<]bTV`PbTS7PbPC`^RTaaX]VFgabT\caX]V@PbW@?
Pa
9^`\c[PET_`TaT]bPbX^]
EUg\]fNU\miX]
Gc`]hY_b]_JhUh]gh]_UJK@J
AU_UfhU'@bXcbYg]U
,1)4.-07gh]g)UW)]X
-EVWUDFW]?KH ILHOG R I VWDWLVWLFV DLPV WR VWXG\ VWDWLVWLFDO
PHDVXUHV WR H[SODLQ FROOHFWLRQ R IREMHFWV ZLWK FHQVXV RU VXUYH\
PHWKRG$5QSUDFWLFH"WKHPRUHREMHFWVVWXGLHG"WKHPRUHFRPSOH[WKH
FDOFXODWLRQV IRU WKH VWDWLVWLFDO PHDVXUH$ ?KHUHIRUH" VWDWLVWLFLDQV
QHHG KHOS IURP FRPSXWHU SURJUDP WR FDOFXODWH WKH VWDWLVWLFDO
PHDVXUH$ >WDWLVWLFLDQ QRW RQO\ QHHGV WR VWXG\ VWDWLVWLFV" EXW DOVR
QHHGVWROHDUQDERXWSURJUDPPLQJDVZHOO9RVWVWDWLVWLFLDQVGRQRW
XVH WR ZULWH FRPSXWHUSURJUDPV DQG FKRRVH WR XVH 3@5#EDVHG
DSSOLFDWLRQV$ 4RZHYHU" 3@5#EDVHG DSSOLFDWLRQVJLYH XVHUV OLPLWHG
IUHHGRP WR DSSO\ FXVWRPIRUPXODV$ ?KHUHIRUH" WKLV VWXG\ DLPV WR
GHYHORSVWDWLVWLFDOVRIWZDUHZKLFKHQDEOHVXVHUVZKLWKRXWRUOLPLWHG
NQRZOHGJHR IZULWLQJFRGHV WR XVH GHULYHGRU FXVWRPIRUPXODV LQ
WKHLU RULJLQDO RU WH[WERRNV#EDVHGIRUP ZLWKLQ FDOFXODWLRQV$ ?KH
DSSOLFDWLRQZDVEXLOWXVLQJWKHLQFUHPHQWDOPHWKRG"ZKLFKLVRQHR I
VRIWZDUH GHYHORSPHQW PHWKRGRORJ\ ZLWK VHYHUDO LWHUDWLRQV$ ?KH
PRVWLPSRUWDQWSDUWR IDSSOLFDWLRQ PRGXOHZDV EXLOWLQ WKHLQLWLDO
LWHUDWLRQ"IROORZHGE\QH[W PRGXOHV" XQWLODOODSSOLFDWLRQ PRGXOHV
KDYH EHHQ EXLOW -SSOLFDWLRQ FDQ EH FRQQHFWHG WR VHYHUDO GDWD
VRXUFHV VXFK DV GDWDEDVHV RUILOHVSURYLGHG E\ XVHUV DQG VWRUH
IRUPXODVWKDWKDYHEHHQPDGHI RUUHXVH$
7H\ZRUGVq IRUPXOD"FRPSXWHUSURJUDP"3@5"GDWDVRXUFH
<& <AGEB7H6G<BA
=cfai`U]gUgYf]YgcZg][bgWcadcgYXc ZVUg]WgmaVc`gQ,R
=cfai`Ug WUb VY UbU`c[cig hc Ub U`[cf]h\a cf gYeiYbWY cZ
ghYdghc WU`Wi`UhY UjU`iYVUgYXcb ghUbXUfXfi`Yg) K\Y igY cZ
Zcfai`Ug ]g jYfm W`cgY`m fY`UhYX hc h\Y kcf`Xc ZaUh\YaUh]Wg
UbX]hgVfUbW\Yg cZgW]YbWY'cbY cZk\]W\]gghUh]gh]Wg) 8`acgh
U``WU`Wi`Uh]cbg]bghUh]gh]Wg'Vch\XYgWf]dh]jYUbX]bZYfYbWY'UfY
VUgYX cb U Zcfai`U) JiX^UbU gUmg' ghUh]gh]Wg ]g _bck`YX[Y
fY`UhYX hc h\Y aYh\cXg cZ [Uh\Yf]b[' dfcWYgg]b[' UbU`mn]b['
XfUk]b[ WcbW`ig]cbg' UbXaU_]b[ fYUgcbUV`Y XYW]g]cbg VUgYX
cbZUWhg UbXUbU`mg]g WcbXiWhYXQ-R) 8bch\YfhYfa]g ghUh]gh]Wg'
k\]W\ ]g U fYdfYgYbhUh]jY aYUgifY cb gUad`Y XUhU Q-R'
JhUh]gh]Wg WUbU`gcVY gYYbUg h\Y cihdih cZUb UWh]j]hmWUff]YX
cih VUgYX cb ghUh]gh]WU` fi`Y UbX WU`Wi`UhYX k]h\ ghUh]gh]WU`
Zcfai`Ug)
@b]h]U``m' h\YaYUgifYaYbhigYXUg XUhUfYdfYgYbhUh]cbkUg
gh]`` XYgWf]dh]jY' cbY cZ k\]W\ kUg h\Y g]nY cZ XUhU
WcbWYbhfUh]cb UbX X]ggYa]bUh]cb) ?ckYjYf' acfY UbX acfY
]bZcfaUh]cbhcVYcVhU]bYXZfcah\Y XUhUaU_Yg]hWcbg]XYfYX
]bgiZZ]W]Ybh aYUgifY) K\ig' h\YfY UfY aYUgifYg h\Uh WUb VY
igYXhc XfUkWcbW`ig]cbg ZfcaUdcdi`Uh]cbVUgYX cb gUad`Y
XUhU' k\]W\ ]g WU``YX ]bZYfYbWY ghUh]gh]Wg) @h aU_Yg h\Y
WU`Wi`Uh]cb UbX Zcfai`U igYX VYWcaY acfY Wcad`Yl)
1/0%)%/*0)%1*/1%.'*('F+)&(( i  *(*( <888
Authorized licensed use limited to: East Carolina University. Downloaded on June 16,2021 at 19:53:54 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KU_X]f
Gc`]hY_b]_JhUh]gh]_UJK@J
AU_UfhU'@bXcbYg]U
hU_X]f7gh]g)UW)]X
DcfYcjYf' h\Y acfY X]aYbg]cbg cZ h\Y XUhU gYh U`gc aU_Y
ghUh]gh]WU` WU`Wi`Uh]cbg VYWcaY acfY X]ZZ]Wi`h cf YjYb
]adcgg]V`Yk\YbXcbYaUbiU``m)
K\YfYZcfY' ]b dfUWh]WY acgh ghUh]gh]WU` WU`Wi`Uh]cbg UfY
dYfZcfaYX k]h\ h\Y \Y`d cZ U WcadihYf) JhUh]gh]W]Ubg kcf_
hc[Yh\Yf k]h\ dfc[fUaaYfg hc WfYUhY Udd`]WUh]cbg'
dfc[fUaa]b[ `Ub[iU[Yg' UbX dUW_U[Yg h\Uh WUb VY igYX hc
ZUW]`]hUhY ghUh]gh]WU` WU`Wi`Uh]cbg giW\Ug JGJJ' I' Gmh\cb' UbX
JK8K8)?ckYjYf'AYZZYfQ.R gU]Xh\Uhib`]_YYldYWhUh]cbg'h\Y
XYjY`cdaYbh cZ acXYa WcadihYfg UbX h\Y UjU]`UV]`]hm cZ
ghUh]gh]WU`dfc[fUadUW_U[YgX]Xbch]adfcjYh\YkUmXUhUkUg
UbU`mnYXUbX ]bhYfdfYhYX) 9YWUigY' h\Ydfc[fUaaYfUg aU_Yf
c Z h\Y Udd`]WUh]cb cf dUW_U[Y igiU``m XcYg bch fYU``m
ibXYfghUbXh\YVUg]W Uggiadh]cbg cfWcbghfU]bhg]adcgYXVmU
