%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU ,661

.DUDNWHULVDVL6LIDW6LIDW)LVLNGDQ0HNDQLN(GLEOH)LOP3DWL%DWDQJ$UHQ $UHQJDSLQQDWD 0HUU

3K\VLFDODQG0HFKDQLFDO&KDUDFWHULVWLFVRI(GLEOH)LOP0DGHIURP$UHQ6WDON6WDUFK $UHQJDSLQQDWD 0HUU )6LQXQJ3UDQDWD 'MDJDO:0DUVHQR GDQ+DU\DGL 
)DNXOWDV%LRORJL8QLYHUVLWDV$WPD-D\D<RJ\DNDUWD )DNXWDV7HNQRORJL3HUWDQLDQ8QLYHUVLWDV*DGMDK0DGD<RJ\DNDUWD  )DNXWDV7HNQRORJL3HUWDQLDQ8QLYHUVLWDV*DGMDK0DGD<RJ\DNDUWD
 

$EVWUDFW
/LNH RWKHU ELRSRO\PHUV DUHQ VWDON VWDUFK FDQ EH IRUPHG D ILOP PDWUL[ E\ KHDW WUHDWHG 7KXVWKHDUHQVWDUFKFDQEHXVHGWRIRUPHGLEOHILOPV7KHREMHFWLYHVRIWKLVVWXG\ZHUHWR GHYHORS WKH SRWHQWLDOLW\ RI WKH DUHQ VWDON VWDUFK DQG WR FKDUDFWHUL]H WKH SURSHUWLHV RI WKH DUHQVWDONVWDUFKILOPV7KLVUHVHDUFKZDVGRQHLQWKLUGVWHSV)LUVWVWHSZHUHWRLVRODWHDQG WR FKDUDFWHUL]H RI WKH DUHQ VWDON VWDUFK 6HFRQGVWHSZDVWRGHYHORSWKHDUHQVWDONVWDUFK HGLEOHILOPV$UHQVWDONVWDUFKZDVXVHGDWFRQVHQWUDWLRQVIURPWRZYVWDUFKLQWKH ILUVWVWHSZKLOHLQWKHVHFRQGVWHSSDOPLWLFDFLGZDVXVHGDWFRQVHQWUDWLRQIURPWR ZYVWDUFK7KHDUHQVWDONVWDUFKFRQVLVWVRIDSSUR[LPDWHO\PRLVWXUHDVK DP\ORVHDQGSURWHLQ(GLEOHILOPVZLWKZYDUHQVWDONVWDUFKKDGWKH ORZHVWYDOXHVIRU:975$GGLWLRQRILQFUHDVLQJDUHQVWDONVWDUFKXQWLOZYUHVXOWHGQR LQFUHDVHGLQILOPHORQJDWLRQZKLOHDGGLWLRQRILQFUHDVLQJDUHQVWDONVWDUFKXQWLOOZY UHVXOWHG LQ LQFUHDVHG ILOP WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK 7KH DGGLWLRQ RI LQFUHDVLQJ SDOPLWLF DFLG XQWLO  ZZ VWDUFK GHFUHDVHG WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK RI DUHQ  VWDON VWDUFK ILOPV 7KH DUHQ VWDON VWDUFK ILOPV ZLWK DGGLWLRQ RI SDOPLWLF DFLG KDG WKH ORZHVW YDOXHV RI :975 RQ  ZZ VWDUFKSDOPLWLFDFLG .H\:RUGVELRSRO\PHU DUHQVWDONVWDUFK HGLEOHILOP

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 %DWDQJ DUHQ VHEDJDL WDQDPDQ SHUNHEXQDQ EDQ\DN GLEXGLGD\DNDQ GL ,QGRQHVLD QDPXQ SHPDQIDDWDQQ\DEHOXPVHRSWLPDOWDQDPDQOD LQ 3RKRQDUHQPHPLOLNLNDUDNWHULVWLN\DQJKDPSLU VDPD GHQJDQ SRKRQ VDJX 0HWUR[\ORQ VS .HGXD VSHVLHV LQL WHUJRORQJ GDODP IDPLOL 3DOPDH 0HQXUXW 0\UQD   3DWL WHUVXVXQ DWDVPROHNXODPLORVDGDQDPLORSHNWLQ$PLORVD

