Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THESIS
Submitted to the English Teaching Department
Tarbiyah and Teacher Training Faculty
as a Requirement to Obtain Bachelor Degree
Written by:
FANDI AHMAD
Reg. No. 15 300 400 034
Batusangkar, September
2020
Yang membuat pernyataan
Fandi Ahmad
NIM. 15 3004 000 34
i
PERSETUJUAN PEMBIMBING
Pembimbing
ii
THESIS EXAMINERS’ APPROVAL
This thesis was written by FANDI AHMAD, Reg. No. 15 3004 00034, entitled:
“STRATEGIES OF THANKING EMPLOYED BY THE ENGLISH
TEACHING DEPARTMENT STUDENTS AT IAIN BATUSANGKAR”, has
been examined by board of examiners of English Teaching Department of
Tarbiyah and Teacher Training Faculty of IAIN Batusangkar on Wednesday,
September 2, 2020 and approved to be accepted as requirement to obtain Bachelor
Degree in Teaching English.
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
iv
gives advice to him during his study. Then, he also thanks to staff of English
Teaching Department, Kak Anggi Rahmadika, S. Pd.I who helped
administratively during writing this thesis. Next, he also thanks to Dean of
Tarbiyah and Teacher Training Faculty, Bapak Dr. Adripen, M.Pd, who has given
assistances to him during academic years. Then, his deepest gratitude is addressed
to Rector of IAIN Batusangkar Bapak Dr. Marjoni Imamora, M.Sc who has given
chance for him study at IAIN Batusangkar untill he got the bachelor degree.
The writer wishes to show his love and gratitude to his beloved father,
Vasmuker and mother, Desi Arianti and his beloved brother and sister; Rio
Ferdiansah, Irwansyah (Alm.) and Nadia Az-Zahra who have given guidance and
support in finishing his study. Then, he really appreciates for his beloved
grandfather from his mother’s family, Bapak H. Buyung and grandmother Ibu Hj.
Wartati, also his grandmother and cousin from his father’s family, Nenek Mian
and Putri Chania who have given supports in every process of his study.
Futhermore, he also delivers his massive thankyou to his beloved friends
Rizky Aulia, Ichsan Dafha, Nabila Swestika Ulya, Apri Nurul Iman, Hardisa Putri,
Ilmalana, Nora Karmila, Refky Michael Kiehl, Rizki Ilahi Putra, Yogi Guntara,
Nurirfandi, Fajar Dimas Muhammad Azhar, Wendi Erik Manurung and all
members TBI’ 15 especially for B class that the researcher can not mention one
by one. Last but not least, his best friends ever, Rava Sonia Salsabila, Jhito
Samudra, Indah Putri Nesia, Ratih Dwi Ningsih, Ranti Juliani, Fatur Ichsan, Susi
Febriana, Deno Alfianto who have given supports in every process of his study.
Batusangkar, 29 July 2020
The researcher,
Fandi Ahmad
Reg. No. 15 3004 00034
v
ABSTRAK
Fandi Ahmad. NIM 15 3004 00034. Judul skripsi: “STRATEGIES OF
THANKING EMPLOYED BY THE ENGLISH TEACHING
DEPARTMENT STUDENTS AT IAIN BATUSANGKAR”. Jurusan Tadris
Bahasa Inggris, Fakultas Tarbiyah dan Ilmu Keguruan, Institut Agama Islam
Negeri (IAIN) Batusangkar.
Permasalahan dalam penelitian ini adalah terbatasnya penggunaan
ungkapan dalam menyampaikan thanking strategy sehingga dapat menyebabkan
pragmatic failure pada mahasiswa Jurusan Tadris di IAIN Batusangkar. Penelitian
ini bertujuan untuk menganalisis thanking strategy apa saja yang digunakan oleh
mahasiswa jurusan Tadris Bahasa Inggris
Penelitian ini menggunakan metode descriptive quantitative, dengan
menggunakan cross sectional design. Populasi dalam penelitian ini adalah
mahasiswa semester 7 yang berjumlah 61 orang. Pada penelitian ini, peneliti
menggunakan teknik total sampling. Instrumen yang digunakan dalam penelitian
ini adalah Written Discourse Completion Test (WDCT). Hasil dari validitas
instrumen dengan hasil secara umum 0,96 (high), sedangkan hasil validasi dari
masing-masing validator adalah 1 (high) untuk aspek pertama, 1 (high) untuk
aspek kedua, 1 (high) untuk aspek ketiga, dan 0,93 (high) untuk keempat. Hasil
reliability instrument adalah 0,60 (moderate agreement). Setelah itu peneliti
menyebarkan WDCT via google form kepada sample.
Hasil penelitian ini menunjukan bahwa strategi dari simple thanking yaitu
thankyou strategy muncul 106 kali dengan persentase 21%, thanks strategy
muncul 52 kali dengan persentase 10,7% dan elaborated thanking yaitu thanking
intensifier strategy muncul 163 kali dengan persentase 33,4%, thanking for
(reason) strategy muncul sebanyak 108 kali dengan persentase 22,1% dan
thanking intensifier for (reason) strategy muncul sebanyak 18 kali dengan
persentase 3,7%. Dari penjelasan di atas, strategi yang paling sering digunakan
oleh responden adalah thanking intensifier yang merupakan bagian dari strategi
elaborated thanking dengan total berdasarkan respon dari 61 orang responden
sebanyak 163 kali digunakan dengan presentase 33,4%. Mahasiswa banyak
menggunakan strategi ini karna strategi adalah cara termudah dan yang paling
umum digunakan serta sesuai dalam situasi apapun, dengan contoh seperti kata
“thankyou very much, thankyou so much”.
vi
Table of Contents
COVER ....................................................................................................................
SURAT PERNYATAAN KEASLIAN SKRIPSI ................................................i
PERSETUJUAN PEMBIMBING ...................................................................... ii
THESIS EXAMINERS’ APPROVAL .............................................................. iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ...................................................................................iv
ABSTRAK ............................................................................................................vi
Table of Contents ............................................................................................... vii
List of Tables ........................................................................................................ix
List of Histograms ................................................................................................. x
List of Appendices ................................................................................................xi
CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION......................................................................... 1
A. Background of the Problem ............................................................................. 1
B. Identification of the Problem ........................................................................... 7
C. Limitation of the Problem................................................................................ 7
D. Definition of Key Terms ................................................................................. 7
E. Purpose of the Research ................................................................................... 8
F. Significance of the Research ............................................................................ 8
CHAPTER II. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE .............................. 10
A. Review of Related Literature ........................................................................ 10
1. Pragmatics and ELT (English Language Teaching) ................................... 10
a. Definitions of Pragmatics ....................................................................... 10
b. Importance of Teaching Pragmatics for EFL Learners .......................... 12
c. Pragmatics Competence for EFL Learners ............................................. 12
d. The Scope of Pragmatics ........................................................................ 14
2. Speech Acts ............................................................................................... 15
a. Definition of Speech Acts ....................................................................... 15
b. Levels of Speech Acts ............................................................................ 17
c. Classification of Speech Acts ................................................................. 23
3. The Speech Acts of Thanking ................................................................... 24
B. Review of Related Studies ............................................................................. 34
vii
CHAPTER III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ........................................... 36
A. Research Design ............................................................................................ 36
B. Population and Sample .................................................................................. 36
C. Research Instrument ...................................................................................... 37
D. Technique of Data Collection........................................................................ 42
E. Research Procedure........................................................................................ 42
F. Technique of Data Analysis ........................................................................... 43
CHAPTER IV RESEARCH FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION ....................... 46
A. Research Finding .......................................................................................... 46
B. Discussion ..................................................................................................... 71
CHAPTER V. CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION ..................................... 76
A. Conclusion .................................................................................................... 76
B. Suggestion .................................................................................................... 76
BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................... 78
APPENDICES ..................................................................................................... 82
viii
List of Tables
ix
List of Histograms
x
List of Appendices
Appendix 1. Table Theory of Thanking Strategies ............................................... 82
Appendix 2. Grid of DCT ..................................................................................... 83
Appendix 3. Discourse Completion Test (DCT)................................................... 84
Appendix 4. Alternative Answer........................................................................... 88
Appendix 5. Validation Sheet ............................................................................... 91
Appendix 6. Validation Result from the Validator ............................................... 93
Appendix 7. Validity Result .................................................................................. 99
Appendix 8. Inter-rater Reliability ...................................................................... 103
Appendix 9. Final DCT ....................................................................................... 105
Appendix 10. Final Grid of DCT ........................................................................ 112
Appendix 11. Code of Data ................................................................................. 113
Appendix 12. Recapitulations of Respondents ................................................... 121
Appendix 13. Sample of Filled WDCT Response .............................................. 141
Appendix 14. Letter of Research Recommendation ........................................... 145
xi
1
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
languages. It is, thus, often assumed that learners can successfully say
thank you in the target language. Expressions of gratitude are closely
linked to the notion of verbal politeness. In the same way as apologies,
expressions of gratitude are produced as a reaction to aprevious action and
have as an objective to restore the balance in the social relations between
speaker and hearer.
