ME)KJlYHAPOJlHbII1 KOHrPECC nCI1XOJIOrOB B AMEPHKE

(1-7 CeHT516p511929 r.)

A. P. JIypUfl

Me)!{)I.YHapa)I.HbIH xonrpecc no nCHXaJIarHH B HbIO-X3BeHe non-

raTaBJI51JIC51)I.aJITa. Euie sa ron 6bIJIH rosno YCTaHaBJI'eHbl cpoxn H
MeCTa, H orpoxaoe l.fHCJIa HCCJIe)I.aBaTeJIbCKHXYl.fpe[)!{)I,eHHH H aT)I,eJIb-
HbIX nCHXOJIaraB naJIYl.fHJIH npHrJIaWeHH51. 3Ta 6bIJI nepasnt xonrpecc,
YCTpoeHHbIH B AMep'I1Ke (see socexs nepnux MHpaBblx xonrpeccos
no nCHXOJrarHH 6bIJIH B Esponey--a aMepHKaHCKa51 nCHXaJIarHl.feCKa51
aCOO~Ha'l(H51rrocrapanacs, l.fTa6 3TOT xonrpecc CTaJI caMbIM 60JIbWHM
no KOJIHl.feCTBY;Yl.faCtHHKOB, KaJIH1IeCTBY C.lI:eJIaHHbIX )I,OKJIa)I,OH, saxe-
HOCTH 3aTpoHY;TbIX npo6neM.
3TO oeccnopao Y)I,aJIaCb opranaaaropaa ci.eana, H xapaxrepn-
3YIOIII.I1e xonrpecc ~I1(PPbI aCTaBJI51IOT)I,aJIeKO aa c06aH CTaTHCTHKY
scex npeaorax nCHXOJIOrHl.feCKHX xonrpeccos: 1 050 tIJIerHaB npHHHMaJIH
B HeM Yl.faCTHe; OKOJIO )I,ByxcaT H3 HHX npO)I,eJIaJIH )I,OBOJIbHO )I,JIH-
rensnoe nyreurecrmre, H aa TOBapI1Iu.eCKHX scrpesax BO ,lI.Bape Hens-
cxoro YHHBepCHTeTa MO)!{HO 6bIJIO BCIO He,ll.eJIIO xonrpecca Ha6JIIO)I,aTb
O)!{HBJIeHHble 6eCe)I,bI WBe'H~apCKHX nCHXOJIOrOB C 5lnOHCKHMH, CO-
BeTCKHX Y1IeHbIX C nCHXaJIOraMH, npaexasunora HS I1H,lI.HH H KI1.Ta51;
6bIJIH npe)I,CTaBJIeHbI nCHXOHeBpaJIOrH I3paSHJIHH H HOBOH 3eJIaH-
]J.HH, WBeH~apHH H I1TaJIHH, KaHa)I,bI IIi Hcrramta. JlBa)I,~aTb socexs
CTpaH npHCJIaJIH CBOHX )I,eJIeraTaB, H 450 )I,OKJIa)I,OB6bIJIO sacayurano
na SaCe)I,aHH51X aroro orponaoro H HHTeHCHBHO pa60TaBWerO, He-
CMaTp51 aa HCKJIIOl.fHTeJIbHYIO)!{apy, xonrpecca.
O)I,HO nepexacnenae 'ceK~HH, nOCB51llJ,eHHbIXOT)I,eJIbHbIM npa6JIe-'
MaM cospeaeaaoa nCHXOJIOrHH, 3aH51JIO 6bI )I,JIHHHbIH CTIHCOK; 3)I,eCb
6bIJIH 3aCe)I,aHH51, rrocaamennue nCHXaJIarHH )!{HBaTHblX H npHKJIa)I,-
HOH ncnxooormr, reoperacrecnoa H 3KCne'PHM'eHTa'JIbHOH nCHIXOJIOI'HH
H H3Yl.feHHIO xapaxrepa, HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIbHbIM TeCTaM H np06JIeMe MbIW-
JIeHH51, Ca~HaJIbHOH H cpaBHHTeJIbHOH nCHXaJIOrHH, np06JIeMe JIiI1l.f-
HaCTH H MOTHBOB, nCI1XaraJIbBaHHl.feCKoMY perpnexcy H H3Yl.feHl!1.l0
)I,BH)!{eHH51 rnaa npa l.fTeHHH. nCI1XaJIarH caxux pa3JIHl.fHbIX CTpaH

6*
81 A.P.J[YPH5J

.lI,aJIH snecs pe3YJIbTaTbI CBOI1X I1CCJIe.ll,OBaHI1H,11 pacnasuraacs aa

p5IA TeMaTI14eCKI1X CI1Mn0311YMOBCbe3.l1, npe.ll,CTaBJIHJI .lI,eHCTBI1TeJIbHO
xouraoe spenmue Me)!(.lI,YHapO.ll,HOHHaY4HOH xoonepauaa.
GOBeTCKa5I,lLeJIerail1.l15I
1 rrpaexana B HbIO-tlOPK aa HeCKOJIbKO.lI,HeH
.lI,O OTKpbITI1H KOHrpeCCa 11 I1MeJIa .lI,OCTaT04HO BpeMeHI1, 4T06bI CO-
CTaBHThCe6e npeztcraaneuae 0 TOM 06lll.eM tpoae, aa I<OTOPOMnpo-
TeKaJIa BCH paoora Cbe3,ZI,a.
B .aKa.ll,eMI14eCKOH )!(H3HI1 <lMepI1KaHCKOrO YHI1BepCI1TeTa ncaxo-
JIOrl1H 3aHI1MaeT 04eHb 3Ha411TeJIbHOe MeCTO; ee paCCMaTpl1BaIOT KaK
,lLI1CH,l1nJIHHY,.lI,aIOlll.YIO 06lll.YIO rrO.ll,rOTOBKY HapH.lI,Y C 6110JI0fl1eH,
<p113110JI0fl1eH,COl1.I10JI0fl1eH;C npyron CTOPOHbI-Ha aee CMOTP5ITKaK
na rrpaKTI14eCKYIO HaYKY, HenOCpe.ll,CTBeHHO CBH3aHHYIO C aana-raxa
BOCllI1TaHI15I. 3TO onpeneaaer cosepureaao cneuadiauecxoe rrOJIO)Ke-
uae rrCI1XOJIOfl1H B Axepaxe: oaa pa36HTa na .lI,Ba OT.lI,eJIbHbIX Mac-
CHBa, J{a)K.lI,bIHH3 KOTOPbIX 3aHHMaeT B aMepHKaHCKOH HaYKe H )K113HI1
3Ha411TeJIbHOe MeCTO, HO 06a H30JII1pOBaHbI zrpyr OT npyra, senyr
He3aBI1CHMOe cyurecrsoaanne H xapaK'I'epI13YIOTCH BrrOJIHe caMOCTOSI-
l1eJIbHbIM pa3BI1TUeM. [1CHXOJIOrHH, KaK CPI1JIOColcpcKaHHaYKa (npa
TOM caMOM lllHPOKOM 'rrOHHMaHI1I1 CPHJIOCOCPI1H,
xaxoe npWIHHTO 11
B repMaHCKI1X YHI1BepCHTeTa:x), BKJII04a,eT B CBOH COCTaB ace JIa6o-
paropao-reoperasecxae H3bICKaHHHnaz; )KI1BOTHbIMH11JIIO.lI,bMH;neaa-
rornuecxas rrCHXOJIOfl1HCTaBHT CBoeH sanasea 06JIer4aTb 11 pauao-
HaJIH3HpOBaTb npouecc BocnHTaHH5I, BHOCH B Hero sees TOT KOMrrJIeKC
npaeaos TeCTl1pOBaHI1H }[ npaKTI14eCKOro H3Mepe'HI1H HHTeJIJIeKTa,
KOTOPbIfI Y Hac BKJII04aeTCH B nporpaMMbI ne.ll.OJIOrl14eCKHX 06cJIe-
.lI,OBaHI1H; npa OTCYTCTBHI1 nenoaoraa KaK Cne!l1.l1aJI'bHO'H
,njIiCll.l1nJI'H-
HbI-BeCb 3TOT KOMnJIeKC sonpocos COCTaBJI5IeT B AMepI1Ke< npo-
rpaavy nenaroravecxoa nCI1XOJIOfl1H.
3TH .lI,Ba cexropa HBJI5IIOTCSIOCHOBHbIMIf M0lll.HbIMIi MaCCI1BaMI1
aMepl1KaHCKOH rrCI1XOJIOrI1H; nepaua H3 HHX C03.l1.aJIpSI.lI,Cnel1.HaJIbHbIX
TeOpeTI14eCKHX HaCTpOeHI1H (3TO CJIOBO nonxoznrr K aMepHKaHCKOH
nayxe 60JIbllle, 4eM CJIOBO«Te4eHHe»), H B n~pBYIO 04epe.ll.b-6 H x 3-
B 110 P 113 M; BTOPOH pa3BI1JI He06bI4aHHYIO no CBoeH OpraHI130BaH-'
HOCTH H CBoeMY Ma'ClllT3I6y pa60TY no nCHXOJIOr.!1,4eCK'HM .113-
M e p e H 1151M, OXBaTI1Bllll1M TbICH411 lllKOJI H .lI.eCHTKH Ba)KHeHlllHX
rrCHXOJIOrH4eCKHX 06JIaCTeH. 11 O.ll.HaKO3TIi zraa MaCCHBa CYlll.eCTBYIOT
B AMepHKe 6e3 BC5IKOrO n04TH KOHTaKTa '.lI.pyr C npyroa, 4aCTO HrHO-
pHpyH B3aHMHoe" CYlll.eCTBOBaHHe. B Hsro-Hopxe, aa 120-H YJIIil1.e, aa
Teppl1TOpHH KOJIYM6HHCKoro YHHBepCHTen, CTOHT .lI,Ba 3.l1,aHHH:[1CI1-
.XOJIOrH4eCKHH HHCTHTYT C ero I1HTepeCHbIMH JIa60paTOpH5IMHI rro

