The Effects of Teacher-Student Relationships: Social and Academic Outcomes of

Low-Income Middle and High School Students

Emily Gallagher (2005)

Teachers play an important role in the trajectory of students throughout the formal schooling
experience. Although most research regarding teacher-student relationships investigate the
elementary years of schooling, teachers have the unique opportunity to support students
academic and social development at all levels of schooling. Positive teacher-student relationships
enable students to feel safe and secure in their learning environments and provide scaffolding for
important social and academic skills. Teachers who support students in the learning environment
can positively impact their social and academic outcomes, which is important for the long-term
trajectory of school and eventually employment.
When teachers form positive bonds with students, classrooms become supportive spaces in
which students can engage in academically and socially productive ways. Positive teacherstudent relationships are classified as having the presence of closeness, warmth, and positivity.
Students who have positive relationships with their teachers use them as a secure base from
which they can explore the classroom and school setting both academically and socially, to take
on academic challenges and work on social-emotional development. This includes relationships
with peers, and developing self-esteem and self-concept. Through this secure relationship,
students learn about socially appropriate behaviors as well as academic expectations and how to
achieve these expectations. Students in low-income schools can especially benefit from positive
relationships with teachers.
Students in high-poverty urban schools may benefit from positive teacher-student relationships
even more than students in high-income schools, because of the risks associated with poverty.
Risk outcomes associated with poverty include high rates of high school dropout, lower rates of
college applications, low self-efficacy, and low self-confidence. There are several factors that can
protect against the negative outcomes often associated with low-income schooling, one of which
is a positive and supportive relationship with an adult, most often a teacher. Low-income
students who have strong teacher-student relationships have higher academic achievement and
have more positive social-emotional adjustment than their peers who do not have a positive
relationship with a teacher.
There is substantial research on the importance of teacher-student relationships in the early
elementary years. However, little is known about the effects of teacher-student relationships on
high school students. Studies show that early teacher-student relationships affect early academic
and social outcomes as well as future academic outcomes, but few researchers have looked at the
effects of teacher-student relationships in later years of schooling. Researchers who have
investigated teacher-student relationships for older students have found that positive teacherstudent relationships are associated with positive academic and social outcomes for high school

students.
Academic Outcomes
Although many studies focus on the importance of early teacher-student relationships, some
studies have found that teacher-student relationships are important in transition years; the years
when students transition from elementary to middle school or middle to high school. Studies of
math competence in students transitioning from elementary to middle school have found that
students who move from having positive relationships with teachers at the end of elementary
school to less positive relationships with teachers in middle school significantly decreased in
math skills. For students who are considered at high risk for dropping out of high school, math
achievement is significantly impacted by the perception of having a caring teacher. Furthermore,
students who went from low teacher closeness to high teacher closeness significantly increased
in math skills over the transition year, from elementary to middle school. These studies show that
relationships with teachers in the later years of schooling can still significantly impact the
academic achievement trajectories of students.
Another example of the importance of teacher-student relationships in high school students stems
from intervention studies aimed at improving academic outcomes for low-income students. In
one intervention study that aimed to increase positive relationships between low-income high
school students and their teachers, results showed that students who participated in the
intervention significantly improved their GPA over the course of five months. Such research
shows that positive teacher-student relationships can improve academic skills in students as early
as middle school and as late as high school. In addition to positive teacher-student relationships,
students motivation to learn is another factor that influences social and academic outcomes.
A possible reason for the association between academic improvement and positive teacherstudent relationships is students motivation and desire to learn. Motivation may play a key role
in the relationship between teacher-student relationships and academic outcomes. Motivational
theorists suggest that students perception of their relationship with their teacher is essential in
motivating students to perform well. Students who perceive their relationship with their teacher
as positive, warm and close are motivated to be more engaged in school and to improve their
academic achievement. Students motivation to learn is impacted positively by having a caring
and supportive relationship with a teacher.
Motivation is closely linked to students perceptions of teacher expectations. Studies of middle
and high school students have shown that students shape their own educational expectations
from their perceptions of their teachers expectations. Students who perceive that their teachers
have high expectations of their academic achievement are more motivated to try to meet those
expectations and perform better academically than their peers who perceive low expectations
from their teachers. Due to the influence of expectations on motivation, expectations can be an
important factor on a students academic achievement.
Furthermore, teacher-student relationships have an impact on the academic self-esteem of

