpret and evaluate the potential for errors of validity (e.g., items or instruments that do not measure what they are intended to measure) and reliability (e.g., items or instruments that do not measure a construct consistently). • Questionnaires may be in paper form and mailed to participants, delivered in an electronic format via email or an Internet-based program such as SurveyMonkey, or a combination of both, giving the participant the option to choose which method is preferred. • Using a combination of methods, survey administration can help to ensure better sample coverage (i.e., all individuals in the population having a chance of inclusion in the sample), therefore reducing coverage error • For example, if a researcher were to only use an Internet-delivered questionnaire, individuals without access to a computer would be excluded from participation. • Self-administered mailed, group, or Internet-based questionnaires are relatively low cost and practical for a large sample. • Improving the visual appeal and graphics of surveys by using a font size appropriate for the respondents, ordering items logically without creating unintended response bias, and arranging items clearly on each page can increase the response rate to electronic questionnaires. • Attending to these and other issues in electronic questionnaires can help reduce measurement error (i.e., lack of validity or reliability) and help ensure a better response rate. • Conducting interviews is another approach to data collection used in survey research. Interviews • Interviews may be conducted by phone, computer, or in person and have the benefit of visually identifying the nonverbal response(s) of the interviewee and subsequently being able to clarify the intended question. • An interviewer can use probing comments to obtain more information about a question or topic and can request clarification of an unclear response • Interviews can be costly and time intensive, and therefore are relatively impractical for large samples. Mixed methods • Used when no one method is adequate to address the planned research aims, to reduce the potential for measurement and non- response error, and to better tailor the study methods to the intended sample • For example, a mixed methods survey research approach may begin with distributing a questionnaire and following up with telephone interviews to clarify unclear survey responses • Mixed methods might also be used when visual or auditory deficits preclude an individual from completing a questionnaire or participating in an interview. Questionnaire construction • A questionnaire that is poorly formatted can lead respondents to miss questions, confuse respondents, or even cause them to throw the questionnaire away. • First, the questionnaire should be spread out and uncluttered. • Researchers should not try to fit more than one question on a line because that could cause the respondent to miss the second question or get confused. • Second, words should never be abbreviated in an attempt to save space or make a questionnaire shorter. • Abbreviating words can be confusing to the respondent and not all abbreviations will be interpreted correctly. • This could cause the respondent to answer the question a different way or skip it entirely. • Lastly, ample space should be left between questions on each page. Questions should not be too close together on the page or the respondent might be confused as to when one question ends and another begins. • Leaving a double space between each question is ideal. Formatting individual questions • In many questionnaires, respondents are expected to check one response from a series of responses. There may be a square or circle next to each response for the respondent to check or fill in, or the respondent might be instructed to circle their response. • Whatever method is used, instructions should be made clear and displayed prominently next to the question. If a respondent indicates their response in a way that is not intended, this could hold up data entry or cause data to be miss-entered. • Response choices also need to be equally spaced. For example, if you’re response categories are "yes," "no," and "maybe," all three words should be equally spaced from each other on the page. • You do not want "yes" and "no" to be right next to each other while “maybe” is three inches away. • This could mislead respondents and cause them to choose a different answer than intended. It could also be confusing to the respondent. Question wording • The wording of questions and response options in a questionnaire is very important. Asking a question with the slightest difference in wording could result in a different answer or could cause the respondent to misinterpret the question. • Oftentimes researchers make the mistake of making questions unclear and ambiguous. Making each question clear and unambiguous seems like an obvious guideline for constructing a questionnaire, however, it is commonly overlooked. • Often researchers are so deeply involved in the topic being studied and have been studying it for so long that opinions and perspectives seem clear to them when they might not be to an outsider. • Conversely, it might be a new topic and one that the researcher has only a superficial understanding of, so the question might not be specific enough. • Questionnaire items (both the question and the response categories) should be so precise that the respondent knows exactly what the researcher is asking. Question wording • Researchers should be cautious about asking respondents for a single answer to a question that actually has multiple parts. This is called a double-barreled question. • As a general rule, whenever the word and appears in a question or response category, the researcher is likely asking a double-barreled question and measures should be taken to correct it and ask multiple questions instead. Ordering items in a questionnaire • The order in which questions are asked can affect responses. • First, the appearance of one question can affect the answers given to later questions. For instance, if there are several questions at the beginning of a survey that asks about the respondents’ views on terrorism in the United States and then following those questions is an open-ended question asking the respondent what they believe to be dangers to the United States, terrorism is likely to be cited more than it otherwise would be. • It would be better to ask the open-ended question first before the topic of terrorism is "put" into the respondents’ head. • Efforts should be made to order the questions in the questionnaire so they do not affect subsequent questions. • This can be hard and nearly impossible to do with each question, however, the researcher can try to estimate what the various effects of different question orders would be and choose the ordering with the smallest effect. Questionnaire instructions • Every questionnaire, no matter how it is administered, should contain very clear instructions as well as introductory comments when appropriate. • Short instructions help the respondent make sense of the questionnaire and make the questionnaire seem less chaotic. They also help put the respondent in the proper frame of mind for answering the questions. • At the very beginning of the survey, basic instructions for completing it should be provided. The respondent should be told exactly what is wanted: that they are to indicate their answers to each question by placing a checkmark or X in the box beside the appropriate answer or by writing their answer in the space provided when asked to do so. • If there is one section on the questionnaire with closed-ended questions and another section with open-ended questions, for example, instructions should be included at the beginning of each section. • That is, leave instructions for the closed-ended questions just above those questions and leave the instructions for the open-ended questions just above those questions rather than writing them all at the beginning of the questionnaire. Advantages of Survey Research • It is an inexpensive method of conducting research. • Surveys are a practical solution for data gathering • It is a fast way to get the results that you need. • Surveys provide opportunities for scalability. • It allows for data to come from multiple sources at once. • Surveys give you the opportunity to compare results. • It offers a straightforward analysis and visualization of the data. • Survey respondents can stay anonymous with this research approach. • Surveys can cover every component of any topic. Disadvantages of survey research • There is always a risk that people will provide dishonest answers. • You might discover that some questions don’t get answers. • There can be differences in how people understand the survey questions. • Surveys struggle to convey emotions with the achievable results. • Some answers can be challenging to classify. • You must remove someone with a hidden agenda as soon as possible. • Surveys don’t provide the same level of personalization. • Some respondents will choose answers before reading the questions. • Accessibility issues can impact some surveys. • Survey fatigue can be a real issue that some respondents face. Conclusion • Survey research is a useful and legitimate approach to research that has clear benefits in helping to describe and explore variables and constructs of interest. • Survey research, like all research, has the potential for a variety of sources of error, but several strategies exist to reduce the potential for error.