Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of Teaching andContemporaryApproaches
Introduction
In the earlier three units you were acquainted with how we learn, tlie various approaches
to learning and some of the strategies to optimize learning. In the current unit, different
models of teaching are being discussed. We have cast each model as a way of teaching
students do learn facts, concepts, skills, analysis of values and also to enable them to use
the strategies suggested by each model and develop particular ways of thinking. This is a
way of helping students to expand their styles of approaching problems i n the present and
in the future.
Learning outcomes
After working through this unit you will be able to :
understand the concept of models of teaching;
know the different models of teaching;
examine the applicability of tlie different models ofteaching;
a identify the various contemporary strategies used in tlie teaching - learning process.
Improved concept
building strategies
Formation of
specific concepts
--- Formation of
inductive concepts
Development of
alternative perspectives
Selfdassessment
2. In your own subject area, think of how you could of use this rnodel in different
areas to achieve one or more of the learning gains fro111 this tnodel.
/-4
Scientific process
Spirit of creativity
training
Independence and
Autonomy in learning
Tolerance of ambiguity
II Tentative nature of
knowledge I
Figure 2 Features of the inquiry training model
Strategising Teaching and
Self-assessment Learning : hlodels of Teaching
& Contemporary Approaches
3. Develop a resource bunk of puzzling situations and tasks which your students
would enjoy solving through this model. Your frame of reference niay be
your academic subject and social issues.
Self-assessmen t
3. Develop some concept hierarchies in your subject area and transact your
class through the procedure suggested by this model.
r Models of intelle~tualDvelopment
i
I
Models, based on studies of student's intellectual development (Kohlberg, 1976; Piaget,
1952; Sigel, 1969; and Sullivan, 1967), are used to help us adjust instruction to the
I
I
stage of maturity of an individual student and to design ways of increasing the student's
I
rate of development. The long term goal of sucli models is to teach students to think
I
effectively. Tliey rest on the assumption that matching curriculum to the students' stage
I
I of develop~nentand appropriately organized instruction can accelerate intellectual
development. Piaget, a major proponent of this approach, maintains that human beings
I develop increasingly complex levels of thinking in definite stages. Each stage is
I
cliaracterized by the possession of certain concepts or intellectual structures called
schemes. An individual uses these schemes as he interacts with the environment. While
interacting, new experiences are i~icorporatedinto the present patterns of behavior which
Piaget called as tlie process of assimilation. When the cognitive structure is changed,
to fit the new experience that occurs, it is termed as the process of accommodation.
Constantly, through tlie process ofacco~nmodationand assimilation, cognitive activities
are undertaken as per one's developmental progress.
Alternatively, this model suggests tlie idea ofoptimal mismatch i.e. by pitching instruction
slightly above tlie current level ofthe students, enabling them to push tlieir way towards
I
the next stages; an idea originally put forth by Vygotsky's zone of proximal development.
Towards Understanding
the Processes o f Teaching
Research llas indicated that tliis model is particularly useful for young adults and
and Learning i n H i g h e r specially for cliildren from socially, emotionally and econo~nicallydisadvantaged
Education backgrounds.
Self-assessment
5. Think of all the sttldeiits you know who huve problems with learning. Using
this niodc.1, develop strategies to reach out to them.
New clioice
Integration
Self
initiated
Independence
New orielitation
Confidende
Figure 3 Phases of personal growth in the non-directive process
Strategising Teaching a n d
When this approacli is utilised in classroo~nteaching, it leads to a number of benefits for Learning : Models of
the learner and requires that tlie teacher becomes a facilitator and not a director of & Contemporary Approaches
students' learning. This may be presented diagrammatically as follows:
Non-directive
.
-
Enhances personal awareness
Self-assessment
6. List out the characteristics of a non-directive teacher, based on the
understanding which you have derived.
7. Draw up a proJi:le of classroonz where the non-directive approach is being
followed.
