You are on page 1of 237

Irrigation Water Conveyance

After completing this session the student will be aware of the


features of irrigation water conveyance systems and how they may
affect on farm water management.
Conveyance System Requirements

I Deliver water to every part of the irrigated area at a rate and


elevation that permits proper operation of the application
system;
I Be compatible with the application equipment;
I Convey the water as economically, efficiently and safely as
possible; and
I Be accessible for Operation and Maintenance.
On Farm Conveyance System
Conveyance System Schematic
Conveyance Efficiency

Volume....Delivered
Ec =
Volume....Diverted
I In the Western States, an estimated one-third to one-half of
the water diverted for irrigation is lost between the source and
point of use
I NRCS NEH Part 623, Chapter 2, Irrigation Water
Requirements
Conveyance Losses

I Operational spills
I Seepage
I Consumptive Use by vegetation & evaporation
I Leakage around structures
Typical Conveyance Efficiencies
Distribution Efficiency Study

Element 3yr Rounded Average 3yr Rounded A


Volume Diverted, (ac-ft) 355,000 (59 acre-inches) 355,000 (59 a
Canal Waste (-), (ac-ft) 25,000 7Lateral Wast
Distribution Efficiency 72% Farm Waste 150,000 (25 a
Application Efficiency 41% Overall Farm Efficiency 30%
I 1988-1990, Riverton Unit - Wind River Project, USBOR,
(72,000 acres)
Conveyance System Components

I Open Channels
I Pipelines
I Conveyance Structures
I Diversions & Pumps
I Headgates, Wasteways, Division Boxes, Turnouts
I Water Measurement Devices
I Check & Grade Control Structures
I Flumes, Siphons & Culverts
Diversion Dam or Pumps

I They should:
I Provide the Required Flow Rate
I Provide the Required Elevation or Pressure
I Perform Properly over the entire Irrigation Season
I Accommodate Fish or Other Resource Concerns
I Perform without Excessive Operation & Maintenance

And if they don’t:


I Plan repairs, replacement; or
I Develop an IWM strategy to deal with the constraint.
Diversion Dam
Diversion Dam
Diversion Dam
Headgates, Turnouts & Other Ditch Structures

I They should:
I Provide the required flow rate & elevation or pressure
I Screen excessive or undesirable debris
I Accommodate expected sedimentation
I Provide opportunity for water measurement
I Perform without excessive Operation & Maintenance

And if they don’t:


I Plan repairs, replacement; or
I Develop IWM strategy to deal with the constraint.
Headgates & Turnouts
Headgates & Turnouts
Headgates, Turnouts & Other Structures
Headgates, Turnouts & Other Structures
Headgates, Turnouts & Other Ditch Structures
Other Ditch Structures
Other Ditch Structures
Other Ditch Structures
Other Ditch Structures
Canals & Ditches

I They should:
I Have capacity for the required flow rate
I Screen excessive or undesirable debris
I Accommodate expected sedimentation
I Limit Losses to an acceptable amount
I Perform without excessive Operation & Maintenance
I
I And if they don’t:
I Plan repairs, replacement; or
I Develop IWM strategy to deal with the constraint.
Canals & Ditches

I Features:
I Used for main canal, laterals & on farm transport
I Open channel, gravity flow
I Water surface controls the delivery elevation
I Natural earth or lined channels
Canals & Ditches
Canals & Ditches
Canals & Ditches

I Benefits:
I Accommodate small to large flows
I May accommodate large debris
I Many alternatives for water measurement
I Low to moderate construction cost (unlined)
I Intercept runoff & groundwater
I May provide some storage capacity
I May support some riparian functions
Canals & Ditches

I Disadvantages:
I Must have adequate slope
I May require checks & grade control structures
I Prone to operation waste (up to 50
I Seepage, vegetative & evaporation losses
I Seepage may damage adjacent land & property
I May occupy a large area & require crossing structures
Canals & Ditches

I Disadvantages: cont.
I May provide source of weed seed
I Susceptible to erosion, sedimentation, flood damage, &
rodents
I Higher maintenance than pipelines
I Poor maintenance reduces capacity
I Can be a safety concern
Canals & Ditches
Typical Unlined Canal/Ditch Losses

I Loss to Ditch-side Vegetation 0.5% - 1% per mile


I Loss to Ditch Evaporation 0.5 % per mile
Ditch Canal Lining Alternatives
Ditch Canal Lining Alternatives

I Traditional Canal Linings 1 to 10 / sq ft)


