Name: ______________________________________________________ Score: _________

Grade & Section: _____________________________________________ PT #: __________

Rubric for Critical Analysis

Excellent Satisfactory Unsatisfactory

Component Total
4-5 points 2-3 points 0-1 point
Analysis of Provides a thorough, accurate analysis Provides a description, but only minimal Student does not accurately assess the
author’s of the author’s justification of the worth analysis, of the author’s justification of the author’s arguments justifying the study.
justification (x2) and significance of the study worth and significance of the study
Analysis of Provides a thorough, accurate analysis Provides a description, but only minimal Student does not accurately assess study
author’s of the study design, sample selection, analysis, of the study design, sample design, sample selection, and data
methods (x2) and data collection methods used in this selection, and data collection methods collection methods used in this study
study used in this study
Analysis of Provides a thorough, accurate analysis Provides a description, but only minimal Student does not assess accurately study
validity and of study bias, reliability, author analysis, of study bias, reliability, author bias, reliability, author credentials, and
credibility of the credentials, and publication venue credentials, and publication venue publication
study (x2)
Writing (x2) Overall, writing was clear, succinct, and Overall, writing was organized but lacked Overall, writing was disorganized and did
reflects the depth of student thinking/ some polish, and might not convey the not reflect a deep understanding of the
analysis. Paper is organized logically true depth of student understanding of the topic.
with adequate transitions between topic.
sections.
Mechanics Consistently grammatically correct with Few errors in spelling and grammar Utilizes poor spelling and grammar.
rare misspellings. evidenced.
Timeliness The output was submitted on time. The output was submitted a day late. The output was submitted two or more
days late.

Comments/ Suggestions:
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Parent’s/ Guardian’s Signature over Printed Name: ___________________________________________ Date: __________________

Name: ______________________________________________________ Score: _________

Grade & Section: _____________________________________________ PT #: __________

Rubric for Critical Analysis

Excellent Satisfactory Unsatisfactory

Component Total
4-5 points 2-3 points 0-1 point
Analysis of Provides a thorough, accurate analysis Provides a description, but only minimal Student does not accurately assess the
author’s of the author’s justification of the worth analysis, of the author’s justification of the author’s arguments justifying the study.
justification (x2) and significance of the study worth and significance of the study
Analysis of Provides a thorough, accurate analysis Provides a description, but only minimal Student does not accurately assess study
author’s of the study design, sample selection, analysis, of the study design, sample design, sample selection, and data
methods (x2) and data collection methods used in this selection, and data collection methods collection methods used in this study
study used in this study
Analysis of Provides a thorough, accurate analysis Provides a description, but only minimal Student does not assess accurately study
validity and of study bias, reliability, author analysis, of study bias, reliability, author bias, reliability, author credentials, and
credibility of the credentials, and publication venue credentials, and publication venue publication
study (x2)
Writing (x2) Overall, writing was clear, succinct, and Overall, writing was organized but lacked Overall, writing was disorganized and did
reflects the depth of student thinking/ some polish, and might not convey the not reflect a deep understanding of the
analysis. Paper is organized logically true depth of student understanding of the topic.
with adequate transitions between topic.
sections.
Mechanics Consistently grammatically correct with Few errors in spelling and grammar Utilizes poor spelling and grammar.
rare misspellings. evidenced.
Timeliness The output was submitted on time. The output was submitted a day late. The output was submitted two or more
days late.

Comments/ Suggestions:
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Parent’s/ Guardian’s Signature over Printed Name: ___________________________________________ Date: __________________