Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Figure 3.8 Photo of a 1930’s German autobahn concrete pavement near Berlin.
(Note cracking in outer truck lane of the 12-m (39-ft) slabs.)
78
Approximately 30 percent of the l Pavement Designs
former west German autobahn and 82
percent of the former east German Original Autobahn Concrete
autobahn are constructed with concrete Pavement Design. The following
pavement (approximately 4,168 km information was obtained during a
(2588 mi) of concrete out of 10,900 km meeting of the Study Tour and German
(6769 mi) total). The West German highway officials in Berlin and also
pavements constructed prior to 1970 from references 3 and 7.
are jointed plain and jointed reinforced
concrete, and only dowelled JPCP was Planning and initial construction of the
constructed after 1970. Germany German autobahn was started in the
favors dowelled JPCP because of the 1920’s. The first German autobahn
extensive use of deicing salts and the ideas were based on car-only
potential for corrosion of reinforced highways, built in northern Italy by
pavements. Over the years, the design Piero Puricelli in the 1920’s. (7) The
of the German concrete pavements has first cross-section of a four-lane
changed considerably; however, the divided highway was created in 1926,
current JPCP design has been built the word “autobahn” first appeared in
extensively since the early 1970’s both 1928 (7), and the design speed was 160
as new pavement and as overlays of km/h (100 mph) in non-mountainous
old concrete pavements. areas. These pavements were
conceived as two lanes in one direction
An extensive research and with 7.5-m (24.5ft) pavement width.
development program has been A policy statement on the principle of
underway in Germany for many years, performance required of the
at such institutions as the Federal construction industry and also on
Highway Research Institute (BAST) contract and procurement procedures
and the Munich Technical University to was issued by Fritz Todt, Inspector
improve concrete pavement materials, General of the German Highway
construction and design. Many Administration, in 1933:
excellent technical articles can be found
in the literature from this research. “It is not always the lowest bid which
should be given preference. Quality
Concrete pavements have also been is the most important criterion.” (7)
constructed at airports in Germany.
The Study Tour visited the new A decision was made about that time
Munich II International Airport that to construct the autobahn highway
was just opened in May, 1992. This network with concrete pavements. By
airport was constructed with more than 1940 approximately 4000 km (2480 mi)
2 million square meters (2.4 million of four-lane divided autobahn
square yards) of 36-cm (14.2 in) highways were constructed. During
dowelled JPCP for runways, taxiways the war years the government
and aprons. For comparison, Dulles prohibited using steel for any purpose
International Airport has 1.2 million other than military. A concrete
square meters (1.4 million square pavement research program was
yards) of 38.1-cm (15-in) undowelled JPCP. carried out in the 1930’s with the
79
construction of many test sections. The use different quality aggregates in each
general design evolved as follows, layer. The upper layer used only high-
although there are some variations of quality aggregate as judged by
this design. compressive strength and wear tests
(typical types were granite, basalt and
Slab: Uniform thickness, 20-25 cm (8- quartzite) and the elimination of
10 in) JPCP (some thinner and thicker), impurities and flat particles. A
mostly two-layer construction. Top somewhat inferior aggregate (local
slab layer is 9 cm (3.5 in) thick and gravel) was used for the lower layer
contains high-quality aggregate (3-cm for economic reasons.
(1.2-in) maximum size). The lower slab
layer is 13 cm (5 in) thick and contains Aggregate gradation was closely
local gravel aggregates (5cm (2-in) controlled through use of several size
maximum size). requirements. It appears that a fairly
uniform dense aggregate gradation
Width of traffic lane = 3.75 m (12.3 ft) resulted from this specification.
(two lanes in one direction)
Flexural strength requirements
Joints: Spacing for plain jointed included 3.7 MPa (540 psi) minimum
concrete sections = 8-12 m (26.539 ft) and 4.4 MPa (640 psi) average.
Compressive strength requirements
. Spacing for jointed reinforced sections were 32 MPa (4,700 psi) minimum and
= 1230 m (39-98 ft) (stopped in 1937) 39 MPa (5700 psi) average. Strengths
were tested with specimens made
Typical expansion joint spacing during construction and by means of
12-18 m (39-59 ft). (Note: It was tests on cores made at approximately
common practice to systematically 60 days. (3)
increase the joint spacing from slab to
slab in increments of 1 m (3.3 ft) or so, Very dry (zero-slump) concrete with a
with periodic return to the first water/cement ratio usually of 0.45 or
spacing.) less. No air entrainment admixture
was used.
