Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Basics of Distillation Process @equipments.
Basics of Distillation Process @equipments.
2
Distillation – Basic Theory
Physical Separation Processes, contd..
Fractionation is a unit that has both a reboiler to supply
heat at the bottom and a condenser to take heat out from
the top. This is normally called distillation.
Absorption is a unit that has no method at the top of the
tower to take heat out. An external liquid is supplied
from outside the system to absorb material from the
vapor.
Stripping is a unit that has an external stream (gas or
steam) supplied from outside the system to strip light
material from the liquid. It may have a reboiler at the
bottom of the tower to put heat in.
Distillation – Basic Theory
5
Distillation – Basic Theory
Where-
6
Distillation – Basic Theory
Fractionation System
7
Distillation – Basic Theory
8
Distillation – Basic Theory
Trays
9
Distillation – Basic Theory
Packings
10
Distillation – Basic Theory
Distillation Process
Description
Distillation columns carry out physical
separation of liquid chemical components
from a mixture by
a combination of transfer of heat energy (to
vaporize lighter components)
mass transfer between the liquid and vapor
phases.
Distillation – Basic Theory
12
Distillation – Basic Theory
13
Distillation – Basic Theory
Basic Operation and Terminology, contd..
Certain products can be drawn from one of the
trays and is called side draw off.
Each tray attains a “equilibrium temperature”. A
temperature profile takes place along the
distillation column, the highest being at the
bottom and the lowest being at the top.
Packed Vs Tray Column and Tray
Types
Packed Column Vs Tray Column
Packed Column Tray Column
Low pressure drop High pressure Drop
Good for vacuum service Not recommended for high vacuum
service
Less flexibility for side draw Flexible for side
draw
Good for corrosive service Expensive for corrosive
service
Ideal for small diameter Expensive for small
diameter
Not preferred for high pressure Good at high pressure
Not used for Residence time Good when high Residence
time
limitations required
Usually avoided for low Good for low liquid
loading
Liquid loading 15
Packed Vs Tray Column and
Tray Types
Various types of trays are used in the Industry. The following are
commonly used:
Valves Trays or improved valve trays
Sieve Trays
Bubble cap trays
Baffle Trays
Valve trays are widely used and offer the following advantages
over other types:
Offer better efficiency at varying gas load
Cost is lower
Works better at lower vapour loading
Packed Vs Tray Column and
Tray Types
Sieve trays are used often and are selected for fouling
service. They are one of the cheapest trays.
Bubble cap trays are most expensive and were used
widely, but lately use has diminished. It provides
positive sealing against weeping.
Baffle trays are the least efficient and are used only in
high fouling service
For small diameter column, cartridge trays are specified.
Multi-pass trays are used for large diameter columns
Packed Vs Tray Column and
Tray Types
Packing
Packing were often used in the early years of development of
process industry and lately they are again gaining popularity
Random or structure pickings are used. Popular random packings
are pall rings, IMTP, CMR, rasching ring etc. Structure packings are
more proprietary. The most popular are corrugated plates.
Random packings are widely used compared to Structure packing
They are evaluated based on surface area per unit volume. Higher
the value, better the packing.
The design of distributors and redistributors is very critical for
satisfactory performance of the packing
Distillation Calculation
Methods
Estimate using Short-cut methods
The operating pressure for column is to be decided. In
general lower the operating pressure, easier the
separation. However, lower the pressure, larger the
column size. Select optimum pressure based on
expected temperature, utilities available, product
degradation, refrigeration requirement etc.
Initial estimate on pressure drop may be done based on
70 mmwc for pressure drop in each tray and 40 mmwc
per meter of packed height for random packing.
Distillation Calculation
Methods
HETP
HETP (Height Equivalent to a Theoretical Plate) values are used for
calculating total packed height from the number of trays calculated using
simulator.
HETP value is calculated based on experience and vendor information.
While calculating the HETP, the liquid distribution for each bed plays a
major role.
The typical value of HETP for most random packing is 300 mm to 800 mm.
The corresponding value for structural packing is some what lower. Smaller
the packing, lower the HETP value
The total packed height is divided into number of beds. Each bed may
have height equivalent to 6 to 15 theoretical trays for random packing.