I Compacted Clay
I Concrete Lining
I Buried Geomembrane
I Exposed Geomembranes
I Concrete Covered Geomembranes
I Spray-applied Membranes
I Reduce seepage loss by 90 - 95
I Service life 20 to 50 years.
Ditch Canal Lining Alternatives

I PAM Canal Treatment


I Cost 0.005 to 0.02 / sq ft
I May reduce seepage loss by 30% - 50%
I May require annual treatment
I Doesn’t work in all situations
Pipelines

I They should:
I Deliver the required flow at the required elevation/pressure
I Provide opportunity for water measurement
I Perform without excessive operation & maintenance
I
I And if they don’t:
I Plan needed maintenance, replacement; or
I Develop IWM strategy to deal with the constraints
Pipelines

I Features:
I Gravity or Pressure Flow
I Available head / pressure controls delivery elevation
I Above ground or underground installations
I PVC, PE, Concrete, Steel & Aluminum materials
Pipelines

I Benefits:
I Less dependent on topography than ditches
I Greater flow control = less operational waste
I Very small water losses (0.01 - 0.15 ft3/ft2)
I Little to no loss of land use
I Eliminate weed seed production
I Less susceptible to environmental damage
I Typically fewer maintenance & safety concerns
Pipelines
Pipelines
Pipelines
Pipelines
Pipelines
Pipelines

I Disadvantages:
I Moderate to high cost compared to unlined ditch
I Not feasible for large flows
I Must screen out debris and prevent sedimentation
I Fewer and more expensive alternatives for water measurement
I Provides no riparian function values
Pipelines
Summary

No irrigation system is worth a hill of beans if the water is not


available to the crop at the time that the plants require it

Questions?
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Section 1

Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream


Control

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Kegunaan
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Mengontrol tinggi muka air di bagian HULU


Buka-tutup : berdasarkan tekanan air
Tipe :
Begemann gate
Vlugter gate
AMIL gate

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Subsection 1

Begemann Gate

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Begemann Gate
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Terdiri dari :
Daun pintu
(datar)
Engsel
(horizontal)
Penyeimbang

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Perlu kehilangan enersi yg besar :z > h

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Pada posisi tertutup :


 
1 2
ρgbh2 h + a = p × (G + W ) (1)
2 3
G : berat pintu, W : berat penyeimbang
Jika a = 12 h dan p = 83 h, maka:

W = 1.6ρg b h2 − G

(2)

α antara 15 - 55o , maka Decrement : 4h = 0.4 − 0.17 tan α


Untuk α antara 45 - 55o , maka 4h = 0.2 h, dan kedalaman
air di bangunan menjadi (h − 4h)

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Subsection 2

Vlugter Gate

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Vlugter Gate
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Terdiri dari :
Daun pintu
(drum)
Engsel
(horizontal)
Penyeimbang

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

2
Kehilangan enersi relatif kecil : z = 1.0( V2g )
Disarankan : bh = 5 dan a = 12 h
Decrement : 4h = 0.15 h

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Subsection 3

Amil Gate

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Amil Gate
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Terdiri dari :
Daun pintu radial
Pelampung pada
bagian depan daun
pintu
“servo tab” (bag daun
pintu yg ditekuk)
Dua penyeimbang
Daun pintu : trapesium
V : H = 1 : 0.5

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Indeks dimensi D : D = 100 d


Free flow : z ≥ 12 × 10−4 D Q = 3.0 × 10−6 D
Submerge : Q = 4.4 × 10−5 D 2.1 z 0.4
Q : debit, m3 /det ; D : indeks dimensi ; z : kehilangan head,
m

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Lanjutan...
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control Begemann Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control Vlugter Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage Amil Gate

Desain untuk Q dan z


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Desain untuk Q dan z tertentu:


D :
Submerge : D ≈ 120Q 0.48 z −0.19
Free flow : D ≈ 160Q 0.40
b = 56x10−4 D
H = 45x10−4 D
z ≥ 0.27 h
4h ≈ 0.05 h
Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Section 2

Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream


Control

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Kegunaan
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Mengontrol tinggi muka air di bagian HILIR -


Buka-tutup : berdasarkan tekanan air -
Tipe :
Avis gate
Avio gate

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Subsection 1

Avis Gate

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Avis Gate
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
Terdiri dari : B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Contoh AVIS Gate


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Dimensi AVIS Gate


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Indeks dimensi : R/B


R ≈ r (jari-jari pelampung, cm) : R = 100r
B ≈ b (lebar dasar, cm) : B = 100b
Dimensi yg umum:

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

AVIS Gate: High Head vs Low Head


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Dibedakan:
Low head : E = 0.74b ; B = 2.13R
High head : E = 0.92b ; B = 1.89R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Head loss chart : untuk pemilihan pintu


