Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Proposed
Pangsapuri
5 Tingkat
BLACKFOX ENGINEERING SDN BHD 627019-P
Lot 2040, Tingkat 1, Bangunan SBJ, Pasir
Pekan, Wakaf Baru, 16250, Wakaf Bharu,
Kelantan, Malaysia
Tel: 09-7181812 Fax: 09-7181812
Email: black fox _60@yahoo.com
Part 4 V E R I F I C A T I O N E S T E E M D A T A
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING AND BUILT ENVIROMENTAL
BFC43303
SECTION 8
PROJECT
(STRUCTURE)
TABLE OF CONTENT
4.6. Summary……………………………………………………………….. 16
REFERENCES
MINUTES OF MEETING
APPENDICES
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
1|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Column (C13)
Type of Design Manual Calculation Esteem Software
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
Slab (FS10)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
Short span Midspan = 118.57 mm2/m (Asreq) Midspan = 181 mm2/m (Aspro)
= 314 mm2/m (Aspro) (H10 – 250mm)
(H10 – 250mm) Support = 166 mm2/m (Aspro)
Support = 90.34 mm2/m (Asreq) (H10 – 250mm)
= 314 mm2/m (Aspro)
(H10 – 250mm)
Long span Midspan = 67.76 mm2/m (Asreq) Midspan = 181 mm2/m (Aspro)
= 314 mm2/m (Aspro) (H10 – 250mm)
(H10 – 250mm) Support = 166 mm2/m (Aspro)
Support = 90.34 mm2/m (Asreq) (H10 – 250mm)
= 314 mm2/m (Aspro)
(H10 – 250mm)
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
2|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Foundation P21 (C13)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
Shear OK OK
(vertical shear, punching shear)
Cracking OK OK
3|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Deflection OK OK
-
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK -
4|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Column (C30)
Type of Design Manual Calculation Esteem
Software Description (Used)
960mm2
Required 1001mm2
Asrequired and Asprov
Main
from manual
reinforcement
calculation was
(Main bar)
4H25 smaller than esteem
8H16
Provided 1473mm2
1608mm2
Shear reinforcement
H8-300 H8-300
(Shear link)
Slab (FS2)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
H10-300 H10-250
Short span
(262mm2 – Asprovided) (314mm2 – Asprovided)
OK OK
Deflection
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
5|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Foundation (C30)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
Main reinforcement
3H16 8H10
(Main bar)
(400 mm2) (557 mm2)
Shear
(vertical shear, punching shear) OK OK
Cracking OK OK
Size of pile cap
900 x 1350 x 400 900 x 900 x 300
Type of pile
150 x 150 150 x 150
Number of pile
4 pile 4 pile
6|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual < (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual < (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual < (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual < (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
7|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Column (C17)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual < (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual < (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
Slab (FS35)
Type of Manual calculation Esteem software
design
= 127 mm2/m (Asreq) = 181 mm2/m (Aspro)
= 262 mm2/m (Aspro) (H10 – 250mm)
Short span
(H10 – 300mm)
= 72 mm2/m (Asreq)
= 197 mm2/m (Aspro)
= 262 mm2/m (Aspro)
Long span (H10 – 250mm)
(H10 – 300mm)
OK OK
Deflection
(I/d) actual < (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual < (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
8|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Foundation (C17)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
Cracking OK OK
Size of pile cap
1350 x 900 x 800 1350 x 900 x 800
Type of pile
150 x 150 150 x 150
Number of pile
5 pile 5 pile
9|Page
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
10 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Column (C14) (1G, A4)
Type of Design Manual Calculation Esteem Software
Shear reinforcement
H8– 250mm H10 – 100mm
(Shear link)
OK OK
Deflection
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
OK OK
Deflection
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
11 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Foundation P14 C14 (1G, A4)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
Main reinforcement
7H16 – x-axis
(Main bar) 8H16
(1407 mm2)
(1609 mm2)
11H16 – y-axis
(2212 mm2)
Shear
(vertical shear, punching shear) OK OK
Cracking OK OK
Size of pile cap
1350 x 900 x 650 1400 x 900x 650
Type of pile
150 x 150 150 x 150
Number of pile
6 pile 6 pile
12 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Deflection OK OK
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
Deflection OK
OK
(I/d) actual< (I/d) -
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
allowable
Cracking OK OK
-
13 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Column (C43)
Type of Design Manual Esteem Description Difference
Calculation Software (Used) (%)
Shear reinforcement
H8– 250mm H10 – 250mm H10 – 250mm -
(Shear link)
OK OK
Deflection (I/d) actual< (I/d) (I/d) actual< (I/d) - -
allowable allowable
OK OK
Cracking - -
Slab (FS35)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
OK OK
Deflection
(I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable (I/d) actual< (I/d) allowable
Cracking OK OK
14 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Foundation (C43)
Type of design Manual calculation Esteem software
Cracking OK OK
Size of pile cap
1300 x 1229 x 650 1350 x 1229 x 650
Type of pile
150 x 150 150 x 150
Number of pile
5 pile 7 pile
15 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
4.1. SUMMARY
In nutshell, the comparison result between manual calculation and Esteem software are
approximately similar in all section. However, there are some differences in calculation due to the
safety factor for Esteem software more high than manual calculation. During analysis and design
works it involves the manual calculation and several software such as Esteem Plus software and
AutoCAD software. In this design phase, more explanation about software that helps to complete
the design works and a few data information in design analysis. The aim of this phase is to translate
function or process in every components specification of software.