1 B ee cocras BXOilIiJlIi: I1. Hi Lll n a a s p e a a, B. M. 50pOBCKH", C. r.

I' e JI JI e p ill T e j;j H H A. P. JI Y P H s.
 ME)f(.D.YHAPO.D.HbJP! KOHrPECC nCHXOJlorOB 85

06~eii:, npHKJIa)I:HO'ii: H CpaBHHTeJIbHoii: nCHXO'JIOrHH H Teacher's col-

lege-c. 3HaMeHIiTbIMH pa60TaMH Top H ,Ua ii: K a no nCHXOJIOrHqe-
CKHM H3MepeHH5!M, 60raTbIMH TeCTOJIOrHqeCKHMH H. nelI.arOrHqeCKHM!H
HCCJIe.lI.OBaHH;5!M,H.
3.lI.aHH5! CT05!T .lI.pyr nporns zipyr-a, H H3 OKOH
O.lI.HOrO BH.lI.HbI OKHa zrpyroro: HO pa60THHKH nCHXOJIorHqeCKOrO
HHcTHTyra HaBp5!.lI. JIll xorzta 3arJI5!.lI.bIBalOT B Teacher's college, KOTO-
PbIii: no H{C MHeHHlO 3aHHMaeTC5! npUKJIa.lI.HbIMH TeCTaMH, a He HaCT05l-
me'ii: nCHXOJIOme'ii:; pa60THHKlI Teacher's college OOBCe'MHe mrrepe-
CYlOTC5I TeM, qTO npOHCXO,UHT B nCHX'OJIOrHqeCKOM HHcTHTyTe, 3aHH-
MalOlll.eMC5I sonpocaaa He-)!{H3HeHHbIMH, qJl1JIOCOCPCKHMH,
a6CTpaKT-
HbIMH. Me)!{.lI.Y 060HMH cexropava-vpeaxaa rpaunua, H MHe npHXO-
.lI.HJIOCb BH.lI.eTb 3T)' rpaHHU;y BO scex YHHBepCHTeTaX (J.1eJIbC~OM,
rapBa.lI.CKOM, npHHCTOHCKOM), C nCHXOJIOmqeCKHMlf HCCJIe,ZI:OBaHH5IMH
KOTOPbIX MHe npHllIJIOCb 3HaKOMHTbC5!: Psychology H Educational
psychology BXO.lI.51TB pasnue CHCTeMbI .lI.HCU;HnJIHH,pa3BHBalOT CBOH
MeTO.lI.bI, pacryr He3aBHCI1MO zrpyr OT .apyra.
51 He CKa3aJI 6bI, qTO aMepHKaHCKHe nCHXOJIOrHqeCKHe HHCTHTY-
TbI (BXO.lI.51lll.He B COCTaB CPHJIOcocpCKoro HJIH aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOrO
IJ;HKJia .lI.HCU;HnJIHH) He HMelOT csoero JIHu;a. MHe npmUJIOCb 6bITb
B u;eJIOM P5!.lI.e TaKHX HHCTHTYTOB, H TO ooiuee, qTO 51 suaec H3 3THX
noceurenajr, YKJIa,ll,bIBa'eTc5IB H3BecTHYlO KapfJ'HHY, HeCOMHemIO xapax-
'repuyio .lI.JI5I opraHH3aU;HH aMepHKaHcKoii: nCHXOJIOrHH HHCTI1TYTOB.
Ilpescae BcenQl-3Haql'rreJIbHa'51 qaCTb 3THX HHCTHTYTOB HeCOMHeHHO
npoHHKHYT3 nacrpoennew 6HX3BHOpI13Ma. 51 He pellIHJIC5I ObI rosoprrn.
06 aMepHKaticKoM OHX3BHOpJ13Me, KaK 0 llIKOJI'e, KaK 0' HanpaBJIe'HHH;
Y 6HX3BHopH3Ma reneps HeT caoero oprannsauaoauoro uearrpa,
csoero U;eHrpaJIbHOfO MeTO.lI.a, CBoeR 3aMKHYTaH H O.lI.HOP0.I/..Hoi1:
CH-
CTeMbI H H.lI.eii:; ysensre, csnrarounre ,ce651 6HX3BHopHCTaMH., B KOH-
KpeTHbIX HCCJIe.lI.OBaHH5!XfOBOP5!T na pa3HbIX 5!3bIKaX, npanepxor-
BalOTC5I pa3HbIX CPHJIOCOCPCKHX
B3fJI5I.lI.OB, BH.lI.51Tnepe.n nCHXOJIOfHeii:
pasaue sana-m. YOTCOHa (Watson), XeHTepa (Hunter), Beii:/c-
C a (Weiss) H 313 1lI JIH (Lasch ley), KOHeqHO, HH npa KaKHX YCJIOBH5IX
HeJIb35! npHqHCJIHTb K O.lI.HOMYTeqeHHlO. ECJIH qTO 06be.ll.HH5!eT HX-
3TO He llIKOJIa, a 06JIaCTb HCCJIe.lI.OBaHH5IH HCCJIe.lI.OBaTeJIbCKHena-
CTpOeHH5I. B OCHOBe pa60T Ka)!{.lI.OfO H3 HHX JIe)!{HT COrJIaCHe B TOM,
qTO He C03HaHHe H cy6beKTHBHbIii: MHP, a' noseneane 5!BJI5!eTC5Inpen-
MeTOM HCCJfe)l:OBaHH5! .ll.JI5! nCHXOJIOfa. K 3TOMY sneumeay nose-
.ll:eHHlO OH MO)!{eT. nO,UXO,UHTbC JIlo6bIMH MeTo,UaMH, nepeuocs crena
H OnbIT 300nCHXOJIOfHH, H MaTepHaJIbI crapux nCHXOJIOfHqeCKHX
HCCJIe.lI.OBaHHii:,nOCKOJIbKY OHH HMeJIH .lI.eJIO H C 06beKTHBHoii: CTO-
POHOii: nOBe,UeHH5! (cp. «BbIpa3HTeJIbHa51 MeTO,UHKa» By H,U T a). Ilpa
scex 3TOM-OH .ll.OJI)!{eH OCTaBaTbC5I HCCJIe.lI.OBaTeJleM nOBe.ll.eHH5I,
06beKTHBHbIX peaKUjHM q'eJIOBe'Ka, YCJIOBHii:, orrpenensnoumx HX pas-
86 A. P. JIYPlffl

BHTHe" BOCrrHTaHHe, YCTaHOBJIeHH5IHaBbIKOB, rrOCT05IHHbIX «CTaHAapT-

HbIX)) peaKIJ,HH: opraaaaaa (reaction pattern). Bee 3TO He C03AaeT
HarrpaBJFeHH5I(H60 3AeCb euie ner 0611J,HOCTlIB P a 3 P e III e H H H arax
sanas), HO onpeneaser Kpyr, 06JIaCTb HCCJIe.lIJOiBaHHH,
11 aror Kpyr
HCCJIe)l.OBaHHH:MbI acrpesaex B 3HaqHTeJIbHOM q11CJIe aMepHKaHCKHX
nC11XOJIOr11qeCKHX
HHCTHTYTOB. HH O)I.HH H3 HHX He HBJIHeTCH HHCTH-
ryTOM, lJ,eJIHKOMCTOHIIJ,HMaa n03HIJ,HHX KaKOH:-HH6Y)I.bIllKOJIbI;
, «)I.eMO- ,