Understanding thanking strategies are important for EFL learners as a
candidate of teacher is important. Students should use appropriate strategy to
thank someone depend on certain situation. Thanking strategies appropriately
learned by English Students is to raise their awareness of thanking by looking
at the situation. In a different situation it may sound weird to thank. This
condition can be called as pragmatics failure because it is inappropriate usage
of thanking. People must be aware of the context of thanking strategies and
be able to determine the best thanking strategies that has to be applied in a
context. For example, if a teacher or lecturer has done something for the
speaker like making a recommendation letter although the lecturer is very
busy with his/her works. It is high imposition for lecturer and the status is
higher than the speaker. The student can not say just the word ‘thanks’
because the imposition is high for the lecturer. They should say “thankyou
very much mam/sir for making this recommendation letter.” This is one of the
elaborated thanking strategies. This strategies will run the relationship
become smoother and avoid the pragmatics failure.
There are several types of Thanking that should be mastered by the
students; Cheng (2005) divided two types of thanking strategies: (a) simple
thanking, by using the word thank you or thank, and (b) elaborated
thanking, including four sub-subcategories (i) by thanking and adding
one intensifier, (ii) by thanking and adding two intensifiers (iii) thanking
for (reason), by thanking and mentioning the reason, and (iv) thanking +
intensifier + for (reason), by thanking and adding intensifier(s) and the
reason by Cheng (2005).
6
me this note. I can understand more while using your note.” even the
situation is informal and the relationship is between friends.
Finally, the phenomenon above inspires the researcher to conduct the
research to describe about thanking strategies used by English Teaching
Department Students. This research will be conducted at IAIN Batusangkar.
1. Theoretically
Theoretically, the result of this research hopefully may give
information about strategies of thaking strategies used by English
Teaching Department of Tarbiyah and Teacher Training Faculty of
State Institute for Islamic Studies (IAIN) Batusangkar.
2. Practically
Hopefully, the researcher hopes that this research may be useful
for:
a. English Students
Hopefully, the result of this research can give contribution to the
students such as by knowing the strategies of showing thanking
strategies can make the students understand about pragmatics
competence and also know that in utterance not only grammar is
our focus but also know how to make someone feel comfort to talk
to us.
b. Lecturer
The result of this research is hopefully can give contribution to the
lecturers. She/He will get information about types of thanking
9
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
2. Speech Acts
a. Definition of Speech Acts
In communication, speakers use language to do things other than
describes reality. In addition to make statements such as “the sky is
blue”, speakers make utterances with certain intentions that have an
effect on the listeners. Saying thankyou, asking a request or
complaint are some of the acts that a speaker can perform. When
16
people utter a sentence, it is not just to say things but rather actively
to do things.
According to Yule (1996), Speech acts define as the action
performed via utterances. When people have conversation, they not
only produce utterance but also perform action. There are sorts of
things that can be done with words, such as ask questions, give
orders, and make promises. Speech act theory, therefore, defines and
classifies the speech acts that are realized by language speakers. In
the other hand Austin (1962), defined speech act as what actions we
perform when we produce utterance. Then Searle (1969), says that
speech act is the unit of linguistics communication is not as has
generally been supposed, the symbol, word or sentence, or even the
token of the symbol, word or sentence, but rather the production or
issuance of the symbol, word or sentence in the performance of the
speech acts (Mey, 2001)
Moreover, Cutting (2002) Speech acts is actions which are
performed by saying something and stated that being able to use the
appropriate speech acts can be defined as having the knowledge to
communicate with others. Furthermore, Searle (1969: 16) states that
the production or issuance of a sentence token under certain
conditions is a speech act, and speech acts are the basic or minimal
units of linguistic communication. Speaking a language is
performing speech acts such as making statements, giving
commands, asking questions, making promises, etc. Thus, viewing
speech acts as the basic unit of communication allows Searle to
explicitly associated speech acts with the study of language (its
production, its interpretation) and meaning (both speaker meaning
and linguistic meaning) (Schiffrin, 1994: 55).
It can be concluded that, Speech Acts is actions performed via
utterances. Speech Acts is not just a linguistics in general but rather
the action of word and sentences.
17
2. Illocutionary Act
Austin (1962: 108) says that illocutionary act is an
utterance which has a certain force. It is an act performed in
saying something. It is the intention behind the words. It is the
act of using utterance to perform a function. When saying
something, a speaker does not only produce utterance with no
purpose. S/he forms an utterance with some kind of function in
mind. The formulation of illocutionary act in saying X, s asserts
that P (Leech, 1983: 199). P refers to the proposition or basic
meaning of an utterance. In Yule‟s example “I‟ve just made
some coffee”, the speaker makes an offer or statement (Yule,
1996: 48).
Closely associated with the notion of illocutionary acts is
the concept of illocutionary force, the communicative plan, or
design behind a speaker‟s remark (Leech, 1983: 200).
Examples of illocutionary acts include accusing, apologizing,
blaming, congratulating, declaring war, giving permission,
joking, marrying, nagging, naming, promising, ordering,
refusing, swearing, and thanking. The functions or actions just
mentioned are also commonly referred to as the illocutionary
„force‟ („point‟) of the utterance.
Austin (in Coulthard, 1977: 18) distinguishes locutionary and
illocutionary acts. He states that the interpretation of the
locutionary act is concerned with meaning whereas the
interpretation of the illocutionary act is concerned with force.
Performing an illocutionary acts means issuing an utterance that
carries an illocutionary force. The meaning of a locutionary
utterance has a potential of different illocutionary force.
19
3. Perlocutionary Act
According to Austin (1962: 108), perlocutionary act is the
achieving of certain effects by saying something. It concerns the
effect an utterance may have on the hearer. Put slightly more
technically, a perlocution is the act by which the locution and
illocution produce a certain effect in or exert a certain influence on
the hearer. Still another way to put it is that a perlocutinary act
represents a consequence or by-product of speaking, whether
intentional or not. The effect of the act being performed by
speaking is generally known as the perlocutionary effect (Mey,
2009: 1003). The formulation of the perlocutionary act by saying X
s convinces h that P (Leech, 1983: 199). For example, by saying
“I‟ve just made some coffee”, the speaker performs perlocutionary
act of causing the hearer to account for a wonderful smell, or to get
the hearer to drink some coffee (Yule, 1996: 48-49). Moreover,
some effects of the perlocutionary acts are in the following:
(a) Hearer knows something
A hearer knows or realizes something in mind especially
information as a result of experience or because s/he has learned or
been told.
(b)Hearer thinks of something
A hearer has a particular idea or opinion about something or
somebody or when s/he uses the mind to consider something that a
speaker says.
(c) Hearer is doing something
A hearer is doing something because the speaker expects him
or her to do it or causes him or her to have something.
(d)Hearer is convinced
A hearer believes something because the speaker gives a good
reason to do it.
(e) Hearer feels irritated
A hearer feels irritated because the speaker annoys him or her
by saying some statements which cause slight irritations.
(f) Hearer feels frightened
A hearer feels frightened because the speaker frightens him or
her through the speaker‟s statement.
(g) Hearer is amused
A hearer is amused because the speaker makes him or her
20
1. Representatives or Assertives
Searle (1979: 12) states that the point or purpose of
the members of the representative class is to commit the
speaker to something’s being the case, to the truth of the
expressed proposition, e.g. stating, boasting, complaining,
claiming and reporting. Therefore, testing a representative
can be done by simply questioning whether it can be
categorized as true or false. This is similar to Yule’s
definition (1996: 53) that representatives state what the
speaker believes to be the case or not. By performing a
representative or an assertive, the speaker makes the
words fit the world (belief).
2. Directives
Searle (1979: 13) states that directives are attempts
by the speaker to get the hearer to do something such as
ordering, commanding, requesting, advising, and
recommending. They express what the speaker wants.
According to Yule (1996: 53), by using a directive, the
speaker attempts to make the world fit the word (via the
hearer)
(a) You may ask
(b) Would you make me a cup of tea?
Example (a) is a suggestion that has a function to
get the hearer to do something as what the speaker
suggests, i.e. suggests someone to ask. Meanwhile, in
example (b), in saying an interrogative sentence, the
speaker has an intention to perform a request that has a
function to get the hearer to do something that the speaker
wants, i.e. requests someone to make him/her a cup of tea.
The speaker does not expect the hearer to answer the
22
5. Declarations
Searle (1979: 16) states that declarations effect
immediate changes in the institutional state of affairs that
is they change the world via the utterance. According to
Yule (1996: 53), the speaker has to have a special
institutional role, in a specific context, in order to perform
a declaration appropriately; typically examples include
excommunicating, declaring war, marrying, firing from
employment, nominating, etc. Some examples of
utterances classified as declarations are:
(a) Boss : You are fired!
