Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J8/
.- i
t I
..
. ,
'·.\ \\:_~\;;·Iii·'
·.NEW DELHI
<\ ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.l25/2Ql7
In the matter of:
COURT ON: IT$ MOTION .... APPLICANT
VERSUS
STATE OF KARNATAKA .... RESPONDENT
INDEX
Sl. No. Particulars Pages
1 Compliance report for the on;lers of 2-1 B.>_,
th<;! Hon'ble NGT during its h~arin~
on 21.~0.2019 in respect of OA z_l~6
No.l25/2017 along with supporting
affidavit '
I I
• . • ? .•...
\ ...
7 Annexure-7: Copy of work order .,.... ;2.-Z-o ~ .-
',_
_,
\ ~. ~ issued by AEE(SWM,
\ ·~\ Mahadevap1,1ra Divn. Dtd.
"16.11.2019
8 Annex1,lre~8:. Copy of Work order ,_,.z_ 2 oct -
dt. 11.11.2019
9 Annexure"9: True translated copy _ 21Lo $ -
. from Kannad t.o English clt.
16.03.2019
10 Annesure-10: .Copy of office order '2:2.-c G...:.2-2..o1-
dt. 19-03.:-2019
11 Annexure-11: .Copyof . ... Fore$t, 2.-i.o g -22-11
Ecology & . . Environment
Secretariat N otificc;~.tiqn · · dt.
19.01.201($
. I
.. .. .
Based on the above recommendations and in line with the action Plan submitted to the committee
on30.07 .20 19, BBMP has taken steps to comply \vith the requirements as detailed below.
r-----··---·------- ------ -
Recommendations/ Particular of the
suggestions/ views ·of works with Status of
Direction/ order No. the Committee headed completion dates the work/
Sl.
19 (1)and 19 (2) of by Hon'ble Justi_ce as per the action as Remarks of BBMP
No NGT N.Sathosb Hedge in its committee report on
report. dated 15\.11.2019
dated :20.09.2019 :20.09.2019
1. I 19 (4) No further It is recomrriend~d that I Maintenance of . I Ongoing The concretization of SWD is avoided
channelization and no further narrowmg and Storm water dram in all Big Rajakaluves having width
concretization of concretization of R~ja more than 4.00 mtrs. However, due
Rajakaluves. Kaluves_ (storm water to development/ construction of
drains) should be allqwed buildings by side of Rajakaluves, the
to ensure the hydrologic retaining walls are unable ~o
function of natural withstand the exterior pressure. At
drains (percolation ··of these points after technical
water, remediation, etc.) verification 'U' shaped drain is being
~
NOT may kindly issue constructed, with intermediate
___ !______ I orders in this regards. pervious section LJ:!s>les in the form
' NGT may kindly issue constructed, with intermediate
II orders in this regards. pervious section / holes in the form
of circular openings for enabling
recharge of ground water. where
I· wi~th of _the land . available for
i . •i
1
1 RaJakaluve 1s less than 4.0 m .
I Channelization of Storm water drain
is being avoided in the outskirts of
the city and natural flow of the
Rajakaluves is allowed, especially the
downstream flow Df Vrushabhavathi
Valley, Challaghatta Valley, Hebbal.
Valley and Kormangala Valley.
.2. 6 {a} The authorities In spite of directions no 1. Survey of . BBMP has As per the directions of Ho·n 'ble NGT
must conduct a survey survey of 30 meter buffer Buffer zone requested and in . resportse to request oiThe
in the buffer zone of zone around the lakes around the the Chief Engineer lake Division Bruhat
the lake to identify the have been done and also lakes 30 Commission Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
encroachments and not marked on the meters along er Survey (Enclosed as Annexure 1 )for
appropriate exercise ground. Hence, the the Lake settlement conducting survey of Bellandur,
should be undertaken extent of encroachment Boundary and Survey Varthur, Agara Lakes for demarcation
to remove them. for the prohibited and Record to of Buffer zones and also to identify
activities/work maintenance demark the the encroachments within the buffer
/structure could not be ofthe same Buffer zone zone area, The Joint Director, Survey
assessed in the butTer in the three Settlements and Survey Records vide
zones of all lakes. The lakes. in his letter dated 21.11.2019 has
NGT may kindly take 2. Removing of submitted a detailed map prepared in
note of it and issue encroachme co-ordination with Karnataka State
order to BBMP and nt around Remote Sensing Application Centre{
Revenue Department to the lake and KSRSAC} demarking the lake
complete the work in maintenance boundary and 30m buffer zone from
three months and report of trees and the lake boundary along with details
compliance. plants. of the structure within the 30m of
buffer zone. The letter dated
~
21.11.20 1'9 of The Joint Director,
Survey Settlements and Survey I
Records ,is( enclosed as Annexure
- .... ~.
2),Details of encroachments of
structure within 30m buffer zone
(Satellite image by KSRSAC) with
regard to Bellandui- and . _vari:hur
lakes is enclosed as Annexure3,4
and map is enclosed as Annexure
5,6.
It may kindly be ri.oted
that the · Hon'ble High As per the Hon'ble High Court :
Court vide dated direction WP.3840 l /20 14datcd
18.06.2019 in 18.,06.2019.
. .- The Storm
. .. Water
WP.38401/2014 have Division BBMP has identified
directed to State . 2626encroachments· on Storm Water
Government to survey Drain and 1409 Nuq1bers of
storm water drains and encroachments have been removed as
then follow up of eviction on 15-11-2019.
of encroachments. The
outcome of the survey to
be carried out by the
Commissioner of survey
settlement and land
records may be taken as
final and all
encroachments should
be removed by BBMP /
Revenue Department in
time bound manner.