KpaTH3M)) aMepHKaHCKHX nayuaux yqpe)K)I.eHHH: qallJ,e scero CBO)l.HTCH

K HaHBHOMY nOJIO)KeHHIO, qTO HaYKa )I.OJI)KHa HBJIHTbCH CHCTeMOH:
nOJIO)KI1TeJIbHbIX 3MrrHpHqeCKHX 3HaHHH:, B KOTOPbIX npanuanaans-
nue, CPHJIOcocpCKaeYCTa'HOBKH BHlOCHT JIlIIllb Bp!e'.lI;'HbrAarrpaopaae:
orpoxace 61~bIllHHCTBO aMepilfKaHCKHX nC'lfXOJI'Of'OB-i1'C'CJIe)I.OBaTeJIei
CqHT·aIOT ce6H «CBo60)I;HbIM'Hl) 01' KaKOr,o-JFH6o,onpenexenaoro CPHJIO-
corpcxoro B3fJIHACl', OT npHHa'AJI'e)KHOCT11K KaKOMY-H116Y)l.b nCH'XOJIO-
rHQeCKOMY HarrpaBJIeHHIO,-H B aMep11KaHCKHX 11HCT11ryTaX MO)KHO
HaH:TH rrpe)I.CTaBHTeJIeH:COBepIlleHHO pa3JI11qHbIX YCTaHOBOK11'nacrpoe-
HHH; O)l.HaKO-B 60JIbIlIHHCTBe lI3 HHX npoi6JFeMbI nO~Be:AeHHHC1'OH1'
B OCHOBe pa60TbI; ana-nrrem.naa qaCTb pa60THHKOB (qTO oc06eHHO
xapaxrepno )I.JIH aMepHKaHCKHX HCCJIe)I.OBaTeJIeH:) rrpOBO)l.HT CBOH
pa60TbI O)I.HOBpeMeHHOH na qeJIOBeKe H aa )KHBOTHbIX; JIy.•.•
IlIHe axe-
pHKaHCKHe HCCJIe)I.OBaHHH(nanp. pa60TbI no HaBbIKaM JI3IlIJIH 11 XeH-
Tepa) 6bIJI11rronyxenu HMeHHO TaKHM MeTO)I.OM,npa K01'OPOM rpaanuu
300nCHXOJIIOrHH 11 nCHXOJIOr'J11H
qeJIOBeKa CrJIa)KHBaIOTCH,H ncnxocrorna
nepepacraer B 06IIJ,yIO nayxy 06 06'beKTHBHbIX MexaHH3Max nose-
AeHH5I.
PH.ll.OM C 3THM MaCCHBOM pa601', 4HC1'O HCCJIe.ll.OBaTeJIbCKHX,
reo-
peTHqeCKHX B CBOHX OCHOBax, CTOHIIJ,HXaa rpanane nCHXOJIOrH'H:H
6HOJFOrH4eCKHx HaYK,-c He06blqaH:HOH: opraHH30BaHHocTbIO pa3BHJICH
H BTOpOH: orpoxaua MaCCHB aaepasaacxax nCHXOJIOrH~eCKHX HCCJIe-
AOBaHHH, C1'OJIb»ce xapaxrepaun AJIH aMepHKaHCKOH:npaKTHKH, CKOJI:b-
KO nepsun xapaxrepen AJIH axepaxaucxon reopaa,
IlCHXOJIOrHH He06blqaH:HO IlIHPOKO 3aXBaTHJIa B AMepHKe pHA
npaKTHqeCKHX, nenaroranecxnx 06JIaCTeH:. Ka)KAa51 IllKOJIa rrbITae1'C51
paIJ,HOHaJIH3HpOBaTb, nCHXOJIOmqeCKM oriocaoaars CBOH: nezarorase-
CKHH npouecc: aasonu nexoropsrx IlITaTOB (nanp. MaCCaqY3eTc) npen-
nHChIBaIOT BbI)I.eJI51Tbocooue rpyrrriu )I.JIH yqeHHKOB, np05lBJI51IOIIJ,HX
onpeAeJIeHHYIO crerreas OTCTaJIOCTH, nepexO)I.51IlJ,YIO qepe3 YCTaHoB-
neaasre )l.JI51 HHTeJIJIeKryaJIbHOH: HOPMbI rpanauu. 3TO orrpezreaaer
He06xo)I.HMOCTb nCHXOJIOrHqeCKOrO 06CJIe)I.OBaHHHBO BCeH:cera III KOJI,
H HaAO 3aMe1'H1'b, qTO TaKa51 panora oprauaaoeaaa B AMepHKe HC-
KJIIOqHTeJIbHO xopouro. HeCKOJIbKO JIeT TOMy Ha3a)I., xorzta 3TO )l.BH-
)KeHHe 6bIJIO eure nHOHepCKHM,-3a)I.aqH npOH3BO)I.H1'b TaKHe 06cJIe-
.ll.OBaHH516bIJIH nopysenu CnelJ,HaJIbHbIM <<flepe.ll.BH)KHbIMKJIHHHKaM)),
 Mf;/KD,YHAPOD,HbIU KOHrPECC T1CI1XOJlorOB 87

'e3.l1.HBIllHMH3 ropo.aa B ropon H npOH3BO.ll.HBIllHM HHTeJIJIeKryaJIbHOe

oocaenosanae .lI.eTe'HCOi()lTBeTCTBYIOIIr;HX
urxoor, B Te'IeHHe' nOCJIe.n:;iHlX
,JIeT nOJIO)l{eHHe H3MeHHJIOCb,H nO'ITH npa Ka)l{.lI.OHIllKOJIe H Ka)l{.lI.OM
.lI.eTCKOM yspeacnenan cyurecrsyer «nCHXOJIOr», aa .lI.OJIe xoroporo
.JIe)l{HT TeCTHpOBaHHe ncex jI.eTeH, onpeneaeuae HX YMCTBeHHoro
YPOBH5I, IllKOJIbHOH npHrO.ll.HOCTH H T. n.
COBepIlleHHO nOH5ITHO, 'ITO TaKHe IllHpOKHe aanaxa lIOTpe60BaJIH
H cepsesaoro HaY'IHOrO 060CHOBaHH5I np06JIeMbI n CH X 0 JI 0 r H 'I e-
CK H X H 3 M e P e H HH, iIf M'O)l{HOCKa3aTb, 'ITO HILr.ll.e sra rrporineaa He
naurna TaI{KX IllHPOKHX CPOPMyrJIy6JIe'fLHOH pa3pa60TK.H, KaK B aMepH-
KaHCKOH nenarornsecxon nCHXOJIOrILIL nOCJIe pa60T Top H .lI.a 'HK a
M'O)l{HO cxaaam., 'ITO aMepHl<:aHCKa5IrrCIiXOJlOrH5I B 3Ha'IHTeJIbHOHCBO-
eH 'IaCTH 5IBJI5IeTC5I H3M'ep5IIO~le'iI nCHx'OJIOrneH. Heotiu-
'IaHHO TOHKHe MeTO.ll.bI Ii3MepeHH5I nCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHX CPYHKlI,HH,IHX
nO.ll.p06HblH H TO'IHbIH MaTeMaTH'IeCKHH aHaJIH3, npaxeaenae crannap-
TH30BaHHblX TeCTOB aa orpoxmoa MaTepIfaJIe H nrapoxoe HCnOJIb30Ba-
HHe KOppeJIaTHBHOro H3Y'IeHH5I nCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHX npOll,eCCOB,-BOT
'ITO CTaJIO OCHOBHbIMH Cnell,HcpH'IeCKHM.lI.JI5Isroro lI,HKJIa avepaxan-
,CKHX HCCJIe.ll.OBaHIiH.113Mep5IIO~a5I nCHXOJIOrH5Ipacnpocrpanana CBOH
narepecu H .lI.aJIeKOsa npenensr H3MepeHH5I IiH'T'e'JIJIeKTaH oaapen-
HOCTH. Y'IeCTb see rpaxropu rrenarorusecxoro npouecca, Bblpa3HTb
HX B TO'IHbIX uarppax, YCTpaHHTbcoBceM CJIY'IaHHble, HeY'ITeHHble
cpaKTopbI H CTPOHTb socrraraaae C OTKpbITbIMH rJIa3aMH If TO'IHO
,y'ITeHHbIMH YCJIOBH5IMH-BOT OCHOBHble aazta-nr, CT05I~He nepen 3TOH
nCHXOJIOrHeH,-H ee .lI.aHHble HaIllJI.H eerie npaaeneuae B illIiJPOKOH
nenaroraxecxoa npaxrnxe. B anepaxancxax (KaK H BO BC5IKHX) IllKO-
zrax npouserana 3K3aMeHbI, HO B 3K3aMeHe OCTaBaJIaCbncer.aa Macca
HeY'ITeHHOro, CJIY'IaHHoro. 113Mep5IIO~a5I npHKJIa.ll.Ha5I rrCHXOJIOrH5I
rrOCTaBHJIa aonpoc 06 H3MepeHHH TPY.ll.HOCTH npe.ll.b5IBJI5IeMbIX na
3K3aMeHe sonpocos H-rrpOBe.ll.5I 60JIbiliHe CJIO)l{Hble HCCJIe.ll.OBaHH5I-
nOJIY'IHJIa lI,HCPPbI,crporo xapaxrepasyioutae TPY.ll.HOCTbnpem-aanse-
MbIX na 3K3aMeHe sonpocos. CTaH.lI.apTH3all,H5I ne.aarornxecxoro Ma-
repnana KocHYJIaCb H rrpaBOITHCaHH5I, H OTPbIBKOB .lI.JI5I 'ITeHH5I, H
MaTeMaTH'IeCKIiX aana-r, H B pe3YJIbTaTe scero aroro lI,HKJIa HCCJIe.ll.O-
BaIIHi1 auepaxanuu pacnonararor Terrepb 3Ha'IHTeJIbHbIM rreztaroraxe-
·CKHM MaTepHaJIOM, pacnOJIO)l{eHHbIM B crporo MaTeMan{'IeCKH ouenea-
HOM nopazxe TPY.ll.HOCTH.
3TH .lI.Ba lI,HKJIa COCTaBJI5IIOT.lI.Be Ba)l{HeHiliHe rpynnu axepasaa-
-'CII:HXnCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHX HCCJIe.ll.OBaHHH,Ka)l{.lI.a5I H3 H'HX HMeeT CBOH,
.xapaxrepaue .lI.JI5I aMepHKaHCKOH HayKH YCTaHOBKH H .lI.OCTH)l{eHH5I;
-ooe OHH COCTaBJI5IIOT
06~HH CPOHaMepHKaHCKOH HaY'IHOH MbICJIH.
HeCKOJIbroo B C110pOHeOT 06~errCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHX HCCJIe.ll.OBaHHH
,CT05IT aMepHKaHCKHe pa60TbI no rrCHXorraTOJIOrHH. TaK ace, KaK H

