Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION

PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
JOLO MUNICIPAL POLICE STATION
Marina St., Jolo, Sulu

MEMORANDUM

FOR : Provincial Director

Isabela Police Provincial Office
Baligatan,Ilagan,Isabela
(Attn: Invest Branch)

FROM : Chief Of Police

SUBJECT : Spot Report on Shooting Incident

DATE : NOVEMBER 6, 2015

1. Reference Blotter Entry No. 11-009 dated November 6 2015.

2. Please be informed that on or about 9:30 pm of this date that a shooting incident
transpired at the Barangay Hall of Minante 1 Cauayan City Isabela where in the victim was
identified as Roger Palma y Recto,35 years old, married, tricycle driver and a resident of
Minante 2 Cauayan City Isabela, while the at suspect was identified as SPO2 MANUEL REYES
Y PEDRO, 31 years old, married, presently assigned at La Union Police Station and a resident
of Minante 1 Cauayan City Isabela.

3. Investigation conducted disclosed that on the said date,SPO2 MANUEL REYES

Y PEDRO went to the house of ROGER PALMA to advice to stop that the loud music of videoke
but Palma and his companion did not pay attention that resulted to misunderstanding wherein
SPO2 Reyes said this statement “ Kapag di kayo titigil, babarilin ko kayo”. Therefore Roger
Palma said that he will report to the barangay but SPO2 Reyes said “ hindi ako natatakot sa
barangay! Magreklamo kayo!” Thus, Roger Palma went to the barangay hall to ask for
assistance without knowing that SPO2 Reyes followed him ultered these word to quote against
the victim “PAPATAYIN KITA WALA YAKA!” and shot Roger Palma in his head that caused his
instant death. The suspect was arrested and recovered from his direct possession and control is
one (1) 9mm beretta pistol with serial number ABC 12345 and one (1) magazine loaded with 12
live ammos and immediately brought to the police station for inquest proceeding.

4. For information.

MANWIN G VENEZUELA
Police Senior Inspector
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES.)
PROVINCE OF ISABELA………….) S.S
CITY OF CAUAYAN………………..)

AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS

I, NESTOR B ANDRES, 35 years old, married, barangay kagawad and presently

residing at Minante 1, Cauayan City Isabela after having been duly sworn to in accordance with
the law, do hereby deposes and state:

That on November 6, 2015 at about 9:30 in the afternoon while conducted my duty on
our Barangay Hall I saw the victim Roger R y Palma together with the suspect Spo2 Manuel
Reyes y pedro living with the conversation ultered these words to quote against the former
PAPATAYIN KITA WALANG YAKA!.

Thereat I saw the victim shot by the said suspect and sustained gun shot wound on his
head and was rushed to Cauayan Specialist Hospital but pronounced dead on arrival by Dr.
Tomas Nicolas III attending physician.

That I executed this affidavit/statement to attest the veracity of aforementioned facts and
to support file charge/s in court against the suspect.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto affixed my signature this 6th day of November
2015 at Cauayan City Isabela.

_______________________
Nestor B Andres

SUBCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me this 6th day of November 2015 at Cauayan City,
Isabela.

Administering Officer
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
Civil Security Group
Firearms and Explosives Office
Camp Crame, Quezon City

Control No.1019-11212-036
MEMORANDUM

FOR : PCINSP MANWIN G VENEZUELA

Chief of Police
Cauayan Police Station
Cauayan City, Isabela

FROM : C, FEO

SUBJECT : Firearm Records Verification Report

DATE : NOVEMBER 06, 2015

1. Reference : Memo from that office November 06, 2015 with subject same as above.

2. ICOW the above reference, be informed that per verification from records of this
office, one (1) SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro of Barangay Minante 1, Cauayan City, Isabela is a
licensed/registered firearm holder of caliber 9mm beretta pistol with serial number ABC 12345
as of this date.

3. Further be informed that as of this date, caliber 9mm beretta pistol with serial
number ABC 12345 is a licensed/registered firearm per verification from records of this office.