The utterance above brings about the change in
reality and they are more than just a statement. This
utterance can be used to perform the act of ending the
employment or to declare someone is fired from her or
his job.
c. Classification of Speech Acts
Yule (1996) classifies speech acts into several types as follows:
(a) Verdictives
Verdictives are typified by the giving of verdict, as the
name implies, by a jury, arbitrator, or umpire. However, they
need not be final; they are, for example, an estimation,
reckoning, or appraisal. It is essential to give a finding to
something-fact or value-, which is for different reasons hard to
be certain about.
(b) Exercitives
Exercitives are exercise of power, right, or influence. The
examples are appointing, voting, ordering, urging, advising,
and warning.
24
(c) Commisives
Commisives are typified by promising or otherwise
undertaking. They commit the hearer to do something, but
include also declaration or announcements of intention, which
are not promise, and also rather vague things, which can be
called espousal, as for example siding with.
(d) Behabitives
Behabitives are very miscellaneous group and have to do
with attitudes and social behavior. The examples are
apologizing, congratulating, condoling, cursing, and
challenging.
(e) Expositives
Expositives are difficult to define. They make plain how
utterances fit into the course of an argument or conversation,
how words are use, or in general are expository. The examples
are; I reply”, “I assume”, and “I postulate”.
Sub-categories
Thankyou Thankyou (TY)
Simple Thaking
Thanks Thanks (TS)
Thanking + intensifier Thankyou very much.
Thanks a lot.
Thanking + intensifier Thankyou very much
+ intensifier indeed.
Thankyou + for Thank you for your
Cheng (2005)
(reason) consideration and
Elaborated Thanking
your attention to all of
the things that we
brought forward.
Thankyou + intensifier Thank you very much
+ for (Reason) for showing us your
home.
Simple Thanking Thankyou or Thanks.
Elaborated Thanking Thankyou very much
Thanking
Thankyou for helping
me.
Appreciation and It’s much appreciated.
Adding Intensifiers
Appreciation and If you don’t want to be
Adini and Ragiliati
Stating the Reasons public later, I’d
(2013) Appreciation
appreciare that.
Appreciation and We would really
Adding both appreciate if you could
Intensifiers and come.
Reasons
Showing Relief Than ks goodness.
Non-gratitude
Thanks God
31
For easier the thanking strategies will be summarized in the table below
Table 2.2
Thanking Strategies
Thankyou Thankyou
Simple Thanking
Thanks Thanks
Thankyou very much
Thanking + Intensifier
Thanks a lot
Thanking + Intensifier +
Thankyou very much indeed
Intensifier
gratitude epressions. Then, the researcher finds the differences which are the
object of the study and the way of informal style in oral speech.
Furthermore, the research done by Adini & Iragiliari under the title “The
Speech Acts of Thanking used by EFL learners”. They found that the result of
research showed that the subjects are aware of the use of thanking. There are
some aspects that need to be taken into consideration based on the findings
and discussions for improving of the quality of speech. And then how to say
thankyou correctly, when to say thankyou and what is the importance of
saying thankyou. This research has similarities and differences with the
researcher’s research. The similarity with the researcher is about gratitude in
speech acts. The differences are this research discussed about thanking. The
differences are the instrument of this research used role-play. The result of
this research seems that unnatural because of the participants are aware of
making mistakes and seems like the respondents answer the situation not
based on what they wanted to.
Then, the next research by Dalilan (2012) under her title “Strategies in
Expressing thanking in English Realized by Indonesian Learners”. She
revealed that the gratitude strategies employed by the participants of study
ranged from from simple, brief thankings to length, complex thankings. All
participants produced mixed speech acts sets of thanking in the following
conditions : a) social status b) indebtness c) breaking promise, but in informal
area or setting public the participants tend to use simple thanking.
This research has similarities and differences with the researcher’s study.
The similarities are this study focused on expressing thanking and also talking
about strategies in English in various situations. The difference is, this
research focus on mixed speech acts sets of thanking.
36
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
A. Research Design
This research was descriptive quantitative research with cross-
sectional design. Gay (2000:11) states that descriptive involves collecting
data in order to answer the question concerning the current status of object
of the study. The description is in the form of words and language, in a
specific context naturally and by utilizing a variety of natural methods.
Bryman and Bell (2007) defines that a cross-sectional design entails the
collection of data on more than one case and at single point in time in
order to collect a body of quantitative data in connection with two or more
variables, which are then examined to detect patterns of association.
Dealing with this theory, this research have described students
strategies in using thanking strategies in the seventh semester students of
English Department of IAIN Batusangkar registered 2018/2019 Academic
Year.
Table 3.1
Population of this Research
No Class Number of Student
1 TBI A 15
2 TBI B 21
3 TBI C 25
TOTAL 61
The table shows that there were 61 students of seventh semester have
participated in this research. Consist of class A, B and C. The total of
population were 61 students.
2. Sample
According to Gay et al (2012) sample is a group of individuals,
items, or events that represents the characteristics of the larger group from
which the sample is drawn. It means that sample is the representative of
the population that is used in data collection. Moreover, to get the data the
researcher uses sampling technique. Gay et al (2012) says that sampling is
the process of selecting a number of individual for a study in such a way
that they represent the large group from which they were selected.
In this research, the researcher took all of the students as sample,
because the population less than 100. According to Fraenkel and Wallen
(2009: 106), in the descriptive research a minimum sample is 100. It
means, the researcher used total sampling technique to take the sample.
According to Sugiyono (2010: 85), total sampling is a sampling technique
is all members of the population are used as sample. That, the sample of
this research was 61 students.
C. Research Instrument
The instrument of this research used DCT (Discourse Completion
Test) as the main data collection tool. A DCT is a written test containing
short descriptions of a particular situation intended to reveal the pattern
38
content validity of the instrument, the researcher will use use the
Aiken's V formula in Hendryady (2017: 173) to calculate the
content-validity coefficient based on the results of evaluating by
the validators for an item in terms of the extent of the item.
Represents the measured construct. The following is the Aiken’s
formula that researchers will use:
V = ∑ s /[n (C – 1)]
S = R – lo
Where: lo = Lowest scoring rate
C = Highest score
R = The number given by the validator
n = Number of validator
E. Research Procedure
This research conducts by applying several steps as follows:
1) Finding research problem
After reading some sources and discussing with academic advisor,
a research problem that the researcher is interested in was a found.
The research problem is the impact of students’ academic stress
toward their learning outcome. It involves the fifth semester students
of English Teaching Department 2017/2018 academic year as the
population and sample of this research.
2) Collecting the source and references
To be able comprehend the problem, as many as related sources and
references about the research problem will collect and discuss. Those
43
Table 3.2
Data Classification
Data from WDCT Classification Strategy
Thankyou very much Thankyou very Thankyou very much
for your
much (Thanking + for your
recommendation letter
mam/sir Intensifier) for your recommendation
recommendation letter is classified as
letter sir/mam (for + Thanking +
reason) Intensifier + Reason
3. After collecting the data via DCT, rensponses will be coded based
on the thanking strategies.
To make easier, the researcher makes codes for thanking
strategies. The following table is the code for thanking strategies
that made by the researcher.
Table 3.3 Code for thanking strategies
No. Thanking Strategy Code
1 Thankyou TY
2 Thanks TS
3 Thanking + Intensifier TI
4 Thanking + Intensifier + Intensifier TII
45
Where:
P = the index of percentage
F = the number of frequency
N= the number of sample
46
CHAPTER IV
RESEARCH FINDING AND DISCUSSION
A. Research Finding
1. Data Description
Based on the results of data analysis that has been done, the
researcher shows the findingd of relating to the question to the research
problem. What are are thanking strategies used by English Teaching
Department Students at IAIN Batusangkar and What is the highest
thanking strategies they used?
This section presents the result of Written Discourse Completion
Test (WDCT) in terms of the thanking strategies used by English
Teaching Deparment Students. It has been mentioned in the previous
chapter that there are two strategies in thanking strategies by Cheng
(2005). There are simple thanking and elaborated thanking. The
researcher has expanded the results in data analysis each of strategies.
Tables below sumarize the result of thanking strategies used by
English Teaching Department Students, there are 488 total thanking
strategies are made, which is from the eight scenarios and 61
respondents. Elaborated Thanking (thanking + intensifier) was the
highest strategy that used by English Teaching Department Students
with the highest frequency. The researcher also found another responds
in the findings. In this section the data will be shown in the table where
the table will consist of the total of the stratetgy for English Teaching
Department Students used in each DCT that have been provided, for
more details can be seen in the following tables below.
47
Table 4.1
Total frequency of Thanking Strategy
Thanking Sub-strategies Frequency Percentage
Strategies per
Strategy
Simple Thanking Thankyou 106 21,7%
Thanks 52 10,7%
Elaborated Thanking + Intensifier 163 33,4%
Thanking Thanking + Intensifier 0 0,0%
+ Intensifier
Thanking +for 108 22,1%
(reason)
Thanking + Intensifier 18 3,7%
+ for (reason)
Another responds 41 8,4%
Total 488 100%
Histogram 4.1
Total percentage of thanking strategies used by EFL students
30
25
20
Total Frequency of Thanking
15 Strategies
10
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
2. Data Analysis
There are two thanking strategies than can be used by EFL students
on Cheng’s theory (2005). They are simple thanking and elaborate
thanking. In simple thanking there are two sub categories; thankyou
and thanks. Whereas, in elaborate thanking, there are four sub
categories; thanking + intensifier, thanking + intensifier + intensifier,
thanking + for (reason), thanking + intensifier + for (reason).