.DUDNWHULVDVL6LIDWVDIDW)LVLNGDQ0HNDQLN(GLEOH)LOP%DWDQJ$UHQ$UHQJD3LQQDWD 0HUU

XPXPQ\D GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHPEXDW ILOP GDQ JHO\DQJNXDW*DUFLDHWDOPHODSRUNDQ EDKZD NDQGXQJDQ DPLORVD \DQJ WLQJJL DNDQ PHPEXDW ILOP PHQMDGL OHELK NRPSDN NDUHQD DPLORVD EHUWDQJJXQJ MDZDE WHUKDGDS SHPEHQWXNDQPDWULNVILOP.DQGXQJDQDPLORVD EHEHUDSD SDWL WHODK GLNHWDKXL VHSHUWL VDJX PHQJDQGXQJ DPLORVD  VHPHQWDUD WDSLRND PHQJDQGXQJDPLORVD.QLJKW2OHK NDUHQD LWX SDWL EDWDQJ DUHQ MXJD EHUSRWHQVL XQWXNGLJXQDNDQVHEDJDLSHPEXDWHGLEOHILOP 3HQDPEDKDQ VHQ\DZD DGLWLI SDGD SHPEXDWDQ ILOP GLODNXNDQ XQWXN PHPSHUEDLNL VLIDW IXQJVLRQDORUJDQROHSWLNJL]LGDQNDUDNWHULVWLN PHNDQLN ILOP 6HQ\DZD SODVWLFL]HU VHSHUWL JOLVHURO GDQ VRUELWRO EDQ\DN GLWDPEDKNDQ GDODP SHPEXDWDQ HGLEOH ILOP XQWXN PHPSHUEDLNL VLIDW PHNDQLNQ\D 3HUPHDELOLWDV XDS DLU ILOP GDSDW GLWXUXQNDQ GHQJDQ SHQDPEDKDQVHQ\DZDKLGURIRELNVHSHUWLOLSLG (PXOVLILHU SHUOX GLWDPEDKNDQ NH GDODP SHPEXDWDQHGLEOHILOPDJDUSHUFDPSXUDQDQWDUD NRPSRQHQ SHQ\XVXQ ILOP \DQJ EHUVLIDW KLGURILOLN GDQ KLGURIRELN EHUODQJVXQJ VHPSXUQD .RPELQDVL DQWDUD NRQVHQWUDVL SDWL SODVWLFL]HU HPXOVLILHU GDQ OLSLG KDUXV VHVXDL XQWXNPHQJKDVLONDQNXDOLWDVILOP \DQJEDLN 3HQJDPDWDQVLIDWVLIDWILVLNGDQPHNDQLN ILOP VDQJDW SHQWLQJ GLODNXNDQ NDUHQD DNDQ PHQJJDPEDUNDQIXQJVLGDQDSOLNDVLHGLEOHILOP WHUVHEXW *RQWDUG HW DO  PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD ILOP \DQJ EDLN DGDODK ILOP \DQJ PHPSXQ\DL ODMX WUDQVPLVL XDS DLU PLQLPDO NDUHQD IXQJVL XWDPD ILOP DGDODK PHQJKDPEDW PLJUDVL XDS DLU DQWDUD PDNDQDQ \DQJ GLNHPDV GHQJDQOLQJNXQJDQQ\D/HELKODQMXW.URFKWD HW DO 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

