Professional Documents
Culture Documents
if,fsb7 @! yjtv,thb8 @_@_ o8 1164 +9090` TK8AJCNF5 sakresp@mail.ru lf sakresp@top.ge AFCB ! KFHB
3JWYT,BC4 V{FHLFVZTHT,J=
LQTC .DTKFYB UFVJLBS FHXTDYT,BC VTJHT NEHPT
LF CFRFLHBCB GFCE{B UFDWTS VFHSKF UFV.FK,T,TK
JGJPBWBFC MDT.YBCF LF {FK{BC OBYFIT XFLTYBKB
QFKFNBCF LF VPFRDHJ,BCSDBC=
VBIFC GJKBNBREHB WEUWDFYUB
VBPYBS
xtdyt,bc vtjht nehbw xfnfh- fkehb cbt,b erdt lffvnrbwf8 cf[t,7 hjv bcbyb fhxtdyt,bc
lt,f7 fzfhfib rb 2 evfqktcb fhxtdyt,bc vtjht nehbcsdbc vtjht nehib uflfcfnfyb cf-
cf,zjc fhxtdyt,bw8 vtjht ne- cgtwbfkeh cbfib $ _)% fvjv- fhxtdyj .esbc vtidtj,bs vb-
AFHCB= 4
vtjht nehpt fvjvhxtd- yj .esbs vjtv-
kt,c vjtvcf[eht,f !)!$ cffh- cf[eht,f8 uflf-
xtdyj e,fyb7 ufvjyfrkbc itv- cfnfyb cffhxtd-
s[dtdfib itmvybkb ) e,fyb7 yj .esbc vj-
cnfwbjyfhek cfvrehyfkj s[jdybs wtcrjc
RTKB LTUYFYB5 &FKBFY LFLT,BSB lfotct,ekt,t,cf lf bpjkf-
wbfib +rfhfynbyb7 sdbsbpj-
cfntktajyj-cf-
byajhvfwbj
UFVJYF[JY UFVJCFDFKB
&FKBFY lflt,bsb ybifybf7 hjv gfh-
nbt,b rdkfd thsfl veifj,ty lf wlbkj-
,ty ufvjyf[jy ufvjcfdfkb8 dabmhj,7 erb- UTHVFYBBC TKXB5 CFMFHSDTKJC
LFCFRFHUB LHJ FHF FMDC=
lehtcfl lflt,bsb afmnbf7 hjv sfdfl
veifj,ty fvfpt7 2 fvbc itcf[t, cfmfhs-
dtkjib fii-bc tkxvf ;ehyfkbcnt,c uf-
yew[flf8 rtkb ltuyfybc smvbs7 fv cf-
CFMFHSDTKJC lfcfrfhub lhj fhf fmdc8 fh ,fl ufyb[bkfdty bvbc vfubdhfl7 hjv gfhnyb-
rbs[bc uflfzhf fii-bcf lf tdhjrfdib-
itb&kt,f bvbc smvf7 hjv 2 3itb&kt,f fhxtdyt,b jht,b b.dyty ltvjrhfnbek ghjwtcib8 vt vuj-
hbcf cfmvt fh fhbc8
vjvfdfkib ertstcfl xfnfhltc lf ybf7 hjv fvbc ufvj thstek gbhjd-
3tc fhbc mfhsekb gjkbnbrbc kblt-
vfiby vbdbqt, vjyfobktj,fc gjkb- yt,t,c dth lfdflfyfifekt,s7 vfuhfv
ht,bc uflfcfo.dtnb8 bcbyb veifj,ty ufvjcfdkbc &t,yfpt lf
nbreh ghjwtct,ib47 fhfvtl f[kf c[dflfc[df gbhjdyt,t,c c[dflfc[df
xdtyufy fhbc fvbc v[fhlfzthbc cehdbkb bv gbhj,bs7 hjv bcbyb
eylf bveifjc .dtkfv bvbcsdbc7 hjv odkbkb vbe&qdbs fv ufydbsfht,fib8
vpfl bmyt,bfy rjycnhemwbekb lbfkjubc ufcfuh&tkt,kfl47
mdt.fyfib cbnefwbf ertstcb uf[ltc tc eahj fhbc ghjwtcb7 hjvtkcfw
2 fw[flt,c fii-bc tkxb8
lf mdt.fyf ufvjodtdt,c ufevrkfdltc7 sfdbcb ufhrdtekb lbyfvbrf fmdc7 hj-
2 fvbc itcf[t, uthvfybbc tkxvf cf- vtkbw ,tdhc sbsmjc fhw cehc7 vfu-
mfhsdtkjib /e,thn mybhi- hfv tc ghjwtcb sbsmvbc fdnjvfne-
3UFLF.DBHT,F4888
hbc7 3mfhsekvf jwyt,fv4 thsfl vjltc7 hjv lfgbhbcgbht,f lf jgj- dbsfht,fc7 hjvtkibw xdty dbv.jat-
eylf dbveifjs7 bvbcsdbc7 hjv fv pbwbbc euekt,tk.jaf v[jkjl ,bs lf vpfl dfhs7 dbveifjs vfs-
rhbpbcblfy ufvjdblts7 2 ufyfw[f- fqhvfdt,c rhbpbcc8 fvbnjv7 xdty th- sfy thsfl7 hjv gjkbnbrehb rhb-
lf ,flhb ]fafhb&tv tdhjrfdib- sfl eylf dbveifjs7 vfs ijhbc7 pbcblfy ufvjcfdfkb vjb&t,yjc4888
MFHSEKB gjkbnb-
rehb w{jdht,bc lf-
2
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
HFWF DFHS7 TCF DFHS888
888RFHUFL VJVBCVBYTS DFB-GJKBNBRJCT,J= uf.fk,t,fpt hjv cfe,hj,s7 [fk[vf uff.fk,f0
cbhw[dbkbc lthtayt,c fqfh vjdfo.j,sj7 uf- fhf8
vjfw[fltc8 itbo.fktc [fk[b8 vflkj,f eylf ubs[- f,f [fk[bcsdbc cbhw[dbkbc lthtaybc vjo.j,f
hfs vjcf[ktj,fv0 dbc vjqeyek ndbyib lfb,flf7 dbyw uff;qthf7 se
dbyw ufvj[dtlbs7 fh xfdfnfht,sj7 eylf utsm- tctw ufhtlfy itvjult,ekbf0
dfs7 hjv tvb]yt,bs8 ufbuts c[dfj,f0 [fk[b uf&ktds vfylfnc smdtyw7 c[dt,cfw lf gbh-
]th dby [fhs7 hfc ofhvjflutys7 cfpjufljt- dtk flubkpt ufcekb gfhnbbc fvjvhxtdtkc fib-
,fc hjv bodtds lf cfresfh sfdc otcpt7 tsbrfpt yt,s cbhw[dbkbc lthtaybs fy c[df cf[bc fmwbbs0
lf rfyjypt vfqkf f.tyt,s0 cfthsjl7 hjujhw smdtyc sfdc eojlt,s7 ghj-
fy dby udtcfe,ht,bs7 dbyw cbhw[dbkbc lthta- tdhjgekt,b se vtlfcfdktstt,b7 hjujh vjeoj-
yt,ib eylf tnfht,byts [fk[c0= lt,s fy smdtyc7 fy c[dbc vjv[htt,c7 fhxtdyt,bc ,j-
fy % oesbc oby ufgjkbnbrjct,ekb7 ufeut,hj- brjnbcrty0 tcff lfcfdkehb qbht,ekt,f0
,fib vj[dtlhbkt,b hjujh ,tlfds lf fv,j,s7 xf- fhxtdyt,pt eylf vbdbltc .dtkf gfhnbbc vjv[-
dfnfht,s7 fy fh xfdfnfht,sj0= dby [fhs7 hfc ofh- ht lf7 fy ,bektntyb uflf[fpjc7 fy itvj[fpjc vtj-
vjflutys0= dby vjuwfs fvltybc uf,tldbc eakt,f0= ht nehib ufcekblfy ths-thsb8
fy fhxtdyt,bc lqtc7 hjwf levbkbc lqtf7 hj- se gjkbnbrjcj,s7 ufyf gjkbnbrjct,b [fhs0
ujh ,tlfds hfbvt fmwbbc vjo.j,fc0 fy pjubthsb gjkbnbrjcj,fcfw hjujh ,tlfds7
kjubrfcsfy hjujh [fhs0 ufn.j,s vo.hfkfl= smdtyb ofhcekblfy ufvjvlbyfht0
esfhuvybs vjcf[ktj,fc lf
HF FHBC FM CFRJVTYNFHJ0
,thib ufpts 3dtxthyb n,bkbcbc4 aehwkt,pt uf-
vjvtmdt.yt,byf tc vwbht rjvtynfhb5 3flubkj,hbd
cfpjufljt,fc ndbyc e,ehqfdc ghtpbltynj,bc rfy-
lblfnb 3tdhjgekb cfmfhsdtkjlfy4 lfdbs ,fmhf&t8
{vbs ofhvfhsf sfdbcb cbn.df @_!@ otkc cgjhnbc cf- cohfab fqjh&byt,bc abmhj,s7 &dbhafcj vrbs{dtkt,j7 hfc eylf it/
cf{ktib ths-ths obyfcffhxtdyj vbnbyupt s,bkbcbc fvthbrtksf utuvfc8 vfu- gbhltc sfdbcb fhxtdbc itvs{dtdfib ghtpbltynj-
.jabkvf vthvf ubub euekfdfv8 fv]thfl ,qfdbkb hfv cfmfhsdtkj fm hf ,bc rfylblfnb bctsb mdt.ybcf7 hjujhbw cfmfhs-
f{klf .jdtk vbc ufvjcdkfc peulblib7 cflfw vf;j- iefibf0 fk,fs7 ,fnjyb dtkjf7 cflfw v&dbydfht,c eveitdhj,f lf vjcf{kt-
hbnfhj,bc rfylblfnfl b.hblf rtyzc7 b.j tc obyf- {fpfhf&t7 hjwf sfdbc j,bc vtcfvtlb gehbc &bt,fibf8
cffhxtdyj vbnbyub se cfntktdbpbj xfhsdf8 ububc utuvfc cf{tkojlt,fc lf b&ekt,ekbf ew{jtsib ufbmwtc0 gfce{b sf-
fh xfvjhxt,jlyty vbcb .jabkb se lqtdfyltkb sf- ehxtdlf7 vbfybiyt,lf7 dbcbs vjlbc8 bc eylf ittwfljc7 itmvyfc sfdbc mdt-
yfgfhnbtkt,b7 sdbsvfhmdbf 3ghtvbth-vbybcnhb4 ub- hjv sfdbcb uhfylbjpe- .fyfib cfveifj flubkt,b lf cfthsjl7 w{jdht-
jhub dfif&t7 se gfhnbf 3ktkjc4 f{fkodtekt,b 2 kj,bs bub ittcfn.dbct- ,bc bctsb gbhj,t,b7 hfw b&ekt,bs uflfcf{kt-