4. For information.

FOR THE CHIEF, FEO:

ARNOLD CANADA VILLANUEVA

Police Senior Inspector
Asst. Chief, Records Section, FLD
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL PROSECUTION SERVICE
OFFICE OF THE PROVINCIAL PROSECUTOR
Cauayan City, Isabela

People of the Philippines Criminal Case Nr__________

Plaintiff

-versus- For:

Manuel Reyes y Pedro, resident

Of Brgy. Minante 1, Cauayan City, Isabela MURDER
Accused
x----------------------------------------------------x

CRIMINAL COMPLAINT

The undersigned Chief of Police of Cauayan Police Station, Cauayan Isabela, under
oath, accuse Manuel Reyes y Pedro of the crime of MURDER, defined and penalized under
article 248 of the Revised Penal Codde, committed as follows;

“That on November 6, 2015 at about 9:30 in the evening, a cell phone call
received by personnel of Cauayan Police Station from Brgy. Kagawad Nestor B. Andres
of Minante 1, Cauayan City that SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro, 31 years old, married,
presently assigned at La Union Police Station and a resident of Brgy. Minante 1,
Cauayan City shot Roger R. Palma in his head that caused his instant death with the
used of calibre 9mm at the barangay hall of the said place. Upon receipt of the report,
team led by the COP proceeded at the said place and upon arrival thereat, said team
together with the said Brgy. Kagawad saw SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro in the Barangay
hall and arrested him. Recovered from his direct possession and control is one (1) 9mm
Beretta pistol with serial number ABC 12345 and one (1) magazine loaded with 12 live
ammos. Said suspect together with the recovered items was brought at Cauayan City
Police Station.”

CONTRARY TO LAW
Cauayan City, Isabela, November 6, 2015

MANWIN G. VENEZUELA
Police Chief Inspector
Chief of Police

EXHIBITS:
“A”- Picture of one (1) calibre 9mm beretta with serial number ABC 12345 and one (1)
magazine loaded with 12 live ammos.

WITNESS:

1. PO1 Bobby Agustin – Cauayan City Police Stattion, Cauayan City, Isabela
2. PO1 Charlton Estabillo Jay - -do-
3. Brgy. Kagawad Nestor B. Andres – Brgy. Minante 1, Cauayan City, Isabela

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this 7th day of November 2015 at Cauayan City,
Isabela, Philippines. And that I hereby certify that I have personally examined the herein affiant;
that I am fully convinced that he voluntarily executed and understood their criminal complaint.
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES.)
PROVINCE OF ISABELA………….) S.S
CITY OF CAUAYAN………………..)

JOINT AFFIDAVIT OF ARREST

We PO1 AGUSTIN BOBBY, PO1 CAPOQUIAN JERON AND PO1 ESTAVILLO

CHARLTON JAY, legal ages and presently assigned at Cauayan Police Station Isabela after
having been duly sworn to in accordance with the law, do hereby deposed and state the
following:

1. That on or about 9:30 PM of November 06, 2015 a cell phone call received by
personnel of Cauayan Police Station from Brgy. Kagawad Nestor B. Andres of Minante 1,
Cauayan City that SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro, 31 years old, married, presently assigned at
La Union Police Station and a resident of Brgy. Minante 1, Cauayan City shot Roger R. Palma
in his head that caused his instant death with the used of calibre 9mm at the barangay hall of
the said place. Upon receipt of the report, team led by the COP proceeded at the said place and
upon arrival thereat, said team together with the said Brgy. Kagawad saw SPO2 Manuel Reyes
y Pedro in the Barangay hall and arrested him. Recovered from his direct possession and
control is one (1) 9mm Beretta pistol with serial number ABC 12345 and one (1) magazine
loaded with 12 live ammos.

2. That we (PO1 Bobby Agustin, PO1 Jeron Capoquian and PO1 Charlton Jay
Estavillo) immediately arrested the suspect and thereafter informed him of his constitutional
rights in language and dialect known by him in the presence of Barangay Elected Officials.

3. That we brought the suspect to the Police Station for further investigation and
proper disposition;

4. That we are executing this affidavit/statement to attest the veracity of the

aforementioned facts and to support the filing of appropriate charge/s in Court against the
arrested person.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, We hereby affixed our signatures this ____ day of November
2015 at Cauayan City, Isabela.

