NOTES

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
1 of 13

Page 1 of 13
 COMMENT SHEET
CLIENT : M/s HPCL, VIZAG EIL Job No. B016
PROJECT : VRMP : CPP (606) Transmittal No.
Document Name P&ID-REV-O CPP
Instrumentation
Review Code

S. COMMENT/ RESOLUTION/ ACTION EIL BHEL REPLY EIL BHEL REPLY

No. OBSERVATION by BHEL dated COMMENTS COMMENT dtd.20/9/19
09/05/18 dtd. 17/9/18

P&ID for HP Dosing

system(1-81-219-
U0007)
1. Chemical inlet line to Chemical is added Nil Point closed -- --
mixing tank to be manually. Hence,
shown. chemical inlet line is
not required.
2. Inter-connecting Complied in revised Connecting P&ID Shown in revised -- --
P&ID number drawing not still not P&ID
and line number indicated.
for DM water
inlet line to be
mentioned.
3. Designation of DM Complied in revised Nil Point closed -- --
water shall be drawing
WDM as per tender.
4. Line numbers for Complied in revised Repetition in line Corrected in -- --
chemical inlet lines to drawing no. i.e., c-8120 revised P&ID
pumps to be mentioned.
5. Designation of strainer Complied in revised Nil Point closed -- --
shall be “G” as per drawing
tender.
6. Refer Interlock table Complied Nil Point closed -- --
PAL shall be indicated
in tag number against I-
8102.
7. Refer Interlock table Complied Nil Point closed -- --
BHEL to mention
whether HP dosing
pump trip is given at
low level or low level
of metering tank. Tag
number to indicated
against I-8101
8. Pump start/stop Note-15 is modified Nil Point closed -- --
indication/push button suitably in the revised
in local/DCS drawing.

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
2 of 13

Page 2 of 13
 9. As per Cl. 5.v (b), Calibration pot shown Nil Point closed -- --
Calibration pot to be in revised drawing
provided as per tender.

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
3 of 13

Page 3 of 13
 COMMENT SHEET
CLIENT : M/s HPCL, VIZAG EIL Job No. B016
PROJECT : VRMP : CPP (606) Transmittal No.
Document Name P&ID-REV-O CPP
Instrumentation
Review Code

No. COMMENT/ RESOLUTION/ ACTION by EIL BHEL EIL BHEL

OBSERVATION BHEL dated 09/05/18 COMMENTS REPLY COMMENTS REPLY
dtd.17/9/18 dtd. 20/9/19

10. BHEL to Capacity of Mixing and Sizing criteria Sizing criteria Nil Point closed.
explain the metering tank is based on document to be is storage for
basis for 2% solution submitted. 12 hrs and 2%
capacity concentration as Na3 solution
concentration.
PO4.12H2O and 12
hours storage time.
111 All drains within All individual drains Refer comments Complied. Nil Point closed.
the skid shall be within the skid are from HPCL. Drain to OWS
collected within the disposed to storm water. Chemical drains is shown.
skid at single point shall be connected
to OWS
and disposed to
storm water
12 Tag number Corrected in revised Nil Point closed. -- --
(serial drawing
number) of
motor is
different from
that of pump.
BHEL to
check and
correct
Type of LG Indicated in
and LT shall revised
be indicated in P&ID, Rev.3
the P&ID

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
4 of 13

Page 4 of 13
 COMMENT S HEET
CLIENT : M/s HPCL, VIZAG EIL Job No. B016
PROJECT : VRMP : CPP (606) Transmittal No.
Document Name P&ID-REV-O CPP
Instrumentation
Review Code