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Desain
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

berdasarkan:
head loss z dan debit Q
Variasi muka air di hulu V
Persyaratan:
Tidak akan terjadi overtopping
High Head AVIS gate: R > 143 (V + z)
Low Head AVIS gate: R > 250 (V + z)
Kapasitas sesuai dgn Q (pada free flow)
High Head AVIS gate: R > 66Q 0.40
Low Head AVIS gate: R > 57Q 0.40
Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Pada Q desain, R Terpilih menghasilkan z


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Pintu dengan R terpilih menghasilkan z aktual pada Q desain


High Head AVIS gate: z = 1.0 × 106 R −4 Q 2 + 0.05 × 10−2 R
Low Head AVIS gate: z = 0.6 × 106 R −4 Q 2 + 0.05 × 10−2 R
Dimensi:
High head : b = 1.89x10−2 R; h = 1.00x10−2 R;
r = 1.60x10−2 R; 4h = 0.05x10−2 R
Low head : b = 2.13x10−2 R; h = 1.13x10−2 R;
r = 1.80x10−2 R ; 4h = 0.05x10−2 R
Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Subsection 2

Avio Gate

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Avio Gate
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
Terdiri dari : B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Contoh AVIO Gate


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

High Head vs Low Head


P E R
T
U

T
High head

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Low head

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Head loss chart


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Desain
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Berdasarkan:
head loss z dan debit Q
Variasi muka air di hulu V

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Persyaratan:
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Tidak akan terjadi overtopping


High Head AVIO gate: R > 25 (V + z), Low Head AVIO gate:
R > 50 (V + z)
Kapasitas sesuai dgn Q (pada free flow)
High Head AVIO gate: R > 87Q 0.40 , Low Head AVIO gate:
R > 73Q 0.40

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Pada Q desain, R Terpilih menghasilkan z


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Pintu dgn R terpilih menghasilkan z aktual pada Q desain


High Head AVIO gate: z = 9.8 × 106 R −4 Q 2 + 0.05 × 10−2 R
Low Head AVIO gate: z = 2.4 × 106 R −4 Q 2 + 0.05 × 10−2 R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Avis Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Avio Gate
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Dimensi:
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

High head : b = 0.90x10−2 R ; w = 0.90x10−2 R ;


h = 1.07x10−2 R ; bs = 2.50x10−2 R; r = 1.80x10−2 R ;
4h = 0.05x10−2 R
Low head : b = 1.80x10−2 R ; w = 0.90x10−2 R ;
h = 1.07x10−2 R ; bs = 2.50x10−2 R; r = 1.80x10−2 R ;
4h = 0.05x10−2 R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Section 3

Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Mengontrol aliran hanya ke satu arah


=⇒Drainase
Buka-tutup pintu ⇐= tekanan air ⇐= otomatis
Umumnya di daerah Pasang surut (tidal area)
Tipe :
Pintu klep (flap gate)
Tidal sluice

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Pintu Klep (Flap Gate)


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Terdiri dari :
Daun pintu
Engsel (dipasang horizontal)

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Bentuk Persegi empat:


P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Upstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Downstream Control
Hydro-mechanical Regulator for Drainage

Bentuk Bulat:
P E R
T
U

T
T

A
S T I

N I A N
I N
B
O G O R

Yuli Suharnoto Ph.D. - IPB University SIL-432: BANGUNAN HIDROLIKA


HYDRO-MECHANICAL
REGULATOR FOR
UPSTREAM CONTROL

Asep Sapei 1
 Mengontrol tinggi muka air di bagian HULU

 Buka-tutup : berdasarkan tekanan air

 Tipe :
o Begemann gate
o Vlugter gate
o AMIL gate

Asep Sapei 2
Begemann Gate

 Terdiri dari :
o Daun pintu (datar)
o Engsel (horizontal)
o Penyeimbang

Asep Sapei 3
Perlu kehilangan enersi yg besar : z > h

Pada posisi tertutup :

G : berat pintu, W: berat penyeimbang

Jika a=1/2 h dan p = 3/8 h, maka

α : antara 15 – 55 0, maka Decrement : h = 0.4 – 0.17 tan 

Untuk α : antara 45 – 55 0, maka h=0.2 h, dan

Kedalaman air di bangunan menjadi (h - h)


Asep Sapei 4
Asep Sapei 5
Vlugter Gate

 Terdiri dari :
o Daun pintu (drum)
o Engsel (horizontal)
o Penyeimbang

Asep Sapei 6
Kehilangan enersi relatif kecil : z = 1.0 (v2/2g)

