Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Feedback PDF
Feedback PDF
for
Electronic Circuits
by
Prof. Michael Tse
September 2004
Contents
Feedback
Basic feedback conguration
Advantages
The price to pay
Feedback Amplier Congurations
Series-shunt, shunt-series, series-series, shunt-shunt
Input and output impedances
Practical Circuits with loading effects
Compensation
Op-amp internal compensation
Oscillation
Oscillation criteria
Sustained oscillation
Wein bridge, phase shift, Colpitts, Hartley, etc.
si
input
so
output
basic amplier
Careful!!
sf
f
feedback network
Characteristics
+
si
input
so
basic amplier
sf
output
so = Ae = A(si - s f )
f
feedback network
so = A(si - fso )
Hence, the overall gain is
si
Ao
so
Ao =
so
A
=
si 1+ Af
If Af >> 1,
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
Ao
1
f
4
Simple viewpoint
si
input
so
basic amplier
sf
output
f
feedback network
so 1
f
si
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
Obvious advantage
If the feedback network is constructed from passive elements having
stable characteristics, the overall gain becomes very steady and
unaffected by variation of the basic amplier gain.
Quantitatively, we wish to know how much the overall gain Ao
changes if there is a small change in A.
Let assume A becomes A + dA. From the formula of Ao, we have
dAo dA 1
=
Ao A 1+ Af
Obviously, if Af is large, then dAo/Ao will be reduced drastically.
1
Feedback reduces gain sensitivity! In fact, the gain is just Ao
.
f
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
so
Another advantage
Suppose the basic amplier is
distortive. So, the output does
not give a sine wave for a sine
wave input.
output
input
so
1/f
si
Other advantages
si
ni
A
so
si
input
Signal-to-noise ratio:
so si
=
no ni
+
A
basic amplier
sf
so
output
f
feedback network
so
si
= A
no
ni
8
Terminologies
Basic amplier gain = A
Feedback gain = f
Overall gain (closed-loop gain) =
A
1
1+ Af
f
Some books use T to denote Af.
10
Feedback ampliers
What is an amplier?
si
so
Rin
Avin
+
vo
voltage amplier
11
Models of ampliers
Ro
+
vin
Rin
iin
Avin
io
+
vo
Aiin
Rin
voltage amplier
iin
current amplier
io
Ro
Rin
Ro
Aiin
transresistance amplier
+
vo
+
vin
Aiin
Rin
Ro
transconductance amplier
12
so
output
basic amplier
sf
voltage
voltage
feedback network
vi
vf +
vo
13
vi
ve
Ri
Ave
vo
fvo
Ao =
vo
A
=
v i 1+ Af
14
RIN =
vi
vi
=
ii v e /Ri
v e + fv o
= Ri
ve
= Ri (1+ Af )
Ro
vi
ve
Ri
Ave
vo
RIN
+
fvo
15
vi
ve
Ri
Ave
io
+
vo
io =
v o - Av e v o + Afv o
=
Ro
Ro
Hence,
ROUT
+
ROUT =
fvo
vo
Ro
=
io 1+ Af
16
Equivalent model
Ro
1+ Af
A
1
Closed-loop gain =
f
1+ Af
+
Input resistance = Ri ( 1 + Af )
vi
Output resistance =
Ri ( 1 + Af )
Av i
1+ Af
vo
Ro
1+ Af
NOTE: We did not consider loading effect of the
feedback network, i.e., we assume that the feedback
network is an ideal amplier which feeds a scaled-down
copy of the output to the input.
feedback network
17
so
output
basic amplier
sf
current
voltage
feedback network
vo
18
ie
Ro
+
Ri
Aie
vo
fvo
Ao =
vo
A
=
ii 1+ Af
19
ie
Ro
vi
RIN =
v i Riie
=
ii
ii
Ri
vo
Aie
RIN
ie
ie + fv o
Ri
=
1+ Af
= Ri
fvo
20
ie
Ro
+
Ri
io
vo
Aie
io =
v o - Aie v o + Afv o
=
Ro
Ro
Hence,
ROUT
ROUT =
fvo
vo
Ro
=
io 1+ Af
21
Equivalent model
A
1
Closed-loop gain =
f
1+ Af
Ri
Input resistance =
1+ Af
Output resistance =
Ro
1+ Af
ii
Ri
1+ Af
Aii
1+ Af
vo
Ro
1+ Af
22
vo
ve
Ro
Ave
Ri
io
+
f io
io
A
=
v i 1+ Af
RIN = Ri (1+ Af )
Desirable!