PO1 BOBBY AGUSTIN PO1 JERON CAPOQUIAN PO1 CHARLTON JAY ESTAVILLO
Affiant Affiant Affiant

SUBCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this _day of November 2015 at Cauayan City, Isabela

MANWIN G VENEZUELA
Police Senior Inspector
Chief of Police

CERTIFICATION

THIS IS TO CERTIFY that I have personally examined the affiants and I am fully satisfied and
convinced that they voluntarily executed the foregoing affidavit and understood the contents
thereof.

MANWIN G VENEZUELA
Police Senior Inspector
Chief of Police
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
ISABELA POLICE PROVINCIAL OFFICE
CAUAYAN CITY POLICE STATION
CAUAYAN CITY, ISABELA

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Chief and Explosive Office

Camp Crame, Quezon City
(Attn: C, Records Section, FLD

FROM : COMPAC Commander

SUBJECT : Firearms Verification Request for

DATE : NOVEMBER 07, 2015

1. Reference : Spot report dated______________

2. Request conducts verification to the person SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro, 31

years old, married, presently assigned at La union PS and a resident of barangay Minante 1,
Cauayan City, Isabela whether the person is firearm license holder or of any kind of firearms in
your office after confiscated from his direct possession and control one (1) 9mm caliber pistol
beretta with serial number ABC 12345 and one (1) magazine loaded with 12 lives Ammos. and
likewise to determine the identity of the registered owner.

3. Further request furnish this office a copy of the result of your verification.

Thank you for your usual cooperation on this matter.

FOR THE CHIEF OF POLICE

MANWIN G. VENEZUELA
Police Senior Inspector
 Republic of the Philippines
Province of Isabela
Cauayan Specialist Hospital
San Fermin, Cauayan City Isabela
Tel. No. (078) 642-7650
PHILHEALTH ACCREDITED

MEDICAL CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that SPO2 MANUEL REYES y PEDRO, 31 years old, male,
Name of Patient Age Sex

married with stated residence of Minante 1, Cauayan City, Isabela

Marital Status Complete Address

was examined and treated in this hospital as OUT PATIENT on

November 06, 2015 with the following impressions/diagnosis/findings:

Date of Examination/treatment

Physically and mentally fit

This certification is issued upon request of the interested party for whatsoever
legal and legitimate purpose/s it may serve him/her

Given this 6th day of November 2015 at Cauayan Specialist Hospital, Cauayan
City, Isabela Philippines.

IZA C. TABAO, MD
Medical Officer III
License No. : 0123456
 POLICE BLOTTER

On or about 9:30 PM of November 06, 2015 a cellphone call received by this

Police Station from Barangay Kagawad Nestor B Andres and reported that a
shooting incident transpired at the Barangay Hall of Minante 1, Cauayan City
Isabela. Upon receipt of the report, the team led by COP Venezuela proceeded
at the said place and upon arrival thereat, said team together with the said
Barangay kagawad saw the victim lying with his blood identified as Roger Palma
y Recto, 35 years old, married, tricycle driver and a resident of Minante 1,
Cauayan City, Isabela while the suspect identified as SPO2 Manuel Reyes y
Pedro, 31 years old, married, presently assigned at La union Police Station and a
resident of Barangay Minante 1, Cauayan City Isabela. Initial investigation
disclosed/conducted that SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro went to the house of
Roger Palma y Recto to advice to stop the loud music of videoke but Palma and
his companion did not pay attention that resulted to a misunderstanding wherein
SPO2 Reyes said the statement “kapag di kayo tumigil, babarilin ko kayo”
therefore Roger Palma said that he will report to the barangay but SPO2 Reyes
said this statement “ hindi ako natatakot! Magreklamo kayo! Walang barangay
barangay sa akin!” thus, Roger Palma went to barangay hall without knowing that
SPO2 Reyes followed him and shot Roger Palma in his head that caused his
instant death. SPO2 Reyes were arrested and recovered from his direct
possession and control is one (1) magazine loaded with 12 live ammos. The
suspect was arrested and brought at Cauayan Police Station together with the
recovered items for proper disposition.
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
Philippine National Police
Isabela Police Provincial Office
CAUAYAN CITY POLICE STATION
Cauayan City, Isabela

November 6, 2015

The Honorable City Prosecutor

National Prosecution Service
City Prosecution Office
Cauayan City Isabela

Sir,
I have the Honor to send to your good office the attached records of invesgation for a
case of MURDER wherein the victim was one Roger Palma y Recto, 35 years old married,
tricycle driver and a resident of Minante 1, Cauayan City, Isabela. The suspects were:

SPO2 MANUEL REYES y PEDRO, 31 years old, married, presently assigned at La

Union Police Station and a resident of Brgy. Minante 1, Cauayan City, Isabela (under arrest).