Disarankan : b/h = 5 dan a=1/2 h

Decrement : h = 0.15h

Asep Sapei 7
Asep Sapei 8
Asep Sapei 9
Amil Gate

 Terdiri dari :
o Daun pintu radial
o Pelampung pd bagian
depan daun pintu
o “servo tab” (bag
daun pintu yg
ditekuk)
o Dua penyeimbang

 Daun pintu : trapesium


V:H = 1:0.5

Asep Sapei 10
Asep Sapei 11
 Indeks dimensi D : D = 100d

 Free flow : z ≥ 12x10-4D


 Sumerge :

Q : debit, m3/det ; D : indeks dimensi ; z : kehilangan head, m

Asep Sapei 12
Asep Sapei 13
 Desain utk Q dan z tertentu:
D : Submerge :

Free flow :
b=56x10-4D
H=45x10-4D
z≥0.27h
h≈0.05h

Asep Sapei 14
HYDRO-MECHANICAL
REGULATOR FOR
DOWNSTREAM CONTROL

Asep Sapei 1
 Mengontrol tinggi muka air di bagian HILIR

 Buka-tutup : berdasarkan tekanan air

 Tipe :
o Avis gate
o Avio gate

Asep Sapei 2
Avis Gate

 Terdiri dari :

Asep Sapei 3
Asep Sapei 4
 Indeks dimensi : R/B
R ≈ r (jari2 pelampung, cm) : R = 100r
B ≈ b (lebar dasar, cm) : B=100b

 Dimensi yg umum

Asep Sapei 5
 Dibedakan:
o Low head : E=0.74b ; B=2.13R
o High head : E=0.92b ; B=1.89R

Asep Sapei 6
 Head loss chart : utk pemilihan pintu

Asep Sapei 7
 Desain
o berdasarkan: - head loss z dan debit Q
- Variasi muka air di hulu V
o Persyaratan:
 Tidak akan terjadi overtopping

 Kapasitas sesuai dgn Q (pada free flow)

Asep Sapei 8
 Pintu dgn R terpilih menghasilkan z aktual pada Q desain

o Dimensi:
High head : b=1.89x10-2R ; h=1.00x10-2R ; r=1.60x10-2R ;
h=0.05x10-2R
Low head : b=2.13x10-2R ; h=1.13x10-2R ; r=1.80x10-2R ;
h=0.05x10-2R

Asep Sapei 9
Avio Gate

 Terdiri dari :

Asep Sapei 10
Asep Sapei 11
High head

Low head
Asep Sapei 12
 Head loss chart

Asep Sapei 13
 Desain
o berdasarkan: - head loss z dan debit Q
- Variasi muka air di hulu V
o Persyaratan:
 Tidak akan terjadi overtopping

 Kapasitas sesuai dgn Q (pada free flow)

Asep Sapei 14
 Pintu dgn R terpilih menghasilkan z aktual pada Q
desain

oDimensi:
High head : b=0.90x10-2R ; w=0.90x10-2R ; h=1.07x10-2R ;
bs=2.50x10-2R; r=1.80x10-2R ; h=0.05x10-2R
Low head : b=1.80x10-2R ; w=0.90x10-2R ; h=1.07x10-2R ;
bs=2.50x10-2R; r=1.80x10-2R ; h=0.05x10-2R

Asep Sapei 15
HYDRO-MECHANICAL
REGULATOR FOR
DRAINAGE

Asep Sapei 1
HYDRO-MECHANICAL REGULATOR FOR
DRAINAGE

 Mengontrol aliran hanya ke satu arah


Drainase

 Buka-tutup pintu tekanan air otomatis

 Umumnya di daerah Pasang surut (tidal)

 Tipe :
o Pintu klep (flap gate)
o Tidal sluice

Asep Sapei 2
PINTU KLEP (FLAP GATE)

 Terdiri dari :
o Daun pintu
o Engsel (dipasang horizontal)

Asep Sapei 3
 Bentuk :
o Persegi empat

Asep Sapei 4
o Bulat

Asep Sapei 5
o Semi Bulat

Asep Sapei 6
 Hidrolika

o Analisis gaya saat tertutup, persegiempat, vertikal


Gaya yg bekerja : gaya hidrostatika

A F1 = ½ ℎ12
F2 = ½ ℎ22

=adalah massa jenis air (1000kg/m3)


= adalah gravitasi (9.81m/s2 )

Pusat gaya: 1/3 h dari dasar

Seimbang : ∑MA = 0

Asep Sapei 7
o saat terbuka persegiempat

Gaya yg bekerja :