students. High-poverty students often have low academic self-esteem and low confidence in their
academic and vocational futures. Thus, positive relationships with teachers are important in
supporting higher levels of self-esteem, higher academic self-efficacy, and more confidence in
future employment outcomes. Self-confidence and future aspirations have a significant impact on
students interest in school, their academic self-efficacy and in turn, their academic achievement.
In addition to academic achievement, positive teacher-student relationships provide important
social outcomes for students.
Social Outcomes
Although there is more research regarding the academic effects of positive teacher-student
relationships for older students, there are notable social outcomes as well. Teachers are an
important source of social capital for students. Social capital in a classroom setting is defined as
caring teacher-student relationships where students feel that they are both cared for and expected
to succeed. Social capital from positive teacher-student relationships can manifest itself in many
different ways. For high school students, positive teacher-student relationships can reduce rates
of dropping out by nearly half, help explore options for college, and provide support for further
academic or vocational aspirations. Common reasons for dropping out include low levels of
family support, low academic achievement, poor relationships with peers and adults, and low
interest in academics. Positive teacher-student relationships can impact students social and
academic outcomes, and thus reduce drop-out rates. Low-income students often have neither the
support they need to complete high school nor access to the information they need to pursue
education beyond high school. It is important for low-income students who experience academic
difficulties and negative social outcomes to gain social capital from their teachers, because
research shows they can benefit from the guidance and support. Further, teacher-student
relationships can impact peer relationships in schools.
Teacher-student relationships can have a significant effect on the peer acceptance of students.
Teachers interactions with students can affect classmates perceptions of individual students, in
turn affecting which students classmates choose to interact with and accept. Conflicting
interactions between teachers and students may convey a lack of acceptance, causing other
students to also reject the student involved in the conflict with the teacher. Peer rejection
significantly impacts self-esteem of students leading to several negative social outcomes.
As mentioned earlier, students with high self-esteem are more likely to be self-efficacious and set
higher goals. Self-esteem also affects students socially. Students with high self-esteem are more
likely to have positive relationships with peers as well as with adults. Self-esteem also affects
students mental health outcomes including reducing anxiety and symptoms of depression. Selfesteem is especially important during adolescence and helps students develop a positive sense of
self. A positive sense of self in adolescence leads to future outcomes including relationship
satisfaction, job satisfaction, occupational status, emotional regulation, and physical health. The
support of positive teacher-student relationships for self-esteem and related social outcomes
affects students during schooling as well as in their future educational and occupational
outcomes.

Conclusion and Limitations

Although there is extensive research on the positive effects of teacher-student relationships on
elementary school students, there is little research on middle and high school students. Middle
and high school is when students begin to think about their academic futures, which are informed
by academic achievement and social capital in elementary years. Early high school is usually
when students dedicate themselves to graduating or decide to drop out. Currently, high school
dropout rates are high, and improving teacher-student relationships for students at this stage may
decrease dropout rates. Similarly, high school is when students decide if they plan to attend
college or stop their education. Therefore, it is important to develop positive teacher-student
relationships during this time.
Empirical evidence does show that teacher-student relationships are very important for high
school students. Studies that have investigated older students relationships with teachers have
found that students improve both academically and socially from positive teacher-student
relationships. However, much of this research is dated. Due to the ever-changing nature of the
American educational system and the increasingly diverse student body, more current studies are
needed to look at the effects of teacher-student relationships for this changing population. It is
important to learn more about teacher-student relationships for low-income students to decrease
high school dropout, and improve students social-emotional development. Conducting research
on the relationship between high school students and teachers may be essential in improving the
outcomes of low-income middle and high school students, and can potentially inform future
interventions to help older students perform better both academically and socially.
Retrieved From: http://steinhardt.nyu.edu/appsych/opus/issues/2013/fall/gallagher