ROUT = Ro (1+ Af )
Desirable!
Ao =
23
ie
io
Ro
Aie
Ri
io
f io
Ao =
Input resistance:
RIN =
Output resistance:
ROUT
io
A
=
ii 1+ Af
Ri
1+ Af
Ro
=
1+ Af
Desirable!
Desirable!
24
ii
Ro
Ri
Aie
vo
fvo
What are the effects on the gain, input and output resistances?
25
ii
yi
y11
vi
vo
y22
y21vi
y11f
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
y22f
y21fvo
26
ii
yi
y11
vi
vo
y22
y21vi
y11f
y22f
y12fvo
27
y22f
+
ii
yi
y11
vi
vo
y22
y21vi
y12fvo
28
y22f
+
ii
vi
yi
y11
vo
y22
y21vi
y12fvo
29
ii
y22f +y22
vo
vi
y21vi
y12fvo
30
in resistance ()
ii
vi
-y 21v i
y 22f + y 22
vo
Use Thevenin
y12fvo
31
ie
ii
in resistance ()
+
vi
vo
( y 22f
-y 21ie
+ y 22 )( y11 + y11f + y i )
y12fvo
32
A=
Feedback gain
f = y21f
Ao =
Input resistance
Output resistance
RIN =
ROUT =
( y 22f
-y 21
-y 21
=
+ y 22 )( y11 + y11f + y i ) y oT y iT
A
1
1
=
1+ Af
f y12f
(y11 + y11f
1
+ y i )(1+ Af )
1
(y 22f + y 22 )(1+ Af )
33
WHY?
34
2.
3.
4.
5.
35
Example
Rf
a
+
is
Type of feedback:
Appropriate 2-port type:
+
vo
RL
shunt-shunt
y-parameter
36
Example
a
is
+
vo
RL
Rf
37
Example
Converting to y-parameter
is
Note: this
goes to the
ve input
of A.
vi
+
Ri
Ro
avi
+
vo
RL
Rf
y11f
y22f
-1
Rf
y 22f =
y12fvo
y11f =
1
Rf
y12f =
1
Rf
38
Example
Converting to y-parameter
is
vi
+
Ri
Ro
+
vo
avi
y11f
RL
y22f
y12fvo
y11f =
1
Rf
y12f =
-1
Rf
y 22f =
1
Rf
REMEMBER:
y11f and y22f are conductance!
39
Example
Casting it to standard form
is
vi
+
Ri || R f
Ro
Rf||RL
avi
+
vo
y12fvo
y11f =
1
Rf
y12f =
-1
Rf
y 22f =
1
Rf
40
Example
Casting it to standard form
is
vi
+
Ri || R f
Ro || R f || RL
a(R f || RL )
vi
Ro + R f || RL
+
vo
-v o
Rf
41
Example
Finally, we get the standard form
ie
is
vi
+
Ri || R f
Ro || R f || RL
Aie
+
vo
R f || RL
(R
|| RL ) + Ro
R || R )( R || R )
(
A = -a
(R || R ) + R
i
A = -a
Ri R 2f RL
1
(Ri + R f ) ( R f RL + Ro R f + Ro RL )
42
Example
Apply standard results:
Ri R 2f RL
1
(Ri + R f ) ( R f RL + Ro R f + Ro RL )
A = -a
Feedback gain:
f =
-1
Rf
Ao =
A
1
= -R f
1+ Af
f
Input resistance
Output resistance
RIN =
ROUT =
if Af >> 1
Ri || R f
1+ Af
Ro || R f || RL
1+ Af
43
Frequency response
Gain and bandwidth
si
input
A(jw)
basic amplier
sf
A( jw ) =
output
ALF
jw
1+
p1
20log10|A| (dB)
f
feedback network
ALF
slope = 20dB/dec
p1
44
Frequency response
Gain and bandwidth
The overall (closed-loop) gain is
A( jw )
1+ A( jw ) f
ALF
=
jw
1+
+ fALF
p
Ao ( jw ) =
ALF
1
=
w
j
1+ fALF 1+
p1 (1+ fALF )
20log10|A| (dB)
basic amplier
ALF
feedback amplier
Ao,LF
p1
pc
45
feedback circuit
sustained oscillation at certain frequency
46
so
output
47
Af = 1
2.
