You are on page 1of 286

‫!

"
'& ‪#$%‬‬ ‫  
      ‬

‫اﻟﺪﻛﺘﻮر ﺳﻌﻴﺪ اﻟﻮردي‬


‫أﺳﺘﺎذ ﺑﺎﺣﺚ ﺑﻜﻠﻴﺔ اﻟﺤﻘﻮق ﺑﻔﺎس‬
‫ﻋﻀﻮ ﻣﺨﺘﱪ اﻟﻘﺎﻧﻮن اﻟﺨﺎص ورﻫﺎﻧﺎت اﻟﺘﻨﻤﻴﺔ‬
‫إﻃﺎر ﺳﺎﺑﻖ ﺑﻮزارة اﻟﺪاﺧﻠﻴﺔ‬

‫ﺟﺮﺍﺋﻢ ﺍﻟﺴﺐ ﻭﺍﻟﻘﺬﻑ‬


‫ﻋﺒﺮ ﻭﺳﺎﺋﻞ ﺍﻟﺘﻮﺍﺻﻞ ﺍﻹﺟﺘﻤﺎﻋﻲ‬
‫ﻭﺍﻟﻤﻮﺍﻗﻊ ﺍﻹﻟﻜﺘﺮﻭﻧﻴﺔ‬
‫  
  ‬
‫" !        ‪$%&' 88.13 #‬‬
‫‪   
 ()& * +,-‬‬

‫ﺗﻘﺪﻳﻢ اﻟﺪﻛﺘﻮر ‪:‬‬


‫ﻋﺒﺪ اﻟﺤﻤﻴﺪ أﺧﺮﻳﻒ أﺳﺘﺎذ اﻟﺘﻌﻠﻴﻢ اﻟﻌﺎﱄ ﺑﻜﻠﻴﺔ اﻟﺤﻘﻮق ﻓﺎس‬
‫رﺋﻴﺲ ﺷﻌﺒﺔ اﻟﻘﺎﻧﻮن اﻟﺨﺎص‬
‫ﻣﺪﻳﺮ ﻣﺨﺘﱪ اﻟﻘﺎﻧﻮن اﻟﺨﺎص ورﻫﺎﻧﺎت اﻟﺘﻨﻤﻴﺔ‬

‫اﻟﻄﺒﻌﺔ اﻷوﱃ ‪2020‬‬


‫‪1‬‬
‫!"
'& ‪#$%‬‬ ‫  
      ‬

‫ﺍﻟﻜﺘﺎﺏ ‪ :‬ﺟﺮﺍﺋﻢ ﺍﻟﺴﺐ ﻭﺍﻟﻘﺬﻑ ﻋﱪ ﻭﺳﺎﺋﻞ ﺍﻟﺘﻮﺍﺻﻞ ﺍﻻﺟﺘﻤﺎﻋﻲ ﻭﺍﳌﻮﺍﻗﻊ ﺍﻹﻟﻜﺘﺮﻭﻧﻴﺔ‬


‫‪ :‬ﺳﻌﻴﺪ ﺍﻟﻮﺭﺩﻱ‬ ‫ﺍﳌﺆﻟﻒ‬
‫ﺍﻹﻳﺪﺍﻉ ﺍﻟﻘﺎﻧﻮﱐ ‪2020MO2478 :‬‬
‫‪978-9920-39-850-3 :‬‬ ‫ﺭﺩﻣﻚ‬
‫‪ :‬ﻣﻄﺒﻌﺔ ﺍﻷﻣﻨﻴﺔ ‪ -‬ﺍﻟﺮﺑﺎﻁ‬ ‫ﺍﻟﻄـﺒﻊ‬
‫‪05.37.20.04.27‬‬ ‫ﺍﳍﺎﺗﻒ‪ - 05.37.72.48.39 :‬ﺍﻟﻔﺎﻛﺲ‪:‬‬
‫ﺍﻟﱪﻳﺪ ﺍﻹﻟﻜﺘﺮﻭﱐ‪E-mail: impoumnia@yahoo.fr:‬‬

‫‪2‬‬
‫!"
'& ‪#$%‬‬ ‫  
      ‬

‫اﻟﻠﻮﺣﺔ ﻣﻬﺪاة ﻣﻦ ﺻﺪﻳﻘﻲ اﻟﺨﻄﺎط ﻣﺤﻤﺪ وﻫﺮى‬

‫‪3‬‬
#$% &'
"!       
  

4
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺗﻘﺪﻳﻢ‬

    


  ()* '+
,9 : ; , - * . /, 012 3456  ) .6 7* ,  
< +4< $ &= >? @* . 7* 
 A. B42 3456 * 5C
;>5E FC GH I - + $HJ KC  L56 M<DN5H " D+6
"O  & 3 - 9 : 7* $ &= >? $& KC P:+
 * *Q R S2T U *<' :2 34Q
&
+, 7* '
 U , QC VSW B X MQ, - *  T
&: $ 'CJ 7* &+&' U%2 "  T LP 
J >5' #6
Y *6 $ 7* QZ 3[\2 #$  &'5 ]  &'5 E +^ A.
% _
" : : U  ; Y *6 &QS2 I +^ A.
;T $ T `<' >5'< '
1 U ,  A. Y *6
"U +^ a^ A.
% _ &:  b Rb
ced f 7* .>?
:* g MN h N N
\N ce E  b* h &C +, \H
: B 7 Tm \6 +^ kl'2 T " +^ YMN R J i
j j
n ,T 6 K C eo b* T'
 p'
 q '52 Qs
r X ;%&
6  E $H6 7+tu U +, a4C  v eb* ,n >? M:*
Qw x
y X V^  b z C{ >t6 eb* ,U|. 6 U }
" <'  ~ B^ S*
#6 - +^ `^ C xQ %&C B6 *<'* h+ h6 05:+ x
, +&^ R S2T :2 M4d2  7z R [J f<€QC >5'

5
#$% &'
"!       
  

KC   P
% &:  b % D4
 BH 05:+ # %& C
x<2 `^ .
% _ 7* Q~ 7Q+  BjC ,K<Q' K
%
. MH "7+tu U +, 6 a, &: f+ h6 +, 6 `,  &CT +^
U , * 2 2 k52  U +^ a^ Ap &, hD
"t6
- ,Y + ‚% < BQ+&C P # ,n  A. ƒ%&:+
QC M\ - +^ 6 `^
% _ &:  b C   . P a 

BN„ b . " *Q   U 5l   T 


B6 E " + :'C ; : H$ p   B2 C C  ' #$% &'
%E&
%M 
J   H' R S+m &M+ # i< BC<
jC Y
*
"7_
g DH t$  b +^  [ #$% &'
%E& C% *
hm . *Q   U 5l   T  *
 a l Y ,6 h C R\t 7*  D   C% * .. … - 3 E
- †‡H ,     T  
 
- ˆl1 f' ;. ‰C BQ2 7Q+  Q   C% * MQ
     T  
>5' +,
% _
"Š0 :'QZ M:C 7* Y ;‹ ' U 'Qw MH'2
, 'QZ [  ŒH6 # @'  < 7* C% * MH
7 h'H& xy !m ;&N*  :C ƒ W BH 7Q+ T ,  [  
`D ;% ŽC & 7 h'H& xy
% - `^ \e‡C +^
";%$ S
6 Bm S2 h6 05:+ T %‰= &, X /E+ h6 % t n  .
  T  
>5' #6 +, BH ˆ2
6
#$% &'
"!       
  

&4C :. *J `<'+ "   M<  '   . "  
"g D   MH &r  B4)2 05:+ H% ˆ‘ t `$
7* a\lT KC ƒ /2 wM:* R\t 7* n  . BH `Hr 2 * .
"g D U 5lC ./+/'2 h  Y ,6 ˆC v . N j2  
Q+ 7* E YMN &N* $ lC ‚%  BH &w
x
D+6 M:* ;&, E h E%J E ,M:C aN h C *  
R,J - n 2%T h+ h6 KC aH T , M52* R l2  U C'<
 " *Q     T  
6 +$ '
H 4S C `<' 88.13 % h  Š0  :~ h  Y ,6 g) -
"h%  Š0  D Q' P:
7QD2 &H ,Y p () . - Š0  D Q' VS€C
  wC  W U% Y ,J 7*  }
r d n 
E 4 f<’ 7 ;%$      T  

" C0
- `+l >:+
  B<'“ n  ” N:+ h6 +& •' – Rj
"Z Q
Bm , :'QZ &<C >t BH  x 1 () .

./0 1)2 134 '51


a^ <C — ' <' ! 
6
9 H – – &5 7C &Q= #&
'* 
2020 31? 04 ˜ `H 1441 w^ ! 14 g v\

7
#$% &'
"!       
  

8
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﻣﻘﺪﻣﺔ‬

    


  ()* '+
,9 : ; , - * . /, 012 3456  ) .6 7* ,  
< +4< $ &= >? @* . 7* 
 A. B42 3456 * 5C
;>5E FC GH I - + $HJ KC  L56 M<DN5H " D+6
"O  & 3 - 9 : 7* $ &= >? $& KC P:+
R$ 5 5St T Z U C “m 7* AH2  \DH  A. 3456
A 5 ;% vm  x ,.% 5  V €[J *C i  
">5' #6 +, R'
 - Œ ™ E 7   , : 7* 2+ 
+, / 83&' 9 / : 6 
  3*ŒT  + D .6 7* >5' #6 +, '2
3<)    l 7Qv6 7* MH , N<€ .%l2 ,* ,;$&' M:*Œ6
%S' f<’ #P5 R D: 7* g/ 3456 k, , M<6 7* +P5
`, MH ,h  ” Q+  

J a^ 7* 34)6 , :*ŒJ


6 eš &'2 , eQ+& U 'Qw -  t ›jC k‰s  )*
1
"B, N Qw 
+, - `^ C 3H  & +&^ U '+P f<’ hjC &w x
 S* œm >5' +4C k2% # Š0 +P M:* >5' #6
#6 N +, %
& 7* 25 SN N+ , , +%
& a^

;&+~ ]   C %1:* R * ,"  b `^ KC >5' #6 +," :*C $bH − 1
https://www.hespress.com/opinions/417587.html :i+ .

9
#$% &'
"!       
  

-  ' P: (&C +, D+6 N+ E p [6 QwC >5'


": Q<' 45 :N Š$J (&C UT Z
7* 28 SN QC QD* .% &C MH H 4S +, *6
Qw< " <5 C  R [6 7* [ #jC .&2 7Q+ T %
&
& ,& >? 7* , +, C ,g%u % HJ % 5tJ P ,>5' - `^
" ,‹ h  B< ¡:+ *
M, - . C U *<'  ;$6 $Z 3 H 4S
#6 +^ ƒ!Q . - 4S H x ,A>Q) '1 U +.~
H 4S +, "  & `v ;‹ ' >2
&  M
E  >5'
B <+l B2>* - ]  N h E !m ,N +^ : `4C .
"2 'N .E6 
 x<2 .6 7* 3456 H 4S h‡H ” '+ 

7* BC X4+ h6 N4S< 05:+ * Tm M:* &¢ T h6 K'+ H 4S +,
" MHš 5:* H 4S :M* $ .  ,  b*
" $2 83&' / B- 1CD :; <= >? @A : :
 &)A
.&+ T H 4S +^ h :' `<l+ A&w Š0 +P g
C
. "M*E 7+tu +, 6 ,U
& 6 ,Y ' Y ‰: C 9 * B C Tm
M< a$   h  a^  & `v A2 * * w:+ xC
;$  ¡:2 # 3 
 & a4< — & &M' M
6% X n0
`^ h m  + D* h $ g%u a :  - `^ h m  B6 X B:* 19
:]   X %1:* R * ," P: H 4S h  - ;g " : 5w 7C &£6 − 2
"4 V ,pdf 0SC www.adala.justice.gov.ma
f6 2200 ;&4 *¤ * ' 'Q~ % QC YDT `+&S <   &Q  − 3
Y ,J H ,1976 9% *¨%!ª 23 :! N: g&C ©+% 2 ,1966 Q+$ ¨h E 16 - §%b ¦21−$¥
"49 ;$ 

10
#$% &'
"!       
  

U *<' n « f<’ 9 - B+, `^ . Q1+ ,>5' +, -


[ X g
,$ &4< % 5   $ 7+tu œm M< M<2 % HJ
" .% ¬ t6 <
#jC 6 (5l* 6 n*
“ T M
% _ h) >5' #6 +4C ]    h6 >?
X g& T >0 +4C 9  œm S ” cQ $ &^ Œ w+ h6
*&:  t 5 *6 +^ A. ˆ5) L5S+ :. , ,B*E B'Q

    


. +^ A.
% _ R Z h+
Lš } e 7* + 
 A. R'
 hm , "  
n ' +w < e 3s + k, B+^ h :' `<l+ 7* M:* ,Qw
"7+tu a4C 9  5C
U <' ‚%  6 ,   * U 4NS LNS H
g UT , % 1 &* MC ­,\
,   f4S C % /
$ &^ V €[J ®'C MH Œ w+ ,   ˆ
 A. R'

 <  n 2% - hQ0:+ >5' +, - ” cQ
  -  N2% ;>tJ  u U&M[ , "4>0 `, - >M1
* 6 
 6 U   `+e 7 g
f2 p 6 3J 
6 7QH 5" .>? nª i2 6 ,¯C iN *   
L56 U&. 1 7* 7_ $& E6 X RS^ &” ;M1 7 45
M*\ $ &, h'D+ T ,%‰4 c 5 KC h /Q+ T V €[J ®'C

*E a, X t%  g&  7QD2  ƒ!: A. 7* > 6 h6 #$C h E & − 4
  X  '+ h  hJ ,%‰4 - 6 T k, x! X 3‰Ns :: ,V €[J
M'D+ ] m * 6 tª ¡€[ 4N 7* H 6 5
:+ 7QH ": `+e 7 2 I
 b* 'N . 7 T b* '+ MH 3 E <
+jC \' °:' M'D¬ 6 B4NSC
"  :
:]   X %1:* 3J    ( N2% R, R * : $\* w − 5
https://www.albawabhnews.com/3730016

11
#$% &'
"!       
  

5: C \* ±&, E ,>Q) T a\t6 h &C .>? *E - h1M:H


 %E  QC BC m vm K* 4 ²p  } MQC 3*   ;&<
 7* \C B\*/ B 3M ,B pm C  x! ; '* &w
n2 - q : X +&H l* UP , ,; * 4 :M* 5C 1
 .m B* MQC B*  5C Y =  .m QMC M'C * œm $6 _ ,x! 7QD+
V €[¤  W ; ^ C i &SC C! E   +Œ2 Q‰:* ².
H  5, ;&, :C x! X g :C Q4 M$6 & ,” >M1
6
".%$ 500 .%&  * *?
&+&q  
U% 5'C vb* 3456 &    H
,   U S:* f<t 7* 22  m  ,Œ/C
U [ n :
Yw +2 ¯C i+ H 7*   q C , f<€QC
7 >5'2 †6 M52* ®'C 7* :… , S 
% n2+ n 2
3s (< ” 46  'd
r 2 ^ - M: +>5' 6 S€1 U +^
7
"  :~ Ug   ~ U C' K < e
†6 E ,n 0 h  MQ¢ T ³N< T Z 3 Ug DN AMH
¡€[ Y  &H , [ €+ & # c/ +€< g DH 3
9 >H g C  , %M‰C p\t 7* ¬ ¯C iN C BC , X :+ &2 P:C
Q‰6 l
C &Q BC 2% C * ' C : B'C H 8,&w 19 &HE

% 4:~ f< - ,2020 + 01 ©+% C @EQC &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 6
"%1:* >? ,2020¨3712
:]   X %1:* R * : 3J *&€* $&´ lt   ~ − 7
https://al-sharq.com/article/04/02/2020
&'C , 4  &'C < 5 9 H œm ( c a\^  "   U% 5' :+ & 3:QD2 & − 8
µ C% w2 xC  %E 9 >NC n S* B6 € C ¡€ 5l &E6 5l  4 AŒ 
"" &£ §¤  ' g N1 k:Q ,  , R 6 >W

12
#$% &'
"!       
  

$H¤  W ; ^ C 9  &S C! E   Ug $m 3C 2 *<'*


7* 2 − 447 SN - MC X M< VS: R 'HJ ,” >M1
P:C Y  B6 &Eb* Bm n: C Q4 Y *6  H , :~ h 
?% Q4 3DH ,` $ i¶ —, % * &'C MH4C Y  ,/* :+ &
5, K:v 7+M1C x! 7 B5 '* Bm n: 6 7* B2tbQC x!
9
"·J - % 5  S * H 
, 'Q - `^ >5' +, KC Y&l 7 '+ h!m R ^ H
KC M:C Œ ,BC M1 ¡€1  1 + £ 'Q + £ '2 ,
eQ+&< 

J D U +^ Q~ Y6 .  >5' +,
- Bl5) C' 7 \DH  , C'S - + ? *6 QZ #6 - $&' Y,
@* p U! 6 Q1 h&<5 -  t ,Y&€
 >N ;g
m M*
10
"$ &4 eQ+&
Y, C k‰¢ h6 - h ¸ `, &+ ,>5' +, - `^ C * NH
g) - Qw 5 7* B4+ B6 + # +& C , ” /'+  B*E
, ,% 5  P - `^ C   B< `<l+ * . "   B *
BjC A%'[ h ¸ #:'  ~ C `<'2 S€[ '5lC P /Q+
Q+ MH % 5  *6 ,g H g) - Qw $H6   7* Y, `4+
g) - ¡€1< Qw B4:Q+ # +& x! :'+    ~
11
"   N… B *

,2020/2105/445 : $& i5<2 f<* - 2020/03/19 ©+% C NSC &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 9
"%1:* >?
:]   X %1:* R * ,"3J 7*Œ - >M1" : U/ &£6 − 10
www.7iber.com/2015
ŽW ƒ ^ '*  7* 
 : 4C ,"% 5  P - `4<   +^" :• <DH − 11
https://platform.almanhal.com/Files/2/23357 :]   C %1:* ,/~ :2 C

13
#$% &'
"!       
  

U ²* U 5 52 a^


% _ h6 B< % ' 7QH
;$&= h2 h6 l+š 7 $ ®'5 M Dtm Œ“ x ,  t
M'Q
6 7+tu a, Y,T +% « h2 h6 h  ¡:C
n$u 6 * ' 4S 6 Y ' Y ‰: 6 * 7*J +^ 6 ,M*E
K 7* A>? *\
 +P - ;« , .&w $ A. " * '
" ')
F= &/* " >? @A # G : E:
H&2 T ,U% D^ % M
 Mv<+ I '5e ;>? ! h 
*J '+š ,7£ '+š Ug wH ,/ 6 /Q” B) R :+d h6 fj+ ,Ug 
U :*b   6 , Cm KC ,U$¹ 7H$ KC §Œ  E N ,ˆ

12
"U\H 0
B '+ 456 B<  $   9 : ®'C h6 ?%   H
,   YZ , š Y= *6 B‡H , +$   B
% _ 5C +$ *6
.&w 4Q *\
 '+P œm ( C Bm , " \t6  H*
;>5E kQ‰ Q+ A '2 , : n  7* 'l VS:C  Ys
13
"( } : n  MQ+s X R$ ,n  5E 7*
z *d ‘ +z 7z +{ o  z ¥ : œ '2 B n  7* MQ+s X & *6
h
z {z vz ‘ .
‘ d pz <d 5z ‘ 2z Tz z ; z&<‘ z K d d&<{ 
{ {
‘ Hz gz  z&Mz [d 'z Cz %‘ jz {C d2j‘ +z ‘ Iz o vd U z:Sz 4‘ d‘
C6 A % * N+P +5: : 7* ,14 ¦h z d
{ Nz ‘  . xz ²{ zº 6d ◌ۚ  &C6z ; $ M[z
d d z z z z

 X %1:* R * ," BC ,BQ, :  C ®+' " :v% ^ #&M* 7C f<t 7C f
+ − 12
https://download-policies-laws-pdf-ebooks.com/30316-free-book : ] 
, e6 ," 5l2 % * <j2
%$ : MC >M1 Q+ " :N<W – &5 7C 7£ &5 − 13
C' f+  '*  , :*J Y<' - N<N A%E$ %$ X RS^ U 5<l T
 *&*
"32 V ,2008 ,  + , <' U
%& <E , :*J Y<'<
  h E !‡H , NN' 0 5 ;^ . , :S4Q< !  &< , h C MH Q+ +u A. − 14
== 4 X :C !  Y 6 hm *jH " g<' KC (/ . - i , D+6 BH!  &<“ xH \%

14
#$% &'
"!       
  

* o– z %z + :  ,U 
{  R
{ {Cd 5 5{:z" B V R
 7 ;+.
z‘ o d ‘
z
‘d E6 ,`„ ^ { „ ,{o– C ¯d P
z C Tmo do– Yz o ,z o  iN‘ o: ‘d z ,d 4‘  ‘ „ :R  z ?7o .d
{ *{ b‘ d U :
{ S4d  d ‘ z ,f{ ,/ { { ‘d E6z , C
U : z ‘ ‘ o Yz +z —„ oz  ,{ z  R * „
15 { {
" "U\H 0
hª 7* 'l ¢‹ VS Bj[ - U$% * h6 '5l 7*
'+P H "M5.* f<€QC g MN e 7* ( }m = h+ B‡H :
  } s  * ' M$ 5* - aN Q C Πy *\

')  :~ h  3 H E ,U '+P 7* .>? 3 H &H , *
‰:C `<'+ H $ Q= M* ,6 Ug  x ,) 
-
16
"!  X n '
'+P - Y= MH  X D+6 #F+  7  *
½ NjC 1  7 + hª k† , , 'l VS:C *\

>0C  & – 5H – h $ 7* h &+ 7+ 52 T " œ '2 BC ¢‹
{ :*{ b‘ d‘ K
*z >{ ‘ 0z {C U z {{ z !d b‘ +d 7z +{ o  z " œ '2 B - $% E ,17 "<
z z :*b‘ d‘ h
MH : 7*  +s $ *6 ,18 " :{5*d  v‘ {m z  z”‘ d <d Qzz , {
‘ &z Hz 5d zz E‘ 

p <52 T ;&< Kv . &< H g&M[ 'C%jC 2j+ I v¥ : œ '2 R  p ;&^ B: $% ,B  * = =
:Y ,6 v\v B  * 4 X :C + I !m !  X  jH ,¦ h
N . x² 6 &C6 ;$ M[
" ;&< Kv &<“ h6 : .&,6
"9 : &: T – &: T ,R&'C i 
H h+ h6 :   "$ B2$ M[ $2 B6 : ] 
http://quran.ksu.edu.sa/tafseer/katheer/sura24-aya4.html
 :~ +P" : ;$ %$  &5 , *\
 '+P -  C R,  N 7* &+/ ‰
,U >C ,Š' n  %$ , * ' H  <<
,]  g/~ ," ') h  C % * *\

" .&'C * 491 V , '5e T ©+% 2 h &C
"2766  6 4NS ,¦89¥ <* ,B ­N< ¦2766¥ #% €5 Bt6 − 15
"13 V ,`C
* :N<W – &5 7C 7£ &5 − 16
"108 +u ,Y 'J ;%
− 17
"58 +u ,n/,J ;%
− 18

15
#$% &'
"!       
  

: R z z , &¾ ‘ Cz Œd 7‘ z , d 5z '‘ [d z:vz o&,z : R z z , ;z z z ‘ z 7d C‘ d&Qo z =d z:vz o&,z " V B


B{ ‘ <z z do– Xo z o {5o: ho 6z – d&5‘ z {:vz o&,z : R z z Hz , { z²{ ‘ d 7‘ z ¾ { z Cz 6z 3d ‘ jz
z
20
"¿ N‘ Ed Bd d z{ z ,19 a
¿ d Hd { <{ ‘ d n {
d 5z
: R z z z <o
z z
9 : KC * '< :* &  O2 4Q *\
 '+P H
7* * E 7 H , <) N a\tJ C •4 ,R$ 5 Y, M*
B:* n<l* < h  "B'QC iQ+ 6 h  *E 7* ˆ¢ h6 Bj[
X #l:2  *\ UŒ% 5 7 $ 'CT Y\
 a\tjC •4
M:* ') U '+P ‰ - *Z B<'™ &  , 
"Š0 +P
 H/*' " >? @A #  & I : &-
  R 'H6 +™ œm M<QZ - ') U '+P 35.! &
N* VS ;& 7QD2 # Š0 +P M:Q) 7* , M< 5 '
  R 'H6 Y™ P: H 4S h   :~ h  KC
" +ΠU C'C M<  '2
. - g D X  '2  + D 3456 &H x! ?% 7
< t& ;% « h  R % X  N+ U C Q* &+/2 - hj1
"B:* Œ,  YZ . * BC cQ* . * 
% M<<s ;. ‰ X
`<'2 p * * ,6 ) ,  R 'H6 Š0 +P Y &

7z *{ À&[z 6z ({ P { { {{
‘ o d‘ - z .d z B
d %z z o– {  { z ez 7‘ z ƒ d ‘ ({ P
d d W ‘ o - z ƒ
{ d d W {
d ‘ 0z <À  -{ `d ‘ N‘  a
{ ¿ Hd − 19
d
‘d ^ ‘d  z { <{ ‘ d‘ `„ ,z  { '2z +
‰ { &{ ^ ‘  N { Hz h S' aN N‘ ‘  dz {m AE œ z '2z do– R z z h { S'{ ‘ 
d ‘ z ‘ z z z ‘
¾ {  z Š{ 6z n { z z d z Cz lz *d z .z 7‘ *{  z d{ z { ²z { ‘ d‘ Xzz $À  {
o Ad Dzz ‘ *d z `{ ‘ N‘ {C ` ,z >z { ‘ 0{C Bd 5o
z 7‘ *z Xzz
+&^ cš" z .z Rd d +z z <o
z z B‘ <z z – { do  Xo z À {5o: z Á ,z ‘ Mdd z z *z hd
d 2z f z ‘ Ez R z z Bd o jzz E ‘ M‘d : z R{ zb<{
À
:]   C
http://hadithportal.com/index.php?show=hadith&h_id=48&sharh=1673&book=33
: M, š : *  ]   C %1:* ,48 % +&, #% €5 L4 − 20
http://hadithportal.com/index.php

16
#$% &'
"!       
  

R ª v ,~ . U 5vm 


ae , *Q'  & x+s NC
" MH Y$ 
>? @A # G " )& K41  L − 1
9% y *Q'  & h‡H  :~ ;l h  7* 3 ;$  ,
 & + " ” 2% - KE% 1 K›  Q+w< •J  N &)
hN< hN… MQ+ h6 7Q+ E , * ' C : ; D M
%+ *Q'
. - ;$&4 µ P< 5e %Ž l MQ+ h6 7Q+ "    xC
"h 
* ' C : &C *Q'  & x+s ' (P h6 h!m J H
.
% _  *m g :
 5
X L:* B: ,QwQ< <_ .% 5 C
1C B›6 Œ 2 g :
 . " Q+~ 7* %Ž ¡€1 e 7* `^
7 &5* * ' C : ­Ns 5C :<'    - >5E
"Bj1C *Q'  & x+s
a^
% _  $ œm *  :~
 U M N:2 B6 x!
¯s T * ' U C : h‡H ,P: H 4S +, M:* +%
& U +^
<< UT , - Tm H 4S  hj1C KN4S `, -  <2 'C 
Y ' Y ‰: X ½ N^ ;% « M5<l2 6   UgT MD2
¯+ , †j1C *g\ 6&5* R m H ,UT ^  C - *6 "U 
b
B )'2 * 6 7* g D Y *6 ;š 5* U + [ +& % W 7+%ŽQ<
`<'2 ;š 5* + [ 142 w2 2018 :
3H , ,
6  7*
 <2 * ' C : ME,  U 'C  Πw2 I K, - , H 4S wC
x+s - ;š 5 + 1 % $ • 1C Œ + * . 21"U 'C * i¶
"   - *Q'  &

,211 V, " 2018 − * ' C : >


 :~
 N:2 R, +2 " : * ' C :
% − 21
www.pmp.ma : * ' C :
 ] ET  X %1:*

17
#$% &'
"!       
  

- ¦ Q+~ 7* %Ž¥ ]& `^ C  & <


. š 5 g $
A $ * m `+e 7 x! , Q4 Y *6 ;š 5*  & H% x+s
%  h $ ,g D Y *6 Q+~ 7* B^ & # %Ž 7 ®+' C &
RSN QC Š0 h  - ;eb* . 22"&C `4 <,QC
"23  :~ ;l h  7* 349 – 95 – 3
:‡H 24 ;š 5 + 1 ()* - `Q' C LQ2 T 5
: h6 C
"g D Y *6 †j1C 3,e  UT [T .6 ŒC‡C N:

+ h6 &C T š 5 g $ h6 . % e . - Bm B5: “ * R 6


7 ;š 5* Š$6 6 #$ * %« B^ 7* . Q+~ 7* %Ž e 7*
g $ . 7QD+ h6 “ 25"A>? 6 B< :w . h E6 g
Q+~

%$ : /~  & - M 7 ƒH " : &Q= % 2 &:HE – # '5 &£6 Žt &Z − 22
"198 V ,2017 œ J '5l ,+Œ P:< Š' /E ," % *
X \ S= 7+ I * , *Q'  &< B* m &: ]& l X “ : B6 X 95 ;$  ¡:2 − 23
$&¢ , & f+% S #% « B6  N+ # Â<5 ˆ5D C C ($+ h6 ,  D ;& 
# `4 G  7* *jC Â<5 . $&¢ ,B+ [ R5 Y& < e 3s x! (&+¸ 6 B
6 *Q f…* 6    &)  & A. 3Q6 !m "1Q<   U  *  + h6 B<
g 7* &  b Q42 h6 7Q+  & h6 M… , *Q' ; 6 l<< C 2 h
" <QQ<  D E M* ‡C '1+ h6 `4 G  X K'+ , M'C 2 R 6
: B6 X 349 ;$  ¡:2
µ1+ "`4 ². œm B5<lC Y&2 h6 `5
# ]& l ^ ². Y *6 k &+ h6 “
ˆ5D C C <~ 5  * / ]& l ($+ h6 ,^ ². Y *6 ®+' <e +&2 4S
B5 l* $&¢ h6 ,-/~  D 
 g$6  ;%SC H* ;E* i #&+ KC .g :v6 6
"n<l ®+' Â<5* 

J
M:* SNC M :2   ®'5 + h6 ;š 5 + 1 ()* - `Q' $%6 7 7Q+ − 24
 C %1:* ," Š0  :~ ;l h  - ;š 5 + 1" : 5w 7C &£6 : \*
:] 
https://www.coursdroitarab.com/2017/03/pdf_3.html
+l <' : ; * 4 R 6 g$6 - ;g N /Q U ** 
*" :#.~ &, &5 RE − 25
U%&¸ * /E ," :M R J !Q: <Q'
% U ª &  ; W
"342 V ,2015 œ J '5l ,;.  ,  

18
#$% &'
"!       
  

  ‰ ,  'C g


<' +% Ž U  5 }
V €[J +. &+&s , M*  5<l µ P `s &* , Q+~ MH 3y
"""  D Y
 g$6 ,x (P A$&, # 2 ; * * KQM
" + 1 R5 Y&'C ^ #$ N   n<l* . _ x! >? œm
M< RS^ 1 X %'+ &H +p U  5 5: C B6 >?
BC k1 n w
 !‡H ,tu ®'5 h $ MD'C KQDC YH , <* E
Y y‡C Y2 h6 ;>tJ Ap 7Q+ B‡H Q4 Y *6 Ž, g &
\ M
%D, h6 " µ C C &CT Q4 U   &H " S : U *<'
& h2 M:+ &2 <* E B+. 7* ;>tJ A. &Ej2 Q4 Y *6 BC k1
x! ,BC k1 +. VS€C 1 e 7* B N?m 2 * 34<6
. - ®: Q= U$ MT *, E ƒ Y a 7* 310 SN< $ :

26
""n 5
;š 5 + 1 h6  :~ ;l &  -   Y<' 7* B6 E
+$  %«J 7 ®+' <lC C4S 1 e 7* *&
A. * - h2 T * ' C : h6 ,   &Q' . BC ,\ +:'
h6 x! ";š 5 + 1 œm ˆH D:* e . m <6 He # &
B M  h E NE Q+ +6 7* %ŽQ< `^ L:*  :~ (P
7 * ' C : h q  , - ;š 5 + 1 l
C Q4 œm ;š 5*
x '52 * ' C : , M  h E NE Q+ +6 - 'C  C Y 
27
";š 5 + 1 = ˆH k:52

08/69 % ;š 5 + 1 f<* - ,2009/03/13 ©+% C µ C C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 26
 :~ ± 4CJ U
%& /E* U%1:* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,08/70
"50 V ,2 $&'  D U$ MT <<
,R&' ;%ŒC N'  :~ h b1 ++&QC
- ,2008/10/30 ©+% C ,4498 $& 3s µ C C  :²
T Q4QC 4:~ H0 7 %$  % − 27
"50 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,20/2008/1884 % f<

19
#$% &'
"!       
  

;% 5 ;š 5 + 1 KQD2 #% Ž 7* i B‡H x '52


p\t 3512 g D X 3) Π NH ,x< E & %D4C
x< E & %D, ;š 5 B+ [ 7QD+ I 1 hC BC k1
`, .&, * ' C : ; D l'+ # ƒ Y a 7* 3 ;$  xC N ’
E & %D4C 1 KQD2 Y&'C B6 , *Q'  &
% _
x+s - `^ œm H ) C BN: kl 6 & h+ ;š 5 B+ 1C x<
%D, hC Q4 B< U$% * . " M
% _ `, *Q'  &
O
6 µš ,Y ' Y ‰: C <' %*J 7* 4:~ + D - * ' C :
+ 1 C B:QD2 - A%&S* &“ T %D, . , 4:~ U <~ $ 'T
+& H& B'* h+ # *J ,h  ¡ 7* m ,B*& 7* ;š 5
28
"A$% K'+  &~
<e 7 >5' , 7* 4) h2 h6 “ ;š 5 + 1
R5 Y&'C µ C C &CT Q4 3D &H ,  D 'C  x+s
B6 ; '* , :*J L SQ<  D - <t& +Œ ” Y&2  + 1
, <Q C :*J ;/MJ f<’ i% . <t& +Œ h6  H X
©+% C B BC E R\t 7* 3C  h‡H , M: + 1 +&2   B R€
-  D 4C gm <e X ˆH ° B6 ,R&' +Œ œm 2013/05/07
Q4 œm *Q'  &  ,‡C 'C  œm ,‹ >1+ h6 h $ ()
71 ;$  - .H2 (P µ[  + 1 h6 % 5  X , S€ +/
S€ l<< B< :w 7* ¢‹ 5 l* 7QD2 h6 Ã2 ,A\ 6
29
"f< C `H <t& +Πn E 7 n ? * . B5 '* ] ~ 'C QC

4: f<* - ,2009/04/02 ©+% C 09/205 $& 3s h 1N1C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 28
"114 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,2/08/647 $&
$& 4:~ f< - ,2014/03/12 ©+% C µ C C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 29
www.maroclaw.com : h  n0* <w ]   C %1:* ,2013/2102/1109

20
#$% &'
"!       
  

l
C *Q'  & ;% vm - `^ h6 œm ;% [ 7* &C T >t6
;& - D+6 3C v A&w C Š0 +P X , i š 5 g $
<Z 7* 36 SN ¡:+ , ,Ä +P \* M:* % * U '+P2
:Q+ T +%MQ~ E e 7* D ­N, " h6 X ,  :~ Ug
;%S A. - S€1 B b* X *Q'  & ;% vm 7* %Ž
6 `4 X D  ,m <e *m ŀ1 `^ C Y  `+e 7 B:Q+
"" Q4 & ;š 5* Y 
MH ,   -  E ›jC k‰s ;š 5 + 1 H h!m
>? , 'C  x+s 7 * ' C : ­Ns &'C a^ g DT &, 5
7* K:e X B)N2 * 5C  'H 3 MH x! 7* ? X †6
#jC Y  + T , .&+&2 6 $&s Q4 .$&s , p5  D Y
%
œm gw< - 7+%Ž 7* &+&' Y *6 / , 1+ _ , M$6 5 gm
" Q+~ U 5vm g'C `<' 1 œm  D+ ,g D
>? @A # G " M3:= − 2
# : %l E% ;+ * X &.  Yw Q &
<D2 - B\0
 Q+~ n 2% - B:* ;$ N
T 6 7* I ' A&M[
7* S€ U l< 7Q+ $ #6 ¯2 Y& Q+~ % vª = &'
#&s Y *6 S€ :*J U l< ) * . "Bm R B+. &+&s
+&^ : U&w ±&,jC  '
 ;% « M<  H >5E
U+
, " p ” 2% U 5vm M< H ˆ5) 52 ~ /0 xN
5E +&^ : C 3 '
 : %l :*J L S
KSS€* e6 K
&:M* 3N… ,3J  ” /Q2  U%l
(: . 4H * - SS€* +%$m U :C 3<t , +&^ : -
30
"~ 7*

,10 $&' , eP <Z ," Q :+H / 6 GHT Ä:~ Œ/CT" :+4 +% 2
− 30
"14 V ,2015 31?

21
#$% &'
"!       
  

+ <H , ^ % M…m œm #$b+ * E .  :~ $ - U 5v


h6 , q! - Q+~ ( U5v “  :~   - M X ^
B<
R'
C `42  w: . h!m U 5v H " p 2 . M
V\€
T G  BC K'+ # & œm R< N<€ Be
31
" M< h  , R  B< ) '   ,
Y+  ;&Q J .6 7*  :~ ;$  - U 5v h+ x '52
7 ¡€[ #6 g * 7Q+ T B6 x! ,32 M*C  :~ &' c‹ M<
¡€[ E hJ ,'N p BC 2% U 5vm h $ Q+ &'+ 'N BC 2%
A. ,  :~ ;l h  - B< VS: ;g  :+ 6&5* 7* &N+
" :'* Q+~ ¡€1 n 2%  &+ 7* `2 X + U 5v '™ :+
U 5vm +, 6&5* 9+ A&w  :~ ;l h  œm ( C
7Q+" B6 X ¡:2  B:* 286 ;$  QC x! ,
 H C ~
Ã+  R,J - & * U 5v 
7* <
+jC ~ U 5vm
g
   - %* i * . ," x! \€C MH h 
"P: H 4S h  6  :~ h  QC

QwC    U 5vm 7Q+ B‡H x '52
-  'H E6 '+ # :+ ' Ž= M
6% X Æj+  , ,  U 5v
 * 352% &    h2 *&: U 5v
"   f4S 6  

, e6 ," <<s


%$ :  :~ U 5v - +&^ Q<' 
  P*" :#$Q= &p % − 31
Y<' a^ <E ,ŽW ƒ ^ 1 :2 C '*  ,a^ - Y<' A%E$ %$ : *&*
"1 V ,2018 −2017 '* ~ 
 , 

± 4C¤   <w C %1:* R * ,"   ~ -  :~ U 5v" : % +$ C6 <* − 32
"104 V ,2018 : 2 $&' ,  

22
#$% &'
"!       
  

C :< 6 B< :w œm <' Ç<C $wQC B6 X Q'  x
X :+ '* gm + h6 , 6   12 & R 'H6 $C * '
2 & :+ ' A. " 6  U% 5 7QD2 #  6 4NS
2 , , D  N* e 7* 6 ,  D eP µ 5) e 7*

m , 7* g
"B:+ '* 3y * C :+ '* Ž= Œ wm 4NS :+ '*
 U% 5' 7QD ¡: } , p ]  ˆC , 6 4NS
Ž4QC `H2 v , Œ : - &N2 h6 †j[ 7*  U *<' E ,
" < 7QD R  7* € :+ '
U 5v 
 C   U 5vm 7Q+ x! œm H ) C
- B6 >? ,©m """ 7 ,$M1 ;$ M[ , T M
6% X tJ
& : ” Ss h6 +&Z U 5v <
h2 h6 “ R,J }
“ , ,G < ++& l<< DÈ U 5v 
} hJ ,G 
h6 “ Y ,J hJ " Œ :    … KC M:C Y w ¯ :. h+ h6
^ ®:<  '+ p KQ€ x1 X T K Y/~ X k:52
#$ * $ ´&+ KC )+ I BjC 3,‹ Q4 h6 K, - $ C %$ S
33
" Q+~ 35+ e 
 :~ & 7 <E f<¬ Q  :~ & H Y<'* . E
& X RS^ $wQH x GH ˆ
- h+ BJ ,#$ 
:N '5l !m , $¸ &E A$ T N+ T g D< BQ+&2 Q
h6 h $ , ^ ¢ 4 X BQDQC 5' 7* 7y Q &<
- x1 B'* nF+ & _ 5' x! ¯%$m ¡S€ >? ;%& - h+
: x1 nF2 kQH B< 34"U 5vm 7* Q & B*&+ * &S*

g D <wQC %1:* ,1970  19 ©+% C ,14 9 49 $& 3s X J i<w 7 %$  % − 33


"32 V ,20 $& X J i<w
"107 V ,`C
* : % +$ C <* − 34

23
#$% &'
"!       
  

# C  '
 B:Q+ B‡H B+&+ KC *& U 5v <
VS€C G 
; €< gw< h6 E "]  & 4 7* `4< R w - ; W
U 4N   B2 + *&: ) N* *6 L5S+ :
+p  ;% «  N+ _    * X MZ
" ” 46
U! L5S2 †‡H 35M e 7*   C 3 k* U 5v $6
k U% 5' 3 E k* B6 +° ®: Q= U   &H , <l* w,
k U    1 C C E M .$% 6 & ,  5
 H Q4 q  
Q4 Y *6 `4 É   k , *, M 7* EJ ” 'C
36
" B< k:w ;$ M[ (
œm  , \C    h+ Q+~ $ h‡H , p
%‡C
, *Q'  & x+4 ;š 5* + [ +&2 N+ T B6 >?
+ h6 &C T C ,g D Y *6 Q+~ U 5v‡C <N U 5v 
+&2
" *Q'  & 3l
Tm Y$  6 Y° 5 x!

ˆt X ') !m & a^ C K & X c : T BjC   & #° g D h‡H ;% [¸ − 35
¡€[ X ' œm \2 Mm M n 5 ½ N6 ˆ5D w2 Œ M ” V W hN<
& BH h'l ^ h E ,x! h E  ,f2 p `+e 7 Mm n 5 ½ N6 B2 X $   7*
hN< Œ M 7* & a^ C K & H'QC w ˆ+P 7* &Q & h\lC X kM
 &< 5: C ;$  BD + B5'+ C h  `5l2 - jlt6 & h+ B‡H ,” V W
&5 n ´m A$% 6 ,481 V ,51 : ,2000/05/18 < ,a 62 : 22340 % 7'l " &
g/~ h  U\+&'2 ±&,J 5e ,"+ g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
 " :<l
M 1m ©+% 2 :* +° ®: Q= Y ,jC % * , + /Q Q= Y ,6 +
,2015 œ J '5l ,   U%&¸ * /E U%1:* ,  &<w, 2014 Y k,
"110 V
122 % 4N 08 k:H * 26 : 1446 % 7'l - +° ®: Q= 7 %$  % − 36
https://eleslam-elqanon.yoo7.com/t1702- : ]   C %1:* 1957−02−05 ©+% C
topic

24
#$% &'
"!       
  

>? @A # G "  N )& K41 O −3


n 5
J X ; \ " B6 X P: H 4S h  7* 100 ;$  ¡:2
1 e 7* + 1 4C *Q'  & ˆ2 ,37   ;$&4
x+s - %ŽQ< `^ h  L:* H "38" M+4 *ŒT 3 E !m
A. 7 RŒ : - `^ D+6 B4:* ,;š 5 B+ 1C *Q'  &
" *Q'  & µ
B< 2+ # , + 1
q$&, &H    - *Q'  & Y$ 2 ;&* *6
n 2% Y+ 7* ‚&52 <* E M[6 
ÃQC %E h  7* 101 ;$ 
 & x+s + I  < Q+ H " 'C  ()* 'N
MH `^ ˆ+ ” 2% ©+% 2 7* M[6 
6 t$ †j1C *Q'
,2006¨02¨20 . h E + 1 (&+m " h6 g D   &H "Y$  5C
- H 4S h  - M< VS: ~ Y$ 2 &*6 $&, (P hm ,
'C  ()* Q+~ hm , "P: ©+% 2 7* ‚&52 <* E M[6 

Y ' Y ‰: 7* '+ # 4:~ Y$  &*6 p e & A.  ^ h2
µC L+° Tm M'+ T Q4 hm , ,  <2 A>2 h6 Q4Q<
39
"" M*$  *Q'  &

,C  ¡€1 UQC *Q'  & ˆ2 " B6 X  :~ ;l h  7* 4 ;$  ¡:2 − 37
; E %* % &SC ,'N Y™   :~ U D ©:C * 1 N' C Y$  C
1 RŒ :C D+6 ˆ2 "x! X ,‹ h  ¡:+ *&: L<S C ˆ2 "BC à gÊ
""x! \t X h  ¡:+ I * , 'C Q<  +% «  eš + 1 3 E !m ,B+ [ 7
,;>E .  6   , - 'C  x+4 *ŒT + 1 MH h2  UT ^ H' − 38
"P: H 4S C `<' 88"13 % h  7* 99 ;$  ¡ œm ( k+
f< - ,2008/12/26 ©+% C ,37/202 $& 3s g D5 %& C &CT Q4 7 %$  % − 39
"63 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,06/21−67 %

25
#$% &'
"!       
  

6 m µ


6 i A\ 6 101 ;$  - B< VS: J
;l h  7* 6 ;$  U D* `H f+ l:+ h6 7Q+ Y$ 2
"40  :~
.    h6 œm Y ' +& . R\t 7* ¡<€
&'2 ,U<E g) X :2 , - > 74 , C* Q<E 6 R 
:C< '1+ , M:* :/¢ * E6 * MD'C :,N2 ,t6 :12 U<E
>? C! E 3 E !m  t 9j+ µ 5,m 7* .“ * ,;F^ IJ C
+& ¡€[ `, - 3 E !m 6  * D :* 3 E * !m 44
B+12 Y& B: ^ E! - B, B4:* . B +&2 6 h6 Y, C
 *6 Q< H ,Y6 R % 3Œ6 U<E 7* H ,9 : KC B * B2%
`2 X ; <* kQ‰  *6 .  E  *6 \'H †6 <'  ' .C&2 
41
"h m E

6 'C  Ugm 7* gm C *Q'  & Y$ 2 &*6 l:+" : B6 X ;$  A. ¡:2 − 40
"Y$ < 'e  h  A '+ gm C ,BC *j2 6  D l< BC Y2 QE 4 6 `4
². œm *Q'  & H% B: 2+ gm E ,;$  A. YMN* - 'C  Ug‡C &S+
"^ ². 6 `4
<,* R\t `4 G  7 %$  gm E ,;$  A. YMN* - `4 Ug‡C &S+
. 7* R J n  7*    U D H •Q `4 6 #$&  `4
"h 
" &< M
%$ R\t Q4 A€2 gm E ,;$  A. YMN* - QE 4 Ug‡C &S+
" QE 4 6 'C  6 `4 gm M<Q1+ I 7+ V €[¤ 5: C xE ( lT . #F+
;&Q< + * B2&* h2 ,A&*6 BC l gm tª ©+% 2 7* g&C Y$ < &+& 6 #F+
" C  ;$  - ;$&4
"BN h  œm 2 M* m  4
 3 E !m H *Q'  & Y$ 2 ;&* f2
3 - A&*6 7* C * # 2 ;&  4
 BH N22 # Y 7* g&C &+& 7* Y$  6&5+
"BN2
 & U *<' 5[ +2 * `+e 7 P: >M1 `+lC  
Ç\C 7* fl* − 41
U C  :~ i% ;& N ,BC% &5 Y 1. ! * 4 BC Y&2 ,;>M1    3J
"¯C iN C B4N X %1:* "Y& ; #° $ sT C

26
#$% &'
"!       
  

” .  h6 % , :2 X ; < Q<'  b `<l:* 7*


x , 6 
[ €2 *&: , Q<  *6 v &* % M… fb
 * •Q'* A 5 &1 :* ')* › QE Æj+ fb MH
:^ a\tJ C •4 ;% « œm    #$ 2*  
A” 4 E hjC $   ,M*E 7+tu a, +, Y,
'QC i Bj[ 7* * C 6 ,>M1 6  6  A ™ - +^
"  :~ 'C  < e 3s + YZ ¯<
. tu *E
 
%$ [ - fb . h+ h6 X x! Ç<5 :, &
†J ,;%E 
   ~ ,g D MH , <* *
E6 ” '
 MQMH œm  ^ 3456 ,  )* 7* 34)6
hJ ,9 : YQ' 5: C D+6 7 h  R  5: C ˆH i , , ^m
 , E6 . * ' Q1+ 5+2 L56    
R'

"B'
 $ &, Ae ’ H' .>? 7*
'S+ T k, <M
lC   0 :<Q'
 & + 0 A. Ç<5
 f<€QC e ,¸ "Bm B S+m $ * n '
 ¡S€ >? X
:K<SH R\t 7* B :2 % () .
>? )/G :P I (,Q
%& @A )/G : ;E (,Q

27
#$% &'
"!       
  

28
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ ﺟﺮﻳﻤﺔ ﺍﻟﻘﺬﻑ‬: ‫ﺍﻟﻔﺼﻞ ﺍﻷﻭﻝ‬

,* : !  ,;% w^ C *" . BjC 0< -  '+


v , .4 ;% w^ C *" . 6 42 "" /C M*% M5
, :S4 
* >vj2 - A%  ;% w^ KC ” 1 \' A%  C * - Q'

FC ˜ +H kQ+ ,R C +!m  H ,!6 M:* E - hJ ,M:* C
n C BH ,BC 6 BC BH R + 43""n gH 7* BjE ˜ g N
44
" M5
#6 :S4  ,g  #6   ,xE
f<* *$ª 5 ." BjC   &: 'H MN c\l - *6
45
""<*  l 6 , /< ,  l* 6 \
   0 C , <* ,  NN , , ,A>?
L+°C  R J , 7* K  KC  /* &H N:^ g MH *6
46
" ' BC6 7* h m  N:+ h6 ]  , M51 7 — W /
'+P -  YMN* h6 f+% ' A. R\t 7* ­,\+
t6 wC `<'+ * *6 ,: N 6 / C Y q X °+ *\

- t&+ MH x! 4 4DN >' 1  E 9 : ; , 7*
47
">M1 Q+

, 
 
b* - ± * `s ,#$ CJ Œ >H &Q= 7+& &Z , ;$ * ˆ4 9*  − 42
"743 V ,1419 ,   '5l ,U >C
"8 /215 ::0 ,4 /155 :ƒ 4 :0* ,4 /324 :
& [ , ,4 /190 :+& LH − 43
&<w ," n' h  " :#° +HT %‰:* 7C Y* 7C &Q= 7+& R } DN Š6 *\' − 44
"1102 V ,U >C ,+Œ P: 5l< N %$ , 
. :/ 6 f+'C 342 V : MN K - #/ 7C BH 4 /324 :
& [ , ‰ − 45
"xC ®+'2 6 ¦YJ 7* N: \t¥ n¤ : 7* N 6 C$ 6 5 7* Y, gµC *
,4 /190 : + :' +& LH , .&'C * 9 /119 :µ5 , .&'C * 7 /42 :&5 - SN ‰ − 46
" .&'C * 3 /185 :7+&C 7C [ , , .&'C * 3 /199 :'<+/< ` ^ K52 ,202
"37 ,`C
* :N<W – &5 7C 7£ &5 − 47

29
#$% &'
"!       
  

 :~ h  7* 442 SN -   &H Š0 (P *6


!m , ². 6 ¡€[ œm M5 6 ' g $m H &'+ " B6 X ¡:+ #
"" Mm 35  ²p 6 ¡€1 % 5  6 š iy ' A. 3 E
88"13 % h  7* 83 ;$  - D+6 (P A$% 6 # f+' iN .
6 ' g $m :  C h  . R&* - &S+ " B6 MH $% 
¡€1 % 5  6 š iy ' A. 3 E !m , ². 6 ¡€[ œm M5
"" """ Mm 6 Bm 35  ²p 6
 Q 1/1R " HN 1 S*  BQ/&' T/?U PF0 T V!
1&/ WX- Y'4 (- ,F= WQ [ \4 ]^ L " _`a b >?
4L @4'A/ P2 &3C- U ,3'4= >* c)/  W)/  (5 ?
4L 5  >*  3'4= c)/  WXd T P (5 eL _1&'/ ]^
,fd  ,&3g ,fd W- , hfi 5  ,_8[  ]^-
kjU (d \4 /3'4
h $ $ :
 X ¡ (P h6 SN . R\t 7* D+6 K5+ E
5
X   ¡€[ œm *J 5 . $ :
 C $S ,% 5t
a&S \Q= W E! 6 >0 7 +  k:'* 7QDH % 5t *6 ,&Ej
48
"n
A+ + m *\
 BN  % '+ T ¡S: ” Š0 (P
 `, œ '2 – (š -   * hJ ,49 V €[J * B+4C
"`C
* : 5w 7C &£6 − 48
, ,< N<’ U N+'2 U$% 6 ƒ M: iN X %  U '+P 7* &+&' U%
& − 49
9  †j[ 7* 'C g $m E " BjC U C' h  7* 296 ;$  - #/~ (P BH
X  '+ , ²p x<2 œm 6 Mm .$ :
m 6 ,BC M< k & ²p 6 ,V €[J % 5  PC
,x1 B X x! 2 hm k, ,P: ;$ m alC 6 ;š 5* $ :
 x! 6 g $ . P
+&^ U% 5 7* .&+&s 7Q 7* h E 7 
 E! h $ ². 6 ¡€[ BC &S !m 6
== "" Q+~ ()* U \ T 6 U H\ 6 U%1: 6 C  6 &+&M 6 c S 6

30
#$% &'
"!       
  

A. + £ ,50 9 :   C% 4:* pm 5. .  %J B X h m


51
" M+ ? '+P & * ‰ 6 7* *
-  YMN* X p\t 7* :N  ²e A. 7* \l
Y  .H2 YŒ\ µ P h E%J .  Rg  ,h  BN 0<
.6  &  :~ Ug/~ . * – P I l+3 −  Q+
− ;E l+3 – Q+~ A. 52* X (P
%& $R (  >? )/G 5 : P I l+3
h6 h eš MH µ1+ ' X S:+ $ :
m 'H   N+
6 BHPC i 6 Bm U&:
6 7* n  †j[ 7* h+ h6 ,;$&= h2
” Y+  . ‹ :' A. " :< $ :
 . h+ h6 K'+ E ,A% 5 
;% €+ # #:' 7E H2 ;% « 7 \DH ,< $  7E
Y  - O
6 µš . \' h6 C – P I @%C –k :~ &S
D+6 :+j2% :‡H , 5'1* ;>E ” `42  
 , Q+
− ;E @%C –  Q+ - \' ” `42  
<  '

l
C A>0 &:
6 7* E H !  &'+d " B6 X #° U C' h  7* 302 ;$  D+6 BH E = =
Bm U&:
6 7* n  35 J $  3 E  %*6  h  . 7* 171 ;$  C :5 al &,m
""B:e .6 7 A% , 35 6 6   x ;% U C' C
+P h6 K, - ,Š0 A>‰ * >5E 1C n% +  Q+~ #/~ f+' h6 ­,\
35 J $  3 E  %*6 $ :
m 6 B2  5 7*   f ’ A ™ - .! & #°
#° +P< H  `4+ , ,B:e .6 &: A% , 35 6 6 ,Bm U&:
6 7* n 
_ "B:e .6 &: Bm &:Q< % ,T 2 6 ,34 hm n ' 2 ;&:   3 E !m
 7* V €[¤ +^ >H2 -  'H E6 #/~ Š0 K'+P - $% * h6 B'* LD+
. ,V €[J % 5  6 PC 9  †j[ 7* ' $ :
 6 g $m E MQ+wC x! 
"  :~ g   &2 6 % , 2  x<2 7* Q[ 2 E6
„ z ‘  -{ ‘ . z
{ 4‘ 5z ‘  z z z z Yz $z ª {:Cz z:*‘ zo E ‘&z z z " : gË ;%
7* 70 +u - œ '2 B &S* − 50
d :<‘ £
""\ D{ N‘ 2z z:‘ <z tz 7‘ o _„ >¾ {zE Xz { 5lo  7* . z
d :<‘ Do Hz z U
º z ‘ . z z „ z „ d :‘ zŒ%z z
"127 V ,`C
* :N<W – &5 7C 7£ &5 − 51

31
#$% &'
"!       
  

>? )/G 5 :P I @%C


– #$ * ›&,6 K:E% œm B*  ƒ ¢ ~ 7* A>0E  hm
− E mQ – #:'* tu − e I mQ
>? + 9 T5 : e I mQ
. R&* - &S+ B6 X 88"13 % h  7* 83 ;$  ¡:2
' A. 3 E !m ². 6 ¡€[ œm M5 6 ' g $m  C h 
X  '+ """ Mm 6 Bm 35  ²p 6 ¡€1 % 5  6 š iy
0SC P: . $%  k, ,: `+e 7 6 ;š 5*  6  P
NC P: . .$&¢ I 6 M:'+ I ². 6 ¡€[ œm M* h E 6 x1
6 lW - ;$% U% 5' R\t 7* M< ' 7Q+ 7 ¢‹
E *w ,U S< 6 U 5l 6 U C 6 U&+&M 6 c S
f+'2 - ;%    '2 T "  6 v5 6 ;%1: K* D
"h  M<  '+   3 E !m Tm   $ x+4 5* 
'H <l+  4:~ #$  7E h6 ;$  A. R\t 7* LD+
MH µ1+ ' X S:+ − 6  – K'* ¡€1 B* $ :
m 6 g $m
Bm U&:
6 7* n  34  †j[ 7* h+ h6 ,;$&= h2 h6 h eš
–E: – :< $ :
 . h+ h6 K'+ E − : – A% 5  6 BHPC i 6
B& hfi =  4= (& " (E)'/ GL Oi : 6 
'H ¯ :. h+ h6 <l+  - Q * µ 1: h6 x!
6 g $ . ()*   ¡€1 K'2 + h6 – 1 – $ :
m 6 g $m
– 2 – $ :

=  4= (& − 1
h6 &C ,k:' , 7* $ :
 L<lS* 7 g $ L<lS* f<¬
*6 ,n a&S Qs R6 + 2 6 >0 7 +  BC &S+ g $

32
#$% &'
"!       
  

K B X K'* ¡€[ œm ' 6 *6 $ :


m œm °:H $ :

52
"K'
X   ¡€1 œm ' 5:C g $ 6 $ :
 `4+
&* ´ \H 53 " C! E 6 44 ” k &   3 E g
&Ej 5

"$ :
 6 g $ ´ * %&C ;&: ' 4
6 C  6 R C g
>5' 
7* <
#jC `4+ .
<+ h6 Bj[ 7* h+ h6 M ,x1 6 l 5
X 2 g
;% [
54
"g $ 6 $ :
 4 -   ;& 9 : 7* * ' h .!6 -
(P h‡H ,$ :
 g $ 4<lS* KC k:' \t 7* ? C
2 g
Q+~ A. - g/~ &, , ,&, g/~ ' & Š0
- h+ h6 B:Q+ T !  h6 &Eb+ _ ,$ :
 6 g $ `+e 7 
g
, :+ 6 12 <Q' 0S 3 E +6  :~  b 7* ,
"   al C 6 H1 <
 6 P: `+e 7  2
" B6 X ¡:2 P: H 4S h  7* 87 ;$  H x! 7* E6 C
 W ; ^ C i* 6 
6  P: 4) BN '+ ¡€[ #J 7Q+
:'+ * . ,"""" : `+e 7 6 ;š 5* +lC ;%S - `^ C i* 6
$Z h+ & ,!  ;$%m 7* C  #6 ;š 5* +lC h+ & $ :
 h6
7  b Y2 K ^ <E - "tª %&S* #6 6 t6 N4 7 
- " C
AP 2 *  ;$ ‡C Y  m M hC M'H$ 7Q+ T 
V StT Y&'C Ì # % ®:C ®: Q= 3D % e .

YMN -
%$ : ¦ 4:¥ H 4S +, + £ - Š0 g D % $" : §H 7, − 52
https://www.maroclaw.com/ :]   C %1:* R * ,"  D >+ ' ;l
"110 V ,2006 ,   '5l ,/~ *. %$ ," V W U C' h  " :]\ Œ &w &5 − 53
- 
 ;$ M[  U D* 7* <Q* ;E* ," 3J 5[ X  Q+ " :;%
µ  − 54
"15 V ,2014/2013 '* ~ 
 ,/~ ;C Žt &Q= '*  ,a^

33
#$% &'
"!       
  

h6 <'C   4: 7* n<l ;g  '52 &  l - 5 C
: l< S€1 BNSC B5:+ I   C S€[ . + I n<l
B< 3S * % em - P * 1 :* h $ ,B:+ * P . BC Y  * E h6
g
  X  '2  A\ 6 ;%E 44 ;$  7*   ;N
x1 0 - x! ÇH6  k, : `+lC 6 ;š 5* +lC P: h E
B<< k:52 &CT ^ &+6 # BH h'l % H xC "n 2%
B'* K'+ _ ˆH &  & - BC Ì H B*&'T #Œ <' ¡ 
55
"hj1 ” BD:C L+°
g
,x1 $Z 6 K 0 - ÇH6 g
`4+ $ :
 H h!m
QC 6 H1 U\
 2 6 P: 
 - 3<Q'

Tm  b 7* !  kN'+ T "   f4S   
%'2 6 56" B:1+ C B Y q B2 h $ ¡€[ $  $wQC *J `<'2 !m
" :Q) 6 ¢‹ NSC g
B:'2
> ? hfi B&N − 2
. $%  k, """  P X  '+ B6 X A\ 6 83 ;$  ¡:2
. .$&¢ I 6 M:'+ I ². 6 ¡€[ œm M* h E 6 x1 0SC P:
- ;$% U% 5' R\t 7* M< ' 7Q+ 7 ¢‹ NC P:
,U S< 6 U 5l 6 U C 6 U&+&M 6 c S 6 lW
"  6 v5 6 ;%1: K* D E *w
L+° K' . i  Q+ Y  - n<l H B< g :C
K'2 2 g
 `4+ C , <*  B+. BQ
m EC  Q<

$& 4:~ f< - ,2014 +C6 02 ©+% C 485 $& 3s ®: Q= 7 %$  % − 55
"342 V ,2014 ,77 $& ®: Q= g D <wQC %1:* ,2013/3/6/9511
"`C
* : §H 7, − 56

34
#$% &'
"!       
  