cfvjdfhbdbs vleqfht ,fnjy cfveibfc nbgbcyfbhyb7 ,f 3vfhikbc utuvfc47 hjvtkvfw ufhlfmvyf tdhjgf8 fv ,ekt,c cehdbkc fqe&hfdc xmfhf lf,heylyty iby8 vfu-
fuhtsdt c{dflfc{df gjkbnbrehb it{tlekt,bc mfk- res{bs itb&kt,f hfvltybw uyt,fds7 bvltyb sfdcfnt{b hfv fhf= 3tdhjgekb cfmfhsdtkjc4 rfylblfnb fqu-
,fnjyt,b7 hjvkt,bw {ibhfl e{fvc rbdbkpt uflflbfy8 vjbujyj7 vfuhfv tyfpt evfk tc c{fhnekf vjuflut- dbsmdfvc7 hjv fhxtdbc itvs{dtdfib ztyt,bs itvjbs-
pjubthsb gjkbnbrjcbc kjubrfib .dtkfathb ,f 2 3cfl thtrkt lf cfl xdtyb rjkvtehytj,bc sfdv- mfheyt,c tdhjgbc mdt.yt,c lf vfs kbltht,ib xfvj-
otchbuib dth fhbc8 gfhnbf 3ktkjc4 gbhdtkvf rfw- ]ljvfhtj48 bvfs{jdht,c rdjnt,c mfhsdtkb tvbuhfynt,bc
vf vfverf {fpfhf&tv cfmfhsdtkjc cfpjufljt,hbd- rbltd thsb cfrbs{b vbylf 3ufdfbfcyj48 dbcvtylb lf ew{jtsib iteath{t,tkb w{jdht,bcf lf veifj,bc-
gjkbnbrehb lf trjyjvbrehb fqjh&byt,bc sfdbc dbcvty kfy&qdf-ubyt,bc bv ybfqdfhc7 hjvtkbw sfdc lf- sdbc8 bjkb ofhvjcflutybf7 hf lftvfhst,f cfmfhs-
utuvfc hfnjvqfw 3vfhikbc utuvf4 eojlf8 vfuhfv hf fn.lf gfhnbf 3mfhsekb jwyt,bc4 kblthc ,b&byf bdf- dtkjc fctsb7 erfwhfdfl gfce{bf7 gjkbnbrbs7 sbs-
lfvjrblt,ekt,f fmdc cfmfhsdtkjc 3vfhikbc utu- ybidbkc7 vbcb bv ufyphf{dbc ufvj7 hjv lf{vfht,jlf mvbc lfnthjht,ekb mdt.fyf hfvltybvt okbc itvltu
vfcsfy47 fy 3vfhikbc utuvfc4 cfmfhsdtkjcsfy0 bc- sfyfvjmfkfmtt,c tdhjgfib cfveifjc ijdyfib lf uf- cfthsjl uferfwhbtklt,f=
vty fsfc]th vjcvtybk 3vfhikbc utuvf7 3vfhikbc utu- vf{ctylf5 cojhtl tc bltf b.j @_!( otkc &bhbsflb yf- cfbynthtcjf7 hjv fhw jhb okbc obyfs7 fhw vju-
vf4 lf sfdc bvndhtd5 hfc eylf ybiyfdltc tc0 fk,fs7 obkb ghtpbltynbc gjcnpt 3tdhjgekb cfmfhsdtkjc4 dbfyt,bs7 lfdbs ,fmhf&bc ghjuhfvbc fv yfobkbc ufvj
,fnjy {fpfhf&tc sfdbcb obyfcffhxtdyj lhjbcf lf rfylblfnbc lfdbs ,fmhf&bc obyfcffhxtdyj ghjuhfvbcf8 rhbnbrbc thsb cbn.dfw fh smvekf8
wtw{kbc lblb yfobkb bmbsrty eylf vbtvfhsf7 hjv vbcb abwbcvfudfhb lfgbht,f vjrkt lf yfstkb b.j5 hj- f{kf rb7 j/j/j/j=
erts ufytvfhnf fvjvhxtdkbcsdbc qhvf fphb7 hjvt- ujhw rb ghtpbltynb uf{lt,f7 bub itvjbdkbc lfcfdkts fctf cfmvt8
kbw fk,fs xflt,ekbf fv utuvbc lfcf{tkt,fib8 wyj- tdhjgbc .dtkf cf{tkvobaj kblthc lf vjqdfotc7 vj- hf fhbc fm cfrjvtynfhj0=
,bkbf7 hjv ]jh] r8 vfhifkb fii-bc .jabkb cf{tk- bgjdt,c bvfs sfy{vj,fc cfresfh mdt.yt,ib cfmfhsdt- DFLBV FYFCNFCBFLB7
vobaj vlbdfyb b.j8 wyj,bkbf bcbw7 hjv vbcb cf{tkb kjlfy ufcnfh,fbntht,bc lfe,hrjkt,kfl itcdkb- cfmfhsdtkjc lfvcf{eht,ekb
tojlf vtjht vcjakbj jvbs lfyuhtekb tdhjgbc cf lf cfveifjpt vjo.j,bc cfmvtib8 ,fnjy ,fmhf&bc ;ehyfkbcnb8
3
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
VLEQFHT SFDT,B
THSB it[tldbs7 sbsmvbc ite&kt,tkbf7 vybidytkjdfyb cnhfntubekb gj- dkbc itvs[dtdfib7 fv-
pbwbt,bc vmjyt7 hfvltybvt fv,bwbehb flfvbfybc gjkbnbrehb yf,b]t,bc uf- fc yfvldbkfl ufyf-
vjsdkf7 itcf&kj vjmvtlt,t,bc cmtvt,bcf lf vjltkt,bc fut,f lf7 fvbc cf- [jhwbtkt,lf8
ae&dtkpt7 hfbvt vjotchbut,ekb /bgjstpbcf lf rjywtawbbc xfvj.fkb,t,f8 vjcf[ktj,bc wy-
sevwf7 \|66 cfereybc byukbcbc htdjkewbbc7 \|666 cfereybc cfahfyutsbc ht- j,btht,fib v[jkjl
djkewbbc7 \\ cfereybc !)!* okbc st,thdkbc htdjkewbbc lf jmnjv,hbc thsb obyfcffhxtdyj
uflfnhbfkt,bc itcofdkbcfc bjkfl itcfvxytdb [lt,f7 hjv bcbyb ufvtjht- itgbht,f +eahj cf-
,fl cwtyfht,c itbwfdty8 \\6 cfereybc athfl htdjkewbt,cfw efvhfdb vcufd- cjofhrdtsbkb s[-
ct,f fmdc cfereybc obyfyltk ghjwtct,sfy7 jqjyl7 sfylfsfyj,bs7 cf[tkv- jdyf‘ fbcf[f 2 ufdei-
obaj uflfnhbfkt,bc ntmyjkjubt,ib fhf&fkflj,hbdb vtsjlt,bc [dtlhb- dfs bdfybidbkb7 vj-
sb obkb vybidytkjdyfl ufbpfhlf lf ghjwtct,b ecbc[kjl7 fy sbsmvbc ecbc- dfks xdty=
[kjl xfnfhlf8 vbe[tlfdfl bvbcf7
hjv jgjpbwbf7 jgjpb-
\6\ cfereybc ief gthbjlblfy uf- wbehb vfcvtlbf7 vfsbdt7 dbsjv 3cfpj-
FHTEKJ,BC VBPYBS
vjxylf hfvltybvt yfihjvbw cf[tkvob- ufljt,hbdb4 jhufybpfwbt,b velvbdfl
aj uflfnhbfkt,bc ufy[jhwbtkt,bc uf/rbdbfy7 hjv fhxtdyt,b njnfkehfl
ntmybrf-ntmyjkjubbc itcf[t,8 hj- uf.fk,lf7 fvbc fh c]thfs sfdfl jgj-
ujhw uflfnhbfkt,t,bc sfyfvtlhj- pbwbbc bv otdht,cfw7 hjvkt,bw fhxtd-
dt stjhtnbrjcb tldfhl kbendfrb yt,ib vjyfobktj,lyty8 vfs bwbfy7 hjv
ITSBS[YBKB AFHCB=
vjudbs[hj,c5 3fv vbvfhsekt,bs lt- 3uf.fk,t,bc4 bcnjhbf fhtekj,bc uf-
nfkehb bycnhemwbt,bc ajhvekbht- vjodtdbc vbpybs itsbs[ybkb afhcbf8
,f vjf[lbyf vtvfhw[tyt kblthvf ,kfy- .dtkf lfvjerblt,tkb cjwbjkj-
rbv7 vfuhfv vbc s[pekt,fc ofhvfnt,f ubehb ufvjrbs[df vbf[kjt,ekbf fh-
fh vj/.jkbf8 ,kfyrbc obyfvjh,tlbc xtdyt,bc htfkeh itltut,sfy8 fhxtd-
uf,hbtk yjlbc yfihjvb ufvjmdt.ylf yt,bc vfcj,hbd uf.fk,t,fc dthw thsb
gfhb;ib \|66 cfereybc ,jkjc8 yjlbc lfvjerblt,tkb lfvrdbhdt,tkb dth
rjywtawbf 2 3jcnfnehb uflfnhbfkt-
,f4 2 b.j ufwbkt,bs dhwtkb7 dblht
cf[tkvobaj uflfnhbfkt,f sfyfvtl-
VBIFC GJKBNBREHB WEUWDFYUB flfcneht,c8
ufpdbflt,ekb lf ghjdjwbht,e-
kb vbptpt,bs7 dbsfht,bc lf&f,dbc lf
hjdt ufut,bs8 [jkj ebkb- cfhqdtdfl7 sevwf udhxt,f rbltd thsb uflfnhbfkt,bc upbs [tkbceakt,fib
fv rbyubc vbth itchekt,e- evybidytkjdfytcb vjvtynb5 fhf&fkf- vjcdkbc cehdbkbc ufvj[fnekt,fv7
kb byukbcehb sfhuvfyb7
cffrfidbkb bv.jat,f ths- lj,hbdb ,h&jkf7 sfdbcb fhcbs7 fhbc cffrfidbkbc vbvfhs eylj,kj,f ea-
!*!! otkc ufvjxylf cfsfe-
hbs 3gjkbnbrehb vjcfp-
udfhb weuwdfyubc gjpbwbf- cfpjufljt,fib lfvrdblht,ekb7 pyt-
j,hbd qbht,ekt,fsf cbcntvfpt lf-
hj ufpfhlf8 fvudfhb enbafhb mvtlt-
,t,b rbltd ths[tk flfcneht,c7 hjv
ht,t,b lbl gjkbnbrfpt ib 2 hf yf,b]bw fh eylf uf- ae&yt,ekb tsbrehb lf cjwbfkehb bub chekt,bs fh yfyj,c [tkbceakt-
lf cf[tkvobaj uflfnhbf- rjywtawbf lf ghfmnbrf7 hjvkbc vb- ,fib .jaybc gthbjlib xfltybk lfyf-