h\Ycfm cb h\Y UbU`mg]g) K\ig' h\Y dUW_U[Y ]g igiU``m bch
UWWcadUb]YXVmUXYeiUhYYld`UbUh]cbgch\Uhbcb(ghUh]gh]W]Ubg
WUbibXYfghUbXh\YghUh]gh]WU`g][b]Z]WUbWYcZh\Ydfc[fUa)
DcghghUh]gh]WU` gcZhkUfYigYghkchmdYgcZigYf]bhYfZUWYg'
bUaY`m[fUd\]WU` UbX WcaaUbX`]bY ]bhYfZUWYg) Q/R ?ckYjYf'
>L@ VUgYX Udd`]WUh]cbg UfY f][]X UbX Xc bch []jY igYfg h\Y
ZfYYXca hc W\Ub[Y cf WfYUhY h\Y]f ckb ghUh]gh]WU` ZibWh]cbg)
:cbhfUf]`m' WcaaUbX `]bY ]bhYfZUWY #:C@$ []jY h\Y igYf h\Y
ZfYYXca hc XYZ]bY h\Y]f ckb ghUh]gh]WU` ZibWh]cbg cf igY
dfYj]cig`m WfYUhYX ZibWh]cbg) @h XYg][bYX Zcf gdYW]U`]ghg k]h\
XYYd ibXYfghUbX]b[ UbX cZZYf bch cb`m dckYfZi`' Vih U`gc
Z`Yl]V`Y ghfiWhifYg) ?ckYjYf'igYfgbYYXhc\UjY h\YYldYfh]gY
hcVYUV`YhcWfYUhYcfacX]ZmYl]gh]b[ghUh]gh]WU`ZibWh]cbg
8g U fYgi`h' ghUh]gh]W]Ub bYYX hc WcbXiWh acfY ]b(XYdh\
ghiX]Yg hc WfYUhY cfacX]ZmdUW_U[Yg cfZibWh]cbgh\UhUfYbch
mYhUjU]`UV`Y) FbYWcbWYdhh\UhWUbVYigYXhc cjYfWcaY]h]g
WU``YX fYigY' Vm ghcf]b[ dfYj]cig`m WfYUhYX ZibWh]cbg UbX
fYig]b[h\Ya]ZbYYXYX) FbYcZh\Y]bgh]hih]cbgcf[cjYfbaYbh
U[YbW]Ygh\UhUdd`mh\]gWcbWYdh]b]hgUWh]j]h]Yg]gh\YJhUh]gh]Wg
@bXcbYg]U'bUaY`m9UXUbGigUhJhUh]gh]_#9GJ$) 9GJ]gUbcb(
XYdUhaYbh [cjYfbaYbh ]bgh]hih]cb k\]W\ ]g fYgdcbg]V`Y Zcf
WcbXiWh]b[VUg]WghUh]gh]WU`UWh]j]h]Yg]b@bXcbYg]UQ0R)
8`acgh U`` ghUh]gh]W]Ub ]b 9GJ Wcaacb`m igY ghUh]gh]WU`
Udd`]WUh]cbg hc dfcWYgg XUhU k]h\ WYfhU]b Zcfai`Ug) K\Y
Zcfai`UbYYXghcVYWcbjYfhYX]bhcUgWf]dhgch\Uh]hWUbVYfib
k]h\]bUWcadihYf) K\ig'h\YWcadihYfWUbdYfZcfacdYfUh]cbg
VUgYXcbYl]gh]b[gWf]dhg) K\YfYZcfY'bchU``9GJ"g ghUh]gh]W]Ubg
WUb kf]hY dfc[fUa gWf]dhg YUg]`m VYWUigY h\Ym bYYX gdYW]U`
YldYfh]gY hc Xc ]h) :cbgYeiYbh`m' gcaYh]aYg gcaYcbY k\c ]g
)/)
WUdUV`Y hc kf]hY dfc[fUag' k]`` aU_Y gWf]dhg Zcf dUfh]Wi`Uf
Zcfai`Ug gc ch\Yf ghUh]gh]W]Ub WUb igY h\Ya) ?ckYjYf' cZhYb
dfc[fUaaU_YfgXcbchaU_YXcWiaYbhUh]cbcZh\Y]fdfc[fUag
UbXaU_Y]hX]ZZ]Wi`hZcfigYfghc acX]Zm]Zh\YfYUfYa]bcfcf
aU^cfW\Ub[Yg)
@@) E8?4G87 J BE>
K\Y Z]fgh ghiXmkUg WcbXiWhYXVm?Ug\]achc' ?]^]_UhU' !
E]g\]XU Q1R' K\]g ghiXm U]ag hc WfYUhY U gYUfW\ Yb[]bY Zcf
aUh\YaUh]WU` Zcfai`Ug cb h\Y kYV Vm ]bXYl]b[ ]h) 8 gmghYa
Wcbg]gh]b[ cZhkc giVgmghYag kUg XYjY`cdYX) FbY giVgmghYa
]g hc Wc``YWh kYV XcWiaYbhg ]bW`iX]b[ DUh\DC cV^YWhg UbX
]bXYl]b[ ]h ig]b[ YjYfm bcXY ]b YjYfm `YjY` cZh\Y DUh\DC
;FD hfYY) Fh\Yf giVgmghYag ]g U gYUfW\ Yb[]bYg h\Uh k]``
dfcj]XY gYUfW\ fYgi`hg VUgYX cb h\Y `YjY` c Z WcadUh]V]`]hm
VYhkYYbigYf"g eiYfmUbXgYeiYbWY c Z]bXYlYXDUh\DCbcXY
Y`YaYbh) @b h\]g ghiXm U`gc aYbh]cbYX h\Uh' ]XYU``m h\Y ]bXYl
k]h\ h\Y 9=J aYh\cX fYdfYgYbhg h\Y cjYfU`` ghfiWhifY cZh\Y
aUh\YaUh]WU`Zcfai`U'WcbgYeiYbh`m h\Y`Uf[YfcfWcad`Ylh\Y
Zcfai`U UbX h\Y acfY Wcaacb gYUfW\ _Ym' gYUfW\ Yb[]bY
dYfZcfaUbWYk]``XYWfYUgY)
=ifh\Yf fYgYUfW\ ]g WcbXiWhYXVm >ic' K]Ub' PUb[' ! C]
h\Uh ]adfcjY gYUfW\ Yb[]bY dYfZcfaUbWY Vm UXX]b[ rWcibhs
Uhhf]VihY hc DUh\DC hfYY Q2R) K\Y fYgi`hg cZh\]g ghiXm UfY
YlhYbXYXDUh\DCk]h\UXX]h]cbU`Uhhf]VihYg'bUaY`mh\YWcibh
cZcdYfUhcfgigYX]bcbY`YjY`hfYY)K\ig'hcXYhYfa]bYk\Yh\Yf
cbY aUh\YaUh]WU` YldfYgg]cb ]g X]ZZYfYbh Zfca Ubch\Yf' h\Y
gYUfW\ Yb[]bY XcYg bch bYYX hc W\YW_ h\Y k\c`Y bcXYg UbX
fYgi`hWUbVY[YbYfUhYXaiW\ZUghYf)
@b -+,1 BUd`Ub Q3R dfcdcgYg U bYk U`[cf]h\a hc dUfgY U
aUh\YaUh]WU` YldfYgg]cb UbX Z]bX ]hg fYgi`h) K\]g fYgYUfW\
dfcXiWYgUaUh\YaUh]WU`YldfYgg]cbdUfg]b[U`[cf]h\aWU``YXU
gd`]h(UbX(aYf[Y U`[cf]h\a) @b [YbYfU`' h\Y gd`]h(UbX(aYf[Y
U`[cf]h\a Wcbg]ghg cZhkc ghU[Yg) @b h\Y Z]fgh ghYd ]h gd`]h h\Y
[]jYb ghf]b[ ]bhc h\Y `]gh c ZcV^YWh WU``YX rMUf]UV`Ygs h\Uh ]g
WcbhU]bgUb]bhYfaYX]UhYfYgi`hUbXUbUWh]cb) K\YgYWcbXghYd
Wcbg]ghg ]b aYf[]b[ h\Y `]gh c ZMUf]UV`Yg WfYUhYX ]b h\Y Z]fgh