M:* MN+ & U% 5'C ®+' LQ< C g NE 2 6 ,E!  H  
" C $S ¡€1
`+e 7 x! , :Q) h+ & ¢‹ h+ E h!m   K'H
& , ²+&C H  6 `<l+ hjE ,x! 4 ;% [ /* B51 g+
VCJ C BNS+ hjE ,A>? 7 A/y N EC * ¡€1C MS<+ H h+
S€[ h+ &   h6 C 57"B< \$ . '“ ,A4 % J 6
3 E <E  YH , '* M< #F+ ^ . h‡H +% 5  6 '5e
"B'5e 3 E NE   &+&s - f'2 B< & U% 5'
YŒT  Q+ - B< :w S€[ &+&s h‡H R,J E -
h+ & ;% [ 35
E K' . 58"`4+ \H Tm #$  7E H
- B< ' 7Q 7* h+ h6 N+ , :Q) h+ & , ¢‹
U$¥ U% 5 X R  g, h6 g D   &H " R ^  … g)
h 
`, - H '+ ,;> 4C 72  ¦U €
5 U  e 5
n &,6 ” Y&2  ;š 5 + 1 D+6 g D 5 E ,59 ^ .
h6 " BH g  R * ,  &) >5 ° C &CT Q4 C x< E
9 """ C ”« B5* - + 1 Qo ?z x< E   ;$ '

<, •Q2 4C ," #$' Y\  - >5' `, ;g


m" : #Ë & &'
7C 7£ &5 − 57
"59 V ,1431 , +$' ,g D< — ' &M' ,> 
&5 n ´m A$% 6 ,1999/11/14 < a 60 : 20571 % 7'l - +° ®: Q4 % − 58
;%$ S U\+&' ±&,J 5e ,U C' h  cš - +&^  :~ 
" :<l
k, M 1m ©+% 2 :* ®: Q= Y ,6 BN g%|C B< <'* ,2003 : 95 % h  C
"662 V ,2010 ,; D #$  U%1:* ,C &<w ,"2004 Y
- ,2009/02/16 ©+% C ,255 $& 3s +&[ C &CT Q4 7 %$  , - x! ‰ − 59
"68 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,08/1037 % f<

35
#$% &'
"!       
  

x! """" & *    '*  ! 


6 * ' C : C R b* AŽ, !1
x< E n ;& &2 7* D+6 ? C BQ
C AE! Y& 7* ? C
60
";%E Q4 C
h  N+ , h%  h  - D+6 A&w *J . *
h  <l2  B6  &C , Q< 5: &+&4 C K+/~ g D
] ~ X M 7* h E ,R5* >? 4 X  a l a D x! >?
61
"B< :w S€[ I '* ®'C h C B2% 5 - N¬ hjC n ' 7* N+ h6
h E " B6   # #° g D D+6 B
E B . iN
h‡H ;%1: U% 5' - ,‹ B< :w 
 E+ I µ , & ] ~
U% 5'  7* Bm 3M 7* ¡€[ X '2 h6 () Q4
^ U  &* 3 E  MN:E  U C\ '  … q!
. & a^ C  & h6 3S<€
 & Q4 h6 &N2 BH h'l
w: Ç2 .$% 6  U% 5' 3 E ,  U% 5'C $S
h+ h6 &'+ T hj1 . - 7 l A>+ * h‡H M< ^ M52% 
62
""'* >0C () Q= BC 2 _  & $6 +&2 - T&
;H*  Q+ h E%6 h6 Ä g D   a  iN -
S€1 B4N X A! 
6 3':C  e Y  - M'  3<y D -
?% `C  Y ‰:< 7+%j *&W 7* BjC ¯C iN    C
63
" '* ~ 
b t$ BN œm ˆH al2 m BQ
C AE+ I BE

- ,2008/10/30 ©+% C ,4498 $& 3s µ C C  :²


T Q4QC 4:~ H0 7 %$  % − 60
"62 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,20/2008/1884 % f<
"18 ,`C
* : µ  ;%
− 61
"88 V ,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* A$% 6, 1998/02/22 < a 61 : 8334 % 7'l − 62
c\ Bm % [6 ,2012 # * 02 ©+% C 2811 $& 3s i NSC  :²
T Q= 7 %$  % − 63
Y<' <E ,R J h  - 4C >  ;$ M[ : ;E* ," ¯C iN  " # 41
"28 V ,2014 – 2013 '* ~ : ,
C 
  

36
#$% &'
"!       
  

B2 . $&S . - h%  Š0 +P B


E * hjC &'
U% 5' - + 4+ h6 R ¢  œm jw<+ 7* 5 ? h6 x! $Q=
H '* B<'   K'2 œm #$b2 & :Q) U% [m l'H <Q'
B<Q'+ & 5+ x1< T Z ¯2 x! * 7 ,%MQ~ 5 ? &
"  b 7* ¡<Q< ! 
X !  e 7* <Q' >C ' ½ NJ T$ &* +&2 *6
BH *J >H ,A>? X i K'* ¡€[ X S:+ BE X ,
% em - .+&C Q4 A. vj2    7* BJ ,() Q= œm
"<' , 7* Tm ®: Q= C  DÈ T  ++& Ml<

;&, X Œ  C l4  ‰ U l' g) - x! ¡<€2 .


l<
"x<2 6 T& A. ” 3S<€
  al Π2 h6 M<
B:'2 7+ I hm !  K'2 - ˆH °4:2 T   +&2 - Q4
µ P X .H2 &* 5* ' f2 œm D+6 &Q+ C ¢‹
" H h C<l
W*- c  WL M1 T n4 oXd T m1p >? &  : :
_3'4 
h6 “  ' h6 : LD+ A\ 6 83 ;$  U D* 7* \l
†j[ 7* h+ h6 − 1 − ;$&= h2 h6 › K

6 Keš MH H+
− 2 − A% 5  6 BHPC i 6 Bm U&:
6 7* n 
m1p >? &  N  -1

I h‡H 64 ;$&= h2 h6 g $ 6 $ :


 ()* ' - µ1+
¡€[ \* fS+ 7QH ,
m H 'N h+ \H ;$&= ' 72

,+ΠP:< &* ^ %$ ," N 7 >5' +4C


 ~ " :#&5' .C a% e R − 64
"203 V ,2008 ,œ J '5l ,h

37
#$% &'
"!       
  

, h $  ' 2% & h+ B ;$&= ' 5 h $ g 12% C
h2 65";$&=   BC i BJ 
. ¡ BjC * ¡€1 R+ 7*
7* ;[% t6 & h\H hjC !  R+ *&: K  7+. - ;$&= '
Y  h\H hjC R+ 6 ,\* *Q N 7* ;$ N
\ B ˆ
 C * h\H
"#&<5 ($ 7* U&'* FC
:'* ' X $ :
 6 g $ S:+ h6 :'+  ' K'H
N+ C ,\* [ <l* &+&4 . h+ h6 Y/<+ T B6 >? ,;$&= 6
66
"] ~ &S 7 MH 2   ‰ - R&+ h E hm 5: &+&4
;&: ' h2 h6 µ1+ T   K'2 - R ^ . H
= .$ :
m '+ k, ” <'  N E EC * 2 &+&s ;$&=
:QD* h+ #6 , 5 &+&4 . h+ h6 N+ C , Q+~
0 7* ;$&= ' µ 5:
 M+e 7 7Q+  

J ‹ :'
œm ¡€[ 5 \* E &+&s ' &+&s Y& ?% H!  'H ,$ :

.&+&s 7Q+ :'* ' xC &S+ h E !m ,Ê2* 6 a%
B6 A>?
= Ë 7 \* +&^ h+ hjE 67"$ :
 C l4  ‰ C  '
 C
? C  ^ A. NH ,a%  . 36  Q< !  RH U.wQ<
Ë . ” $S h6 X R&2 .$ :
m  ‰H ' K'2 Y& 7*
"4
Bm 7²Ql+ C MH  6  ½ N6 , f+'2 -  *6
Q4 x! - B< C % T , & -  MN B<Ss 7* G 
" ' X ]  `5l - Íl¬ I Y$ * ®:

"13 V ,`C
* : 5w 7C &£6 − 65
"17 V ,`C
* : ;%
µ  − 66
"620 V ,`C
* ," U C' h  cš - +&^  :~ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m − 67

38
#$% &'
"!       
  

 - :+ * E MH , */ .°, 7Q+ T ;&: : 1 '


'+  Q<  W 6   ; ^ C iy ' $ :
‡H , \tJ
C  hJ 68"\* &  QC n S* h\H hjC g $ 2  E , H
¡€[ BC ,2 B<.6 e 7* % , = ¡€1 '™   ”
'+ " Y [ $ " N $ :
m h6 Š0 g D   E "k/< ke '+
" ;% 5'C 1Q< M  ' &E6 # """ &. 1 ;$ M1 $ :
 H
M* M5:+ ' "$" ;% 5 hm , "Y ' (% 1 C &w Y *6 " $
l
C 3y ,Bm 35 # ¡€1 % 5  š iy 1Q<
h  7* 47 SN< :+ ‹ :' B'* h2 _ ,Y ' (% 1 - c S
69
" M<6 7* B2tb* K'+ B, - Q  P: H 4S
. 7 [ N* [ b+ BjC ]& `^ C  l `, - R h6 E
,wN 5 * œm &Q+ F* ' , 5t  U\N,  ,6 ” + B6 ,n$
KC A% , œm  &+  & *C 9 * X #l:+ _ x[ \C .
E  Q+ BC H2 ,BH @'+ # ˆ
 - .š '+ 7* Bl ’
70
"h  - H'* .
¡€1 œm C: ' hj[ 7* 7+ I !m B‡H R,J } -
H+ \H , M4  , - BC  2 6 A% 5  6 BHPC
* ±&s h6
- 
% B6  e 7 P:+ 7* H 2+ T x '52 " .$ :
‡C
:w &   ,% , + T h 4* - n
 hJ ,h 4*
+& C i xE &'+ T * H &'+ * &+&s - ; ' hJ ,x! B<

"18 V ,`C
* : µ  ;%
− 68
,11/1241 $& 4:~ f< - 2013/02/26 ©+% C U+% C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 69
"%1:* >?
K, 4H A$% 6 ,1970/05/31 -  D :
40 R 615 $& 7'l - +° ®: Q= % − 70
"224 V ,+Œ P:< Š' ,"h  Y\  +," : *

39
#$% &'
"!       
  

&+&' BH + #$ *6 . h 4* - n


 71 "B< :wQ< ŀ1
h6 7Q+ T E ,A% 5  6 
 *C 9 * #6 + T 9 : 7*
"n '< \= h+
H '+ * >5'< +, '+ * KC /Q j* &C cl2 :.
7QD+ ¯C i+ N< 4N X `<'2 C H , ' &+&s 5
:QC
7 >5'2 '+ h6 “ #%$ —  $ N C % ? ;%Œ ¯ :. hjC R
MH .51* N YC6 & E ;%Π+ΠhjC `<' 7QD2 !m *6 "#6
Y q m #6 7  >5'2 i MH ,$ N 4% M:* l'2 h < at
h  M<  '+ Q+ 'N . '+ , N ' $ :
m L+‹
hm n '< B'D¬ & Bm U&:
6 # +Π% 5  PC iQ+ BJ
"AP 2 * 4 35v
Q
m Q  P:C Y  ¡€[ $‡C Ä g D Ì % e . -
- ' ) 3 E †6 k $ ¯C i+ N C B4N X 2 S€[ 32 R
- `, 7* M BC xy * h6 Q4 U  H ,Y ‰: µ
5 $ N
M< :wQ< :'*   %*J B5 7* 35+ C B< $ $* >5'
X w:+ * * M4 X & +&2 6 q 5vm h $ ¯C i+ N l
C
72
"M*E 7+%E % 5 C i* B+12 7* x!
c  WL M1 T n4 >? &  Xd T /  − 2
_3'4  W*-
U% 5' h2 h6 &C T , ' &+&s ;% «   œm
* , BC  2 6 A% 5  6   PC iy  - <Q'

"623 V ,`C
* ," U C' h  cš - +&^  :~ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m − 71
c\ Bm % [6 ,2013/04/02 ©+% C ,2703 $& 3s i NSC  :²
T Q= 7 %$  % − 72
"31 V ,`C
* : # 41

40
#$% &'
"!       
  

- ;%    '2 T , A\ 6 83 ;$  7* ;>tJ ;N 7* $ N+


M<  '+   3 E !m Tm   $ x+4 5*  f+'2
"h 
*\ œm ƒ ¢ <* , +&~ B*\
œm B2 , - ƒ ¢ h  H
- A% $ +$j2 l , ” ':+ $ p Q+ ; ^ ¢ k, , +:'
/' ; 4H , 5<
T C “m 'H  D L5S+ ,B QE6 X Qw
Î&t E 73 "B'QZ A&<C B:+$ *&W 'H$ h ¸ l'2 *
h  %& 7* ˆ¢ * A. 7* ¡:+ 'Q 6 P 6 % 5 ¸
"B'QZ t$
h6 §H 7, ! + % 5  iQ+ * P iQ+ * KC /Q<
9  *6 "B* 
 B*E - 6 B2! - ¡€1 ´ P C 9 
"Qw t$ ¡€1 ” k‰¢    +& C `<'+ MH % 5  C
:M K h6 " h6  '* K*MN 7+. KC /* &  D Q' h6
 7 &'C Š “T $ ^  ) X :5:2 MlC) *\ 
74
""$H¤  W ; ^ C i  .
6 P B )* iQ+ h6 “  Y *6 h  B< g :C
B 7* % 5  6 PC iQ+ h6 Bj[ 7* i >5'2 E h‡H —  C ,% 5 
T B‡H , M<  '+  '+ T B:QD2 * h6 6 ,B'Q
œm gÄ+ 6 ,Bm
& B6 :'+ T . ,B< g :C   $ x+s 7Q+ T H '+
"  ^ , """ >M12 6 
B6 X BN2 7Q+ C , , 5* L56
h E kQH ,BC ; \H  U% 5 BH Ç S2 # n<
J *6
  ¡€[ œm 7 [ *6 $ :
m ” &++ B6 !  U% 5 7* YMN

%$ P ,"h  BN - % *


%$ : M\ M C `4<2  %«J" :K, < h ,m − 73
"72 V ,P: ©+% 2 T '5e h &C ,U >C Q<' 
"`C
* : §H 7, − 74

41
#$% &'
"!       
  

i A% , 6 Bm &:


6 7* n   J *J x! L  4C
  h E +6 n ' `4* h+ $ :
 x! h‡H B:e .6 &: A% 5 C
75
"BC Â # n<
J 6
7e* BjC 1 f  U 5l2 7* B6 g D   &H
BS, - š 5 5 . ,"@~ - E" BN hjC ;$ ' aH
X >vj< @~ - A!N 0
 BE :'+ x! h6 , † , X
Œ : A. NH 76"AN:2 - *J C (Ë B^ S , %&m - Q4
B'Q
iQ+ ;$ ' aH 7e* BC   f h6 Q4 U  
h6 E ,;$ ' aH 7e* h+ h6 - ?+ T #$ 7e* BJ A% 5 
RS^ 6 7* A!N 0
 BC g $ @~ - E BN E!
BC  !N: R\0
 Q+wC B'C * L hm  &+ B^ S , X
`, - H A\ 6   % 5  - H* 3 E Q4 h6 X R&+ _ " M<
"1
  f h6 µ C C &CT Q4 U   t6 Œ  -
9  X #l:+ f . +l +/~ UC €Q< \Q BC
KC A% , œm  &+ >0 ‰ - A% 5  A%& 7* ˆ¢ B< :w *C
ˆ
 -  t NSC BH @'+ # ˆ
 - .š '+ 7* Bl ’
Q+~ :+ ‹ :' BC H2 B< :w Bm Q:+ # N4S
%*J 7* ' hJ   B2 D+6 . 77"   H'* . E 
 , - BC  2 ,9 : KC A% 5  ¡€1 *E 7* ˆs 
" q5v

"634 V ,`C
* ," U C' h  cš - +&^  :~ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m − 75
$& 4:~ f< - ,2009/03/19 ©+% C 1819 $& 3s ;&C  :²
T Q= 7 %$  % − 76
"109 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,09/41
,08/68 % ;š 5* + [ f<* - ,2009/03/13 ©+% C µ C C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 77
"75 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:*

42
#$% &'
"!       
  

= (& " %& $R : E:


,A% M…m 6 BQQ'2 gÊ C M~ . , +F \t . \'
$ :
m h+ h6  Q+ Y  µ1+ , ,BC < %MQ~ e ,m
\' hJ ,:< $ :
m . B< :wQ< 9 : % , œm #$b2  '
U% 5' - 7Q2 T  Q+ ;%lt , Q+~ Ap /Q 7E .
9 : 7* >E < ˆ¢ h\ T . hJ , †\ m - m , MN :1
78
"B< :w œm C: :1 ' C
MH , Q+ - #$  7E ‹ : .6 7* . $ :
 \'H
7* ;% - Q+~ A. Y2 T B &C  Q+~ /Q °:'
# 88"13 % h  7* 72 ;$  - B< ¡S:  & 79"%S
6 lW l
C 
T (  T % +6 - \' 
$&,
*m , *Q' U  6 7E *J - ” AN U&+&M 6 c S
6 7E *J - ) ' 6 Π6 '5 U 5l U C l
C
*m YQ' % ‰6 X ) ' U S< l
C *m *Q' U 
<
+6   6 +°5 'Q Y\  
f<’ l
C
"  m * $  0 p Q'2 t6
7* <
+jC 6 ,A\ 6 ;%E 
 &,‡C `42 h!m \' H
al BN ®'C $&, & "%MQ~ < œm ' R S+‡C LQ2 h6 †j[
. 

6 ae ±\v -  Q+ - \' ” `42  

80
" C  \ v ,g+ 6 'N \ ,c S 6 R \ :

P:< gvm %$ ,"Æ% * U C' h  - V €[J X ' ~ " :45 <t c &_ − 78
"212 V ,2009 œ J '5l ,h$%J ,+Œ
"624 V ,`C
* ," U C' h  cš - +&^  :~ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m − 79
'5l ,;.  , C' DM: %$ ," V W  : U C' h  cš" : %  &5 +ŒH − 80
"574 V ,2012 ,  

43
#$% &'
"!       
  

N2* USC ] ~ ±&s  H c S 6 R C \' `42


T # c S 6 R *6 ,A>? R Bm B 7* B 
l+ 4C
81
" \' N BH H2 \H &, ¡€[ Q* œm Tm S+
C : . E X .H2 U 5vm g +    7* . \'
82
"¦;š 5 + 1¥ š 5 g $ - ]& `^ C  l `2 X 6 * '
M< U&Q   ‹ :' ŒC‡C MQ, - */<* h2 Q4
" :<' °: V\€
T
- 7EE \' X D+6 ¡: $% %  U '+P ®'C -
B6 X #° U C' h  7* 302 ;$  B< 3S , , Q+
. 7* 171 ;$  C :5 al &,m l
C A>0 &:
6 7* E H!  &'+
U C' C Bm U&:
6 7* n  35 J $  3 E  %*6 h 
;$  7* ;>tJ ;N M< 3S:H :<' 
*6 ,"   x ;%
Q1 %S Y
 C  '2" B6 pC h  . 7* 171
7* $& X /y >0C 3 Œ !m :< Q ae 7* .>? Œ*
""9 :
Q+ É \' h6 % 7* B6 #° g D   x '52
HC Tm `4+ T ,U C' h  7* 302 ;$  É M< VS: 
>0C 9 : 7* $& X  U% 5 :QD C  +Œ2 p 6 ,7+°:
h+ h6 h  <l+ T ,n* . * !m k ~ g M v /y
7* $& œm  & n h+ h6 kN+ C ,  :'*  &,  0 C +Œ
Y6 ,B:* ;&, € R &2 `+e 7 x! h E6 g
,\< h E  9 :
h E 6 ,M 'NC Tm 7+ I x! Y$ * , M:* % 6 © ;& RC

"38 V ,`C
* : µ  ;%
− 81
"8 V ,`C
* : 5w 7C &£6 − 82

44
#$% &'
"!       
  

É ^ A$% 6 * $ N* h E  , M<M“ h E B6 %S+ T B<Q' Q, w


B< :w Q M œm [ +&2 X Y&6 7 l h6 7* B2  &*
. +€ R'* Q¢ B6 B+& A% m B 3  )%6 BC S? 3:QD2
h‡H ²e t U+&  H g  & ±45 /EQC  N… B 4 h6 B Œ
7* ;% Ž C Y<'* .  , Q+ É \' °: BC H+ _ .
,Q' C B< :w g\*Œ KS€ KN… &+6 M &2 1 x<2 h6
h+ v 7* M:* M< (\e ;% « 1 R
% Q, w:E
83
"&:
>? X $&S . É ^ X ':
!  Y  `+e 7 `42 \' h6 g D   Π: A. NH
+ 1 A. hJ , U% 5 7QD2 Q
% U M œm + [ +&C
* . *Q' `H C K<* ' KN… 5 7* M< (\e 

" \' B'* `42


X Y+  Q+~ #$  7E h6 `5
* R\t 7* : LD+ h!m
, +% 5  6 '5e h E g
K'* ¡€1 B* $ :
m 6 g $m 'H `s
7* n  †j[ 7* h+ h6 ,;$&= h2 h6 MH µ1+ ' X S:+
. - `4+ h6 K'+ E ,A% 5  6 BHPC 9 * MH 6 Bm U&:
6
" :<' µš A\ 6 ;%E Be P H )m $ :

&C T C  4: `4 A&, N+ T #$  7E H2 h6 >?
"#:' 7E H2 7* x! œm H ) C
>? +G " 9& T5 : E mQ
jlW h6 x! ,~ - J .  :~ &S 6 #:' 7E
M:C `+N 9
6 ,&Q' 5 7* . 2  ~ <?6 ,g :


: 13023 % 7'l ¦1351 V − 479 − 15/12/1996 < − a 60 : 11632 % 7'l − 83
: ¯C i+ N X M4N - .C ;%
;! B2$% 6 ,62
https://www.facebook.com/sarahebrahim1992127/posts/230838467594941/

45
#$% &'
"!       
  

œm ] ~ ;$%m Bw2 &Q' NH ,#$  'N 7* ;$% fQC $&4+


`s œm Bw2 T ;$% h‡H jlW - *6 ,h  M*“ :'* w ±&,m
#:' 7E .C e , 6 7* 84"'N œm 3M™ hm * w
v – 6  – 4:~ A. -  :~ &S 7 ±&4 
 4: -
–: – h%  Š0 g D Y *6 B2 5l2 & x! &'C al
  1, : 6 
- 6 , :~ h  at œm Mw : -  :~ &S Q+
 + . ,+w ” <' * YZ 'H n 2% œm Mw ;$%
85
" :~ h < f ’ BC Y  # 'N hjC Q+~ 2* <
Y  

J ‹ :' C < X ] ~ h E !m Tm `4+ T MH
h E !‡H ,g&  ()QC Y6 ,* BE<C x! `<'2 g
Q+~
>? Q+ Y *6 h 86" :~ &S `4+ \H x! 7* gÊC \. 
" +&S
- +&S >? Q+~ +&S Q+~ KC /Q ›6 Œ 2
Q+~ U 5vm 7* M
6 h+ +&S >? Q+~ U 5vm hm , ,U 5v
* : 6 &S U 5vm 7* F+6 $ h+ jlW U 5vm hJ , +&S
Tm 35+ T ,4C :e C ÄN °: - Q+ B &S H , N &
&Ej< H E >? k52 UH ‰2 U$&'2 M*  7 C 6 ,B5,   C
+$ * 6 ' * B< R&2 * 5 0H jlW *6 , 'l NSC AH2 7*
87
"U l X > 6 *\ &  Y, Y& * U 5v ;F*

,2006 , C : ,+Œ P:< Y<' %$ ," Y '  :~ h  - / " : ] £% %S:* − 84
"107 V
"124 V ,2006 ,i2 ,'* ~ P: /E* ," Y '  :~ h " : >S ƒH − 85
"108 V ,`C
* :] £% %S:* − 86
"135 V ,`C
* : >S ƒH − 87

46
#$% &'
"!       
  

h6 7Q+ T #$  'N 6 h  7 %$ S ¯< H * NSC


±&,6 'H fS+ \H ,;% ’ ;, Qvª ;$%m 7 %&S+ I * Q+~ C fS+
6 ,h  BC f ¬ h6 $%6 B< H A$%6 !m Tm Q+ BC   %«
h E  A$ N+ h6 A% &QC h E jlt 2>H B': B2$%m Y&€+ I J X
88
" ‰+
BH ;$% ~ <?6 hjC &w Š0  :~ h  œm ( C
 Q+ 89 , MH  :~ &S kN !m Y2 T +&Q  .
M*  &C T x +&Q Q+ MH ,~ 7* f:S . 7Q) t&2
,ˆH Y ' &S . M*  <l &S h6 >? , :~ &S H2 7*
Y '  :~ &S 90"  t  : &S M*  h  <l+ T 4C
 † E%jC <' H2 * Q+~ n 2% œm ] ~ ;$%m ° BC &S+
"h  M5<l+
& S, !m  Q+ -  :~ &S `4+ x '52
,$ :
 \'C B< k:w œm .&:+ k ' T&C <' ! 
V W &S *6 " \' $ :
 x! `4 ;$% B+& UH2
, Q+ n 2% g% h E # ÄN: H& 6  5 x! A% 5 C
\* +&4< R Z T —  C Q+~ Ap #:' 7E Y  <l* >? MH
œm .&:+  ' hjC BQ< 6 B< :w C %«  H2 &* 7
" C! E B< :w
 :~ &S . Š0 g D , BC $S #:' 7E H
 Bj[ 7*  Q< A&:
6 * hjC <'+ !  h6 35v <E `4+ #
'5l ,µ C :*J '5l* ,"  D MH
%$ : Y '  :~ h  cš" : #$% &'
− 88
"42 V ,2020 œ J
"43 V :  iN − 89
"627 V ,`C
* ," U C' h  cš - +&^  :~ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m − 90

47
#$% &'
"!       
  

HC #° g D , `4+ . 91">tJ ” %Ž `4<+ h6 L


= * µ 1: ;š 5QC  !  h+ hjC ;$% <' B+°:
92
"x! `s œm B2$%m Bw2 h6 #$  7E
B2T , } É .  h6 X &Ej  A\ 6 AE! `5
 '52
g
*6 ,Y ' k :~ &S ;% ˆH €+ :' B:E% h6 +&Q Q+
  -  N* MH V W  :~ &S X R&+ # :
g D U 5l  ' &: E6 1C : LD
* x! ,93 
" Q+ - #:' 7E VS€C
>? )/   1, " 
 M3CN : :
7* &+&' - Š0 g D .! A\ 6   U D * * w
H2 $wQC MH* `, - Y2  Q+ h6 X &Ej œm B2%
+ I ,;$% <' B+°:'C Y '  :~ &S - Q #:' 7E
: - B5?% !   g
- Q V W  :~ &S H2 ;% ŽC
"A% 5  6   š 'Q
7*
Q+ - <l+ T h " h6 µ C C &C Q4 U   &H
!  P k* `4+ # Y ' &S H2 N+ C  t &S 
  n   J $  3 E  †6 I . < :QD %*J
qC : [  U% 5 3 E !m  N* <' . ,A% , 6 B, -
* . 94 "" : *\
7 ±&4< = h+ \H &S . `s k* """

+ [ f<* ,2018/07/19 ©+% C 21062 $& 3s g D5 %& C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 91
: ¯C i+ H * X Q
 :4N X %1:* ,18/2902/86 $& ;š 5*
https://www.facebook.com/ritaje2014/notifications/
©+% C , &CT   ;& ,°* +%MQwC +$ ST l:e Q= 7 %$  , − 92
"%1:* >? ,2018 : 1099 $& D - 2018/08/30
"64 V ,2008 ,g D5 %& ,;&+&~ c w: '5l* ," g D Y *6 H 4S " :Ã+: /+/' &5 − 93
,08/68 % ;š 5* + [ f<* - ,2009/03/13 ©+% C µ C C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 94
"75 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:*

48
#$% &'
"!       
  

X :+ Y+   `, - : [ U% 5 P h6 U   Q4 h6 :'+


hm BC  +   % 5  š iQ+ AP:C Y  * hjC !  <
" 44 h E
7E C $S hjC U   &H g D5 %& C &C Q4 *6
* hjC <'+ !  h6 35v <E `4+ #  :~ &S . #:'
Bm , ">tJ ” %Ž `4<+ h6 L  Bj[ 7*  Q< A&:
6
. ,1Q< B* q ' P:C Y  K:‰ h6 K5+ R ^ Œ  œm ( C
ˆ
% ,¸ E   g Q< BD+'2 x! hj[ 7* h6 :+ <'+
95
"• ' :M Bl=
±&,6 -
* A ™ iN - A% &C %
&H #° g D *6
 -  :~ &S h6 % 5  X %
& #° ®: g D h6 B2%
:QD*  . U% 5  ½ N6 3 E k* H* '+  
,‹ ±&4+ I ^ h E !‡H 96"% 5  9* :< [$ t 6 K'* '
&S . h E 7 , Q+ - M &  :~ &S H2 7
.P  UT  7 \ ^ .$% 6   ;% 5 U! 7* $ N*
97
"N+ . h‡H B< :w `, - M
7* &+&' - B
E +° ®: Q= B< 3C6$ B .
3 E k* `4+    -  :~ &S " h6 ; '* q%
B< RT&
 œm  , T qC : [ B< :w œm M ½ NJ
X ! &S 7 ±&42 I . hm Q4 X T x! 7* EjC

:4N X %1:* 18/2902/86 % ;š 5* + [ f<* - 2018/07/19 ©+% C 21062 $& , − 95
https://www.facebook.com/ritaje2014/notifications/ : ¯5H * X Q

©+% C , &CT   ;& , C' °* +%MQwC +$ ST l:e Q= 7 %$  , − 96
"%1:* >? ,2018 : 1099 $& D - 2018/08/30

 " - <l &5 n ´m A$% 6 ,731 V h C QZ a 13 : 744 % 7'l − 97
"772 V ,`C
* ," U C' h  cš - +&^  :~

49
#$% &'
"!       
  

^ .M‰
  $ :
 \ 7* $ N+ &S . h6  e R\

98
"B<= >? - $&S . - : l k4:* h+ 2 7* 0
$jC
7E 6  :~ &S h6 X &Ej 7Q+ AE! `5
 $ :

- 12 : [ B< & ½ NJ 3 E k* Y+  Q+ - #:'
7 G  :0+ xH "B< :w 'Q
% 5  6 PC 9 * q! &,
* . ,B*& 7*  :~ &S H2 &QC R< t6 ‹ : - 45
A>‰ 6 Š0 g D e 7* g
− A\ 6 x! LD2 E − B+2 2
” `s  <
 - 45 7* G  N'+ T x! h6 >? "#°
" \'
>? )/G " F& q $+'N ' (  : ;E @%C
Y  .H2 YŒ\ µ P h E%J 7 R J <l - :v&s
SN* 1C  ' h $ Q2 7 ;%S hjC :+6% 7 , Q+
l52* 
 A. , Q+~ A. ” `42 h6 7Q+  
 f<€
7Q+ T B &C # :<' 7E% BC `4+ *  t µ P h E%J C
" Q+ $ 7 +&^
!  e 7* p'
 +  al f<’ 
 A” &S

 KC .% em - /Q 7Q+ ;>E . , Q+ N:
– e I mQ –
%& A. - >5E 1C :Qq  .  
mQ – ;>tJ U: - M›6 3'2 &  
\ 

– E

 " : . #&Z kNlS* A$% 6 ,1998/03/05 < a 60 : 13874 % 7'l − 98
"88 V ,2019 œ J '5l ,;.  +Œ P:< $Q= %$ ," n!  Ç\5 

50
#$% &'
"!       
  

)/G ?QN " E/12  <= (  Pr&' : e I mQ


>?
h <l* :* +P5 ; ^ B2&M[ # : %l $6 &
Y\  R S2 
- :2 ;%v ±&,m œm 7+P' &,
7* > 7 k:0
 , ,h  ; , - @' µ6 7* &+&' U>?
7* +&^ : B*& * g% a   - +&< al
"g$J - F X Y2  -  E  'H p 

Q+ N:C \ R ^ '5lC p  − 
 A. ŒC6 7* '
M
6% X    * &w − M
%$ $&SC 74  
– : – A>? 7 ›6 + T # n 2 `5l2 – 6  – ¯C i+ N
NSC % 5t *<' %$ S* &,6 12 3456    
− &- – ]  &+  >t6 v – E: – *
s- c/ 4r'G= (D' H  Y4 >? : 6 
i+ H    *  ()QC e , 6 7*
St R Z A% 5 C ¯C i+ N ;%lt ŒCm X Q' 
,¯C
 D U 5l ®'5 x! &'C  ' v – 1 –   n 2%T
– 2 – ¯C i+ N X  Q+~
>? # G nN6 @,0 Pt s- c/Q H  − 1
K*&€ 7Q+   2 * BjC ¯C iN f+'2 7Q+
>* tª = #6 6 % 5tJ ˆC % ,U <' P ,%S E% 1* 7*
* '+ xC . ,š 5 +&N C , [$%& 7* M:rQ+d E ,Y.¸
* Y&€
 7Q+ "3J X  5'[ EJ   U 51
 œm Rt& `+e 7 x! ,3m LNS* #6 R\t 7* ¯5N
V W `5l Qs 6 ,Y&€ C V t n , LH ¯5N< Q


51
#$% &'
"!       
  

:* ¯C iN * L56 & " ,< ;/MJ , Q4 f2p X BC
13 Q 7* \l 7+‹  MH 7QC V €[J Q~  H* 2006 :

T/':* ¯C i+ N X 4N x<Q+ T 7* L56 x! 7* E6 C 99 " :

U 5vm 6 7* U 4N g 1m œm $HJ 7* > &Q'+ x ,I ' 7


U 5[ X & L5jH ,7+tu 7 f<€ @QM :™ $
100
" < ^ U%l * Ï % em - ;% « ¯C i+ N
.E6    * .6 7*  . L56 &
M%ª 7 >5'< V €[¤  * L+ . 101, a\e X T'

Q~ `+e 7 6 %S ) 6 P: C  Š<
6 R\t 7* +4C
Q~ ¯C iN LQ+ 102"š 5* 1C &N C :2 R\t 7* M:C
 N U%1: = X (\e 7* 4NS C 7+& g &J
ME% 1* `+e 7 6 , MH #6 g&Cm C  C `<' `+e 7 g
M'*
;% « k &
 >5' +,
% 5St g DH B<' _ ,>0 *
" 5Q< B Dtm
Be1+ # \' °: `¢ ” /Q+  ¡ SW A” .
Y  h6   # Š0 g D A&E6 * . , Q+ Y  (P
. BN BQ
C 1Q< :<'   U% 5 $ :
‡C K:‰

https://mawdoo3.com/%D9%85%D8%A7_ : ]   C %1:* R * : %&S − 99


* -
%$ :      S2 N… " :#&' 
 fS &+b* − 100
"159 V ,2016 ,/~ ` v< N6 P ,"¯5N
. 7* < 7* C  7* Y&€ n+ *&:'H , A. X h *$m S, B6 %$ œm − 101
" B: •€ 'S 7* '™ ;&+& % H6 H )m 6 7* B< KQ  UT = M‰2 `5l
, C' H 4S  E P ," GHT I ' ¯C iN n 5[ " : – &5 &Q= • %
" .&'C * 49 V ,°*
: h +% &
&Q= X (\e k+ ¯C i+ N Y&€
 +/* R, U *<' 7* &+/Q< − 102
" .&'C * 18 V , +%MQ~ n E ," +° ;% ¯5N"

52
#$% &'
"!       
  

% , œm #$b2 h6 †j[ 7* , q5v R , - n '< 5* :1* '


QC P: xC Y  B6 Bl= ˆ
B*C i B< :w
103
" :<' °: ” `4+ 
. ¯C iN   
= I ' ( C f<’ -    * 3456 &H .
3 E M* 5 A. h6 >? ,R & , q&, %$ f<È 5* K:2
+, . T6 ,h  a, g$ 5* 7* O
6 6&5QC Y&lS2 MH q&,
U 5[ MH C 3J Ug DH E R ^ '5lC Q1 &Q+ # ,>5'
%&6 &H ,U 51 A. X >5' +, ›J ‰ "  
+, - `^ X &Eb+ 2012 Œ+ 5 ©+% C % h  a, i<Z
104
"   * f<’ X 3J X >5'
7* 25 SN QC QD* +^ A. '2 n0 -
q  ,P: H 4S +^ Q‰: K iN MQs ,105%
&
,]  Y\  ,#°5 'Q Y\  ,n Y\  UT Z
QC M< ) N $< +^ A. $ &^ %Q
C  '2 .
 * 3J X >5' +, D+6 Q12 $ A. ,h 
g DN ‰:C  t K ;& ¯ :. x! œm H ) C " 
) t >? +)H g DH i 3J R Z h6 :'+ _ 106,] 

f<* - 2018/07/19 ©+% C 21062 $& 3s g D5 %& C &CT Q4 7 %$  , −103
: ¯5H * X Q
 :4N X %1:* ,18/2902/86 $& ;š 5* + [
https://www.facebook.com/ritaje2014/notifications/
: ;&4 *J C h  a, i<w ]   : %&S − 104
https://www.ohchr.org/AR/HRBodies
P: (&C +, " p [6 C N* >5' #6 N +, h6 X SN . ¡:+ − 105
" QD* : Q<' 45 :N Š$J (&C UT Z -  '
:. K ;&'C   Q+~ R Z Š0 (P ‰ , − 106
== :MC&)% u & #v 8A- PF0=- $%&' 03 − 07 #  

53
#$% &'
"!       
  

' , +p #$&= >? hMZ †6 BH h 45 '1+ h E hm ,h <
M'H&+ # . ,3¤ p'
 p M4:Q+  +^ C &/ .%'[
107
" +^ A. Y&€
 - f' œm
R & % em hŒ w2 h ª    * >5' +, hm
g DNC *= h  a, >5' +4H ,B2 St M:*  ,*J
. C *=    * h6 K, - ,, %S2 ,] m
KC `H 7Q+ fE cl+ x ,] m . * MQ´ T ,:2 :2
; 7*   B42  p\0
 &: f'2 R02 T œ J '“ C ,K:v
108
" 5 7* U\H ;%& ,% 1T
 +$ ' ; 4< \Q* $&* &'+ ,Y 1C GHT I ' H
I ' . * * ' g :v6 :C$ª :\t6 7* $w 05:+ T x , M1'
* - ¯[ 7* O
J  0 h6 x! "B2 * f<€QC GH
g%u   V €[J KC   N .   

‰ >C R\t   ~ 4H * R Z - '+P ÇN &


&” g  # = =
7* 11 − 607 SN œm 3 − 607 SN 7* RSH '2 X #¢ . ,U l'Q< u ~ '
"Š0  :~ h  QZ
: MC&)% ; <= P3'- $%&' 53 − 05 #  
>5 : %l * 
:2   ²C ²q X Š0 (P B\t 7* 7.% #
]  R$ 5< 

J :5< h  . ) & ,  ET U\* ' R Z -  (%Œ
YCm NE ,U  5 >N12 ,  m * $ X ;&' x<2 a% X ;%4 ` v $ '*
… ]   E   $'
:zfi H-C Mw MC& & _x BN? yfdI /r+- $%&' 09 − 08 #  
;$ N
T   U\* ' - Š0 x<M v +2 - ›  6 7* h  . g 
7eQ< S€1 U  5  W ; ^ +^ * . ;$6 1
,   ;% w +/* 7*
"Q $ ST U *<' :2 R Z - 7+QQ< <5 n0 '
 X %1:* R * ,">5' #6 +, $ &,    *" :Q+E • − 107
https://units.imamu.edu.sa/Conferences : ] 
" iN − 108

54
#$% &'
"!       
  

+ h6 R,J 7* R , #jC 7Q+ T , †j1C  N p$ 52 % HJ


!J `4<2   w U * qT   R$ 5 g DH œm B<+s
109
"   M*C P M4C iy 7+tu C
Bm R h ,P: + & 
7* ¯C iN % 5 H
” 1* <
L56 & B‡H ,'N< \' °: BH H+ Qw< c *
D+6 Y&€+ , +°^ < ' % 5tJ P - Y&€+d ,Y\ T 

7* ®'5 5 7* A&+™ 2 , ">M1   - >5E 1C
;& R\t 7* 7+tu C !J a ^m œm B<+s Š “  NT BQ
110
"¯C i+ H    * X xC LQ2 R 'H6

* 22  ;&, Q+~ †6 :'+ T MH  Q+


%$ $&SC :. :E !m − 109
\QH ,a%ŒJ g DN . 22 ;>lt  ¯ :. C ,¯C i+ H   
': C6 &Q^ &5 N< (&+m 7 :e 7*¤ * ' ++& 3:< 6 2020/03/17 ©+% C
 D eP< :e N B+™ #  D 45 N<t X +‰:
^ >C&2 3s
7QD+ +&H ˆ+š AP B5 ,l n .% + DC N< * ' C : šm 3s
"': C6" h6 Ç\5 - g  , "Y ' Y ‰: C >lt 9 * X #l:2 ~ 
j2 ‹ :
,#>.~ R S2 ˆ
   U 5[ X %1:* +&H ˆ+š - M…" & h E
R 'HJ 
j2 ‹ : 7QD2 , . f:' X D+s 7QD2 U ¢°C —&+ .
*Q' U l< $M i€52 BN2 7 \DH ,Y ' Y ‰: C >lt i* X #l:2 *m
""&w  %E g C 4H 
X B `<'2 - ,   * - BC , X AP +&H - R  & ': C6 h E
+&Q4 lC X J i<w X h E"  %E 9 >H % 1 7* &4< &  a\?m U $
B2 . E+ h6 *6 ,"""$ N QW % 7E *6 7 v&4+ h6 KQ
 >? g<' ,g<'<
"" 4DH A. &  7 ±&4 ,""" Mm 3N<+ T 7E *J
a\?m" C 2 ,&  `<?  &2  ,";%lW œm S+ I g C" h6 N< ©1 6%
:* %2 h6 , Q<' U 
b 7+& X   b ;%Π%4 ,B 5
T & 
""&w - ) N U<S
g<' ,n, %$ L56 ,B+m &'C NE B:+$ 7 &2% &  BH `<02 # &<5" h6  )6
A%&S* 7* W % ""N kQ* h+ kQ* n C - h<. * Y\ .   7+
https://www.yabiladi.ma/articles/ :]   C
h < C0 <w ," !Q ¯C iN : ] ~ *&t - B< :w " :&'<C 7C .C − 110
"303 V ,2017 : 5 – 4 $&' ,  :~ Y<'  :~

55
#$% &'
"!       
  

B< #F+ * h6 œm ;% [ 7* &C T  . 7 +&^ 5


:QC
2 * . # +2 * X D+6 #F+ hj1 . -
{
R
%‡C B*&€ LQ2  0S 7+ & *&t Y&+ +*6  
7+$0 n w m ¨ 6 &+02 ;$ m X RS^ †j[ 7* U&+02

% R
%m `+e 7 6 +2 * `+e 7 ;š 5* x! ,7+tu
h %l M*&+  U 5l 6 +%N v$ 4 *C 6 ;>S S
7Q+ ,Y&€ 4N - U +&4 x<2 M‰2 , "A>? ¯5H * z
Y&€ f<* ;% +Œ 6  M4N 7* ; š 5* qg g &¤
&+  `+e 7 U +&4 $ $ R 5
 7Q+ xE ,ŀ1
111
"] 
L+ BJ ,¡ SW 7* QZ - ¯C i+ H * B51+ MH x
7QH , :<' B'* `42 _ ,K'* %M} X U C     *m
"< <
E D+6 B*&€

s- c/Q H  \4 >? )/  
 M3C' {&- − 2
7 ;%$ S  D Y ,J ®'C R\t 7* l: A. R : 

X % e . - °:


n :e -  T  , <Q 7* N<’ E =
Q' C V W `4< - $% * X + ‚%  4 Y ,6 ±\v
" D
112
|^'-  1'-6 )+ T4 D # − 
MH g  ;š 5* + 1C Y&2 1 hE - ^ .   ¡€<2
 * U 4N LNS+ . 2018¨04¨26 ©+% C ÍH B6
7QD2 BC k1 e 7* ;%1:* C* :+ &C ¯C iN  
- A&) ,& U< \ >? ½ NJ E """ n! E t $ :
m

https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/ : %&S − 111


"%1:* >? 2018/12 % ;š 5* + [ f<* - 2018/08/06 ©+% C − 112

56
#$% &'
"!       
  

+% :
B<E . ,f') a&C Bm ,BQ¢ &,6 T" : M:* BN… - BS€[
g% Q¢ R& E6 Bm """ 7*Œ :* %w* Y% Bm "‰ 6 Nt * B+Q<
Bm ,B45[ $ N ? l &) &4: ,Bv$ = &+%6 *&:
^ ‹ :
 Q+ h6  '* """ "B+/: >? g :? 4 (%  $ N /*%
ŀ1 A% 5  BHPC 3* & BC k1 M52%  :<' 
h6 kN1 7 R bQE BNSC A%'1C 9  B .m M: 
3522 <SC 4< 3y T  B, - BC k1 .P  +! EJ
"B N +$ * %«6 M:
n , X H+ B6 Q4 ². Y *6 B* &: BC k1 &E6 &
H U <' B< 3) ¯C iN    4N X
"4S $ N C% = . M:* BH&. h6 M5,  . B6 &EjH + 1 C
R\t 7* q C\* D  ‰ M
%$ &'C Q4Q< K52 &
 ¯C iN    * X P * """ M* *6 ƒ% *
QZ ME% [  ,A\ 6 Bm >[6 * 5 7* U% 5' 7* QZ M:Q)
 5 ” V W ¯C iN    U 4N X $HJ 7*
h/* >? h m Bm " U% 5 E " M< `<'2 299 œm H )m 267 .$&
h6 $ N< &C T ,gTb. * 4:2   ,B<* K b 7* A & *
Y  7* . B6 BC k1 †j1C &E6  """"F:2 h6 H< )%6 Ll5:+
*‰: œm M* †6 ¯C iN 4N X BC 4C .P MC C
h6 Q4Q< K52 , """ ]& `^ C  l œm E E 4S
& ]& `^ C  l œm M BC k1 7 ;%$ S A\ 6 U% 5'
R& $Z BC B* q 5 7*  :<'  &N2 U% 5 3:QD2
,h/* >? h m BE ,f') a&C $Z B6 ,
^ ‹ : g% Q¢
B*  ,  W B5<= kN1 h6 ,$ N H * ‹ : KC 7* '+ B6
9
MwC 4S H * KC 7* B6 ,q%  X g\
¸ g N'D Œ/C C

57
#$% &'
"!       
  

M< <e  U% 5' . "$ N< /*% B6 ,&
H ? e B6 ,
*
 &C6 ¯C iN X BC k1 4NS K'5 V €[J 7* &+&'
:<' p xC 34H , M< `<' C M:* &+&' Y  ” ” w m
,88"13 % P: H 4S h  7* B<+ * 83 SN - M< VS:
š 3*  "B $ 4 X $ #6 BC k1Q< h+ h6 >? 7*
+&QE +% 5  BN E ŀ1 ]& `^ C  l 'Q
% 5 
:<'  4:~ :+ ‹ :' B, - 1+ * . """ kN1
x! 6 7* B2tbQC QS ( : Q4 B'* 3': """ 
""   x! X B5 '*
A. - M h6 ^ . U ,   R\t 7* L) . E
U% 5 B ¯5N X B4N ˆ , B<* J h :' `<e6 & Œ :
h6 †j[ 7* C ,A% 5  BHš B*E iy h6 †j[ 7* BC k1Q< : [
% ' H  B C &N2 U% 5 3:QD2 †J ,34 hm BC  œm #$b2
B B E ,n ' 2  M<E . Œ/C !N: R\0

} 3s & "h/* >? ,a&C ,R 5 7* * 7* ˆs U% 5 D+6
(\e R\t 7* `s # :<' °: x! - C  Q+ ‹ :
x "V €[J 7* >5E $& e 7* ME% 1* :+ & A. X
7 4 # ,M $‡C 3D *&: n X 3 E Q4 H
'Q
7* : 6 7*    * 0
 nS `+l
h  7 Y 2 4 - , S€[ U C , NS2 ,B< :w š
"B2 D Y, Y&
113
/5X-  1'-6 )+ T4 D # − n
©+% C ;š 5* + 1C 1 Y&2 ^ . ()* Œ : % em -
Y<' <C — ' <'< ! 
6 BNSC B6 p\t 7*  '+ 2018/02/23

"%1:* >? 2018/11/27 ,2018/08/06 ©+% C 1090 $& , −113

58
#$% &'
"!       
  


 ?&5 `: +$ E6 .Π7C   +$ S  
# BC k1 e 7*   7* C  '2 & < A” """
B6 $ N C B* qT h :' `<l YQ'< ,N E5N B4N 0

" ;% 5' A” BC\e B .6 K, 5S C BN E B S²
 K'+ h eË
.Π7C '* wC a^ <C """ 
* - i ~ f g D @<2
R % 7* h ‰:2 ! * " B R\t 7* *J C BN E ""h 5S M
%&
>S* i²C ;&
H 
* &.[  6 7* K*¤ h'D¬ :, g D
B2\.b*  % '  m iy   J A. h6  '* ""n0 C R&'
h < 5e U 5v 2 '*  ! 
jE #% 5  B') Q<'
U :+ &2 U C* l
C H 5
'2 †6 " M:  b < e 3s
"  m
p 35v Q4 e 7* M1 :* U < ;&'C D ƒ%$m &'C
P:C Y  BC k1 h6  D  N e 7* /w: Ž4 7*
iy  U% 5' . A\ 6 Mm % 1 Ž4 C :QD U :+ &
- Mm % 1 *Q' U 
b V €[¤  Y, P C
"U 5vm h &C Mm M5 44 >?   k $ U :+ & x<2
51 `+e 7 3 E   A. 5 h6 Q4 U  
A. h2 —  C YQ' B - ,N < <
 . 25:'
@<2 ":   C  P  BC k1 h6 " :< 3M & U% 5'
M
%& .Π7C '* wC a^ <C """ 
* - i ~ f g D
¡€[ . M:* $S X ' 7Q+ ;% 5' A. h‡H ,"h 5S
SN . ‹ : h2 xC , < C '*  ! 
jE Q'+ # 1
iN 7* 85 SN< 5e M<6 7* B2tb* K'+ BC k1 X `5l:2
"h 
. M h‡H ^ .   U , R\t 7* LD2 E h!m
B<5 h  Y, X , E6 h+ h6 BH   N '*  ! 
6

59
#$% &'
"!       
  

.>? * M:C H ;2


J \ $+ h6 “ # a\tJ a *
7+tª V €[6 B<*Œ `, - 2% ;>lt U T/ -  & , D+6
3s + B<' _ ".% 5  MHš M'Q
7* R :2 , 

Bm  * 6 7* B2tbQC Q4 3D ,  :~ g  < e
,¦.%$ f6 hv\v¥ .%$ 30"000"00 .%& ;H  *0C B< 3Q,
f6  *¥ .%$ 100"000"00 A%& &* D+'2 ]& `^ C  lQ< B$jC
"k$J - % 5  S * ¦.%$
114
.~-  1'-6 )+ T4 D # – }
KN…* `, - KM   Q+wC `<'2 Œ  NH
- M'  ¡<€2 , f
wC &C Q4 X 3<,6 K*Q
f
  " h: 3s R * P:C 2019 9% * 26 ©+% C Y  M hE
 * X  W B4N " ;$% n/, Îs ³N
±&,J 32 " R  . - g  * 7Q) 7* B6 ,¯C i+ H  
hj1 >C&2 - 1H be ¯š - < * ˆ
*&'C % *
2 h6 &'C S UwN2 &H , :N'2 $$/2 B ,  Q+ < ,Q<
K5€: h  ¤ \ G%J 7* % . 1200 7* E6 +Œ2
7QE ,( S X p ;jH * , M*&t X ' M Π+&. K b
l< 3Œ T 3 E """ <, 'lC B)+ R * X \Ne ?+
U N<* h  at ,7e . % *$ nt 5
. 5€: U : 
hQ:+ V €[6 M:* $ N
  g+ ;$ m C *Q' x< R\,
h 6 `<e6 *&'C , +$  MH … 7 ‰: °C t6 h&* n/,6 œm
'<+ h6 &++ # #$ s ]   """ [% U 26 C * h :' l<
,K5€: h  J 7* B2&5 < * M* - ¦"""¥ l5 % $

>? ,2019/2106/677 $& 4:~ f< - ,2019 :[ 28 ©+% C %$ S 2912 $& , − 114
"%1:*

60
#$% &'
"!       
  

. #$ s ]   \H """ $ N g 3s h D: + 7* 7+&N


h6 Tm kC6 R `1 7* . 7e C &5 . < * T ,:
""$ 5'
 <‰< E+
()* R  h6 x< E & Y *6 c‹ MQ< (
 &:
A= BQD* k:5+ B6 """ B4N X AP BC C Y  7* . + 1
R  P:C Y  # . B6 Q4 Y *6 B* &:  )6 ,\SN2 <}
"¯C i+ N X B2 :+ &2 &Eb+ B6 B:'C S€[ &S+ I B6 L) 6
. E  ' hjC Q4 3': Π: f< M
%$ &:
B'* K'+ M `, - C v P: H 4S h  7* 83 ;$  - ;$&=
" M<6 7* B2tb*
nAN $3CN Y4 >? : :
, E f2M< U S: $&'* = #%H 
2 `5l2 . n 2

 %S R
%m K*&€Q< 

J 
 œm H ) C 7Q+
A¹ : 2 2014+ H 19 - ,2009 Y i
j2 ˆ
 +&N 2S
Q* E>*6 %T $ % <* 19 Â<5QC U%& NSC ¯C iN * e 7*
115
"¯5H Eš - M
6 KC  & H&+ Â<5* KC
p¬  +/Q< ‰ >‰: l:* T 5m n 2 `5l2  &
*&€* h6 2017 + * - EP< #N: i 7< 6 , B<Q'
7* E6 hD+ ,I ' * X Y&€* % <* 1"2 7* E6 Â<C n 2
* 646 R$ '+ . ,`5l X Y+ E +&N U  * - $ h<* 340
`5l2 *&€* $& Â<C 2020 :
- 116"Y+ E +&N U  * 7*

https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki : +&5+  ' 


Q< ]   : %&S − 115
https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki : +&5+ * 7* ; * U *<' − 116

61
#$% &'
"!       
  

œm S2 I ' -   ˆ


S:* ] v L5S Y&€* #% <* n 2
117
"Πw .
US C < < . U  *m L+ `5l MH '} <' E
U } % em - eJ 7* QZ KC 6 KHe KC g
,;%S
  <
E h6 C " 0 p M<t +  U Qw l
C
`5l2 U 5<
7 Rg  :‡H ,U 5<
U C “m ” Tm p'
 +
?:<'   - B'
  *m &* 118 n 2
KC SW 7* % em - B'
 7Q+ n 2 h‡H Y<'* . H
;& KC 6 ,;%S US C 6 C E 6 2 v$ = ˆH KS€[
T œ J  ^ - B'
 h E !m "5< L 6 U QZ V €[6
R S2 X #F+ * B< #FH KS€[ KC %S= BJ \' BC `42
 tJ UT ^ - B‡H ,119 B< (\e C >0< 4Q+ I * N2 p
e 7* BC <'  *m $  `4+  } .  h+
"&, ¡€[ 7* E6

https://www.aljazeera.net/news/scienceandtechnology/2020/2/13 : %&S − 117


;6* \% 170 MHe6 M[6 3 R\t ;& ‰H = -  D  $ ?\C 75 7* E6 3'H% &H − 118
&) * ,6 U%& & "   U 5l2  1   MC
10 :e* &<wC , .ŒC6 7* ,¦n 2 ¥ `5l2 Œ/C  [ 
+ D - K&*
ƒ Œ &<wC , ,  $ 52 K26* &<wC , ,t6 :e* 
U5 U&<
170 QE = " : #  1 h & ";& 
% B<l* B5 ;&< 40 tª &< ,B<l* [
: ]   C %1:* R * "n 2 -   QMC ;6* \%
https://www.okaz.com.sa/local/na/1713048


 C   Q+ 7 /~  b " :] 51 , &5 a 4
m g * − 119
," U *<' :2  4H * h  hj1C 2012 : 5 % Y
Q< 5e  
C' U% *T '*  ,Y ' h  - >  %$ X RS^ R
T *&* , e6
"39 V ,2018 ,h  <E ,;&4

62
#$% &'
"!       
  

tª ¡€1  C U% 5 BC \* ¡€[ Y+ *&:'H


B+& S¢ Qw x< Q:* h E 7* } h‡H n 2 `5lC QZ
:wQ< 3M  E U% 5' x<2 hH ,  U% 5'C <'
Q+ Y  M5+  \' xC `4H ,9 : 7* $& Y *6 B<
"
nN M  <= H  $/g T4 >? : E:
,%MQw< * . *\ m U *&t Y&2    3456 &
X   al + A% 5 C ]  Y\  C f2 3456
Y\  a
- * :* S4C k‰¢ Y\  7* (: MH "3J M
6%
Q+ E B+&s A+l2 B m Ë Bm R M w x!
" +N +^ 7* E6 , QC
VJ ,;$&' ˆ
  2S U\w &'2
x '52 "+&^ ]  Y\  R [6 .6 ,3J Z&
x! ,5 Y\ m . ]  Y\  h6 &Eb2 Ušb E 3456
Y\  œm #&< 1 7* R4 œm f4S 7* > H$ *
E6 B6 ]  Y\  35v6 AQ 7* << U:
R\€H "] 
*\  <
 B6 , +&< f4S 7* %MQ~ œm R -  &
< . ;%& 35v6 !m ,%MQ~ *  N R Z - ;%v 3v&,6  ;&,
 - k, p \* ©+%  Y& h6 `5+ I < N2 $* +&2 X
120
"V €[J KC š 5
6 *<' œm h<S+ 456 9 : <?6 h6 hE - R$ “ &,6 \H
* E <Q< l'2 ;>tJ A. h6 ,    - W 7 h45+
W 7 `<' -  * B L2 †6 E ,O  3 - B: 45+

https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D8 : +&5+  ' Q<' 


Q< ]   − 120

63
#$% &'
"!       
  

 ,tJ Y\  
<?6 - ;$N ;/ . ,B'*  N
—&+ ,*\  ^ - \ H L56 m <* $Z ¡€1 &'+ I M<DNC
121
" MQ+&2 2  ;$  R, A>? *  N+ B%|C
l'2  ,    ” /Q2   W A. h6 >?
U C “m p 3 E hm , M'*  N U%1: X `<' - `^ <Q<
†‡H ,>5' #6 - M+, R'
T $HJ Y *6 R w LN2 , ;>E
:¢ I 7+ $HJ 7* &+&' BH w:+ & /:* x! C * - &'2
U%1: - .‰ M 7 >5' % em - h :+ +^ A. R\0

* . ,.% 5  MHPC i 6 ,$H¤  W ; ^ X g&  œm
BC cQ* . * UŒ ™  M%ª MN* 7  : g * = M<'“
"h  ‰ -  '2 R 'H6 œm
t$ .¹52 32 C   Q<    A. ›J ‰
X Q & , %  U '+P 7* A>0E Š0 (P h‡H ,*\  &M1
B:* 2 ;$  3S # 88"13 % h  QC  A. R\0
 ‰:2
+ Y ‰ C B:s #“ ,h  . U D D¬ %&m E " h6 X
YQ'< B* 4 ;%$ Y ‰   N4S C V t a l 
C
, p $&* 12  +&^ : U ª 3J 5[
1 :5 - $% f+'< 5e *&t #% 5  6 Æ! ¡€[ B\t 7* P:+
ˆW ¡€1 . +&+ ,   H 4S *&€C A&'C kQ2 ,A\ 6
"" N4 '5e U! :M* ~ '* `H   N4S< #+4
U 
b* 7Q) t&2 3456    H x '52
7* 33 ;$  , ,88"13 % h  7* 8 ;$  ÌQC P: H 4S

R S2 
" : * K, 4H :   H 4S R, U *<' 7* &+/Q< ‰ − 121
" .&'C * 81 V ,2011 œ J '5l ," ¯C iN œm ;&+~ 7* +&^

64
#$% &'
"!       
  

T B6 , QD* N*   H 4S U *&t +, h‡H h  .
h+  3J 5[ X YQ' *  U *&t % 5  Œ“
6 M<[ h E NE U \ m 6 +% M[m U\ +&2 O
J M)?
"  m N4 †QD*
Q+ n 2% . % e . - : )QC \ B * .6 '
:K<
C + h6 7Q+ x! ,    
; ]   P: -
; % / e 7* U <' -
†jC MN 7Q+ T 'H6 7QD2 ;$ * P:C ]   Y  !‡H
h '+ P: +&* R  2 E h‡H U ²p 6 V €[J `, - 
!m *6 "P: H 4S h  M:QD2  $ &^ - E x! 7 hT b*
,% / U <' ¡S€ g DN -  Q+~  R 'HJ Ug 
 b* ;% vm  *m * ,B<'2 B:QD2  T b* &'+ `<' ,  h‡H
"h  BC B*/<+ * ! È - ° & h E hm P: +&*
% / U <'2 e6 & A&w 88"13 % h  œm ( C B6 x!
N4S % Œ U <'2 DÈ " B6 X ¡:2  B:* 36 ;$  QC
&'+ = #6 P Y&'C P: +&* Y/<+ +^ 6&5 ˆC   
p ";g
 U5v  , - ˆC 6 `<' 4
* ,h < 5e Q+
•Q' S€1 U › Q< ¡S€ /^ - P: +&* D+  0
M5w, B< M2 P >? K* D 5 Q\* 
3J 5[
X ' tª ¡€[ E X M2 E ,\4* Mm ƒ '
"" M: % 5t ;%E K* D
h  h E !m B6 µ C C &C Q4 U   % e . -
*/<* h+ h6 h $ R * #6 P ®HC P: +& `^ kl 6 & H 4S

65
#$% &'
"!       
  