•
88 A. P.JlYPHfl

Ka)l{.ll.a51H3 YKa3aHHbIX JIHHHH HCCJIe.ll.OBaHHH,aMepHKaHCKa51 nCHXO-·

na:TOJIOrH5I pa3BlfBaeTCSI CaMOCTOSlT'eJIbHOI
H nOlITH He CBH3aH<l HH
C 06meH, HH C nenar-ornaecxoji nCHXOJIOrHeH. Oaa nOqTH He 3aHM-
crsyer HHqero OT 3KcnepHMeHTaJIbHO-nCHXOJIOrnQeCKHX HCCJIe.ll.OBa-
HHt'I (H B 3TOM OHa 3HaqHTeJIbHO orcraer OT HeKOTopbIX eBponeHCKHX
nCHXOnaTOJIOrHqeCKHX JIa60paTopHH), OHa npHMeH5IeT xacro npaxra-
xecxae MeTO.ll.bI, xoropsre asrparioransr B TeCTOJIOflH"feCKO'H
npaxrnxe,
HO CneQH¢HqeCKHM .ll.JISIaMepHKaHCKOH nCHXOnaTOJIOrHH SlBJI5IeTCSI
He
3T1O. . l1,n::eSI lICHXHqeCKOH rarnensr, HCCJI·e.ll.0BaHl15l KOHKpeTHOH
JIHqHOCTH H 06pa30BaHHSI xapaKTepa--BOT TOT Kpyr np06JIeM, KOTO-
pue 60JIbllIe scero 3aHHMaIOT axepaxaacxoro nCHXOnaTOJIOra. 3.ll.eCb
HCnOJIb3yeTcSI B 3HaqHTeJIbHOH CTeneHH TeopHSI nCHXOaHaJIH3a; HO'
na aMepHKaHCKOH nonse OHa nperepnesaer saasarensnsre H3MeHeIHH5I;
ee nbITaIOTCSI CBSl3aTbC llIHpOKHMH 6HOJIOrHqeCKHMH 0600meHHSlMH,
060CHOBaTb ¢H3HOJIOrHqeCKH, C6JIH3HTb C HCCJIe.ll.OBaHlH5IMH
¢H3lH'O-
JIOrHH a¢¢eKTOB, p'a60TaMH, CBSl3aHHbIMHC H3yqeHHeM .ll.eSlTeJIbHOCiH
aBTOHOMHOH HepBHOH ClfCTeMbI,--H B rpynax aMeplfKaHCKHX ncaxo-
naTOJIOrOB nClfXOaHaJIH3 nepepaoaruaaercs, nepepacraer B llIlfPOKYIO.
6HOJIOrHqeCKYIO H HeBpOJIOrHQeCKH-o'6ocHoBaHHYIO CHCTeMY 3HaHlfH
o JIlfqHOCIlf.
DO)l{aJIyH--3THM lfCqepnbIBaIOTCSI OCHOBHble JIHHHH rex avepaxaa-
CKHX nCHXOJIOrlf.qeCKHX HCCJIe.ll.OBaHlfH,xoropue ynHpaIOTCSI B reope-
rnuecxae, oouienayuuoro 3HaqeHHSI BbIBO.ll.bI1. 11 HHTepeCHO: B HaYKe
o JIlfqHOCTH, B aanaue npocnennrs ee passarae, ee xapaxrep, ·ee·
.ll.eSlTeJIbHOCTbB 06meCTBe,--B 3TOH HaYKe C6JIH)l{aIOTCSInee 3TH rpa
06JIaCTlf, npaxrnsecxn 6bIBllIlfe COBepmeHHO oropsaunuua .ll.pyr OT
npyra, opraHlf3aQHOHHO He lfMeBllIlfe .ll.pyr C .ll.pYroM naxaxoro KOH-
TaKTa. Bupacraer H.ll.eSl 06be.ll.lfHeHlfSl 3THX .ll.HCQlfnJIlfH B O)I.UH KOM-
nJIeKC--KOMnJIeKC HayK 0 QeJIOBeKe, H C03.ll.aHlfSl Tex opraHH3aQHOH-
HbIX yCJIQBlfH, npn KOTOPbIX 3TOT KOMnJIeKCMor 6bI 6bITb scecropoaue
If CHHTeiJiQeC~H: li3YQeH. l1ieJIbCKlfH Y:HlfBepc.lfTeT, Ka)l{'e'T'C5I,nepBblH
H3 YHHBepCHTeTOB Avepaxa, KOTOPbIH BCTaJI na 3TOT nyrs. Ha ero
reppnropaa yxce CTPOlfTCSI60JIbllIOe anaane HHCTHTYTa cosepurenno-
nosoro rnna, KOTOPbIH .ll.OJI)l{eH .ll.aTb YCJIOBlfSl .ll.JISI pa3BHTHSI 3TOH
ClfHTeTlfQeCKOH nayxn o QeJIOBeK'e. Institute of Iiuman Relation-e-rare.
, Ha3bIBaeTCSI3TOT HOBbIH lfHCTlfTYT (MbI naex ero 3CKH3 ua pHC. 1),--
I
OH .ll.OJI)l{eH 6Y.ll.eT 3aHSlTbCSIlf3YQeHlfeM JmQHOCTHco scex OCHOBHbIX
ee cropon: nClfXOJIOrHQeCKHHIf reHeTHQeCKHH OT.ll.eJIbI (n-pa r 33 e JI JI
H .ll o n zc) 6Y.ll.YT 3aHSlTbI 3KCrIepHMeHTaJIbHOH xapaxrepacrnxon
B3pOCJIOro If peceuxa: OT.lI.eJI nCHXOOlfOJIOrHlf (.II.-p 113 P K C) oY.leT

1 Mbi He OCT3HaBJIIIBaeMClI 3J\eCb na aaepnxaacxon nCHXOTeXHHKe, HMelOlllelt TaM

cosepuremro cneuaoasecxue <jJ0PMbl.
 MEJKD,YHAPOll,HbIH KOHFPECC nCHXOJIOFOB 89'

HCCJIe.II.DBaTbnDBe.II.eHHe aHTpDnDH.II.HbIX D6e3b5lH, ':)TDH npen-crynenn

lJeJIIOBeKa, a -COUHDJIDrHlJeCK.HJ1:
DT.II.eJI 3aHMeTC51 .II.aJKe CDUHOJIDr.HlJe-
CKHMH np'06JI'eMa'MH. K 3TOMY HHCT'IHyry, KOTDpbIH Y)f{e CeHlJa'C pac-
noaaraer aecswa 3HalJHTeJIbHhIM
K a n H T a JI 0 M - 0 K 0 JI 0 14 000 000 ~-------- ...---.-.~-.-.--
.
.II.OJIJIaPDB, npHCDe.II.HH5IeTC5I ueJIa51
rpynna BcnDMDraTeJIhHbIX YlJpe)f{.II.e-
HHH, CB5I3aHHhIX npexoie ncero C
erD nCHXHaTpHlJeCKHM H HeBpDJID-
rHlJeCKHM DT.II.eJIDM H CDCTaBJI51IO-
llJ,HM TO, lJTD HDCHT B 3TDH CHCTeMe
«Human Welfare grDup» (npoexr
3THX lJaCThIO Y)f{e nocrpoenaux
3.II.aHHH MbI .II.aeM na pHC. 2.) BC51
CHCTeMa B ueJIDM CD3.II.aeT cosep-
ureno HCKJIIOlJHTeJIhHhle no 6DraT-
CTBY y~JIDBH51 .II.JI51H3YlJeHH51 lJeJID-
BelJeCKDH JIHlJHDCTH,H MhI 6Y.II.eM C
HHTepecDM D)f{H.II.aTh, KaK pasoaser-
C513TD HDBDe 6DJIhWDe HalJHHaHHe.
O.II.HaKD MD)f{HD JIH TeM caMhIM
ClJHTaTh, lJTD rrD.II.JIHHHD HaYlJHOe "t.;;:;:===---~-_..,.../;.~
~
H3YlJeHHe lJeJIDBelJeCKDH JIHlJHDCTH ~~---. .
XDTh CKDJIhKD HH6Y.II.h oriecnexeno PIIC. 1