- gaya hidrostatika (bidang miring)


- gaya hidrodinamik (aliran)
F= ( 2− 1)
- berat pintu
W= ρpintug Vpintu
Pada bukan tertentu (α) : ∑MA = 0

Asep Sapei 8
o debit

Q  K .  .a .b 2 . g .h1
Q: debit, m3/det
K : koefisien
μ : koefisien aliran
a : bukaan pintu vertikal, m
b : lebar pintu
g : gaya gravitasi
h1: tinggi muka air di hulu
 air h1
y 
 pintu
a = y sin (180-β)

Asep Sapei 9
Asep Sapei 10
TIDAL SLUICE

 Terdiri dari :
o Daun pintu (2 buah)
o Engsel (dipasang vertikal)

Asep Sapei 11
Asep Sapei 12
o Pintu tertutup – permukaan air di dalam < set point
o Pintu terbuka – permukaan air di dalam > set point
dan permukaan air di luar < set point
o Pintu tertutup – permukaan air di dalam > set point
dan permukaan air di luar > set point

Asep Sapei 13
Debit

o Free flow: Q  1.7bH 1.5 , z > 1/3 H

o Submerge : , z < 1/3 H


1 1
Q by 2 gz  4.4 by z
 

Q : debit, m3/det
b : lebar pintu, m
H : tinggi muka air di atas ambang di hulu, m
y : tinggi muka air di atas ambang di hilir, m
z : kehilangan enerji, m
α : koefisien (=1)

Asep Sapei 14
contoh

- Luas 6000 Ha
- Hujan 10 mm/hari
-Tinggi ambang 1.20 MSL
- Target drainase sampai 0 MSL

Asep Sapei 15
contoh

Asep Sapei 16
DIVERSION STRUCTURES

Asep Sapei 1
Fungsi bangunan diversi

 Mengalihkan aliran air lebih yang tidak diperlukan


o irigasi
o pengendalian banjir
 Dibuat di titik percabangan
 Percabangan : umumnya menjadi 2 saluran dgn
dimensi berbeda karakteristik hidroloka
berbeda

Asep Sapei 2
Asep Sapei 3
Sal. diversi

Asep Sapei 4
Operasi bang. Diversi untuk irigasi

 Opsi alokasi air irigasi:


o Splitted flow : cara pembagian air tradisional
(kontinu)
o Intermittent flow : “on - of irrigation”
o Adjustable flow : debit aliran dapat
disesuaikan dgn kebutuhan
 Opsi bang. Diversi :
o Tergantung opsi alokasi air
o Splitted flow pembagian yg proporsional
o Intermittent flow di saluran utama: rotasi
atau adjustable
o Adj. flow adjustable di sal utama, intermt.
atau rotasi di sal. sekunder
Asep Sapei 5
Asep Sapei 6
Asep Sapei 7
Operasi bang. Diversi untuk peng. banjir

 Proportional diversion
 Hanya diversi banjir : Apabila debit melebihi
batas tertentu dialihkan
 Proportional diversion sampai kapasitas maks.
saluran asal, kemudian debit lebih di alihkan

Asep Sapei 8
Apabila Q melebihi Q maks :
o Saluran ongoing yg diproteksi
o Saluran diversi yg diproteksi

Asep Sapei 9
Apabila Q melebihi Q maks :
o Saluran ongoing yg diproteksi
o Saluran diversi yg diproteksi

 Debit desain : periode ulang tingkat resiko


tinggi Asep
jagaan
Sapei 10
Sensivitas bang. diversi

 Sensitivitas:
o ratio antara variasi debit diversi dgn variasi
debit saluran ongoing
o Dipengaruhi kurva lengkung (rating curve)

Asep Sapei 11
Asep Sapei 12
Sensivitas diversi
pengendali banjir

Asep Sapei 13
Asep Sapei 14
Sensivitas diversi irigasi

Asep Sapei 15
Pertimbangan Desain

 Efek aliran balik (back water)


o Qdominan tdk menimbulkan efek aliran balik
o Q < Qdominan : positif backwater curve sedimentasi
o Q . Qdominan, negatif backwater curve penggerusan

Asep Sapei 16
Pertimbangan Desain

 Efek aliran balik (back water)


o Qdominan tdk menimbulkan efek aliran balik
o Q < Qdominan : positif backwater curve sedimentasi
o Q . Qdominan, negatif backwater curve penggerusan

 Kekritisan aliran :
o Sub kritis : mempengaruhi bangunan
o Super kritis : tdk mempengaruhi
Asep Sapei
bangunan 17
Pers. Hidrolika

