Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Arianne Joy S. Magaling, Lou Jazzel D.Punzalan and Hanz Nicole L. Torino
Bachelor of Science in Psychology
Abstract
This study aimed to explore on the lived experiences of the Filipino mental health
caregivers. Their intrinsic and extrinsic values were unfolded using
phenomenological method, particularly the “pamamaybay” and “kapwa-oriented”
approach. Significant implications were found in terms of value cultivation for
human development and communal well-being. Whereas karangalan, lakas-ng-
loob, pagpapahalaga, pagpapakatotoo. pakikiramdam, panlipunang-pagtanggap,
and pansariling-kakayahan were revealed to be the mental health caregivers’
intrinsic values, kagandahang-loob, katarungan, positibong-pananaw, and tiwala
were found to be their extrinsic values. The findings suggested that beyond the
complexity in relationship building in the Philippine psychiatric setting, both
caregivers and patients attain functionalism, which promotes self-sufficiency
necessary for maintaining one’s dignity. The shared self revealed the Filipino
mental health caregivers’ revolving strengths, developments, and morality fiber.
Extension of “self” limits the shadow casts within the patients (others). Filipinos
are proven to have strong self and cultural values embedded unconsciously
within their lives.
Key words: shared self, intrinsic values, extrinsic values, Filipino mental health
caregivers
Introduction
Methods
2.Shared Stories
1. 3.In-Depth
Exposure/ Interview
Observatio
n
5.Personal
6.Thematic 4.Intersubjective
Reflection
Documentation Validation
Data Analysis Procedure. Firstly, an in-depth interview was conducted which was
audio-taped with the participants’ consent. The verbatim transcription of the
taped-interview was encoded to extract, classify, and summarize the participants’
responses. The development of catalogued-emerging codes into a pattern called
themes followed. The themes were grouped to form clusters (superordinate and
subordinate themes). Extraction of excerpts from the original transcript using a
quotation that best captured the essence of their thoughts, emotions about what
is being studied was made.
3.1 Intrinsic Values. The table summarizes the Filipino mental health caregivers’
intrinsic values. These values were categorized based on their choices,
commitments and self-development.
Table 1
The Intrinsic Values of the Filipino Mental Health Caregivers
Superordinate Sub-ordinate Example of Illustrative Text
Themes Themes
1.Pakikiramdam a. Pandama (Sensing) “Kapag disturbed ang pasyente, usually
nagcu-curse at nagmumura, definitely, di mo
kayang magbuild ng anumang rapport”
3.2 Extrinsic Values. Extrinsic values were categorized based on their moral
obligations, moral virtues and related strengths. Fundamental principles that
revolve within the society were also enveloped. Thus, by contrast to intrinsic
values, extrinsic values are gained from the social interactions that pertain to the
benefits of the ‘others’ extensively.
Table 2
The Extrinsic Values of the Filipino Mental Health Caregivers
Superordinate Sub-ordinate Example of Illustrative Text
Themes Themes
Kagandahang a. Altruismo (Altruism) “Hindi ko na hangad na umasenso sa
Loob buhay, ang hangad ko na lang
makatulong sa mga pasyente”
Awa (Compassion) “Naroon ang awa. Hindi lang sa
pasyente, kundi maging sa kaanak.”
The profound and powerful meaning of ‘extrinsic values’ outlines the ethos
of sharing, seeing, and caring by the Filipino Mental Health Caregivers to employ
genuineness and humanity that is embedded unconsciously within them.
Kagandahang Loob is the value relation of Filipino dimension of
conscience by acting purely for the sake of others. Filipino mental health
caregivers showed value of altruism by doing whatever benefits the patient in
need regardless of their motives. They also expressed sentiment of pakikiramay
upon seeing the patient and their families struggle.
Katarungan conceptually refers to carrying consideration with the fairness
in the defense of certain basic rights of the patients (Panopio, et. al., 2007). This
theme is supported by the positive value of pagtitimpi or fundamentally
understanding the behavior of the patients by not inflicting harm unto them
despite their deviant behavior. This is a way of helping the patients maintain their
dignity.
Tiwala is another major theme that was extracted from the mental health
caregivers’ lived experiences. This theme served as the initiation of rapport and
relationship building and believed to be the preliminary task of the Filipino mental
health caregivers that must be fulfilled.
Positibong Pananaw is seen as a constructive view of life to build a healthy
outlook. It describes Filipino mental health caregivers’ way of learning
(pagkatuto) from their line of work and everyday experiences with the patients
(others). The value also brings out the communal well-being of both the patients
and the caregivers which results to growth, development, and optimism.