DUHQ \DQJ PHPSXQ\DL ODMX WUDQVPLVL XDS DLU WHUNHFLO &DUD3HQHOLWLDQ $ %DKDQ3HQHOLWLDQ %XDK DSHO PDQDODJL0DOXV V\OYHWULV 0LOO \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ PHPSXQ\DL EHQWXN XNXUDQGDQZDUQD\DQJVHUDJDP%DKDQNLPLD \DQJGLJXQDNDQDGDODKDNXDGHV1D 62DVDP ERUDW +&O 1D2+WLR SHWUROHXP HWHU HWDQRO 1D2+ LRG &+ &22+ VRUELWRO DVDP SDOPLWDW]HLQ1DD]LGDVLOLNDEOXHJHO % $ODW3HQHOLWLDQ $ODWDODW \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ SLVDX VDULQJDQ D\DNDQ RYHQ HNVLNDWRU PXIIOH WLPEDQJDQ VDOWRULXV EXUHW PLNUR.MHOGDKO VSHNWURIRWRPHWHU MHQLV VSHFWURQLF   DODW DODW JHODV +RW SODWH GHQJDQ VWLUUHU NDLQ VDULQJ SODW XNXUDQ      FP GDQ RYHQ /OR\GV 8QLYHUVDO 7HVWLQJ ,QVWUXPHQW WLSH  V PLNURPHWHUFDZDQDNULOLNRYHQGDQ DODWJHODV & 7HPSDWGDQ:DNWX3HQHOLWLDQ 3HQHOLWLDQGLODNVDQDNDQGL/DERUDWRULXP %LRLQGXVWUL)DNXOWDV%LRORJL8QLYHUVLWDV$WPD -D\D <RJ\DNDUWD GDUL EXODQ 2NWREHU  VDPSDLGHQJDQ-XOL ' -DODQQ\D3HQHOLWLDQ 3HQHOLWLDQ GLODNXNDQ GDODP WLJD WDKDS \DLWX  7DKDSLVRODVLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQ$QDOLVLVSDWL PHOLSXWL UHQGHPHQ NDGDU DLU NDGDU DEX NDGDU DPLORVD NDGDU SURWHLQ GDQ NDGDU OHPDN 7DKDS LQL EHUWXMXDQ XQWXN PHPSHUROHK SDWL EDWDQJ DUHQ 3URVHV SHPEXDWDQQ\D PHQJDFX SDGD :DUDVWXWL  GHQJDQ EHEHUDSD PRGLILNDVL3URVHV LQL GLPXODL GHQJDQ SHQJHOXSDVDQ NXOLW OXDU EDWDQJ DUHQ NHPXGLDQ EDJLDQ GDODP HPSXOXU \DQJ EHUZDUQD SXWLK GLSLVDKNDQ (PSXOXU VHODQMXWQ\D GLJHUXV GLWDPEDKNDQ DLU GDQ GLUHQGDP VHODPD  MDP NHPXGLDQ GLSLVDKNDQWHPSDWQ\D/DUXWDQPHQJDQGXQJ SDWL  GLHQGDSNDQ VHODPD  MDP NHPXGLDQ DLU GLSLVDKNDQ GDUL HQGDSDQQ\D 6HWHODK



%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU

)6LQXQJ3UDQDWDHWDO

WHUSLVDK DQWDUD SDWL GDQ DLU UHQGDPDQ SDWL VHODQMXWQ\DGLNHULQJNDQGDQGLD\DN  3HQHOLWLDQXWDPDGLODNXNDQGHQJDQPHQJXML  IDNWRU \DLWX SHQJDUXK NRQVHQWUDVL SDWL GDQ DVDP SDOPLWDW WHUKDGDS VLIDWVLIDW ILVLN GDQPHNDQLNHGLEOHILOP\DQJGLKDVLONDQ 7DKDSSHPEXDWDQHGLEOHILOP 7DKDS LQL PHQJNRPELQDVLNDQ  IDNWRU \DLWX NRQVHQWUDVL SDWL GDQ DVDP SDOPLWDW 3URVHV SHPEXDWDQ HGLEOH ILOP PHQJDFX SDGD :DUDVWXWL  GHQJDQ EHEHUDSDPRGLILNDVL D 3HPEXDWDQ HGLEOH ILOP GHQJDQ YDULDVL NRQVHQWUDVLSDWL 3HPEXDWDQ HGLEOH ILOP GLPXODL GHQJDQ PHODUXWNDQ SDWL GHQJDQ YDULDVL NRQVHQWUDVL    EY GDODP DNXDGHV VHEDQ\DN  PO &DPSXUDQ GLDGXNGHQJDQKRWSODWH PDJQHWLFVWLUUHU GDQ GLSDQDVNDQ VDPSDL VXKX & VHODPD  PHQLW 6HODQMXWQ\D ODUXWDQ GLWDPEDK SODVWLFL]HU VRUELWRO VHEDQ\DN  EE SDWL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 \DLWX :975 WHUNHFLO 9DULDVL NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ DGDODK     EESROLPHU