ghYd' UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y df]cf]h]Yg cZh\Y]f UWh]cbg) BUd`Ub U`gc
WfYUhYg:J:JZfUaYkcf_cf:ighca]nYXJWf]dh]b[]b: VUgYX
cbgd`]hUbXaYf[YU`[cf]h\a)
8bch\Yf fYgYUfW\ WibXiWh Vm JdUb[YbVYf[' N]`_Y' !
=fUbWnm_ Q4R ]b -+,2 U]aYX hc Vi]`X U V][ XUhU UfW\]hYWhifY
acXY` Zcf ]bhfU(gif[]WU` fYaU]b]b[ h]aY dfYX]Wh]cbg ]b fYU`
h]aY VUgYX cb YjYbh XUhU cb cdYfUh]b[ Yei]daYbh)
JdUb[YbVYf[' N]`_Y' ! =fUbWnm_ igY UdUW\Y _UZ_U Ug YjYbh
ghfYUa]b[ d`UhZcfa Zcf XUhU ]b[Ygh]cb ! X]ghf]Vih]cb) K\]g
`UmYf UWhg Ug U WYbhfU` dc]bh XUhU WcbbYWh]cbVYhkYYb gYjYfU`
XUhU gcifWYg UbX WcbgiaYfg cf gmghYa) K\Y fYgi`hg cZ h\]g
ghiXm ]g U dfchchmdY cZfYU`h]aY XUhU dfcWYgg]b[ gmghYa hc
dfYX]Whh\YfYaU]b]b[h]aYigU[Yc ZUgif[Yfmfcca)
DUbm ghiX]Yg igY DUh\DC XcWiaYbhg ]b Zcfai`U gYUfW\
Yb[]bYg UbX WcadihY aUh\YaUh]WU` YldfYgg]cbg k]h\cih h\Y
dfYgWYbWY XUhU gcifWY) 9ih' h\YfY UfY gh]`` ZYk cf YjYb bc
ghiX]Yg h\Uh ih]`]nY DUh\DC Ug U fYdfYgYbhUh]cb cZ
aUh\YaUh]WU` YldfYgg]cbg ]bWU`Wi`Uh]cbgk]h\h\YdfYgYbWYcZ
XUhUgcifWYg) @bh\]gghiXmkYZcWigcbZ]``]b[h\YfYgYUfW\[Ud
Vm ih]`]n]b[ DUh\DC Ug U fYdfYgYbhUh]cb cZ Zcfai`Ug UbX
1/0%)%/*0)%1*/1%.'*('F+)&(( i  *(*( <888
Authorized licensed use limited to: East Carolina University. Downloaded on June 16,2021 at 19:53:54 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
dYfZcfa ghUh]gh]WU` WU`Wi`Uh]cbg UbX igY UdUW\Y _UZ_U hc
WcbbYWhcifXUhUdfcWYgg]b[gmghYahcgY`YWhYXXUhUgcifWY)
@@@) @ 8G;B7F
(# 2<I<8H:?3:EF<I
K\]gghiXmZcWig cbaU_]b[h\Y]bhY[fUhYXXUhUdfcWYgg]b[
gmghYa ig]b[ DUh\DC Ug Zcfai`U fYdfYgYbhUh]cb' gmghYa
Wcbg]ghg cZZfcbhYbXUbXVUW_YbX Udd`]WUh]cbg U]ag hc YbUV`Y
igYfg'bUaY`mghUh]gh]W]Ubgk\cXcbch\UjYWcX]b[YldYfh]gYhc
dfcWYggXUhUk]h\WYfhU]bghUh]gh]WU`Zcfai`Ug) K\YVUW_YbXWUb
VY igYXVm YUW\ ZfcbhYbX Uddg h\fci[\U gYfj]WY gc h\Uh ]h]g
bch`]a]hYXhcWYfhU]bd`UhZcfag)
8 g]ad`Y kYV(VUgYX W`]Ybh Udd`]WUh]cb k]`` VY aUXY Ug
ZfcbhYbX) K\Y W`]YbhUdd`]WUh]cb gYfjYg Ug Ud`UWY ZcfigYfghc
kf]hY WYfhU]b aUh\YaUh]WU` Zcfai`Ug) K\]g Udd`]WUh]cb k]``
WcbjYfh ]h hc U CUKYl ZcfaUh h\Yb U aU_Y fYeiYghg hc h\Y
gYfjYf) JYfjYfk]``dYfZcfaWU`Wi`Uh]cbgVUgYXcbh\Y Zcfai`U
UbX XUhU gY`YWhYXh\Yb gYbX fYgdcbgY aYggU[Y) FdYfUhcfg UfY
`]a]hYX hc VUg]W ghUh]gh]Wg UbX VUg]W aUh\YaUh]WU` cdYfUhcfg
giW\ Ug ai`h]d`]WUh]cb' X]j]g]cb' UXX]h]cb' giVhfUWh]cb' g][aU
cdYfUh]cbg'dfcXiWhg'hf][cbcaYhfm'UbXdckYf)
)# 3OIJ<C+<L<BEFC<DJ
JmghYa XYjY`cdaYbh aYh\cX igYX ]g h\Y JmghYa
;YjY`cdaYbh C]ZY WmW`Y #J;C:$ k]h\ ]bWfYaYbhU` acXY`)
K\YgY aYh\cX U]ag hc dfcXiWY U \][\ eiU`]hm gcZhkUfY h\Uh
aYYhgcfYlWYYXg WighcaYfYldYWhUh]cbg'fYUW\YgWcad`Yh]h]cb
k]h\]bh]aYUbXWcghYgh]aUhYg Q,+R' K\YghU[YgcZ@bWfYaYbhU`
acXY`VUgYXcbJUdihfUQ,,RUfYUgZc``ckg5
p IYei]fYa Ybh 8bU`mg]g5 ]XYbh]Zm h\Y bYYXg cf
YldYWhUh]cbgc ZigYfgcZh\YgmghYahcVYVi]`h)
p JdYW]Z]WUh]cb5 gcfhYXcihYjYfmfYei]fYaYbhk\]W\cbYg
UfY dcgg]V`Y hc VY Zi`Z]``YX UbX k\]W\ UfY bch) 8ZhYf
h\Uh' fYgYUfW\Yf []jY df]cf]hm gWU`Y Zcf YUW\ gY`YWhYX
bYYX)
p 8 fW\]hYWhifY ;Yg][b5 XYhYfa]bY h\Y Wcaaib]WUh]cb
aYW\Ub]ga VYhkYYb ZfcbhYbX UbX VUW_YbX' giW\ Ug
dfchcWc`gUbXXUhUYlW\Ub[Y`Ub[iU[YghUbXUfXg)
p :cXY5]ad`YaYbhUh]cbbYYXgk]h\WYfhU]bdfc[fUaa]b[
`Ub[iU[Yg)
p KYgh5 W\YW_ h\Y dYfZcfaUbWY cZ YUW\ bYk`m UXXYX
ZibWh]cbcfWcadcbYbhUbX]hg]bhY[fUh]cbk]h\ Yl]gh]b[
WcadcbYbhgh\Yb[chcbYlh]hYfUh]cbg)
*# 2<GK@H<C<DJ(D8BOI@I
9UgYX cb]bhYfj]Ykg WcbXiWhYXk]h\ gYjYfU` Yad`cmYYg]b
giV(X]fYWhcfUhYXUhUVUgYXYjY`cdaYbh#G9;$'fYgYUfW\YfZcibX
gYjYfU`dfcV`Yag]bYjYfmXUmdfcWYggUh9GJ) K\YgYdfcV`Yag
UfY]``ighfUhYX]bh\YZ]g\VcbYcf]g\]_UkUX]U[fUaVY`ck)
)/*
 UWWcfX]b[ hc 9Ub[cf ]b 9fcc_Y Q,3R Ubm gcZhkUfY h\Uh \UjY
 $ !%#!" JLJgWcfYacfYh\Ub2+]gUWWYdhUV`YcfigUV`Yhch\YigYf)