The researcher used statistic descriptive to analyze the data.
Descriptive statistics are used to describe the basic features of the data
in study. It provides simple summaries about the sample. Together
with simple graphics analysis, they formed the basis of virtually every
quantitative analysis of the data. The researcher also classified the
strategies used by the respondents in the first item until the eighth item.
The data can be seen as follows :
49
a. Item 1
The situation and context from item 1 described below :
Situation : (borrowing notes). Context : You were sick and missed
class last week. You feel better and go to class today. You ask
your close friend, who is in the same class, to lend you the notes
from last week so you can make copies. Your friend agrees to
lend you the notes. When you return the class notes, what
would you say?
Table 4.2
Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in item 1
(Equal status, High Familiarity, Low Imposition)
Strategies Total Data No. Data
Data Code
Thankyou 12 - Thankyou my 1 TY
friend
- Thankyou 7 TY
- Thankyou so 21,25 TI
much
- Thankyou so 6
much my friend TI
Thanking + 0 -
Intensifier +
Intensifier
Thanking + for 21 - Thankyou for 22,24 TRf
(reason) lending me your
notes
- Thankyou for 49,14 TRf
helping me
- Thankyou for 5 TRf
lend me your notes
- Thankyou for 14 TRf
helping me
Thanking + 2 - Thankyou very 17 TIRf
Intensifier + for much for your help
50
- Thankyou so 38 TIRf
much my
bestfriend for
borrowing me this
book
AR (Another 3 - You have saved 36 AR
Respon) my life
- Here’s your note, 19 AR
You helped me a
lot, next time I will
help you my friend
Table 4.3
51
ITEM 1
35
30
25
20
ITEM 1
15
10
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
52
b. Item 2
The situation and context of Item 2 described below :
Situation : Book extension day. Context : “You are writing a term
paper for one of your courses. For this paper, you borrow a
book from one of your Lecturer, whom you know very well.
You are supposed to return the book to him/her tomorrow.
However, you need to keep it for another 2-3 days to complete
your paper. So you ask your lecturer if you can keep the book
for a few more days, and she/he agrees. When you return the
book to your lecturer, what would you say?”
Table 4.4
Thanking strategies used by EFL students in Item 2
(Higher status, High Familiarity, Low Imposition)
Strategies Total Data No. Code
Data
Thankyou 9 - Thankyou 12, 29 TY
Students mom/sir
- Thankyou, 35 TY
miss
- Thankyou sir 41, 46 TY
Thanks 6 - Thanks sir 58 TS
Students
-Thanks mam 56,31 TS
Thanking + 30 - Thankyou 1, TI
Intensifier Students very much 14, 15,
sir/mam 16, 22,
23
- Thankyou so 11, 13 TI
much miss
- Thanks a lot 4, 6 TI
mom / sir
- Thanks a 19 TI
bunch, sir
Thanking + 0 Student -
Intensifier +
Intensifier
Thanking + 10 - Thankyou for 37 TRf
for (reason) Students allowing me to
keep this book
mam
- Thankyou for 47 TRf
53
allowing to
keep this book
sir
- Thankyou for
lending me the
book sir, Im 24 TRf
very grateful
- Thankyou for 5 TRf
your kindness
miss
Thanking + 2 - Thankyou 8 TIRf
Intensifier + Students very much for
for letting me
borrow this
book mam
- Thankyou 18 TIRf
very much
about this
AR (Another 4 - Apologize me 36 AR
Respon) Students to late bring
your book
-Im grateful 34 AR
mam, you have
helped me
for helping me). The students mentioned the reason after saying
thankyou. Next, in the Thanking + Intensifier + for (TIRf) only 2
students answered the questionnaire with the expression like
(Thankyou very much my friend for borrowing this note). The
students wanted to thank to the hearer with intensifier and
mentioned the reason. The last one, there are 4 students answered
another responds like (Apologize me to late bring your book).
The researcher calculated the frequency and percentages
the variations of thanking strategies used by EFL students in item
2
Table 4.5
Frequency of Thanking Strategies used by EFL
students in Item 2
Strategy Frequency Percentage
Thankyou 9 14,75%
Thanks 6 9.84%
Thanking + Intensifier 30 49,18%
Thanking + Intensifier + 0 0,00%
Intensifier
Thanking +for (reason) 10 16,39%
Thanking + Intensifier + for 2 3,28%
(reason)
Another responds 4 6,56%
ITEM 2
50
45
40
35
30
25 ITEM 2
20
15
10
5
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
c. Item 3
The situation and context of Item 3 described below :
Situation : Recommendation letter. Context : “You want to apply
for a scholarship. It requires recommendation letter from three
lecturers. You have already asked two lecturers whom you
know very well to write that letters. You decide to meet and ask
the third lecturer, although you don’t know very well, to write
a letter for you because you took a course with him/her last
semester. She/he agres to write the recommendation letter for
you. A few days later, when you meet the lecturer, she/he tells
you that she/has sent out the recommendation letter. What
would you say?”
Table 4.6
Thanking strategies used by EFL students in Item 3
(Higher status, Low familiarity, Low Imposition)
Strategies Total Data No. Code
Data
Thankyou 9 - Thankyou 9 TY
Students mom/sir
- Thankyou, miss 11 TY
- Thankyou sir 12, 17 TY
Thanks 4 - Thanks mam 51 TS
56
Students
Thanking + 30 - Thankyou very 1,2,3,6 TI
Intensifier Students much sir
- Thankyou so 14, 20 TI
much mam
- Thanks a lot mom 22, 37 TI
/ miss
- Thanks a bunch, 42 TI
mom
Thanking + 0 Student -
Intensifier +
Intensifier
Thanking + 13 - Thankyou for 15,16 TRf
for (reason) Students your help mam/sir
- Thankyou for the 8
help sir
- Thankyou for 21
your time mam
- Thankyou for 16
helping me sir
- Thankyou for the 13
recommendation
miss
Thanking + 1 - Thankyou so 4 TIRf
Intensifier + Students much for
for recommendation
sir
AR (Another 3 - Im so grateful 5 AR
Respon) Students mam
- I am glad to have 27
this paper from you
Based on the table above, the researcher found several
strategies used by the students in responses Item 3. First, 9
students answered by using thankyou (TY) expression like
(Thankyou miss, Thankyou sir). Second, 10 students answered
the questionnaire by using thanks (TS) like (Thanks miss, thanks
mom). In the first and second strategies, students only answered
simple thanking without mentioning the reason or intensifier. The
students only mentioned simple thanking. Third, 30 students used
thanking + intensifier (TI) like (Thankyou very much sir,
thankyou so much miss, Thanks a bunch sir). It is because the
57
status was talking about lecturer and student which means low to
higher status. Fourth, none of the students answered by using
thanking + intensifier + intensifier (TII). Fifth, 13 students
answered by using Thanking + for (TRf) like (Thankyou for
lending this recommendation letter ma’am, thankyou for
helping me). The students mentioned the reason after saying
thankyou. Sixth, in the Thanking + Intensifier + for (TIRf) only 1
student answered the questionnaire with the expression like
(Thankyou so much for recommending me this scholarship
ma’am). The students wanted to thank to the hearer with
intensifier and mentioned the reason about recommending the
student to get the scholarship. The last one, there are 3 students
answered another responds like (Im glad to have this paper from
you). This answer was not classified as thanking strategies
The researcher calculated the frequency and percentages
the variations of thanking strategies used by EFL students in item
3
Table 4.7
Frequency of Thanking Strategies used by EFL
students in Item 3
Strategy Frequency Percentage
Thankyou 9 14,75%
Thanks 4 9.84%
Thanking + Intensifier 30 49,18%
Thanking + Intensifier + 0 0,00%
Intensifier
Thanking +for (reason) 13 21,31%
Thanking + Intensifier + for 1 1,64%
(reason)
Another responds 3 4,92%
ITEM 3
50
45
40
35
30
25 ITEM 3
20
15
10
5
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
d. Item 4
Situation and context of Item 4 described below :
Situation : Moving to new rent house. Context : “You are about to
move to a new rent house. You have a lot of boxes and some
small furnitures, but you don’t have a car. You ask your close
friend who has a car to help you move. Your friend hesitates
because she/he is very busy, but then agrees to help you move.
After two of you load your things into the car, drive to your
new rent house, and then finish carrying everything to your
new rent house, what would you say?”