+DVLO'DQ3HPEDKDVDQ $ .DUDNWHULVWLN3DWL%DWDQJ$UHQ 3DWL EDWDQJ DUHQ GLSHUROHK GDUL HPSXOXU SRKRQ DUHQ \DQJ VXGDK WXD GHQJDQ FDUD HNVWUDNVL3DGDSULQVLSQ\DHNVWUDNVLSDWLEDWDQJ DUHQVDPDGHQJDQHNVWUDNVLSDWLVDJX(NVWUDNVL SDWL EDWDQJ DUHQ GLPXODL GHQJDQ PHQJKDQFXUNDQ EDJLDQ GDODP EDWDQJ HPSXOXU GDQ PHQJHQGDSNDQ SDWLQ\D 5HQGHPHQSDWL\DQJGLSHUROHKGDULEDWDQJDUHQ VHEHVDU 3DWLEDWDQJDUHQPHQJDQGXQJELRSROLPHU SURWHLQ \DQJ FXNXS EHVDU GLEDQGLQJNDQ SDWL ODLQQ\D 7DEHO  $GDQ\D SURWHLQ LQL NHPXQJNLQDQ GDSDW PHPEDQWX SHPEHQWXNDQ FURVV OLQNLQJ PDWULNV ILOP \DQJ WHUMDGL DQWDUD SURWHLQ GHQJDQ SURWHLQ DWDX SURWHLQ GHQJDQ NDUERKLGUDW ,QWHUDNVL GDSDW WHUMDGL PHODOXL LNDWDQ LRQLN DWDXLNDWDQGLVXOILGDDQWDUSROLPHU *HQQGLRVGDQ:HOOHU 3DGD7DEHOWHUOLKDWEDKZDSDWLEDWDQJ DUHQ WLGDN PHQJDQGXQJ ELRSROLPHU OHPDN VHGDQJNDQSDWLVDJXGDQWDSLRND +DO LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD GDODP SHPEHQWXNDQ HGLEOH ILOP GHQJDQ EDKDQ GDVDU SDWL EDWDQJ DUHQ SHUOX GLWDPEDKNDQ DVDP OHPDNXQWXNPHQLQJNDWNDQKLGURIRELVLWDV ILOP Q\D GDQ PHPSHUEDLNL VLIDW EDUULHUQ\D WHUKDGDSXDSDLU 3DWL EDWDQJ DUHQ PHQJDQGXQJ DPLORVD 7DEHO6HPHQWDUD.QLJKW PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD WDSLRND PHQJDQGXQJ DPLORVD  .DQGXQJDQ DPLORVD SDWL VDJX PHQFDSDL  'DWDGDWD WHUVHEXW PHQXQMXNNDQEDKZDNDGDUDPLORVDSDWLEDWDQJ DUHQ OHELK WLQJJL GLEDQGLQJNDQ MHQLV SDWL ODLQQ\D .DGDU DPLORVD VDQJDW SHQWLQJ SHUDQDQQ\D GDODP SHPEHQWXNDQ PDWULNV ILOP WHUXWDPD SDGD FURVV OLQNLQJ DQWDU SROLPHU 0\UQD  *DUFLD HW DO  MXJD PHODSRUNDQ EDKZD NDQGXQJDQ DPLORVD EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDS SHQXUXQDQ QLODL :93 ILOP $PLORVD EHUWDQJJXQJ MDZDE WHUKDGDS SHPEHQWXNDQ PDWULNV VHKLQJJD ILOP DWDX FRDWLQJ PHQMDGL OHELK NRPSDN GHQJDQ SHQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DPLORVD +DO LQL PHQJLQGLNDVLNDQ EDKZD SDWL EDWDQJ DUHQ EHUSRWHQVLVHEDJDLEDKDQHGLEOHILOP 3DGD 7DEHO  WHUOLKDW EDKZD NDGDU DLU SDWL EDWDQJ DUHQ OHELK WLQJJL GLEDQGLQJNDQ

%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU



.DUDNWHULVDVL6LIDWVDIDW)LVLNGDQ0HNDQLN(GLEOH)LOP%DWDQJ$UHQ$UHQJD3LQQDWD 0HUU

MHQLV SDWL ODLQQ\D +DO LQL NHPXQJNLQDQ GLVHEDENDQ ROHK NHDGDDQ DLU GDODP EDKDQ EHUDGD GDODP EHQWXN WHULNDW VHKLQJJD UHODWLI VXNDU GLKLODQJNDQ SDGD ZDNWX SHQJHULQJDQ 6HEDJLDQ DLU \DQJ WHUNDQGXQJ GDODP VXDWX EDKDQVXNDUGLKLODQJNDQNDUHQDWHULNDWGHQJDQ PROHNXOODLQPHODOXLLNDWDQKLGURJHQEHUHQHUJL EHVDU0H\HU .DUDNWHULVWLN SDWL EDWDQJ DUHQ \DQJ ODLQ DGDODK NDQGXQJDQ EDKDQ DQRUJDQLN LPSXULWLHV $GDQ\D UHVLGX DQRUJDQLN GDSDW GLWXQMXNNDQ GHQJDQ NDQGXQJDQ DEX GDODP EDKDQ 3DWL EDWDQJ DUHQ VHSHUWL KDOQ\D SDWL \DQJ ODLQ PHQJDQGXQJ EDKDQEDKDQ \DQJ GLSHQJDUXKL ROHK OLQJNXQJDQ WHPSDW SRKRQ DUHQWHUVHEXWWXPEXK3DWLEDWDQJDUHQWHUQ\DWD PHQJDQGXQJ DEX \DQJ SDOLQJ UHQGDK  GLEDQGLQJNDQMHQLVSDWLODLQQ\D