U% 5 P: 7QD2 * !m )N* B b* k52 C  - B‡H ,x! + C
B< 2 —  C ,YQ' œm    R S+‡C Y  7* B ,% ?J C iy
122
"P: X B*&m 5 µ , #4  b*
*  N<    - % /< cN g DN H B< g :C
eb* Bm C ,®'5 A&'+ E n 0 h  ³N< T Z i ,U%1:
&2 œm &q  5 3 , 5Q< D¬ h6 “ ,h  QC
cQ* .  +^ A. ƒ t Y& 5 H$ p x<2 m ,>5' +,
M:* ®'5 &“ % / U <' LNS H "7+tu +4C 9  Y& ,BC
f:' X ®+s 6 ,7+tu `, -  
6 ,ˆ
Y\E B<E
 '+  J - '2  R 'HJ 7* x! >? œm """ .
"h  M<
BH `42 h * .    C % / g DH hjC :< x
K'* ¡€1 : [ U% 5 B2 \* `<' 7QD2 !‡H , Q+
:' . ¡€1 . h E g
,A% 5  BHš 6 B*E iy h6 M:Q+
Q+~ h‡H ,A>? 6 ,#6 - B'* f<t % / 7* tª ¡€[ 6 ,R  C
X <l+ h6 Π 7Q+ %MQw< cN* g DN . hJ ,`42
" :<' BH `42 —  C ,U <' hQD*
BC k1 Y  h6 NSC &CT Q4 U   $&S . -
" ;% 5 7QD+ # """   ;&+~ - %1:* R * X `<'2 P:C
;% 5' C 1 C Q4 A. Y *6 BH  " n6 <E """ i+
¡€1 % 5  š iy  ;% 5' . ,]  * - ;%E
B'* h2 _ ,   ;&+~ C P: l
C 3y ,Bm 35 #

$& 4:~ f< - ,2014/03/12 ©+% C µ C C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 122
www.maroclaw.com : h  n0* <w ]   C %1:* ,2013/2102/1109

66
#$% &'
"!       
  

K'+ B, -   P: H 4S h C 'C  RSN :+ ‹ :'
123
" M<6 7* B2tb*
 n2 U: X D+6 a&S+    7  *
RS^ &” +&H e *   6 7* V €[6 e 7* Mv&,m +
AMH "  * c C%6 X x '52 RS^ ,U&. 1 7* 7_ $& E6 X
U: X P:2  U .N hJ :<' °: ” `4+ D+6 :
¡€[ `, - H M:* D* 3:QD2 !m ,%MQ~ X M) + n2
"A\ 6 MlC `5
 Y ,J iN M< #F2 †‡H K'*
; <= 1/Y C- >? : &-
R$ 52 3J Y&€ B5QC 7Q+ Y ‰ . ]  &+ 
, * ¡SÈ `+e 7 K*&€* QZ 6 tª Y&€* * 

 h+ 2 7* ]  &+ < SS’ h ” V W Y W X
BC  t : ¯1 l'+ ,BC  t  H , * $ / . * ¯1*
124
"7+tu *    
 R 5
 B+e 7 7Q+
A¹5+  ‰ tJ 
  C 7 ›6 + T ]  &+ 
[ EJ e € 0 L56 , ,3J *&€* &  * 7*
40 7* E6 h<+ ;‹ ' U‰: - h<* ' L56 & ,7. : -

 $& %&+ K, - ,M<Q U
g :v6 *+  m +&+C 
%
125
" +:

% % <* 110 —, 3J *&€* p &+   

>? ,17/2172 % 4:~ f< - 2018/10/01 ©+% C NSC &C Q4 7 %$  , − 123
"%1:*
,n
^ Y<' C' 5 ," 3J *&€ O
J  " : l' C6 &Q= #&Z − 124
"11 V ,2000 ,;. 
"140 V ,`C
* : #&' 
 fS &+b* − 125

67
#$% &'
"!       
  

]  &+  *&€E 3J 5[ X ,  U *&W ®'5H


h6 !m , SW C lC 2 ,U N<  *&t ,&'C 7 R S2 *&t
X (\e >0< Œ“ T MD'5 K*<'* KHe KC °4:+ :. R S2
t&2 †6 :'+ _ " 
 ,  H'QC Tm M:C $ 5 
 hQD*
+F ;%   +^ C Q2   W U\
 a l -
6 †QD* f1E 7 7+tu ;%& Y& N+ _ ,&'C 7 UT S2
M'y U\
 A. 7 \' g N B< 2+ * . , M< (\e
126
" SW C lC
&+   Q+ `s &* R, R¹  % + x
h E%6 B'* `42 . &+  .  2 !m . k:'QC ? ] 
? T Y6 4:~
]  &+  2    hjC ®'5 + :.
7E% hJ `42 T ¦U 1¥ % 4 6 v$ 4 `+e 7 6 ¡€1<
T , ]  &+  ” Q+  S€< ‰ ,H* >? \'
"127 B5,  >? B< <l+
T  ]  &+  ” /Q+  ¡ SW … - B6 
- µš .6 h‡H ,B< (\e C n ^ ,  >0 6&5 , 7* LQ2
- Q+~ `42 h6 7Q+ T —  C ,$N* ‰+ :<' .  4:
V €[6 M< <e &  U% 5 h6   35v6 !m & * "BC ?
A   * X
 x! ,B: 3'H% & +F h6 
 >? h tª
"&, ¡€[ 7* E6 M< <e  +$ ' U\
 - H g D

,a^ 
% <Z ," 3J `+e 7   Q+ " :* w^ . e >Q
Y 6 − 126
"341 V ,2015 : ,]  $&' , 'C  : ,g\CE
"108 ,`C
* :N<W – &5 7C 7£ &5 − 127

68
#$% &'
"!       
  

&'C Q4Q< 3C  h E  " B6 #° g D   % e . NH
h& - 
 &H U5 $jC MH ‰C 3e ,6  & 3S= h6
:w Ç\5C $% * X 
j2 :+ 25v M 5 Y q U5v Q4
V W ]  &+  X   
 7* QZ $ 7* M<
* X M, - Y ' g ^ Î&È  
U% 5 7QD2 M C
X 
 A. )C Y  # . M h6 U% """   
128
"":N ¡4N +2 A&E6 * . ,BC V W H 

 <?6 h6 `5
* R\t 7* B‰,\* 7Q+ * .6 hm
E ,  n 2%T 5St T Z 3456 & <  
- \ 7* Bs  ,R'
 - M
7* AH2  ‰: C M< R 5
+&< 
 R'
 5 x! C * 3'2 , ,/ & 3
""" f2 p C  R E H '
>? )/G ?QN " F (  Pr&' : E mQ
, +&^    
q652    7* ? X
,
7* M5
* 0<2 T ;&+& *\ m <
#6 ;j1 h6 &Eb 7* B‡H
US KC Q™ 5+? :2 ;%v 7* B:, - B<[ C Œ N< %M‰H
x ". :*+ œm A%M} B RŒ T # ( + 0<+ h6 l+ I ;%S
7* > SÈ h6 M:Q+ v&4 Y\  
E hjC R 7Q+
h6 kCj+ -
Ñ %M} p k5
M0<2 7 
M: Q+& al %M}
;% «
%& A. % em - % x " +&^ : I - µ€:+
- al 
" Q+ `s - +&< 
 % &  '
C  `+e 7  v – 6  – 'N 6 R  œm % e .
− E: – f2 p  >t6 – : –

,`C
* : <t .C 7, A$% 6 ,1997/10/28 < a 63 : 2250 % 7'l − 128
"86 V

69
#$% &'
"!       
  

(&Q  P $/g T4 >? :6 


l
C R C 22  Q+ †6  Q+ - J
6 š iy †m 4C , Q+w< #$  7E hd2 , M< R&2 U% 5
"BC  2 h6 34  †j[ 7* h+ ,  'Q
6 % 5 
š iy U% 5'C ­N< `+e 7  Q+ %S2 7Q+ .
h &C 6 ,E6 6 tª ¡€[ %D4C \* Y ' (% 1 - A% 5  6  
7Q 7* N2* USC 3 E  U% 5 7 tª ¡€[ #6 %D,
";%  * * œm S+ h6
C' 0< C h+ h6 LSH :'* 0<C h+ h6 R - µ1+ T
2 # ˆ4 - M< ' 7Q+  U wM< U 0< 7* .>0C 6
¢‹  hH , :Q) 6 ¢‹ h+ &  h6 E , BH
,:Q)  6 ®+'2 6 + :E MH A>? Q, !m *6 "A>? Q¢ T :,
3<' x Œ 34DH ;6*T R  7* ,L+‹ C g  ]Œ + R  7QH
129
" + : 6 ®+' `+e 7 C g  B[H U&H6   B
Q+ h6 X &Ej 7* &C T B‡H A\ 6 AE! `5
* E X g :C
6 ¡€1 PC iQ+ 7 [ Q 5:C Tm Y2 T $HJ œm B 
lW l
C R 
T 
 7* <
#6 `+e 7 x! B*,
“ " *Q' U  7E *J - ” AN U&+&M 6 c S 6
H2 &*  - <Q' ½ NJ MQ, - Œ 2 h6 () Q= X
"®:< MQ,  '2 < e 3s MH \' µš
&C ^ E BH h'l % h6 ®: Q= U   &H
&)  4: n 2% C Y  7 l h6 M:* E Π+ I &5* BC &+b
BC Y  * h6 Œ + I B6 E , Nª Mm % 1 
 &,‡C ]& `^ C  l

"465 V ,`C
* : ;$ %$  &5 − 129

70
#$% &'
"!       
  

X .% :52 I Q4 B'* h2 _ 4D ¡€[ 6 PC iQ+ M
.% h+ H E \<'2 BC 3D * <'2 I h  7* L4 9
6
130
"R lC ®:< )'*
h6 %S x! * B‡H ,  †6  Q+ - J h E !m
6 g ¢ [ tj+ , ,U E^ l
C 'N `+e 7  2+d
Y6 C “m 'N h+ h6 #+ , * \'H x! h+ h6 X ,;% [
7* :—  Rb 9 : 7* } œm ¡€[ B+ h6 \* x! 7* " 5<

;% [m 7+« ^ 7* ¡€[ œm .&,6 >1H ? A. + / Q+ 2%


&'2  ^ A. - " + / Q+ 2* . Bm % 1 h6 M:* MN+
131
" Q+ ” Y2 ¡€1 x! œm + / ' $ :
m ;% [
34H ;% [ `+e 7 !  'H * >0 R6 UH ‰2 & hH
" Q+~
7 US R'
C D+6 `4+ &  H 'N R 7 \DH
3s !m x! ,;% U 6 ,Æ wC g
,w `+e
U 5vm µš H+ h6 ,9 : 7* $& KC B &2 6 AP 2 hjC BH \'
NSC R 7 !  :0+ & "ÆS w - B5, S US
" :<' `s - M
7* AH2  % 5  C  œm jw<+ *
-' $/g T4 >? : :
4:~ #$  7E `s 
6 , 7* 'H%  * C  652
 ‰ ,R 7* ›6 E6 3456 & †jC Y/~ 7Q+ 4C ,
3 - >5E 1C \' °: `s X ;>5E ;%& 7*  - A&™

g D <wQC %1:* ,69833 $&  : f<* ,1981 Œ+ 09 ©+% C 973 $& ®: Q= % − 130
"185 V 34 – 33 $&' ,2000 :$ Q %& ,X J i<w
Š' /E U%1:* ," % *
%$ : N4S &: a l -  " : h<
Q h+* − 131
"214 V ,2014 œ J '5l ,   U%&¸

71
#$% &'
"!       
  

9 : 7* $ &= $& KC %S= Av6 k5+ # R \t X ,O 


" '  Ž, 7+
%<52 h6 7Q+  ;$&' ˆ
 DNC ›J A” k‰s C 
7 ;% 5 U C* [ €+ # p 
\ 1 7 \DNH , MH
h *6 - M<'2 + U S<* 6 , :'* U M~ M* + [ 6 U\
*
!m P: *J <
 &'2 C  H " M< (\e 7* %MQ~ 7y
a l X \' xC `s . ,Y\  H 4S 

"& 

v , C  `+e 7  4:~ #$  7E Y  %S x
,;&+ h2 &  , ,  tJ 
 &,‡C \' µš `s
`4+ < #$  7E H "©m """ U S<* ,U%1:* ,  m N4
7 ,Bm .$ :
m   % 5  6 PC iy U% 5 C E $wQC
+ 7QE ,µP . n ? - " \' µš `4C Tm Y2 T Q+~
… - Bm MM+ 6 ,BN: ” ­N¢ tª ¡€1 M*  U% 5
" Q+ Y2 T ,BHe 7* Tm B4H + T `<0*
C  X ¡S: A ™ - %  U '+P <?6 U%
&
7* 3¨19 ;$  \* x! 7*  Q+ - \' 
7* <
E

7* <
\' C  U    ' U C' h 
0<C h &* . * E C  C $+" pC C  C $S U$&, ,
g
, 5l C 6 & ˆ€C 3 E g
, C  +e 3 E +6 MQMH 7Q+
œm M QZ - #$b2 ,;6/Z  , 6 } - U<E ;% - C  3 E
M[6 H 4S y ""N R m ‰: h '*m &'C 6 ;* R J MN+ k:'*
132
" C  \ U $6

"217 V ,`C
* : h<
Q h+* − 132

72
#$% &'
"!       
  

`4  'N <


 . C  hjC R 7Q+ `5
 &Ej2
>? 6 P:< B* R * 7 ;% 5 C  A. h2 h6 #+ ,
X %MQ~ 7* >5E $& (\e <l+ T C  - :<' `s hJ ,x!
h E !m *6 ,$ &= $&' , * (\e . h+ h6 N+ C ,BQD*
"`42 T \' h‡H x! \t
7E% H N+ B6 +° ®: Q= U   x 5l2
7* $& œm n S+ h6 *Q f…* `, -  Q+ - \'
Q' Q, w x! h E k* ;&, € R &C \< h E  9 :
133
" M<M“ h6 %S+ T ! 
+&C M Y  h6   , ®:C C0 ®: Q= 3*  E
, ,B, -  .m '2  U% 5 M:QD2 `4<    &) + [
  œm Œ 4 &' 7 4 BD -  \2 BjC M BN
h6  '* "B*St * A&) llt C$ B6 2 (eJ w B*St
G  & &)  .m :< [ 5
7QD2 M 7* *& + 1
#6 Œ 2 I () Q= h6 U   M5'2 - ®: Q= h6 >? "`4
tb   Q+~ 5: C :<' ” 3s  +l M:*
% B'* h+ _  . B 3M 7* %'[ 6 PC 9  &S ”
®:< B)'+ h < #.~ aW 'C C1* BH h'l
134
"R lC
,5<  ' 6 +Œ 6  ' C C  - \' `42
7* $& E6 KQ C  Qs  ;$  `<'2 6 % M…m BC &S+  ' H
œm C  Qs  ;$  <2 :'H +Œ *6 , M< (\e 7* 9 :
&5 n ´m A$% 6 ,734 V ,h C QZ ,1955/03/21 < ,a 25 : 36 % 7'l − 133
"355 V ,`C
* ,"+ g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
" : •l
$& 4:~ f< - ,1994/05/19 ©+% C ,4553 $& 3s ®: Q= 7 %$  % − 134
V ,52 $&' ,2000 :$ Q %& – X J i<w g D <wQC %1:* ,92/22071
"266

73
#$% &'
"!       
  

E 7+tª V €[6 œm M 7* qŒ ,  + , ,¡€[ 7* E6


- C  ce :'+ MH 5<  ' *6 135" C E 7* B<Qs * X '<l+
Mš h $ 6 .¹š 2 !m \' `42 , &++ 7* ´1 a
¡€[ 7* E6 e 7* + h6 “ (\e . h6 >? , M< (\e &'C
" - \' `s 
.6 7* A% 5 C P: `¢ * . "&,
# %4 C '5+ 7* h6 :, w &Q= %E& + x '52
h6 œm BQ< 35v ,— S:* ! ¡€[ œm  U% 5 BH h $
R, ¯ :. B5* N…* M< <l+ ¡€1 . œm 
2  a% J
Bm 
 Y\ m œm Mw* 3 E B2$%m 7 ,hN4S ” <'+ hjC #
w* `<0* … - %4 )C B2$%m 7 & ,  C A&,

 
M< <l+ T h6 A¹ %  W MN 
 +Ë B<
<e H &++ h E * >? `s  ,H* &'+ T  :~ &S h‡H ,Bm
HC Tm `42 T  Q+ - \' h6 % H 136"%4 X h tu
>0C 9 : 7* $& X  U% 5 :QD C  +Œ2 p 6 7+°:
137
"n* . * !m ] ~ g tJ ,/y
.N Y4 >? : E:
. # 3C  f2 p KC f2 p 7 +&^ % em - /Q 7Q+
7* $& KC ˆC+ Ä% * * ¯\
jC * R 5
 6 R
%m ΠM
3C v % C 02 % U* - 5E*  m  $ Y&€
C KE1
MZC +  N2 p µlW C '+ *  & A. &2 ,3H 48 A%&*

" .&'C * 218 V ,`C


* : h<
Q h+* − 135
"743 V ,`C
* ," V W  : U C' h  cš " ::, w $Q= − 136
C QZ ,2003/01/22 < ,a 63 : 23787 % 7'l , +° ®: Q= % − 137
," + g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m A$% 6 ,734 V ,h
"358 V ,`C
*

74
#$% &'
"!       
  

R\t 7* M:C H R S2 7* M:y MD'C 7 KE1 /y Y %jC


KC "f2 p 
B'H% &: ¯1* E M'Q+  R S2 Q0 &2
CC! U% [m `+e 7 R
%m R 5
 ;$ X &Q'+ # R : f2 p
`+e 7 R S2 +e h2 , ,  DH 6 )%6 R
%m U l=
EP C V W Ä @+ ŀ1 RQ4 - 7Q2 <* * ;$
$ & ;>0 7+/È ;&, ” ;>0  lC . ¦  lC¥ ˆW
R S2\ B*&€+ # Y&€ U  C ” h/È ~ '* ;&,
138
"7+tu C
- H2 T +/* 7* R : f2 p B4+ H /Q . ›6 Œ 2
 H ,$HJ KC *&€
 % 1 EJ B<'  ,3C  f2 p
T ,J C 6 ,B:* 3C <¬ $ + T ,RQ= f2 . X H+ hu L56
E! f2. . hu f2p <?6 "RQ= f2 . h &C S€[ &w $ 

 C E - M*&€
 7Q+ , ,;%l* U *&t ” 4J RÈ
"A>? n 2 `5l2 M4+  +/  C R'
 6 , p
%m ;>S
 
 7* <
f2 p % 5   *m &* 7 R¹  cl+ .
? :<' ” `42
h6 : LD+ , Q+ Y  .H2 YŒ\ µ P œm ( C
BJ , \' . µš .J N+ f2 p + h6 7Q+ # 
h6 h E #J 7Q+ T , +F C Q= hH ,KHe KC 2   H &5*
" MHe6 7* t&2 h $ †QD* X <l+
Q+ ” `42  
 7Q) 7* f2 p $ '5
C R h6 >?
x! ,B\em X At6 05:+ T *6 . ,BC \' µš H2 Y&' ,
KC U   +Ë ­Ns h6 M:Q+   W <
 x<2 &'+ I f2 p h6

https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki : +&5+  ' Q<' 


 : %&S − 138

75
#$% &'
"!       
  

*&: x! ,f2 p l


C :<' `s  *m X &M1+  H , MHe
, ,US * 01C >tJ . YH ,tu C KHl &,6 S+
—  C ,M:C +&^  N2 Q+ h6 B:* n C 6 B'* h E 7 7Q+
\' `4H   `+e 7 B2   U% 5 BQ< œm S2
";
H2 E f2p <?6 h6 œm D+6 ;% [ %&™ x! 7 \DH
V €[J 7* > &Q'+ , ,   hQD* w2  *m X  ,
E% 1QC  ,6 h*H ,MN2 . 7* ;%$ S ;$% U   w2 œm
,7+tª V €[6 * w: 6 n 2 `5l2  Q< ÆS l
hQD* 7 7+tª V €[6 (\e `+e 7 \' `42 D+6 :.
7* E6 ( 7* 7y +&, U 5l2 ¯ :. x! 7* E6 C "  
"`<l* 1C :<' `42 :. ;&,  * - KS€[
l
C  a 5l C R U% 5  Ap ‰: C 7Q+ x
} 3 B6 % 5  X 3J `+e 7 ' ~ X f2 p
  ~ f2p %M… &'C  t , \ >? f2 p C 2  ~
139
" Q+ - (P M5<l+  \' H2  .>?
308 ;$  - ¡ # #° (P fQC % e . - &1
 '+ hN< `+lC A>?  7* E " B6 X U C' h  7* %*

& #° (P h+ xC "" 303 ;$  - M< VS: *0 C
 \' 
&,m `+e 7  hN< `+e 7  KC
" Mm % [6
&,m hN< % 5  :'+ T x! h6 $&S . - ®'5 +

m ,#Ë C e U! R S2\ <
B'5lC MH , \' 

"345 V ,`C
* :* w^ . e >Q
Y 6 − 139

76
#$% &'
"!       
  

;. … R 4N
T ‰ :<'  hN< `+e 7  KC (P
h6 œm † :²Qe N< U v$ 4 +FC 7+&' g, f2 p C 
°: BH H2 !m Tm $% C'C   X  '+ T h 
nŽ< 5' p &, ) (P t&2 x "H* >? . \'
140
"7+M #&+6 X
Y  X & U5v" h6 #° g D   U D Ap 5l2
h E œ J QM C K5 4: X hN< `+lC B< :w C M
œm B2$%m A ™ % 5  P< [&t 7QD2 
 x<2 hjC < X
141
""#:' #$  Q+~ :E% B'* `4+ # *J x!
%* 166 ;$  ¡: H f2 p ƒ Œ h6   t6 Œ  -
;$  C M~ & (P hJ   X °+ T U C' h  7*
142
"7e %& BC `D+ ] ~ A&Q'2 'H 6 R  + C ,%* 308
” 2% 7Q+  ~ (6 k[ 7* $H¤  E + £ x! -
"f2 p
,#:' #$  M:E% `4C `42  Q+ h6 R \t
x! hJ ,°:' . ” H2  <
 3 E M* , \' °: H2
>0+ T E Q+~ '5e 7* >0+ T (5l H , Q+~ f - vb+ T
g
  '5l iN B  H , Q+ '5e 9& 6 w:W

780 V ,`C
* ," U C' h  cš - +&^  :~ 
 " : <l &5 n ´m − 140
" .&'C *
D - ,2018/08/30 ©+% C , &CT   ;& , +$ ST l:e Q= 7 %$  , − 141
"%1:* >? ,2018 : 1099 $&
R * - h)% g\ ! A$% 6 ,1038 V 429 24/10/1991 < a 59 : 13707 % 7'l − 142
:]   C ," hN< `+e 7   C " : h: 3s 3J X %1:*
http://www.soutalomma.com/Article

77
#$% &'
"!       
  

\'< 5: C B6 E 143"tJ \' 


6 C  `+e 7 2%

 x ,R  5
X $% m \'< 
7* AE! 2 * h‡H
M< ¡  UT ^ >? - \' H2 V\€
 X #° g D
144
" :<' ;H ‹ : MH 3s !m h 
Me PC  Q+ Y  h6 œm 45 . R\t 7* ¡<€
Q+~ Ap  :~ % vu 22 B< 2+ ,A\ 6 M<SN2 2  † E%6
®+' - Xw2  & % vu E ,;% C' +/:2 - Q2 
"%Ž 7

'5l ,h ,+Œ P:< H  %$ ,"  :~  b -  N jlW" :p $ £ &Q= − 143
"259 V ,2005 œ J
," % * <<s
%$ : ;ËJ a l - ;6 &) f:'<  :~ ~ ' " : &Q= Y\
h\[ − 144
"180 V ,2018 ,œ J '5l ,+Œ P:< Š' /E

78
#$% &'
"!       
  

€ YG -& :;E l+3

45 + ,K'* ¡€[ e 7* *~ 'N n 2% U5v &'C
M Dtm , 7* ,2 'N ¡€1 . KC \' &+&s -
 b 22 6 7* ,B< 5 ' 'N< *w   VS:<
145
"'N 7  :~
 : Q4C Y/ †C  :~  b g MN  &
>C& 6 C' . B )* Q+~ h E%6 H2 X 52  
7 D+6 2+ E 146" Q+~ 7 R b C h  B/:+ # #Œ,
%«J 7 & B b* Y  K'* ¡€[ `, -  :~  b U5v
"%Ž   b* Q4+ B6 k:'QC , Q+~ MH 3552 
V €[J $&4 h6 &C T %Ž  C' 7 +&^ 5
7* 95 ;$  ¡ œm ( 5H " Q+ n 2% 7  : K b
B6 X ¡S: C , j A. - , & (P &w P: H 4S h 
`+e 7 52 R 'H¤ K<6 K< H .E! Æu V €[J '+
:—  2 , x! H 4S
; MN 6 M:M* 3 E NE P: +&* -1

; P:< h +&* ¯ :. 7+ I hm N4S ;$  n 46 -2

n 46 P: g%&* ¯ :. 7+ I hm U *&W *&* C l -3

; N4S ;$ 
; U *&W *&* ¯ :. 7+ I hm fD -4

"129 V ,`C
* : #$% &'
− 145
P:< H  %$  & Q<' %& ,"U C' h  - * ' Y ,J cš" : : &' * E − 146
"507 V ,2002 œ J '5l ,h ,+Œ

79
#$% &'
"!       
  

n 46 ¯ :. 7+ I hm a S C hN< h' 5 h Œ -5


"U *&W *&* C l
6 /* 6 
 6 ;%S 6 C  MH h2  R,J -
,ƒ% W - UP & Q+~ n 2% - 3<Q'
  tJ >5' ae
B'C * U%'2 6 Q+~ 2* H'* MH 7Q+ T  R,J } -
6 N4S ;$  ,  <6 \ H BNSC  '+ ,n 5
J 7* 5
>5' ae 6  m <
l
C 6 /* 6 ;%S 6 
 )
x! fD 6 U *&W *&* 6  5 6 (Œ 6 $% 6 ,tJ
";$  A. 7* œ J ;N - Mm % 1  b 522 4C
H\t ,+ I !m ,A\ 6 18 ;$  - M< VS: UT ^ -
 b* D+6 22 ,P:< &+& +&* K'2 ,h  . U D
"P:< +&* ¯ :. 7+ I hjE A\ 6 4 3 2 $:5 - Mm % 1 V €[J
 7  : K b V €[J $&, & (P h6 LD+ .
"M b* ;% vm - B 52 “ # 2 &C $&, ,
h‡H H 4S >? t6 
 Q+ n 2%T 5: C *6
 b &  5e S€[ NSC !  M<Q4+  :~  b
- <Q' <
 7 ‰: ®0C " :~ h  - ;$%  :~
 :~ U C' Qs M< 2+ B:  :~  b Y  h‡H 
wC <' &  b E – P I @%C –  Q+~ ;%
– ;E @%C – Q+~ BH 3552 # %Ž

80
#$% &'
"!       
  

>? )/G -4 : P I @%C

M<  '+ :<'  " h6 X ƒ a 7* 444 SN ¡:+


1958  15 `H* 1378 œ J $ } 3 - §%b 1.58.378 % >M‰< H

, 147 B* ,6 } 3€ # >M‰ . "" H 4S h  C QC '
"P: H 4S C `<' 88.13 % h  B<=
U C' hjC &w P: H 4S h  VS g
 R\t 7*
– e I mQ – U *0 7* O
6 1C h2  Q+ 7 ;%
^ P v , w, 6 (5l f2 - Q2 t6 U C 7*
RŒ T < t6 U C 7 \DH – E mQ – $ C G 
− EE mQ −  t UT 4C `<'2  :~ h  M:QD+
 : e I mQ
B< Y4 Y/m " †jC *0  :~ h  7* 35 SN '+
-    & <Q' C $: 7* :'* 0<5* * ' :+/W ;& N #$b+ hjC
” ^ %2  k, ($  t $ `s †jC *0 Œ y "" <Q
M< $   +  +4< 5  U C' \t X x! U* ;&'
148
"($  t &NH
;& -  Q+ X *0 C 6 & (P hjC &w x
U *^ g
¹% R & g
¹% œm M* h+ *&: x! ,UT ,

'+P U D } ©:2 B6 X ¡:2  88"13 % h  7* 126 ;$  QC x! − 147
œ J $ } 3 - %$ S 1"58"378 % f+P >M‰ 
T h  . U D N €
77"00 % h  C BQQ2 A>02 2 E P: H 4S h  hj1C ¦1958  15¥ 1378
"¦2002 CE6 23 ¥ 1423 % 7* 25 ©+% C 1"2"207 % f+P >M‰ AN:C %$ S
"761 V ,`C
* : :, w $Q= − 148

81
#$% &'
"!       
  

œm B  xE – 6  – 5:J R &< % W h b1 g%Œ


 v – : – K*Q' KN… g%Œ Q‰: U ²p U 
b
& KC &: 6 7+&Q'  J K<S: 6 K
*<C& K<Q `, -
− &- – $HJ `, -  >t6 – E: – x< \
 ‚i ƒ M2  P 1  >? -4 : 6 
3GI P 1% G„
100"000 7* *0C  '+ B6 X 88"13 % h  7* 81 ;$  ¡:2
g
¹% R & g
¹% *E ¡€1 ;g
 X .%$ 300"000 œm

 &,m l
C , 5:J R &< % W h b1 g%ΠU *^
"A\ 6 72 ;$  - M< VS:
7Q+ 7 , i ;g
 7 ±&42 ;$  A. h6 ­,\
 E t6 % €2 h6 7Q+ , .% &,6 >tJ . '+ h6
7_ .>? R & g
¹% `, -  . UÈ k* x ,""" >M1
";%E C' C B<  '+ B‡H  . ‰* &,6 A\ 6 E!
ƒ )v Mj MA‚ eL WG >? -4 : :
B)& BQ…
7* *0C  '+ " B6 X 88"13 % h  7* 84 ;$  ¡:2
- :5 
 &,‡C 2+  E 7 ,.%$ 200"000 œm 100"000
Î~ 6 E 4 6  D U ²p 6 i w `, - ,A\ 6 72 ;$ 
*Q' U%$ 6 Q‰: 6 
b U ²p 6 +~ 6 +45 6 + 
`, - 6 q N 6 M* M* 6 7* g%Π;& 6 +Π`, - 6 ,n0 C
f<* ¡€[ E 6 *Q' l< h 6 6 R % &,6 6 f…*

82
#$% &'
"!       
  

&. [ 6  D & * 6 ;Q* 6 3 E b* *Q QM* 6 4<SQC


149
"B2$ M[ +$j2 g 7*
U ²p 6 i w œm M*  h E <E ;$  A. X g :5H
M< VS: . `5l2  C' h‡H A\ 6 E! 7_ .>? 6  D
7* &M h E g
C' - 
& (P h6 ­,\ ";$  A. -
B 3 E !m +$ :e* k, 6 , N…* 6 , 1 6 ,g D< <Z 
X g :C <  '2 g D X ) ' + D &,m - &. [ N
" NS A.
`5lC Ì , ®:C 3*  h6 ®: Q4 `5
% e . -
R % œm ,%  U% 5 M MH B Œ  X ƒ a 7* 135 SN
E K'* f…* &) M* 7+ I B25C c°  h6 ; '* ,g D
g D R % YQ :'+ h E C l<? B5l2  # SN xC Ã+
150
"P: H 4S h  BC X B< ¡:+ # *J n0 C
M<  '+ 5+2 R 'HJ iN h6 &w  :~ h  œm ( C
7* *? :
œm M[ 7* i5^ C  '+ " B6 X ¡:+ # 263 SN
7* 6 g D R % 7* &,6 h .6 7* ,.%$ Tª ¶ œm K¶ K *
MN …C M*  g :v6 * ' ; R % 6 g
¹% 7* 6 K*Q' KN…

!m 6 P:H , + 6 +4C 6 +C g


M  h E +6 , H 6 QZ :. @~ C $S hm − 149
C2 &H . ,  :~ 'C  œm #$b+ t6 Q+ +6 6 Bm M5 B, - C! E % 5t6
; :< ]+/N<2 * C - A$  &: h  a^ C0 Q‰: " D " Ê'<C &£6" kQ
263 $Q< 5e 
b* ². `, -  QMC +F ;wp 4H * - @~ % & M2  
7* 45 42 $Q< 5e < 4< U `, - C! E % 5t6 !m P ,ƒ a 7* 265
:]   C %1:* ," n0 C H 4S  " h: 3s R * : %&S " H 4S h 
https://maraje3.com/2009/10
g D <wQC %1:* ,4 9 205 $& 3s ¦ C
X J i<w¥ ®: Q= 7 %$  % − 150
"133 V ,  :~ $ - ,2000 :$ Q %& ,X J i<w

83
#$% &'
"!       
  

6 g [6 R
%m 6 U&+&q 6 U% [m 6 RjC , ” M*  5C 6
6 MHPC 9  &SC x! :< >? Y
% 6 C C 6 , M')
E6 6 &, X  . 3' !m "Ml<  Y, 6 .%'1C
i5^ h‡H , <~ g :v6 , Q= - KN<4 g D J 6 g D R % 7*
""K:
œm :
7* h+
p , - U QW C &C Q4 U   % e . -
M .P  1, N U% 5' RJ h6 2020 # * 14 ©+% C
€1 C ;& < BNE Ž4 C :QD    

12 , C : U% 5' 7* .>? K SN C l< R % g D J
6 M* M*  /* g :v6 K*Q KN…*  .m Q+~ #$  7E

6
E M55C 6 M* M* +$j2 g :v6 p  Y, 7* iy †6  e M55C
151
"h  - B< VS:* .
@GI B%,  B%-1 B%E) $ " >? -4 : E:
†% FG K1 B- 1  T/1)'&
7* *0C  '+ " B6 X P: H 4S h  7* 82 ;$  ¡:2
K
*<C& K<Q *E ¡€1 ;g
 X .%$ 200"000 œm 50"000
&,m l
C ,x< \ & KC &: 6 7+&Q'  J K<S: 6
""A\ 6 72 ;$  - M< VS: 

T  h6 >? , i ;g
 7 ±&4+ SN h6 ?H
k* x ,B*E ¡€1< ;g
 . ‰* 7* M‰* 
h+ h6 &'+
 J K<S: 6 K
*<C& K<Q *E ¡€1 ;g
 3<y

4: f<* - ,2020/05/14 ©+% C 50 $& 3s U QW C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 151
"%1:* >? ,2020/112 % i5<2

84
#$% &'
"!       
  

`5l2 !  h‡H < U% 5 - x< \ & KC &: 6 7+&Q'
"A\ 6 82 ;$  - ;$% C' B<
I $ " >? -4 : &-
M* 5
'+ , C  UN - E! 7* >? œm B* 
E
88"13 % h  7* 85 ;$  7*   ;N QC B<  '+ ,$H¤
, [ EJ .  . '+ ".%$ 100"000 œm 10"000 7* *0C
œm B+ # . ,E 4 Y *6 ƒ 2  + D 5 ? Q1+ ,
7Q) %&:+ I * .* 6 M* M* MN 3 E M* V €[J
"A\ 6 .E! `C  U ²N
& 152 k0< P: H 4S h  7* 47 SN h6 œm ;% [ %&™

&, M[ KC B2&* c 2 i54C $H¤ B  X  '+ h E
K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$ 50"000 10"000 KC .%& c + *0C M[6
"KC'
- Xw2 MC 3456 P: H 4S h  -  Q+wH
154
, N<’ 5, U C X ¡:+ 153 1958 >M… h E *&'C ,ˆH U *0

1378 œ J $ } 3 - %$ S n0 C H 4S h  hj1C 378"58"1 % f+P >M‰ − 152
"2856 V ,1958  27 ©+% C %* 2404 $& Q
 ;&+~ ,1958  15 R `H
;&+~ ,1958  15 - %$  n0 C H 4S h  hj1C 1"58"378 % f+š >M… − 153
"2856 V ,1958  27 ©+% C %* 2404 $& Q

:—  1 X U C' 3 E , − 154
c + *0C ;&, :
&, M[ KC B2&* c 2 i54C  '+ :h'C%J i* W SN
&,‡C 2+  E 7 ˆH KC' K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$ 100000 1200 KC .%&
+~ 6 +45 6 +  Î~ E 4  D i w `, - 38 SN C :5 

"n0 C *Q' U%$ 
b U|p
;%E 
 iN:C  52* X U C' iN `5l2 :h'C%J 9$  SN
==h 6 6 R % &,6 6 f…* 4 6 q N 6 M* M* 6 7* g%Œ ;& 6 +Œ `, -

85
#$% &'
"!       
  

. * P: H 4S h  - 5^ U C' 7 •€ œm (P g~


x! C * - 9 : `<l+ h6 05:+ T x ,>5' #6 +^ % S Tm
M*E 7+tu +, Y, h $ M:6 M*\J +^
*m H E 9 : L5S+ ,    œm x! #$b
Tm ,q St
" * 6 ! 
5^ U C' 4C Š0 (P fQC B+: 7* &C T :.
. 3<
 C' R & œ 6 KC 7* '+ BJ ,  7*
, 5, U C X ¡:2 %  U '+P 7* &+&' 3Œ T , ,M:

& * 6 ;Q* Y6 3 E b* *Q QM* 6 4<SQC f<* ¡€[ E 6 *Q' l< ==
"B2$ M[ +$j2 g 7* &. [ 6  D
:5 U C' M< `5lH  W q , ´ H ;%E U S€1 œm B  52* *6
"— h'C%J C  SN -
c + *0C M[6 
&, M[ KC B2&* c 2 i54C  '+ :h'C%J C  SN
&,‡C $H¤ B  7 ˆH KC' K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$ 50000 10000 KC .%&
"38 SN - :5 

B  7 .%$ 100000 50000 KC .%& c + *0C  '+ :h'C%J 7*  SN
"46 45 K<SN - K:' V €[J U ²p œm 
 iN:C
$HJ œm +l iN:C B  7 .%$ 50000 5000 KC .%& c + *0C  '+
"Œ/N
 B*&+ h6 h &C
  al C 6 0< &+  ;%$m `+e 7 B+ 7* E :hQW &, SN
- K:' V €[J 6 U ²p œm *m $HJ œm *m B+  X += H1* <
* tJ
5000 1200 KC c 2 *0C &, M[ A S6 i54C  '+ 53 52 46 45 41 RSN
"ˆH KC' K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$
7+M[ Y +6 
KC c 2 ;& i5^ C R
% . X  'H 
X <
 U, * !m
".%$ 1200 200 KC .%& c + *0C ,K:v

&, M[ KC B2&* c 2 i54C  '+ 41 SN - B< VS:* . C *J `<'2 !m
".%$ 5000 œm 1200 KC .%& c + *0C M[6
*0C M[6 
&, M[ KC B2&* c 2 i54C  '+ :%* hQW &, SN
  6 Ug $m P 7* E ˆH KC' K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$ 20000 5000 KC .%& c +
">0<  W ; ^ C iy % 6

86
#$% &'
"!       
  

B  X #/~ U C' h  7* 01/298 ;$   '2 \QH


6 ƒ $ 50"000 œm 25"000 7* *? M[6 
œm 7+M[ 7* i5^ C $H¤
QC M<+&'2 2 ;$  AMH x! 7* E6 C "KC' K2 . &,‡C
C'< k$J &^ H% 2 , 2006 :$ 20 - §%b 23"06 h 
BH Bw+ # 3 - B6 X R&+ _ ,7+M[ œm Y +6 ¶ 7* 5^
- t6 R $ >2 , H 4S  - 5^ U C' , œm n0
" .&+&12 U C' A. * 7* H A ™
‡ #2 * ,H  @~  S3C . N : E mQ
=-
`<' 88"13 % h  - Š0 (P 6 *0 C   œm
tª  g N)m œm &q  tJ U C' 7* <} ,P: H 4S C
- H 7QD2 UT * P:C Y2   6 U 5l X / 7*
 w, 6 (5l f2 - Xw2 U C' A. "V €[J `,
– : – $ C %$ S ^ P - v – 6  – ] 
; <= H  @~  S3C . N : 6 
* w, Œ“ T " B6 X 88"13 % h  7* 37 ;$  ¡:2
. - M< VS: UT ^ -  D %QC Tm   N4S
"&, M[ w^ ;&* Πw2 T6 X ,h 
 E N4S * 7* N4S ;$<  M: 4 Œ“ T
7* 81 76 75 73 $ - M< VS: ~  , -  D %QC Tm
"h  .
g :C B: %$  — w'
 *jC S€ &C Q4 i 7Q+
3b 4 C *j+ h6 () - 5 5 * ' C : 7* iQ<* X

87
#$% &'
"!       
  

81 76 75 73 $ C *J `<'2 !m Mm ƒ l'2 N4S ;$  Ap


: n h  . 7*
X g& T 6  C <' ~ n 2% X š 5 ®+4 -
; +€ 6 F 6 n .% 6 h ¸ +&~ *^
;$ C  6   &) ~ C 6 n^ wC ;$ [ -
"n .% wC 6  ~
X ®+4 6 #°:' /Q 6 . X š 5 ®+4 -
""7+‹  C %«
N4S * w, j* h6 ;$  A. R\t 7* LD+
 D j[ L56 & ,B:* N4S ;$<  M: 4 6 ,  
h  - ;$&4 UT ^ - , D %QC Tm x! Œ“ T , , 4C
"°^ 5
X
6 ,Y ' Y ‰: C \ p h6 K5+ ;$&4 UT ^ œm ( C B6 E
;>lW ~ ®'C n 2% X ®+4 C 6 ,B2Ë6 $H6 x< ¡€1C
p e ' hJ M: j:* - k52 h6 H 4S X “  , ” ;$ [ 6
"$ p $ ~ N4S Q' U ** * É :+
B6 X P: H 4S h  7* 104 ;$  ¡:2 D+6 a  iN -
. 7* 71 ;$  - ;$% R 'HJ &,6 2* &) C' U%& !m
6   N4S w, 6 #% & (5l f2 Π ,h 
%&S+ h E !m ,&, M[ ;&  D %* QC   * &
%&S+ h E !m K * K2P: ,#M[ fS 6  5
6 6 *+ 1C
" +:
6 +:
fS 6 <SH 6 +M[ NSC
. 7* 73 72 K2$  - ;$% R 'HJ &,6 &) C' U%& !m
* & 6   N4S w, 6 (5l f 7Q+ h 

88
#$% &'
"!       
  

h E !m &, M[ Πw2 T ;&  D % iN QC  
h E !m K * K2P: ,#M[ fS 6  5
6 6 *+ 1C %&S+
" +:
6 +:
fS 6 <SH 6 +M[ NSC %&S+
f2 6 N4S w4C 4< ;%  R 'HJ n 2%  , -
;$  h‡H ,P: X 52 % vu 4Q+ h6 B:Q+ T ^ h6 C ,(5l
7 %$  — w'
 *6 l
C UΠ6 & P: H 4S h  7* 106
4
6 #% $ (5l* 7* $& E /w, S€ &C Q4 i%
3:QD2 !m ,   N4S< 5: C Mm ƒ l'2 N4S ;$ 
`<'    7* R J n 5 7* R J (N M<  '+ T 'H6
X g :C ,A\ 6 71 ;$  - M< VS: x<2 
T Y ' Y ‰: +4C
6 t$ %&S+ , :' *^ l< 5 7* 6 * ' C : 7* <e
. - "J X %H i *6 N:+ <l C B<2 7* U
hv
<w' %*¤ )  BNSC @EQC &CT Q4 i% %&6 % e
5* 7* ,";%l
6 + † : #% €5 L4" n E 7* © /w4C *6
. h6 &N+ M~ — 7* <e X g :C , 'C ;&, 4C :  a Hu
3C< N € K:eQ< ,  7*J C * B2 4N 7QD2 n 
155
" M< `N :+&
;P: /w, * ' C : 6 A\ 6 ;%E *^ l<< Œ“ E
N4S< 5: C Mm ƒ l'2 N4S ;$  4
6 :'
"M[ 6 -  M: 5 + 0 — w'
  D *jC  
E /w4C B: %$ S *J C Q4 i% % '[m x< E X “
5: C Mm ƒ l'2 N4S ;$  4
6 #% $ (5l* 7* $&

©+% C , <w' %*¤ )  BNSC @EQC &CT Q4 i% 7 %$  *6 − 155
"%1:* >? ,2017/1101/1108 % f< - 2017/11/07

89
#$% &'
"!       
  

*6
24 6 R\t Q4 i% %&S+   N4S<
;$  4
6 #% $ (5l* 7* $& E /w, % g 0m 6 &+jC  w'

"   N4S< 5: C Mm ƒ l'2 N4S
MH h+  UT ^ ¡È A\ 6 Mm % 1 Y ,J 3 E !m
/w, h‡H ,B2Ë6 $H6 &,6 6 x< ¡€1C 6 Y ' Y ‰: C 9 * <
7* 108 ;$  QC R,J } - :_ h+ N4S ;$  6 (5l
6  6   $ . - 5 5 Q4Q< /™  h  iN
$& E /w4C *j˜2 h6 ,;%S - `4< ;g
 6  W ; 4< ;g

7* ;$  4
6  & ()* ;$  BH UP # #% $ (5l* 7*
C : 7* iQ<* X g :C w' ! N: C RQ1* 4C   N4S
"1 7* <e X g :C 6 * '
- D+6 BC RQ'* *6 U 5l %&m f2 6 f4S w,
%
& A t2 * h6 +° ®: Q= U   &H , %  U '+P
7 M<2 % HJ g%u 9 h+ h6 . >5' +, h) R\t 7*
- °4:2 T MH\t X Q< $ &^ C &* >? Bm M< >0
*S'* q $6 .$%* $&'2 h6 M Hª k*2 h6 &S C qC %$ S*
,BCv BQ Qw & 2 .ŒN2  x<2 Tm $ 6 R\?6 E 7*
;&* m <l* U +, 3 %
& M<N+  U +^ h6 h 54C
Y& , C  X g C H x ,;ˤ J C l X ½ N^ C
156
">5' +, x<H - % &+ T M5w,
N4S 6  7 ±&42   U D A. 3 E !m
4: n 2%  , -    U 4N 7 !H ,  

.C 7, , &QM


C6 ‹ : &5 A$% 6 ,2009/06/16 < a 63 : 15902 % 7'l − 156
- 4< U< X J i<w 7* %$ S %
& h\ T X `<' 
*" : <t
"131 V ,2011 '5l ," 2011 9% *

90
#$% &'
"!       
  

&: . * ? M5w, 6 M\?‡C ^ g D< 7Q+ . , . 


? xC R< B< Π2%T 7Q+ # ] 
U QW &C 7 %$ S ^ - A&w R¹  . 7 n~
;l h  7* 90 SN U D* X &:
 # 2020/05/14 ©+% C
- 3<Q'
 M  h E NE 
b* #6 a\?m Œ X ¡:+ #  :~
* ŀ1 BC , 0
 M h6  '* "*~ Q' n 2%
  U% 5 7QD2 U .+&H 5 ¯C i+ H   
157
"  † 4NS a\?‡C ^ B'* K'+ _
=- , #2 * : :
X P: H 4S h  7* 104 ;$  7* ;>tJ 5 * ;N ¡:2
N X BC 6 $ C %$ S ^ P:C *j2 h6 Q4Q< 7Q+ " B6
"" f €
 M:  D ^ P NE h  iN 7* 105 ;$  L)2
<lC x! ,h  . - M< VS: U N €  5: C $ C
  N4S 6 :' #% & (5l - , D %QC 1 7*
(5lQ< 5: C (5
6 A S6 6 t$ x! , :'   * & 6
U 5l  5: C ^ % & ©+%  — $&' - ,* #% &
"   N4S< #% 5t  Ks &: tJ +% &
X g :C Tm + h6 7Q+ T $ C G  ^ P:H x! X g :C
P: <l C w
 KQD2 + , , D %QC ,1 7* <e
<l+ h6 1Q< 7Q+ "M M<Q4H P: f 2 *6 ,^ al:QC
P:C 3*   N4S 6 (5l iN - $ C %$ S ^ P
"B5<e - .$&¢ t6 & - 6 , U% 5

"%1:* >? ,2020/112 % i5<2 4: f<* - ,2020/05/14 ©+% C 50 $& 3s %$  − 157

91
#$% &'
"!       
  

*&'C Tm AN:2 7Q+ T ^ al:* 7* g/ A% 5 C P: <e


E "7'l ae 7* `+e #J C  >?  † B 7QD ^ >S+
6 t2 [ - h E g
,A\ 6 œ J ;N U D N ’ 6 R\tm
E 7 .%$ 7000 œm 1000 7*  * *0C B<  '+ ,N: 7 ( :*
">tj2 Y+
g D n6$ &H $ C G  ^ P U 5l2 VS€C
µ C C  :²
 Q= 3D , ,P: U 5<l C w
 X Š0
^ al:* P:C """ ]& `^ C  l ;& N B$jC K:‰ X ^ C
7*  * $& 6 ±\C E c 5S C0 ±&,J K* K2&+~ C
158
"P: f+% S* B<Qs g  ;&+
- $ C G  ^ al:* P:C K:‰ X ^ h6 
- 55
3 E      P: 3<Q'
  ;&+~ iN
$% x[ h &C `4
 E ›6 B , * $& 6 ±\v - $
# x! 7* E6 $% `¢ UT ^ ®'C - P: hm C " *  t
N4S< #$ * #:'* %« 7* B: 2+  ‰ , *0 Bs h6 7Q+
"(5l 6
~ ®'C '5e h6 g D5 %& C &CT Q4 U   x
:w C `,\ %Ž<   MH N+ T   %6 X % vª 7* BN<È *
7   - \* Q4Q< C ,# ®+'2 X % S B<
®+' x <Q2 . + 4) 'QC 9 * 7* B<È * H 4S `+e
^ P:C *J *g\* E6 +lC #:' %Ž (&S C6% #:
'“ _ ,:' ®+' 5
X f4S - B< Y4 $‡C G 

- ,2008/10/30 ©+% C ,4498 $& 3s µ C C  :²


T Q4QC 4:~ H0 7 %$  % − 158
"53 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,20/2008/1884 % f<

92
#$% &'
"!       
  

05:+ 9
6 X :5* :e &~ ®'5C %&S
# ^ P <e
159
"B C w

   " >? M-4 : EE mQ
X B ,m 7* ? C B6 &w  :~ h  VS œm : C
7QD+ RŒ T B‡H , X C' ¡¬ H P: H 4S h 
;ËJ $H6 &,6 6 A&M — 6 x< &)  C `<'+ H  : U C
– M: 5C ;6 œm B < 5: C *J xE – T 6 − <
−  v
% mˆI  1  1 & ‰ ,†% 1! >? : 6 

7* i5^ C  '+ " B6 X  :~ h  7* 179 SN ¡:+
K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$ 200"000 œm 20"000 7* *0C K:
œm M[6
6 x< ¡€1 ,  W ; ^ C * 6 5
6 H 2% 7* E ,KC'
"x< ¡€1 Y, > C t6 6 ,&M' — ¡€1
100"000 œm 10"000 7* *0C :
œm M[6 v\v 7* i5^ C  '+
; ^ C * 6 5
6 H 2% 7* E ,KC' K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$
" h  . 7* 168 SN - Mm % 1   ;ËJ g D J ,  W
6  2% !m ,A\ 6 K2N - Mm % 1 C' f D2
g D J 6 &M' — ¡€1 6 x< ¡€1  W ; ^ C i 6 
l
C ,x< ¡€1 Y, > C R\t 6 ,   ;ËJ
6 *Q' U 'Qw 7E *J - ” AN U&+&M 6 c S 6 lW
6 +Π6 5 l
C 6 YQ' % ‰6 X ) ' U S< l
C

f<* - ,2009/05/18 ©+% C 09/10865 $& 3s g D5 %& C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 159
"136 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,2009/11/7007 $& 4:

93
#$% &'
"!       
  

%   
 MH C :<' µš `s <
E l
C
" +°5 'Q
 AG @3A- m 1! >? -4 : :
 X  '+ B6 X  :~ h  7* 444"2 SN ¡:+
. ".%$ 120"000 œm 12"000 7* *0C M: 5C ;6 &) 2
h  7* 5 ;$  QC  :~ h  VS œm BH )m 3y SN
 Π. B:* + 0 ,160 g : &) f:' C% 4QC `<' 103"13 %
"K:~ KC /Q X :5* h+ M: 5C ;6 œm B+ #
- D¬ M: 5C ;6* B<= h+ #  H x '52
. h E hm ,P: H 4S h  i A\ 6 444"2 SN œm BC
7 +&^ &: — SN - M: ±&4:
U  [m ;& >+ SN
":<'  C
&)  4: Y C Q4 3': A\ 6 444"2 SN< 5l2
l* - " €1" n M e 7* MN X g :C M: 5C ;6*
"¯C i+ H    QC 4N X š 5 :C BC 2 +&H
5e ;$&'* H  6 Q¢ h E 'N . hJ &[J Q+~ C B$‡C 3D
7E 3 iN - y  U% 5 3456 ƒ a 7* 118 SN<
N Qs 3 E 4D h % 5  161"*Q f…*  .m 4:~ #$ 
" M* M*
% _ g :v6 < 3)'2 l<
%

,¦2018 + H 22¥ 1439 ;tu $ } 5 ©+% C 1"18"19"% f+P >M‰ AN:C %$ S − 160
"1449 V ¦2018 9% * 12¥ 1439 ;tu $ } 23 ©+% C 6655 $& Q
 ;&+~
4: f<* - ,2020/05/14 ©+% C 50 $& 3s U QW C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 161
"%1:* >? ,2020/112 % i5<2

94
#$% &'
"!       
  

h6 œm ,Š0 h  -  C'  ' R\t 7* ¡<€ h!m


U 
b 6 $HJ &) ” 2%  , - Q+~ A. X  & (P
6 (5l fC ^  *m Œ 6 E ,ˆH *0 C'C , * NSC
(5l /w, xE , :'* UT , -  - <Q' N4S w,
%QC  ]   7* N4S ;$  4
6 < 7QD
 , - Tm  Q+ - 5^ U C' X (P 5+ I " D
"B2Ë6 $H6 &,6 6 A&M — 6 x< ¡€[ œm BM2

 Q+
%$ $&SC :*$ * >1 h6 &C T :.
<e & h+ *&'C B:+ &2 4C !  Y  h6 œm   
 , Q+~ ˆ+ T ,n ' 7* BN'+ T 4NS '5* ®'C M<
" †j[ - Bv2 2 # Ž4 C C v k52
35+ h6 !  h *‡C B6 œm ;% [ 7* &C T a  iN - B6 E
h  7* 109 ;$  ¡ , x! ,n ' 7* 3<N    4
B:QD+ * 4 U 5vm UT ^ E - `¢ B6 X ¡:2  P: H 4S
:•+ * g :
C 
;  W ; ^ C `<'+  h E !m − 6
6 Y$  C 3l
6 N' M<Q[ Q+ œm +  h E !m − n
~ g :
 * ' 6 % 5  $C .= 2 C †j[ - U%&
"h  a, &) Q~ U E M   &)
h6  Q+wC M*  `¢ B‡H ;$  A. U D* X g :C
l
C x! ,  œm .&:
6  ' 4 Q4 Y *6 35+
- M< $ T $ $M1 7+ : g
6 ,U&: 7* € +&2
,G   & ,* <e U 5vm 
+&2 B:Q+ """ w^ * m
162
" 'C Q< &, )+  7* /'+ * 4 U 2 5v U&E6 * !m

"P: H 4S h  7* .&'C * 109 7* $ x! hj[ - % − 162

95
#$% &'
"!       
  

7* QZ B< $2 A\ 6 L) . E U 5v . h6 >?


 W ; ^ R :2  H ,$H¤  W ; ^ M›6 Ug :

*<'* 44 h E  B4 U 5v \= h+ h6 7Q+ T  Q<
$% * U 5vm 4SC `<' <l g D ®H% % e . - "9 : &
5 7* ;%  :Hm #&
±&,6 UŒ ™ U% 5' h6  '*  -
& + /2  l 3s — * Â<5* <2 \N gš ()QH """ 1
#&
±&,6 7 ±&4+ # %1: R  <SC B* 4m 2 # 5
1Q<  W ; ^ % em - t&+ ±&,J A. 7 &'5 E &'C :Hm
7* B+ £ Y/6 C , B:QD2 * 4 U 5vm 7* (P . :
 
163
""7+tu g& 
`4 µš W 4 hJ .% + * p Ug :
T A. h6 ^
>? t P:C &N+ T Qw H , M< , C Y2    4<S
' h2 h6 W 4 Ã2 ,xC % D B4<S* hm C ,L4
"Bm U&:
6 7* œm M5 , 7* 44 q! - 44 M:QD+ 
&N+ T 2 7* ,   4<S* P: `¢  µš   B'C e
- Qw :'2 T ¡€1  W ; ^ iy   P:+ 7* , C 7*
164
"gÏ
U5v h6 œm ;% [ 7* &C T  C 7 +&^ Y t -
, :'* M 6 ¡€[ &)  Q+ n 2% X  :~  b
B5 l+ h6 %ŽQ< 7Q+ , , &  b 22 ;% Ž C B: 2+
"%Ž 7 ®+' C

08/69 % ;š 5 + 1 f<* - ,2009/03/13 ©+% C µ C C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 163
"50 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,08/70
"367 V ,`C
* ," + g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m − 164

96
#$% &'
"!       
  

>? )/G T4 ŠN € T4 {/&' : ;E @%C


5C — * R&C 7*  * H$ . MN c\l - ®+'
+ 0 Q2 ,'N 2* `2 X g/ MH 165 ">0 C %« a ^m
7 ƒ¬ ®+' H ” "%Ž n 6 # %Ž  - B:* 

J
B<  '+ \Q BH w 'N 2* X  N2 C BE $Z
166
"BC  l+ 7 Tm L:Q+ T ®+' H x ,h 
7* Q+ %  7* H ,  : h+ & ®+'<  'N
B <Q tJ K 6 U C' h  - M< VS: ~
~ hJ B: Í[ : %Ž ®+'2 7 B b* Y/<+ +$ * jlt 2+
 H `+e 7 M':* (P 6% Qw C ;% ) R 6 q %$ \t X
B<6 7* `4+ jlt  : jlt6 &H Q+ 2% 7QH , M52* X C
167
"®+' C B< ( Y/<+ jlt &* jlt6 3 iN - n '
A>0E <l+  Q+ 7 2 : %Ž 7 ®+' h6 >?
7 \DH – œ J ;N – B0<5* +&2 E B*  :'* e š `s
%Ž 7 ®+' C 5 l ” ¡È  tJ Y ,J 7* QZ
–   ;N –  Q+ 7 2 :
_/1N Q5 {/&' Œ+' O ‹ : e I mQ
X g&  % 5  'Q g+m . ‰* 7* M‰* . 
x 168"¡€1<   /E X vb+ C$6 %« 1+ . , *

'5l ,3+ 
\ %$ ," + MN 
" : *\
 h b1   J ;%Œ − 165
"35 V ,13 g/~ ,©+% 2 h &C ,  
"29 V ,`C
* : K, < h ,m − 166
"34 V ,2017 œ J '5l ,+Œ P:< $Q= %$ ," ®+'  $ " : #5 */ &Q= − 167
"72 V ,`C
* : K, < h ,m − 168

97
#$% &'
"!       
  

7* %Ž `, 169"%« 7* BC 6  % Ž ®+'2 &' 7* h E


% h  7* 87 ;$  B i
b2 %Ž 7 ®+' <e -  Q+
$wQC  P: 4) BN '+ ¡€[ #J  * l'2  88"13
6 :' (5l - <Q' U% 5' R\t 7* B< ' 7* B:y
h6 %« BC `^  'Q $ MH C :'   N4S
#% ~ +P - M< VS: U <1 µ P `H ®+' <l+
"Q' BC
+>S  b Y ,6 . R w . - Q' BC #% ~ +P
`^ Y  h6 : K5+ Mm ( C  ,$' U */ h  - ;$%
.H2 &'C – T 6 – :'* µ š H2 ;% « Y/<+ ®+' . -
–  v –  t Y ,J A+&2 D¬
{/&' Œ+' O ‹ : 6 
¡€[ E " h6 X $' U */T h  7* 78 SN ¡:+
B²l€C 7 ˆH B<'NC T ,Bv&,6 # #$  6 #:' %Ž 7 R b*
""%Ž x! - š 5 5 . jlW . h6 35+ *&: x! , D+6
h E%6 v\v X Y2 &  b h6 SN . R\t 7* LD+
;&* 3Œ T  b A. h6 #6 ,M:C 55 \ %Ž jlW .
*&:  Q+ - % Ž H x 170"jlW ;NC M

6 , 7*
4) h E #  Q+ g 7* BC 6 # %Ž ®+'C  l+
%« RS, – 1 – !  ¡€1 7*  jlt U 5vm g B< + B
– 3 – M:C 55
\ $ #6 jlW 7 2  %Ž h+ h6 – 2 –

/E ," % *
%$ : v% œm B  &* %Ž 7 ®+' " :k K*6 &Q= & − 169
"18 V ,2014 ,œ J '5l ,;.  ,   U%&\ *
"7 V ,`C
* : K, f
+ %6 − 170

98
#$% &'
"!       
  

XC„ − 1
* ¯2 " . BC jlW A\ 6 78 SN - Š0 (P  &
&S >? 7* x! ,B: ¯ * “ h E * 'H 6 ,B<'H “ h E
171
""%Ž ±&,
. +>S  b - jlW h6 % 5  X g D BN 
 &
- jlt BC R\t '+ # ]  Y/ ,]  Y/ C R\tm
- ¡€1 :lS+ h6 . , + : R5C Y/ $ . +>S  b
¯< . 7 4 !‡H ,>0 C Ž+ T k, °5 ‰ BE<

. h E ,4 & B6 ¯%&+ 4C /Q 7* ;%& X h E ,


172
" +>S B b* + jlt 4
Y2 œ J K2% B ,MN ]  KN+' g) - h!m jlW H
Š “m 'NC Y2   ,B<'H h  + *6 ¯2 - Xw+ 5<
'NC
;%S - Xw+  Q+ - jlW "h  B':Q+ gÊC Y  - Xw+
B2 . , M: ¯ * h  + g [6 'H - Q+ ,  
B*MNQC jlW h6 E "`, B h $ ². 6 tª ¡€1  U% 5
'H #6 2 'N - Xw+ #$ * ›&,6 7+°: 7* h+ A\ 6
"/Q 6 ¯%$ - Xw+ #:'* M v ,#&'
#&'2 'NC Y  “ , , '* 7+°:' H2 7* &C T jlW Y 
,/_ E%&* 'N B: %& 7* h+ h6 “ , C “m 6 5<
h E g

3:*6 hm , &*  : Bg * N:2 /Q >? >0S 6 h:w hm ,


"R,J ®'C - &* ]  B g *

%$ S* ," &+&~ ]& h  cš - ˆ


 " : #%M: aŒ &5 A$% 6 ,R\C f+'2 − 171
"777 V ,1997 ,Y/T
g/~ ," Y BC Y/T +‰ : ]& h  cš - / " : #%M: &£6 aŒ &5 − 172
"312 V ,1966 ,;.  C' DM: %$ ,R J

99
#$% &'
"!       
  