The term direct instruction has been used by researchers, to refer to a pattern ofteaching,
which consists of tlie teacher explaining a new concept or skill, to a large group of
students, liaving them test their understanding by practicing under liis/lier direction
(controlled practice) and encouraging them to participate in their own seats under his/
her guidance (guided practice). Because tlie model is highly structured and teacher-
directed, it can flourish only in an environment which supports atraditional educational
approacli wherein tlie teaclier is in control and shapes the learning of liis/lier students.
The model is, as tlie name suggests, direct. It approaches academic content, systematically.
Its design is sliaped to generate and sustain motivation through pacing and reinforcement.
Through success and positive feedback it tries to enlia~iceone's self esteeni. As a model,
it is highly structured. 'TIie role of tlie teacher, according to this model is to provide tlie
knowledge of results, lielp students pace tliemselves and reinforce desirable
behaviors.
Tlie direct instruction model plays a limited, but ~ievertlielessimportant role in a
co~npreliensiveeducational programme. Researcli on direct instruction indicates that tliis
approach is effective in pro~notingstudent lear~iingin reading and math, especially for
students from lower socio-economic backgrounds.
Figure 5 presents tlie learning gains to students from tlie direct instruction model.
Towards Understanding
the Processes of Teaching
and Learning i n Higher b Mastery of academic skills and content
Education
b Student motivation
actually needs them, to establish the new behavior. Studying, exercising, playing the piano
and assertive social behavior are some such examples. Consequently, it is important that
the person has ways of rewarding liimself or herself in order to monitor and regulate his
behavior, so as to eliminate undesirable or maladaptive behaviors.
The structure of such models is moderate to low. Altliougli the instructor is important in
initiating the possibility ofthe program, the student ultimately has co~itrolover tlie situation
and maintenance of activities, many of which are carried out witlioi~tthe supervision of
the teacher.
This model not only targets maladaptive beliaviors by eliminating them, but also lias powerful
nurturant effects. It teaches individuals that they can control their environments and
tl~emselvesand this enhances self-esteem. It also encourages people who perceive the
world from a behavioral point of view, to note the stimulus and reinforcements, in their
interactions with people and tliings.
'The advantages which accrue to the learner from this model, are presented in Box 8.
Awareness of environment
Sense of control over oneself
and environment
Self control b Increased self esteem and
confidence
Increase i n desirable behaviors
Decrease in undesirable behaviors
Self-assessment
8. Evaluate the three behaviouristic n~odelswhich you have read. Which arilong
these do you think is the ntost desirable for college ~ ~ O S S ~ - O Oand
~ I S~ ~ h y ?
Let us now try to co~isolidateall tlie models ofteaching, which you have been exposed to,
into a comprehensive sumniary figure :
Approach Salient features Teacher's role Outcomes
Infon~iation To teach students To organize Development
processing the skills of learning and convey of higher
approach through thinking. information as order
lneaningfullyand cognitive
effectively as skills like
To increase students' possible. reasoning,
ability to seek and master induction,
information, organize it, concept
build it, test hypotheses Teacher could fonliation
and apply tliis learning in use methods like
their exploration of self I demonstrations, Development
and the world around I lecturers, ' of alternative
them. 1 readings etc. 1 perspectives,
Towards Ilnderstanding
independence
t l ~ cProcesses of Teaching
and Learning i n lligher and ailtono~ny
Education in learning.
Personal All individuals are To be a The students
models of essentially capable facilitator are able to
teaching of making their own develop
decisions / dealing personal
constructively with To create an awareness.