% .DUDNWHULVWLN 6LIDWVLIDW )LVLN (GLEOH )LOP 3DWL%DWDQJ$UHQ 3DGD SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GLDQDOLVLV VLIDW VLIDW ILVLN HGLEOH ILOP GDUL SDWL EDWDQJ DUHQ \DQJ PHOLSXWL  VLIDW \DLWX VLIDW PHNDQLN GDQVLIDWSHQJKDPEDWDQEDUULHU6LIDWVLIDW PHNDQLN WHUGLUL DWDV HORQJDVL GDQ WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK VHGDQJNDQ VLIDW EDUULHU WHUKDGDS XDSDLUGLWXQMXNNDQGHQJDQQLODL:975  3HQJDUXK.RQVHQWUDVL3DWL%DWDQJ$UHQ WHUKDGDS6LIDWVLIDW)LVLN(GLEOH)LOP 3HPEXDWDQ HGLEOHILOP SDGDWDKDS LQLGLODNXNDQGHQJDQYDULDVLNRQVHQWUDVL SDWLEDWDQJDUHQEYGDQVRUELWRO  EE SDWL .HWHEDODQ  ILOP WLGDN GLSHQJDUXKL VHFDUD VLJQLILNDQ SDGD SHQDPEDKDQNRQVHQWUDVLSDWLNH WHWDSLEHUEHGDQ\DWDNRQVHQWUDVLSDWL *DPEDU .HWHEDODQ ILOP GLSHQJDUXKL ROHK  IDNWRU XWDPD \DLWX MXPODK SDGDWDQ WHUODUXW GDQ XNXUDQ SODW SHQFHWDN3HUEHGDDQNHWHEDODQILOP\DQJ GLKDVLONDQ GLVHEDENDQ ROHK NRQVHQWUDVL SDWL \DQJ EHUEHGD -DGL NHWHEDODQ ILOP \DQJ GLSHUROHK GDSDW EHUEHGD VDWX GHQJDQ\DQJODLQ 3DGD *DPEDU  WHUOLKDW EDKZD SHQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL SDWL WLGDN DNDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ HORQJDVL ILOP +DO LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD SDGD NLVDUDQ

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 GDQ VRUELWRO  EE SDWL 3HPLOLKDQ



%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU

)6LQXQJ3UDQDWDHWDO

LQL GLGDVDUNDQ SDGD QLODL :975 \DQJ SDOLQJNHFLOJP MDPZDODXSXQ WLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWDVHFDUDVWDWLVWLNSDGD ,  $VDP SDOPLWDW \DQJ GLWDPEDKNDQ SDGD WDKDS LQL DGDODK   EESDWL 3HQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW VHFDUD NHVHOXUXKDQ WLGDN PHQLQJNDWNDQHORQJDVL ILOP*DPEDU +DVLO LQL WHUQ\DWD EHUEHGD GHQJDQ SHQHOLWLDQ /DL GDQ +XH\  EDKZD SHQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW DNDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ HORQJDVL ILOP ELOD PHOHELKLWLWLNNULWLVQ\DDNDQPHQXUXQNDQ VLIDWHORQJDVLWHUVHEXW %HUEHGD KDOQ\D GHQJDQ HORQJDVL SHQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW DNDQ PHQXUXQNDQ WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK ILOP *DPEDU  3HQXUXQDQ QLODL WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK NHPXQJNLQDQ GLVHEDENDQ FURVV OLQNLQJ DQWDUSROLPHU ILOP KDQ\D EHUEHQWXNSDGDJXJXV2+SDWLGLEDJLDQ OXDU VDMD +DO LQL PHQ\HEDENDQ SHQXUXQDQ NHUDSDWDQ PDWULNV ILOP \DQJ EHUGDPSDN SDGD SHQXUXQDQ WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK ILOP +DVLO VHUXSD MXJD GLSHUROHK:DUDVWXWL3HQLQJNDW DQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW WLGDN PHQLQJNDWNDQ NHSDGXDQ SROLPHU SHQ\XVXQ ILOP WHWDSL DNDQ PHQJXUDQJL WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK ILOP \DQJ WHUEXDW GDUL WDSLRND 3HQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDWVHODLQWLGDNEHUSHQJDUXKVHFDUD VLJQLILNDQ WHUKDGDS HORQJDVL MXJD WHUKDGDSNHWHEDODQILOP3DGD*DPEDU WHUOLKDW EDKZD SHQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW VDPSDL  EE SDWL WLGDN DNDQ EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDS NHWHEDODQ ILOP+DOLQLGDSDWGLVHEDENDQ NDUHQDNRQVHQWUDVLSDGDWDQWHUODUXW\DQJ GLJXQDNDQ VDPD \DLWX  EY XQWXN VHWLDS NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW VHKLQJJD SHQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW GHQJDQ NLVDUDQ  EE SDWL WLGDN DNDQ PHQ\HEDENDQ SHQLQJNDWDQ NHWHEDODQILOP\DQJVLJQLILNDQ 3HQDPEDKDQ OLSLGD GLNHWDKXL GDSDW PHQXUXQNDQ QLODL :975 ILOP 3HQDPEDKDQ PLQ\DN EXQJD PDWDKDUL  JONHGDODPIRUPXODVLDNDQPHQXUXQNDQ