J h6 x! ,`^ 7 ƒ W ;% €+  Q+ - jlW


NE B+6% 7 '+ h6 B ,>5' #6 +, - `^ ¡€[  B6 .
X g&  ,`^ ” 4 Y& l+š 7 ,g [ * `H g [
* >E B6 #%M: aŒ &5 ! + % e . - "7+tu a,
h+ h6 #% Ž 7* i B6 , 'Q P X g&  jlW h+
(F ,   - F* : %6 h+ h6 N+ C , : gO #&'
173
"$ ' ¡€1< j ¯< 7 4
M :C &  bQ<

6 '+ ,  E ›6 jl€<
K, NH ,jlW . U 5vm g - Q+ M:C aN , +&' +>S
7& kN'+ ,% Ž `2 X +>S  b - jlW U 5vm g +
174
"g' . 7* +&'  b -
Q+ - jlW . ,jlW ( U 5v‡C */<* % Ž h+ x
' g $m 6 $ :
m . , Q+w< #$  7E U 5vm - Q+ m 
* :<' `s 
&,m `+e 7 .P ,% Ž PC iy :'*
"% Ž   - jlW 35v ,x! 35v6 !‡H ,x B2$%m B2
x , *Q'  & - $ µ š `s :'+ jlW . U5v
MH † E%6 H2 35+ *&:  & A. - &* He A% 5 C % Ž H
®+' C ^ B: 2+ $ C ^ H "jlW H2 D+6 35v6 & h+
X D+6 #F+ , . ,jlW U5v X :+ 3456 $ hjE
"%Ž

* ," Y BC Y/T +‰ : ]& h  cš - / " : #%M: &£6 aŒ &5 − 173
"332 – 331 V ,`C

h  N %$ ," % *


%$ : 5l< &  b - jlW 7E% " : K, f
+ %6 − 174
"13 V ,2014 œ J '5l, A%E$ 
% , Q<' 
 <<
,+ΠP:<

100
#$% &'
"!       
  

€ − 2
BC 'H !m ,AŽ+ A« R + ,!J N: &) 0< - `<l+ %Ž
X t&+ # h S: . ,N: &) %Ž ,!6 BC `^6 6 . *
175
"iNJ R*J - ¡: ;&1  */ gŽ ,gÊ
S+ +$ * h+ & , Q+~ 7* %Ž S+ # %Ž
6 A%'[ - % Ž S+ C$6 h+ & ,B * - 6 BQ - % Ž
M< V¢  ] ' 7* tª k:'* #6 6 BHš 6 B*E 6 BNe
x ,#:'* %« $ .  Q+ 7 2+ # %Ž 176"9 :
"%Ž 7* (: . 7 % e . - ˆH ±&4:

PC 9 * E . ,Š$J %Ž C D+6 kQ+ E 6 #:' %Ž


5+ # %Ž MH 177"  - E A% 5  ¡€1 'Q
6
A%'[ BNe - % Ž S+ # %Ž B<*6 7* % ŽQ< 6
A% 5  BHš - BC 6 * X ;F^ h/^ IJ 0 B5< œm t&+
178
"B  '2 #  w
- h  S+ # !J . #:' %Ž H t6 ;% 5'C
6 `4C R\tm E #6 ,   >? a^ X S:H ,  * >? 4<S*
6 h   X + # %Ž E ,%E ¡€1< +:'* 4<S*
< U N:S* - B, 6 ,BNe 6 BHš 6 B'Q
- B, 6 ; ^ - B,

%$ ,
$  '5l ,
 &<w ,"n' h " :#° +HT %‰:* 7C Y* 7C &Q= − 175
" .&'C * 33 V ,2008 ,U >C ,%$ 
* ," Y BC Y/T +‰ : ]& h  cš - / " : #%M: &£6 aŒ &5 − 176
"345 V ,`C

,1964 ,;.  ,  ' '5l ,]  g/~ ,"U */T - ]& h  cš" : i* h<
− 177
"315 V
"68 V ,`C
* : K, < h ,m − 178

101
#$% &'
"!       
  

;& €+ . 179"¡€1< Š$J /E , N: YTu YQ , +N


g/M
 +€   7 2 : %Ž .ŒC6 7* %
180
""" F g 1Hm 50
#:' %Ž 7 ®+'  *m &* R, g MN KC Î  % +
- *J . , Š0 (P h6 >? ,#$  +< B<C  Y&' ‰
7 ®+' - `^ 6 *&: A\ 6 Bm % 1 ( R a 7* 78 SN
"#:' #$  7+%Ž
®'C H2 7* &C T %Ž 7 #:' ®+' X RS4<
h6 , , i = %Ž h+ h6 M›6 7*  

J µ P
"š 5*  t h+
- `^ l'+ k, = %« h+ h6 7* #:' %Ž - &C \H
T MH Q4 #:' %Ž *6 ,#$  %Ž hj[ x! - Bj[ ®+'
R :+ T * E \* S€[ h6 <H "®+' C 5 l `, % Ž L: N+
- $S ¡€1 h‡H ,AP:+ I B2Œ, - R  k5
 h m 'Q
7*
`4<+ h6 Q¢ # #:' %Ž 7 ®+' C 5 l l+ T R 
. ®+'<

6 L<S+ # #:' %Ž hJ ,R  P  H B'QC
%Ž /, - k5+ 'Q 7* : H ,P:+ I Y$ * R  h6 ,`4 %Ž
181
"®+' C ^ Ç
r +d T # Q4

%$ : h%  #%$ g D h  - B: ®+' #:' %Ž" : K*&£ K, 7Q. − 179
"27 V ,2018 œ J '5l ,+Œ P:< Š' /E ," % * <<s
#:' %Ž" : +E – &5 a % H ,() . R, U *<'  N 7* &+/ ‰ − 180
" .&'C * 44 V ,2012 œ J '5l ,U >C , Q<'  %$ "B 6
: R J g/~ ,"Š0 $' U */T h  g) - U */T +‰" :#C/ h*j* − 181
"403 V ,1982 U >C ,   '5l ,U */T %$ S*

102
#$% &'
"!       
  

V €[6 6 ¡€[ X S:+ *&: š 5*  t %Ž h+


®+' 7Q+ \H 7+$&= >? V €[jC `<'2 & h E !m *6 q C K:'*
. B: ®+' “ # %Ž hjC °* - <' Q4 3D &H B:
$H X S & %Ž h+ h6 k:'QC , SW BH H2 # %Ž
7+$&'* V €[6 X %Ž S:+ & B6 >? 182"q C $H6 X 6 K'*
- Ke€:*  E !m ®+' - `^ p Y+ x! * M+. &+&s h $
U% 5 ¯C i+ N C B4N X + 7QH ,\* K* 4 ²ME , Q‰:* ².
7 j:* - '+ T BQ
C &,6 E! h $ 9 NC K* = `, - H 7QD2
U ²p D+6 Q¢ V €[J Q¢ h  hJ , &  :~ g 
" Q‰:
7 ®+' h6 g D   &H , S€[ h+ h6 D+6 “ %Ž
š 5* %« &2 ;% ŽC &+ h6 “ *Q  $ Y  &: %Ž
I R ^ Œ  - Bm , "*~ 'N n 2% 7  4D< ŀ[
R\t 7* E , ()* U :+ & g
 R\t 7* Q4Q< 35+
S€[ U%Ž2 & 9 c ]& `^ C 5 l hjC Mm Q $M1 ;$ M[
Y&'T ®+' C 5 lQ< R Z T —  C ,M B<6 7* h& 'N< w
L+° K'+ <
]  9
6 X :5* >? q 5<e xC h2 ,B55

183
" p5 Y&'C
,R  iQ+ T # %Ž . #:' %Ž h6 h!m R \t
184
, = h+ h6 “ #$  %Ž E . ,  * >? 4<S* S+ 7
"45 V ,`C
* : K*&£ K, 7Q. − 182
$& cË i5<2 4: f<* - ,2020/02/11 ©+% C NSC &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 183
"%1:* >? ,2019/2106/975
+P g MN g%ª g) - ®+'  $ " :&£6 &
.C ,n . &5 &£6 š6 − 184
"13 V ,2018 ,œ J '5l ,;.  ,+Œ P:< &' %$ ," g D Y ,6

103
#$% &'
"!       
  

$&=  C &M h+ h6 Y/<+ * . , S€[ h+ h6 “ E


`s ,!    7* jlW Y  h6 >? "&+&4< \C  J X 6
®+'2 - !   b* Y  H E h+ T ,    - %Ž
"%Ž jlW KC 55
\ $ 35+ I * %Ž
33A  F& – 3
%« M 7* jlt ¯ :. h+ h6 +>S  b Y  N+ T
6 ,%Ž ( œm $6 # . jlW h+ h6 &C T C ,t6 M 7*
,R b B52% # jlW KC 55 lC Y  7* &C T t6 ;% 5'C
185
"% Ž n 6 # %Ž KC
55 lC% - 45 h6 X +° ®: Q= g D 
 &
C  BQMH - () G  D¬ T #  7
. %Ž jlW KC
A. Y  X & +&2 h6 "B<l5+  B552 n1+ h6 Tm ®: Q=
, M< ®: Q4 C % T   ) %*J 7* D+6 . lC
%Ž hJ ,š 5* >? 6 š 5* BjC %Ž fC `<'+ H *J xE
186
" 55
lC% jlW KC B:C H2 * . š 5
2+ # %Ž 6 vJ - Xw2  Q+ - 55 \
, F   - E +$ * h+ h6 BH Y/<+ T ,* µ 1: 7
X #&'    - R ^ . E N h+ h6 7Q+ m
ˆ^ - Q+ ®= %« ” AN X 2+ !m ,% 5   ' P
187
"B< :w *E 7*

,`C
* ," Š0 $' U */T h  g) - U */T +‰ " :#C/ h*j* − 185
"405 V
"19 V ,`C
* :&£6 &
.C ,n . &5 &£6 š6 − 186
, +%&:
T , '* ~ U 5l %$ ,"Y '  :U C' h  cš " :* C6 EŒ &Q= − 187
"118 V ,1986

104
#$% &'
"!       
  

$wQC Bm , , )N*  Q+ - #:' %Ž h E 


B‡H "#:' %Ž M: 2+ ,% 5  * Î&È :'* ' $ :
m
!‡H , Q+ - )N* \ . 55 \ hjC D+6 R 7Q+
$ C ^ &'5H "M:C 55 \' 3)H %Ž 35v Q+~ 35v
55 \' H2 &* - 45< ;% « ¯ :. k52 T *Q'  & -
" q 5v‡C % Ž f<+ T  N2 \' A. hJ ,%Ž  'H KC
œm *Q'  & U , 3S<t *&'C B6 Š0 g D   x
\ ¯ :.  e & B b* Y C R + *J h‡H M $m
188
"]& `^ C K5 l C `,\ %Ž B52% * KC ;š 5*
¡€[ 'NC \S* %« ¯ :. Y$ * B6 55 \ - h!m J H
*6 . 189 " x! i X & Íl€ Y 6 !m Tm  N* 55 µ CH
X 4+ +:'* %Ž MH h+   Q+ - B c * >?
- 5<
v6 ±&s I  Q< MM   U% 5 h6 U 5vm ! 
"BN
€ T4 {/&' %3 /1N : :
3s ,M:C 55
\ %« jlt 7*  b h E%6 UH2 !m
# %Ž ®+'2 R b X H , .% vª M< 3522  b
. ,  b `s X 2+ # vJ . h!m ®+' H ,B²l€C Bv&,6
190
" .¹/

4: f<* - ,2020/05/14 ©+% C 50 $& 3s U QW C &C Q4 7 %$  , − 188
"%1:* >? ,2020/112 % i5<2
"74 V ,`C
* : #5 */ &Q= − 189
* ," Y BC Y/T +‰ : ]& h  cš - / " : #%M: &£6 aŒ &5 − 190
"370 V ,`C

105
#$% &'
"!       
  

+&2 'S 7* BJ ,L) % ' D¬ T Š$J %Ž h6 ;& 
191
"g%u p, Q™ i
6 X M'* ; ^ . 5* 7* h *^ ,IJ
- BH 2 # ¡€1 & ±&¢ # IJ &* 9  Kp 7* i<H
D+6 M 7* i B6 E "B:e .6 B\*Œ KC A% , 2 6 ,BHš
"%Ž . w, +& ;&,* >+ '* X a N2T
- <l* ++&2 l<
() ; D U '+P <?6 l'2 x
h 5C K*/<* + h6 h $ ,% ŽQ< B4:*  ®+' Â<5* K'2
;& - Š0 g D A&E6 * . ,+& . g ;&Q' i
J
Q +&2 () Q4 B6 U&E6 +° ®: Q= h6 E 192"U%
Y  X U  C $6 7* p Y&+ * h  h/QC h/2 h6 “ ®+'
®+' +&2 h6 D+6 U   193 "®+' Q +&2 $&SC . %Ž
Y/ A D* X K'+ ¡ h  - 7+ I BC 5
6 3*  k* %Ž 7
 ‰ ; QC () G  BC + _ . ,BSt - :'* >+ '*
194
" C\
I * ,®+' Â<5* +&C () g D R\
 . h!m ;&  H
 , - k, 7 "A&+&s +e K52 6 ,A$&s   S (P D+
hJ ,ˆC) h $ R w . ¯+ h6 :'+ T MH xC g D R\


,¡€ n < ÎeJ QZ U%1:* ,"%  ±$, - ®+'  $" : h<4E • − 191
"24 V ,2011 œ J '5l ,i2
,`C
* ," Š0 $' U */T h  g) - U */T +‰ " :#C/ h*j* − 192
"425 V
f+š ,&£6 &
.C A$%  ,1992/05/31 < " < +%$m" a 35 : 4378 % 7'l − 193
," <' +%$ Q4 Y ,6 g D BN g) -  & i<Z h  cš " : § 5l &£6
"118 V ,2014 œ J '5l , 5l< 9  Eš ,  g/~
f+š ,&£6 &
.C A$%  ,1996/02/11 < " < +%$m" a 40 : 2180 % 7'l − 194
"121 V ,`C
* : § 5l &£6

106
#$% &'
"!       
  

> jlW 7 ®+' H ,B*  jlW ( X f+ ®+' +&2


Q ®+' +&2 - k + h6 “ x 195"~ jlW - B: f<¬
*  ;$ Q4  2 ,B<  7*  , ,B' 6 7*  , ,%Ž
&, ·6 œm S2 ,x '52 ®+' - &+/H %Ž ±&,6 # jlW
196
"%Ž ±&,m &Q'* R b h+ *&:
- %Ž 7 ®+' Â<5* +& 5: C ) . . h E !m
7* &C T  Q+~ 5: C B‡H ,$' U */T h  Y ,6 % em
Q4  2 " B6 X 3S  88"13 % h  7* 91 ;$  œm (
 W ; ^ C i 7 2 : %Ž ~ #$  #:' ®+' +&2 -
:•+ *   6 ;%S - `^ C i 6
; : g
H2 &* −
; % D 'N n 2%  … U C\* −
; BQw, %Ž ‹ : −
; W * ' ‚$ 5Q< H %Ž w, ®+' KC 
: −
; ;/w:
; N4S   U\* '* % −
- g D< ,:Q ++& l< & & (P h+ ;$  A”
&: ”  '
 G  X “  >+ ' ®'C ) ®+' +&2
; * M:* " Q+ 7 2 : %Ž 7 `4 ®+'< A+&2

: #$' Y ‰: - M: ®+' +&2 5l g ltJ " :5' '1* 7C &Q= 7C L  − 195
"201 V ,2019 œ J '5l ,  + $ ST h  5* ," 5l2
%$
,N: :   g/~ ," #$'  P U 'H Y ‰ - ˆ
 " : hŒN ¯C 7C &Q= − 196
"175 V ,2009 ,œ J '5l ,  + $ ST h  5*

107
#$% &'
"!       
  

Y  &* - 45 R\t 7* Mm R 7Q+  , : g


H2 &*
$ ŀ1 &S n ? 45 g S
 #4 C N4S
i   C :' #6C tJ E P: g% * ' 4<S
";%S - `^ C i  W ; ^ C
%Ž 7 ®+' ¡¬ H ›6 U! 3 E hm >+ ' A. h6 >?
, 7 2 : #:' %Ž ¡¬ H x! \t X †‡H #$ 
®'5H x! * 7 "BQw, A‹ : &+&s ;% [ 35
E %'+ #
: g
H2 &* % D 'N n 2%  … U C\QE ‹ :'
7Q+ >+ '* M<E ,! < +$  ') 6 N4S U\* '* %
* 
:+ \* ®+'2 +&2 6 7* ” 9 :²
 q * G <
" ^ %Ž w,
®+' +&2 D¬ h6 k:'QC ,  D ®+' h+ h6 h!m 6&5 H
Œ :  … ; * <' µPC x! - , . ,G  $ MT
Q h2 h6 k:'QC ,\* E ®+' h+ h6 x! - J , q C\*
197
" ^ BQ ®+' Œ w+ T h6 X ,%Ž 4C ®+'
®+' " h6 '+ ®+' - &' `s X V¢ Š0 g D H
%ŽQ< `¢ h6 “  :~ h  7* 108 ;$  U D 5e BC Y4
7* ;š 5* BC 6 # `4 R ^ ŀ1 %Ž 7 \* E D+'2
.Œ ™ #$ N2 %«J x<2 $ &, - ®+' x! k5+ h6 l+š Q+~
198
"" A&+&s - 0 5 0< C

"23 V ,`C
* : h<4E • − 197
f<* - ,2009/05/18 ©+% C 09/10865 $& 3s g D5 %& C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 198
"136 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,2009/11/7007 $& 4:

108
#$% &'
"!       
  

,199  D U% Y ,J 7* QZ X (\e R\t 7*


X ®+' Q +&2 ¡¬ H %
& Š0 g D hjC R 7Q+
,tJ Œ  7* ” Y4  5 f<È , ,A\ 6 ;%E >+ ' #&.
µ C C  :²
 Q= U&+6 &H " ” l4 U C\  ‰ ,
A%& %Ž 7 D+'2 ]& `^ C  l L:QC G  ^
; '* ,Â<5 . 7* H <l C w
 3DH% ,.%$ 1"500"000"00
`4 ®+' L:* - ++&2 l<
7* p C &C Q4 h6
h6 2 Q4 A. h6 BC Y4 Â<5 C B 3D ]& `^ C  lQ<
B'* h+ # *J , 4D C `,\ %Ž ~ H E BC Y4 Â<5
K'2 _ ]&* ®+'2 7* BC Ì H B<= - fj &C ^
200
"A&+j2
* U :+ &2 P:C M Y  - M'  ¡€<2 t6 Œ  -
R :2 1 PC iy :1* U% 5 D2 ¯C i+ H   
7* %ŽQ< Q4 3D ,B<Q+ # U
%& * 'Q
B'Q
7*
201
".%$ 150"000 A%& ®+'C  4:
7 2 %Ž 7 ®+' C <' Y ,J .6 A. 3 E h!m
% $ ,%Ž 7 &  b `s µ PC M\ -  Q+
U! Y ,J 7* &+&' ¯ :. 3Œ T 7 "®+' Â<5* +&2 - g D
 $ H% - •4 V St C  t NSC `<'2 () ” µ 52%
"? 7* &) ®+'  $ H% - `^ B 7* ,®+'

"  D U$ MT Y ,J C V W `4< ‰ − 199


,2008/10/30 ©+% C ,4498 $& 3s µ C C  :²
T Q4QC 4:~ H0 7 %$  % − 200
"62 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,20/2008/1884 % f< -
4:~ f< - ,2019 + :+ 10 ©+% C ,4 $& h l lC &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 201
"%1:* >? ,2018/2102/628 $&

109
#$% &'
"!       
  

{/&' K41- D„ K0I I {&- P : E mQ


€ T4
7 ®+' C 5 l - `^ p 7+ V €[J (P $&, &
h6 7Q+ 7+ V €[J E − T 6 –  Q+ 7 2 : %Ž
-  t * ,6 6 E –  v – ®+' C 5 l  $ .&) Y 2
h  U 5l2 ¡¬ H %Ž 7 ®+'  $ - •4 V St
−  v –  Q+ M:* H 4S
€ T4 {/&'- 3C " $2 # T/? yfdI : 6 
* m - `^ + B6 X 202  :~ ;l h  7* 7 ;$  ¡:2
 , N ’ 6 4: 6 + : 7 2 : %Ž 7 ®+'< &  &
Q+~ BH 3552 #:'* 6 #$ * 6 ] %Ž  S€[  '2 7*
";š 5*
!m ,  &*  He S:2 h6 * 'N:* U! †6 7<' U 'Qw< 7Q+
'N n 2% 5 J X U:
C%6 :*   NSC 3
j2 & 3 E
l 6 * ' C : 5 7* *Q'  & * m  , - x! ,*~
"O
J †  - B< VS: M*. R Z iy Q+ hj1C ]&
f:' D. :* + DC k:'2  ;%E U 'Qw< 5: C ,B6 >?
&'C Tm He S:2 h6 M:Q+ T B‡H ,O
J †  , ,g : &)
"" 4D 7* Š E h!m X pS,
7 2 : %Ž 7 ®+' <e - `^ 35+ ;$  A. 4H
";š 5* Q+~ BH 3552 # %Ž<  S€[  '2 7*  

g : &) f:' C% 4QC `<' 103"13 % h  7* 7 ;$  ÌQC ,A\ 6 7 ;$  Q2 2 − 202
,¦2018 + H 22¥ 1439 ;tu $ } 5 ©+% C 1"18"19 % f+P >M‰ AN:C %$ S
"1449 V ¦2018 9% * 12¥ 1439 ;tu $ } 23 ©+% C 6655 $& Q
 ;&+~

110
#$% &'
"!       
  

7Q+ T #°, 1C `^ ,  . 6&5 , 7*   h6 k:'QC


R w D+6 34H & ;$  A. h6 >? "®+' <lC Y&+ h6 A>0
®+' <lC .% &C Y&2 h6 * ' 'N: NSC p ' U 'Qw<
 - x! %S2 ::Q+ " M*. R Z iy Q+~ 3 E !m %Ž 7
6 ,; D 6 ,K* 4 U 'QwE :M U 'Q~ ®'5 5: C 
, * ' 'N: µš -2 3 E !m x! ,tJ :M U‰: ®'C
" M, 7 ( H& C k:'2 6 M<y  ²p 'QC iy  R 'H6 3 E
+ DC k:'2  U 'Q~ h‡H ;6Q< M*  h E !m *6
, +% ~  & - &* He S:2 h6 M:Q+ T g : &) f:' D. :*
7* xC Š E h!m 7 3<S, !m Tm %Ž 7 ®+' C  l2
h6 B:Q+ BN &
. ]& `^ ,  hJ l:* µš . " 4D
";^ B2$%m B< B<y * X g :C BC xQ+ 6 B, 7 RΠ:+
‚$ 5 A. 7 ƒ¬ I A&w P: H 4S h  œm ( C
" B6 X B:* 87 ;$  ¡:2 , ,  :~ ;l h  .6  * '
 W ; ^ C i* 6 
6  P: 4) BN '+ ¡€[ #J 7Q+
7* B:y $wQC : `+e 7 6 ;š 5* +lC ;%S - `^ C i* 6
N4S 6 :' (5l - <Q' U% 5' R\t 7* B< '
<l+ h6 %« BC `^  'Q $ MH C :'  
BC #% ~ +P - M< VS: U <1 µ P `H ®+'
- `^ B Š$6 %ŽC 6 7* E " 6&5 i
b2 .% &C ;$  AMH ""Q'
203
""B: ®+' <e

* ," Y BC Y/T +‰ : ]& h  cš - / " : #%M: &£6 aŒ &5 − 203
"351 V ,`C

111
#$% &'
"!       
  

B:Q+  Q+ 7* %« B^ 7* E h6 h!m L) 7* h E !m


<e  *m &* 7 Rg  :‡H %Ž . 7 ®+' <l+ h6
"? U*J  7 2 : %Ž 7 ®+'
7 g
 C k2* V €[6 X Ug&  7* <È T ; ^ H
, H* B*6 3 E , Π3 E x*6 \* B  7QH ,R 6 P: `+e
&+&' D+6 ¯ :. ? %Ž 7 ®+' C 5 lQ<  & H% B `¢ MH

jC g 5 %$ œm U%$ ? U S€[ R :2  N4S UT  7*
g :CJ \* 7Q+ MH , 7* h ,J ®'C - <È T G  - @5 MH
? %Ž 7 ®+' C 5 l+ h6 É .
P: H 4S h  7* 88 ;$  - A&w UT¹  A. 7 n~
X h  . 7* 87 85 83 $ U D* `5l2 B6 X ¡:2 
œm &´ B52* &S h E !m U*J `, - B  6 
M: n:+ 7* 6 g ,J v%< `¢ "g ,J v% % 5  P ;g

"L4S $ ;l* ¯<

,U*J C Y+ 7* `, -  :~ g  6&5 i


b2 ;$  AMH
"%Ž 7 ®+' <l ]& n S - `^ g ,J v%< l'2
 52* &S h+ h6 . O
6 µPC (P A& `^ . h6 >?
iQ+  h E !m *6 "g ,J v% % 5  P ;g
 œm °:+
"`^ . p 35+ \H 3 š ˆH
# BN -  0 #6 + + ;$  A. B
E # B .
h E !m Tm , v% œm % 5  P - - `, R  Œ Y&'C R+
:Z v% h+  ^ A. NH , D+6 ” 9  œm ° & 
 :~ 6 &  & H% p Œ“ 3    wC M<
7* .g :C6 35w6 †6 H* œm &:+ 7QE , - M< :Z .% 5 C

112
#$% &'
"!       
  

# A\ 6 A :
# R  - B6 x! X 2+ 204"  š >? \
<e  & x+s B `¢ MH , Œ 3 E x*6 h6 tu .&,6 BH R 
" / 7C + B   E , D+6 . BC 6 &  hJ ®+'
6 C$J B2 N:S* &,6 A1+ 7QE - ˆH S+  h E !m *6
B‡H ,Q'Q< \Q h E BjC \* BNS+ hjE , v% iy T U% 5'C BH+
MQ+ T BJ %Ž 7 ®+' <e Bv% Œ“ T A\ 6 88 ;$< 5e
<e - v% `, g MN ®'C /“ B . \t X "š 5* 1C
g&  q 5l2 M[6 7*  ; H &'C %Ž  !m %Ž 7 ®+'
,  C AE! - 7'l B%ª B+12 - U N:S* X #&'
205
" C$J - E2 X 2 +:'* %«6 M<E %«J A.
5 l p `¢ . 7+‹  v% KC 7* h E !m  Rg  Y W -
? É   n 6 # #:' %Ž 7 ®+' C
<e - /Q >? ‹  ,6 R, g MN KC \t % v &
# IJ 7* ( . %Ž . h6 % 5  X ,#:' %Ž 7 ®+'
k2j+ T *6 . ,A% 5  BHš S+ # g&  g ¡€1 BC i¢
206
"%«J A. * 7 ®+' `4+ T —  C /Q 7
h $ h E 7
&,m - U    ' /Q Q= D+6 B
E # B .
; H 3 3 E .% 6 hJ 7+‹  B4+ T Š$J ®+' h6 q%
k
jC '1+ 7 kl'+ Š$J ®+' h6 U:
i¶ 7 2 .&
207
"xC '1+ T Q' . Â<5+ T 7* ,; H g 

"196 V ,`C
* : h<
h+* − 204
U D+'  P C~ KC #&~ %Ž Y ,6
%$ œm &[ " : &'
) H YE6 − 205
"136 V ,2017 ,+Œ P:< Š' /E ,"  
"140 V ,`C
* : &'
) H YE6 : MN \W .  N2 hj[ - % − 206
"143 V ,`C
* :&'
) H YE6 − 207

113
#$% &'
"!       
  

{/&'- 3C K4 #U1! N  T)/ T/? yfdI : :


h6 7Q+ 7+ V €[J H'* VS€C lC *J h6 &5+ &
, Q+ 7 2 : %Ž 7 ®+' C 5 l  $ .&) Y 2
"%Ž - 5 &) Y&2  & A. h6 œ J <. 7* K5+ ,
Q+~ 2* h6 . n 5
J 7* Qw M A” i *J 7
- MN f<È gTb. ,V €[6 ;& C &, S€[ h+ T &
$% 6 H 4S h  h6 E "¯% 1* . * ,•6  H KC Q+~
H 4S :M* U St * k[2 ,hj1 . -  t U D*
h6 “  M~ H' l: Ap al &N 7* h E x " q  b*
"®+' C 5 lQ< 'C  &  & .&) B2
" B6 X ¡:2 .&w  :~ ;l h  7* 8 ;$  œm ( C
KE% 1 6 K›  6 K<J K< N &) &  & Y 2 h6 7Q+
"" M:  &* K b V €[J 6 Mv% &) , Q+~ n 2% -
7 2 : %Ž 7 ®+' <e h6 ;$  A. 7* MN+ ,
K›  &) 6 , Q+w< •J  N &) B+ h6 7Q+  Q+
n 2% - KE% 1 &) B+ h6 7Q+ E ,; :~ $&'2  , - Q+~ -
&* R b ¡€1 &) 6 ,gTb. 7* : BH 7* v% &) 6 , Q+~
R 6 X & M b* 7 K*j  , - K*j Eš . ,M:
" ” h*+  P:
* ,6 '2  :~ ;l h  - ;$% Y ,J A. h6 >?
H 4S h  -  t U D* $ Y&  , - Tm `5l2 T , *
U DQC g  A&w h  . œm ( C "  t S A% 5 C P:
~ 7 &  :~  b 22 ¡¬ H + J C `5l2  t
H 4S h  7* 95 ;$  QC x! , H 4S `+e 7 52
"  :~  b 7 +&^ 5
:QC MlC `5
 P:

114
#$% &'
"!       
  

;$ * `+e 7  Q+ n 2% R , - B‡H M< g :C 


h‡H ,  m N4 6 * 6 , % ;&+ 6 <Z 3 E g
N4
, ,A\ 6 95 ;$  - 7+%E V €[J &) B2 h6 “  &
Tm N4S ;$  n 46 &)  & H% 7Q+ T Bm , ,2 iN
". P:< +&* $ Y&  , -
B6 X MS:C P: H 4S h  7* 114 ;$  D+6 A&Eb2 * .
(5l ,  &) ,A$ Y&  , - ,P: +&* M* - R  Y&+
<e +&2 “ ,%Ž - 5   N4S 6 #% &
"%Ž< 55 U C  P ©+%   M[6  R\t ®+'
k:'QC , Q+w< •J  N 7 ±&42 A\ 6 95 ;$  h6 ­,\
7 52 * R 'HJ 7  :~  b &+&s œm °:2 †6
l52* . ®+' C <' 'C  &  & 7 " H 4S `+e
, p BC 2% 35v Q+~ 7 ¡€[  b* 3522 !‡H , *Q'  & C
Q+~ 7 } : %«J 7 & B b* ;% Ž C 2+ x! h‡H
" H
*6 , H 4S l
C P: `+e 7 2+ # < 5: C .
 * 
T tJ 
  5C 2+ # < 5: C
6 ¯C iN QC 4NS ,  `2 X 2  b h‡H , 
`<' ,  xE ,n 2 6 f2 M< 5: C  ,  6 ,+2
"    f4S % Œ ¡¬ H
{/&' K4 " Ž+ y,'06 : E:
* ' &  7* g :
 B6 X 88"13 % h  7* 113 ;$  ¡:2
+  &C Q4Q< V St + ,•4 V St¸ Q‰:
KC Π:  , - x! ,B< k & 6  & 7e* .!N ;&C
"   f4S 6 U 5l •_ KC K2 V €[J

115
#$% &'
"!       
  

Q4Q< V St &:+ M< k & 7e* $&'2  , - B6 >?


".&,6 7e* .!N ;&C + 
+  Q4Q< V St + 5:6 (5lQC *J `<'2 !m
h QC 6 n0 - 5:J (5lQ< Ä  * .!N ;&C
"B'+Œ2
B h+  Q+ - B< :w 6 % Ž H ;$  A. 4H
Q+~ g B^ # %Ž 7 ®+' C 5 lQ< A $ H% - % W
7e* 6 B:e* .!N ;&C +  &C Q4 œm B, - H
M:e* $&'2 ¡€[ 6 M 7* E6 M< k & h E !m "B< k &
<
 3 E !m *6 ".&,6 7e 6 B:e &C Q4 % ¬ h6 B<H
 Q4Q< &':+ V St :MH 5:6 (5l* .  - <Q'
h QC 6 n0 - 5:J (5lQ< Ä  * .!N:C &+
"B'+Œ2
7 2 : %Ž 7 ]& ®+'  $ ¡È U D A.
T . ,;%S - `^ C i 6  W ; ^ C i 6  6 
Q+ 7 2 : %Ž 7 ®+' <lC <' x<2 7 >E f<È
":<' 

116
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ ﺟﺮﻳﻤﺔ ﺍﻟﺴﺐ ﺍﻟﻌﻠﻨﻲ‬: ‫ﺍﻟﻔﺼﻞ ﺍﻟﺜﺎﻧﻲ‬

7* 3') d & q * f<€QC    * 3 E !m


#6 +,
% _ M
6% X  ,
&* *
&.6 `s 6
R$ 52 ,M:C H % ' ,V €[J KC < % `<t ,>5'
`<È  ' $ &4< Y 2 Y&. - ,U W n% w ,% HJ g%u
7*  A. R'
 h‡H "  %6 X U + 0 A. `s Y *6 /,
 A. R, , <5: U + 0 A. 7 4 & V €[J ®'C e
MD'C * 1  R$ 52 ,Y\ 7* . N  N P: g DH œm
"K'* f* R, #6 - \t $w h ,J  ? - ,®'5
KN ²H œm A&*  C 9 : 7* * ' X *J . °+ I
* ' U S€1 B  '2  x.  ,K'*  ;2
6 g 5e6 K* = 7*
"   * [ 
7*
  C H&M* K'* ~ ;2
J ²H 3456 &<H
  U\Q^ % :
 œm C : C H$ _    U S:*
NÈ Y\‰ - 012  '* ~ C ;2
J *E &M2   /'
208
" l
MZ 
% f<t ;% 2    
g% ;% 2
U% 5 BC ;2
J &,6 Y  , x! 7* E6 œm *J %l2 &
"209 ¯C i+ H    * B */ 
,  n 2% - M:* ®'5 ˆ
, h* 4 xE
 ,M\*Œ `, - h* = e 7*  U% 5 P %2 H$ ,

©+% C ,9 H #M~ (N * ,Q<' 45 — ' <'< C0 C : 7 %$  h C − 208
" 2020/05/17
,2018/11/27 ©+% C ,1090 $& 3s +$ EjC &CT Q4 7 %$ S ^   ‰6 − 209
"BH% `4< C %1:*

117
#$% &'
"!       
  

,210 ;%E ²p C h* 4 œm M* +% $ %&m œm """ n h* 4 ².
'Q [$ t ²* U% 5 R'
 X ®'5 Y&m p\t 7* :+
 Ug DNC * U 4N X H
1C B2 
b* B\*Œ
Ug DNC K1* P 6 R'
 g
E 7 $ 'C œm . &+ , 
AP 5C Y = $‡C Ì , g D %&6 & "  
`, -  .m  
U% 5 B:Q) š 5 5 :C +&H l*
211
"M* M M /* g :v6 K*Q KN…*
. C ,   * %M… * M‰+ I Q+wE 
;& - B~ *\
 '+P B 3)'2 ,h  Y& +& ¯<

h6 >? , +&^ M:* Q+& ') K D+6 B 3l2 E ,U 5


:*
- >5E 1C 3›
&    * hE - Xw+ &+&~
œm + x! ,U 
b A ™ V €[J KC 1   % 1
ƒ% t †C Ug DN A. •Q'* 7* &+&' & &+ # 9 ,
h $ MNJ h :' h<l+ M<'wH ,   g  5 a l
"7+tª V €[6 *E a, X x! i':H ,% 6 ,
- , M~ '* ;% «  N2 U% * ;& p k52  Q+wH x

"h  6  * X g
U l'* 7* &w
 * g)
v – R J 45 –  Q+ . * ŒCm R\t 7* x! X Q'
– ]  45 – MC E Q+~ A. h E%6 &+&s

R, ,""" n K* 4 ².  & 7 ;%$  ,2020/05/04 ©+% C 2020/04 $& +% $ − 210
"; * 4 :M H : UT\t U E< ®'C ()*
4: f<* - ,2020/05/14 ©+% C 50 $& 3s U QW C &C Q4 7 %$  , − 211
"%1:* >? ,2020/112 % i5<2

118
#$% &'
"!       
  

@A )/G U : P I l+3


x ,U N 7* BC Y+ * B'5e B, . gÊ . *
* [ f+'2 +&C Y  :* Ã2 :<'  Q+ .C e , H
./y  (6 } &+&s x! &'C v – R J <l –  YMN
− ]  <l – MD'C 7
W- W3'i/ r4 _^ @A ./&N : P I @%C
–   ;N – t6  7* BC B51+   /Q al 5
– œ J ;N – ,\l 0 BN+'2 X Q' 

@A ./&N : e I mQ


.6 &: BN+'2 X ':
,< * [ f+'C e , 6 7*
– ]  MN c\l - BN+' al x! &'C v – T 6 – 0<
−  v
% " @A ./&N : 6 

r
z %&S* 7* ;‹ ' C' 0< w'* - 
" n5‘ *z R'N ,n

r MH , 5Á
z ,
r
d ¨
‘ 5d

‘ ,
r d +z ,3d 5‘ 5z
z
"c%  Y\C B .6 #6 ,BC BQ[ : B<Q - °
z „ 

o
" &,6
z  { : Yz *6z Bd 5o
z 
o zd 2 zT" "Bd z:'z z ,Ad >z o z ,Bd Qzz [z 9 o Ñ
z
212
z z z : z Co  o& 
" . o
z Bd 'z lz z gz Ê
‘ o 
o
z
R& L+° ­N< a\e‡C g
1 0< 6 -  C $ H
2 1 k:'QC n  . 213"Bm Í*2  ®+% ' R'
C 6 B<
https://www.arabdict.com/ar : ]   ,3+$ n w'* − 212
"83 V ,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* A$% 6 ,1969/10/06 < 39 : 782 % 7'l − 213

119
#$% &'
"!       
  

0< - 1  , BH i Y\ L5 MH 1 *6 ,e 
214
"&, k:'* X
7QC B Sm 7Q+ # ' 4C $&'2  
6 h6 >?
: \* R + hjE ~ - ¡:C \ x h2 & , , Bm B+
' - ¡:C l52* 5 h+ & "fJ >5E 6 ƒ J 6 % J ´6
7C 6 ,(% 1 7C 6 ,ˆ< E ^ - ¡ 6 ,`£J ,50 C fH
- ¡ 6 "h 5~ ,€5 E : `<W - ¡:C \ < h+ & " /
n5 f + , . E >? h+ & "`
N ,`H : E : 7+&
"+/:W 6 %^ 6 < E U ^ &,6 NSC
FCD= " @A ./&N : :
g%$Œm . C ¡€1 fS2 h6 g MN c\l -  C &S+
) >^  E ,!J + * E ¡: - t&H ,¡
YJ E œ '2 – g\C 7* Í1C >5' ,&2 H  <
215
"VCJ
' 7* . ‰ h6 . N c 5S* - W & ,
X g %$Œ S:2 BE  YMN* - >5'  . % 5  0<
 .m + * E BH t&H . X ,1 * &4* B6 n5
< %^ ,gÏ \ ) C f  E ,B. n5
½ NJ 7* x! >? ,% J YJ VCJ ,&2 H  ,+/:W
*6 ,xp &SC Tm B*MN* `4+ \H B< ,  . ¡:< 5
216
" BH '2 \H n5 M*

"150 V ,1407 œ J '5l ,U >C < %$ ," ( } n E " :%: 7C .C &Q= − 214
"254 V 1 g/~, #% SJ ©1< 
 − 215
"441 V 1 g/~ ,W 
C6 &< . N c 5S* − 216

120
#$% &'
"!       
  

'+ # ]  c\l - D+6 ½4< . k:' . *
Î&¬ 6 BN &: ¡€1 %& 7* ˆ¢ >5'2 6 ' a Sm E . 
217
">0 & B'Q

>5'2 E 5
&'+" BjC ƒ a 7* 443 SN - Š0 (P BH ,
- xE BH "" :'* ' #6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [
;% 5 6 K1* 6 7 [ >5'2 E " BjC P: H 4S h  7* 83 ;$ 
"" :'* ' +6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 * 7* e , >s
T 
E " BjC  #° U C' h  7* 306 ;$  3H
P< [&t A 7* B #jC 7QD+ C :'* ' $ :
m X Q1+
"" % 5  6
' $ :
m . " BjC :Q U C' h  7* 291 ;$  BH
6   Bm U&:
6 7* n  35 J $  3 E  >0< ,% 
6 BHš Î&¬ C >0<  .m E xE ,B:e .6 &: A% , 35 6
""Bm :'* ' $ :
m x! 7QD+ h6 h $ A% 5 
7* E KC n% 2 `H2 $ U N+' A. R\t 7* ­,\
X x! ,#° Š0 K  - BN+'2 E < MN f+'
h  -  . * Q1 &Q+ N+'2 7QD2 # :Q +P \t
6  C M~ µ1+ I C' U '+P 5 ? \t X B6 E ,Š0
"Y h * - B  µ1+ I E ,c S
- *4 %*J 7* .   ,\l MH BN+'2 2 E 
A % # <
B< – X R
 +&, &C *\
 '+P
, &¾ ‘ Cz Œd 7‘ z , d 5z '‘ [d z:vz o&,z : R z z , ;z z z ‘ z 7d C‘ d&Qo z =d z:vz o&,z " : BH g  #% €5

UT S2 
`+e 7 &Q' ƒ Œ Q+ X  D U 5l2 " : <t .C K, − 217
"76 V ,2015 ,;%S: ,h  N %$ U%1:* ," +&^

121
#$% &'
"!       
  

B{ ‘ <z z do– Xo z o {5o: ho 6z o–


{  d&5‘ z {:vz o&,z : R z z Hz , { ²z { ‘ d 7‘ z ¾ { z Cz 6z 3d ‘ jz
z : R z z
"219 "¿ N‘ Ed Bd d z{ z ,218 a¿ d Hd { <{ ‘ d n {
d 5z
: R z z z <o
z z
n 5
7 ˆH <
B< – X R
 kM:+ I +&^ . NH
,h S' 7* &[6 `N ,`H x!   m ,®'5 MD'5 KQ<

7 k† œ '2 B 45
– hm C ,BC : KQ< X  x
h E , " p U< < $% 7* x! 7 2+  ,220 7+H 
{
5À + h6 – . M:H ,M< x! h $r >H ,% N h v 6 h5+ hQ<
" – C p < T <M Y¿  †J ”
M‰N, B2 ** E hSC h  +2 U& *\
 '+P H
U%‰4 7* h E x<H , 5 \QM* h  . 7+ <H ,KC ' 7*
221
" * +e #jC Ag+ * E 6 B) 6 B2 H°2 6 B5 - ,Bm ;g

Y ,6 #&. X Š0 +P M:* ') U '+P U%
&
*C iy  RJ 7* .  h6 U  H , *\
 '+P
5 B6 >? " M< n ' MQ+™ X 3<Q'H ,A% 5  BHš h 
7  /y :+j2% M< n ' µ š Q+~ A. h E%J  '

7z *{ À&[z 6z ({ P { { {{
‘ o d‘ - z .d z B
d %z z o– {  { z ez 7‘ z ƒ d ‘ ({ P
d d W ‘ o - z ƒ
{ d d W {
d ‘ 0z <À  -{ `d ‘ N‘  a
{ ¿ Hd − 218
d
‘d d^‘  z { <{ ‘ d‘ `„ ,z  { { { ‘ N{ Hz h S' aN N‘ ‘  dz {m AE œ z '2z do– R z z h { S'{ ‘ 
d ‰'‘ 2z +&^ z ‘ z z z ‘
¾ { z Š{ 6z n { z z d z Cz lz *d z .z 7‘ *{ z d{ z { ²z { ‘ d‘ Xzz $À  {
o Ad Dzz ‘ *d z `{ ‘ N‘ {C ` ,z >z { ‘ 0{C Bd 5o
z 7‘ *z Xzz
+&^ cš" z .z Rd d +z z <o
z z B‘ <z z – { do  Xo z À {5o: z Á ,z ‘ Mdd z z *z hdd 2z f z ‘ Ez R z z Bd o jzz E ‘ M‘d : z R{ zb<{
À
:]   C
http://hadithportal.com/index.php?show=hadith&h_id=48&sharh=1673&book=33
: M, š : *  ]   C %1:* ,48 % +&, #% €5 L4 − 219
http://hadithportal.com/index.php
o:+o zŒ xz { zzº E ◌ۗ ¾ <‘ { >z
{ ‘ 0{C   ‘& z zo– 5À d z Hz o–
{  h { $ 7*{ hd
d z ‘&+z 7z +{ o  5À zd 2 Tz z " : œ '2 BC x! − 220
"Y 'J ;%
7* 108 +u ,"h z <d Qz '‘ +z d zE z {C Mdd ²5„ z:d Hz ‘ Md 'd { ‘ *o {”„ %z œº z {m o vd ‘ Md <z Qzz ¾ *o 6d d„ {
"105 V ,`C
* :#Ë & &'
7C 7£ &5 − 221

122
#$% &'
"!       
  

K‰N< 7+. h 5C ®'5 & x! Bv&¢ # i5< ‰ 
"R,J  ? - ®'5 MD'5C
>? T4 @A ^ : E mQ
. BjC Š0  :~ h  -  f+'2 X :H'2 h6 : `5

E , :'* ' #6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [ >5'2 E


6 ¡€[ œm M5 6 ' g $m . h  . -  h6 D+6 :Q<
35  ²p 6 ¡€1 % 5  6 š iy ' A. 3 E !m , ².
" Mm
 h6 . KN+' 7+. % * R\t 7* B‰,\* 7Q+ * R 6
 H ,222 45 R 'HjC ˆ52+  :C , 45   jC ˆ52+ * 5 ?
'H a Sm X S:+  :C ,n5 C 45 N a Sm X S:+
9 * B h+ ›\E h‡H 'N 6 NS C *J `<'2 g
,  C L5
- &, B< &' `^ h+ x ,B*E B 3M 7* % 5 C
"BHš A% 5  6 ¡€1 *E . '* KQ+~
Tm ,MH … 6 † E%6 - g
h ” 12   Q+ h6 E
:w œm :'* ' $ :
m 7QD+ BJ  7* ;%lt &[6  h6
, 7QD+  h6 K, - ,   B * B'Q
œm gÄ+ _ B<
i' 223 " 5
7QD+  E hm B< ,BHš - B< &' iQ+ *
" H 7QD+ 
E i<H L4 >?
,B< &' `^ , 7*  * `N+  h E hm B6 >?
6 A% 5  B< :w š 7* R :+ ›\E , ,h E%J - B'* BC 1+

"13 V ,`C
* : 5w 7C &£6 − 222
"178 V ,`C
<* : &Q= Y\
h\[ − 223

123
#$% &'
"!       
  

Y+ T :5H Q+w< h 'N , 7* h N<¬ †6 Tm ,A%'[ c“
$  3 E  †j[ 7* :'* ' B< :w œm ] ~ &:
6 !m Tm 
a S‡C ˆH `4+  h‡H 224 "B:e .6 &: A% , 6 BC  2 h6
"Bm :'* ' $ :
m x! 7QD+ h6 h $ B< :w œm  6 N
`42 :C , H &'+ tª ¡€[ R * aË B6 K'* ¡€[ 7 R H
NSC BN x! Q+ !m ,a%
B6 ¡€1 . 7  !m  Q+
225
"Bm :'* ' $ :
m h $ : [
Q+wH , 7  /Q+ # °:' . h!m  - $ :
 H
[&t 7QD+ * C HH  *6 ,;$&= ' $ :
m µ12 
;% 5' 6 K1 >5' $ :
‡C Tm  Q+ Y2 T ,% 5  6 P<

m E! &+&4 x! - µ1+ T ,$&= ¡€[ œm >s 7QD2 
$S ¡€1 &+&s MD'C 6 $HJ l
 N+ C \* E ¡€1
226
"g : h &C t6 <
#jC U% 5' 7*
;&:   X n ' µ[ hE - Xw+ tª % '* ¯ :. B6 E
7* ;>tJ ;N &C ˆH  - m  - n<l* >? *6 .
- ;%    '2 T" B6 X ¡:2  88"13 % h  7* 83 ;$ 
M<  '+   3 E !m Tm   $ x+4 5*  f+'2
 hj1C ;%    X #F+ T *J . h6 :'+ * . ""h 
":<'
-  7 /Q+  h6 X &Ej 7Q+ `5
* X 
j2
,n5 œm 45 U NS 7* N $ :
m . B )* h+  hE

"618 V ,`C
* : %  &5 +ŒH − 224
"344 V ,`C
* :* w^ . e >Q
Y 6 − 225
 %$ U%1:* ," N4S *\  U '+P - L4S $ `," : L)<C l − 226
"38 V ,2014 ,/~ , Q<'

124
#$% &'
"!       
  

NS KC h [ " Q< L5 'H 6 ' $ :


m X YH  *6
"M:C  ^ i5< H+ KQ+~ KC aN $ Π+ _ , '
&:
 , " B6 NSC &CT Q4Q< , - g  x '52
œm ( C B6 >? ,UT  - g  # f œm ,M+ [ - K1
:1*   T 'H6 35+ B6 K5+ wM wl<5 R jC Y  C f
A% 5  7Q+ k,   6 $Z X °+ T , H '+ —  C K1Q<
227
"" 5

@A S : ;E @%C


,\l #0< f+' X  R\t 7* : M… &
+ Œ 7* Bm ‰ !m B6 >? ,B2 N U$&'2 hm &, ( X B6 <
– :<'  ¯ :. , ,K  X  hjC : K5
Š0 h 
–   ;N – :<' >?  − œ J ;N
%& @A : e I mQ
+ #  . ,BQ2 R\t 7* L) . E :<'  hm
C `42  - \' "E6 6 tª ¡€[ %D4C #6 , \
SNC Mm al 2 ;$&'* 
. ,BC (\e X >0 '™ <

+&4< 5
:* ¯ :. D+6 h
, C `<' R J SN - `$
":<'  Q+~ #$  7E ~ '* g :v6 M:
VS: :<' `s 
7* <
C 2 k* :<'  `4+
+6 - \' 
U$&,  88"13 % h  7* 72 ;$  - M<
” AN U&+&M 6 c S 6 lW l
C 
T 
 7* <

$& cË i5<2 4: f<* - ,2020/02/11 ©+% C NSC &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 227
"%1:* >? ,2019/2106/975

125
#$% &'
"!       
  

U 5l U C l
C *m , *Q' U  6 7E *J -
l
C *m *Q' U  6 7E *J - ) ' 6 Π6 '5
Y\  
f<’ l
C *m YQ' % ‰6 X ) ' U S<
* $  0 p Q'2 t6 <
+6   6 +°5 'Q
"  m
hJ "B*& 7* n5 6 B< :w %D4C ; T B6 ´&5 7*
 X  '+ , ,B< :w ;Ž, -  + h6 µ1+ T h 
BQ
 E! & h+ h6 µPC ,Bm B ¡€1 n ? - %&  :<'
228
" H E :'2 B: 6
 KC ˆ<È 3Œ T E 4 ®'C h6 œm ;% [ 7* &C T B6 >?
BC 2% C M * ' C : MH 3'C 2 Π NH ,:<' >?  :<'
g DC `<' 42"10 >M… 7* 16 ;$< 5e :<' >? 1  N ’
B6 .$ N* + 1C Y&2 1 h6 - M'  ¡€<2 "B2  St n
,# N0  5
J a C &,J Y+ $  # ,2015/10/25 ©+% C
a t$  %J ÎH C Y+ h E  , , 5 :*   —,
k1 C j N2 ,5< "9&' C/" - <Q B'<
 '  5
J
]  * h $ BQ1+ B5+ 6&C x! 7 AFN
  ,x! 7* B':Q+ BC
B6 c‹ """ &. 1 Ž, """ 2016/05/03 <wC f< ƒ%$m X g :C """
®'C t‹ Q
# N? &,J  5
J a C ˆ5D C ±$ ^ Y+
hT$ 5+ M 1 & KHl 7* n  , *\ U$ 1
¯ C 7+$ ,x*6 7+$" U% 5'C 1 + M h6 M:C 1 
 5
J a C ˆ5D C ±$ ^ Y+ B6 c‹ """ &. 1 Ž, ,""""
 hT$ 5+ › 1 M &. [ B6 ,« , h E # N? &,J

"213 V ,`C
* : * K, 4H − 228

126
#$% &'
"!       
  

K, - "x<, #$ ?" 1Q< R+ h E M h6 ND* ,M:C 1


œm + M:C (/: 5
h6 &. 1 ND* , C  U% 5'C 1 BC 6
B':QC Y  M h6 Tm M[N+ h6 1 $%6  5
J a C )%6 'l
a C ˆ5D C ±$ ^ Y+ B6 c‹ """ Y Y &. 1 Ž, """ M:*
M 1 & ,%lN 5 B :2 &'C ,# N? &,J  5
J
C  U% 5'C """"¯ C 7+$ x* 7+$" U% 5'C M:C 1  hT$ 5+
* Qw:* Ug  $M1 ;$ M[ hm , """ K5~ B &:+ ˆ
Y\E
1 [ C Y  M hE MH i5 T  D lC D Y *6 p6
% h  7* 16 ;$  ‹ : 12 B2 . B6 h6 , C  U% 5'C B) -
A\ 6 E! _ \l Q4 h6 B2  St n g DC `<' 10"42
7* B2tb* K'+ B, - 3C v A\ 6 M œm  * hjC 3':
229
""B<6
7e* `, - 2 #  h6 * ' C : U   ^ . NH
X M 3'C H ,:< >? 
. $M[ ±\v %D4C  5
6 aC
M $‡C 3* H ,^ ². D+6 BEŒ # *J . ,9
J .
"$M1 ;$ M[ R\t 7*  p 35v *&'C ,:<' >?  N €QC
hJ ,9
6 #6 X &:* >? h  VS: N ’ A ' B .
Y h * -   k* 352 SNC M: +&^ `5
E :<'
 5
6 a
-  + h6 '+ fH ,&, ¡€[ 7* E6 Ž4QC
I x! 7* E6 C ? :< >? 5
Q4 A '2 $M[ ±\v %D4C
&:
  i
J h C E :<' °: 1 : 2 C %E ^  '+
":< >? 5
h E 1 B  '2 #  hjC R< M<

2016/07/11 ©+% C ,U  C &CT Q4 ,&Q= C +C  G  /E* 7 %$  , − 229
"%1:* >? ,2016/18 $& U N ’ n g D f<* -
g D f<* - 2016/05/16 ©+% C ,  D M~ iN 7 %$  , D+6 B
E B iN
"%1:* >? ,2015/124 $& U N ’ n

127
#$% &'
"!       
  

Y ' (% 1 -   C `<'2 Π - ,B iN: +2


A&w  :~ h  7* 444 SN U D ( C " B6 Q4 U  
( 7* :< Ã+ MH xC , H 4S h  X C' - R ,6 &
K52 , ":<'   Q+ Y  .H2 (P k0C V t
T R ^ Π - BC '  h6 Π:   M
%$ &'C Q4Q<
6 U C 
C *Q 7+ I B ,:< >? 5
Tm h+ h6 &'+
T ,   
 C 6 #°5 'Q R S2 
C 6 U 5l
L+° B2 . R ^ K'+ _ ,]  B*MNQC  * œm k+
230
"" M:* B2g C L+° x! 6 7* B2g C
, , M<<'2 - H* 72 I Q4 hjC R ^ . X <'2
VS€C H 4S h  X R ,6 *&:  :~ h  hjC U   †m
R ,6  :~ h  h6 R ^ ,V t ( 7* :< H2 <l+ MH C'
:+ ‹ :' ¡¬ H i ˆH C' ¡¬ H H 4S h  X
h  7* 444 SN >N2 Ug
6 & Q4 h2 —  C , Q+~
H2 ?%  4: 7* M x '52 U6C
z ,B<Q¢ I * B<£
z  :~
(% 1 - c S l
C `s # :<' °: MH C , <* E .‹ :
"Y '
l
C °, + h6 B< n ' - µ1+ T :<'  h6 x!

7* <
#jC `4+ . C """ U%1:* 6 U C* H 4S
Y ' (% 1 C 2 &  h6  e ,A\ 6 72 ;$  - .&+&s 2  :<'
35  & h2 Q4 ,:<' >?  7 +&4< R Z T B‡H
7+ I B :< >? 
. Π: A. -  h6 U    nS
#°5 'Q R S2 
C 6 U 5l 6 U C 
C *Q
"   
 C 6

% cË Ä5<2 4: f<* - ,2019/12/17 ©+% C NSC &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 230
"%1:* >? ,2019/2106/1416

128
#$% &'
"!       
  

Q4 B
E # B * w:+ B:  # B .
<
Tm . * Bm n: M % m " h6 U    U+% C &C
&E6 # a n &. 1 ;$ M[ A&:N2  :~  b 7* ¡<Q 6 7*
"Y ' (% 1 C &w Y *6 " $ " ;% 5'C 1Q< M  '
% 5  š iy 1Q< M M5:+ ' "$" ;% 5 hm ,
h2 _ ,Y ' (% 1 - c S l
C 3y ,Bm 35 # ¡€1
B, - Q  P: H 4S h  7* 47 SN< :+ ‹ :' B'*
231
"" M<6 7* B2tb* K'+
<
+jC `4+ :<'  hjC R A\ 6 B<SN2 `5
 &Ej2
B< >2 # B h6 , H 4S 
C ˆH i \' °: `s
?% Π: - $M1 M 
 ?% :< >?  % 5  - E 4 ®'C
,B44S2 K'+ nS<  Z B2 . ,*Q h * - S, & BE
3s h‡H , :< B  . :<' >?  7 :<'  /Q+ * hJ
h:H :<' `42 I !m *6 , 4: . # :<'  Y *6 :E \'
" N ’ . # :<' >?  Y *6
%& 8[ @A : E mQ
&+&s n g D ‰:C `<' 42"10 % h  7* 16 ;$  ¡:2
.%$ 700 œm .%$ 300 KC c 2 *0C  '+" B6 X 232 B2  St
:   ~ 52*
; fNW g+ 6 f:' R 6 52* −

,11/1241 $& 4:~ f< - 2013/02/26 ©+% C U+% C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 231
"%1:* >?
17 R `H 1432 h D*% 7* 16 - %$ S 1"11"151 % f+P >M‰ AN:C %$ S − 232
"4392 V ,¦2011 Q5
5 ¥ 1432 R[ 6 ©+% C 5975 $& Q
 ;&+~ ,2011 il?6

129
#$% &'
"!       
  

; :<' >?  52* −


" """"" −
hjE ,:< >? 1C 2 &  h E !m B‡H ;% [ 35
E h!m
NSC 6 n5 3C - + 6 ,n5 œm ;š 5* <2 
% \* +
h+ B‡H ,n5 >? h tª V €[6 A&M1+ I ,V t h * #6 - *
`<' h  7* 16 ;$< DÈ N ’ h  ‰ - '+ :< >? 5

"n g D ‰:C
lC D Y *6 M U ¢°2 " h6 Q4 U   $&S . -
 R$ 5C Y  BE MH i5 T <
*  e 7 Ug   D
7* 16 ;$  ‹ : 12 B2 . B6 h6 , C  U% 5'C 1 * 1
_ \l Q4 h6 B2  St n g DC `<' 42"10 % h 
B2tb* K'+ B, - 3C v A\ 6 M œm  * hjC 3': A\ 6 E!
233
"B<6 7*
4:  7* '+ * KC /Q % '* h6 œm B5: 7* &C T :.
,K'* *6 6  $ :
m X Q1+ R J hE . i , N ’ B:* '+ *
H2 &* . C ,% 5  9* : Î&¬ * $Z X Q1+ ]  hE
k* 4: '+ % 5  P< Î$ t 
H "B*& 7* \' °:
>? - + 
E ,K'* *6 6  X \Q1* 7+ I  , \ 
234
"K'*  $ :
m X Q[ hm N ’ MH \
®'C - D+6 A&w :<' >?  :<'  KC /Q .
:<' >?  7* A% &C '“ # ÄN +P E %  U '+P

2017/04/17 ©+% C ,U  C &CT Q4 ,&Q= C +C  G  /E* 7 %$  , − 233
"%1:* >? ,2016/65 $& U N ’ n g D f<* -
"338 − 337 V ,`C
* "+ g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
" :<l &5 n ´m − 234

130
#$% &'
"!       
  

U C' h  7* 2/621 ,1/621 ,9/387 $ ÌQC M<  '+ N ’


"ÄN
" B6 X ¡:2  ' U C' h  7* 435 ;$  D+6 E E
+&, - 6 \ >? 7* B< :w M* -  6   !m
hH t6 l
C x! B0<C6 6 Bm BC 'C n* - 6 B'* ]N<2
6 % :+$ K¶ X &+/2 T *0C M[6 
X &+/2 T ;&* i5^ C'
""KC' K2 . &,‡C
,:<' >? :<'  KC A/y ?% ' (P h6 ­,\ H
, ,:<' >?  X n ' - Š0 A>‰ 7* $&12 E6 h E &H
B 6 # Š0 +P \t X " 5, C B 6 4: B<'
 R&'* ( N2% - . + _ ,.%$ 700 Πw2 T *? 7 ;% 5 C
"A + 4D (P .H+    +^ f') 5C :<' >? 
$  = :<' >?  :<'  KC /Q . h E &
K BC Ut6 # 6&5 h6    7+ g MN ®'C e 7* &+&[
At6 %MQ~ X <) N ; ^  H B

6 \' - ')
*E h/2 K A. '“ _ ,9 : Y *6 * C Œ/  * 
 C
3r *d !m BQ B*E X ­H 4H ,KQ B '™ K/QC h 
M1+ h6 h $ 3S 3r *d !m BQ B*E %&q ,9 : Y *6 3S
a N: g + ; , 9 : X h   N+ . ,9 : KC x!
;/ T p *E T  €[6 M:* '“ ´0+d .~ 7 MH°+d
;g  C  . ‰+ h6 g NW - h g 1+ * MN: <4+ h6 MQ<'+ MH
 . ‰+ h6 g NW - 3* !m  %+ T M* 5D0+ T h6 ;% Ml
235
" \ - 3* !m D0 C

"479 V ,`C
* : ;$ %$  &5 − 235

131
#$% &'
"!       
  