<I& E8FH?G 4 A 7 7 <F6HFF<B A

(# 18HI@D>8B>EH@J?C
GUfg]b[ U`[cf]h\a ]g bYYXYX gc h\Uh h\Y WcadihYf WUb
ibXYfghUbX h\Y gYaUbh]W aYUb]b[ cZh\Y []jYb Zcfai`U UbX
WU`Wi`UhY]h) K\YdUfg]b[U`[cf]h\a]gWfYUhYXVmcVgYfj]b[h\Y
hfYY ghfiWhifY cZh\Y :cbhYbhDUh\DC XcWiaYbh Q,4R' 8g Ub
]``ighfUh]cb' h\Y Zc``ck]b[ ]g U aUh\YaUh]WU` Zcfai`U k]h\ U
=][),) @g\]_UkU;]U[fUa jUf]UV`Y'bUaY`ml)

K\YfY UfY Zcif [fcidg cZ dfcV`Ya h\Uh aU_Y XUhU ##0&1 $)#4 (l $$*-  #,$
dfcWYgg]b[ Vm Yad`cmYY VYWcaY fYXibXUbh ]b 9GJ ])Y) K\YfYdfYgYbhUh]cbcZZcfai`U , ]bh\Y DUh\DC XcWiaYbh
Yad`cmYY g_]``' dfUWh]WY' UjU]`UV]`]hm' UbX ]ad`YaYbhUh]cb cZ WUbVYgYYb]b=][ifY-5
gWf]dh #gYY Z][ifY ,$) Lg]b[ Z][ifY , fYgYUfW\Yf Zcfai`UhY
%*3348*8043 ÀA  -3+4,03.7)*8/)( '438-38&
ZibWh]cbU`UbXbcb(ZibWh]cbU`fYei]fYaYbhUgZc``ckg5 %*551<&
%,0:0,-!&
,) =ibWh]cbU`fYei]fYaYbh %*551<&
%802-7!&
pJmghYa h\Uh a]b]a]nYg * Y`]a]bUhYg h\Y bYYX Zcf %*551<&
ĆSOWUÄĈ
gWf]dh]b[) %+6=&"%!+3&
%-3&#%!+3&
p8``ckgZcfai`UghcVYWcad]`YX'ghcfYX'acX]Z]YX'UbX %!*551<&
fYigYX) %*551<&
%20397!&
p;cYgbchfYei]fY]bghU``Uh]cbhcigYh\YUdd`]WUh]cb) %-3&$%!+3&
%+0&;%!+0&
p:UbVYigYXcbYjYfmXYj]WY) %!*551<&
%!*551<&
%+3&%!+3&
%!*551<&
-) Ecb(ZibWh]cbU`fYei]fYaYbh %!*3348*804 3 ;21&
p@bdihaYW\Ub]gah\Uh]gYUgmhcibXYfghUbX) =][)-) =cfai`UfYdfYgYbhUh]cb
pK\YfYgdcbgYUbXghUhigcZh\YUdd`]WUh]cbUfYYUgmhc
ibXYfghUbX) @bh\Y`YZhdUbY`]gUDUh\DCXcWiaYbhZcfaUhh\Uh]gigYX
Ug ]bdih cb h\Y gmghYa #gYY Z][ifY -$) K\Y f][\h dUbY` ]g Ub
+# 4<IJ@D>/<J?E;I ]``ighfUh]cb cZh\Y XcWiaYbh ]b h\Y Zcfa cZ hfYY) 9UgYX cb
@bh\]gghiXm'h\fYYhmdYgcZgcZhkUfYYjU`iUh]cbhYW\b]eiYg =][ifY - ]h WUb VY gYYb h\Uh YUW\ giV(hfYY WcbhU]bg cbY
igYX UfY V`UW_(Vcl hYgh]b[' k\]hY(Vcl hYgh]b[' UbX JcZhkUfY YldfYgg]cbWcbg]gh]b[c ZZcifbcXYgh\Uh]gUdd`m'cdYfUhcf'hkc
LgUV]`]hm JWU`Y #JLJ$) 9`UW_ Vcl hYgh]b[ ]g WcbXiWhYX hc cdYfUbXgbcXYg)9mgYY]b[h\]gdUhhYfbh\YdUfg]b[U`[cf]h\a]g
YjU`iUhYh\YWcad`]UbWY cZUgmghYak]h\gdYW]Z]YXZibWh]cbU` WfYUhYX'h\YZc``ck]b[]gh\YdgYiXcWcXYcZh\YU`[cf]h\a5
fYei]fYaYbhgig]b[WcffYgdcbX]b[fYgi`hgUbXgWYbUf]ck]h\cih
DLMU STRKTEP GEOGWOEVI PEVLIPEVMGEO JRTPWOE MQ EVL  TISTIUIQVEVMRQ
h\YbYYXhcibXYfghUbX]hg ghfiWhifYcf]bhYfbU` `c[]W Q,-R) NY YMVL MQSWVUVTIEP HEVE VÀSI
igY ghUhY hfUbg]h]cb aYh\cX hc XYf]jYX U`` h\Y hYgh WUgY UbX
JWQGVMRQ SETUIĀJRTPWOEÁ HEVEÃÁ GROUÁ XETUÁ EKKTIKEVIBSUĂĄ
YbgifYYbXigYfWUbibXYfghUbXh\YghUhYcZh\YaUW\]bYVUgYX GOIEQ EOO YLMVI USEGI MQ PEVLPO HRGWPIQVÂ
cb]hgfYgdcbgY) TRYCIUWOV Ǽ ÅǺ
JRT ĀEOO TRYU MQ HEVEĂĄ
N\]hY Vcl hYgh]b[igYXhc hYghdfcWYXifY cf]bhYfbU` `c[]W JRT ĀEOO ESSOÀARHIU MQ HRGWPIQV EU TIXITUI RTHITĂĄ
MJ ĀVLITI MU QR XETMEFOI RSITEQHĂĄ
cZUbUdd`]WUh]cbdfc[fUa Q,.R) @h]gYZZYWh]jY]bXYhYWh]b[UbX GEOGWOEVI IZSTIUUMRQ MQ RQI UWFVTII
fYgc`j]b[ dfcV`Yag' Vih hYghYf aigh \UjY _bck`YX[Y UVcih ÆIOUI Ą
MJ ĀXETMEFOI MU TIUITXIH NIÀÆĄ
]bhYfbU` ghfiWhifY UbXWcX]b[c Zdfc[fUaQ,/R) @h]gXcbYig]b[ KIV NIÀ XEOWI
h\Y VUg]g dUh\ aYh\cX k\]W\ Yld`U]bYX Vm DW:UVY Q,0R hc ÆIOUI Ą
KIV HEVWP JRT VLEV XETMEFOI
YbgifYg YjYfm WcXY ]b h\Y dfc[fUa ]g YlYWihYX gc h\Uh 6
Udd`]WUh]cb dfc[fUa WUb fYUWh hc U`` dcgg]V`Y igYf ]bdih HR VLI GEOGWOEVMRQ VR VLEV UWFVTII

]bW`iX]b[Yffcf]bdih) 6
]
ESSIQH TRYCIUWOV
Kc YbgifY igYfg WUb UWWYdh UbX igY h\Y gmghYa' ]h ]g O
TIVWTQ EKKTIKEVIBSU JRT TRYCIUWOV
bYWYggUfm hc aYUgifY h\Y igUV]`]hm cZh\Y gmghYa) Q,1R K\YfY ]`
UfYbcUVgc`ihYaYUgifYgcZigUV]`]hm' g]bWY' ]Zh\YigUV]`]hmcZ
Ub UfhYZUWh ]g XYZ]bYXVmh\Y WcbhYlh]bk\]W\h\Uh UfhYZUWh]g =][).) GgYiXcWcXY
igYX) 8 ei]W_ UbX `ck Wcgh aYh\cX hc aYUgifY igUV]`]hm ]g Gc]bhYfghUfhg Zfcah\Y XYYdYgh giV(hfYY UbXWU`Wi`UhYg h\Y
gcZhkUfY igUV]`]hm gWU`Y #JLJ$) JLJ Xc bch fYei]fY aUbm aUh\YaUh]WU`YldfYgg]cb]b]h)@Zh\YfYbcb(biaYf]WjUf]UV`Y]g
fYgdcbXYbhghc[YhUWWifUhYfYgi`hg#gUm'3(,-fYgdcbXYbh$ Q,2R) dfYgYbh' h\YbW\YW_]Z]hfY`UhYXhch\YhmdYcZh\YfYgYfjYX_Ym
JLJ gWcfY fYfdfYgYbh igYftg UWWYdhUbWY hc h\Y gcZhkUfY UbX jUf]UV`Y)@ZU_Ym]gfYgYfjYX'h\Ydfc[fUak]``fYd`UWY]hk]h\U
fYdfYgYbhUh]cb cZ ]hg jU`iY) @Z ]h ]g bch U fYgYfjYX _Ym' h\Y

1/0%)%/*0)%1*/1%.'*('F+)&(( i  *(*( <888 )/+

Authorized licensed use limited to: East Carolina University. Downloaded on June 16,2021 at 19:53:54 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
dfc[fUa k]`` fYhf]YjY h\Y WcffYgdcbX]b[ XUhia ]b XUhUgYh Udd`]WUh]cbh\Uhk]``]bhYfUWhk]h\ gmghYa) =cifdfcWYggYgh\Uh
VUgYXcbbiaVYfcZfckUbXWc`iab) UfY X]fYWh`m j]g]V`Y hc h\Y igYf' bUaY`m gY`YWh]b[ XUhUgcifWY'
ghcf]b[ Zcfai`Ug' WU`Wi`Uh]b[ Zcfai`Ug' UbX fYig]b[ ghcfYX
)# 3OIJ<CHKDD@D>F HE:<II Zcfai`Ug)
K\YfYUfYh\fYYhmdYgcZXUhUghcfYg]bh\YUdd`]WUh]cb)=]fgh'
h\Y XUhU Z]`Y ]g U XUhU ghcfY ]b h\Y Zcfa cZU Z]`Y k]h\ :JM
YlhYbg]cbh\Uh]gid`cUXYXVmh\YigYf) JYWcbX'h\YXUhUgcifWY
;9 ]g U XUhUVUgY k\YfY igYfg ghcfY XUhUh\Uhk]`` VY igYX ]b
WU`Wi`Uh]cbg)K\Yh\]fXUbXZ]bU`]gh\YZcfai`UXUhUVUgY'k\]W\
]g h\Y XUhUVUgY k\YfY igYf ghcfY dUfh]Wi`Uf aUh\YaUh]WU` cf
ghUh]gh]WU`Zcfai`U)
*# 5I<*8I<+@8>H8C

=][)/) Iibb]b[dfcWYgg

=][ifY/g\ckgh\Yfibb]b[dfcWYggYgWcadUf]gcbVYhkYYb
dfcdcgYX gmghYa UbX I gcZhkUfY) I igYfg bYYX hc kf]hY
dfc[fUaa]b[ gWf]dh gc h\Yb fib ]h ig]b[ I Yb[]bY hc [Yh h\Y
fYgi`hg) N\YfYUg' ig]b[ dfcdcgYX gmghYa igYf WUb kf]hY h\Y
XYg]fYX Zcfai`U k]h\ h\Y >L@ h\Uh \Ug VYYbdfcj]XYX) K\Yb'
h\Y Udd`]WUh]cb k]`` Xc h\Y WcbjYfg]cb UihcaUh]WU``m UbX
dfcj]XYh\YfYgi`hg)

=][ifY 1 WcbhU]bg hkc hmdYg cZUWhcfg' bUaY`m igYfg UbX

_UZ_U)LgYfgUfYU``dYcd`Yk]h\Ub]bhYfYgh]bh\YYl]ghYbWYcZ
h\]g Udd`]WUh]cb) LgYfg WUb igY U`` h\Y ZYUhifYg UjU]`UV`Y
VYWUigY h\YfY ]g bc X]j]g]cb c Zfc`Yg Zcf WYfhU]bigYfg) @b h\Y
YbX'h\Y Udd`]WUh]cbk]``igYh\Y XUhUcbh\Y_UZ_Uhcd]WhcXc
h\YWU`Wi`Uh]cb)
=cfai`U kf]h]b[ ZYUhifY YbUV`Y igYf hc kf]hY U
aUh\YaUh]WU` Zcfai`U ig]b[ j]fhiU` _YmVcUfX dfcj]XYX)
=cfai`UgVY gUjYXj]Uh\Y gUjY ZYUhifY) EYlh'igYfg WUbfYigY
Zcfai`Ug Vm gY`YWh]b[ h\Ya ]b h\Y Z]Y`Xg dfcj]XYX) LgYf WUb
W\Ub[Y UbX XY`YhY Zcfai`Ug h\Uh \UjY VYYb gUjYX) LgYfg WUb
U`gc W\ccgY XUhU gcifWYg Zfca XUhUVUgYg cf id`cUXYX Z]`Yg)
=]bU``m' ]ZU`` ]bdihg \UjY VYYb Wcad`YhYXVm h\Y Udd`]WUh]cb
igYf'gmghYak]``X]gd`Umh\YWU`Wi`Uh]cbfYgi`hgcbigYfgWfYYb)

+# 3OIJ<C(H:?@J<:JKH<
K\Y dfcdcgYX gmghYa igYg U h\fYY(h]Yf UfW\]hYWhifY Ug
g\ckb ]b =][ifY -0) K\YfY UfY h\fYY hmdYg cZ`UmYfg ]b h\]g
UfW\]hYWhifY Q-+R'bUaY`mh\YXUhUVUgY`UmYf'Udd`]WUh]cb`UmYf'
=][)0) ;UhUZ`ckX]U[fUa
UbXdfYgYbhUh]cb`UmYf) K\Y gYfjYfcfUdd`]WUh]cb`UmYf]gVi]`h
Kkc hmdYgcZYlhYfbU` U[Ybhg'bUaY`m8dUW\YBUZ_UUg Ub k]h\ h\Y ^UjU dfc[fUaa]b[ `Ub[iU[Y UbX ]g XYg][bYX hc VY
XUhU ghfYUa]b[ d`UhZcfa UbX igYfg Ug h\Y ]b]h]Uhcf c Z h\Y UV`Y hc dfcWYgg Zcfai`Ug ]b h\Y DUh\DC ZcfaUh) JYfjYf8G@

1/0%)%/*0)%1*/1%.'*('F+)&((  *(*( <888 )/,

Authorized licensed use limited to: East Carolina University. Downloaded on June 16,2021 at 19:53:54 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
WUb VY UWWYggYX j]U h\Y ?KKG * ?KKGJ dfchcWc` UbX igYg % 6?@J<"9EN4<IJ@D>
aYh\cXg giW\Ug ><K' GFJK' UbXFGK@FE) @hWUbUWWYggh\Y K89C<)@@) N\]hY(VclgWYbUf]c
XUhUVUgY hc fYhf]YjY h\Y ghcfYX Zcfai`U UbX 8dUW\Y BUZ_U hc
5I@D> *EDJ<DJ
fYhf]YjYXUhUh\Uh\UgVYYbgY`YWhYXVmh\YigYf) G Uh\ -D F K J ,NF<:J<;0KJFKJ
+8J8IEKH:< / 8J?/ .
j olT 1$ .
! "  #
, Ec PYg <adhmJhUW_<lWYdh]cb

- -6&/ PYg Ec J8O<lWYdh]cb

. PYg PYg Ei``Gc]bhYf<lWYdh]cb
/ O -%" PYg PYg ,+3,1
0''!
2'3' S o - % ,- N " ,+$ PYg PYg 13+3
4
JK,J N 
,+ PYg PYg 04)+3
7"@ D

=][) 2) JmghYa8fW\]hYWhifY KUV`Y@@WcbhU]bgUk\]hYVclhYghgWYbUf]cWcbg]gh]b[cZhYb

]bXYdYbXYbh dUh\g XYf]jYX Zfca Z`ck([fUd\ UbX biaVYf cZ
Fb h\Y W`]Ybh g]XY cf dfYgYbhUh]cb `UmYf h\Y Udd`]WUh]cb ]g WmW`caUh]W Wcad`Yl]hm Q,0R) ?ckYjYf' gcaY dUh\g WUb VY
Vi]`hig]b[?KDCUbX^UjUgWf]dh) K\ig' W`]YbhgWUb UWWYggh\Y
WcjYfYX k]h\ h\Y gUaY ]bdih' WcbgYeiYbh`m h\Y biaVYf cZ
Udd`]WUh]cb ig]b[ U kYV VfckgYf UbX ]bhYfbYh WcbbYWh]cb j]U
]bdihg]gg]l)
WcadihYf) DmJHC gYfjYf igYX ]b h\Y XUhUVUgY `UmYf hc ghcfY
XUhU]bh\YZcfacZZcfai`Ug]b`UhYlZcfaUh) FZ h\Y g]l hYgh gWYbUf]cg dYfZcfaYX' h\Y dfc[fUa WUb
,# 4<IJ@D>8D;,L8BK8J@ED dfcj]XY cihdih ]b `]bY k]h\ YldYWhUh]cbg) K\Y Z]Zh\ gWYbUf]c ]g
h\Y `cb[Ygh fibb]b[ gWYbUf]c' VYWUigY h\Y cdYfUhcfg igYX UfY
$)B8:A"9EN4<IJ@D> h\Y acgh WcadUfYXhc ch\Yf gWYbUf]cg) @h g\ci`XVY bchYXh\Uh
K\YfYUfY-1hYghgWYbUf]cgWcbXiWhYX'U``gWYbUf]cgWUbfib h\Y XUhU igYX \Ug VYYb fYUX VYZcfY YUW\ hYgh WcXY ]g fib)
giWWYggZi``m) ?ckYjYf' h\YfY ]g cbY gWYbUf]c h\Uh gh]`` fibg K\YfYZcfY' h\Y h]aY bYYXYXhc fYUXh\Y Z]`Y ]g bch ]bW`iXYX ]b
jYfm g`ck`m) K\]g ]g WUigYX Vm h\Y aYW\Ub]ga cZ\UbXg\U_Y h\Yfibh]aYg\ckb]bhUV`Y@@)
UbXgYbX]b[XUhUVYhkYYbh\YAUjUgYfjYfUbX8dUW\YBUZ_U)
&3E=JM8H< 5I89@B@JO3:8B<
K89C<) @) GYfZcfaUbWYhYgh
K\YbiaVYfcZJLJfYgdcbXYbhgkUg ,2dYcd`Y'Wcbg]gh]b[
CgbW^] E C`^_^aTSagabT\ cZ ,1 JK@J ghiXYbhg aU^cf]b[ ]b JhUh]gh]Wg UbX JhUh]gh]WU`
FRT]P`X^ @ T\ ^`g @ T\ ^`g @ T\ ^`g :cadih]b[ UbX , 9GJ Yad`cmYY) LgUV]`]hm hYgh]b[ cb h\Y
E c]bX\ T E c]bX\ T E c]bX\ T
caT caT caT Udd`]WUh]cbdfcXiWYgUgWcfYcZ2-)24) K\ig' h\YUdd`]WUh]cb]g
0), +)++,g +)+,-aV +)+10g +)-++aV -)-/.g ,)4-4aV ]b [ccX WUhY[cfm UbX WUb VY igYX Vm igYfg) ?ckYjYf' K\Y
0)- +)+,4g +)+-4aV +)+3,g +)-++aV -)+,0g -)+3/aV
`ckYgh gig gWcfY kUg /2)0 k\]W\ kUg []jYb Vm h\Y ghUh]gh]Wg
ghiXYbh) 8WWcfX]b[ hc \]a' h\Y Udd`]WUh]cb gh]`` \Ug
0). +)++.g +)+-+aV +)+/4g +)-++aV ,)42,g -)+3/aV
g\cfhWca]b[g]b]hgcdYfUh]cbgVYWUigYh\YfY]gbc ZibWh]cbZcf
0)/ +)++,g +)+-`a V +),0+g +),44aV 0)11,g -),++aV aUhf]lcdYfUh]cbgcbh\YXUhU)
0)0 +)++,g +)+/-aV +)+0-g +)-44aV /)0..g -).-,aV K\Y ZfcbhYbX gh]`` bYYX gcaY ]adfcjYaYbh hc aU_Y ]h
g]ad`YfUbXYUg]YfZcfigYfghc`YUfb) 9YWUigYeiYgh]cbbiaVYf
KUV`Y @ ]g U WcadUf]gcb cZh\Y dYfZcfaUbWY VYhkYYb h\Y
,+ #@ \UjY hc `YUfb U `ch VYZcfY @ WUb igY h\]g ZYUhifY$ UbX
Yb[]bY UbX ch\Yf XUhU dfcWYgg]b[ gcZhkUfY' bUaY`m I UbX
eiYgh]cbbiaVYf/#@h\]b_@bYYX\Y`dZfcaUhYW\b]WU`dYfgcb
dmh\cb) NY igY Gmh\cb UbX I Ug WcadUf]gcb k]h\ h\Y
hc VY UV`Y hc igY h\]g ZYUhifY$ Q--R \Ug h\Y `ckYgh UjYfU[Y
dfcdcgYX gmghYa VYWUigY cZ h\Y]f YUgY cZ aYUgif]b[
fYgi`hgWcadUfYXhch\Y gWcfY ]bch\YfeiYgh]cbg) Jc'VUgYXcb
dYfZcfaUbWY UbX dcdi`Uf]hm Uacb[ ghUh]gh]W]Ubg Q-,R) @h
h\YigYftgdYfgdYWh]jYh\]g Udd`]WUh]cb ]g gh]``fUh\YfX]ZZ]Wi`hhc
UddYUfgh\Uhh\Y Yb[]bYdfc[fUa\Ugh\Y kcfghdYfZcfaUbWY ]b
`YUfb)
hYfag cZfib h]aY UbX aYacfm igU[Y WcadUfYX hc ch\Yf XUhU
dfcWYgg]b[gcZhkUfY) K\Y `cb[fibb]b[h]aY]gdfcVUV`mXiYhc M ) : F E : C L J @ F E
h\YaYW\Ub]gacZdUfg]b[Zcfai`UgZfcah\YCUKYO ZcfaUhhc
U ZU]f`m Wcad`Yl DUh\DC WcbhYbh) @b UXX]h]cb' h\Y \][\ 9UgYX cb h\Y fYgi`hg cZ h\]g ghiXm' gYjYfU` WcbW`ig]cbg
Wci`X VY cVhU]bYX) K\Y dfcdcgYX gmghYa WUb ghcfY UbX fYigY
aYacfmigU[Y WcadUfYXhc IUbXdmh\cb]g `]_Y`m XiY hc h\Y
aYW\Ub]ga cZ dUfg]b[ h\Y DUh\DC Zcfai`U k]h\ h\Y ^UjU aUh\YaUh]WU` Zcfai`Ug ]b DUh\DC fYdfYgYbhUh]cbg) K\]g
fYgYUfW\ aU]b cihWcaY ]g DUh\DC YjU`iUhcf Yb[]bY hc
;FDdUfgYf`]VfUfmk\]W\ghcfYgXcWiaYbhgUg]bdihghfYUa]b
hfUbg`UhY Zcfai`Ug ]b h\Y Zcfa cZ DUh\DC ]bhc Udd`]WUh]cb
aYacfm)
`c[]W UbX WcbbYWh ]h hc XUhU gcifWYg VUgYX cb cdYb gcifWY
ac]g_c aUh\a`) 9`UW_(Vcl UbX k\]hY(Vcl hYgh]b[ k\]W\ UfY
WcbXiWhYX hc ZfcbhYbX Udd`]WUh]cbg UbX dfcWYgg]b[ Yb[]bYg

1/0%)%/*0)%1*/1%.'*('F+)&(( i  *(*( <888 )/-

Authorized licensed use limited to: East Carolina University. Downloaded on June 16,2021 at 19:53:54 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
g\ck YldYWhYX fYgi`hg) =fca h\Y igYftg dc]bh c Zj]Yk ig]b[
JLJ'h\YgWcfY]g2-)24k\]W\aYUbgh\YgmghYa]g]bh\Y[ccX
WUhY[cfmUbXUWWYdhUV`YVmfYgdcbXYbhg)
?ckYjYf' Zcf `c[Uf]h\a]W YldfYgg]cb CUKYO(DUh\DC
dUfgYf dfcXiWYX X]ZZYfYbh ZcfaUh cZ WcbhYbh DUh\DC
XcWiaYbh) :cbgYeiYbh`m' Yb[]bY WUbbch Xc h\Y WcadihUh]cb
VYWUigY cZ ]htg ib]eiY ghfiWhifY) =cf hYadcfUfm cf ei]W_
gc`ih]cb igYf aigh igY bUhifU` `c[Uf]h\a]W UddfcUW\ hc
WcadihY`c[Uf]h\a]WYldfYgg]cb)
I < & 9 H G H E 8 E 8 F 8 4 E 6 ;
K\]g ]b]h]U` ghiXm Wci`X VY YldUbXYX ]bhc k]XYf gWcdYg
giW\ Ug UXX]b[ aUhf]l cdYfUh]cbg hc h\Y aUh\a` WU`Wi`Uhcf'
]adfcjY`UhYlhcDUh\DCdUfgYfhc\UbX`YU[fY[UhY cdYfUh]cb
`]_Y J][ac]X UbX GfcXiWh cdYfUh]cbg' UbX Ubm ch\Yf fY`UhYX
ZYUhifYg) K\Y dYfZcfaUbWY cZ XUhU ghfYUa]b[ k\]W\ ]g
]bhY[fUhYX hc h\]g gmghYa' ])Y) 8dUW\Y BUZ_U' U`gc bYYXhc VY
]bWfYUgYX hc gYfjY `Uf[Y Uacibh cZ WcbWiffYbh igYfg)
@adfcjYaYbh cZdUfgYfg U`gc bYYX hc VY XcbY' giW\ h\Uh U``
dUfgYfcihdihWUbVYWcbgiaaYXVmYb[]bY)
E898E 8A 6 8F
M)N EPcbT\QT`V$J&!*()("&- /RQFLVH5QWURGXFWLRQWR9 DWHP DWLFDO8RJLF$
ATeL^`Z2F_`X]VT`FRXT]RT#5caX]Taa@TSXP&
M*N FcSYP]P&!)10."&9 HWRGD>WDWLVWLND$ 5P]Sc]V2G4EF<GB&
M+N =TUUT`a$ =& A& !)11-"& GWT abPbXabXRXP] P]S bWT R^\_cbT`& 6RXUQDO R I 
- SSOLHG>WDWLVWLFV $**/%*+,&
M,N H]eX]$ 4&$ ;^U\P]]$;& !)111"& :H<P]S6^\\P]S%[X]T%6^]U[XRb
^`Fg]T`Vg35Q.HUN" 7$ DQ G<RXUDKPDGL" 9$ HGV$!" /RPSXWLQJ>FLHQFH
DQ G>WDWLVWLFV !__&*,.%*-+"&C`^RTTSX]Va^UbWT+)abFg\_^aXc\^]bWT
<]bT`UPRT&
M-N 5CF& !*()1"& ?HQWDQJ .<>$ ETb`XTdTS U`^\ 5PSP] CcaPb FbPbXabXZ2
Wbb_a2''eee&Q_a&V^&XS'\T]c'['aTYP`PW&Wb\[
M.N ;PaWX\^b^$ ;&$ ;XYXZPbP$ L&$  AXaWXSP$ F& !*((0"& <]R^`_^`PbX]V
5`TPSbW9X`abFTP`RWU^`<]STfX]V@PbW@?BQYTRb& 51115QWHUQDWLRQDO
/RQIHUHQFH RQ >\VWHPV" 9 DQ DQ G / \EHUQHWLFV >9/ '%%+! !__& +-)1%
+-*+"&BaPZP2<888&
M/N :c^$ ;&$ GXP]$ K&$LP]V$ 9&$ ?X$ K& !*())"&4@TbW^S^U4SSX]VP]
4bb`XQcbTX]b^@PbW@?U^`9^`\c[PETb`XTdP[& 5QWHUQDWLRQDO /RQIHUHQFH
RQ/RPSXWHU>FLHQFHDQ G: HWZ RUN?HFKQRORJ\ $)+1(%)+1+&
1/0%)%/*0)%1*/1%.'*('F+)&(( i  *(*( <888
Authorized licensed use limited to: East Carolina University. Downloaded on June 16,2021 at 19:53:54 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
M0N >P_[P]$ I & !*()."& 4  A Te  4[V^`XbW\ b^ CP`aT P @PbWT\PbXRP[
8f_`TaaX^] P]S Xba 4__[XRPbX^] b^ 6`TPbT& ?KH 1OHYHQWK 5QWHUQDWLRQDO
/RQIHUHQFHRQ>RIWZDUH1QJLQHHULQJ- GYDQFHV"*/*%*//&
M1N F_P]VT]QT`V$ A &$ J X[ZT$ @ &$  9`P]RhgZ$ 5& !*()/"& 4  5 XV 7PbP
P`RWXbTRbc`T U^` X]b`P%ac`VXRP[ `T\PX]X]V bX\T _`TSXRbX^]a& ?KH *WK
5QWHUQDWLRQDO /RQIHUHQFHRQ /XUUHQWDQ G2XWXUH ?UHQGV R I 5 QIRUPDWLRQ
DQ G/RPPXQLFDWLRQ ?HFKQRORJLHVLQ4 HDOWKFDUH 5/?4'%&*!"+)(%+)/&
M)(N FWP`\P$ F& >&$  FX]VW$ 4 & !*()."& F^UbeP`T7TdT[^_\T]b?XUT 6gR[T&
5QWHUQDWLRQDO6RXUQDOR I 9 RGHP 1QJLQHHULQJDQ G=HVHDUFK ?HFKQRORJ\"
-%)(&
M))N FP_cb`P$ F& <& !*(*($ - )-"& -FDGHPLD$ ETb`XTdTS U`^\ 4RPST\XP2
Wbb_a2''eee&PRPST\XP&TSc'+-*.0**('<]R`T\T]bP[O@ ^ST[&S^Rf
M)*N >WP]$ @& 8& !*())"& 7<998E8AG 4CCEB46;8F GB 5?4 6 >  5B K 
G8FG<A: G86;A<DH8 9BE 9<A7<A: 8EEBEF& 5QWHUQDWLRQDO
6RXUQDOR I > RIWZDUH1QJLQHHULQJ - SSOLFDWLRQV"+)%,(&
M)+N FgPXZWcSSX]$ @& @ &$ 4]P\$ 6&$ EX]P[SX$ 4 & E&$  6^]^`Pa$ @& 8&
!*()/"& 6^]dT]bX^]P[ F^UbeP`T GTabX]V H aX]V JWXbT 5 ^f @TbW^S&
75:1?57, 3DPH ?HFKQRORJ\" 5QIRUPDWLRQ >\VWHP" /RPSXWHU:HWZRUN"
/RPSXWLQJ"1OHFWURQLFV" DQ G/RQWURO"./%/,&
M),N =^dP]^dXS$  <`T]P& !*((1$ =P]cP`g"& >RIWZDUH ?HVWLQJ 9 HWKRGV DQG
?HFKQLTXHV$ ETb`XTdTS U`^\ <CF< G`P]aPRbX^]a2
Wbb_2''bX`&X_aXb`P]aPRbX^]a&^`V'*((1'=P]cP`g'CP_T`*((.&_SU
M)-N @R6PQT$ G& =& !)1/."& 4  6^\_[TfXbg @TPac`T& 5111 ?UDQVDFWLRQV RQ
>RIWZDUH1QJLQHHULQJ"+(0%+*(&
M).N 5`^^ZT$ =& !]&S&"& >@>#-TXLFN DQG GLUW\ XVDELOLW\ VFDOH$ 5TPR^]aUXT[S
JPg2 ETSWPbRW6^]ac[bX]V?bS&
M)/N Gc[[Xa$ G&$  FbTba^]$ =& A & !*((,"& 4 6^\_P`Xa^]^ U DcTabX^]]PX`Ta U^`
4 aaTaaX]V J TQaXbT HaPQX[Xbg& < URFHHGLQJV R I  @<- '%%) /RQIHUHQFH"
!__&/%))"&@X]]TP_^[Xa&
M)0N 5`^^ZT$ =& !*()+"& FHF2 4  ETb`^a_TRbXdT& 6;@=:-8 ; 2  @>-.585?C
>?@051>"*1%,(&
M)1N 4caQ`^^Za$E&$ 5 caeT[[$ F&$ 6P`[Xa[T$ 7 &$ 6WPdRWP]XShT$ :&$ 7P[\Pa$ F&$
7TdXbb$ F &&&&&&&&&&&&&JPbb $ F& !*(),"& 9 DWKHP DWLFDO 9 DUNXS 8DQJXDJH
9DWK98! AHUVLRQ( $% 'Q G1GLWLRQ$ J +6ETR^\T]SPbX^]&
M*(N >c\P`$ F& !*()1"& 4  E8I<8J BA  6?<8AG%F8EI8E 54 F87
4CC?<64G<BAF 4 A 7  E8F84E6; BCCBEGHA<GL& 5QWHUQDWLRQDO
6RXUQDOR I > FLHQWLILF=HVHDUFK"++0-/%++0.*&
M*)N >c\P`$4 & !*()1$4_`X[0"&9 HGLXP$ETb`XTdTSU`^\G^_.7PbPFRXT]RT
C`^V`P\\X]V ?P]VcPVTa U^` *()12
Wbb_a2''\TSXc\&R^\'SPbPS`XdT]X]dTab^`'b^_%.%SPbP%aRXT]RT%
_`^V`P\\X]V%[P]VcPVTa%U^`%*()1%+1QP[Q.0)1P0
M**N FPc`^$ =& !*()+$ =c]T )0"& &% ?45:3> ?; 7 : ; B  - . ; @ ?  ?41
>C>?19 @>-.585?C >/-81 >@>!$ ETb`XTdTS U`^\ @TPac`X]V H2
Wbb_a2''\TPac`X]Vc&R^\')(%bWX]Va%aca&
)/.