kt,bc [tkjdyt,fpt48 lflufc7 v[jkjl ufbefht- pfybf vjobyffqvltubc fphjdyt,fcf lf ifekt,c lf thsb cekb fmdc vjbgjdjc
cfvoe[fhjl7 ,kfyrbc uh&yj,t,pt fgtkbht,f7 hfsf bc b&e- &fkfeakt,f7 htdfyibc ecfcnbrtcb
lf yjlbc yfihjvt,b by-
ct,c vlujvfhtj,fc8 kt,ekb uf[ltc fqbfhjc jgjytynbc ajhvbs fqcfchekt,kfl8
nthytnbsfw dth vjdb&bt8 +jgjpbwbbc7 obyffqvltuj,bc vj&hf- gbhdtkbdt vbnbyut,vf fxdtytc7 hjv
vtjwt cfereybc vtjht-vtcfvt fso- ,bc ufvj.tyt,bs ufyf[jhwbtktc8 j,bc888‘ vjhfkehb egbhfntcj,f lf fhxtdyt,pt jgjpbwbbc v[fhlfvzthb
ktekib ufy[jhwbtkt,ekb htdjke- fvhbufl7 lhjsf ufyvfdkj,fib uf- vjmvtlt,t,bc cfvfhskbfyj,f8 tktmnjhfnb mexfib ufvjcdkt,c lblb
wbt,bc ntmyjkjubt,bc itcf[t, cfby- vjbrdtsf cf[tkvobaj uflfnhbfkt- cojhtl fv vjvtync dth fy fh bs- tysepbfpvbs fh it[dtlhbf8 lffyjy-
nthtcj yfihjvt,bf rehwbj vfkgfh- ,bc itcfchekt,kfl fewbkt,tkb gb- dfkbcobyt,ty cffrfidbkb lf vbc ah- ct,ekb cf[tkvobaj uflfnhbfkt,bc
ntc 3cf[tkvobaj uflfnhbfkt,bc ntm- hj,t,bcf lf afmnjht,bc cbcntvehb st,c itafht,ekb ufthsbfyt,f8 vjcehyt cffrfidbkb sfdfl cfmfhsdt-
ybrf4 lf fynjybj uhfvibc 3wb[bc hdt- xfvjyfsdfkb7 hjvkbc wjlyfcf lf @__# otkc7 itdfhlyf&bc rktgnjr- kjib fh bv.jat,f7 dthw xfvjlbc lf
ekt,b4 +vtcfvt yfobkb‘8 lfwdfc vbptp-itltuj,hbd se fhf7 rj- hfnbekb vvfhsdtkj,bc gbhj,t,ib7 fhw fgbht,c xfvjcdkfc8 ghtpbltyn.j-
vtjht vcjakbj jvbc itvltu7 htkfwbeh abyfkfvlt vfbyw vbd.f- cffrfidbkb7 tmcwtynhek-fhfjhlb- abkbc xfvjcdkf vbcbdt ueylbc otd-
vcjakbjc uflfyfobkt,bc f[fk cmt- dfhs7 hfw ghfmnbrekfl fhfths[tk yfhekb sdbct,t,bcf lf eyfh-xdtdt,bc ht,bc vybidytkjdfy yfobkc fh cehc8
vfc7 [tkbceakt,bc fhfrjycnbnewb- bmyf lflfcneht,ekb8 vbe[tlfdfl7 v[cytk vptzf,erfl ofh- ufthsbfyt,ekb jgjpbwbbc ufhrdt-
ehb wdkbkt,t,bc 3vjlthybpbht,e- FQYBIYEKB STJHBT,BC VB[TL- vjxbylf8 vvfhsdtkb &fkf vhfdfk- ekb yfobkb7 [vfvfqfkb ufyw[flt,t,bc
kb cfv[tlhj4 ntmyjkjubt,b vj/.df7 DBS7 YT,BCVBTHB [TKBCEAKT,BC hbw[jdfyvf gjkbwbbc rjhljyt,vfw vbe[tlfdfl7 vpfl fhbc vjmvtlt,t,b cf-
hjvkbc e,flkj lbljcnfnbf7 erdt CF>HLTYB OTHNBKT,B &FKFEA- dth b[cytc8 eylf ufdb[ctyjs7 hjv fv rfyjyvlt,kj lfh,fpblfy uffuh&tkjc8
yf[ctyt,b tldfhl kbendfrb7 yfihj- KT,BC ITVLTUB O>FHJT,BF5 EA- gjkbwbtkt,bc [tkafcb bv lhjc (_- jgjpbwbbc gfhkfvtynib itcdkfpt cf-
vbs 3cf[tkvobaj uflfnhbfkt,f8 KT,FVJCBKT,F +KTUBNBVEHJ,F‘7 )_ kfhb b.j7 hjvtkcfw [ibhfl fhw frfidbkbc sfy[vj,fw lf efhbc smvfw
ghfmnbrekb cf[tkv&qdfytkj48 CFRFLHJ HTCEHCT,B7 UFVJWLB- f&ktdlyty lf sfyfvlt,j,bc itcf,fvbc thsyfbhfl lffpfhfkt,c cffrfidbkbc
gjcncf,zjsf cbdhwbc gjkbnbreh KT,F LF WJLYF7 FHFVFNTHBFKE- .jdtksdbeh 3ityfnfyc4 bmbs s[jdl- bctlfw itkf[ek htgenfwbfc8
lfikf-lfyfobkt,bcfc7 ufwbkt,bs HB +ACBMJKJUBEHB7 BLTJKJUB- yty8 3dfhlt,bc htdjkewbbc4 gfsjcb7 [TKBCEAKT,FV FXDTYF7 HJV UF-
lf[dtobkb nbgbc hdjkewbehb cwt- EHB‘ AFMNJHT,B7 VFNTHBFKEHB cfpjufljt,bc c[df yfobkt,sfy th- LFVO>DTN DBSFHT,FIB ITE&KBF LF
yfhb bmyf ufvj.tyt,ekb7 hjvkbc fd- HTCEHCT,B LF CFYMWBT,B +LFC}F‘8 sfl7 &fkjdfyb cnhemneht,bc sfyfv- FMDC EYFHB7 RFYJYBTHT,BC AFHUKT,-
njhb ]by ifhgbf hfvltybvt yfihj- [tkbceakt,bc ufyrfhuekt,fib ihjvkt,bc lblb yfobkbcsdbcfw vjv- IB HFLBRFKEHFLFW BVJMVTLJC8
vbs8 vfsufy &bhbsflbf7 fhf&fkflj,- fhct,ekb ufdktybc +&fkfeakt,bc‘ tc [b,kfdfl ufvjb.eht,jlf8 fvbnjv lf fvhbufl5 cffrfidbkbc [tkv&qdfyt-
hbdb ,h&jkbc bltfpt lfae&yt,ekb tmdcbdt o.fhj7 cfpjufljt,bc v[hblfy c[df vcufdcb vbptpt,bc ufvj7 bjkfl kj,bs vjmvtlb jgjpbwbf dth
cf[tkv&qdfytkj 2 3lbmnfnehblfy v[fhlfzthbc7 vjhxbkt,bcf lf sfyfv- vj[th[lf rjhevgbht,ekb ,behjr- it&kt,c [tkbceakt,bc ktubnbvfwb-
ltvjrhfnbbcrty48 ihjvkj,bc o.fkj,bsff8 hfnbekb fgfhfnbc xfvjikf8 bc tzdmdti lf.tyt,fc9
cfmfhsdtkjib 23dfhlt,bc htdjke- hjltcfw vvfhsdtk cbcntvfc tpqe- sevwf7 /thfrkbnt tatctkbc fh [tkbceakt,fc uffxybf cfrvfj
wbf47 .bhubptsib 3nbnt,bc htdjke- lt,f fy cfthsjl tcgj,f [tkvbcfod- b.jc7 3vlbyfhbc thscf lf bvfdt o.fk- wjlyf lf ufvjwlbkt,f7 oby fqelutc
wbf4 lf @_!_ okbc vjdktyt,b7 fhf,ts- ljvj,f ufdktybc +&fkfeakt,bc‘ tmdc ib jh]th dth it[dfk47 hflufy 3o.f- ghjdjrfwbek vjmvtlt,t,c9
ib 3fhf,ekb ufpfa[ekb47 @_!( okbc lfvjerblt,tk o.fhjcsfy 2 [tkb- kbw c[dff lf ityw c[df [fh erdt48 @_@_ fhct,ekb jgjpbwbehb vj&hfj-
cjv[tsbc htdjkewbf +afibybfybc ceakt,f cecnlt,f lf vbcb lfv[j,f okbcsdbc cfmfhsdtkjib itmvybkb ,bc vjmvtlt,t,bc ajhvf lf ibyffh-
[tkv&qdfytkj,bs‘ lf vhfdfkb c[df cf- bjkflff itcf&kt,tkb8 dbsfht,f rfhlbyfkehfl ufyc[dfdlt- cb dth vjf[th[t,c ,behjrhfnbekb
[fk[j cfghjntcnj vj&hfj,f7 vybidyt- fvhbufl7 sfyfvtlhjdt ntmyjkj- ,f !* okbc obyfyltkbcfufy8 fgfhfnbc xfvjikfc9
kjdfyobkfl7 3[fdthljdfyb htdjke- ubt,bc vb[tldbs7 jgjpbwbfcf lf [t- lqtbcfsdbc cfmfhsdtkjc vjcf[kt- jgjpbwbf dth ufvjb.dfyc mexfib
wbbc4 bltjkjubc ]by ifhgbc fhf&fkf- kbceakt,fc ijhbc ,h&jkf vbvlbyf- j,bc vybidytkjdfyb yfobkbc wyj,bt- [fk[bc lbl hfjltyj,fc9
lj,hbdb ,h&jkbc stjhbbc vtsjlt- htj,c fv &fkeakt,bc ^ o.fhjc vj- ht,fib cffrfidbkbc vvfhsdtkj,bc gt- [tkbceakt,bc ufyrfhuekt,fib
hbjlb fcjwbhlt,f flfvbfybc qbhct- fhct,ekb htcehct,b bctdt bjkfl bm-
,bc itkf[dbc7 cfresht,bc eakt,bc yt,f vbcsdbc [tkvbcfodljvb7 hjujhw
BHVF BYFIDBKB JGJPBWBEH [tk.jabc7 abpbrehb lfcf[bxht,f-uf-
yflueht,bc7 cfcfvfhskj ecfvfhskj-
fhxtdyt,fvlt b.j8
fvudfhfl7 itb&kt,f lblb fk,fsj-
4
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
3DAKJ, RFDRFCBFC4=
5
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
3RJHJYF45 NTCNT,B7 GBH,FLTT,B7 DFMWBYF LF PJUB HFV C[DFW888
HF FHBC PCR-ghjwtcb7 fye gjkbvt- ufyerbs[fj,bc vbvfhs ufvjsmvekb7