X  '+ L56 h  hJ nS< $ S* &: . h6 


By BN:C AŒ/  h  QH , Q+~ UC ´ T Q+~  …
"%MQ~ Y *6 h E !m * KC A&, h E !m * KC BH `+N “ T B*C
7 TΠ:2 ,BH h  N 7 TΠ:2 :'+ B*E 7 h  RΠ:2 hJ
E 7 RŒ :+ 7 7Q+ ®+'2 T , D+6 q 5 7 ,   a^
Y *6  h  7* * (/ ,h  '5e ® :+ ME RŒ :2 ,gÏ
" BH Q  (/ . ,BN
† M‰N, X P 3N2  iQW U% Ž 7* B6 x!
,BS€[ B*E iQ+ * E 7* B‰N, h  š  ' + £ .
!m * KC aN2 I 236"BQ[ T n 5
T  T L+wC B< R l+d \H
" \ 6 Ë 2 & R l . h E

"94 V ,`C
* :#Ë & &'
7C 7£ &5 − 236

132
#$% &'
"!       
  

%& @A )/G -4 5 : ;E l+3


h  - M< VS: ~ f<’ %? X  Q+ hm
7* x! – R J <l – ;$&= h E%6 H2 œm M*  - ƒ s , :~
− ]  <l – MHQC (P .6  C' R/m 6
%& @A )/G 5 : P I @%C
#$ * ›&,6 K:E% œm :<'  Q+ ƒ s ,t6 Q+ #jE
−   ;N – #:'* tu – œ J ;N –
9 T5 : e I mQ
7 [ >5'2 E BjC  '+ A&w ƒ a 7* 443 SN œm ( C
f+' iN . , :'* ' #6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6
SN QC B< R 4 B:* 83 ;$  - P: H 4S h  A :52 #
>4 U% 5 hE &N2 ;&, ;% 5 H )m * , :~ h  7* 444
" * 7* e , h2
B6 X ¡:2 .&w 88"13 % h  7* 83 ;$  œm ( C B6 E
$%  k, ,: `+e 7 6 ;š 5*  6  P X  '+ """
.$&¢ I 6 M:'+ I ². 6 ¡€[ œm M* h E 6 x1 0SC P: .
;$% U% 5' R\t 7* M< ' 7Q+ 7 ¢‹ NC P: .
,U S< 6 U 5l 6 U C 6 U&+&M 6 c S 6 lW -
"  6 v5 6 ;%1: K* D E *w
Q+~ #$  7E h6 : K5+ U D A. g
 R\t 7*
#6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [ >5'2 $ :
‡C `4+ 
–  v – K'* ¡€1 M*  U% 5 h2 h6 − T 6 – :'* '
−  v – :<  h+ h6 v

133
#$% &'
"!       
  

&  9 3A T)
'N 6 1  8R m34  T d 83&N L : 6 
&
[$ t U% 5 BC  N Y  `+e 7 $ :
 . `4+
*% $wQC `4+ MH "B >s 7QD2 6 ,B< :wQ< % 5  6 P<
* :'* ' B &:2 h6 h $ A% 5  BHš Ag , Î&¬ C B< :w
237
"R = 6 ¡ BjC B< :w f2
h $ c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [ >5'2 $ :
‡C  h+ h6 µ[ H
. hm ,  7  /Q+ # . :'* ' 5 +6 7QD2 h6
" ' A. $ :
‡C Tm `4+ T >tJ
;% 5 E Q1H c& >4 U% 5 7* A>? 7 1 >5' *6
BH t&+ B\em X k:' . ,B*E 7* ˆs 6 B< :w š iy
>4 `4+ ,' $ :
m ¯ :. h+ T & ,n' $ :
m D+6
6 ,<E 7C 6 <E 6 h, B6 tª 7 R+ 7QE , * C 9 
238
"$ N œm k'+ 7* R 6 – `<t 6
6 B: R+
5 B< :w œm M :+ I  2+ ®'5 ‰ -  H
6 h, B6 B: BE B B%$Π7 4H m K'* >? 6 :'*
Y  # M NSC &CT Q4 3$6 % e . - 239 "<E
<E BjC tª ¡€[ p\t 7* fS+ ] m QC ;% 5 7+ &C
240
"n6

"158 V ,`C
* : &[% kNlS* h N+* − 237
"72 V ,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* − 238
"77 V ,`C
* : <t .C K, − 239
>? ,17/2172 % 4: f<* - 2018/10/01 ©+% C NSC &CT Q4 7 %$  , −240
"¦`4< - \* E ^ ¡ ‰6¥ ,%1:*

134
#$% &'
"!       
  

>s 7QD+ # >5' 6 ,K1 >5' l


C `4+ h!m  H
N X <Q' ;% 5' #l:2 h6 N+ ,¡€1 C B ^m + ,& 6
>5' '5e +2 h6 <' * ,g#&C 6 K1* 6 c%  ­N 6  6
X K'+ xC ,x! +&2 g D< + ,h */ h  , f<¬
%SC C1* MQ, h E Tm  ½ N6 MQ, - E2 h6 Q4
241
"n 5
J
,tu h * 7* f<¬ M '* ½ NJ R'
H M 7* B6 x!
- xE '+ T & ,h  . - ,& 5
'+ H ,tJ ²C 7*
t&2  R 'HJ &+&4 ++& l< G < k52 x ,tª h *
#$  7E 12  ½ NjH t6 M 7* " M*& 7*  7Q)
&C T x , .H2 &* 5* - ,\S ®: Q4 Q+w<
M M<Q'
  U% 5' L) 1C Π2 h6 ^ ;%&S* Q4Q<
Q2 3 E hm MH ,B*  Y& 6  Y  3S<€
 fE  -
, M< ) '   ½ NJ 7*  ' V\€
T ++&2 l<C
"<' Y&'T ®:< ) h E Tm B552 MQ, <'C */<* †‡H
^ h6 % 7* " B6 +° ®: Q= U   % e . -
h C X B2C Q1+ h6 B4S “ :<'  Q+ - $ C %$ S
H B52 h6 ®: Q4 k:+ k, M< Ag D k:C   ½ N6
% M‰
 M, :* K5  = ½ NJ 45C    : 7* B52%
242
""L4S B X h  , R/ q% 5 **
Q4 7 %$  , E Š0 g D Y *6  U 5l2 7*
'+ <* T B 7+$ T BjC B< :w f h6 BH U   µ C C &C

"38 V ,`C
* : L)<C l − 241
V ,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* A$% 6 ,1984/06/12 < a 53 : 7462 % 7'l − 242
"75

135
#$% &'
"!       
  

 U% 5 7* QZ 7QD+ Bm % 1 R  h6 " ; '* B, - 5

4: hm , ,¦B &[% T 7, T ,B 7+$ T <* T ,*\ m ¯1*¥
f+' :<' L5 f $ :
m #°: H2 M*  <l2 
L) 1C A\ 6 B * - ,‹ &:
6 BC k1 hm , ,Bm &: C
4:~ :+ ‹ :' h‡H """ 1 š iy 45   6 •
243
"" M<6 7* M ;tb* K'+ R ^ Π - ;H* 
R/0 U% 5 B2 h6 h%  BN 7*   + a  iN -
œm x! Œ  Y6 $w ge ;% x! È g
p 
. ;6 œm
A. … - _ ? X 5
R/0 % 5  < , M 4C ’ ¯<
X M,
#6 7* M:
= gem 52 †6 ;6 RC  H 7QD+ B6 gem 7*
7QD2 !m ,) E6 *J h+ , N+P ;6 ¯<
>? . ,¡€[
244
"g ^ C ’ ¯<
X , R/0
" B6 U    +° ®: Q= g D D+6 A&+b+ #6 .
+ Y\
+ [ C + KH ¢% " `+l - M< :wQ< M B2 5
&'+
% t < . ‰ 36 xQ<E6 6 Y, . [ C + #$% >W c 5
c™ .% 5  MHš - M< :w Î&È ½ N6 A. h‡H "@<'* \ Œ
245
"" M*E
- M+ D* 6 ;6 - R/0 hjC R % . X :5'2 -
,R &  3456 *&'C , :< 5
A% 5  Πw 7* L56 & (% 1

08/69 % ;š 5 + 1 f<* - ,2009/03/13 ©+% C µ C C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 243
"50 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,08/70
"333 V ,`C
* ," + g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m − 244
,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* A$% 6 ,1940/02/26 < a 10 : 355 % 7'l − 245
"77 V

136
#$% &'
"!       
  

;6 C Ä:~ Î4 X  '2 +&, U '+P2 X H2 ,n0 M:*


E h‡H —  C 246":<' < ;% x<2 7* *‹ &[6 E6 U C'C
<E x! :< 5
i : [s .% 5  “ Ä: g ¢m U! ;% 5
";6*T MM2 2
B& hfi  G @A M34 N  : :
¡€1 &+&s M U% 5 3:QD2 !m Tm  Q+ Y2 T
I * %S* >? % 5  P X g&  hjC x! <'+ ,B< :w
&+&4 . h+ h6 <l+ T (P 7 "`^ . B h+ ¡€[ &+
9 : 7* ²N :_ h+ h6 BlC ) , 5 h+ hjC N+ m , $
247
"B< :w X '
7QD2  ;% 5' 6 K1 >5' $ :
‡C Y2 h!m  Q+wH
¡€1 
m E! &+&4 . - µ1+ T B6 >? ,$&= ¡€[ œm >s
7* $S ¡€1 &+&s MD'C 6 $HJ l
 N+ C ,\* E
248
"g : h &C t6 <
#jC U% 5'

Q+~ 52* &'+" B6 X ¡:+ #  :~ h  7* 503"1"2 SN Y ,J 5e x! − 246
.%$ 10"000 œm 2000 7* *? M[6 
œm &, M[ 7* i5^ C  '+ Ä:~ Î4
:   UT ^ - >0 + D* - 7'*6 7* E KC' K2 . &,‡C 6
6 : '5e U! U% [m 6 R6 6 R 'HjC 7E *J 7* .>? 6 *Q' Ug DN - -1
" :  ?J
6 : '5e U! % 6 U\w2 6  m 6 N2 . 6 C* 
% l
C -2
" :  ?J
Y ‰: ­N4C KN< V €[J 7* 6 Q' - \*Œ 'N 2* h E !m C' f D2 -3
"" .>? 6 *Q' Ug DN - 7*J
"334 V, `C
* ," + g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m − 247
"38 V ,`C
* : L)<C l − 248

137
#$% &'
"!       
  

6 ;% '* g
jC 9 : & hH '* . V €[J 7* >H
6 M:MQC Ml= - '2 ²H xE &2 ,M
jC hH'+ _ E6 ,U :E
NS A”  ½ N6 h NH x , :'* t6 U N 6 MH,
T ,B< :w S€[ &+&s X &< H E h E k* % ' 
 6
m U  5 ;C 3 ; ' H ,B+.  C 6 ^ BQ
 E! µ1+
7* &+&' & MC *<'* M<' B< :w S€[ X & C
"9 :
 U% 5' + NE &* &+&4C S€ . () Q= '2
7*  Q+ BC Y2 H E &+&s B< :w $&, BjC R< M .E!
. &'+ , Π: C l4 U C\ U l' } g) - x! ,B*&
"®: Q= e 7* M< '2 T    7* *J
Q4" B6 BH U   +° ®: Q= 7 %$  % NH
 …  U% 5 7*  Bm B 7* ¡€[ '2 h6 ()
B< :w 
m E+ <H ] ~ µ , !m BN:E  U C\ BS,
U C $S ¡€1 x! 7* Q4 3 5
 k* B2% 5 - ,‹
249
"" ®: Q= & Bj1C R&~ ;% vm Œ™ \H
%4 @A /  : E:
,:<'  Q+ Y  h E%6 7*   7E . \' °: hm
 , \' 7E% H2 h &C Q+~ A. Y  7 +&^ 7Q+ T Bm ,
>?  Q+ Y *6 ¯ª h , ,tJ h E%J  C UH2
":<'  Q+ Y *6 i , M: +&^ f<
 :<'
:'2 F \t . .N . R * X Æj2 \'
M~ ,*J % M…m :'2 J - \' h‡H xC ,*J %M…

,`C
* : B. #&Z kNlS* A$% 6 ,1938/04/18 < a 8 : 1302 % 7'l − 249
"77 V

138
#$% &'
"!       
  

6 R 6 'NC %MQ~ < R S2 #6 ,P: (1 (+ % 1T


†j[ , - R ^ . <*  - #. °: . 250"y 6 C E
 Q+ - \' g N h6 >? , \' l
C 2  ~ hj[
251
" N ’ œm 4: 7* R42 m , Q+~ B'* N:2 T
” `42  
 iN:C :<'  Q+ - `42 \'
    * `+e 7 
T , Q+ -
T B‡H ,R J SN - SNC M: +&^ `5
& Bm , ,  
"B<SN2 2 * %  $
- AŒCm µP . H2 ;% « X &Ej  x! * 7
:<'  Q+~ C' C G  ^ H " $ C G  ^ ¡
LS+ T \' ” 3s   ‰ 6 h  E! X V¢ h6 “
µš ŒCm . x! 7* + 0 252"< N \' ­N EC g NE
" Q4 ” BS<€
  +l \'
  ‰  ½ N6 h 52 ;% « X &Eb+ #° g D H
+° ®: Q= U&E6 &H " \' °: ŒC N+ C MH S,
 RS, M:* µ š H2 h6 U C 265 ;$  `5l “ B6 X
7* C v QM h6 E! X ^ °m !‡H ,k*Q N= 6 = - #6  :<
 ½ N6 E! X ;‹  ]&  & ;$ M[ 3 E ]&  & ;$ M[
h E ÒSt 6 *Q . .  BH S,  4 h C h &C

  ¬% 2
%$ : *\
 '+P -  :~ `4 Ugm " : Ä &Q= %$  &5 − 250
"197 V ,2019 ,œ J '5l ,U >C , Q<'  %$ U%1:* ," % *
"39 V ,`C
* : L)<C l − 251
"17 V ,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* − 252

139
#$% &'
"!       
  

:<'  - \' µš n '


 6 7* 253"BD  5 \
 e C ^
"h%  Š0 g D - B2 5l2 ®'C $% & 1C
' f2 X Q B6  Q+~ Š0 g D U 5l2 7QH
C : h6 - M'  ¡€<2 Œ  NH ,:< >? 
†jC f2 p 
7* 16 ;$< 5e :<' >? 1  N ’ BC 2% C M 3'C 2 * '
BjC +&My   M h6 "B2  St n g DC `<' 42"10 >M…
N2 .  * k<2 < fS:* —, 2015 :
7* CE6 M[ hD? -
BQ[ B5
- (š R : BN2 . %E 1 7* """ B& %
\
l 7'<+ – " U% 5'C B< $% BC S 6 x+ I ¯ª , C  U<C
Q4 U   , """ "T 7 Bl'2 3 E x*6 , 54 & + x* R +$
T <
*  e 7 Ug   D lC D Y *6 M U ¢°2 h6
B6 h6 , C  U% 5'C B) - 1 [ C Y  BE MH i5
n g DC `<' 42"10 h  7* 16 ;$  ‹ : 12 B2 .
M œm  * hjC 3': A\ 6 E! _ \l Q4 h6 B2  St
254
"B<6 7* B2tb* K'+ B, - 3C v A\ 6
. - Q4 U   \'< <
i f2 p hE * [H
+ % e . - " 4: i N ’ B2   :< 7+ I  h6 ^
T , Q+~ ( X q! - #l:2  N< U v$ 4 h6 g MN ®'C
, Q+~ Q¢ T h  H ,h  BQ¢ `^ \= h2 hJ q! - L<S2

% 4N ( 2 Q QZ 01 : 0262 % 7'l - +° ®: Q= 7 %$  % − 253
: ] ET  C %1:* ,1931−06−11 ©+% C 341
https://eleslam-elqanon.yoo7.com/t1702-topic
,2017/01/02 ©+% C ,U  C &CT Q4 ,&Q= C +C  G  /E* 7 %$  , − 254
"%1:* >? ,2016/60 % U N ’ n g D f<*

140
#$% &'
"!       
  

% 5  P - `^ . , Q+~ B< U&  # `^ Q¢ m


255
" `+e 7 M B< &  #
H2 R, B+6% ŒC U 5
:* ;& B 3426 &H #° g D *6
²C - f2 .  ½ NjC : l % Mm h6  H  - :<' µš
xH ½ NJ x<2 M'} ;%' h 
Q
4C &'S %wC <
Π - 256""U C' h  7* 171 ;$< 5e \' x<2 U 5v  E
^ n 5
6 7* BC t6 H g
BH h'l ^ h E !m" B6 &E6 t6
- 3v&, &  ' h6 B:* $ N+ <Q BC 5
6 - A$% 6 * 6 &C
* B ¡St #  0 - T B'5e - i R/: <r
h E "R/: <r

7* $& $ $ S2 !m Tm xE h+ T . *  * A% 5 C LQ+


M 
6 X $+ 4C h &+& h 
B:l+ R/: h E 6 ,BH %MQ~ $H6
X M'Q“ # R/: x! <r
X  6 
7* BC M~ 7* + *
257
".$& ;E
h * -  &  hC 3 7+% 7+. , h!m ; ' H
`s h‡H ,%MQ~ e 7* M 
 U% 5 ! N &QC C V t
"V t h * -  h E  \' 3s x!
- \' 7E% % M‰
 - N+ " B6 D+6 #° g D   E
n: ½ N¤ M R
%m 7* H* B6 ^ R+ h6  Q+
258
"" Y ' `+l X <l R/: Hš - . B:* .% &

&  P* w, , :~ U 5v -   5  P* &* " : c – &5 #b − 255

%$ :  :~ U 5v - US ;%S w, *  :~ @N 7* &Q ] 
"136 V ,2018 œ J '5l ,+Œ P:< C' U
%& /E* ," % *
"357 V ,`C
* ,"+ g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
" :<l &5 n ´m − 256
,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* A$% 6 ,1990/03/08 < a 58 : 6625 % 7'l − 257
"115 V
&5 n ´m ,736 V ,h C QZ ,1954/11/12 < ,a 24 : 1928 % 7'l − 258
"355 V ,`C
* ," + g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
 " :<l

141
#$% &'
"!       
  

½ N6 3' !m Tm H2 T " +° ®: Q= , \' H
h'l ^ h E , H$ S C Y6 B'5lC g
Y h * -  6 
h6 h $ .&) h'l 7* Y *6 h E  h6 X B2  &* - ° & BH
.&) h'l [ 3 E ,Q (+ USC BC M~ S, & B6 K5+
 * .% 5 C LQ+ * B 3SSt #  0 - T M'5e - 3
7* '™  ‹ :' M‰+ I !m BH h'l ^ h‡H x! h E  " *
`s fE B:* K5+ T *& ;%S X * \= .&) h'l 7*
h+ B‡H h  . -  RS4C  & ' - \' H2 7*
259
"" BD + B5'+ %S ‹ 
 QMC M h$6 &H ;&4 C' U% *  &C g D *6
3 ,6 * ' C : hE - M'  ¡€<2 Œ  - n 2 `5l2
Î&È 
r U% 5 ,¡€[ œm Æ w2 - B !m QE 4 œm  M*
20 ;$<  5e B5 'QC 5 l* ,Ôn 2 Ó * C A% 5  B'Q
BHš
h6 "U *<' :2  4H * hj[ - 2012 : 5 % h  7*
QM 7 M[6 v\v ;& i5^ C M 5 'QC 3D %$ R 6 Q=
. ,U:
±\v ;& ++/' C' N:2 fC U*6 Bm C:
/2* ,®: C B< Y4 BH 7'lH , :²
T Q= B2&+6 # ^

7* <
`+e 7   r Q+ h E%6 hE X B:'e -
2 e * 2 U 5v $M[ % m ,;H* >? U *<' :2
U5v  C $S ¡€1 &+&s 7* a% J <t ,B< :wQ<
*& V f2p  ,‡C B5<e 7 ^ U N ,BN<2 Y q +&E
+ _ RJ - §% S ® : ,  :H MS4H  :~ € œm
:'+ 
r h6 4)* ,7'l 3DH% <' +$ s Q4 h6 >? "BD

,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* A$% 6 ,1990/11/13 < a 59 : 15799 % 7'l − 259
"115 V ,`C
*

142
#$% &'
"!       
  

B<Ss - G  Bm 7²Ql+ C ,B< R& L+° ­N< a\e‡C 1
N+ C   t  &S Q+~ Y  h  <l+ T  &  MN
`+lC 6  ¢‹ h+ & r Q+ - $ :
 h6 E ,Y ' &S H2
h6 % 7* B6 œm U% [6 "½ NJ R&QC ; ' ;% & 6 +%
 U% 5 7*  Bm B 7* ¡€[ œm '2 h6 () Q4

m E+ <H ,] ~ µ , !m BN:E  U C\ BS,  …
¡€1 x! E 7* Q4 3 5
 k* ,B2% 5 - ,‹ B< :w
U% [6 " Q4 A. & x! hj1C R&~ ;% vm Œ“ \H U C $S
B6 R J 4< &+b  :²
 , U  &* 7* 3C  h6 œm Q4
BC H2 C  & ' KC q C\* MH …  & 'C µ ,6
B, - q5v X $% 6 ” M h$6  Q+w< H E   ‹ :'
MQ< B$m - &:
 , M< ^ B52% * œm #$b2 h6 †j[ 7* 0
$6
Y  M hjC ,ˆ5D Ž= - B< :w R6 7*  t6 Bm n:* . C
* . B'Q
A% 5  œm gÄ2 U% 5 ½ NjC n 2˜ B5C
260
""nS< H$ S* MQ, h+ x , Q4 Bm 3jQe
±\v HC `4+ :<'  Q+~ #$  7E h6 œm h!m ¡<€
5 7QD2 T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [ >5'2 $ :
m . 

6 ‹ :
,K'< C  6 K'* ¡€1 M* $ :
 . h+ h6 , :'* ' #6
7* <
#jC %MQ~ < œm S+ 4C \ $ :
 x! + h6 v
T C ,#$ * 7E% œm ˆH ƒ ¢ T :<'  Q+ Y  h6 >? "

" D+6 #:' 7E H2 7* &C

13 ©+% C 3y  ;% +Œ ,https://www.emaratalyoum.com : ]   X %1:* − 260


"2019 +

143
#$% &'
"!       
  

9& T5 : E mQ


: BC Q+w< #:' 7E  :~ h  g MH '+
9
6 X : A. `s *~ 'N n 2% ;$%m #6 , *
261
" MN €QC Y+    U DQ< ¡€1 H'*  H
H+ h6 “ x , +&Q' ~ 7* '2 :<'  Q+
c& U% 5 $ :
m œm ] ~ ;$%m Bw2 K, `4+ . , :~ &S MH
,A% , œm #$b2 h6 U% 5' A. hj[ 7* BjC BQ< * , :< B< :w œm
 U% 5 3 E !m B6 >? 262"   B * B*C 9  œm 6
M X  ^ A. -  :~ &S  H  qC ,&* :1*
263
"i' U 5vm
#:' M:E% €+ +&Q Q+ '2 qT , } -  Q+wH
#6 ,;$% <' B+°: Y &S  - &S , :~ &S ;%
7* k:' . 7QD+  BE%$m B: U%&  ½ NJ k:'QC M <
- ½ NJ 3 E !m <' .  N+ ,A% 5  B< :w P Î&t
.  N+ ,Be 1 \'C M < !m Tm &S H+ T : [ q!
 ;$  +ŒC BN . Y  6 Y h * -  U% 5 U%& !m <'
7* X M) 6 V €[J 7* $ &= >? $& X  U% 5 Qs
264
"Y h * - h &+
h6 ^ R+ h6  Q+ -  :~ &S U 5vm - N+
 1 :  … 7* p&*  ½ N6 iN 7* 3C v  :~ &S

,$ [ 5* ,"c š - `Q' V W  :~ h " :#$< ]Q' &C – •5 &Q= − 261
"228 V ,2020 œ J '5l ,U l

,   U%&¸ * /E ," ;6 &) #:' f:' Q+ " : &[% kNlS* h N+* − 262
"162 V ,2016 ,œ J '5l ,;. 
"114 V ,`C
* : . #&Z kNlS* − 263
" .&'C * 706 V ,`C
* ," V W  : U C' h  cš" : :, w &Q= − 264

144
#$% &'
"!       
  

- . M 7* .% & ^ 35v6  ½ NJ 3*$ * , MH U%&


265
"9 : K 6 - B< :w %& 7* ˆ¢ % 5  P Î&¬ _ q!
H $&= ¡€1 $ :
 :<' ‹ : H2 “  Q+ NH
hJ : g
œm j A. - ƒ ¢ T , 5
12    J C `<'+
7* AP:+ 6 B5+ * 6 BC AN+ * hQD* '+ ¡€1 h6  N
- Q+ V t  : &S œm  , - h T x 266" U% 5
N+ ;$% <' :E% X   Y '  :~ &S C ,] ~  g

" Q+~ A. Y 


6 ,  m N4 X U <'2 C C Y+ 7 7Q+ T x '52
,+2 QC BC , X ;&+02 ) 6 ,¯C iN C B4N ˆ , X
7* ˆs 6 tª ¡€[ % 5  š 7* Î&È ²* U% 5 7QD2
)N* '+ *J MH ,B+& : g
H2 Y&'C B H$ - xQ+ h6 ,B*E
6 ' R 'H6 7* B< R&2 H 4) <Q' U% 5' 3 E  e
" * 7* ˆ^ c&
" B6 µ C C &C Q4 U   ,A\ 6 AE! $%  5l2
$ :
m œm M ;$%m Bw2 h6  4: -  :~ &S H N+
h6 µš i Bm , ˜ xC I . M:< &  45   J
N+ C  7, B+& H2 h6 T  t  : &S M & H+
%« 6 : g
hm , , .P :+ '*   J $ :
m ;$%m :+ '*

– <l &5 n ´m A$% 6 ,h C QZ ,1945/01/15 < a 15 : 147 % 7'l − 265
Y ,6 BN g) - Š0  :~ h  cš - +&^  :~ 
" : 45 >Q

U%&¸ * /E ,  &<w ," +° ®: Q= Š0 X J i<w
"532 V ,2011 – 2010 œ J '5l ,  
"13 V ,`C
* : 5w 7C &£6 − 266

145
#$% &'
"!       
  

4:~ :+ ‹ :' h‡H """ MN  U% 5 - )N* 1 C
267
"" M<6 7* M ;tb* K'+ R ^ Π - ;H* 
. :<'  Q+ h6 œm A\ 6 B<SN2 `5
_ ¡<€ h!m
H2 &* ´ T ,Y '  :~ &S H2 M*  N+ +&Q Q+
œm #$b2   ½ N6 - :<' °: `s  e ,] ~ & : 7,
Y C ">0 e 7* A% , 6 B< :w *E 7* ˆ^ % 5  Î&t
Q+ `42 ,#:' 7E Y  ,A\ 6 ;$&4 A‹ :'C #$  7E
2 M52* X  :~  b 22 x! X 2+ :<' 
"B< n '
%& @A )/G -4 : ;E @%C
 " h6 X Š0  :~ h  QZ 7* 444 SN ¡:+
$ } 3 - §%b 1"58"378 % >M‰< H M<  '+ :<' 
:'+ * . "" H 4S h  C QC ' 1958  15 `H* 1378 œ J
H 4S h  VS X  C hj[ - R ,6 &  :~ h  h6
- M< VS: . Q+~ A. 52 4 C' H x ,P:
"A>? Y6 H 4 h E !m * , M52* N 7 ‰: ®0C h  .
- ( & A&w P: H 4S C `<' 88"13 % h  œm ( C
H&M M~ , :<'  Q+ 52* X 4 U C'
&w Š0  :~ h  VS g
C B6 >? – œ J ;N –  C
X  '2 h  . - t6 VS ¯ :. B‡H  , A. ?% BjC
−   ;N – :'* UT , - 

08/69 % ;š 5 + 1 f<* - ,2009/03/13 ©+% C µ C C &CT Q4 7 %$  , − 267
"50 V ,`C
* , H 4S  -  D Q' C %1:* ,08/70

146
#$% &'
"!       
  

$%&' 88k13 #   " %& @A )/G -4 : e I mQ


* +,-
U C $H6 & (P hjC &w 88"13 % h  $* œm ( C
 … NE  C H&M M~ 4C f<È  C' :*
:•+ E U C' A. f<’ &+&s 7Q+ , ,A$ :
m
 B)& BQ… 
 A PG $ " @A : 6 
k)v jU  #  )- #  : )& m PG 
%E h  7* 72 ;$  7* ;>tJ ;N QC B<  '+
 . R [6 E ¡È ;N A. ".%$ 100"000 œm 20"000 7* *0C
R  B  X n '< µ1+ " M:Q) 7* '+  h6 x[ T
g :v6 *Q' ; R % 6 g
¹% K*Q' KN… g D g 
x<2 
T 
 7* <
+jC 2+ h6 Q‰:* ²p 6 M* MQC M* 
U&+&M 6 c S 6 lW . ;$  A. 7* œ J ;N - ;$%
U C l
C 6 , *Q' U  6 7E *J - ” AN
6 7E *J - ) ' 6 5< ) ' 6 Π6 '5 U 5l
*m YQ' % ‰6 X ) ' U S< l
C *m *Q' U 
<
+6   6 +°5 'Q Y\  
f<’ l
C
X µP . #F+ "  m * $  0 p Q'2 t6
"A $6 ;%E  (6

 ‚i ƒ M2  P 1  WG @A : :


3GI P 1% G„
X .%$ 300"000 œm 100"000 7* *0C  '+ B6 X 81 ;$  ¡:2
h b1 g%ΠU *^ g
¹% R & g
¹% *E ¡€1 ;g

72 ;$  - M< VS: 
 &,m l
C , 5:J R &< % W
"A\ 6

147
#$% &'
"!       
  

i V €[¤ ;g
 
&,6 '+  h6 ´&C
V €[¤ B !m ;$  A. U D* 7Q) t&+ MH x ,M*C
7* '2 C' A. hjC w E "A\ 6 Mm % 1 
 C 7+%E
œm % x! ' , X n '< (P .$% 6  U C' &[6
+4C M'y <l2  , H&M ²N M<012   : 
,
# ¡€1 Œ w2 &  >4 ;g
 
6 E 7*  t
" M<Q+  
b Q1 B 3M
BQ… ƒ )v Mj MA‚ $ " @A : E:
B)&
œm 5"000 7* *0C  '+ B‡H 88"13 % h  7* 84 ;$  ,
,A\ 6 72 ;$  - :5 
 &,‡C 2+ 
E 7 ,.%$ 20"000
6 +45 6 +  Î~ 6 E 4 6  D U ²p 6 i w `, -
`, - 6 ,n0 C *Q' U%$ 6 Q‰: 6 
b U ²p 6 +~
&,6 6 f…* `, - 6 q N 6 M* M* 6 7* g%Œ ;& 6 +Œ
QM* 6 4<SQC f<* ¡€[ E 6 *Q' l< h 6 6 R %
+$j2 g 7* &. [ 6  D & * 6 ;Q* 6 3 E b* *Q
"B2$ M[
&,‡C B+ #  X  Y & (P h6 ­,\
6 i w C *J `<'2 g
 D l< œm A\ 6 ;%E 

l< A. y ;% « BD2  x! E 4 6  D U ²p
œm B  X C' iN:C D+6  E "Q~ e 7* Y, C
6 
b U ²p 6 +~ 6 +45 6 +  q\12 f<€QC Î~
M<E A. hJ , + 0 iN: x! n0 C *Q' U%$ 6 Q‰:
h2 T h6 Q~ e 7* Y, C k‰s h6 “  &< U 
b*
"V €[J e 7*  . >4 < )

148
#$% &'
"!       
  

6 7* g%ΠD+6 Q1  .  7* +^ R Z &* &


E , *Q' l< h 6 6 R % KN… xE q N 6 M* M*
& * 6 ;Q* 6 3 E b* *Q QM* 6 4<SQC f<* ¡€[
"B2$ M[ +$j2 g 7* &. [ 6  D
 C - 
# Š0 (P fQC B+: 7* &C T :.
,B2$ M1 B+$j2 5
:QC &. [ 6 +ΠB< :w h E g
;&, M<'
 <5: QMQ< % 5  &. 1 BC k‰¢ # + X R&+ * .
LQ+ T  ,Y<‰  Sm R&' a ,m - g D & 2  , ´$b+
"R 'H n '  ' h $ c& < BD+'2 - 55
h2 hjC
 T/1)'& @GI B%,  B%-1 B%E) @ :&-
†% FG K1 B- 1
< : 
*<C& U ²p •_ BC Y+ # Y p % &< ‰
% &* - ,x< \ & KC &: 6 <Q - 7+&Q'  J
+&+ +$ S 
 UT w f<’ - ,h&<5 KC h '
 Y, C k‰s h6 “ U <Q A. h‡H , E1 + D *&W
"h E #6 e 7* % ,T < ) h2 T h6 ,`\ * '
V €[J gTbp B  Y & Š0 (P hjC &w x
 P: H 4S h  7* 82 ;$  .$&s ;$&1* C'C B< 
;g
 X .%$ 200"000 œm 50"000 7* *0C  '+" B6 X ¡:2
6 7+&Q'  J K<S: 6 K
*<C& K<Q *E ¡€1
;$  - M< VS: 
 &,m l
C ,x< \ & KC &:
""A\ 6 72
‘ WG @A :A0
M* 5
'+ , C  UN - E! 7* >? œm B* 
E
88"13 % h  7* 85 ;$  7*   ;N QC B<  '+ ,$H¤

149
#$% &'
"!       
  

, [ EJ .  . '+ ".%$ 50"000 œm 10"000 7* *0C


œm B+ # . ,E 4 Y *6 ƒ 2  + D 5 ? Q1+ ,
7Q) %&:+ I * .* 6 M* M* MN 3 E M* V €[J
"A\ 6 .E! `C  U ²N
 Q+ X (P .6  U C' QZ A. 3 E h!m
UT ^ , .%$ 300"000 5"000 KC * c 2 U *? . ,:<'
*Q'  & C  t k52 R ^ '5lC U *0 A. ,A\ 6 <SN
2  H ,%Ž l< ]&* ®+'2 7* BC ¢ h6 7Q+ * H vb2 T
Q+ - %Ž  Y ,6 7 +&^ 5
:QC R J SN - B<SN2
h  hm C  Q+ - ;&, 3 U C' A. h6 E "
X †j[ - ¢ I   UT , ®'C X E!  \DH  '+  :~
"P: H 4S h 
k   "  %4 @ & %& @A M6 : E mQ
C' VS€C 7QD+ A&w  :~ h  QZ œm ( C
œm B  X  '+ # 179 SN ,:<'  Q+ X
X  '+ # 444"1 SN − T 6 − B2Ë6 $H6 &,6 6 x< ¡€[
−  v − M: 5C ;6Q< B 
WNˆ  1  †% hfd 1! WG @A -4 : 6 

7* i5^ C  '+ B6 X 268 :~ h  7* 179 SN ¡:+
K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$ 200"000 œm 20"000 7* *0C K:
œm M[6

Q2 >0C G  73"15 % h  7*   ;$  ÌQC ,A\ 6 179 ;$  ®+'2 © 2 − 268
7* 13 ©+% C 1"16"104 % f+P >M‰ AN:C %$ S  :~ h  QZ Y ,6 ®'C
il?6 15¥ 1437 ;&' ! 11 ©+% C 6491 $& Q
 ;&+~ ;¦2016 + 18¥ 1437 R[
"5992 V ,¦2016

150
#$% &'
"!       
  

6 x< ¡€1 ,  W ; ^ C * 6 5
6 H 2% 7* E ,KC'
"x< ¡€1 Y, > C t6 6 ,&M' — ¡€1
100"000 œm 10"000 7* *0C :
œm M[6 v\v 7* i5^ C  '+
; ^ C * 6 5
6 H 2% 7* E ,KC' K2 . &,‡C 6 .%$
" h  . 7* 168 SN - Mm % 1   ;ËJ g D J ,  W
6  2% !m ,A\ 6 K2N - Mm % 1 C' f D2
g D J 6 &M' — ¡€1 6 x< ¡€1  W ; ^ C i 6 
l
C ,x< ¡€1 Y, > C R\t 6 ,   ;ËJ
6 *Q' U 'Qw 7E *J - ” AN U&+&M 6 c S 6 lW
6 +Π6 5 l
C 6 YQ' % ‰6 X ) ' U S< l
C
%   
 MH C :<' µš `s <
E l
C
" +°5 'Q
KC C' - 
& (P h6 SN . R\t 7* ­,\+
C p $H6 x<Q<  W ; ^ C i   R 'H6 n 2%
œm 6 x< ¡€[ œm M* ~ A. hE KC D+6 
E ,;&,
"A&M —
iN MH 22  UT 4< 5: C C' (P fNt &
168 SN , M:Q) ƒ%&:+ 7+ , < ;ËJ g D 6 &) ~

, v m %E! ,.$T 6 B2tm B2  Œ B H x< R6 ƒ a 7*


"B* 6 B2t6
 ^ - ;% C' N DQC x! C' &+&1C D+6 Y  E
6 x< ¡€1  W ; ^ C i 6  6  2% !m +$ '
> C R\t 6 ,   ;ËJ g D J 6 &M' — ¡€1

151
#$% &'
"!       
  

°: ” `4+  
 &,m l
C ,x< ¡€1 Y,
"A\ 6 ;$&= . E :<'
6  52* X ;% U C' .&, 3 A. h6 >?
g D J 6 &M' — ¡€1 6 x< ¡€1  W ; ^ C i 6 
B6 x! "x< ¡€1 Y, > C R\t 6 ,   ;ËJ
h2  UT ^ - " B6 X ¡:+ A&w ƒ a 7* 180 SN œm ( C
Œ“ ,(N . RSH &,6 QC ,ˆH 4: C ;% C' MH
a^ 7* E6 6 &, 7* h *^ C K*w X ¢ h6 ,x! X ; \
7+P œm J X i¶ 7* h  . 7* 40 SN - M< VS:
œm K:
7* *  7* : C D+6 M< ¢ h6 7Q+ E ,EJ X :

"U:
P
, 4: U C M<E . A\ 6 179 SN - ;% U C' h6 C
VS: U C' &,m H )m 180 SN U D* `5l2 7Q+ B‡H
œm K:
7* *  7* : C ] ~ X ^ 6 ƒ a 7* 40 SN - M<
A” ^ ' & 180 SN h6 X &Ej 7* &C T B6 >? "U:
P
B: l ®? 6 B m M:Q+ , Q4Q< +Œ H ) U C'
";&, X Œ  E U C\*  … BD2 * ,

l
C 22  :<'  
%$ $&SC :6 C
A\ 6 U C 7* B<SN2 2 * h6 X &Ej 7* &C T   
 * &,6 `+e 7 ~ A. &,m n 2%  , - #F2
t$6 # A\ 6 179 SN L+°C x! ,    6  
” `42  
 7Q) +°5 'Q %   

" \'

152
#$% &'
"!       
  

 AG @3A- m 1! @N @A -4 : :


 :~ h  QZ œm BH )m 3y # 444"1 SN ¡:+
,269 g : &) f:' C% 4QC `<' 103"13 % h  7* 5 ;$  ÌQC
7*  * *0C M: 5C ;6 &) 2  X  '+" B6 X
"".%$ 60"000 œm 12"000
U ‰,\* ±\v w SN p ') :2g R\t 7*
  ,SN . - ;% C' C `<'2   , <[ œ J , 

6
" \' °: ¡È
R ,6 *&'C  :~ h  - + SN . M… 1 , 7QH
7+ I x , H 4S h  X  Q+ n  VS€C >tJ .
R t$m h * C h E ,  :~ h < SN . H ) % * 7* ¯ :.
VS: KC n<l Y w S¢ k, H 4S h  - Ì .
"  
&) B < 6 & SN . h6 ­,\ H C' , 7* *6
60"000 12"000 KC c 2 *? 7 ;% 5 4: C M: 5C ;6
7* g : &) f:' R [6 E / C' &+&12 x! - B+ ? ,.%$
- H* 7+ I (P h6 ' :6 >? " - Q #:' f:' M:C
h  7* 85 ;$  h x! , 4<* 72 I SN p  ^ h6 x!
c + *? X ¡:2 $HJ &) B  X  '2  88"13 %
$ Y& M‰+ —  C ".%$ 50"000 10"000 KC ·J k$J ´&,
k$J 7+&^ VS€C '* KS: -  ^ n% < ‰ x! % + aH
·J &4< *0 i¶ 7* 6 —, H ) 7Q+ T , C'< ·J
" Q+ + 4D  'N +^ >H2 - aN `<¬ h6 C'<

,¦2018 + H 22¥ 1439 ;tu $ } 5 ©+% C 1"18"19"% f+P >M‰ AN:C %$ S − 269
"1449 V ¦2018 9% * 12¥ 1439 ;tu $ } 23 ©+% C 6655 $& Q
 ;&+~

153
#$% &'
"!       
  

SN . `5l2 h6 X &Eb h6 $ K‰,\ K2 . œm H ) C


ƒ a 7* 443 SN h6 x! , \ VS€C U  [m ;& >

#6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [ >5'2 E BjC  '+


5C ;6 &) 2  X  '+ 444"1 SN " :'* '
h6 x! 7* MN MH " :<' œm ;% [m +6 ” 3 K<SN \E , M:
A '+ M: 5C ;6 &) 2  X  '+  :~ h 
? T Y6 :< h E g
4:
X :<'  C ¡¬ H ¢ ƒ a 7* 404 SN hJ x!
h  X A% & - `,T . – A&'C 404"1 SN Æj , H 4S h 
;6 &) B < C $&¢ – P: H 4S C `<' 88"13 %
X  , 7Q) t&+ T ;6 &) B  h6 :'+ _ , M: 5C
\' µš 7 ±&4+ # . >tJ . hjC :Q< !m , H 4S h 
¡: -  Q? Y *6 :jC R ::Q+ B‡H ,Bs 
$&¢  -
SN . VS€C C% D* U>N2 B h
g D h6 ,] 
 '+ # n g D h C 6 P: H 4S h C B\ - g

" N ’ A% 5 C :<' >?  X

154
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺧﺎﺗﻤﺔ‬
 
  ~ :
%$ R\t 7* ¡<€
B6 œm , +&^  
7* .>?     
, QM* U *? %m - Xw2 ,~ A. + 4) $H¤   + £ ¯ :.
  U% 5 B2 BN B 3
7*  $% `s h6 †j[ 7*
"A>? œm
4) E '™   H v $ Y& - M 7* 7Q+ 1 7
•_ ­Ns - t6 M 7* ,B4C 5 lQ< g D œm jw<+ ~ p
7 `D M5[ g%$ '+%C KQM &) U 'C  x+s 7 * ' C :
. ,;š 5 + 1 ;l* œm h bw<+ + 4D <?6 '“ _ ,U +^
M<'“ _ , + 4D 5 ? & H2 T  * N<2 <l2 š6 E ;l*
" 'C  - M, 7 h<€+
f2 A ™ - >2 E 4 ®'C & U M2 $ 7 x. 
‰:C `<' h  U D B'DÈ :< >? 
B6 X :<' 
>? M<'“ ,:<'  + 4D ;% +^ 7* f'D+ _ ,n g D
;$  % em - ” ¢  <+/p U *0 5C U + 1 +&2 - K5?%
".%$ 700 300 KC * c 2  %E h  7* 16
wC \ B * E ˆ52 cš 6 7* fb . g  x
# ,h%  Š0 g D< U 5lC  /_ , MH ,š , 
E +:2 6 7* , +&, QM*  D U% Y ,jC 4<* D+6 7QD2
- . + h6 x! E 7* K<*ª ,() ” KQM K
% ,K, 5
"~ B2 . VS€C , l U C'S E 1 Œ ™

155
#$% &'
"!       
  

156
‫!"
'& ‪#$%‬‬ ‫  
      ‬

‫ﻣﻠﺤﻖ‬
‫ﺑﺒﺎﻗﺔ ﻣﻦ اﻷﺣﻜﺎم واﻟﻘﺮارات اﻟﻘﻀﺎﺋﻴﺔ‬
‫اﻟﺼﺎدرةﰲ ﺟﺮاﺋﻢ اﻟﺴﺐ واﻟﻘﺬف‬

‫‪157‬‬
#$% &'
"!       
  

158
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺠﺮﺳﻴﻒ‬


2019 ‫ ﺷﺘﻨﱪ‬28 ‫ ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬2912 ‫ﺗﺤﺖ ﻋﺪد‬
270
2019/2106/677 ‫ﰲ اﳌﻠﻒ اﻟﺠﻨﺤﻲ ﻋﺪد‬

:‫اﻟﻘﺎﻋﺪة‬
" |<I M+QD Y4 mi   M3& 3'4 T)/ 6
k? U3'4- 6L .N  T)/ 6 UL B)& BQ… $
 @A  >?  " &-' †/+' ƒ6 N /i
T /d 9 T 0 G .%  g ,m, " $2- c
?q mCA &-' ’ _F4  L i V T €' >C
kP3 14 “ / y,„
s‹ " #% = (4 ”" M34 P B)
N ? 1&/
|/QN 1&- , M~QN kkk )% = Xi 8-1N " (i ‚g'
B3f' 4‘ FA ‡I T 'U 1200 T E5
,S,= \4 # mX , 10 \4 r&  '4ƒ /1U B ‚A
k"K% &C- W!/ PE'= \4 FQg #[/ T)5

% 3g †% FG #-


4:~ + D - 35v . f
wC &C Q4 U%&6
:& KC BS Æu ^ ,2019/11/28 ©+% C , +$ '
; Q4 A” x< E
f
 <m * :]& `^ C  l

"%1:* >? , − 270

159
#$% &'
"!       
  

;& ²” * 4 c&* ! B: n:+


 G T
²” h * 4 #% ' Š' h! 
T A%Œb+ """" kQ KC
";&
®Q+ I 7*Œ :* , Q4 Ap  D ;& t$ BC 2% C M
`+e 7 M* MQC M*  g :v6 K*Q KN…*  .m ,Y$  &*6 B<
Ug $m NΠ% 5t6  P:C  gC Y  ,  m Y\ m <

l
C 9 : KC (/N U% v6 Y ' Y ‰: C 3<t6 44 >?  

b U ²p `, - KM   ,  m Y\ m <

`, - KM   ,n0 C *Q' U%$ Q‰:
Q‰:* ².  .m ,  m Y\ m <
`+e 7 x! E ,$HJ
- MC X M< VS: R 'HJ ,  m Y\ m <
l
C
K<SN P: H 4S C `<' 88"13 h  7* 85 – 84 − 83 −72 $
" :~ h  7* 265 – 263
K0  G T
H  
« = 7* .‹ : S<€ MQ< * ' C : 'C * X g :C
$& ]  2019/04/16 ©+% 2 a Ψ924 $& R J  D lC D
2019/04/24 ©+% 2 a Î /1010 $&   2019/04/18 ©+% 2 a Î/975
<m * h6 M:* $ N+ 7+< ,f
 eš e 7* 7+/w:
 X  * P X """ kQ &Q B6 MH  '+ + 1C Y&2 f

³N f
  " h: 3s 2019 9% * 26 ©+% C """ ] 
<C f
wC <4 l< h 6 MH q " """ ;$% n/, Îs
C 7* ;$ N
 1' g :5 % 1 C c 6 7*  [% U 26
,h  M<  '+ *m T 'H6 &'2 U * q A. h6 ,g+ ;$ m

160
#$% &'
"!       
  

† 6 M'Q
;%$ ;%SC
 C!  Ug $ , - k52 †6
$ 6 9
6 #6 X &:+ I M5,  h6 & w^ C q 5vm + I *
B<Qs *J C :' `, -  D 'C  x+s iQ ,9Q<* #$ *
  7* €:C + 1 `H%6 ,h  Y ,J 5e B2g $m  b*
"A\ 6 Bm % 1  C ;%1:
7* /w: a Î /924 $& Ž4 - +&My MQ< (
 &:
#jC gT$ - ?+ T B6 BH c‹ 2019/04/16 ©+% C f
 eš e
Y& 3QS Y/ - ]  B, 7* ;$ N
 - ?+ B6 L+°2
" + 1 VS€C Rb
#6 7 C 
e 7* /w: a Î / 975 Ž4 - +&My MQ< (
 &:
 X %1: R  h6 c‹ 2019/04/18 ©+% C f
 eš
³N f
  " h: 3s 2019 9% * 26 ©+% C """ #% 5t
7* . BS¬ B‡H """ 4N """  &QC %1: " ;$% n/, Îs
* X  W B4N 7+%E K' œm B
%m B:+ &2 X Q
B6  )6 ,2019/03/26 ©+% C x! h E ¯C i+ H   
#M~ •4 Y ' hj1 '5* 7* Y\  H 4S R Z - ˆ1:+
 l5 X RS^ 6 7* V t f<QC Y&2 B‡H  0 p :e
i% h E  &' U ;&+ `+e 7 ” Y  Ug B2 . :M
+%
3Œ T Ug h‡H  $ &^ , ” V W P M~ (H
45 % :e #M~ •4 Y ' hj1< B'52 4C B6  )6
 0 p e 0 % $ :e  7* K:e g+m ;$ m ()* - `Q'
X U :+ & 7* QZ E K:e 7* QZ U$ M[ X &Q 
R Z - U  t $ 7 ±&42 ¯C i+ H    4N
H+ B6 " e ?" #Ž^ %&Q< 5: C g+ ;$ m C 7* ;$ N

x< E & &Q+ hjC $&'
 X . V €[J gTb. U +. X

161
#$% &'
"!       
  

VS€C ,q$ M1C gT$ 6 7* V €[J gTb. g


jC f
wC
U 2J M<C l< h 6 œm B * R\t 7* BM # $ 
;$ m C 7* ;$ N
 6 7* V €[6 g S,‡C c 6 7*  [%
;$ N
 E %E 1' ^ C K:e C  †6 7* ? C g+
%& C )%6 C 7* q\ $H6 l< h 6 7* t6 QZ
X H+ B6 %E ^ h 
7* $M[ U ¢°2 , e ? #Ž^
* X B4N X .P    :+ & VS€C  )6 ,q +.
† $ 7* . B‡H 2019/04/16 ©+% C 3 E ¯C i+ H   
hjC R w - Bl16 B4N '5* } % 5tm  0C .P X Q &
P:+ B6 A$ N* Y q Bm B+ h6 - 55
h E g+ ;$ ‡C `<' R J R 
St R w . - Bl16 B2 C E } h6  )6 , 44 >?  
+:2 . M:* &p :e #M~ •4 Y ' hj1< B'52 R\t 7*
¡€[ #jC 9  œm <l* &´ T     P Y ' #6
"BN 6 B b* 3 E NE
7* /w: a Î /1010 $& Ž4 - +&My MQ< (
 &:
H 4S R Z - ˆ1:+ B6 c‹ 2019/04/24 ©+% C f
 eš e
* 5 7* B Q<* $  ` lC 7* QZ X H+ BE Y\ 
C% 0* ; : 2017 :
tuba press M:*   NSC 
b*  m +% 5tm
M< Ss  &' U   ;&+~ 2018 :

 24 I '
; :  e - D L56 2019/03/19 ©+% C B6  )6 ,2018/09/24 ©+% C
; : UT * ;& %, h6 B `5
& ,%4QE N2 24 n E  
+% 5t  7* M< Ss  $  ` lC ©:C —&+ B6 ,;%E
; :C  W $   lC &' U ;&+wC  W $   lC .
N< tuba press *\  EP C  W $   lC 24 I ' C% 0*
"blanda.com guercif com 24 B2&+ >C

162
#$% &'
"!       
  

2019/05/06 ©+% C x< E & e 7* M a l:


 &:
 &* X AP BC C Y  7* . + 1 ()* R  h6 c‹
N   & C R  . ˆC% P:C Y  x! &'C www .motasilpro.com
 )6 ""¯C i+ H"    QC  W B4N X E
<} A= BQD* k:5+ B6 E E f  R  š  2 E . B6
()* VS€C ,R  hQD* 7 ( H&< &'* B6 &Eb* \SN2
¯ :. h6 B 35H ,9 : 7* QZ * &* 4C 6 B6 c‹ + 1
#Ž^ %& C g+ ;$ ‡C S€ <4 :w< e 7* U 5 \2
f
wC l< h 6 R % <2 U 5 \ A. B 6 KC 7* , e ?
;$ N
 C ^ . 7 g C? V €[J c 6 7*  [% U 2m
 )6 "x! - M,6 Y& ?% g :5 ;$  SS€ )%J l 7*
Y  E f  R  %, U 5 \2 U  t 7* B 35v * X g :C B6
2 f
 <m * & e 7* + 1 +&2 &'C  )6 ,AP:C
+&C - L+°2 #jC gT$ ®HH  D eP e 7* Bm (

#jC gT$ ®H% &'C Bm (
 Y+ g * ,3QS `4C */<* *J
i+ H    QC  W B4N X :+ &2 h $ ,L+°2
eP e 7* B &
 &: S, C B'5* '1+ †QDQC ¯C
, †QD* &Ej + 1 ()* ;N P $ 6 :+ & A”  D
L+°C œ$6  D eP e 7* &'C H Bm (
 2 B6  )6
 BN VS€C Bm (
 2 E , '* :+ & R  VS€C
7* Q[ ;%SC œ$6 >tJ - ,Y\  H 4S R Z - ˆ1 M5QC
""N2 24 n E"   ; : e 7* B <* $ 
M Ž, 2019/09/12 ©+% C ;&': <~ C D ƒ%$m X g :C
+. , 1 M~ 7 c&* ! Ž, #% ' ! Š' ! B H$ Ž,
gT$¸ <M* M ( H$ iQ ,  D lC D Ž= `H « ^ M

163
#$% &'
"!       
  

-/~  S g$6 &N+ C c&* ! œ$6 , <1 U H& 7* QwQC


iQ M M* - .%$ ¦100"000¥ A%& &* D+'2 iQ
f
 <m * & g &
 Š' ! iQ ,M œm (

‰: x< E & &:
6 9 :²
 5
X  Bm (
¸
iQ<* h6 f
 <m * & g &
 - c&* !  % , Q4Q<
n: 6 7* M a l:
 - +&5 &'C g  <1 U H& +&2
! #% ' ! iQ ,( H$ 6 H$ E 5 U H& +&2 “ B6 Bm
M*6 ,x< E & E iQ< - c&* !  % '+ I , <M* Š'
3%$6 « ^ M p '[6 2019/10/31 <~ B H$ $&  ( H&
c&* ! Ž, Š' ! Ž, 2019/11/14 ©+% C ;&': < t|C D
`, - ;l h6   Š' ! t&2 ,M Ž, #% ' ! Ž,
¦ <~ ©+% 2 5 *+ 15¥ g &
 VS€C x! Q<
>? B<E*
p 3 + 1 C 3*&2  M~ h6  )6 Q<
>? 'C  h6  
,H& $% * ' C : 3Q Q<
>? QM % 5  iQ NS
- `5l2 I P: H 4S h  7* 97 ;$  h6 L) 6 #% ' ! t&2
! BC Y&2 # H& &E6   +lC Y¢ I g &
 h6 D A.
3* †6 L)2 < * & ” Y&2  + 1 h6  )6 Š'
+ 1 C S€[ NSC Y& gTb. X “ h E B6 §1 K*&
} $% iQ c&* ! t&2 "(H& A. $% * ' C : 3Q
%Q
 ( H& VS€C K } B<+È 2 M h6 L) 6 (H&
&E6   RSN< Y , iQ Š' ! t&2 D 1 :* -
BC M   Bm n: 7 , +l Ug - <t ¯ :. h6
! 
¤ Rb
7 ,B:'C S€[ &S+ I B6 L) 6 R  P:C Y  # .
%2 B:'C S€[ &S+ I Y R * h E R  h6 M L) 6 Š'
- $% * h6 L) 6 1 M~ 7 c&* ! t&2 ,;/.  D % 5 

164
#$% &'
"!       
  

I M h + 1 - g  * X g :C 4S 7* 9


6 B i :+ &
NS p 1 M~ h6 % 5  iQ 0*$ w4C U 5v 
C R&+
3 E g &
 ;l* h6 M `, - C v QM % 5  D A. -
M $m iQ ]  J t$ 3 E 'C  + 1 h6 Q<

C : 3Q ,-/~ ˆ g$6 X $ M[ n<l ®+' C ^


h6 L) 6 M   œm Š' ! t&2 , 'C  RSH `H $ * '
P: H 4S % em - t&+   +$ +lC BC Y  B<E* BC Y  *
( C B6  t <[ Ugm  &2 N4S 'C * h6  )6
3 1 M~ h6 g &
 VS€C at ¯ :. h‡H f< ` v
g :C B * P:C Y  B<E* h6   >? B<E* `, - 'C    NS p
! t&2 ";g  iQ 7+%Ž* V €[6 7* . 
 U l'* X
;$  3t B<E* `, - 'C  h6  )6 Š' ! 'H* &E6 #% '
]& l 6 * ' C : B0<52 g &
¥ P: H 4S C  W 97
” B \ T f< >tj2 h6  )6 ¦ <~ ©+% 2 5 *+ 15 MQ<
B:* 99 ;$< P: H 4S h  + 1< ( iQ aW
M~ h6 D A. - p N T 1 M~ h6  )6 ,B:* 100 ;$<
'C  % 5  iQ + 1 +& Y&2 h6 M< “  . ;%Ž
#6 L)+ T 
 Y 1C Y& R  h6 ‰,\* iQ Q<
>?
:+&* MH'2 :'*    R  h6 K'* ¡€[ #6 `, -  6  .m
,7+%Ž* K:e* U\
* X g :C B * P:C Y  B<E* h6 f

U 5<l R5 Y& B<E* ;gC e ,

6 'C  R5 Y& iQ
, U l'* X g :C B * P:C Y  B6 L) 6 M t&2 , &
"2019/11/28 *j ,;&Eb*

165
#$% &'
"!       
  

(X' 1&-
:)& K41 " – 
:%i S1 "
41'=- $%&' H1 y,f-
I BE MQ< B g &
   Y&'C M ( H$ H$ ,
"P: H 4S h  7* 97 ;$  - B< VS: *+ 15 6 Y¢
B6 X œ J qH - P: H 4S h  7* 97 ;$  ¡:2 ,
5 ]& l 6 * ' C : B0<52 g &
C *Q'  & ¯s "
QM &+&s P: +&* +. 7QD+ J X *+ 15 n <~ ©+% 2
22 Tm 'C  X B5l2  ]  ¡: œm % 1+ Bm M
""g &
 h\lC x! X
B g &
 
T f< ` v U l'* œm ( C Bm ,
h E <~ ©+% 2 h6 2019/05/06 ©+% C Bm B g &
 h6 K52 M œm
3 E <~ ©+% 2 g &
 ©+% 2 KC < N ;& h6 #6 2019/05/23 -
"A$% K'+ i
b* >? VSW ” %  H& B'* h+ _ *+ 17
S! "
T4 #  )- #  : B)4 BQ… UL +G y,f- -1
 <L F4L % $/g
" B6 X œ J B2H -  :~ h  7* 263 SN ¡:+ ,
Tª ¶ œm K¶ K2j* 7* *? :
œm M[ 7* i5^ C  '+
7* 6 K*Q' KN… 7* 6 g D R % 7* &,6 h .6 7* ,.%$
, ” M*  5C 6 MN )C M*  g :v6 * ' ; R % 6 g
¹%
Y
% 6 C C 6 , M') 6 g [6 R
%m 6 U&+&q 6 U% [m 6 RjC

166
#$% &'
"!       
  

 Y, 6 .%'1C 6 MHPC 9  &SC x! :< >?


""Ml<
U l'* 7* T , M* *6 ƒ% * R\t 7* T Q4Q< 35+ I ,
& Mm h :²Qe 7Q+ ;š 5* + U 5vm $6 #6 #&MQ 45
M 7* B6 x! ,Y q x ()* 4:~ 6 7* A\ 6 M $m -
`, - 3J U 4N ;%1: :M U% 5' % 5  7Q+ T œ 6
$& %¥ H .% 5 C Tm f2 h6 7Q+ T  .m K*Q' KN…
X $  7Q+ T B6  v M 7* ,¦2008/11/19 - §%b 1/916
5e  . 4:~ :+ ‹ :' H2 &* - 45< N4S U C 
* \t X :<' C M* 2T  :~ h  QZ 7* 263 SN<
" :<' °: H2 ;% « Y& 7* %E SN Be1+
`, - q 5vm 
 UH Y q x Q+ 3 E  ,
;$  x! X ¡:2 E B$m 352 k, ;g  M - J h6 ,M
$ X g :C Tm $ œm % S+ T B6 ,  :~ ;l h  7* œ J
Y
* ,$   QSC R* KQ€ 7 A/:* ,K< &* h .C
g) - Q4 h‡H ,R, 7* I
,R } 7* R t ,$& nS C
L+° 
M'+ T ,  :~ ;l 7* 389 286 K2$< T m x!
"B:* B2g C ^ Bm  * 6 7* M ;tb* Y&'C
H  M 4L Q ƒ 30 ( *-  A-  y,f- -2
C- • B- S^Q M: & v- |%0 ++D 8[
k <L F4L %
7* E  '+ " B6 X P: H 4S h  7* 72 ;$  ¡:2 ,
44 >?   6 Ug $m 6 fΠt  6 !m 6 P:C  gC Y 
6 Y ' Y ‰: C 3<t6 !m >0< C:* MH i&* 6 N<’ U&:* 6
""
 7* <
+jC 9 : KC (/N U% v

167
#$% &'
"!       
  

P 7 2+ h6 ;% « 3e[ A\ 6 ;%E ;$  hm ,


6 Y ' Y ‰: C T\tm 44 >?   6 Ug $ 6 N/ % 5tJ
"9 : KC (/N ;% vm
R  P C C Y  7* . BjC   & M h E 7² ,
7* T Q4Q< 35+ I B‡H ,  Ug $ 7QD + 1 ()*
+ U 5vm $6 #6 #&MQ 45 U l'* 7* T M* *6 ƒ% * R\t
R\tm M: 22 & % 5tJ x<2 hjC R< M< $  7Q+ ;š 5*
"9 : KC (/N U% v6 6 Y ' Y ‰: C
`, - q 5vm 
 UH Y qT x Q+ 3 E  ,
;$  x! X ¡:2 E B$m 352 k, ;g  M - J h6 ,M
$ X g :C Tm $ œm % S+ T B6 ,  :~ ;l h  7* œ J
Y
* ,$   QSC R* KQ€ 7 A/:* ,K< &* h .C
g) - Q4 h‡H ,R,T 7* I
,R } 7* R t ,$& nS C
L+° 
M'+ T  :~ ;l 7* 389 286 K2$< T m x!
"B:* B2g C ^ Bm  * 6 7* M ;tb* Y&'C
 <L F4L % C- )v jU UL y,f- -3

 .m " B6 X  :~ h  QZ 7* 265 SN ¡:+ ,
SN 7*   œ J K2N Y ,J 5e M<  '+ Q‰: U ²p
""263
U l'* 7* T , M* *6 ƒ% * R\t 7* T Q4Q< 35+ I ,
& Mm h :²Qe 7Q+ ;š 5* + U 5vm $6 #6 #&MQ 45
"Y q x ()* 4:~ 6 7* A\ 6 M $m -
`, - q 5vm 
 UH Y q x Q+ 3 E  ,
;$  x! X ¡:2 E B$m 352 k, ;g  M - J h6 ,M
$ X g :C Tm $ œm % S+ T B6 ,  :~ ;l h  7* œ J

168
#$% &'
"!       
  