B AMepHKe?
Onem. cepseauue H rJIy6DKHe npHlJHHbI 3aCTaBJI51IOTHac CHJIbHD
CDMHeBaTbC5I B 3TDM. CDBepweHHD nDH5ITHD, lITD CHHTeTHlJeCKa51
HaYKa 01 JIHlJHDCT'HMD)f{5T pa3BHBaTbC51 'fIOIJIbKIQI
B nJIalHOBOM !lDP05l.II.Ke,

Pllc.2

TDJIbKD B CHCTeMe, lJaCTH KDTDPDH cnaauu e.II.HHDi1 D6llJ,ei1 MeTD.II.DJID-

mei1. MbI BnDJIHe MbICJIHJIH pa3BHTHe TaKDH HayKH B YCJIDBH51X Ha-
urero CDI03a, H TDJIbKD lITD 3aKDHlJHBWHHC5I BceCDI03HbIH Cbe3.II. no
nDBe.II.eHHIO xenoaexa .II.eMDHCTpHpDBaJI, HaCKDJIbKD nJID.II.DTBDPHD BHe-

•
90 A. P. JIYPHfl. .

ceune e,lI,HHOH:HaY4HOH: MeTO,lI,OJIOrHH-MaTepHaJIHCTH4eCKOH: ,lI,HaJIe

THKH-B HayKH, 3'HLI1MalOw.HeC5I LIeJIOBeK:OM.
YiMeHHo 3THX YCJIOBHH: e)lHl-IO}1 MeTO)lOJIOrHLIeCl<OH:OCHOBbI HE
B COBpeMeHHOH: aMep1HKaHCKOH:HaYKe. IlparMa11I13M, HaCKB03b npe
mlTaBWHH: see aMepIIKaHCKHe HCCJIe,lI,OBaHH5I(MbI rOBopHM 0 rex 11
HHX, K0110pble TaK HJIH I1HaLIe CB5I3aHbl C nCHXOJIOnreH:), OCTaBJI5I
qmJIOCO<pCKHeYCTaHOBKH H 06W.YIO MeTO,lI,OJIOrHlO na «JIHLIHOe YCMC
rpeane» Ka)!{,lI,OrO pa60THHKa. «<PHJIOC0<pH5I-3TO Moe LIaCTHoe ,lI,eJI
M0I1 y6e)!{,lI,eHH5I He BJIH5IIOT na MOIO HaYKY»-C TaKHMH YTBep)!{,lI,{
HH5IMI1 MHe npHWJIOCb BCTpeLIaTbC5I LIYTb JIH He B Ka)!{,lI,OH:anepaxai
CKOH: JIa60paTopHH. MHe BCTpe4aJIHCb Y4eHble, C Y,lI,OBJIeTBOpeHHe
rOBopHBWHe, -rro OHH «3KJIeKTI1KH», ,lI,YMa513THM no.a-repxnyn., 4r
OHI1 CBo60,lI,HbI OT BC5IKOH:npe,lI,B351TOCTHB HaYLIHOM I1CCJIe,lI,OBaHH
COBepweHHO nOH5ITHO, LITO npn TaKHX YCTaHOBKax Ka)!{,lI,a51naoop:
TOpH5I npespauraercs B ll.HKJI MaJIO CB5I3aHHbIX ,lI,pyr C .il.PyroM Tel
06be,lI,HHeHHbIX paase npaKTHLIeCKHMH 3a,lI,aLIaMH, ,lI,a euie TOH neoco:
HaHHofl-H rrJIOXOH-<pI1JIOCO<pHe}l, KOTOpa51 CTHXHHHO npOHHKaeT
Ka)!{,lI,Oe HCCJIe,lI,OBaHHe.YiMeHHo 3TO OTCYTCTBl1e e,lI,HHOH MeTO,lI,OJ
rH4eCKOtl YCTaHOBKH, KOTOpa51 B YCJIOBI151XrOCrrO,lI,CTBYIOW.eHB OKP;
)!{eHHH 6yp)!{ya3HOH: <pHJIOCO<pHl1HeH36e)!{HO sener K rrpOCaLII1BaHI1
Hal1BHbIX 11,lI,eaJIHCT114eCKHX
KOHll.enll.HH:,-HMeHHO 3TO C03,lI,aeT YCJlOBI
BHyTpeHHe xpaitne He6JIarorrpH5ITHble ,lI,JI5I CHHTeTHLIeCKOH HayKI1
LIeJIOBeKe, rrOCTpoeHHOH aa nO,lI,JIHHHO HaYlfHOM <PYH,lI,aMeHTe. M
OXOTHO sepav, LITO 3,lI,aHHe, Pl1CYHOK xoroporo Mbl rrpHBeJIH 3,lI,eC
CTaHeT TOp)!{eCTBOM HaY4HOH TeXHHKH 11 BepXOM nneumero 60raTCTJ
JIa60paTopHbIX YCJIOBl1H:, O,lI,HaKO Mbl He BepHM, LITO 3TO BHeWH{
60raTCTBO C03,lI,aCT 4TO-H116Y,lI,b ,lI,pyroe, LIeM BHeWHee 06be,lI,HHem
nozi O,lI,HOH:KpbIWeH: LIaCTHbIX HCCJIe,lI,OBaHl1H:,xoropue Be,lI,YTC5I 0
,lI,eJIbHbIMH rrpl1BJIeKaeMblMl1 ryna Y4eHbIMl1. B YCJIOBH5IX xarnrran:
crnxecxof opranasauna Mbl He BH,lI,HM nepcnexrna ,lI,Jl5I rrpOH1I1KH
BeHl151C03HaTeJIbHO nOCTpoeHHbIX 11 rrO,lI,JlHHHOnay-msrx 06W.HX MeT
,lI,OJlOrI14eCKHX xonuerruna B LIaCTHble MeTO,lI,HKH OT,lI,eJIbHblX I1CCJ
.lI.OBaHI1H:,H B 3TOM MO)!{HOppe,lI,yra,lI,blBaTb BHYTpeHHIOIO HI1w.eTY 3TO
04eHb HHTepeCHoro H 60raToro HaLII1HaHH5I.
Mbl O'lepTHJlH B caMOM 6erJIOM' 3CK113e OCHOBHble JlI1HHH axep
KaHCKOtI ncaxonornuecxoa HaYKI1. Ha ee <pOHe npourerr IX Me)!{.zj
na PO,lI,HblH: rrcI1XOJIOrI14eCKl1H:xoarpecc.
TaK xce, KaK 11 BC5I aMepl1KaHCKa51 HaYKa, xonrpecc 6bIJI Jll1W
uenrpansnux BbI,lI,Bl1HYTbIX B IIJlaliOBOM nopszn.e TeM; B 113BeCTH
Mepe OH 6bIJI JIl1WeH H BHYTpeI-IHero IIJlaHa, T. K. cexuna HaMe4a
He CPOJIbKO BHYTpeHHI1H nJIaH, CKOJIbI<Ore 06JIaCTI1, np06JIeMbI, I
Topble HaWJII1 ce6e MeC110 aa xoarpecce.
O,lI,HaKO, KaI< 11 Ka)!{,lI,bIH:CTI1Xl1}IHO BblPOCWHH: npouecc.c-xonrp:

