Portfolio Assessment of Noor Mustafa
Criterion
1. Identification of a need or
opportunity with a brief analysis
leading to a design
brief
2. Research into the design
brief resulting in a
specification
3. Generation and exploration of
design ideas
4. Development of proposed
solution
5. Planning for production
6. Product realization
7. Testing and evaluation
Comments of Examiner Mark
 Detailed analysis of problem and need clearly identified.
 Descriptive design brief and reference to the user requirement is detailed. 4 out of 5
 Design brief is clear, showing the constraints very clearly
 Conclusive information gathered from research.
 Critical findings in mood board, product analysis, questionnaire, designer research and client profile 9 out of 10
 Detailed specification that is linked well with research.
 A range of ideas with appropriate solutions. Evaluation of ideas are detailed according to the desired
specifications
17 out of 20
 Annotations are detailed and good but can be more presentable.
 Comparative analysis of ideas carried out.
 Development of idea is reasonably good, through the use of range of different techniques, details are
included through sketching which gives the understanding of the design.
12 out of 15
 Good use of CAD to develop a solution.
 Effective use of modelling to set up an effective planning for production.
 Detailed working designs are present with the detailed dimensions.
8 out of 10
 Step by step whole manufacturing process is displayed using cutting list, time plan and flowchart.
 The product is completed to a good standard, with the accuracy and according to the expected
specifications and functions. 27 out of 30
 Step by step photographic record of whole manufacturing process.
 Real time testing carried out as the client took the product to the actual locations.
 Evaluation done against all the specifications developed.
7 out of 10
 Identification of strengths and weaknesses of the product.
 Future modifications are bit ambiguous.
Total mark awarded 84 out of 100