59
Table 4.8
Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in Item 4
(Equal status, High familiarity, High imposition)
Strategies Total Data No. Code
Data
Thankyou 13 - Thankyou 3, 12, 35 TY
Students - Thankyou, 29
dude
- Thankyou sob 54
Thanks 11 - Thanks 2, 44, 55 TS
Students - Thanks dude 32, 37
- Thanks friend 28,
Thanking + 14 - Thankyou so 60, 16 TI
Intensifier Students much my friend
- Thankyou 21
very much
- Thanks a 36
bunch
- Thanks a lot 26, 56
Thanking + 0 Student -
Intensifier +
Intensifier
Thanking + 12 - Thanks for 18 TRf
for (reason) Students your help
- Thankyou for 13, 50
your helps
- Thankyou for 24, 39,
helping me 48
19
- Thankyou for
helping me
dude
Thanking + 2 - Thanks a 38 TIRf
Intensifier + Students bunch bro for
for helping me
- Thankyou so 6
much for your
help
AR (Another 9 - Please help 34 AR
Respon) Students me, I will give
you money
- I owe you one 5
- I cant imagine 8
without your
60
help
Based on the table above, the researcher found several
strategies used by the students in responses Item 4. First, 13
students answered by using thankyou (TY) expression like
(Thankyou dude, Thankyou bro). Second, 11 students answered
the questionnaire by using thanks (TS) like (Thanks, thanks my
friend). In the first and second strategies, students only answered
simple thanking without mentioning the reason or intensifier. The
students only mentioned simple thanking. Third, 14 students used
thanking + intensifier (TI) like (Thankyou very much dude,
thankyou so much my friend, Thanks a lot). Fourth, none of the
students answered by using thanking + intensifier + intensifier
(TII). Fifth, 12 students answered by using Thanking + for (TRf)
like (Thankyou for helping me dude, thankyou for your helps
even you are very busy). The students mentioned the reason after
saying thankyou. Sixth, in the Thanking + Intensifier + for (TIRf)
only 2 students answered the questionnaire with the expression
like (Thankyou very much bro for your help, I don’t know how
to bring this furniture without you). The students wanted to
thank to the hearer with intensifier and mentioned the reason after
helping the student to move to new rent house. The last one, there
are 9 students answered another responds like (I owe you one,
Please help me I will give you money). These answer was not
classified as thanking strategies. These answered were give by the
respondents because the situation was their close friend and the
respondents did not just want to say thankyou but wanted to give
or threat after that.
The researcher calculated the frequency and percentages
the variations of thanking strategies used by EFL students in item
4
61
Table 4.9
Frequency of Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in
Item 4
Strategy Frequency Percentage
Thankyou 13 21,31%
Thanks 11 18,03%
Thanking + Intensifier 14 22,95%
Thanking + Intensifier + 0 0,00%
Intensifier
Thanking +for (reason) 12 19,67%
Thanking + Intensifier + for 2 3,28%
(reason)
Another responds 9 14,74%
Based on the frequency table above, we can conclude that
the most strategies in item 4 used by EFL students was thanking +
Intensifier with 22,95%, and the lowest strategies used by EFL
students in item 1 is thanking + intensifier + intesifier with 0,00%
percentage. While another responds used by EFL students was
14,74%. Moreover the histogram can be seen as follow :
Histogram 4.5
Percentage of Thanking strategies in Item 4
(Equal status, High familiarity, High imposition)
ITEM 4
25
20
15
ITEM 4
10
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
62
e. Item 5
The situation and context of Item 5 described as follow :
Situation : Paper writing extension. Context : “You are writing a
term paper for one of your courses. You are working hard on
the paper, but you have to stop because you also have to study
for final exams in your other courses. The paper is due for
tomorrow, and you need few more days to finish it. You decide
to ask the lecturer who teaches the courses, whom you don’t
know very well for an extension days. Your lecturer hesitates
because it won’t be fair for other student in the class, but then
she/he agrees to give you an extension days. A few days later,
when you turn in the paper, what would you say to your
Lecturer?”
Table 4.10
Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in Item 5
(Higher status, Low familiarity, High imposition)
Strategies Total Data No. Code
Data
Thankyou 16 - Thankyou 1, 14, TY
Students mom/sir 16, 36,
60
- Thankyou 12, 55
- Thankyou so 2, 8,
much sir/mam
- Thankyou 18, 23
very much sir
- Thanks a lot 46
mom / sir
Thanking + 0 Student - TII
Intensifier +
Intensifier
63
ITEM 5
45
40
35
30
25
ITEM 5
20
15
10
5
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
f. Item 6
Situation and context of Item 6 described below :
Situation : Fixing computer. Context : “You are having troubles
with your computer or laptop, it keeps crashing. You know
someone at school who knows a lot about computers and you
ask the person to help you eventhough the two of you are not
close friends. She/he hesitates because he/he is very busy fixing
someone’s laptop too, but then agrees to help you, and ends up
spending the whole afternoon fixing your laptop. After the
laptop is fixed, what would you say?”
66
Table 4.12
Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in Item 6
(Equal status, Low familiarity, High imposition)
Strategies Total Data No. Code
Data
Thankyou 8 - Thankyou 29, 35, TY
Students 55, 59
- Thankyou bro 20
Thanks 8 - Thanks my 1, 31, 44 TS
Students friend
- Thanks dude 32
- Thanks 12, 46,
51
Thanking + 13 - Thankyou so 2, 14, TI
Intensifier Students much 16, 41,
61
laptop
-Thankyou very 13
much for to
help
AR (Another 8 - I wil never 6 AR
Respon) Students forget what you
have done
- Sorry to 27
disturb you
- you are my 8
saver
- I wanna rent 34
your laptop
reason after helping the student to move to fix their laptop. The
last one, there are 9 students answered another responds like (I
can’t do my thesis without you, You are my saver). These
answer was not classified as thanking strategies.
The researcher calculated the frequency and percentages
the variations of thanking strategies used by EFL students in item
6
Table 4.13
Frequency of Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in
Item 6
Strategy Frequency Percentage
Thankyou 8 13,11%
Thanks 8 13,11%
Thanking + Intensifier 13 21,31%
Thanking + Intensifier + 0 0,00%
Intensifier
Thanking +for (reason) 19 31,15%
Thanking + Intensifier + for 5 8,20%
(reason)
Another responds 8 13,11%
Histogram 4.7
Percentage of Thanking Strategies in Item 6
(Equal status, Low familiarity, High imposition)
ITEM 6
35
30
25
20
ITEM 6
15
10
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
g. Item 7
Context and situation of Item 7 described below
Context : Writing recommendation letter. Situation : “You just
have found out about a very good scholarship, but the deadline
is two days away. Since this scholarship would help you
financially, you decide to apply. You ask your academic advisor,
whom you know very well, to write a recommendation letter
for you to apply this scholarship. Your academic advisor
hesitates because she/he is very busy about the project and the
deadline is in two days, but she/he finally agrees to write the
letter. When you meet your academic advisor the next day,
he/she tells you that he/she has sent the letter by e-mail. What
would you say?”
70
Table 4.14
Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in Item 7
(Higher status, High familiarity, High imposition)
Strategies Total Example No. Code
Data
Thankyou 17 -Thankyou 2, 35 TY
Students - Thankyou 9, 12,
mom/sir 18, 21,
27
- Thankyou, miss 7
- Thankyou so 3, 11,
much miss/sir 16, 22,
29, 36
- Thankyou very 31
much for your help
mam
- Thankyou very 38
much mom for
helping me make a
letter of
recommendation
AR (Another 4 - Sorry sir, do you 34 AR
Respon) Students open your email
sir?
- I can’t tell how 5
grateful I am orall
your help miss
- Im very 25, 41
thankful/grateful
like (Thankyou very much for your help mam). The students
wanted to thank to the hearer with intensifier and mentioned the
reason after making a recommendation letter for the students. The
last one, there are 4 students answered another responds like
(Sorry sir, do you open your email?). This answer was not
classified as thanking strategies because this asnwer was not
related to the situation.
The researcher calculated the frequency and percentages
the variations of thanking strategies used by EFL students in item
7
Table 4.15
Frequency of Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in
Item 7
Strategy Frequency Percentage
Thankyou 17 27,87%
Thanks 4 6,56%
Thanking + Intensifier 26 42,62%
Thanking + Intensifier + 0 0,00%
Intensifier
Thanking +for (reason) 7 11,48%
Thanking + Intensifier + for 3 4,92%
(reason)
Another responds 4 6,56%
ITEM 7
45
40
35
30
25
ITEM 7
20
15
10
5
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
h. Item 8
Context and situation of Item 8 described below :
Context : Scattered notes. Situation : “You and your classmate,
whom you aren’t so close very well, are walking to the class.
You accidentally drop your papers and notes, which scatter all
of over the middle of crowded corridor. Your classmate helps
you to pick up your papers and notes. When your classmate
gives the papers and notes to you, what would you say?”