The bill of quantities (sometimes referred to BQ) is a document prepared by the cost
consultant (often a quantity surveyor) that provides project specific measured quantities of the
items of work identified by the drawings and specifications in the tender documentation.
The quantities may be measured in number, length, area, volume, weight or time. Preparing a bill
of quantities requires that the design is complete and a specification has been prepared. The bill of
quantities is issued to tenderers for them to prepare a price for carrying out the works. The bill of
quantities assists tenderers in the calculation of construction costs for their tender, and, as it means
all tendering contractors will be pricing the same quantities (rather than taking off quantities from
the drawings and specifications themselves), it also provides a fair and
accurate system for tendering.
The contractor tenders against the bill of quantities, stating their price for each item.
This priced bill of quantities constitutes the tenderer's offer. As the offer is built up
of prescribed items, it is possible to compare both the overall price and individual items directly
with other tenderers' offers, allowing a detailed assessment of which aspects of a tender may
offer good or poor value. This information can assist with tender negotiations. The priced bill of
quantities will also:
Assist with the agreement of the contract sum with the successful tenderer.
Provide a schedule of rates assisting with the valuation of variations.
Provide a basis for the valuation of interim payments.
Provide a basis for the preparation of the final account
16 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
4.3. Bill of Quantity for the Structure
17 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Bottom Bar (T16)
Ground Beam 1720.8
1st Floor Beam 1720.8
2nd Floor Beam 1720.8
kg 3.65 31404.60
3th Floor Beam 1720.8
4th Floor Beam 1720.8
Roof Beam -
8604
Top Bar (T12)
Ground Floor Beam 1720.8
1st Floor Beam 1720.8
2nd Floor Beam 1720.8
kg 3.54 36549.79
3th Floor Beam 1720.8
4th Floor Beam 1720.8
Roof Beam 1720.8
10324.8
Top Bar (T16)
Ground Beam 1720.8
1st Floor Beam kg 1720.8 3.65
2nd Floor Beam 1720.8
Total 331340.04
18 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
19 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
C Bar Reinforcement
Main Bar T12
Stump 660.42
Ground Floor Column 1294.59
1st Floor Column 1184.67
kg 3.54 23003.91
2nd Floor Column 1184.67
3th Floor Column 1184.67
4th Floor Column 989.26
6498.28
Main Bar T16
Stump 13.15
Ground Floor Column -
1st Floor Column -
kg 58.41
2nd Floor Column - 3.65
3th Floor Column 45.26
4th Floor Column -
58.41
Total 195420.81
20 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
21 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
Total 688399.34
22 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
23 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
CADANGAN MEMBINA DAN MENYIAPKAN BLOK
PANGSAPURI 5 TINGKAT DI KAMPUNG BARU, KUALA LUMPUR
ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT QUANTITY RATE AMOUNT (RM)
Top Bar (Mid. + Distribution)(T10)
Ground Floor Slab 1137.95
1st Floor Slab 1137.95
2nd Floor Slab kg 1137.95 3.54 16113.37
3th Floor Slab 1137.95
4th Floor Slab -
4551.8
Top Bar (Support)(T10)
Ground Floor Slab 1768.15
1st Floor Slab 1768.15