·.>6'/
...
The Committee vide its I
i I
i
:
"·'":'/
/
~
' I
I
I
I -------- ---- I
3 7. (a) The Commission I No . CCTVs and watch j Installation arid . As · regards to Bellandur Lake BBMP
recommends that towers have been maintenance of I has installed 54 No. of 360 degree
CCTVs should be installed around the Street lights, CCTV . cameras and 200 No. LED
installed at appropriate Varthur lake. More CCTV camer:as street lights at appropriate locations
locations for ensuring numbers of CCTV and and control room of lake boundary to ensure that no
that ng _C&D waste is watch towers is required around the Lake. C&D waste is dumped and to
dumped in the buffer to be installed at monitor the· construction in Buffer ,!
zone area of the lake. Bellandur lake also. The zone area.. I
dumping of C &D
wastage is being reported The work of erecting 4 ··No of Watch
by locals at Varthur lake. tower in Bellandur lake area is in
The NGT may kindly take progress, the expected date of
note of it and direct the completion of Watch Tower will be
BBMP to install the 31st January 2020
CCTVs around Varthur
lake within two months. The BBMP is spending
It has been reported Rs198.00Lakhs to install CCTV,
(with photographs) that Street Light and Watch Towers at
some of the CCTV poles Bellandur lake.
installed around
Bellandur lake have As regard to Varthur lake BBMP is
fallen during heavy installing 54 No's 360 degree wireless
wind/ miscreants for cameras and 200 No's LED street
reasons of poor quality of lights at the cost of 198 lakhs from
works. The BBMP should 15/11/19.
take necessary measures So far 20 CCTV cameras and 85 LED
to protect the CCTVs. street lights have been installed and
balance works are in progress.
BBMP is proposed to erect 4 No's of
Watch Towers in Varthur Lake area,
I_ -
the date ofcompletion of installation
of street lights, cameras and watch
towers will be 15/02/2020.
r4 I.7should
{b) Security Guards I No rriarshalsj watchman
be deployed at have been deployed at
Removing of
encroachments
r
1 ·,
(i) Physical Guarding of lake and
buffer zone at Bellandur and
the most vulnerable Varthur lake despite the unauthorized Agara Lake (Presently
locations to keep committee's suggestion construction_and under the custody of
+-vigilance. on illegal to deploy them with prevention of Karnataka Forest
dumping of debris and immediate effect. The ·illegal dumping of Department · J · has been
to •- prevent illegal dumping in the C&D waste. done by deploying 21
encroachment buffer zone has been Marshals on 24 hours
activities. reported. The _NGT may duties. Exclusive Mahindra
kindly take a ·note of it Bolero ·Jeep ·.-has·. ·been
and direct the BBMP to provided . for effective
deploy the marshals patrolling of Lake Boundary.
within one month. The Marshals were deployed
with effect from 0 1 Mar
2018. The C&D Waste/Solid
wastedumping has been
controlled after physical
surveillance by marshals at
Bellandur. -The total
expenditure incurred so
farto Marshallsover the past
19 months is
Rs.l,29,63,882/-
{ii) Physical Guarding of lake and
buffer zone at Varthur Lake
has been done by deploying
2 l Marshal son 24 hours .
duties. The Marshals were
... deployed with effect from
16Nov 2019. Exclusive'
.Mahindra Bolero Jeep has
been provided for effective
patrolling of Lake Boundary.
~e total ~xpenditure of I
Marshalls for 12 Months is ~
j
Rs.79, 54,463.00. the work·
order of deployment of
Marshal at Varthur lake is
enclosed as Annexure-7 ·
5 7 (c) In case anyone is The BBMP has booked Removing of September- Notice boards and sign boards have
founp t() Q~ d:umping som~ ~ases against the encroachments 2020 been instaUe<;l at important loc_ati9ns
C&D waste or· debris .dumpers of C &D waste ·unauthorized at Bellandur and Varthur · lake area,
into the lake or its but the penalty .imposed construction and informing public about the penalty of
buffer zone, a penalty is not to the tune of Rs. 5 prevention of ~s.S.OO Lakhs that will be im. posed .
of Rs.S Lakhs be lakhs per offence. illegal dumping of for each offense of dumping C&D 1
imposed for each C&D waste. waste or debris into the _lake_ or its 1
'8
.-'
'g 1
11. Stru-ctures between 1
Maintenance of i Ongoing the commissioning of STPs as per
30-75 meters of Storm water drain activity Govt. Notification No. _FEE 316
Rajakaluves, which are EPC _ 2015, Bengaluru, Dated.
under construction, be 19.01.2016.
restrained from
I-
constructing further • No new facility or expansion- of
existing facility within the buffer
I without the prior
zone as per zoning regulations
permission of the
2015 of rajakaluves / SWDs are
Hon'ble Tribunal and
permitted.
in any event not until
the corp_missioning of • Structures between 30 - 75 rots of
the STPs-~ rajakaluves which have already
been c:on~tructe4 prior _ ~o _- 97-05-
12. - Permission _ or Maintenance of Ongoing 2015 but are uninhabited, .riot
sanction or consent or Storm water drain activity allowed to be occupied until_ the
EC for structures commissioning of STPs and
between 30-75 meters production of consent for
of Rajakaluves where operation of STPs from KSPCB.
construction was below
25% of the total built • No structures are permitted to be
constructed within the buffer
up area as on
zones of rajakaluves as per zoning
07.05.2015 Forward
regulations20 15.
