Portfolio Assessment of Nawfel Waqar
Criterion
1. Identification of a need or
opportunity with a brief analysis
leading to a design
brief
2. Research into the design
brief resulting in a
specification
3. Generation and exploration of
design ideas
4. Development of proposed
solution
5. Planning for production
6. Product realization
7. Testing and evaluation
Comments of Examiner Mark
 Need of the design according to the target user clearly identified
 In depth analysis of design problem. Link with design clearly established. 4 out of 5
 Design brief is clear, showing the constraints very clearly
 Thorough research of design brief with the data collected.
 Specifications of the product are justified through a detailed research analysis. 9 out of 10
 The mood board, product analysis and questionnaire are linked with the client profile
 A wide range of ideas with appropriate solutions. Evaluation of ideas carried out.
 Comparison of the initials shows the understanding of the technical knowledge 16 out of 20
 Annotations could be more detailed.
 Development of idea is reasonably good, through the use of wide range of different techniques,
small details are included through sketching which gives understanding of the design.
12 out of 15
 Good use of CAD to develop a solution.
 Effective use of modelling to set up an effective planning for production.
 Detailed working designs are present with the detailed dimensions.
9 out of 10
 Step by step whole manufacturing process is displayed using cutting list, time plan and flowchart.
 The product is completed to a reasonable standard, with the accuracy and most importantly
according to the expected specifications specification and functions. 27 out of 30
 Step by step photographic record of whole manufacturing process.
 Real time testing carried out as the client took the product to the actual locations.
 Evaluation done against all the specifications developed.
7 out of 10
 As a result of evaluation, the suggestions for the future; some better points could have been
included.
Total mark awarded 84 out of 100