Dowels 35.6 cm (14 in) long, 2.2cm
(0.875 in) diameter round steel dowels Foundation:
with a sleeve on one end.
Considerable effort made to reduce the
Dowels spaced 30.5 cm (12 in) near damaging effects of frost heave and
center of slab with closer spacing excess moisture. This was done by
toward edge. placing longitudinal drains to intercept
ground water flowing towards the
Longitudinal joints tied (3.75-m (12.3-ft) highway or to lower the ground water
lane width). table, and by placing layers of granular
materials (often sand was used)
Concrete: Most pavements were
constructed in two courses for ease in
compaction of very dry concrete and to
80
between the slab and the subgrade. Many original sections of the German
Often the grade line was raised 0.9 m autobahn are still in place and serving
(3 ft) or more above the natural ground heavy traffic in the former East
level, and in cuts the roadway was Germany, whereas the former West
excavated below grade and backfilled Germany has previously rehabilitated
with selected material. (3) In the Berlin most of the old pavements. The Study
area, the concrete pavement was often Tour had the unique opportunity to
placed on the sand subgrade. observe many of these old pavements
during the trip from Munich to Berlin
Shoulders: Usually 0.38 m (1.25 ft) and also on the freeway loop
wide inner (left) and 2.2 m (7.33 ft) surrounding Berlin (Berliner Ring).
wide outer (right). Pavement included They are fairly rough, due mainly to
17.8 cm (7 in) of concrete capped with the many transverse cracks that have
7.6 cm (3 in) of AC for color spalled and faulted. No obvious
delineation. In cases where dark- pumping was observed and the 50-
colored concrete was used in the traffic year-old concrete showed no durability
lanes, plain concrete was used in the problems. A large reconstruction effort
top course of the paved shoulder strip is currently underway in the former
for color delineation. (3) East Germany and the concrete from
these pavements is being recycled into
Construction: Usually two lanes either lean concrete base or the upper
formed at same time with a tied layer of the granular blanket.
weakened-plane longitudinal joint.
The concrete base for the shoulder strip During the visit to a reconstruction site
was constructed before the pavement on the A10, described below, a piece of
slab and was used as a base upon old concrete pavement was obtained
which to mount the rails carrying the and submitted to the Construction
heavy construction equipment used in Technology Laboratories (CTL) for
the mixing, placing, and finishing analysis. The official petrographic
operations. Tamping and some analysis is given in the Appendix and a
vibration of the concrete was summary is provided here.
performed. (3)
1. The sample is a hard, dense,
All placing, finishing, and preliminary good-quality concrete consisting
curing operations were completed of siliceous and calcareous
under sunshades that spanned the aggregates in a portland cement
entire pavement. Woven-reed curing paste. The paste-aggregate bond
mats were left in place for 3 weeks and is tight and the concrete
were kept continuously wet during fractures through coarse and fine
that period. aggregate particles.
Figure 3.9 Construction site on the A10 south of Berlin showing catch basins at edge
of slab that are connected to longitudinal pipe under the lean concrete base
and connected to the manhole shown on the left.
Bridge Ends: End lug is placed more the contractor is warned that further
than 15 m (49 ft) from backwall of repairs may be needed. Originally this
structure and then an AC surface over occurred more often; now it seldom
a CTB are placed to the backwall, as occurs. If the project is not accepted it
shown in Figure 3.10. affects the contractor’s reputation and
it is considered in future contract
A four-year warranty system exists for awards. Since performance on
concrete and asphalt pavements, previous contracts is considered in
during which the contractor is awards, the contractor’s reputation is
responsible for repair of any problems important.
that develop.
The words “emergency lane” are used
The government relies on the warranty to describe the shoulder because these
and on the contractor protecting his pavements are constructed to a full
reputation if problems develop. A 11-m (36-ft) width so that during any
small amount of money is withheld future rehabilitation, four lanes of
until final acceptance at the end of the traffic can be carried on one side of the
warranty period. If major problems divided highway.
develop, the project is not accepted and
84
bridge
Projects constructed without dowel the field. (2) There is now a new
bars have faulted significantly. Many catalog for rehabilitation alternatives
of these are in the former East also. The Study Tour rode over several
Germany where the government sections of the design and also
prohibited dowels. Dowels are needed observed a construction site. It was
in the German climate and traffic to observed and reported from various
control faulting. sources that this design is performing
very well under heavy traffic.