 Weir for water level control

b dibuat minimal utk menekan biaya

Asep Sapei 18
 Orifice for water level control

 = 0.5 - 1

Asep Sapei 19
 Orifice for discharge control

Asep Sapei 20
Side spillway effect

 Sepanjang longitudinal head konstan, dan ke arah hulu:


o Level muka air menurun
o Head loss V2/2g menaik
 Kehilangan enersi α V2/2g

perhitungan ke arah hulu : step by step

Asep Sapei 21
No side spillway effect

 Penurunan head gradual: α = 0, maka tdk terjadi kehilangan enersi


 Hc >>> α V2/2g
 Hc << Hc
 Hofftake = Hongoing
 Hc = Hongoing - p

perhitungan menjadi sederhana


Asep Sapei 22
Lebar minimum

 “Check” pada pemasukan dibuat pd kondisi aliran sub kritis


kehilangan enersi dan tractive force kecil
 Bangunan didesain dgn menentukan garis muka air sepanjang
bangunan, dan menentukan bilangan Froud (F=V/(gy)0.5)

Asep Sapei 23
Garis muka air

 Enersi konstan sepanjang bangunan;


o Free offtake: Enersi head = Hongoing
o Control offtake : Enersi head = Hc + p
 Berdasarkan enersi kecepatan (V2/2g)

Perhitungan langsung: dgn broad crest weir

Asep Sapei 24
Asep Sapei 25
Jenis/Tipe Bangunan Diversi

 Free dan controlled offtake

 Open offtake

Asep Sapei 26
Konfigurasi Bangunan Diversi

 Tujuan: memenuhi offtake dan control


o Tipe regulator (tanpa, muka air, debit, ratio debit)
o Cara pengendalian (pasif, manual, hydro-mechanical)
o Tipe aliran (overflow, underflow)

 Free offtake

Asep Sapei 27
 Passive diversion

Asep Sapei 28
 Gate diversion

Asep Sapei 29
DIVERSION STRUCTURES
-Design examples -

Asep Sapei 1
Free offtake – Overflow free offtake

 Konfigurasi

Asep Sapei 2
 Kinerja :
o Tergantung kedalaman
aliran ongoing
o Seperti side channel
spillway
o Kelemahan:
 Lebar weir tdk realistik
 Kedalaman aliran di ongoing
channel tdk dpt dikendalikan
 Tergantung karakteristik
hidrolik sal. Ongoing
 Efek drawn down

Asep Sapei 3
 Design parameter:
o Parameter yg diketahui
• Kedalaman aliran di saluran ongoing:
• Ytarget : aliran mulai terdisversi
• Ymaks : debit terdisversi maksimum
• Luas penampang aliran, A
• Kecepatan aliran, V
• Kehilangan head (agar free flow), z
o Variables design:
 Lebar weir, b
 Tinggi ambang, p
o Hydraulic parameters:
 Head maksimum, Hmax
 Kedalaman aliran di bag hulu dari Z, yx
 Kecepatan aliran di bag hulu dari Z, Vx
 Head di bg hulu dari Z, Hx
 Debit sepanjang b,Asep
Qx Sapei 4
Asep Sapei 5
 Design condition:
1. Aliran mulai terdisversi saat kedalaman aliran > kedalaman
target : p = ytarget
2. Hmaks = ymaks + (vmaks)2/2g
3.

4. Bend loss = , maka Hx=yx


5.
6. bt= ∑ b
7. Qt = ∑Qx

Asep Sapei 6
Free offtake – Gated free offtake

 Konfigurasi

Asep Sapei 7
 Kinerja :
o Tergantung kedalaman
aliran ongoing
o Efek side channel spillway
tdk ada
o Kelemahan:
 Tergantung karakteristik
hidrolik sal. Ongoing
 Efek drawn down

Asep Sapei 8
 Design parameter:
o Parameter yg diketahui
• Kedalaman aliran di saluran ongoing:
• Ytarget : kedalaman maksimum
• Luas penampang aliran, A
• Kecepatan aliran, V
• Kehilangan head (agar free flow), z
o Variables design:
 Lebar pintu, b
 Maksimum bukaan orifice, w
o Hydraulic parameters:
 Head maksimum di sal ongoing, Htarget
 Head di offtake, H

Asep Sapei 9
Asep Sapei 10
 Design condition:

1. Htarget = ytarget + (vtarget)2/2g


2. Ht = Htarget
3.

4. wt = 2/3Ht

Asep Sapei 11
Asep Sapei 12
Passive Diversion – Overflow offtake with
orifice control

 Konfigurasi

Asep Sapei 13
 Kinerja :