:93 ILOP EHUEDVLV SDWL *DUFLD HW DO  -HQLV OLSLGD MXJD GDSDW PHP SHQJDUXKL SHQXUXQDQ :93 ILOP 0F+XJK GDQ 6HQHVL  PHODSRUNDQ EDKZD SHQLQJNDWDQ MXPODK UDQWDL DVDP OHPDN DNDQ PHQXUXQNDQ :93 ILOP 3HQLQJNDWDQNRQVHQWUDVLOLSLGDMXJDDNDQ PHQXUXQNDQ QLODL :93 ILOP GDUL DSSOH SXUHH 3DGD *DPEDU   WHUOLKDW EDKZD SHQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW GLDWDVEESDWLDNDQPHQLQJNDWNDQ :975 ILOP .RQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW  EE SDWL PHUXSDNDQ QLODL :975 SDOLQJ NHFLO GLDQWDUD VHPXD SHUODNXDQ 3HQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW GLKDUDSNDQ GDSDW PHQXUXQNDQ :975 ILOP1DPXQKDOLQLWLGDNGLLNXWLGHQJDQ SHQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL HPXOVLILHU NDUHQD VLIDW ILOP \DQJ KLGURILOLN VHKLQJJD DNDQ PHPEDWDVL NHODUXWDQ DVDPSDOPLWDWGDODPVLVWHPILOP 3HQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW VHODLQ EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDS QLODL :975 ILOP MXJD EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDS QLODL NHODUXWDQ ILOP GL GDODP DLU 3HQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDWDNDQPHQXUXQNDQNHODUXWDQ ILOP GLEDQGLQJNDQ NRQWURO *DPEDU  +DO LQL GLVHEDENDQ NHPDPSXDQ DVDP OHPDN ODUXW GDODP DLU GLWHQWXNDQ ROHK NRQVHQWUDVL GDQ SDQMDQJ UDQWDLQ\D &RIILQ GDQ )LVKPDQ  3HQLQJNDWDQ NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW GLDWDVEESDWLDNDQPHQ\HEDENDQ SHUPXNDDQ ILOP PHQMDGLWLGDNUDWD'DWD LQL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD SDGD NRQVHQWUDVL DVDP SDOPLWDW WHODK WHUEHQWXN NRQGLVL RSWLPDO SHPEHQWXN PDWULNV ILOP GHQJDQ IXQJVL DVDP OHPDN VHEDJDLSHQDKDQXDSDLU .HVLPSXODQ'DQ6DUDQ $ .HVLPSXODQ %HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLSHUROHK PDND GDSDW GLDPELO NHVLPSXODQ \DLWX 3DWL EDWDQJ DUHQ GDSDW GLJXQDNDQ VHEDJDL EDKDQ SHPEXDW HGLEOH ILOP GDQ VLIDW ILVLN