hfpekb ]fzdehb htfmwbf 2 tc fhbc hyr- ufyc[dfdt,bs ew[jtkb tmbvt,bcufy lf
c fv ahfuvtynt,bc nhbkbjyt,fvlt [t- cfvtlbwbyj jhufybpfwbt,bcufy7 ]th
kjdyehfl ufvhfdkt,bc7 uf,tdht,bc fhfdbc cvtybf=
ghjwtcb7 hbcb fqvjxtyfw erdt itcf&kt-
,tkb [lt,f8 vfuhfv vbcb ufvjvujyt,t-
kb vtwybthbc vekbcbc PCR-ghjwtcb ve- $8 LFFDFLT,BC SFDBLFY
ifj,c7 fye dfhubcbf v[jkjl lyv-csfy=
fvbnjv7 dbyfblfy rjhjyfdbhecb hyv-bc FCFWBKT,TKB
yfnt[bf7 ]th hyv eylf dfmwbjs lyv-fl7
hfw phlbc ghjwtcbc vwlfhj,fc= ghj,- LF UFDHWTKT,BC
ktvf bvfibf7 hjv hyv/lyv-bc yfnt[t,b7
hjvkt,sfyfw PCR-ghjwtcb veifj,c7 ITVFRFDT,TKB PJVT,B
dbhect,b fh fhbfy= tc e,hfkjl7 hyv-
bc ahfuvtynt,bf7 hjvkt,cfw lfvfnt- 3B>J IBIBC VJYF 2 .dtkfpt efht-
,bsb wbkt,bc ufhtit7 hfcfw 3dbhecbc cb vjyj,ff4=
ufhcb4 tojlt,f7 wjw[fk e]htlib itq- }JI ,BKBYUCB7 \6\ cfereybc
otdf7 3byabwbht,f4 fh ite&kbfs8 PCR- vtjht yf[tdhbc fvthbrtkb vothfkb8
ntcnc dbhecbc fqvjxtyf fh ite&kbf= vfc
v[jkjl dbhecbc vjmvtlt,bc ghjlem- sfdlfgbhdtkfl7 rjhjyfdbhecbcufy
nt,bc fqvjxtyf ite&kbf8 tctw lfvjrb- sfdbc lfcfwfd .dtkfpt ufdhwtkt,ek
lt,ekbf bvfpt7 se hfvltyfl cojhfl lf vybidytkjdyfl vbxytek cfiefkt,f-
ufycfpqdhf abhvfv dbhecbc utytnbre- pt 2 gbh,fltt,pt itdxthlt,b8 hjujhw
hb rjlb lf yerktjnblt,bc +jhufyekb
ityfthst,b7 hjvkt,bw vybidytkjdfy
ITSMVEKT,BC GBHBCGBH
.jabsb ntcnt,bc itlfht,bsb vjyfwt-
vt,b vjvojlt,tkb abhvt,bclf+=‘ vb[tl-
dbs8 fhw tc byajhvfwbf fh cf]fhjdlt-
,f=‘8 lfdeidfs7 hjv abhvfv cojhfl ufy-
cfpqdhf yerktjnblt,bc sfyvbvltdhj-
,f7 itvltu 2 PCR-ghjwtcb PCR-wbrkt-
6
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
GFYLTVBBC N.DTJ,FIB
qhvf vj[ewt,c7 bct 2 !_ okbc7 pjufy7 @ ceysmdbc itvltu7 yf[ibhjh;fyubc rjy-
+=‘ okbc ptvjs ,fdidt,cfw9 hjujhw by- wtynhfwbf !_ ___ ppm-vlt flbc= vhfdfk- CFDFKFKJ WBAHT,B
ntycbehb abpbrehb dfh]bibs lfrfdt- hbw[jdfyb rdktdt,bs lflfcneht,e-
VCJAKBJIB rjhjyfdbhecbc itltufl ufhlfwdkbksf hbw[dvf vbkbjy
,ekt,c7 bct 2 cffsj,bs fdnj,ecbc fy kbf7 hjv /fthbc ervfhbcj,bc7 sfd,he[-
vfymfybc +nfmcb‘ cfztcsfy v]ljv v&qj- dtdbc7 lfqkbkj,bc7 e.ehflqt,j,bc #^_ fsfcc uflffzfh,f8 ukj,fkehb gfyltvbbc lhj f[fkb nbgbc rjhjyfdb-
hecbs %* vbkbjyb flfvbfyb lfbyabwbhlf7 hjvtksfufy sbsmvbc $_ vbkbj-
kt,cfw +tc xdtysfyfwff‘= fh itb&kt,f lf c[df cbvgnjvt,bc ufvjvodtdb vbpt-
xdtyvf vtlbrjc-xbyjdybrt,vf fh bwjlyty pb fhbc fhf ;fyu,flbc ervfhbcj,f7 fvfc yb ufvj]fyvhstklf8
]fylfwdbc vcjakbj jhufybpfwbbc wyj,bs7 gfyltvbbc tgbwtynhb f[kf td-
gbh,flbc nfht,bc7 ufycfresht,bs rb7 tuet,f ]fyvhstkb rfwbc jhufybpvb fr-
[fyuh&kbdb+=‘ nfht,bc efh.jabsb7 cf- kbvfnbpfwbbc upbs +vfufkbsfl7 vsf- hjgff7 cflfw dbhecb f[fkb itvs[dtdt,bcf lf ufhlfwdkbksf hbw[db vfne-
kj,c8 cfahfyutsib ,jkj @$ cffsib dbhecbs $@) flfvbfyb lfbqegf7 bnfkbfib
ibib+=‘ v[fhtt,b +b[8 mdtvjs‘8 bv afmnt,bc ib fcdkbcfc‘7 fhfvtl 2 yf[ibhjh;fyubc
itcf[t,fw eylf vjt[ctyt,jlts7 hjwf cbzfh,t7 hfcsfyfw ituet,f fhfdbc fh fvfdt gthbjlib rjhjyfdbhecc ^%# gfwbtynb ittobhf8 f[fkb itvs[dtdt,bc ht-
rjhlekb phlff gjkjytsib7 cflfw ,jkj lqt-qfvtib dbhecbs @# fsfcpt
fvthbrfib7 xbytsib lf c[dfufy gbh,flb- &fke&c7 vbs eahj7 fcfrjdfy flfvbfyt,c
fyb v&qjkt,bw lfbqegyty lf 2 abpb- lf ,fdidt,c7 2 vfs e[ibhlt,fs htcgb- vtnb flfvbfyb lfbyabwbhlf8 ]fylfwdbc vcjakbj jhufybpfwbfib tdhjgbc
vjcf[ktj,fc fahs[bkt,ty7 hjv vjvltdyj tmdcb sdt hsekb bmyt,f lf vje-
rehfl vjdfh]bit vjcofdktt,bw8 gbh- hfnjhekb byatmwbt,b lf fcsvbc it-
,fltt,bc ufvj ctmntv,hbc sdtib crj- ntdt,b9 cfahfyutsib rb lfflubytc7 hjv ojlt,ty fnfhjy gbh,flt8 hsekb dbsfht,ff fii-bw7 cflfw dbhecbc itlt-
ufl ufhlfwdkbksf hbw[db @%_ fsfcc fcwlf8 cgtwbfkbcnt,vf vjeojltc vj-
kbc vjcofdkt cfvb ujujyf +cek gfnfhf7 !# ofvib ceysmdbc lfo.t,blfy fgfhfnb
^ okbc7 crjkbc fdnj,ecib‘ lfbqegf ajhvfklt/blbc lf njketybc +bubdt mfkfmtt,c7 vflkbtht,bc lqtc vjupfehj,bcufy sfdb itbrfdjy7 hfsf dbhe-
cb rbltd eahj fh ufdhwtkltc8 rfkbajhybbc infnib rb fv emvtt,blfy qf-
uthvfybfib8 hfvltyflfw dbwb7 xdtyb fd- njkejkbc‘ lfuhjdt,bc vfybiyt,tk
nj,ect,bc hdf v&qjkbw ite&kjl it- cbuyfkc b&ktdf8 vbc rjvtylfynbc cffsb fvjmvtllt,f8 hfw itt[t,f xdtyc cfvtpj,kjc7 fpth-
,fb]fyib ,jkj lqt-qfvtib dbhecc @# flfvbfyb tvc[dthgkf8 lfbyabwbhlf
bmyf bdkbcbc sdtib7 hjwf w[dbh-gbhlf- #‘8 vfnekj,c cbc[kbc oytdf lf bs-
afhekt,c cffsj,bs vje[lfs gfgfyf- hueyt,f bveyehb cbcntvf7 hfw ufycf- @%__-pt vtnb8 sehmtsib @$ cffsib dbhecb rbltd $@!% flfvbfyc lfelfcnehlf8
ufhlfbwdfkf !@# gfwbtynb8 hsekb dbsfht,f hxt,f hectsib7 cflfw ,jkj
mt,f cbw[tib veifj,f8 hjltcfw gbh,flt resht,bs cfahs[bc itvwdtkbf htcgb-
w[dbhcfw afhfdc lf gbhcfw lf7 sfy cf- hfnjhekb fy uekbc lffdflt,t,bc vmj- vjyfwtvt,bs7 byabwbht,eksf hbw[dvf jh vbkbjyc uflffzfh,f8
[tcfw vzblhjl trdhbc7 bub .dtkf7 gbh- yt flfvbfyt,bcsdbc8
,flbc vfnfht,tkb bylbdblbcsdbc cf- eylf fqbybiyjc7 hjv gbh,fltt,bc .JDTK !* OFVIB RJDBL !)-BS
THSB FLFVBFYB BQEGT,F
ibibf +w[flbf7 egbhdtktcfl 2 fdflv.j- nfht,bc vjv[htt,blfy fhfdby7 fhw vt-
at,bcsdbc7 vj[ewt,bcsdbc lf gfnfhf lbrjct,b7 fhw ]fylfwdbc cfvbybcnhjc
,fdidt,bcsdbc‘7 vfuhfv vfc rfnfcnhj- ofhvjvflutykt,b lf fhw gjkbnbrj- TDHJGFIB rjdbl !) .jdtklqbehfl eghtwtltynj vfcinf,t,bs dhwtk-
aekb itltub itb&kt,f vj/.dtc7 serb ct,b ptvjs xfvjsdkbk gbh,flbc efh- lt,f8 cnfnbcnbrehb fyfkbpbc sfyf[vfl lflubylf7 hjv .jdtk !* ofvib td-
vfymfybc fy7 vbs eahj7 fdnj,ecbc v&qj- .jabs v[fhtt,pt [vfc fh bqt,ty7 cbn.- hjgbc rjynbytynpt thsb flfvbfyb bqegt,f rjdbl !)-bcufy8 ufcek rdbhfc ufh-
kb uf[lf welfl= vt ibibs de.eht, nfm- dfcfw rb fh &hfdty= lfwdfkt,bc @) ___ itvs[dtdf lflfcnehlf7 hfw afnfkeh itvs[dtdfsf !( ~-