The Positive Student-Teacher Relationship

David Thomas (Nov 2000)
The teacher student relationship is very important for children. Children spend approximately 5
to 7 hours a day with a teacher for almost 10 months. We ask ourselves what is considered a
good teacher? All of us have gone through schooling, and if fortunate had a favorite teacher. A
positive relationship between the student and the teacher is difficult to establish, but can be found
for both individuals at either end. The qualities for a positive relationship can vary to set a
learning experience approachable and inviting the students to learn. A teacher and student who
have the qualities of good communications, respect in a classroom, and show interest in teaching
from the point of view of the teacher and learning from a student will establish a positive
relationship in the classroom. I will be focusing on the relationship between the student and
teacher, involving a setting in the primary grades, which I have found second grade to be
extremely important for the student to gain a positive attitude for their future education.
Children have different strategies for learning and achieving their goals. A few students in a
classroom will grasp and learn quickly, but at the same time there will be those who have to be
repeatedly taught using different techniques for the student to be able to understand the lesson.
On the other hand, there are those students who fool around and use school as entertainment.
Teaching then becomes difficult, especially if there is no proper communication. Yet, teachers,
creating a positive relationship with their students, will not necessarily control of all the
disruptive students. The book, Responsible Classroom Discipline written by Vernon F. Jones and
Louise Jones discuss how to create a learning environment approachable for children in the
elementary schools. According to the Jones, Student disruptions will occur frequently in classes
that are poorly organized and managed where students are not provided with appropriate and
interesting instructional tasks.
The key is, teachers need to continuously monitor the student in order for him or her to be aware
of any difficulties the student is having. Understanding the childs problem, fear, or confusion
will give the teacher a better understanding the childs learning difficulties. Once the teacher
becomes aware of the problems, he or she will have more patience with the student, thus making
the child feel secure or less confused when learning is taking place in the classroom.
The communication between the student and the teacher serves as a connection between the two,
which provides a better atmosphere for a classroom environment. Of course a teacher is not
going to understand every problem for every child in his or her classroom, but will acquire
enough information for those students who are struggling with specific tasks. A significant body
of research indicates that academic achievement and student behavior are influenced by the
quality of the teacher and student relationship. The more the teacher connects or communicates

with his or her students, the more likely they will be able to help students learn at a high level
and accomplish quickly.
The teacher needs to understand that in many schools, especially in big cities like Los Angeles,
children come from different cultures and backgrounds. A teacher then needs to understand the
value of the students' senses of belonging, which can be of greater value and build self worth for
minority students. If the teacher demonstrates an understanding of the students culture, it will
provide a better understanding between the teacher and the student. The Mind of Man states,
children who are yelled at feel rejected and frightened because a teacher shouts at them. The
example above demonstrates the feelings the child has towards the teacher leading to inhibiting
the child from learning. The reasons for children to be yelled at vary from teacher to teacher, but
shouting should not be the solution for children who find education a difficult process or simply
lack of learning experiences, but sometimes teachers find yelling at the child as the only quick
solution.
Therefore, those teachers who demonstrate respect towards their students automatically win
favor by having active learners in their classroom. The arrogant or offensive teacher will lack
these positive qualities due to his or her lack of control over the children. Teachers should assert
that they should also be treated with respect and their responsibilities to ensure that students treat
each other with kindness. According to the Jones, teachers are encouraged to blend their warmth
and firmness towards the students in their classroom, but with realistic limits.
Another point, I have often found critical, are the number of times the teacher does not correct
the students who find calling names to their classmates amusing. Children who are teased or
bullied by other children find themselves being victimized by their peers. Children who have
become victims of this nature find learning difficult. They will be stressed out not only by trying
to achieve academically, but also because the names they have been appointed by their
classmates are destructive, demeaning, and destroy self-esteem. Therefore, it is important for
teachers to have children respect each other. Usually, a type of lesson involving with self-esteem
can be an excellent activity for children who are involved in this destructive nature.
Teachers who are in a classroom everyday have experienced one time or another student(s) who
are disruptive and/or find learning boring. Teachers understand that if this behavior continues in
the classroom and if they do nothing to prevent this from happening, the outcome proves to be
disastrous for both types of participants. The student will conclude that his or her behavior is
permissible, and will draw away from learning, therefore it is essentially important for the
teacher to explain to the child the importance to learn. Though we understand that learning
cannot be forced. Learning becomes a process for an individual where he or she feels
comfortable with learning whether its in a classroom or at home. Mike Rose explains in Lives
on the Boundary that It is what we are excited about that educates us. Roses quote can be
applied to children at an early age, just as well as it can be applied to adults.