Asep Sapei 14
 Design parameter:
o Parameter yg diketahui
• Kedalaman aliran di saluran ongoing:
• Ytarget : kedalaman saat aliran mulai terdisversi
• Ymaks
• Luas penampang aliran, A
• Kecepatan aliran, V
• Kehilangan head pada control, zc
o Variables design:
 Lebar orifice, bc ▪ bukaan orifice, w
 Lebar offtake, b ▪Tinggi ambang, p
o Hydraulic parameters:
 Htarget
 Head di hulu pd aliran dominan, Hdom
 Head di atas ambang pd aliran dominan, H
 debit terdisversi pd aliran dominan, Qtdom
 debit ongoing pd aliran dominan, Qcdom
Asep Sapei 15
Asep Sapei 16
 Design condition:
1. wc ≈ ytarget
2. Htarget = ytarget + (vtarget)2/2g
3. ztarget =  (v)2/2g

4. pt = Htarget + ztarget
5. Tdk ada efek backwater : Hdom = Huniform
6. Ht = Hc – pt ; Htdom= Hcdom – pt
7. ;

8.

9. Qdom = Qtdom + Qcdom Asep Sapei 17


Asep Sapei 18
Asep Sapei 19
Passive Diversion – Proportional

 Konfigurasi

Asep Sapei 20
 Kinerja :

Asep Sapei 21
 Design parameter:
o Parameter yg diketahui
• Kedalaman aliran di saluran ongoing:
• Luas penampang aliran, A
• Kecepatan aliran, V
• Kehilangan head pada control, zc
o Variables design:
 Lebar weir ongoing, bc ▪ tinggi ambang ongoing,pc
 Lebar weir offtake, b ▪Tinggi ambang offtake, pt
o Hydraulic parameters:
 Hongoing
 Hc
 Ht

Asep Sapei 22
Asep Sapei 23
 Design condition:
1. ;
2.
3.
4.
5.
6. pc = pt
7.

Asep Sapei 24
Asep Sapei 25
Asep Sapei 26
Passive Diversion – Proportional with orifice
control

 Konfigurasi

Asep Sapei 27
 Kinerja :

Asep Sapei 28
 Design parameter:
o Parameter yg diketahui
• Kedalaman aliran maksimum di saluran ongoing, yongoing
• Luas penampang aliran, A
• Kecepatan aliran, V
• Kehilangan head pada offtake, zt, free flow
o Variables design:
 Lebar weir ongoing, bc ▪tinggi ambang ongoing,pc
 Lebar weir offtake, bt ▪Tinggi ambang offtake, pt
 Bukaan orifice, wc
o Hydraulic parameters:
 Hongoing
 Hc
 Ht
Asep Sapei 29
Asep Sapei 30
 Design condition:
1. ;
2.
3.
4.
5.

6. pc = pt
7.
8. Yc=2/3Hc = wc pada Qongoing=(1-n)Qincoming

Asep Sapei 31
Asep Sapei 32
Asep Sapei 33
Gated Diversion – Gate offtake with weir
control

 Konfigurasi

Asep Sapei 34
 Kinerja :

Asep Sapei 35
 Design parameter:
o Parameter yg diketahui
• Debit maksimum di saluran ongoing, Qtarget
• Luas penampang aliran, A
• Kecepatan aliran, V
• Kehilangan head pada offtake, zt, free flow
o Variables design:
 Lebar weir ongoing, bc ▪tinggi ambang ongoing,pc
 Lebar weir offtake, bt ▪ Bukaan orifice pintu, wt

o Hydraulic parameters:
 Hongoing
 Hc
 Hdom incoming

Asep Sapei 36
Asep Sapei 37
 Design condition:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

Asep Sapei 38
Gated Diversion – Overflow offtake with gate
control

 Konfigurasi

Asep Sapei 39
 Kinerja :
Sama dengan overflow offtake with orifice-control

Asep Sapei 40
 Design parameter: sama dgn overflow offtake with
orifice control
o Parameter yg diketahui
• Kedalaman aliran di saluran ongoing:
• Ytarget : kedalaman saat aliran mulai terdisversi
• Ymaks
• Luas penampang aliran, A
• Kecepatan aliran, V
• Kehilangan head pada control, zc
o Variables design:
 Lebar orifice, bc ▪ bukaan orifice, w
 Lebar offtake, b ▪Tinggi ambang, p
o Hydraulic parameters:
 Htarget
 Head di hulu pd aliran dominan, Hdom
 Head di atas ambang pd aliran dominan, H
 debit terdisversi pd aliran dominan, Qtdom
 debit ongoing pd aliran dominan, Qcdom
Asep Sapei 41
Asep Sapei 42
 Design condition: Sama dgn overflow offtake with
orifice control
1. wc ≈ ytarget
2. Htarget = ytarget + (vtarget)2/2g
3. ztarget =  (v)2/2g

4. pt = Htarget + ztarget
5. Tdk ada efek backwater : Hdom = Huniform
6. Ht = Hc – pt ; Htdom= Hcdom – pt
7. ;

8.