A plate load test in which pressure is
repeatedly applied to and removed The catalog provides for a direct
from the soil in stages is conducted in comparison between concrete and
the field to ensure that a minimum asphalt designs. The granular blanket
bearing elastic modulus is achieved on is the same for both concrete and
top of the subgrade (minimum is 45 asphalt pavements to control frost
MPa (6,525 psi)) and on top of the heave, provide uniform support and to
granular blanket layer (minimum is 120 provide some bottom drainage. The
MPa (17,400 psi)) for concrete AC pavement layers are built on top of
pavements. (8) this, as are the concrete base and slab.
The German pavement design catalog The pavement design used for the new
is an excellent method to communicate Munich II International Airport is
the details of the pavement design to given under the description of projects
visited.
85
J Compressive strength is measured
l Concrete Material and Construction with a 3-cm cube. The minimum
strength is 35 MPa (5075 psi).
An extensive research program was
started in the 1930’s into cements and J It was stated that some AC can be
concrete mixtures that included the used in recycled concrete mixtures.
construction of many test sections. A
detailed description of the old 1930’s J Air void content and void system
autobahn concrete mixtures is given in quality control are specified in
reference 3. Reasons for the excellent reference 2. Tests are conducted the
durability of the old autobahn concrete first day of production and again if
are previously given. there is any doubt as to air content.
The bubble spacing must be less than
Current German concrete requirements 0.2 mm (0.008 in) and the micropores
are as follows: must be at least 1.8 percent.
J 4 to.6 percent entrained air, The air void system may be tested in
including air void system equipment viewed by the Study Tour
requirements. at the Cement Research Facility in
J Water/cement ratio < 0.42 to Dusseldorf. The equipment labelled
provide dense mixture. “DBT” costs about $20,000 and is
J 340 kg/m3 (573 pounds/yd3)) manufactured by a Danish company.
cement. It relies on Bernoulli’s principle that
J Mixing time is 45 seconds minimum. larger air bubbles, representing air
J Graded aggregates. voids, rise to the surface faster. A
J Aggregates must pass freeze-thaw small tube sample, 2.5 cm (1 in) in
and alkali-silica reaction tests. diameter, of fresh concrete is taken
J Freeze-thaw tests are run on from the newly placed slab, placed in
aggregates for 300 cycles in aggressive the equipment, and the amount of air
solution and loss cannot 0.2 percent per time period is measured. This
maximum. equipment can produce results in
J If reactive aggregates are present, about 20 minutes on the air void
low-alkali cement (less than 0.6 percent content and spacing and can be used
alkali) is specified. If problems still on the construction site. It reportedly
exist, the aggregate is changed. correlates well with linear traverse
J No flyash is used in highway results on hardened concrete.
pavement.
J Germany uses the center-point Some ASR distress has recently
loading flexural beam test, which they developed on the northern Berliner
found to be 10-15 percent higher than Ring autobahn pavement due to high-
the third-point loading test. A alkali cement used on project (in the
minimum of 5.5 MPa (800 psi) for the former East Germany). The East
center-point loading flexural strength at German government dictated the
28 days, which corresponds to about source of the aggregate and cement for
4.9 MPa (711 psi) in third-point this project. No “D” cracking problems
loading.
86
were observed, probably due to the use rehabilitation alternative depends on
of only high-quality hard aggregates in the following criteria: (6)
the slab surface.
J Traffic restrictions during
Various construction items: reconstruction,
J Possibility of the use of recycled
J The use of a “tent” to protect the materials,
newly placed concrete from rain and J Adequate clearance for bridges,
sun may provide a significant effect. J Required improvements of cross-
This procedure also would reduce the slope and other geometrics,
temperature and thermal gradient of J Required widening of the cross
the fresh concrete, which would reduce section (lane or shoulder), and
detrimental curling of the slab. This is J Economics.
still being done today as discussed
under the Munich airport project The following types of rehabilitation
description. are currently being performed on the
German autobahn pavements. (6)
J Curing is done with either water
sprinkling or wax-based curing JPCP Overlay with Interlayer: The
compounds. existing concrete pavement is fractured
into pieces less than 0.5 m (1.6 in) in
J The two-lift construction of the slab size. Then a 10-cm (4-in) interlayer of
results in smoother profile as well as a either lean concrete (notched) or AC
more economical mixture where high- material is placed on top of the existing
quality stone is expensive. concrete pavement. A JPCP overlay is
then placed to the same thickness as a
Cement-treated base compressive newly constructed pavement (i.e., 26
strength requirement is a minimum of cm (10.2 in) for the heaviest traffic
9 MPa (1305 psi) to provide resistance class).
to erosion.
