Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- Academic speaking
13.1. Introduction
The list above relies on language features that help measure communicative
competence from the linguistic point of view. Yet, we have to be cautious not to
assume only speech quality is sufficient for academic speaking. We are to add the
academic perspective into the speech analysis to help design focused material for
the students in our course.
Thus, considering the speaking situation can prove very effective in terms of
contextualizing students as to the whole picture in academic speaking training,
once in academics students have a purpose, something they are trying to
accomplish or set in motion.
In contextualizing, the audience and occasion of defending one's thesis play great
influence, however it is actually the purpose which can more successfully
contribute to effectiveness. For most speaking in academic contexts, there are two
general purposes: to inform or to persuade. The line between informing and
persuading is not absolute, and many speeches will do some of both. Nonetheless,
they are useful guides for speakers.
When a speaker seeks to inform, they want the audience to leave the speech
knowing more than they knew beforehand. Speakers may want to explain an idea
or process, share new information, or show how to do something.
When a speaker aims to persuade an audience, they want them to adopt a new
position or belief, to change their minds, or to be moved to action. Persuasion calls
a speaker to advocate one position among others that are possible and be willing
to defend it against challenges.
Graduate and postgraduate students are required to present more frequently and
in more advanced genres of presentations (such as seminars, forums, PhD
confirmation, conference papers, and academic posters) as part of the formal
communication of their research. This being so planning is your number one step;
you must examine what you want to achieve with your presentation, for example,
do you want to inform, persuade, inspire, or convince your audience?
The audience is also another important concern to take into account when
preparing your presentation. Thus, right from the start the presenter should
establish a positive environment, getting the audience's attention and signaling the
beginning. It is appropriate to greet them and to introduce yourself, as well as, to
give the title of your presentation and to introduce your subject.
You may want to give acknowledgements right at the beginning too. In case you
have been sponsored or even encouraged by a particular organization, professor,
collaborator, etc. saying their names and degree of involvement.
A good tip is to get your audience involved by asking direct or rhetorical questions,
for instance. You can also give an anecdote, unusual or surprising facts, or an
illustration from real life could be employed.
Think of the main objectives of your presentation. It is a nice idea to establish two
main objectives: a general and a specific objective. The general objective should
be to inform, to present an overview of a topic, discussing it or explaining its
present situation.
Whereas the specific objective should be focused on what you expect your
audience to understand and what you want them to remember.
Use features of discourse to give long and short turns of cohesion and coherence.
For example, speakers need to use referencing "This is the problem..." and
connectors, "Thus, ..."
There are several differences between speaking and writing, for example, writing
includes some medium which enables the recording of the message while
speaking involves only air. There are also other dissimilarities, though. Speaking
presupposes a greater flexibility, the speaker may say whatever suits him at the
moment, and the interaction speaking presupposes also grants it more spontaneity
which may result in mistakes, repetition, sometimes less coherent sentences
where even grunts, stutters or pauses might be meaningful.
On the other hand, academic writing and speaking have some similarities, both are
linear, explicit, have a central point and are presented in standard language. And
according to Andy Gillett (1989) "academic spoken style is also similar in many
ways in that it is formal, explicit, hedged, and responsible. However, it is less
complex and objective than written language."
13.1.3. Pronunciation
Being able to speak clearly is an important aspect of learning a second
language; it is also a cherished skill in the academics. It allows you to
successfully participate in discussions, to give presentations, as well as to
communicate your academic ideas.
Match the 8 features on the left to the ideas they mean on the right. Ten ideas are
given, use them all.
1. Formal
2. Explicit
3. Precision
4. Hedged
5. Responsible
6. Accuracy
7. Complex
8. Objective
Read the comments about this task in the virtual campus. The comments are
posted in the section "Evaluation".
Go to the TED - Ideas worth spreading - web page (www.ted.com) and search for
the most viewed talks. Choose one talk and after watching a video fill out the
speech assessment chart below.
YES? NO COMMENT
Rules of language?
Did the speaker choose the right vocabulary? x The vocabulary is very clear.
Did the speaker connect together what he/she In fact, She mentioned some
said and connect this with what other authors x writers such as Shakespeare to
said effectively? connect ideas with
Paralinguistic features
Did the speaker make use of their body Yes, She did. She used body
x
language to transmit their message? language to communicate
Communicative function
Social meaning
Read the comments about this task in the virtual campus. The comments are
posted in the section "Evaluation".
Graphs
Charts
Maps
Photos
Drawings images
Models
Video/film
Objects
Transparencies/slides
Power Point" slides
Video projection/projector
Handouts
1. On the TED video you've watched did the speaker use any visual prompt?
Which one(s)? Please, describe the resource(s).