cbc fy fdnj,ecbc v&qjkc7 dbcfw w[db- gbh,fltt,bc bhudkbd tc byajhvf- bfy phlfc ofhvjflutyc8
hbw lfafhekb fmdc8 cf,tlybthjl7 evt- wbf vjcf[ktj,bc cfrvfj yfobkbcsdbc vcjakbjib cek ! #^^ ___ flfvbfybf lfqegekb rjhjyfdbhecbcufy7 hj-
ntcj,fv vjndbyf7 hjv gbh,flbs ufvjo- wyj,bkbf lf7 fvbnjvfw bvfhst,f vf- vtksfufy #$_ ___-vlt itvs[dtdf tdhjgfib abmcbhlt,f8 fqybiyek rjynbytynpt
dtekb ceysmdbc uf&ytkt,f vfc rfhuc cj,hbdb cfghjntcnj vfybatcnfwbt,b vjcf[ktj,fsf evhfdktcj,fc fyfkjubeh gbhj,t,ib eotdc w[jdht,f7 hj-
fhfathc vjenfylf lf sfdfl vjbabm- tdhjgbc cf[tkvobajt,ib7 hjvkt,cfw ujhw tc @_@_ okbc vfhncf lf fghbkib [lt,jlf8
hf w[dbhbc ufysfdbceakt,f7 gbh,flbc ofv.dfyb vtlbfcfiefkt,t,b sbsmvbc fh ufdhwtkt,ekb byajhvfwbbs7 ev&bvtcb vlujvfhtj,ff cfahfyutsib7 cf-
gbhpt xfvjotdf8 pju fdnj,ecib7 vfqf- fiemt,ty8 cfvfubthjl7 gbh,flbc ufhtit lfw byntycbehb sthfgbbc gfkfnfsf )% ~ erdt uflfndbhsekbf lf tmbvt,b
pbfib se c[dfufy cgtwbfkehfl ufvj- cf[kblfy ufvjcdkbcsdbc itvjbqtc ]f- lfvfnt,bs rhbnbrek vlujvfhtj,fib v.ja gfwbtynt,c dth bqt,ty8
.jabkb [fk[b +ntvgthfnehbc vpjvt- hbvt,b 2 %_ tdhjlfy +uthvfybfib‘ ! ___
,b lf cfltpbyatmwbj [cyfht,bs [tkbc
lfvveifdt,tkyb‘ itybidyt,c f&ktdty
tdhjvlt +bnfkbfib‘8
f[kf7 cfyfv gbh,flbc lflt,bs v[f- CTH,TSBC GFNHBFHMB
vfs7 dbcfw w[dbhptw fh ertsbf gbh,flt8
lf7 fv lhjc fhw v&qjkt,c lf fhw vf-
htptw dbn.jlts hfvtc +,eyt,fib [jv
.dtkfathc jhb v[fht fmdc‘7 hjujhw db-
RJHJYFDBHECBS
qfpbt,bc sfyfvihjvkt,c .jdtk @-# cf-
fsib fhfdby fvfhfut,c f[fk-f[fkb gbh-
hecbcufy 3sfdlfwdbc cfertstcj cfie-
fkt,fpt4 vfyfvlt7 ]th rjhjyfdbhecbc
UFHLFBWDFKF
,fltt,bs8 fhflf7 cojhtl fctf htrjvty- ufdhwtkt,bc upt,pt eylf dsmdf jlyfd CTH,TSBC vfhskvflblt,kehb trktcbbc
lt,ekb ]fyvjc vbth7 hflufyfw ceys- eahj lfodhbkt,bs lf7 rfhufl ufvjx- [tkv&qdfytkb7 gfnhbfhmb bhbytjcb rjhjyfdbhe-
mdbcufy lfyfvek lf s,bkb gbh,flbc ylt,f7 se hjujh udbwfdc fy fh udbwfdc cbs ufhlfbwdfkf7 2 fvbc itcf[t, byajhvfwbfc ,hb-
ptlfgbhpt efvhfdb dbhecb lf ,fmnt- gbh,flt8 nfyekb vtlbf mdt.ybc ghtpbltyn fktmcfylh de-
hbf uhjdlt,f lf7 thsb gbh,flbc it- lffdflt,bc ufdhwtkt,f +thsvfyt- xbxpt lf.hlyj,bs fdhwtkt,c8
ewdktkfl7 cffsj,bs nfht,fv lfwdbc sbcsdbc uflfwtvf‘ fbh-odtsjdfyb upbs 3gfnbdb vmjylf7 hjv itysfy ehsbthsj,f vmj-
yfwdkfl ereitltub itb&kt,f ufvjb- [lt,f7 fye bv evwbhtcb i[tat,bs7 hfw yjlf8 ityyfbhb flfvbfyt,b fhfcjltc vblbfy4 2 ufyfw[flf dexbxvf sfdbc by-
qjc +pfa[ekbc cbw[tib vjveifdtsfs- [dtkt,bc lf wtvbyt,bc7 yfrkt,fl 2 kf- cnfuhfv udthlpt8 )_ okbc cfcekbthj gbhc rjhjyfdbhecb $ yjtv,thc lf-
dbc rb 2 .jdtk @_-#_ oesibf vfsb wdkf gfhfrbc lhjc ufvjb.jaf8 itlfht,bs elfcnehlf7 vfc ,tkuhflbc cfv[tlhj cffdflv.jajib vrehyfkj,lyty7 sevwf
cfzbhj7 fye lff[kjt,bs !^ +=‘ gbh,f- lblb odtst,b vjvtynfkehfl bktmt- jhufybpvvf dth ufe&kj byatmwbbc vbvlbyfhtj,fc lf ufhlfbwdfkf8
lt lqtib‘7 sfy7 fhw yf[vfhc fuhjdt,c ,f7 [jkj fthjpjkbc cf[bs ufvj.j-
fhfdby cgtwbfkeh ehyt,ib +hjujhw abkb7 fye evwbhtcb odtst,b7 vwbht vf- GFYLTVBFV TGBCRJGJCB
,bjkjubehfl cfibi vfcfkfc=‘7 lf7 w[f- cbc ufvj7 hfvltybvt oesblfy yf[tdfh
lbf7 fv fhfhct,ek ehyt,cfw fhfdby cffsfvlt &kt,ty /fthib8 fmnbehb db- BVC[DTHGKF
fyflueht,c= hect,b !-@__ vbrhjvtnhbc +vbkbvtn-
OVBYLF cbyjlbc otdhb lf ,jh]jvbcf lf ,f-
cfae&dkbfyflff itcofdkbkb gbh,f- hbc vtfsfctlb yfobkb‘ pjvbc odtst,- rehbfybc tgbcrjgjcb kfpfht +cfvfl,tubidbkb‘
lbc [fyuh&kbdfl nfht,bc c[df efh.j- ibf vjmwtekb7 o.kbc vjktrekt,bc uf-
ufhlfbwdfkf8 cfgfnhbfhmjc cfpjufljt,fcsfy eh-
absb v[fhtt,bw +gbh,fltcsfy7 fct htit dbhecb /fthib dth &kt,c= vfhsf- sbthsj,bc cfvcf[ehbc [tkv&qdfytkbc7 ltrfyjp
dsmdfs7 vbthst,ekb ;fyu,flbc7 yf[ib- kbf7 bub itb&kt,f fqvjxtybk bmyfc yt-
fylhbf ]fqvfb&bc smvbs7 tgbcrjgjcc c[df sfyv[-
hjh;fyubc lf njmcbrehj,bc ufyv- ,bcvbth ptlfgbhpt7 vfuhfv erdt ltfm- kt, lffdflt,fcsfy thsfl rjhjyfdbhecb /mjylf8
cfpqdhtkb fgfhfnehbs‘5 nbdbht,ek fye ecbwjw[kj vlujvf-
UFVJ}FYVHSTKT,EKB FLFVBFYB
!‘8 xfceysmek /fthib mdtbslt,f ;fy- htj,fib7 hjvtkcfw ufvhfdkt,f fqfh
u,flbc itvwdtkj,f 2 ;fyu,flbc yjh- ite&kbf lf7 fvbnjv7 cfibihjt,fcfw
7
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
.FK,B LTVJRHFNBF
[tkf[fkb sdkbc ghjwtcb uh&tklt,f lf cf- ,bc lfvgeht,kfl7 vfsb gjkbnbrehb fv,b-
NHFVGBC lfevjhxbkt,kj,f lfvqegdtkbf fii-bc lt- ,jkjj lfcrdyf ufvfh]dt,ek-lfvfhw[t,e- wbt,bc vjvotchbut,kfl 2 fvthbrtk ]fhbc-
vjrhfnbbcsdbc8 ghtpbltynbc vbth lfvfhw[t,bc fhfqbfht- kbc sfj,fpt jabwbfkehfl fh ufvjew[f- rfwsf vbth ufqt,ekb cbc[kbc afcfl8 vfs
,f lf fhxtdyt,bc itltut,bc ufghjntcnt,f bodtdc fii-bc lt,bfs 2 nhfvgb ghtpbltynbf8 .dtkf itv- fvthbrf eylfs sfdbfysb sfdbcsdbc8 vfs fh
s[dtdfib bc stsh cf[kib vjvfdfkb okbc eylfs c[dbcsdbc vjvfhsekb fvthbrf8
bvb]bc itkf[dfc vstk vcjakbjib8 htcge,kbrtkt,vf ey- @_ bfydhfvlt bmyt,f7 fye byfeuehfwbfvlt8 nhfvgb lf nhfvgbpvb bc vjdktyff7 hj-
lf itbuyjy7 hjv fhxtdyt,ib lfvfhw[lyty7 lffhoveyjy ght- itvltu lfe,heylt,f sfdbc cfmvtc 2 ,bp- vtkcfw ,fbltybc js[okbfyb gfepf dth it-
pbltynb lf fsmvtdbyjy vfc fqbfht,bc yfyfnhb cbn.df888 ytcc7 vfuhfv uffuh&tkt,c dth,fkeh fytkt,c7 dth uffathvrhsfkt,c8 leqbkb
,h&jkfc ltvjrhfnt,bcf lf ,fbltybc ob- lfo.t,ekbf7 hfcfw elfdjl vj/.dt,f wdkb-
ltybc sdfkt,bc cbkfvf- yffqvltu8 kt,f8 [tlfdc fvfc vcjakbj7 vfs ijhbc xdty0
pbs fh b.j ufvjodtekb7 ,fbltybc $-okbfy ghtpbltynj,fc dtzdj,7 hjv [tlfdltc=88
ltvjrhfnsf lfgbht,f nhfvgb cbwjw[ktc ufevofht,c7 bct7 hj- vcjakbjpt fhfathb vjuf[ctyjs7 vfu-
b.j vsfdfhb 2 se ufudf- ujhw nhfvgbc $-okbfy vvfhsdtkj,fc uf- hfv cfmfhsdtkj hjv dth [tlfdc7 afmnbf8