Definitely children learn when they enjoy learning, but also they need some control over the
teacher (s) decisions. Authoritarian control is often destructive to students who are in the
primary grades, and eventually upper grades teachers have difficulty dealing with children who
were taught with an authoritarian teacher. Children in primary grades feel the urge to talk about
their problems, fears, or even show their knowledge, but at the same time they want to be
listened too. The student will feel valued and respected. Students feel flattered when the teacher
eventually gives them the option of contributing, or in other words the teacher asks for an
opinion, which is usually not offered to the students. The teacher(s) does not have to give up all
their control, rather teachers share control with students and encourage interactions that are
determined by mutual agreement.
For teachers conducting a classroom and shaping the minds of the young students, teachers who
communicate effectively with their students should give appropriate and helpful feedback to their
students. Interaction between the student and teacher becomes extremely important for a
successful relationship through the entire time of a school year. A close, but limited relationship
between the student and teacher can be helpful for those students who are shy, and find speaking
in front of the classroom difficult or children who have low self-esteem. The tension these
students hold in a classroom will have the confidence they had always wanted, but never
achieved due to not having a good relationship with the teacher.
Another important point is raised when teachers think of themselves as traditional are
following the canonical approach. The traditional teachers follow the famous list of books to be
read by his or her students. Many children will not enjoy reading because they do not have the
background to understand the material. They do not have any interest in the book, which makes
reading confusing and difficult to understand. Students have felt what mattered most was the
relationship teachers established with their students providing guidance to students who have felt
inadequate or threatened. Teachers who follow the traditional curriculum do not necessarily
need to focus on their traditional ideas, but rather interact with their students and find interesting
topics to discuss with their students.
Therefore, how does a teacher hold a relationship that leads to effectively teach the children? The
answer becomes clear when teachers interact with, and learn more about their students. Our first
educational experience, which takes place in the primary years of our life, sets the principles for
our future education. Every school year an elementary teacher deals with new faces and new
attitudes. Some children find themselves lacking an interest in learning and others feel playing
and fooling around at school with friends is the happiest moment of their life. The solution to
inappropriate behavior will not automatically get rid of the poor attitude of these children, but is
to establish a positive relationship. Teachers can establish a positive relationship with their
students by communicating with them and properly providing feedback to them. Respect
between teacher and student with both feeling enthusiastic when learning and teaching. Having
established a positive relationship with students will encourage students to seek education and be

enthusiastic and to be in school. Remembering our favorite teacher will be recognized because
they had at least in one way or another the qualities I discussed in this essay, although we are not
aware of it during the time we are in school, but teachers are well recognized at a later time of
our lives.

Retrieved From: http://www.csun.edu/~acc50786/Education.html