their life. atmosphere of
empathetic
com~nunication, Resi~ltsin
People are only understanding and affective
temporarily deflected regard in tlie growth and self
fro111their path. classroo~n development
People are full of The teacher Realization of
pote~itialand are allows the student one's potential
innately driven to to grow at his own wliich is
realize this potential pace and respects reflected in a
his iiidividuality. variety of
social and
academic
goals
Behavioristic All behavior is To use Development
models of observable, reinforce~ne~it of desirable and
teachi~~g identifiable and judiciously to adaptive
contingent delete behavior
upon undesirable
the variables in the behaviors and
environment; can sustain Development
be modified through desirable of self
learning principles. behaviors. management
skills
To develop new
skills and beliavior
In learning, using
tecli~iiquesof
beliavior modification
Self-assessment
9. Try to visuali,-e various IVUJ).Y in n~hichyou ctrn coiiihille t/ifc>r.erit111otl'c.l.s
of
teaching to create a better Ieur.riing enviro~i~iient ill voz~rclusc.r.oorir
10. Do you thirik the speclfifi'cgoals of' tetrchirlg in u pal-tictrlar clclss should
deterniirie yolrr choice of' rilociel, or. ~lioz/1cIchoice of riiorlel o'ererririlie the
gouls of teaching?
Participants are given a slip of paper and a felt pen and are asked to write one idea
related to tliat topic per slip. Tliey can generate as many ideas as they wish. At tlie end
of the allocated time, all tlie ideas so generated are collected and discussed. Tliis method
assures confidentiality to tlie participants and also ensures maximum involven~entof the
group. The teacher functions as a facilitator and helps to present all the ideas and views
in a perspective.
Role play
It involves tlie enactment of an identified tlierne. It is an excellent technique for expanding
participants' awareness and showing them alternative behaviors. At its simplest level,
role playing is dealing with problems through action. A problem is identified, acted out
and discussed. Tlie essence of role playing is tlie involvement of participants and observers
in a real problem situation and the desire for resolutio~iand understanding that tliis
involvement engenders. It allows tlie learners to :
explore their feelings
gain insight into their attitudes, values, perceptio~is
develop tlieir problem solvingskiIIs
explore subject matter in various ways.
'rhe teacher must engage tlie class in a ~neaningfulfollow-up discussion after the role -
play to ensure tliat learning has taken place.
Case vignettes
These are brief case exemplars of persons, events or situations which tlie teaclier wants
a particular group of students to analyse or discuss. They are very ilsefill in tapping
students' analytical, reflective and problem solving skills. Tliey motivate learners greatly,
lead to a variety of insights being developed and lend tliemselves to group work very
well. Because tliey involve inductive processes, tliey usually lead to better for~natioliof
ideas and concepts.
Focus group tasks
Originally known as the 'focus group interview technique', it aims to gather inforination
fiom a number of persons their perceptions, ideas, opinions, beliefs etc. on different
topics and issues. Tlie assumptio~ibehind this type of approacli is that in a group, people
tell more or give a deeper understanding of what they think or feel about a specific topic.
It is also a non-threatening situation.
Towards Understnndillg Focus group tasks are usefill in building up collective insights and arriving at a common
the Processes o f Teaching
and L e a r n i n -g i n H i g h e r
shared understanding
Education
7-10 voluntary members who participate.
Group members share a commonality.
The data generated are qualitative
The moderator steers the discussion, probes selectively
and maintains the focus of the discussion.
Summury
In this unit, various models of teaching have been discussed ranging from infor~iiation
processing, personal models and behavioral to the more contemporary approaches to
teaching in tlie classrooni. It niust be remembered, that a model ofteaching is not a fixed
~ ~ r ~ i ~ ~ i n ~ , o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i
or uncliangeable teacliing formula which is unresponsive to the learni~igstyles of students. 8, c~~~~~~~~~~~
A~~~~~~~~~~
On tlie contrary, ~nodelsof teaching offer broad paradigriis which interact with individual
styles of learning to enhance tlie comfort and effectiveness of learning.
Suggested readings
Eggen Paul and Kauchak Don (1999) Educatiotial Psychology, New Jersey: Prentice
Hall.
Hamaclieck Don ( 1990) Psychology of Teaching, Learning and Growth, Boston :
Ally11and Bacon.
Joyce, B. and Weil, M. (1996) Models of Teaching, Boston: Ally11and Bacon.
Woolfol k, Anita (200 1) Educational Psychology, Boston: A l lyn and Bacon.