vfh]dt,byt,s7 fii-bc vj- evofhf cbwjw[kt ltvjrhfnbekvf gfh- jgjpbwbbcf lf vfspt vbnvfcybkb cfpjuf-
mfkfmtj,f ufhfynbht,e- nbfv lf bcnt,kbivtynvf8 cbcntvfv dth ljt,bc mvtlt,blfy ufvjvlbyfht7 cfcbrtsj
kb utmyt,fs8 buef nhfvgb 2 cbcntvbcufy udthlpt vluj- fh xfyc8 bctsb ituh&yt,ff7 sbsmjc ths fl-
lfdevfnjs fv erfyj- vb ,bpytcvtyb7 fhf bvbnjv7 hjv vbkbfhlt- ubkfc ufdb.byts lf se hfqfw vj&hfj,fc
yj,fc cf[tkufysmvekb hb lf ,bpytcvtybf7 fhfvtl bvbnjv7 hjv df[th[t,s7 v[jkjl erfy8 fhflf #_ otkbf7
3rfhectkt,b47 .fk,b ,b- cbcntvbc cfobyffqvltuj cehdbkt,b fmdc8 hfw yfyfnh 3lfvjerblt,kj,fib4 dbv.jat-
ektntyt,b7 cffhxtdyj lqblfy stsh cf[kib itcdkbcf bc cbc- ,bs 2 bcts 3ltvjrhfnbekib47 hjujhw
e,yt,pt htcge,kbrtk ntvfnehfl fw[flt,lf 2 3dfibyunjybc zf- xdtyc cnhfntubek gfhnybjhc fmdc8
lfvrdbhdt,tksf fhlfi- j,bc4 lfihj,fpt7 yfnjlfy ufvjcdkfpt7 vfdfyb vtn.dbc7 hf ufto.j,f7 fctsbf gf-
dt,f7 ajcnbc v[hblfy tdhjrfdibhbc ececehj,fpt7 fdqfytsb- nfhf mdt.yt,bc ,tlbj8 xdty hjv 3gfnfht-
LFF[KJT,BS fvudfhb vjojlt,t,b udtc- ,b4 dfhs7 cbf[kt fh fhbc8 vcjakbjib 3gf-
BV ITWLJVFC
vbc cfghtpbltynj fhxtdyt,ib 3ufvfh]dt,e- nfht,b4 ,tdhbf7 ufwbkt,bs vtnb7 dblht
kb4 ltvjrhfnbekb gfhnbbc rfylblfnbc 3lblt,b48 jqjyl 3gfnfhfj,fv4 vfs c[df hfv
]j ,fbltybc ,fyfrblfy lf fhf vfhnj8 ufy- fcofdkf 2 zref-ujyt,bc mdt.ybc cfcfhut,-
cfresht,bs fmnbehj,c .jabkb ghtpblty- kjl nhbfkb9 cfqb7 ghfuvfnekb7 ujybdhe-
LQTVLT DBVRBS=
nb ,fhfr j,fvf7 hjvtkbw bct7 hjujhw .j- kb uflfo.dtnbkt,t,bc vbqt,f9 htfkehb
dtksdbc7 vjmvtlb ghtpbltynbc ljyfkl w[jdht,bc ujybdhekb fqmvf lf fhf dbh-
nhfvgbcflvb v&fahb rhbnbrbs ufvjlbc8 ob- nefkehbc htfkehfl ofhvjcf[df8 fhfht-
yfcffhxtdyj vfhfsjyib vfy thsj, fmnbe- fkehbc lf dbhnefkehbc vbvfhs sf.dfybc-
hb v[fhlfzthf ufvjfdkbyf vbcb .jabkb db- wtvfv hf vjenfyf xdtyc vtpj,tk gfnfhf cjv-
wt-ghtpbltynbc ,fbltybc vbvfhs8 j,fvf bct [tsc7 cek f[kf[fy db[bkts 2 vofht cbvfh-
sfdlflt,bs ufvjlbjlf ,fbltybc v[fhlfv- skt7 vfhw[b8 ijhtekbs7 dbhnefkehbs7
zth ltvjrhfnt,bc sfd.hbkj,t,pt7 sbs- fhfhtfkehbs ufnfwt,fv ufvjbodbf tc lf
mjc bc .jabkb.j ghtpbltynj,bc rfylblf- cfresfhb [fk[bc efphj [jwdf-;ktnf8
nb lf fhf ,fbltyb8 lfcfdktsib ufodhsybkb cjv[tsbc kb-
js[b okbc ufyvfdkj,fib ghtpbltyn lthb lf vbcb ueylb7 [tkbceakt,fib 3at-
nhfvgbc v[hblfy obyfvjh,tlb j,fvfc cbcnt- hflb htdjkewbbc4 upbs vbcekb7 lfcfdkt-
vfnehvf rhbnbrfv7 [ibh itvs[dtdfib kfy&qdf- sbc vjsf.dfyt lf vjbvtlt7 actdljgfnhb-
ib uflfcekvf7 3cfystk-cfrvtdtkb4 fh lfrfh- jnbpvbs uf,het,ekb7 zjuhbnbc it,he-
uf lf vtjs[t okbcsfdpt7 w[tk cffhxtdyj vf- yt,ekb v[fhblfy vtpj,kt,bcf lf cfresfhb
hfsjyib bxbyf sfdb8 nhfvgpt lf,jqvbkvf ghj,ktvt,bc itv.eht7 cf,tlbcothj yf,b]c
j,fvfv uflfkf[f .jdtkudfhb gjkbnrjhtm- lufvc7 hbsfw cfresfh sfdcfw lf mdt.fyf-
nekj,bc obstkb [fpt,b lf sfdlfdbo.t,bs cfw ev&bvtc dbsfht,fib f.tyt,c8
trdtsf vbc vkfy&qdtk ghtpbltync 2 dbsfhwf 888@ okbc ufyvfdkj,fib cjv[tsb fynbhe-
cf&ekdtk cfereyjdfy vnthc8 tctw fhfcfcb- lfidt,ekb efvhfdb itwljvt,b lf vbdbqt,s lfy ]fhbc ufvj.dfyfpt7 vcjakbjib fvt- cekb ghjgfufylbc ,eltl bmwf8 ufxylf he-
fvjdyj cbf[ktf fvthbrbc gjkbnw[jdht,fib8 itltuc7 hjvtkcfw dthfahbs deojlt,s lt- hbrbc ;fylfhvj,blfy [tkbc fqt,fpt7 c[df cekb cfv[tlhj ,fpt,bc cfobyffqvltuj kj-
ghtpbltynj,bcsdbc vt,h&jksf vjrhfnbekc7 ufvzdbhdfktc7 ceasfc8 bcts stvt,pt7 hjvkt,bw fvthbrbc /tutvj- peyut,b8 crjkt,ib fbrh&fkf hecekb tybc
,bko ithrbyt,fc v[fhb fe,f 3dbht,bcf4 lf ltvjrhfnt,c fh vjcojys htcge,kb- ybpvbc v.fhb cfae&dtkbf= cofdkt,f8 thtdfyib uf[ibhlf fvthbrtkb7 td-
3cgbkjt,bc4 fvjvhxtdtkvfw7 sfy bctsb rtksf cb]bent 2 ,bektntyt,bc ufyvtjht- lf fhf vfhnj fv,j,lf7 frtst,lf rb- hjgtkb7 yfnjtkb vfqfkxbyjcyt,bc dbpb-
vfcinf,bs7 mdt.ybc bcnjhbfc hjv fh f[- ,bsb uflfsdkbc vjs[jdybc ufvj8 vfs fhw ltw lf hjv cf,jkjjl fh vbtqobf sfdb- nt,b8 ghfuvfnekfl vjfphjdyt cjv[tsvf7
cjdc8 gbhdtkb ltvjrhfnsf cbv,jkjf7 vt- bc vjcojys7 hjltcfw nhfvgb cf]fhjl cb vbpyt,bcsdbc7 cbcntvfv 2 xtvb fphbs7 lfcfdkehb dfmwbybs uf,het,ekvf7 lfrfhuf
jht 2 htcge,kbrtkt,bc8 gbhdtkc v[fhb fw[flt,c uf.fk,t,bc sfj,fpt7 fvbnjv ght- &bhvjvgfkvf7 vfuhfv ]thfw vatsmfdvf7 upf xdtekb cba[bpkt7 htfkj,bc ituh&yt,f lf
*$ vbkbjyvf lfezbhf7 vtjhtc 2 *!-vf8 pbltync offhsdtc vtlbfib cbn.dbc sfdb- uflfertnf 2 $ okbs ufb[fyuh&kbdf fh- fpth,fb]fysfy vjkfgfhfrt,fc jvb fv]j,b-
gbhdtkb vtnb gjgekfhj,bs cfhut,- ceakt,f8 cfrvfhbcbf vfy fhxtdyt,bc uf.fk- ct,j,f8 yf7 w[flbf lfcfdktsbc bvtlbs8
kj,c ku,n-c otdht,ib lf v[fhlfvztht,- ,t,fpt lfbo.jc kfgfhfrb7 hjv ntktofv.- jhfl uf.jabkb fvthbrf 2 thsb it[tl- cfvoe[fhjl7 .jdtkbdt tc xdtyc ef[-
ib7 nhfycdtcnbnt,ib7 thsyfbhcmtcbfysf dfyb evfk thsdt,f cbn.dt,bs 2 cbvfhsktc dbs nhfvgbc mfjnehb vvfhsdtkj,bs it- kjtc ofhcekc vfujyt,c7 jqjyl thsb
j]f[t,bc itmvybc vcehdtkt,ib7 athflrf- fh ittatht,f8 oe[t,ek-ufvjqdb&t,ekb7 dtqfh uf/.dt,f ufyc[dfdt,bs 2 lfvfhw[t,bs uf,hfpt,e-
ybfyt,ib7 ktc,jctkt,ib7 vwbhtokjdfysf mdt.fyf7 cflfw ghtpbltyncfw eotct,ty lqtvlt fhct,ek7 vfuhfv nhfvgbc vbth cf- kb cjv[t,b7 cbcntvfnehb vbnbyut,bs lf
vbth cmtcbc itwdkbc ghjgfufylbcnt,ib7 wtypehfc7 cflfw ntkt;ehyfkbcnb sfdc cbrdlbkjl lfzhbkb cbcntvbc vbth itmv- fynbcfvsfdhj,j ufvjcdkt,bs vjbs[j-
utb-gfhflt,bc xfnfht,bc v[fhlfvztht,ib eakt,fc f&ktdc ghtpbltynbc cbn.df ufo.- ybk w[jdht,fc 2 vjxdtyt,bs ltvjrhfnb- dty ghtvbth afibybfybc uflflujvfc lf gf-
dbnjc 2 ltvjrhfnbekfl fh xfbsdkt,f8 fv fc7 cbwhetc7 afhbcbdtkeh qbvbkc 2 fii- ce[bcut,fib vbwtvfc8 xdty rb7 @__( okbc jv-
2 rjycthdfnjhsf fphbs7 .dtkf uflfmfyt-
ib lfvfhw[t,ekb [tkbceakt,f lf ght-