Strongly, Tanauan (2012) noted that ‘Kapwa’ points out the meaning of
“love” in the space that Filipinos share as one humanity. Hence, by living to its
meaning, men become true to the loving purpose of life. Also, “shared self” is a
notion that opens up heart doors of the “I” to include “others”. It bridges the
deepest individual recess of Filipinos with anyone outside himself, even total
strangers (De Guia, 2005).On a study conducted by Reyes (2014), he
considered ‘Kapwa’ theory parallel to the authenticity of a person through living a
life of inter-personal self-giving. Person is essentially a “we” term. Person exists
in its fullness only in the plural. Also, according to Jocano (2000), it is given to
observed Filipino traits that what makes a virtuous person composes a
dimension of compassion, the act of altruism, together with self-worth and
dignified relationships. Extrinsic values are found out that the value is pursued
not for in its own sake but for the sake of something else, especially for the
benefits it will bring about (Bunnin, 2004) Profoundly, Manauat (2009), defined
Filipino caring as a broad sense that carries a variety of meanings. To care is to
feel concern (be bothered, worry, love, think about), to show concern (hug,
caress, pay a visit, spend time with) and understand what the other is going
through (empathize, sympathize).Ultimately, it is the context of caring that will
further illustrate why it is a value.
3.3 Implications
The dynamics of the intrinsic and extrinsic values of the Filipino mental
health caregivers contribute to the development of the ‘shared self’ that brings an
extended sense of self in the Philippine Psychiatric setting. Through these
values, not only the patients (other) are developed into a constructive milieu but
also the ‘self’ (caregivers) which is continuously being able to fuse oneself
through understanding beyond differences and growing rather than isolation and
stagnation.
Within these values, with or without limitations, is where Filipinos can
produce great advancement to human and socio-economic development (Titular,
2013). In the rapid advancement of the world, every society must cultivate
strengths to continue moving forward. Hence, in this gradual expansion, human
helping is a major key to attain good and functional society.
Consequently, the mentally ill patients, together with the Filipino Mental
Health Caregivers must not be barred by human limitations to attain
‘functionalism’ as in the case of the social stigma for them. The shadow casts of
their mental illness, the nature of their difficulties, and circumstances, often limits
their opportunities for further human growth and development (Townsend, 2011).
However, although the patients (other) are mentally challenged, there is
an extent to a large degree of rebuilding ‘functionalism’ for the society, their
families, and most especially, for their own selves. Thus, according to Seligman
(2011), what matters in life includes an account of people’s responsibilities and
obligations toward others and their interpretation of the sort of the society that
they affirm as good. Deeply in connection, Suu Kyi (1994) noted that “the true
development of human beings involve much more mere economic growth. At its
least, there must be a sense of empowerment and inner fulfilment. This alone will
ensure that human and cultural values remain paramount”.
The Psychiatric setting in the Philippines, as in the core value of ‘Kapwa’
theory, is a proving ground that “I” and “other” are one (ikaw-at-ako-ay-iisa)
through ‘shared self’ because both caregivers and patients attain goals and
development in the process of social interaction producing communal well-being.
On the Philippine moral recovery context (Licuanan, 2010), the goals of (1) sense
of common good, the ability to look beyond selfish interests, a sense of justice
and a sense of outrage at its violation, (2) the value and habits of discipline and
hard work and (3) the value and habits of self-reflection and analysis, the
internalization of spiritual values, and an emphasis upon essence rather than on
form are developed by Filipino mental health caregivers. This is seen at their
developing capabilities in their achievement connected to the daily life of patients
(other) that is implemented by the act, particularly to their profession,
occupations, and jobs.
In all, the contribution of the ‘shared self’, with or without limitations,
produces great advancement to the human and socio-economic development by
being functional of both the ‘self’ (Filipino mental health caregivers) and ‘other’
(patient) in the rapid advancement of the Philippine society. In a current wave of
modernization where there is conflict, trouble, violence, and risks, Filipino mental
health caregivers are one of those who still work to build human development
beyond the fundamental challenge of the promotion of shared human values and
necessary skills.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
Barker, P. (2008). Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing: The Craft of Caring. USA:Taylor and
Francis Group LCC
Ballard, K., O’Brien, P., & Kennedy, W. (2013). Psychiatric Mental Helath Nursing. USA:Jones
and Barlett Learning
Enriquez, V. (1992).From Colonial to Liberation Psychology. Quezon City Philippines: University
of the Philippines Press.
Erikson, E. (1959). Identity and the Life Cycle, Volume 1. USA:Norton
Feist and Feist (2012). Theories of Personality. Philippines:McGraw Hill Companies, Inc.