S. COMMENT/ OBSERVATION RESOLUTION/ EIL BHEL REPLY EIL BHEL

No. ACTION by BHEL COMMENTS COMMENTS REPLY
dated 09/05/18 dtd.17/9/18 Dtd.20/9/19
Contractor to note the
following observation and
submit revised updated P&IDs.
Comments are typical indicated
for some Instruments, however,
contractor shall review similar
comments in other P&IDs and
update the same in all the
other applicable P&ID s .
1. Legend P&ID to be furnished EIL legend P&ID Noted. Point closed Noted --
including all symbols used in is followed
P&IDs.
2. Control valve sizes are Control valve Noted. AS built drawings Noted --
indicated as HOLD Same to sizes will be However with control valve
be finalized and indicate in finalized based revised P&ID sizes will be
P&IDs. on vendor data to be provided. provided.
and will be
shown
accordingly.
3. Safety valve sizes including Safety valve sizes Noted. AS built drawings Noted --
Set Pressure, inlet outlet pipe will be finalized However with control valve
rating and spec break are based on vendor revised P&ID sizes will be
indicated as HOLD. Same to data and will be to be provided. provided.
be finalized and indicate in shown
P&IDs. accordingly. Set
pressure, inlet&
outlet pipe rating
and spec break
are shown in
revised P&ID.
4. Instrument Tag nos. and Complied Noted. Point closed Noted --
equipment nos. shall start with
last two digit of the P&ID nos.
5. Vessel cladded/ uncladded to Complied Noted. Point closed Noted --
be ensured to meet nozzle
size requirement.
6. Proper representation to be Corrected in Noted. Point closed Noted --
indicated in the P&IDs for the revised P&ID
signals taken from DCS to

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
5 of 13

Page 5 of 13
 PLC and vice versa.

7. Gas detectors not indicated in As per BHEL Contractor Shown in relevant Noted Point
the P&ID. practice, HC response is not P&ID Closed.
analyzers will be acceptable. We
shown in the GA understand that
drawing and not in instead of HC
P&ID. analyzers , it’s
HC detector.
17. P&ID no. 1181(HP dosing Signals related to Contractor Complied in Noted Point
system): motors/drives response is not revised drawing. closed.
shall be as per acceptable. All
MCC signal, if any, shall be
Drive control control room
indicated in P&ID. philosophy. indication/com
(TYPICAL COMMENT) Hence, not mend shall be
shown separately shown with tag
in P&ID. no. in P&ID as
per BEDP-part-
B, section-9.

29. Contractor shall update the Complied Complied Noted

P&IDs keeping all the
above points and any other
points required as per tender
scope and specification.

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
6 of 13

Page 6 of 13
 attached

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
7 of 13

Page 7 of 13
 As commented earlier,
Interconnecting line number is to
be mentioned.

As commented earlier, applicable

interlock numbers to be mentioned
against pumps

As commented earlier, pump

discharge flow/pressure/
temperature (min/nor/max/des)
to be indicated.

NOTES

Type of LG/LT shall be as per tender.

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
8 of 13

Page 8 of 13
 COMMENT SHEET
CLIENT : M/s HPCL, VIZAG EIL Job No. B016
PROJECT : VRMP : CPP (606) Transmittal No.
Document Name P&ID-REV-O CPP
Instrumentation
Review Code

S. COMMENT/ RESOLUTION/ ACTION EIL BHEL REPLY EIL BHEL REPLY

No. OBSERVATION by BHEL dated COMMENTS COMMENT dtd.20/9/19
09/05/18 dtd. 17/9/18

P&ID for HP Dosing

system(1-81-219-
U0007)
1. Chemical inlet line to Chemical is added Nil Point closed -- --
mixing tank to be manually. Hence,
shown. chemical inlet line is
not required.
2. Inter-connecting Complied in revised Connecting P&ID Shown in revised -- --
P&ID number drawing not still not P&ID
and line number indicated.
for DM water
inlet line to be
mentioned.
3. Designation of DM Complied in revised Nil Point closed -- --
water shall be drawing
WDM as per tender.
4. Line numbers for Complied in revised Repetition in line Corrected in -- --
chemical inlet lines to drawing no. i.e., c-8120 revised P&ID
pumps to be mentioned.
5. Designation of strainer Complied in revised Nil Point closed -- --
shall be “G” as per drawing
tender.
6. Refer Interlock table Complied Nil Point closed -- --
PAL shall be indicated
in tag number against I-
8102.
7. Refer Interlock table Complied Nil Point closed -- --
BHEL to mention
whether HP dosing
pump trip is given at
low level or low level
of metering tank. Tag
number to indicated
against I-8101
8. Pump start/stop Note-15 is modified Nil Point closed -- --
indication/push button suitably in the revised
in local/DCS drawing.

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
9 of 13

Page 9 of 13
 9. As per Cl. 5.v (b), Calibration pot shown Nil Point closed -- --
Calibration pot to be in revised drawing
provided as per tender.