(ATLARGED)

ATTACHMENTS/ENCLOSURES:

1. Sworn Statement of Complaint

2. Sworn Statement of Witness
3. Affidavit of Arrest
4. Documentary Evidence:
a) Spot Report
b) Death Certificate and Autopsy/Necropsy Report of Victim
c) Copies of Photographs and Sketch of the Crime Scene;
d) Copies of Photographs of the Victim;
e) Copies of Photographs of the Pieces of Evidence Recovered and Seized; and

FACTS OF THE CASE:

On or about 9:30 PM of November 6, 2015, a cell phone call received by personnel of
Cauayan City Police Station from Brgy. Kagawad Nestor B. Andres of Minante 1, Cauayan City
that SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro, 31 years old, married, presently assigned at La UniBon
Police Station and a resident of Brgy. Minante 1, Cauayan City shot Roger R. Palma in his
head that cause his instant death with the used of caliber 9mm at the Barangay hall of said
place. Upon receipt of the report, team led by the COP proceeded at said place and upon arrival
thereat, said team together with the said Brgy. Kagawad saw SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro in
the Brgy. Hall and arrested him. Recovered from his direct possession and control is one (1)
9mm beretta Pistol with Serial Number ABC 12345 and one (1) magazine loaded with 12 live
ammos. Said suspect together with the recovered items was brought at Cauayan City Police
Station.

On account of the foregoing, a case of MURDER is being referred against the suspect
for proper disposition. Further, your advice/recommendation on the matter shall be highly
appreciated.

Very truly yours,

MANWIN G. VENEZUELA
Police Chief Inspector
Chief of Police
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
Philippine National Police
Isabela Police Provincial Office
CAUAYAN CITY POLICE STATION
Cauayan City, Isabela

CYNIDMS

MEMORANDUM

FOR : THE CHIEF

Rural Health Unit
Cauayan City

FROM : Chief of Police

SUBJECT : Request of Police

DATE : November 7, 2015

1. Request conduct autopsy examination to the cadaver of Roger Palma y

Recto, 35 years old, married, tricycle driver and a resident of Minante 1 Cauayan City Isabela
who was shot to death by SPO2 Manuel Reyes y Pedro. The cadaver was moved at Saint Peter
Funeral home at San Fermin Cauayan City Isabela.

2. In this regard, the undersigned would like to request to your good office
the aforesaid case for proper disposition.

3. Your usual cooperation and prompt action regarding this matter is very
much appreciated.

4. Further request acknowledge.

ANGELIE T. VILLAGANTOL
Police Superintendent
 Republic of the Philippines
Province of Isabela
CITY OF CAUAYAN

City Health Office

POST MORTEM EXAMINATION

November 8, 2015

NAME: ROGER PALMA Y RECTO, 35 years old, male, married

Address: Minante 2, Cauayan City Isabela
Date & Time of Examination: November 8, 2015 AM
Requesting Officer: ANGELIE T. VILLAGANTOL
Police Superintendent
PNP Cauayan City Isabela

Findings:

1. 1 cm X 1 cm gunshot wound, occipital area, left

2. No other significant findings noted.

FELIZA E. MORLA, M.D.

City Health Officer
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
CAUAYAN CITY POLICE STATION
Cauayan City, Isabela

CAUAYAN CITY
POLICE STATION
IPPO

Case Title: MURDER

Complainant/Victim: Roger Palma y Recto
Suspects: Manuel Reyes y Pedro
IS No: II-06-INVIZE-12345 Date:
Prosecutor: Prov./City:
CC No: Date:
Presiding Judge: Court: