Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HA GI
9VX NPVtZ TX YR aXN SXaW NZTarZR RZNX
e aP Z X
,,
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
EC9 9ZYfYbhY =ZYfYbhY GNOXN ). ( >] hfUV] ]XUX XY gighUbW]Ug dcf WUd] UfYg
"/+. a ( a]b UfhYf]c U UfhYf]c U [ caYfi UfYg gY[ b Y dYgc ac YWi Uf
Fa NZPVN CR Y XRPaXN 9VX NOVXVQNQ
9[iU 1 ')
? caYfi Uf KcX]c +, ')
WUd] UfYg
? iWcgU 1) ')
:ckaUb
Wxdgi U Abi ]bU ..)) ')
E]c[ cV]bU 0'))) )%0.
G9: 9 V a]bU /2'))) )%)).
" +. a ( a]b
=gdUW]c XY :ckaUb
9fhYf]c U UZYfYbhY ?N Y XqPaXN T NZQR PN TNQN ZRTN VbNYRZ R R SVX NZ
U Wxdgi U XY :ckaUb 9fhYf]c U YZYfYbhY
P Z YRZ SNPVXVQNQ aR XN Y XqPaXN PN TNQN
9 V VbNYRZ R QR VTaNX NYNs Y XRPaXN % = X]xaYhfc
Hcfcg XY YbX]XifU
ac YWi Uf XY U dfchY bU d Ugaxh]WU U V a]bU Yg g c XY ibcg
/ bUb aYhfcg% a]YbhfUg eiY gY WfYY eiY cg dcfcg XY U
aYaVfUbU [ caYfi Uf gcb XY ibcg 1 bUb aYhfcg "1)
Ub[ghfcag SuT ' K]b YaVUf[c% U U V a]bU bc diYXY Z] hfUfgY
=d]hY ]c XYV]Xc U gi WUf[U bY[Uh]jU m U fYdi g] b Y YWhfcghxh]WU
Y YfW]XU dcf Ug WUf[Ug bY[Uh]jUg XY cg dfchYc[ ]WUbcg XY U
dUfYX WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf'
K hUbc 9VTa N ). % aiYghfU W ac U WUf[U Y zWhf]WU UZYWhU U
aYaVfUbU Z] hfUW] b XY XYlhfUbcg XY X]ZYfYbhYg dYgcg ac YWi UfYg dcf Y
[ cazfi c' Dcg XYlhfUbcg gcb dc ]gUWxf]Xcg eiY gY diYXYb
=bXchY ]c
ZUVf]WUf Wcac ac zWi Ug bYihfUg c Wcb WUf[Ug bY[Uh]jUg c
,,+
6N V aX ). >] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf% Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m gi Wcbhfc
')
9ZYfYbhY =ZYfYbhY
UfhYf]c U :X YR aXN :X YR aXN UfhYf]c U
)%1 Yt VP P X VQR UVQ p VP
R VtZ R VtZ
9VX NOVXVQNQ RXN VbN
<YlhfUbc dc ]WUh] b]Wc
- YY T ) YY T
)%/
FYihfU
HA GI
XYlhfUbc
)'-
Hc ]Ub] b]Wc
XYlhfUbc 5 cYNZ
)%+
Pp aXN
R VtZ
) (/ YY T
1 ++ +/ ,) ,- ,1 -+
ENQV Y XRPaXN RSRP Vb j ? caYfi Uf :ckaUb ? caYfi Uf
>] hfUW] b bYhU
6 ]Xfcghxh]Wc Wxdgi U cga h]Wc Wc c]XY
9VTa N ). % =ZYWhc XY fUX]c ac YWi Uf m U WUf[U Y zWhf]WU XY dfYg] b
dfYg] b dfYg] b dfYg] b
XYlhfUbc gcVfY gi Z] hfUV] ]XUX dcf cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg' Mb jU cf " ) aa [
"/) aa [ " 1 aa [ ",+ aa [
XY ') ]bX]WU eiY U gighUbW]U gY Z] hfU hUb ]VfYaYbhY Wcac Y U[iU%
a]YbhfUg eiY ib jU cf XY ) ]bX]WU eiY bc gY Z] hfU' Dcg XYlhfUbcg gcb 9VTa N ). +% JYgiaYb XY Ug ZiYfnUg eiY dfcjcWUb U Z] hfUW] b dcf cg WUd] UfYg
dc ]gUWxf]Xcg eiY diYXYb ZUVf]WUfgY Wcac ac zWi Ug bYihfUg c Wcb [ caYfi UfYg' Dcg jU cfYg acghfUXcg gcb Ygh]aUW]cbYg dUfU gYfYg iaUbcg gUbcg'
,,,
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
Yt VPN
YghUXcg dUhc []Wcg% Wcac gY UbU ]nU axg UXY UbhY'
6 X VQR TX YR aXN
,/
4H 8AGB 78? 6B89 6 8AG8 78 9 ?GE46 nA ,-
T
64C ?4E :?B 8EH?4E 4H 8AG4 ?4 G4F4 78
YY
,+
R VtZ
9 ?GE47B :?B 8EH?4E >] hfUW] b
,)
ZfUWW] b
DU C> Yg ibU aYX]XU XY dfcXiWhc XY U WcbXiWh]j]XUX +1
]Xfxi ]WU m Y xfYU XY gidYfZ]W]Y XY cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg'
DU C> bc gY diYXY aYX]f X]fYWhUaYbhY% dYfc gY diYXY Ygh]aUf 9ZYfYbhY =ZYfYbhY
7V NZPVN N X XN T
YldYf]aYbhU aYbhY X]j]X]YbXc U L>? dcf Y Z] hfUXc bYhc' Z]b Z]b
PN VXN TX YR aXN
dfYg] b XY hfUWW] b3
9VTa N ). ,% 9iaYbhc XY U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY Yb Y d UgaU eiY Z imY U
C > 6 ?>J ( HfYg] b XY Z] hfUW] b bYhU hfUjzg XY WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf' FcfaU aYbhY% Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY ibU ei]bhU dUfhY
XY ei]Xc XY cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg gY Z] hfU UW]U U Wxdgi U XY :ckaUb%
<YV]Xc U eiY U L>? hchU dUfU UaVcg f] cbYg Yg XY Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY WcbWYbhfUbXc Ug Ug dfchY bUg d Ugaxh]WUg eiY bc gY Z] hfUb' Dcg UiaYbhcg Yb U
+. a ( a]b m U dfYg] b bYhU XY Z] hfUW] b Yg XY ) aa [% U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b "hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf ( Z i c d Ugaxh]Wc fYbU
bcfaU C> gY WU Wi U Yb Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY +%. a ( a]b dcf aa UiaYbhUb U jY cW]XUX U U eiY UiaYbhU U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY d Ugaxh]WU U
c Uf[c XY WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf4 Ug X]ga]biW]cbYg Yb U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b h]YbYb
[ XY dfYg] b XY Z] hfUW] b' ;iUbXc C> gY YldfYgU dcf ))
Y YZYWhc WcbhfUf]c'
[fUacg XY dYgc XY f] b% h]YbY ib dfcaYX]c XY -%+ a ( a]b
dcf aa [% ib jU cf ibUg -)) jYWYg axg U hc eiY Y C> XY U
aUmcf U XY cg XYaxg g]ghYaUg WUd] UfYg XY WiYfdc' DU aYX]U U U ZcfaUW] b XY Wx Wi cg eiY gY U c Ub Yb Y hfUWhc if]bUf]c% U
C> XY aiW cg chfcg hY ]Xcg Yb Y WiYfdc Yg gc c U fYXYXcf XY )') aYbiXc Yb Y ifzhYf% cVghfimYbXc Ug Y Z i c XY gU ]XU XY hfUWhc
a ( a]b dcf aa [ ( )) [' =ghY U hc C> dUfU cg WUd] UfYg if]bUf]c m UiaYbhUbXc U dfYg] b XY U Wxdgi U XY :ckaUb' =ghU
[ caYfi UfYg Wcbhf]VimY U gi fxd]XU hUgU XY ei]Xc g]hiUW] b fYXiWY U L>? m YjYbhiU aYbhY diYXY WUigUf
Z] hfUW] b' ]XfcbYZfcg]g "X]ghYbg] b m X] UhUW] b XY U dY j]g fYbU m cg
9ibeiY UiaYbh C> UiaYbhU U L>? m X]ga]bimY Wx ]WYg m diYXYb XU Uf c ]bW igc XYghfi]f Y f] b U aYbcg eiY gY
C> fYXiWY U L>?% WUaV]cg Yb C> HfcVUV YaYbhY bc dfcdcfW]cbYb U ]j]Y U cVghfiWW] b'
ib aYWUb]gac df]aUf]c dUfU U fY[i UW] b X]Uf]U bcfaU '
8? 4H 8AGB 78 ?4 CE8F nA BF nG 64 78?
UW] b XY U L>?' 9 [ibUg YbZYfaYXUXYg% g]b YaVUf[c% fYXiWYb Y
6B?B 78 64C ?4E :?B 8EH?4E 7 F AHL8 ?4
C> fYXiW]YbXc Y b aYfc XY WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg ZibW]cbU Yg
G4F4 78 9 ?GE46 nA :?B 8EH?4E
]Yg "fYXiW]YbXc Ug U gidYfZ]W]Y XY Z] hfUW] b c
UiaYbhUbXc Y [fcgcf XY U aYaVfUbU WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf 9 aYX]XU eiY U gUb[fY dUgU XY U UfhYf]c U UZYfYbhY U hfUjzg XY
m fYXiW]YbXc gi WcbXiWh]j]XUX ]Xfxi ]WU' Hcf Y Yad c% U cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg U Ug UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg% U
]dYfhYbg] b Wf b]WU bc Wcbhfc UXU diYXY [fUXiUfgY WcbWYbhfUW] b XY dfchY bU d Ugaxh]WU UiaYbhU Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY
fYXiW]f C> UiaYbhUbXc Y [fcgcf XY U aYaVfUbU ib +) "9VTa N ). ,% ' DU fUn b XY YghY UiaYbhc Yg eiY
VUgU XY WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf m% Z]bU aYbhY% Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY ibU ei]bhU dUfhY XY ei]Xc XY cg WUd] UfYg gY
<U UbXc cg WUd] UfYg hUb gYjYfUaYbhY eiY Um ibU dzfX]XU Z] hfU UW]U U Wxdgi U XY :ckaUb% c eiY WcbWYbhfU Ug dfchY bUg
XY ZibW] b WUd] Uf' d Ugaxh]WUg [ caYfi UfYg eiY bc gY Z] hfUb' Kidcb]YbXc eiY U
dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XU bcfaU XY d UgaU eiY ]b[fYgU U cg
WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg Yg XY +1 aa [% YghY jU cf giY Y Y YjUfgY
8? 4H 8AGB 78 ?4 CE8F nA 7EBFGiG 64 78
U ibcg ,/ aa [ WiUbXc U gUb[fY U WUbnU Y YlhfYac YZYfYbhY
?4 6iCFH?4 78 5BJ 4A 7 F AHL8 ?4 G4F4
XY cg WUd] UfYg' Hcf c hUbhc% U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XU
78 9 ?GE46 nA :?B 8EH?4E
dfcaYX]c XY Ug dfchY bUg d Ugaxh]WUg XY cg WUd] UfYg
DUg aYX]W]cbYg X]fYWhUg XY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU Yb U Wxdgi U XY [ caYfi UfYg gY YbWiYbhfU U aYX]c WUa]bc YbhfY +1 m ,/ aa [%
:ckaUb m Yb X]ZYfYbhYg dibhcg XY h Vi c dfcl]aU Yb Ub]aU Yg XY c U fYXYXcf XY ,+ aa ['
YldYf]aYbhUW] b ih] ]nUbXc a]Wfcd]dYhUg Ub gi[Yf]Xc eiY ibU <cg ZUWhcfYg eiY ]bZ imYb Yb U dfYg] b cga h]WU
Ygh]aUW] b fUncbUV Y XY U dfYg] b XY U Wxdgi U XY :ckaUb Yb Wc c]XY WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf gcb cg g][i]YbhYg3 " U dfYg] b
iaUbcg Yg XY Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY 1 aa [ Yb WcbX]W]cbYg bcfaU Yg' cga h]WU Wc c]XU d Ugaxh]WU UfhYf]U 4 m "+ U ZfUWW] b XY
= UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU Yb U Wxdgi U XY :ckaUb fYXiWY d UgaU Z] hfUXU dcf cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg "ZfUWW] b XY
U L>?% a]YbhfUg eiY U X]ga]biW] b XY YghU dfYg] b UiaYbhU U L>?' Z] hfUW] b ' = UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XU
K]b YaVUf[c% cg WUaV]cg Yb U dfYg] b XY U Wxdgi U XY :ckaUb d Ugaxh]WU UfhYf]U Y YjU U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XU
bcfaU aYbhY bc g]fjYb Wcac ib aYX]c df]bW]dU dUfU fY[i Uf U L>?' WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf% eiY U gi jYn h]YbXY U X]ga]bi]f U L>?'
= UiaYbhc XY U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b hUaV]zb WcbWYbhfU Ug
=b W]Yfhcg YghUXcg dUhc []Wcg UgcW]UXcg Wcb U cVghfiWW] b XY dfchY bUg d Ugaxh]WUg m UiaYbhU U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY
hfUWhc if]bUf]c% U dfYg] b XY U Wxdgi U XY :ckaUb diYXY UiaYbhUf [ caYfi Uf' "jYf 9VTa N ). ,% ' <YV]Xc U eiY U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b gY
bchUV YaYbhY% dfcjcWUbXc ibU fYXiWW] b ]adcfhUbhY XY U L>?' Hcf XYZ]bY Wcac U L>? X]j]X]XU dcf Y Z i c d Ugaxh]Wc fYbU % U ZfUWW] b XY
Y Yad c% U dfYW]d]hUW] b XY WU W]c c XY xW]Xc f]Wc diYXY WcbXiW]f Z] hfUW] b gY diYXY UiaYbhUf Y YjUbXc U L>? c
,,-
6N V aX ). >] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf% Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m gi Wcbhfc
HA GI
G9:
dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf'
;cb Y UiaYbhc XY Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU % ]b]W]U aYbhY gY Z] hfU ibU
ZfUWW] b aYbcf XY d UgaU ZiYfU XY cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg% c eiY
dfcjcWU ib UiaYbhc axg Ybhc XY U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY WUd] Uf
[ caYfi Uf m ib YZYWhc aYbcg ]b ]V]Xcf gcVfY U L>?' =b WcbgYWiYbW]U% EYV
]bW igc Wcb ibU dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf WcbghUbhY% ibU aUmcf
C4::E4 B
hUgU XY Z i c gUb[i bYc UW]U Y [ cazfi c h]YbXY U UiaYbhUf U L>? m
ibU aYbcf hUgU XY Z i c gUb[i bYc UW]U Y [ cazfi c h]YbXY U ERZNX
NZT R
X]ga]bi]f U L>?' SXaV
G9:
4H 8AGB 78 ?4 CE8F nA 7EBFGiG 64
64C ?4E :?B 8EH?4E 4H 8AG4 ?4 G4F4
78 9 ?GE46 nA :?B 8EH?4E 9VTa N ). -% =ZYWhc XY cg UiaYbhcg XY U fYg]ghYbW]U UfhYf]c Uf UZYfYbhY "J9%
dUbY gidYf]cf c fYg]ghYbW]U UfhYf]c Uf YZYfYbhY "Ja]% dUbY ]bZYf]cf Yb Y
KY U Ygh]aUXc eiY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf Yg Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU % dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf "H?J9EG m [ caYfi Uf
XY Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY /) aa [ Yb WcbX]W]cbYg bcfaU Yg' Dcg hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b "L>? '
RZNX
[ caYfi Uf fYXiWYb U L>?' )) -))
bRX PVQNQ YX YVZ
FcfaU
YX YVZ
DU dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf Yghx XYhYfa]bUXU dcf
NZTarZR
hfYg jUf]UV Yg% WUXU ibU XY Ug WiU Yg Yghx VU c Wcbhfc
.) 1))
Z]g]c []Wc3 " dfYg]cb UfhYf]U 4 "+ fYg]ghYbW]U UfhYf]c Uf
9XaW
UZYfYbhY4 m ", fYg]ghYbW]U UfhYf]c Uf YZYfYbhY' KUb[fY fYbU
Z i]f
= UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U h]YbXY U Y YjUf U dfYg] b ) +))
]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf m% dcf hUbhc% U UiaYbhUf U L>?' K]b YaVUf[c% ) + , -
Wcac gY X]gWih]fx axg UXY UbhY% YghY YZYWhc Yg Uacfh][iUXc dcf ER V RZPVN N R V XN RSR RZ R
w Z YNX
aYWUb]gacg UihcffY[i UXcfYg eiY aUbh]YbYb ibU dfYg] b [ caYfi Uf
fY Uh]jUaYbhY WcbghUbhY U aYX]XU eiY Z iWh U U dfYg] b UfhYf]U '
= UiaYbhc XY U fYg]ghYbW]U XY Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg +.) +)))
fYXiWY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf m X]ga]bimY U L>? "
))
9VX NPVtZ TX YR aXN
Z] hfUW] b
aYWUb]gac Y YjU U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf m% g]YadfY bX]WY
) +))
eiY Y UiaYbhc XY U fYg]ghYbW]U YZYfYbhY bc fYXinWU XYaUg]UXc
) + , -
Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU % U L>? UiaYbhU ][YfUaYbhY "jYf9VTa N
ER V RZPVN N R V XN NSR RZ R
). -% ' K]b YaVUf[c% XYV]Xc U eiY U Wcbghf]WW] b UfhYf]c Uf w Z YNX
YZYfYbhY hUaV]zb fYXiWY Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU % U ZfUWW] b XY
9VTa N ). .% =ZYWhc XY WUaV]c Yb U fYg]ghYbW]U UfhYf]c Uf UZYfYbhY c U fYg]ghYbW]U
Z] hfUW] b m U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY [ caYfi Uf UiaYbhUb U UfhYf]c Uf YZYfYbhY gcVfY U hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf m Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU '
aYX]XU eiY UiaYbhU U fYg]ghYbW]U UfhYf]c Uf YZYfYbhY' Hcf c
hUbhc% g] U Wcbghf]WW] b XY Ug UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg Yg [fUjY "axg
XY Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY ib UiaYbhc XY hfYg jYWYg Yb U fYg]ghYbW]U Hcf hUbhc% U Wcbghf]WW] b UfhYf]c Uf YZYfYbhY h]YbY ib YZYWhc
UfhYf]c Uf YZYfYbhY % Y UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY V]Zxg]Wc gcVfY U L>? "9VTa N ). .% ' 9 b]jY Yg acXYfUXcg XY
YlWYXY Y UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf Wcbghf]WW] b% Um ib ][Yfc UiaYbhc XY U L>? dYfc% Wcb ibU
WUigUXc dcf U Wcbghf]WW] b UfhYf]c Uf YZYfYbhY' ;iUbXc cWiffY Wcbghf]WW] b [fUjY% Um ibU X]ga]biW] b XY U L>?' DU WUigU
YghU g]hiUW] b% Y ZiYfnU bYhU dcfeiY U Z] hfUW] b Yb fYU ]XUX df]bW]dU XY U YjYbhiU X]ga]biW] b XY U L>? Yg U g][i]YbhY' 9
X]ga]bimY% c eiY dfcjcWU ibU fYXiWW] b XY U L>?' aYX]XU eiY U Wcbghf]WW] b YZYfYbhY gY jiY jY gYjYfU m Y d UgaU
,,.
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
QRX VstZ
C> L>? =bZYfaYXUX fYbU % X]UVYhYg aY ]hig%
+')
6 Z aY QR dVTRZ
]dYfhYbg] b% YbjY YW]a]Ybhc
T QR R
fYbU Yg %.
¨?J9EG L>? > i c gUb[i bYc fYbU % UiaYbhc XY Ug dfchY bUg
YX YVZ (
d Ugaxh]WUg' ')
H9??J9EG L>?
,,/
6N V aX ). >] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf% Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m gi Wcbhfc
GNOXN ). HfYg]cbYg Udfcl]aUXUg m fYg]ghYbW]Ug 6aNQ ). + cfacbUg m UihUWc]XYg eiY ]bZ imYb Yb U
jUgWi UfYg Yb U W]fWi UW] b XY ib f] b bcfaU hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf "L>?
C R VtZ RZ RX RPV VRZ R C PRZ NWR Y ZN Na NP VQR 8SRP O R XN G9:
YY T QR G NX ER
FcfUXfYbU ]bU
ZNX IN PaXN
8YON PNPVtZ 6 YVRZf 9VZ ER V RZPVN =d]bYZf]bU
HA GI
9fhYf]U fYbU )) )) ) =bXchY ]bU
,,0
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
?N Z R VZRS VZN XN R VZRS VZN e XN RZQ RXVZN R VZTRZ X bN fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c m U[iU% Wcac gY XYgWf]VY Yb
NZTarZR RZNXR e QV YVZaeRZ XN N N QR SVX NPVtZ TX YR aXN % ;Ud]hi c +1'
DUg cfacbUg eiY WcbhfUYb Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg m YZYfYbhYg% Hcf hUbhc% cg b]jY Yg Y YjUXcg XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA eiY gY dfcXiWYb
dfcjcWUbXc fYXiWW]cbYg Yb U L>? m Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU % Wcb ibU X]YhU VU U Yb gcX]c c Wcb ibU XYd YW] b XY jc iaYb UmiXUb U
]bW imYb bcfYd]bYZf]bU m Yd]bYZf]bU ]VYfUXc XY U azXi U aUbhYbYf U L>? m U YlWfYW] b bcfaU XY dfcXiWhcg XY XYgYW c
gidfUffYbU ' =b [YbYfU % cg b]jY Yg gUb[i bYcg XY YghUg aYhUV ]Wcg% Wcac ifYU m WfYUh]b]bU% eiY XYdYbXYb XY U Z] hfUW] b
cfacbUg gcb dUfU Y cg U U UWh]j]XUX XY g]ghYaU bYfj]cgc [ caYfi Uf dUfU gi YlWfYW] b' 9 a]gac h]Yadc% U Wcbghf]WW] b XY Ug
g]adxh]Wc4 dcf hUbhc% U bcfUXfYbU ]bU m U Yd]bYZf]bU h]YbYb dcWU UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg ]bXiW]XU dcf U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA UiaYbhU U
]bZ iYbW]U gcVfY U YacX]bxa]WU fYbU % YlWYdhc Yb WcbX]W]cbYg fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf XY gcX]c m U[iU% c eiY UmiXU U fYghUifUf Y
UgcW]UXUg Wcb ibU ZiYfhY UWh]jUW] b XY g]ghYaU bYfj]cgc jc iaYb gUb[i bYc m U dfYg] b UfhYf]U ' =ghY YZYWhc XY U Ub[]chYbg]bU
g]adxh]Wc% Wcac ibU YacffU[]U [fUjY' AA dUfU UmiXUf U UihcffY[i Uf U L>? gY UbU ]nU Wcb axg XYhU Y axg
Ghfc jUgcWcbghf]Whcf% YbXchY ]bU% Yg ib dzdh]Xc eiY UXY UbhY Yb YghY WUd hi c'
diYXY gYf ]VYfUXc dcf Ug Wz i Ug YbXchY ]U Yg jUgWi UfYg
XU UXUg XY cg f] cbYg% Ug Wcac dcf chfcg hY ]Xcg' = dUdY 8X tdVQ Zr VP QR VbNQ QRX RZQ RXV QV YVZaeR XN
Z]g]c []Wc XY YghY UihUWc]XY bc gY WcadfYbXY R V RZPVN bN PaXN RZNX e NaYRZ N XN N N QR SVX NPVtZ
Wcad YhUaYbhY' K]b YaVUf[c% U YbXchY ]bU diYXY Wcbhf]Vi]f TX YR aXN % Mb UihUWc]XY eiY X]ga]bimY U fYg]ghYbW]U
U U YacghUg]U "a]b]a]nUbXc U dzfX]XU XY gUb[fY WiUbXc jUgWi Uf fYbU m Yg ]VYfUXc dcf Y YbXchY ]c jUgWi Uf Yb hcXc
gY WcfhU ib jUgc gUb[i bYc% c eiY XU U Y YbXchY ]c m ]VYfU Y WiYfdc Yg l]Xc b hf]Wc XYf]jUXc XY YbXchY ]c' Mb b]jY
YghY dcXYfcgc jUgcWcbghf]Whcf' Dcg b]jY Yg d Ugaxh]Wcg XY VUgU XY dfcXiWW] b XY l]Xc b hf]Wc dUfYWY gYf ]adcfhUbhY
YbXchY ]bU hUaV]zb UiaYbhUb Yb aiW Ug YbZYfaYXUXYg dUfU aUbhYbYf U jUgcX] UhUW] b XY cg f] cbYg m U YlWfYW] b
UgcW]UXUg Wcb Yg] b jUgWi Uf% Wcac hclYa]U XY YaVUfUnc% bcfaU XY gcX]c m U[iU' Hcf hUbhc% U UXa]b]ghfUW] b XY
]bgiZ]W]YbW]U fYbU U[iXU m ifYa]U Wf b]WU% m diYXYb ZxfaUWcg eiY ]b ]VYb U ZcfaUW] b XY l]Xc b hf]Wc UiaYbhU
Wcbhf]Vi]f U U jUgcWcbghf]WW] b fYbU m U L>? X]ga]bi]XU Yb U fYg]ghYbW]U jUgWi Uf fYbU m fYXiWY U L>? m U YlWfYW] b
U [ibUg XY YghUg UZYWW]cbYg Z]g]cdUhc []WUg' if]bUf]U XY gcX]c% c eiY YjYbhiU aYbhY dfcjcWU ]dYfhYbg] b
UfhYf]U ' =b U [ibcg dUW]YbhYg ]dYfhYbgcg c Yb dUW]YbhYg Wcb
?N NZTV RZ VZN R VZTR RSR RZ RYRZ R XN N R V XN UhYfcgW Yfcg]g% Y XU c XY YbXchY ]c jUgWi Uf m U dfcXiWW] b
RSR RZ R RZ XN YNe rN QR XN P ZQVPV ZR SV V XtTVPN % Mb U hYfUXU XY l]Xc b hf]Wc diYXYb Wcbhf]Vi]f U ib UiaYbhc XY
dchYbhY jUgcWcbghf]Whcf fYbU % Ub[]chYbg]bU AA% diYXY U jUgcWcbghf]WW] b fYbU m U ibU dfYg] b UfhYf]U Y YjUXU'
Wcbg]XYfUfgY ibU cfacbU W]fWi UbhY m ib dfcXiWhc cWU
UihUWc]XY c cfacbU dUfUWf]bU dcfeiY gY ZcfaU Yb cg f] cbYg m
Yb U W]fWi UW] b g]ghza]WU' Dcg fYWYdhcfYg XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA ?N NTXNZQVZN e XN O NQVPVZVZN QV YVZaeRZ XN R V RZPVN
Yghxb dfYgYbhYg Yb dfxWh]WUaYbhY hcXcg cg jUgcg gUb[i bYcg XY bN PaXN RZNX e VRZQRZ N NaYRZ N XN N N QR SVX NPVtZ
cg f] cbYg' K]b YaVUf[c% cg jUgcg gUb[i bYcg dfY[ caYfi UfYg% TX YR aXN % DUg dfcghU[ UbX]bUg "H?=+ m H?A+ m U VfUX]W]b]bU
YgdYW]U aYbhY Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg% dUfYWYb YghUf UWh Ub Wcac cfacbUg m UihUWc]XYg eiY WUigUb jUgcX] UhUW] b%
fY Uh]jUaYbhY dfchY[]Xcg XY U Wcbghf]WW] b aYX]UXU dcf UiaYbhc XY Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m UiaYbhc XY U L>?' =ghUg
Ub[]chYbg]bU AA Yb U aUmcf U XY Ug WcbX]W]cbYg Z]g]c []WUg gighUbW]Ug gY X]gWihYb Yb;Ud hi c 0' 9ibeiY Yghcg
UgcW]UXUg Wcb U UWh]jUW] b XY g]ghYaU fYb]bU Ub[]chYbg]bU% Wcac jUgcX] UhUXcfYg bc dUfYWYb gYf XY [fUb ]adcfhUbW]U Yb U
XifUbhY ibU X]YhU VU U Yb gcX]c c dfYg] b XY dYfZig] b fYbU fY[i UW] b XY Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU c U L>? Yb WcbX]W]cbYg
fYXiW]XU XYV]Xc U YghYbcg]g XY U UfhYf]U fYbU ' =ghU dfchYWW] b gY bcfaU Yg% diYXYb Uacfh][iUf cg YZYWhcg jUgcWcbghf]WhcfYg
XYVY U U ]VYfUW] b XY jUgcX] UhUXcfYg% YgdYW]U aYbhY l]Xc fYbU Yg XY cg bYfj]cg g]adxh]Wcg c U Ub[]chYbg]bU'
b hf]Wc m dfcghU[ UbX]bUg% eiY WcbhfUffYghUb cg YZYWhcg AA% YgdYW]U aYbhY gig YZYWhcg dUfU WcbhfUYf Ug UfhYf]c Ug
jUgcWcbghf]WhcfYg XY U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA Yb Yghcg jUgcg gUb[i bYcg' UZYfYbhYg'
K]b YaVUf[c% Ug UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg gcb aim gYbg]V Yg U U 9 cdcbYfgY U U jUgcWcbghf]WW] b XY Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg%
Ub[]chYbg]bU AA' <YV]Xc U eiY U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA Wcbghf] Y Ug dfcghU[ UbX]bUg UmiXUb U dfYjYb]f fYXiWW]cbYg YlWYg]jUg XY U
dfYZYfYbhYaYbhY Ug UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg Yb U aUmcf U XY Ug L>? m XY Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU ' =b WcbX]W]cbYg YghfYgUbhYg% Wcac
WcbX]W]cbYg Z]g]c []WUg% Y UiaYbhc XY cg b]jY Yg XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA U XYd YW] b XY jc iaYb c XYgdizg XY ibU W]fi[ U% U
Y YjU U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf U h]Yadc eiY fYXiWY Y Z i c UXa]b]ghfUW] b XY Ubh]]bZ UaUhcf]cg bc YghYfc]XYcg "9AF= % Wcac
gUb[i bYc fYbU ' <YVY hYbYfgY Yb WiYbhU eiY Y UiaYbhc XY U U Ugd]f]bU% eiY ]b ]VYb U g bhYg]g XY dfcghU[ UbX]bUg% diYXY
ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA [YbYfU aYbhY cWiffY Yb W]fWibghUbW]Ug dfcjcWUf fYXiWW]cbYg g][b]Z]WUh]jUg XY U L>?'
UgcW]UXUg Wcb X]ga]biW] b XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U c XYd YW] b XY
jc iaYb% eiY h]YbXYb U X]ga]bi]f U L>?' =b YghUg W]fWibghUbW]Ug% Y
4HGBE8:H?46 nA 78 ?4 G4F4 78 9 ?GE46 nA
UiaYbhc XY b]jY XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA% U WcbhfUYf Ug UfhYf]c Ug
:?B 8EH?4E L 78? 9?H=B F4A:HlA8B E8A4?
YZYfYbhYg% UmiXU UYj]hUf <]ga]bimY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf
m U L>?' K]b YaVUf[c% U a]gac h]Yadc% U fYXiWW] b XY Z i c
gUb[i bYc fYbU WUigUXU dcf U Wcbghf]WW] b UfhYf]c Uf YZYfYbhY Dcg aYWUb]gacg XY fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b ]bhf bgYWcg U cg f] cbYg
Wcbhf]VimY U U X]ga]biW] b XY Z i c U hfUjzg XY cg WUd] UfYg bcfaU aYbhY aUbh]YbYb Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m U L>? fY Uh]jUaYbhY
dYf]hiVi UfYg% c eiY U gi jYn UiaYbhU U WcbghUbhYg% U dYgUf XY cg WUaV]cg aUfWUXcg Yb U dfYg] b UfhYf]U '
,,1
6N V aX ). >] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf% Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m gi Wcbhfc
HA GI
9XaW
YX YVZ
-
U[chUf U fxd]XUaYbhY Y jc iaYb gUb[i bYc'
+
C
,,2
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
HfYg]cb UfhYf]U
]Xfcghxh]Wc [ caYfi Uf
dfYg] b
? caYfi Uf
Yd]hY ]c
L>?
Hfcl]aU
FU; EUWi U XYbgU
fYUVgcfW] b FU;
QilhU[ caYfi Uf
Wz i Ug
9ZYfYbhY
=ZYfYbhY
UfhYf]c U
UfhYf]c U JYb]bU
AbhYfbc
Y xgh]Wc
EUWi U XYbgU 9b[]chYbg]bU AA
xa]bU
D]gc K hUbc
a gWi c aYaVfUbU =ZYfYbhY 9ZZYU ei] Uf
<]ghU
Z]VfU UfhYf]c Uf UfhYf]c Uf
hiV]hc
fYg]ghYbW]U fYg]ghYbW]U
9VTa N ). ( % =ghfiWhifU XY UdUfUhc milhU[ caYfi Uf% XYacghfUbXc gi
dcg]V Y dUdY XY fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b Yb Y Wcbhfc XY U ZibW] b XY U bYZfcbU' 9VTa N ). ((% EYWUb]gac XY fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b XY U axWi U XYbgU dUfU U
UihcffY[i UW] b XY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf m U hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b
[ caYfi Uf "L>? XifUbhY U X]ga]biW] b XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U fYbU '
XY Wz i Ug Yd]hY ]U Yg Yb cg h Vi cg X]ghU Yg eiY YbhfU Yb YghfYW c
WcbhUWhc Wcb Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg m YZYfYbhYg' DUg Wz i Ug XY U
axWi U XYbgU Wcbh]YbYb Y UdUfUhc XY ?c []% eiY WcbghU XY =ghcg Xcg WcadcbYbhYg XY aYWUb]gac XY
cf[xbi cg gYWfYhcfYg ]bhfUWY i UfYg X]f][]Xcg UW]U Ug UfhYf]c Ug% fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b hiVi c[ caYfi Uf% eiY cdYfUb ibhcg dcf
c eiY gi[]YfY eiY YghUg Wz i Ug diYXYb YghUf gYWfYhUbXc ibU aYX]c XY U YghfiWhifU UbUh a]WU YgdYW]U XY UdUfUhc
gighUbW]U UW]U Ug UfhYf]c Ug' milhU[ caYfi Uf% dfcdcfW]cbUb gY U Yg XY fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b
U Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg m YZYfYbhYg dUfU ibU
?N QV YVZaPVtZ QRX PX a QR QV QR XN YpPaXN QRZ N PNa N UihcffY[i UW] b YZ]W]YbhY XY U L>? XifUbhY cg WUaV]cg Yb U
QVXN NPVtZ QR XN N R V XN NSR RZ R e NaYRZ QR XN dfYg] b UfhYf]U ' ;iUbXc UaVcg aYWUb]gacg ZibW]cbUb
XVOR NPVtZ QR RZVZN% DUg Wz i Ug XY U axWi U XYbgU XYhYWhUb ibhcg% U L>? WUaV]U gc c ibcg dcWcg dibhcg dcfWYbhiU Yg%
WUaV]cg Yb Y gia]b]ghfc XY W cfifc XY gcX]c U h Vi c X]ghU U ]bW igc Wcb [fUbXYg Z iWhiUW]cbYg Yb U dfYg] b UfhYf]U YbhfY
hfUjzg XY gY U Yg eiY bc gY WcadfYbXYb Wcad YhUaYbhY' Dcg cg a]hYg XY 0. m /) aa ['
YghiX]cg YldYf]aYbhU Yg Ub gi[Yf]Xc eiY ibU ?>J 8X OX aR QR XN S YNPVtZ QR NZTV RZ VZN RQaPR NuZ Yp
X]ga]bi]XU fU Ybh]nU U jY cW]XUX XY Z i c Yb Y UgU XY Yb Y% XN N N QR SVX NPVtZ TX YR aXN Qa NZ R XN UV R Sa VtZ RZNX%
c eiY UiaYbhU U fYUVgcfW] b XY dcfWYbhU Y XY ]cbYg XY ;cac gY aYbW]cb UbhYf]cfaYbhY% ibU UWW] b
gcX]c m W cfifc YbhfY[UXcg U UgU UgWYbXYbhY XY Yb Y m% dcf Wcbghf]Whcf dfYZYfYbW]U XY U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA gcVfY Ug
c hUbhc% fYXiWY U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY W cfifc XY gcX]c Yb Ug UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg UmiXU U dfYjYb]f fYXiWW]cbYg [fUjYg
Wz i Ug XY U axWi U XYbgU' =ghU X]ga]biW] b Yb U XY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf m U L>? WiUbXc U
WcbWYbhfUW] b XY W cfifc XY gcX]c ]b]W]U ibU gY U XY U dfYg] b XY dYfZig] b fYbU WUY dcf XYVU c XY c bcfaU '
axWi U XYbgU eiY h]YbY Xcg YZYWhcg "9VTa N ). ((% 3 " DU UXa]b]ghfUW] b XY ZxfaUWcg eiY V ceiYUb U
X]ga]bimY U fYg]ghYbW]U U Z i c gUb[i bYc Yb Ug UfhYf]c Ug ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA "]b ]V]XcfYg XY U Ybn]aU
UZYfYbhYg% c eiY Y YjU U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU [ caYfi Uf m WcbjYfh]XcfU XY Ub[]chYbg]bU c eiY V ceiYUb U UWW] b
XY U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA "UbhU[cb]ghUg XY cg fYWYdhcfYg XY
UmiXU U eiY U L>? jiY jU U U bcfaU ]XUX4 m "+ UiaYbhU U
Ub[]chYbg]bU AA diYXYb dfcXiW]f fYXiWW]cbYg XY U L>?
]VYfUW] b XY fYb]bU XY Ug Wz i Ug milhU[ caYfi UfYg XY Ug
aUmcfYg XY c UV]hiU WiUbXc U dfYg] b UfhYf]U fYbU
UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg m YZYfYbhYg% eiY gcb cg df]bW]dU Yg
XYgW]YbXY dcf XYVU c XY c bcfaU ' Hcf c hUbhc% ibU
i[UfYg XY U aUWYbUa]Ybhc XY fYb]bU' DU fYb]bU ]VYfUXU XY Wcad ]WUW] b ]adcfhUbhY XY igc XY Yghcg aYX]WUaYbhcg
YghUg Wz i Ug ZibW]cbU Wcac ibU Ybn]aU dUfU UiaYbhUf U dUfU hfUhUf U dUW]YbhYg eiY h]YbYb ]dYfhYbg] b XYV]Xc U
ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU A% eiY gY Wcbj]YfhY Yb YghYbcg]g XY U UfhYf]U fYbU "V ceiYc dUfW]U XY U UfhYf]U
Ub[]chYbg]bU AA' Hcf h]ac% U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA WcbhfUY Ug fYbU Yg ibU X]ga]biW] b gYjYfU XY U L>? eiY% Yb
UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg% c eiY UiaYbhU U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU U [ibcg WUgcg% diYXY WUigUf ]bgiZ]W]YbW]U fYbU U[iXU'
[ caYfi Uf m UmiXU U eiY U L>? jiY jU U U bcfaU ]XUX' K]b YaVUf[c%
,-)
6N V aX ). >] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf% Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m gi Wcbhfc
HA GI
XY cg jUgcg gUb[i bYcg ]bX]j]XiU Yg dUfU fYg]gh]f Y Ygh]fUa]Ybhc
XifUbhY Y UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U % c eiY gY WcbcWY Wcac U LiVi Uf dfcl]aU
Ua]bcxW]Xcg
aYWUb]gac a]c[zb]Wc' Dcg YghiX]cg XY jUgcg gUb[i bYcg ]bX]j]XiU Yg
fYUVgcfW] b
"YgdYW]U aYbhY UfhYf]c Ug dYeiY Ug Yb hcXc Y WiYfdc Ub
XYacghfUXc eiY fYgdcbXYb U UiaYbhc XY U hYbg] b XY U dUfYX c U
Ygh]fUa]Ybhc XY U dUfYX aYX]UbhY U WcbhfUWW] b XY a gWi c ]gc
LiVi Uf dfcl]aU
jUgWi Uf' = Ygh]fUa]Ybhc XY U dUfYX jUgWi Uf dYfa]hY ib aUmcf JYUVgcfW] b XY FU;
acj]a]Ybhc XY ]cbYg XY WU W]c XYgXY Y ei]Xc YlhfUWY i Uf UW]U Ug
Wz i Ug% c eiY UWY eiY gY WcbhfU][Ub U hfUjzg XY cg aYWUb]gacg
X]gWih]Xcg Yb;Ud hi c 1' =ghU WcbhfUWW] b Yj]hU Y Ygh]fUa]Ybhc YlWYg]jc ExWi U XYbgU FU;
XY jUgc m% U a]gac h]Yadc% U UiaYbhUf U fYg]ghYbW]U jUgWi Uf% UmiXU
U dfYjYb]f UiaYbhcg YlWYg]jcg XY Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m XY U L>?
WiUbXc UiaYbhU U dfYg] b UfhYf]U ' EUbW U
9fhYf]c Uf UZYfYbhY
XYbgU
9ibeiY Y aYWUb]gac a]c[zb]Wc dfcVUV YaYbhY cdYfU Yb U fYg]ghYbW]U
fYU ]aYbhUW] b
aUmcf U XY Ug UfhYf]c Ug Yb hcXc Y WiYfdc% U [ibcg Z]g] c[cg
Ub WiYgh]cbUXc gi ]adcfhUbW]U Yb Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m U
UihcffY[i UW] b XY U L>? dcfeiY YghY aYWUb]gac gYbg]V Y U U L>?
dfYg] b bc h]YbY ZcfaU XY XYhYWhUf X]fYWhUaYbhY WUaV]cg Yb Y
Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU c U L>? dYf gY' Hcf chfc UXc% YghY 9VTa N ). ()% Hcg]V Y dUdY XY U fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b XY U axWi U XYbgU Yb U aYX]UW] b XY
UiaYbhc XY U hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf "L>? XYgdizg XY ibU Wca]XU f]WU Yb dfchY bUg'
aYWUb]gac diYXY gYf axg ]adcfhUbhY dUfU dfchY[Yf U f] b XY
ibU Yg] b ]bXiW]XU dcf ]dYfhYbg] b' =b fYgdiYghU U UiaYbhcg
fYdYbh]bcg XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U % U fYgdiYghU Wcbghf]Whcf Mb aYWUb]gac g]a] Uf hUaV]zb diYXY Yld ]WUf cg aUfWUXcg
a]c[zb]WU Yb Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg gY dfcXiWY Yb gY[ibXcg m% UiaYbhcg Yb Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m U L>? eiY cWiffYb Wcb
[fUbXYg UiaYbhcg Yb cg b]jY Yg XY [ iWcgU Yb gUb[fY Yb dYfgcbUg
dcf c hUbhc% UhYb U U hfUbga]g] b XY UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b
Wcb X]UVYhYg aY ]hig bc Wcbhfc UXU' <YV]Xc U eiY U [ iWcgU% Wcac
UfhYf]U U cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg'
U [ibcg XY cg Ua]bcxW]Xcg% hUaV]zb gY fYUVgcfVY ibhc Wcb Y gcX]c
Yb Y h Vi c dfcl]aU % Y UiaYbhc XY U YbhfY[U XY [ iWcgU U cg
?N VZTR N NX N QR RrZN e XN UV R TXaPRYVN NaYRZ NZ RX SXaW
h Vi cg UWY eiY fYUVgcfVUb Y YlWYgc XY gcX]c ibhc Wcb U [ iWcgU'
NZTarZR RZNX e XN N N QR SVX NPVtZ TX YR aXN % 9 dYgUf XY eiY
=ghY UiaYbhc XY U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c% U gi jYn% X]ga]bimY U
= Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m U L>? gcb fY Uh]jUaYbhY YghUV Yg Yb U
WcbWYbhfUW] b XY W cfifc XY gcX]c Yb U axWi U XYbgU% c eiY UWh]jU
aUmcf U XY Ug WcbX]W]cbYg% Um W]fWibghUbW]Ug Yb Ug eiY YghUg
ibU X] UhUW] b XY Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg aYX]UXU dcf
jUf]UV Yg WUaV]Ub g][b]Z]WUh]jUaYbhY' Hcf Y Yad c%KY gUVY eiY ibU
fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b hiVi c[ caYfi Uf m cg UiaYbhcg giVg][i]YbhYg XY
]b[YghU U hU XY dfchY bUg UiaYbhU Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m U L>?''
Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m U L>?'
;cb ibU X]YhU U hU Yb dfchY bUg U Uf[c d Unc% Wcac ibU eiY Wcbh]YbY
=ghcg Y Yad cg XYaiYghfUb eiY Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m U L>?
[fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XY WUfbY% cg UiaYbhcg Yb U L>? m Y Z i c
dYf gY bc gcb Ug jUf]UV Yg df]aUf]Ug Wcbhfc UXUg dcf Y aYWUb]gac XY
gUb[i bYc fYbU gY XYVYb Yb dUfhY U WfYW]a]Ybhc XY cg f] cbYg' K]b
fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b hiVi c[ caYfi Uf' = dfcd g]hc df]bW]dU XY YghU
YaVUf[c% U L>? m Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU hUaV]zb UiaYbhUb YbhfY
fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b Yg UgY[ifUf ib gia]b]ghfc WcbghUbhY XY W cfifc XY
ib +) m ib ,) Yb c + cfUg XYgdizg XY eiY ibU dYfgcbU ]b[]YfU
gcX]c U h Vi c X]ghU % XcbXY h]YbY i[Uf Y dfcWYgUa]Ybhc Z]bU XY U
ibU Wca]XU f]WU Yb dfchY bUg'
cf]bU' Hcf c hUbhc% Ug U hYfUW]cbYg eiY h]YbXYb U UiaYbhUf U
MbU dcg]V Y Yld ]WUW] b XY UiaYbhc XY U L>? Yg U g][i]YbhY' MbU
fYUVgcfW] b XY W cfifc XY gcX]c Yb cg g]h]cg hiVi UfYg UbhYg XY U
Wca]XU f]WU Yb dfchY bUg ]VYfU Ua]bcxW]Xcg Yb U gUb[fY% eiY gY
axWi U XYbgU h]YbXYb U dfcjcWUf ib UiaYbhc XY Z i c gUb[i bYc
fYUVgcfVYb Yb cg h Vi cg dfcl]aU Yg' <YV]Xc U eiY cg Ua]bcxW]Xcg m
fYbU m XY U L>?% c eiY UmiXU U eiY U ]VYfUW] b X]ghU XY W cfifc XY
Y gcX]c gY fYUVgcfVYb ibhcg dcf WchfUbgdcfhY Yb cg h Vi cg
gcX]c jiY jU U U bcfaU ]XUX% XY acXc eiY gY diYXUb aUbhYbYf Ug
dfcl]aU Yg% Y UiaYbhc XY U fYUVgcfW] b XY Ua]bcxW]Xcg hUaV]zb
hUgUg bcfaU Yg XY YlWfYW] b XY gcX]c m U[iU' "jYf9VTa N ). ()% '
Ygh]ai U U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c' =ghY UiaYbhc XY U fYUVgcfW] b XY
MbU gYWiYbW]U cdiYghU XY YjYbhcg cWiffY WiUbXc gY fYXiWY
gcX]c X]ga]bimY Y gia]b]ghfc XY gcX]c U U axWi U XYbgU "jYf9VTa N
U fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf dfcl]aU ' Hcf Y Yad c% WiUbXc cg h Vi cg
). ()% % eiY dfcjcWU ibU X]ga]biW] b XY U fYg]ghYbW]U XY Ug UfhYf]c Ug
dfcl]aU Yg Yghxb XU UXcg " c eiY diYXY cWiff]f Wcac fYgi hUXc
UZYfYbhYg aYX]UXU dcf fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b hiVi c[ caYfi Uf% Wcac gY
XY ibU ]bhcl]WUW] b dcf aYhU Yg dYgUXcg% Wcac Y aYfWif]c% c
X]gWih] UbhYf]cfaYbhY' DU X]ga]biW] b XY U fYg]ghYbW]U UfhYf]c Uf
[fUbXYg Xcg]g XY ZxfaUWcg% Wcac Ug hYhfUW]W ]bUg % gi WUdUW]XUX
UZYfYbhY UiaYbhU Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU m U L>?% c eiY dYfa]hY eiY
dUfU fYUVgcfVYf Y W cfifc XY gcX]c X]ga]bimY' ;cac
U YlWfYW] b XY gcX]c gY aUbhYb[U U ib b]jY WUg] bcfaU a]YbhfUg
WcbgYWiYbW]U% gY UXa]b]ghfUb [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XY W cfifc XY
UiaYbhU U YlWfYW] b XY cg dfcXiWhcg XY XYgYW c XY aYhUVc ]gac
gcX]c U h Vi c X]ghU m% g]b U WcadYbgUW] b UXYWiUXU% WUigUf Ub
XY Ug dfchY bUg% Wcac U ifYU'
fxd]XUaYbhY ib U[chUa]Ybhc YlWYg]jc XY jc iaYb' MbU XY Ug
fYgdiYghUg WcadYbgUhcf]Ug ]adcfhUbhYg dUfYWY gYf ibU
,-
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
,-+
64ClGH?B ) /
HA GI
ERNO PVtZ aOaXN RZNX
e RP RPVtZ
9 aYX]XU eiY Y Z] hfUXc [ caYfi Uf YbhfU Yb cg h Vi cg YlWfYW] b XY aiW Ug gighUbW]Ug' Hcf hUbhc% ib dYeiY c WUaV]c
fYbU Yg% Z imY gYWiYbW]U aYbhY U hfUjzg XY Ug dUfhYg Yb U Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf c U fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf diYXY
giWYg]jUg XY hiVi Yh Y h Vi c dfcl]aU % UgU XY Yb Y% h Vi c dchYbW]U aYbhY WUigUf ib WUaV]c fY Uh]jUaYbhY [fUbXY Yb U
X]ghU % h Vi c Wc YWhcf% m WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf UbhYg XY eiY gY YlWfYW] b if]bUf]U' Hcf Y Yad c% ibU X]ga]biW] b XY ) Yb U
YlWfYhY Wcac cf]bU' 9 c Uf[c XY YghY Wifgc% U [ibUg fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf% XY 01%. U /)%0 D ( X U% UiaYbhUf U Y
gighUbW]Ug gY fYUVgcfVYb gY YWh]jUaYbhY XY cg h Vi cg XY jc iaYb XY cf]bU XY %. U 2%, D ( X U "WUg] ib UiaYbhc XY ,
biYjc U U gUb[fY% a]YbhfUg eiY chfUg gY gYWfYhUb XY U jYWYg g] U hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf "L>? gY aUbhij]YfU
gUb[fY U iaYb hiVi Uf' >]bU aYbhY% U cf]bU eiY gY ZcfaU m WcbghUbhY' =b fYU ]XUX% cg WUaV]cg Yb U fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf m U
hcXUg Ug gighUbW]Ug Yb U cf]bU fYdfYgYbhUb U giaU XY hfYg Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf Yghxb YghfYW UaYbhY WccfX]bUXcg dUfU
dfcWYgcg fYbU Yg Vxg]Wcg Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf% fYUVgcfW] b Yj]hUf [fUbXYg Z iWhiUW]cbYg Yb U YlWfYW] b if]bUf]U'
hiVi Uf m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf3 =b gY[ibXc i[Uf% U X]ZYfYbW]U XY U Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf% eiY
YlWfYW] b f]bUf]U 6 Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf hiVi Uf Yg fY Uh]jUaYbhY bc gY YWh]jU "YgYbW]U aYbhY hcXcg cg gc ihcg Yb
;cbWYbhfUW] b d Ugaxh]WU
,-,
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
,--
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
HA GI
9LH A 4
:caVU XY 9LHUgU Yb Y UXc VUgc UhYfU XY U
A 4
aYaVfUbU'
9LH " , aN
+' = gcX]c gY hfUbgdcfhU U hfUjzg XY Ug aYaVfUbUg VUgc UhYfU Yg
,-.
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
?N VZ PV V R aZ YRPNZV Y QR NZ R NP Vb N N XN
RNO PVtZ QR RrZN % 9 [ibUg dUfhYg XY h Vi c%
F(9 F(9 YgdYW]U aYbhY Y h Vi c dfcl]aU % fYUVgcfVYb ac zWi Ug [fUbXYg
aN Wcac Ug dfchY bUg U hfUjzg XY d]bcW]hcg]g% ib h]dc XY YbXcW]hcg]g'
4GC A 8
C =b YghY dfcWYgc% U dfchY bU gY UX ]YfY U VcfXY Yb WYd] c XY U
aYaVfUbU ia]bU % m YghU dcfW] b XY U aYaVfUbU gY ]bjU[]bU U
]bhYf]cf XY U Wz i U UghU eiY gY dY ]nWU dcf Wcad Yhc m gY ZcfaU
;cbhfU hfUbgdcfhY ibU jYg Wi U eiY Wcbh]YbY U dfchY bU' MbU jYn XYbhfc XY U Wz i U%
U dfchY bU gY X][]YfY Yb gig Ua]bcxW]Xcg Wcbgh]himYbhYg% eiY gY
9VTa N )/ % EYWUb]gacg XY hfUbgdcfhY UWh]jc gYWibXUf]c' DU WY XU gidYf]cf
aiYghfU Y Wc hfUbgdcfhY XY [ iWcgU m Ua]bcxW]Xcg ibhc Wcb ]cbYg XY gcX]c fYUVgcfVYb U hfUjzg XY U aYaVfUbU VUgc UhYfU Yb Y ei]Xc
U hfUjzg XY UXc Ud]WU XY Ug Wz i Ug Yd]hY ]U Yg hiVi UfYg% gY[i]Xc XY ibU ]bhYfgh]W]U ' <YV]Xc U eiY U d]bcW]hcg]g fYei]YfY YbYf[ U% gY
X]Zig] b ZUW] ]hUXU U hfUjzg XY Ug aYaVfUbUg VUgc UhYfU Yg' DU WY XU ]bZYf]cf Wcbg]XYfU ibU ZcfaU XY hfUbgdcfhY UWh]jc'
aiYghfU Y WcbhfU hfUbgdcfhY XY ]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc XYgXY Y ]bhYf]cf XY U
Wz i U U hfUjzg XY U aYaVfUbU Ud]WU m UW]U Y iaYb hiVi Uf4 = G NZ R YpdVY N N a NZPVN aR R RNO ORZ
acj]a]Ybhc XY ]cbYg XY gcX]c UW]U U Wz i U% U c Uf[c XY ib [fUX]YbhY NP VbNYRZ R% HUfU U aUmcf U XY Ug gighUbW]Ug eiY gY fYUVgcfVYb
Y YWhfcei a]Wc YghUV YW]Xc dcf U VcaVU XY gcX]c dchUg]c Yb U aYaVfUbU c gYWfYhUb UWh]jUaYbhY% Yl]ghY ib a]hY Yb U jY cW]XUX U U eiY gY
VUgc UhYfU % dfcdcfW]cbU U YbYf[ U dUfU Y hfUbgdcfhY XY cg ]cbYg XY
diYXY hfUbgdcfhUf Y gc ihc% eiY U aYbiXc gY XYbca]bU
]Xf [Ybc XYgXY Y ]bhYf]cf XY U Wz i U UW]U U in hiVi Uf' 9LH% hf]ZcgZUhc
XY UXYbcg]bU4 ?DML% hfUbgdcfhUXcf XY [ iWcgU4 F =% ]bhYfWUaV]UXcf XY hfUbgdcfhY axl]ac' =ghY a]hY gY XYVY U U gUhifUW] b XY cg
gcX]c ]Xf [Ybc4 K?DL% WchfUbgdcfhUXcf XY gcX]c [ iWcgU' g]ghYaUg XY hfUbgdcfhY YgdYW Z]Wcg ]bjc iWfUXcg WiUbXc U
WUbh]XUX XY gc ihc YbhfY[UXc U h Vi c "WcbcW]Xc WcacWUf[U
hiVi Uf gidYfU U WUdUW]XUX XY Ug dfchY bUg hfUbgdcfhUXcfUg m XY
KY aUbh]YbY U X]Zig] b ZUW] ]hUXU XY gcX]c U hfUjzg XY U
Ug Ybn]aUg YgdYW Z]WUg ]ad ]WUXUg Yb Y dfcWYgc XY hfUbgdcfhY'
aYaVfUbU ia]bU % m Yg YghU X]Zig] b XYgWYbXYbhY XY gcX]c UW]U
= g]ghYaU XY hfUbgdcfhY XY [ iWcgU Yb Y h Vi c dfcl]aU Yg
Y ]bhYf]cf XY U Wz i U U eiY dfcdcfW]cbU U YbYf[ U dUfU Y
ib ViYb Y Yad c' FcfaU aYbhY% U [ iWcgU aYX]V Y bc UdUfYWY
hfUbgdcfhY UgWYbXYbhY g]ai hxbYc XY [ iWcgU U hfUjzg XY U
Yb U cf]bU dcfeiY YgYbW]U aYbhY hcXU U [ iWcgU Z] hfUXU gY
aYaVfUbU ia]bU ' Hcf hUbhc% YghU fYUVgcfW] b XY [ iWcgU gY
fYUVgcfVY Yb Y h Vi c dfcl]aU ' K]b YaVUf[c% WiUbXc U WUf[U
XYbca]bUhfUbgdcfhY UWh]jc gYWibXUf]c dcfeiY U [ iWcgU a]gaU
Z] hfUXU YlWYXY U WUdUW]XUX XY cg h Vi cg dUfU fYUVgcfVYf
gY fYUVgcfVY WiYghU Uff]VU WcbhfU ib [fUX]YbhY ei a]Wc% dYfc Yg
[ iWcgU% gY dfcXiWY U YlWfYW] b if]bUf]U XY [ iWcgU'
gYWibXUf]U U hfUbgdcfhY UWh]jc df]aUf]c XY gcX]c'
=b Y gYf iaUbc UXi hc% Y hfUbgdcfhY axl]ac XY [ iWcgU
Ghfc dibhc ]adcfhUbhY Yg eiY gY X]WY eiY ibU gighUbW]U gY
dfcaYX]U Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY ,0. a[ ( a]b% a]YbhfUg eiY U WUf[U
gcaYhY U hfUbgdcfhY UWh]jc WiUbXc U aYbcg ibU XY Ug
Z] hfUXU XY [ iWcgU Yg gc c XY Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY +. a[ ( a]b "L>? w
YhUdUg XY U fYUVgcfW] b ]ad ]WU hfUbgdcfhY UWh]jc df]aUf]c c
[ iWcgU d Ugaxh]WU 6 +. a ( a]b w a[ ( a ' ;cb [fUbXYg UiaYbhcg
gYWibXUf]c% UibeiY chfUg YhUdUg XY dfcWYgc XY fYUVgcfW] b
Yb U L>? m ( c U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY [ iWcgU Yb d UgaU eiY UiaYbhUb U
diYXYb gYf dUg]jUg' HUfU U fYUVgcfW] b XY [ iWcgU% Y
WUf[U Z] hfUXU XY [ iWcgU dcf YbW]aU XY ,0. a[ ( a]b% Y YlWYgc XY
hfUbgdcfhY UWh]jc gYWibXUf]c cWiffY Yb U aYaVfUbU ia]bU %
[ iWcgU Z] hfUXU bc gY fYUVgcfVY m dUgU U U cf]bU'
dYfc U X]Zig] b ZUW] ]hUXU dUg]jU cWiffY Yb U aYaVfUbU
9VTa N )/ +% aiYghfU U fY UW] b YbhfY U WcbWYbhfUW] b
VUgc UhYfU % m U WUdhUW] b dUg]jU dcf Y Z i c aUg]jc cWiffY Yb
d Ugaxh]WU XY [ iWcgU% U WUf[U Z] hfUXU XY [ iWcgU% Y hfUbgdcfhY
cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg'
hiVi Uf axl]ac XY [ iWcgU m U hUgU XY dzfX]XU XY [ iWcgU Yb
FRP RPVtZ NP VbN RPaZQN VN RZ X uOaX % 9 [ibUg gighUbW]Ug U cf]bU' LYb[U Yb WiYbhU eiY WiUbXc U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY [ iWcgU Yb
gY gYWfYhUb Yb cg h Vi cg dcf hfUbgdcfhY UWh]jc gYWibXUf]c% d UgaU Yg XY )) a[ ( )) a m U WUf[U Z] hfUXU Yghx Yb gi b]jY bcfaU " +.
eiY U aYbiXc ]ad ]WU WcbhfU hfUbgdcfhY XY U gighUbW]U Wcb a[ ( a]b % bc Um dzfX]XU XY [ iWcgU Yb U cf]bU' K]b YaVUf[c% WiUbXc U
]cbYg XY gcX]c' =b Y WcbhfU hfUbgdcfhY% U YbYf[ U ]VYfUXU XY WcbWYbhfUW] b d Ugaxh]WU XY [ iWcgU gY Y YjU dcf YbW]aU XY
acj]a]Ybhc WiYghU UVU c XY ibU XY Ug gighUbW]Ug "d' = '% AcbYg Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY +)) a[ ( )) a % UiaYbhUbXc U WUf[U Z] hfUXU U
XY gcX]c dYfa]hY Y acj]a]Ybhc WiYghU Uff]VU XY ibU gY[ibXU Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY +.) a[ ( a]b% Wca]YbnU U UdUfYWYf ibU dYeiY U
gighUbW]U Yb U X]fYWW] b cdiYghU' WUbh]XUX XY [ iWcgU Yb U cf]bU' =ghY dibhc gY XYbca]bUiaVfU dcf
,-/
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
HA GI
Fa NZPVN aR R NZ NZ NP VbNYRZ R R aR Z RdUVORZ
=lWfYW] b aZ YpdVY QR NZ R% DU fUn b dcf U eiY cg gc ihcg
.))
hfUbgdcfhUXcg UWh]jUaYbhY U aYbiXc Yl ]VYb ib axl]ac XY
6N TN SVX NQN QR TXaP
,-1
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
L Vi c dfcl]aU dfchY bUg eiY hfUbgdcfhUb ibU [fUb ZfUWW] b XY cg ]cbYg XY gcX]c
U hfUjzg XY U aYaVfUbU ia]bU ib]XU U hfUjzg XY Wc hfUbgdcfhY
aYWUb]gac Wcb a h]d Yg bihf]YbhYg cf[xb]Wcg Wcac Ua]bcxW]Xcg
A 4 6X 6B m [ iWcgU' = gcX]c UX]W]cbU gY hfUbgdcfhU XYgXY Y iaYb hiVi Uf
HA GI
)B TXaP N NYVZ pPVQ
U ]bhYf]cf XY U Wz i U dcfWcbhfU hfUbgdcfhY aYWUb]gacg eiY
Agcga h]Wc fYUVgcfVYb gcX]c a]YbhfUg gYWfYhUb chfUg gighUbW]Ug Yb U in
hiVi Uf% YgdYW]U aYbhY ]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc' ;cac gY X]gWih] Yb
pPVQ TpZVP ON R ;Ud hi c , % U gYWfYW] b XY ]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc Yb U in hiVi Uf
Yg ib dUgc ]adcfhUbhY Yb U Y ]a]bUW] b XY ]cbYg XY V]WUfVcbUhc
XY h Vi c "aYX]UbhY U WcaV]bUW] b XY
Wcb U ;G , dUfU ZcfaUf +;G,% eiY iY[c gY X]gcW]U
9VTa N )/ -% M hfUYghfiWhifU WY i Uf m WUfUWhYf gh]WUg XY hfUbgdcfhY df]aUf]c Yb +G m ;G+ ' 9ibeiY Y FU C DU VcaVU XY
XY h Vi c dfcl]aU ' Dcg h Vi cg dfcl]aU Yg fYUVgcfVYb Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY 9LHUgY dfcdcfW]cbU
Y /. XY gcX]c% Y W cfifc% Y V]WUfVcbUhc m Y dchUg]c Z] hfUXcg m
ZiYfnU df]bW]dU dUfU U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c% W cfifc m U[iU U
YgYbW]U aYbhY hcXU U [ iWcgU m cg Ua]bcxW]Xcg Z] hfUXcg' Dcg h Vi cg
dfcl]aU Yg hUaV]zb gYWfYhUb xW]Xcg cf[xb]Wcg% VUgYg Y ]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc
hfUjzg XY h Vi c dfcl]aU % Yl]ghYb U [ibUg X]ZYfYbW]Ug Yb cg
UW]U U in hiVi Uf' aYWUb]gacg dcf cg eiY Y gcX]c m Y W cfifc gY hfUbgdcfhUb U
hfUjzg XY UXc ia]bU XY Ug dcfW]cbYg hYadfUbU m hUfX U XY
E845FBE6 nA L F86E86 nA 8A U aYaVfUbU hiVi Uf dfcl]aU '
7 98E8AG8F C4EG8F 78 ?4 =b U df]aYfU a]hUX XY h Vi c dfcl]aU % Y gcX]c gY fYUVgcfVY
,-2
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
+')
MfYU ;
XN YN aOaXN
')
)B
F(9 Ggac Uf]XUX
)%.
;G ,
6 ZPRZ NPVtZ QR Xr aVQ
)%+
)%
,.)
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
HA GI
F(9
F(9
Wcac fYgi hUXc XY U ][YfU WUf[U dcg]h]jU XY U in hiVi Uf Yb
9LH fY UW] b Wcb Y ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U ' 9ibeiY Y WchfUbgdcfhUXcf
C
FC;;+ aiYjY WUbh]XUXYg ][iU Yg XY WUh]cbYg m Ub]cbYg U
A 4 ]bhYf]cf XY U Wz i U% Um ibU ][YfU Zi[U XY ]cbYg XY dchUg]c
; C
)6X UW]U Y iaYb% WfYUbXc ibU WUf[U dcg]h]jU XY
Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY 1 a] ]jc h]cg Yb Y iaYb hiVi Uf' =ghU
WUf[U dcg]h]jU ZiYfnU U WUh]cbYg Wcac E[+ m ;U+ dUfU
X]ZibX]fgY XYgXY U in hiVi Uf U hfUjzg XY YgdUW]c
dUfUWY i Uf m UW]U Y ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U '
= gY[aYbhc [fiYgc XY ViW Y UgWYbXYbhY XY Yb Y Yg
7Va q VP QR N N dfxWh]WUaYbhY ]adYfaYUV Y U U[iU'' Hcf hUbhc% U aUmcf dUfhY XY
x 9a RYVQN
U[iU eiY Y[U U YghY gY[aYbhc dYfaUbYWY Yb Y h Vi c% U dYgUf XY U
x iPVQ R NP rZVP
x 5aYR NZVQN fYUVgcfW] b XY [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XY gc ihc' = ei]Xc hiVi Uf Yb U
fUaU UgWYbXYbhY gY jiY jY aim X] i]Xc U aYX]XU eiY Z imY UW]U Y
9VTa N )/ 0% EYWUb]gacg XY hfUbgdcfhY XY gcX]c% W cfifc m dchUg]c Yb Y UgU h Vi c X]ghU % ibU WUfUWhYf gh]WU eiY Yg ]adcfhUbhY dUfU dYfa]h]f eiY
UgWYbXYbhY [fiYgU XY Yb Y' =bhcbWYg ib C DU VcaVU XY 9LHUgU Yb U
cg f] cbYg X] imUb c WcbWYbhfYb U cf]bU Yb X]ZYfYbhYg WcbX]W]cbYg%
aYaVfUbU WY i Uf VUgc UhYfU aUbh]YbY ibU VU U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY gcX]c
Wcac gY UbU ]nU Wcb axg XYhU Y Yb;Ud hi c +2'
]bhfUWY i Uf m ib dchYbW]U Y zWhf]Wc bY[Uh]jc Yb U Wz i U' = WchfUbgdcfhUXcf
gcX]c% + W cfifc% dchUg]c Yb U aYaVfUbU ia]bU hfUbgdcfhU Yghcg hfYg
]cbYg XYgXY U in hiVi Uf UW]U Ug Wz i Ug% ih] ]nUbXc U YbYf[ U dchYbW]U GH5H?BF 7 FG4?8F
]VYfUXU dcf U X]Zig] b XY gcX]c Yb ib [fUX]YbhY Y YWhfcei a]Wc UW]U Ug
Wz i Ug' = gcX]c hUaV]zb gY hfUbgdcfhU U ]bhYf]cf XY U Wz i U hiVi Uf dcf
= gY[aYbhc [fiYgc XY U fUaU UgWYbXYbhY XY ViW Y XY Yb Y
WcbhfUhfUbgdcfhY XY gcX]c ]Xf [Ybc' DU WUf[U dcg]h]jU " 1 aN XY iaYb XYgYaVcWU Yb Y h Vi c X]ghU ' DU df]aYfU dcfW] b XY h Vi c
hiVi Uf Yb fY UW] b Wcb Y ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U ZiYfnU WUh]cbYg Wcac E[+ m ;U X]ghU ZcfaU Y aUWi U XYbgU% ib [fidc XY Wz i Ug Yd]hY ]U Yg
+ dUfU X]ZibX]fgY XYgXY U in UghU Y ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U U hfUjzg XY U j U WcadUWhUg eiY ZcfaU dUfhY XY U Wcad Y c milhU[ caYfi Uf m
dUfUWY i Uf'
dfcdcfW]cbU ib Wcbhfc XY fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b XY U L>? m Y
Z i c gUb[i bYc Yb YghU a]gaU bYZfcbU'
DU g][i]YbhY dUfhY XY h Vi c X]ghU Yghx aim Wcbjc iW]cbUXU m
ViW Y UgWYbXYbhY XY Yb Y' = gY[aYbhc XY [UXc XY U fUaU
h]YbY aiW Ug XY Ug a]gaUg WUfUWhYf gh]WUg XY fYUVgcfW] b XY
UgWYbXYbhY h]YbY ibU WUdUW]XUX XY fYUVgcfW] b aiW c aYbcf
gY[aYbhc [fiYgc XY U fUaU UgWYbXYbhY XY UgU XY Yb Y' =g
eiY Y gY[aYbhc [fiYgc m U fUaU XYgWYbXYbhY XY [UXU bc
XYW]f% fYUVgcfVY Wcb Uj]XYn U aUmcf U XY cg ]cbYg% ]bW i]Xcg Y
fYUVgcfVY WUbh]XUXYg g][b]Z]WUh]jUg XY b]b[ibc XY Yghcg gc ihcg'
gcX]c% Y dchUg]c m Y W cfifc% dYfc Yg dfxWh]WUaYbhY ]adYfaYUV Y
Mb WcadcbYbhY ]adcfhUbhY XY U fYUVgcfW] b XY gc ihcg Yb U
U U[iU m U ifYU' Hcf YghU fUn b% gY Y WcbcWY Wcac Y gY[aYbhc
fUaU UgWYbXYbhY [fiYgU Yg Y FU C :caVU XY 9LHUgU Yb Ug
XY X] iW] b dcfeiY hUaV]zb X] imY Y Z i]Xc hiVi Uf'
aYaVfUbUg VUgc UhYfU Yg XY Ug Wz i Ug Yd]hY ]U Yg' 9 ][iU eiY Yb
9dfcl]aUXUaYbhY Y . XY U WUf[U Z] hfUXU XY W cfifc XY
Y h Vi c dfcl]aU % U fYUVgcfW] b XY chfcg gc ihcg Yb Y gY[aYbhc
gcX]c gY fYUVgcfVY Yb Y h Vi c X]ghU hYadfUbc' cg
[fiYgc XY UgU UgWYbXYbhY XY Yb Y Yghx YghfYW UaYbhY
WchfUbgdcfhUXcf XY W cfifc XY gcX]c aiYjY Y W cfifc XY gcX]c
fY UW]cbUXU Wcb U WUdUW]XUX XY fYUVgcfW] b XY FU C :caVU XY
XYgXY Y iaYb hiVi Uf UW]U U Wz i U% m Y FU C DU VcaVU XY
9LHUgU% eiY aUbh]YbY ibU VU U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY gcX]c
9LHUgU hfUbgdcfhU Y gcX]c ZiYfU XY U Wz i U U hfUjzg XY U
]bhfUWY i Uf' DU VU U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY gcX]c ]bhfUWY i Uf% U gi jYn%
aYaVfUbU VUgc UhYfU "9VTa N )/ ( % ' = W cfifc gY X]ZibXY ZiYfU
dfcdcfW]cbU ib [fUX]YbhY ZUjcfUV Y dUfU Y acj]a]Ybhc XY gcX]c
XY U Wz i U UW]U Y ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U fYbU U hfUjzg XY WUbU Yg XY
XYgXY Y ei]Xc hiVi Uf UW]U U Wz i U'=b Y UgU UgWYbXYbhY
W cfifc Yb U aYaVfUbU VUgc UhYfU '
[fiYgU% Y acj]a]Ybhc XY gcX]c U hfUjzg XY U aYaVfUbU ia]bU
cg X]ifzh]Wcg h]Un X]Wcg% eiY gY ih] ]nUb Uad ]UaYbhY dUfU hfUhUf
Yghx aYX]UXc df]bW]dU aYbhY dcf ib gcX]c% + W cfifc%
hfUghcfbcg Wcac U ]dYfhYbg] b m U ]bgiZ]W]YbW]U WUfX UWU%
;chfUbgdcfhUXcf XY dchUg]c "FC;;+ "9VTa N )/ 0% ' =ghU
]b ]VYb Y WchfUbgdcfhUXcf XY W cfifc XY gcX]c'
dfchY bU XY WchfUbgdcfhY Yb U aYaVfUbU ia]bU ih] ]nU U
YbYf[ U dchYbW]U ]VYfUXU dcf U X]Zig] b XYgWYbXYbhY XY
GH5H?BF 7 FG4?8F G4E7lBF L GH5H?BF
gcX]c Yb U Wz i U dUfU ]adi gUf U fYUVgcfW] b XY dchUg]c Yb
E86B: 7BE8F 6BEG 64?8F
U Wz i U WcbhfU ib [fUX]YbhY XY WcbWYbhfUW] b'
DU fUaU UgWYbXYbhY [fiYgU XY UgU XY Yb Y Yg Y g]h]c XY DU gY[ibXU a]hUX XY h Vi c X]ghU m Y h Vi c Wc YWhcf
UWW] b XY cg dcXYfcgcg X]ifzh]Wcg XY UgU ZifcgYa]XU% xW]Xc Wcfh]WU giVg][i]YbhY h]YbYb WUfUWhYf gh]WUg ZibW]cbU Yg
YhUWf b]Wc% m ViaYhUb]XU% hcXcg cg WiU Yg ]b ]VYb U UWW] b g]a] UfYg' 9bUh a]WUaYbhY% gY WcadcbYb XY Xcg h]dcg XY
XY WchfUbgdcfhUXcf FC;;+' =ghcg X]ifzh]Wcg gcb Wz i Ug X]gh]bhcg% Y WY XUg df]bW]dU Yg m Wz i Ug ]bhYfWU UXUg
,.
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
A 4 6X 6N) T)
F(9
9LH A 4
C
6X
;
L Vi c X]ghU hUfX c
m h Vi c Wc YWhcf Wcfh]WU
,.+
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
;G+ ;G + G+
HA GI
9LH
+;G,
A 4
9LH A 4
;G , 6X
; 6B
6X
9LH
VZR NX P VP VQR A 4 OX aRNQ R QR PNZNXR
NZ NT ZV N QR X RPR R x 4YVX VQN
x8 V Z XNP ZN x G VNY R RZ
x 8 XR RZ ZN
+;G,
hfUbgdcfhUXcfYg Yb UXcg cdiYghcg XY U aYaVfUbU WY i Uf Yb
9LH
WcadUfUW] b Wcb Ug Wz i Ug XY h]dc 9' = WcbhfUhfUbgdcfhUXcf XY ;G , 6B
W cfifc V]WUfVcbUhc Yb U aYaVfUbU Ud]WU XY Ug Wz i Ug XY h]dc HYbXf]b
6X
: gY UaUdYbXf]b m Yg X]ZYfYbhY U hfUbgdcfhUXcf XY W cfifc 9LH
V]WUfVcbUhc XY Ug Wz i Ug XY h]dc 9' Dcg ]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc gcb
hfUbgdcfhUXcg UWh]jUaYbhY ZiYfU XY U Wz i U ]bhYfWU UXU XY h]dc :
6X
Yb Y UXc VUgc UhYfU XY U aYaVfUbU WY i Uf dcf U ]Xf [Ybc
9LHUgU% m Y V]WUfVcbUhc gY gYWfYhU UW]U U in% Y ]a]bUbXc Ug Y
YlWYgc XY V]WUfVcbUhc d Ugaxh]Wc Yb U U WU cg]g' DU ]bXiWW] b XY
9VTa N )/ ( % ;z i Ug ]bhYfWU UXUg XY h]dc 9 m h]dc : XY h Vi c Wc YWhcf' DUg
U WU cg]g aYhUV ]WU Wf b]WU UiaYbhU Y b aYfc XY Wz i Ug Wz i Ug XY h]dc 9 Wcbh]YbYb ]Xf [Ybc 9LHUgU Y ]Xf [Ybc dchUg]c 9LHUgU
]bhYfWU UXUg XY h]dc :% eiY Wcbhf]VimYb U ibU aUmcf YlWfYW] b XY Yb U aYaVfUbU ia]bU m gYWfYhUb ]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc a]YbhfUg
V]WUfVcbUhc% a]YbhfUg eiY U UW]Xcg]g UiaYbhU Y b aYfc XY fYUVgcfVYb ]cbYg XY V]WUfVcbUhc m dchUg]c Yb U UW]Xcg]g' =b Ug Wz i Ug XY
h]dc :% cg hfUbgdcfhUXcfYg XY ]Xf [Ybc 9LHUgU Y ]Xf [Ybc dchUg]c
Wz i Ug XY h]dc 9'
9LHUgU gY YbWiYbhfUb Yb U aYaVfUbU VUgc UhYfU m fYUVgcfVYb ]cbYg XY
MbU X]gWig] b axg XYhU UXU XY YghY aYWUb]gac gY dfYgYbhU Yb
]Xf [Ybc a]YbhfUg gYWfYhUb ]cbYg XY V]WUfVcbUhc m dchUg]c Yb U U WU cg]g'
;Ud hi c , ' DUg Wz i Ug ]bhYfWU UXUg hUaV]zb diYXYb fYUVgcfVYf c = WcbhfUhfUbgdcfhUXcf XY W cfifc V]WUfVcbUhc Yb U aYaVfUbU Ud]WU XY Ug
gYWfYhUf ]cbYg XY dchUg]c% Wcac gY aiYghfU Yb9VTa N )/ ( %' DUg Wz i Ug XY h]dc : gY UaUdYbXf]b m Yg X]ZYfYbhY XY hfUbgdcfhUXcf XY W cfifc
WUfUWhYf gh]WUg ZibW]cbU Yg XY h Vi c X]ghU hUfX c V]WUfVcbUhc XY Ug Wz i Ug ]bhYfWU UXUg XY h]dc 9'
,.,
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
EYXi Uf
.
.1
WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf 6X ))%)
-)
hU
4
Ug
A
U
Ugh
)B .)%)
47
+.
H9
hU
Ug
H RN +)%)
SVX NQ TX YR aXN
)')
]bU
.%) h]b
YU
;f
]bU ;
6B +') Abi
MfYU
aOaXN
C
') m FU C ;
? iW
WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf aYXi Uf' Dcg WcbXiWhcg Wc YWhcfYg aYXi UfYg fYUVgcfVYb
XY ZcfaU UWh]jU Y gcX]c m gYWfYhUb ]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc m gcb dYfaYUV Yg U )%+)
cgU
U ifYU% eiY gY fYUVgcfVY Yb Yghcg gY[aYbhcg hiVi UfYg' DU fYUVgcfW] b XY
U[iU Yb cg WcbXiWhcg Wc YWhcfYg aYXi UfYg Yghx Wcbhfc UXU dcf U )% )
;G,
9a]b
WcbWYbhfUW] b XY cfacbU Ubh]X]ifzh]WU'
Hfch
)%).
cxW]X
Y bU
=b U U WU cg]g% Ug Wz i Ug ]bhYfWU UXUg XY h]dc : gYWfYhUb
)%)+
cg
V]WUfVcbUhc m fYUVgcfVYb UWh]jUaYbhY ]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc' Hcf
c hUbhc% Ug Wz i Ug ]bhYfWU UXUg iY[Ub ib dUdY W UjY Yb U Hfcl]aU :iW Y XY <]ghU ;c YWW]cbUbXc
fY[i UW] b xW]Xc VUgY XY cg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg' hiV]hc Yb Y hiV]hc hiV]hc
-' DU dYfaYUV] ]XUX XY h Vi c X]ghU hUfX c m XY WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf 9VTa N )/ (,% ;UaV]cg Yb Ug WcbWYbhfUW]cbYg dfcaYX]c XY X]ZYfYbhYg
Wcfh]WU U U[iU Yghx Wcbhfc UXU dcf U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY 9< % gighUbW]Ug Yb X]ZYfYbhYg dibhcg XY g]ghYaU hiVi Uf Yb fY UW] b Wcb U
eiY hUaV]zb gY XYbca]bU jUgcdfYg]bU' ;cb U hcg b]jY Yg XY WcbWYbhfUW] b XY YgU gighUbW]U Yb Y d UgaU m Y Z] hfUXc [ caYfi Uf' Mb
jU cf XY ') ]bX]WU eiY U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY U gighUbW]U Yb Y ei]Xc hiVi Uf
9< % Yghcg gY[aYbhcg hiVi UfYg gcb dYfaYUV Yg U U[iU dYfc%
Yg U a]gaU eiY U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY YgU gighUbW]U Yb Y d UgaU' Dcg jU cfYg
Yb UigYbW]U XY 9< % gcb j]fhiU aYbhY ]adYfaYUV Yg U U[iU' ]bZYf]cfYg U %) ]bX]WUb eiY U gighUbW]U gY fYUVgcfVY Wcb axg Uj]XYn eiY Y
=ghU WUfUWhYf gh]WU YgdYW]U dfcdcfW]cbU ib aYWUb]gac U[iU% a]YbhfUg eiY cg jU cfYg gidYf]cfYg U %) ]bX]WUb eiY U gighUbW]U gY
]adcfhUbhY dUfU Wcbhfc Uf Y [fUXc XY X] iW] b c WcbWYbhfUW] b fYUVgcfVY Yb aYbcf aYX]XU eiY Y U[iU c gY gYWfYhU Yb cg h Vi cg' H9 %
6BA7H6GBF 78 E86B: 74 87H?4E8F [fUX]YbhY% Wcac hUaV]zb cWiffY Yb Y h Vi c Wc YWhcf Wcfh]WU '
Hcf c hUbhc% Y WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf aYXi Uf hUaV]zb iY[U ib
9ibeiY cg WcbXiWhcg Wc YWhcfYg aYXi UfYg [YbYfU aYbhY
dUdY W UjY Yb U fY[i UW] b XY Yei] ]Vf]c xW]Xc VUgY'
fYUVgcfVYb aYbcg XY . XY U[iU Z] hfUXU m Y gcX]c% gcb Y g]h]c
Z]bU dUfU dfcWYgUf U cf]bU m% dcf c hUbhc% iY[Ub ib dUdY Wf h]Wc
E8FH 8A 78 6BA68AGE46 BA8F 78
Yb U XYhYfa]bUW] b XY U dfcXiWW] b Z]bU XY U[iU m gc ihcg Yb U
7 98E8AG8F FB?HGBF 8A 7 98E8AG8F
cf]bU'
F8: 8AGBF GH5H?4E8F
DUg Wz i Ug Yd]hY ]U Yg XY cg WcbXiWhcg Wc YWhcfYg h]YbYb
ZcfaU WUg] WiVc]XU % Wcb gidYfZ]W]Yg ]gUg m fY Uh]jUaYbhY dcWUg K] ib gc ihc gY WcbWYbhfUfx Yb Y Z i]Xc hiVi Uf Yghx
a]hcWcbXf]Ug "9VTa N )/ (+% ' DUg WUfUWhYf gh]WUg YgdYW]U Yg XY XYhYfa]bUXc dcf Y [fUXc fY Uh]jc XY fYUVgcfW] b XY
YghY gY[aYbhc hiVi Uf gcb Ug g][i]YbhYg3 YgY gc ihc jYfgig U fYUVgcfW] b XY U[iU' K] gY
' DU dYfaYUV] ]XUX XY WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf aYXi Uf U U[iU fYUVgcfVY ib aUmcf dcfWYbhU Y XY U[iU% U gighUbW]U
Yghx Wcbhfc UXU dcf Y b]jY XY 9< ' ;cb b]jY Yg U hcg gY jiY jY axg WcbWYbhfUXU' K] gY fYUVgcfVY ib aUmcf
XY 9< % Y U[iU gY fYUVgcfVY Wcb Uj]XYn Yb Y dcfWYbhU Y XY gc ihc% U gighUbW]U gY X] imY axg'
]bhYfgh]W]c aYXi Uf% c eiY fYXiWY Y jc iaYb XY cf]bU m 9VTa N )/ (,% aiYghfU Y [fUXc XY WcbWYbhfUW] b XY jUf]Ug
WcbWYbhfU U aUmcf U XY cg gc ihcg Yb U cf]bU' gighUbW]Ug Yb X]ZYfYbhYg gY[aYbhcg hiVi UfYg' LcXcg cg jU cfYg
+' 9 X]ZYfYbW]U XY h Vi c Wc YWhcf Wcfh]WU % Y WcbXiWhc XY YghU Z][ifU fYdfYgYbhUb U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY ei]Xc hiVi Uf
Wc YWhcf aYXi Uf Yg dYfaYUV Y U U ifYU m Yl]ghYb X]j]X]XU dcf U WcbWYbhfUW] b d Ugaxh]WU XY ibU gighUbW]U' K] gY
hfUbgdcfhUXcfYg XY ifYU eiY ZUW] ]hUb U X]Zig] b XY U gidcbY eiY U WcbWYbhfUW] b d Ugaxh]WU XY U gighUbW]U Yg
ifYU U hfUjzg XY Ug aYaVfUbUg ia]bU m VUgc UhYfU ' WcbghUbhY% WiU ei]Yf WUaV]c Yb U fY UW] b XY WcbWYbhfUW] b XY
Hcf c hUbhc% dUfhY XY U ifYU hiVi Uf gY fYUVgcfVY Yb Y ei]Xc hiVi Uf ( d UgaU fYZ Y U WUaV]cg Yb U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY
]bhYfgh]W]c aYXi Uf% c eiY UmiXU U UiaYbhUf U ei]Xc hiVi Uf'
cgac U ]XUX Yb YghU fY[] b XY cg f] cbYg m Wcbhf]VimY 9 aYX]XU eiY Y Z] hfUXc gY aiYjY U c Uf[c XY g]ghYaU
U U WUdUW]XUX [YbYfU XY cg f] cbYg dUfU ZcfaUf cf]bU hiVi Uf% U WcbWYbhfUW] b UiaYbhU dfc[fYg]jUaYbhY U axg XY ')
WcbWYbhfUXU' =ghY hYaU gY X]gWihY Yb;Ud hi c +2' g] gY fYUVgcfVY axg U[iU eiY gc ihc% c g] U UV]Xc ibU gYWfYW] b
,' = WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf aYXi Uf Yg WUdUn XY gYWfYhUf bYhU XY gc ihc Yb Y ei]Xc hiVi Uf' K] U fY UW] b XY
]cbYg XY ]Xf [Ybc WcbhfU ibU [fUb WcbWYbhfUW] b' WcbWYbhfUW] b gY jiY jY dfc[fYg]jUaYbhY ]bZYf]cf U %)% YghY
,.-
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
g][b]Z]WU eiY gY U fYUVgcfV]Xc fY Uh]jUaYbhY axg gc ihc U hUgU XY fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf dfcl]aU hUaV]zb UiaYbhU XY
eiY U[iU' Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY 1 a ( a]b "/. XY U L>? U Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY
DUg gighUbW]Ug fYdfYgYbhUXUg Yb U dUfhY gidYf]cf XY 9VTa N )/ (,%% 20%. a ( a]b "/. XY U L>? ' Hcf c hUbhc% Y Yei] ]Vf]c
Wcac U WfYUh]b]bU% gY WcbWYbhfUb aiW c Yb U cf]bU' =b [ caYfi chiVi Uf gY fYZ]YfY U YW c XY eiY U hUgU hchU XY
[YbYfU % YghUg gighUbW]Ug bc gcb bYWYgUf]Ug dUfU Y WiYfdc m fYUVgcfW] b UiaYbhU U aYX]XU eiY UiaYbhU U WUf[U Z] hfUXU% UibeiY
cg f] cbYg gY Ub UXUdhUXc dUfU fYUVgcfVYf Ug gc c ib dcWc Y dcfWYbhU Y XY L>? fYUVgcfV]Xc Yb Y h Vi c dfcl]aU dYfaUbYWY
HA GI
c bUXU c ]bW igc dUfU gYWfYhUf Ug Yb cg h Vi cg% YlWfYhUbXc fY Uh]jUaYbhY WcbghUbhY% U fYXYXcf XY /. '
Ug [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg Yb U cf]bU' Hcf Y WcbhfUf]c% Ug LUaV]zb gY dfcXiWY W]Yfhc [fUXc XY Yei] ]Vf]c [ caYfi chiVi Uf
gighUbW]Ug fYdfYgYbhUXUg Yb U dUfhY ]bZYf]cf XY U Z][ifU% Yb chfcg gY[aYbhcg hiVi UfYg% YgdYW]U aYbhY Y UgU XY Yb Y' Dcg
Wcac U [ iWcgU m cg Ua]bcxW]Xcg% gY fYUVgcfVYb aYWUb]gacg dfYW]gcg fYgdcbgUV Yg XY Yghc bc gY WcadfYbXYb
ZiYfhYaYbhY' LcXUg YghUg gcb gighUbW]Ug eiY Y WiYfdc Wcad YhUaYbhY% dYfc diYXYb XYVYfgY Yb dUfhY U WUaV]cg Yb Ug
bYWYg]hU dUfU WcbgYfjUf m WUg] b]b[ibU gY d]YfXY Yb U cf]bU' ZiYfnUg Z g]WUg Yb Y h Vi c m Y ]bhYfgh]W]c fYbU W]fWibXUbhY% Wcac gY
UbU ]nU axg UXY UbhY' =ghx W Ufc eiY cg aYWUb]gacg dUfU Y Yei] ]Vf]c
?N RXNPVtZ QR P ZPRZ NPVtZ QR Xr aVQ aOaXN VZaXVZN
[ caYfi chiVi Uf diYXYb cWiff]f ]bXYdYbX]YbhYaYbhY XY Ug
XN Yp VPN R aRQR a VXVfN N N RbNXaN XN RNO PVtZ QR NTaN
cfacbUg m diYXYb XYacghfUfgY Yb f] cbYg Wcad YhUaYbhY U]g UXcg
X uOaX RZNXR % DU ]bi ]bU% ib dc ]gUWxf]Xc ih] ]nUXc dUfU
c ]bW igc Yb gY[aYbhcg hiVi UfYg dfcl]aU Yg Wcad YhUaYbhY U]g UXcg'
aYX]f U L>?% bc Yg fYUVgcfV]Xc b] gYWfYhUXc dcf cg h Vi cg
= Yei] ]Vf]c [ caYfi chiVi Uf UmiXU U dfYjYb]f U gcVfYWUf[U
fYbU Yg' Dcg WUaV]cg Yb U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY ]bi ]bU Yb X]ZYfYbhYg
XY cg gY[aYbhcg hiVi UfYg X]ghU Yg WiUbXc UiaYbhU U L>?' =
dibhcg U c Uf[c XY h Vi c fYbU % dcf c hUbhc% fYZ Y Ub WUaV]cg
Yei] ]Vf]c [ caYfi chiVi Uf UWh U Wcac chfU bYU XY XYZYbgU
Yb U WUbh]XUX XY U[iU dfYgYbhY Yb Y ei]Xc hiVi Uf'
dUfU Uacfh][iUf cg YZYWhcg XY cg WUaV]cg YgdcbhxbYcg Yb U L>?
Hcf Y Yad c% U fY UW] b XY WcbWYbhfUW] b XY ei]Xc hiVi Uf (
gcVfY U dfcXiWW] b XY cf]bU' "DU chfU bYU XY XYZYbgU% X]gWih]XU
d UgaU XY ]bi ]bU UiaYbhU U Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY ,%) Yb Y YlhfYac
UbhYf]cfaYbhY% ]bW imY cg aYWUb]gacg UihcffY[i UXcfYg fYbU Yg%
XY cg h Vi cg dfcl]aU Yg% c eiY ]bX]WU eiY U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY
YgdYW]U aYbhY U fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b hiVi c[ caYfi Uf% eiY
]bi ]bU Yb Y ei]Xc hiVi Uf Yg hfYg jYWYg aUmcf eiY Yb Y d UgaU
UmiXUb U dfYjYb]f [fUbXYg WUaV]cg Yb U L>?' LfUVU UbXc ibhcg%
m Y Z] hfUXc [ caYfi Uf' <YV]Xc U eiY U ]bi ]bU bc gY gYWfYhU b] gY
cg aYWUb]gacg UihcffY[i UXcfYg m XY Yei] ]Vf]c
fYUVgcfVY XY cg h Vi cg% ibU fY UW] b XY WcbWYbhfUW] b XY
[ caYfi chiVi Uf dfYj]YbYb [fUbXYg WUaV]cg Yb Y Z i c XY
ei]Xc hiVi Uf ( d UgaU XY ,') g][b]Z]WU eiY gc c ib hYfW]c XY
ei]Xc Yb cg h Vi cg X]ghU Yg WiUbXc Y WUaV]cg XY dfYg] b
U[iU eiY gY Z] hf dYfaUbYWY Yb Y h Vi c fYbU m eiY Xcg hYfW]cg
UfhYf]U c WiUbXc Um chfUg U hYfUW]cbYg eiY XY chfc acXc
XY U[iU Z] hfUXU gY U fYUVgcfV]Xc Wcac Y ei]Xc dUgU U hfUjzg
U hYfUf Ub U caYcghUg]g XY jc iaYb m XY gcX]c'
XY h Vi c dfcl]aU ' 9 Z]bU XY cg WcbXiWhcg Wc YWhcfYg% U
fY UW] b XY WcbWYbhfUW] b XY ei]Xc hiVi Uf ( ]bi ]bU d Ugaxh]WU
9H8EM4F 9lF 64F 78? ?lDH 7B AG8EFG 6 4?
UiaYbhU U Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY +. "jYf9VTa N )/ (,% % c eiY ]bX]WU
C8E GH5H?4E 64C ?4E L E8A4?
eiY gc c eiYXU ( +. XY U[iU Z] hfUXU Yb Y h Vi c m eiY gY U
fYUVgcfV]Xc axg XY 22 ' DUg ZiYfnUg cga h]WUg ]Xfcghxh]WUg m Wc c]XYg [cV]YfbUb U hUgU
XY fYUVgcfW] b U hfUjzg XY cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg% U ][iU eiY
Wcbhfc Ub U Z] hfUW] b Yb cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg' Dcg WUaV]cg
E8:H?46 nA 78 GH5H?4E Yb U fYUVgcfW] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf diYXYb ]bZ i]f U gi jYn Yb Ug
ERNO PVtZ dfYg]cbYg cga h]WUg ]Xfcghxh]WUg m Wc c]XYg XY ]bhYfgh]W]c fYbU m%
<UXc eiY Yg ZibXUaYbhU aUbhYbYf ib Yei] ]Vf]c dfYW]gc YbhfY U Yb h]aU ]bghUbW]U% Yb U fYUVgcfW] b XY U[iU m gc ihcg XY cg
fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf m U Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf% Yl]ghYb a h]d Yg h Vi cg fYbU Yg'
aYWUb]gacg XY Wcbhfc bYfj]cgc% cfacbU m cWU eiY fY[i Ub U
INX R Z YNXR QR SaR fN Sr VPN e N N QR RNO PVtZ% 9
fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf% U ][iU eiY Yl]ghYb dUfU Y Wcbhfc XY U
aYX]XU eiY Y Z] hfUXc [ caYfi Uf dUgU U hfUjzg XY cg h Vi cg
Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf' MbU WUfUWhYf gh]WU ]adcfhUbhY XY U
fYbU Yg% bcfaU aYbhY gY fYUVgcfVYb axg XY 22 XY U[iU m
fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf Yg eiY U fYUVgcfW] b XY U [ibcg gc ihcg
U aUmcf U XY cg gc ihcg' Dcg ei]Xcg m Y YWhfc ]hcg gY
diYXY fY[i UfgY ]bXYdYbX]YbhYaYbhY XY chfcg% YgdYW]U aYbhY U
fYUVgcfVYb XY cg h Vi cg U ]bhYfgh]W]c fYbU m XY U U cg
hfUjzg XY aYWUb]gacg XY Wcbhfc cfacbU '
WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg' DU hUgU bcfaU XY fYUVgcfW] b WUd] Uf
dYf]hiVi Uf Yg XY Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY +- a ( a]b'
8DH ? 5E B :?B 8EH?BGH5H?4E1 ?4
DU fYUVgcfW] b U hfUjzg XY cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg gY diYXY WU Wi Uf
G4F4 78 E845FBE6 nA 4H 8AG4 8A
XY U g][i]YbhY aUbYfU3
E8FCH8FG4 4? 4H 8AGB 78 ?4 64E:4
GH5H?4E JYUVgcfW] b 2 C> w >iYfnU bYhU XY fYUVgcfW] b
Mbc XY cg aYWUb]gacg axg Vxg]Wcg dUfU Wcbhfc Uf U fYUVgcfW] b DU ZiYfnU fYUVgcfVYbhY bYhU fYdfYgYbhU U giaU XY Ug ZiYfnUg
hiVi Uf Yg U WUdUW]XUX ]bhf bgYWU XY cg h Vi cg dUfU UiaYbhUf cga h]WUg ]Xfcghxh]WUg m Wc c]XYg eiY ZUjcfYWYb c gY cdcbYb U U
gi hUgU XY fYUVgcfW] b Yb fYgdiYghU U UiaYbhc XY U WUf[U fYUVgcfW] b U hfUjzg XY cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg' =ghUg ZiYfnUg
hiVi Uf "UiaYbhc XY Z i c XY YbhfUXU hiVi Uf ' =ghY ZYb aYbc gY ]bW imYb Ug g][i]YbhYg3 " dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU XYbhfc XY cg
WcbcWY WcacYei] ]Vf]c [ caYfi chiVi Uf' Hcf Y Yad c% g] U L>? WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg "dYf]hiVi Uf
UiaYbhU XY +. U .) a ( a]b% Y jU cf UVgc ihc dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU SH;T % eiY gY cdcbY U U fYUVgcfW] b4
,..
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
HYf]hiVi Uf AbhYfgh]W]U LiVi Uf LiVi Uf eiY Yghxb X]fYWhUaYbhY ]bZ iYbW]UXcg dcf cg WUaV]cg YacX]bxa]Wcg
WUd] Uf ei]Xc Wz i Ug iaYb fYbU Yg gcb Ug dfYg]cbYg cga h]WUg ]Xfcghxh]WUg m Wc c]XYg XY cg
WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg' cgDU dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf
H]Z Yghx ]bZ iYbW]UXU dcf U dfYg] b UfhYf]U m Ug fYg]ghYbW]Ug XY Ug
H9?; / aa [
UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg m YZYfYbhYg' Wcac g][iY3
, aa [
¨]Z ' Dcg UiaYbhcg XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U h]YbXYb U Y YjUf Y dYf]hiVc
¨; . aa [
dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf Uf m X]ga]bi]f U hUgU XY
,+ aa [
9 [fUbY
fYUVgcfW] b' =ghY YZYWhc gY Uacfh][iU Yb W]YfhU aYX]XU dcf
+G +G
Z i]f aYWUb]gacg UihcffY[i UXcfYg eiY aUbh]YbYb ib Z i c
F(9 F(9 gUb[i bYc fYbU fY Uh]jUaYbhY WcbghUbhY% Ug Wcac
( YY T 9LH
ERNO PVtZ ZR N dfYg]cbYg ]Xfcghxh]WUg fY Uh]jUaYbhY WcbghUbhYg Yb cg
R VtZ jUgcg gUb[i bYcg fYbU Yg'
+' Mb UiaYbhc XY U fYg]ghYbW]U XY Ug UfhYf]c Ug UZYfYbhYg c
9VTa N )/ (-% JYgiaYb XY Ug ZiYfnUg cga h]WUg ]Xfcghxh]WUg m Wc c]XYg eiY YZYfYbhYg fYXiWY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf
XYhYfa]bUb U fYUVgcfW] b XY ei]Xcg dcf cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg' Dcg jU cfYg m h]YbXY U UiaYbhUf U hUgU XY fYUVgcfW] b' 9ibeiY U
biazf]Wcg eiY gY aiYghfUb gcb Ygh]aUW]cbYg XY cg jU cfYg bcfaU Yg dUfU
Wcbghf]WW] b XY Ug UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg UiaYbhU U dfYg] b
iaUbcg' DU dfYg] b XY fYUVgcfW] b bYhU Yg bcfaU aYbhY XY ibcg ) aa [% c
]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf [ caYfi Uf% X]ga]bimY U dfYg] b
eiY UWY eiY Y ei]Xc m cg gc ihcg gY fYUVgcfVUb Yb cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg U
aYX]XU eiY gY hfUbgdcfhUb U hfUjzg XY Ug Wz i Ug XY cg h Vi cg fYbU Yg' 9LH% ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf' = gY[ibXc XYhYfa]bUbhY
Lf]ZcgZUhc XY UXYbcg]bU4 H9?;% dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf4 H9?g] df]bW]dU XY cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg'
% dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU XY Z i]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U 4 ¨;% dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY U fYUVgcfW] b Yg U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY XY d UgaU Yb Yghcg
WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf4 ¨g]% dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XU XY ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U '
WUd] UfYg4 Y UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY UiaYbhU U
fYUVgcfW] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf'DU dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY XY cg
"+ dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU Yb Y ]bhYfgh]W]c fYbU "Hg] ZiYfU XY WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg Yghx XYhYfa]bUXU dcf c g][i]YbhY3 " Y
cg WUd] UfYg% c eiY ZUjcfYWY U fYUVgcfW] b4 ", Wc cf dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY d Ugaxh]WU g]ghza]WU "Y UiaYbhc XY U
dfYg] b cga h]WU c]XYU XY d UgaU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf WcbWYbhfUW] b XY dfchY bUg d Ugaxh]WUg XY U gUb[fY g]ghza]WU
dfchY bUg "¨; % eiY ZUjcfYWY U fYUVgcfW] b4 m "- dfYg] b h]YbXY U Y YjUf U dfYg] b cga h]WU XY Wc c]XY WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf%
cga h]WU Wc c]XY XY Ug dfchY bUg Yb Y ]bhYfgh]W]c fYbU UiaYbhUbXc Ug U fYUVgcfW] b 4 m
"¨g] % eiY gY cdcbY U U fYUVgcfW] b' "+ U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] bª;iUbhc aUmcf Yg U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b%
9VTa N )/ (-% aiYghfU Ug ZiYfnUg bcfaU Yg Udfcl]aUXUg eiY aUmcf Yg U ZfUWW] b XY d UgaU Z] hfUXc U hfUjzg XY [ cazfi c m% Yb
ZUjcfYWYf m cdcbYfgY U U fYUVgcfW] b dYf]hiVi Uf' <YV]Xc U eiY U WcbgYWiYbW]U% axg WcbWYbhfUXU gY jiY jY U dfchY bU Yb Y d UgaU eiY
dfYg] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf bcfaU dfcaYX]U U fYXYXcf XY , aa [m eiYXU' Hcf hUbhc% Y UiaYbhc XY U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b hUaV]zb
U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU XY ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U fYbU dfcaYX]U / aa [% h]YbXY U ]bWfYaYbhUf U hUgU XY fYUVgcfW] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf' <YV]Xc
Yl]ghY ib [fUX]YbhY XY dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU dcg]h]jU XYgXY Y WUd] Uf U eiY U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b gY XYZ]bY Wcac U dfcdcfW] b XY ?>J (
dYf]hiVi Uf U ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U XY U fYXYXcf XY 0 aa [% eiY gY JH>% diYXY dfcXiW]fgY ib UiaYbhc XY U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b Wcac
cdcbY U U fYUVgcfW] b XY ei]Xc' =ghU cdcg]W] b U U fYUVgcfW] b XY fYgi hUXc XY ib UiaYbhc XY U ?>J c ibU X]ga]biW] b XY U JH>'
ei]Xcg Yghx axg eiY WcbhfUffYghUXU dcf Ug dfYg]cbYg cga h]WUg 9 [ibcg jUgcWcbghf]WhcfYg fYbU Yg% Wcac U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA% UiaYbhUb
Wc c]XYg eiY ZUjcfYWYb U fYUVgcfW] b' DU dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XU U fYUVgcfW] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf U X]ga]bi]f U JH> m UiaYbhUf U
d Ugaxh]WU% eiY ZUjcfYWY U fYUVgcfW] b% Yg XY ibcg ,+ aa [% m U ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b% Wcac gY UbU ]nU axg UXY UbhY'
dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XU XY ]bhYfgh]W]c% eiY gY cdcbY U U
fYUVgcfW] b% Yg XY . aa [% c eiY dfcjcWU ibU ZiYfnU cga h]WU ;UaV]cg Yb Y WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf C> hUaV]zb diYXY ]bZ i]f
Wc c]XU bYhU XY ibcg 0 aa [ eiY ZUjcfYWY U fYUVgcfW] b' Hcf c U hUgU XY fYUVgcfW] b dcfeiY C> Yg ibU aYX]XU XY U
hUbhc% fYghUbXc Ug ZiYfnUg ]Xfcghxh]WUg bYhUg eiY gY cdcbYb U U dYfaYUV] ]XUX m Y xfYU XY gidYfZ]W]Y XY cg WUd] UfYg' 9iaYbhU
fYUVgcfW] b "0 aa [ XY Ug ZiYfnUg cga h]WUg Wc c]XYg bYhUg eiY h]bhU> UiaYbhUf U fYUVgcfW] b% a]YbhfUg eiY U X]ga]biW] b XY C> axg VU c
ZUjcfYWYb U fYUVgcfW] b " 0 aa [ gY cVh]YbY ibU ZiYfnU fYUVgcfW] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf' C> dYfaUbYWY fY Uh]jUaYbhY WcbghUbhY
fYUVgcfVYbhY bYhU XY Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY ) aa [' =ghY jU cf Yg U hc% Yb U aUmcf U XY Ug WcbX]W]cbYg Z]g]c []WUg' 6aNQ )/ )
g]a] Uf U YbWcbhfUXc Yb cg WUd] UfYg [ caYfi UfYg% dYfc Yb gYbh]Xc fYgiaY cg ZUWhcfYg eiY diYXYb ]bZ i]f Yb U hUgU XY
WcbhfUf]c' fYUVgcfW] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf'
= chfc ZUWhcf eiY Wcbhf]VimY U U U hU hUgU XY fYUVgcfW] b
C R V ZR VZ R VPVNXR UVQ p VPN e Yt VPN P X VQR RZNXR %
XY ei]Xc Yb cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg Yg ibU [fUb
=b h]aU ]bghUbW]U% cg WUaV]cg Yb Ug ZiYfnUg Z g]WUg WUd] UfYg
WcYZ]W]YbhY XY Z] hfUW] b "C> XYV]Xc U U U hU WcbXiWh]j]XUX
dYf]hiVi UfYg ]bZ imYb Yb U fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf U WUaV]Uf Ug
]Xfxi ]WU m U [fUb gidYfZ]W]Y XY cg WUd] UfYg'
ZiYfnUg Z g]WUg Yb Y ]bhYfgh]W]c fYbU eiY fcXYU cg h Vi cg' Hcf
<YV]Xc U eiY U hUgU XY fYUVgcfW] b Yg bcfaU aYbhY XY +- a (
Y Yad c% ibU X]ga]biW] b XY U ZiYfnU XY fYUVgcfW] b U hfUjzg XY
a]b m U dfYg] b XY fYUVgcfW] b bYhU Yg XY ) aa [% C> bcfaU aYbhY Yg XY
Ug aYaVfUbUg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg% WUigUXU dcf Y UiaYbhc
Udfcl]aUXUaYbhY +%- a ( a]b dcf aa ['
XY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf c U X]ga]biW] b XY
ERTaXNPVtZ QR XN SaR fN Sr VPN PN VXN R R V aOaXN R % U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf% fYXiWY U
Dcg Xcg XYhYfa]bUbhYg XY U fYUVgcfW] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf WUdhUW] b XY ei]Xc m gc ihcg XY
,./
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
HA GI
¨; JYUVgcfW] b
¨9 ¨;
>> ¨;
C> JYUVgcfW] b 9LH
FYhc
>>% ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b4 C>% WcYZ]W]YbhY XY Z] hfUW] b WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf4 H9? fYUVgcfW] b
;% dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf4 ¨9% dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY
XY d UgaU UfhYf]U 4 ¨;% cga h]Wc Wc c]XY WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf
dfYg] b4 J9 m Ja]% fYg]ghYbW]Ug UfhYf]c UfYg UZYfYbhYg m YZYfYbhYg%
9LH
>i[U
fYgdYWh]jUaYbhY'
,.0
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
Y YZYWhc XY UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U gcVfY U dfcXiWW] b XY cf]bU' Y YWhfc ]hcg' 9g]a]gac% WiUbXc gY acX]Z]WU U ]b[YghU XY
;iUbXc U UihcffY[i UW] b XY U L>? Yghx U hYfUXU% Wcac cWiffY U aYbiXc gcX]c% cg f] cbYg XYVYb U ighUf U YlWfYW] b if]bUf]U XY gcX]c
Yb U YbZYfaYXUX fYbU % cg UiaYbhcg XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U diYXYb XY aUbYfU Udfcd]UXU g]b WUaV]cg ]adcfhUbhYg Yb U
dfcjcWUf UiaYbhcg aiW c aUmcfYg XY U L>?' YlWfYW] b XY chfcg Y YWhfc ]hcg' NUf]Ug cfacbUg Yb Y WiYfdc
Mb gY[ibXc YZYWhc XY UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b UfhYf]U fYbU eiY dfcdcfW]cbUb YghU YgdYW]Z]W]XUX XY fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf dUfU
UiaYbhU U dfcXiWW] b XY cf]bU Yg eiY X]ga]bimY cg dcfWYbhU Yg XY X]ZYfYbhYg Y YWhfc ]hcg m U[iU'6aNQ )/ fYgiaY U [ibUg XY
Ug WUf[Ug Z] hfUXUg XY gcX]c m U[iU eiY gcb fYUVgcfV]XUg dcf cg Ug cfacbUg axg ]adcfhUbhYg dUfU fY[i Uf U fYUVgcfW] b
h Vi cg' 9ibeiY cg aYWUb]gacg fYgdcbgUV Yg XY YghY YZYWhc bc gY hiVi Uf% gig df]bW]dU Yg g]h]cg XY UWW] b gcVfY Y h Vi c fYbU m
WcadfYbXYb Wcad YhUaYbhY% ]bW imYb ibU WUgWUXU XY ZUWhcfYg Z g]Wcg% gig YZYWhcg gcVfY U YlWfYW] b XY gc ihcg m U[iU' 9 [ibUg XY
Ug Wcac YZYWhcg dUfUWf]bcg m cfacbU Yg' = UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b YghUg cfacbUg gY UbU ]nUb Wcb axg XYhU Y Yb;Ud hi cg +2 m
UfhYf]U dfcjcWU ib ][Yfc UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf ,)% dYfc Uei fYdUgUacg VfYjYaYbhY gig UWW]cbYg hiVi UfYg fYbU Yg'
dYf]hiVi Uf% YgdYW]U aYbhY Yb cg jUgcg fYWhcg XY U azXi U fYbU % m
?N NXQ R ZN R VYaXN XN RNO PVtZ RZNX QR QV e XN
ibU dcghYf]cf
RP RPVtZ QR N V % DU U XcghYfcbU% gYWfYhUXU dcf Ug Wz i Ug XY
UiaYbhc XY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU XY ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U fYbU
U ncbU [ caYfi cgU XY U WcfhYnU gidfUffYbU % Yg ib ]adcfhUbhY
' ;cac gY X]gWih] UbhYf]cfaYbhY% ib UiaYbhc Yb U dfYg] b
fY[i UXcf XY U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c m U gYWfYW] b XY ]cbYg XY
]Xfcghxh]WU XY ei]Xc ]bhYfgh]W]U fYbU UiaYbhU U Zi[U XY
dchUg]c Y ]Xf [Ybc dcf cg h Vi cg fYbU Yg' Mb g]h]c df]bW]dU XY
gcX]c UW]U U in hiVi Uf% c eiY fYXiWY U fYUVgcfW] b bYhU
U UWW] b XY U U XcghYfcbU Yb cg h Vi cg fYbU Yg gY YbWiYbhfU Yb
XY gcX]c m U[iU m UiaYbhU U b axg U hUgU XY dfcXiWW] b XY
Ug Wz i Ug df]bW]dU Yg XY h Vi c Wc YWhcf Wcfh]WU '' = aYWUb]gac
cf]bU WiUbXc UiaYbhU U dfYg] b UfhYf]U fYbU '
dcf Y WiU U U XcghYfcbU UiaYbhU U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c m U
Mb hYfWYf ZUWhcf eiY Wcbhf]VimY U U bUhf]ifYg]g dcf dfYg] b m U
gYWfYW] b XY dchUg]c Yg Ygh]ai UbXc Y gcX]c' C
X]ifYg]g dcf dfYg] b Yg fYXiWW] b XY U ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU
:caVU XY 9LHUgU Yb Y UXc VUgc UhYfU XY U aYaVfUbU XY h Vi c
AA' DU Ub[]chYbg]bU AA dcf g a]gaU UiaYbhU U fYUVgcfW] b XY
Wc YWhcf Wcfh]WU ' DU U XcghYfcbU hUaV]zb UiaYbhU U dYfaYUV] ]XUX U
gcX]c dcf cg h Vi cg m Ygh]ai U U gYWfYW] b XY U XcghYfcbU% c
gcX]c XY UXc ia]bU XY U aYaVfUbU aYX]UbhY U ]bgYfW] b XY
eiY UiaYbhU U b axg U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c' Hcf hUbhc% U
WUbU Yg XY gcX]c Yd]hY ]U Yg' Dcg aYWUb]gacg WY i UfYg XY U UWW] b XY
X]ga]biW] b XY U ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA Wcbhf]VimY U U
U U XcghYfcbU gY UbU ]nUb Yb
X]ga]biW] b XY U fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf XY gcX]c eiY gY dfcXiWY
;Ud hi c 01'
WiUbXc UiaYbhU U dfYg] b UfhYf]U '
Dcg Ygh ai cg axg ]adcfhUbhYg dUfU U U XcghYfcbU gcb cg
Mb WiUfhc ZUWhcf eiY diYXY Wcbhf]Vi]f U U bUhf]ifYg]g dcf
g][i]YbhYg3 " UiaYbhc XY U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY dchUg]c YlhfUWY i Uf4 m
dfYg] b Yg ]bhYfbU ]nUW] b XY dfchY bUg hfUbgdcfhUXcfUg XY gcX]c
"+ UiaYbhc XY cg b]jY Yg XY XUb[]chYbg]bU AA% eiY h d]WUaYbhY
XYgXY Ug aYaVfUbUg Ud]WU Yg UghU Y W]hcd UgaU XY cg h Vi cg
cWiffYb Yb WcbX]W]cbYg UgcW]UXUg Wcb XYd YW] b XY gcX]c m jc iaYb c
fYbU Yg% fYXiW]YbXc Ug U WUbh]XUX XY gcX]c eiY gY diYXY hfUbgdcfhUf
dfYg] b gUb[i bYU VU U' = UiaYbhc XY U gYWfYW] b XY U XcghYfcbU
U hfUjzg XY Ug aYaVfUbUg WY i UfYg' =ghY YZYWhc XY UiaYbhc XY U
UgcW]UXc Wcb YghUg UZYWW]cbYg WUigU fYhYbW] b fYbU XY gcX]c m U[iU%
dfYg] b UfhYf]U diYXY YghUf aYX]UXc% Yb dUfhY% dcf ibU X]ga]biW] b
c eiY UmiXU U fYghUifUf Y jc iaYb XY ei]Xc YlhfUWY i Uf m U dfYg] b
XY U ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA m chfUg gY U Yg UihUWc]XYg c
UfhYf]U UW]U U bcfaU ]XUX'
dUfUWf]bUg'
;iUbXc Um ib XzZ]W]h XY U XcghYfcbU% Wcac cWiffY Wcb U
XYghfiWW] b c aU ZibW]cbUa]Ybhc XY Ug gidfUffYbU Yg "=bZYfaYXUX
6BAGEB? BE BA4? 78 ?4
XY 9XX]gcb % Um ibU aUfWUXU dzfX]XU XY gcX]c XY WiYfdc m
E845FBE6 nA GH5H?4E
UWiai UW] b XY dchUg]c' Hcf Y WcbhfUf]c% U gYWfYW] b YlWYg]jU XY
DU fY[i UW] b dfYW]gU XY cg jc aYbYg XY Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m Ug U XcghYfcbU% Wcac cWiffY Yb dUW]YbhYg Wcb hiacfYg gidfUffYbU Yg"
WcbWYbhfUW]cbYg XY gc ihcg fYei]YfY eiY cg f] cbYg YlWfYhYb K bXfcaY XY ;cbb % gY UgcW]U Wcb U fYhYbW] b XY gcX]c m U
X]ZYfYbhYg gc ihcg m U[iU U jY cW]XUXYg jUf]UV Yg% U jYWYg X]ga]biW] b XY U WcbWYbhfUW] b d Ugaxh]WU XY dchUg]c XYV]Xc% Yb
]bXYdYbX]YbhYaYbhY ibcg XY chfcg' Hcf Y Yad c% WiUbXc dUfhY% U U gYWfYW] b YlWYg]jU XY dchUg]c dcf cg f] cbYg' 9ibeiY U
UiaYbhU U ]b[YghU XY dchUg]c% cg f] cbYg XYVYb YlWfYhUf axg fY[i UW] b X]Uf]U XY Yei] ]Vf]c XY gcX]c gY diYXY aUbhYbYf a]YbhfUg
dchUg]c a]YbhfUg aUbh]YbYb U YlWfYW] b bcfaU XY gcX]c m chfcg Yl]ghUb b]jY Yg a b]acg XY U XcghYfcbU% Y
Y ZN FV V QR NPPVtZ 8SRP
,.1
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
DU ]bWUdUW]XUX dUfU U ighUf U gYWfYW] b XY U XcghYfcbU XY aUbYfU WfYUh]b]bU eiY XYdYbXYb df]bW]dU aYbhY XY ibU L>? UXYWiUXU dUfU gi
UXYWiUXU UZYWhU Yb [fUb aYX]XU U fY[i UW] b XY U YlWfYW] b fYbU XY YlWfYW] b' Hcf hUbhc% Y UiaYbhc XY U ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA
dchUg]c m U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY dchUg]c XY cg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg' Hcf dYfa]hY eiY cg f] cbYg fYhYb[Ub gcX]c m U[iU g]b dfcjcWUf U
hUbhc% U U XcghYfcbU Yg ]bW igc axg ]adcfhUbhY Wcac fY[i UXcf XY U fYhYbW] b XY dfcXiWhcg XY XYgYW c aYhUV ]Wcg'
WcbWYbhfUW] b XY dchUg]c eiY XY U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY gcX]c% Wcac gY
?N U Y ZN NZ VQVa q VPN NaYRZ N XN RNO PVtZ QR NTaN%
UbU ]nU Yb;Ud hi c ,)'
HA GI
DU UWW] b fYbU axg ]adcfhUbhY XY U 9< Yg UiaYbhUf U
?N NZTV RZ VZN NaYRZ N XN RNO PVtZ QR QV e NTaN% DU dYfaYUV] ]XUX U U[iU XY h Vi c X]ghU % Y h Vi c Wc YWhcf m Y Yd]hY ]c
Ub[]chYbg]bU AA Yg ei]nxg U cfacbU XY fYhYbW] b XY gcX]c axg XY WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf' =ghY YZYWhc UmiXU U WiYfdc U WcbgYfjUf U[iU Yb
dcXYfcgU XY WiYfdc' ;cac gY X]gWih] Yb;Ud hi c 2% U W]fWibghUbW]Ug Wcac U XYg ]XfUhUW] b' =b UigYbW]U XY 9< % U
ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA UiaYbhU Yb W]fWibghUbW]Ug dYfaYUV] ]XUX XY cg h Vi cg X]ghU Yg m cg WcbXiWhcg Wc YWhcfYg U
UgcW]UXUg Wcb dfYg] b gUb[i bYU VU U m ( c jc iaYb XY ei]Xc U[iU Yg VU U% c eiY UWY eiY cg f] cbYg YlWfYhYb [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg
YlhfUWY i Uf VU c% Wcac XifUbhY ibU YacffU[]U c dzfX]XU XY gU XY cf]bU X] i]XU% ibU UZYWW] b UaUXU
m U[iU XY cg ei]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg dcf giXcfUW] b YlWYg]jU c X]UVYhYg ]bg d]XU' Hcf c hUbhc% Ug UWW]cbYg XY U 9< iY[Ub ib
X]UffYU gYjYfU' = UiaYbhc XY U ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA dUdY W UjY Yb Y Wcbhfc XY [fUXc XY X] iW] b c WcbWYbhfUW] b XY
UmiXU U bcfaU ]nUf U dfYg] b UfhYf]U m Y jc iaYb YlhfUWY i Uf U U cf]bU% Wcac gY Yld ]WU axg UXY UbhY Yb;Ud hi cg +2 m 0/'
UiaYbhUf U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c m U[iU XY cg h Vi cg fYbU Yg U 9< gY ibY U YgdYW Z]Wcg N+ fYWYdhcfYg Yb cg h Vi cg X]ghU Yg
hfUjzg XY hfYg YZYWhcg df]bW]dU Yg3 hUfX cg% cg h Vi cg Wc YWhcfYg m cg WcbXiWhcg Wc YWhcfYg% UiaYbhU
' DU Ub[]chYbg]bU AA Ygh]ai U U gYWfYW] b XY U XcghYfcbU% U ZcfaUW] b XY acbcZcgZUhc XY UXYbcg]bU W W ]Wc m U UWh]jUW] b
eiY U gi jYn UiaYbhU U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c' XY Ug dfchY bUg ei]bUgUg "9VTa N )/ (0% ' =ghU UWW] b% U gi jYn%
+' DU Ub[]chYbg]bU AA WcbhfUY Ug UfhYf]c Ug YZYfYbhYg% eiY h]YbY Xcg Ygh]ai U Y acj]a]Ybhc XY ibU dfchY bU ]bhfUWY i Uf% UaUXU
YZYWhcg gcVfY U X]bxa]WU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf eiY UiaYbhUb U UWiUdcf]bU + "9IH + % U UXc ia]bU XY Ug aYaVfUbUg WY i UfYg'
fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c m U[iU' Hf]aYfc% U Wcbghf]WW] b UfhYf]c Uf DUg ac zWi Ug XY 9IH + gY U[fidUb m gY Zig]cbUb Wcb U
YZYfYbhY fYXiWY U dfYg] b ]Xfcghxh]WU WUd] Uf dYf]hiVi Uf% c aYaVfUbU WY i Uf dcf YlcW]hcg]g dUfU ZcfaUfWUbU Yg XY U[iU eiY
eiY UiaYbhU U fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf bYhU% YgdYW]U aYbhY XY cg dYfa]hYb ibU fxd]XU X]Zig] b XY U[iU U hfUjzg XY Ug Wz i Ug' Um
h Vi cg dfcl]aU Yg' =b gY[ibXc i[Uf% U Wcbghf]WW] b UfhYf]c Uf chfUg UWiUdcf]bUg% 9IH , m 9IH -% Yb Y UXc VUgc UhYfU XY U
YZYfYbhY% U fYXiW]f Y Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU % UiaYbhU U aYaVfUbU WY i Uf eiY dfcdcfW]cbUb ib WUa]bc dUfU eiY Y U[iU
ZfUWW] b XY Z] hfUW] b Yb Y [ cazfi c m UiaYbhU U gU [U fxd]XUaYbhY XY Ug Wz i Ug% UibeiY YghUg UWiUdcf]bUg bc
WcbWYbhfUW] b XY dfchY bUg m U dfYg] b cga h]WU Wc c]XY Yb cg Yghxb fY[i UXUg dcf U 9< ' Dcg UiaYbhcg Wf b]Wcg Yb cg b]jY Yg
WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg' =ghY aYWUb]gac hUaV]zb UiaYbhU U XY 9< hUaV]zb UiaYbhUb U ZcfaUW] b XY U dfchY bU 9IH + Yb
ZiYfnU fYUVgcfVYbhY Yb cg WUd] UfYg dYf]hiVi UfYg m UiaYbhU Ug Wz i Ug hiVi UfYg fYbU Yg U Ygh]ai Uf U hfUbgWf]dW] b XY [Yb
U fYUVgcfW] b hiVi Uf XY gcX]c m U[iU' 9IH +' ;iUbXc U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY 9< X]ga]bimY% Ug ac zWi Ug
XY 9IH + gcb hfUbgdcfhUXUg XY fY[fYgc U W]hcd UgaU WY i Uf%
,' DU Ub[]chYbg]bU AA Ygh]ai U X]fYWhUaYbhY U fYUVgcfW] b XY Y ]a]bUbXc Ug cg WUbU Yg XY U[iU XY U aYaVfUbU ia]bU m
gcX]c Yb cg h Vi cg dfcl]aU Yg% Ug UgUg XY Yb Y% cg fYXiW]YbXc U dYfaYUV] ]XUX U U[iU' =ghUg UWW]cbYg XY 9< gY
h Vi cg X]ghU Yg m cg h Vi cg Wc YWhcfYg' Mbc XY cg YZYWhcg UbU ]nUb Wcb axg XYhU Y Yb cg WUd hi cg +2 m 0/'
X]fYWhcg XY U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA Yg Ygh]ai Uf Y FU C :caVU
XY 9LHUgU Yb U aYaVfUbU VUgc UhYfU XY Ug Wz i Ug
JYbU LiVi Uf
Yd]hY ]U Yg hiVi UfYg' Mb gY[ibXc YZYWhc Yg Ygh]ai Uf Y LiVi Uf
]bhYfgh]W]U iaYb
]bhYfWUaV]c XY gcX]c ]Xf [Ybc Yb U aYaVfUbU ia]bU % ei]Xc
Wz i Ug
YlhfUWY i Uf m U dfYg] b UfhYf]U % Wcac X]gWih]Xc Yb;Ud hi c ,)' fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c Yb cg h Vi cg dfcl]aU Yg' 9b[ AA Ygh]ai U Y ]bhYfWUaV]c XY
gcX]c ]Xf [Ybc "F = Yb U aYaVfUbU ia]bU m FU C LfUbgdcfhUXcf XY 9LHUgU
9 a]gac h]Yadc eiY U Ub[]chYbg]bU AA UiaYbhU U fYUVgcfW] b XY
m WchfUbgdcfhY XY V]WUfVcbUhc XY gcX]c Yb U aYaVfUbU VUgc UhYfU ' =ghcg a]gacg
gcX]c hiVi Uf fYbU % gi YZYWhc jUgcWcbghf]Whcf gcVfY Ug UfhYf]c Ug YZYWhcg XY 9b[ AA dfcVUV YaYbhY cWiffYb Yb jUf]Ug chfUg dUfhYg XY h Vi c fYbU %
YZYfYbhYg hUaV]zb UmiXU Yb Y aUbhYb]a]Ybhc XY U YlWfYW] b bcfaU ]bW i]Xc Y UgU XY Yb Y% h Vi c X]ghU %
XY dfcXiWhcg XY XYgYW c aYhUV ]Wcg Wcac U ifYU m m h Vi c Wc YWhcf' 9 % JYWYdhcf XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA h]dc A'
,.2
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
JYbU
LiVi Uf
LiVi Uf ?4 46G I46 nA 78? F FG8 4
]bhYfgh]W]U iaYb
Wz i Ug A8EI BFB F CiG 6B 4H 8AG4 ?4
ei]Xc
E845FBE6 nA 78 FB7 B
DU UWh]jUW] b XY g]ghYaU bYfj]cgc g]adxh]Wc% g] Yg [fUjY%
4DC )B diYXY X]ga]bi]f U YlWfYW] b XY gcX]c m U[iU U WcbhfUYf Ug
4DC +
9NH N+ UfhYf]c Ug fYbU Yg% c eiY fYXiWY U L>?' K]b YaVUf[c% ]bW igc
)B cg b]jY Yg VU cg XY UWh]jUW] b g]adxh]WU X]ga]bimYb U
?J9EGg
HfchY bU
NPNY N YlWfYW] b XY gcX]c m U[iU U UiaYbhUf U fYUVgcfW] b XY
Ii]bUgU
;'9' 9 gcX]c Yb Y h Vi c dfcl]aU % U fUaU UgWYbXYbhY [fiYgU XY
4GC UgU XY Yb Y m ei]nxg Yb Ug dUfhYg axg X]ghU Yg XY h Vi c
4DC )
fYbU ' =ghc cWiffY dcf U UWh]jUW] b XY cg fYWYdhcfYg
?J9EGg
HfchY bU
9NH N+ >cgZcf] UW] b UXfYbzf[]Wcg Yb Ug Wz i Ug Yd]hY ]U Yg XY cg h Vi cg fYbU Yg'
DU Ygh]ai UW] b XY g]ghYaU bYfj]cgc g]adxh]Wc hUaV]zb
UiaYbhU U ]VYfUW] b XY fYb]bU m U ZcfaUW] b XY Ub[]chYbg]bU AA%
c eiY gY giaU U YZYWhc [YbYfU dUfU UiaYbhUf U fYUVgcfW] b
9WiUdcf]bU + "9IH + hiVi Uf m X]ga]bi]f U YlWfYW] b fYbU XY gcX]c'
,/)
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
HA GI
M]bi ]bU
L>? 6
H9?]bi ]bU
"
> i c XY d UgaU fYbU a ( a]b
MH9 w N (H9? H9
H> 6 ;H9 6
a]H9 "H9?H9 NH9 (H9?H9
6 MH9 w N
H9?H9 NH9
LUgU XY fYUVgcfW] b =UVgcfW] b fU "hY 6 WUf[U Z] hfUXU LUgU XY YlWfYW] b 6 a[ ( a]b% aac ( a]b c a=e ( a]b
"L>? w H9?g M w N
LUgU XY gYWfYW] b LUgU XY YlWfYW] b 6 LUgU XY YlWfYW] b ;Uf[U Z] hfUXU a[ ( a]b% aac ( a]b c a=e ( a]b
;g% LUgU XY XYdifUW] b XY gighUbW]Ug4 a]H9 % JY UW] b XY YlhfUWW] b XY H9 4 =JH>% Z i c d Ugaxh]Wc fYbU YZYWh]jc4 L>?3 hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf4 H% WcbWYbhfUW] b
d Ugaxh]WU4 H9 % xW]Xc dUfU Ua]bc ]d f]Wc4 H9?H9 % WcbWYbhfUW] b XY H9 UfhYf]U fYbU 4 J:>% Z i c gUb[i bYc fYbU 4 JH>% Z i c d Ugaxh]Wc fYbU 4 K% ibU gighUbW]U4
M% WcbWYbhfUW] b XY cf]bU4 N% WUiXU XY cf]bU4 NH9 % WcbWYbhfUW] b XY H9 jYbcgU fYbU '
,/
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
H9?]bi ]bU 6 a[ ( a ))
G9: YX YVZ
.)
P ZPRZ NPVtZ YT QX
FaR QR P RN VZVZN
L>? 6 +. a ( a]b
M]bi ]bU 6 +. a[ ( a
' :U UbWY dcg]h]jc HfcXiWW] b
N6 a ( a]b
QaPPVtZ QR P RN VZVZN e
+
)
K] U L>? X]ga]bimY fYdYbh]bUaYbhY Yb ib .) % cg f] cbYg
) + , -
C
,/+
6N V aX )/ JYUVgcfW] b m gYWfYW] b hiVi Uf fYbU
H9?H9 H9
6
HA GI
H9
H9?H9
,/,
HA 747 I Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
6 Y N NPV ZR QRX NPXN NYVRZ QR VZaXVZN P Z RX NPXN NYVRZ QR U B=% ?fUb[Yf BH% Xc ;Ufac BE% Yh U 3 ]dYfhYbg] b3 Z]g]c c[ U m
7VSR RZ R Xa % KY diYXYb UWYf Ug g][i]YbhYg [YbYfU ]nUW]cbYg Z]g]cdUhc c[ U' ;cadf H mg]c +3 +,2,% +) +'
C Y]b B<% KUbXg BE3 LfUbgdcfhY XY ifYU m dchYbW]U W b]Wc XY cg ifYUfzh]Wcg'
WcadUfUbXc Y UW UfUa]Ybhc XY ibU gighUbW]U Wcb Y UW UfUa]Ybhc XY
;iff Gd]b FYd fc mdYfhYbg +.3 ---% +) /'
]bi ]bU% Y YghxbXUf XY cfc dUfU aYX]f U L>?3
CbYddYf E9% Ckcb L % F]Y gYb K3 >]g]c c[ U ac YWi Uf XY Yei] ]Vf]c
" g] U hUgU XY UW UfUa]Ybhc XY U gighUbW]U Yg ][iU U U XY U
Xf]Wc' F =b[ B EYX ,0+3 ,-2% +) .'
]bi ]bU% U gighUbW]U gc c gY Z] hfU m bc gY fYUVgcfVY b] gY gYWfYhU4 Cc :3 cfacbU dUfUh]fc]XYU m fY[i UW] b XY hfUbgdcfhY XY WU W]c
"+ g] U hUgU XY XYdifUW] b XY ibU gighUbW]U Yg aYbcf eiY U hiVi Uf fYbU ' ;iff Gd]b FYd fc mdYfhYbg +/3 -).% +) 0' EU f]XYg
XYdifUW] b XY ]bi ]bU% U gighUbW]U XYVY UVYf g]Xc fYUVgcfV]XU N% ;UaUf[c KE% NYffYm >3 LfUbgdcfhY XY Ua]bcxW]Xcg Yb Y f] b'
dcf cg h Vi cg XY bYZfcbU4 m ", g] U hUgU XY XYdifUW] b XY ibU ;cadf H mg]c -3 ,/0% +) -'
gighUbW]U Yg aUmcf eiY U XY U ]bi ]bU% U gighUbW]U XYVY gYf EW;cfa]W B9% = ]gcb < 3 h Vi c WcbhcfbYUXc X]ghU ' ;cadf H mg]c
gYWfYhUXU dcf cg h Vi cg XY U bYZfcbU' 9 Wcbh]biUW] b gY .3-.% +) .'
YbiaYfUb Ug hUgUg XY Y ]a]bUW] b Udfcl]aUXUg XY U [ibUg XY EcY KE3 caYcghUg]g XY WU W]c Yb U gU iX m Yb U YbZYfaYXUX fYbU '
;cadf H mg]c /3 01 % +) /'
Ug gighUbW]Ug eiY bcfaU aYbhY aUbY Ub cg f] cbYg3
EcbhY <:' =lhfYa]XUX UgWYbXYbhY [fiYgU XY UgU XY Yb Y' ; ]b B 9a KcW
FYd fc 23 20-% +) -'
Fa NZPVN GN N QR NPXN NYVRZ YX YVZ F]Y gYb K% >f ]yf B% EUfd Yg <% Yh U 3 9WiUdcf]bUg Yb Y f] b3 XY
ac zWi Ug U aYX]WUaYbhcg' H mg]c JYj 1+3 +).% +))+'
? iWcgU )
HU aYf D?% KW bYfaUbb B3 ;cbhfc ]bhY[fUXc XY hfUbgdcfhY XY FU U c Uf[c
KcX]c )%2 XY U bYZfcbU' ; ]b B 9a KcW FYd fc )3 /0/% +) .'
; cfifc ', JY] m J>% = ]gcb < 3 L Vi c X]ghU XY aUa ZYfcg3 Z]g]c c[ U%
Z]g]cdUhc c[ U m UbUhca U ac YWi Uf' H mg]c JYj 1)3 +00% +)))'
HchUg]c +%) J]Y[ L% NU cb N3 <YgUffc c XY ]b ]V]XcfYg XY K?DL m K?DL+'
>cgZUhc +.%) <]UVYhc c[]U / 3 +)02% +) 1'
Jcgg]Yf :;% :U Yf E=% KhiXYf J93 LfUbgdcfhY XY gcX]c Yd]hY ]U m gi
Abi ]bU +.%)
Wcbhfc dcf U U XcghYfcbU3 U ]ghcf]U XY biYghfc Ybhcfbc ]bhYfbc
;fYUh]b]bU -)%) fYj]gUXU' H mg]c JYj 2.3 +20% +) .'
Jcm 9% 9 VUhU]bY EE% HUghcf Kc Yf FE3 JY[i UW] b m ZibW] b WY i Uf
]bhYfWU UXU XY WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf' ; ]b B 9a KcW FYd fc )3 ,).%
+) .'
:]V ]c[fUZ U KYY[a] Yf B;% =W ZY Xh B % D]Yg Y B;3 <YgUZ cg Yb U aYX]W] b XY U hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b
:]Y H3 dzdh]Xcg bUhf]ifzh]Wcg m fY[i UW] b bcfaU XY cg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg' ;cadf [ caYfi Uf3 ibU dYfgdYWh]jU XY UVcfUhcf]c W b]Wc' =bZYfaYXUX fYbU Wf b]WU
H mg]c 13 + % +) 1' UjUbnUXU +.31-% +) 1'
<Y d]fY =% ?U[bcb C:3 >ibW] b Z]g]c []WU XY WchfUbgdcfhUXcf FU C KhUfigW Yb c 93 =ZYWhcg VYbYZ]W]cgcg XY dchUg]c Y YjUXc3 Wcbhf]ViW] b XY
+; "FC;; Yb Wz i Ug bc dc Uf]nUXUg m Yd]hY ]cg hfUbgdcfhUXcfYg' cg WUbU Yg XY C VUgc UhYfU Yg fYbU Yg' ]dYfhYbg] b 0 3 ) .% +) 1'
;cadf H mg]c +.4 13 10 % +) 1' KhUfigW Yb c 93 JY[i UW] b XY hfUbgdcfhY Yb Y h Vi c WcbYWhcf m Y
>zfU] Y =% <]n]b =3 ;cbhfc WccfX]bUXc XY =FU; m FU % C 9LHUgU Yb Y WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf Wcfh]WU ' ;cadf H mg]c +3 .- % +) +'
WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf fYbU ' B 9a KcW FYd fc +03 +..-% +) /' >fcaaE% L cagcb K;% : Ubhn J;3 Yei] ]Vf]c [ caYfi chiVi Uf% fYhfcU ]aYbhUW] b
H]cbhY B% JcgYbh U J% ? bnY <% Cfi[ KE3 Mb]cbYg YghfYW Ug XY hiVi c[ caYfi Uf m caYcghUg]g XY U gU ' B 9a KcW FYd fc 23 ++0+%
h Vi c dfcl]aU m gig dfchY bUg XY WUbU ' 9fWc XY HZ i[Yfg -/23 100% +))1'
+) 1' OUb[ C% CYghYbVUia :3 9W UfUa]Ybhc gYWfYhcf XY h Vi c dfcl]aU 3 ib
?cbnU Yn N]WYbhY 9% KUYn >% Ecbncb ;E% 9g]fkUh Ua B% ?Ufj]b BD3 hfUbgdcfhY gcW]c XYgWi]XUXc XY U ZibW] b fYbU ' ; ]b B 9a KcW FYd fc ,3 +2 %
XY gcX]c XY YlhfYa]XUXYg UgWYbXYbhYg [fiYgUg Yb U dUhc[Yb]U XY U +) 1'
]dYfhYbg] b' H mg]c JYj 223 +,.% +) 2' OUb[ L% OY]bVUia K% OY]bghY]b 9E3 JY[i UW] b XY Yei] ]Vf]c
U B=% :fUbXg EO3 = g]ghYaU fYb]bU Ub[]chYbg]bU U XcghYfcbU3 [ caYfi chiVi Uf3 ZibW] b XY h Vi c dfcl]aU UWh]jUXU dcf Z i c' 9fWc XY
aYWUb]gacg fYbU Yg m caYcghUg]g W]fWi Uhcf]U' =b3 KY X]b <O% HZ i[Yfg -/23 /-,% +) 0'
?]YV]gW ? "YXg 3 L Y C]XbYm ª H mg]c c[m UbX HUh cd mg]c c[m% ,p QUaUnU ] G% Ag ]nUkU C% ]fc UaU <% >i ]hU L% K ]VUhU K3 hfUbgdcfhY XY
YX' FiYjU Qcf 3 JUjYb HfYgg% +)))' Y YWhfc ]hcg Yb Y WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf fYbU m gi fY[i UW] b dcf Y g]ghYaU
U B=% Xc ;Ufac BE% XU K] jU 99% OUb[ R% U E=3 ]dYfhYbg] b ]bXiW]XU fYb]bUUb[]chYbg]bU U XcghYfcbU' ; ]b KW] "DcbX ,,3 0.% +) 2'
dcf cVYg]XUX3 ]bhYfUWW] b XY cg aYWUb]gacg bYifc iacfU Yg m fYbU Yg'
;]fW JYg /3 22 % +) .'
,/-
KeTWhV Wb W aZ wf T fcTyb % jjj ba a WbVgeTaf Tgbe Vb`
64CiGH B ) 0
HA GI
6[ PR NPVq d QVXaPVq QR [ V N2 ERTaXNPVq QR XN
[ Y[XN VQNQ QRX Xo]aVQ[ Rc NPRXaXN d XN P[ PR NPVq QR [QV[
GTeT dh Tf Vw h Tf W Vh ecb YhaV ba a Vbee VgT` ag W U a W be aT VbaV ageTWT f a VT`U bf `cbegTag f a Tf gTfTf W
fgTe UTyTWTf a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te Vba haT VbaV ageTV za kVe V za W fb hgbf Vb`b fbW b l cbgTf b <fgT VTcTV WTW cTeT
e Tg iT` ag VbafgTag W Vgeb gbf bfVbaV ageTV za gbgT W e Zh Te T kVe V za W TZhT aW c aW ag ` ag W T kVe V za W
fb hgbf a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l cbe b gTagb T bf`b Te WTW fb hgbf f a V fTe T cTeT T fhc ei i aV T fc V T ` ag VhTaWb T
gT`U wa W U e Zh Tef Vba ce V f za cTeT i gTe dh Tf Vw h Tf aZ fgT W xdh Wbf f ` gTWT
f VbageT ZTa b f [ aV[ a CT bf`b Te WTW fgt W g e` aTWT cbe
T VTag WTW W fb hgb ce aV cT ` ag V beheb W fbW b" W i W WT
;BE BA4F 4AG 7 HEhG 64F 6BAGEB 4A 4
cbe ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te Gbe gTagb a ZeTa
6BA68AGE46 A 78 4 BE A4
` W WT T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l T VbaV ageTV za
W V beheb W fbW b fgta e Zh TWTf cbe T VTag WTW W TZhT < Vh ecb g a ha cbW ebfb f fg `T W e gebT ` agTV za cTeT e Zh Te
kgeTV h Te < TZhT VbecbeT gbgT fgt Vbageb TWT cbe )" T T bf`b Te WTW c Tf`tg VT l T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b dh bc eT
aZ fgT W xdh Wbf dh fgt e Zh TWT cbe YTVgbe f dh T g eTaWb T kVe V za e aT W TZhT aW c aW ag ` ag W T gTfT
W g e` aTa T f W3 l " T kVe V za e aT W TZhT dh fgt W kVe V za W fb hgbf La Y Vgbe ce aV cT W fgT e gebT ` agTV za
Vbageb TWT cbe ` g c f YTVgbe f dh aY hl a a T Y geTV za f[be`baT Tag W hewg VT 8;?" gT`U wa T`TWb iTfbce f aT :hTaWb
Z b` eh Te l T e TUfbeV za ghUh Te T bf`b Te WTW W bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f Th` agT cbe aV `T W b
<a fg VTcxgh b W fVhg `bf b f Zh ag 2 )" ` VTa f`bf abe`T f W V e bf fb hgbf a bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f f ih i a
dh [TV a dh bf e yba f ` a a kV fb W TZhT T W `Tf TWb VbaV ageTWbf" T Z taWh T c gh gTe T cbfg e be f Ve gT `tf
kVe gTe haT be aT W h WT3 " ` VTa f`bf dh [TV a dh bf 8;? b dh Th` agT T c e` TU WTW W bf g Uh bf W fgT f l bf
e yba f Vbaf ei a TZhT T kVe gTe haT be aT VbaV ageTWT3 +" VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f T TZhT Vb`b f W fVe U a
` VTa f`bf W e gebT ` agTV za e aT dh Vbageb Ta T :Tc gh b 0 <fg ` VTa f`b Th` agT T e TUfbeV za W TZhT
bf`b Te WTW l T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b a xdh Wb l W f` ahl ib h` a W be aT c eb ab T g eT
kgeTV h Te3 l ," ` VTa f`bf W f W l Tc g gb cbe fT dh abgTU ` ag T gTfT W kVe V za e aT W bf fb hgbf
W g e` aTa T aZ fgT W TZhT l fT dh gT`U wa TlhWTa T :hTaWb [Tl ha kV fb W TZhT a Vh ecb l f e WhV T
Vbageb Te ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te T bf`b Te WTW l bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te T f Ve V za W 8;? cbe
T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b cTeg W T [ czY f f cbfg e be W f` ahl b dh e WhV T
c e` TU WTW W g Uh b W fgT l bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f T
TZhT b dh [TV dh f kVe g a `Tlbe f VTag WTW f W
E jBA8F 8J6E8GB 8J68FB 78 4:H4
be aT `tf W h WT Gbe gTagb T gTfT W f Ve V za W 8;?
9BE 4A7B BE A4 7 H 74
W g e` aT a ZeTa ` W WT f e yza kVe gT be aT W h WT b
Cbf e yba f abe`T f g a a haT abe` VTcTV WTW cTeT iTe Te VbaV ageTWT
Tf cebcbeV ba f e Tg iTf W fb hgbf l TZhT a T be aT a
e fch fgT T W i efbf W fTYxbf :hTaWb [Tl ha kV fb W TZhT a
864A F BF E8A4 8F C4E4 8J6E8G4E
Vh ecb l T bf`b Te WTW W bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f f e WhV bf
BE A4 7 H 74
e yba f ch W a kVe gTe be aT Vba haT bf`b Te WTW gTa UT]T
Vb`b -( `Ff` C haT VbaV ageTV za dh f fb b T e W Wbe W :hTaWb [Tl ha ZeTa kV fb W TZhT a Vh ecb e yza
haT f kgT cTeg W T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te abe`T ch W kVe gTe [TfgT ( C WxT W be aT W h WT Vba haT
Gbe VbageTe b VhTaWb [Tl ha WwY V g W TZhT a Vh ecb l T VbaV ageTV za gTa UT]T Vb`b -( `Ff` C < e yza e T mT
bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f T gT bf e yba f ch W a fgT `ce f baTag [TmTyT T Vbag ahTe e TUfbeU aWb
kVe gTe be aT `hl VbaV ageTWT Vba haT bf`b Te WTW W ) (( T fb hgbf f a e TUfbeU e ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W TZhT a Tf
),(( `Ff` C ZhT ` ag `cbegTag bf e yba f ch W a cTeg f W fgT f W T a YebaT aV h Wb g Uh b W fgT gTeWxb l
kVe gTe ha ZeTa ib h` a W be aT W h WT b ha ib h` a c dh yb bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f
+.-
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
G Tf`T
bf`b Te WTW
:beg mT
(
.
GN N QR SXa [ QR [ V N
, ,(( /(
,(( ,((
YX YV
ET:
DwWh T
? F ET:
(
YB Y YV
RcP RPVq
+..
6N o aX[ )0 :baV ageTV za l W hV za W be aT
HA GI
W ( - gebf cbe VTWT geb W TZhT W `Te b dh kc VT T etc WT
Vh ecb T geTiwf W iTe Tf ehgTf aV h Wbf bf ch `ba f cbe
W f[ WeTgTV za dh f cebWhV a Tf ixVg `Tf W aThYeTZ bf dh
iTcbeTV za a Te fc eTWb geTVgb ZTfgeb ag fg aT cbe Tf U U a TZhT W `Te J a `UTeZb eTgza ThfgeT Tab W T ixVg `T W
[ V f Tc cbe iTcbeTV za l geTafc eTV za l bf e yba f cbe T ha aThYeTZ b cbWexT U U e TZhT W `Te Vba `cha WTW
kVe V za W be aT J e dh e T aZ fgT W xdh Wbf cTeT ZhT Te
fgT cweW WT c eb T VTcTV WTW W bf e yba f cTeT Ybe`Te ha
: NbRQNQ R RPoSVPN QR XN [ V N
c dh yb ib h` a W be aT VbaV ageTWT ` a ` mT T aZ fgT W
xdh Wbf a V fTe T cTeT `Tag a e T [b` bfgTf f haT YhaV za Fe aT >eTi WTW fc VxY VT f hg mT T ` ahWb a agbeabf V xa Vbf
dh f fc V T ` ag `cbegTag VhTaWb [Tl fVTf m W TZhT cTeT cebcbeV baTe haT fg `TV za etc WT W T VbaV ageTV za W
fb hgbf a T be aT :hTagb `tf VbaV ageTWT fgw T be aT `Tlbe f et
:hTaWb [Tl ha WwY V g W TZhT a Vh ecb bf e yba f
T ZeTi WTW fc VxY VT W T be aT <a T `TlbexT W bf VTfbf T
Ybe`Ta be aT VbaV ageTWT T Vbag ahTe kVe gTaWb fb hgbf
ZeTi WTW fc VxY VT W T be aT Th` agT a T ` ag Vba Th` agb
` ageTf Th` agTa T e TUfbeV za W TZhT l W f` ahl a
W T bf`b Te WTW W T be aT 9VTa N )0 " CT ZeTi WTW fc VxY VT W
ib h` a W be aT < e yza [h`Tab ch W cebWhV e haT
T be aT f a `UTeZb f haT ` W WT W c fb W bf fb hgbf a ha
VbaV ageTV za `tk `T W be aT W ) (( T ),(( `Ff` C VhTgeb ib h` a WTWb W be aT l cbe b gTagb fgt W g e` aTWT cbe
T V aVb i V f T bf`b Te WTW W c Tf`T a ` eb l gT`Tyb W Tf `b wVh Tf W fb hgb Gbe VbageTe b T
8 Zhabf Ta `T f W W f egb Vb`b eTgza ThfgeT Tab bf`b Te WTW fgt W g e` aTWT fb b cbe a ` eb W `b wVh Tf W
ch W a VbaV ageTe T be aT [TfgT )( ((( `Ff` C <fgT fb hgb a ha ib h` a WTWb
[TU WTW c e` g dh eTgza fbUe i iT a W f egb f a CT ZeTi WTW fc VxY VT W T be aT f kce fT Z a eT ` ag a
U U e TZhT3 J ch W bUg a e fhY V ag TZhT T geTiwf W bf ZeT`bf cbe ` geb Z ` " l a bf f e f [h`Tabf abe`T ` ag
T ` agbf aZ e Wbf l TZhT cebWhV WT a Vh ecb cbe iTexT W ) (( T ) ( 0 Z ` Th` agTaWb a ( (() cbe VTWT +- T ,(
`Ff` C W Th` agb W T bf`b Te WTW W T be aT <fgT e TV za
` gTUb f`b W bf T ` agbf Cbf Ta `T f TWTcgTWbf T
age T ZeTi WTW fc VxY VT l T bf`b Te WTW f T g eT VhTaWb [Tl
agbeabf W TZhT Wh V fh a g a e haT VTcTV WTW `xa `T
VTag WTW f `cbegTag f W `b wVh Tf ZeTaW f a T be aT Vb`b
cTeT VbaV ageTe T be aT Cbf VTfgbe f cbe ] `c b ch W a
Z hVbfT ` W bf W eTW bVbageTfg hg mTWbf Vba Y a f W TZazfg Vbf b
VbaV ageTe T be aT fb b T habf -(( `Ff` C
T Zhabf Tag U zg Vbf <a fgbf VTfbf Tf ` W V ba f W T ZeTi WTW
fc VxY VT W T be aT ch W a fhZ e e YT fT` ag haT be aT `hl
I[XaYR QR [ V N [OXVTN [ V[ VbaV ageTWT T c fTe W haT bf`b T WTW he aTe T abe`T
+./
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
; ZTWb TfV aW ag ( (
CT bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb ag efg V T a VTf gbWTf Tf cTeg f W
` `Ueb
Vh ecb f W Tcebk `TWT` ag +(( `Ff` C dh f f ` Te T T
8fV aW ag Zeh fb ( ( (
bf`b Te WTW c Tf`tg VT :b`b f W fVhg z a:Tc gh b - bf
` `Ueb
TVg i WTW bf`b Te Vbee Z WT dh kc VT T TgeTVV za
K Uh b W fgT 8;? ( (
ag e`b Vh Te f W Tcebk `TWT` ag 0 `Ff` C " CT
bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb ag efg V T a T `wWh T W e yza f I Vb VV za Vbeg VT 8;? ( (
ghU gb
`hV[b `Tlbe l ch W Th` agTe cebZe f iT` ag [TfgT
Tcebk `TWT` ag ) (( T ),(( `Ff` C a T chagT cw i VT W T D Wh Te ag e be 8;? ( 8;?
VbaWhVgb Vb Vgbe
`wWh T <fgb f Za Y VT dh ag efg V b ` Wh Te e aT [T
TVh`h TWb fb hgbf a ZeTa kV fb W TZhT LaT i m dh f 8;? [be`baT Tag W hewg VT3 ET: V beheb W fbW b3 ( a i `xa `b
W geTafcbeg TVg ib b c e` TU WTW3 a i `bW eTWb W
T VTamT T T gT VbaV ageTV za W fb hgbf a T `wWh T f
geTafcbeg TVg ib b c e` TU WTW3 T gb a i W geTafcbeg TVg ib
`Tag a ` W Tag ha Y h]b dh UeTWb W ageTWT l fT WT W b c e` TU WTW3 8;? T 8;? Th` agT T c e` TU WTW T TZhT b
fb hgbf l TZhT a T `wWh T he T
+.0
6N o aX[ )0 :baV ageTV za l W hV za W be aT
ag efg V b ` Wh Te <k fg V egT e TUfbeV za cTf iT W < cTfb , f Y h]b TW V baT W xdh Wb [TV T TfT W
V beheb W fbW b W T eT`T TfV aW ag W ZTWT W TfT ? a W fW g Uh b cebk `T b dh [TV dh xdh Wb
W ? a dh gT`U wa f f aV T ` ag `c e` TU T [ c ebf`zg Vb Ybe`TWb ce i T` ag a T eT`T W fV aW ag
TZhT b dh f fh`T T T T gT VbaV ageTV za W fb hgbf Y hlT [TV T T eT`T TfV aW ag LaT i m dh fg xdh Wb fgt
W ag efg V b ` Wh Te e aT a T eT`T TfV aW ag f Ub`U Ta ba f TW V baT f T
CT eT`T W fV aW ag W TfT W ? a a VbageTfg Vba T ag efg V b l TZhT c e`Ta V a xdh Wb ghUh Te [TfgT
HA GI
eT`T TfV aW ag f `hl c e` TU T TZhT l T bf`b Te WTW W dh f fgTU V ha ZeTW ag bf`zg Vb W (( `Ff` C l T
xdh Wb ghUh Te f ZhT T etc WT` ag T T bf`b Te WTW ` Wh Te bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb ag efg V T Th` agT T -(( `Ff` C
e aT Gbe b gTagb TZhT f W YhaW W fW T eT`T W fV aW ag cTfb -" Ch Zb haT i m `tf xdh Wb W T eT`T
W TfT W ? a [TV T ag efg V b l T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb W fV aW ag T VTamT dh Ue b Vba xdh Wb ag efg V T
ghUh Te Th` agT ZeTWhT ` ag T ` W WT dh Y hl [TV T T chagT ` Wh Te [ c ebf`zg Vb cTfb ." l T ` W WT dh xdh Wb
W TfT W ? a ghUh Te [ c ebf`zg Vb W T eT`T W fV aW ag W TfT W
? a Y hl [TV T T eT`T TfV aW ag f Ub`U T
CN [ V b[XaP NQ[ R XN PNa N QRX V R VPV[ YRQaXN R NX Vbag ahT` ag `tf fb hgb Yh eT W bf g Uh bf l f W cbf gT
UV R [ Yq VP[ K a aWb a Vh agT fgTf VTeTVg exfg VTf W a ag efg V b ` Wh Te
TfT W ? a TaT V `bf T[beT Vz`b T `wWh T e aT f <fgbf cTfbf f e c g a haT l bgeT i m Vba Y Vgb a gb W
ih i [ c ebf`zg VT M W b 1%)" Ge ` eb fhcbaZT dh TZe ZTe `tf l `tf fb hgb T T `wWh T a kV fb W TZhT :ba
TfT W ? a fgt aT W xdh Wb Vba haT VbaV ageTV za W fhY V ag g `cb <fg cebV fb TgeTcT ZeTWhT ` ag bf
+(( `Ff` C T ` f`T dh fT W g Uh b cebk `T 9VTa N fb hgbf a T `wWh T l `h g c VT ZeTW ag W
)0 + cTfb )" 8 Vbag ahTV za T Ub`UT W ba f TVg iT W VbaV ageTV za fgTU V Wb cbe Ub`U b TVg ib W ba f
kge ` WTW TfV aW ag Zeh fT a TfT W ? a e WhV T Yh eT W Zeh fb UhV TfV aW ag W ? a Y aT ` ag
VbaV ageTV za W ageb W g Uh b l Th` agT T VbaV ageTV za iTaWb T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb ag efg V T T ) (( T ),((
ag efg V T 3 <fgT Ub`UT fgTU V ha ZeTW ag W `Ff` C Vb`b f `h fgeT a cTfb /
VbaV ageTV za W (( `Ff` C age xdh Wb ghUh Te l Gbe b gTagb T e TUfbeV za e c g g iT W V beheb W
xdh Wb ag efg V T 9VTa N )0 + cTfb " < x` g W fbW b cbe TfT TfV aW ag Zeh fT W ? a l Y h]b
ZeTW ag f W Tcebk `TWT` ag (( `Ff` C cbedh T Vbag ahb W V beheb W fbW b ah ib W fW g Uh b
W Yhf za cTeTV h Te W ba f W e Ze fb T g Uh b Y aT ` ag cebk `T T TfT W ? a f T`T T `h g c VTWbe W
VbageTee fgT geTafcbeg W ba f Yh eT W T hm VhTaWb f VbageTVbee ag < V beheb W fbW b e TUfbeU Wb W TfT
T VTamT ZeTW ag W VbaV ageTV za W (( `Ff` C TfV aW ag W ? a f f Zh TZe ZTaWb T V beheb W
< cTfb + f dh Y h Wb ghUh Te a eT`T W fV aW ag W fbW b e V wa ZTWb `h g c VTaWb Tfx fh VbaV ageTV za
UhV W ? a l xdh Wb ag efg V T T VTamT etc WT` ag a ag efg V b ` Wh Te
dh Ue b bf`zg Vb W U Wb T T zf`bf f W TZhT dh fT W T
eT`T W fV aW ag CT bf`b Te WTW ag efg V T f `Tag a a ,((
C4C8 78 Gl5H B 7 FG4 K 78 BF
`Ff` C W U Wb T geTafcbeg Vbag ahb W ba f Yh eT W TfT
6BA7H6GBF 78 E86B: 74 8A 4 BE A4
TfV aW ag Zeh fT W ? a 8fx cbe fx fb b geTafcbeg TVg ib
8J6E8G474 6BA68AGE474
W V beheb W fbW b Yh eT W T eT`T TfV aW ag Zeh fT f VTcTm
W fgTU V e fb b ha ZeTW ag W VbaV ageTV za W (( `Ff` :hTaWb xdh Wb ghUh Te fT W TfT W ? a l Y hl [TV T
C dh f `hV[b ` abe dh T VTamTWb g Uh b Vbagbea TWb W fgT a T Vbeg mT e aT xdh Wb f
cbe f fg `T `h g c VTWbe W VbageTVbee ag W hl Vba haT bf`b Te WTW W fz b T e W Wbe W )(( T
+(( +(( +(( +(( ,(( (( ,(( ,(( (( ,(( ,(( ,((
+(( +(( +(( +(( ,(( (( ,(( ,(( (( ,(( ,(( ,((
9VTa N )0 + J fg `T `h g c VTWbe a VbageTVbee ag a TfT W ? a cTeT cebWhV e haT `wWh T e aT [ c ebf`zg VT Cbf iT be f ah`we Vbf fgta a
` bf`b f cbe geb"
+.1
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
ET: ? F he T ? F ET:
4 HE84 6BAGE 5HK8 4 AG8EFG 6 B
+((
E8A4 87H 4E ; C8EBF G 6B K 4 4
)(( +((
+(( 9BE 46 A 78 BE A4 6BA68AGE474
ET:
CT he T Vbage Uhl T e W Wbe W ,( T -( W T
:beg mT
bf`b Te WTW -(( T .(( `Ff` C" W ag efg V b ` Wh Te
e aT VhTaWb e yza fgt Ybe`TaWb haT be aT W `tk `T
VbaV ageTV za 8 W Y e aV T W V beheb W fbW b T he T f
e TUfbeU cTf iT` ag W g Uh b :hTaWb [Tl ha WwY V g W
.(( .(( .(( .((
TZhT l T VbaV ageTV za fTaZhxa T W 8;? f T gT ZeTaW f
ET: VTag WTW f W he T f e TUfbeU a cTf iT` ag W fW bf
? F
DwWh T
? F
ET: VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f ` Wh Te f ag eabf [TV T ag efg V b
Le T < ` VTa f`b W e TUfbeV za W he T a T `wWh T e aT
) (( ) (( ) (( ) (( f f Zh ag 8 ` W WT dh TZhT Y hl [TV T Tee UT cbe
TfT TfV aW ag W ? a l [TV T bf g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f W fgT
9VTa N )0 , =be`TV za W haT be aT VbaV ageTWT VhTaWb bf a i f W [be`baT l Vbeg VT f e TUfbeU cbVT he T cbedh fgbf f Z` agbf
Tag W hewg VT 8;?" fba T gbf K aZT a Vh agT dh xdh Wb dh fT W TfT W fba `c e` TU f T T he T i eGNOXN )0 (" <a ce f aV T W
? a f W hl c eb f VbaV ageT T ` W WT dh f TUfbeU TZhT W bf g Uh bf T gTf VbaV ageTV ba f W 8;? TZhT f e TUfbeU
W fgT f l bf g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f :ba a i f T gbf W 8;? T bf`b Te WTW W T
etc WT` ag W fW g Uh b Vb Vgbe Vbeg VT l T
be aT f Tcebk `TWT` ag T ` f`T dh T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb ag efg V T
` Wh Te e aT a T cTc T dh f W Tcebk `TWT` ag ) (( `Ff` C Cbf
VbaV ageTV za W he T Th` agT etc WT` ag cbedh T he T
iT be f ah`we Vbf fgta a ` bf`b f cbe geb" ab f `hl c e` TU a fgT cTeg W g Uh b
8 ` W WT dh xdh Wb ghUh Te Y hl [TV T bf VbaWhVgbf
Vb Vgbe f ` Wh Te f ag eabf g a hZTe T a `tf e TUfbeV za
),( `Ff` C 9VTa N )0 , " < g Uh b W fgT g `ceTab W hl W TZhT b dh e fh gT a haT VbaV ageTV za T a `Tlbe W he T
T a `tf xdh Wb ghUh Te cbedh fg f Z` agb Vb`b a xdh Wb <fgT T gT VbaV ageTV za W he T a xdh Wb ghUh Te
TfT TfV aW ag W ? a geTafcbegT TVg iT` ag V beheb W W VbaWhVgb Vb Vgbe ` Wh Te ag eab [TV dh T he T f
fbW b Yh eT W g Uh b c eb f e Tg iT` ag `c e` TU T W YhaWT Yh eT W g Uh b [TV T xdh Wb ag efg V T e aT <fgT
TZhT W Yhf za f i YTV gTWT a ZeTa ` W WT cbegeTafcbegTWbe f W
8 ` W WT dh xdh Wb Y hl [TV T g Uh b Vb Vgbe Vbeg VT he T LK%8) l LK%8+ <fgbf geTafcbegTWbe f W he T fba TVg iTWbf
T VTag WTW W TZhT e TUfbeU WT W c aW YhaWT` agT ` ag W cbe 8;? b dh Th` agT T a `tf geTafcbeg W he T Yh eT W
T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W 8;? <a Thf aV T W 8;? fg VbaWhVgb Vb Vgbe ` Wh Te ag eab VhTaWb bf a i f W 8;?
f Z` agb f VTf `c e` TU T TZhT l ab e TUfbeU TZhT c eb fgta iTWbf < `bi ` agb f `h gta b W TZhT l he T Yh eT W
Vbag a T e TUfbeU aWb fb hgbf l W hl T a `tf T be aT :hTaWb bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f ` Wh Te f ag eabf `Tag a haT T gT
[Tl haT T gT VbaV ageTV za W 8;? g Uh b Vb Vgbe Vbeg VT f VbaV ageTV za W he T a xdh Wb ghUh Te l Y aT ` ag a T
ih i `hl c e` TU T TZhT cbe b dh T[beT f e TUfbeU a be aT Thadh T he T f e TUfbeU
ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W TZhT W g Uh b T ag efg V b W T Vbeg mT < cTc YhaWT` agT W T he T a T Vbage UhV za T T VTcTV WTW
WbaW f TeeTfgeTWT cbe bf VTc Te f c e ghUh Te f dh Y hl a W VbaV ageTV za W be aT f i W aV T cbe [ V[b W dh Tf
etc WT` ag Gbedh f e TUfbeU a ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W TZhT c efbaTf dh aZ e a haT W gT T gT a cebg xaTf dh cebWhV
a T Vbeg mT a hZTe W a T `wWh T e aT ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W he T Vb`b cebWhVgb W W f V[b a gebZ aTWb
ch W a VbaV ageTe fh be aT `hV[b ` ]be dh Tf c efbaTf VhlT
fgb TlhWT T ce f eiTe T T gT bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb ag efg V T aZ fgT W cebg xaTf l cebWhVV za W he T fgTa UT]bf CT W fahge V za
` Wh Te f TfbV T Vba haT VbaV ageTV za UT]T W he T a ag efg V b ` Wh Te
8 ` W WT dh xdh Wb ghUh Te Y hl T b TeZb W bf l ha W g e beb Vbaf W eTU W T VTcTV WTW W VbaV ageTV za W be aT
VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f ` Wh Te f [Tl `tf e TUfbeV za W
TZhT W xdh Wb ghUh Te T ag efg V b c eb T VTag WTW gbgT W N RPV PaXNPVq QR a RN QRX P[ QaP [ P[XRP [ NX N N
TZhT f e Tg iT` ag c dh yT a Vb`cTeTV za Vba T dh f QR ;R XR P[ VOadR N XN YnQaXN R NX UV R [ Yq VPN
TZe ZT T ag efg V b Vbeg VT < TZhT e TUfbeU WT f LaT c efbaT fTaT Z a eT ` ag kVe gT T e W Wbe W ( T
geTafcbegTWT cbe bf iTfbf e Vgbf T T fTaZe i abfT :hTaWb .( W T VTeZT Y geTWT W he T W c aW aWb W Y h]b W be aT l
[Tl a i f T gbf W 8;? bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f f ih i a fgTWb W [ WeTgTV za <a Z a eT T gTfT W kVe V za W he T
c e` TU f T TZhT cbe b dh xdh Wb T Y aT W bf fgt W g e` aTWT ce aV cT ` ag cbe b f Zh ag 2 )"
VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f g a f aV T ` ag T ` f`T VbaV ageTV za W he T a c Tf`T3 " gTfT W Y geTV za
bf`b Te WTW dh xdh Wb ag efg V T W T `wWh T e aT Z b` eh Te K=>"3 l +" e TUfbeV za W he T ghUh Te e aT <a
T e W Wbe W ) (( `Ff` C i e9VTa N )0 + " Gbe b gTagb T cTV ag f Vba aY e` WTW e aT dh g a a ZeTaW f e WhVV ba f
e TUfbeU e gTagT TZhT Vb`b f T cbf U bf e yba f Ybe`Ta a T K=> T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W he T Th` agT
be aT T gT` ag VbaV ageTWT kVe gTaWb VTag WTW f abgTU ` ag W ib i aWb T VTeZT W he T Y geTWT l T gTfT W
abe`T f W fb hgbf a T be aT ` ageTf TZe ZTa TZhT T kVe V za W he T T a i abe`T ZhT T T gTfT W cebWhVV za W
xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l Vb`c afTa bf WwY V gf W TZhT VbecbeT he T" T c fTe W T e WhVV za W T K=>
+/(
6N o aX[ )0 :baV ageTV za l W hV za W be aT
HA GI
)((
-( e fgTag <fgT e V eVh TV za W he T cebcbeV baT ha ` VTa f`b
e fgTag
+( TW V baT cTeT Ybe`Te haT `wWh T e aT [ c ebf`zg VT ; U Wb T
+(
? kg e be F dh T he T f hab W bf cebWhVgbf W W f V[b `tf TUhaWTag f
`wWh T )- dh W U a f e kVe gTWbf cbe bf e yba f fg ` VTa f`b cTeT
Le T
VbaV ageTe T he T Tag f W dh f kVe g f f aV T cTeT T
ag eab
Vbab`xT W bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f VhTaWb [Tl fVTf m W TZhT
`wWh T +(( +((
+/)
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
8hadh f ag eVT`U Ta ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W xdh Wb l fb hgb T f Vbaf eiT T T gT VbaV ageTV za W fb hgbf fgTU V WT cbe
geTiwf W bf iTfbf e Vgbf [Tl cbVT W hV za a gT W T VbaV ageTV za ` VTa f`b W VbageTVbee ag
W xdh Wb ag efg V T a VTWT a i W T `wWh T e aT W U Wb T T
Ybe`T W L W bf VTc Te f W bf iTfbf e Vgbf dh TVg Ta Vb`b 8X NaYR [ QRX SXa [ N Tao R[ YRQaXN RQaPR XN PN NPVQNQ QR
ag eVT`U TWbe f a VbageTVbee ag Gbe b gTagb P[ PR NPVq QR [ V N : egbf iTfbW TgTWbe f ch W a Th` agTe
bf iTfT e VgT ab Ve Ta T [ c ebf`b Te WTW ` Wh Te abgTU ` ag Y h]b fTaZhxa b W T `wWh T e aT ` aTaWb
c eb i gTa dh f W f c Tfx T Zhabf W bf fb hgbf W T `wWh T e aT l e WhV aWb T
CT fgehVgheT a Ybe`T W L W bf iTfbf ` a ` mT T VTcTV WTW `tk `T W VbaV ageTV za W be aT Cbf ZeTaW f
cweW WT W fb hgb W ag efg V b c eb ab i gT Y h]b `Tf ib Th` agbf W T ce f za Teg e T gT`U wa ch W a Th` agTe Y h]b
W xdh Wb l fb hgbf [TV T T fTaZe T geTiwf W Tf ce f ba f fTaZhxa b W T `wWh T e aT a `Tlbe ` W WT dh a bgeTf
Vb b W f bf`zg VTf [ Webfgtg VTf [TU ghT f dh YTibe V a T e Z ba f W e yza l g aW a T TiTe ag efg V b [ c ebf`zg Vb
e TUfbeV za a fgbf VTc Te f <a VbaW V ba f W fgTWb e WhV aWb Tfx T VTcTV WTW W VbaV ageTV za W be aT :b`b f
fgTV baTe b bf iTfbf e Vgbf iTa fb b T VTag WTW W fb hgb W fVhg z Tag e be` ag T VTcTV WTW `tk `T W VbaV ageTV za
l TZhT dh f TUfbeU W bf g Uh bf ` Wh Te f l W e yza fgt W g e` aTWT ab fb b cbe ai W 8;? f ab
gT`U wa cbe T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb ag efg V T W T `wWh T
e aT aV hfb Vba a i f `tk `bf W 8;? T VTcTV WTW W
IN N RP N R VPV[
`Ff` C `Ff` C
VbaV ageTV za W be aT f e WhV et f Y h]b fTaZhxa b ` Wh Te
Th` agT b fhY V ag Vb`b cTeT e WhV e T [ c ebf`b Te WTW a
+(( +-( +(( T `wWh T e aT
JhfgTaV T W fb hgT
? F .(( JhfgTaV T W fb hgT
0((
0((
1(( Cbf VT`U bf a T bf`b Te WTW l ib h` a W xdh Wb ghUh Te T
JhfgTaV T W fb hgT
-` ( `
) ((
; h e f Z` agb
; fgT gTeWxb
1((
D Wh Te
:beg VT
B Y[XN VQNQ YB Y
.((
0`
+/
6N o aX[ )0 :baV ageTV za l W hV za W be aT
HA GI
ZhT T T W xdh Wb ag efg V T V eVhaWTag dh fW f Z` agbf
Tcebk `TWT` ag ) (( `Ff` C VhTaWb T VbaV ageTV za
fTaZhxa T W 8;? f T gT 6[ QaP [ P[XRP [ R YRQaXN R V R [ CT VbaV ageTV za W
:hTaWb f Ybe`T be aT W h WT Vb`b e fh gTWb W VbaV ageTV ba f xdh Wb a bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f ` Wh Te f ag eabf gT`U wa
UT]Tf W 8;? T bf`b Te WTW ag efg V T ` Wh Te f ` abe W ) (( W c aW W b f Zh ag 2 )" 8;?3 l " T bf`b Te WTW W
`Ff` C3 a Vbaf Vh aV T T bf`b Te WTW W Y h Wb ghUh Te W TfT ag efg V b ` Wh Te V eVhaWTag fgTU V WT cbe ` VTa f`b W
W fV aW ag gT`U wa f ih i ` abf VbaV ageTWT <fgT W f` ahV za VbageTVbee ag <a ce f aV T W ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W 8;?
a T VbaV ageTV za f W U a cTeg T [ V[b W dh f TUfbeU fgbf VbaWhVgbf fba `hl c e` TU f T TZhT l TZhT f
` abf he T a ag efg V b ` Wh Te W fW bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f W YhaW W fW g Uh b [TV T xdh Wb ag efg V T [TfgT dh f
VhTaWb bf a i f W 8;? fba UT]bf l e yza fgt Ybe`TaWb ha ZeTa T VTamT dh Ue b bf`zg Vb l xdh Wb ghUh Te g a
ib h` a W be aT W h WT Tcebk `TWT` ag T ` f`T VbaV ageTV za dh ag efg V b
` Wh Te e aT ) (( ),(( `Ff` C" Gbe b gTagb f cebWhV ha
5aPXR N PR QR R QRXTNQ[ QR ;R XR CT W ZTWT eT`T TfV aW ag c dh yb ib h` a W be aT VbaV ageTWT VhTaWb bf a i fW
f f aV T ` ag `c e` TU T TZhT c eb e TUfbeU T Zb W 8;? fba T gbf ; U Wb T dh T e TUfbeV za W TZhT Th` agT T
V beheb W fbW b ; U Wb T T T gT VbaV ageTV za W V beheb W VbaV ageTV za W he T a xdh Wb ghUh Te l T dh bf VbaWhVgbf
fbW b a xdh Wb ghUh Te Vb`b e fh gTWb W T ` aTV za W Vb Vgbe f ` Wh Te f ag eabf g a a geTafcbegTWbe f W he T
TZhT W TfT W fV aW ag W ? a k fg V egT W Yhf za cTf iT fc VxY Vbf dh YTV gTa abe` ` ag T W Yhf za ZeTa cTeg W
W V beheb W fbW b W fW T eT`T TfV aW ag W ZTWT [TV T T he T T gT` ag VbaV ageTWT a bf VbaWhVgbf f W YhaW W fW
ag efg V b ` Wh Te Gbe b gTagb xdh Wb ghUh Te f ih i `tf T hm ghUh Te [TV T ag efg V b ` Wh Te <fgT TUfbeV za W he T
W h Wb T ` W WT dh V beheb W fbW b f W YhaW Yh eT W a T `wWh T e aT Vbage Uhl T T T gT bf`b Te WTW W ag efg V b
g Uh b l TZhT c e`Ta V a g Uh b ` Wh Te l T T gT VTcTV WTW W VbaV ageTV za W e yza
GTeg W T he T TUfbeU WT a ag efg V b ` Wh Te
W fW bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f gT`U wa f W YhaW [TV T MTe bf chagbf `cbegTag f T Vbaf W eTe ch W a ab
T eT`T TfV aW ag W ib i aWb Tfx T he T T f fg `T e fh gTe bUi bf a fgT W fVhf za Ge ` eb Thadh V beheb
ghUh Te l TlhWTaWb T ce i a e fh ` aTV za W T W fbW b f hab W bf ce aV cT f fb hgbf dh Vbage Uhl a T
`wWh T e aT <fgTe V V T] W he T f ha ` VTa f`b T [ c ebf`b Te WTW W ag efg V b ` Wh Te e yza ch W
TW V baT dh Vbage Uhl T T `wWh T e aT [ c ebf`zg VT VhTaWb f T a V fTe b kVe gT haT be aT `hl VbaV ageTWT
dh Vbag a cbVb V beheb W fbW b CT [ c ebf`b Te WTW W
5aPXR N PR QR R T aR [ QR ;R XR CT cTeg Zeh fT W TfT T be aT a fgTf V eVhafgTaV Tf f W U T Tf T gTf
TfV aW ag W ? a gT`U wa f cetVg VT` ag `c e` TU T VbaV ageTV ba f W bgebf fb hgbf fc V T ` ag W
TZhT c eb ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W fbW b V beheb cbgTf b l bgebf cebWhVgbf W W f V[b Vb`b T he T LaT VbaW V za a T dh
ba f f geTafcbegTa TVg iT` ag W fW g Uh b T ag efg V b fgb bVhee f T W f[ WeTgTV za TVb`cTyTWT W haT aZ fgT
` Wh Te Gbe b gTagb xdh Wb a T eT`T TfV aW ag Zeh fT W UT]T W fbW b :b`b f W fVhg z a:Tcxgh b +( haT aZ fgT
TfT W ? a f ih i `hl W h Wb VTl aWb T haT VbaV ageTV za UT]T W fbW b fg `h T T Ybe`TV za W Tf [be`baTf
W Tcebk `TWT` ag ),( `Ff` C TaZ bg af aT l T Wbfg ebaT dh ]hagTf cebibVTa haT ti WT
e TUfbeV za W fbW b W bf g Uh bf ` ageTf W ]Ta T he T l
GrOaX[ QV NX RY N [ < g Uh b W fgT g `ceTab g a cebc WTW f bgebf fb hgbf cTeT `Tag a e T be aT T gT` ag VbaV ageTWT
f ` Te f T Tf W TfT TfV aW ag Zeh fT W ? a cbe b dh f cebWhV J ZhaWb J ch W a kVe gTe ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W be aT
haT `Tlbe W hV za W xdh Wb ghUh Te [TfgT Tcebk `TWT` ag )(( `Ff` W h WT f a Th` agTe T kVe V za W fbW b <fgT [TmTyT f
C T ` W WT dh bf fb hgbf f e TUfbeU a ` ageTf dh TZhT c e`Ta V bZeT T W f` ah e T f Ve V za W 8;? dh e WhV T
a g Uh b e TUfbeV za W TZhT a bf f Z` agbf ghUh Te f `tf W fgT f
f a T g eTe f Za Y VTg iT` ag T e TUfbeV za W fbW b
GrOaX[ QV NX N Qo[ d rOaX[ P[XRP [ R P[ VPNXR = aT ` ag [Tl haT ib h` a W be aT bU ZTgbe b W VgTWb
<a g Uh b W fgT gTeWxb l bf g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f Vbeg VT f T cbe T VTcTV WTW `tk `T W VbaV ageTV za W e yza l T
bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb W c aW W a i W 8;? :ba VTag WTW W fb hgb dh W U kVe gTef Gbe gTagb f f
a i f T gbf W 8;? fgbf g Uh bf fba `hl c e` TU f T W U a kVe gTe ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W fb hgb W U a e
TZhT l f e TUfbeU a VTag WTW f f Za Y VTg iTf W TZhT J a TVb`cTyTWTf W T `xa `T VTag WTW W TZhT a V fTe T cTeT
`UTeZb T he T ab f `hl c a geTag a fgT cTeg W T kVe gTe Tf Gbe ] `c b f f W U a kVe gTe .((
a YebaT b dh Th` agT T VbaV ageTV za W he T T ` W WT ` bf`b f W fb hgb VTWT WxT fgb e dh e cbe b ` abf
dh f e TUfbeU TZhT <fg cebV fb c e` g dh T `Tlbe ( - gebf W be aT f T VTcTV WTW `tk `T W VbaV ageTV za W
cTeg W T he T Zh T g Uh b W fgT l f TVh`h be aT f W ) (( `Ff` C
+/+
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
< cebV fb W VbaV ageTe b W h e T be aT e dh e dh bf ` gTWT cbe ZeTWb W [ c ebf`b Te WTW W ag efg V b ` Wh Te
e yba f kVe g a TZhT l fb hgbf W Ybe`T T Zb + aVTcTV WTW W bf g Uh bf W fgT f g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f l VbaWhVgbf
+/,
6N o aX[ )0 :baV ageTV za l W hV za W be aT
%
6BAGEB 78 4 BF B 4E 747 78 BF
;wY V g [xWe Vb
9 H 7BF 8JGE468 H 4E8F K 4
6BA68AGE46 A 78 FB7 B
HA GI
fbW b f ba `tf TUhaWTag a Vb`cTeg ` agb Ff`bee V cgbe f
kgeTV h Te CT VbaV ageTV za W fbW b a c Tf`T abe`T ` ag
f e Zh T W ageb W x` g f fge V[bf W ),( T ),- `<d C Vba J Ve V za W 8;?
c gh gTe T cbfg e be"
haT VbaV ageTV za ceb` W b W Tcebk `TWT` ag ), `<d C
CT bf`b Te WTW ceb` W T T e W Wbe W +(( `Ff` C 0
`Ff` C VhTaWb f Vbee Z cbe TgeTVV za ag e za VT" l eTeT i m
VT`U T `tf W o T+ :b`b f W fVhg z a:Tc gh b - fgTf G Tf`T 8;?
iTe TU f W U a Vbageb Tef Vba ce V f za cbedh W g e` aTa T
W fge UhV za W xdh Wb age bf Vb`cTeg ` agbf ageTV h Te l
kgeTV h Te
? F c e` TU WTW a
g Uh bf W fgT f
8 VYNPVq QR XN [ Y[XN VQNQ XN Ym VPN N N V QR VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f
XN P[ PR NPVq XN Ym VPN QR [QV[
G8>bf` 5 )sG8> E 8 ``b C" 9VTa N )0 0 ?be`baT bf`bee V cgbeT%Tag W hewg VT 8;?" e T ` agTV za
` VTa f`b cTeT e Zh Te T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te a e fch fgT T ha
Gbe ] `c b Vba haT VbaV ageTV za W fbW b c Tf`tg Vb WwY V g W TZhT
W ), `<d C T bf`b Te WTW c Tf`tg VT f fg `TexT T
cTeg e W fgT Yze`h T a Tcebk `TWT` ag 10 `Ff` C
F FG8 4 78 E8GEB4 8AG46 A
GTeT f e `tf kTVgbf fc V T ` ag a VbaW V ba f
BF BE868CGBE 47;
TfbV TWTf T aY e` WTW e aT f fh aV h e Tcbeg W Tf
VbaV ageTV ba f c Tf`tg VTf a ha WTW f W ``b C" W 9VTa N )0 0 `h fgeT bf Vb`cba ag f Utf Vbf W f fg `T W
bgebf Wbf fb hgbf Z hVbfT l he T2 e gebT ` agTV za bf`bee V cgbe%8;? cTeT Vbageb W T VbaV ageTV za
G8>bf` 5 s QG8>ET ``b CR QGZ hVbfT ``b CR QGhe T ``b CR W fbW b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l T bf`b Te WTW :hTaWb T bf`b Te WTW
Th` agT cbe aV `T W b abe`T W U Wb T WwY V g W TZhT cbe ] `c b
KT f fg `TV ba f W T bf`b Te WTW c Tf`tg VT fh af e fg f fg `T W e gebT ` agTV za YhaV baT W T f Zh ag `Ta eT2
ce V fTf W ageb W habf cbVbf chagbf cbeV aghT f W Tf ` W WTf ) La Th` agb a T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te dh a
W e VgT` ag gwe` abf cetVg Vbf f Za Y VT ha Th` agb a T VbaV ageTV za W
Ebe`T ` ag bf ba f W fbW b l bf Ta ba f TfbV TWbf fbW b c Tf`tg Vb" VThfT Tf Vw h Tf a ei bfTf fc V T f
ce aV cT ` ag U VTeUbaTgb l V beheb" e ce f agTa T e W Wbe W T`TWTf Vw h Tf bf`bee V cgbeTf hU VTWb a
1, W bf bf`b f kgeTV h Te f l T Z hVbfT l T he T [ cbgt T`b Tag e be V eVT W bf a V bf fhceTzcg Vbf
Vbage Uhl a T e W Wbe W + T - W bf bf`b f gbgT f J a cTeT aVbZ e
`UTeZb W U Wb T dh T he T c a geT YtV ` ag a T `TlbexT CT VbageTVV za W Tf Vw h Tf bf`bee V cgbeTf [TV dh f
W Tf ` `UeTaTf V h Te f ] eV cbVb Y VTm ce f za bf`zg VT TVg i a ai TaWb f yT f a ei bfTf T Vw h Tf a ei bfTf
a VbaW V ba f W fgTWb fgTV baTe b Gbe b gTagb bf ba f W TW V baT f a bf a V bf fhceTzcg Vbf dh h Zb
fbW b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l bf Ta ba f TfbV TWbf fba bf geTaf` g a fgTf f yT f cbe gT b W T Z taWh T
ce aV cT f W g e` aTag f W `bi ` agb W xdh Wb T geTiwf W c gh gTe T T T c gh gTe T cbfg e be
T ` `UeTaT V h Te <a Vbaf Vh aV T cbW `bf W fVhg e + <fgbf cbg aV T f W TVV za VbaWhV Wbf T T [ czY f f
Vbageb W T bf`b Te WTW l Vbageb W T VbaV ageTV za W ba f cbfg e be fg `h Ta T U eTV za W 8;? dh f T `TV aT
fbW b T ` f`b g `cb a Zetah bf f Ve gbe f b i fxVh Tf" a Tf g e` aTV ba f
8hadh ` g c f ` VTa f`bf Vbageb Ta T Dbagb W T a ei bfTf
kVe V za W fbW b l TZhT cbe bf e yba f Wbf f fg `Tf ce `Te bf , CT 8;? aZe fT T gbee ag fTaZhxa b l f geTafcbegT T bf
fgta fc V T ` ag aib hVeTWbf a T e Zh TV za W T e yba f WbaW Th` agT T c e` TU WTW T TZhT W bf
VbaV ageTV za W fbW b l bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te2 g Uh bf W fgT f gTeWxbf bf g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f Vbeg VT f l
)" f fg `T bf`bee V cgbe%8;?3 l " ` VTa f`b bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f ` Wh Te f
W Tf W
+/-
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
+/.
6N o aX[ )0 :baV ageTV za l W hV za W be aT
HA GI
Ge f za Teg e T Ge f za Teg e T
,( Ethf T
+- ? cbk T
T YX
+( ;ebZTf ;ebZTf
47; XN Ym VPN
- DbeY aT 8 Vb[b
G8>8MG 5 - Ff` (
( E Vbg aT : ba W aT Tag [ c eg af ib"
+//
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
+/0
6N o aX[ )0 :baV ageTV za l W hV za W be aT
XN YN Y8]
47; d
),0
`wW Vbf TfbV TWbf Vba ha Th` agb W ib h` a W be aT l e WhVV ba f W RQ
HA GI
ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te Vb`b T W TU g f ` ghf `T Vbageb TWT b V RYN
[O aVQ[
T W TU g f afxc WT <a fgbf VTfbf Th` agb W T aZ fgT W TZhT f ei
Vb`b haT e fch fgT Vb`c afTgbe T cTeT Th` agb W T bf`b Te WTW
NPVq QR [QV[ R
c Tf`tg VT l b T W f` ahV za W ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te ),,
Gb W cf T b f W kV f iT bVTf baT ` ag bVhee a Thf aV T W
fgx`h bf Y f b zZ Vbf VbabV Wbf cTeT T f W Gb W cf T cf VzZ aT cbe
A[ YNX
] `c b ch W f e VThfTWb cbe aY e` WTW f ` agT f Vb`b T
fdh mbYe a T b bf geTfgbeabf bUf f ib%Vb`ch f ibf l ch W VbaWhV e
T `cbegTag f [ cbaTge ` T 8 W Y e aV T W TW cf T T Thf aV T W
),(
6[ PR
f W aV hfb a ce f aV T W [ c eaTge ` T b W c V za W ib h` a
f eTeT c eb Z a eT ` ag f W U T f ba f a bf V agebf
[ cbgT t` Vbf W f W VThfTWTf cbe geTh`Tg f`b aY VV za b V ehZxT
; Y V aV T cTeV T W ` VTa f`b W T f W b dh cebibVT haT )+.
aZ fgT aTW VhTWT W TZhT [ cbW cf T" b ch W bVhee e haT ( +( .( 1( ) ( )-( )0(
aVTcTV WTW cTeT TVV W e T bf xdh Wbf a cTV ag f dh [Ta fhYe Wb TR N QR [QV[ Y8] QoN
ha TVV W ag V e UebiTfVh Te a cTV ag f `Tlbe f Vba W ` aV T b 9VTa N )0 () <Y Vgb W ZeTaW f VT`U bf a T aZ fgT W fbW b fbUe T VbaV ageTV za W
a cTV ag f Vexg VT` ag aY e`bf <a Thf aV T W haT aZ fgT fbW b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te a c eebf a VbaW V ba f abe`T f xa T eb]T" l W fchwf
TW VhTWT W TZhT f cebWhV W f[ WeTgTV za [ c eaTge ` T T W T [be`baT Tag W hewg VT 8;?" l f U bdh Teba bf f fg `Tf W e gebT ` agTV za W T
c fTe W bf ZeTaW f Th` agbf a bf a i f W 8;? f W xa T Tmh " K aZT a Vh agT dh Vbageb W T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b a xdh Wb
kgeTV h Te Yh W Y V ag a Thf aV T W fgbf f fg `Tf W e gebT ` agTV za :beg fxT
W ;e ;Ti W 9 ObhaZ "
E8FCH8FG4F AG8:E474F 78 BF
864A F BF BF BE868CGBE 47;
K F87 fbeV za cbe bf g Uh bf e aT f :hTaWb T aZ fgT W fbW b f UT]T bf
ai f iTWbf W fgTf [be`baTf fg `h Ta T e TUfbeV za W fbW b
<a haT c efbaT fTaT bf`bee V cgbe%8;? l bf ` VTa f`bf W Tf W
cbe bf e yba f l ce i a a ZeTaW f cweW WTf W fbW b Thadh T
YhaV baTa a cTeT b cTeT e Zh Te T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l
aZ fgT W fbW b ch W e WhV ef [TfgT ha )( W b abe`T Gbe
T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b Vba ce V f za T c fTe W bf VbafgTag f W fTYxbf
VbageTe b Vba haT T gT aZ fgT W fbW b T W f` ahV za W T
W T W f[ WeTgTV za aV hfb Vba W fTYxbf TW V baT f Vb`b haT T gT Ybe`TV za W fgTf [be`baTf c e` g dh bf e yba f kVe g a
aZ fgT W fT fgbf f fg `Tf W e gebT ` agTV za Z a eT ` ag ch W a ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W fbW b
`Tag a e T bf`b Te WTW c Tf`tg VT eTmbaTU ` ag VbafgTag 9VTa N ; U Wb T T `cbegTaV T W T TaZ bg af aT l T T Wbfg ebaT
)0 () `h fgeT dh ha Th` agb a T aZ fgT W fbW b [TfgT f f i V f b a T e Zh TV za W T kVe V za W fbW b cbe bf e yba f f
abe`T g a fb b ha c dh yb Y Vgb fbUe T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W cbWexT aY e e eeza T` ag dh gT`U wa W f `c yTa ha cTc
fbW b f `ce dh bf ` VTa f`bf W T 8;? l T f W YhaV ba a `cbegTag a T e Zh TV za W T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b a
xdh Wb kgeTV h Te 8hadh fgTf [be`baTf Th` agTa TDbagb
abe`T ` ag
W fbW b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te gT`U wa Th` agTa ib h` a
:hTaWb YT T ` VTa f`b W T 8;? b W T f W abe`T ` ag
W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te Th` agTaWb T e TUfbeV za W TZhT ]hagb
bgeb gbWTixT ch W Vbageb Te T bf`b Te WTW kgeTV h Te l T
Vba fbW b Gbe b gTagb T TaZ bg af aT l T T Wbfg ebaT
VbaV ageTV za W fbW b Vba haT Y Vg i WTW eTmbaTU f `ce dh
g a a cbVb Y Vgb fbUe T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b kV cgb a
[TlT fhY V ag aZ fgT W xdh Wbf cTeT dh UeTe ib h` a W Te b W VbaW V ba f kge `Tf
be aT bU ZTgbe b l Tf cweW WTf W TZhT VThfTWTf cbe T e fc eTV za T <fgT e Tg iT cbVT `cbegTaV T W T T Wbfg ebaT a T e Zh TV za W T
fhWbeTV za b Tf cweW WTf ZTfgeb ag fg aT f J a `UTeZb f bf VbaV ageTV za W fbW b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f `h fgeT a
` VTa f`bf W T 8;? l T f W YT Ta f `h gta T` ag T kc e ` agb e ce f agTWb a 9VTa N )0 ( <fgT Y ZheT `h fgeT Y Vgb
VbaV ageTV za W fbW b c Tf`tg Vb l T bf`b Te WTW fgta `T fbUe T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W fbW b W VT`U Te T aZ fgT W fbW b
Vbageb TWTf Gbe gTagb VhTaWb Th` agT T aZ fgT W fbW b W fchwf `tf W f f i V f a Wbf VbaW V ba f2 )" a VbaW V ba f abe`T f3 l "
W U bdh Te f fg `T gbgT W 8;?%f W f cebWhV a VT`U bf W fchwf W dh f U bdh TeT f fg `T W e gebT ` agTV za W
T Wbfg ebaT ` W Tag T ` aTV za W Tf Z taWh Tf fhceTee aT f l T
e Tg iT` ag ZeTaW f a T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W fbW b <a
aYhf za W T Wbfg ebaT T bf Ta `T f T haT i bV WTW VbafgTag cTeT dh
Thf aV T W bf ` VTa f`bf W f W W 8;? a aZ a bgeb ` VTa f`b
bf a i f c Tf`tg Vbf ab chW eTa Th` agTe a W f` ah e K aZT a Vh agT
W e gebT ` agTV za f VTcTm W e Zh Te TW VhTWT` ag T
dh VhTaWb T aZ fgT W fbW b f `h g c Vz cbe f f T VbaV ageTV za
VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W fbW b l T bf`b Te WTW
c Tf`tg VT VT`U z fb b age ha ) l ha a T`Ubf VTfbf <fg [T TmZb
aW VT dh aV hfb f a ha f fg `T W e gebT ` agTV za W T Wbfg ebaT
CN RX QR XN N TV[ R V N d XN NXQ[ R [ N R RX P[ [X QR XN
YhaV baT T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b c Tf`tg Vb ch W e Zh Tef U a J [T
[ Y[XN VQNQ QRX Xo]aVQ[ Rc NPRXaXN d XN P[ PR NPVq QR [QV[
e T mTWb ` f`b g cb W kc e ` agb W fchwf W U bdh Te T Ybe`TV za
:b`b f W fVhg z a :Tc gh b 0 gTagb T TaZ bg af aT Vb`b T T Wbfg ebaT W TaZ bg af aT Vba ` f`b e fh gTWb
]h ZTa ha cTc `cbegTag a T e Zh TV za W T e TUfbeV za W fbW b
+/1
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
TaZ bg af aT l T T Wbfg ebaT ab g a a ha Y Vgb `cbegTag kge `T W fbW b Vb`b bVhee a T aY e` WTW W 8WW fba <a fg VTfb
fbUe T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W fbW b Ge ` eb Vb`b f [Tl haT W Y V aV T W f Ve V za W T Wbfg ebaT b dh cebibVT haT cweW WT
W fVhg z Tag e be` ag T TaZ bg af aT l T T Wbfg ebaT kV f iT W fbW b a T be aT l VbaWhV T haT W f` ahV za W ib h` a W
Th` agTa T e TUfbeV za W fbW b l TZhT cbe bf g Uh bf e aT f xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l haT W f` ahV za W T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b3 8`Ubf
fbW b VTag WTW c eb cbVb VT`U b W fbW b VbaV ageTV za <a <a Z a eT bf fgx`h bf ce `Te bf dh Th` agTa Tc g gb cbe T
f ZhaWb hZTe ` ageTf ` VTa f`b W f W W 8;? f T fT fba bf TfbV TWbf Vba bf WwY V gf W fbW b l T W f` ahV za W
YhaV baT VhT dh e g aW aV T [TV T ha Th` agb W T ib h` a fTaZhxa b b T W f` ahV za W T ce f za Teg e T TfbV TWbf
VbaV ageTV za W fbW b c Tf`tg Vb f Vb`c afT Vba ha Th` agb Vba T afhY V aV T V eVh Tgbe T
W T aZ fgT W TZhT b haT `Tlbe f Ve V za W 8;? a c Tf`T < ` VTa f`b a hebaT W Tc g gb cbe T fT f Tat bZb T
dh g aW T W h e xdh Wb kgeTV h Te [TV T T abe`T WTW < ` VTa f`b W T f W 8 Zhabf W bf ` f`bf V agebf a hebaT f a T
f fg `T 8;?%f W V cfT Vba Ve V f bf f fg `Tf W TaZ bg af aT e Z za 8M+M W V e Ueb cTe V a fgTe aib hVeTWbf cbedh Tf
l T Wbfg ebaT cTeT e Zh Te T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b a f ba f a fgT e Z za TY VgTa Vba Ye Vh aV T gTagb T f W Vb`b
VbaW V ba f abe`T f aV hfb a cTV ag f VbaT Wbfg eba f`b Tc g gb cbe T fT f `h gta T` ag a bf Ta `T f 8W `tf bf
ce `Te b dh g a a a i f kge `TWT` ag T gbf W e Y ]bf V eVh Tgbe bf cebibVTWbf cbe T ce f za Teg e T UT]T b T
T Wbfg ebaT T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b c Tf`tg Vb Z a eT ` ag W f` ahV za W ib h` a fTaZhxa b TY VgTa gTagb T f W Vb`b
Th` agT fb b T e W Wbe W + T - `<d C cbe aV `T W b abe`T Tc g gb cbe T fT T ` f`b g `cb
+0(
6N o aX[ )0 :baV ageTV za l W hV za W be aT
B a A; JTaWf AD2 KeTafcbeg W he T l cbg aV T V xa Vb W bf he Tewg Vbf GTaaTU V e KC CTlgba 8K2 <age ZT W e Z WT W fb hgbf l bkxZ ab a T
:hee Fc a E c[eb ?lc eg af -2 ,,, (). `wWh T e aT 2 cTc W T Tedh g VgheT W ` VebiTfbf Jbl A G[lf b
Ba cc e D8 Bjba K? E f a J2 = f b bZxT `b Vh Te W dh Ue b I aT G[lf b +(/2 =.,1 (),
[xWe Vb E <aZ A D W +/ 2 )+,1 ()- JTaWf AD B a A;2 :babV ` agbf Y f b zZ Vbf fbUe ah iTf g eTc Tf
Bbf[ ` mh K8 ET T`heT B <ZTf[ eT E g T 2 I V cgbe f W cTeT T W TU g f afxc WT a YebZwa VT Jbl A G[lf b I aT G[lf b
iTfbce f aT M)T l M)U2 W `b wVh Tf T f fg `Tf Y f b zZ Vbf G[lf b +))2 =)),1 ().
I i 1 2 )0)+ () JTaWf AD CTlgba ?<2 CT Y f b bZxT W T VbaV ageTV za he aTe T2 haT
HA GI
ETjTgT :D GTaaTU V e KC2 :baV ageTV za a be aT W `T`xY ebf2 haT TVghT mTV za J ` a E c[eb 12 )/0 ((1
e i f za W T Tedh g VgheT ` Wh Te e aT l bf geTafcbegTWbe f W N a e ; D gV[ N< JTaWf AD2 ` gTUb f`b W he T l T`baxTVb l
` `UeTaT A :b`c G[lf b 9 )002 011 ()0 Vbageb W T kVe V za e aT W a gezZ ab : a A 8` JbV E c[eb )(2
E f a J =e ue A DTec f ; g T 2 8VhTcbe aTf a e yza2 W ),,, ()-
`b wVh Tf T ` W VT` agbf G[lf b I i 0 2 (- (( P `` e`Ta :8 ?h l <C 8[a AJ g T 2 LaT f yT W T bf`b Te WTW W Y h Wb W
F f a <K = agba I82 D `UeTaT W TVhTcbe aT% W e Z WT2 f Zh f aWb ha ag fg ab T V e Ueb Vbageb T T fTV WTW W T f W ETghe -.02 10 ()1
a Z`T Jbl A G[lf b P `` e`Ta :8 C U ;< Ba Z[g P82 V eVh gbf a hebaT f fhUlTV ag f T T f W l T
GT ba KC <WjTeWf 8 DTggfba ;C2 V eVh TV za ` Wh Te e aT [b` bfgTf f W Y h Wbf ETg I i E hebfV )02 ,-1 ()/
:b`ce G[lf b 21/ ()
GTaaTU V e KC2 <fgehVgheT l YhaV za W Tf kge ` WTW f W ZTWTf W TfT
W ? a :b`ce G[lf b 2 (.+ ()
+0)
64CiGH B
ERTaXNPVq R NX QR [ N V[ PNXPV[ S[ SN [ d
HA GI
NT R V[2 RT NPVq QR X[ YRPN V Y[ R NXR N N RX
P[ [X QRX b[XaYR N Tao R[ d RX b[XaYR QRX Xo]aVQ[ Rc NPRXaXN
+0+
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
GNOXN ( =TVgbe f dh ch W a T g eTe T W fge UhV za W N N [YNXoN mPVQ[ ON R aRQR [b[PN PNYOV[ R XN
cbgTf b age ageTV h Te l kgeTV h Te QV VOaPVq QRX [ N V[ CT TV Wbf f ` gTUz VT Th` agT T
= h Wbf VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b kgeTV h Te a cTeg T cebibVTe T
9NP [ R ]aR QR XNeN "8 9NP [ R ]aR QR XNeN "
cweW WT W cbgTf b W Tf Vw h Tf ` ageTf dh T T VT bf f
XN PnXaXN 7V YV aV XN L "M 9aR N QR XN PnXaXN NaYR N ` gTUz VT e WhV T VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b a xdh Wb
XN L "M kgeTV h Te 8hadh bf ` VTa f`bf e fcbafTU f W Y Vgb
afh aT ; Y V aV T W afh aT W TU g f W T VbaV ageTV za W ba f W [ WezZ ab fbUe T
` ghf" W fge UhV za ag eaT W cbgTf b ab f Vb`ce aW a
8 Wbfg ebaT ; Y V aV T W T Wbfg ebaT Vb`c gT` ag ha Y Vgb W Th` agb W T VbaV ageTV za
<aY e` WTW W 8WW fba" W ba f W [ WezZ ab f e WhV e T TVg i WTW W ET %B
<fg `h TV za %TWe aweZ VT 9 bdh b %TWe aweZ Vb 9b`UT 8KGTf <fgT e WhVV za T fh i m W f` ahl T
8 VT bf f 8V Wbf f VTcgTV za V h Te W cbgTf b l Th` agT T VbaV ageTV za W
C f f V h Te cbgTf b kgeTV h Te CT T VT bf f g a Y Vgb VbageTe b
<] eV V b TZbgTWbe W fc TmTaWb cbgTf b W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te T Tf Vw h Tf l
8h` agb W T bf`b Te WTW W xdh Wb
g aW T VThfTe [ cbcbgTf ` T
kgeTV h Te
+0,
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
HA GI
E 8
/ 8KG
(, `<d WxT" "
" 5
"
"
EB
, ( `M % /( `M % -( `M
+( `<d WxT"
9VTa N D VTa f`bf W f Ve V za W cbgTf b l e TUfbeV za W
fbW b cbe Tf Vw h Tf ce aV cT f W bf g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f l W fgT f
gTeWxbf 9B VTaT W cbgTf b ZeTaW 3 <ET: VTaT W fbW b c g T 3
IFDB VTaT W cbgTf b ` Wh Te kg eab e aT
)
1 `<d WxT" bgeTf i V f f ch W a f Ze ZTe W c aW aWb W Tf a V f WTW f W
+0-
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
8cP RPVq a V N VN QR [ N V[
9b`UT W 8KGTfT a T ` `UeTaT V h Te UTfb Tg eT +
<Y Vgb W T T Wbfg ebaT
<fgT Ub`UT fTVT fbW b W T Vw h T T ag efg V b l T
` f`b g `cb `h i cbgTf b T ag e be W T Vw h T
s [ YNX
< f ZhaWb cTfb W cebV fb f T W Yhf za cTf iT W
cbgTf b W fW ag e be W T Vw h T T Y h Wb ghUh Te
<agbaV f ha %B CT Ub`UT W 8KGTfT Ve T haT T gT
)
VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b ageTV h Te dh cebcbeV baT T
<Y Vgb W B kgeTV h Te
Yh emT `ch fbeT cTeT T W Yhf za cTf iT W cbgTf b W fW VbaV ageTV za
T Vw h T T h` a ghUh Te CT ` `UeTaT h` aT W Tf (
Vw h Tf ce aV cT f f `hl c e` TU T cbgTf b cbedh ( ) + , -
[Tl Wbf g cbf W VTaT f fc V T f dh c e` g a dh bf 4XQ[ R [ N XN Ym VPN s [ YNX
+0.
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
[cVYNQN QR NXQ[ R [ N
.(
f Ve V za W cbgTf b ` W Tag T ` abf VhTgeb ` VTa f`bf2
) < Th` agb W T VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b a xdh Wb -(
YX QR XN YN
kgeTV h Te fg `h T T VbaV ageTV za W fbW b %B 9b`UT W
,(
8KGTfT b dh Th` agT T VTcgTV za W cbgTf b T geTiwf W T
HA GI
` `UeTaT UTfb Tg eT <fg Th` agb W T VTcgTV za W +(
T (
cbgTf b T fh i m Th` agT T VbaV ageTV za W ba f W cbgTf b
NPVq N
ageTV h Te b dh [TV dh cbgTf b f W YhaWT T geTiwf W T
(
XN Ym VPN
` `UeTaT h` aT [TV T g Uh b )(
6[ PR
< Th` agb W T VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b kgeTV h Te
Th` agT ZeTW ag W cbgTf b W fW xdh Wb (
+(+-,(,--(--.(.-
ag efg V T e aT [TV T ag e be W T Vw h T c g T b
6[ PR NPVq QR [ N V[ n VP[ Y8]
dh e WhV T YhZT W ba f W cbgTf b W fW ag e be W
9VTa N , <Y Vgb W T VbaV ageTV za W ba f cbgTf b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te fbUe T
Tf Vw h Tf T geTiwf W T ` `UeTaT UTfb Tg eT
VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W T Wbfg ebaT K aZT a Vh agT dh bf c dh ybf VT`U bf a
+ < Th` agb W T aZ fgT W cbgTf b fg `h T T T VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b cebibVTa ZeTaW f VT`U bf a T VbaV ageTV za W
fxag f f W VTaT f W cbgTf b l fh geTaf bVTV za W T Wbfg ebaT
V gbfb T T ` `UeTaT h` aT b dh T fh i m
Th` agT T YTV WTW W W Yhf za W cbgTf b T geTiwf )
W T ` `UeTaT 8W
, < Th` agb W T VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b fg `h T T f Ve V za B
W T Wbfg ebaT cbe T Vbeg mT fhceTee aT dh fg `h T T a VbaV ageTV za
`tf T f Ve V za W cbgTf b Vb`b f kc VT T Vbag ahTV za B
,
8 Wbfg ebaT
VbaV ageTV za
N NXQ[ R [ N R VYaXN XN RP RPVq QR [ N V[ CT T Wbfg ebaT
fg `h T T e TUfbeV za TVg iT W ba f W fbW b cbe Tf Vw h Tf B kVe V za
ce aV cT f W bf g Uh bf W fgT f gTeWxbf l bf VbaWhVgbf +
B
Vb Vgbe f i e :Tc gh b 0" <fg Y Vgb fgt ` W TWb cbe ha ET %B kVe V za
9b`UT W 8KGTfT dh geTafcbegT fbW b [TV T TYh eT T geTiwf W % 8W
T ` `UeTaT UTfb Tg eT W T Vw h T l [TV T xdh Wb ag efg V T B Vbafh`b
e aT T ` f`b g `cb dh Ub`U T cbgTf b [TV T T Vw h T Gbe b 9VTa N - D VTa f`b W e gebT ` agTV za Utf Vb cTeT Vbageb W T VbaV ageTV za
gTagb T T Wbfg ebaT gT`U wa g a ha Y Vgb cbW ebfb a W cbgTf b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te cbe T T Wbfg ebaT 8 W"
Vbageb W T i bV WTW T T dh Tf Vw h Tf ce aV cT f f Ve gTa
cbgTf b l e TUfbeU a fbW b a 9VTa N - <a fg f fg `T W e gebT ` agTV za ha
La f ZhaWb Y Vgb W T T Wbfg ebaT f Th` agTe a ` eb Th` agb W T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W cbgTf b fg `h T T
W VTaT f W cbgTf b a T ` `UeTaT h` aT l cbe b gTagb fh f Ve V za W T Wbfg ebaT l cbe gTagb Th` agT T VbaV ageTV za
c e` TU WTW T cbgTf b b dh Th` agT T a `tf T Y VTV T W c Tf`tg VT W T Wbfg ebaT U bdh )" < Th` agb W T
T T Wbfg ebaT cTeT fg `h Te T f Ve V za W cbgTf b Gbe b gTagb T Wbfg ebaT c Tf`tg VT cebibVT agbaV f ha `TeVTWb Th` agb
T T Wbfg ebaT g a ha Y Vgb cbW ebfb cTeT Th` agTe T W T kVe V za W cbgTf b cbe bf e yba f U bdh " < Th` agb
kVe V za W cbgTf b Vb`b f `h fgeT a9VTa N + W T kVe V za W cbgTf b h Zb e WhV T VbaV ageTV za W
cbgTf b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te W e Ze fb T b abe`T VxeVh b +
8X NaYR [ QR XN P[ PR NPVq QR V[ R QR [ N V[ Rc NPRXaXN l U bdh ," Gbe b gTagb fg ` VTa f`b W e gebT ` agTV za
R VYaXN XN RP RPVq QR NXQ[ R [ N <a bf f fg `Tf W Vbageb W TVg T W `Ta eT f aweZ VT Vba Y Vgb W e Vgb W Th` agb W
e gebT ` agTV za a ZTg iT YTVgbe dh f Vbageb T Z a eT ` ag T VbaV ageTV za kgeTV h Te W cbgTf b cTeT iTe T kVe V za
g a ha Y Vgb W e gebT ` agTV za a Vbageb TWbe <a VTfb W W cbgTf b VhTaWb Th` agT T aZ fgT W cbgTf b 9VTa N ."
f fg `T W Vbageb W T Wbfg ebaT%cbgTf b T gTfT W f Ve V za W
T Wbfg ebaT cbe T Z taWh T fhceTee aT fgt Yh eg ` ag Vbageb TWT 8X OX[]aR[ QRX V RYN QR R [NXVYR NPVq QR NXQ[ R [ N NSRP N
cbe T VbaV ageTV za W ba f W cbgTf b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te R T N YRQVQN XN RTaXNPVq QRX [ N V[ <a Thf aV T W f Ve V za
9VTa N , `h fgeT dh ha Th` agb a T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W W T Wbfg ebaT Vb`b bVhee a cTV ag f Vba aY e` WTW W
cbgTf b W Tcebk `TWT` ag + `<d C ch W Th` agTe T VbaV ageTV za 8WW fba T f Ve V za e aT W cbgTf b f T g eT b dh [TV dh T
c Tf`tg VT W T Wbfg ebaT W fW VTf ( [TfgT ha `tk `b W .( aZ )(( ` VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te Th` ag T a i f
haT VbaV ageTV za VTf )( i V f fhc e be T T abe`T c ZebfT` ag T gbf Gbe VbageTe b Vba haT f Ve V za kV f iT W
< Y Vgb W T VbaV ageTV za W ba f W cbgTf b cTeT fg `h Te T T Wbfg ebaT T Wbfg eba f`b ce `Te b" T f Ve V za W cbgTf b
f Ve V za W T Wbfg ebaT f cTeg W ha cbW ebfb f fg `T W Th` agT Vbaf W eTU ` ag b dh cebibVT haT cweW WT W cbgTf b
e gebT ` agTV za cTeT e Zh Te T kVe V za W cbgTf b Vb`b f `h fgeT cbe bf e yba f b dh VbaWhV T [ cbcbgTf ` T
+0/
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
/(
B Vbafh`b
.( 7VR N VPN R [ N V[
GN N QR RP RPVq QR [ N V[
G Tf`T B -(
VbaV ageTV za
,(
Y[X YV
8 Wbfg ebaT
B f Ve V za +(
I Vb VV za Vbeg VT
7VR N [ YNX QR [ N V[
g Uh bf
(
7VR N ON N R [ N V[
)(
B kVe V za
9VTa N . D VTa f`bf ce `Te bf cbe bf dh haT aZ fgT iTWT W cbgTf b Th` agT
( - )( )- ( - +(
T kVe V za W cbgTf b K aZT a Vh agT dh Th` agb W T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT 6NaQNX aOaXN X YV
W cbgTf b Th` agT W e VgT` ag T f Ve V za W cbgTf b cbe bf g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f 9VTa N 0 I TV za age T i bV WTW W Y h]b a bf g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f
Vbeg VT f aW e VgT` ag Th` agT T f Ve V za W cbgTf b T iTe T VbaV ageTV za Vbeg VT f l T f Ve V za W cbgTf b l Y Vgb W bf VT`U bf a T aZ fgT W
c Tf`tg VT W T Wbfg ebaT cbgTf b K aZT a Vh agT dh haT aZ fgT T gT W cbgTf b a T W gT ` ]beT a
ZeTa ` W WT Y Vgb W Th` agb W Y h]b ghUh Te cTeT Th` agTe T f Ve V za W
cbgTf b bfUTeeT fb`Ue TWT `h fgeT VThWT ghUh Te abe`T Tcebk `TWb a T
,0
`TlbexT W Tf VbaW V ba f Y f b zZ VTf ;Tgbf W DT a V > 9 e a e IN > U fV[
>2 ; c aW aV T W Y h]b W B f Ve V za a bf ghUbf Vbeg VT f W fgT f W T eTgT
8` A G[lf b -.2 =1+ )101 "
,.
XN YN
+00
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
HA GI
W ba f W [ WezZ ab a[ U T f Ve V za W cbgTf b f ` W Tag
T e WhVV za W T TVg i WTW W ET %B 9b`UT 8KGTf <fgT
KhUh Te W fgT e WhVV za T fh i m W f` ahl T VbaV ageTV za W cbgTf b
gTfT W Y h]b
ageTV h Te l T cbfg e be W Yhf za cTf iT W cbgTf b T geTiwf W T
` `UeTaT h` aT [TV T g Uh b CT TV Wbf f gT`U wa ch W
e WhV e a ` eb W VTaT f W cbgTf b a T ` `UeTaT h` aT
% B f Ve V za :ba TV Wbf f `tf ceb baZTWT dh WheT iTe bf WxTf [Tl ha
I Vb VV za Vbeg VT Th` agb a T kVe V za he aTe T W cbgTf b < ` VTa f`b W
VbaWhVgbf
fg Y Vgb f W U a cTeg T ha Y Vgb W T TV Wbf f Veza VT
dh a[ U T e TUfbeV za W TZhT l V beheb W fbW b a bf
g Uh bf cebk `T f b dh Th` agT fh` a fgeb W ib h` a
B f a VT`U bf W fgT fg `h TaWb Tfx T f Ve V za W cbgTf b <fg Y Vgb
kVe V za
Tah T Y Vgb a[ U Wbe W bf ba f W [ WezZ ab fbUe ET
9VTa N ( <Y Vgb W T aZ fgT iTWT W fbW b fbUe T kVe V za e aT W %B 9b`UT 8KGTf Gbe gTagb T TV Wbf f Veza VT VbaWhV T
cbgTf b K aZT a Vh agT dh haT W gT T gT a fbW b W f` ahl T T Wbfg ebaT haT cweW WT W cbgTf b
c Tf`tg VT dh g aW T W f` ah e T f Ve V za W cbgTf b cbe bf g Uh bf ` ageTf dh T TV Wbf f TZhWT VbaWhV T haT W f` ahV za W T kVe V za
Vb Vgbe f Vbeg VT f J a `UTeZb T W gT T gT a fbW b Th` agT
W cbgTf b
f `h gta T` ag fh` a fgeb W xdh Wbf T VbaWhVgb Vb Vgbe Vbeg VT dh g aW
T Th` agTe T f Ve V za W cbgTf b Cbf Y Vgbf bch fgbf W haT W gT T gT a
fbW b f VbageTee fgTa age fx cbe b dh [Tl cbVbf VT`U bf a T kVe V za W
8SRP [ OR RSVPV[ [ QR a N QVR N NX N R [ N V[ d
cbgTf b K=>2 gTfT W Y geTV za Z b` eh Te
ON N R [QV[
;heTag T `Tlbe cTeg W T [ fgbe T W T [h`Ta WTW T W gT gxc VT
e WhV aWb Tfx T Yh emT `ch fbeT cTeT T W Yhf za W [T f Wb UT]T a fbW b l T gT a cbgTf b a Vb`cTeTV za Vba T W gT
cbgTf b T geTiwf W T ` `UeTaT h` aT :ba ha `bW eaT gxc VT <a cbU TV ba f T f TWTf dh ab [Ta kc e ` agTWb T
Th` agb W T gTfT W Y h]b ghUh Te cbgTf b aWhfge T mTV za Vb`b T ge Uh OTab`T`b dh i i a T e Z za
T`Tmza VT W abeg W 9eTf T aZ fgT W fbW b ch W f e gTa UT]T
f Ve gTWb f kch fT Vbag ahT` ag cbe g Uh b b
Vb`b )( T ( ``b WxT l T aZ fgT W cbgTf b ch W ZTe T ((
dh ` a ` mT Th` agb W T VbaV ageTV za W
``b WxT <fgT aZ fgT f W U T dh Vbafh` a haT W gT dh
cbgTf b ghUh Te l Th` agT T f Ve V za a gT W cbgTf b
Vbag a ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W YehgTf l i eWheTf l ab T ` agbf
La VThWT ghUh Te T gb gT`U wa Th` agT a ` eb W
cebV fTWbf CTf cbU TV ba f dh Vbafh` a fg g cb W W gT ab
VTaT f 9B W T gT VbaWhVgTaV T a T ` `UeTaT fh a kc e ` agTe Th` agbf W T ce f za Teg e T e TV baTWbf Vba
h` aT 8hadh bf VTaT f W 9B abe`T ` ag fgta T WTW a aY e` WTW f VTeW biTfVh Te f
aTVg ibf f TVg iTa a e fch fgT T Th` agbf a T :ba T aWhfge T mTV za l Th` agb W Vbafh`b W T ` agbf
i bV WTW W Y h]b b dh Th` agT abe` ` ag T cebV fTWbf dh T ` ahWb g a a ha T gb Vbag a Wb W fbW b l UT]b
VbaWhVgTaV T W cbgTf b T geTiwf W T ` `UeTaT Vbag a Wb W cbgTf b [T [TU Wb Th` agbf WeT`tg Vbf a T aZ fgT
h` aT W fbW b l W f` ahV ba f a T aZ fgT W cbgTf b <a T `TlbexT W bf
< Y Vgb W Th` agb W Y h]b ghUh Te f fc V T ` ag cTxf f aWhfge T mTWbf Vbafh`b ` W b W cbgTf b f fz b W +( T
/( ``b WxT l Vbafh`b W fbW b f W ),( T )0( ``b WxT
`cbegTag cTeT TlhWTe T ce f eiTe T kVe V za abe`T W
cbgTf b WheTag bf VT`U bf a T aZ fgT W fbW b Gbe
Cbf fghW bf kc e ` agT f l V xa Vbf [Ta W `bfgeTWb dh T
] `c b Vba haT T gT aZ fgT W fbW b [Tl haT W f` ahV za
Vb`U aTV za W haT W gT T gT a fbW b l UT]T a cbgTf b Th` agT
W T f Ve V za W T Wbfg ebaT dh cbe fx fb T g aW exT T
e fZb W [ c eg af za l aY e` WTW f VTeW biTfVh Te f l e aT f
W f` ah e T gTfT W f Ve V za W cbgTf b l cbe b gTagb T TfbV TWTf J a `UTeZb haT W gT e VT a cbgTf b cTe V cebg Z e
e WhV e T kVe V za he aTe T W cbgTf b J a `UTeZb T T gT VbageT bf Y Vgbf TWi efbf W haT W gT T gT a fbW b e WhV aWb T
gTfT W Y h]b ghUh Te W fgT dh bVhee Vba haT aZ fgT T gT W ce f za Teg e T l e fZb W TVV W ag V e UebiTfVh Te aY e` WTW
fbW b g aW T Th` agTe T f Ve V za W cbgTf b 9VTa N ( W Tf Teg e Tf VbebaTe Tf l aY e` WTW e aT Cbf Y Vgbf
" Gbe b gTagb bf Wbf Y Vgbf W haT aZ fgT T gT W fbW b T U a Y V bfbf W Th` agTe T aZ fgT W cbgTf b fba fc V T ` ag
W f` ahV za W T f Ve V za W T Wbfg ebaT l T T gT gTfT W i W ag f VhTaWb f Vb`U aTa Vba haT W gT UT]T a fbW b
Y h]b ghUh Te f VbageTee fgTa age fx cbe b dh [Tl cbVbf CTf cThgTf W gwg VTf chU VTWTf cbe iTe Tf beZTa mTV ba f
[Ta e Vb` aWTWb e WhV e T aZ fgT W gwg VT W V beheb W fbW b
VT`U bf a T kVe V za W cbgTf b 8f ` f`b Vba haT
T Tcebk `TWT` ag .- T )(( ``b WxT Vbee fcbaW ag T
aZ fgT UT]T W fbW b [Tl cbVbf VT`U bf a T kVe V za W
)-T + Z WxT W fbW b b + 0 T - 0 Z WxT W V beheb W fbW b"
cbgTf b W U Wb T bf Y Vgbf Vb`c afTWbe f W Th` agb W
` ageTf f Th` agT T aZ fgT W cbgTf b T ) ( ``b WxT , /
T f Ve V za W T Wbfg ebaT l T W f` ahV za W Y h]b ghUh Te
Z WxT" cTeT TWh gbf fTabf
fbUe T f Ve V za W cbgTf b
+01
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
64 6 B E8A4 K 4 6BA68AGE46 A
78 BA8F 78 64 6 B 8JGE468 H 4E
Cbf ` VTa f`bf cTeT e Zh Te T VbaV ageTV za W ba f VT V b f M gT` aT ;+
GK?
TaT mTa a W gT a :Tcxgh b 0( ]hagb Vba T aWbVe ab bZxT W TVg iTV za
Tf [be`baTf e Zh TWbeTf W VT V b T [be`baT cTeTg eb W T
GK?" l T VT V gba aT Gbe b gTagb T e Zh TV za W bf ba f VT V b
f TaT mT fb b Ue i ` ag a fg VTcxgh b
:T ag fg aT :T e aT C U eTV za W :T
CT VbaV ageTV za W ba f W VT V b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te e TUfbeV za e TUfbeV za W [h fbf
abe`T ` ag c e`Ta V fge VgT` ag Vbageb TWT W ageb W habf
cbVbf chagbf cbeV aghT f W fh a i abe`T , `<d C :hTaWb T 9VTa N (( I fch fgTf Vb`c afTgbe Tf T T W f` ahV za W T
VbaV ageTV za W VT V b ba mTWb a c Tf`T ` W TWT cbe T [be`baT
VbaV ageTV za W ba f W VT V b W fV aW T a i f UT]bf
cTeTg eb W T GK?" l i gT` aT ;
[ cbVT V ` T" T kV gTU WTW W Tf Vw h Tf a ei bfTf l `hfVh Te f
Th` agT abgTU ` ag l ch W a VTfbf kge `bf cebibVTe g gTa T
[ cbVT Vw` VT <fgT VbaW V za f VTeTVg e mT cbe VbageTVV ba f bf a i f ih i a T T abe`T WTW :hTaWb T VbaV ageTV za W ba f
fctfg VTf W ` fVh b fdh wg Vb ? c eVT V ` T Th` agb W T W VT V b f iTWT f fg `h T T TVg i WTW :JI W Tf Vw h Tf
VbaV ageTV za W VT V b" W ce ` T kV gTU WTW a heb`hfVh Te l cTeTg eb W Tf b dh cebibVT haT e WhVV za a T f Ve V za W GK?
ch W cebibVTe Tee g` Tf VTeWxTVTf cbe b dh VTf ab f cebWhV e TUfbeV za zf T3 a VT`U b kV fb
8cebk `TWT` ag -( W T gbgT VT V b a c Tf`T W VT V b f W cbf gT a bf [h fbf Gbe gTagb T e Zh TV za W Te T W T
- `<d C" k fg a Ybe`T ba mTWT dh f T Ybe`T dh g a VbaV ageTV za W ba f VT V b fgt ` W TWT a ZeTa cTeg cbe bf
TVg i WTW U b zZ VT a Tf ` `UeTaTf V h Te f < e fgb f Y Vgbf W T GK? fbUe T e fbeV za zf T
ha T Tf cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf ,( " b Vb`c ]TWb a Cbf [h fbf f a `UTeZb ab g a a ha fh` a fgeb
Ybe`T ab ba mTWT Vba Ta ba f Vb`b YbfYTgb l V geTgb )( " aTZbgTU W VT V b Gbe b gTagb T TeZb c Tmb T aZ fgT W
Cbf VT`U bf a T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W ba f W [ WezZ ab VT V b W U dh UeTef Vba T kVe V za W VT V b cbe
aY hl a a T ha za W VT V b T Tf cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf :ba T geTVgb ZTfgeb ag fg aT l bf e yba f < e Zh TWbe `tf
TV Wbf f f ha ` abf VT V b T Tf cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf Gbe `cbegTag W T e TUfbeV za W VT V b a T`Ubf f g bf f T
VbageTe b Vba T T VT bf f haT `Tlbe VTag WTW W VT V b f ha T Tf GK? dh e Zh T T VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT W VT V b T geTiwf
cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf Gbe b gTagb bf cTV ag f Vba T VT bf f fba `tf W ge f Y Vgbf ce aV cT f2 )" fg `h TaWb T e fbeV za zf T3
fhfV cg U f T T g gTa T [ cbVT Vw` VT " fg `h TaWb T TVg iTV za W T i gT` aT ; dh h Zb
:b`b bVhee Vba bgeTf fhfgTaV Tf W beZTa f`b T aZ fgT W Th` agT T e TUfbeV za ag fg aT W VT V b3 l +" Th` agTaWb
VT V b W U dh UeTef Vba T cweW WT a gT W VT V b T TeZb T e TUfbeV za W VT V b a bf g Uh bf e aT f 9VTa N (( "
c Tmb J a `UTeZb T W Y e aV T W bf ba f Vb`b fbW b l < Vbageb W T e TUfbeV za W VT V b ZTfgeb ag fg aT l
V beheb ZeTa cTeg W T kVe V za W VT V b bVhee a Tf [ V f ag eVT`U b W VT V b a bf [h fbf f TaT mT a bgeT cTeg 3
CT gTfT [TU ghT W aZ fgT W VT V b a T W gT f W e fgb W fgT f VV za f V ageT a bf ` VTa f`bf dh
Tcebk `TWT` ag )((( `Z WxT Vba Tcebk `TWT` ag 1(( `Z Vbageb Ta T kVe V za e aT W VT V b
WxT W VT V b kVe gTWb a Tf [ V f 9T]b V egTf VbaW V ba f T
kVe V za W VT V b Y VT ch W kV W e T aZ fg za W VT V b 6BAGEB 78 4 8J6E86 A 78 64 6 B CBE
cbedh VT V b gT`U wa ch W f Ve gTef a T hm ag fg aT Gbe BF E jBA8F
b gTagb geTVgb ZTfgeb ag fg aT l bf ` VTa f`bf e Zh TWbe f
< VT V b f Y geT l e TUfbeU a bf e yba f c eb ab f
dh aY hl a a T TUfbeV za l f Ve V za ag fg aT W VT V b ]h ZTa
f Ve gT Gbe b gTagb T gTfT W kVe V za e aT W VT V b f
ha cTc `cbegTag a T [b` bfgTf f W VT V b Vb`b f TaT mT
VT Vh T W T f Zh ag `Ta eT2
a:Tcxgh b 0( :Tf gbWb VT V b a Vh ecb 11 " f
kVe V za gbgT W VT V b 5 VT V b Y geTWb
T `TV aT a [h fb Vba fb b T e W Wbe W () a xdh Wb
e TUfbeU Wb
kgeTV h Te l )( a xdh Wb ageTV h Te l bf beZtah bf
V h Te f Gbe gTagb [h fb TVg T Vb`b ha ZeTa W czf gb W Jb b T e W Wbe W .( W VT V b c Tf`tg Vb fgt
VT V b l Vb`b Yh ag W VT V b VhTaWb T VbaV ageTV za W VT V b ba mTWb ,( f ha T Tf cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf l
a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te g aW T W f` ah e )( Ybe`T Vb`c ]bf Vba Ta ba f Vb`b YbfYTgb Gbe
Lab W bf e Zh TWbe f `tf `cbegTag f W T TUfbeV za l U eTV za W b gTagb fb b T e W Wbe W .( W VT V b c Tf`tg Vb
VT V b cbe bf [h fbf f T GK? :hTaWb T VbaV ageTV za W VT V b a f Y geT a Z b`weh b Ebe`T ` ag T e W Wbe W
xdh Wb kgeTV h Te VT cbe W UT]b W b abe`T T TVg i WTW W 11 W VT V b Y geTWb f e TUfbeU Wb cbe bf g Uh bf l
e V cgbe f f af U f T VT V b :JI" a T ` `UeTaT V h Te W Tf fz b f kVe gT T e W Wbe W ) W VT V b Y geTWb
Z taWh Tf cTeTg eb W f f e WhV b dh ceb`h i haT `Tlbe 8cebk `TWT` ag .- W VT V b Y geTWb f e TUfbeU
f Ve V za W GK? Ch Zb fgT [be`baT TVg T W e VgT` ag fbUe a g Uh b cebk `T - T +( f e TUfbeU a TfT
bf [h fbf cTeT Th` agTe T e TUfbeV za W fT f zf Tf W ? a l , T 1 f e TUfbeU a bf g Uh bf W fgT l
U eTV za W fT f W bf [h fbf" l U eT ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W Vb Vgbe <fg cTgeza W e TUfbeV za f f ` Te T W
VT V b a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te W ib i aWb Tfx VT V b fbW b
+1(
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
HA GI
6NXVS[ VN)"
)"
8KG 6NXVS[ VN
W ? a T GK? fg `h T T e TUfbeV za W VT V b CT i gT` aT ;
VT V ge b " l T VT V gba aT gT`U wa fg `h Ta T e TUfbeV za W
VT V b a T eT`T TfV aW ag Zeh fT W TfT W ? a l a
g Uh b W fgT Thadh fgTf [be`baTf ab fba gTa `cbegTag f
AN"
VhTag gTg iT` ag Vb`b T GK? cTeT e WhV e T kVe V za e aT W
6NXVS[ VN)" VT V b
cbe Vb`c gb cbe geTafcbeg TVg ib T geTiwf W T Vw h T ` VTa f`b W W fUbeWT` agb dh f ch W kc VTe W T f Zh ag `Ta eT bf
+1)
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
8cP RPVq QR PNXPV[ 8cP RPVq QR PNXPV[ 8cP RPVq QR S[ SN [ 8cP RPVq QR S[ SN [
E8:H 46 A 78 4 8J6E86 A 78
Cbf g Uh bf e aT f g a a ha `tk `b W geTafcbeg abe`T cTeT
4:A8F B E8A4 K 4 6BA68AGE46 A
e TUfbeU e YbfYTgb W Tcebk `TWT` ag ( ) ``b ` a :hTaWb [Tl
78 BA8F 78 4:A8F B 8JGE468 H 4E
` abf W fgT VTag WTW W YbfYTgb a Y geTWb Z b` eh Te
f aV T ` ag gbWbf YbfYTgb Y geTWb f e TUfbeU :hTaWb [Tl `tf Dtf W T ` gTW W `TZa f b W Vh ecb f T `TV aT a bf [h fbf
W fgT VTag WTW kV fb f kVe gT Gbe b gTagb YbfYTgb CT `Tlbe cTeg W e fgb f aVh ageT W ageb W Tf Vw h Tf Vba
abe`T ` ag Vb` amT T W eeT`Tef a T be aT VhTaWb fh ` abf W ) hU VTWb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te 8hadh T
VbaV ageTV za a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f iT cbe aV `T W ha VbaV ageTV za c Tf`tg VT gbgT W `TZa f b f W Tcebk `TWT` ag
h`UeT W Tcebk `TWT` ag ( 0 `D C b dh WT haT VTeZT ghUh Te ) 0 `<d C `tf W T ` gTW W fg f ha T Tf cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf
W YbfYTgb W Tcebk `TWT` ag ( ) ``b ` a Tfh` aWb haT K=> Gbe b gTagb T VbaV ageTV za ba mTWT Ue W `TZa f b f fb b W
W ) -` `a ; U Wb T dh T `TlbexT W Tf c efbaTf aZ e a Tcebk `TWT` ag ( 0 `<d C
ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W YbfYTgb a bf cebWhVgbf tVg bf l T VTea T CT aZ fgT W Te T abe`T W `TZa f b f W Tcebk `TWT` ag -(
VbaV ageTV za W YbfYTgb Z a eT ` ag f `Tag a cbe aV `T W ) T +(( `Z WxT c eb fb b Tcebk `TWT` ag T ` gTW W fgT aZ fgT f
`D C3 T fg a i [Tl haT kVe V za Vbag ahT W YbfYTgb a T be aT TUfbeU WT cbe geTVgb ZTfgeb ag fg aT GTeT `Tag a e dh Ue b W
< g Uh b cebk `T abe`T ` ag e TUfbeU age /- l `TZa f b bf e yba f W U a kVe gTe fg `TZa f b TUfbeU Wb
0( W YbfYTgb Y geTWb < g Uh b W fgT e TUfbeU Tcebk `TWT` ag T ` gTW W T aZ fgT W Te T W `TZa f b b W ) -
T e W Wbe W )( W T VTeZT Y geTWT l fz b f e TUfbeU a T )-( `Z WxT Cbf e yba f abe`T ` ag kVe gTa T e W Wbe W )(
c dh yTf VTag WTW f a TfT W ? a bf g Uh bf T )- W `TZa f b a Y geTWb Z b` eh Te
Vb Vgbe f l bf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f 8cebk `TWT` ag CT kVe V za e aT W `TZa f b ch W Th` agTe
)( W YbfYTgb Y geTWb f kVe gT a T be aT abgTU ` ag WheTag kV fb W `TZa f b b W f` ah e T VTf
<a g Uh b cebk `T T e TUfbeV za W YbfYTgb f cebWhV V eb WheTag T W c V za W `TZa f b ; U Wb T dh `TZa f b
ce aV cT ` ag T geTiwf W T ixT geTafV h Te < YbfYTgb aZe fT T fgt aib hVeTWb a `hV[bf cebV fbf U bdhx` Vbf W Vh ecb
T Vw h T W fW T hm ` W Tag ha VbgeTafcbegTWbe W fbW b% aV h WT T TVg iTV za W `hV[Tf am `Tf fh VbaV ageTV za W U
YbfYTgb l fT W T Vw h T T geTiwf W T ` `UeTaT UTfb Tg eT e Zh Tef fge V[T` ag
` W Tag ha cebV fb dh ab f Vb`ce aW U a c eb dh ch W CT e Zh TV za W T kVe V za W `TZa f b f bZeT
aib hVeTe ha ` VTa f`b W VbageTgeTafcbeg a dh YbfYTgb ce aV cT ` ag VT`U TaWb T e TUfbeV za ghUh Te < g Uh b
f ag eVT`U T cbe ha Ta za cebk `T Z a eT ` ag e TUfbeU fb b T e W Wbe W - W
Cbf VT`U bf a T VTcTV WTW W e TUfbeV za W YbfYTgb ghUh Te `TZa f b Y geTWb < f g b ce aV cT W e TUfbeV za f TfT W
gT`U wa ch W a bVhee e a W Y e ag f VbaW V ba f aY h e a T ? a WbaW f e TUfbeU Tcebk `TWT` ag .- W T VTeZT
kVe V za W YbfYTgb Gbe ] `c b haT W gT UT]T a YbfYTgb Y geTWT W `TZa f b Jz b haT c dh yT VTag WTW cbe b Z a eT
ch W Vba g `cb Th` agTe geTafcbeg `tk `b W 4- " W `TZa f b Y geTWb f e TUfbeU a bf g Uh bf W fgT f l
e TUfbeV za W YbfYTgb e WhV aWb Tfx T g aW aV T W dh Vb Vgbe f
YbfYTgb f W eeT` a T be aT Cbf ` VTa f`bf dh e Zh Ta T e TUfbeV za W `TZa f b ab
CT GK? ch W W f `c yTe ha cTc `cbegTag a T e Zh TV za f VbabV a U a c eb 6aNQ [ + e fh` T Zhabf W bf
W T VbaV ageTV za W YbfYTgb T geTiwf W Wbf Y Vgbf2 )" T GK? YTVgbe f dh aY hl a a T kVe V za e aT W `TZa f b K aZT a
ceb`h i T e fbeV za zf T U eTaWb Tfx ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W Vh agT dh iTe bf YTVgbe f dh T g eTa T kVe V za e aT W VT V b
YbfYTgb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te W Tf fT f zf Tf3 l g a a Y Vgbf f ` Te f fbUe T kVe V za W `TZa f b
" CT GK? W f` ahl T TUhaWTaV T W VbgeTafcbegTWbe f W
YbfYTgb W fbW b a T ` `UeTaT Tc VT b dh T fh i m e WhV T
AG8:E46 A 78 E8A4
e TUfbeV za W YbfYTgb cbe bf g Uh bf e aT f Gbe b gTagb
864A F BF 78 6BAGEB 78
f `ce dh Th` agT T GK? c Tf`tg VT CT e TUfbeV za
9 H 7BF 8JGE468 H 4E8F
ghUh Te W YbfYTgb W f` ahl l f kVe gT `tf YbfYTgb
<fgTf ag ee TV ba f age YbfYTgb T GK? l VT V b f < ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te fgt W g e` aTWb ce aV cT ` ag
TaT mTa Vba `tf W gT a:Tcxgh b 0( cbe dh Ue b age T aZ fgT l T fT WT W TZhT l fT <a
+1
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
HA GI
:T kgeTV h Te :T kgeTV h Te TVh`h TV za b cweW WT W Vgeb gbf l xdh Wbf cebibVTaWb
VbaV ageTV za VbaV ageTV za ZeTi f Vbaf Vh aV Tf VTeW biTfVh Te f a habf cbVbf WxTf
?be`baT cTeTg eb W T ?be`baT cTeTg eb W T Gbe b gTagb f ch W a i e bf T]hfg f f fgw` Vbf dh bVhee a
a e fch fgT T Tf Tab`T xTf W T YhaV za e aT Vb`b haT
Mb h` a W xdh Wb Mb h` a W xdh Wb
Vb`c afTV za a V fTe T dh dh UeT T kVe V za W
kgeTV h Te 8 VT bf f ` gTUz VT kgeTV h Te 8V Wbf f ` gTUz VT
Vgeb gbf l xdh Wbf Vba T aZ fgT
+1+
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
+1,
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
Eb e aT Cxdh Wb
HA GI
ce f za kgeTV h Te ib h` a W Y h Wb
= h Wb e aT
kVe V za
ib h` a W Y h Wb
9VTa N (+ D VTa f`b Utf Vb W e gebT ` agTV za W xdh Wb e aT %VbecbeT cTeT Vbageb W ib h` a fTaZhxa b ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l T ce f za Teg e T
C a Tf fb WTf aW VTe Y Vgbf cbf g ibf3 xa Tf chag WTf aW VTe Y Vgbf a ZTg ibf
+1-
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
+ TWTcgTU f
Dh eg
8fx a VbaW V ba f abe`T f bf fcTV bf ag efg V T f TVg Ta
Vb`b ha W czf gb W e Ubf cTeT kV fb W xdh Wb
) Th` agTaWb T i V f a ib h` a W )( T +( gebf <fgT f ghTV za
( cebibVT W `T Vb`b f kc VT a:Tc gh b - c eb gT`U wa
( - )( )- ( - +( +- ,( TVg T Vb`b haT `cbegTag it ih T W W fUbeWT` agb W T
I[XaYR QR Xo]aVQ[ Rc NPRXaXN XV [
V eVh TV za cebg Z aWb f fg `T VTeW biTfVh Te Ye ag T haT
9VTa N (- I TV za Tcebk `TWT age ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te c ZebfT fbUe VTeZT dh cbWexT cebibVTe W `T ch `baTe
l ib h` a W fTaZe dh `h fgeT haT e TV za VTf a T a eTaZb
afhY V aV T VTeWxTVT
abe`T c eb gT`U wa `h fgeT dh ib h` a W fTaZe ab Vbag a T
<a e fh` a ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l
Th` agTaWb VhTaWb ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f ih i kV f ib
:hTaWb bVhee fgT VbaW V za ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te TW V baT ib h` a W fTaZe T ` ahWb f Vbageb Ta f `h gta T` ag
e fW a bf fcTV bf ag efg V T f l f cebWhV W `T c eb Tf VTag WTW f VhTag gTg iTf W W fge UhV za W xdh Wb
age ag efg V b l T fTaZe W c aW a W Tf cebc WTW f
Gbe b Z a eT Vb`c afTet T W Y e aV T l ib h` a fTaZhxa b Yxf VTf W T V eVh TV za l bf fcTV bf ag efg V T f Tfx Vb`b
Z a eT ib i et f aV T ` ag T T abe`T WTW T c fTe W T UT]T W T W at` VT W ag eVT`U b W xdh Wbf T geTiwf W Tf
`TfT W Z zUh bf eb]bf ` `UeTaTf VTc Te f
+1.
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
TR N d NXVQN QR [QV[
)(
TZhT2 )" Vbafge VV za W Tf Teg e b Tf e aT f dh
9 bdh b W TaZ bg af aT
W f` ahl T K=> f T TVg iTV za f `ctg VT f 0
s [ YNX
f i eT3 " Th` agb W T e TUfbeV za ghUh Te W fT .
Ebe`T
l TZhT3 l +" fg `h TV za W T U eTV za W e a aT
HA GI
,
l Th` agb W 8aZ l Ybe`TV za W T Wbfg ebaT bf
VhT f Th` agTa T a `tf T e TUfbeV za ghUh Te J 8aZ bg af aT T gT
T e WhVV za W ib h` a fTaZhxa b f b
fhY V ag ` ag ZeTaW Vb`b cTeT W f` ah e T ( .( 0( )(( ) ( ),( ).(
ce f za Teg e T f fgw` VT f cebWhV haT TVg iTV za C R Vq N R VNX YY ;T
TW V baT W f fg `T a ei bfb f `ctg Vb W U Wb T T 9VTa N (. <Y Vgbf W T Ybe`TV za kV f iT W TaZ bg af aT 8aZ " b U bdh b W T
W f` ahV za W fg eT` agb W bf Ybe`TV za W 8aZ a T VheiT W aTge he f f W ce f za e aT K aZT a Vh agT dh bf
UTebee V cgbe f Teg e T f hU VTWbf a f ab ai f T gbf W Ybe`TV za W 8aZ W f` ahl a T c aW ag W T aTge he f f cbe ce f za
VTebgxW b l TeVb Tzeg Vb KbWbf fgbf e Y ]bf b dh [TV dh T ce f za Teg e T f T `hl f af U T bf VT`U bf a T aZ fgT W fbW b
]hagbf ]h ZTa ha cTc `cbegTag a T etc WT < U bdh b W T Ybe`TV za W 8aZ W fc TmT T aTge he f f cbe ce f za cTeT e WhV e T
ce f za Teg e T
e fg ghV za W ib h` a fTaZhxa b dh bVhee a
VbaW V ba f TZhWTf Vb`b T [ `beeTZ T KT`U wa
J a `UTeZb T TVg iTV za kV f iT aTcebc TWT W f fg `T l 9VTa N (. K aZT a Vh agT dh VhTaWb Vbageb W T
a ei bfb f `ctg Vb ch W WTe hZTe T haT VTfVTWT W Y Vgbf dh aTge he f f cbe TaZ bg af aT f Vb`c gT` ag YhaV baT T VheiT
aV hl a Th` agbf a T f Ve V za W e a aT Ybe`TV za W 8aZ W aTge he f f cbe ce f za f `c aTWT VheiT abe`T " b dh
l e TUfbeV za e aT W fbW b dh iTa T ce f za Teg e T ; aW VT dh f ch W a bZeTe Th` agbf a T kVe V za W fbW b
[ V[b T TU TV za W bf a ei bf f `ctg Vbf e aT f T ` ahWb VhTaWb f Th` agT T aZ fgT W fbW b Vba VT`U bf `xa `bf a
e WhV T ce f za Teg e T a T [ c eg af za fc V T ` ag T ce f za Teg e T
VhTaWb f TfbV T Vba bU f WTW Gbe VbageTe b VhTaWb bf a i f W 8aZ ab
ch W a fhce ` ef a e fch fgT T haT `Tlbe aZ fgT
W fbW b VheiT T gT W TaZ bg af aT " Vb`b bVhee
C4C8 78 4 4A: BG8AF A4 8A 8
a T Zhabf cTV ag f [ c eg afbf dh g a a haT
6BAGEB 78 4 8J6E86 A E8A4
VTcTV WTW T g eTWT cTeT W f` ah e T f Ve V za W
Lab W bf Vbageb TWbe f W T kVe V za W fbW b `tf cbW ebfbf W e a aT l T Ybe`TV za W 8aZ T VheiT W aTge he f f
Vh ecb f 8aZ Cbf VT`U bf a T aZ fgT W fbW b f TfbV Ta Vba cbe ce f za ab f TV eVT gTa `c aTWb Gbe b gTagb
VT`U bf e VxcebVbf a T Ybe`TV za W 8aZ l fgb T fh i m VhTaWb Th` agT T aZ fgT W fbW b fba a V fTe bf
Vbage Uhl a ZeTa ` W WT T `Tag a ` agb W bf dh Ue bf Th` agbf `hV[b `Tlbe f W T ce f za Teg e T cTeT
VbecbeT f W fbW b :hTaWb T aZ fgT W fbW b f iT cbe aV `T Th` agTe T kVe V za W fbW b l `Tag a e
W b abe`T T f Ve V za W e a aT l T Ybe`TV za W 8aZ dh Ue b W fbW b Gbe ] `c b a T `TlbexT W Tf
W f` ahl a ; U Wb T dh T 8aZ g a iTe bf Y Vgbf `cbegTag f c efbaTf ha Th` agb W )( i V f a T aZ fgT W
cTeT Th` agTe T e TUfbeV za ghUh Te W fbW b Vb`b f kc VT a fbW b cebibVT ha Th` agb W fb b habf cbVbf `` W
:Tc gh b 0 ha a i e WhV Wb W 8aZ W f` ahl T ?Z a T ce f za Teg e T ` ageTf dh a fh] gbf dh
e TUfbeV za ghUh Te W fbW b l TZhT Th` agTaWb Tfx T ab ch W a fhce ` e T Ybe`TV za W 8aZ W `Ta eT
kVe V za e aT W fbW b l TZhT < e fh gTWb a gb f TW VhTWT a e fch fgT T kV fb W fbW b ` f`b
` a ` mTe Th` agb a ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l Th` agb W fbW b T aZ fgT [TV dh T ce f za
T ce f za Teg e T dh W bgeb `bWb bVhee exT VhTaWb Teg e T f i [TfgT a -( `` ?Z Gbe b gTagb
Th` agT T aZ fgT W fbW b :Tcxgh b )1
Gbe VbageTe b VhTaWb T aZ fgT W fbW b W f` ahl cbe W UT]b < hfb W Yte`TVbf cTeT U bdh Te bf Y Vgbf W T 8aZ
W b abe`T bf a i f iTWbf W 8aZ cebibVTa e g aV za W [T W `bfgeTWb f e V xa VT` ag `cbegTag cTeT ` ]beTe T
fbW b l TZhT l f bcba a T Tf e WhVV ba f W T ce f za Teg e T dh VTcTV WTW W bf e yba f cTeT kVe gTe fT l TZhT :hTaWb T
W bgeb `bWb f cebWhV exTa Gbe gTagb bf VT`U bf a T TVg i WTW W Ybe`TV za W 8aZ f U bdh T Vba ha a[ U Wbe W T am `T
f fg `T e a aT%TaZ bg af aT TVg Ta Vb`b ha cbg ag e Zh TWbe W T Vbai eg WbeT W TaZ bg af aT <:8" i e9VTa N (0 ( l (."
kVe V za W fbW b l Vb`b ha T`c Y VTWbe W ` VTa f`b W b ha TagTZba fgT W e V cgbe W 8aZ T VheiT W
aTge he f f cbe ce f za cTeT `Tag a e fgTU f Tf ce f ba f aTge he f f W ce f za e aT f W fc TmT T ce f ba f `tf
fTaZhxa Tf l bf ib ` a f W Y h Wbf VbecbeT f UT]Tf b dh aW VT haT `Tlbe VTcTV WTW W bf e yba f cTeT
kVe gTe fbW b cbedh T[beT f ch W a `Tag a e a i f
Y [ N PVN QR X[ PNYOV[ R XN N TV[ R V N R XN abe`T f W kVe V za W fbW b Vba ce f ba f Teg e T f
RTaXNPVq QRX R]aVXVO V[ QR [QV[ d XN NX R NPVq QR XN e WhV WTf <fg W fc TmT` agb W T aTge he f f cbe ce f za
N Va R V [ R Vq CT `cbegTaV T W 8aZ cTeT e Zh Te cebcbeV baT T UTf cTeT bf Y Vgbf [ cbg afbe f Veza Vbf W
dh Ue b W fbW b l [TV e dh ` VTa f`b W aTge he f f bf a[ U Wbe f W T <:8 l bf TagTZba fgTf W e V cgbe W
cbe ce f za f T `tf Y Vg ib f `h fgeT a 9VTa N (0 ( 8aZ a cTV ag f [ c eg afbf
+1/
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
+10
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
HA GI
kgeTV h Te ; fchwf W iTe bf WxTf W aYhf za W 8;?
cebZe f ibf a T aZ fgT W fbW b a T W gT :b`b f f yT z
ib h` a W fTaZe l ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f iTa
ab `tf W - T )( l T ce f za Teg e T gT`U wa f iT Tag e be` ag bf e yba f g a a haT VTcTV WTW Tfb`UebfT cTeT
` abf W )( `` ?Z Cb ` f`b f V egb cTeT bf cTV ag f Vba ZhT Te fh kVe V za W fT l TZhT Vba T aZ fgT dh ch W iTe Te
fxaWeb` W 8;? aTW VhTWb a dh bf a i f W 8;? W fW gTa fb b haT WwV `T cTeg W b abe`T [TfgT gTa T gb Vb`b )(
ch W a iTef iTe Tf i V f i V f b abe`T
Gbe b gTagb bf a i f T gbf W 8;? ab VThfTa Th` agbf
`cbegTag f W ib h` a W xdh Wb VbecbeT b W T ce f za Teg e T N V TR N NX N QR [QV[ a VYR X[ V RYN N V N Va n VP[ d NP VbN
Thadh Cbf a i f T gbf W 8;? ch W a VThfTe e WhVV ba f f i eTf X[ V RYN N Va n VP[ 8 ` W WT dh Th` agT T aZ fgT W fbW b T
a T VbaV ageTV za W ba f W fbW b kgeTV h Te CT eTmza W fgb
cebWhVV za W fbW b a V T ` ag f e geTfT Z eT` ag Vba e fc Vgb T T
f dh Th` agb W T e TUfbeV za W TZhT cbe bf e yba f W hl
aZ fgT < e geTfb W g `cb WT Vb`b e fh gTWb ha c dh yb Th` agb a
fbW b kgeTV h Te l T ` f`b g `cb c dh yb Th` agb W T
UT TaV W fbW b TVh`h Tg ib b dh cebibVT ha Z eb Th` agb a
ce f za Teg e T dh f cebWhV cebibVT T cweW WT W fbW b W xdh Wb
ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te <f ce aV cT ` ag fg c dh yb Th` agb
kgeTV h Te a T be aT T geTiwf W T aTge he f f T ce f za
a ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te b dh W f aVTW aT iTe bf
<a cTV ag f dh [Ta c eW Wb fh VTcTV WTW cTeT f Ve gTe 8;?
W U Wb T T W fgehVV za W bf a V bf fhceTzcg Vbf ib h` a W ` VTa f`bf a Vh ecb cTeT Th` agTe T kVe V za W fbW b <fgbf
+11
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
4KBE IB H 8A 78 F4A:E8 K IB H 8A 78
iDH 7B 8JGE468 H 4E 64HF47B CBE 6BA7 6 BA8F DH8 64HF4A :E4A78F
8A98E 87478F 64E7i464F 4H 8AGBF 8A 8 IB H 8A 78 iDH 7B
8JGE468 H 4E 6BA IB H 8A 78 F4A:E8
<a c efbaTf Vba afhY V aV T VTeWxTVT VbaZ fg iT ib h` a
ABE 4 B E87H6 7B
W fTaZe ch W Th` agTe age ha )- l ha ( l
ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te T i V f Th` agT a ha (( <a iTe Tf VbaW V ba f ib h` a W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te Th` agT
b `tf CT eTmza W fgbf Th` agbf ch W ag aW ef abgTU ` ag c eb ib h` a fTaZhxa b c e`Ta V abe`T b
e kT` aTaWb9VTa N (+ a V T ` ag T afhY V aV T aV hfb f e WhV Z eT` ag <fgTf TY VV ba f Z a eT ` ag f
VTeWxTVT e WhV ZTfgb VTeWxTVb l a Vbaf Vh aV T a V Ta cbe T YhZT W xdh Wb l cebg xaTf [TV T ag efg V b b dh
W f` ahl T ce f za Teg e T <fg Y Vgb T fh i m TVg iT g aW T W f` ah e ib h` a W fTaZe CT e fch fgT W bf
` g c f f fg `Tf W e g aV za W fbW b fc V T ` ag e yba f T fgTf TY VV ba f f f ` Te T T e fch fgT W fchwf W
f fg `T e a aT%TaZ bg af aT%T Wbfg ebaT I88J" l f fg `T haT [ `beeTZ T f W V e bf e yba f e g a a fT l TZhT a ha
a ei bfb f `ctg Vb 8W `tf T ce f za Teg e T UT]T a fx ag agb W e fgTheTe ib h` a fTaZhxa b [TV T T abe`T WTW
` f`T [TV dh bf e yba f e g aZTa fT l TZhT Gbe b gTagb J a `UTeZb ZeTa cTeg W kV fb W xdh Wb f Y geT [TV T
bf e yba f e g a a ib h` a a ha ag agb W W ib i e T ag efg V b l cebibVT `tf W `T
ce f za Teg e T l ZTfgb VTeWxTVb T a i f abe`T f
J T afhY V aV T VTeWxTVT ab f W `Tf TWb ZeTi Th` agb a
FiA7EB 8 A89EBG 6B1 ChE7 74 78
ib h` a W fTaZe T ` ahWb ch W W ib i e ZTfgb VTeWxTVb l T
CEBG8iA4F 78 C 4F 4 8A 4 BE A4 K
ce f za Teg e T cetVg VT` ag [TfgT T abe`T WTW l T kVe V za W
E8G8A6 A 78 FB7 B CBE BF E jBA8F
fbW b i aghT ` ag ib i et T T abe`T WTW Thadh ib h` a W
xdh Wb kgeTV h Te l ib h` a W fTaZe Th` agTet `Tag a e Cbf ` VTa f`bf Z a eT f dh VbaWhV a T W `T kgeTV h Te f
VbeTmza W U gTWb Ub`U TaWb TW VhTWT` ag J a `UTeZb f e i fTa a :Tc gh b - LaT VThfT V xa VT `cbegTag W W `T f
VbeTmza fgt `hl W U gTWb f cbf U dh T ce f za Teg e T ab fxaWeb` a Yezg Vb <a fxaWeb` a Yezg Vb bf VTc Te f
ch WT Th` agTe b fhY V ag Vb`b cTeT e fgTheTe T cebWhVV za W Z b` eh Te f c eW a ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W cebg xaT a Y geTWb l T
be aT T T abe`T WTW :hTaWb bVhee fgT f ghTV za bf e yba f be aT W U Wb T Th` agb W T c e` TU WTW W bf VTc Te f
Vbag a Ta e g a aWb ib h` a [TfgT dh f W fTeeb T haT VbaZ fg za Z b` eh Te f J ch W a c eW e W ge agT T -( ZeT`bf W cebg xaT
V eVh Tgbe T f i eT l T c efbaT ch W i aghT ` ag `be e W W `T c Tf`tg VT a T be aT VTWT WxT b dh T i V f [TV dh T
ch `baTe T ` abf dh f gb` a ` W WTf Vbee Vg iTf VbaV ageTV za W cebg xaT c Tf`tg VT VT ZT T ` abf W ha g eV b W b
<a T afhY V aV T ` bVteW VT Tf iT ih bcTgxTf VTeWxTVTf l Tf abe`T l e WhmVT T ce f za bf`zg VT Vb b WT c Tf`tg VT T a i f
Tab`T xTf VbaZwa gTf W VbeTmza Th` agb W ib h` a UT]bf <fg Y Vgb [TV dh bf VTc Te f W gbWb Vh ecb Y ge a
fTaZhxa b f ei Vb`b haT Vb`c afTV za V eVh Tgbe T `cbegTag ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W xdh Wb a bf W i efbf g ] Wbf b dh T fh i m
dh TlhWT T dh ZTfgb VTeWxTVb l T ce f za Teg e T ih iTa T cebibVT W `T l W f` ahl ib h` a W c Tf`T
iT be f abe`T f <fgT Vb`c afTV za c e` g dh aV hfb CT e g aV za e aT W fbW b a fxaWeb` a Yezg Vb f
VbeTmza W U gTWb `Tag aZT ha a i i gT W ZTfgb VTeWxTVb cebWhV T geTiwf W ` g c f ` VTa f`bf TVg iTWbf cbe T YhZT
W cebg xaTf l xdh Wb W c Tf`T T xdh Wb ag efg V T aV h WT T
fg `h TV za W iTe bf f fg `Tf W e g aV za W fbW b Vb`b
4KBE IB H 8A 78 F4A:E8 64HF47B
I88J l f fg `T a ei bfb f `ctg Vb Cbf e yba f Vbag a Ta
CBE 4KBE 64C46 747 I4F6H 4E
e g a aWb fbW b l TZhT [TfgT dh ib h` a c Tf`tg Vb f
:hT dh e VbaW V za dh Th` ag T VTcTV WTW iTfVh Te gT`U wa [Tet dh e fgTU V VTf T T abe`T WTW J a `UTeZb W U Wb T T ZeTa
ib h` a W fTaZe Th` ag cTeT aTe fgT VTcTV WTW TW V baT La VTag WTW W e g aV za W fbW b l TZhT T VbaV ageTV za W
Th` agb W T VTcTV WTW iTfVh Te e WhV a V T ` ag T ce f za ` W T W cebg xaT c Tf`tg VT f W hl T a `tf b dh [TV dh f Y ge
aTWb V eVh Tgbe b i e9VTa N (+ " b dh VbaWhV T haT W f` ahV za T a `tf xdh Wb T bf g ] Wbf W Vh ecb < e fh gTWb a gb f haT
W ZTfgb VTeWxTVb l haT W f` ahV za W T ce f za Teg e T CT VTxWT W T e g aV za `Tf iT W xdh Wbf cbe bf e yba f [TfgT dh f cebWhV
ce f za cebibVT T e g aV za W TZhT l fT a bf e yba f [TfgT dh ha W `T kgeTV h Te ge ` aWb T ` abf dh f afg ghlT ha
ib h` a W fTaZe Th` agT b fhY V ag Vb`b cTeT aTe T VTcTV WTW geTgT` agb cTeT e fgTheTe Tf cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf
kgeT
,((
6N o aX[ I Zh TV za e aT W cbgTf b VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b
HA GI
<aZ A D W +//2 )1., ()/
cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf f W U T T W fgehVV za W Tf Vw h Tf
= eev J ?b aW ebc A> 9 aW f IA2 D VTa f`bf W W g VV za
[ ctg VTf b dh e WhV T VTcTV WTW W [xZTWb cTeT f ag g mTe
`c VTWbf a :T l DZ [b` bfgTf f B Wa l ag 0 2 ))-/ ()
fhY V ag f cebg xaTf c Tf`tg VTf CT V eebf f gT`U wa f TfbV T >hlgba 8:2 Vbageb W T ce f za Teg e T 2 YhaV za fc V T W bf e yba f l bf
Vba ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W g ] Wb Y Uebfb a T fgehVgheT W Y h Wbf VbecbeT f JV aV - 2 )0)+ )11)
[xZTWb b dh `c W a ZeTa ` W WT Y h]b W fTaZe cbegT T ?T A<2 < e yza T [ c eg af za l T bU f WTW ? c eg af za ,)2 . -
geTiwf W [xZTWb <fgT `c WTaV T T fh i m Th` agT T ce f za ((+
?T A< Wb :Te`b AD WT J iT 88 NTaZ P ?T D<2 FU f WTW
VTc Te a gbWb V[b iTfVh Te cbegT b dh gT`U wa Vbage Uhl
W fYhaV za e aT [ c eg af za2 ixaVh bf ` VTa V fgTf ETghe
T T YhZT W xdh Wb l cebg xaTf [TV T T VTi WTW c e gba T haT I i jf E c[eb bZl )-2 +./ ()1
VbaW V za T`TWTTfV g f ?T A< >eTaZ e AG Wb :Te`b AD g T 2 ? c eg af za2 Y f b bZxT l
LaT i m dh f c eW a xdh Wbf l cebg xaTf W T V eVh TV za Tf Y f bcTgb bZxT :b`ce G[lf b 2 +1+ ()
e fch fgTf e aT f fba f ` Te f T Tf bUf eiTWTf a bgeTf TY VV ba f ? U eg J: ; f e > > U fV[ > NTaZ N2 W i ef WTW `b Vh Te l
e Zh TV za W bf VTaT f e aT f W cbgTf b G[lf b I i 0-2 +)1
TfbV TWTf Vba T W f` ahV za W ib h` a c Tf`tg Vb <f W V e bf
((- BT` BJ JV[e U e D ?T c e a DC2 = f b bZxT e aT W cbgTf b2
e yba f Vbag a Ta e g a aWb fT l TZhT [TfgT dh ib h` a ag ZeTV za W T e fch fgT e aT T TZbgT` agb W cbgTf b a T
c Tf`tg Vb l T ce f za Teg e T f e fgTU V a T T abe`T WTW <a W gT I yza ag 1+2,) ()0
T Zhabf VTfbf ib h` a c Tf`tg Vb ch W Th` agTe cbe aV `T W DV;babhZ[ 88 Obha A?2 ?b` bfgTf f W cbgTf b2 b VbabV Wb b
W fVbabV Wb l bf U a Y V bf cTeT T fT hW = f b bZxT 9 g[ fWT" + 2 )((
b abe`T W U Wb T Th` agb W T VTcTV WTW iTfVh Te a T V eebf f3 Tf
()/ Db JD2 ?b` bfgTf f W VT V b a T fT hW l a T aY e` WTW e aT
T gTf ce f ba f a T V eVh TV za cbegT ch W a W TgTe a ZeTa ` W WT
:b`ce G[lf b .2 )/0) ().
Tf i aTf l cbe b gTagb Th` agTe T VTcTV WTW iTfVh Te Dh af N M eUehZZ =? E ]fg G KTaZ N?N2 Ti W m e aT W fbW b a T
afhY V aV T VTeWxTVT2 W T Y f bcTgb bZxT T Tf fgeTg Z Tf W
geTgT` agb <he ? Teg A +02 )0/ ()/
9 U bZeTYxT GT ` e 9=2 I Zh TV za W T [b` bfgTf f W cbgTf b : a A 8` JbV
E c[eb )(2 )(-( ()-
8 kTaW e IK :beWTg < :[T`Ue l I ; ` ? < TWTe ;2 8V Wbf f Ibff e 9: 9T e D< JghW e I82 KeTafcbeg W fbW b c g T l fh
l VT V b he aTe b A 8` JbV E c[eb /2 +-)) (). Vbageb cbe T T Wbfg ebaT2 T [ fgbe T W ah fgeb agbeab ag eab
8ebafba GJ > U fV[ >2 <Y Vgbf W c? fbUe cbgTf b2 ah iTf e i fTWT G[lf b I i 1-2 1/ ()-
kc VTV ba f cTeT Tag ZhTf bUf eiTV ba f A 8` JbV E c[eb 2 JgTehfV[ a b 82 <Y Vgbf U a Y V bfbf W cbgTf b iTWb2 Vbage UhV za W
)10) ()) 9 U e A Dhe e ? Db[ UU E NTZa e :82 DTa ]b e aT W bf VTaT f W B UTfb Tg eT f e aT f ? c eg af za /)2 )()- ()0
YbfYTgb l fh YTgb :b`ce G[lf b ,2 //) (), N[ gba GB 8cc CA JTVVb IC g T 2 JbW b ce f za Teg e T l aY e` WTW
9 G2 cwcg Wbf aTge hewg Vbf l e Zh TV za abe`T W bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f :b`ce VTeW biTfVh Te2 `tf i W aV T dh e fcT WT Tf e Vb` aWTV ba f W
G[lf b 02 ) )) ()0 e WhVV za W fbW b W T 8` e VTa ? Teg 8ffbV Tg ba : eVh TV za ) .2
9 T a A :[baV[b D C i D2 :bageb e aT W T [b` bfgTf f W 00( ()
VT V b YbfYTgb l `TZa f b : a A 8` JbV E c[eb )(2 ) -/ ObhaZ ;92 8at f f VhTag gTg ib W cTc W T T Wbfg ebaT a T e Zh TV za
()- W cbgTf b 8` A G[lf b --2 =0)) )100
:bj l 8N Ae2 Vbageb T TeZb c Tmb W T ce f za Teg e T G[lf b I i
/ 2 +) )11
,()
64CiGH B (
HA GI
ERTaXNPVq mPVQ[ ON R
,(+
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
,(,
6N o aX[ ( I Zh TV za tV Wb%UTf
W tV Wbf cebWhV Wbf cbe Vh ecb VTWT WxT 8cebk `TWT` ag ?:F +% cTeT Ybe`Te tV Wb `hl WwU ? :F+ dh T fh i m
0( ` dh iT ag f W ? f aZ e Wb b cebWhV Wb VTWT WxT cbe Ybe`Tf :F l ? F < kV fb W :F fg `h T abe` ` ag
` gTUb f`b ` ageTf dh ? CT VbaV ageTV za W bf Y h Wbf e fc eTV za dh ` aT :F W xdh Wb
VbecbeT f abe`T ` ag f W Tcebk `TWT` ag ( ((((, `<d kgeTV h Te
C J a T`beg ZhTV za T cebWhVV za aZ fg za W Te T W tV Wbf CTf e TVV ba f bch fgTf g a a hZTe VhTaWb f TZe ZT haT
VThfTexT VT`U bf gT f a bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f ? UTf Yh eg Vb`b [ Wezk Wb W fbW b ETF?" T T fb hV za
HA GI
VbaV ageTV za gT`cza W U VTeUbaTgb
CT TVV za W bf T`beg ZhTWbe f tV Wb%UTf dh mtf f ch WT ETF? ? :F+ ET?:F+ ?F
kc VTe ` ]be f f Vbaf W eT f fg `T T`beg ZhTWbe dh f
VhTag gTg iT` ag `tf `cbegTag a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te2 <a fg VTfb F?% W ETF? f Vb`U aT Vba
f fg `T T`beg ZhTWbe W U VTeUbaTgb ? :F+ cTeT Ybe`Te ?:F TW V baT % 8fx T UTf WwU
+
ET?:F+ e `c TmT T UTf Yh eg ETF? 8 ` f`b g `cb T
VbaV ageTV za W ? :F+ W f` ahl cbedh e TVV baT Vba
F FG8 4 78 4 BEG :H47BE 78 5 64E5BA4GB
ETF?" cebibVTaWb `tf :F cTeT Vb`U aTe Vba ? F cTeT
< f fg `T gT`cza W U VTeUbaTgb VbafgT W haT fb hV za W TZhT e `c TmTe T ? :F+2
dh Vbag a Wbf aZe W ag f2 )" ha tV Wb WwU ? :F+3 l
" haT fT W U VTeUbaTgb Vb`b U VTeUbaTgb W fbW b :F ? F nn ? :F+ nn ?:F +% ?
ET?:F+"
? :F+ f Ybe`T a Vh ecb cbe T e TVV za W :F ETF? E 8
Vba ? F2 :TeUza Vb
:F ?F n n n n n ne n `
nn
Ta[ Web Vb`b
? :F+ < e fh gTWb a gb cbe b gTagb f haT g aW aV T cTeT :F
a i f a T fTaZe cTeT W f` ah e c eb T W f` ahV za W :F
<fgT e TVV za f agT l a VTag WTW f kge `TWT` ag c dh yTf a T fTaZe a[ U T e fc eTV za l W f` ahl T gTfT W
W ? :F+ f Ybe`Ta T ` abf dh T am `T Ta[xWe Wb VTeUza Vb :F i aV ` agb < Th` agb W ?:F a fTaZe +% VbaV ageTV za
fgt ce f ag <fgT am `T f fc V T ` ag TUhaWTag a dh bVhee f Vb`c afT Vba Th` agb W T kVe V za
Tf cTe W f W bf T iwb bf ch `baTe f WbaW :F a TamT` agb3 CT e aT W ?:F+%
Ta[ WeTfT VTeUza VT gT`U wa fgt ce f ag a Tf Vw h Tf c g T fW
bf g Uh bf e aT f WbaW :F e TVV baT Vba ? F cTeT Ybe`Te ? 7V mYVPN PaN V N VbN QRX V RYN NY q QR OVPN O[ N [
:F+ KbWbf bf tV Wbf aV h Wb ? :F+ fgta ba mTWbf [TfgT V egb chagb 8
? :F+ ba mT WwU ` ag cTeT Ybe`Te c dh yTf VTag WTW f W ? cTeg e W Vbaf W eTV ba f W UT TaV W `TfT Tf VbaV ageTV ba f W
l ?:F % +2 ? l ?:F % + fba cebcbeV baT f T T VbaV ageTV za W
? :F+ nn n ? ?:F %+ ? :F+2
? :F + nn n ? ?:F %+
< f ZhaWb Vb`cba ag W f fg `T T fT W U VTeUbaTgb
bVhee ce Wb` aTag ` ag Vb`b ET?:F+ a b kgeTV h Te GTeT VhT dh e tV Wb T VbaV ageTV za W tV Wb a e TV za Vba
fhf ba f W fbV TWbf f W Y a cbe T VbafgTag W W fbV TV za B
xdh Wb ET?:F+ ba mT VTf cbe Vb`c gb cTeT Ybe`Te ?:F % +
l ET Vb`b f Zh 2 ? s?:F %+
B 5
ET?:F +n nn E 8 ?:F +% ? :F+ )"
8[beT ]hagTaWb gbWb f fg `T g a `bf T <fgT VhTV za aW VT dh a haT ? :F+ fb hV za T
f Zh ag 2 VTag WTW W ? Ue f ZhT T
? :F+
:F ?F nn ? :F+ nnn ? ?:F +% ? 5B s
nn ?:F +% "
E 8
CT VbaV ageTV za W ? ab W fbV TWb :F+ ab f ch W
` W e a fb hV za cbedh f W fbV T etc WT` ag
; U Wb T T WwU W fbV TV za W ? :F+ < [ a :F l ? F b a ? l ?:F % + f a `UTeZb
T VbaV ageTV za f kge `TWT` ag UT]T :F W fh gb a T fTaZe f W e VgT` ag cebcbeV baT T T
:hTaWb f TZe ZT ha tV Wb Yh eg Vb`b ?: T T fb hV za VTag WTW W ? ab W fbV TWb :F+ Gbe b gTagb <VhTV za ch W a
gT`cza W U VTeUbaTgb Th` agb W ? U eTWb W tV Wb f ee fVe gb W T f Zh ag `Ta eT2
,(-
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
<VhTV za + fgt fVe gb a gwe` abf W T VTag WTW gbgT W e yba f ` ageTf dh GVb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te fgt
:F W fh gb a fb hV za J a `UTeZb T `TlbexT W bf Vbageb TWb cbe T Ye Vh aV T e fc eTgbe T 8 Th` agTe T gTfT
TUbeTgbe bf V xa Vbf ` W a :F a fTaZe g af za GVb " a W T e fc eTV za bf ch `ba f ` aTa :F W c Tf`T
hZTe W T VTag WTW e T W :F 8YbeghaTWT` ag T VTag WTW l T W f` ah e T e fc eTV za bf ch `ba f iTa T GVb
W :F a T fTaZe f haT YhaV za a T W GVb `h g c VTWb cbe I fh gTWbf Y f b zZ Vbf abe`T f W T [b` bfgTf f tV Wb%UTf
Vb Y V ag W fb hU WTW W :F 3 UT]b Y f % W bf fYh embf VbbeW aTWbf gTagb W bf ch `ba f Vb`b W bf
VbaW V ba f Vb zZ VTf Vb Y V ag W fb hU WTW W :F f e yba f l bf geTfgbeabf TV WbUtf Vbf bVhee a VhTaWb hab b T`Ubf W
( (+ ``b `` ?Z T g `c eTgheT VbecbeT <fgb f Za Y VT fgbf ` VTa f`bf W Vbageb fgta T g eTWbf T g eTaWb Tfx
dh ( (+ ` `b f W ? :F+ fgt ce f ag a T fTaZe WheTag lT f T ?:F % + VbaV ageTV za b GVb W kgeTV h Te
VTWT `` ?Z GVb D W Wb Gbe b gTagb <VhTV za + f ch W xdh Wb
e fVe U e Vb`b :hTaWb Tf T g eTV ba f W dh Ue b tV Wb%UTf e fh gTa W
ha VT`U b ce `Te b a ?:F W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te %+ VbaV ageT%
( (+sGVb" V za f f VbabV Vb`b ` gTUz Vb geTfgbeabf TV WbUtf Vbf Gbe
? 5Bs
?:F +% ," gTagb T TV Wbf f VThfTWT cbe haT W f` ahV za ce `Te T W ?:F% +
T VbaV ageTV za f W ab` aT TV Wbf f ` gTUz VT ` ageTf dh T VT%
8PaNPVq QR ;R QR [ ;N RXONXPU :b`b f W fVhg z Tag e be` ag cweW WT VThfTWT cbe ha Th` agb ce `Te b W ?:F % + VbaV ageT%
f Vbfgh`Ue kce fTe T ? VbaV ageTV za a ha WTW f W c? a TV za f T`T T VT bf f ` gTUz VT 8V Wbf f VThfTWT cbe haT
hZTe W VbaV ageTV ba f e T f I Vh eW dh c? 5 CT Th` agb W GVb f T`T TV Wbf f e fc eTgbe T ` ageTf dh
VbafgTag W W fbV TV za cB" f ch W kce fTe W `Ta eT T VT bf f VThfTWT cbe haT W f` ahV za W GVb f W ab` aT T VT bf f
f ` Te e fc eTgbe T
6a bN QR bNX[ NPVq QRX V RYN QR NY q QR OVPN O[ N [ 9VTa N
cB 5 B
( ( `h fgeT bf VT`U bf a c? W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
Gbe gTagb cbW `bf kce fTe T ? VbaV ageTV za a VhTaWb T cebcbeV za W ?:F %+ cTeT Vb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f T %
<VhTV za , a ha WTW f W c? gb`TaWb bZTe g`b a ZTg ib W g e W :hTaWb Tf VbaV ageTV ba f W fgbf Wbf Vb`cba ag f
fT VhTV za b dh Teeb]T b f Zh ag 2 fba ZhT f T cTeg W e V[T W <VhTV za 0 f Vbai eg a
bZTe g`b W ) dh f ZhT T ( Gbe b gTagb VhTaWb bf Wbf
( (+sGVb " Vb`cba ag f W f fg `T gT`cza fba ZhT f c? W T
% bZ ? 5 % bZ cB % bZ
?:F+% fb hV za f ` f`b dh cB . )" W f fg `T gT`cza W
-" U VTeUbaTgb :hTaWb f TZe ZT UTf T f fg `T cTeg W
:F W fh gb f Vbai eg a ?:F % + VThfTaWb ha
Gbe b gTagb Th` agb a T cebcbeV za W ?:F %+ cTeT Vb l Th` agTaWb
( (+ s GVb " c? Vb`b f W fce aW W T VhTV za W ? aW efba%?Tff UT V[
c? 5 cB bZ VhT f
?:F+%
V za :hTaWb f TZe ZT tV Wb f T`beg ZhT Vba ?:F% +
." h Zb f Vbai eg a :F W fh gb W f` ahl aWb T e TV za
W ?:F+% cTeT Vb l W f` ah e c? W kgeTV h Te
<a hZTe W geTUT]Te Vba ha bZTe g`b a ZTg ib cbW `bf
Y h Wb h Te
VT`U Te f Zab W bZTe g`b ai eg e ah` eTWbe l
C[ R PVN QR XN [XaPVq NY[ VTaNQ[ N QR R YV NQN [ XN PN VQNQ d XN P[ PR NPV[ R
W ab` aTWbe a g `b gwe` ab hfTaWb T lW bZTe g`b
RXN VbN QR X[ P[Y [ R R QR XN [XaPVq NY[ VTaNQ[ N ; T g gh TV za
e g`bf cTeT cebWhV e b f Zh ag 2
VheiT a 9VTa N ( ( iTe bf chagbf fba i W ag f Ge ` eb
?:F+ c? W f fg `T f ` f`b dh cB VhTaWb VTWT
c? 5 cB bZ
( (+ s GVb " W bf Vb`cba ag f ?:F % + l Vb`cTyxT " Vbafg ghl -(
/"
W T VbaV ageTV za gbgT W f fg `T gT`cza <a f ZhaWb hZTe
GTeT f fg `T gT`cza W U VTeUbaTgb cB f . ) l f fg `T W T`beg ZhTV za f `tf Y VTm a T cTeg V ageT W
<VhTV za / f ch W fVe U e W T f Zh ag `Ta eT2
?:F +% ( )((
c? 5 . ) bZ A[ YNX
( (+sGVb 0" [ R N Q[
N R QR OrSR R S[ YN QR
N R QR OrSR R S[ YN QR
a [ R RX PaR [
<VhTV za 0 f T VhTV za W ? aW efba%?Tff UT V[ l - /-
Vba T f ch W VT Vh Te c? W haT fb hV za f `b Te
5N R NT RTNQN
gPVQ[ NT RTNQ[
;)6B [ 6B)
C[ PR
,(.
6N o aX[ ( I Zh TV za tV Wb%UTf
T VheiT WbaW c? fgt V eVT W cB W f fg `T <fg Y az` ab < f fg `T gT`cza W YbfYTgb g a ha cB W . 0 dh ab fgt
f Za Y VT dh VT`U b W c? cTeT VhT dh e VTag WTW WTWT W tV Wb b ]bf W c? abe`T W / , a bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f c e` g dh
UTf TyTW WT T f fg `T f ` abe VhTaWb c? fgt V eVT W cB W f fg `T YhaV ba V eVT W fh `tk `b cbW e gT`cza J a
f fg `T < f fg `T gT`cza f Zh f aWb eTmbaTU ` ag Y VTm cTeT
`UTeZb fh VbaV ageTV za a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f UT]T fb b
) ( ha WTW f W c? T VTWT TWb W cB dh cTeT f fg `T gT`cza W
T e W Wbe W 0 W T VbaV ageTV za W gT`cza W U VTeUbaTgb
U VTeUbaTgb f kg aW W fW ha c? W Tcebk `TWT` ag - ) T / )
Gbe b gTagb cbW e T`beg ZhTWbe gbgT W f fg `T W YbfYTgb a
HA GI
ha WTW f Dtf T t W fgbf x` g f cbW e T`beg ZhTWbe W f` ahl
xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f `hV[b ` abe dh W f fg `T
etc WT` ag O VhTaWb
gbWb :F f [T Vbai eg Wb a ?:F % + b VhTaWb gbWbf T`beg ZhTWbe W U VTeUbaTgb
?:F % + f [T Vbai eg Wb a :F f fg `T g a <a VbageTfg Vba fh cTc ` abe Vb`b T`beg ZhTWbe kgeTV h Te
kgeTV h Te ch W f e Vbageb TWb Vba ce V f za cbe e Tg ib `tf UT]b dh a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te VT`U T Tcebk `TWT` ag a
gTfT W ` aTV za l TW V za W ?:F % + cbe bf e yba f l cebcbeV za T bf VT`U bf W c? W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
gTfT W ` aTV za W :F cbe bf ch `ba f ?Tl haT Z eT W Yhf za W ? l ?:F % +` W Tag
T ` `UeTaT V h Te Thadh fgbf ba f e dh e a iTe Tf
[beTf cTeT T VTamTe dh Ue b Vba xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
F FG8 4 78 G4C A 78 9BF94GB
kV cgb cbe etc Wb dh Ue b dh f cebWhV a eb]b
8hadh f fg `T gT`cza W YbfYTgb ab f ha gT`cza W xdh Wb Vw h Tf W fTaZe :F f a `UTeZb ch W W YhaW ef etc WT` ag T geTiwf
kgeTV h Te `cbegTag W f `c yT ha cTc `cbegTag a T W gbWTf Tf ` `UeTaTf V h Te f <fgT W Yhf za W bf ` agbf W
gT`cza W xdh Wb ghUh Te e aT l W bf xdh Wbf ageTV h Te f f fg `T gT`cza W U VTeUbaTgb [TV dh c? a
Cbf ce aV cT f ` agbf W f fg `T gT`cza W YbfYTgb fba xdh Wb ageTV h Te VT`U VhTaWb [Tl VT`U bf a c?
, %l
? Vbee bf ?GF 5 , :hTaWb ha tV Wb Yh eg Vb`b ?: kgeTV h Te Gbe fgT eTmza bf f fg `Tf gT`cza W Tf
TyTW Wb T haT ` mV T W fgTf Wbf fhfgTaV Tf [ WezZ ab Vw h Tf TlhWTa T ce i a e VT`U bf a c? W xdh Wb
f TV cgTWb cbe T UTf ?GF ,5 l Vbai eg Wb T ? Vbee bf, %2 kgeTV h Te c eb ch W a gTeWTe iTe Tf [beTf a T VTamTe T
`tk `T Y VTV T
?: ET ?GF, ET? Vbee bf, ET: <a Z zUh b eb]b T [ `bZ bU aT ?U" f ha gT`cza `cbegTag W T
f Zh ag `Ta eT2
< e fh gTWb W fgT e TVV za f dh tV Wb Yh eg ?: f
e `c TmT cbe haT VTag WTW TW V baT W ha tV Wb WwU ? n n n n ??U
D W T c af za
ETF? ET? Vbee bf, E 8 ?GF, ? F ? l ?:F % + `bi ef T geTiwf W Tf ` `UeTaTf V h Te f T ` ahWb
e geTfT T VTcTV WTW `tk `T W Tf cebg xaTf ageTV h Te f cTeT
<a fg VTfb haT UTf Yh eg ETF? f ag eVT`U T cbe haT UTf T`beg ZhTe Tf Tab`T xTf TV WbUtf VTf kgeTV h Te f WheTag iTe Tf
WwU ET ?GF, cebibVTaWb fz b ha Z eb Th` agb W c? [beTf
,(/
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
[ NXR
cebg xaTf fgta UTfgTag V eVT W c? ageTV h Te
( A[ YNX
PNYOV[ QR ; R X[ SXaVQ[ P[
()
C V PV V[ V [UoQ VP[1 [Q[ X[ NY [ R R a N [XaPVq
P[Yr R m R R]aVXVO V[ P[ XN YV YN ;" 6[ PR NPVq (
? `bf fgTWb W fVhg aWb bf f fg `Tf gT`cza Vb`b f bc eTeTa (+
aW i WhT ` ag a bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f J a `UTeZb gbWbf (,
geTUT]Ta ]hagbf cbedh ? f Vb` a T Tf e TVV ba f W gbWbf fgbf
(-
f fg `Tf Gbe b gTagb f `ce dh [TlT ha VT`U b a ?
(- )( )- ( -
VbaV ageTV za a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te dh Ue b W gbWbf bf
GN N QR bR VXNPVq NXbR[XN
f fg `Tf gT`cza VT`U T T ` f`b g `cb <fg Y az` ab f T`T
[ YNX 3 (
ce aV c b fb[xWe Vb l fgt hfgeTWb cbe T f Zh ag
9VTa N ( ) :T`U b a c? W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te VThfTWb cbe ha Th` agb b
Yze`h T UT]T2
W f` ahV za W T gTfT W i ag TV za T i b Te kce fTWT Vb`b i V f b abe`T
? 5 B) s
;<: I 8?) ;<: I 8? ;<: I 8?+
5Bs 5 B +s
8) 8 8+
4H 8AG4E 4 I8AG 46 A 4 I8B 4E
B) B l B+ fba Tf VbafgTag f W W fbV TV za W ge f 7 F AHK8 8 9 H 7B 8JGE468 H 4E ;"
e fc Vg ibf tV Wbf ?8) ?8 ?8+ O 8) 8 8+ fba Tf 6BA68AGE46 A K 4H 8AG4 8 C;
VbaV ageTV ba f W bf ba f a ZTg ibf Ue f dh Vbafg ghl a
J T Ybe`TV za ` gTUz VT W :F c e`Ta V VbafgTag
UTf f W bf ge f f fg `Tf gT`cza
a Vb bgeb YTVgbe dh TY VgT T T GVb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te f
CT `c VTV za W fg ce aV c b f dh VhT dh e VbaW V za dh
T gTfT W i ag TV za T i b Te :hTagb `Tlbe f T T i b Te
VT`U dh Ue b W hab W bf f fg `Tf W T`beg ZhTV za gT`U wa
VT`U T dh Ue b W gbWbf bf W `tf cbedh bf f fg `Tf W i ag TV za ` abe f T GVb :b`b f W fVhg z Tag e be` ag
T`beg ZhTV za a e T WTW f T`beg ZhTa age fx VT`U TaWb ? WT l VhTaWb :F T VbaV ageTV za Th` agT T ? :F+ VbaV ageTV za l ?
ih gT age bf CT VbaV ageTV za gT`U wa Th` agT cbe b gTagb UT]T
eeTe c? W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
9VTa N ( ) `h fgeT bf VT`U bf Tcebk `TWbf a c? fTaZhxa b
E8:H 46 A E8FC E4GBE 4 78
VThfTWbf cbe Th` agb b T W f` ahV za W T gTfT W i ag TV za
8DH 5E B g6 7B 54F8
T i b Te K aZT a Vh agT dh Th` agb W T i ag TV za T i b Te T
CT f ZhaWT xa T W W Y afT VbageT bf W fgheU bf tV Wb%UTf Tcebk `TWT` ag WbU W b abe`T Th` agT c? W xdh Wb
UTaV f f Vbageb W :F xdh Wb kgeTV h Te VbaV ageTV za kgeTV h Te a Tcebk `TWT` ag ( + J c? W bf Y h Wbf
cbe bf ch `ba f La Th` agb W T i ag TV za ` aT :F VbecbeT f f / ,( Vba i ag TV za T i b Te abe`T Whc VTe T gTfT W
W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te dh cbe TVV za `Tf iT e WhV i ag TV za iT c? T Tcebk `TWT` ag / .+ Gbe VbageTe b haT
< [ VbaV ageTV za Gbe VbageTe b W f` ahV za W T i ag TV za W f` ahV za W T i ag TV za T i b Te T ha VhTegb W b abe`T e WhV
Th` agT :F l ? VbaV ageTV ba f a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te c? a ( ,- <f W V e f c? f / , a haT i ag TV za T i b Te
abe`T e WhV e T i ag TV za T ha VhTegb W b abe`T e WhV c? T
. 1- ; U Wb T dh T gTfT W i ag TV za T i b Te ch W VT`U Te
abgTU ` ag W fW ha `xa `b W ( [TfgT ha `tk `b W )- i V f
647H6 747 CH BA4E 78 6B)
iT be abe`T f ch W Vb`ce aW e YtV ` ag Vhtagb ch W VT`U Te
8DH 5E8F 4 9BE 46 A 8G45 64 78 6B)
f fg `T e fc eTgbe b c? W bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f
:F f Ybe`T Vbag ahT` ag a Vh ecb cbe cebV fbf
` gTUz Vbf ageTV h Te f LaT i m Ybe`TWb f W YhaW W fW
Tf Vw h Tf a bf Y h Wbf ag efg V T f l T fTaZe l T fTaZe
4H 8AG ;" 4 6BA68AGE46 A
dh Y hl T geTafcbegT T bf ch `ba f WbaW f W YhaW T bf
8FG H 4 4 I8AG 46 A 4 I8B 4E
T iwb bf l h Zb f geTafY e T T Tg`zfY eT cbe
i ag TV za ch `baTe 8cebk `TWT` ag ) `b C W :F W fh gb Eb fb b T gTfT W i ag TV za T i b Te aY hl a?
f aVh ageT abe`T ` ag a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te Vbee fcbaW ag T ha VbaV ageTV za VT`U TaWb GVb W bf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f c eb
GVb W ,( ``?Z ? CT VbaV ageTV za TY VgT T gTfT W i ag TV za T i b Te
J T gTfT W Ybe`TV za ` gTUz VT W :F Th` agT GVb V za Gbe b gTagb 9VTa N ( `h fgeT dh T gTfT W i ag TV za T i b Te
W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te gT`U wa Th` agT Gbe VbageTe b Th` agT W VhTgeb T V aVb i V f b abe`T T ` W WT dh c? W f` ahl
haT gTfT ` gTUz VT W f` ah WT e WhV T GVb J Th` agT T W iT be abe`T W / , T iT be Yh eg ` ag tV Wb W / ( Gbe VbageTe b
Ye Vh aV T W i ag TV za ch `baTe :F fgt fbc TWb ha Th` agb W c? c Tf`tg Vb cbe aV `T W / , cebibVT haT W f` ahV za
Yh eT W bf ch `ba f l GVb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te a T gTfT W i ag TV za < VT`U b a T gTfT W i ag TV za cbe VT`U b W
W f` ahl Gbe gTagb bf VT`U bf a T i ag TV za ch `baTe b c? ha gTe b f `hV[b `Tlbe T a i f e WhV Wbf W c? Vbee fcbaW ag T
T gTfT W :F CT Ybe`TV za W bf g ] Wbf ch W VT`U Te ai f iTWbf W ? VbaV ageTV za" a Vb`cTeTV za Vba a i f iTWbf
xdh Wb kgeTV h Te GVb W c? CT eTmza W fgb f dh Vb`b
,(0
6N o aX[ ( I Zh TV za tV Wb%UTf
i ag TV za T i b Te e WhV WT
HA GI
C[QR NY[ VTaNQ[ QRX V RYN R V N [ V[ CT e Zh TV za
) e fc eTgbe T W dh Ue b tV Wb%UTf f ha g cb Y f b zZ Vb W
f fg `T gT`cza cbedh TVg T etc WT` ag l `Tag a T? T
IR
,(1
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
,)(
6N o aX[ ( I Zh TV za tV Wb%UTf
HA GI
B ;
;6B ; <a e T WTW xdh Wb kgeTV h Te ab f ` f`b dh
;)6B f Y geT a bf g Uh bf CT e TUfbeV za W Y geTWb
E 8
?:F +% ab e fh gT a T f Ve V za a gT W ? cbedh
;)6B
:TeUza Vb T ? f Ve gTWT f Vb`U aT Vba ?:F Y geTWb %+ l f
Ta[ WeTfT cbe b gTagb ab f kVe gT
;)B
6B)
6B) 6B) ;)B ;6B % FR V aXN P[ N ;" R X[ rOaX[ 9T]b abe%
VbaW V ba f `T T gTfT W ghUh Te ? T f Ve V za f geTgT W
9VTa N ( , J `h fgeTa bf ` VTa f`bf V h Te f cTeT b f Zh ag 2 ,,(( `<d WxT l T gTfT W Y geTV za cbe ?:F +% f fbUe
)" f Ve V za TVg iT W ? a g Uh b e aT 3 " e TUfbeV za ghUh Te ,+ (`<d WxT Gbe gTagb Tf VTag WTW f W fgbf Wbf ba f
W ?:F+%cbe Vb`U aTV za Vba ? cTeT Ybe`Te ? :F+ dh f W fbV T
dh ageTa a bf g Uh bf fba VTf ZhT f l f Vb`U aTa Vba
cTeT Ybe`Te :F l ? F3 l +" ET e TUfbeV za T VT`U b W ?
f Ve gTWb <fg cTgeza W ? T f Ve V za bVhee a g Uh b cebk `T
age fx cTeT Ybe`Te :F l ? F Gbe gTagb f W V dh
f Z` agb TfV aW ag Zeh fb W TfT W ? a l g Uh b W fgT g `ceTab ?:F +% l ? abe`T ` ag f g gh Ta age fx a bf g Uh bf
< cebV fb W g gh TV za ab f W gbWb kTVgb cbedh fh [TU e
ha Z eb kV fb W ? a bf g Uh bf cTeT f e kVe gTWbf a T be aT
cebg xaT geTafcbegTWbeT a UbeW h` aT W T ` `UeTaT
<fg kV fb W ? 0( `<d WxT" U eT T Vh ecb W bf tV Wbf ab
V h Te3 T ` f`b g `cb haT ? a ag e be W Tf Vw h Tf f
ib tg f cebWhV Wbf cbe ` gTUb f`b :b`b f W fVhg et `tf
Vb`U aT Vba T cebg xaT geTafcbegTWbeT <agbaV f ha f `h i
TW Tag T `Tlbe cTeg W fg ? ab f kVe gT Vb`b ? Ue c eb
W ageb W T Vw h T cbe ha ZeTW ag W VbaV ageTV za dh [T f Wb
fgt a Vb`U aTV za Vba bgebf gT`cba f he aTe bf fc V T ` ag
fgTU V Wb cbe ET %B 9b`UT W 8KGTfT a T ` `UeTaT
YbfYTgb l T`baxTVb
UTfb Tg eT < ZeTW ag W ET `bi ` agb W ageb W T Vw h T
:hTaWb [Tl kV fb W ?:F % + fbUe ? a T be aT
cebcbeV baT T a eZxT cTeT `bi e ? a T W e VV za bch fgT
Vb`b bVhee a T T VT bf f ` gTUz VT kV fb W ?:F %+ ch W a%
W fW ag e be W T V WT [TfgT h` a ghUh Te
ab f e e TUfbeU Wb Gbe gTagb kV fb W ?:F+% f W ]T a
< ?:F % +Z a eTWb a T V WT VhTaWb ? W fbV T
bf g Uh bf l Y aT ` ag f kVe gT a T be aT b dh
W fW ? :F+" h Zb f `h i Vh fgT TUT]b T geTiwf W T ` `UeTaT
TlhWT T Vbee Z e T T VT bf f ` gTUz VT
UTfb Tg eT [TV T xdh Wb ag efg V T e aT l c e ghUh Te
<a T TV Wbf f [Tl kV fb W ? e Tg ib T ?:F +% VThf%
fTaZe VTc Te < e fh gTWb a gb f dh cTeT VTWT ? f Ve gTWb
aZ e TUfbeV za Vb`c gT W ?:F % +3 kV fb W ?
a h` a ghUh Te ha ?:F %+ ageT a T fTaZe
cTfT T T be aT a Vb`U aTV za Vba gT`cba f he aTe bf
fc V T ` ag YbfYTgb l T`baxTVb l Y aT ` ag f kVe gT a
;6B 9 GE47B 8F E845FBE5 7B CBE Ybe`T W fT f 8fx ` VTa f`b Utf Vb cbe VhT bf e yba f
AG8E466 A 6BA ;" 8A BF GH5H BF Vbee Z a T TV Wbf f b T VT bf f f haT g gh TV za aVb`c gT
V za W ? VbageT ?:F +% W ]TaWb cTfTe hab h bgeb
Cbf ba f W U VTeUbaTgb ab c a geTa YtV ` ag a T ` `UeTaT h` aT
a T be aT l f ` aTa W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
UeTaTf W Tf Vw h Tf ghUh Te f e aT f3 cbe b gTagb ?:F% + fW Ve
Y geTWb cbe Z b`weh b ab ch W f e e TUfbeU Wb W e VgT` ag
F86E86 A 46G I4 CE 4E 4 78 ;"
<a VT`U b ?:F+ % f e TUfbeU Wb cbe ha cebV fb fc V T a dh
8A 4F 6h H 4F AG8E64 474F 78 Gl5H BF
ce ` eb f Vb`U aT Vba ? cTeT Ybe`Te ? :F+ dh i aghT ` ag
7 FG4 8F G4E7iBF K 6B 86GBE8F
f Vbai eg a :F l ? F Vb`b f `h fgeT a 9VTa N ( ,
<fgT e TUfbeV za W ?:F % + f a V T cbe haT e TVV za :b` amTaWb a bf g Uh bf W fgT f gTeWxbf l Vbag ahTaWb
a bf g Uh bf age ?:F % + Y geTWb a Z b`weh b cbe e fgb W f fg `T ghUh Te c g b ghUh Te f Ve gT
l ? f Ve gTWT cbe Tf Vw h Tf ghUh Te f < [ :F+ Ybe`TWb ? cbe geTafcbeg TVg ib ce `Te b CTf VTeTVg exfg VTf W
h Zb f W fbV T a :F l ? F < :F ch W `bi ef YtV ` ag T fg geTafcbeg fba W Y e ag f W Tf W fVhg WTf cTeT
geTiwf W T ` `UeTaT ghUh Te3 cbe b gTagb afgTagta T` ag g Uh b cebk `T TfT W ? a l g Uh b W fgT g `ceTab
f W YhaW a T Vw h T ghUh Te WbaW f e Vb`U aT Vba
? F UT]b T aY h aV T W T Ta[ WeTfT VTeUza VT cTeT Z a eTe < ` VTa f`b W ? TVg ib ce `Te b T f Ve V za f W fVhg z
eTg haT ah iT ? :F+ `b wVh T <fgT ? :F+ f W fbV T T a :Tc gh b 0 l f `h fgeT a 9VTa N ( - FVhee a T
Ybe`T ?:F+%l ? 3 ?:F% + h Zb f W YhaW T geTiwf W ` `UeTaT h` aT W T Vw h T ghUh Te WbaW ? f
T ` `UeTaT UTfb Tg eT a xdh Wb ag efg V T l f geTafcbegTWb W e VgT` ag cbe cebg xaTf fc VxY VTf ha
e VbZ a T fTaZe VTc Te c e ghUh Te CT geTaf% 8KGTfT geTafcbegTWbeT W [ WezZ ab l ha geTafcbegTWbe W
ch egb W ?:F+ T geTiwf W T ` `UeTaT UTfb Tg eT f YTV gT [ WezZ ab%cbgTf b%8KGTfT CT a eZxT a V fTe T cTeT
gTg W cbe Wbf ` VTa f`bf2 )" ET %?:F %+ Vb%geTafcbeg Ub`U Te ? f W e iT W T W fVb`cbf V za W 8KG a
a bf g Uh bf cebk `T f3 l " : %%?:F % + ag eVT`U b a W YbfYTgb W TW abf aT
,))
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
,)
6N o aX[ ( I Zh TV za tV Wb%UTf
I aT KhUh Te I aT Gebk `T
KhUh Te
ag efg V T :w h Tf ghUh Te f h` a ag efg V T h` a
Vw h Tf ghUh Te f
xdh Wb xdh Wb
E 8 AN;CB+
E 8 E 8 E 8
8KG
HA GI
B ; AN;CB+ Xa NYV N
:E4 B :Xa NYV N :Xa NYV N
;6B ;6B ;
:%
;)6B AN;)P[ R[ +
);6B )A;+
:TeUza Vb
Ta[ WeTfT
;)B +
AH8I4 ;4 CF; E8 AH8I4 ;4 CF; E8+ :%
6B)
6B ) E 8 E 8
9VTa N ( . 8`beg ZhTV za W ? f Ve gTWb cbe YbfYTgb Y geTWb ET?% 9VTa N ( / GebWhVV za l f Ve V za W ba T`ba b E? ," cbe
+ f% W ih i T T fTaZe cbe VTWT ET?%
Vbee bf," K aZT a Vh agT dh haT ah iT ?:F Vw h Tf ghUh Te f cebk `T f CT Z hgT` aT f ` gTUb mT a T Vw h T cebWhV aWb
Vbee bf, dh e TVV baT Vba haT ? f Ve gTWT ,l ?:F %
EL<M8 ?8DGJ? I< + < E?, f f Ve gTWT a h` a cbe ha ET %EL<M8 ?8DGJ? I< ,
ag eVT`U TWbe Gbe VTWT `b wVh T W Z hgT` aT ` gTUb mTWT Wbf E? , fgta
cebWhV Wb l f Ve gTWb l Wbf ?:F % +f W ih i a T T fTaZe
?Tl haT W Y e aV T `cbegTag a fgT f Vh aV T W
? kVe V za W b W fVhg Wb Tag e be` ag <a fgb
I aT KhUh Te
VTfb ?:F %+ dh f Z a eT a T V WT ghUh Te l ag efg V T
:b VV baTaWb
h` a
ageT a T fTaZe c e ghUh Te e ce f agT haT ZTaTaV T a gT W xdh Wb
Vw h Tf ghUh Te f
8KG
?:F +% Y Vgb a gb f T TW V za W ha ah ib ?:F % + cTeT B :%
T fTaZe <fg cebV fb W `h fgeT hab W bf ` VTa f`bf ;6B ; 8KG
;
` W Tag bf VhT f bf e yba f ch W a e cba e Tf e f eiTf W
xdh Wb kgeTV h Te W ?:F % + ;)6B
<a VbaW V ba f abe`T f ZeTa cTeg W YbfYTgb Y geTWb f :TeUza Vb + :%
AH8I4 ;4 CF; E8
Ta[ WeTfT
e TUfbeU l fb b f W fcba W +( T ,( `<d WxT cTeT gT`cbaTe ? ;)B
Gbe b gTagb ZeTa cTeg W T T`beg ZhTV za W kV fb W ? a 6B)
6B)
xdh Wb ghUh Te a T TV Wbf f f cebWhV T geTiwf W f fg `T
gT`cza W T`baxTVb
9VTa N ( 0 8`beg ZhTV za W ? f Ve V za cbe T`ba TVb E?+" a T Vb %
g Uh bf W VgheT EL<M8 ?8DGJ? I<+ f W YhaW a T hm ghUh Te WbaW e TVV baT
8J6E86 A 78 8J68FB ;" K Vba ? f Ve gTWb cTeT Ybe`Te E? , dh h Zb f kVe gT GTeT VTWT E? ,
kVe gTWb ha ah ib ?:F %+ f Ybe`T a Tf Vw h Tf ghUh Te f l e Ze fT
:8A8E46 A 78 AH8IB ;6B CBE
T T fTaZe
F FG8 4 78 4 BAi46B
La f ZhaWb f fg `T gT`cza a Y h Wb ghUh Te dh f aV hfb be aT l Wbf ?:F % + f e TUfbeU a a T fTaZe bf
`tf `cbegTag VhTag gTg iT` ag dh gT`cza YbfYTgb ?:F +% Z a eTWb cbe fg cebV fb Vbafg ghl ah ib ?:F % +
< f fg `T fgt Vb`ch fgb W T`baxTVb E?+" l T `ha V za <a bf g Uh bf Vb Vgbe f T TW V za W E? ,T
ba W a b E? , " < ba T`ba b f f ag g mT T cTeg e W Cbf Y h Wbf ghUh Te f f cebWhV a T geTiwf W ha ` VTa f`b W Y e ag
Z hgT` aT dh cebi a ce aV cT ` ag W ` gTUb f`b W bf 9VTa N ( 0 " 8dhx ? f f Ve gTWb TVg iT` ag cbe ghUh Te
T` abtV Wbf a [xZTWb CT Z hgT` aT dh ZT T bf e yba f f ` `UeTaT a h` a WbaW f Vb`U aT Vba E?+
geTafcbegT T Tf Vw h Tf c g T fW bf g Uh bf cebk `T f T Ybe`Te E? , dh h Zb f kVe gT Cbf VbaWhVgbf Vb Vgbe f
eT`T TfV aW ag Zeh fT W TfT W ? a l bf g Uh bf W fgT f fba c e` TU f T E?+ dh ch W W YhaW ef YtV ` ag a
9VTa N ( / " LaT i m W ageb W T Vw h T VTWT `b wVh T W h` a ghUh Te J a `UTeZb T ` `UeTaT h` aT W fg
Z hgT` aT f ` gTUb mT a haT f e W e TVV ba f cTeg W bf g Uh bf f `hV[b ` abf c e` TU T E? , 3 T x%
V ba f cTeT Ybe`Te Y aT ` ag Wbf E? , l Wbf ?:F % + bf Tag f haT i m dh T ? [T e TVV baTWb Vba E?+ Ybe`Te E? , bf
,f
EL<M8 ?8DGJ? I<f Ve gT a h` a ghUh Te cbe ha VbageT% , dh
EL<M8 ?8DGJ? I< WT TgeTcTWb a T hm ghUh Te l f ` aT a
` VTa f`b W geTafcbeg T VT`U b W fbW b dh f T be aT GTeT VTWT E? , kVe gTWb ha ah ib ?:F +% f Z a%
e TUfbeU Wb < ?:F+% f geTafcbegT T geTiwf W UTfb Tg% TgTWb l TZe ZTWb T T fTaZe
` `UeTaT eT ]hagb Vba ET e TUfbeU Wb a xdh Wb
ag efg V T l f VTcgTWb cbe bf VTc Te f c e ghUh Te f 8fx N NPVQ[ V P q VPN NaYR N RX A; , 8cP RPVq Lab W
cbe VTWT `b wVh T W Z hgT` aT ` gTUb mTWT CTf VTeTVg exfg VTf `tf `cbegTag f W f fg `T
a bf g Uh bf cebk `T f Wbf E? , fba f Ve gTWTf a gT`cza W T`ba b T`ba TVb e aT f dh fgt fh] gb T
,)+
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
Vbageb La Th` agb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te ? CT VbaV ageTV za CT eTmza cbe T dh e fgT`bf ?:F % + kVe V za f dh T cweW WT
fg `h T ` gTUb f`b e aT W T Z hgT` aT l cbe b gTagb W ?:F+% f b ` f`b dh T TW V za W ? T T fTaZe
Gbe gTagb Th` agT T Ybe`TV za W E? , l ah ib ?:F % + f e GTeT `Tag a e dh Ue b tV Wb%UTf T kVe V za a gT W tV Wb
hg mTWb a ? T`beg ZhTV za3 haT W f` ahV za a ? T VbaV ageTV za g a W U f e ZhT T T cebWhVV za W tV Wb ab ib tg a Vh ecb
Y Vgb VbageTe b <a T TV Wbf f T kVe V za a gT W tV Wb Th` agT abgTU ` ag
; UT]b VbaW V ba f abe`T f T VTag WTW W ? ` aTWb cbe fc V T ` ag W U Wb T Th` agb W E? , kVe V za cbe b gTagb
f fg `T gT`cza W T`baxTVb e ce f agT Tcebk `TWT` ag -( W ` aTe tV Wb W T fTaZe CT kVe V za a gT W tV Wb gT`U wa
tV Wb kVe gTWb l -( W ah ib ?:F %+ Z a eTWb f ZhT T T gTfT W ?:F a gb %+ 8W `tf W T fTaZe 8 x%
cbe bf e yba f J a `UTeZb VbaTV Wbf f Veza VT T gTfT W Gbe b gTagb a T TV Wbf f [Tl haT TW V za a gT W ?:F % +W e Ze fb
T kVe V za ch W Th` agTe [TfgT -(( `<d WxT
,
EL<M8 ?8DGJ? I< T fTaZe Vb`b `Tf E? ,l tV Wb g gh TU he aTe b fba
Gbe gTagb Vba T TV Wbf f Veza VT ` VTa f`b Wb` aTag kVe gTWb
cTeT T ` aTV za W tV Wb f T kVe V za W E? , <fg cebV fb gT`U wa <a T VT bf f tV Wb g gh TU l E? , VTxWT W kVe V za T
cebcbeV baT ` VTa f`b `tf `cbegTag cTeT Z a eTe ( ` ageTf dh ?:F+% Th` agT T kVe V za Gbe b gTagb a T VT%
ah ib U VTeUbaTgb WheTag T TV Wbf f Veza VT bf f [Tl haT f Ve V za W tV Wb a gT a ZTg iT b dh f Za Y VT
dh [Tl haT cweW WT a gT W ?:F %+ W T fTaZe dh
f b ` f`b dh fh`Te ? T T fTaZe l dh ab [Tl ah iT
6H4AG 9 646 A 78 4 8J6E86 A 4 54F8 78
?:F +% f Z a eTWb cbe bf e yba f
g6 7B E8A4
:ba UTf a bf ce aV c bf W fVhg Wbf Tag e be` ag cbW `bf VhTag Y VTe T
E8:H 46 A 78 GH5H 4E E8A4 ;"
kVe V za a gT W tV Wb W bf e yba f b T TW V za b ` aTV za a gT
F86E86 A
aTV za W ?:F+ %W T fTaZe W T f Zh ag `Ta eT
<kVe V za W U VTeUbaTgb f VT Vh T Vb`b gTfT W Y h]b W be aT :b`b f W fVhg z Tag e be` ag ? f Ve V za cbe bf cxg gbf ghUh Te f
`h g c VTWb cbe ?:F he aTe b % + VbaV ageTV za aW % h` f a V fTe b cTeT ?:F % + e TUfbeV za l Z a eTV za
aW VT T eTc W m Vba T dh bf e yba f ` aTa ?:F % +W W ah ib ?:F+% TfbV TWb Vba T Ybe`TV za W tV Wb g gh TU
T fTaZe dh f b ` f`b dh TyTW e haT ? T T fTaZe Gbe b gTagb T gTfT W ? T f Ve V za W U e Zh Tef Vh WTWbfT` ag
<a T VT bf f T cweW WT W ?:F % + TlhWT T W ib i e c? c Tf`tg Vb cTeT dh bf e yba f W f `c y a Y VTm` ag fhf YhaV ba f a T
[TV T b abe`T [b` bfgTf f tV Wb%UTf <a VbaW V ba f abe`T f bf g Uh bf e aT f
CT VTag WTW W ?:F ah ib %+ Vbage Uh Wb T T fTaZe T W U a f Ve gTe T ` abf fhY V ag ?
VhT dh e `b` agb WTWb f ZhT T T VTag WTW W ? f Ve gTWT dh cTeT e TUfbeU e VTf gbWb ?:F +% dh f Y geT l [Tl
g e` aT a T hm ghUh Te Vba gT`cba f he aTe bf f a U VTeUbaTgb W U f e fhY V ag ? fbUeTag cTeT f e kVe gTWb Vb`b g gh TU
:b`b f W fVhg z Tag e be` ag Tf Yh ag f ce `Te Tf tV Wb b E?, cTeT UeTe Vh ecb W bf tV Wbf ab ib tg f
W bf gT`cba f he aTe bf f a U VTeUbaTgb fba E? , l Ybf% W e iTWb VTWT WxT W ` gTUb f`b
c[Tg Gbe b gTagb cTeg W T ?:F%+ TyTW Wb T T fTaZe <a T VT bf f T f Ve V za ghUh Te W ? f e WhV T ha
l? kVe gTWb cbe E? ," f VT Vh T ` W aWb ai dh f W `Tf TWb UT]b cTeT bZeTe ha ?:F Vb`c gb % + e TUfbeU e
, kVe V za gTfT W Y h]b W be aT `h g c VTWT cbe be aT
EL<M8 ?8DGJ? I< V za b dh c e` g T bf e yba f Th` agTe ?:F %+ kVe V za
, VbaV ageTV za"
EL<M8 ?8DGJ? I< < tV Wb g gh TU l T`baxTVb ab f kVe gTa a T T VT bf f
< e fgb W ab U VTeUbaTgb ab E? , UhY% cbedh ab [Tl kV fb W ? W fcba U cTeT Vb`U aTe
Y e kVe gTWb a T be aT f ` W W g e` aTaWb ha iT be Vba gT`cba f f a U VTeUbaTgb3 cbe b gTagb ab [Tl ah ib ?:F% + f
VbabV Wb Vb`b tV Wb g gh TU CT VTag WTW W tV Wb TyTW Wb T T fTaZe a T VT bf f
g gh TU a T be aT f ` W g gh TaWb T be aT Vba haT ;heTag T TV Wbf f ghUh Te ? Th` agT T f Ve V za
UTf Yh eg Vb`b ETF? T ha c? W / , c? W c Tf`T fhY V ag ` ag cTeT e TUfbeU e gbWb ?:F Y geTWb % + Vba
abe`T l c? W Y geTWb Z b` eh Te <fgT g gh TV za fhY V ag ? fbUeTag cTeT kVe gTe ZeTaW f VTag WTW f W E? ,
e i eg bf i agbf dh bVhee eba a T hm ghUh Te l tV Wb g gh TU Vbage Uhl aWb Tfx a ZeTaW f VTag WTW f
VhTaWb xdh Wb ghUh Te Yh g gh TWb cbe ? f Ve gTWb W ah ib ?:F +% T xdh Wb kgeTV h Te VbecbeT gbgT bf
Gbe b gTagb a ` eb W ` dh iT ag f W ETF? fgx`h bf `tf `cbegTag f cTeT Th` agTe ? f Ve V za cbe
a V fTe bf cTeT W ib i e c? he aTe b T / , f ZhT T g Uh bf a T TV Wbf f fba bf f Zh ag f2 )" ha Th` agb a GVb
a ` eb W ` dh iT ag f W ? TyTW Wb T Y h Wb W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te a T TV Wbf f e fc eTgbe T3 l "
ghUh Te dh f Vb`U az Vba YbfYTgb l bgebf gT`cba f ha Th` agb W ? VbaV ageTV za W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
beZta Vbf CT ` W V za W tV Wb g gh TU ab aV hl ? a W f` ahV za W c?" a T TV Wbf f e fc eTgbe T b ` gTUz VT
TfbV TV za Vba E? , cbedh cB W T`ba TVb% CTf Vw h Tf ghUh Te f e fcbaW a W e VgT` ag T ha Th` agb W
CT e TVV za W T`ba b f 1 l T g gh TV za Vba ETF? GVb W T fTaZe Vb`b a T TV Wbf f e fc eTgbe T Vba ha
T ha c? W / , ab ` aT ? W E? , Th` agb a T gTfT W ? f Ve V za Vb`b f Zh bf
Gbe b gTagb T kVe V za a gT W tV Wb cbe bf e yba f f ch W iT hTe Th` agb W GVb iT GVb W Tf Vw h Tf ghUh Te f cebibVTaWb ha
W T f Zh ag `Ta eT2 Th` agb W T Ybe`TV za W ? a Tf Vw h Tf ghUh Te f dh
T fh i m fg `h T T f Ve V za W ? < f ZhaWb YTVgbe dh
<kVe V za a gT W tV Wb 5 E? , kVe V za Le aTe b fg `h T ? T f Ve V za f ha Th` agb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te ?
tV Wb%?:F g gh TU % + kVe V za VbaV ageTV za W f` ahV za W c?"
,),
6N o aX[ ( I Zh TV za tV Wb%UTf
6aNQ [ ( ) =TVgbe f c Tf`tg Vbf b W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te ?:F +% e TUfbeV za l VbaWhV T T VT bf f ?lc e T %
dh Th` agTa b W f` ahl a ? J Ve V za l ?:F % + ` T W f` ahl ? f Ve V za l ?:F % + e TUfbeV za l
I TUfbeV za cbe bf g Uh bf e aT f g aW T VThfTe TV Wbf f
P RYR N ;" FRP RPVq d 7V YV aV ;" FRP RPVq d
;6B ERNO [ PVq ;6B ERNO [ PVq
6BEE866 A E8A4 78 4 46 7BF F1
4KBE 8J6E86 A 78 ;"
HA GI
G8>Vb G8>Vb
8aZ bg af aT 8aZ bg af aT
8[beT dh [ `bf W fVe gb bf ` VTa f`bf cbe bf VhT f
bf e yba f f Ve gTa ? l e TUfbeU e ?:F % + cbW `bf kc VTe
8 Wbfg ebaT 8 Wbfg ebaT
Vz`b bf e yba f e T]hfgTa c? W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
? cbcbgTf ` T ? c ecbgTf ` T VhTaWb f ih i Tabe`T
I Y e waWbf T <VhTV za 0 ? aW efba%?Tff UT V[
VhTV za cbW `bf i e dh T TV Wbf f bVhee VhTaWb T e TV za
La YTVgbe fc V T dh ch W Th` agTe ? CT f Ve V za UT]b W ?:F +% cTeT Vb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te W f` ahl
T ZhaTf VbaW V ba f Y f bcTgb zZ VTf f haT f Ve V za kV f iT W W f` ahl aWb Tfx c? J fgT e TV za W f` ahl cbedh
T Wbfg ebaT CT T Wbfg ebaT fg `h T T f Ve V za W ? cbe T TV Wbf f f VbabV Vb`b ` gTUz Vb
W haT VTxWT a ?:F +
%
,)-
HA 747 I Cbf Y h Wbf VbecbeT f l bf e yba f
GNOXN ( :TeTVg exfg VTf W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te W a T be aT Gbe gTagb a T VT bf f ?:F% + f ` aTWb W
G egheUTV ba f tV Wb%UTf ce `Te TfT xdh Wb kgeTV h Te cbe kVe V za e aT dh g a
; ;" C4:P[) ;6B ` f`b Y Vgb dh TyTW e ha ? T xdh Wb kgeTV h Te <fg
cebV fb TlhWT T W ib i e T ? VbaV ageTV za l c? [TV T
Ebe`T /, ,( `<d C ,( `` ?Z , `<d C
T abe`T WTW
I fc eTgbe b
GNOXN ( `h fgeT Tf VTeTVg exfg VTf Z a eT f W
TV Wbf f
xdh Wb kgeTV h Te W T T VT bf f e fc eTgbe T l ` gTUz VT <a
I fc eTgbe b
T VT bf f e fc eTgbe T [Tl ha Th` agb a c? W xdh Wb
T VT bf f
kgeTV h Te l haT W f` ahV za a ? VbaV ageTV za CT VThfT W
D gTUz Vb
T T VT bf f f G c Tf`tg VT W f` ah WTVb VThfTWb cbe [ c e%
TV Wbf f
i ag TV za I WhVV za W GVb h Zb VbaWhV T haT W f` ahV za
D gTUz Vb
W ? ghUh Te e aT f Ve V za <a Vbaf Vh aV T ab [Tl
T VT bf f
fhY V ag ? a Y h Wb ghUh Te e aT cTeT e TVV baTe Vba gbWbf bf
T< i agb ce aV cT fgt aW VTWb cbe Tf Y V[Tf WbU f b EbgT
?:F +% dh f Y geT Gbe b gTagb ?:F% + fb ab ch W
dh bf geTfgbeabf TV WbUtf Vbf e fc eTgbe bf f a V Ta cbe ha Th` agb
b W f` ahV za W GVb ` ageTf dh bf geTfgbeabf ` gTUz Vbf f a V Ta cbe e TVV baTe Vba ? ab f e TUfbeU l f kVe gT a
ha Th` agb b W f` ahV za W ?:F % + be aT <fgb WT Vb`b e fh gTWb haT W f` ahV za W ?:F c Tf`tg Vb+ % fgTYT%
V ageTWb l Vbee VV za W T T VT bf f cbe b gTagb
e fch fgT Vb`c afTgbe T T haT e WhVV za ce `Te T a GVb
GNOXN ( e fh` Tf VTeTVg exfg VTf W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te a T T VT bf f e fc eTgbe T f haT e WhVV za W ?:F c Tf`tg Vb +%
TfbV TWTf Vba T TV Wbf f e fc eTgbe T l ` gTUz VT Tfx Vb`b Vba VbaV ageTV za VThfTWT cbe haT `Tlbe kVe V za e aT W
T T VT bf f e fc eTgbe T l ` gTUz VT dh f TaT mTa a T ?:F %+
f Zh ag f VV za K aZT a Vh agT dh aTV Wbf f e fc eTgbe T <a T VT bf f ` gTUz VT gT`U wa [Tl haT W f` ahV za W c Tf`T
[Tl haT e WhVV za a c? ha Th` agb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te ? VbaV ageTV za l Th` agb W c? J a `UTeZb T
? VbaV ageTV za l ha Th` agb VThfT W T T VT bf f ` gTUz VT f ha Th` agb W T
a GVb dh f T VThfT a V T W T TV Wbf f CT e fch fgT ?:F Y h Wb+ %VbaV ageTV za <fg Th` agb f Vb`c afT a cTeg
Vb`c afTgbe T f Th` agb W ?:F c Tf`tg Vb % + fTV TWb cbe haT e WhVV za a T Ye Vh aV T e fc eTgbe T dh
VThfTWb cbe T TW V za W ah ib ?:F +% T b kgeTV h Te Th` agT GVb l TlhWT T W ib i e xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
Te xdh Wb cbe bf e yba f < Th` agb W ?:F +% TlhWT T Vb`c afTe c? [TV T abe`T 8W `tf Th` agb W ?:F% + fgTYT%
Th` agb W GVb W ib i aWb Tfx c? c Tf`tg Vb [TV T T V ageTWb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te Th` agT T Y geTV za
abe`T WTW VTeZT W fZTeeTWT W ?:F %+ dh T fh i m cebibVT ha kV fb
<aTV Wbf f ` gTUz VT gT`U wa [Tl haT W f` ahV za a c? l ?:F %+ fbUe ? f Ve gTWb a xdh Wb ghUh Te e aT bf
ha Th` agb a xdh Wb kgeTV h Te ? VbaV ageTV za J a kV fb W ?:F+% a Y h Wb ghUh Te ab f e TUfbeU
`UTeZb a fg VTfb T Tab`T xT ce `Te T f haT W f` ahV za cbedh ab [Tl ? Vba dh ch W e TVV baTe l f kVe gT a
a c Tf`T ?:F+% CTf Vb`c afTV ba f ce `Te Tf aV hl a T be aT <a T T VT bf f ` gTUz VT Tf Vb`c afTV ba f
Th` agb W T gTfT W i ag TV za dh e WhV GVb l e aT ce `Te Tf fba T W f` ahV za W T i ag TV za dh
Vb`c afTV za dh T TZe ZTe ah iTf ?:F % + T kgeT% iT GVb l Th` agT ?:F e aT %+ kVe V za dh
Y h Wb V h Te TlhWT T ` a ` mTe T VTxWT a V T W kgeTV h bfT TlhWT T Vb`c afTe Th` agb a V T W xdh Wb kgeTV h Te
Te ?:F +% VbaV ageTV za ?:F +% VbaV ageTV za
,).
LfUXiW]Xc XY ]b[ zg U YgdU c kkk'cb ]bYXcWhfUbg Uhcf'Wca
F
cg hY ]Xcg aYhUVc ]nUb YghY xW]Xc dUfU cVhYbYf YbYf[ U Yb i[Uf XY
DU U WU cg]g fYgd]fUhcf]U Yg WUigUXU dcf ibU jYbh] UW] b YlWYg]jU XY cg [ iWcgU' ;cb U X]UVYhYg aY ]hig [fUjY% cg b]jY Yg XY xW]Xc
:EG
di acbYg' JUfU jYn cWiffY Yghc XYV]Xc U WcbX]W]cbYg dUhc []WUg UWYhcUWzh]Wc Yb gUb[fY diYXYb UiaYbhUf aiW c% dfcjcWUbXc ibU
Z g]WUg' K]b YaVUf[c% ibU dg]WcbYifcg]g cWUg]cbU aYbhY diYXY UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU [fUjY' =b ib ]bhYbhc dcf WcadYbgUf YghU UW]Xcg]g%
UiaYbhUf U fYgd]fUW] b UghU Y dibhc XY eiY ibU dYfgcbU gY jiY jY gY YlWfYhUb [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XY xW]Xc Yb U cf]bU% U jYWYg UghU .))
U WU h]WU' aac ( X U'
Mb h]dc Z]g]c []Wc XY U WU cg]g fYgd]fUhcf]U cWiffY WiUbXc :YSQ UpY PQ lOUPZ % JUfU jYn gY ]b[]YfYb [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XY
ibU dYfgcbU UgW]YbXY U ibU [fUb U hifU' = VU c WcbhYb]Xc XY xW]Xcg Yb cg U ]aYbhcg bcfaU Yg' K]b YaVUf[c% U UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU
cl [Ybc XY U]fY Ygh]ai U U fYgd]fUW] b% c eiY dfcjcWU [fUjY Yb cWUg]cbYg Yg Y fYgi hUXc XY U ]b[Ygh] b XY W]Yfhcg jYbYbcg
dzfX]XU XY ;G+ m XYgUffc c XY U WU cg]g fYgd]fUhcf]U YjY' MbU jYn xW]Xcg' 9 [ibUg XY YghUg gighUbW]Ug ]bW imYb U [ibcg WcadiYghcg
axg% cg df]bW]dU Yg aYX]cg XY WcadYbgUW] b gcb U ei a]WU UWYh] gU ]W ]Wcg "d' = '% 9gd]f]bU m U Wc c aYh ]Wc% eiY ZcfaU xW]Xc
hUadcbYg WU XY cg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m U WUdUW]XUX XY cg f] cbYg dUfU Z fa]Wc WiUbXc gY aYhUVc ]nU'
UiaYbhUf ;G, YlWfYW] b' 7M M ]QYM O]ZYUOM% ;iUbXc U ZibW] b fYbU gY XYhYf]cfU bchUV YaYbhY%
Um ibU UWiai UW] b Yb cg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg XY cg Ub]cbYg XY xW]Xcg
M MOUPZ U XQ MNp UOM ]Q M PQ YM PU XUY OUpY Qb ]MOQ M]
94 R UPZ 4ZYOQY ]MOUpY XzV] Yg eiY bc gcb YlWfYhUXcg dcf cg f] cbYg' 9XYaxg% U X]ga]biW] b XY U
hUgU XY Z] hfUW] b [ caYfi Uf fYXiWY U Yl
= hzfa]bcUW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU gY fYZ]YfY U hcXcg cg XYaxg h]dcg XY UW]Xcg]g
WfYUW] b XY ZcgZUhcg m F - % eiY fYXiWY U WUbh]XUX
UXYaxg XY cg dfcjcWUXcg dcf Y YlWYgc XY ;G+ Yb cg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg' DU
XY ;G, U UX]Xc XY biYjc U cg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg' Hcf c hUbhc% fYbU Wf b]WU
UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU diYXY XYVYfgY U jUf]Ug WUigUg [YbYfU Yg3 " ]bgiZ]W]YbW]U
Y ZfUWUgc diYXY UgcW]UfgY Wcb UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU [fUjY'
XY cg f] cbYg dUfU YlWfYhUf cg xW]Xcg aYhUV ]Wcg eiY gY ZcfaUb
bcfaU aYbhY Yb Y WiYfdc4 "+ ZcfaUW] b XY WUbh]XUXYg YlWYg]jUg XY xW]Xcg M M OM Z U XQ MNp UOM ]Q M PQ Y M XQY Z
aYhUV ]Wcg Yb Y WiYfdc4 ", UX]W] b XY xW]Xcg aYhUV ]Wcg U WiYfdc dcf 94 n UPZ Qb ]MOQ M] 4ZYOQY ]MOUpY
]b[Ygh] b c ]bZig] b XY xW]Xcg4 m "- dzfX]XU XY VUgY XY cg Z i]Xcg
=lWYgc XY fYhYbW] b XY ;G , c dzfX]XU XY XY WiYfdc
WcfdcfU Yg% eiY h]YbY Y a]gac YZYWhc eiY U[fY[Uf ib xW]Xc U cg Z i]Xcg
WUigU U WU cg]g aYhUV ]WU' DU U WU cg]g aYhUV ]WU bc Yg hUb Wca b
WcfdcfU Yg' 9 [ibUg UZYWW]cbYg YgdYW Z]WUg eiY WUigUb UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU
Wcac U UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU% dYfc U [ibUg XY Ug WUigUg XY U U WU cg]g
gY XYgWf]VYb Yb Ug g][i]YbhYg gYWW]cbYg'
aYhUV ]WU gY XYgWf]VYb Yb Ug g][i]YbhYg gYWW]cbYg'
2OUPZ U N M] ]QYM % DU UW]Xcg]g hiVi Uf fYbU gY XYVY U
2PXUYU ]MOUpY PQ PU ]m UOZ QbOQ[ Z MYTnP]UPZ OM]NpYUOZ
ib XYZYWhc Yb U gYWfYW] b fYbU XY % fYUVgcfW] b XY
UYTUNUPZ]Q PQ P]M Q % LcXcg cg X]ifzh]Wcg dfcjcWUb ib UiaYbhc XY
;G , % c UaVcg' =ghcg hfUghcfbcg gcb [YbYfU aYbhY XY Xcg h]dcg3
Z i c XY ei]Xc U c Uf[c XY cg h Vi cg% dcf c [YbYfU UiaYbhUbXc Y
" XYhYf]cfc XY ;G hiVi Uf fYbU , fYUVgcfW] b% WUigU
Z i c Yb cg h Vi cg X]ghU Yg m Wc YWhcfYg' =ghY YZYWhc WcbXiWY U ibU
dzfX]XU XY ;G , Yb U cf]bU4 c "+ ]bWUdUW]XUX XY f] b
aUmcf fYUVgcfW] b XY FU XY YghUg dUfhYg XY Ug bYZfcbUg' <YV]Xc U
hiVi Uf aYWUb]gac gYWfYhcf dUfU YghUV YWYf ibU cf]bU xW]XU
eiY U fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c Uei Yghx UWcd UXU Wcb gYWfYW] b% U
bcfaU % dfcjcWUbXc U YlWfYW] b XY cf]bU U WU ]bU' =b Yghcg
fYUVgcfW] b XY gcX]c aY cfUXU hUaV]zb WcbXiWY U ib UiaYbhc XY
WUgcg% WUbh]XUXYg ]bUXYWiUXUg XY xW]Xc h]hi UV Y m F - Yghxb
gYWfYW] b m UiaYbhc XY U fYUVgcfW] b XY V]WUfVcbUhc' DUg
YlWfYhU% dcf c eiY Um ibU UWiai UW] b bYhU XY xW]Xc Yb cg Z i]Xcg
fYXiWW]cbYg Yb Y jc iaYb XY ei]Xc YlhfUWY i Uf UgcW]UXUg Wcb Y igc
WcfdcfU Yg' 9 [ibUg WUigUg XY UW]Xcg]g hiVi Uf fYbU ]bW imYbZU U
XY X]ifzh]Wcg hUaV]zb gY UgcW]Ub [YbYfU aYbhY Wcb ibU aUmcf
fYbU Wfcb]WU% gYWfYW] b ]bgiZ]W]YbhY XY U XcghYfcbU "=bZYfaYXUX XY
ZcfaUW] b XY 9b[ AA m U XcghYfcbU% eiY Ygh]ai Ub
9XX]gcb m jUf]cg hfUghcfbcg YfYX]hUf]cg m UXei]f]Xcg eiY XYhYf]cfUb
gYWfYW] b m ;G , fYUVgcfW] b' =ghcg WUaV]cg WcbXiWYb
U ZibW] b hiVi Uf% Wcac K bXfcaY XY >UbWcb] "jYf
U XYgUffc c XY U WU cg]g% eiY gY WUfUWhYf]nU dcf ib UiaYbhc XY U
;Ud hi c ,+ '
WcbWYbhfUW] b XY V]WUfVcbUhc Yb Y ei]Xc YlhfUWY i Uf'
5UM]]QM% DU X]UffYU ]bhYbgU Yg dfcVUV YaYbhY U WUigU axg
6bOQ Z PQ M PZ Q]ZYM% ;iUbXc Ug [ xbXi Ug gidfUffYbU Yg
ZfYWiYbhY XY UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU' DU WUigU XY YghU UW]Xcg]g Yg U
gYWfYhUb [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XY U XcghYfcbU% gY XYgUffc U ibU
dzfX]XU XY [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XY V]WUfVcbUhc XY gcX]c Yb Ug YWYg''
U WU cg]g aYhUV ]WU YjY' ;cac gY X]gWih] UbhYf]cfaYbhY% U
DUg gYWfYW]cbYg [Ughfc]bhYgh]bU Yg bcfaU aYbhY Wcbh]YbYb [fUbXYg
U XcghYfcbU dfcaiYjY U fYUVgcfW] b YlhYbgU XY FU XY cg h Vi cg
WUbh]XUXYg XY V]WUfVcbUhc m U X]UffYU dfcjcWU U dzfX]XU XY
X]ghU Yg m Wc YWhcfYg m% U a]gac h]Yadc% Ygh]ai U Ug gYWfYW]cbYg
;G , XY WiYfdc% eiY h]YbY Y a]gac YZYWhc eiY cg
W] b XY m ;G , fYUVgcfW] b dcf Ug Wz i Ug ]bhYfWU UXUg
]b[ [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XY V]WUfVcbUhc Yb U cf]bU' =ghU ZcfaU XY
XY cg h Vi cg Wc YWhcfYg' =ghY UiaYbhc XY U gYWfYW] b XY m
UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU diYXY gYf [fUjY m WUigUf U aiYfhY%
;G , U fYUVgcfW] b WcbXiWY U U WU cg]g aYhUV ]WU'
YgdYW]U aYbhY Yb b] cg dYeiY cg'
GpXU Z PQ OZY QYUPZ Sl ]UOZ% N a]hcg XY Ygh aU[c
GpXU Z PQ OZY QYUPZ UY Q UYM % N a]hcg [xghf]Wcg
Y WcbhYb]Xc gc c% g]b j a]hcg XY WcbhYb]Xc [Ughfc]bhYgh]bU ]bZYf]cf%
Y WcbhYb]Xc dcf g gc c dfcjcWUf U ibU dzfX]XU XY xW]Xc m ibU
dfcjcWU U dzfX]XU XY ; gYWfYhUXc dcf U aiWcgU XY Ygh aU[c' =
hYbXYbW]U U U U WU cg]g dcfeiY Ug gYWfYW]cbYg XY Ygh aU[c gcb aim
fYgi hUXc bYhc Yg U dzfX]XU XY xW]Xc XY ei]Xc YlhfUWY i Uf m Y
xW]XUg' K]b YaVUf[c% jca]hUf [fUbXYg WUbh]XUXYg XYgXY c axg
XYgUffc c XY U WU cg]g aYhUV ]WU' =ghY h]dc XY U WU cg]g cWiffY
dfcZibXc XY hfUWhc [Ughfc]bhYgh]bU WUigU dzfX]XU XY V]WUfVcbUhc m
YgdYW]U aYbhY Yb fYW]zb bUW]Xcg eiY h]YbYb YghYbcg]g d] f]WU WUigUXU
dfcXiWY UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU XY U a]gaU aUbYfU eiY U X]UffYU WUigU
dcf a gWi cg XY YgZ bhYf d] f]Wc ]dYfhfcZ]UXcg'
UW]Xcg]g'
- 0
F :525 G Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
]ad ]WU jUf]cg dUgcg% Wcac gY aiYghfU Yb 7US ]M ( ( %' 9 =b U [ibcg WUgcg% cg hfUghcfbcg UW]XcVxg]Wcg bc gY UWcadU Ub
YlUa]bUf Y d % gY diYXY XYhYfa]bUf g] Y hfUghcfbc Yg XY fYgdiYghUg WcadYbgUhcf]Ug UXYWiUXUg' ;iUbXc cWiffY YghU
UW]Xcg]g c U WU cg]g' Mb d ]bZYf]cf U 0%- ]bX]WU UW]Xcg]g% g]hiUW] b% U UbcaU U gY WcbcWY WcachfUghcfbc a]lhc xW]Xc VUgY
a]YbhfUg eiY ib d gidYf]cf U 0%- ]bX]WU U WU cg]g' % c eiY g][b]Z]WU eiY Um Xcg c axg WUigUg giVmUWYbhYg XY U
= gY[ibXc dUgc Yg YlUa]bUf Y d UgaU HWc+ m U hYfUW] b xW]Xc VUgY' Hcf Y Yad c% ib dUW]YbhY Wcb ib d VU c
;G , WcbWYbhfUW]cbYg' = jU cf bcfaU XY HWc+ Yg gcVfY gY W Ug]Z]WUf U Wcac UW]X h]Wc' K] Y hfUghcfbc Yghij]YfU aYX]UXc
-) aa [ m dUfU ;G , Yg XY +- a=e ( D' K] Y XYgcfXYb aYhUV ]WUaYbhY% Yghc hUaV]zb ]f U UWcadU UXc XY ib ;G
gY U WUfUWhYf]nUXc Wcac UW]Xcg]g m U HWc d Ugaxh]WU+ d Ugaxh]Wc VU c' ,
UiaYbhU% XYVY UVYf ib WcadcbYbhY fYgd]fUhcf]c Yb Y WcbWYbhfUW] b m% XYgdizg XY ibU WcadYbgUW] b fYgd]fUhcf]U UXYWiUXU
UW]Xcg]g' <Ygdizg XY U WcadYbgUW] b fYbU % Y ;G d Ugaxh]Wc , gUh]cb% ib HWc VU c+' K]b YaVUf[c% g] Y d d Ugaxh]Wc VU c m
U WcbWYbhfUW] b Yb U UW]Xcg]g fYgd]fUhcf]U hYbXYf U U UiaYbhUf dcf VU c ;G, WcbWYbhfUW] b Yghxb UgcW]UXcg Wcb ib UiaYbhc
YbW]aU XY c bcfaU ' Hcf c hUbhc% cg jU cfYg YgdYfUXcg dUfU ibU HWc+% ibc gcgdYW Uf U ib WcadcbYbhY fYgd]fUhcf]c XY U UW]Xcg]g%
UW]Xcg]g fYgd]fUhcf]U g]ad Y gYf Ub ib d d Ugaxh]Wc fYXiW]Xc% Ug Wcac ib WcadcbYbhY aYhUV ]Wc' Hcf c hUbhc% YghY
UiaYbhc XY HWc+m UiaYbhc XY ;G d Ugaxh]Wc , WcbWYbhfU = hfUghcfbc gY W Ug]Z]WUf U Wcac ibU UW]Xcg]g a]lhU' =ghY
W] b XYgdizg XY U WcadYbgUW] b fYbU dUfW]U ' hfUghcfbc dcXf U cWiff]f% dcf Y Yad c% Yb ib dUW]YbhY Wcb
- 1
4M[n Z ( JY[i UW] b xW]Xc VUgY
/)
+) )) 2) 1) 0) /) .) -)
./ )
.+
,.
-1 H9?;G+ "aa [
EYhUV ]Wc
-- ;f b]Wc U WU cg]g ,)
F
fYgd]fUhcf]c
L X6
-)
UW]Xcg]g
9[iXc
:EG
,/ +.
fYgd]fUhcf]c
,+ UW]Xcg]g
A M XM M] Q]UM K94
+1 +)
+- FcfaU
9[iXc
+) fYgd]fUhcf]c .
7US ]M ( ((% Fcac[fUaU xW]Xc VUgY eiY aiYghfU UfhYf]Ug
U WU cg]g
X]YW]gz]g d gUb[i bYc% d UgaU UfhYf]U ;G , % m HWc+ jU cfYg' cg
) W fWi c UV]Yfhc WYbhfU aiYghfU cg a]hYg Udfcl]aUXcg dUfU Y
+
EYhUV ]Wc ;f b]Wc YghUXc xW]Xc VUgY Yb dYfgcbUg bcfaU Yg' cgncbUg gcaVfYUXUg Yb
1 UW]Xcg]g fYgd]fUhcf]c Y bcac[fUaU aiYghfUb cg a]hYg Udfcl]aUXcg dUfU U bcfaU
U WU cg]g H9?
;G+ "aa [ WcadYbgUW]cbYg WUigUXUg dcf g]ad Yg hfUghcfbcg aYhUV ]Wcg
-
m fYgd]fUhcf]cg' HUfU jU cfYg eiY gY YbWiYbhfUb ZiYfU XY Ug
) xfYUg gcaVfYUXUg% gY XYVY gcgdYW Uf ib hfUghcfbc xW]Xc VUgY
0')) 0% ) 0%+) 0',) 0%-) 0%.) 0'/) 0'0) 0'1) a]lhc' "EcX]Z]WUXc XY ;c[Ub E?% JYWhcf >; Bf3 9W]X :UgY
A9 PQ M MYS]Q M] Q]UM <]gcfXYfg ]b h Y C]XbYm% ,p YX' >] UXY Z]U3 O: KUibXYfg% 21/'
;G , cg g XY h z [Ughf hfUWhc ]bhYgh]bU dcfeiY XY X] Mb gY[ibXc Y Yad c gYf U ib dUW]YbhY Wcb Y g][i]YbhY
UffYU "UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU m YbZ]gYaU "UW]Xcg]g jU cfYg3 d % 0% .4 d UgaU ;G, WcbWYbhfUW] b% 0 a=e ( D4 m
fYgd]fUhcf]U ' d UgaU HWc+% .) aa [' =b YghY Y Yad c% Y dUW]YbhY Yg
MbU ZcfaU WcbjYb]YbhY XY X]U[bcgh]WUf cg hfUghcfbcg xW]Xc UW]X h]Wc m dUfYWY UVYf ib WcadcbYbhY aYhUV ]Wc dcfeiY
VUgY Yg ih] ]nUf ib bcac[fUaU xW]Xc VUgY% Wcac gY aiYghfU Yb Y d UgaU ;G , U WcbWYbhfUW] b Yg axg VU U eiY U bcfaU
7US ]M ( ((%' =ghY X]U[fUaU gY diYXY ih] ]nUf dUfU XYhYfa]bUf Y jU cf XY +- a=e ( D' K]b YaVUf[c% U WcadYbgUW] b fYgd]fUhcf]U
h]dc XY UW]Xcg]g c U WU cg]g% Ug Wcac gi [fUjYXUX' =b YghU X]U eiY bcfaU aYbhY fYXiW]f U HWc+ Yghx UigYbhY m HWc+ UiaYbhU ][YfUaYbhY
[fUac% d % ;G , WcbWYbhfUW] b m HWc+ cg jU cfYg gY WfinUb dcf YbW]aU XY jU cf bcfaU XY -) aa [' =ghY XYgWiVf]a]Ybhc
gY[ b U YWiUW] b XY YbXYfgcb UggY VU W ' = W fWi c UV]Yfhc Yg WcadUh]V Y Wcb ibU U hYfUW] b xW]Xc VUgY a]lhU eiY Wcbg]ghY Yb
WYbhfU aiYghfU cg jU cfYg bcfaU Yg m Ug XYgj]UW]cbYg eiY U b UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU% Ug Wcac ib WcadcbYbhY fYgd]fUhcf]c'
diYXYb Wcbg]XYfUfgY XYbhfc XY fUb[c bcfaU ' DUg xfYUg = bcac[fUaU xW]Xc VUgY g]fjY Wcac ibU ZcfaU fxd]XU XY YjU iUf Y
gcaVfYUXUg XY X]U[fUaU aiYghfUb cg a]hYg XY WcbZ]UbnU XY h]dc m U [fUjYXUX XY cg hfUghcfbcg eiY diYXYb YghUf Wcbhf]VimYbXc
2. dUfU Ug WcadYbgUW]cbYg bcfaU Yg XY hfUghcfbcg Ud UbcfaU % HWc+m WcbWYbhfUW]cbYg d Ugaxh]WUg XY
aYhUV ]Wcg m fYgd]fUhcf]cg g]ad Yg' V]WUfVcbUhc' =b ib Ybhcfbc W b]Wc% U ]ghcf]U XY dUW]YbhY m chfcg
9 ih] ]nUf YghY X]U[fUaU% gY XYVY Ugia]f eiY U hfUbgWiff]Xc Y h]Yadc Dcg U Un[cg Z g]Wcg hUaV]zb dfcdcfW]cbUb d]ghUg ]adcfhUbhYg gcVfY
giZ]W]YbhY dUfU ibU fYgdiYghU WcadYbgUhcf]U Wcad YhU% eiY Yg XY / U + Ug WUigUg m Y hfUhUa]Ybhc XY cg hfUghcfbcg UW]XcVxg]Wcg'
cfUg dUfU Ug WcadYbgUW]cbYg jYbh] Uhcf]Ug Yb cg hfUghcfbcg aYhUV ]Wcg
F Z PQ M N]QOTM MYUpYUOM [M]M PUMSYZ UOM] ]M Z]YZ MOUPZNl UOZ
df]aUf]cg m XY , U . X Ug dUfU Ug WcadYbgUW]cbYg aYhUV ]WUg Yb cg
hfUghcfbcg fYgd]fUhcf]cg df]aUf]cg' K] ib jU cf Yghx XYbhfc XY xfYU DUg WcbWYbhfUW]cbYg XY Ub]cbYg m WUh]cbYg Yb d UgaU XYVYb gYf
gcaVfYUXU% Yghc gi[]YfY eiY Um ibU g]ad Y dYfhifVUW] b xW]Xc VUgY' Hcf ][iU Yg dUfU aUbhYbYf U bYihfU ]XUX Y zWhf]WU' Hcf c hUbhc% bc Yl]ghY
Y WcbhfUf]c% g] cg jU cfYg ibU VfYW U Ub] b]WU fYU Yb Y d UgaU' K]b YaVUf[c% gc c W]Yfhcg
dUfU d % V]WUfVcbUhc c HWc+ gY YbWiYbhfUb ZiYfU XY xfYU gcaVfYUXU% WUh]cbYg m Ub]cbYg gY a]XYb XY ZcfaU fih]bUf]U Yb Y UVcfUhcf]c
Yghc gi[]YfY eiY Y dUW]YbhY diYXY hYbYf ibU aYnW U xW]Xc VUgY W b]Wc' = WUh] b bcfaU aYbhY aYX]Xc Yg FU % m cg Ub]cbYg
hfUghcfbc' giY Yb gYf ; m ;G ,' DU VfYW U Ub] b]WU% eiY Yg gc c ibU
=g ]adcfhUbhY fYWcbcWYf eiY ib jU cf xW]Xc VUgY XYbhfc WcbWYdhc XY X]U[b gh]Wc3 Yg U X]ZYfYbW]U YbhfY Ub]cbYg bc aYX]Xcg m
XY xfYU gcaVfYUXU bc g]YadfY g][b]Z]WU eiY Um ib WUh]cbYg bc aYX]Xcg m gY Ygh]aU XY U g][i]YbhY aUbYfU3
hfUghcfbc UW]XcVxg]Wc g]ad Y' ;cb YghU fYgYfjU Yb aYbhY% cg
X]U[fUaUg xW]Xc VUgY gY diYXYb ih] ]nUf Wcac ib aYX]c :fYW U XY Ub]cbYg Yb d UgaU 6 SFU T S ;G , T S; T
fxd]Xc dUfU XYhYfa]bUf Y h]dc YgdYW Z]Wc m U [fUjYXUX XY ib 6 -- +- 6 + a=e ( D
hfUghcfbc xW]Xc VUgY'
Hcf Y Yad c% gidcb[U eiY Y d UgaU UfhYf]U XY ib DU VfYW U XY Ub]cbYg UiaYbhUfx g] cg Ub]cbYg bc aYX]Xcg
dUW]YbhY Uffc U cg g][i]YbhYg jU cfYg3 d % 0%,)4 d UgaU ;G, UiaYbhUb c g] WUYb cg WUh]cbYg bc aYX]Xcg' Dcg WUh]cbYg bc
WcbWYbhfUW] b% +%) a=e ( D4 m d UgaU HWc+% +. aa [' ;cb aYX]Xcg axg ]adcfhUbhYg ]bW imYb WU W]c% aU[bYg]c m dchUg]c% m
Yghcg jU cfYg% ibc diYXY a]fUf Y X]U[fUaU m YbWcbhfUf cg df]bW]dU Yg Ub]cbYg bc aYX]Xcg gcb U V a]bU% ZcgZUhc% gi ZUhc
eiY Yghc fYdfYgYbhU ibU UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU g]ad Y% Wcb m chfcg Ub]cbYg cf[xb]Wcg' Hcf c [YbYfU % cg Ub]cbYg bc
UXYWiUXU WcadYbgUW] b fYgd]fUhcf]U eiY fYXiWY U HWc+ aYX]Xcg gidYfUb U cg WUh]cbYg bc aYX]Xcg m Y ]bhYfjU c
XY gi jU cf bcfaU XY -) aa [ U +. aa [' Ub] b]Wc jUf U YbhfY 1 m / a=e ( D'
- 2
F :525 G Dcg Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg m cg f] cbYg
4 MP]Z ( + 9W]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU UgcW]UXU Wcb VfYW U Ub] b]WU :fckb <% OU[bYf ;93 EYWUb]gacg ac YWi UfYg XY XYhYWW] b xW]Xc VUgY dcf
d Ugaxh]WU bcfaU c UiaYbhUXU Y f] b' B 9a KcW FYd fc +,3 00-% +) +'
;ifh cmg FH% EcY GO3 ZibW] b XY h Vi c dfcl]aU m fYgdiYghU U U
2 XQY Z PQ M N]QOTM MYUpYUOM 3]QOTM MYUpYUOM YZ]XM UW]Xcg]g' ; ]b B 9a KcW FYd fc 23 /+0% +) -'
Z]XZO Z]QXUM 9U[Q]O Z]QXUM <Y;cifgYm L=3 ;UbU Yg XY dfchcbYg UWh]jUXcg dcf jc hU Y3 V]c c[ U
<]UVYhYg aY ]hig "WYhcUW]Xcg]g <]UffYU ac YWi Uf% Z]g]c c[ U m Z]g]cdUhc c[ U XY U ZUa] ]U "N ' H mg]c JYj
2,3 .22% +) ,'
9W]Xcg]g xWh]WU 9W]Xcg]g hiVi Uf fYbU Uaa DD% FU ci F% Yf]b[ Ka]h CK3 caYcghUg]g xW]Xc VUgY' ; ]b B
>U U fYbU Wfcb]WU 9b Xf]Xc WUfV b]Wc 9a KcW FYd fc )3 ++,+% +) .'
]b ]V]XcfYg CUaY CK% U dYf]b ED3 HfcV YaUg xW]Xc VUgY Yb U WYhcUW]Xcg]g X]UVzh]WU' F
=b[ B EYX ,0+3 .-/% +) .'
Abhcl]WUW] b Wcb Ugd]f]bU "xW]Xc =bZYfaYXUX XY 9XX]gcb
CfUih B9% EUX]Ug F=3 <]U[b gh]Wc X]ZYfYbW]U XY U UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU
UWYh] gU ]W ]Wc
g]b [Ud3 jU cf XY ib YbZceiY g]ghYaxh]Wc' ; ]b B 9a KcW FYd fc 03
=bjYbYbUa]Ybhc dcf aYhUbc /0 % +) +'
Abhcl]WUW] b Wcb Yh] Yb[ ]Wc Cifhn A3 9W]Xcg]g hiVi Uf fYbU 3 UbcaU Ug Yb Y hfUbgdcfhY XY ( VUgY m Uacb]UWc
m g bXfcaYg W b]Wcg' =bZYfaYXUX fYbU Wf b]WU UjUbnUXU +.3 ,,-%
UaVfibU
+) 1'
Cifhn A3 EYWUb]gacg ac YWi UfYg m fY[i UW] b XY U UW]X]Z]WUW] b if]bUf]U'
DU VfYW U Ub] b]WU d Ugaxh]WU gY ih] ]nU df]bW]dU aYbhY dUfU X]U[bcgh]WUf ;cadf H mg]c -3 0,0% +) -'
X]ZYfYbhYg WUigUg XY UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU' =b U UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU%
FU[Ua] ?L% Uaa DD3 JY[i UW] b XY Yei] ]Vf]c xW]Xc VUgY Yb U
YbZYfaYXUX fYbU Wf b]WU' 9Xj ; fcb]W C]XbYm <]g +-3 +0-% +) 0'
d UgaU ;G, gY fYXiWY U WcbWYbhfUW] b' K] Y gcX]c d Ugaxh]Wc
HU aYf :>% ; Y[[ <B3 U hYfUW]cbYg Y YWhfc h]WUg m xW]Xc VUgY Yb
DU WcbWYbhfUW] b bc WUaV]U% U WcbWYbhfUW] b XY Ub]cbYg "; c ib
dUW]YbhYg Wcb X]UVYhYg aY ]hig' F =b[ B EYX ,0,3 .-1% +) .'
Ub] b bc aYX]Xc UiaYbhU dUfU aUbhYbYf U Y YWhfcbYihfU ]XUX'
Hif Yfgcb BE% KW kUfhn ?B3 = dUdY XY Ug Ub ]XfUgUg WUfV b]WUg Yb U
K] Y ; d Ugaxh]Wc UiaYbhU Yb dfcdcfW] b U U WU XU Z]g]c c[ U fYbU ' C]XbYm Abh 0 3 ),% +))0'
Yb d UgaU ;G, % U VfYW U Ub] b]WU gY[i]fx g]YbXc bcfaU ' =ghY Yg Jcm 9% 9 VUhU]bY EE% HUghcf Kc Yf FE3 JY[i UW] b m ZibW] b WY i Uf
U aYbiXc fYZYf]Xc Wcac UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU ]dYfW cfza]WU' ]bhYfWU UXU XY WcbXiWhc Wc YWhcf' ; ]b B 9a KcW FYd fc )3 ,).%
K] U X]ga]biW] b XY ;G d Ugaxh]Wc, bc jU UWcadU UXc XY +) .'
UiaYbhc XY ; % XYVY UVYf b]jY Yg UiaYbhUXcg XY Ub]cbYg bc KY]ZhYf BD3 AbhY[fUW] b XY hfUghcfbcg UW]XcVxg]Wcg m Y YWhfc h]Wcg' F =b[ B
aYX]Xcg m% dcf c hUbhc% ib UiaYbhc Yb U VfYW U Ub] b]WU WU Wi UXU' EYX ,0 3 1+ % +) -'
DU UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU WUigUXU dcf ib YlWYgc XY xW]Xcg bc jc xh] Yg KY]ZhYf BD% ; Ub[ Q3 =ei] ]Vf]c xW]Xc VUgY YlhfUWY i Uf m hfUbgdcfhY XY ]cbYg
YbhfY WcadUfh]aYbhcg XY Z i]Xcg WcfdcfU Yg' >]g]c c[ U ":Yh YgXU ,+3
"UXYaxg XY ; % Wcac Y xW]Xc xWh]Wc c cg WYhcxW]Xcg% gY UgcW]U Wcb
,/0% +) 0'
ib UiaYbhc XY U VfYW U Ub] b]WU d Ugaxh]WU XYV]Xc U U WU XU
MXiaUb B% QYY B3 UW]Xcg]g hiVi Uf dgYiXc fYbU 3 WcbX]W]cbYg eiY ]a]hUb U
Yb ;G, bc gY WcffYgdcbXY Wcb ib UiaYbhc ][iU XY ; ' 9 [ibcg
UW]Xcg]g hiVi Uf fYbU ' 9Xj ; fcb]W C]XbYm <]g +.3 ,.1% +) 1' NU zg H?%
Y Yad cg XY UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU UgcW]UXU Wcb ibU VfYW U :Uh Y <3 9W]Xcg]g hiVi Uf fYbU X]ghU ]dcdchUgza]WU' =bZYfaYXUX fYbU
Ub] b]WU bcfaU c UiaYbhUXU gY aiYghfUb Yb 4 MP]Z ( +' 9 Wf b]WU UjUbnUXU +.3 ,),% +) 1'
WU Wi Uf U VfYW U Ub] b]WU% gY diYXYb fYXiW]f U [ibUg XY Ug NUbXYbVYf[ JB% JmUb JE3 EYWUb]gacg XY hfUbgdcfhY XY [ ihUaUhc' H mg]c
dcg]V Yg WUigUg XY U UW]Xcg]g aYhUV ]WU' JYj 2,3 /+ % +) ,'
OY]bYf A<% NYf UbXYf BO3 hfUbgdcfhUXcfYg XY Uacb UWc m gi dUdY Yb Y
Yei] ]Vf]c xW]Xc VUgY' H mg]c 203 -/.% +) 0'
:]V ]c[fUZ U
:Uh Y <% 9ffiXU B3 >cfaUg ]dYfdchUgza]WUg XY UW]Xcg]g hiVi Uf fYbU 3
UgdYWhcg W b]Wcg m Z]g]cdUhc []Wcg' =bZYfaYXUX fYbU Wf b]WU UjUbnUXU
+.3 ,+ % +) 1'
:fYhcb K% :fckb <3 JY[i UW] b XY U UW]X]Z]WUW] b ia]bU dcf U N
9LHUgU' >]g]c c[ U ":Yh YgXU +13 , 1% +) ,'
-+)