2. Did the speaker use linking words, such as: and then, next, finally, etc? Which
other linking words did you hear on the talk? Can you think of more?
Read the comments about this task in the virtual campus. The comments are
posted in the section "Evaluation".
13.1.5. Organization
1. Tell your audience the purpose of your 7. Explain how the topic will be
presentation in one or two clear sentences. developed.
2. Introducing major point (s). Introduction 8. Leaving the audience with a strong
'take-home message'.
- Introduction: 1, 2, 6, 7
- Conclusion: 4, 8, 13
Read the comments about this task in the virtual campus. The comments are
posted in the section "Evaluation".
Starting in the mid 1980's some began to question many aspects of CLT, some
even started doubting its validity as an efficient methodology, claiming it leads to
early fossilization, while others assert that the problem with CLT is the
considerable reluctance of most teachers to give up traditional techniques in order
to really engage in the communicative methodology.
Despite all that CLT has left a legacy to teaching methodologies and continues to
be of great influence principally towards syllabus and curriculum design stating the
importance of aspects as communicative competence, meaning negotiation, and
learner-centeredness.
On the other hand teachers nowadays are more free to start questioning and
rethinking their choices as to curricula and courses they will bring to their
classrooms.
This text aims at introducing some basic concepts involved in curriculum and
course design.
Curriculum is the name given to any educational programme which states: a) the
objectives of the programme, its educational purpose; b) the means used to
achieve these ends, that is: the content, teaching procedures and learning
experiences which are necessary to achieve this purpose, c) the means used to
assess whether or not the educational ends have been achieved.
1. Linguistic factors.
4. Geographical aspects.
The Spanish Curricular Design is based on a set of principles that have been
adopted by the Spanish Autonomous Communities. Some of these are the
following (Madrid and McLaren 1995: pp. 18-20):
a) Language as communication
b) Communicative competence
The concept of proficiency underlying the general goals that we have stated is the
development of the student's communicative competence defined as a set of
subcompetences (see Canale 1983):
c) sociocultural competence,
d) discourse competence,
e) strategic competence,
The L1 is a resource of knowledge which learners will use both consciously and
subconsciously to help them sift the L2 data in the input and to perform as best as
they can in the L2. (Ellis 1986: p. 40)
The students are considered the centre of the teaching and learning processes.
Consequently, the communicative situations proposed must satisfy their needs and
interests and should be related to their personal experiences. Thus, connections
are established between what is taught and the linguistic and sociolinguistic
knowledge that the students already possess. This interconnection is believed to
favour the integration of the new elements in the student's cognitive network and
produce meaningful learning.
The previous goals also assume that students build up their own competence quite
autonomously and independently, not necessarily following the stages and steps
established by the FL syllabus. In this long process, it is vital to promote learning
strategies that help the students to learn how to learn, learn autonomously, control
and become responsible for their own learning.
Read the text above on Curriculum and Course Design then, reduce it from its
original contents (1060 words) to a summary of approximately 600 words. Write it
using as much of the original text as possible, as well as the tips mentioned in
section 1 of this course keep its academic style.
On the other hand teachers nowadays are more free to start questioning and rethinking their choices
as to curricula and courses they will bring to their classrooms. Curriculum is the name given to any
educational programme which states: a) the objectives of the programme, its educational purpose;
b) the means used to achieve these ends, that is: the content, teaching procedures and learning
experiences which are necessary to achieve this purpose, c) the means used to assess whether or not
the educational ends have been achieved. Syllabus is a more restricted concept and usually refers to
a description of the contents of a course of instruction and the order in which they are to be taught.
The Common European Framework for Languages (CEF) (2001) describes what learners have to
learn and the skills they have to develop to communicate effectively The Spanish Context The
Spanish Curricular Design is based on a set of principles that have been adopted by the Spanish
Autonomous Communities Language as communication Language is conceived as a dynamic
phenomenon, not simply as a system of forms structures and words, but basically as a system of
communicative acts and situations. Communicative competencThe concept of proficiency
underlying the general goals that we have stated is the development of the student's communicative
competence defined as a set of subcompetences The role of the L1The mother language is not
considered an obstacle to learning the foreign language that causes interference The importance of
contextualization and discourse Traditionally, the FL elements were frequently presented in
isolation, with little or no social context, in separate sentences which did not form a complete
discourse. The learner-centred curriculum The students are considered the centre of the teaching
and learning processes. The FL curriculum is thus concerned with the planning, implementation,
management, administration and evaluation of the foreign language programme, whereas the FL
syllabus has a narrower scope and focuses on the selection and grading (if any) of contents.
Read the comments about this task in the virtual campus. The comments are
posted in the section "Evaluation".