•
 ME)f{PYHAPOPHblU KOHrPECC nCJ1XOJIorOB 91

HeCOMHeHHOOTpa}!{aJI OCHOBHbIeJIYlHI1Y1
pa3BYlTYlH aMepYlKaHCKOH HayKYl
H OCHOBHble rrp06JI,eMbI, soxpyr K01'Op'bIX BeAeTCH HaM60JI'ee rOpH4a51
pa60Ta COBpeMeHHOH MYlPOBOll rrCYlXOJIOrHYl.
HaM Ka}!{eTCH nenpasaasnsra nyrex OCTaHaBJIYlBaTbCHB KpaTKoM
C006I.IJ:eHI1IYlH3 soex (I1JIH XOTH 6bI rviaauux) ,lljOKJIaAaX cses.aa, Apyr
sa ,lI.pyrOM rrepe4l1CJIH5I I1X rrOJIO}!{eHYlH; MbI OCTaHOBI1MCH3AeCb JIYllllb
na . HeMHorYlX ,lI.OKJIaAax, 4aCTO BbIAalO~YlXCH, HO 4aCTO-p5IAOBbIX 11
JIYllllb TI1rrYl4HbIX AJI5I rex YlJII1 YlHbIX TeH,lI.eHl.(YlI1:B COBpeMeHHOll HaY4-
HOI1:MbICJIYl.
Ka}!{,lI.bIll CKJIOHeH BYl~eTb B 60JIblllOM Ma'11epUaJIe 'Po, lITO< eMY
rrOKa3aJIOCb ocorieuno Ba)KHbIM, 6bITb Mo~eT - TO, K BOCrrpH5ITYllO
4ero IOH 6bIJI MaKCI1MaJIbHIOrrOJJ,rOTOBJIeH.Ilanryuraa 3TI1 CTpOKI1 BOC-
rrpYlH5IJI Cbe3JJ, KaK JJ,eMOHCTpaI.(l1lO
IOCHOBHbIX rrpI1HI.(YlrrYlaJIbHbIX YCTa-
HOBOK COBpeMeHHoro aMepYlKaHCKOro 6YlX3BYlOpl13Ma Yl KaK CTI1Xl1llHO
co scex CTOPOH pacryutae 11 HaMe4alO~YleCH TeHAeHI.(YlYl rrpeOJI.OJIeHI151
ero rrpYlMI1TYlBHbIX B3rJIHAOB, ero MeXaHYlCTYlqeCKOrOMYlPOB033peHYlH1.
TYlrrYl4HbIM ,lI.JI5I pa60T cospeaeanoro 611X3BYlOpYl3Ma5IBJI5IeTCHYl3-
Y4eHYle 4eJIOBeKa YlJIYl }!{YlBOTHOro, acxo.aauree Yl3 rrOJIO}!{eHYlH, qTO
CJIO}!{HeHlllYle CTOPOHbI rrOBeAeHYl5I BblpacTalOT Yl3 npocrux nyrea no-
crenenaoro YlX YCJIO}!{HeHI15I,nyrea BOcrrYlTaHYl51Yl3BeCTHbIX HaBbI!{OB.
3TYl HaBblKYl MoryT 6blTb socnaraxu JIYllllb na oase BpO}!{,lI.eHHbIX <pOpM
noseneaaa, Yl aaysenae KaK HaBbIKOB, TaK 11 apoacnemrux <pOPM rro-
BeAeHYl5I CTaJIO OAHOH Yl3 OCHOBHbIX TeM COBpeMeHHOH axepaxancxof
rrCIIXOJIorYlYl. O,lI.HaKO aMepYlKaHCKaH rrCYlXOJIorYl5I He TOJIbKO onncsr-
saer, OHa npezcne scero H ·H3Mep5IeT; H aanaxa H3yqeHU5I HaBbIKOB H
BpO}!{JJ,eHHbIX peaxuaii rrpespatnaercs B 3aJJ,a4Y H3MepeHH5I I1X ycroji-
qIIBOCTH, HX CHJIbl.
Coaepurenno He CJIyqaHHO rr03TOMY, qTO rrepBbIM AOKJIaAOM, no-
Mew,eHHbIM B rrOBeCTKe xonrpecca H rrp04HTaHHOM na 3aCeAaHHYl cex-
I.(IIM rro noaeneumo )!<HBOTHbIX, 6bIJI ,mOKJIa.rr,
nporp. Yo pn e Ha (War-
den-Columbia) '06 H3MepeHHH MOTI1BOB rrOBeJJ,eHI15I y }!{H-
BOT H 0 r o. 3TY 0pYlfl1HaJIbHYlO aanaxy aBTOp ocy~eCTBJIHJI CJIeAYlO-
U.(YlM 06pa30M·: }!{eJIaH H3MepHTb CHJIY, C KOTOPOll AeHcTByeT na }!{Yl-
BOTHoe (KPbICy) MOTHB rOJIo.n.aHH5I, OH caxcan ee B rrOMeII.(eI1He, B AP'Y-
rOM KOHI.(e xcroporo 6bIJIa rrOJIO}!{eHa rnnna, K KOTOPOH }!{HBOTHOe,
04eBYlAHO, CTpeMHJIOCb; Me}!{,lI.y }!{YlBOTHbIM H rrauieii 6bIJIH CAeJIaHbI
cneuaansnue MeTaJIJIYlqeCKYlerrOJIOCKH, sepea xoropsre }!{I1BOTHOe He-
1136e}!{HO .lIiOJI}!{HO6bIJIO npocerart, H OT KOTOPbIX rrOJIY4aJIO CI1JIbHble
3JIeKTpYlQeCKYley.aapu. 3aAa4a 113MepemI5I CYlJIbI MOTMBOB CBO,lI.YlJIaCb,
6JIaro,lI.ap5! TaKOll YCTaHOBKe, K aanaue Yl3MepeHYl5I roro, CKOJIbKO paa

1 Ilonpooaee na aTOM 51 OCTaHaBJIHBaIOCbB crarse «0 nyrsx COBpeMeHHof:! nCHXO-

norHH» - «ECTeCTB03HaHHe H MapKCH3M».
92 A. P. JJYPH51

xpuca neperieraaa K nmue, H'eCMOTp51na nOJIY4aeMbIe eio 3JIeKTpOl{Q)K-

nue lllOKH. CTaB5I OnbITbI Ha'~ rOJI'O.U9M,)f{a)f{,ZI;OH,nOJIOBbIM M'liCTHl-IKTOM
H MHCTMHKTOMMaTepHHCTBa (B nOCJIe~HHX ~BYX CJIY4a5lX MeCTO naunr
3aHHMaJIa CaMKa HJIM ~eTeHbIlll), Vopnen OKa3aJIC5I B COCT05lHHM113-
MepHTb CHJIY 3THX MOTHBOB H paCnOJIO)f{HTb HX B Onpe~eJIeHHOH no-
CJIe~OBaTeJIbHOCTH p5l~.
MbI rrpHBeJIH 3TOT ~OKJIa~ KaK THnH4HbIH npnvep xopourero axe-
pHKaHCKorO HCCJIe~OBaHH5I, rrOCB5Iw.eHHOrO H3MepeHHlO BpO)f{~eHHbIX
cpOpM nOBe~eHH5I; OTBJIeKa5lCb OT cneuarpasecxoa CTPYKTYPbI xaxcnoro
H3 npaaeneanux HHCTHHKTOB,-6HX3BHOPHCT C4HTaeT HC4epnaHHOH
H peureauon np06JIeMY, eCJIiYfeMY y~aICTC5I aupaairn, ee B O~.H'03Ha4-
HbIX, rrOJIY4eHHbiX B O~HHaKOBbIX YCJIOBH5IX,UHcppaX; cosepurenao no-
H5ITHO, 4TO 3TH BblBO~bl TOT4aC )f{e nepeHOC5ITC5I aa 4eJIOBe4eCKOe
06lUeCTBO, H npotineva MOTHBaUHH 4eJIOBe4eCKOrO nOBe~eHH5I C4l;lTa-
eTC5I ycneumo peureunoa, eCJIH HCCJIe~OBaTeJIlOy~aCTC5I H3MepHTb a6-
COJIlOTHYlO CHJIY OT~eJIbHbiX «HHCTHHKTOB»Y nO~OnbITHbIX. )KHBOTHbIX.
Cosepurenuo TO ace KaCaeTC5I H BTOPOH'H3 HaMe4eHHbIX HaMH npo-
6JIeM-rrpo6JIeMbI HaBbIKOB. 3Ta np06JIeMa 51BJI5IeTC5I,nO)f{aJIYH, ca-
MOH THnH4HrOH np06JIeMOH .L\JI5IaMepHKaHCKOH nCHXOJIOrHH nOBe.L\eHH5I.
Ilpaxenenae MeTO~a YCJIOBHblX pecpJIeKCOB H cneuaansno supaooraa-
HOrO .L\JI5I3TOH uemr MeTO.L\aJIa6HpHHTOB rrOKa3aJIO, 4TO HaBbIK 51Bo'l5l-
eTC5I pe3YJIbTaTOM CJIO)KHOHCHCT€'Mbl np106 H OlllH60K, npn KOTOPOH
y~a4HbIe peaKUHH nO~KpenJI5IlOTC5I H OCTalOTC5I, a neynaxaue-e-rop-
M0351TC5IH HC4e3alOT. I'onu HCCJIe~OBaHHH YKpenHJIH B aMepHKaHCKHX
asropax y6e)f{.L\eHHe, 4TO HMeHHO B 3THX repvauax aCCOUHaU"15l
~BH)f{eHHH, rrO~KperrJIeHH5I H TOpMO)f{eHH5I MO)KeT 6bITb supaaceu BC5I-
KHt'I HaBbIK, H 4TO HaBbIK Y 4eJIOBeKa B CYlUHOCTH HH4eM npHHUHnH-
aJIbHbIM He OTJIH4aeTC5I OT HaBbIKa Y )KHBOTHoro. MexaHHCTH4eCKHH
B3rJI5I~ na noseneaae 4eJIOBeKa nOJIY4HJI CBOlO np04HYlO OCHOBY B
aMepHKaHCKOH nCHXOJIOfHH nOBe~eHH5I, H 6bIJI crpaacen na xonrpecce
B ueJIOM pane ~OKJIa~OB.
O~aKO, HM'eHH'O3TOT B3rJI5I)I; na M1exaHH41eCKYlO OCHOBY HaBbIKOB
• 6bIJI nO~BeprHYT caMbIM cepseanua COMHeHH5IMaa xonrpecce, H HH-
TepeCHO, 4TO 3TH npaKTH4eCKHe COMHeHH5IHCXO~HJIH OT xpynaemuero
nCHXOJIOra, aaecurero B csoe BpeM5I ocooeuno MHOrO B Y4eHHe 0 Ha-
BbIKax,-lopH.L\aHKa.
TopH~aHK c~eJIaJI ua xonrpecce OOJIblllOH .ll.OKJIa~ 06 OCHOBHbIX
cpaKTopax 06Y4eHH5I. nBe OCHOBHbIe ero MbICJIH CBO~HJIHCb K KpHTHKe
nsyx OCHOBHbIX nOJIO)f{eHHH crapoii reopaa o6Y4eHH5I. Ilepsas 3aKJIlO-
4aJIaCb B KpHTHKe POJIH nOBTOpeHH5I ~JI5I 06Y4eHH5I, BTOpa5l-B KpHTH-
xe cooTBeTcTBeHHoH POJIH HaKa3aHH5I. KaK HarJI5I~HO H aa sxcnepaaen-
TaJIbHOM xarepnane nOKa3aJI TopH~aHK, nOB"fIOpeHHe MO)f{eT H He
urpart. OCHOBHOHp'OJIH ~JI5I 06pa30BaHH5I HaBbIKa. 13bIBalOT CJIY43H, K8-
 ME)!{llYHAPOllHbIH KOHrPECC nCI1XOJIorOB 93

