MOMENT COMPARISON - PILE RAFT

LEGEND
GROUP
OLD LAYOUT NEW LAYOUT (1.1) NEW LAYOUT (1.3)

Mx (MAX) = 3998 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2368 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3552 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -5424 kNm Mx (MIN) = -3915 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4856 kNm
11
My (MAX) = 2961 kNm My (MAX) = 2157 kNm My (MAX) = 2831 kNm
My (MIN) = -6299 kNm My (MIN) = -5228 kNm My (MIN) = -6624 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 4185 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2835 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3831 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -5418 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4059 kNm Mx (MIN) = -5259 kNm
12
My (MAX) = 1608 kNm My (MAX) = 1709 kNm My (MAX) = 1704 kNm
My (MIN) = -4021 kNm My (MIN) = -3604 kNm My (MIN) = -4419 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 2799 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2623 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3325 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -2371 kNm Mx (MIN) = -2133 kNm Mx (MIN) = -2787 kNm
13
My (MAX) = 1571 kNm My (MAX) = 1971 kNm My (MAX) = 1965 kNm
My (MIN) = -3607 kNm My (MIN) = -3192 kNm My (MIN) = -4059 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 2932 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2354 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3178 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -4949 kNm Mx (MIN) = -5008 kNm Mx (MIN) = -6153 kNm
21
My (MAX) = 3323 kNm My (MAX) = 4868 kNm My (MAX) = 6690 kNm
My (MIN) = -5532 kNm My (MIN) = -6899 kNm My (MIN) = -9013 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 1640 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2336 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2421 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -3520 kNm Mx (MIN) = -3883 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4112 kNm
22
My (MAX) = 4219 kNm My (MAX) = 4946 kNm My (MAX) = 6395 kNm
My (MIN) = -5313 kNm My (MIN) = -6151 kNm My (MIN) = -8439 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 2289 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2122 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3606kNm

Mx (MIN) = -4515 kNm Mx (MIN) = -3599 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4574 kNm
23
My (MAX) = 3975 kNm My (MAX) = 2008 kNm My (MAX) = 2994 kNm
My (MIN) = -5228 kNm My (MIN) = -6393 kNm My (MIN) = -7659 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 2449 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3034 kNm Mx (MAX) = 5121 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -4313 kNm Mx (MIN) = -3820 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4556 kNm
24
My (MAX) = 2225 kNm My (MAX) = 2240 kNm My (MAX) = 3208 kNm
My (MIN) = -7153 kNm My (MIN) = -6350 kNm My (MIN) = -7047 kNm
 MOMENT COMPARISON - PILE RAFT
LEGEND
GROUP
OLD LAYOUT NEW LAYOUT (1.1) NEW LAYOUT (1.3)

Mx (MAX) = 2799 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2380 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2482 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -3085 kNm Mx (MIN) = -2716 kNm Mx (MIN) = -3173 kNm
31
My (MAX) = 2770 kNm My (MAX) = 1161 kNm My (MAX) = 1736 kNm
My (MIN) = -4334 kNm My (MIN) = -4407 kNm My (MIN) = -4729 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 2191 kNm Mx (MAX) = 1997 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2241 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -5442 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4983 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4982 kNm
32
My (MAX) = 873 kNm My (MAX) = 358 kNm My (MAX) = 764 kNm
My (MIN) = -7198 kNm My (MIN) = -5442 kNm My (MIN) = -5440 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 1264 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3058 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3249 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -4087 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4253 kNm Mx (MIN) = -4338 kNm
33
My (MAX) = 3083 kNm My (MAX) = 3488 kNm My (MAX) = 3672 kNm
My (MIN) = -5925 kNm My (MIN) = -5814 kNm My (MIN) = -6375 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 5871 kNm Mx (MAX) = 2967 kNm Mx (MAX) = 3200 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -1136 kNm Mx (MIN) = -1915 kNm Mx (MIN) = -2674 kNm
34
My (MAX) = 3042 kNm My (MAX) = 2819 kNm My (MAX) = 3535 kNm
My (MIN) = -3923 kNm My (MIN) = -3745 kNm My (MIN) = -4275 kNm

Mx (MAX) = 2356 kNm Mx (MAX) = 401 kNm Mx (MAX) = 527 kNm

Mx (MIN) = -3927 kNm Mx (MIN) = -6210 kNm Mx (MIN) = -5244 kNm
35
My (MAX) = 308 kNm My (MAX) = 443 kNm My (MAX) = 508 kNm
My (MIN) = -3469 kNm My (MIN) = -6208 kNm My (MIN) = -5227 kNm