Foundation Judgment)
be withdrawn. The
Hon'ble Tribunal m_ay
issue appropriate
directions and orders
keeping in view the
interests of the buyers
who would eventually
suffer financial loss.
10 I 16.Post removal of The BBMP and BOA Disposal of silt Ongoing A detailed project report is under
waste from the ·· Lake should take the work as
76
/ ,. .
removed from activity preparation tD dispose off the silt
and... from . / the suggested in Para 16 at lakes and Storm removed from Storm Water Drain and
I I Rajakaluves, the State 1
col_umn 2 and s~oul:d W~ter_Drain in
J Lakes in a scientific manner in :
I ought to prepare a fimsh the -task m 2 SCientific manner. abandoned quarries as per Solid
detailed ·project report months from the Waste Management Rule 2016 so
with. respect to completion of works of that the quarry land is reclaimed and
disposal of the same. 1 desilting by_ the BDA. also such reclaimed land can be later
. . . "I It is suggested. that if any used for afforestation· and 1 or play 1
1
officer I official transfers/ grounds or parks.
retires as stated in Identification of specific quarry out of
column 5 in this table available quarries at Marenahalli,
the ihcumbent officer· Bag.alur, · Hullalliwill be decided in
would be responsible ·for respect of disposal · of silt from
execution of works and Bellandur and Varthur lake, keeping ;
liable for Factions as if in mind the size of landfill i
_, his name is a .part of the ·requirement with minimum
column 5. The name-s transportation is · being · done ·.. by
stated in column 5 may. Bangalore Development Authority,
be accepted. are part of the DPR.
If the concerned
authorities (BBMP and
BDA) do not complete the
works and take more
time to complete the
work and take mor:e time
to complete; the Para
26(xii)and (xiv)of the NGT
order dated 06.12.2018
may be invoked.
__ ,,./
... /
2-)~;;;
J '
IN THE NATIONAl.. GREEN TRI6UNAL PRI~<;IPAL BENCH
.·! •
NEW D~LHI
\.
'\,·'
·. ,-.~
. OA·No. 125/2017
';'\~
\ '
VERSUS
AFFIDAVIT
stated .therein are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and
1r,
• : 1:
No of Correction~ N~·
. 1 ,
~l9 b
4. That the Annexures Accompanying status ··report filed with the,
'.
\
... appllc:~tlon "re true an~ corr~c:t copies of the originals.
' \
\ \-~
-.;'\ l.DEPONENT
~. Aw1 t---s>
VERIFICATION:
r~· the deponent c;1bove nam.ed, do her~by verify', and state on solemn
affirmation that the contents of the paras 1 to 4 are true and correct
20 19
~--1
~ I .
Z 6 NOV 10191
t I
,,,
ztg~
..,:t
Sir,
Su9: Reql)est to conduct swvey of 8ellandur and Varthur Iukes un~er the jurisdiction of Bengalurt,J East
Taluk and demarcation of 30 rn puffer zones from Lake Bound.arv Regarding; ·
Ref: Order of Hon'ble NGT datec,l 21.10.2019 in respect of application No. 125/2017.
With reference to the above subject, As per the order dated 21.10.2019 of the Hon'ble NGT in
respect to applic!ltion No. 125/2017, it is directe9 to rem9ve stn,Jcture coming ~nder 36m bLiffer zones
from lake boundary of Bellandvr, Varthur and Agara labs.
In the order of Principle Bench of Hon'bll! NGT dated 20.09.·2019 It is mentioned as below.
9.6 (a) "The authorities to survey buffe.r zone aroun.d Bellandur ~ake, Varthur Lake and. Agara Lake to
identify the encroachment and appropriate exercise should be under taken to remove them"
In view of the above, • · .
I
It is requestec;!.to direct the concerned to conduct s'urv~y Qf 8ella.ndWr Lake, Varthur Lake and
Agara lake and m~rk the boundary of lake, the 30m QVffer zone and identify .the strvcture encroached
within 30m buffer zone and communicate the report to this offi~e as this information/report is to submit
Hon'ble NGT on 27/11/2019.
. I
Chief Engineer
·Lakes, BSIV'!P
-~-··-··-··-~
I,, • I.-- ..
~~~~
t
·Government of l<arnataka ·
· . ;· Office of the Commissi"ner
Qepartment of St.Jrvey,
· s.ettlement!; and land records
. , , \. .. . , . , , . , ,. . . .. . . ,. ,. ·;, ..... ; • ,. ..!<,.~ ,ci[~le Ban.g~l9r~ ?60QQ1 . --.-
t)lo. SS\R¥11025/625/2019 · Date: 21.11.2019 ·
. \
.\-~·'
\
To,
The Chief Engin~er
Lakes, B8MP.
3rd floor, Annex -3 building
Bengaluru
'''
Sir,
. . . .
S!ub:- Demarcation of auffer zones·of Bellandur and Varthur lakes comes under Bengaluru
East Taluk- reg. . · · . ·
Ref:- Your office letter No. CE/Iakes/PR/283/2019.-20; date 04.11.2019.
. .
With reference to the above subject, under ref letter cited above. It is requested to
furnish the Report regarding Oernarcation Qf Buffer zones of Bellandur and Varthur lakes coming
l,mder j'urisdiction of Bengalt,Jru East Taluk, as the same to ·be sub~itted1 to National Green
Trib.unal at the earliest. ·
Regarding the structures obse.rved within the said lakes, the detailed map prepared in, co·
ordination with KSRSAC demarklng the lake bour,dary a'nd 30 mts ·buffer zone .frpm ~Fike
Boundary have prepared along with details of ·structures within 30mtr Buffer zones from Lake
aoundary ano some are enclosed for your information. '
Your:; faithfully,
SdF
Joint Director
Land Records
(En·qulry and Investigation) .