Table 4.16
Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in Item 8
(Equal status, Low familiarity, Low imposition)
Strategies Total Data No. Code
Data
Thankyou 22 - Thankyou 5, 14, TY
Students 15,16,
35, 43,
55, 58,
59,
- Thankyou, 11
friend
74
- Thankyou 1, 41
bro/sist
Thanks 9 - Thanks 25, 42 TS
Students - Thanks dude 23, 32
Thanking + 12 - Thankyou so 2, 8, 21, TI
Intensifier Students much 61
- Thanks a 17, 19
bunch
Thanking + 0 Student - TII
Intensifier +
Intensifier
Thanking + 11 - Thanks for 3, 18, TRf
for (reason) Students your help 26, 30,
57
AR (Another 6 - I really 4 AR
Respon) Students appreciate your
help
- God bless you 34
- You are my 36
angel
- It’s nice to 48
have a bestfriend
like you
- You have 52
saved my life
Based on the table above, the researcher found several
strategies used by the students in responses Item 8. First, 22
students answered by using thankyou (TY) expression like
(Thankyou , Thankyou bro). Second, 9 students answered the
questionnaire by using thanks (TS) like (Thanks, thanks dude).
75
Table 4.17
Frequency of Thanking Strategies used by EFL students in
Item 8
Strategy Frequency Percentage
Thankyou 22 36,07%
Thanks 9 14,75%
Thanking + Intensifier 12 19,67%
Thanking + Intensifier + 0 0,00%
Intensifier
Thanking +for (reason) 11 18,03%
Thanking + Intensifier + for 1,64%
1
(reason)
Another responds 6 9,84%
Based on the frequency table above, we can conclude that
the most strategies in item 8 used by EFL students was thankyou
with 35,07%, and the lowest strategies used by EFL students in
item 8 was thanking + intensifier + intesifier with 0,00%
percentage. While another responds used by EFL students was
9,84%. Moreover the histogram can be seen as follow :
Histogram 4.9
Percentage of Thanking Strategies in Item 8
(Equal status, Low familiarity, Low imposition)
ITEM 8
40
35
30
25
20 ITEM 8
15
10
5
0
TY TS TI TII TRf TIRf AR
77
B. Discussion
Based of the data description and data analysis, some strategies were
used by English students at IAIN Batusangkar. This research found total
result that the most thanking strategies used by EFL students were
thanking + intensifier with percentage 33,4%, and the lowest thanking
strategies used by EFL students is thanking + intensifier + intensifier with
percentage 0,00%. In this strategy, the most widely used expression is the
expression “Thankyou so much” or “Thankyou very much”. An
example of this expression can be seen after someone has done something
or a favor for the speaker. The phrase “..so much” and “very much” can be
defined as a stressing that the speaker really thank someone because they
have done the favor. The strategies that used by EFL students in the data
analysis are influenced by some factors such as situation, status,
familiarity and imposition. It will be different answers from the
respondents if the situation is affectted by those factors. It had shown that
students were aware to use thanking strategies because of the different
situation which are given. From the research findings, the researcher found
that the result was different from the preliminary observation that the
students actually aware of pragmatic failure. They used appropriate
thanking strategies if they were given such a situation depended on
different context whom they are talking to; higher or lower status, how
close the relationship (familiarity) between the speaker and hearer, and
how high the imposition caused for the hearer.
First, the researcher found the most strategies used by EFL students in
the item 1 : You were sick and missed class last week. You feel better and
go to class today. You ask your close friend, who is in the same class, to
lend you the notes from last week so you can make copies. Your friend
agrees to lend you the notes. When you return the class notes, what would
you say? is thanking + for (reason) with frequency 21 students and
34,43% percentage, and the lowest strategy used by EFL students is
78
she/he is very busy about the project and the deadline is in two days, but
she/he finally agress to write the letter. When you meet your academic
advisor the next day, he/she tells you that he/she has sent the letter by e-
mail. What would you say? is thanking intensifier with frequency 26
students and 42,62% percentage, and the lowest strategy used by EFL
students is thanking intensifier + intensifier with frequency 0 student and
0,00% percentage.
Last, the researcher found the most strategies used by EFL students in
the item 8: You and your classmate, whom you don’t so close very well,
are walking to the class. You accidentally drop your papers and notes,
which scatter all of over the middle of crowded corridor. Your classmate
helps you to pick up your papers and notes. When your classmate gives the
papers and notes to you, what would you say? is thankyou with frequency
22 students and 36,07% percentage, and the lowest strategy used by EFL
students is thanking intensifier + intensifier with frequency 0 student and
0,00% percentage
From the research finding above, it shows that the students used
different thanking strategies based on the situation and context. This
research has similarities from the research by Yasami and Rastefar (2014).
Their research showed that Iranian EFL learners only used simple
thanking strategies without mentioning the favor with 80% percentage for
intermediate and advanced learners. Next, the research from Yusefi (2015)
about thanking strategies used by Kurdish speaker based on gender and
age. The result of this research indicated that simple thanking was the
most frequently strategies used by male and female Kurdish speaker. The
result from other studies by Dalilan (2012) revealed that Indonesian EFL
learners answered the illustration given by using simple thanking such as
thankyou and thanks whether it is formal or informal situation. This also
supported the research by Meiramova & Kulzhanova (2015) in their
research also revealed that simple thanking was the most strategies used
by Kazakhstani learners.
81
Contratry from the research that the researcher has mentioned above,
the result of this research revealed that the most preferred thanking
strategies in any kinds of situation was thanking intensifier. This research
supported by Iragiliati (2013), she found that elaborated thanking were
kindly preferred in all situation, formal or informal, lower to higher or
even equal status. This research confirms that Indonesian learners tend to
use thanking intensifier – the ones frequently expression used by
Indonesian native speaker when somone have done a favor for them.
Respondents are a influenced by some factors to respond the situation
given but thanking intensifier was the most strategy used. Stressing the
expression of thankyou after mentioning thankyou it self, because the
students consider this strategy is sufficiently polite to be used in any kinds
of situations wether it is influenced by some factors. In line with this, the
thanking intensifier strategies are expressed through the words “thankyou
very much, thankyou so much.”. It can be concluded EFL learners at IAIN
Batusangkar used thanking intensifier because this is one of the easiest
strategy to be used to express gratitude whether they are influenced by
some factors such as context, situation, familiarity, status and imposition.
Furthermore, in pragmatic competence, when we talk to someone,
possessing grammatical knowledge alone does not always produce a
successful communication; the knowledge of how to use the forms of the
language (i.e. grammar) in a way that is appropriate to the situation or
context in the speech community is also important. It means that not only
the knowledge of grammatical but also the pragmatics competence should
be considered. In Hymes’s much quoted formulation, it is a competence
“when to speak, when not, and as to what to talk about with whom, when,
where, in what manner” Hymes (1972).
82
CHAPTER V
CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION
A. Conclusion
This thesis analyze the thanking strategies used by seventh-semester
students of English Teaching Departments at IAIN Batusangkar. Based on
the data that have been analyzed, the researcher concludes that the
respondents used different ways in thanking the WDCT. After analyzing
the data, several conclusions are found to answer the research questions.
This research answered the research question, for thanking strategies,
elaborated thanking was the highest strategy that used by the EFL students,
spesifically thanking intensifier with 33,4%.
This thanking strategies are used to reveal the way the respondents
thank the interlocutor after doing a favor. The result shows that the
respondents apply almost all the types of thanking strategies. They are
thankyou that appears 106 times 21,7% and thanks that appears 52 times
10,7%. Furthermore, thanking + intensifier appears 163 times 33,4%,
thanking + for (reason) appears 108 times 22,1%, thanking + intensifier +
for (reason) appears 18 times 3,7% and none of student used thanking +
intensifier + intensifier that appears 0 time with no percentage. From the
explanation above, the highest strategy that used by the respondents
elaborated thanking (thanking + intensifier) strategy. Moreover, there were
also another responds that the researcher found in the research with 8,4 %.
It could be the evidence that the students have ability in communication so
the answered were not related to the strategy.
Thus, this research also provides the evidence that thanking strategies
used by EFL learners at IAIN Batusangkar depends on the various factors
such as situation, context, status (lower or higher), familiarity, and
imposition. All in all, the researcher has proven that the thanking strategies
can be analyzed through WDCT (Written Discourse Completion Test).
This research can discover the types of thanking strategies used by the
respondents.
83
B. Suggestion
Based on the result of this research, the researcher give some
suggestion as follows :
1. Lecturers
From the result of the research, thanking strategies used by english
students in general is elaborated thanking. Lecturers can persuade the
the students that elaborated thanking more preferable to use and it
should be continued.
2. The Students
Considering the result of the research above, to the students, the
students are expected that to use appropriate thanking strategies
depends on the situation and context so it will not make the
communication failure to whom they are talking to.
3. Next Researcher
For the next researcher, it is hoped that he/she can conduct a
research about an analysis of politeness strategies that happen in a
certain place and certain people.
84
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Adini, N., & Eragiliati, E. (2015). The Speech Acts of Thanking Used by EFL
Learners.
Bryman, A., & Bell, E. (2007). Business Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Cutting, J. (2008). Pragmatics and Discourse: A Resource Book for Students (2nd
Ed.). New York: Routledge.
Gay, L., & Airasian, P. (2000). Educationnal Researh: Competencies for Analysis
and Aplication. New Jersey: Pearson Education.