9. Qdom = Qtdom + Qcdom Asep Sapei 43


DROP STRUCTURES
AND
STILLING BASIN

Asep Sapei 1
Fungsi :

Meredam/menurunkan enersi aliran air yg berlebihan


agar aliran air tidak merusak

Tipe :
o Meredam enersi pada saluran yg curam
o Meredam enersi pada bangunan pengendali

Asep Sapei 2
Cara meredam enersi:

o Gesekan dengan dinding saluran


o Tumbukan dengan dasar saluran
o Turbulensi di stilling basin (kolam olak)

Asep Sapei 3
Drop/fall Structures:

o Chute (saluran miring)


- Beda elevasi ± 5 m
- Aliran : super kritis

Asep Sapei 4
o Vertical drop (bang. Terjun)
- Beda elevasi < 5 m
o Inclined drop
- Kemiringan saluran V : H = 2:1; 1:1 atau 1:2

Asep Sapei 5
Design :

o Komponen bangunan terjun:


 Pengendali (control) : notch, weir atau gate
 Kolam olak : USBR standard basin atau SAF basin

Asep Sapei 6
o Tipe komponen pengendali:
 fixed : weir, notch, screen
 manually regulation
 hydr. regulation

Asep Sapei 7
o Kolam olak :
 Dasar kolam olak lebih dalam
 Dibatasi oleh dinding vertikal (Rectangular stilling
basin)

Asep Sapei 8
 Dengan Onion outlet
Mencegah penggerusan selepas bangunan olak
(perubahan koef. Strickler 60 m1/3/s menjadi
30 m1/3/s)

Asep Sapei 9
Hirolika kolam olak:

o Bilangan Froude

 Fr < 1 : sub kitis


 Fr > 1 : super kritis

Asep Sapei 10
o Aliran jet

Subtitusi vj
2 persamaan tsb diselesaikan dgn cara iterasi

Asep Sapei 11
Asep Sapei 12
o Lompatan hidrolik (hydraulic jump)
Aliran super kritis berubah menjadi sub kritis dan y3>ymin

Asep Sapei 13
Kedalaman minimum kolam olak agar terjadi lomp. hidrolik

Asep Sapei 14
Asep Sapei 15
Kolam olak standar:

o Tujuan desain:
stilling basin dgn undisturbed jump (ybasin=yconj)

meningkatkan efisiensi :
 Memperdalam dasar
 Ambang di ujung kolam
 tinggi jatuh
 chute block : memecah aliran
 baffle block : menurunkan enersi tumbukan

Asep Sapei 16
Kolam olak standar:

USBR : US bureau of reclamation


SAF : St Anthony Falls Lab
Asep Sapei 17
Kolam olak dgn baffle block:

o USBR type III:

 Utk Fr > 4.5 ;

Asep Sapei 18
o USBR type IV:

 Utk 2.5 < Fr < 4.5 ;

Asep Sapei 19
o SAF basin: Lb dan yb lebih kecil

 Utk 1.7 < Fr < 17 ;

Asep Sapei 20
Asep Sapei 21
Kolam olak tipe bucket:

o Bucket basin : dalam

Asep Sapei 22
o Vlugter basin

Asep Sapei 23
Asep Sapei 24
Kolam olak tipe lain:

o Volume basin :utk regulator Avis atau Avio

Asep Sapei 25
o Vertical drop basin

drop number

Asep Sapei 26
Asep Sapei 27
Pemilihan kolam olak

o Berdasarkan nilai Froude dari aliran jet

 Frj = 1 : tdk perlu kolam olak


 1<Frj<1.7 : tdk perlu, perlu pelindung (rip rap dsb)
 1.7<Frj<2.5 : end-sill basin
 2.5<Frj<4.5 : USBR tipe IV
 4.5<Frj<13 : USBR tipe III atau end-sill
 Frj>13 : Nilai Fr diperkecil dgn membuat lebih
lebar atau lebih dalam

Asep Sapei 28
Asep Sapei 29
o Berdasarkan z/Ha

Asep Sapei 30
Asep Sapei 31
Asep Sapei 32

You might also like