Tabel 1.

Luaran Fisik (nadi, durasi rawat, penilaian nyeri)

Nomor Penulis Jurnal Jumlah Sampel apa Jenis penelitian Hasil EBM
Sampel rekomendasi
10.1186/s1 Seiiedi-Biarag L, Italian 6 128 Systematic Massage terapi menurunkan LOE 1A
3052-020- Mirghafourvand M Journal of studies preterm Review gastric residual volume dan
0818-4 Pediatrics infants muntah pada bayi premature.
10.3389/fp Liu Z, Gang L, Frontiers in 23 RCT 2005 Systematic Infant massage dapat LOE 1A
ubh.2021.6 Yunwei M, Lin L Public infants Review RCT meningkatkan frekuensi defekasi
63581 Health dan menurunkan gejala konstipasi
pada anak dengan konstipasi
fungsional.
10.1186/s1 Gao L, Jia C, Huang BMC 26 2644 anak Meta-analysis Mendukung pediatric massage LOE 1A
2906-018- H Compleme studies dalam mengobati diare akut pada
2324-4 ntary and anak.
Alternative
Medicine
10.1016/j. Tuba Koç Complem 149 Term Randomized Acupressure and massage were LOE 1B
ctim.2019. Özkan, Didem ent Ther neonat neonates Controlled effective in reducing pain in
08.004 Şimşek Med, 2019 e with 2500- Trial neonates during the heel lancing
Küçükkelepçe, Se 4000 g procedure.  Acupressure and
miha Aydin body massage techniques can be
Özkan  weight applied for procedural pain
management in the newborn
10.1097/N Tondi M. Effects of 60 Term Randomized Postoperative massage may LOE 1B
NR.00000 Harrison, Roger Massage infants infant with Controlled reduce pain and improve
00000000 Brown, Travis on CCHD Trial physiological parameters in
459 Duffey, Corrie Postopera between 1 infants with congenital heart
Frey, Jacob tive Pain day and disease.
Bailey, Marliese in Infants 12 months
Dion Nist, Lauren With
Renner, Jill Fitch Complex
Congenital
Heart
 Disease

10.1111/js Duygu Gözen, J Spec 90 Term Randomized Abdominal massage is effective LOE 1B
pn.12237 Özge Eda Yılmaz, Pediatr infants infants Controlled to reduce bilirubin levels of
Şadiye Dur, Nurs. Trial newborn infants
Sabiha Çağlayan, 2019
Ayhan Taştekin
10.31838/sr Hamidreza Sys Rev 80 Term Randomized Massage is one of the cost-free LOE 1B
p.2020.9.13 Khoshnezhad Pharm infants infants Controlled and simple solutions to reduce
1 Ebrahimi, Soroor 2020 Trial pain in infants
Sohrabi,
Shabahang
Jafarnejad,
Saeideh
Iranmanesh,
Somayeh
Esmaeilian

Tabel 2. Hubungan Ibu-Anak

Nomor Penulis Jurnal Jumlah Sampel apa Jenis penelitian Hasil EBM
Sampel rekomendasi
10.26911/t Hartanti AT, Salimo Indonesian 120 ibu dan RCT Baby massage efektif LOE 2B
heijmed.20 H, Widyaningsih V Journal of anak usia meningkatkan perlekatan dengan
19.04.02.1 Medicine 3-6 bulan ibu dan durasi tidur dan efektif
0 menurunkan jumlah dan durasi
terbangun saat tidur
10.3389/fp Porreca A, Parolin Frontiers in 20 Usia 2-7 Correlational Peningkatan signifikan dalam LOE 2B
 syg.2016.0 M, Bozza G, Freato Psychology mother- bulan study interaksi ibu-anak
2049 S, Simonelli A children

Tabel 3. Luaran Pertumbuhan dan Perkembangan (berat badan, inteligensi, kemampuan belajar pengetahuan)

Nomor Penulis Jurnal Jumlah Sampel apa Jenis penelitian Hasil EBM
Sampel rekomendasi
10.1097/N Badr LK, Abdallah The 34 Prematur Meta-analysis Massage terapi dapat meberikan LOE 1A
MC.000000 B, Kahale L American studies kenyamanan pada bayi di NICU
000000017 Journal of untuk meningkatkan berat badan
7 Maternal/C dan perkembangan mental.
hild
Nursing
10.1016/j.i Taheri PA, Goudarzi Infant 44 Bayi Case control Massage tubuh jangka pendek LOE 2B
nfbeh.2017 Z, Shariat M, Behavior healthy prematur dengan minyak bunga matahari
.11.002 Nariman S, Matin and selama 5 hari meningkatkan berat
EN Developme badan bayi prematur dan
nt menurunkan durasi di NICU secara
signifikan
10.1016/j.c Lu LC, Lan SH, Compleme 15 Premature Systematic Massage terapi meningkatkan LOE 1A
tcp.2020.1 Hsieh YP, Lan SJ, Lin ntary studies neonates Review berat badan harian dengan 5,07
01168 LY, Chen JC Therapies gram/hari.
in Clinical
Practice
10.1111/js Xiaoning Zhang, J Spec 112 Preterm Randomized Preterm infants who underwent LOE 1B
pn.12238 Jun Wang Pediatr infants infant with Controlled the two‐week massage
Nurs 2019 GA 32-34 Trial intervention had higher mean
weeks weight, height, and head
circumference
 10.1111/jo Heeyoung Kim, J Clin 55 premature Randomized Enteral feeding improvement LOE 1B
cn.13850 Kyoung sook Nurs, infants infants Controlled massage can be helpful for
Bang 2018 with GA < Trial achieving earlier full enteral
34 weeks feeding, more increased
superior mesentery artery, and
faster growing
 
10.5539/gj Lusiana Gultom, Global 34 Term Randomized There were significant LOE 1B
hs.v11n10 Renny Sinaga, Journal of infants infants Controlled differences in suckling durations
p142 Kandace Sianipar Health Trial and body weight of the babies,
Science, after giving infant massage.
2019
10.17159/ Hanifarizani, Indian 30 Term Randomized After four weeks of massage, LOE 1B
2310- Rahma Dian; Journal of infants infants Controlled the weight, length, chest
3833/2021 Silvani, Yulia; Public Trial circumference and head
/vol51n1a Gayatri, Mergy; Health circumference increased among
6 Permadi, Research babies aged 3 to 6 months who
Prasetya Ismail & received stimulation of baby
Developm massage. Overall, the results of
ent, 2020 this study reassure that baby
massage affects the growth of
the infant

Tabel 4. Luaran Psikososial (cemas, depresi, insomnia, takut, kemunduran perilaku)

Nomor Penulis Jurnal Jumlah Sampel apa Jenis penelitian Hasil EBM
Sampel rekomendasi
10.1590/15 Rodriguez-Mansilla Revista 7 Anak 6 Systematic Efek terapeutik massage pada anak LOE 1A
18- J, Gonzalez- Latino- articles bulan – 18 review kanker dengan kemoterapi dan
8345.1774. Sanchez B, Torres- Americana tahun terapi lain menunjukkan
2903 Piles S, Martin JG, de penurunan dalam nyeri, mual,
Jimenez-Palomares Enfermage muntah, stress post trauma,
M, Bellino MN m depresi, cemas dan peningkatan sel
 darah putih dan neutrophil.
10.31080/ Nurry Acta 60 Term Randomized Massage’s therapy is effective LOE 1B
ASPE.201 Ayuningtyas Scientific infants infants Controlled to increase sleep quality, in
9.02.015 Kusumastuti Paediatric Trial infants aged 3-6 months.
s, 2019