Af = 180o
The idea is
If the signal, after making a round trip through A and f, has a gain of 1
and a phase shift of exactly 360o, then it oscillates. But, in the negative
feedback system, there is already a 180o phase shift. Therefore, the
phase shift caused by A and f together will only need to be 180o to
cause oscillation.
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
48
T = Af
|T| (dB)
crossover frequency
(where the gain is 1)
wo
0dB
w
w
fT
If fT = 180o, OSCILLATES!
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
49
Phase margin
Phase margin is an important parameter to evaluate how stable the
system is.
Phase margin fPM = 180o fT
|T| (dB)
crossover frequency
(where the gain is 1)
wo
0dB
w
w
fT
180o
50
Compensation
Compensation is to make the amplier more stable, i.e., to increase fPM.
REMEMBER: We should always look at T, not A or Ao.
|T| (dB)
crossover frequency
(where the gain is 1)
wo
0dB
p1
p2
w
w
fT
180o
51
crossover frequency
after compensation
|T| (dB)
crossover frequency
before compensation
0dB
pa
p1
p2
w
w
before compensation
after compensation
180o
52
|T| (dB)
crossover frequency
before compensation
za
0dB
p1
p2
crossover frequency
after compensation
w
w
before compensation
after compensation
180o
p1
p2
90o
180o
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
54
p1
p2
90o
180o
phase margin 45o
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
55
RL
Equivalent model:
RL
next stage
to next stage
ro//RL
2C
RIN
56
1
2(ro || RL || RIN )C
= 2p (5)
to active load
C
RL
RL
output stage
57
Data:
Q1 differential Q2
input stage
Q13B
Q13A
Q14
Q3
Q4
output
+Vcc
Q20
Q16
VEE
Q5
Q6
DC gain = 70 dB
Poles:
30 kHz
500 kHz
10 MHz
Q23
Q17
58
p1 = 30 kHz
Bad stability
because of the
substantial phase
shift!
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
59
p1
90o
180o
phase margin 45o
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
60
p1 = 30 kHz
pa
Bad stability
because of the
substantial phase
shift!
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
61
slope = 20 dB/dec
70 dB
0 - 70
-70
=
log p1 - log pa 4.477 - log pa
Hence, pa = 9.5 Hz
pa
p1 = 30 kHz
62
63
Q13B
Q13A
Cc
Q3
Q4
Q14
output
+Vcc
Q20
Q16
VEE
Q5
Q6
Q23
Q17
64
+
Q3
Q13B
Q4
Given:
Ro17 = 5 M
Ro13 = 720 k
Ri23 = 100 k
Q13A
Cc
Q14
output
+Vcc
Q20
Q16
VEE
Q5
Q6
Q23
Q17
Gm = 6 mA/V
Gain of CE stage:
ACE = Gm[Ro17||Ro13||Ri23]
Miller-effect capacitor
CM = Cc (ACE + 1)
= 518.74 Cc
65
+
Q3
Q13B
Q4
Cc
Equivalent ckt:
Ro4||Ro6
+Vcc
Q16
VEE
Q5
Q13A
Given:
Ri16 = 2.9 M
Ro4 = 10 M
Ro6 = 20 M
Q6
Ri16
CM
Q17
main gain stage
CE stage
VEE
pa = 1 / 2 CM [Ro4||Ro6|| Ri16]
and CM = 518.74 Cc
Hence, Cc = 15 pF
66
Oscillation
In designing feedback ampliers, we want to make sure that oscillation does
not occur, that is, we want stable operation.
However, oscillation is needed to make an oscillator. As shown before, the
criteria for oscillation in a feedback amplier are
1.
2.
Thus, the same feedback structure can be used to make an oscillator. In other
words, we construct a feedback amplier, but try to make it satisfy the above
two criteria.