·n•"!'~'-· ,, ..., ,, . . . -
'
3,
!J
2
•I
~
~
I
~\~q
\ . .
'·. o)!tails .of structures comes within.30m buffer zone marked (satellite'
i .,.{. • ,t <,.~ . -·~ .. C 414 $ P 4 ,; c.,:: ;.e; ON i 10 U c;. ¥,: ,; ,; .. ts .> ,£ ,:o ~· -i
-~- sy.!~~·
--- --- ..
-P.rtla·l Structures
..
..
-~
- -6
Full structures
1
2
BelunJ
Sellandvr Amani kere. . ... .
2
1
'
"
28
....,...,_
4 '
.
18
-
......--.......--.-
3 lbbal1,1ru '12 13: .. 18
. . ' ....
' .. ·' '. .. , ·,•. . .
4 Ag~r~--" ___ 43
.......
04 02
-
Oetails.of structures as
.......,.,. . . .- ..... r.,-----0-,;-----.,.----;•.--.----,~,~· ··...-n--~..
per Viltage m~g i~ inlet c~~aL ~.ith~n the, ~uffer
•r· ··--· - ' ..,~ ~ 0
zone.
":'''~-
-·-·- .~.
Sl. No. Village Sy.No. Inlet canai.No. . ·Partial Structures Full Structures
as marked on
f-•
1 - aeluru 2
M!l!_
.1'
.....
'
10 I
.............. --~-~....
'. Nil
·--·---
'
'
-:-or . . ... ~---·-- ..
r---
~-
2 -Bellandur Amani kere 1
4
2
3 ..
. -Nil
02
--
___ Nil
...
...·---~---
Nil
......
OJ. ..
3 lt)baluru 12 5 Nil' Nil
. 6 . 01·
r-·
Nil
! --,...,--
i
7 ,. ....
01 ~
Nil
4 Agar a 43 ..
8- - - . - . Nil ' Nil
~~-~
9 ....
Nil Nil I
.·
I 10 .. Nil Nil
I 11 Nil
..
Nil
12 01 .. Nil
: .. ' _---..,..
13 •'.
01 !
~
Nil
.
BBMP has to tal<e in.itlation to identify the structures· ~oming within the 30 Mtr buffe.r zones with
reference to the map prepared in co-ordination with KSRSAC. ·· ·
Sd/·
. (C.· N SRIDHAR)
· Joint Director Land Records
.· ... (Enquiry and Investigation)
'
f\N N l:. "\) "L -'1-
:1-2.,00
I
I ...
0 0
"19. ' . 29
,
. . .. . . .. .. .. . .. ' . .
De~~il~ of stru~.tyr~~ ~~ e.~r V!i!~g~ P},ap in !rr~~. ~.~.n.~t.-wi.thin the buffer • • ..,. • .,...,. • "~"'' ,~,.--.- ·• ,.,. -,--.--.f r ,., .. ,. ,.... • r .- , ... ~ • '? 1\' •
zone .
.,.,......_....,...._
0 •
-
51. No. village Sy.NoP.. .Inlet canal No. as · Oetails of
. rna.rked I Structures · ·
• 0 0 0 ... ~ .~-- .
1 Varth~r 319 "1,2,3 Structures not.
'
.,
- ..
exist:
...
·
BBMP has to take initiation to identify the structures coming within the 30 Mtr buffer zones 'with
reference to the.map prepared in co-ordination with I<SRSAC.
· Sd/·
(C. N.SRIDHAR) :
Joint Oirector Land Records
{Enquiry and Investigation)
Map -showing '.fan.k of-lbba{uru (Sy. No.l2), Agara-(Sy. No:43) and Belanduru Amanikere(-sy. No.1), i3elucu {Sy. No.2), ViHages, Begwu and Varthuru Ho'hlies,
i\ I,
Benga!um Sout11 and Bengaluru East Taluks, Bengaturu Urban District N i
1:1:000 ;I
Map Showing Tank ofVarthuru (Sy. No.319) Village, Varthuru Hobli,
'-------------=~~---=-====-:-Bengaluru East Taluk, Bengaluru Urban Dis._t_n_·c_t______
f-.·· Legend .
lo 3<Jmts Bu1!tfer
•
t'·' '
~
,
"~t·
~-
~
, .•
.
f/<~~h
\ ,~
.. :
···..--~·-... . . ··: .
.;
2-~o3
I
·~ .·.
~~St. EXECUTIVE ENGINEER OFFICE, MAHAOEVAPURA DIVISION BANGALORE~SG0048
.'\ ' .. .: ' '
I
'\ '~
\ Ji I
I To,
Karnataka Ex-Servicemen's Welfare Society (R) ·
Bangalore
SUB: Deployment
. .of Marshals·around Varihur . Lake in.Ward-149
..
Varthur.
. .
****"' ...
With respect to the above s~,Jbjeet and reference in ·order ~o monitor arid
control unauthorized dumping. of. Garba.ge & C&O ...v._iaste around Varthl,Jr .Lake,_
orders has been issued to Appoint .Marshals.. .
You are hereby instructed to Appoint 6 M.ar.shals per shift in 3 shifts
(including Night Shift), Total18 Marshals, 1 Chief Marsh.al1 arid 3 Drivers. Th~s wo·rk
order will be put into effect from 16-11-2019 for a peri.od of 1 year.
. .