2nd Floor Slab kg 1768.15 3.54 25037.00
3th Floor Slab 1768.15
4th Floor Slab -
7072.6
Total 41150.38
24 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
CADANGAN MEMBINA DAN MENYIAPKAN BLOK
PANGSAPURI 5 TINGKAT DI KAMPUNG BARU, KUALA LUMPUR
BILL A : STRUCTURE
25 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
4.4. Taking off- Foundation
FOUNDATION (PILE)
Excavation, m3
20
0.8 P1
0.8 Pile cap that contains 1 pile
0.4
5.12
64
1.5 P2
0.8 Pile cap that contains 2 pile
0.8
61.44
48
1.5 P3
1.4 Pile cap that contains 3 pile
0.85
85.68
2
1.5 P4
1.5 Pile cap that contains 4 pile
0.95
4.28
7
1.9 P5
1.9 Pile cap that contains 5 pile
1
25.27
5
2.4 P6
1.5 Pile cap that contains 6 pile
1.3
23.4
205.19
26 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
CADANGAN MEMBINA DAN MENYIAPKAN BLOK PANGSAPURI 5 TINGKAT DI
KAMPUNG BARU, KUALA LUMPUR
FOUNDATION (PILE)
Formwork, m2
20
4 P1
0.8 Pile cap that contains 1 pile
0.3
19.2
64
4 P2
0.8 Pile cap that contains 2 pile
0.7
143.36
48
4 P3
1.4 Pile cap that contains 3 pile
0.75
201.6
2
4 P4
1.5 Pile cap that contains 4 pile
0.85
10.2
7
4 P5
1.9 Pile cap that contains 5 pile
0.9
47.88
5
4 P6
1.5 Pile cap that contains 6 pile
1.2
36
458.24
27 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
CADANGAN MEMBINA DAN MENYIAPKAN BLOK PANGSAPURI 5 TINGKAT DI
KAMPUNG BARU, KUALA LUMPUR
FOUNDATION (PILE)
Concrete, m3
20
0.8 P1
0.8 Pile cap that contains 1 pile
0.3
3.84
64
1.5 P2
0.8 Pile cap that contains 2 pile
0.7
53.76
48
1.5 P3
1.4 Pile cap that contains 3 pile
0.75
75.6
2
1.5 P4
1.5 Pile cap that contains 4 pile
0.85
3.83
7
1.9 P5
1.9 Pile cap that contains 5 pile
0.9
22.74
5
2.4 P6
1.5 Pile cap that contains 6 pile
1.2
21.6
181.37
28 | P a g e
Blackfox Engineering Sdn Bhd
Structure Report/Part-4
REFERENCES
Aurich, J. C., Schweitzer, E., & Mannweiler, C. (2008). Integrated design of industrial product-
service systems. In Manufacturing systems and technologies for the new frontier (pp.
543-546). Springer, London.
Chiocchio, F., Forgues, D., Paradis, D., & Iordanova, I. (2011). Teamwork in integrated design
projects: Understanding the effects of trust, conflict, and collaboration on
performance. Project Management Journal, 42(6), 78-91.
Kibert, C. J. (2016). Sustainable construction: green building design and delivery. John Wiley &
Sons.
29 | P a g e
MINUTE OF MEETING 4/2020
DATE: 16 April 2020 (Thursday)
TIME: 9.00 pm
PLACE: Via google meet
Member Present:
1. Muhammad Ruzain bin Hamidon (Chairperson) RUZAIN
2. Kavitha A/P Balekerisnan (Secretary) KAVI
3. Farah Hanim Binti Hanafi FARAH
4. Mohamad Nor Zaini bin Mat Jusoh ZAINI
5. Muhammad Izzul Aliff Han Bin Mohd Fauzan IZZUL
Absent with apologies: Nobody absent in this meeting
NO SUBJECT ACTION BY
CHAIRPERSON ADDRESS
1.0 The chairperson welcomed and thanked to everyone that present. The RUZAIN
chairperson want to see the progress of the project
DISTRIBUTION OF WORK
The chairperson and the board members responsible for the work listed:
2.0 (a) Design of beam ALL
(b) Design of Slab
(c) Design of column
OTHER MATTER
3.0 3.1 Discuss on the esteem application problem (column ALL
failed)
CLOSING
4.0 The chairperson summarized the discussion during the meeting and RUZAIN
thanked to the board members. The meeting was adjourned at 10.30pm
…………………. ………………….
(KAVITHA A/P BALEKERISNAN) (MUHAMMAD RUZAIN BIN
Secretary HAMIDON )
Chairperson