%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU



.DUDNWHULVDVL6LIDWVDIDW)LVLNGDQ0HNDQLN(GLEOH)LOP%DWDQJ$UHQ$UHQJD3LQQDWD 0HUU

HGLEOH ILOP WHUEDLN SDGD NRQVHQWUDVL SDWL  EYGDQDVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWL +DOLQLGLWXQMXNNDQROHKKDUJD:975WHUNHFLO \DLWXJP MDP % 6DUDQ %HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLSHUROHKPDNDGDSDWEHULNDQVDUDQ\DLWX 3HUOX GLODNXNDQ SHQHOLWLDQ WHQWDQJ SHPEXDWDQHGLEOHILOPSDWLEDWDQJDUHQGHQJDQ MHQLV DVDP OHPDN \DQJ ODLQ VHKLQJJD NHPXQJNLQDQ QLODL SHQXUXQDQ :975 VLJQLILNDQ 'DIWDU 3XVWDND
&RIILQ ' 5 DQG 0 / )LVKPDQ  3K\VLFDO DQG 0HFKDQLFDO 3URSHUWLHV RI +LJKO\ 3ODVWLFL]HG 3HFWLQ6WDUFK )LOPV - $SSOLHG 3RO\PHU6FL *DUFLD 0$ 01 0DUWLQR DQG 1( =DULW]N\ 3ODVWLFL]HG6WDUFK %DVHG7R,PSURYH 6WUDZEHUU\ )UDJDULD ; $QDQDVVD 4XDOLW\ DQG 6WDELOLW\ - $JULF )RRG &KHP    *DUFLD 0$ 01 0DUWLQR DQG 1( =DULW]N\  /LSLG $GGLWLRQ WR ,PSURYH %DUULHU 3URSHUWLHV2I(GLEOH6WDUFK%DVHG)LOPVDQG &RDWLQJV-)RRG6FL *HQQDGLRV$DQG&/:HOOHU(GLEOH)LOPV DQG&RDWLQJVIURP6R\PLONDQG6R\3URWHLQ &HUHDO)RRG:RUOG *RQWDUG 1 6 *XLEHUW DQG -/&XT(GLEOH :KHDW *OXWHQ )LOP ,QIOXHQFH RI 7KH 0DLQ 3URFHVV 9DULDEOHV RQ )LOP 3URSHUWLHV 8VLQJ 5HVSRQVH6XUIDFH0HWKRGRORJ\ -)RRG6FL   *RQWDUG16*XLOEHUWDQG-/&XT:DWHU DQG *O\FHURO DV 3ODVWLFL]HUV $IIHFW 0HFKDQLFDO DQG :DWHU 9DSRU %DUULHU 3URSHUWLHV RI (GLEOH :KHDW *OXWHQ )LOP- )RRG6FL  .LP .Z & - .R DQG + - 3DUN  0HFKDQLFDO 3URSHUWLHV :DWHU 9DSRU 3HUPHDELOLWLHV  DQG 6ROXELOLWLHV RI +LJKO\ &DUER[\PHWK\ODWHG 6WDUFK%DVHG (GLEOH )LOPV-)RRG6FL .QLJKW-:7KH6WDUFK,QGXVWU\3HUJDPRQ 3UHVV2[IRUG

.URFKWD -0 ($ %DOGZLQ DQG 02 1LVSHURV &DUULHGR  (GLEOH &RDWLQJV DQG )LOPV WR ,PSURYH )RRG 4XDOLW\ 7HFKQRPLF 3XEO &R,QF/DQFDVWHU%DVHO .URFKWD -0 DQG &' 0XOGHU  -RKQVRQ  (GLEOH DQG %LRGHJUDGDEOH 3RO\PHU )LOPV &KDOOHQJHV DQG 2SSRUWXQLWLHV )RRG 7HFK   /DL 0 DQG +XH\  3URSHUWLHV RI 0LFURVWUXFWXUH RI 6KHHWV 3ODVWLFL]HG ZLWK 3DOPLWLF $FLG- &HUHDO &KHP      0F+XJK 7+ DQG ( 6HQHVL  $SSOH:UDSV $1RYHO0HWKRGWR,PSURYHWKH4XDOLW\DQG ([WHQGWKH6KHOI/LIHRI)UHVKFXW$SSOHV- )RRG6FL 0\UQD 21&  (GLEOH &RDWLQJV DQG )LOPV EDVHG RQ 3RO\VDFFKDULGHV GDODP  -0 .URFKWD ($ %DOGZLQ DQG 02 1LVSHURV &RUULHGR HGV(GLEOH&RDWLQJDQG)LOPVWR ,PSURYH)RRG4XDOLW\7HFKQRPLF3XEO&R ,QF/DQFRVWHU%DVHO :DUDVWXWL 0  3HQJDUXK 3HQDPEDKDQ 6RUELWRO GDQ $VDP 3DOPLWDW WHUKDGDS 6LIDW 0HNDQLN GDUL .HWHEDODQ (GLEOH )LOP GDUL 3DWL 8EL .D\X 6NULSVL )DNXOWDV 7HNQRORJL 3HUWDQLDQ8*0<RJ\DNDUWD