:. ·.... Lf?-/E. . '"'''
Asst•. Executi~e
.. ,.
Engln•!er'{SWM)
.
'Mahade1vapura Olvi~lon
~opyto:
1. Joint C9mmissioner BBMP Mahadevapura Division. ·
2. Chief Engineer (lakes).
3. Chief Engineer BBMP Mahadevapura Division.
4. Superintendent Engineer BBMP M<lhadevapu'ra Division.·.
' ' 1'\ N N ~:=" ~ "'~ ~ o
'
r
~·
. ~ .' '. ,. .', ~ ' .. '. . •' .
,.
~~ ' .·
"
.~-~
~2-oy
l .•:
t
~ I
fl
il.,
~ \:.•
·r·----- ~- -~- .,,. --~~- ~~ "_. -_. ;~~~--~--~ -~~t: ~:~--~·". ~·.....:.~·~~--~~: -~- ...... .
\_.A
~~ -. · y~~: EE-2/SWM-1/ WO/.o:1/ 2019~20 ·. : · ··
I \~;j~~!i~}~~~~f~:~t~~~i ,· ~~rJcor~~r
'·•
~engaluru -{5\J,O,:;Q4s~:, · .
,I . ': _:.-.. . /' ... ··. ,·- .. -,:··.'. ·<,·: ..·',:_ ... ::<: :··''<:'
·1
I .::$.Cib_: 1;,~.~$i.Qn,. Finane~.- Build, 0perate·~·Ti:$.hsfer750. r\!lTP~'Construction· aDq·
I
j
·:
.·. : ,_· :_ '~~p1b!ition wa,ste proc~~sing,Ja,eility' qperation &. 'rnairiienance .for ·20
· y~ars at Ka'nnur, ·SicJerahalli Hobli, . Sengah:ir~ East Taluk,
. . ..
'Seng_aluru.
. .
· ' . •' '
I '·· ,...
Scanned by CamScanner
' . ANNE X\JRE .... \.1
• ~ f
• .uo5
TRANSLA 1'1~D COPY
. .
,
J G9~er~~n!_e~1t ~:f Karn~t~~ka. ! .
Bengaluru.
To,
Sl.l'S
' Sub: Regarding the Civil Appeal No. 5016/2016 ·a~d . I
***** I
With ·reference t~ the above subject, the copy of the order dated
05.03.2019 passed by the Hon' ble Supreme Court in Civil
. Appeal No.
.
5016/2016 and other connected cases. In the ·said J udgi11ent the Civil
Appeal No. 5016/2016 and 8002-03/20 16 have been dismissed and ·the
. .
direction issued by the H~1n'ble National Oreen Tribunal Bonrd_ in
Original Suit No. 222/2014 dated 04.05.2016.has cancelled except :the .
' ..
Respondent-9 & 10. Theliefore, · 1 have been directed t() send ·the
Judgment of the Hon 'ble Supreme Court along with this letter 1()r fur! her
..
action.
Yours faithfully, ·
. Sd/-
(K.S. JAGADEESHAREDDY)
Under Se_cretary to Govei·nment.
Urban Development Dept.
I'',,,_ t • ~-
''
t.f \I .· ?.-20.{;
. TRANSLATED
.. ,..
COPY
'
EMBLEM· .
SRl)HAT B.ENGALURU MAliANAGARA PALIKE
Qftice of the Commissionei·, Naraslmharaja Squar~, B.et1galuru-560 002
\
·-.....----· . .. --·-.·---·
..,
\·No}IeNiNaYo/PR/1084/20
\ . .
1&-19 ---:-·- Dated: 19/03/2019 ·
'· j
\.~
\ OFFICE. ORDER.
"62. In the light·of the above.. .discus.~ion; we. pass the following
order.
(i) Civil Appeal No. 5016 of 20 I? .and Civil Appeal Nos. 8002-
8003 of 2016 filed hy the appellants/respondent nos. 9 and
I 0 are hereby dismissed. The impugned judgment and order
in so far- as appellants/responde.nt Nos.9 and 10 are
concerned is sustait1ed.
(ii.) All the other appeals are he:teby allowed . and the
diction/condition No. 0) in the qrder ·dated 4..5 .20 16is
hereby · set aside except the direction issu~Gl agai!1st
respondent Nos . 9 and 1.0".
.. _[ __ ,
·,.
. ~' ...
1,. •
, ,· I. f 1...2.01~
' J
the Original .Suit No. 222f2014 (Forward Foundation ~ Ors. V/s. State of
\.
Ktirnataka & Ors) date9 .04-05-2016, have been r~-fixedand ordered.
\ ·'
·~ ' . . .
, .\ As per the. order dated 05-03-2019 issued by the Hon.'-ble Supreme
\:.~Court in Civil .Appeal No. 5016/~016 and other Civil Appeals, the buffer
\ zone prescribed. to the· tanks and !~ajakaluves by the National Green
Tr]hunal has been set asid~. . Therefore, the approval for the plan to be
granted as per the buffer zone prescribed to the Tanks and Rajakaluveys
· as per the Master Plan 20 15; . ·
.·r-l:~nc
-~-
· 1\)sure:
.1'
'·i
. .' ·. .
I ~ '
AN/\\~X'.IJR£ -II
z_.~t?~
,:_.om~.-~•. ; ~~~~
. · \' · · · ·· · · ·· ·~·-1
~ i
\>L · · ·
\ ' ... ·.
. ·.' . . , · ·.
. ' ·. . . .
'~ws ~~rr:ctiaw~~z:bt":b
. ~ ·~~ ' ..... ,::;;J_,:· .· ··: •. ·:::·.:> ' .