rna, HeCMIQTp5I aa MfiorOKpaTHOe nIOBTOpeHHe, HaBbIK He socnartaaaer-

CH; 6b1BaIOT 06paTHbIe CJIY'laH-KOr 1I.a npa pa~HIQHaJIbHOH opraunsauna
MaTepHaJIa HaBbIK (HJIH 3anOMHHaHHe) 06pa3yeTC5I COBepweHHO nesa-
BHCHMO OT rrOBTOpeHH5I, B CHJIY caMOH opraHH30BaHHOCTH xarepaana.
To, 'lTO rrpHrrHCbIBaJIOCb paasure JIHWb MeXaHH'leCKoMY rr08TopeHHIO-
)l,OJI}!{HO 6bITb npanacaao OCMbICJIeHHOH 0 p r a H H 3 a uH H MaTepHaJ1a,
rrpaBHJ1bHOii Y C T a HOB K e yvauterocs, H npa 9THX YCJIOBHHX paoora
nporexaer HecpaBHeHHO nponyxrasnee, 'leM npa MeXaHH'leCKOM oopa-
30BaHHH aCCO~HaTHBHbIX CBH3eH.
CIIOJIb xce ,CPYH.rr.aMeHT3'JIbHaero KpHTHKa, POJIH H3'Ka3aHH'H B 06y-
'leHl1H. TcpH.rr.a~IK .rr.aJI pe3KHH IQTBO.rr.rrOJIO}!{eHHIO, xoropoe OH cax BbI-
CT3Bl1JI MHoro JIeT H saa H xoropce paccaarpasaao HaKa3aHHe, KaK
rpaxrop, rrpoTHBOrrOJIO}!{HbIH nooutpenmo, KaK rpaxrop, OCJIa6JIHIOw.m1:
HaBbIK. PH.rr. axcnepnaeuroa rrOKa3aJI, 'lTO HaKa3aHHe xaute scero He
aezrer K IQ'CJIa6JIeHl1lO'HaBbIKa, rrpOTHB xoroporo OHO aanpaeneno, HO
cosnaer HOBbIH HaBbIK, aa rrOHBJI'eHl1e xoroporo rrenon or, rrpHMeH5IB-
illHH ero, H He paCC'lHTbIBaJI. OCJIa6JIeHHe HaBbIKa MO}!{eT 6bITb C03-
.nano He H3<Ka3aiHl1eM, al 'I13MreHeHHeM CTPYKTYPbI axra, YCTaHQ.BOK
JIl1'lHCCTH, nepexmouerraea ere .rr.eHTeJIbHOCTH na npyryro CHCTeMY.
Y}!{e B 3TOM noxaane Topnnaaxa BH,ll.HbI CHMrrTOMbI 60JIbWOH CMe-
HbI MHpoB033peHl{ii. MeXaHH'leCKHe rro cYI1I.eCTBY TepMHHbI, B KOO'Q.-
psrx BbIpa}!{aJIlHCb CJIO}!{Hble rrCHXOJI'OrH'leCKH'e: cpaKTbI (nomcpenaeaae,
rrOB1'OpeHHe, TOpOMO)KeHHe), 331MeHHIOTCHHOBbIMH, B3HTbIMH U3 .rr.oporo-
~eJIOCTHOro MHpoB033peHHH (ycraaosxa, opraaaaauaa, CTpYKTypa);
3TH rrOH51THHBBO.rr.HTCH.rr.a)Ke B TaKHe '5IK06bI npocrsre npouecca nose-
)l,eHHH, xa« HaiBbIK; rrOHHTHe aCOOUHa~H'H, oeapaaaeasno rOCrrO,ll.CTBO-
sasurea B crapon nCHXOJIOrHH, CMeHHeTCH HOBbIM nOHHTI1eM 0 p r 3 H l1-
3 a ~H 11.
Bee 3TO OKa3aJIOCb zraaexo He CJIY'laHHbIMH, BbIXBa'leHHbIMH H3
oouiero KOHTeKca 3~M'e'laHH51MH, 3TH nOJIO)KeHHH HaWJII1 csoe 6JIeCTH-
uiee pa3BHTHe B ~OKJIa:.n.:eK e JI Ie p a
(Kohler, Berlin), C,ll.eJIaHHOM'Haon-
HOM H3 aexepnax aacenaana xonrpecca. Flcaxoaora 06bI'lHO crpeaa-
.JIHC~ CBO,ll.HTb B03HHKHOBeHHe H3BeCTHbIX CPOPM noaeneuaa-vace pas-
HO, WJIa JIH pe-n, 0 rraMHTH H Te'leHHH MbICJIHTeJIbHbIX llKTOB HJIH. 0
BHeWHHX HaBb!KaX, rrpHBbI'lKaX-K .rr.eHcTBHIO cooTBeTcTBYlOmHX acco-
u.Ha~HH. )locTaTO'lHO 6bIJIO ,ll.BYM rrpe.rr.CTaBJIeHHHM I1JIH ,ll.BYM ,ll.BH)Ke-
HHHM coanacri, npyr C .apyroa, 'lT06bI 6bIJIa oopaaosaaa COOTBeTCT-
BYIOW.aH B3aHMHaH CBH3b, cooTBeTcTBYIOu.(aH aCCO~Ha~HH. Keaep CKJIO-
HeH ~eJIHKOM oraeprars raxoe TOJIKOBaHHe, xoropoe B csoe BpeMH
6bIJIO rrOJIO)KeHO if B IQCHOBY HaY'lHOrO no.axona K BocnHTaHIO. )laJIeKO
He BO scex CJIY'la51X .rr.Be cosnanarourae peaxuaa scrynaror B aCCO~H-
aTHBHYIO CBH3b; .rr.JIHaroro He06xo.rr.HMO,'lT06bI OHH 06be,ll.HHHJIHCb B
l<aKOH-TO 06meH CTpYKType; 1I.Be peasuaa, B3HTbIe H3 pasaux CTPYI<TYp.
94 A. P. JlYPHfl