Gay, L., Mills, G., & Airasian, P. (2012). Educational Research: Competencies
and Analysis for Applications. America: Pearson.
Rohmah, N. (2016). Gratitude Strategies used by the characters "I Love You,
Man" Movie (Unpblished Graduating Paper). Yogyakarta: Sunan Kalijaga
University.
Xu, L., & Wannaruk, A. (2015). Reliability and Validity of WDCT in Testing
Interlanguage Pragmatic Competence for EFL Learners. Journal of
Language Teaching and Research, 6(6), 1206-1215.
Yasami, F & Rastegar, S. (2014). The use of Thanking Strategies among Iranian
EFL Learners of Different Profeciency Levels. Science Direct, 9(8), 1926-
1930
Yusefia, K., Gowhary, H., Azizifar, A., & Esmaeili, Z. (2015). A pragmatic
analysis of thanking strategies among Kurdish speakers of Ilam based on
gender and age. Science Direct, 2(2), 28-39.
Classification of
Strategy Semantic Formula
Strategy
Thankyou Thankyou
Simple Thanking
Thanks Thanks
Thankyou very much
Thanking + Intensifier
Thanks a lot
Thanking + Intensifier +
Thankyou very much indeed
Intensifier
Number
Status Formality Respondents Situations
of Item
Equal-status
High
You and your
familiarity Informal Borrowing notes 1
classmate
Low
imposition
Higher-status
High
You and your
Familiarity Formal Book extension 2
lecturer
Low
imposition
Higher-status
Low
You and your Recommendation
familiarity Formal 3
lecturer letter
Low
imposition
Equal-status
High-
You and your Moving to new
familiarity Informal 4
friend rented-house
High-
imposition
Higher-status
Low-
You and your Paper writing
familiarity Formal 5
lecturer extension
High-
imposition
Equal-status
Low-
You and your
familarity Informal Fixing computer 6
friend
High-
imposition
Higher-status
High- You and your Writing
familiarity Formal academic recommendation 7
High- advisor letter
imposition
Equal-status
Low-
You and your
familiarity Informal Scattered notes 8
classmate
Low-
imposition
90
Nama / Name :
NIM / Reg. No :
Kelas / Class :
Please read the following scenarios carefully and write down what you
would say if you were in these situations
No English Indonesian
1 You were sick and missed Kamu sakit dan melewatkan kelas
class last week. You feel minggu lalu. Kamu merasa lebih
better and go to class today. baik dan masuk kelas hari ini.
You ask your close friend, Kamu meminta kepada teman
who is in the same class, to dekatmu, yang berada dikelas yang
lend you the notes from last sama, untuk meminjamkan catatan
week so you can make minggu lalu sehingga kamu dapat
copies. Your friend agrees to menyalinnya. Temanmu setuju
lend you the notes. When you untuk meminjamkan catatan
return the class notes, what tersebut, apa yang akan kamu
would you say? katakan?
5 You are writing a term paper Kamu sedang menulis tugas akhir
for one of your courses. You untuk salah satu mata kuliah. Kamu
are working hard on the bekerja keras untuk menyelesaikan
paper, but you have to stop makalah teresbut, akan tetapi kamu
because you also have to harus berhenti karna harus belajar
study for final exams in your untuk ujian akhir di mata kuliah
other courses. The paper is yang berbeda. Tugas akhir tersebut
due for tomorrow, and you harus dikumpulkan besok, dan
92
need few more days to finish kamu butuh beberapa hari lagi
it. You decide to ask the untuk menyelesaikannya. Kamu
lecturer who teaches the memutuskan untuk bertanya kepada
courses, whom you don’t dosenmu, yang kamu tidak terlalu
know very well for an dekat, untuk tambahan hari.
extension days. Your lecturer Dosenmu ragu karna itu tidak adil
hesitates because it won’t be bagi mahasiswa lain yang ada
fair for other student in the dikelas, namun akhirnya dosenmu
class, but then she/he agrees setuju untuk memberikan tambahan
to give you an extension hari. Setelah beberapa hari
days. A few days later, when kemudian, ketika kamu
you turn in the paper, what mengumpulkan tugas akhir
would you say to your tersebut, apa yang akan kamu
Lecturer? katakan?
Alternative Answer
2 You are writing a term paper for • Thankyou very much mam/sir
one of your courses. For this for giving me additional days to
paper, you borrow a book from keep the book
one of your Lecturer, whom you • Thankyou for allowing me to
know very well. You are keep the book, sir/mam
supposed to return the book to • Thankyou very much, sir/mam.
him/her tomorrow. However, Indeed
you need to keep it for another • Thankyou sir/mam
2-3 days to complete your paper. • Thanks sir / mam
So you ask your lecturer if you
can keep the book for a few
more days, and she/he agrees.
When you return the book to
your lecturer, what would you
say?
5 You are writing a term paper for • Thankyou so much for your
one of your courses. You are consideration giving me an
working hard on the paper, but extra days to finish the term
you have to stop because you paper mam/sir
also have to study for final • Thankyou for giving some extra
exams in your other courses. The days to finish the paper mam/sir
paper is due for tomorrow, and • Thankyou very much mam/sir
you need few more days to • Thankyou, mam/sir
finish it. You decide to ask the • Thanks a lot, mam/sir
lecturer who teaches the courses,
whom you don’t know very well
for an extension days. Your
lecturer hesitates because it
won’t be fair for other student in
the class, but then she/he agress
to give you an extension days. A
few days later, when you turn in
the paper, what would you say to
your Lecturer?
7 You just have found out about a • Thankyou very much for your
very good scholarship, but the consideration allowing me to
deadline is two days away. Since apply the scholarship, mam/sir
this scholarship would help you • Thankyou for the
financially, you decide to apply. recommendation letter, mam/sir
You ask your academic advisor, • Thankyou so much indeed,
whom you know very well, to mam/sir
write a recommendation letter • Thankyou, mam/sir
for you to apply this scholarship. • Thanks, mam/sir
Your academic advisor hesitates
because she/he is very busy
about the project and the
deadline is in two days, but
she/he finally agress to write the
letter. When you meet your
academic advisor the next day,
he/she tells you that he/she has
sent the letter by e-mail. What
would you say?
LEMBAR VALIDASI
Petunjuk :
ASPEK PENELITIAN
NO
1 2 3 4
ITEM
0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Saran-saran
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
...............................................................................................................................
Batusangkar, 2020
Validator
a. Validator Pertama
LEMBAR VALIDASI
DISCOURSE COMPLATION TEST (DCT) “STRATEGIES OF SHOWING
THANKING EMPLOYED BY THE ENGLISH STUDENTS AT IAIN
BATUSANGKAR”
Petunjuk :
ASPEK PENELITIAN
NO
1 2 3 4
ITEM
0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4
1 √ √ √ √
2 √ √ √ √
3 √ √ √ √
4 √ √ √ √
5 √ √ √ √
6 √ √ √ √
7 √ √ √ √
8 √ √ √ √
Saran-saran
DCT yang disebarkan kepada responden hanya DCT
yang berbahasa Inggris saja
Batusangkar, 2020
Validator
b. Validator Kedua
LEMBAR VALIDASI
DISCOURSE COMPLATION TEST (DCT) “STRATEGIES OF SHOWING
THANKING EMPLOYED BY THE ENGLISH STUDENTS AT IAIN
BATUSANGKAR”
Petunjuk :
ASPEK PENELITIAN
NO
1 2 3 4
ITEM
0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4
1 v v v v
2 v v v v
3 v v v v
4 v v v v
5 v v v v
6 v v v v
7 v v v v
8 v v v v
Saran-saran
Format tes sudah baik dan mencakup poin-poin yang akan diukur.
Perlu sedikit perbaikan dalam penulisan beberapa kata
c. Validator Ketiga
LEMBAR VALIDASI
DISCOURSE COMPLATION TEST (DCT) “STRATEGIES OF SHOWING
THANKING EMPLOYED BY THE ENGLISH STUDENTS AT IAIN
BATUSANGKAR”
Petunjuk :
ASPEK PENELITIAN
NO
1 2 3 4
ITEM
0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4
1 √ √ √ √
2 √ √ √ √
3 √ √ √ √
4 √ √ √ √
5 √ √ √ √
6 √ √ √ √
7 √ √ √ √
8 √ √ √ √
Saran-saran
Instruments nya sudah Ok untuk disebarkan kepada respondents
Batusangkar, June 30th 2020
Validator
To find the validation result, the researcher used Aiken’s formula where :
V = ∑ s /[n (C – 1)]
S = R – lo
Where: lo = Lowest scoring rate
C = Highest score
R = The number given by the validator
n = Number of validator
106
Based on the validity above, the validity coefficient is 0,93, it means the
validity of this aspect belongs to “High”
The result of all aspect are aimed to get the validity of the product.