·
\.~ · · · miie~ ptJf.\1~, ~·t9e;·.
·. . •. . ~} '-7" . :
l:::~:.::i:;g tl'..:thnrity i.e !3~.Ulfi<tlu·r·e. Development ~·\mhority.(BD:\) and Bruhath Bc::::.,::t~u :.:ab<>.nagar'-1
!':.:: : c ;:::ILL\!)) to insi~:t for im.tn1latior: of STf>~i in Rc5iclcntin.l Apartments w\~!1 5C.• l::~:~~j nnd abcn'e
,incc.pcctiv•: of CXbt"en~~e ofl.iC:WCl' line and for trcrt!mcnt Of (;(~Wngc (O tjrp<tn rcu::;c ::;\cmdard!.i nnd to
1 reuse the !;amc within their premises. .· . ..
· Wbcrcas, it is opined that cnlablis.hm~nt nf sewage trca1tmcnt plants in OrotJp Housing
Proj1:ct·s, Commercial Sstnblishmcnts o.nd s~ch otl1cr Institution~·· help in prevention of pollut;iqn of
water bodies ·~part from .reduCing the fresh \\'atcr demand ·in· such establishments as Brmgalorc is
\ fncin!!; shortage ofr~csh wnt~r sppply by BWS&SB. : .. · . .· · . . .- · · .
\ -~ :Nl1creforc, in. order to r.n~urc. treatment of sc.,vaGe generA teo in. the Oroup Hou,sing Projects,
,, C'(_rnmcrci.1.l EG~a.blislup~nts ~nd ~u~h ~th.cr. In:llil.~l~iops ·.!J.nd :9. ensure rc.t;tsc o( trcat_ccl.'.v~tcr _for
\ _I~011··Pot;~.bl~ purposes. ;apar,t fr~rn .cnD~~rm~ pr.c:vcntloi~ of pollution Qf lt\.lcc~ o.nd other watc~ boc,l1es,
·t1lc Stl:lt~ C1overnmcnt h~rcby 1ssuc r.hrcclmn unc)cr oectlon 5 of the .{:;nvJronmcnl" (ProtcctJon) Act,
· t9BG in c~;ercisc of the powr.r.·s deJ~'cc:ttcd to ll~c ~tt~tc_.Govcnuncnt vlc,lc Not,ifico.tion No.S.O.l52 (E),
dated: 10.02.1988 to the Authorities listed in the Table-1 l,lcloi.v as mentiqncd ngainst each of such
authorities. · · ..... ·:
· Table - 1
r·--
~- ~~rg;n~ion.of tbc ;\1,1th6nty" issuccl' . ~- · · . · .· · ·~ ·
1 Sl. . Wlth the direction \,l.lidcr section 5 of PlrCction under 'section" 5 of Environment .
, Np._
-~-~.viron~cE.!J~ccti..on) ~~· 19.Q.0...~-~ (P.roJec~on) Act, 198_6
1 ' 2 . ;: .. ": ... · . . ·... ''3-w:----
-l~l·T!lc- Commissioi1eZ Bmhati1 . Bengaluni ,· -·..·---·-~--~-- · -----·-·-~·
I . Mul1~nagara P;;lilce _ (8_13r;1Pf, · ~.R.Squarc·, Slmll: ap... p. ~-ov.~ · .pian fo.r .. construction of
Benr.:aluru-560002. ·· ; · ·· · · · ·· ·· · ·
-ry'"'·-;~~ .. · · . ·~·..:·. ;· ·-~-~ bl:lildu}£S ~md. ~!!velqprncpt .o.C .layout m.
-· I Th~ . :_ · ~ 0 1~lmi ...,loncr, . B~m.~alorc resp~ct of activities listed in Tab1c:2. of:this
pc~r~loJ:q~·,~nL . J\u~hcrlt?' (BD~), ripWic~~ion only 'cfte.(p.r9~\i.cticin\9( ~cp,v cif
~~~~10\~dnJo.h ~oa~,, 1\.\ltnBIIl Par.l{ Wc~1t, Consent .fo_r ~~u.tnbli~.lunc1.1t IQI~E) .lfil'lUccl
--~·-~ ~nlur:u •. SGOO .. O. . under the: .Water {~l·ev,:ntion .<m~ Control .of
3. :I Th·~ . Commjssior)'cr, · · tlie -B<mgruorc P()ll!ltion) Act, _19i4 lJy. the ·Karnataka. State
Mctropoliti:J.n Region Development Pqllution Contr9l ~oar.d .for cstoblishmcnt of
.: IAuth. orisY ·lB.· MRDAL No.1, Ali Ankar R.oad, sewag.c · tr~atme_nt · J?1al!t o_f .. '!PPr9priate.
__:_____ . Bt::~&~~rt1~_~56~052.: -~~-~--___....,.,:,_ c~.paclly ..
I
·l.. The Con1missioncr of u!i UJ(: . City
(.·-~·--··-·- __£::_r_yo~~~!.9~s in th.:_Stat~ . · ·---L~-··.:..-.....:._.......,._..:._ ..
f5. · ·n_:!~ Cbc:drn1<in, Ban~~alore Water Snpp!y Sb~ll provide watc_rco:mcc_t~on.to the activili~r.
i :L~ :sc_wc:mgc Bou.ra .(B\Vssp), Camcry covered under_ thl~.tchrcct_lcn m Table:<~ only
.1 t!llat·an, Bengaluru- 5G0009 after ·prqductlon of 'copy of Consent for
·j · .8stab1Jshmcnt (CF£) i!:sucd under tl1c '.Vntcr
(Prevention and· Control :of. Pollution) Act,
1974 ·by the :Kariwtaka State· Poliution
Contrql Board for establishment ··of sewage
f.ro_ a.tmcnt -t?lMt of nrmi·oni-inlt: ci.fu2_ecitv.· .