JPCP Overlay with Thick Fabric
Germany believes strongly in bonding Interlayer: The existing concrete
the lean concrete base or CTB to the pavement is fractured into pieces less
slab to reduce curling and erosion. than 0.5 m (1.6 ft) in size. Then a
This is accomplished by notching the geotextile interlayer is placed on top of
base 35 percent of its thickness the existing concrete pavement. A
immediately after placement exactly slightly thicker JPCP overlay is then
beneath the transverse and longitudinal placed on top of the fabric (i.e., 27 cm
joints of the concrete slab. (10.6 in) for the heaviest traffic class).
The debonding with the underlying
l Rehabilitation layer and the additional elasticity of
the geotextile fabric requires a thicker
A new rehabilitation catalog is slab. However, the softer fabric
available. Selection of the material may also reduce curling
stresses in the JPCP overlay.
87
Total Width Reconstruction: The burlap drag was used along with the
entire pavement is completely removed smaller top-size aggregates, the noise
and a new JPCP with untreated level was about the same as a porous
crushed permeable base constructed. AC surface. This change was recently
This pavement type is new for made in the construction specifications.
Germany; however, it makes it possible Germany has experimented with
to recycle up to 100 percent of the old various exposed aggregate surfaces but
pavement. The JPCP thickness is believes that the longitudinal burlap
increased (i.e., 30 cm (12 in) for the texture along with high-quality hard
heaviest traffic class). aggregates in the upper slab will
provide low noise and good friction.
Lane Reconstruction. A cross-section
is shown in Figure 2.10. A porous l Project Sites Observed
concrete base is recommended having
a void content of more than 20 percent New Munich II International Airport.
and compressive strength exceeding 15 The Study Tour visited the newly
MPa for a thickness of 40 cm (15.7 in). opened airport and observed some of
The permeability coefficient required the 2 million square meters (2.4 million
for this base’ is less than lOA m/s. The square yards) of concrete pavements as
new JPCP is placed directly on this well as having a presentation on the
layer but is constructed thicker (i.e., 30 construction of the pavements. Figure
cm (12 in) for the heaviest traffic class). 3.11 shows a photo of a runway under
The new lane is tied securely to the construction. The JPCP constructed at
adjacent slab by five corrosion- Munich II Airport is defined as
protected bars (Zcm-diameter (0.8 in)) follows: (4, 5)
per 5-m (16.5ft) slab).
Slab: 36 to 40-cm (14.2 to 15.8-in)
AC Overlay: A 12-cm (4.7-in) AC JPCP constructed in two layers.
overlay is sometimes placed where a 40 cm (15.8 in) on ramps only.
rehabilitation life of six to eight years is
desired. Top 14 cm (5.5 in) includes crushed
granite for better freeze-thaw resistance
l Noise Pollution and friction.
A major concern about traffic noise Bottom 22-24 cm (8.7-9.5 in) used local
exists in Germany as in other European gravel aggregate.
countries. Until recently, most of the
concrete pavements were textured with Double course construction was
transverse tining, which was very good achieved in a single pass of a slipform
for friction and hydroplaning but paver in 15 m (49 ft) width.
caused considerable road noise and
vibrations. It was found that this Runway cross-section varied, with
texture produced 3 dB(A) greater central 30 m (98 ft) being 36 cm (14.2
rolling noise than AC pavements and in) and outer 15 m (49 ft) on each side
was not allowed to be used in urban thinning to 26 cm (10.2 in). The total
areas. If, however, a longitudinal width is 60 m (197 ft).
88
Figure 3.11 Photo of runway under construction at the new Munich International
Airport. (Note the “tent” coverings placed behind the paver to provide
curing protection to the surface for seven days.)
89
Dowels and tie bars were placed on Tie bars were placed automatically in
top of the lower layer. outer longitudinal joints.
Figure 3.12 Thick granular blanket placed beneath lean concrete base in Germany.