,ekib7 rfwj,hbj,fc uflfityt,bs hjv lf efvhfdb c[df fhfltvjrhfnbekb mvtlt- bc ntkttrhfyt,blfy uflvjqdhbkc7 fvthb-
,bs ufvjhxtekb 3dbht,b4 +ltvjrhfnbekb rekb w[jdht,bc otcbc vjhtrkfvtc8 pbltynb lfdbwfdbs7 lfvfhw[t,f7 ufvfh]-
tvemht,f=88
dt,fl ufvjdfw[flts
ufycfresht,ekb v[fhlfzthf buh&yj- gfhnbf‘ lf vfsb kbltht,b vjbs[jdty htc- *! vbkbjy nhfvgbc fvjvhxtdtkc c[df fvt-
lf gfhkfvtynbc oby
,jlf fhfktufkehfl vw[jdht,sf v[hblfy8 ge,kbrtkb nhfvgbcufy fhxtdyt,ib lfvfh- hbrf eylf7 bctsb7 vlblfhcf lf qfhb,c ij-
wtrdf-sfvfib vjdfo.-
vfsb hfjltyj,f7 jabwbfkehb vjyfwtvt- w[t,bc fqbfht,fc7 obyffqvltu itvs[dtdf- hbc eacrhekc hjv fvjfdct,c8 vfs sdfk-
dts8
,bs7 !! vbkbjyc fzfh,t,c7 fhfjabwbfkehbs ib fii-bc ltvjrhfnbek ufydbsfht,fc pb- ib sfdbclfeyt,ehfl vbkbfhlthb nhfvgb7
bv itwljvfc lqt-
2ufwbkt,bs vtnc8 fhxtdyt,vf lfudfyf[f7 hjv fyb vbflut,f7 bct7 hjujhw vbc bvb]c vstkc c[df vbkbfhlthsf obyffqvltu vt,h&jkfl
vlt dbvrbs=
fii-b fqhbw[dbfyj,f vjbrjzkt,c8 lfcnehb vcjakbjib8 bmwf 2 cfiefkj lf lf,fkb atybc mjvfufl7
fvbcf cfbmbjib v.jasf [vt,bf 2 fsfcj,bs fii-c cfghtpbltynj fhxtdyt,vf lffh- lfvcfmvt,kfl7 cjwbfkehb gbhj,t,bc uf- /FVKTN
bmfehvf v[fhb ,fbltyc lfezbhf8 oveyf vcjakbj bvfib7 hjv fv mdt.fyfib cfm- vfev]j,tct,kfl7 cfresfhb mdt.ybc ghj,- ZBGFIDBKB7
fhfktufksf tcjltyb fmnbehj,f ,fb- vt dth fhbc rfhufl8 dblht ,bektntyt,bc ktvt,bc vjvudfht,kfl lf fhf c[df mdt.yt- GJKBNJKJUB8
3DAKJ, RFDRFCBFC4=
hfw itt[t,f hectsbc ufhtit7 lfvjerblt,kfl vjm-
8
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
CBN.DF 2 VBPFYIB
/BVYB FHXTDYT,C
9
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
CGJHNB
&KTDFB CFRDBHDTKB CEVJ
LFLT,BS ,FKFYCSFY
KTRDB
MFHSDTKVF cevjbc-
nvf ktdfy ujhuf&tv +nj-
xbyjibyb‘ yjtv,hbc ,f-
ijpt vt-!# ,h’jkf uf-
COJHBF888
ijpt lflt,bsb ,fkfycbc
lfcf,tdt,kfl lfhxtyb-
kb jhblfy thsb it[dtl-
hbc vjut,fqf czbhlt,f8
VFIBY7 hjwf mfhsdtkb df;t,b cfby- ueiby vbcb jgjyty-
afhmnj vfnxt,bs 3udfyt,bdht,ty47 xdty- nb vtcfvt vftufibhf
vf mfk,fnjyt,vf uvbhekb ufvfh]dt,bs jrbyejvb b.j7 hjvtk-
ufudf{fhtc8 vfw lblb obyffqvltuj-
cfe,fhbf ubjhub x{fb&bc ufodhs- ,f ufeobf mfhsdtkc7
ybk 3kfyx{espt47 hjvtkvfw xtvgbjy- sevwf7 bjhbrbhbc bk-
sf kbufib cnevhfl hevbytk 3rke;c4 tsbs vfbyw lfvfhw[lf8
!5_ c&kbf lf vtstmdcvtntlabyfkib njxbyjibybc vjv-
bsfvfit,c +3jmhjc4 ujkb ^(-t oes- ,thc vjto.j,f7 sdbs vfnxt,b rb )-!_ ltdyj vtnjmt lqtc rf-
pt {fnbf z.jybfv ufbnfyf‘8 lf !%-!^ ltrtv,thc ufbvfhst,f8 bctb bmyt,f8
vjhbub tnfgbc rtyzbc.hf @^ yjtv- ,T;FY LJKB&T VFYEXFH UBJHUF&T
RJDBLBC SFY{KT,BS
ktdcj7 bctsb cfxem-
ht,b ufdertsts5 TDHJ,FCRTNB
xhlbkjts vfrtljyb-
fc ufbcfl evfqktcb HJUJHW vjut{ctyt,fs7 rjhjyfdbhecbc gfylt- kt,c lfdegbhbcgbhlt,bs8
cfpjufljt,bc abyf- vbbc ufvj tdhj,fcrtnbc cfrdfkbabrfwbj hfeylbc ituf{ctyt,s7 hjv bkbfc
keh hfeylib tmyt,f it{dtlht,b vbvjcdkbc yfwdkfl ths-thsb vjyf- pehjcbc ueylc abyfkehb
lt,benb7 yfjvfhb obkt mdt.ybc cfh,btkpt itrht,fc bsdfkbcobyt,c8 tnfgbc cfupehb7 hjujhw vj-
cjv{tsb rb 3,4 lbdb- vfdfkb ajhevbc ths-ths
pbjyib fqptdlf= jhufybpfnjh mdt.fyfc7 erdt
cjv{tsb 2 xhlb- ufyfqlt,ekb fmdc lf lf-
kjts vfrtljybf !5_8 cf{tkt,ek rdfhntnc jhb
cf,jkjj vlujvf- ufvfh]dt,bs kblthj,c7 sf-
htj,f5 cjv{tsb 2 !!7 yfw st,thdfkib lfutuvbkb
bcb dflfvlt lftvidblj,f ,bzt,c8 xhlbkjts vfrtlj- vjhbub 3afy]hbc4 vbqt,fptw
pjub fmwtync ckjdfrb cgtwbfkbcnbc cfhtrjhlj ybf 2 )7 cfmfhsdtkj fw{flt,c ghtntypbfc8
2 {esokbfy vjqdfotj,fcf lf fv gthbjlib vbcb {tk- 2 *7 tcnjytsb 2 # me- lfd&tys7 hjv lfndbhse-
v&qdfytkj,bs 3]dfhjcfysf4 vbth ufvfhsek $* vfnxpt kf8 kb uhfabrb fmdc ab,fc thsf-
frtst,c7 vfuhfv bvfc rb fqfh fv,j,ty7 cffvf.j hf lfu- hfw itt{t,f ,j,j- lths mfhsdtk rjvbcfhcf lf
dbnjdf mfhsdtkt,c8 se fctsfl tcgfytssfy fv{fyfueh kt,c7 nbnekbcsdbc ntmybreh ltktufnc vthf,
sfvfiib vjgjdt,ek ofhvfnt,fc xfdesdkbs7 vfiby fh b,h&jkt,ty cfahfy- hfnbidbkc7 hjvtkbw 3f4 lf
]j,lf7 vfibydt7 ufvfh]dt,ekbc cnfnecbs lft{ehf utsb7 tcgfytsb7 ,tk- 3t4 ]ueat,bc sfvfit,c vjtv-
melb lf sfdfotekb qbhctekfl ufud.hjlf0 fct {jv ubf lf bnfkbf7 {jkj cf{eht,f8
fhfthsb vbcb rjktuf vjmwtekf lf vfs lqtcfw rtsb- 3f4 lbdbpbjyib lfob- fv;fvfl xdtyb sfyfvtvfvekt
kfl b{ctybt,ty8 yfehlyty fdcnhbf7 xt- fqybiyekb ajhvfnbc itcf,fvbcfl7 cfmfh- cf,th&ytsbc rey&ek rhtnfpt
fct hjv7 nehybhbc lfcfo.bcib etafc .jabk ght- {tsb7 eyuhtsb lf sdtkj7 abytsb7 cth,tsb lf idtbwfhbf 3,f,kbc4 bv.jat,f7 cflfw mfkfm bhfr-
pbltyn vbitk gkfnbybcflvb ufvjsmvekb vflkbtht,f7 etkcb8 ghbywbgbs cejvbc mfkfm tcgjjib ufvfhsfdty kbjyib mfksf tdhj,fcrtnbc
hjvtkvfw f{fkb rjynbytynehb ajhevbc lfae&yt,bsf UBJHUB IJSF&T ]ueaehb nehybhbc it{dtlht,c7 cflfw @( yj- itcfhxtdb wbrkbc yfrht,t,b
tv,thc vfcgby&kt,c7 {jkj #_ yjtv,thc ytbn- fhrdtdty ehsbthsj,fc8
hfkehb fkgehb cf{tkvobajc ofhvjvfluty- DBNFKB ]FAFHB&T
HDF THB
CFSEJ VTJS{T KTUBJYTHB
LQTC cfmfhsdtkjc thjdyekb yfrht,b itvjlujvbc thsf sfcpt vtjht vfnxc etk-
csfy mfkfm /kfyt/kbib ufvfhsfdc8 fqybiyekb it{dtlhbc gbhlfgbh htgjhnf;c 3nt-
ktbvtlb4 @! cffsblfy lf !% oesblfy itvjudsfdfpt,c8
fvfcj,fib rjhjyfdbhecb ab]bc ueylbc ths,fifl @)+=‘ vjhfu,tc lfelfc-
PTLBPTL VT[EST
VJCRJDBC wcrf xbyt,ek rjylbwbt,- pecnfl bchjkf8 itltufl7 vbcb vfh-
nehlf7 hbc ufvjw vbcb lf bnfkbbc ,h&jkf ufemvlf lf7 bctdt hjujhw neh-
ybhbc cnfhnpt ahfyut,sfy7 rey&ektkt,c fv]thflfw ntmybrehb ofut,f xf- ibf lf tdhjkbufib ptlbptl vt[est uf- ub mvtlt,bc rjtabwbtynb v[jkjl #-
tsdkt,fs fyufhbibs _5@(8 vfh]dt,f vjbgjdf7 sevwf7 bubdtc dth c ufenjklf8
ajhcvf;jhbc ufsdfkbcobyt,bs7 &ytkb cfsmvtkbf7 hfvltyfl cohfafl ufvj- dbn.dbs sjhybrt ityutkbfpt8 mfhsdtkb wcrfib cfertstcjt,b ybrjkf vb-