.. "·(~,' ,,
t>f:·C:-~t:;;-··Qlr MiiiiiCfP:~~- •Acim"TnTtiti·i'iioii~· Shall ensure. that tl1c '\irlJa..n 1ocalbodleu i.n the
-· ~.........,.,., ~i ...........
V,'V.l"•1ain. ·, 'fo\vcr, .Dr. B.R.,\mbedkEtr State ca.ming tlnd·cr ·thc·"juri~dict!on DMA ·or
V!'cr.lhi, l:1cngalunl~SGOOO l. ripprove p1an for con5t~Ctioiiof b~ilCli.ng~ Md
dev'~1opmen"t of luyo1tt inr.~sp~d of ·activities
· listecl in· Table-2 of this notification onlv "alter.
prod. u2ti~n·· ·o·r ··, ·ceii)y ··or G(.n1~~n·t ·· for
Est:ahlishmcnt ·ICF:El issued ~ndei:· ·the .water
·;·.
{P~cve~ti~n ,:a~4. :t:6ntf,o_l. ·P~Hu~onf '·Act, ·or.
1974 ··:.by
the · 'Karnataka··· State ·'Pollution·
Con'tro1 Board for establishment of .sewage
!Lept~n~~-~ .El<¥1t or agoropriate caJ?apitv. . .
-;r~·:rThc .~1anaging o"fi·cct_or, r<ar.nataka U'rSan Shall . provide · water .con~cction to thCl
Water Supply and. ~eweragc Board, No.5, activities covered ·u.·ri~cr this direction Table I in
,JalaBha\'Eln P\ Stage, lsr Phnsr., BTM ·2, only after production of copy of Consent
Layo'ut, llanncrglmtta Road, Bengnluru • for ·Establishri1cnt {CF'E} in!Jl,led under thr.
S60029 . :· . Water (Pre\·ention and Conlrol of Pollution)
Act, 1974 l.ly the Karnntaka State Pollut,ion
Control Doard for establishment of sewage
~-------' trea.~ment ]21~t of ~Epropri.ate! c~paci,tv. ._.__
...........-....,-.P>"...."""\'........,...........
-··-~-,.....,.,..., ..,.,.~..,..._,,....,_,...,. ...._
' \
-si.- -·
.. ... --
... ~. ...···-~~....--..._,..__~
~l!siguati~n of the Ati.thodty_h.:s~~d
...
~· . ··~-~~ ....,.._ ..........~--·......
Dirct;:Uon U!Hlc.r section !;; (Jf ED\dronmcnt j
.....-··-··, --.----
' .. ,
.
!H>.
··--
l
w1th the ~;hre~t;ion untlcr scct1on •>.Qf
1,:;:-nv1ronmc':L
•
.
• )A ct, __19136
+-IP rotecb~u
2 .. .·
....,. _______ .
'
(I' t tic ) A ·t 1986
f_..,..__________
~---· ·
.c.,
ro cc .n --·~,..--..:.....,__.,..
3
0 ,.,, ,n
~~ w
.
__. ,;_____,
\
-~ Tl~~-~- .Director; Town Planning, ~~:LS-S-.h-~1~ a;provc -··pln_n_fc~:--co·;-s-~~-~cti<~;~--~-r-1
1
DuJlclm~, BensaluDJ. . bu1_ldt~gs and· dcvr.lopn~ent of ·layout tn i
rtHipc~t .of .~c~v(tiu~ listed in Table ·2 of U1is .·
'' notifi~~tion· only q.rt~r production of c:ofly ur
C()nscnt fur i :E~L;;il,Jlizhmcnt .·(CFE) l!lSUI!O
\1 .; \,lnd"eF":tl'lc Water .(Pr~vcntiun nnd. of! Control
\.~ ·· ·I'o.llu tlon) Ac:t, ;1974 .by ·the 1\nrna~~ St!lte j
\ Poliuuo~
.. : . . . Board for cstnblishr~ent of '
·Co.ntrol . ., .
\I·~
\
_,_,........,_____,____,....,___.._...._ _,_,..,._ cap;;:,cJty. . . ·-----·- . _./
9. I CEO & ~xecutivc Member, Kamntakn Sl;ali .approve plan fo:- conslntction . or I
Industrinl . Arc~s J)f.vc;lr;>p~t:llt Soard bnildinz~ . nn~l dcvelopmeul of layout in I
(KIADBL respect of nctivitic:; li~ted in T~i.Jlc·2 of this ·
No. 49, Eost Wu1g, Klum.iju Bbnvan, R~Jcr. notilicatia·n cil)lcr for their own :usc or for the \
Course .Hoaa·: tiang~lqre ._ s"6o'OOl. ' : occupiers Qnly after prorlur.tion of .copy or I
'· 1 'i' :,l , .· . Ccna~:nt for· Sstoblishmt'n1 ·(CF~l l~surHll
'· · ·• Llntler. ·thu Wa.tcr ·(Prcvcnthm ancl Oenlrel or
Po11ution) Act, 1974 by th: 1\,nmataka. State
Pollutiot! Control l.3oard for e!itublishmcnt of
. ::;cwngc treatment plnllc L•f npprJpriatc
capacity.