Y
* ,$   QSC R* KQ€ 7 A/:* ,K< &* h .C
g) - Q4 h‡H ,R, 7* I
,R } 7* R t ,$& nS C
L+° 
M'+ T  :~ ;l 7* 389 286 K2$< T m x!
"B:* B2g C ^ Bm  * 6 7* M ;tb* Y&'C
)& C%A 4 $ " WG @A >? y,f- -4
T4 I $ " B G @A >? )4 ) )- BQ% yfd
A‚ Mj $ " B G @A >?  <L F4L % $/g
kn- )& M= )v
+ 1 h6 X 3S P: H 4S h  7* 99 ;$  hm ,
;%S - `^ C i 6  6   , - 'C  x+4 *ŒT h2
,;%E ;$  - M< VS:  UN C <SN U DQ< H
% 1 L:~ 7* %Ž l 7* + [ #6 7*  t g  f< h6  e
"R5 Y& p|* h+ VSW ” ;l 'C  h‡H A\ 6 Mm
kB)4 BQ… $ " B G @A >? y,f- -5

X %1: R  h6  D lC D Y *6 +&My M c‹ ,


f
  " h: 3s 2019 9% * 26 ©+% C """ #% 5t 
BS¬ B‡H """ 4N """  &QC %1: " ;$% n/, Îs ³N
 W B4N 7+%E K' œm B
%m B:+ &2 X Q 7* .
h6 x< E & Y *6 c‹ ,¯C i+ H    * X
Y  x! &'C """  &* X AP BC C Y  7* . + 1 ()* R 
QC  W B4N X E N   & C R  . ˆC% P:C
f  R  š  2 E . B6  )6 ,¯C i+ H   
B6 Q4 Y *6  )6 ,\SN2 <} A= BQD* k:5+ B6 E E
B2 :+ &2 &Eb+ B6 B:'C S€[ &S+ I B6 L) 6 R  P:C Y  # .
"¯C i+ N X

169
#$% &'
"!       
  

 " h: Q¢ # M AP # R  - g  ,


% * ±&,J 32" •+ * " ;$% n/, Îs ³N f

,Q< hj1 >C&2 - 1H be ¯š - < * ˆ
*&'C
7* E6 3+N2 &'C S UwN2 &H , :N'2 $$/2 B ,  Q+ <
M Œ +&. K b K5€: h  ¤ \ G%J 7* % . 1200
R * X \Ne ?+ 7QE ,( S X p ;jH * , M*&t X '
. 5€: U :  l< 3Œ T 3 E """ <, 'lC B)+
*Q' x< R\, U N<* h  at ,7e . % *$ nt 5

t6 h&* n/,6 œm hQ:+ V €[6 M:* $ N


  g+ ;$ m C
C * h :' l< h 6 `<e6 *&'C , +$  MH … 7 ‰: °C
- ¦"""¥ l5 % $ '<+ h6 &++ # #$ sT ]   """ [% U 26
+ 7* 7+&N ,K5€: h  J 7* B2&5 < * M*
* T ,: . #$ s ]   \H """ $ N g 3s h D:
<‰< E+ h6 Tm kC6 R `1 7* . 7e C &5 . <
""$ 5'

R&* - &S+ B6 X P: H 4S h  7* 83 ;$  ¡:2 ,
iy 3 E !m , ². 6 ¡€[ œm M5 6 ' g $m :  C h  .
>5'2 E :  , Mm 6 Bm 35  ²p 6 ¡€1 % 5  6 š
+6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 * 7* e , >s ;% 5 6 K1* 6 7 [
" :'* '
œm C: R 'HJ hjC Q4 3': A\ 6 E!  $ :
 Bm ,
" M<6 7* B2tb* B'* K'+ B, - C v M
++&2 l<
G  L:* &  :~ h  7* 141 SN hm ,
h  - 7+% ·J k$J 7+&^ a l - .&+N2 C' &+&s -

170
#$% &'
"!       
  

,  7* 52 Q+~ ;%lt x! -  * Q+~ X  '


"t6 ,  7* Yw S€[
Q+w< % g/~ h6 Π:
%$ &'C p K52 & Q4 hm ,
*J M Ym %& 52 R 'HJ ;%lW 5: C 9  h  -
BC
Y&'   BH ‰ fN€  ‰C B'y B55C Uj2% #
"  D
"k$J - % 5 ;&* &+&s *  S M Qs K'+ ,
&-' 1 K41 " – n
:(i l T
NS C `<' H& VS€C
NS p 3 1 M~ hjC M ( H$ H$ ,
AP # R  
T f< ` v œm Q4 (C Bm ,
 " h: 3s 2019 9% * 26 ©+% C """ ]   X M
œm 3M U% 5 7QD+ B6 K52 " ;$% n/, Îs ³N f

- ¦"""¥ l5 % $ '<+ h6 &++ # #$ s ]  ¥ 5 7* 1
#$ s ]   \H¥ ,¦K5€: h  J 7* B2&5 < * M*
Tm kC6 R `1 7* . 7e C &5 . < * T ,: .
Œ  - C v 1 M~ N B'* h2 _ ¦$ 5'
 <‰< E+ h6
"A$% B'* K'+ _   i
b* >? %  H& h+ R ^
   5<l <1 µ P< H* Ug   & hm ,
"\[ p5C L+° 
: S! l T
 & - SN `H M `, - C v *~ R 'HJ hm ,
"A\ 6 *Q'

171
#$% &'
"!       
  

n  * RS, - š 5 5 . †6 Q4Q< 35v & Bm ,


"%« 7* ]& `^ C  l
¯< w g  m h  BC LQ+ I %E %Ž hm ,
7* B5
:+ C B<6 7* B2tb* BH 6 7* M $m 3y *m
"Πn 
7* 
:C 7 M e 7* 352% & ;%E R 'HJ hm ,
<e '“ # *J ,% 5 AE 7* I
% t jlW 6 ˆ<0
"R5* Ç* ! ®+'
h6 X ¡ & $' U */ >M… 7* 98 SN hm ,
\'H ¦]& `^ C  l¥  & 3^  ;% W . ~ - %Ž
'N   c\ M Nm œm l‰
6 l)  +% Ž U H °
 : +$ ' $ &^ ;$ - N 7* Y, * xE BC %«m 2% #
®+' +&2 - ;%E ‹ :' ; * + # *J ,'N x!
"BC  l l< `4
" MN+% S* Q4C  & Ë t Y/<+ h  hm ,
E h6 X 3S &  :~ ;l h  7* 637 ;$  hm ,
6 U D+' C 6 A$% Y/<+ * $C 6 *0 C %* %&S2 *&: +ΠQ=
"]&5 AE ;&* $&s h6 f+% S
- ]&5 AE &+&s X 
% & .$ M Q4 Q hm ,
* 307 œm 286 RSN U D 5l2 "k$J &^ - h& M `,
99 97 ,85 ,84 ,83 ,72 $  :~ ;l h  7* 638 œm 633 7* B<+
7* 265 263 K<SN P: H 4S C `<' 88"13 % h  7*
" :~ h 

172
#$% &'
"!       
  

n3I _?
: +%D, &C :< Q4 3Q,
:)& K41 "
" <1 (H& } $C : 6 
h 6 `, - B   VS€C 'C  R5 Y&'C ::
KM   *Q QMQC KN<* V €[6 *Q' l<
- KM    m Y\ m <
`+e 7 $HJ `, -
"n0 C *Q' U%$ Q‰: 6 
b U ²p `,
M*  g :v6 K*Q KN…*  .m 6 7* M ;tb* Y&'C :E:
<
l
C Q‰:* ².  .m  m Y\ m <
`+e 7 M* MQC
>?   Ug $m NΠ% 5t6  P:C  gC Y   m Y\ m
Y\ m <
l
C 9 : KC (/N U% v6 Y ' Y ‰: C 3<t6 44
^ Bm  *  C 6 7* B2tb* " M:* B2g C L+°  m
"k$J -  Z  S B<Qs ,.%$ ¦5000¥ .%& ;H   * *0C B<
:&-' 1 K41 "
k p5C : (i " 6 
<m * ]& `^ C  l ;& N """ M g$jC :() -
- % 5  S B<Qs .%$ ¦15000¥ A%& &* D+'2 f

"k$J
: M1 Y - ;&': :<' <~ C •2 ^ %& ”
²p 3 E ,f
wC &C Q4 C +$   U <~ C ,A\ 6
""" : ;$  7* 5E*  D

”3
 @N5 c 

173
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺼﻔﺮو‬


2020/02/11 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
271
2019/2106/975 ‫ﻣﻠﻒ ﺟﻨﺤﻲ ﺗﻠﺒﺲ ﴎاح ﻋﺪد‬

:m14
41'= #%AN  %3N  P5 %D  G U ;1 >C
3D U & - X- P  –A'A 8[ T ,‹3
eL ;1 >C T4 , ‹3 41'= %3N " y,'0=
"†w \4 h/ — P0  I ,# '
H  \4 U*  ))&N H ' ~ ~C%3 M34
1 B'i X- m14 ˜ TUw " $%™  oXd T ,; <L
|& ~C%3 n%X- .D †? , ?/= @/f' F)&'
"B'i)% i H  @A/ ? (i/ #~ '-

% 3g †% FG #-


- 52 . 2020/02/11 ©+% C NSC &C Q4 U%&6
:BS Æu ^ 4:~ + D
]& `^ C K5 l* K1* """ ˜˜ 3 """ ˜˜ 2 """ ˜˜ 1 : KQ KC
";š 5 + 1 ÌQC
9 H ²” h * 4 4H6 & t h+$ $bH h! 
J M: n:+
;š 5 + 1 ÌQC BC k1* BNSC """ : kQ KC
9 H ²” * 4 h)% “&t ;! 
J B: n:2

"%1:* >? , − 271

174
#$% &'
"!       
  

B< ®Q+ I 7*Œ :* Q4 A. !N ;$ t$ BC 2% C BC k1
h  7* 84 −83 RSN< 5e   L:~ : 4:~ Y$  &*6
 W ; ^ - t&  :~ h  7* 442 SN ,P: H 4S
h $ %S P `+e 7 ;š 5* +lC ;%S - `^ C i V €[¤
Y  xE P: H 4S h  7* 89 − 87 $Q< 5e `5* h!m
h $ Š0 : /E 7* h!m X RS^ h $ µ 1 +S2 l0C
µ  , H 4S h  7* 35 ;$  B< ¡:2  5e :' U l< % '[m
  Ug $m +Œ2 BH* h $ ¡€[ ;% +Œ2 3C w2
2 1 ;N< 5e ,” >M1 V €[¤  W ; ^ C i &SC C! E
,g : &) f:' C% 4QC `<' 103"13 % h  7* 447 SN 7*
O  g h 52 &” H* h $ ŀ[ C e U! U l'* ~ '*
% h  7* 59 − 57 − 56 − 4 $Q< 5e K2! V €[J :+&
C l U! U l' ~ '* A ™ K2 V €[J +4C `<' 08"09
"ŀ1
Q4 B2 . & x< E & %D4C −
H  
M H$ l
C """ KQ e 7* *& ;š 5 + 1 X g :C
&C Q4 i% & œm ,4H6 & t h+$ $bH h! 
J
 D Y
 M: ;$b Q4 A. ˆ5) C C <w , NSC
 ,""" M* - 2019/09/16 ©+% C D Â<5* 2019/06/13 ©+% C
4C NS A” ,%&:E %ŒQ+m (H """ n/4C g D 6 †6 MH h)'+
* &+&w Y ' Qw< 2019/05/17 ©+% C  Ž, Y ' hj1 C M*.
a\l 5 B6 , , 5 ;P +$ ^  X A$ ' % ,""" '}
. R 0[J %D^ 7* U :e K:e  C ':*d ,Y ' Q~ R 0[6
M<t&2 ?% .$lC 3*  'Q~ % e 7* x! ,Y ' Q~

175
#$% &'
"!       
  

,1N C Ug C qT = 7 ,%D^ - M,jC K5 l* ,]  1C


,x! &'C ;š 5* B6 >? ,`,T ©+% 2 œm Y ' Q~ $ ' Uj%6
,BC k1 .+&+  """   ;&+~ X NŒ % 5t6 P:C ²H
,""" kQ %&:E %ŒQ+‡C """ n/, (H 2 E" :•+ * H, S 3:QD2
B2 . P X °+ I B6 ," """ /E* U&N* X wM+ wl<C  /+
ˆ+š +S2 œm x! &'2 C , 
b >? Ug $ N/ % 5tJ
,"""   ;&+~ U 4N X AP:C Y  ,K1 BH M‰+ +&H
, MD'C % M…m ,ˆ+P . % `:2 +2 ;$ m 3y *&'C
©+% C Y  , ,” >M1 X °* RŒT B6 E ,tu ®'5
2 E wq" : h: 3s  ±$,  t - R * P:C 2019/05/20
N U\w' """ 'QwC ;D 
+ %&:E %ŒQ+‡C """ n/, (H
i* W &Q= 
b C 2 /E* t$ ³N <5<5 7*  , `<¬
7QD2 +&H P:C Y  , ” cQ µlW E xC Œ w* ,"7* D<
 U 4N $ % 7* U ² M< <e .&. [ K1 %
U 4N X .P 7Q+ T ŀ[ `, . ;%S h6 ?% , 
% em - t&2 ,. )% MHQC Tm YQ'< cN ]  
+ 1 R5 Q<* ,M, - 
 ŀ1 C l U! U l'
6 7* B$‡C :)& K41 " : """ BC k1 X ^ ,;š 5
,P: H 4S h  7* 84 −83 RSN< 5e   L:
i V €[¤  W ; ^ - t&  :~ h  7* 442 SN
5e `5* h!m h $ %S P `+e 7 ;š 5* +lC ;%S - `^ C
µ 1 +S2 l0C Y  xE P: H 4S h  7* 89 − 87 $Q<
:' U l< % '[m h $ Š0 : /E 7* h!m X RS^ h $
+Œ2 3C w2 µ  , H 4S h  7* 35 ;$  B< ¡:2  5e
; ^ C i &SC C! E   Ug $m +Œ2 H* h $ ¡€[ ;%

176
#$% &'
"!       
  

h  7* 447 SN 7* 2 1 ;N< 5e ,” >M1 V €[¤  W


C e U! U l'* ~ '* ,g : &) f:' C% 4QC `<' 13"103 %
K2! V €[J :+& O  g h 52 &” H* h $ ŀ[
V €[J +4C `<' 08"09 % h  7* 59 − 57 −56 − 4 $Q< 5e
"ŀ1 C l U! U l' ~ '* A ™ K2
.%$ 5000 A%& &* D+'2 K1 ;& N B$jC :1 K41 "
"·J - % 5 ;&* &+&s  S B<Qs * ,M:* &, 
"*&* V U%1:* C%jC B+ [ `H%6
 ,K1 ( H$ e 7* ” œ& ,\ + 1 X g :C
M<' BC k1 :MQC `<'+ H ;š 5 + 1 c\m p\t 7* iQ
<} ;š 5 B+ [ hQD* &E6 ,R * R&C  m ;&+ P +&*
" M:QD* U 5v + 1 $M[ g &
 iQ \SN2
4 U 5vm &S ,BC k1 ( H$ e 7* ” œ& ;E X g :C
:M  l5< J `5e €:C 3$6 , B M<6 7*  '
H 4S C  - µ€  l5 J `5e € ,BC k1 C  W
 D  N :+ '* Ž= , *g\  J `5e € , C0
H* h1 &) """ 'QwC  t + [ ,2019/05/20 ±&,6 fS+
"2019/2018 :

C U\w U e€: 4T , 5e ;$ M1C
Ž, ,2019/11/26 < M›6 U < ;&'C D ƒ%$m X g :C
+&2 3Q h)% “&t ;! 
J UŽ, , 1 BC k1
3$6 ,T * i BE ,M :MQC T 6 `<'2 , <1 (H& 7* QZ
:
KC  * B 3 E B6 BC k1 c‹ ,P +&* BE :M  l5 C
7* 97 ;$  h6 x! ,MQ< Â<5 g &
 VS€C  v 2013 2009
7QD2 g &
 h6 x! ,g &
 +e ‰:2 P: H 4S h 

177
#$% &'
"!       
  

. ˆ5D C E i% h‡H R  B2 VS€C , M'} i M ®'C
i<wQ< %C U&M1
 * ' C : i g &
 BC Y  7*
(H& - 35 Q4 Uj%6 %H ,R * 7* €:C 3$6 X J
U  C c\ <M* h+$ ! 
J iQ ,()Q< MQ) <1
,Bm n: C A% '[m BC k1 +. 7* &Ej &'C ,;š 5 + 1
% <lC 2 B6 ,%&:E %ŒQ+‡C  m ;&+wC N4 B6 n 6
ÍH 'Q~ l16 ±&,J B< &: ,""" '} R 6 l0 'Q~
7* QZ P:C Y  B6 , 'Q~ * X V €[J 7* QZ Yw”
B6 6 ,""" . ,#'Q~ µ 1: X """ (H 2 E Yw. R, UT 
h E 7* . *
6 h6 ,Ywp R, UT  7* QZ C C Y  7* .
+&H U e€: ®'C 7QD2 %SC   `H%6 B6 ,Ywp x!  /+
% 7* <lC 3 E l0 h6 ,%S BC A&*6 'Q~ %S* A%
UT  h6 """ ¡€[ - +&N UP ,""" * h6 L) 6 , 'Q~
2 M< Q?6 ;&
h6 L) 6 Rb
7 , < A%D, X g :C UP
B6 L) 6 ,   R J 
b* * Y 4 &'C kN1 œm M<
,;š 5 + 1 U H* Q4 B< 3) , wl<5 C n<
J f
“&t ;! 
J 3$6 ,U%1: x<2 E P:C Y  7* . BjC jH
2020/01/21 <wC ,K1 ( H& M:* € 3Q<
` v 7* QwQC
;! 
J UŽ, ,B H$ $M[ ;š 5 + 1 $M[ BC k1 Ž,
,]& `^ C K5 l 7 h+$ ! 
J Ž, BC k1 7 “&t h)%
 BN &'C """ kQQ< (
 %2 $M1 7*  g\tm &'C
BNSC Y ' Qw< « , h E B6 c‹ ,   KQ B$6 ;$ M1
  x<2 P:C Y  7+« ^ +SC """ 6&C ]& Qw 7* D
B6 ,  x<2 +C Y  B6   < * - U <'
X #$ ,+S 7* A%¢ h E ¦6¥ h6 ,7+« ^  C ¦Y 6¥ %S+ h E

178
#$% &'
"!       
  

h B6 c‹ ,   KQ B$6 ;$ M1  BN &'C """ &. 1
#&'+ h6 h $ M< Q?6 ;6* h6 $ ' $&SC Y ' Q~ h E l<

<e M AP * h6 ,  C B < T tj2 Y ' Q~ h6 ,&,6 M<
%S ˆ<+ h E M h6 T Y6 L4 AP * h E hm E+ T B: B<
c n« 6 Yw. #6 + I B6 $ H6 Rb
7 , * NSC %S+ h E
'Q~ ;%$m h6 Tm Y } B6  &C %D^ C  e −6– 1 h6
¦6¥ Ž, hm E+ T B6 Tm , Ž, V €[6 ;& ¯ :. h6 ,x! 3DH%
#6 h $ *\E U$ 1* ¯ :. 3 E B6 &E6 ,V €[6 ;& * Y6 A&,
%S &. 1 X 3) R : BN2 ” %S+ h E BC k1 h6 ,f:
MN &'C """ ;&. 1 X #$ ,  ƒ% t 3 E   x<2 h6 &EjH
†6 ,/E - C* †6 3,‹   KQ M$6 ;$ M1 
† .$lC 3*  'Q~ % h6 V €[6 ;& %D4C 3²H
, S€[ 60 —, œm S+ %D^ h 1 E2 T †6 ,h4S+
V €[6 ;& ¯ :. h6 U&E6 ,3'  M: . UP    h6
R C 3<S2 'Q~ % h6 ³H ±&,6 9 : Rt$ h6 h %S+
<
+  $'+ I g Cu h6 U$ H6 Rb
7 ,MQw ®H 2 ¯%&
'Q~ - 7+« ^ h6 3H )6 ,M< Ht ' &'C /E œm .g :C6
&'C """ &. 1 X #$ ,.>? Ž, x! &'C v K<* ' . +&5 -
_ BNSC « , h E B6 c‹   KQ B$6 ;$ M1  BN
7+&H N '+ T B6  œm <t$ V €[6 ;& Ž, , l<
%S+ h E BC k1 h6 3l
U« ^ &,m h6 ,(T X
h6 c‹ %S B< 3) ,7+tª V €[6 œm H )m f2 p l
C
œm %D^ 5<e †6 n 5 ae *
6 h6 ,\'H 3 E   x<2
B:* <e *
6 h6 *
6 3':* X h6 >2 6 f: #6 7+ I (T
*
6 """ Qe H h6 $ H6 Rb
7  b Q4C B5e t +S Y&

179
#$% &'
"!       
  

3 E    . †6 +&N 7+ B6 7+« ^ 96% X  E 7* ›


BN &'C """ &. 1 X #$ ,[ 6 
#6 Q+ I  t$
B $ %S* BNSC « , h E B6 c‹   KQ B$6 ;$ M1 
œm t$  M Œ e 7* B< 2 B6 ( +S 'Q~ %
V €[J Tm ;%$ 0 M:* 35<e ,R % g  V €[6 ;& & 
E ° ¯%& %D, g :v6 h %S+ V €[6 ;& ¯ :. h6 Ke€:
3*  U .+&H ¯ :. h6 &EjH %S B< 3) ,B<5
R , œm
h %S+ V €[6 ;& ¯ :. h6   K . %S h6 .+SC
`
B6 c‹ B+. 7* &Ej &'C ,""" &. 1 X #$ ,  : MN2”
  KQ B$6 &'C Bm (
 Q4 U% 'Q~ % ;& N
#6 ¯ :. 7+ I 'Q~ hQ4+ V €[J 7* QZ 7+ B6 c‹
. %S h6 , 'Q~ % ƒ Œ BNSC Ž, M h6 c 6 n«
KQ M$6 ;$ M1  MN &'C """ ;&. 1 X #$ , ^ K
MN '2 T UŽ, """ Qe H h6 /E C ;eb* †6 3,‹  
,X &: UŽ, †6 p 3,‹ .%D, g :v6 B6 V €[6 ;& H%
³H 3v&, 'Q~ * Q4 S€[ 40 7* E6 Ž, x! &'C
3v&, \'H B6 V €[6 ;& H% 7+« ,  E *
6 Qe H h6 , *%
F C Y2 'Q~ % hjC c°2 3 E Qe H h6 /E C *% ³H
h6   K †6 U&E6 M< .P 2  %S 3) g [6 ;&'
`C
?% BC k1 f<È 2020/01/28 <wC   7* g/ x!
7 h+$ ! 
J Ž, ,B: h)% “&t ;! 
J UŽ, %D^
h+$ ! 
J H% ;/.  D Q4 U  H ,]& `^ C K5 l
BC k1 +. c\‡C Y  B6 L) 6 , ,\ ;š 5 + 1 &E6
  Y& VS€C ,U  5  C 7 :02 :e  l5 h6
BC k1 h6 , + 1 i g &
 h\lC œm °:+ B‡H g &


180
#$% &'
"!       
  

BC k1 h6 44 h E g &


 h6 ;š 5 + 1 7* €:C 2
h\lC H$ 7 B:* TŒ :2 '+ _ Q4 <²
6 X n 6 <~ Ž,
f $%6 BC k1 h6 L) 6 Œ :   ¡W () - ,g &

@  *
6 h6 , <5<5 ;% vm ,V €[J 7* QZ Y&
C Y ' Q~
Y  'Q~ - µ€:* BE Y ' Q~ A%D, 5
'Q~ % *
®N M:* \y h E ;6 µ
h6 ,AŒ/N
 T = A+SC BC k1
+ I $M1 h6 wl<5 R 6 7* Q #jC 2 I Qe H h6 Y ' Q~
X U% 5' %S 7* QZ P BC k1 h6 *
6 .$
œ$6 ,BH  \2 h6 &'C +&H P:C Y  E K1 MH  ´ B4N
RSH h6 St% <l+ +S h6 ,7+tª V €[6 ›% KC
C w
 $ + 1 R5 iQ BC k1 `, - C v + 1
, $ x< E & iQ ,K1Q<  ^ %Ž< & U 5<l<
QZ ()* 3 E + 1 h6 4)* BC k1 ( H& Q< 3l 6
h  `5e 'C  h\lC œm #$b+ g &
 h\lC h6 34) 6 (H& 7*
R5 Y& 3Q <1 (H& QwC 3y P: H 4S
, H 4S +, 7Q) %
& h6 34) 6 () - ,\[ + 1
œ& Z& VJ VS€C ±&^ 3l? H 4 C : ` vC 3$6
,h1 MH °2 & h2 h6 7Q+ VJ B2 . h6 34) 6 ”
- .P . <2 m ,%S +&N +SC + I 1 h6 34) 6
* fS+  D  N Ž= h6 ,xC ¢°2 <l+ T . ;&+~
   h6 %S+ h E Q~ h6  &E6 $M1 h6 Y ' Q~ - 
k1 BC C   VS€C 'Q~ %S* .% BC k1 .P
V €[J h6 BC k1 B5E H L+w c& U% 5' $ \H BC
<e 'Qw< O
J h  C 3$6 ,/E X Qwq  Ž, 7+
 lC X AH2 h $ Rt& $%6 1 hjC 3< ,h+$ ! 
J B<

181
#$% &'
"!       
  

,;H* >?   h E%6 h6 ;Q* 3 E Î% J h6 µ€


VS€C , , 12 T . n<
J ” &S , wl<C Q<E h6
g : h6  t 7E *6 - .+SC `<'+ MH ;6 +SC `<' h 
$M1 h6 , * U S€[ 7. Y h * -  E 7.+S2 2 Æ\
:+ h E%J h6 /EQ< V €[J BC Ž, # n<
J  &E6
7* g &
C 3$6 *g\  B BC k1 h6 Q  >? 'C Q<
” œ& VJ $ '5
 3Q ,h+$ ! 
J B< <e 'Q~
 , & U 5<l - V St Y& BC k1 ;g C L+°
he€: Y ' Q~ Ž¢ B6 &Eb+ O
J h  h6 h+$ ! 
J
µ€:QE w* *
6 h6 &N2 ;$ M1C œ$6 Ke€: w
- h<w
h6 h)% ;! 
J 35 ,BC k1 ( H$ M< <e 5w, Qe H E
/w, H , :
E $&“ µ€ h6 C
U: $'2 ” œ& &.1
"2020/02/11 <~ *j< f<
% 3g (X' 1&-
:)& K41 "
H&C 2019/11/26 <wC BC k1 ( H$ Y&2 , : (i " − 
B*, Y&  &C , M<E* œm B g &
 h\l5C L+° œm *+
BC `<'+ H  t ,P: H 4S h  7* 97 ;$  U D
, * ' C : e 7* i ˆ5D C E i% e 7* g &

" M'} i M<E M M ®'C X A% S
&+&s Y&' ;š 5 + 1 R5 Y& œm *+ •[ H&C 3*&2 E
"B:MQC `<'+ H BC k1 +.
41'= FC3- H1 " : 6 
h‡H ,P: H 4S h  7* 97 ;$  U D 5e Bm ,
xC ,]& l 6 * ' C : BQ<2 g &
C ¯s *Q'  &

182
#$% &'
"!       
  

,š 5 g &
 <2 6 Â<52 p RE* <6 M . ]& l h‡H
- V St 5,  . * ' C : hjC R   Ç  >? 7*
R t h  hJ ,M œm ]& l 7 %$ S š 5 g &
 Â<52
]& l œm x! $ :
m - L+‹ A\ 6 ¡: hJ ,x! X ¡:+ _
*Q'  &
% _ X  ^ B2 . - °+ * ' C : % $ ,BN
" M+s Ugm ! N:
 &'C M5*
T ,   <Q' K, : 7* B‡H x! X 
j2 Bm ,
hJ ,M œm š 5 g &
 Â<52 B:* ;%$ 5QC œ+ h6 ]& l< 7Q+
Œ M . ,  :~ *SW e6 œm Ug &
 Â<52 Mm RE M~
%
* . ,Y Y a 7* 37 ;$  U D $ :
 B% - \_ ˆ5D C E
Q4 7 %$ S ^ M:C 7* Y ,6 ;& -  D Q' B<
>? 15/1414 $& 4:~ f< - 2015/09/28 ©+% C ;l: C &C
©+% C %$ S g D5 %& C +/ &C Q4 , ,%1:*
: h6 BH g  # ,%1:* >? 2016/43 $& 4:~ f< - 2016/07/25
A” ˆ5D C E 4<S* i% 5 7* M œm Â<5 š 5 g &

R %D^ C M f<C G  ;>tJ A. *6 X g :C Q4
g &
 B0<52 œm * ]& l iQ< C w
 ,A\ 6 <'< M* *6
L4S $ S* . C ,h < f ’ >? k5+ , Q
% NSC B'C *
"B, % Bl:*
} g &
 KQD2 Y&'C `<' H& VS€C Bm ,
g &
 hjC p LD2 ,%E g &
 X Q4 (\e C B‡H ,M
X 5l   $ &+&s 2 + 1 - ;l M <?6 7QD2
,;š 5 + 1 7* €:C H* h E B6 E ,B M M } f
M X ' B:Q+ .= ;gC ,SN* 1C M 3:QD2 
KQD2 7* (P . t2  + 0 h‡H —  C ,`$ 1C Bm M
7* B H  N , 2m - <Q ,BC k1Q< M M< g &

"xC `s & , M m&5 *, BN 7 ( H& Bww, +&2 6

183
#$% &'
"!       
  

L+° K<1 K'H& $% K'+ BlC `5


*  Bm ,
"š 5 g &
 R5C
# ' /U 1/1R 1&- H1 " : :
+ 1 ;š 5 + 1 X M \e R\t 7* Q4Q< K52 ,
,   $&= . * `H BC k1Q< <*  +p :QD2 †6 , ,\
:M* VS€C  jlW c\m K1 ( H$ iQ *&'C  t
 ^ B:M* h6 Tm ,T * 01+ h E B6 >tJ . &E6 *&'C BC k1
B+ 1C x! K1 ( H$ 7Q) ,  m ;&+ P +&* .
& <' B2 p ;š 5 + 1 R5 Y&'C RT&
 B'* h+ _ , ,\
U <1< *= + 1 Ug  —  C ,7+ I hjE L5jH BE%&2 2
"   5<l
:S! " šš n
l
* 6 7* BC k1 $m œm &q 1 + [ hm ,
"A\ 6 Mm % 1 RSN `H ^ .  5+&C
- `^ C i V €[¤  W ; ^ - t& L: ¡¬ H -
w2 µ  `5* h!m h $ %S P `+e 7 ;š 5* +lC ;%S
&SC C! E   Ug $m +Œ2 H* h $ ¡€[ ;% +Œ2 3C
C e U! U l'* ~ '* ,” >M1 V €[¤  W ; ^ C i
: K2! V €[J :+& O  g h 52 &” H* h $ ŀ[
tjC ,B5,  h!m h $ ] ~ Y  ,A\ 6 L:~ `s µ :* hm ,
+&^ 2 *<' 
 7* <
R'
C V €[J % µ 
X %S B2 . ­N, ,n
^ 6 H?N +S ª 6 f2 p E
Ky tª h * œm  N h * 7* %S B2 . R
%m M< v ΠM~
V t h * - ¡€1 $ ;% « * , M< RS^ 7* V €[J
; ^ *^ + £ x! ,V t 1C ;%$  U *<' B2 . h2 h6

184
#$% &'
"!       
  

Y  ,ŀ1 C l U! U l' ~ '* Ã2 E ,$H¤  W


X `5l2 , † &C 6 ª alC /w:2  U <Q' 7* QZ 6 <Q'C
6 L 6 R
% 6 w 6 Qw * ŀ[ C e U! U l'*
C l U! U l' 7* <M* QwQC x! `<'+ h6 ,""" !
" :'* >+ '* `H Tm Mm ƒ 7Q+ T  ŀ1
  VS: * Œ :< ' U l' % QC Bm ,
h6 Q4Q< 35v &H , .E! f  :+ ‹ :' 'C  ()*
KN…* 7* * ' A$ 2+ Y g DH . , 'Q~ g DH t$ h E +S
BC 46 k‰¢ k, S€[   Q1+ I +S h6 E ,Ke€:*
‹ :' B'* h2 _ ,A\ 6 Mm j* U D M< ¡:2  +^ C
;tb* Y&'C L+° x '52 K'+ Q  >? A\ 6 R 'H¤ :+
" M<6 7* M
/E 7* h!m X RS^ h $ µ 1 +S2 l0C Y  ¡¬ H -
: :' U l< % '[m h $ ,Š0 :
e 7* A$ ' '*/* h E # Y ' Q~ Ž, B6 M &E6 ,
*g\ C œ$6 ,;%E 'Q~ % 7* ; $ X g :C ,""" '}
x! R\t 3'  ±&,J +SC Y  6 ,2018/04/24 - §%b*
A% +&H U e€: ®'C 7QD2 %SC   `H%6 B6 &Eb* Y
"%S . BC A&*6 'Q~ %S*
`<' 88"13 % h  7* 35 ;$  U D 5l2 Bm ,
21 ;$  µ š 3H
  m N4 E X “ B‡H P: H 4S C
B6 ,Š0 : /E +&* œm L+° X RS^ <lC Y&2 h6
,R w . - M< VS: U C'< L+°2 h &C +S2 E  '+
>1+ T h  . h6 K5+ H?2: :S h  ( C B6 >?
xE , :M* eš6 :
Y\H6 Œ wm - 5? ƒ  U Eš œm Tm

185
#$% &'
"!       
  

¡È Y ,6 #6 7QD+ T !m ,;%S* +% 2 /w:2  +/N< U: œm


"]  Y\ 
n ? Y *6 B‡H ,¡:C Tm C T Q+ T 6&5 T m Bm ,
;&+~ RS, Y&  , - 5 C' $&s    VS:
6 7* M ;tb* Y& K'+ 35 ;$  - %E L+° X  
" B:* B2g C L+° x!
:%& @A +G h› r
6 7 [ >5'2 E BjC ,  :~ h  7* 443 ;$  3H ,
" :'* ' +6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 >s ;% 5
,UT  - g  # f œm ,M+ [ - K1 &:
 ,
35+ B6 K5+ wM wl<5 R jC Y  C f œm ,( C B6 >?
$Z X °+ T , H '+ —  C K1Q< :1*   T 'H6
" 5
A% 5  7Q+ k,   6
U :+ & UT  h6 &N+ _ f< <W A\ 6 <'< Bm ,
 4: U5v Y&'C Q4 3': &H :<'  U% 5 7QD2
" M:* B2g C R K'+ M `, - :<'
:%& >? +G h› r
(P h6 ,P: H 4S h  7* 44 ;$  ¡ 7* tb+ ,
A. 3 E !m , ². 6 ¡€[ œm M5 6 ' g $m E , H   Š0
" Mm 35  ²p 6 ¡€1 % 5  6 š iy '
X ;%1: UT   t B2 += f< ` v 7* tb+ ,
B6 ,K1 ( H$ e 7* ” œ& ,2019/05/17 ©+% C i+C C5 *
:   ÂS C U :+ & 7* QZ %E  X P: 2

186
#$% &'
"!       
  

 /+ """ kQ %&:E %ŒQ+‡C """ n/, 2 E "" wl<5 n<
jC" −
"""" ;6 .j2 7+2 /E* U&N* X wM+ wl<C
""" 'QwC ;D 
+ %&:E %ŒQ+‡C """ n/, (H 2 E wq" −

b C 2 /E* t$ ³N <5<5 7*  , `<¬ N U\w'
"7* D< i* W &Q=
%ŒQ+‡C """ E4C n/^ iN:C +$  H% """ n/, (H 2 E" −
"7* D< i* W &Q= 
b* /E* U&N* X hQwM+ %&:E
.P MQQ'2   E N  U :+ & U% 5 hm ,
& K1 hjC ;& ‚%  7.! - `<È h6 †j[ 7* ,] m * X
3': wl<5 n<
jC f h6 x! ,g+ +€ \Q'

:+ H 1+ ,U\w' œm ;D R
%m œm $6 # wM C
œm (
 R\t 7* 352 I    . ,K1Q< :1*  
$& %D, X ˆH ° *J h6  &E6 7+ ,A\ 6 Mm j* $M1
R J K1 'Q~ % KC *\E U$ 1* 3' V €[J 7*
X g&  #6 + h6 h $ , wl<5 R 6 œm S+ h6 h $ ,  
] '2 3 E U\w' œm M< 2  ;& h6 M'}  &E6 U&N
 t A%= M< &Q   wM:Q 0S C R  h6 E ,# g$ 7*
#l:+ ,p O  g   N R J 1 
 E! X A/E2
,>0 ‰ - ›% 5  ›%& 7* ˆ¢ M*C 9  X x[ \C
E! , ' X B+1 R t$m h‡H xC ,x! œm B2$%m A ™ &Eb+
$ &, BH Y/<+ I ,& '+ T A\ 6 
J R'
C M< U <'2
7* È C ,A‰ M X %MQ~ (\em `¢ C ,% 5t 6 Ç\C
" >M1< <
`<'
, Q  B b* h2 xC P: +&* . A\ 6 K:‰ hm ,
I ,UT  B2 . P:C Y  7* . \'H B6 Q4 B2 . Y *6 &E6 B6  t
"B<5 7* Π:* = ' 72

187
#$% &'
"!       
  

. l 6  f+% ' hjC Q4 3': A\ 6 <'< Bm ,


Q4 M :2  U% 5' X a 5l Y y `5l:2  4:~ (P
- C v  4: h6 ,x! X 
j2 p 35v ,A\ 6 $% 4: X
"x! 6 7* B2tbQC L+° —  C K'+ K:‰ `,
 &   h& M Qs K'+ ,
:&-' 1 K41 "
:9 c e 7* *& & U 5l VS€C −
, ” `,\ %Ž 7 &* D+'2 ]& `^ C 5 l 3Q ,
";š 5 + 1 C ;l M H$ U Q<* `H
&+ h6 “ *Q  $ Y  &: %Ž 7 ®+' hm ,
"*~ 'N n 2% 7  4D< ŀ[ š 5* %« &2 ;% ŽC
g
 R\t 7* Q4Q< 35+ I B‡H R ^ Œ  - Bm ,
hjC Mm Q $M1 ;$ M[ R\t 7* E , ()* U :+ &
B<6 7* h& 'N< w S€[ U%Ž2 & 9 c ]& `^ C 5 l
q 5<e xC h2 ,B55
Y&'T ®+' C 5 lQ< R Z T —  C ,M
" p5 Y&'C L+° K'+ <
]  9
6 X :5* >?
: 6 ;& N *& & U 5<l VS€C
U <1 H E  6 ;& N &  l +&2 -  % ,
,“ 7* &) 3'H% , <.J 4<S NS B 7_ 3M !m ,  
" p5C B'* L+° 05:+ _ ,   U 5 M: $b*
 & U , `H  4: 6 7* 7+$6 K:‰ hm ,
"A\ 6 <SN *Q'

188
#$% &'
"!       
  

%« `^6 & h+ ,B<6 7* 7+$6  K:‰ n 2% C Bm ,
* , ›% 5  ›%'[ - ” 6 ,""" ]& `^ C K5 l C š 5* T ,
<e h‡H ,% t :C 7 M e 7* 2% & %E 'N h6 Y$
l<
7* p * `H B C w
 Q4 Uj2% % * k5+ ®+'
A  Q  ^ %Ž 2 'N ;%lt x! -  * ++&2
" A&'C ^ al:* `H R&  C
 & Ft e E X &  & - f+% S C ¢ ,
Qs B'* K'+ _ , & ;l h  7* 124 SN U D 5l2
l<
7* p C Q4 Uj2% , .Ë t A% 5 C  &   M
"k$J - B, - ]&5 AE ;&* &+&s ++&2
n3I _?
:#%D, C QC &C :< Q4 3Q,
;š 5 + 1 VS€C ;%  <1 (H& } $C :1 -
"\[ p5C R
:() -
 4: 6 7* """ K:‰ ;tbQC : )& K41 " ˜˜
Y&'C ".%$ Tª ;P " 10"000 .%& ;H  *0C B< ^ :<'
 S B<Qs ,B:* B2g C L+° Bm n:  C 6 7* B2tb*
"k$J &^ -  Z
:&-' 1 K41 "
g Cm p5 Y&'C :9 c e 7* *& & U 5l VS€C
" M'H% `2 X  S
: 6 ;& N *& & U 5<l VS€C

189
#$% &'
"!       
  

p5 :1 -
D+'2  6 ]& `^ C K5 l ;& N """ M g$jC :() -
 S B<Qs * ".%$ Tª v\v" ,M:* &,  .%$ 3000 A%& &*
"k$J &^ -  Z
: M1 Y - ;&': :<' <~ - •2 ^ %& ”
""" : 7* * . Q4 C +$   U <~ C A\ 6

”3
 @N5 c 

190
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺎﻟﺮﺑﺎط‬


2014/03/12 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
272
2013/2102/1109 ‫ﰲ اﳌﻠﻒ اﻟﺠﻨﺤﻲ ﻋﺪد‬

:m14
9 * {- * /1 $2 ]C4 1 +,  5 wL
!<Q W' ‚A ]3N (-- W’ †w /Y'- ^% /    P
O‹ $+'-  T U W [I- c M34 * T)
N  wL
k>? +G " F&
@%g \4 ”   `'/ %01 /ƒ >g T /d #/1N
’- &-' eL œ 8i/    S! "  
l+- GL
8[ /i (& ,'f /G^ )+ eL )& K41
k3

% 3g †% FG #-


:H  
C : 5 7* Y& š 5 g &
 ÌQC 'C  x+s X g :C
©+% C Œ : - /w:  D eP Ž= X x! - ;&: , * '
©+% C Bm !m ,µ C eš e 7* ,a ¦…¥ $& 3s ,2013/06/25
VS€C  D `s LH R&' +Œ 7* <t& +Œ <e ,2013/05/07
š iy  ,    ®'5C ;%1: A\ 6 M U ¢°2
!m ,2013 +C6 25 11 ©+% C * ,Y ' #6 Y *6 :*J L S % 5 

www.maroclaw.com : h  n0* <w ]   C %1:* − 272

191
#$% &'
"!       
  

x< UC ’ .g% U [ A. " :BH R  A\ 6 MQ< L+°2 BH $%
E 7 R b . 9$  &Q= x< hm " :  )6 ,"9$  &Q=
g  ,A\ 6 MQ< ¢°2 $% 6 # ,2013/04/25 ©+% C """ * v ,".
* v ,"x<Q< ;š 5 ;* 3s 2  :*J ;/MJ :C% s " :BH
,9$  &Q= UC ’ .g% [ " :BH $% 6 ,2013/04/25 ©+% C ¦…¥
7 ::+ 7 Ywp h6 ,. E 7 R b . 9$  &Q= x< h6
"":
¬ 7 ^ C E R
;&+~ 7 &, R b A% 5 C ¦h"6¥ N4S< (
 &:
;&+~ C .P 2 R6 7* A\ 6 MQ<  * VS€C  
6 # ,A\ 6 M . ;%1: % 5tJ %&S* hjC L) 6 ,;%E
%^ 6 & ,¦("6¥ . ,% '* 
 B'
 ?% BN:C %^ B'*
" ^ œm R :M S€1 B2 , R, P _ &Ej<
  ;&+~ C  b* .% 5 C ¦Y"Y¥ N4S< (
 &:
  ;&+~ C .P 2 R6 7* A\ 6 MQ<  * VS€C
A\ 6 M 7* L+° 3<2 7* S€[ †jC 34) jH ,A\ 6 ;%E
M:* $   ,A\ 6 MQ< S€1 ; ^ R, %1: W 4 7* &Ej<
"&,6 `, -  #6 1+ T AP 2 * hjC
K2&+~ * '+ BjC L) 6 , +&My A\ 6 MQ< (
 &:
7* M'* N2 . T S2 6 \'H BjC &E6 ,¦…¥ ¦…¥ K 
&,J `5
 [ R, M<²
6 X $< ¦h"6¥ ¦Y"Y¥ 7* E e
&'C % 4 X Y&6 B6  &2  ,B, .P h6   
Y M* 
2 BH $+ I # ,g4S DC `<' _J % % &

J 3 E , C:~  J - h  a, 5* Q1 
%:
hjC &E6 "B, UP  [ R, B<'H ;$% H'* . B M
c‹ :C ,&Ej 0 - g  BJ , $ 7+ I BC œ$6 # L+°

192
#$% &'
"!       
  

'C 2 ;/M6 A&) U [ A. ¯¢ 7* hjC x1+ B6 ¦h"6¥ N4S<
+e - B+6% &C6 <E B6 A&: :+ ,B:'C Œ M $&¢ h6 h $ ,  &<
BjC c‹ BjC  )6 , < 
b R 0[ +e g4S f<* >C&2
Agm 6 , q/M6 7 R J R b . ,  &< % BNSC ,x<
#6 M4:Q+ I BjC &E6 E ,¦…¥   ;&+~ ;& N L+°2 #J
"MHe 7* AP + h6 &'5+ I B6 Tm ,P: C L) ¡t2
©+% C ;&': <~ .tª U < ;& - D 3%$6 ,
&'C ,¦…¥ ! 
J B H$ 5 7* %Œb* K:‰ .Ž,  2014/02/26
Y&2 ,  D lC D Ž4QC h $  C l* Ug   ,B+. 7* &Ej
<t& +Œ N Y&' ¡È <1 (H& 7* QwQC ¦…¥ ! 
J
\DH ,B<E* 'C QC ¢° 5 l Y&' , D `s LNC 5 lQ<
,B<E* 'C * X `H+ B2T &* 7 2  *^ i<wQ< % Y&' 7
œ$6 ,P: H 4S h  7* 71 SN U D* X x! - &:

U H& } $% x< E & iQ ,A\ 6 ;%  (H& C ;EQC
35 g %m Q4 U%H , p ]  9
J Y&'T ( H& 5 7* ;% 
D
%$ - %Q
 ,.~ - 35 K, œm (H& } -
I BjC n 6 ,Bm n: 7 A\ 6 M +. 7* &Ej &'C " M1 :*
% 5  Q4 U%H ,&,6 #6 * P: 6 7* Q
% nw
 #6 “
R :2 , $ iQ x< E & Q< R :2 ,;/.  D
R iQ , D U C\*  ‰ B) &'C ,M ( H$ Q<
"2014/03/12 <~ *j - D ) %H ,Bm  _ B<E* ;g C
(X' 1&-
:(%&'
3
6 ,A\ 6 M `, - * ' C : 5 7* ;%  'C  hm ,
 C K<' P: H 4S h  7* 45 44 K<SN U D* X

193
#$% &'
"!       
  


b U ²p Î~ E 4  D i w `, - 2
"n0 C *Q' U%$
1C ‰ V t #Œ h  . ,P: H 4S h  hm ,
M*, “  , *Q'  & x+s p D¬  &  `$
" ” &
¯s " : B6 X P: H 4S h  7* 72 ;$  3S ,
3S E ""¦""¥ ]& l 6 * ' C : Â<52 g &
C *Q'  &
&) *Q'  & 9% y " : B6 X  :~ ;l h  7* 3 ;$ 
""¦""¥ ” 2% - KE% 1 K›  Q+w< •J  N
g &
 h6 p LD2 ,f< ` v X Q4 (\e‡C Bm ,
"•6  NE * ' C : 5 7* MQ< Â<C R ^ Œ  -
¢‹ NSC $&¢ A&w ,P: H 4S h  œm ( C Bm ,
7 52 ~ - n ' M< #“ 7+ K<J K< N +°,
:- 67 ;$  q$&, !m , H 4S `+e
"MN 6 M:M* 3 E NE h š : 6 P: +&* −
"h š  6 h +&* ¯ :. 7+ I hm h55 UT  n 46 −
"UT  n 46 ¯ :. 7+ I hm C l n 46 −
n 46 ¯ :. 7+ I hm a S C hN< h Œ h' 5 −
"¦…¥ C l
Y q  , - " :B6 P: H 4S h  7* 68 SN  )6 ,
h55 UT  n 46 h‡H C l n 46 7+š : 6 P: #+&*
""g Eš MNSC h'C +

194
#$% &'
"!       
  

- H 1 ;%$ q   U% 5 7QD2 # P: hm ,


,‹ h!6 T ,M 5 7* A\ 6   &~ - AP + I , M,
% 1 V €[J 7* &,6 #6 N Q¢ T ¦6"(¥ h6 E ,AP:C KN4S<
, H 4S h  U D 5l2 P: hjC <' * ,A\ 6 67 SN - Mm
h E !m BJ , \ AP œm ,‹ L+° ,   Bw2 h6 Ã+
h+ h6 h $ R * #6 P ®HC P: +& `^ kl 6 & H 4S h 
P: 7QD2 * !m )N* B b* k52 C  - B‡H ,x! + C */<*
,YQ' œm    R S+‡C Y  7* . B ,% ?J C iy U% 5
"P: X B*&m 5 µ , #4  b* B< 2 —  C
P:C M 7 %$  L+‹ h!m #6 7* f< <t Y *6 Bm ,
B  X g   E , Q4 Y *6 L+° A%  $ :
 ,nw

 e ,P: C ,‹ ¡t+ I B6 B:* $ N+ #  D eP Ž4QC
, w4E .% 5  7Q+ T nw
 +6 7+ KN4S U ¢°2 h6
M b* h6 Y$ * D - $M1E Mm (
¸ ›¹ &
 k, T
" 5'* k52 'C  h‡H , <Q=  :~
 & x+s ' Š0 (P H ,A\ 6 E!  \DH ,Bm ,
UT ^ , $ &  ) t P: H 4S  - *Q'
:B6 X ¡ # ,P: H 4S h  7* 71 SN - M< VS:
:5 U ²p E 4  D i w œm B  6   , -"
E 4 i w ´™  &* &'C Tm 2 T 'C  h‡H ,45 SN -
< ²M< 7+ I hm ,U 'C  C 5 l , * < - ;%E U ²p
"" ²p i% 7* + 1C 'C  #wH *
:*J ;/MJ f<’ i% . <t& +Œ h6  H X Bm ,
BC E R\t 7* 3C  h‡H , M: + 1 +&2   B R€ , <Q C

195
#$% &'
"!       
  

gm <e X ˆH ° B6 ,R&' +Œ œm 2013/05/07 ©+% C B
 &  ,‡C 'C  œm ,‹ >1+ h6 h $ () -  D 4C
µ[  + 1 h6 % 5  X , S€ +/ Q4 œm *Q'
:w 7* ¢‹ 5 l* 7QD2 h6 Ã2 ,A\ 6 71 ;$  - .H2 (P
h  cš BC E - Ê<QW "$¥ B5 '* ] ~ 'C QC S€ l<< B<
7 n ? * . "¦
$  '5l 90 4N ,R J g/~ ,  :~ ;l
"f< C `H <t& +Πn E
<Q %
$ 7* 23 ;$< *, ,A\ 6 E!  $ :
 ,Bm ,
B'C * 6 B   6 ¡€[ #6 X ®5 g m Œ“ T" :B6 X ¡:2 
,B‡H ,"h  M< ¡:+  Ug¸ 5e UT ^ - Tm B$m 6
'C  C ¢° + 1 ,A\ 6 l
* `H P: n ? - ,B2 . R ^
R K'+ \[ 5'* Ug  & ;>tJ B2 . h‡H ,h  MD+ E
" p5 Y&'C
" * ' :+/W `2 X  S g Cm K'+ ,
686 œm 636 7* ,372 œm 318 7* ,315 œm 286 7* RSN< 5l2
" 'C  RSH ,ƒ"Y"a 7*
n3I _?
cË 5< 4:~ + D - 352 . &C :< Q4 c°2
: +%D,
`2 X  S g Cm * , * ' C : 5 7* ;%  'C  R5 Y&'C
" * ' :+/W
"µ C C &C Q4 C :<' <~ - •2 ^ %& ”

196
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺼﻔﺮو‬


2020/03/19 :‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
273
2020/2105/445 : ‫ﻣﻠﻒ ﺗﻠﺒﺲ ﻋﺪد‬

:m14
F0 T Y› s- c/Q- W-A \4 / 1N *- # ' 
*-  WX- _15XN 1~'A 19 15 • 8 -   v-
#/1N H $   cž ‰   1&-  ?+-  ^ / 1'
H  M 4L l- + 3N †w #[ W%& ki T4 ?'4
‘ D„ m2- •A 1, N%& )v C- -w5
k   T 2 − 447 (,Q% 3g ,#q 8 i'

% 3g †% FG #-


©+% C ;&': :<' M< - NSC &C Q4 U%&6
: BS Æu ^ i5<2 4:~ + D - 352 . 2020/03/19
 G T Q4 A. & x< E & KC
"9 H ²” h * 4 ]Q #
"h! A%Œb+ """ : kQ
K0  G T
Ug $m 35C 2 *<'* Q‰6 l
C &Q Y  BC 2% C M
R 'HJ ,” >M1 $H¤  W ; ^ C 9  &S C! E  
t$ , :~ h  7* 2 − 447 SN - MC X M< VS:
"4:~ Y$  &*6 B< ®Q+ I 7*Œ :* Q4 Ap  D ;&

"%1:* >? , − 273

197
#$% &'
"!       
  

H  
µ C% ¯%$ e 7* /w: #&MQ 45 Ž= - g  * X g :C
¯%& /E* h6 B:* $ N+ # 2020¨03¨14 - §%b 397 $& 3s >W
¯C i+ N C BC , X :+ &2 P:C Y  A\ 6 M h6 .$ N* *<'* k<2
;% 5' 52 E &w 19 &HE  %E 9 >H g C  , %M‰C p\t 7* ¬
AŒ  &'C , 4  &'C < 5 9 H œm ( c a\^  "  
 %E 9 >NC n S* B6 € C ¡€ 5l &E6 5l  4
:' ," &£ §¤  ' g N1 k:Q ,  , R 6 >W µ C% w2 xC
%1: 7 A% N
 &'C Ž, , /E * œm A¹ &
 2 *J C
&'C MH4C Y  ,/* :+ & P:C Y  7* . B6 BSÈ 4NS h6 &E6
P # %1: 7 % 6 "   ;% 5' E ` $ i¶ —, % *
S€1 4N at 2 &H 4N - < 5  %E 9 >H X
R S2 ˆC% &'C ""n! E f+/* t P +p RMZ ¡€[ 7*
Ž= - Bm (
 +‰:
^ >C&2 3s B')C U*6 * ' C : C
" :+ & C :'Q< E ] 
P:C Y  \'H B6 c‹ ]  Ž= - BC k1Q< (
 &:
$Z *J h E L4 >? W h6 <'+ B6 B¢°2 `C
&Eb* :+ &
 %E 9 >NC BC m VS€C P * h6 ( c kQ &E6 H ,B:* ,/*
" 5 BH* h &C M AP & L4 >?
`H x< E & e 7* A\ 6 M C2   A. X g :C
"h < 5e BQE = &S Q4 A. X B ,6 # A\ 6 K5
7.% M p Ž,6 2020/03/16 <wC D ƒ%$m X g :C
n 6 Bm n: 7 ,B H$ A%Œb+ Ž4 `5e B+. ,R  
MH 5< ;/.  D Q4 U  H Q4 7* N' 5 e   C

198
#$% &'
"!       
  

&S h6 4)* M %Œb* H% , $ x< E & iQ
B iQ ,x! &N+ C &* RΠ:2 :+ & C :' $* >?  :~
fD+ I 2020¨03¨19 <~ *j< f< /w4H ,fN€  … ·6
"&+& M
% 3g (X' 1&-
Bm n: 6 7* x< E & e 7* C2 M hm ,
"A\ 6
"A\ 6 E! H Œ :   ¡€<2 ,
B2 H  Ug  +&My Bm n: 'N C   M hm ,
" Q4 ;j. Y *6 BH  $& , " <SN*
"B:*  D 
T .6 $J &
 T hm ,
R 'HJ U5C R< H  : Q4 & 32 ,
"B$‡C R2 MQ< C:
B ^ ‰ fN€  ‰C M y Q4 Uj2% ,
" < '  
"M B<Q4+  S hm ,
"·J - % 5 ;&* Q4 U$&, ,
n3I _?
A&'C * 365 − 295 – 290 – 286 RSN A\ 6 RSN< 5l2
" ƒ Y a 7* 636 SN
: +%D, &C :< Q4 3Q,

199
#$% &'
"!       
  

K:v 7+M1C x! 7 B5 '* Bm n: 6 7* M ;tbQC
"·J - % 5  S * H  5,
C :<' <~ - A\ 6 : M1 Y - ^ %& ”
""" :;$  7* * . NSC &C Q4 C +$   U <~

200
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺘﺰﻧﻴﺖ‬


2018/08/06 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
2018/12 ‫ﰲ ﻣﻠﻒ ﺷﻜﺎﻳﺔ ﻣﺒﺎﴍة رﻗﻢ‬

:m14
_1! m‹3 /i #/1' 3%C' 8[ Q+,5 W- ]'i QD
q / ' P&I (5 ()i/ 80I  +,  $
T/? /& yfdI ?5 "+D Q,- &')' yfdI
k} ΠT 444 (,Q # %4 P
'i Ÿ (3 T >? %& @A 1QN M34 WGN
,.&! Œ1- t W ,2 œ4  )'a P1 t W-
kkk AQ  œ4 B- T Y'&/ W ,^' 8[ AL W5
c/Q \4 W- ]'i +Q, B&3'' yfdI T 1/1& SFg
— , %4 $%&'- #  1/1&  q #q~4L 1-L  %4 s-
 T W%/  83 (,Q " W%4 y, %& `4 W- $+'/
k* +,

% 3g †% FG #-


2018 31? 06 ©+% C

+ D - 5< :<' M<wC 3/C &C Q4 U%&6


:BS Æu ^ +$N +$ ' 4:~
" Q4 A. & x< E & KC
 G T """""" : ]& `^ C  l

201
#$% &'
"!       
  

"""" ! B:  :
:  G T """"" KC
:H  
`^ C  l e 7* K*& ,\ ;š 5 + 1 X g :C
2018/05/07 ©+% C  D Y
 M: $b """ ! B* = l
C ]&
h6 MH g  # 266572 226383 $& K< , 2018/07/19
* U 4N LNS+ . 2018/04/26 ©+% C ÍH ]& `^ C  l
BC k1 e 7* ;%1:* C* :+ &C ¯C i+ H   
7* M':* kN1 7* <Ne $e A&Q'2 A$ N* B n! E t $ :
m 7QD2
&'C BC k1  E ,$l C f<  QQ< A&+&q ƒ\' U *&W
>€2 K<'  C e 7* K5w' e 7* B:+ &2 U <'2 X $
M:* BN… - BS€[ - A&) ,& U< \ >? ½ NJ E
"‰ 6 Nt * B+Q< +% :
B<E . ,f') a&C Bm ,BQ¢ &,6 T ":
Bm """ 7*Π:* %w* Y% Bm "kN1 `+$ : t&* /:
T +e
? l &) &4: ,Bv$ = &+%6 *&:
^ ‹ : g% Q¢ R& E6
""B+/: >? g :? 4 (%  $ N /*% Bm ,B45[ $ N
 7* (6 U [m +! E6 '2 U< x<2 E h6
&+Œ6 (\e C :<' M< k0l2 +lC 3J 
 .m 
,B, - :< 5
'+ * . , M< `<' qg M< ¡€[ 500 7*
Q+ 2% & BC k1 '“ _ , >? B M M } hJ
"B, - 
3 š m 3J 5[    H 4S hJ
, * NSC +P5 V €[J 4<S* BH  Š “ < 3v&,6
h */ - &'2 BC k1 e 7* 52 R J   x<2 E hJ

202
#$% &'
"!       
  

72$Q< 5e H 4S h   :~ h  M<  '+  h 
RSN 88"13 % P: H 4S h  7* 86 84 82 71 91 83
" :~ h  7* 443 442
3* & BC k1 M52%  :<'   Q+ h6 E
R bQE BNSC A%'1C 9  B .m M:  ŀ1 A% 5  BHPC
3y T  B, - BC k1 .P  +! EJ h6 kN1 7
"B N +$ * %«6 M: 22 <SC 4<
7* BC k1 'C * )* , M* ‰: ‰ + 1 R5 iQ
7* 443 442 K<SN U D H :<'   4: 6
H 4S h  7* 86 84 82 71 91 83 72 $  :~ h 
A%& #$ * ®+'C ]& `^ C  lQ< ^ &* ,88"13 % P:
BC k1 Qs ·J - ]&5 AE ;&* &+&s * ,.%$ 80"000
" S
7* 2018/04/30 ©+% C /w:* :+ '* Ž= 7* ;%SC B+ [ `H%6
"KvC `H* 2018/61 $& 3s R C%$C .C  D  N e
"f< - ;€   Ug X g :C
2018/07/23 < .tª h E U < ;&'C D ƒ%$m X g :C
f< C N6 ]& `^ C  l ( H$ Ž, A%Œb* BC k1 Ž,
& M:* <2 ]& `^ C  l ( H$ e 7* *&* ,\m + [
&Ej &'C ,;/.  D % 5  %H , € BC k1 %Œb* x< E
T """ n 7+ ;š 5 + 1 C :QD +M< H BC k1 +. 7*
hC `<'2 <[ H$ A%Œb* % vjH "Bm n: C '[jH AEC B `C

œm >1* """ kN1 +&QE BN 352 v #jC B+ [ - Y&+ I 1
R 'H¤ #$  #:' 7E 7QD2 T ;š 5 + 1 h6 E ,B N T B6

203
#$% &'
"!       
  

