!

, #

19 1924

6
>= < :

#
2013
 :

TROTSKYISM OR LENINISM?
Speech Delivered at the Plenum of the Communist Group in
the A.U.C.C.T.U. , November 19, 1924
J. Stalin: Works , vol. 6, p. 338-373.
Foreign Languages Publishing House
Moscow, 1953
| 1924 6| ~}

. # }
= #
6
:
.1 < | <
} - # }

> . |
.
.2 } # - - 1924
| 6
. =
# > |
| .
6 |
|
<
.
| .3 #
> -
< ~} <
- 6 | #
< # || <
 < || > |
.

.4
.
> = 6
| 6 6
#
| ~} # 6.

4
 >

# |
. |

}

: 23 101 . 1918

| } . =

6 <
| 6 .
| | ~}
| 6.

 #$ % " !
< .
< .1917 10
<
.
} :
. .

. =
. . 6
< 6
| .
6 | 6
| .
% .
) .
. 6 #
6 # )+ = 6= .
, #
6.
10< .1917 :
%
| |~| 6 =
 .
. .
10 .2 10 2
.
% | .
| |~| 6

.
.
~
.

< .
| -} | -
| ? . 6
.
< 1917 } 6
| } | . ?

.
> . = ~
| > # =
~
.

#
| :
.
8
 .

} | ~} |.
= ? 6 < .
.6 6 |
6 | 6

I I ~}
6 .
.
| 6 # | >
= = : ~
| = }| K
. <
|| M .
< 16< . :
#
# .
| 6 .
. 20 - 2 .2
6= #
. :
| P .

9
 6 . 6=
| 6 #| |
~ |
!
= 6 |
M } } . =
} .
.
6
6 = = .
.
< = + . +
.
| 6 ~ | + ~
. T > .
.
| 6
< 6 <
~ . ~
= ~ W . }

=
. ~
.
=
10
 . | | ~
.
= ~ ~ W <
} <-
.
6 < 6 I
~ <-
.

} < ~

|
.
6 > ~ ) <
| 6 .
| | . |
}
< .

.
+ | . 6
<- M
# }
| <.

11
 )*+('&
? | 6 b < .
<
> | =
| 6 < .
6
~
= ...
6 ~
.
- < :
8 6F )*,-E: 4 J 234 / 01.
:

( |
( 6= )
(
(
( | )
( >
(
( .


| i
} i
 } .
> | T
1
. <
. -
k
. #
# | |
| .
)
}
|
.
.
~ # . +
|

>
| . 6
|

: | | 1
|( . |
| ) P
- 7 1917 - |
# .
=

| .


1917 |
.

13
 } | .
|
M . =
}
) . | = 6
(
.
.
% } 2 .
} -
.
}
.
6
+ 6 }
| .
} .

# . -
< >
. = |
.

2 % 14 22 1917 57} .#
| = } . .
= - .
14
| =| 6 =
) (1917 ) (
.
| 6 =
6 .
6 . 6
| | .
= .
= ~}
6 . } 6
| | |
6 | | .
| 6 |
| #
6 =| *
| 6 *

x | ~ .

|| # . |
> | 6
)
i
. = | .
T > |
= = .
i
15
 | T |
} 6 . :

- : 1919|
. 6
) ( 6
|
|
.
6
~ ~ <
~ .
) (
?

| . 6
~
6 <} .}
6
|.
-T : 1919 T >{
T = }
. 6 %
.
6
6 . 6

. 6
} | = .
= .
16
 -? 6 >=< JC 6F &@ AB- 8ED
:

( | |
~
(
(
( ~
(

( =
| | | <
( ?
|
(
| =.
=
| .
?
.
~
#
. | .
.

= 6
17
 # |
.

6
#
= |
| ~ . = | 6 - <
#
. =
- 9
b .
6 9
#
% ) : (.
? | 6

. =
| , |
. 6
= }
| }

?
# |
| ~ | . =

} . )

18
 b
6
.
| 6
? | .
b 66 . .
6 .
6 < .
6 .

. |
|
6 .
= ~ }
. =

?= }
< .
6# .
=
.

| . = 6 %
| T # | . =
|
| . }
} |

19
 .
} .
6
} }

.
E -? 6! " 1
:
( > ? |
( |
( | 3 | ?
| #
( |

|
( | > | }

24 26< 1917 | 3 |
. }
. 94 51| .
|
| |
> .

| # > |
.

20
 ( ? |
| ( |
| |.
>{
|.
#
# <
. |
>

| }

. |
} || |
. |

> |

.
| >
< . >
6
| |.

. } }
# : b |
- .
6 <
.
21
 b
.
b ~
| . b
b ?
, I|
| .
b.
b
| 6 >
= | } > .

b .
|
.
6 |
| > b .
= } 6 . |
= )6 (
b )} =( .
6
. 6

# | <.
)6 : 71 ( .}
6 6 < .
| <

22
} #
| ~ . 6


= 6
- . %
10<= %
15< ) ( . 6
- 15< 6
- 25< .
= 10 16<.
10< :
)
#

( )
- (
|
)#
) |
( ? .
?
}
) | | |
.

23
 P % 16<
:
,
?



< |
.
6.
# 6
25< #
|
25< . .
# 25< :
. =
. | |
- ) 25<(

.
| I|
)6 } | !(

# # .
- .

25<.

24
 %
| .~ # |

| .
| . 6

|
. | .

25

6 <

. = 6
<
| #
= | 6
} ~ #
< . > 6
< - <
# <

| < . <
T . = .
~} .
|
|
| | |
~} !
| ~} :
.| > > #
. >

26
 |
# . %
. ~} } 1905

|.
6 ~}
)6 .(1905 = 6 ~}
> ~} >

| . 6
:
~}

! )6 25 | .(1913
6 .
.|
T . | |
T ,
#T
. # -
| 6 6 ~
#|. ) >( |

. P ~}
P |
|| .
6 .

27
 .| | .
#| | ~}

. 6
) .
6 |
<

| . =
6 } .
} .#

>
| . 6
# #| = 6 |
|
) (
. P
6 ) = .
| 6 = } < ~}
6 ~} .

6 < < .
| ~ - |
#|
. |
. ~}
28
 | .
| = }.
|
.1 > . 6 6 >
> 6 <
> ) I| :~ ~} ?
< ~}
? . ~} }:
~} ~} |
.
~} ~
1903 I
. :
| M } .1903
M |
}
) .:
~
(.

. | ~}
~} 6 ~} .

.

29
 . | . |
)( |
. | T
6 | #
.
| : | -
< . <
| < .

| .

.
.| | . |
|

} | .
| .
}
| . =
? 6 = 6 .
. )

| 6
) 104 ( .

30
 . 6 <

||
| b

? 6 K . }
= >=

.
, ~ 6:
6
, ~ :
~
: , ~

.
< ! : ?
)6 :
(.
, 6
6:
M :
.
- : } } #.
- :
<
< = - :
.
31
 , 6) . : (.
| 6 .
=
| 6 | = : =
.

=
| > T|.
6 = T <
# | .
|.
6


| .
= P | = | |
6
.
>
:
| 6
| |
. | | . #
. #
#
| .
32
 T |
~} .
.
:

.2013/1/2 3960

33