·-1cTTri1-c--~. i~-1-nn~glng Dir~~~~~---BSSC-Oh·1... '-·s~~lJl. ~;~vid~!· pem1ancl;;.t.. ~;~:~~~·-~~~necti~~;;·~~--
csscm,I, OESCOM, MESCOM a(Jd .the.'activitic$ covered unc!~r this din•c:tion at
HE:SCOM. Tnb!e-:2, onl_v nftC':.._J3~9.E!.'~S.UQE!...qf __s9.)?•.!:_~f
CDl.H>en~ for E:>tablishmtnt (C:FE) is~;u::c
lh;clcr th!!. Watcl· (Prerc;t;;;·;···r;j)(f"toi~txol.o!
Pollution) Act, 1974 by th::: KnmataJca Stnte
Pollu i.inn Ccihtrol Board for r:siablishmcn t cr I
1
sewage · trcc:1tml:.nt . plnnt of UJ)pt·op:i~\te j
capm.cfl)'. However, (hiu dircctiun shall not be
mndc applicable for ~em pornry COnTlCCtiOti
.......,.._________ . provid.cd· for construction pbn.:;e.
'"--..o;oo:•
,... . . .. ---·---.- · - .·-· ----·j
ll. I The Member Secretary, Ka.rnataka St&te Shall inc.ludc the activit.ic:~ cuvcrc:d under this !
Ppilutian Control Board, No. 49, Parisasra direcUcm . under
the. consent mechanism . in !
Shavano., C~1lJrch Street, Bengaluru. nccon;hu1c~ · with th~ ·p·rovi.':ians: oi the w·atcr !
(Prevention and Contrcl of Pollutio.n) A~l, I
19~tl b.r~d the. Rule~ mwle lhen:uncJer and !
shrul c~~surc that such l!Ctivities listed b 1
Tuble~~ · a~so . arc csto.bhhcd · n.\ong with 1
sewage . trcntmen~ . piDill of:. ·apprapria~e i'
cnpac(ty and ~nechanisrn fjr n!use of tn:att::cl I
.... wat,~r ~Is put in Jlluce. ns dir(!c:t~d by CPC8 .
Such cctivi.tics s~all· be.: i.~sucd .wiU1 Cfo'E: I
CFQ fu116wina the ;c.tLll! _t)rcHcodU~e of hLW,, r~!tt~r
·ensuring permissibility of such activity. , .
- - - - - - - -....... _____ .! ___.....".. . . ---·-· -·---~----~------.!
,_.. ~~ ~~ ~[ •·'' .
,, . ....•I
u~~rler thb .Nt)tirication in ci.llumn :3. p( the: abtlvc.'rnblc·l :;1'11.!!1 b1· tdndt·
·: !:::· dirr.ctio;J itl!HH!cl
:.·,::..;:<~·;:l::e fer the oc;Gvities listccl'in the TA.bJe . :?, below:
. · . TRblc- 2
·lr·..,..·-...,.....,-------
: Sl. !· -· . ----~------.-...........-------~·--- . -··--.-- .
J\ctivitic~ thut need to. install Sewerage Trcatmcoll"lants.JSTP} ~;ompulsqrily o.nd.
--
~i.~: :. .: ...... ,.~·-··~·-·-.l....._~--·-----~t!.~S....C o£Jr_£~t-~.~ Wll_l:~~._..:_.~ _ ___:__.
i) 1Jill tl,e lt!Hidc.ntial Group Hou~in_g Projecl!i I J\par1mr.m~ witl1 20 Units and o.bovc or h:1ving
! "--: •••
7
..1.!:-~~~~bu~it \:.E_nrcn or _2.000 sg,W'ft n:~.t£: in~~;sl,lP!~ l~a.~cnt s~~!l ins~~L§_TP._ ·--.:-:-......
l1t~i Commc.ma! c~n~~ruclloti~ ProJects _(Co~mcrclals Complexes, om.cc,. 11 ~:latcd acUV!ttcs
·. t··::-:-A~ c_t~.. .t:~·~th tot~l b~1~.~YP ~,r~~.o.f. 2.,. o~o ~qt\l,f~. m~tcr~~.d nbo~.e, ~~~~11 msta~l. SIP. . ~ .
')h!l!. IJ:.nu_cm:~:)nal·lns~ttuttons wtth ~r Wlf:i~out Hastcl facthl)• havuig total bt~~lt up area of n,OOO
[·> -·-+~:~~U~2!:.!: .r:~!£f_~n? ~bq_ve:sl~all ·mstall s:rP: . . . ----------- ... --.....-c;-:---~ -"o ..
· i YJ i J OI'.'J!!ihtps unci An! a Perelopment Projec:ts Wtlh an arr.n of 10 acres :!JJd abc:.ve: shall mstall
~
~
J. S'l'P...-·-··-··-
............. ...
~-
' ·..
.
. .· · . .
. . . ----------..-----... . -
. 1· Th)sd~rcction \~'ill. c~_1117 :t9 ·~rroct .frorn,thci dCltc of its pu?Jicntion in the Govcr~1mcnt Gazette.
'rhc- C\TI!Ctlon UIGUcd .to the 1\arnatnl<a State PollutlQn Control Board v1de Govcrnmellt
Notificol!ort No. 11~1~ 22 tl:PC 20Q.9 (P·l), d~tc.d: '04.08.2010 stands with~rawn. ·
· · · By Order & in th~ Name of the Oovernor of J\nrnntalm
·..
A'JfPA:llAYYA MATHAD
U.nqer Secrctruy to Government
(l'!:cology l}.t Environmeqt)
ForcGt, E:cology -~-~nvir911:mcint Dept. I
•'