%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU

.DUDNWHULVDVL6LIDWVDIDW)LVLNGDQ0HNDQLN(GLEOH)LOP%DWDQJ$UHQ$UHQJD3LQQDWD 0HUU

7DEHO.RPSRVLVL.LPLD3DWL%DWDQJ$UHQGDQ%HEHUDSD-HQLV3DWL/DLQ .RPSRQHQEE 3URWHLQ /HPDN $PLORVD $LU $EX 3DWLEDWDQJDUHQ  1'    7DSLRND      3DWLVDJX     

6XPEHU +DVLO3HQHOLWLDQ  .QLJKW













   .RQVHQWUDVLSDWL 

*DPEDU3HQJDUXK.RQVHQWUDVLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQWHUKDGDSNHWHEDODQ HGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWDSDGD,  .RPSRVLVLILOP VRUELWROEESDWLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQ EY



%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU

)6LQXQJ3UDQDWDHWDO

 D          .RQVHQWUDVLSDWL  D D

*DPEDU3HQJDUXK.RQVHQWUDVLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQWHUKDGDSHORQJDVL HGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUE HGDQ\DWDSDGD,  .RPSRVLVLILOP VRUELWROEESDWLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQ EY



 E







   .RQVHQWUDVLSDWL 

*DPEDU3HQJDUXKNRQVHQWUDVLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQWHUKDGDS WHQVLOHVWUHQJWKHGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUEHGD Q\DWDSDGD,  .RPSRVLVLILOPVRUELWROEESDWLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQ  EY

%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU



.DUDNWHULVDVL6LIDWVDIDW)LVLNGDQ0HNDQLN(GLEOH)LOP%DWDQJ$UHQ$UHQJD3LQQDWD 0HUU

       

D D D

 .RQVHQWUDVLSDWL

*DPEDU3HQJDUXKNRQVHQWUDVLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQWHUKDGDS:975 HGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWDSDGD ,  .RPSRVLVLILOPVRUELWROEESDWLSDWLEDWDQJDUHQ  EY

  DE        

DE E

E E



.RQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWL

*DPEDU3HQJDUXKNRQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWWHUKDGDSHORQJDVL HGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWDSDGD ,  .RPSRVLVLILOPSDWLEDWDQJDUHQEYVRUELWROEESDWLDVDP SDOPLWDWEESDWLPO]HLQ



%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU

)6LQXQJ3UDQDWDHWDO

                 E EF F F EF D

.RQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWL

*DPEDU3HQJDUXKNRQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWWHUKDGDS WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK HGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWD SDGD,  .RPSRVLVLILOPSDWLEDWDQJDUHQEYVRUELWROEESDWL DVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWLPO]HLQ

 D  D             .RQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWL D D D D

*DPEDU3HQJDUXKNRQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWWHUKDGDSNHWHEDODQ HGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWDSDGD ,  .RPSRVLVLILOPSDWLEDWDQJDUHQEYVRUELWROEESDWL DVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWLPO]HLQ

%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU



.DUDNWHULVDVL6LIDWVDIDW)LVLNGDQ0HNDQLN(GLEOH)LOP%DWDQJ$UHQ$UHQJD3LQQDWD 0HUU

          E

D D EF F



.RQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWL

*DPEDU3HQJDUXKNRQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWWHUKDGDS:975 HGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWDSDGD ,  .RPSRVLVLILOPSDWLEDWDQJDUHQEYVRUELWROEESDWL DVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWLPO]HLQ

 D               .RQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWL E EF EF F F

*DPEDU3HQJDUXKNRQVHQWUDVLDVDPSDOPLWDWWHUKDGDSNHODUXWDQHGLEOHILOP KXUXI\DQJVDPDPHQXQMXNNDQWLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWDSDGD ,  .RPSRVLVLILOPSDWLEDWDQJDUHQEYVRUELWROEESDWL DVDPSDOPLWDWEESDWLPO]HLQ



%LRWD9RO9,,2NWREHU