. # 1 B<Q'


 # h  VS€C ,B+ 1C M &+ 
7Q+ T —  C - 4 N B 3 BC k1 h‡H H 4S h 
iQ "B<6 7* C2 * 6 7* BQE 4 H 4S h  œm $ :

]& `^ C  l ( H$ Q< R :2 ";š 5 + 1 R5 Y&'C L+°
X B >vj2 T &'5 E &'C (H$ 7* BC k1 %Œb* A% v6 * h6 Œ *
R ,6 & * Ug  H 4S h  7* 71 ;$  h6 ;š 5 + 1 . 
* & h6 Π* , M)'
  :~ h  7* 443 442 K<SN M<
$% iQ 88 13 ;$  X R ,6 25:' 51 C ˆ522  
1 :* - %Q
 () œm <1 (H& ) %H " <1 (H&
Q'+ B6 n jH Bm n: 7 &+& 7* BC k1 '[6 " D
U6&C *+ 15 n B<Q'C B 4 :* B6 """ kN1QC R Ne¤ c 5lE
- . U\
QC + L56 4C Ll œm Nl2 E 1 7* QZ
 )6 , :M U \t6 * É :+ * . 1 e 7* U <Q' 
B6 BN2 9
6 X 4S +Π
% kN1 +&* BNSC 1 h6
$Z Bm  * hE X UN
6  5+$j i w X  ,¸  '2
I B6 E 5+$j i<w +2 X S¢ I B6 n 6 Rb
7 "U [m
t6 U M 4S C &:* 
% m * ' C : & + [ #jC Y&+
X H+ B6 n 6 Rb
7 ";$S MM œm S2 I B2\
* h6
U <' B< 3) ¯C i+ H    4N X n ,
$ N C% = M:* BH&. h6 M5,  . B6 &EjH ;š 5 + 1 C H
.>N B6 &EjH :+ ' Ž= M:QD2  U% 5' B< 3) "4S
M* U% 5' 7* QZ h6 BH Ug  # a  % D4
 “
7 "
^ R ;%$ N…* +& M:* 5e  4S *‰:Q<
B2 *&t h6 5  &+ x! h6 R NeJ ƒ\ . A% $ h6 n 6 Rb

x! &N2 N2 . U  QC 2 & ³ B< :y ;%$ h6 B5QC 2

204
#$% &'
"!       
  

7 ,' g 7* Q #6 p &'2 I A& * h6 /E &N+ B<' _


+&* . 1 h6 &E6 E " <l - h E 2018/04/26 Y+ B6 n 6 Rb

"3/2 :+&QC """ kN1*


`<'+ *J h6 ŒC6 # ]& `^ C  l ( H$ Q< R :H
œm H )m  < ¯C i+ N Q'
 BC k1 h6   C
B<E* h6 ¯C i+ N 4N X UT   'C Y  7* . BjC '+ B6
 U% 5 Q'
 # BC k1 i X g D œm gw< % t
œm M* U <' } h6 2018/04/26 Y+ <l Y+ - h E B6 ?%
H 4S h  U D* X R ,6 ,L) 1C ]& `^ C  l
X R ,6 E p )'* h  iN 7* 91 84 82 $ E 88"13 %
^ iQ Q4 Ap $'+ V St h6 Π* 259 SN U D*
`5l2 iQ x< E & Q< R :2 ";š 5 + 1 - g  C
¢ ¡€[ BC k1 h6 ŒC6 # BC k1 %Œb* Q< R :H "h 
7+ V €[J gTb. * hC% ¢  €[6 ¯ :. h6 BN… B<Q
&S+ I BC k1 h6  )6 M:e X ;>? p Y&2 h6 $\5< h &++
7 %$  %C &M1
 \* E a    h $ B2 <'2 7* 1
V W n ^ VS€C 2010/04/10 ©+% C %$  N ®: Q=
"2018/08/06 <~ *j< D /w, %H ,;g  iQ ,¯C i+ N C
(X' 1&-
: (i " – 1
`H+ I 1 hC `<'2 <[ H$ BC k1 %Œb* % v6 ,
T B6 œm >1* 3/2 :+&QC """ kN1 +&QE BN 352 v #jC B+ [
M &+  R 'H¤ #:' 7E 7QD2 T ;š 5 + 1 h6 E ,B N
h  . # 1 B<Q'
 # h  VS€C ,B+ 1C
205
#$% &'
"!       
  

œm $ :
 7Q+ T —  C - 4 N B 3 BC k1 h‡H H 4S
Y&'C L+° iQ ,B<6 7* C2 * 6 7* BQE 4 H 4S h 
";š 5 + 1 R5
X :5* >? k52 A\ 6 (H$ 7* BC k1 %Œb* A% v6 * hm ,
;š 5 + 1 C Y&+ I ]& `^ C  l h % 5  x! 9
6
BN U 5v‡C */<* h+ k, 3/2 :+&QC """ kN1 +&* BNSC
\l  & - C 2 BN h6 E , S€1 BNSC ” Y&2 m , N…
X P * - <Q BC k1 ” Y   R 'HJ 7* %Ž2 BC B $ 7*
>? N4SE BC k1 N h6 E ,¯C i+ H    *
88"13 % &+&~ H 4S h  `H A&) ;š 5 + 1 +& 5<l*
NSC h'Q V €[J ” Y+  R 'HJ E Q1+ >tJ h
h  7* 444 SN M< R ,6 7+ h+$ ' V €[J E - 4
&H ;š 5 B+ [ R\t 7* ]& `^ C  l h6 X \DH . " :~
† E%6 M< Â56 &C .$&, BC k1 œm M5  R 'HJ œm al2
X :5* >? (H$ 7* †j1C >v6 * B'* k5+ # gÊ , +:' +$ 
" .$C L+° B'* K'+ ,<
9
6
µ P `H ,\ <J ;š 5 + 1 3*& ,
gÊ N #! 7* *&  D Y
 M: #$6   5<l <1
" , : A. 7* p5C L+° B'* K'+ #
:S! " – 2
:)& K41 "
4: 6 7* BC k1 'C * ]& `^ C  l iQ ,
 :~ h  7* 443 442 K<SN U D H :<'  
,88"13 % P: H 4S h  7* 86 84 82 71 91 83 72 $

206
#$% &'
"!       
  

* ,.%$ 80"000 A%& #$ * ®+'C ]& `^ C  lQ< ^ &*


" S BC k1 Qs ·J - ]&5 AE ;&* &+&s
5lE Q'+ B6 Q4 ². Y *6 B* &: BC k1 &E6 ,
QZ U6&C *+ 15 n B<Q'C B 4 :* B6 """ kN1QC R Ne¤ c
 - . U\
QC + L56 4C Ll œm Nl2 E 1 7*
h6  )6 , :M U \t6 * É :+ * . 1 e 7* U <Q'
B6 BN2 9
6 X 4S +Π
% kN1 +&* BNSC 1
$Z Bm  * hE X UN
6  5+$j i w X B)
I B6 E 5+$j i<w +2 X S¢ I B6 n 6 Rb
7 "U [m
t6 U M 4S C &:* 
% m * ' C : & + [ #jC Y&+
X H+ B6 n 6 Rb
7 ";$S MM œm S2 I B2\
* h6
U <' B< 3) ¯C i+ H    4N X n ,
"4S $ N C% = . M:* BH&. h6 M5,  . B6 &EjH + 1 C H
“ .>N B6 &EjH :+ ' Ž= M:QD2  U% 5' B< 3)
*‰:Q< M* U% 5' 7* QZ h6 BH Ug  # a  % D4

n 6 Rb
7 "
^ R ;%$ N…* +& M:* 5e  4S
B5QC 2 B2 *&t h6 5  &+ x! h6 R NeJ ƒ\ . A% $ h6
B<' _ x! &N2 N2 . U  QC 2 & ³ B< :y ;%$ h6
Rb
7 ,' g 7* Q #6 p &'2 I A& * h6 /E &N+
kN1* +&* . 1 h6 &E6 E " <l - h E 2018/04/26 Y+ B6 n 6
"3/2 :+&QC """
R\t 7* q C\* D  ‰ M
%$ &'C Q4 hm ,
:+ ' Ž=  t f< C H ` v X M \e &'C M* *6 ƒ% *
"""  D  N e 7* /w: 2018¨04¨30 - §%b 2018¨61 $&
BC k1 4N X U <'2 QZ h :QD2 Kv K2%SC `H

207
#$% &'
"!       
  

QZ M:Q)  ¯C i+ H    * X """ 


m 3s
7* <Ne :Q+ """ kN1 +&* c 5S . ":5 7* U% 5' 7*
†6 7‰+ ,$l C QM Bm 3<E #  Q $&´ , M\ 7* ;$ N

X $HJ 7* QZ ME% [  ,";$' C 6 : B R6 ,B %/*
H )m 267 .$& Â 5 ” V W ¯C i+ H    U 4N
7* A & * h/* >? h m Bm " U% 5 E " M< `<'2 299 œm
)%6 Ll5:+ h6 $ N< &C T ,gTb. * 4:2   ,B<* K b
%? X . L4 "  W B5<= kN1 H ,%$ 0+ 7 "F:2 h6 H<
&++ ;* E - M $+ h E  ÄN  QC <' 5l U$ M1
,+$ E6 6 3/C g
 W U 4S C Q' J 6 B<l'C Yw

$& D+6 , +Œ/C +lC x! KN'D G%6 X g\
 7 x. 
""" 41* H…6 `+e 7 p\t 7* ;$ N
 3y  4S U NS
g% Q¢ R E6 Bm "
* 9
MwC 4S H * ,‰ 6 h E Nt *
} #& 7 ,7*Π:* %w* Y% Bm "Bv$ = &+%6 *&:
^ ‹ :
? l &) &:w: "SN C Q~ LDH 
, %$ 02 h6 /0< ` %
,h›2 E C S 3 ,f') a&C Bm BQ¢ &,6 T "B45[ &
N
R &2 ²& B 'H6 BS L4 ,g N') †m , .6 t& 7* jH
7_ :
,$ N /*% Bm ,7e  %6 ƒ% t D+6 n0 (C% QwC
4 (%  Y6 c\ \'H B› h E hm K b KC 7* L<S* B6  &+
+e ,‰ 6 h E Nt * B+Q< +% :
B<E . "B+/: >? g :?
. B6 BC k1 †j1C &E6  ""kN1 `+$ : t&* /:
T
*‰: œm M* †6 ¯5N 4N X BC 4C .P MC C Y  7*
:* M  E 1Q< % 5  ]& `^ C  l œm E E 4S
BNSC >tJ e 7* g
3/2 :+&QC """ kN1QC B 0[ +&C
Ug   kN1 iN:C KN… K+%$ ®'C 7* E Nª ;%E

208
#$% &'
"!       
  

k1 7 ;%$ S A\ 6 U% 5' h6 Q4Q< K52 ";$&'* U  


w
:<'  &N2 U% 5 3:QD2 & ]& `^ C  l œm M BC
$Z B6 ,
^ ‹ : g% Q¢ R& $Z BC B* q 5 7* 
,$ N H * ‹ : KC 7* '+ B6 ,h/* >? h m BE ,f') a&C
,q%  X g\
¸ g N'D Œ/C C B*  ,  W B5<= kN1 h6
/*% B6 ,&
H ? e B6 ,
* 9
MwC 4S H * KC 7* B6
K'5 V €[J 7* &+&' M< <e  U% 5' . "$ N<
M:* &+&' Y  ” ” w m  &C6 ¯C i+ N X BC k1 4NS
B<+ * 83 SN - M< VS: :<' p xC `4H , M< `<' C
$ #6 BC k1Q< h+ h6 >? 7* ,88"13 % P: H 4S h  7*
]& `^ C  l 'Q
% 5  š 3*  "B $ 4 X
* . "3/2 :+&QC """ kN1 +&QE +% 5  BN E ŀ1
VS:  :<'  4:~ :+ ‹ :' B, - 1+
83 72 RSN  :~ h  7* 443 442 SN - MC X M<
B'* 3': ,88"13 % P: H 4S h  7* 86 84 82 71 91
"   x! X B5 '* x! 6 7* B2tbQC QS ( :T Q4
"k$J -  Z  S BC k1 Qs K'+ ,
:&-' 1 K41 "
:(i "
  5<l <1 µ P< H* &  l 3*& ,
" , : A. 7* 5* MH
:S! "
.%$ 80"000 A%& ®+'C B ^ ]& `^ C  l iQ ,
"·J -  Z  S BC k1 Qs

209
#$% &'
"!       
  

U , `H A\ 6 Bm  * 6 7* BC k1 $m hm ,


>0< MH 52  %«J    B:* Y/<+ A\ 6 *Q'  &
"  :~ ;l h  7* 'C  ;$< 5l2
 l `, -  :<'  BC BC k1 Y  hm ,
i &” *Q'  & - Mm % 1 U% 5' R'
C ]& `^ C
4N X U <'2 P `+e 7 ŀ1 A% 5  BHš B * B'QC
- = h+ # gÊ , 0 C +:'* %«6 BC `^6 & ¯C i+ N
l<
7* p C Q4 .$&s %«6 7* B^    ®+'2 X RS^
"A $6 ^ al:* - $>
* `H ++&2
"k$J -  Z  S BC k1 Qs K'+ ,
,  :~ ;l h  7* 636 M<+ * 365 $ U D 5l2
84 82 71 91 83 72 RSN  :~ h  7* 443 442 RSN
"88"13 % P: H 4S h  7* 86
:n3I _?
: +%D, &C :< Q4 3Q,
(i " − 1
" <1 (H& $C
() - − 2
^ Bm  * 6 7* BC k1 ;tbQC : *Q'  & -
-  Z  S B<Qs ,.%$ ¦10"000¥ Tª ;P .%& ;H  *0C B<
"k$J
:&-' 1 K41 "
" p5 : 1 -

210
#$% &'
"!       
  

 }m D+'2 ]& `^ C  l ;& N BC k1 g$jC :() -


"k$J -  Z  S B<Qs ,.%$ ¦20"000¥ f6 h P A%&
:<' <~ C ,A\ 6 : M1 Y - •2 ^ %& ”
7* E2 ²p 3 E 3/C &C Q4 C +$   U <~ C
"""""" : ;$ 

”3
 @N5 c 

211
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﻗﺮار ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ ﻣﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻟﻨﻘﺾ ﺑﺎﻟﺮﺑﺎط‬


2011/06/01 ‫ ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬3/620 ‫ﺗﺤﺖ ﻋﺪد‬
274
2009/3/6/4127-29 : ‫ﰲ اﳌﻠﻒ رﻗﻢ‬

:m14
H)/ 6 †w ’  m1/G T4 ( 1 5? @A >? 5 wL
3 (& (' )%5 |5  W ( †w "  ‚A  T
" (4Q @  ,4 (4Q @  /  @  P ~)%
r 3, c .I- r & B&'/ 5 6' &   ƒ
kP "  r5 -

% 3g †% FG #-


BNSC S€1 BNSC """ kQ 7* H ®: U 5<e X g :C
BNSC S€1 BNSC """ kQ """ <  5
J ;&+w< +&*
2 ©+% C ” ÌH6 L+% S2 ±\v ÌQC ;&+~ iN:C +4< +&*
 :²
 Q4QC ˆ5D C E & """ """ 7+! 
J l
C 2008/12/3
iN & H :²
 L:~ H? 7 %$ S % ® œm * R\* :5C
^ g 0‡C G  2008/11/24 ©+% 2 08/1392 $& D - Q4
L+° +&S2 ;š 5 + 1 R5 Y&'C A DQC Y4 &CT
""" .+&* ¡€[ - """ C<l ;& N M$jC K: l X ^ p5C
".%$ 10"000 A%& &* D+'2

" .&'C * 547 4N ,2017 :$ 70 $& * 4 <wQC %1:* % − 274

212
#$% &'
"!       
  

:c%~ L
" D - BC f< + """ % 1 & \2 h6 &'C
"B2 w:* - Y ' * 4 """ & œm (
 &'C
% 3g  1 1&-
" Me 52%T """ :   Y %J U! U N< ) &'C
:5C * 4 """ ! l
C K: l h& 7* ” œ& ;EQ< ‰
- 5<l µ P< H X J i<w Y *6 H< R5 R\*
"ƒ Y a 530 528 K2$ 
®H% œm * """ ! l
C C<l n X (\e &'C
"<l
:S! "
7 SN at NS Y&' 7* ;€ œ J ®: <
hj[ -
h6 &w ;š 5 + 1 œm ( C B6 x! ,  :~ ;l h  7*
B6 K, - #:'* #$ * %Ž  '2 B6  &+ # """ kQ . %Ž
E ,%Ž g $m `, B RÈ  BN K5+ I 1* lE BQ
m $+ I
g $ . Œ/'+ U 5vm #jC R&+ I """ EP B<y  &+ # """ kQ h6
MH —  C › * Eš .  EP e 7* B:'2 %C R&+ I
, 1996/08/30 - §%b ›  U EPC `<' 59"17 h  ') t
;%$m i<Z ›  Eš +&+ B6 X h  iN 7* 39 SN ¡:+
« = - ;%$ i<Z UT &* 352 h  iN 7* 52 SN ¡:+
69 SN ¡:+ , <~ i% l<
3s i<w 2 E .%¢ U <

C U% E R,J E - € ˆ< 
6 ;%$ i<w B6 X
\H %« #6 (&+ I """ & h‡H —  C " M)? `4 *2  EP

213
#$% &'
"!       
  

MQ
C gm #jC Y  EP y B RÈ    NS X H+
¡:2 E , EP ;/M6 e 7*  0 p K'2 6 ¡tC —&+ I Y$ *
";%E RSN x! X
;& N D+'C Ì B6 BH h'l % U SS:2 7* Xw+ ,
""" ,  a&:N +&2  
 MZ Eš . """ Eš C<l
.* 7  #%$ M<Z g D 6 """ & .+&* ¡€[ - """ a&:H
. q   % Q= h‡H —  C ,]& `^ C 5 l* MNSC """ a&:NC
M< ) '  & - NS p M, - 52 R 'HJ 7* ;%Ž
"9
6 >? X <
 B'* 3 E # *J %E .+&* l
C
,ƒ Y a 7* 95 SN at 7* ;€   ®: <
hj[ -
U$6 E & M5 l* ;E* 7 -/~ 
 g$jC 3NE 1 h6 x!
20"000 Â<5* - ®+' - M5<e U$&, + 1 7 .%$ 500 Â<5*
')<  * Q4 .$&s  t '+$ #$b2 h6 M< h E ,.%$
1986/12/31 >M… 7* 56 SN h6 , &:H 
b* . 1Q<  
B6 ,g . X ¡  :~ h& -  D f+% S C V W
: M< K'+ 1 U 5<e h
; -/~ 
 g$6 -
*Œ\ Q4 i% .$&¢  '+$ 6   D g$6 -
;  D f+% SQ<
 l ®+' Â<5* 7* +²* 5 - Q+ — *  D 
% g$6 -
" 1 e 7* BC
M+ [ R5 Y& < e 3s Y
 A. E g$jC */<* xC .
A. 3H
 & 1 h6 6%  nS   & BH h'l % h6
"Y


214
#$% &'
"!       
  

R\t 7* p 35v % Q= h‡H <


 - g   H\t Bm ,
&  l ;E* ,\ R  ;š 5 + 1 X (\e
UT , 3+$6 & 5  D Y
 h6 g$J 2
3 E # *J 2007/06/09 2007/05/02 2007/01/25 - — X t%b
" \t <
 B'*
h  7* 72 SN at 7* ;€   ®: <
hj[ -
# g &
 M*¢ I (H$ ;&  % v6 K: l h6 x! , H 4S
  E! Y& *Œ\   RSN E! Y& M:* BC <2
 7QD2 †6 1 MH 2  &~ % & ©+% 2 T M¬% 2
M)  5D e  œm ( C B6 ,P C i 
""" M<_ +. 
m 6 †: 6 MQ
m œm >12 T 1
2 I &C D - ‰: g :v6 ±&, <
 - g  * hm ,
B'* 3 E # *J  & - *& B6 k:'QC  :²
 Q= Y *6 B2% vm
" 5* >? <

h  7* 78 SN at 7* ;€ 'C ®: <
hj[ -
H 5
7QD2 †6 1 U&   &~ h6 x! , H 4S
7* U%& """ $& ;&+~ :   ©+% - U%& & M, -
*
15 œm +C6 16 7* U%& """ $& ;&+~ ,2006 +C6 15 œm 9% * 15
I 1 ,2006 + 30 œm 16 7* U%& """ $& ;&+~ ,2006 # *
a &: ;>[j2 7* 3C v . E 2007/01/25 ©+% C Tm M+ [ w2
©+% 2 œm $'+ + 1 ()* 'N  BH 2 Y+ R 6 h6 , Q4
9% * 15 œm $'+ # """ $& Qs  + 1 - ;%E* ;&+ R 6
SN2  ;& h6 < &Ej+ + 1 ) ©+% 2 ©+%  . KC B6 2006
"M[6 6 UŒ ™ M:C

215
#$% &'
"!       
  

'C  &  & - ˆH 3C % Q= h‡H ,œ 6 M 7* ,
- ‰:2 +/ Q4 3 E !m B‡H ,ƒ Y a 7* 12 ;$  ÌQC B6
 &< ˆ* 5
( h‡H '* &  & *Q'  &
Q4 V StT ') t k52 Q  &  & ¯+ *Q'
" +/
 & h‡H h  iN 7* 14 ;$  ÌQC B‡H  v M 7* ,
Q4 h‡H xC ]& h  - ” RQ' & < 5e Y$ 2 &
# *J 'C  &  & Y$ 2 RS, p 35+ I .% - h'l
"9
6 >? X <
 B'* 3 E
B6 x! ,<' Y&' 7* ;€ * W ®: <
hj[ -
% A&Q  1 B2$% 6 # """ $& ;&+~ 7* l œm ( C
h6 `5
`s R QC  $Z 7 ;&+~ +s 7* 7+ I BH h'l
N4S g D*m 3s 1997/08/10 ©+% C %$ S .$& - """ ;&+ B2P
I B6  e P C * 6 5
6 H '+ T R  . P ;$ m h6 """
, ()* 1 e 7* + [ ()* h E h6 R  p `5+
""" ;&+~ œm ( C B6 E " H 4S h  7* 50 SN C \Q  D
iN h6 Y<'* " BH $% # l X &:
 BH h'l % h6 &w
K p\t  h C% 7* EJ } i% """ ]   <* - EP
B6 ,RMZ &) tu *~ °:' Y&'T BN<* e ›&,6 , ~ C
:5* i –  – RMwQ< :5* A\ 6 $%  'H h‡H M 7*
'N . x! X $ >t h6 - :²
 % x! $% 6 E Y<'Q<
i #e . $F< l: a  h6 !m , <Q~ iN - %E e
% U SS:2 7* &Ej+ BN<* #l+ h6 R h'< 7Q+ T !m ,e
Q4 Y *6 N K: l h6 M<_ 6 1 i """ . %Ž h6
% em - †6 X \DH ” i t2 , .>? 6 1 h &S+ †jC

216
#$% &'
"!       
  

E K p a, # ! U + [ ;%E &~ -  P & :M M<Q


Q' h‡H —  C H ~ C <'  D lC D Ž= 7QD*
 D* 0 U H %Ë6 f1E œm &´ h: l BC Y  # - 4S
\Q KH U\ U 5<l C w
 N4S `4 p, %$
‹ :' Œ 2 I % Q= h6 H 4S h  7* R J SN U DQC
*J :* <
<'2 #6 &Q'2 I Q  †6 U6%  L:w< :+
"R lC ®:< .¹ D  '+ #
;& N &* D+'2 M$jC K: l X 3D  Q4 hm ,
f< ` v R\t 7* p 52 *&'C %« 7* M^ * g 7* C<l
M
6% X &+  n0 C (Œ2 %&S2  """ ;&+ h6 B2&:*
* 20 4N 100 $& ;&+~ - 3:Q) P: +&* A% 5 C """ R b +&
±$, 6 ~ 7* <<C °’ $ :. A. ‰: M &Ej2 : •+
a&:H M,F* R\+Œ6 <‡C %%H6 ;&<5C n% * 7*Œ - 3' D* ? ; H
M &C6  U +  x<2 7 Q
7*  R ¬ T k, B ($  '*
.+  7 s . ŒC [ 1 œm Mtm - ¯1. &+N
+/<wJ < x<2 7* '<C M5[ ;N l:QC &+ a&:NC gT/ M4)
,  ¡Q+ k, A% 1C < R&+ h6 * !m c 5[J   C 
A + 4) $ l - 6&5+ +e 7*Œ :*  B*6 S€[ R5€ a&:N
" + 0< '1C ;%SC M<
- . EP iN h6 Y<'* : ;&+~ iN 7* 100 $&' - $% E
~ C K p\t  h C% 7* EJ """ } i% """ ]   <*
U   * . "RMZ &) tu *~ °:' Y&'T BN<* e ›&,6
7* h 2&+~ B:QD2 * g 7* %« ” `^ : l h6 % Q= B'*
""" """ K&:N<   """ Eš C<lQ< :< ,‹ M  

, 

bQE M * M*E :* 7*  m < >s 3 :2

217
#$% &'
"!       
  

- <*  5
6 ;&+ l
C H 4S `+e 7 2% #
«6 # +4< +&* BNSC """ """ P: 7 R b .+&* ¡€[
- U 5vm <
#jC gT$ h $ M*E M'Q
œm g
6 C<l C .P
hm k, B6 + N BH C .% 3<< & Q4 h2 xC ()
Y  7* :Q+ T x! h‡H * ;&+ 7  & %E   h E
“ h H RMwQ< :5* 'H  Q<E 3 E  B6 : x! -  b
hT h ' › Œ : -  N   H*  N   h+ h6
# *J ,R  - $% E g  C M5S i fJ C M'H% K'+ h E
"9
6 >? X <
 B'* 3 E
W%G T
($ Â<5 $C ,A\ 6 K: l 7* (H <l ®HC Ì
"  D f+% S g N
 &'C B $
A\ 6 %E ©+%  C ;&': :<' <~ C •2 % %& BC
3 E ,µ C C €: (% 1C :  ®: Q4QC +$ ' U <~ C
""""" %* """"" 7+% 1 % """""" ;$  7* 5E* QE ^ ²p
, * ' C : Q+ h E # """"" & Y ' * 4 %D4C """ """"
"""""" & ˆ5D 2 E ;& QC

”3
 3N5  i'A c 

218
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺼﻔﺮو‬


2019/12/17 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
275
2019/2106/1416 ‫ﰲ ﻣﻠﻒ ﺟﻨﺤﻲ ﺗﻠﺒﴘ ﴎاح رﻗﻢ‬

:m14
,+,  \4 -& " P    T 444 (,Q
 UN S* ]'- y0 S T %4 ¡'/   †?-
B3N ƒ H    ' 1&- )+ k%& @A >? )/G
,%4 8[ 3 6L /  1&/ 6 P2 ƒ " W- ><& @A  
( -  M43C  M-' ( - )4 T/ b W
K'A eL ] / 6 , <= ( -  9`3 &)A P,N=
T # ' m Y- V/`' WNU P2 B&'/ — ,; W Q)- >?
k†w (G

% 3g †% FG #-


- 52 . 2019/12/17 :©+% C NSC &C Q4 U%&6
:BS Æu ^ 4:~ + D
Q4 A. & x< E & KC
9 H ²” * 4 """ ! 
J B: n:+ """ ]& `^ C  l
""" − 2 9 H ²” * 4 """ ! 
J A%Œb+ """ −1 :KQ KC
t6 M 7* KQM* MNSC

"%1:* >? , − 275

219
#$% &'
"!       
  

B< ®Q+ I 7*Œ :* Q4 A. !N ;$ t$ ” 2% C K::‰
#&Q' g+ R ¤ $  , - K5 :<'  : 4:~ Y$  &*6
 :~ h  7* 157 443 442 400 RSN< 5e ] <  
 X 5 ' C `<' h  C QC 1967/11/14 Y
 7* 1 SN
"K5 :<'
H  
,A\ 6 Mm % 1 R 'HJ C KQMQ< x< E & 'C * X g :C
eš e 7* /w:  D lC D Ž= 7* .‹ : ;&Q
,2019/09/13 - §%b 1$ /ƒ ƒ /1084 $& ,;&+&~ :+& ;$ , N
œm eP ‹ :  ,U\  % '[m X g :C B6 B:* $ N+ #
M:C \t - KS€[  & ,;$'* 
4C  
 #T* (% [
- . T 6 %E $ H6 ,""" """ KQ C *J `<'+ ,Y ' (% 1 C
 , 3:+ ,  v %E e 7* f:'<  '2 B6 '5e >?  ,
cN2  QW 4% - <Q ,   q N* C K5 :<' 
,R J X Y\ - ;v BQ'<2 B1* h/2 Y& K' %£ BQH 7*
BM5 7Q+J A&€C U *&E - <w* ,B< f:'  , :+ '* 3y E
"BNjC g *& 7* <
B6 ,QW nš X 7*&* B6 &E6 +&My """ M œm (
 &:
7* f:'<  '2 B6 &Eb* ,
 , - h E Y ' (% 1 C BH +m

" *+ 20 ” /w' ;&* 5e ;$ M1C œ$6 """ e


 '+ I B6 &Eb* Bm n: 6 +&My MQ< (
 &:
"1  U% 5 ˆH B'* R$ 52 C ,f: #J """ kQ
""" M a l:
 2 x< E & X ;l  ,m X g :C
A\ 6 K5 `H KQM 'C * 3QH   C Bm n: 7 n 6 #
"cË  , - Q4 X M ,m *

220
#$% &'
"!       
  

Ž, 2019/11/12 < M›6 U < ±\C D ƒ%$m X g :C


+. 7* &Ej &'C B<2 X $ T ]  f<È B H$ R J M
 , - h E B6 &Eb*   C n 6 Bm n: C A% '[m « ^ M
,%D^ 7* A¹ N m 2 *&'C 1 M f<È 2019/12/03 <wC ,

D Q4 U  H ,R J ( H$ Ž, g &


 ?% ]  f<È
y O< ! 
J iQ , $ x< E & iQ ;/. 
g$6 &N+ C œ$6 'C  &  & - fN€  … ·jC A%Œb*
:+ '* `H x! g& ¸  '2 B<E* h6 &E6 ,""" 7 -/~ ˆ
;$ M[ 5e f< Q[ %SC œ$6 a '* A%Œb* h6  D lC D
.%$ 5000 - ;$&4 & U 5<l< C w
 ] < $ iQ 5e
"2019/12/17 : <~ *j< f< /w, H
% 3g (šX' 1&-
:)& K41 "
6 7* KQM x< E & C 2 A\ 6  < $ :
 Bm ,
"Y q xSC MM* - l* . *
:h "  M VS€C ˜ 1
7E% H2  Q+ `s µ :* hm , : >? @A P ˜˜ 6
A 7* B #jC % 5  P Î&€C  N Y  B* ,#$ *
6 ¡€[ œm M5 6 ' g $m  Q+ `s Ã+ :C ,R ¤
35  ²p 6 ¡€1 % 5  6 š iy ' A. 3 E !m , ².
;$% &S B

6 #:'* 7E% , '* MH :<' µš H2 * , Mm
"<'

221
#$% &'
"!       
  

& A&w  :~ h  7* 444 SN U D ( C Bm ,
V t ( 7* :< Ã+ MH xC , H 4S h  X C' - R ,6
":<'   Q+ Y  .H2 (P k0C
- BC '  h6 Π:   M
%$ &'C Q4Q< K52 ,

C *Q 7+ I B ,:< >? 5
Tm h+ h6 &'+ T R ^ Π

 C 6 #°5 'Q R S2 
C 6 U 5l 6 U C
R ^ K'+ _ ,]  B*MNQC  * œm k+ T ,  
" M:* B2g C L+° x! 6 7* B2g C L+° B2 .
:91)& ?/= +G P ˜˜ n
"g&  #J 1 ®+'2 M 6 ,
n:Q< M % m Y *6 f< ` v } X (\e C Bm ,
$6 #6 7* R t f< h6 K5+ ,#&MQ 45 ,* } R\t Bm
g :
C ,A\ 6 <SN B2 ¢°2 - g  * i 352 7 6 :+
$ 6   U 5vm <
#6 7* ;$Z Ug   1 U ¢°2
&€C U *&E $  D lC D :+ '* h6 x! ,B< $  7Q+
, 5l ;$ M1 C >tJ . gT$m ,BNjC g *& 7* < BM5 1
;$ M1 hJ ,#&Q' g+¸ 1 ®+'C M Y  X \$ &'+ T B‡H
œm B5:2 h6 R,J 7* R , #jC 7Q+ T MH %Ž 352 3 E hm 5l
3s 2013/12/24 ©+% C %$ S A% - X J i<w x! &E6 E M
V 6 $& f< <wQC %1:* 00/19765 $& 4:~ f< - 2/1789 $&
7* <
12 T .&, 5l ;$ M1 " h6 BH g  # M<+ * 330
B5 352 T †6 Tm c~ nŽ 352 3 E hm   U 5v 

" "g :…J œm

222
#$% &'
"!       
  

Y/~ X k:52  :~ Y ,J 3*$ * ,A\ 6 <'< Bm ,


7* œ J ;$  U D $ :
 ,KQ€ x1 $Z X i K
œm ²+C '+ Q+~ n 2% C BH B51* 6 M* E h6 X ¡:2  ƒ"Y"a
6 7* B2tb* Y&'C L+° Uj2% Q4 h‡H ,   B$m 352 h6
" M:* B2g C ^ Bm n:
: y S # ' y,f- šš 2
B2 . Y *6 45 ,* } R\t Bm n: C M   ,
®5 g m - <Q i5<  , * `C l*  D   . Q4
:+ '* Ž= QC   , B< 3:+ ,Y ' (% 1 C M X
BQH 7* QW 4% h ,H BM h , B: %£ - <w ,
"Y\ - BQ'<2 B
N6 7* Mv '5
A 10+ h * #6 - 6 U l 6 ŒJ &,‡C & 7* hm ,
"A\ 6 Y
 7* 1 SN U D* B l2 
 , - . YQ'
B š Y&'C BQ< ?% 'N A&Q'2 - MQ< *~ : hm ,
h6 
,B, - 'N +$ * U5v 7* Q4 MS<€2 ,n  = BjC
"h  MwC %'+ T6 g - J
L+°2 $Z MH N+ T   j* $'  , U 5vm hm ,
“ C ,  D lC D Ž4QC BC
E! 6 A>? 6 M 7 %$ 
* f< ` v 7Q) &+ T B‡H —  C h  MQ
%  al C B2 5vm
; / , , % & U 5v BCC <' 2 %  l5 C gT$ &N+
 , % 5  Y& Q4 B'* Uj2% # gÊ ,B, - BC Ã gÊ
" q5v Y&' R ^ Π - $'

223
#$% &'
"!       
  

K5 :<'  4: hjC Q4 3': A\ 6 <'< Bm ,
fN€  ‰C B'y * M<6 7* B2tb* B'* K'+ M `, - C v
- N: H* 5^ C' 'wC x! ,ƒ Y a 7* 146 SN< 5e
&+&s *Q'  &   B<Qs ,a '* BE   BH ‰ B,
"ƒ Y a 7* 636 367 K<SN< 5e k$J &^ - ]&5 AE ;&*
:&-' 1 K41 "
A%& &* D+'2 B H$ l
C ]& `^ C  l iQ ,
"BC `,\ %Ž 7 D+'2 .%$ 5000
&  & É ‰: C g :
 ¡È +/ Q4 hm ,
" *Q'  & ()* Q+~ 7  : %Ž 7 ®+' C 5 lQ<
>? 'N h E !‡H ƒ Y a 389 SN U D 5e Bm ,
%&S2 Q4 h‡H k :~ h < N ’ N B 72 I 6 K:‰ œm n:*
" &  & É 5< M St Y&'C c°2 ;g  C ,
*Q'  & U , É Bm >[6 * , Q4 hm ,
S’ >? B'* k52 _ Bm  * 6 7* """ M ;tb* Y&'C 3D
" &  l É ‰:<
" S M'H% Qs K'+ ,
* 362 SN .&'C * 319 ˜ 304 ˜ 297 RSN U D 5l2
7* 641 SN + ? œ A&'C * 635 SN A&'C * 384 SN A&'C
" 'C  RSH  :~ ;l h 

224
#$% &'
"!       
  

n3I _?
- C ? """ `, - #%D, C QC &C :< Q4 3Q,
:""" `,
Bm n: 6 7* """ M ;tb* Y&'C :)& K41 "
K5 :<'  4: 6 7* """ M ;tbQC B:* B2g C L+°
*? N: * 5, K:v 7+M1C B< ^ $'  , $ '5
 *
"k$J &^ -  Z  S B<Qs * .%$ 500 .%& ;H 
& U 5<l - 5< V St Y&'C :&-' 1 K41 "
" M'H% `2 X  S g Cm

”3
 @N5 c 

225
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺎﻟﺪار اﻟﺒﻴﻀﺎء‬


2018/07/19 ‫ ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬21062 ‫ﺗﺤﺖ ﻋﺪد‬
276
18/2902/86 ‫ﻣﻠﻒ ﺷﻜﺎﻳﺔ ﻣﺒﺎﴍة ﻋﺪد‬

:m14
s- c/Q " 4r'G= (D' H  \4 / 1N – m‹3 /d
H = – #& – @A >? '+ /' œ& N – "
k− #& – {/&'

% 3g †% FG #-


:<'   4: \'H &'2 BC k1 :+ &2 hm , """
M% 7* &p k5+  :~ h  - MC X M< VS:
"`, * h &C YQ' & BC >M1 Î &Q= %E& 'Q
©l<2
`H BC k1Q< %m 
C  % ' 'C &H x '52 ,
7* 3C v . E P: H 4S C `<' 72 ;$  7* ;>tJ ;N Y ,6
"Be KH  D  N* &+ X %4 Ž4 % 
%
"BC k1 œm M % 
% 7* € : 3 H*
"BC k1 œm B* %m Â<52 Ž= : 2 H*
*Q'  & - \[ p5 ;š 5 B+ [ - 1 iQ
B< ^ :<'   6 7* R 7+& / BC k1 ;tb*
&  & -  :~ h  7* 443 442 RSN U D* `H

: ¯5H * X Q
 :4N X %1:* − 276
https://www.facebook.com/ritaje2014/notifications/

226
#$% &'
"!       
  

  .%$ 500"000"00 A%& &* D+'2 1Q< BC k1 g$jC 'C 
,·J - AE  S BC k1 Qs BC `,\ #:' %Ž<
K0< C :e f4S &,‡C A% & ‰: $ C ^ P:C R
"R 7+& / BC k1 N X x! N C'
% 3g (X' 1&-
: )& K41 " – 1
:(i l T
<1   U 5<l H E ;š 5 + 1 +&2 -  % ,
U 5 M: $b* G  <.6 NS 4<S B 7_ 3M !m
;$  -  D S ˆ5DC `<' 1986/12/30 >M… MQ‰ E  
" M )* - 5 p5C L+° B'* 05:+ _  :~
:S! l T
 L: 6 7* BC k1 ;tb* ;š 5 + 1 Y 2 ,
" :~ h  7* 443 442 K<SN< 5e :<' 
"Bm n: 6 Q4 Y *6 BC k1 Ž, ,
  Š0 (P h‡H  4: VS€C Bm ,
" :•+ E P: H 4S C `<' 88"13 % h  7* 83 ;$  ÌQC
iy ' A. 3 E !m , ². 6 ¡€[ œm M5 6 ' g $m 
"¦""" Mm 35  ²p 6 ¡€1 % 5  6 š
iN X ¡S: 7QD2  :~ h  7* 442 SN hm ,
¢ >tJ SN U   ®: Q= hE ‰,\* * A\ 6 f+'
" :+ ‹ :' 6 7* i C' ¡¬ H H 4S h  X

227
#$% &'
"!       
  

:#:' 7E #$  7E H2 7* &C T  4: Y 


X g&  - Q2 ;$&= ' $ :
‡C `4+ :9 T5 -1
" :< x! + h6 B< :w % 5  6 š
1Q< :<'   U% 5 $ :
‡C Y  K:‰ hm ,
h6 †j[ 7* , q5v R , - n '< 5* :1* ' . BN BQ
C
xC Y  B6 Bl= ˆ
B*C i B< :w % , œm #$b2
°: ” `4+ 
. ¯C i+ N    QC P:
" :<'
h6 35v <E `4+ #  :~ &S BC $S : 9& T5 -2
” %Ž `4<+ h6 L  Bj[ 7*  Q< A&:
6 * hjC <'+ ! 
">tJ
B* q ' P:C Y  K:‰ h6 K5+ R ^ Œ  œm ( C Bm ,
E   g Q< BD+'2 x! hj[ 7* h6 :+ <'+ . ,1Q<
"• ' :M Bl= ˆ
% ,¸
A\ 6 ] ' X M<E `5l:2  4:~ ; l' f+% ' hm ,
`^ C  l š 7* : . h E M:*  0 h6 - x1< T Z (&2 T
"B'QC 9  ]&
  4:~ :+ ‹ :' h2 A\ 6 E!  '52 ,
" M<6 7* B2tb* K'+ K:‰ `, - C v :<'
35v f< ` v X M \e D< M
%$ &'C Q4 hm ,
BC k1Q< :<'   4:~ :+ ‹ :' H2 ´&
"M<6 7* B2tbQC L+° —  C

228
#$% &'
"!       
  

U%  :~ BC


Y&'   BC k1  ‰ ‰
- N: H* 5^ C' ' * fN€  ‰C B'y Q4
"B,
&-' 1 K41 " : :
B5 l* - g  * `H ®+'C B ^ ]& l iQ ,
" &
h6 œm A\ 6 *Q'  & U , R\t 7* Q4 3M ,
"B, - 3C v BC k1 œm  *
" +$ * +:'* %«6 ]& l C `^6 x BH hm ,
LQ+ h6 >? 7* % t  e 7 \'H 2% 7* E hm ,
">0 C %« `^6 . B<'H h6  e ®+' C */<* h+ h  BC
5e MH µ1+ h E hm ” Y4 & U D+' hm ,
7* B^  \* E D+'2 %ŽQ< `s h6  :~ h  7* 108 ;$<
;T 0 - ( Y& ' $ &^ ; QC µ P* x! h‡H C v %«6
Q4 l<
% em - ^ %«J x<2 %&QC Y/ +& &:
" ++&
n<l ®+' h6 Uj2% ++&2 l<
7* p C Q4 hm ,
- l* . * `H R' %&< B %m —  C 05:+ BH Â 5* %Ž 7
"^ al:*
7* .&'C * 365/364/292/291/290/288/287/286 RSN< 5l2
" :~ h  7* 146 SN 'C  RSH ,  :~ ;l h 

229
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺼﻔﺮو‬


2018/10/01 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
277
17/2172 ‫ﰲ ﻣﻠﻒ ﺟﻨﺤﻲ رﻗﻢ‬

:m14
c 'i)% W- ]'i  3A/ ' " nG @%5 " m34 L
* C- | o5 ,WL |3A 9? hfi 3'4 >‹
>? @A '+ /' œ& (& , <= m1/-
k %G T WN?0‚ B&'/ # ' $ " ) 

% 3g †% FG #-

M< - NSC &C Q4 U%&6 2018/10/01 ©+% C


: BS Æu ^ , +$ ' 4:~ + D - 5< :<'
Q4 A. & x< E & KC
"""" : ;š 5 + 1 ÌQC 1
 G T 9 H ²” h * 4 4H ! h+$ ! B: n:+
: BC k1
m‹3 /i ¢')- W- ]'i § " ( −1
I 7*Π:* Q4 Ap  D ;& t$ BC 2% C BC k1
H 4S h  7* 84 83 RSN< 5e   4: Y$ +
K0  G T "P:

"%1:* >? , − 277

230
#$% &'
"!       
  

H  
©+% C 1 ( H$ e 7* *& ;š 5 + 1 X g :C
B6 .$ N* + 1C Y&2 1 h6 MH g   M: $b 2017/11/15
7QD+ N g&6 ;&+~   4NS X %1:* R QC ÍH
Q   D:+ n6 <E BC 1 `, -   U% 5
""" g C~ n\
 6 7* BC k1 $m *Q'  & - iQ<+ B<J
&  & - P: H 4S h  7* 84 83 RSN< 5e 
f 100 Â<5* - $&= &* D+'2 1Q< B$jC BC k1 X ^
"·J - % 5  S * .%$
c‹ BC k1 Ž, 1 7 """ ! Ž, 2018/04/23 <wC
"] m * - BC 6 A% &C B6 < B) 1 h6
U   ,BC k1 f<È ( H& p\t Ž, 2018/09/17 <wC
p\t 7* iQ<+ 'H - ;EQC 4H ! œ$6 ;/.  D Q4
BH C M `, - C v QM h & U 5<l< C w
 $
<~ *j< f< /w, %H ,h  `5l2 * ' C : 3Q
"2018/10/01
(X' 1&-
: m‹3 /i " : 6 
5<l <1 µ P `H ;š 5 + 1 3*& , : (i "
" p5C L+° B'* K'+ _  
: S! "
: )& K41 "
"A\ 6 l 6 7* BC k1 x< E & C 2 ,

231
#$% &'
"!       
  

R &: ] m * - 1 C BC k1   ,


" Q4 A. Y *6
+6 5 7QD2T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [ >5'2 E 5
&'+ ,
Bm &: % , + 6 Q+ &'+ 'H $ :
m .  h6 , :'* '
" :~ h  - f 7* E6 5+ T 'N ,7e .6 &:
- $% * ÌQC x! B, - 3C v BC k1Q< n: hm ,
n6 <E """ i+ ;% 5 7QD2  N g&6   ;&+~
" Q4 A. Y *6 BC k1 BC   * . """
1Q< BC k1 M5:+ ' " n6 <E " ;% 5 hm ,
;&+~ C P: l
C 3y ,Bm 35 # ¡€1 % 5  š iy
H 4S h  7* 'C  RSN :+ ‹ :' B'* h2 _ ,  
" M<6 7* B2tb* K'+ B, - Q  P:
B'y Q4 U%   M  ‰ ‰ Bm ,
" NN€  D  ‰ C
" % 5 h $ f+% S M Qs K'+ ,
: &-' 1 K41 "
<1 µ P H  H* &  l 3*& , :(i "
" p5C L+° + _   5<l
: S! "
A\ 6 <SN B2 Q<* `H B ^ ]& `^ C  l iQ ,
7 B b* '“ Bm n: 6 7* A\ 6 M $m hm ,
%Ž jlW KC 55 \' h6 Y$ * Q  1 C `,\ %Ž
"( R a 78 SN U D 5e ;š 5* \

232
#$% &'
"!       
  

* ~ M:*  % ++&2 l<


7* p C Q4 Uj2% ,
al:QC $% Â<5 - ®+' Q &+&s BH 5  … %Ž
"BC ^ A&'C ^
'C  &  &   BC k1 Qs 05:+ ,
œm .&'C * 636 − 319 − 304 − 290 − 287 − 286 $Q< 5l2
h  7* 149 146 SN 'C  RSH ƒ Y a 7* 641 SN + ?
" :~
:n3I _?
#%D, C QC &C :< Q4 c°2
m‹3 /i " : 6 
;š 5 + 1 R5 : (i "
: S! "
: *Q'  & -
.%& ;H  *0C B5 '* Bm n: 6 7* BC k1 ;tbQC
" k$J - % 5 f+% S B<Qs * .%$ ¦1000¥ f6
:&-' 1 K41 "
\[ p5 : (i "
&* D+'2 ]& `^ C  l ;& N BC k1 g$jC :S! "
" k$J - % 5  S * .%$ ¦3000¥ Tª v\v A%&
: M1 Y - ;&': :<' <~ - •2 ^ %& ”
"A\ 6
""" : ;$  7* 5E* .

233
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺄﻛﺎدﻳﺮ‬


1090 ‫ﺗﺤﺖ ﻋﺪد‬
278
2018/11/27 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬

:m14
4r'G= (D' H )- W'+QD \4 M/ 1N *- W- ]'i 
@G <= >*- c M34  )
N s- c/
  ++D 8[ H  4L ,)& MA‚ yfd‘
k%& @A >? + 3N W%& M3:L
3G '-: € (& _F4 5w  (G T W- ]'i L
k{/&'%

% 3g †% FG #-


:<' M< - +$ EjC &C Q4 U%&6 2018/11/27 ©+% C
:BS Æu &C ^ #$ 4:~ + D - 5<
Q4 A. & x< E & KC
"""" ]& `^ C  l
−  G T − "+$ E6 ²” * = """ ! B: n:+
"""""" BC k1
I 7*Π:* Q4 Ap  D ;& t$ BC 2% C BC k1
X U C* l
C   4: :4:~ Y$  &*6 B< ®Q+
MC X M< VS: "*Q f…* `, - E5+ N B4N
" H 4S h  7* 67 38 47 46 44 RSN C M: K b M<

"%1:* >? , − 278

234
#$% &'
"!       
  

K0  G T """ ! B: n:+


: H  
ˆ5) C C $ ;š 5 + 1 ÌQC A\ 6 M 'C * X g :C
BNSC B6 p\t 7*  '+ 2018/02/23 ©+% C M: $b Q4 A.
.Œ 7C   +$ S   Y<' <C — ' <'< ! 
6
 7* C  '2 & < A” """ 
 ?&5 `: +$ E6
E5N B4N >tJ . 0
 &H " Y"Y BC k1 e 7* 
K'+ h eË B6 $ N C  % ' Y q h :' `<l YQ'< ,N
;% [ R\t 7* BC\e B .6 K, 5S C  % ' f E B S²

7C '* wC a^ <C """ 
* - i ~ f g D @<2" œm
""h 5S M
%& .Œ
! * " R\t 7* *J C  % ' f $ &, œm *J  &

* &.[  6 7* K*¤ h'D¬ :, g D R % 7* h ‰:2
""n0 C R&' >S* i²C ;&
H
- &N+ h6 $%6 U '*  - &H6 BjC $ N C  % ' hm 2 E
"•5 beC .Œ 7C '* 
#% 5  B') Q<' B2\.b*  % '  m iy   6 M<E
" M:  b < e 3s h < 5e U 5v 2 '*  ! 
jE
%+ Q+ &'+ 'H $ :
m 7QD+ # BC k1 AP * hm ,
2 & $ :
 . h E g
,Bm A&:
6 7 % , BH h6 E , C h  p
®+' 6 LQ< `+e 7 š 5* >? 1C L+° C š 5* 1C
#   h E NE   œm 7 [ *6 5 M:* MN+ ;% 5 C
" % ' `, - H '+ B‡H U% 5' BC 30

235
#$% &'
"!       
  

 % ' C %« - BC k1  - °4:+  :~ &S hm ,


Y/<* BC k1 H —  C MN  U% 5 - )N* : A. h6
- .% v6   < Q & w^ C —&+ h6  % '< B5 * U 5v‡C
" <.J Y&' ,  5 *6 $ H 7* B2 :+ &2
l
C H 5
'2 BC k1 7 ;%$ S R 'HJ hm ,
MC X M< VS: L:~ 1+ _  m U :+ &2 U C*
H 4S h  7* 67 38 47 46 44 RSN C M: K b M<

"n0 C
: *Q'  & - iQ<+ B<J
" M* ‰: ;š 5 + 1 R5 : 1 -
  4: 6 7* M ;tbQC ^ (
:() -
. E *Q f…* `, - E5+ N B4N X U C* l
C
7* 67 38 47 46 44 RSN C M<
MC X M< VS:*
A. ÌQC M< VS: C' C B< ^ * H 4S h 
"   VS:
: 'C  &  & -
+ %  P:C BC k1 M* -  % ' ;& N ^ (

,\ %«J 7 #$ * ®+'2 * , % ' * BQD* X a N2


+% 5m *? < e 3s x! .%$ 200"000"00 Â<5* - $&=  % ' C
2+ * * ^ . N:2 7 >tj2 Y+ E 7 .%$ 10"000"00 .%&
"   x! X
"·J - ]&5 AE ;&* &+&4C ^ (

"S H E BC k1 Qs

236
#$% &'
"!       
  

/w:* 18/208 $& * 2018/02/19 - §%b* Ž4QC 1 œ$6


:•+ * 7QD+ #Q fl< &5 &  D  N e 7*
  Y<' <C — ' <' ! 
6 a 6 & <e X g :C
Y kQ U :+ &2 :+ '* œm * +$ E6 .Œ 7C   +$ S
5<e `, B, -   U% 5' 7QD E5N BC 4C Y
"xC Ž= +s * 
 p ?&5 `: BNSC < C """ 
*
%$  1/06/23 % f+P >M‰ 7* 'C ;N 15 SN X g :C
:M* ‰:C 81"03 % h  N:C ¦2006 + H 14¥ 1427 Y= 7* 15 -
"K D K)N
, 5 09:30  X 2018/02/19 ©+% C 3'<e :m + 0 Ap
n* ;% Y"Y 
 <* ^ ¯C i+ N    4N X
:•+ * 3:+ GLADIATEUR N C M<
\H K* 'H Æ%$ µ & &<5 + x< E   + % N[ + >

9 : X ) U :5* H .&1E :E R*6 7* ;&%6 *H % <QC


U 4 tª ¯< Š%Œ Œ%J $ Y t H1+ Î C \N K[&H
"n0 C ;&+H  C + U N* — l+ >l

"ElC #%*  *‰:* 


H 2 *6 + 
"%e *m L5S A%E$ ;$ M[ t 2
>0 + >Q^ >5E +  X ¯ C% * • ¯C ':+ – >

"n\
"$ N P '*  .Π7C '* 
" * 2t % † 7*  +$ f<* #&: &
H E
KH 4S gš &S .Œ 7C '* wC a^ <E - 
* `<t
"#&)  $ $ N .6 H><H

237
#$% &'
"!       
  

7C '* wC a^ <C """ 


* - i ~ f g D @<2
l<< X J i<wQ< * ' C : i 
% ,h 5S M
%& .Œ
";/M¤  D
L5 $ H U
* - h<5+ 7* . g D - K:N' +Ë
Î
" $ < 'H% <
e –
 6 7* K*¤ h'D¬ :, g D R % 7* h ‰:2 ! *
"n0 - R&' >S* i²C ;&
H 
* &.[
H 4S g D 
 + $ N C '* ~ ©2 h6 % ' 7*
" N2 l4:*  ?J 7*J
C : g D 6 .Π7C '*  U 
b* U
* &,6 - ,R&' ¢
E2 ” * ' C : ˆ5) C E % +$ EjC &C Q4 C * '
&
H 
* - p <.6 T 7* e 7* 
%& Q4 C K:e a,
"/ 3 -  * ;&%6 U ') U\H 7* U v QE% h6 &'C
7* :+ $ H D - B'* `4 2 h6 `5
Q= i% ¯ :. C
C E i% &: 9%& Q' Y +6 R\t <E 350 H * +$ E6 œm BQ=
+$ EjC x< g\E n *\
 U
%& - ;Œ m X H+ ˆ5)
"lt6 U l'  C h E/
g D 7* 7+&
N U :+2 D52 hE% 5+ '* ~ C 7+&
N ®'C
+ £ $ H *‰:* $ N 6 7* 'C * +6  , - M: 'H&+ h6 k
"$ N
k1 f<È 2018/04/17 <wC ,U < ;&'C D ƒ%$m X g :C
  NSC BC k1 2 &N2 < ;$ M1C œ$6 """ ! Ž, BC
<e X g :C *j 7* f< ƒtm %2 x! &'C ,*j< f< /w, %H

238
#$% &'
"!       
  

""" ! Ž, 2018/11/13 <wC ,BC k1 7 n:+ # """ ! * 4


7 """ ! Ž,   NSC BC k1 2 &N2 < ;$ M1C œ$6
Ugm - 7'l C Ã2  $ $ f< >tj2 iQ BC k1
h6 `5
""" BC k1 ( H$ h ;/.  D % 5  %2 Q4 ,Â<5
" & h &C C  0 iN: *j 7* f< ƒtm 2
,h  `5l2 iQ H * ' C : _ &< Q< 3l 6 v
"2018/11/27 <~ *j
:(X' 1&-
+ 1 X g :C A\ 6 4:~ 6 7* BC k1 'C * 3y ,
"]& `^ C  l e 7* A&) *& ;š 5
:1 -
 U <1 `H N #! 7* 3*& ;š 5 + 1 hm ,
"\[ p5 K'+ —  C   .H2
< ;$ M[ 7* 3C  ,   NSC 2 M hm ,
*j 7* f< ƒtm <lC BC k1 * = Y&2 2018/04/09 ©+% C
iN:C BC k1 * = """ ! &+& 7* Y&2 v ,Â<5 gm - 7'l &S
;l* ¯<
&N+ C —&+ I ( H& h6 Tm , Q4 q& < t|C <l
  NSC BC k1 2 h6 &'C ;/.  D % 5  %2 7'l
"2018/09/25 ©+% C
:S! "
NSC  ?% Q4 Y *6 %D^ 7 f<È BC k1 hm ,
"  

239
#$% &'
"!       
  

œm % 1  D  N e 7* /w: Ž4 7* 3C  hm ,


Bm % 1 Ž4 C :QD U :+ & P:C Y  BC k1 h6 A\ 6 B'*
V €[¤  Y, P C iy  U% 5' . A\ 6
44 >?   k $ U :+ & x<2 - Mm % 1 *Q' U 
b
"U 5vm h &C Mm M5
. 25:' 51 `+e 7 3 E   A. 5 hm ,
& U% 5' A. h2 —  C YQ' B - ,N < <

" :< 3M
X  '+ B6 X ¡:2 H 4S h  7* 83 ;$  U D* hm ,
h E 6 x1 0SC ¡: . $%  k, ;š 5*  6  P
7 ¢‹ NC P: . .$&¢ I 6 M:'+ I ². 6 S€[ œm M*
"U C - ;$% U% 5' R\t 7* M< ' 7Q+
f g D @<2 " :   C  P  BC k1 hm ,
h‡H ,"h 5S M
%& .Π7C '* wC a^ <C """ 
* - i ~
Q'+ # 1 ¡€[ . M:* $S X ' 7Q+ ;% 5' A.
BC k1 X `5l:2 SN . ‹ : h2 xC , < C '*  ! 
jE
"h  iN 7* 85 SN< 5e M<6 7* B2tb* K'+
" 25 q p  D  N e 7* ;/w: « 4 hm ,
1 :Q< D M) ” œ& ` v R\t 7* Q4 hm ,
  w4E ” : Ž4 - 7Q) * i p 5+ I :<' <~ -
"Bm  * 6 7* M ;tb M : h2
:&-' 1 K41 "
MH M: $b* 4<S NS B 7_ 3*& &  l hm ,
"\[ 5*

240
#$% &'
"!       
  

B$jC BC k1 X ^ iQ ]& `^ C  l   hm ,


200"000"00 Â<5* - $&=  % ' C ,\ %«J 7 #$ * ®+'2 B
Y+ E 7 .%$ 10"000"00 .%& +% 5m *? < e 3s x! .%$
"   x! 7 2+ * * ^ . N:2 7 >tj2
"·J - ]&5 AE ;&* &+&4C ^ (

"S H E BC k1 Qs


4:~ 6 7* A\ 6 *Q'  & - 7+$6 BC k1 hm ,
= C v +:'* %« ]& `^ C  l C 3^6  Bm C:
A$&s # B  ^ %Ž ~ ®+'C 5 l - = B<'“ _ š 5*
"B  ^ %Ž< ; * ++& Ml<
% em - Q4
" MDH% K'+ ;% * >? k52 U 5<l  C hm ,
" .  Q4+  & Ë t hm ,
;l h  7* B<+ * 633 365 B<+ * 286 'C  RSN 5l2
"  :~
n3I _?
#%D, C QC :< 4:~ + D - 35v . Q4 U%&6
:BS Æu ^ 1 `, - +%D, BC k1 `, -
";š 5 + 1 R5C − 1
;H  *0C B< ^ Bm  * 6 7* BC k1 ;tbQC −2
"k$J - % 5  S * ¦.%$ f6 hv\v¥ .%$ 30"000"00 .%&

241
#$% &'
"!       
  

B$jC BC k1 X ^ )* \[ &  l R5C


¦.%$ f6  *¥ .%$ 100"000"00 A%& &* D+'2 ]& `^ C  lQ<
"U 5<l  C ®HC k$J - % 5  S *
: M1 Y - ;&': :<' <~ - •2 ^ %& ”
7* 5E* . +$ EjC &C Q4 C +$   U <~ C A\ 6
""" :;$ 

”3
 @N5 c 

242
#$% &'
"!       
  

485 ‫ﻗﺮار ﻣﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻟﻨﻘﺾ ﻋﺪد‬


2014 ‫ أﺑﺮﻳﻞ‬02 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
279
2013/3/6/9511 ‫ﰲ اﳌﻠﻒ اﻟﺠﻨﺤﻲ ﻋﺪد‬

:m14
k( $/g T4 * – @A >? '+G – +D
m Y &3N 1 @C " l3% y,'0= 1&- )+ 

>?- ,fd U #/ b W %&- >? @A '+G T n%C
 * U W-   (5  4C% ,fd Q,- W3A/ b @A
44 m T EE mQ W%4 |,  gL " *  i    W/4
* 5  >? @A \4 @ &N ' +,  T
†i ,- †w –  ]' ( $/C-  m‹3 /C-
kW1&6 9ƒ (%&' h  U (& ,nN=
kL  ^G {

% 3g †% FG #-


a 9 ]& `^ C 5 l e 7* (H ®: <e X g :C
& 2013/03/25 ©+% C h +Œ &Q= ! M H$ l
C BC 3DH6 L+°2 ÌQC
7 %$ S % ® œm * µ C C  :²
 Q4QC ˆ5D C E
: $& D - Mm % 1  :²
 Q= & H :²
 L:~ H?
Y4 fj ^ &+jC G  2013/03/18 ©+% C 2013/2602/1437
7* n<l ;g  '52 &  l - 5 C V St Y&'C A DQC
"  4:

www.maroclaw.com : h  n0* <w ]   C %1:* − 279

243
#$% &'
"!       
  