Feldman. (2010). Psychology and Your Life. Philippines:The McGraw-Hills and Companies, Inc.
Gripaldo, R. (2005). Filipino Cultural Traits: Claro R. Ceniza Lectures.Washington DC:The
Council for Research of Values and Philisophy.
Jocano, (2000). Filipino Value System. Quezon City: Punlad Research House.
Leninger, M. (2001). Culture Care Diversity and University: A Theory in Nursing. Sadbury
Masachusetts:Jones and Barlett Publishers
Ortigas, C. (2008 c.1990) Group Process and the Inductive Method: Theory and Practice in the
Philippines.Ateneo de Manila University Press.
Philip Banyard, M. D. (2010). Essential Psychology: A Concise Introduction. London: SAGE
Publications Ltd.
Ryckman, R. (2013). Theories of Personality. 10th ed. New York:Wadsworth Cengage Learning
Schultz, J., & Videbeck, S.. (2013). Lippincotts’s Manual of Psychiatric Nursing Care Plans. 9th
ed. China: Lippincotts Williams and Wilkins
Swami, V. (2011). Evolutionary Psychology: A Critical Introduction. Cornwall:Blackwell BPS
Textbooks
Townsend, M. (2011). Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing: Concepts of Care in Evidenced-Based
Practice. Philadelphia:F.A. Davis Company
Videbeck S. (2004). Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing. Lippincott:Williams and Wilkins
Yacat, J. (2013). Filipino Psychology (Sikolohiyang Pilipino): The Encyclopedia of Cross-Cultural
Psychology. Hoboken NJ: Wiley Blackwell
WEBLIOGRAPHY
Ancheta M.R. (2010). Are We or Are We not Amused? Retrieved on August 30, 2014 from,
http://www.tu.ac.th/resource/publish/interview/tu_doc/2012-Volume14-Special
%20Issue/TU%20Review-Final%20Vol.14.pdf
Aquino, C. (2004). Mula sa Kinaroroonan: Kapwa, Kapatiran and Bayan in Philippine Social
Science.Retrieved on August 30, 2014, from,
http://www.scribd.com/doc/134619030/Clemen-C-Aquino#scribd
Boncan. C. (2008). Re-Visiting Sikolohiyang Pilipino. Retrieved on August 30, 2014 from,
https://philcsc.wordpress.com/2008/08/08/re-visiting-sikolohiyang-pilipino-in-honor-of-
virgilio-enriquez/
Bunnin, Nicholas et. al (2014). Extrinsic Value. The Blackwell Dictionary of Western Philosophy,
Retrieved October 10, 2014 from, http://www.blackwellreference.com/public/tocnode?
id=g9781405106795_chunk_g97814051067 956_ss1-219
De Guia K. (2005). Indigenous Filipino Values: A Foundation for a Culture of Non-Violence.
Retrieved on August 30, 2014 from, http://philippineculture.ph/filer/Indigenous-Filipino-
Values.pdf
DeWall, N. (2011). Social Acceptance and Rejection: The Sweet and the Bitter. Retrieved
January 14, 2014, from
http://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/news/releases/social-acceptance-and-
rejection-the-sweet-and-the-bitter.html
DOH. (2010). The Strategic Thrusts of the Government on Mental Health Setting. Retrieved on
August 30, 2014 from ,http://www.doh.gov.ph/sites/default/files/NOH2005.pdf
Drona, B. (2008). The Flipino Mind. Retrieved September 18, 2014, from
http://www.thefilipinomind.com/2008/01/chapter-vi-understanding-filipino-value.html
Licuanan, P. (2010). A Moral Recovery Program:Building A People--Building A Nation. Retrieved
on November 14, 2014, from, http://www.crvp.org/book/series03/iii-7/chapter_iv.htm
Luzbetak J. (2012).Mission and culture.Retrieved on November 15, 2014 from
http://www.orbisbooks.com/chapters/978-1-57075-965-9.pdf
Manauat, N. (2009). Contextualizing the Filipino Values of Pagkaliga, Pag-aaruga, Pakialam and
the Feminist Ethics of Care. Retrieved on January 28, 2015, from
http://www.crvp.org/book/series03/iiid-4/chapter-6.htm
McLeod, S. A. (2008). Erik Erikson. Retrieved on November 16, 2014, from
http://www.simplypsychology.org/Erik-Erikson.html
Odal, G. (2001), "Mother" Victoria Vera Piedad as a Mutya Figure: A Study of an Archetypal
Image of the self. Retrieved on August 30, 2014, from
http://bromoki.com/ap/experience/comment.php?topic_catid=20)