H/D Ratio for a random packed bed is limited to 8. Often bed height is
restricted to 6 m. Higher packed height per bed is permitted for structure
packing.
Distillation Calculation
Methods
Column Diameter and Height Calculation
Tray Column
Calculate total number of trays required
Calculate column diameter based on vapour and
liquid flow rates. Preliminary calculations can be
done using simulator. Tray vendor will give accurate
data. Tray diameter calculation depends on tray
spacing. Therefore, some optimization calculation
may be required.
Tray spacing varies from 250 mm to 750 mm. Most
hydrocarbon services use tray spacing of 450 mm to
600 mm.
Distillation Calculation
Methods
Column Diameter and Height Calculation
Provide space of about 800 mm to 1000 mm at the top
of 1st tray for man-way.
Provide liquid level at column bottom based on
residence time required. Note that liquid disappears
due to bottom product removal and due to
vaporization.
Provide adequate space between HHLL and the last
tray for proper separation of vapour and liquid.
Column hydraulics shall be such that normal
operation is away from entrainment, flooding,
choking etc.
Distillation Calculation Methods
23
Distillation Calculation
Methods
Packed Column
Calculate HETP as described above. This includes selecting size of
the packing. Larger the packing, smaller the diameter, but higher the
HETP value.
Calculate total packed height above and below the feed location.
Divide the total packed height into number of beds such that each
bed has about 10 theoretical stages.
Calculate column diameter using simulator based on hydraulics data
and packing selected. Specify pressure drop in the range of 25
mmwc to 40 mmwc per meter of packed height. This is finalized
after discussion with packing vendor.
Calculate overall column dimensions as described for tray column.
Distillation Calculation Methods
Packed Column Pressure-drop Calculation Chart
25
Column Internals
Internals
Tray Column
Trays
Chimney Tray
Feed Pipes
Gas Distributor
Partition Plate
Packed Column
Packing
Distributor / Redistributor
Support Plate
Hold drum plate / bed limitors
Feed Pipe
Gas Distributor
Column Internals
Support Plate
27
Column Internals
28
Column Internals
Redistributor
29
Distillation Control
Pressure Control
For steady operation to meet the required performance it
is essential to have a steady pressure of column
operation.
Depending on the type of column and fraction of
condensation of the top vapors, (100% condensation to
minimal Condensation), there are several methods for
pressure control.
Distillation pressure control uses either mass or energy
balances around the unit.
Mass balance methods control pressure by regulating the
amount of flow into or out of the tower.
Distillation Control
PC
M
M
Temperature Control
iThe column must operate at a fixed pressure, which is
the optimum pressure for the separation of the products,
meeting specifications.
In vapor liquid equilibrium phenomena like distillation,
there are three variables of thermodynamic equilibrium
relationship i.e. temperature , pressure and composition.
If any two are fixed, the third is automatically set at its
unique thermodynamic value.
Once the column pressure is fixed, it is necessary to
control the temperatures in the column to get the right
product specification.
Distillation Control
For fee stream, flow rate (capacity) and temperature are controlled
37
Distillation Control
Temperature Control in a Binary Distillation Column, contd.
38
Distillation Control
Temperature Control in a Binary Distillation Column, contd.
39
Distillation Control
Temperature Control in a Binary Distillation Column, contd.