In practice, T is a function of frequency, and the above criteria are
satised for one particular frequency. This frequency is the oscillation
frequency.
67
Oscillator principle
As T = Af, we can deliberately create phase shift in A or f.
si
input
so
A(jw)
basic amplier
f(jw)
output
feedback network
wo
w
w
180o
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
68
Sustained oscillation
There are two problems! How does oscillation start? And how can oscillation
be maintained?
First, there is noise everywhere! So, signals of all frequencies exist and go
around the loop. Most of them get reduced and do not show up as oscillation.
But the one at the oscillation frequency starts to oscillation as it satises the
Barkhausen criteria.
If | T | is slightly bigger than 1, oscillation amplitude will grow and go to
innity. But if | T | is slightly less than 1, oscillation subsides. The question is
how to maintain oscillation with a constant magnitude.
We need a control that changes | T | continuously. Typically, this is done by a
nonlinear amplitude stabilizing circuit, for example, an amplier whose gain
drops when its output increases, and rises when its output decreases.
69
R2
R1
Zp
C
Zs
Zp
Zs
R2
R1
-Z p
A = 1+
Feedback gain
f =
Zs + Z p
where Z p =
R
1+ jwCR
and Z s =
1+ jwCR
jwC
70
R
-1+ 2
R1
T( jw ) =
1
3 + jwCR
wCR
Applying the oscillation criteria, we can nd the oscillation frequency and the
resistor values as follows:
R
T( jw ) = 1 1+ 2 = 3 R2 = 2R1
R1
1
1
fT = 180 o w oCR =
wo =
CR
w oCR
We can choose R2/R1 to be slightly larger than 2, say 2.03, to start oscillation.
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
71
WHY OSCILLATE?
|f|
1/3
freq
ff
fo
+ 90
freq
90
72
+15V
Amplitude control
3k
D2
20.3k
10k
Diode D1 (D2) conducts when vo reaches its
positive (negative) peak.
1k
vo
1k
A 20.3k
16n 10k
vo
1k
16n 10k
3k
B
D1
3k
15V
15V
-15 +
3
1
(v o + 15) = v o
4
3
v o = 9 V.
73
R2
R1
|f|
C
1
29
freq
R'
R1 || R'= R
ff
fo
180o
freq
74
|f|
1
29
freq
1
fo =
2p 6CR
ff
fo
180o
freq
Note that the leftmost resistor in the feedback lter is R (not R). But R//R1 is
exactly R. This will adjust the loading effect of the basic amplier and make the
overall lter circuit easier to analyze since it is then simply composed of three
identical RC sections.
C.K. Tse: Feedback ampliers and
oscillators
75
A
jX1
+
vi
jX2
Ri
Ro
Avi
jX3
jX3
vi
+
jX1
jX2
76
-A( jX1 )( jX 2 )
j ( X1 + X 2 + X 3 ) Ro + jX 2 ( jX1 + jX 3 )
AX1 X 2
j ( X1 + X 2 + X 3 ) Ro - X 2 ( X1 + X 3 )
X1 + X 2 + X 3 = 0
AX1
=1
X1 + X 3
+
vi
Ri
Ro
Avi
jX3
vi
+
jX1
jX2
77
Colpitts oscillator
When X1 and X2 are capacitors and X3 is inductor, we have the Colpitts oscillator.
In this case, we have
jX1 =
1
1
and jX 2 =
jwC1
jwC2
jX 3 = jwL3
+
vi
From X1 + X 2 + X 3 = 0
Ri
wo =
Ro
Avi
1
C1C2
L3
C1 + C2
vi
+
L3
C1
C2
78
T(s) = Gm ZT
where
1/sC1
sL + 1/sC1
ZT
1
1
1
= sC2 +
+
1
ZT
ro || Rc
sL +
sC1
wo =
1
CC
L3 1 2
C1 + C2
C1 Gm Rc ro
Gm C2 (ro || Rc )
>1
>
C1
C2 Rc + ro
79
Hartley oscillator
When X1 and X2 are inductors and X3 is capacitor, we have the Hartley oscillator.
In this case, we have
From X1 + X 2 + X 3 = 0
Ri
wo =
Ro
Avi
1
C3 ( L1 + L2 )
vi
+
C3
L1
L2
80