These are all aspect of DCT (Discourse Completion Test) with several
situation on the table above. From the all aspects table above, validity
coefficient of the test is 0,96. It could be conclude that validity of the test
belongs to “High” and the validity product automatically is “Valid”
109
Cases
Valid Missing Total
N Percent N Percent N Percent
Rater 1 * Rater 2 8 100,0% 0 0,0% 8 100,0%
Total Count 1 4 3 8
Expected 1,0 4,0 3,0 8,0
Count
Symmetric Measures
Value Asymptotic Approximate Approximate
Standard Tb Significance
Errora
Measure of Kappa ,600 ,235 2,475 ,013
Agreement
N of Valid Cases 8
a. Not assuming the null hypothesis.
b. Using the asymptotic standard error assuming the null hypothesis.
Nama / Name :
NIM / Reg. No :
Kelas / Class :
Please read the following scenarios carefully and write down what you
would say if you were in these situations
No English Indonesian
1 You were sick and missed Kamu sakit dan melewatkan kelas
class last week. You feel minggu lalu. Kamu merasa lebih
better and go to class today. baik dan masuk kelas hari ini.
You ask your close friend, Kamu meminta kepada teman
who is in the same class, to dekatmu, yang berada dikelas yang
lend you the notes from last sama, untuk meminjamkan catatan
week so you can make minggu lalu sehingga kamu dapat
copies. Your friend agrees to menyalinnya. Temanmu setuju
lend you the notes. When you untuk meminjamkan catatan
return the class notes, what tersebut, apa yang akan kamu
would you say? katakan?
5 You are writing a term paper Kamu sedang menulis tugas akhir
for one of your courses. You untuk salah satu mata kuliah. Kamu
are working hard on the bekerja keras untuk menyelesaikan
paper, but you have to stop makalah teresbut, akan tetapi kamu
because you also have to harus berhenti karna harus belajar
study for final exams in your untuk ujian akhir di mata kuliah
other courses. The paper is yang berbeda. Tugas akhir tersebut
due for tomorrow, and you harus dikumpulkan besok, dan
113
need few more days to finish kamu butuh beberapa hari lagi
it. You decide to ask the untuk menyelesaikannya. Kamu
lecturer who teaches the memutuskan untuk bertanya kepada
courses, whom you don’t dosenmu, yang kamu tidak terlalu
know very well for an dekat, untuk tambahan hari.
extension days. Your lecturer Dosenmu ragu karna itu tidak adil
hesitates because it won’t be bagi mahasiswa lain yang ada
fair for other student in the dikelas, namun akhirnya dosenmu
class, but then she/he agrees setuju untuk memberikan tambahan
to give you an extension hari. Setelah beberapa hari
days. A few days later, when kemudian, ketika kamu
you turn in the paper, what mengumpulkan tugas akhir
would you say to your tersebut, apa yang akan kamu
Lecturer? katakan?
Alternative Answer
2 You are writing a term paper for • Thankyou very much mam/sir
one of your courses. For this for giving me additional days to
paper, you borrow a book from keep the book
one of your Lecturer, whom you • Thankyou for allowing me to
know very well. You are keep the book, sir/mam
supposed to return the book to • Thankyou very much, sir/mam.
him/her tomorrow. However, Indeed
you need to keep it for another • Thankyou sir/mam
2-3 days to complete your paper. • Thanks sir / mam
So you ask your lecturer if you
can keep the book for a few
more days, and she/he agrees.
When you return the book to
your lecturer, what would you
say?
5 You are writing a term paper for • Thankyou so much for your
one of your courses. You are consideration giving me an
working hard on the paper, but extra days to finish the term
you have to stop because you paper mam/sir
also have to study for final • Thankyou for giving some extra
exams in your other courses. The days to finish the paper mam/sir
paper is due for tomorrow, and • Thankyou very much mam/sir
you need few more days to • Thankyou, mam/sir
finish it. You decide to ask the • Thanks a lot, mam/sir
lecturer who teaches the courses,
whom you don’t know very well
for an extension days. Your
lecturer hesitates because it
won’t be fair for other student in
the class, but then she/he agress
to give you an extension days. A
few days later, when you turn in
the paper, what would you say to
your Lecturer?
7 You just have found out about a • Thankyou very much for your
very good scholarship, but the consideration allowing me to
deadline is two days away. Since apply the scholarship, mam/sir
this scholarship would help you • Thankyou for the
financially, you decide to apply. recommendation letter, mam/sir
You ask your academic advisor, • Thankyou so much indeed,
whom you know very well, to mam/sir
write a recommendation letter • Thankyou, mam/sir
for you to apply this scholarship. • Thanks, mam/sir
Your academic advisor hesitates
because she/he is very busy
about the project and the
deadline is in two days, but
she/he finally agress to write the
letter. When you meet your
academic advisor the next day,
he/she tells you that he/she has
sent the letter by e-mail. What
would you say?
Number
Status Formality Respondents Situations
of Item
Equal-status
High
You and your
familiarity Informal Borrowing notes 1
classmate
Low
imposition
Higher-status
High
You and your
Familiarity Formal Book extension 2
lecturer
Low
imposition
Higher-status
Low
You and your Recommendation
familiarity Formal 3
lecturer letter
Low
imposition
Equal-status
High-
You and your Moving to new
familiarity Informal 4
friend rented-house
High-
imposition
Higher-status
Low-
You and your Paper writing
familiarity Formal 5
lecturer extension
High-
imposition
Equal-status
Low-
You and your
familarity Informal Fixing computer 6
friend
High-
imposition
Higher-status
High- You and your Writing
familiarity Formal academic recommendation 7
High- advisor letter
imposition
Equal-status
Low-
You and your
familiarity Informal Scattered notes 8
classmate
Low-
imposition
119
Coding Of Data
1. TY = Thankyou
2. TS = Thanks
3. TI = Thanking + Intensifier
4. TII = Thanking + Intensifier + Intensifier
5. TRf = Thanking + for (reason)
6. TIRf = Thanking + Intensifier + for (reason)
7. AR = Another Respon
Item 1
Item 2
Item 3
Item 4
Thanks
41 Thank a lot sist, you are very nice TI
Salmatu Rahmah i hope you have a good life
42 Rahmawati Thank you a lot TY
43 fortunately you are, thank you, for TY
Yusra Afriaeini helping me
44 Welia Anggreini Thanks TS
45 Alia Turahma Thanks for your help TRf
46 Suci Putri well done, thanks TS
47 Refky Rahmad Thanks mate TS
48 Thank you for helping me do this TRf
even though you are very busy but
Novita Sari still want to help me
49 I don't know how to thank you. AR
Rani Yunita you are so kind. thank you
50 Erni Eriya Thank you for your help TRf
Susanti
51 Nofi Yanti Big thanks, bro TS
52 Fathmaliya Fitri I owe you one AR
53 Rahmi Hayati thank a bunch mate TI
54 Thank you sob..you are the kind TY
Yuli Asrina poeple
55 Tamara Putri Thanks TS
Jefilia
56 Rehan Kamil Thanks a lot TI
57 Thank a lot friend. Without you I TI
don't know how to move the new
Filda Hidayati house. I have try to find a car but i
Husna didn't get it.
58 Rezi Irviana Thank you for your help TRf
59 Wetna Thank you TY
60 Wila Nofrianti Thank you very much my friend TI
61 Widia Permata Bro, thank you so much for your TI
Sari help and i am sorry
131
Item 5
task miss
25 Silvia Rahmatul Thank so very much TI
Putri
26 I'm so sorry sir, but I really thanks AR
Ledy Mardiah for you sense sir...
27 Thank you mam. This is the big TY
chance for me because you allow
Voni Maisyarah me to join on
28 Leli Elvira Thank you Mrs. You let me to TY
Aliensi finishing my exam
29 Naurah Thank you mrs/mr to give me an TY
Mardhiyah extension days.
30 I am very grateful to you. because AR
you have given me some leeway in
making this assignment. may god
Atika Mezi reward you better
31 Hur’ain Kurnia Thank you for your time mam TRf
32 Aidil Fitra thanks for hearing my beg sir TRf
33 Terimakasih pak sudah TRf
Vivina Rizali memberikan waktu lebih
34 Robby Pratama Thank you so much TI
Putra
35 Indah Zalita Thank you TY
36 Neli Ainul thank you mam TY
Mardiah
37 Warayhan Ahhh thank you sir TY
38 thank you very much mom for the TIRf
relief you have given me, thank
Retta Violona you again mom.
39 Thank you for your kindness. Next TRf
Yovando time, I will arrange a better
Alvarici schedule to be able to do my best
40 Nurafna Thank you very much about your TI
Thayyibah help sir
41 Thank you sir for extention the TRf
Salmatu Rahmah time, i will do the best
42 Rahmawati Thank you mom TY
43 thank you sir for the extension of TRf
Yusra Afriaeini time
44 Welia Anggreini Thanks for helping miss TRf
45 Alia Turahma Thank you so much TI
46 Suci Putri Thanks a lot sir TI
47 Refky Rahmad Thankyou for the extra time sir TRf
48 Novita Sari Thank you for giving me relief in TRf
133
Item 6
Item 7
Item 8