1. Match the concepts on the left with their definitions on the right:
Using your summary above about Curriculum and Course Design, complete the
sentences below using your own words.
Now that we've seen this let's turn to the second ________________________
Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen, let me introduce the main topic
I have chosen to speak about this because we can help others.
I will be glad to talk about this
Now let's think of the first aspect which is encourage students to participate in
English classes
Now that we've seen this let's turn to the second aspect: Strategies for working
inside the classroom.
What I try to bring out is useful strategies to implement in the classroom.
Another way of saying the same thing is: implementing useful tools for improving
the target language.
What is important to remember is help students to acquire the foreign language
Here I'd like to quote Gardners theory of multiple intelligence.
What I've tried to show so far different ways of improving the target language.
In conclusion I would like to say that our responsibility as teachers is to encourage
students to improve the target language.
Read the comments about this task in the virtual campus. The comments are
posted in the section "Evaluation".
b) have to focus on the occasion rather than the audience, which may call for more
formality.
b) advocate one position among others that are possible and be ready to
defend it.
Read the comments about this task in the virtual campus. The comments are
posted in the section "Evaluation".
Reflection task 13.8.
Broadcast media as well as public or university stations are required to serve in the
public interest, thus a PSA is usually an inexpensive way to start a campaign and
get a message out to the public in the United States. They can be done very simply
with a single actor reading or performing a message, or they can be elaborate,
slickly-produced messages with music, dramatic story-lines, and sound or visual
effects.
Example of a PSA
Today, the Internet is a prerequisite to complete homework, search for and apply
for a job, connect with family and friends and access government programs. Low-
income and minority Americans disproportionately find themselves on the wrong
side of the digital divide and excluded from the $8 trillion digital economy and all of
its benefits. More than 80% of FORTUNE 500 companies post their job openings
online only and require online applications. Fifty percent of today's jobs require
technology skills, and this percentage is expected to grow to 77% in the next
decade.
The Everyone On campaign aims to help the 62 million Americans who do not
have the digital literacy skills they need to succeed and help them understand the
relevance the Internet has in their lives. Whether it's finding a job, helping their
children complete homework for school or accessing e-commerce, electronic
medical records and connecting with distant family, it is vital that we encourage
every American to take advantage of the tools they need to succeed.
2. Brainstorm.
3. Prepare an audio record of your PSA - you can use the Debut Video Capture
(you will have to download the software to your computer first on
http://www.nchsoftware.com/software/recording.html). You may also use another
recording software if you prefer.
4. Listen to your PSA and reflect on it from the communicability, intelligibility and
your self-confidence aspects. You may want to use the chart below to help you on
your analysis.
Speech is largely unintelligible; requires great Accent causes severe interference with
2
listener effort. oral communication.
Communicative threshold A
Communicative threshold B
5 Speech is fully intelligible; occasional non- Accent causes little interference, speech
native accent variances do not seriously is fully functional; effective
distract the listener. communication.
Read the comments about this task in the virtual campus. The comments are
posted in the section "Evaluation".
13.2. Review
- In the introduction you have found out how to structure your presentation, as it
also deals with the main differences between spoken and written language. And
besides some insights about pronunciation you'll have the opportunity to watch an
interesting talk.
Enter the virtual campus and access the Reflection exercises section. There you
will find the tasks you have seen during this unit. You have to complete all of them
and, when you finish them, the system will provide you the feedback. If you need
more information, consult the file "Assessment", right under the section
Assessment of the unit.
Remember that, apart from reading the contents and completing the Reflection
exercises, you have to complete the activities and the exam or the final task. The
teacher had provided the information about them in the Group forum.
Bibliography
[1] Bailey, K. et Nunan, D. (2005): "Practical English Language Teaching: Speaking". New
York, MacGraw-Hill.
[2] Balester, V. (2010): "The Perfect Defense". (online) 1st of November, 2013 on:
http://www.youtube.com
[3] Brown, H. (2000): "Principles of Language Learning and Teaching". New York.
Addison Wesley Longman.
[6] Ferraro, V. & Palmer, Kathryn (2005). "Speaking and Arguing: The Rhetoric of
Peace and War". South Hadley, MA.
[7] Gillet, A. (1999): "Using English for Academic Purposes - A guide for students
in higher education". Last updated on November 2013 on:
http://www.uefap.com/index.htm
[10] LeBeau Jr., S. (2007): "English for Academic Public Speaking". Unpublished
Masters Dissertation. Indiana University.
[11] McLaren, N. et Madrid, D. (2004): "Important aspects in Curriculum and
Course Design - The Foreign Language Curriculum", en Madrid, D. y McLaren, N.
(eds.): TEFL in Primary Education. Granada.