{ )p L
" D - BC f< + £ 7C &Q= & % 1 \2 h6 &'C
"B2 w:* - Y ' * 4 #+Œ .C & œm U S &'C
% 3g  1 1&-
h +Π&Q= ! M H$ l
C : l h& 7* ” œ& ;EQ< ‰
H ®: Q= Y *6 H< R5 µ C C K* 4 ²” * 4
"ƒ Y a 7* 530 528 K2$  C 5<l µ P<
:m1 % Xd "
h'l % h6 x! , H 4S h  7* 44 ;$  at 7* ;€
1 œm B5:C T ,Bm  C S€[ . + I BC k1 h6   BH
 ;> R\t B:+ ƒ% * P . BC Y  * E h6 " S€[ NSC
h6 " 7* % B< ¡ * h6 R ^ ,hl2 :+&QC + H 20 E, MQ‰
B2! &, - . """" :2 ;>* R\t B:+ ƒ% * P . BC Y  * E
h  H ";š 5* +lC 5
6 H &'2   P . YZ 'H X #¢
6 B'Q
*  š : h6 g l? 3s V €[J &)  P:C LQ+ T
7 6 š 5* h E g
P: X xE  '2 ;%E 44 ;$  hm C "B:+
 BH h'l % "n 2% x1 0 - x! ÇH6  : `+e
"BDH% K'+ ;%E U D at & h+ %E 4: X Ì
hj1C 1958  15 >M… 7* 44 ;$  7*   ;N ÌQC Bm ,
7 h E  k,  6  P X  '+ B‡H P: H 4S h 
"ˆH : `+e
, E h‡H ƒ Y a 7* 370 365 K2$  U DQC \Q Bm ,
\e C h E Tm   ' K, : 7* \<'* h+ h6 “ % 6
"B*&' #Œ+ <' h S h6

244
#$% &'
"!       
  

 l - 5< V St Y&'C Ì BH h'l % hm ,


+ I n<l h6 " <'C   4: 7* n<l ;g  '52 &
Y  * E h6 : l< S€1 BNSC B5:+ I   C S€[ .
7*   ;N B< 3S * % em - P * 1 :* h $ ,"B:+ * P . BC
P: h E g
  X  '2  A\ 6 ;%E 44 ;$ 
"n 2% x1 0 - x! ÇH6  k, : `+lC 6 ;š 5* +lC
¡  B<< k:52 &C ^ &+6 # BH h'l % H xC
B'* K'+ _ ˆH &  & - BC Ì H B*&'T #Œ <'
"hj1 ” BD:C L+°
n3I _?
- V St Y& 7* BC Ì H BH h'l % ®:C 3D
" &  l

245
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﻄﺎﻧﻄﺎن‬


2019 ‫ ﻳﻨﺎﻳﺮ‬10 ‫ ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬4 ‫ﺗﺤﺖ ﻋﺪد‬
280
2018/2102/628 ‫ﰲ اﳌﻠﻒ اﻟﺠﻨﺤﻲ ﻋﺪد‬

:m14
t ]N 9? WL -A 53A/Q M/ 1'% # ' L
(  - W<4 _1Q/    ‚A T h%)' W /
kWL  % T U W,™ 'i T ?'46 )
' ,
" (E)' GL Oi œ4 N   >? +G @%C'N
&  " (E)'/ = ?U W%4 @,/ S! ,= (&
1,  U1 ' ŒC- = F4 80 ,i
k 

% 3g †% FG #-


- 35v . h l lC &C Q4 U%&6 2019/01/10 ©+% C
:& KC BS Æu ^ ,#$ 4:~ + D
; Q4 A” x< E
""" :]& `^ C  l
 G T +$ E6 ²” * 4 """ ! B: n:+
®Q+ I 7*Œ :*  D ;& A. t$ BC 2% C M """ KC
M< VS: K:<'   4: : 4:~ Y$  &*6 B<
K0  G T "P: H 4S h  7* 85 84 83 $ - MC X

"%1:* >? , − 280

246
#$% &'
"!       
  


 H 
S<€ A\ 6 M M* - +% ~ * ' C : 'C * X g :C
- §%b 01 ;$ / ƒ ƒ Y 588 $&  D lC D #Ž= 7* .‹ :
Y&2 """ kQ h6 B:* $ N+ # h l e 7*6 e 7* /w: 2018/08/03
œ$6 K:<'   VS€C A\ 6 M M* - + 1C
&  D  N 7 2018/07/20 ©+% C 2018/343 $& :+ '* Ž4QC
¯C i+ H    * X 7+%& 4 `v+ # ƒ c
:1 U ¢° 7* QZ hD+ """ 
m 3s ]  """ 
m 3s R J
<‡C Y ' R  a%
¡< . '+ T :* 7* " 5 7* 1 `, -
- Rj+  " """" /’ E% 5QC < C   % 4 h l e
– › Q:2 - MH‹ 2 .%& K+\* h6 K, - ;  7 g4S
n 5
6 7* " "h l e :+&* [ C &< 1Q< ;%SC H* :+ &2
""1Q< ;%SC H* :+ &2 – U% W * h l e ¯,   Mm
B6 &EjH ]  Ž= - 1 œm (
 2 ,45 - T


<m * & e 7* f<E B6 U
%&< QC Y&€QE Q'+
;%$ 5 * C % em - t&< ;%& +% 1 7* QZ +/:C h l e
   * &, A&N2 &: B6 +P5 Q:< :e
U * q 7* QZ p\t 7* Bm B+ UT * P:+ A\ 6 M C ÍH
+% 1* +y ,h l e ¯, k &+ *   Mm $ N VS€C N/
¡<" n B' * gš /2 X '1 R*6 +Œ2 ›
R & ‰ B< ' B ;g
m - 52 _ "iW $\~" "a% 
MH %'+ sms S 
C M 7* 2 B6 $ H6 , :J X UT 
" M:* €:C œ$6 B:* %& 
* h6 $ H6 1 '+ B6 &E6 MQ< +&My (
 &:
B6 BSÈ T 1 `, - e , U% 5' :QD   

247
#$% &'
"!       
  

B6 BSÈ 1 ” 2  S: 


 h6 c‹ M5,  M“
" *\E U$ 1* M:C 3' h6 &'C B M<
%6
2018/12/27 < .tª 3 E U < ;&'C D ƒ%$m X g :C
Ž4 C l* M +. ,B5  1 Ž, cË  , - M Ž,
7* 385 ;$  U D* 7 RΠ:2 ,Bm n: C '[6 ,  D lC D
%Ž2 B6 1 &E6 ,;/.  D Q4 U   ,  :~ ;l h 
 * M 5 7* 7+Q   g >E
M X 3) , 5<
4 % vª - B :CJ B 52 _  
Y&2 h6 B `5
B6 BSÈ T †6 c°H ¯C i+ N QC ;$% U :+ &
†6 $ H6 S: 
 VS€C , eP L S* & MS€C + 1C
B<E* Bm  '2 * h6 ,°* ]& `^ C  l ( H$ Q< R :2 ,BSÈ
- B 52 ¯C i+ H    * K:< [ 
7*
# ,BC V W U
%&  BS€1 :e &'S X Â<C >M12
h l e <‡C +P5 Q:< :e ;%$ 5 Q+ +% 5  S€[ '+
-/~ 
 g$6 &N+ C œ$6 Bm n: 6 7* M ;tb* iQ
`^ C  l ;& N B$jC M X ^ 'C  &  & - iQ
 S M Qs * %« 7* BC `^  .%$ 500"000 A%& D+'2 ]&
U   , $ x< E & iQ ,·J - AE ;&* &+&s
&'C 2019/01/10 <~ *j< ./w, 2 MH 5< ;/.  D Q4
"<2 7* tª M h E h6
% 3g (X' 1&-
S:2 7* B:y &S *j 7* f< ƒtm <lC M Y&2 ,
« = œm Q4 (C B6 Tm ,  D ;&  % em - A%Œb+ ( H$
x! ( H& $& m &S K<M* 7* M Ky `5
B6 p K52 U <~
"<l ®H% B'* $ S+ _ 2018/12/13 2018/11/29 <wC

248
#$% &'
"!       
  

:)& K41 "


"Y q xSC l
* 6 7* M x< E & C 2 ,
* h6 &Eb* Bm n: kN +&My MQ< (
 &: Bm ,
h6 BSÈ T 1 `, - e , U% 5' :QD   
3' h6 &'C B M<
%6 B6 BSÈ 1 ” 2  S: 

" *\E U$ 1* M:C
i+ N QC ;$% U :+ & h6 $ H6 Q4 Y *6 B* & ,
eP L S* & MS€C + 1C Y&2 h6 B `5
B6 ,BSÈ T ¯C
"BSÈ †6 c‹ S: 
 VS€C
h6 p 35v B2 += f< a% 6 X M \e &'C Q4 hm ,
¡<Q B:* + 0 $Z k26 Bm C: E5+ N U :+ &< M % m
7* % T :QD S: 
 hC BH  A&:N+  :~  b 7*
"Bm M<
%6 7* . BSÈ 1
B6 P: H 4S h  7* 44 SN 7* œ J ;N ¡:2 ,
' A. 3 E !m ². 6 ¡€[ œm M5 6 ' g $m H &'+ "
"" Mm 35  ²p 6 ¡€1 % 5  6 š iy
.  % 5  X MM 7*  D $ MT BN 
 ,
;% U C' C BC  q5v  , - 2 B< :wQ< %*6 $ :
m
6 š 5* $ :
 h E g
B:e .6 &: A% , 2 6   x
5 M:* MN+ ;% 5 C 6 f+' C 6 LQ< $wQC k, 6 L+° C
"  œm 7 [ *6
*m µ 1 ‹ : H2 M*  <l2  4: hm ,
' - Q+ $ :
 . B< S:+ ()* ,$ :
 'H - Q
" :~ &S h  .$&,  al C $ :
 \ >t6 , :1

249
#$% &'
"!       
  

œm % 1  D  N 5 7* :+ ' Ž= 7* 3C  hm ,


PC iy :1* U% 5 D2 U :+ &2 P:C Y  M h6 A\ 6 B'*
"h l e <‡C B<Q+ # U
%& * 'Q
B'Q
7* R :2 1
 * 1Q< M M5 U% 5' A. hm ,
" :<' °: B'* `4+ _ YQ'< cN ¯C i+ H  
Bw2 h6 MQ< C: L:~ -  :~ &S H N+ ,
"xC I . M\ &   U% 5   $ :
m œm B2$%m
B6 X ¡:2 P: H 4S h  7* 83 ;$  U D* hm ,
x1 0SC ¡: . $%  k, ;š 5*  6  P X  '+
"U C - ;$% U% 5' R\t 7* &M X ' 7Q+ 7
% 1 :+ ' Ž4QC :QD U :+ & C ;$% U% 5' hm ,
7* 85 ;$  U D* `5l2 B'* K'+ _ 1 . M:* $S ,A\ 6 Bm
"M M* - h  iN
w, X Tm q%* :52 T Q4 h % 5  Bm ,
7* 289 ;$  U DQC \Q M* *6 +%D, . N[ 31 3)
Bm n:Q< M n 2% C 3': & Q4 h‡H ,  :~ ;l h 
"B<6 7* B2tb* B'* K'+ _
`v+ ,U N € L:~ -  D lC D « = hm ,
h  7* 290 ;$  U DQC \Q MN ¬ * U 5vm K, œm M:QDQC
"  :~ ;l
M `, - N: H* 5^ C' ' B'* K'+ ,
"  D BC
Y&'T
"k$J -  Z  S M Qs K'+ ,

250
#$% &'
"!       
  

:&-' 1 K41 "


"-/~  S M$J M* ‰: p5C : (i "
B ^ B5  l
C ]& `^ C  l iQ , :S! "
M Qs * .%$ 500"000 Â<5* 7 + T %Ž 7 ]&* ®+'C
"·J - ]&5 AE ;&* &+&s  S
*Q'  & - M 7+$6 ,
h‡H $' U */ h  7* 77 ;$  U DQC \Q Bm ,
±&,jH h  BC LQ+ h6 >? 7* % t :C 7 h  B52% 'H E
'N h6 35v !m %Ž . ®+'C B52* Y/6 >0< +:'* 6 +$ * %«
"%Ž RS, - š 5 5 .
5 l &*  $ * m Q+  7* %Ž2 7*  `¢ ,
7* 348 ,9 ,7 ,3 ,2 $ U DQC \Q %«J x<2 7 BD+'C M52*
"ƒa
` v A\ 6 *Q'  & U , R\t 7* 3C  Bm ,
5 h E Q+~ n 2% h6 q C\* Œ :  ‰ B2 += f<
U
%& * ¡€[ BS€[ - ]& `^ C  l C m - š 5
" N<
Mm % 1 %«J C B<Q+ #
x<2 7 BD+'C 5 l - = ]& l xC >S+ ,
"%«J
U D+' h‡H  :~ h  7* 108 ;$  U DQC \Q ,
R ^ ŀ1 %Ž 7 \* E D+'2 %ŽQ< `s h6 “ ” Y4
"%Ž %& 5
:* \* ®+' x! h+ h6 l+š B  ^

251
#$% &'
"!       
  

&^ œm .$% K'+ MH  5* Ug  ”  l  5 hm , 7


&* D+'2 Q4 B $&s #  ^ •'N %Ž Yg\+ #
"]& `^ C  l ;& N M ´$b+ .%$ 150"000 A%&  }m
"k$J -  Z  S M Qs K'+ ,
"h < 5l2
n3I _?
: +%D, &C :< Q4 c°2
Bm n: 6 7* M ;tbQC :)& K41 " −1
" S B<Qs * .%$ 20"000 .%& ;H  *0C B< ^
: &-' 1 K41 " −2
p5C : 1 -
`^ C  l ;& N B$jC """ kQ h& X ^ : () -
, S B<Qs * .%$ 150"000 A%&  }m &* D+'2 """ kQ ]&
"U 5<l  C ®HC k$J - % 5
: M1 Y - ;&': :<' <~ - •2 ^ %& ”
². 3 E h l lC &C Q4 C +$   U <~ C A\ 6
""" : ;$  7* * Q4

252
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺘﺎورﻳﺮت‬


2013/02/26 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
281
11/1241 ‫اﳌﻠﻒ اﻟﺠﻨﺤﻲ ﻋﺪد‬

:m14
3'4 >‹ c 'i)% # '  3A/ ' " " m34 L
Si " , C- | 1 o5 ,WL |3A 9? hfi
+,  T 47 (,Q% /' œ& W& N — ,&
k %G T WN?0‚ B&'/ W " )  *

% 3g †% FG #-


^ U+% C &C Q4 U%&6 2013/02/26 ©+% C
:BS Æu 4:~
Q4 A” x< E & : KC −
k G T "( Y: ]& `^ C  l
:* Q4 Ap  D ;& t$ BC 2% C M Y " 6 : kQ
M< VS:  1  4:~ Y$  &*6 B< ®Q+ I 7*Œ
kK0  G T " :~ h  7* 443 442 RSN - MC X
H  
.‹ : S<€ M &) +% ~ * ' C : 'C * X g :C
eš 5 7* /w: 2011/08/01 ©+% 2 995 $&  D lC D Ž= 7*
A\ 6 M h6 .$ N* + 1C Y&2 ( Y kQ h6 B:* $ N+ # ,U+% 2

"%1:* >? , − 281

253
#$% &'
"!       
  

E R +$ ¯ E  Y 1 " ;% 5'C   C B .‡C B< g&  C Y 
"a n kQ %D4C &+&~ ^ C &w* Y *6 "
$& 5C 1 * ; & B h6 c‹ +&My MQ< (
 &:
" 6 < BD+'2 H  U /: 7*
<wC 3%$6 Q4 A. X D 3<,6 f<
* X g :C
% 5  %H ,1 Ž, , ?% M M: f<È 2013/02/05
";/.  D
$ H6   KQ B$6 ;$ M1  BN &'C a n &. 1 Ž,
B6 M+NC Y  h €+ M 1 & &wQ< M* h E B6
U 5<l C gT$¸ <M* iQ " *%&~ $ " 1Q< R+ M Q

" &
œ$6 ]& `^ C  l Ž, M f<È 2013/02/12 <wC
, $ x< E & iQ ,-/~ ˆ C H* & B2 5<lC
"2013/02/26 *j< D U/w,
% 3g (X' 1&-
:)& K41 "
& iQ A\ 6 l 6 7* M * ' C : 3'C 2 ,
" <~ C x! J B$m x< E
7 f<È  < 1 ®+'2 +&My M 6 ,
%'C BN<È % + h6 >? 7* S€[  ?% Q4 Y *6 %D^
"( P*
+6 5 7QD2T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [ >5'2 E 5
&'+ ,
Bm &: % , + 6 Q+ &'+ 'H $ :
m .  h6 , :'* '
" :~ h  - f 7* E6 5+ T 'N ,7e .6 &:

254
#$% &'
"!       
  

¡<Q 6 7* <


Tm . * Bm n: M % m hm ,
M  ' &E6 # a n &. 1 ;$ M[ A&:N2  :~  b 7*
"Y ' (% 1 C &w Y *6 " $ " ;% 5'C 1Q<
š iy 1Q< M M5:+ ' "$" ;% 5 hm ,
_ ,Y ' (% 1 - c S l
C 3y ,Bm 35 # ¡€1 % 5 
- Q  P: H 4S h  7* 47 SN< :+ ‹ :' B'* h2
" M<6 7* B2tb* K'+ B,
B'y Q4 U% ,   M  ‰ ‰ Bm ,
" NN€  D  ‰ C
" % 5 h $ f+% S M Qs K'+ ,
:&-' 1 K41 "
<1 µ P H  H* &  l 3*& , :(i "
" p5C L+° + _   5<l
:S! "
"A\ 6 <SN B2 Q<* `H B ^ ]& `^ C  l iQ ,
%Ž 7 B b* '“ Bm n: 6 7* A\ 6 M $m hm ,
\ %Ž jlW KC 55 \' h6 Y$ * Q  ( Y 4D C `,\
"( R a 78 SN U D 5e ;š 5*
* ~ M:*  % ++&2 l<
7* p C Q4 Uj2% ,
al:QC $% Â<5 - ®+' Q &+&s BH 5  … %Ž
"BC ^ A&'C ^
'C  &  &   M Qs 05:+ ,

255
#$% &'
"!       
  

+ ? œm A&'C * 636 −319 −304 − 290 − 287 − 286 $Q< 5l2


h  7* 149 146 K<SN 'C  RSH  :~ ;l h  7* 641
" :~
n3I _?
: #%D, C QC &C :< Q4 c°2
:)& K41 "
f6 .%& ;H  *0C B5 '* Bm n: 6 7* M ;tbQC
"% 5 h $ f+% S B<Qs * .%$ ¦1000¥
:&-' 1 K41 "
\[ p5 : 1 -
A%& &* D+'2 ]& `^ C  l ;& N M g$jC :() -
"% 5 h $  S * .%$ ¦2000¥ N6
7* E2 ²p 3 E ,A\ 6 : M1 Y - ^ %& ”
""" : ;$ 

@N c 

256
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺘﺎوﻧﺎت‬


‫ﻣﺮﻛﺰ اﻟﻘﺎﴈ اﳌﻘﻴﻢ ﺑﻘﺮﻳﺔ ﺑﺎ ﻣﺤﻤﺪ‬
2016/07/11 ‫ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬
282
2016/18 ‫ﰲ ﻣﻠﻒ ﻗﻀﺎء اﻟﻘﺮب ﻣﺨﺎﻟﻔﺎت ﻋﺪد‬

: m14
(iN ,- M3&- W!4 " 'i #'d @A- # ' 
n 
#v'- $%&' 10k42 #   T 16 m œ4
B&'/ W " |-: _F4 # ' eL @A  / ,WND,'0
kW%G T WN?0‚

% 3g †% FG #-


G  /E* ,U  C &C Q4 U%&6 2016/07/11 ©+% C
:BS Æu ^ U N ’ n g D - 352 . &Q= C +C 
" Q4 A. & x< E & KC
""" :1
 G T
""" :kQ
®Q+ I 7*Œ :* Q4 Ap  D ;& t$ BC 2% C M
42"10 >M… 7* 16 ;$< 5e :<' >? 1  N ’ Y$  &*6 B<
"B2  St n g DC `<'
K0  G T

"%1:* >? , − 282

257
#$% &'
"!       
  

:Hš  
S<€ A\ 6 K:‰ `, - +% ~ * ' C : 'C * X g :C
©+% C ,3075 % ~ ¯%&  D lC D Ž= 7* .‹ :
©+% C B6 .$ N* + 1C Y&2 """ 1 h6 B:* $ N+ # ,2015/11/24
—, ,# N0  5
J a C &,J Y+ $  # ,2015/10/25
 5
J a t$  %J ÎH C Y+ h E  , , 5 :*  
B':Q+ BC k1 C j N2 ,5< "9&' C/" - <Q B'<
 '
ND* ,]  * h $ BQ1+ B5+ 6&C x! 7 AFN
  ,x! 7*
" :^ U : # ! t&2 T "R'*" l
C BCŽ+ h6 $ E BC k1 h6
l* . * 6 7* M x< E & C 2   A. X g :C
"A\ 6
Y +6 &,6 - B6 c‹ ]  Ž= - +&My K:‰ œm (
 &:
&,6 Y  ,# N0  5
J a C 2015 :
7* CE6 M1 &,J
B<* -  5
J a t$  %6 ÎH C B+. '+ T V €[J
t&H ,x! 7* B':QC Y H "9&' C/" - <Q B'<
 '
l
C B< $ C tu . 6&C ¯ª BQ[ B5C Y  """ kQ 1
®NC *   5
J a C V €[J ®'C t&2 h6 œm 1 
” $&´ h6 h $ "T'*" A&C Q¢ h E B6 ND* ,M:C   (/:
"1
7* &Ej &'C ,M Ž, ,2016/03/01 <wC f< ƒ%$m X g :C
"B+ [ &E6 1 Ž, ,%  C n 6 Bm n: 7 B+.
(
 `5
M Ž, ,2016/05/03 <wC f< ƒ%$m X g :C
B+. 7* &Ej &'C """ &. 1 Ž, ,B+ [ &E6 1 Ž, ,Bm
ˆ5D C ±$ ^ Y+ B6 c‹   KQ B$6 C ; &' BN

258
#$% &'
"!       
  

 , *\ U$ 1 ®'C t‹ Q


# N? &,J  5
J a C
h6 M:C 1  hT$ 5+ M 1 & KHl 7* n
""" &. 1 Ž, ,"""¯ C 7+$ ,x*6 7+$" U% 5'C 1 + M
B6 c‹   KQ B$6 C ; &' BN B+. 7* &Ej &'C
B6 ,« , h E # N? &,J  5
J a C ˆ5D C ±$ ^ Y+
h E M h6 ND* ,M:C 1  hT$ 5+ › 1 M &. [
ND* , C  U% 5'C 1 BC 6 K, - "x<, #$ ?" 1Q< R+
$%6  5
J a C )%6 'l œm + M:C (/: 5
h6 &. 1
" M:* B':QC Y  M h6 Tm M[N+ h6 1
(
 `5
M Ž, ,2016/06/28 <wC f< ƒ%$m X g :C
4000 A%& ]&* ®+'C B ^ iQ B+ [ &E6 1 Ž, ,Bm
B$6 C ; &' BN B+. 7* &Ej &'C """ &. 1 Ž, ,.%$
&,J  5
J a C ˆ5D C ±$ ^ Y+ B6 c‹   KQ
 hT$ 5+ M 1 & ,%lN 5 B :2 &'C ,# N?
ˆ
Y\E C  U% 5'C """"¯ C 7+$ x*6 7+$" U% 5'C M:C 1
« ^ M h E h6 &'C ,;/.  D Q4 U  H ,K5~ B &:+
*j< D f<* /w, Q4 U% M:, , ²[ fD+ I <2 7* tª
"2016/07/11 <~
:% 3g (X' 1&-
:)& K41 "
. * `H Bm n: 6 7* M x< E & C 2 ,
"A\ 6 'C  xSC l*
R, 1 KC B:C \t vm X B6 +&My M c‹ ,
R$ 52 œm U%l2 *\E ;$r 1* - \t$ ,# N0C  5
J a C )%6
" Q4 ;j. Y *6 A% m $& M:C 1 

259
#$% &'
"!       
  

7* U\H  b 7* ¡<Q< <


Tm . * A% m hm ,
* 1  R$ 52 BE  D lC D Y *6 B2 ¢°2 A&:N2 n '
Y *6   KQ M$6 &'C """ $M1 ;$ M[ A&Eb2 # gÊ 1
"  5
J a C ˆ5D C ±$ ^ Y+ B6  $ H6 7+ Q4 ;j.
 hT$ 5+ › M 1  &. [ 7+« ,  E "# N? &,J
ˆ
Y\E C  U% 5'C ,""""¯ C 7+$ ,x*6 7+$" U% 5'C ,M:C 1
7+$" U% 5'C 1 + h E M h6 """ &. 1 ND* ,K5~ B &:+
" l
t6 U% 5'C "¯ C 7+$ ,x*
L:~ U N € 7* 35 hj1C  D lC D « = hm ,
"  :~ ;l h  7* 290 ;$< 5e MN ¬ * 35+ I * M:QDQC `v+
lC D Y *6 p6 * Qw:* Ug  $M1 ;$ M[ hm ,
U% 5'C B) - 1 [ C Y  M hE MH i5 T  D
g DC `<' 42"10 h  7* 16 ;$  ‹ : 12 B2 . B6 h6 , C 
œm  * hjC 3': A\ 6 E! _ \l Q4 h6 B2  St n
"B<6 7* B2tb* K'+ B, - 3C v A\ 6 M
% 5 ;&* &+&s + Bm n: 6 7* M $m hm ,
"k$J - B, -
<QQ< * ' :+/W `2 X  &   g Cm K'+ Bm ,
" C0
:&-' 1 K41 "
5<l <1 µ P `H &  l 3*& , :(i "
" p5C L+° B'* K'+ _  

260
#$% &'
"!       
  

:S! "
M M* - B2& N ^ ]& `^ C  l iQ ,
4000 A%& *~ 'N g 7* BC 6 # %Ž 7 ]&* ®+'C
".%$
B bQC R 5+ Bm n: 6 7* M $m hm ,
'N g 7* ]& `^ C  l C 3^  +:' %«J 7 &
;š 5* C v %Ž 'N KC 55 \' 3*$ * B52% # *~
"Š0 $' U */T h  7* 78 77 K<SN ÌQC
B [ B) - ]& `^ C  l [ C M Y  hm ,
"B: BD+'2 Y/<+ +:'* %«
®+' C Y/ B²l€C 6 B<'NC %« >0< 5
7* E hm ,
"Š0 $' U */T h  7* 77 SN U D* ,
\* E   %ŽQ< `¢ h6 “ BC Y4 ®+' hm ,
, Q+~ 7* ;š 5* BC 6 # `4 R ^ ŀ1 %Ž<
" :~ h  7* 108 SN U D*
$' U */T h  7* 98 SN YMNQC %Ž Q1+ ,
M Nm œm lD
6 l)  U H ° % Ž C 3^   W
"'N .  : +$ ' $ &^ ;$ - N 7* BC Y, *
. BD+'C +/ Q4 ¡È # %Ž YMN* hm ,
"  :~ ;l h  7* 7 ;$  YMNQC Q+~ 7* ;š 5* 2 : %Ž
®+' &+&s U% Q4 h2 A\ 6 E!  $ :
 Bm ,
* 4C x! ++&2 l<
7* p  5e ]& `^ C  lQ< `4
"^ . al:* - $>

261
#$% &'
"!       
  

" C0 <QQ< * ' :+/W `2 X  S ¯2 K'+ ,


– 636 – 324 œm 228 – 290 œm 286 252 251 01 RSN< 5l2
n g DC `<' 42"10 h  7* 16 ;$   :~ ;l h  7* 638
"B2  St ‰:2
:n3I _?
#%D, C QC  M , :< Q4 3Q,
:)& K41 "
5e :<' >? 1  7* Bm  * 6 7* M ;tbQC
,B2  St &+&s n g DC `<' 42"10 % h  7* 16 ;$<
- % 5 * .%$ ¦500¥ ¶ .%& ;H   * *0C x! 7 B5 '*
"k$J
"A&) N:+ T , ^ Bm Â<5+ hjC *j
U *0 g N
T <4 l< œm ^ 7* € <2 hjC *j E
"h  , ” Y4
:&-' 1 K41 "
" p5 :(i "
 }m &* D+'2 ]& `^ C  l ;& N M g$6 :S! "
" S * ' :+/W Qs ,.%$ ¦2000¥ .%$ N6 A%&
: M1 Y - ;&': :<' <~ - •2 ^ %& ”
""" :;$  7* E2 . +$  T U <~ C A\ 6

”3
 @N5 c 

262
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺣﻜﻢ ﺻﺎدر ﻋﻦ اﳌﺤﻜﻤﺔ اﻹﺑﺘﺪاﺋﻴﺔ ﺑﺼﻔﺮو‬


2019 /01/17 ‫ ﺑﺘﺎرﻳﺦ‬88 ‫ﺗﺤﺖ ﻋﺪد‬
283
2019/2103/1938 : ‫ﰲ ﻣﻠﻒ ﺗﻠﺒﺲ رﻗﻢ‬

: m14
}’-  Q,- )% = c%~ c  - $%&'N H  4L
^  3G)- h,0 c%~ M  K1L Pr4 P 1~- C
 ,(& @' B/^N (G T Mr'A T B/F ' " M1
\4 /£ (& $%0 \4 H~i/ rE'= ( &/ #% = (4
c  (& $ " ? 1&N ' H   T Y'&N ,& P /?3N
k '+D M3:L 14  " )% = c%~

% 3g †% FG #-


©+% C ;&': :<' M< - NSC &C Q4 U%&6
: BS Æu ^ i5<2 4:~ + D - 52 . 2019/01/17
Q4 A. & x< E & KC
:]& `^ C K5 l
" N  * """ & −1
" NSC Q< i<w i% """ & −2
9 NC * 4 % 5 7^"! M: n:+
 G Tšš

"%1:* >? , − 283

263
#$% &'
"!       
  

P'4  " – """ −1 :KQ


"9 NC * 4 N
+ &, &5 "! A%Œb+
ˆ  " – """ −2
" NSC h * 4 # : Y\ &5 R[C R }"h! A%Œb+
K0  G T
7* X Ywp c\ l
C c~ nŽ ” 2% C hM
U$&, N R 4 h  MQ‰ :MQC `<'*  g $m R'
 >0
R'
C f:' P ‘ %& >? ” E µ š * ' U l<
R 4 h  MQ‰ :MQC `<'*  g $m R'
 F c\
X M< VS: R 'HJ , ” E µ š * ' U l< U$&, N
 :~ h  7* 441 443 442 381 505 401 400 RSN - MC
Y$  &*6 B< ®Q+ I 7*Œ :* Q4 Ap  D ;& t$
" 4:~
H  
eš e 7* 7+/w: #&MQ 45 #Ž= - g  * X g :C
599 $& 3s ]  ,2018/12/10 - §%b 1048 $& 3s R J , N
* & h6 r : 7* """ r  7* $ N+ 7+< 2018/12/18 - §%b
h6 MH g  Q4 A. & x< E & œ + 1C Y&2 N <m
% 5t6 7QD2 """ ]   X UT * P:C Y+ ÍH * """  &
" """ " 4NSC .P ;$ m œm &Q'+ v ,B'QC iy e<0* U l'* NŒ
BNSC " """ " ŀ1 BC , ¯C i+ N    QC
¯%&<  D /E e 7* Bm (
 &: B  X g  E H 4
NS B 4 &Eb+ _ 2018/02/27 ©+% C 54 % Ž4 - NSC <

264
#$% &'
"!       
  

NSC Q< i<w i% h6 k $ Y / - 4S h6 "h  MQ‰


/* M5QC ¡St i<w U% $ &,m R 6 R &wC l ƒ%$‡C Y 
P E ,* ' * K+/2 6 7* U: 7* K+\* 
- U$&,
,+ ” H ` v A&:N2 e C g $m . ," """ " QC H, x!
, ,Y ' R  +52 X w1+ %
 '+ < * h6 k $ E
$ ' 5
:QC  ~ 5 3+ª wC 3Q6  g0 C$j* œm % [6
 C$j . ,2018 :[ M1 NSC Q< i<wQ< +$ ' ;% &
Ug $m  /* i V W B * 7* BN X l: h  6 &,6 M* 6
#Œ/C BE<C H '* L56 *J C :' h‡H ,;% [¸ "R  2 E
ˆ0D 6 7* U ~ g
¹% ®'C `4C Ug $ +! EJ P:C
< * ” Y+  $M~ - x1 E ,B5 l §)< M<
<D< e<0 U\+ j< n 5 LN+ _ ,  & U 
b* Q i€52
3 E !m . " ” K<* ' ;%$ &) •4 Y ' #6 ®+s —  C
œm '
H 4S :M* ‰: K 7* QZ tb* U%&6 &  &
01< H H2  b* UT * `<t R\t 7* ;$ ~ Y\J w12
U\.b* +6 X H+ T # Y / - 4S h‡H ,U$ M1 •* , ;& N
— b* X R l+ L56 , H 4S :M*
% _ BÈ :M*  lC 6 H v
g&' 72 U M e 7* %j* < BNSC 6 Œ/C  0C *m ;%$
<Q4 D+4 U  &< g%$ "  t U C , NS k'2 ;%$¸
j  = E •4 Y ' #6 X .>vj2 UT  A. * P:
`s LH iQ6 ,*J C :' e 7* ” K<* ' *Q' ;%$ &)
+6 X Y / - 4S H2 &* %E ]     &* -
- `4 h  MQ‰  <5: :M A. B
% _ BÈ Q
% v
&, ) x! Ag% f+ 7* E UT  A. 2 E M &+   /
Y&2 NSC Q< i<w i% & h6 E " :M A. X K<NlQ<

265
#$% &'
"!       
  

h6 MH g  Q4 A. & x< E & œm + 1C B H$ l


C
P:+ ]  &:
h $ - 4 B6  &+ H 4S :M* 9%+ R J M
""" * M:* * ;&'C NΠ% 5t6
eš e 7* +&My """ R J M BC k1Q< (
 &:
7* &+&'C  &* h E """ B6 ]  Ž= - c‹ K+ 1 K2 . hj1C N
* & ›&,jC Y&2 K< K+ 1 VS€C """   
:+& UC Q< i<w i% & ” Y&2    C , N <m
*Q f…*  .m   h  MQ‰:+ N R 4 hj[ -
lE \'H BSÈ , * N… - N >0C t& B* MQC B*  g :v6
  U ¢° C œ$6 " """"   ;&+~ C  &* BNSC BC k1*
- (š """   ;&+~ C h &* Bm :K+ 1 - g  * X $%
, :+& B2 ” •4 hj1 ¡È  
 ) ®'C P 7+ &2
%
 , <4 U C € C `<'+ * M:* )* ;& œm al+ h E
i% N <m * & 5 7* Y ' R  >C&2 , N :+&QC
 ) ®'C >+ h E B‡H 7e . X %0E ,BC Q< i<w
:e * . """ ]   h6 ":e •4 Y ' #6 012
h &+ B‡H Bm 5: C  . 
+ h6 B:Q+ ¡€[ #6  C
h6 B `5+ I B6 N :+&QC •4 hj1 C M* h &QE  ” P:+
\'H ,2018 CE6 M[ 7*   ©+% C "VSW ” St% <lC Y&2
:+&* <m * "h: 3s """   ;&+~ X )* P
h6 % 5  X , +F * ' % 1 X w1+ U%
 '+ N
<56 ¡t2 X h H+ T 7+  S * ' n C%6 7* QZ
St% X RS^ 6 7* N <m  * X #$N 1C
&,6 <* - . # a  Q'* µ< Q'* x! X \* kl 6
X H2 T t6 * '* œ H ) C %%6  5?6 wC 7+% 1

266
#$% &'
"!       
  

t&*  & :+/t X D+ _ R\0


 1C6 R' h<0+ ¡t2
n - S2   >? T*6 U H  :™ C  - QM*  *
R  . h6 " :+& :E
n , X #$ S +< 
2 - K b
* ' % 1 X w1+ U%
 '+ N <m * " h:'
R Q< 5: C *6 """ AP:C . Y  :C B $ 7* . """ kQ B<*Π" +F
R  7* K+\* 6 QC +&. Y&+ NSC Q< i<w i%" h:'
*6""" kQ B<*Œ B $ *&'C AP:C Y  7* . \'H B‡H < * ' Y '
. - *<'* +jC lC D ;$ Hm l+ T B<M“ B‡H W %&S 5: C
Eš - B x+š B *Œ R J M h6 """ ]  M c‹ """ "$&S
* M: %&S+  """   .* 7   Y\  3C
Q< 52 E """ '+ H %E  C +4 i% MH ,]  """""
:M  l5 VS€C , C P:< #F 7 X H+ 7* .
B6 .$ N*  """ U ¢° 5: C ,  , M< H+ T MH - 4S<
B[ - NSC •4 hj1 q  UT  ®'C 7+ &C Y+ 7* .
UT  &+&4 C —    #$ S O  R w C `<'
h+ h6 'e  N N:+ B‡H """" " QC ;%1: K+ 1 C U$% 
g :C """%E  X P:+ C :'* i ” B \ T † $ 7* .
c‹ ,” k1 KC M* g‡C )  * ' C : U<'2 X
T """"" QC B \ T BE 7* >tJ . h  X g  * h6 R J
X """ U :+ &2 7* ©: ®'C X H+ B6 L4 >? MH 5 BC P:+
< * ¡È  U :+ & ,  \'H . B6 %E 
E , .P 5 n 2 `5l2 Bm M'C & Q< i<w i%
KC U ?\5 n, " * + 1 C $2 I t6 UT * 7* © ±\C œ$6
~ Š i<wQ< `C  i c 5S n/^ Q: — ^ i
% BQ
m Qs t6 UT * œm H ) C ,"h/ n/^ Q: N
""" B2 ¢°C M:* &, E 51H M:C M 3+6 "BN2 .

267
#$% &'
"!       
  

x< E & e 7* A\ 6 hM C2   A. X g :C


"   MQE = &S Q4 A. X p ,6 A\ 6 K5 `H
7.% R J M p Ž,6 2018/12/27 <wC D ƒ%$m X g :C
›EC `C
p ,Ž4 `5e M+. ,cË  , - ]  Ž, R  T
ˆ g$6 &N+ C œ$6 1 l ( H$ Ž, E , ›%Œb* Ž,
i<w i% ;& N +/*% ›%$ N <m * ' iQ -/~
, '* KQM M* - .%$ 20000 A%& &* D+'2 NSC Q<
3C EPC 7*6 9% , Q'+ h E B6 """ R J n 6 Mm n: 7
” Q'+  EP< 'C  ;&+~ C P: C N<* h E B6  Y\ 
* ¡tJ C N :+&QC •4 hj1 ¡È )* +6 P:+ I B6
B2 ¢°2 } 7 2 , NSC Q< i<w i% <
7* M< S¢ I - 4S  lC X H+ T - 4 h &* B6 +&MQ
N4S µ 1:
% _ ;$ M1C x< E & œ$6 ,R S2 ;%Œ
EP ;%$ i<Z g D J &  4< U  C ]  M 7 ;%$ S
X h E B6 4)* ” œ& ` v VS€C R J M %Œb* t&2 """
7* A%Œb* 7Q+ k,  D lC D œm ;l ( %m x< E &
R ^ Œ :C `<'2 T †6 M< n~ ;%E ` v X (\e
#%Œb* iQ<* iN . B<E* X M) M< (\e¸ <M* iQ
- S2 ” œ& ` v h6 4)* x< E &  ]  M
C : h6 h  MQ‰ :M*  g $m N R 4 6 7* 'C  % em
- e †J M
b+ 'C  &D'+ C gT$ - `^ * E p * '
%2 Q4 eJ  5E U 5v - `^ iN p *Q'  &
x< E & e 7* ” œ& ` v X (\e¸ ( H& R M*m
"f< - ” ­Ns

268
#$% &'
"!       
  

- ]  Ž, R   7.% R J M Ž,6 2019/01/10 <wC


M c‹ ,KQM %Œb* Ž, E ]& l ( H$ Ž, cË  ,
M ¡È . x< E & ” œ$6  ` v C B \ T B6 R J
c‹ , EP C Y&€* $Z MH . *6 EP< >* '+ # ] 
 m ;&+ Eš $\* 5
:QC x< E & œm 5<e Y& B6 ] 
7 R b . B6 """ ;&+wC <' tJ ` v ®'C E """ .
3C EP >* Q'+ B6  )6 """ ,h  +&'2 5 ;%E ;&+~
P:+ !m H 4S R Z - 01+ B6 1996 :
C
H 4 h E B6 Y\ 
Q4 “ I ,- 4S  lC X S, h6 B `5
,&~ - UT *
7 R¹ 2 B\t 7* # x< E & B,e # Rb VS€C
T """"" * h6  )6 ,&~ - UT  ]  M ” P:+  NS
C : & ;&+& ` v )C Y  B6 P: +&*  
 &'C BC B \
f< VS€C hu &^ n~ C + I B6 Tm &+& P +&QE * '
UT  VS€C R J M %Œb Rb
7 ,5 <'+ T &+&~
l
C T f2 p l
C R J M œm MM+ I 'C  ()*
Tm B4N - x! ¯% [ B6 4)* ]  M 2 " partage" E% 1
X RS^ % ‰ - B6 ]  M  )6 ,R J M œm M<
+ I B6
N<’ + D VS€C U l' 7* QZ Q“ h E """  *g\ 
&< Rb
7 ,P:< i M< h\ R J M œm p
%m +
,  
¸ BQ+&2 &'C UT * +6 P:+ I B6 n 6 ]  MQ< x< E
I B6 2018/04/11 ©+% C R 
 & P: +&* h6 x< E & L) 6
&'C * ' C : Y *6 3*&  
 h6 P:2  UT  X <l+ 7+
P:+ I B6 ]  M n 6 ,2018/03/28 ©+% C *g\  X S, h6
M* gm x< E & iQ ,P: +&*  
 &'C UT * +6
A. %, 7* . ]  M h6 R J c°H """ * VS€C KQM KC

269
#$% &'
"!       
  

" les bons de commande " BQ<2 Y& X 'H $E .P UT 
T B6 ]  n 6 , ' L S* œm BN<QC Y&2 *&'C """ * VS€C
M X 3) UT * ±\C R J %Œb* œ$6 """"" QC B \
R J M œm M<
+ h E  U l' %ËJ 7Q) 7* †6 c°H ] 
e 7* M:* `4 % ‰ - P:< 3 ” ½ N, M< h¸
M Bm M<
%6 UT  A. h6 4)* R J M t&2 ,P: +&*
,+&  
 &'C k, ;Q* k52 P: <Q h6 .P 6 7* ] 
, ” 2  Y iN - """"" * - UP ” 2  UT 
* X P:  +‡C x< E & e 7* A% 5tm \'H 2 & B6
'C  C p \ T ” œ& ` v h6 ]  M %Œb* L) 6 ,"""
f2 p h6 >tJ . &EjH +&MQ B2 ¢°C R J M M* iQ
,; C U ¢° x<2 kN .P:+ I UT  )  : B:* ( ) R :
M* &'C n 2 U v$ = Y  &N+ C R J M %Œb* œ$6
U  H ,;& 3 E R J M C B\ h6 4)* .&E6 ” ]  M
C w
T ]& l ( H$ iQ , MH 35< ;/.  D Q4
U Q<* 'C  RSH `H KQM $‡C R &'C n<l ®+'<

b* $ iQ # >tJ p Q< 3l 6 ,x< E &
M %Œb* H% ,M, - C v KQMQ< C: R 'HJ hE X x!
, l5) MQ‰'* l5) t6 5+$j2 L:wC C * M h6 4)* R J
M: RŒ :2 & ]  M 7* + [ ¯ :. 5+$j 4:~ VS€5H
R 4 VS€C , *Q'  & Ugm >
 +‡C R iQ
h‡H KQ
% K+&My 7+Ž= - R J M   7* ? C N
* E B #/ G  h6 E i' 35+ h6 `^ MQ< L:Q+ h 
Q<E h‡H x! 7 \DH ,B*& 7*   ” t¤ ++& l<
U ¢° h6 E - 4 B6 c°+ I M h  M<  '+ I "h &*"

270
#$% &'
"!       
  

lC D MwM:2 +e . g * 9 œm , 5 9 7* Bm Q


 B< 3 $
2017 :
A%Œb* 7* ( ) f2 p h6 E ,nw  /:
T  D
;g 

6 B iQ B: %&S+ I P: H —  C 2018 -  P:
H% , < '   B ^ ‰ fN€  … ·6 e ,
+6 P:+ I """ QC B\ :+ >tJ . h6 4) 6 ]  M %Œb*
+&* MH BSÈ T x< E & e 7* *& ` v h6 UT *
R Q P: +& <
*g\  p ]  Q '+ EP
I ]  M h6 ‰,\* & U 5<l - 35< V St Y& ;g  C
I 2019/01/17 <~ ^ C `l: *j< D U/w4H  C C +
"&+& hM fD+
% 3g (X' 1&-
: )& K41 " •
n: 6 7* x< E & e 7* 'C2 KQM hm ,
"A\ 6 Mm
"A\ 6 E! H Œ :   ¡€<2 ,
kkk :8 TA \4 ~ .&  n€ y,f- 

kkk : £ y,f- 

QD P+'   )v  )- $%&' @ 4L y,f- 


kkk :qA'5 O ‹ & C%A M1
:>? y,f- 

K*& K+ 1 ()* UT  X M \e C Q4 hm ,


   NSC Q< i<w i% N <m * e 7*

271
#$% &'
"!       
  

Q4Q< 35v # ]  M * h 'C .š  † &* . B6 R J M


-  K1 C i* MH  % 5tJ x<2 P - BE% 1* xE
"M,
h& - ; : Q4 & 32 & xC h2 ,
7* qtb* K'+ M, - C v KQMQ< C: R 'HJ h2  :~
" F g :
C M<6
  M , KQM  ‰  % Q4 hm ,
7* 149 146 K<SN< 5e fN€  ‰C M'y .‰ Ì , < '
" :~ h 
" :* D2 hM B<Q4+  S hm ,
"·J - % 5 Q4 3<' ,
:&-' 1 K41 " •
_   <1 µ P `H & U 5<l 3*& , :\[
" p5 B'* K'+
"A\ 6 SN `H KQM $m 35v , : )*
`5l *Q  $ * m - `^ Q+ E 7 2+ ,
# %Ž 7 ®+' C 5 lQ< &*  $ * m - `^ U C'
" Q+~ BH 3552
h2 Q  jlW KC B:C 55 \' 3C v %Ž hm ,
";H*  b ‹ : E xC
$% %& - ®+' Q4 $&s A ~ “ %Ž hm ,
"al: C

272
#$% &'
"!       
  

" :* D2 hM B<Q4+  S hm ,


·J - % 5 $&, ,
n3I _?
.&'C * 365 − 295 − 290 − 286 RSN A\ 6 RSN< 5l2
"ƒ Y a 7* 636 SN
: +%D, &C :< Q4 3Q,
;&, :C x! 7 B5 '* Bm n: 6 7* kkk M ;tbQC
6 7* """ M ;tb* Y&'C ,.%$ 5000 .%& ;H  *? H  5,
B5 '* Bm n:  C 6 7* B2tbQC , M:* B2g C c°2 F
Qs * .%$ 5000 .%& ;H  *? H  5, ;&, :C x! 7
 l ;& N :* D2 M$jC ,·J - % 5 :* D2  S KQM
.%$ 10000 A%& &* D+'2 NS Q< i<w i% ]& `^ C
"·J - % 5 :* D2  S *
C :<' <~ - A\ 6 : M1 Y - ^ %& ”
""" :;$  7* * . NSC &C Q4 C +$   U <~

”3
 @N5 cššš 

273
#$% &'
"!       
  

274
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﻻﺋﺤﺔ ﺑﺄﻫﻢ اﳌﺮاﺟﻊ اﳌﻌﺘﻤﺪة‬


: 5l< &  b - jlW 7E% " : K, f
+ %6 -1
, Q<' 
 <<
,+ΠP:< h  N %$ ," % *
%$
"2014 œ J '5l ,A%E$ 
%
KC #&~ %Ž Y ,6
%$ œm &[ " : &'
) H YE6 -2
"2017 ,+Œ P:< Š' /E ,"   U D+'  P C~
- ®+'  $ " :&£6 &
.C ,n . &5 &£6 š6 -3
,+Œ P:< &' %$ ," g D Y ,6 +P g MN g%ª g)
"2018 ,œ J '5l ,;. 
g/~ h  cš - +&^ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m -4
/Q Q= Y ,6 + g/~ h  U\+&'2 ±&,J 5e ,"+
Y k, M 1m ©+% 2 :* +° ®: Q= Y ,jC % * , +
'5l ,   U%&¸ * /E U%1:* ,  &<w, 2014
"2015 œ J
h  cš - +&^  :~ 
 " :<l &5 n ´m -5
,2003 : 95 % h  C ;%$ S U\+&' ±&,J 5e ,U C'
2004 Y k, M 1m ©+% 2 :* ®: Q= Y ,6 BN g%|C B< <'*
"2010 ,; D #$  U%1:* ,C &<w ,"
- +&^  :~ 
 " : 45 >Q
– <l &5 n ´m -6
Š0 X J i<w Y ,6 BN g) - Š0  :~ h  cš
,   U%&¸ * /E ,  &<w ," +° ®: Q=
"2011 – 2010 œ J '5l

%$ : M\ M C `4<2  %«J" :K, < h ,m -7
T '5e h &C ,U >C Q<'  %$ P ,"h  BN - % *
"P: ©+% 2

275
#$% &'
"!       
  

`Q' V W  :~ h " :#$< ]Q' &C – •5 &Q= -8


"2020 œ J '5l ,U l
,$ [ 5* ,"c š -
U
%& /E* U%1:* , H 4S  -  D Q' -9
<<
,R&' ;%ŒC N'  :~ h b1 ++&QC  :~ ± 4CJ
"2008 ,2 $&'  D U$ MT
*\  U '+P - L4S $ `," : L)<C l -10
"2014 ,/~ , Q<'  %$ U%1:* ," N4S

%$ : N4S &: a l - " : h<
Q h+* -11
"2014 œ J '5l ,   U%&¸ Š' /E U%1:* ," % *
ƒ Œ Q+ X  D U 5l2 " : <t .C K, -12
,h  N %$ U%1:* ," +&^ UT S2 
`+e 7 &Q'
"2015
>
 :~
 N:2 R, +2 " : * ' C :
% -13
" 2018 − * ' C :
MH
%$ : Y '  :~ h  cš " : #$% &'
-14
"2020 œ J '5l ,µ C :*J '5l* ,"  D
,]  g/~ ,"U */ - ]& h  cš" : i* h<
-15
"1964, ;.  ,  ' '5l
a l - ;6 &) f:'<  :~ ~ ' " : &Q= Y\
h\[ -16
,œ J '5l ,+Œ P:< Š' /E ," % * <<s
%$ : ;ËJ
"2018
œm B  &* %Ž 7 ®+' " :k K*6 &Q= & -17
'5l ,;.  ,   U%&¸ * /E ," % *
%$ : v%
"2014 ,œ J

276
#$% &'
"!       
  

œm ;&+~ 7* +&^ R S2 


" : * K, 4H -18
"2011 œ J '5l ,;.  +Œ P:< Š' " ¯C iN

%$ : MC >M1 Q+ " :N<W – &5 7C 7£ &5 -19
X RS^ U 5<l T
 *&* , e6 ," 5l2 % * <j2
, :*J Y<'< C' f+  '*  , :*J Y<' - N<N A%E$ %$
"2008,   + , <' U
%& <E
h  C % * *\
  :~ +P" : ;$ %$  &5 -20
,U >C ,Š' n  %$ , * ' H  <<
, ]  g/~ ," ')
" '5e T ©+% 2 h &C
'+P -  :~ `4 Ugm " : Ä &Q= %$  &5 -21
, Q<'  %$ U%1:* ," % *   ¬% 2
%$ : *\

"2019 ,œ J '5l ,U >C
U%1:* ,"%  ±$, - ®+'  $" : h<4E • -22
"2011 œ J '5l ,i2 ,¡€ n < ÎeJ QZ
c w: '5l* ," g D Y *6 H 4S " :Ã+: /+/' &5 -23
"2008, g D5 %& ,;&+&~
,/~ *. %$ ," V W U C' h  " :]\ Π&w &5 -24
"2006 ,   '5l
<Q* ;E* ," 3J 5[ X  Q+ " :;%
µ  -25
,/~ ;C Žt &Q= '*  ,a^ - 
 ;$ M[  U D* 7*
"2014/2013 '* ~ 

Y\  - >5' `, ;g
m" : #Ë & &'
7C 7£ &5 -26
, +$' ,g D< — ' &M' ,>  <, •Q2 4C ," #$'
"1431
: ]& h  cš - / " : #%M: &£6 aŒ &5 -27
"1966 ,;.  C' DM: %$ ,R J g/~ ," Y BC Y/ +‰

277
#$% &'
"!       
  

%$ ," V W  : U C' h  cš" : %  &5 +ŒH -28
"2012 ,   '5l ,;.  , C' DM:
,'* ~ P: /E* ," Y '  :~ h " : >S ƒH -29
"2006 ,i2
+&2 5l g ltJ " :5' '1* 7C &Q= 7C L  -30
$ S h  5* ," 5l2
%$ : #$' Y ‰: - M: ®+'
"2019 œ J '5l ,  +
- ;g N /Q U ** 
* " :#.~ &, &5 RE -31
<Q'
% U ª &  ; W +l <' : ; * 4 R 6 g$6
'5l ,;.  ,   U%&¸ * /E ," :M R J !Q:
"2015 œ J
%& ,"U C' h  - * ' Y ,J cš" : &' * E -32
"2002 œ J '5l ,h ,+Œ P:< H  %$  & Q<'
U 5v -   5  P* &* " : c – &5 #b -33
 :~ @N 7* &Q ]  &  P* w, , :~
/E* ," % *
%$ :  :~ U 5v - US ;%S w, *
"2018 œ J '5l ,+Œ P:< C' U
%&
U */ h  g) - U */ +‰ " :#C/ h*j* -34
U >C ,   '5l ,U */ %$ S* : R J g/~ ," Š0 $'
"1982
%$ ,"Y '  :U C' h  cš " :* C6 EŒ &Q= -35
"1986 , +%&:
T , '* ~ U 5l
 P U 'H Y ‰ - ˆ
 " : hŒN ¯C 7C &Q= -36
'5l ,  + ,$ S h  5* ,N: :   g/~ ," #$'
"2009 ,œ J

278
#$% &'
"!       
  

H  %$ ,"  :~  b -  N jlW" :p $ £ &Q= -37
"2005 œ J '5l ,h ,+Œ P:<
Q+ 7 /~  b " :] 51 , &5 a 4
m g * -38
hj1C 2012 : 5 % Y
Q< 5e   
 C  
RS^ R
T *&* , e6 ," U *<' :2  4H * h 
<E ,;&4 C' U% * '*  ,Y ' h  - >  %$ X
"2018 ,h 
   S2 N… " :#&' 
 fS &+b* -39
"2016 ,/~ ,` v< N6 P ,"¯C i+ N * -
%$ :  
," 3J *&€ O
J  " : l' C6 &Q= #&Z -40
"2000 ,;.  ,n
^ Y<' C' 5
," n!  Ç\5   " : . #&Z kNlS* -41
"2019 œ J '5l ,;.  +Œ P:< $Q= %$
7 ƒH " : &Q= % 2 &:HE – # '5 &£6 Žt &Z -42
,+Œ P:< Š' /E ," % *
%$ : /~  & - M
"2017 œ J '5l
/E ," ;6 &) #:' f:' Q+ " : &[% kNlS* h N+* -43
"2016 ,œ J '5l ,;.  ,   U%&¸ *
h  - V €[J X ' ~ " :45 <t c &_ -44
"2009 œ J '5l ,h$%J ,+Œ P:< gvm %$ ,"Æ% * U C'
P:< $Q= %$ ," ®+'  $ " : #5 */ &Q= -45
"2017 œ J '5l ,+Œ
," V W  : U C' h  cš " ::, w $Q= -46
,;.  , 'C '5l , C' DM: %$ , '+P U\+&' tu H
"2012

279
#$% &'
"!       
  

Y<' %$ ,"Y '  :~ h  - /" : ] £% %S:* -47
"2006 , C : ,+ΠP:<
U 5v - +&^ Q<' 
  P*" :#$Q= &p % -48
- Y<' A%E$ %$ : *&* , e6 ," <<s
%$ :  :~

 , 
 Y<' a^ <E ,ŽW ƒ ^ 1 :2 C '*  ,a^
"2018 −2017 '* ~
7 >5' +4C
 ~" :#&5' .C a% e R -49
"2008 ,œ J '5l ,h ,+Œ P:< &* ^ %$ ," N
h  - B: ®+' #:' %Ž" : K*&£ K, 7Q. -50
P:< Š' /E ," % * <<s
%$ : h%  #%$ g D
"2018 œ J '5l ,+Œ

280
#$% &'
"!       
  

‫ﺍﻟﻔﻬﺮﺱ‬
9 ............................................................................................................... 1

9 ..................................................... H 4S +, >5' #6 +, : T 6


'Q - `^ >5' +, KC Y&l : ]    :  v
10 .............................................................................................. *

14 ......................................... *\
 '+P -    :  v
16 .................... Š0 +P -   ~ * ' Y ,J : 'C%
17 ..........................    - *Q'  & * m − 1
21 ..................................................    - U 5v − 2

25 ........    - M*$ 2 *Q'  & µ


− 3
29 ........................................................................ >? )/G : P I (,Q

31 .......................... :<' `s 


 Q+ h E%6 : R J 45
32 ..............................................................  Q+ h E%6 :R J <l
32 .....................................................  4:~ #$  7E : œ J ;N
32 ............ K'* ¡€1 $ :
 6 g $ 'H - Q+ *m µ 1 : T 6

32 ............................................................................. $ :
 6 g $ 'H : 1
34 ..........................................................................   ¡€1 K'2 : 2
BHPC i 6 Bm U&:
6 7* n  †j[ 7* ;$&=  ' :  v
37 ............................................................................................. A% 5  6

37 .................................................................... ;$&=  ' h2 h6 : 1

281
#$% &'
"!       
  

BHPC i 6 Bm U&:


6 7* n   ' hj[ 7* h+ h6 : 2
40 ................................................................................................ A% 5  6

43 .................................................................. $ :
 'H - :<' `s :  v
45 ................................................  4: - #:' 7E :   ;N
46 ......................................................................................  :~ &S : T 6

48 ................................  Q+~  :~ &S - g D U 5l2 :  v


50 .................  Q+ - \' ” `42  
 : ]  <l
Q+ N:2 - +&^   
 R'
 : œ J ;N
51 ..................................................................................... 

51 ................................. ¯C i+ H    *  : T 6

51 .................   n 2%T St R Z ¯C i+ N * : 1

56 .... ¯C i+ N * X  Q+~  D U 5l ®'C : 2


56 ............................... 3/C &C Q4 7 %$  , − 6
58 ............................. +$ EjC &C Q4 7 %$  , − n
60 ......................... f
wC &C Q4 7 %$  , −ƒ
61 ................................................................. n 2 `5l2  :  v

63 ....................................................    `+e 7  :  v


67 ....................................................... ]  &+  l
C  : 'C%
69 ..............  Q+ N:2 - 
\ 
 R'
 :   ;N
70 .......................................................... 'N 6 R `+e 7  :T 6

282
#$% &'
"!       
  

71 ...................................................................... C  `+e 7  :  v


74 ................................................................................ f2 p  :  v

79 ................................................................ %Ž  C' :]  45


81 .............................................................  Q+ C : R J <l
81 ................................................................................... *0 : œ J ;N
h b1 g%ΠU *^ g
¹% R & g
¹%  C : T 6
82 ..................................................................... 5:J R &< % W

g%Œ Q‰: U ²p U 


b œm B  C :  v
82 ............................................................................ K*Q' KN…

 J K<S: 6 K
*<C& K<Q `, -  C :  v
84 ............................................... x< \ & KC &: 6 7+&Q'

85 ............................................................... $HJ `, -  C : 'C%


G  ^ P , w, 6 (5l f2 :   ;N
87 ................................................................................... $ C

87 .......................................... ]   w, 6 (5l f2 : T 6

91 .................................................................... $ C %$ S ^ P :  v


93 ..........................................  :~ h  -  U C :   ;N
93 ..................... < ;ËJ $H6 &,6 6 &M' — ,x< &)  : T 6
94 .................................................. M: 5C ;6 &)  C :  v
97 .......................  Q+ 7 2 : %Ž 7 ®+' : ]  <l
97 ............................... A+&2 NE ®+' a 4
 µ š : œ J ;N

283
#$% &'
"!       
  

98 .................................................................. ®+' a 4


 µ š : T 6

99 .............................................................................................jlW – 1

101 ......................................................................................... %Ž – 2

104 ............................................................................ 55 \' − 3


105 ......................................................... %Ž 7 ®+' Â<5* +&2 :  v

7 ®+'  &C  W tJ Y ,J ®'C R, :   ;N


110 ................................................................................... %Ž

110 ............... %Ž 7 ®+' C 5 l - `^ p 7+ V €[J : T 6


114 ...... ®+' C 5 l  $ .&) Y 2 h6 7Q+ 7+ V €[J :  v
115 .............................................. ®+'  $ - •4 V St :  v

117 ............................................................. %& @A )/G : ;E (,Q

119 ............................................................  Q+ . * : R J 45


119 ........................................ BC B51+  A/y  f+'2 : R J <l

119 ........................................................................ f+'2 : œ J ;N

119 ........................................................................ 0< -  f+'2 : T 6


120 ............................................................... c\l -  f+'2 :  v

123 ...........................................................  7  /y :   ;N


125 ..........................................................................  (6 : ]  <l

125 .........................................................................:<'  : œ J ;N

129 ................................................................... :<' >?  :   ;N

284
#$% &'
"!       
  

133 ...................................... :<'  Q+ C h E%6 : ]  45


133 ..................................................:<'  Q+ h E%6 : R J <l
133 .......................................................................... #$  7E : œ J ;N

' #6 5 7QD2 T c& 6 >s ;% 5 6 7 [ >5'2 $ :


m : T 6
134 .................................................................................................. :'*

137 ................................... K'* ¡€1 M*  U% 5 h2 h6 :  v


138 .......................................................................... :<  h+ h6 :  v

144 ........................................................................ #:' 7E :   ;N


146 ...................................................:<'  Q+ C : ]  <l
`<' 88"13 % h  - :<'  Q+ C : œ J ;N
147 .................................................................. P: H 4S C

g
¹% K*Q' KN… g D g  R % `, -  :T 6
147 ............. Q‰:* ². 6 M* MQC M*  g :v6 *Q' ; R % 6

h b1 g%ΠU *^ g


¹% R & g
¹ B  :  v
147 .................................................................... 5:J R &< % W

KN… g%Œ Q‰: U ²p U 


b `, -  :  v
148 ......................................................................................... K*Q'

7+&Q'  J K<S: 6 K


*<C& K<Q 
: 'C%
149 .............................................................x< \ & KC &: 6

149 ....................................................................... $H¤ B  : * t

15 ............  :~ h  - M<  ' :<'  UT , :   ;N

285
#$% &'
"!       
  

150 ................ B2Ë6 $H6 &,6 6 x< ¡€[ &) B  C : T 6
153 .................................... M: 5C ;6 &) 2  C :  v
155 ............................................................................................................ y t
  - ;%$ S  D U% Y ,J 7*  5C `4<*
157 ....................................................................................................... 

275 ......................................................................... ;&Q'  .jC 4T


281 ....................................................................................................... 9MN

286

You might also like