]fyvhstklt,bfy rjdbl-!)-bcufy v&bvt ajhdfhlb hecek uhfylib fqybi- kenbyjdb +!( mekf7 !@ vj[cyf‘ lf vf-
byabwbht,ekt,b lf it&kt,ty yek tnfgpt firfhfl xhlbkibf8 br ]tbvcb b.dyty +@% mekf7 @ vj[cyf7 @
se fhf bcbyb yjtv,hbc ,jkjc fhvbtkt,b vbey[tyib 3,fbthyc4 tc- gfcb7 # xfzhf‘7 3,fbthyib4 rb ]fkty ht-
]ueaehb hfeylbc abybipt nevhyty lf gbhdtkb nfbvbc itvltu # byjklcb +!( mekf‘ lf etbl ,tkldb-
ijnkfylbfcsfy ithrbyt,fc8 mekbs fut,lyty7 vfuhfv vtcfvt lf vt- yb +!) mekf‘ ufvjbhxyty8
se bcbyb dtqfh uffuh&tkt- js[t gthbjlt,b vjbutc lf ofhvfnt- wcrf fv ufvfh]dt,bs cojhtl 3,f-
,ty fcgfhtpj,fc7 fk,fs7 fvbs ,fw bptbvtc 2 ()5(!8 bthyc4 ufesfyf,hlf +* vjut,f7 # of-
3,jh]qfkjcfysf4 utuvt,bw sjhybrt ityutkbfv v[jkjl !) oe- ut,f‘ lf uthvfyek rke,sfy vtjht-vt-
itbwdkt,f7 hflufy7 cfdfhfe- sb bsfvfif7 [ctyt,ek lhjib rb ^ me- cfvt flubkt,c b.jac8 vjvltdyj neh-
ljl7 xdtyt,eht,c cojhtl ab- kf7 # vj[cyf7 ! gfcb lf ! xfzhf vbbsdf- ib lbvbnhbc bnelbcbc ueylb @^ yj-
]tkt,sfy vjeotds vt-* flub- kf8 mfhsdtkvf ktubjythvf #-lfy ! tv,thc vjcrjdib vflhblbc 3htfkc4
kbcsdbc ]f{b8 jhmekbfyb lf %-lfy $ cf]fhbvj xf- lfe[dlt,f8
RJ,F RJ,F{B&T fulj7 [jkj jh]th cfvmekbfyb fhf- HJCNJV HFZDTKBIDBKB
10
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
CEKSFSFYF
CFYSTKB
qhvf voe{fht,bs beo.t,bfy lf sfyfeuh&yj,ty ufvjxtybk cf{tkvobaj lfht]fy tkbf&t7 vb{tbk leylef j]f{t,bs elbltcb uekbcnrbdbkbs
vjqdfotc7 qbhctek vfvekbidbkc7 egbhdtktc vtuj,fhc uehfv ueyfdfc &dbh- beo.t,bfy f{kj,tkb flfvbfybc7 rtsbkij,bkt,bs lf cfsyjt,bs ufvjhxte-
afcb vteqkbc kb gbhjdyt,bc
YFYEKB V{TB&T-UEYFDFC
t,bfy lf sfyfuh&yj,fc ew{flt,ty qbhctek vfvekbidbkcf lf ertsbkij,b-
ktc flfvbfyc7 ,fnjy uehfv ueyfdfc &dbhafcb vteqkbc
ufhlfwdfkt,bc ufvj8
yfyekb +yfyf‘ ueybf j]f{bs cfv&bvfhc ew{flt,c ,fnjy uehfv ueyfdfc vt-
SBYF ]QFVF&T7 WBEHB SJHLBF7 JSFH ZBSFYFDF7 ,JYLJ eqkbc
YFYEKB V{TB&T-UEYFDFC
]BMBF7 RKBVTYNB ]FY]QFDF7 ,FREH UEKEF7 HFEK XBKFXFDF7
PEHF, UJUJ{BF7 DF;F ABABF7 ]TVFK RDBHNBF7 DFKTHB
ZFYNEHBF7 LTVBRJ KJKF&T7 KFEHB ]FYFIBF7 KTHB
ZBSFYFDF7 NFHBTK LUT,EF&T7 LTVEH UFLTKBF7 VTHB ZBSFYFDF7 ufhlfwdfkt,bc ufvj8
FYPJH ZBSFYFDF7 YJLFH IFHNFDF7 STYUBP IFYFDF7 STVEH
CEHUEKF&T7 IFMHJ ZBSFYFDF7 VEHVFY YFZ.T,BF7 UBDB CJCTKBF7
FDSFYLBK ,TCTKBF7 VFVERF RDFHFW{TKBF7 YEUPFH VJKFI{BF8 cjcj mjbfdf7 hj,thn zfynehbf7 ubf rewbf7 ubf mj,fkfdf voe{fht,fib sf-
yfeuh&yj,ty ,fnjy uehfv ueyfdfc vteqkbc
dbnfkb {fpfhf&t7 ltveh ufltkbf7 gtnht ,thfbf7 stveh rfkfylf&t7 tkbp-
,fh kjvbyf&t7 cgfhnfr mj,ekbf7 ,tcbr rbkfcjybf7 pfeh fvbkf{dfhb7 df{nfyu
rbryf&t7 cfvdtk vfhcfubidbkb7 yjlfh pfpf&t7 hjvfy rdfzf&t7 ]fv,ek oekfbf
YFYEKB V{TB&T-UEYFDFC
ufhlfwdfkt,bc ufvj8
j]f{t,bs sfyfeuh&yj,ty ef{kjtc vtuj,fhc uehfv ueyfdfc cf.dfhtkb vt-
eqkbc7 qbhctekb mfk,fnjybc
YFYEKB V{TB&T-UEYFDFC
fo ufhlfwdkbkb hjvfy rbpbhbfc vteqkt kbf flfvbf j]f{bs voe{fht-
,bs sfyfeuh&yj,c ,fnjy uehfv ueyfdfc vteqkbc
ufhlfwdfkt,bc ufvj8
YFYEKB V{TB&T-UEYFDFC
cfpjufljt,f peulbltkbc cf{tkbs jsfh afwfwbf7 ,jylj ]bmbf7 vehvfy ufhlfwdfkt,bc ufvj8
yfz.t,bf7 behb ueuexbf7 sfvfp wfyfdf7 ubdb cjctkbf7 rfhkj dtref7 df;f ababf
uekbcnrbdbkbs beo.t,bfy7 hjv ufhlfbwdfkf ecfsyjtcb7 rjk{b mfkbc ufy-
cf{btht,f7 cfjwhfl s,bkb lf vjcb.dfhekt vteqkt7 ltlf lf ,t,bf7 v{tb&tt- fo ufhlfwdkbkb styubp rfkfylf&bc vteqkt ajsjkf rfkfylf&t j]f{bs
,bc cf{tkjdfyb udfhbc qbhctekb vfylbkjcfyb sfyfeuh&yj,c ,fnjy uehfv ueyfdfc vteqkbc
YFYEKB V{TB&T-UEYFDFC
voe{fht,fib v.ja hfbjybc cfgfnbj vjmfkfmtc7 ,fnjy uehfv ueyfdfc vteqkbc
11
1 !^$8 IF,FSB7 @! YJTV,THB7 @_@_ OTKB8
GFYJHFVF
RJDBL-!)-BC DFMWBYF LQTCFCOFEKB
IFD ,FPFHPT B.BLT,F RHT,F OVBLFSF VSFDFHFYUTKJPSF
3NEW YORK TIMES4 bc wyj,bs rjhjyfdbhecbc cfobyffqvltuj VBMFTKBCF LF UF,HBTKBCF LF C{DFSF
dfmwbyf xbytsib erdt ifd ,fpfhpt b.blt,f8 vbe[tlfdfl bvbcf7 hjv
vcjakbjib fhct,ekb dfmwbyt,b ]th rbltd cfntcnj ht;bvibf lf OVBLFSF E{JHWJSF PTWBCF &FKSF SAKARTVELOS
jabwbfkehfl vbcb uf.bldf fh lfo.t,ekf7 xbytsib afhvfwtdnek RE S P U B L I K A
rjvgfybt,sfy lff[kjt,ekb gbht,b vfbyw f[th[t,ty vbc uf.bldfc8 @! YJTV,THC cfmfhsdtkjc ovblf
dfmwbybc afcb ^__ ljkfhblfy bo.t,f lf !%__-vlt flbc8 dfm- vfhskvflblt,tkb cfvjwbmekj tr- DF:F AIFDTKFC 148
wbybc vbcfqt,fl vjcf[ktj,f cffsj,bs lufc hbuib8 bc js[b ktcbf lqtcfcofekj,c vsfdfhfyut- NTK5 @#)-_#-$#
dfmwbyf7 hjvtkcfw lqtc vcjakbj udsfdfpj,c7 ]th rbltd kjpsf 2 vbmftkbcf7 uf,hbtkbcf7 ehb-
rdktdbc vtcfvt afpfibf7 vfuhfv gtrbyb vfbyw vjbs[jdc ght- tkbcf7 ctkfabtkbcf7 tuelbtkbcf7 ,f-
gfhfnbc cohfa ufvjidt,fc888 hfmbtkbcf +fctdt bthjvbtkbcf lf vsfdfhb htlfmnjhb
nf{ybtkbcf‘ rht,bc {ctyt,fc8
888flfvbfyt,b qdsbc yt,fc fyutkj- CGFHNFR MJ,EKBF
3CFMFHSDTKJC
ghjtmnb tdhjgbc cfbydtcnbwbj ,fyrbc abyfycehb v[fhlf-
zthbs ufy[jhwbtklf lf vbcb qbht,ekt,f lff[kjt,bs !8#
.JDTKUDFHB HTRKFVF vbkbjyb kfhbf8
ghjtmnb bsdfkbcobyt,lf cfat[vfdkj ,bkbrbc vjo.j,fc7 HTCGE,KBRF4
UFPTSC /FTHBDBS CZBHLT,F= cfpjufljt,hbdb cfgbhafhtijt,bcf lf fdnjcflujvbc vit-
yt,kj,fc8 ITYB UFPTSBF7
FEWBKT,KFL
ufyfsfdcts htrkfvf .dtkfpt cfzbhj lf cfylj uf- cbjybc nf&hbc cfvjyfcnhj rjvgktmcib flubkj,hbdb lf
ew[jtkb nehbcnt,bc lf vjvkjwdtkt,bc hfjltyj,f vel-
ptsib lf fvbs {tkb iteo.dts !_@ okbc .jdtklqb-
UFVJBOTHT7 HFCFW
vbdfl vfnekj,c7 vjyfcnthsfy fhct,ekb byahfcnhemnehf
ehb ufvjwtvbc fqjh&byt,fc8 rb dtqfh frvf.jabkt,lf ufphlbk vjs[jdyfc8 ghjtmnbc lfc-
FM OFBRBS{FD7
hekt,bc itvltu rb chekfl vjotchbulf nehbcnekb bya-
xdtyb fyufhbibf5 1GE19TB7601536020100009. hfcnhemnehf7 hfw htubjyib nehbpvbc ufydbsfht,bcsdbc
12