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
10 of 13

Page 10 of 13
 COMMENT SHEET
CLIENT : M/s HPCL, VIZAG EIL Job No. B016
PROJECT : VRMP : CPP (606) Transmittal No.
Document Name P&ID-REV-O CPP
Instrumentation
Review Code

No. COMMENT/ RESOLUTION/ ACTION by EIL BHEL EIL BHEL

OBSERVATION BHEL dated 09/05/18 COMMENTS REPLY COMMENTS REPLY
dtd.17/9/18 dtd. 20/9/19

10. BHEL to Capacity of Mixing and Sizing criteria Sizing criteria Nil Point closed.
explain the metering tank is based on document to be is storage for
basis for 2% solution submitted. 12 hrs and 2%
capacity concentration as Na3 solution
concentration.
PO4.12H2O and 12
hours storage time.
111 All drains within All individual drains Refer comments Complied. Nil Point closed.
the skid shall be within the skid are from HPCL. Drain to OWS
collected within the disposed to storm water. Chemical drains is shown.
skid at single point shall be connected
to OWS
and disposed to
storm water
12 Tag number Corrected in revised Nil Point closed. -- --
(serial drawing
number) of
motor is
different from
that of pump.
BHEL to
check and
correct
Type of LG Indicated in
and LT shall revised
be indicated in P&ID, Rev.3
the P&ID

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
11 of 13

Page 11 of 13
 COMMENT S HEET
CLIENT : M/s HPCL, VIZAG EIL Job No. B016
PROJECT : VRMP : CPP (606) Transmittal No.
Document Name P&ID-REV-O CPP
Instrumentation
Review Code

S. COMMENT/ OBSERVATION RESOLUTION/ EIL BHEL REPLY EIL BHEL

No. ACTION by BHEL COMMENTS COMMENTS REPLY
dated 09/05/18 dtd.17/9/18 Dtd.20/9/19
Contractor to note the
following observation and
submit revised updated P&IDs.
Comments are typical indicated
for some Instruments, however,
contractor shall review similar
comments in other P&IDs and
update the same in all the
other applicable P&ID s .
1. Legend P&ID to be furnished EIL legend P&ID Noted. Point closed Noted --
including all symbols used in is followed
P&IDs.
2. Control valve sizes are Control valve Noted. AS built drawings Noted --
indicated as HOLD Same to sizes will be However with control valve
be finalized and indicate in finalized based revised P&ID sizes will be
P&IDs. on vendor data to be provided. provided.
and will be
shown
accordingly.
3. Safety valve sizes including Safety valve sizes Noted. AS built drawings Noted --
Set Pressure, inlet outlet pipe will be finalized However with control valve
rating and spec break are based on vendor revised P&ID sizes will be
indicated as HOLD. Same to data and will be to be provided. provided.
be finalized and indicate in shown
P&IDs. accordingly. Set
pressure, inlet&
outlet pipe rating
and spec break
are shown in
revised P&ID.
4. Instrument Tag nos. and Complied Noted. Point closed Noted --
equipment nos. shall start with
last two digit of the P&ID nos.
5. Vessel cladded/ uncladded to Complied Noted. Point closed Noted --
be ensured to meet nozzle
size requirement.
6. Proper representation to be Corrected in Noted. Point closed Noted --
indicated in the P&IDs for the revised P&ID
signals taken from DCS to

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
12 of 13

Page 12 of 13
 PLC and vice versa.

7. Gas detectors not indicated in As per BHEL Contractor Shown in relevant Noted Point
the P&ID. practice, HC response is not P&ID Closed.
analyzers will be acceptable. We
shown in the GA understand that
drawing and not in instead of HC
P&ID. analyzers , it’s
HC detector.
17. P&ID no. 1181(HP dosing Signals related to Contractor Complied in Noted Point
system): motors/drives response is not revised drawing. closed.
shall be as per acceptable. All
MCC signal, if any, shall be
Drive control control room
indicated in P&ID. philosophy. indication/com
(TYPICAL COMMENT) Hence, not mend shall be
shown separately shown with tag
in P&ID. no. in P&ID as
per BEDP-part-
B, section-9.

29. Contractor shall update the Complied Complied Noted

P&IDs keeping all the
above points and any other
points required as per tender
scope and specification.

01-OCT-2019
SADHNA SINGH (8424)
13 of 13

Page 13 of 13