40
DISTILLATION COLUMN - Design
41
DISTILLATION COLUMN - Design
Vapor-Liquid Traffic
Hydraulic Design Proprietary Software to arrive at
Column Diameter
Pressure Drop across internals
Flooding
42
COLUMN INTERNALS
PROCESS REQUIREMENTS
Primary Requirements:
Efficiency
Capacity
Secondary Requirements:
Low Pressure Drop
Resistance to Fouling
Resistance to Corrosion
43
COLUMN INTERNALS
TYPES
Trays
Random Packing
Structured Packing
Grids
44
TRAY TERMINOLOGY
45
TRAY TERMINOLOGY
Active panel
Inlet
panel Valve
Exit weir
Man way
panel
Downcomer beam
Downcomer panel
VALVE TRAY
46
Tray Types
LIQUID VAPOR FLOW IN A TRAYED COLUMN
47
Tray Types
LIQUID VAPOR FLOW IN A TRAYED COLUMN
Double pass
48
DOWNCOMER TYPES
49
SELECTION CRITERIA
Capacity
Efficiency
Turndown
Pressure drop
Fouling resistance
Tradition
50
SELECTION CRITERIA
DECISION PARAMETER
PRESSURE DROP IMPORTANCE
SYSTEM: FOULING OR NOT
SYSTEM: SPRAY OR FROTH
SURFACE TENSION
51
SELECTION CRITERIA
Entrainment Flooding
Excessive liquid flow rate generated by droplets
Choking
Vapour blocking condition is induced
Downcomer Flooding
Gas liquid layer exceeds downcomer height
Weeping
gas flow unable to counterbalance
Sealing (Dumping)
gas liquid layer to flow over outlet weir
Blowing
gas bypassing occurs
52
SELECTION CRITERIA
Flooding:
Occurs when vapor and liquid flow rates exceed
capacity of column
Flooded tray acts as a restriction to the liquid flow
down the column
Symptoms
build up of liquid
excessive pressure drop
Two types –
Downcomer flooding – high flow & small tray spacing
Jet flooding – low flow & excessive liquid entrainment
53
SELCTION CRITERIA
Liquid Entrainment:
Increases with
hole vapor velocity
Reduction of tray spacing
Decreases with
increased liquid weir load and increased
fractional perforated area
High surface tension
54
SELECTION CRITERIA
55
SIEVE TRAYS
56
BUBBLE CAP TRAYS
57
VALVE TRAYS
Valve Trays
Moving Valves
Fixed Valves
Moving Valves:
Moves up & down as per vapor load
Movement is restricted by
Valve legs
External cage
Might become loose / lost from tray deck due to corrosion /
erosion & hence requires inspection / sometimes replacement
Fixed valve trays:
valves are integral with the tray deck providing a fixed opening for
liquid vapor interaction.
58
VALVE TRAYS
59
TRAYS WITHOUT DOWNCOMERS
60
CHIMNEY TRAYS
Not Mass Transfer devices
Used as draw trays
Transition trays
Protection against leakage
Used to remove one phase of two immiscible liquids
in a column
Sometimes used in lieu of enlarged downcomer
additional residence time
better liquid / vapor separation
less chance of flooding due to overloaded
downcomer
61
ERD TRAYS
Columns operating at maximum flow rates
results in trays being blown off from the tower attachments
TRAY MANWAY PANEL: Weakest point -
strengthened by stiffner bars
top manway clamp - increased size and change shape
TRAY HARDWARE:
Other trays floors: Also pull out of truss line hardware
usage of structural bottom tray clamps
TRUSS ENDS: Failure at the ends of integral formed trusses
Strengthened by providing Shear Clips
TIE TRUSSES:
Usage of bolting clips and angle clips
62
SELECTION CRITERIA
PRESSURE DROP:
63
SELECTION CRITERIA
FOULING
* COUNTER-CURRENT TRAYS
SMALL I.D. - LIMITED OP. RANGE
* BAFFLE TRAY
LOW EFFICIENCY
* SIEVE TRAY
64
DRIVERS for Advancements
INCREASE IN EFFICIENCY
More intimate contact of vapour & liquid
INCREASE IN CAPACITY
Maximise useful pressure drop
OPTIMISE REVAMP COST & TIME
Minimise cutting and welding
INCREASE IN FOULING RESISTANCE
Increase run length
65
FUNCTIONAL ZONES
Contacting zone
Downflow zone
Vapour-liquid
disengagement
zone
66
OPTIMISED TRAY
Capacity limitation by
67
Tray Development Timeline
68
HIGH PERFORMANCE TRAYS
69
HIGH PERFORMANCE TRAYS
KOCH-GLITSCH
VG-0
MV-1
SULZER
MVG
70
HIGH PERFORMANCE TRAYS
TRITON
SULZER
MVGT
71
SUPERFRAC® Tray Technology
72
SUPERFRAC® Tray Technology
73
TRAYS
Mechanical Advances
Mechanical Strengthening
Engineering features
To reduce installation time
To reduce column modifications for revamp jobs
74
HIGH PERFORMANCE TRAYS
Koch-Glitsch:
Bi-FRAC ™, Max frac, Nye ™ , SUPERFRAC® , Ultrafrac
Sulzer:
Vortex (Downcomer) Tray™, Nutter MVG™ Tray
Norton:
ProvalveTM Tray, TritonTM Trays
75
HIGH PERFORMANCE TRAYS
Bi-FRAC ™
Nye ™ MAX-FRACTM Vortex (Downcomer) Tray™
76
TRAY v/s PACKED COLUMNS
MERITS OF TRAYED COLUMNS
Wide Operating range than Packed Columns
High Pressure services
Higher L/V ratio
Very Low liquid rates - incomplete wetting in packing
Higher diameter
High residence time of liquid
Trayed columns permit easy cleaning - presence of solids
High no. of Liquid Withdrawals
Constructional features - limitation for smaller dia.
77
TRAY v/s PACKED COLUMNS
MERITS OF PACKED COLUMNS
Constructional features limitation for smaller dia. - Packing
cheaper than trays
Low Pressure services - Pressure drop / liquid thermally
sensitive
Low L/V ratio
Acids and corrosive applications - Ceramic, PP, Carbon etc.
Lower diameter
Packed preferred for tall towers
Liquid tendency to foam - packing preferred because of low
degree of liquid agitation
Absorption operation
Lower column size & higher capacity - equivalent trayed column
78
PACKINGS
PACKING CLASSIFICATION:
Random Packing
Structured Packing
79
PACKINGS
DESIREABLE PACKING CHARACTERISTICS:
Maximise Efficiency
Maximise the specific surface area
Spread Surface area uniformly
Promote uniform distribution
Freely drain any liquid
Maximise wetting
Maximise Capacity
Maximise the void space
Minimise friction
Ensure uniform resistance
Permit easy disengagement
80
RANDOM PACKINGS
Evolution:
First Generation – 1907 – 1950’s
Raschig rings
Lessing rings
Berl Saddles
81
RANDOM PACKING
82
STRUCTURED PACKING
Evolution:
First generation – 1940’s
Panapak
Second generation – late 1950’s
High efficiency wire mesh packings – application restricted
to Vacuum distillation
high cost, high sensitivity to solids, low capacity
Third Generation – late 1970’s
Corrugated Structured Packings
High capacity, low cost, low sensitivity to solids
retaining high efficiency
1980’s – accelerated rise in popularity
83
STRUCTURED PACKING
MIXING CELL
84
FLEXIPAC HC Structured Packing
FLEXIPAC® HC™
LIQUID structured packing
enhances the liquid
STREAM drainage from one
element to the next,
resulting in reduction of
TOWER
liquid hold up at the
SHELL
interface.
The smooth transition
between the packing
elements with an
enlarged turning
radius for the vapor
flow, reduces the VAPOR
pressure drop and
STREAM
increases capacity.
85
FLEXIPAC® HCTM Structured Packing
86
GRIDS
87
GRIDS
TYPES OF GRIDS:
Koch-Glitsch ‘C’ Grid
Koch-Glitsch EF- 25A Grid
Koch-Glitsch Flexigrid # 2 & # 3
Nutter # 3 Snap – Grid
Sulzer Mellagrid
88
PACKED COLUMN INTERNALS
Feed Pipes
Liquid Distributors /
Redistributors
Liquid Collector plates
Bed Limiters
Support Plates
89
Column Internals
Internals
• Tray Column
Trays
Chimney Tray
Feed Pipes
Gas Distributor
• Packed Column
Packing
Distributor / Redistributor
Support Plate
Hold drum plate / bed limitors
Feed Pipe
Gas Distributor
90
Column Internals
Distributor
91
PACKED COLUMN INTERNALS
92
LIQUID DISTRIBUTOR
93
LIQUID DISTRIBUTORS
LIQUID DISTRIBUTOR TYPES:
Gravity Distributors
• Principle used - internal head of liquid
• Pan distributor
• Trough distributor
Pressurised Distributors
• Principle used - pressure drop across the orifice
• Pipe orifice distributors
• Spray Header distributors
94