nanpaaep, BXO,lI,ml~He B pasnue CHCTeMbI BOCnpH5lTI15l,xoryr ,lI,eC5lTKH

paa cosnaaan, H BCe ace He scrynars B B3aI1MHYlO CB5l3b. DpI1H~Hn
aCCO~I1a~HH ,lI,OJI)!(eH6bITb 3aMeHeH rr p H H u H nOM 0 p r a H H 3 a u H H,
H sro He :eCTh JfHIlIb nCllXlOJIJOfHilIleCKiH
OnHCaTeJibHbB1 T'epMH'H, 3TO-
nOH5lTHe, xoropoe 5lBJI5leTC5la,lI,3KBaTHbIM ,lI,JI5luenoro psna <pH3HOJIO-
qeCKHX H 06Il1.e6HOJIOrHqeCKHX 3aKOHOMepHOCTeH. AKTI1BHOCTb qeJIO-
sexa H )!(HBOTHOro 3aKJIlOqaeTC5l HMeHHO B opraHH3a~HI1, peryxsuna
CBoeH ,lI,e5lTeJIbHOCTI1,HanpaBJIeHHOH Ha npHcnoc06JIeHHe K cpe,lI,e H
OBJIa~eHI1e 3TOH Cpe,lI,OH, K 3TIOT npouecc MO)!(eT 6bITb nOH5lT OTiIIO,lI,b
He B repaanax aCCO~I1a~HH, HO JII1Il1b B repvaaax opraaasanaa ue-
JIOCTHOHCI1CTeMbInOBle,llleHH5l.
Hano 3aMeTHTb, ,qTO npaauan aCCO~Ha~HH, pe<pJIeKTOpHOHcxexsr,
KOTOPbIH 06bIqHO onpenenan nocrpoenae ncero noaenenna, naurex
CBOlO pesxyro KpItTHKY H CO CTOPOHbI HeBpOJIOrHqeCKHX. ,lI,aHHbIX, H
6JIeCT5lIll.HH ,lI,OKJIa,lI,J13Il1JIH, xpynnejnuero, nO)!(aJIYH, asrepnxancuoro
BCI1XOHteBpOJIOra,.zr,aJIMCKJIlOqI1T'eJIbHYlOno mrrepecy CBO,lI,KYOTHOC5l-
IlI.I1XC5l crozta 3KcnepI1MeHTOB. B caMOM nene, eCJII1 BC5lKHH HaBbIK
CKJIa,lI,bIBaeTC5lB pe3YJIbTaTe orrpenenermux pe<pJIeKTOpHbIX aKTOB,
HMelOIlI.HX CBOH'CTporO-YCTOHqHBbIe HeBpOHHbIe ,lI,YrH,-TO ,lI,OCTaTOqHO
pa3pYIlIHTb 3TH ,lI,yrH, qT06bI nunan, YCTpaHHJIC5lcaMbIH HaBbIK. Jl3Il1-
JIH np'O,lI;eJIaJI p~,lI, HCKJIlOqHT'e'JIbHOHHTe!peCHbIX no CMeJIOCTHonbITOB
C neuepeopauaea )!(HBOTHbIX H y6e,n:HJIC5l,'1110 npH 3KCTHpnaQHH JIlO-
ooro Y'IaCTKa KOPbI Y )l{HBOTHOro HaBbIK BOBce He sunanaer, fa JIHIlIh
npOHCXO,ZUfT06Il1.ee T'OpMO)!(eHae, ocuiee CHli)!(e'Hll'e' Ha:BbIKa. Y,lI,aJIeHHC
KOPbI OKa3bIBaeT TaKHM 06pa30M nexoropoe posaoe aanepaorsarouree
BJIH5lHUe na paasarae lHaBbIWOIB,
noeute npn YAaJIeHHH: 700/0 KOPbI !Ha-
BbIKH MorYT npO,lI,OJI)!(aTb 06pa30BbIBaThC5l, )!(HBOTHOe OCTaeTC5l ,lI,0-
crynasra ,lI,JI5106yqeHH51. DOBbIIlIeHHe aKTHBHOCTH JIlO60H ,lI,e51TeJIbHO-
CTH OKa3bIBaeTC51B03MO)!(HbIM H nOCJIe HapYIlleHH51 JIlO60H 'IaCTH KOPbI
)!(HBOTHOrO,-H 3TH 3KcnepHMeHTbI cpasy )!(e CTaB51Tnozt COMHeHl1e
TOT B3rJI51,lI" 'ITO B OCHOBe 06pa30BaHH51 HaBbIKOB JIe)!(HT HeBpOJIOrH-
qeCKHH MexaHH3M OT,lI,eJIbHbIX,crporo JIOKaJIH30BaHHbIX nYTeH. Onsrru
nOKa3aJIH, 'ITO MbI CTOHM nepen nepeCTpOHKOH scex OCHOBHbIXnpan-
~HnOB, KorropbIMlf MbI npHBbIKJIiH cnepaposan. B 'HameM aH3JIH3e
HeBpO,lI,HHa'MlI'IeCKHX nponeccos: npe:,lI,CTaSJI;eHHe0 M03re KaK 0 CH-
creue HeBpOHHbIX emonru, COCTaBJI5llOIlI.HX6a3y pe<pJIeKTOpHhIX ax-
roa.s-nasaaaer ycrynarr, csoe MeCTO cosepureuuo ,n:pyroMy B033pe-
HHlO aa M03r, KaK na ~eJIOCTHbIH peryaapyiounnt anrrapar, 06JIa,lI,alO-
IlI.HI1 H3BeCTHOH HHTerpaTHBHOH <pYHK~lfeH H ,lI,eHCTBYlOIlI.HHno COBep-
IlIeH'HO OC06bIM' .zr,lfHaMlf'IeCKHM npnauarraa 1

1 B rOJlbKO sro asnuemuen 3aMeqareJlbHolt KHHre «Brain Mechanisms and Intel-

ligence» J19111IIHnaer oxepx CBOHX xpaltae anrepecnux Hllett.
 ME)/{ll,YHAPOlI,HbIH KOHrPECC nCHXOJIorOB 95

3a OCHOBY noaezieana aauaaaror rrpHHHMaTbC5I He OTneJlbHble

perpaesropnue aKTbI, HO ooaee oounre H 60JIee Il.eJIbHble CHCTeMblaK-
THBHOCTH, C novoun.ro KOTOPbIX OCYlll.eCTBJI5IeTC5Inpacnocorinenne
opranaaaa K cpe.ae. ;:ho rrOJIO)!{eHHe 6blJIO nonraepacneao H pa3BHTo
aa xoarpecce Il.eJIbIM PR.ll.OM.ll.OKJIa.ll.OB, HCXO.ll.51lll.HX
H3 sxcnepaxearos
Hci.ll. caMbIM pa3JIHlIHbIM. MJTepHaJIOM. 113BecTHbIH aMepHKaHcKHH HC-
cnenoaare.n, K 0 r x H JI JI (Coghill) nOKa3aJI na xarepaane pa3BHTH5I
aKCOJIOT
Jl5f, -rro OT.ll.eJlbHble perpxexropnue .ll.BH){{eHH5Ipa3BHBalOTC5I Y
Hero 3Ha1.fW!1eJIb'H0
nosnnee, 1.feMo6W;He xpyrmsre ,lI,BH)!{eHH5Iscero re-
Jla HJlH 60VIblllliX C,HCTeM,H lI110 perpaexropnsre ,lI.BH)!{e'HHH,aanpavep
nam.ua, HBJlHlO1'CHna caMOM .ll.eJIe pY.ll.HMeHTOM, ocra'rouuoii <pOPMOH
OT 60JIee pamrax, 06lll.HX .ll.BH)!{eHHHI{OHe1.fHOCTH,B nO)lp06Hb1X HCCJle-
.ll.OBaHHHXKOrXHJIJlOM 6bIJIa npocneacena 3aBHGHMOCTb01]',lI,eJlbHbIX .ll.BH-
)!{eHHii OT TaKHX 06lll.HX <paKTOPOB, KaK rrOJIO)!{eHHe TeJIa )KHBOTHoro
H T. .ll.. Ty ace aaxonoaepaocrs JI e B H H (Lewin) rrpOCJIe.ll.HJI H na
MaJI,eHbKHX ,lI;eT5IX, ,lI,eMOHcTpiHpoBaB ci-esny na HCKJllOlIHTeJIbHO anre-
pecasrx <p11JIbMaX,-rro pa3B11TtHlepedeuxa He H'JlJerrno n~H OCJlO)!{He-
HH5I OT,lI,eJIbHbIX pe<pJIeKTOpHbIX ,lI,BH)!{eHHH B 60JIee xpynaue H CJlO)!{-
nsre rpyrrrrbI, HO rro rryTH ,lI,H<p<pepeHIl.HaIl.HH,BbIlIJIeHeHH5I OT.ll.eJIbHbIX
pea'KIl.H'H as ooeree ll:eJlOCTHbIX, AH<P<PY3HbIX cacresr ABH)!{eHH5I. Ha
pa3HbIX sranax pa3BHTH5I, KaK 31'0 6bIJIO rrOKa3aHOJIeBHHbIM, )lBH)!{eHH5I
orrpe,meJI5IlOTC5IC O)lHOH C1'OPOHbI CT P Y K T Y P 0 H B C e H K 0 H K P e T-
H 0 H CP e zt bI, KOTOpa5I BbI3bIBaeT npacnocooarexsnue 'peaKIl.HH pe-
6eHKa,-H C .ll.pyroH-,lI,eHCTBHeM .ll.OMHHHPYlOlll.HX, aeztyutnx CHCTeM,
xoropue CMeH5IlOTC5Ina Ka)!{;lI,OM arane pOCTa perieaxa (TaKa5I ,lI,OMH-
aapyrouras CHCTeMa cnaxana euie He BbI.ll.eJI5IeTC5IH3 ,lI,H<P<PY3Ho-pea-
rRp~lOIll;eH M0'l10plH~H, 3a11e'MTaKOH 5IBJI5I'eTC5Ixsararomas pysa, yxce
3aTeM rr05IBJl5IeTC5IBe.ll.Ylll.HH xa paxrep orrTH1.feCKOH CHCTeMbI npncno-
CO6 JIeHll'H, lIT06bI B ,lI,aJlbHeHmeM OHa CMeHH'JIaCb HOBbIMH Be.ll.YllI.I1MH
CHCTeMaMlI). 06a1 OCHOBHbIX YCJIOBR5I-TOrrOJIOrH5I rrOJI5I, B KOTOPOMHa-
XO)lHTC5I oprauasa, 11 crpyxrypa ero aenyunrx CHCTeM-Orrpe)leJI5IlOT
cnoacnsre <pOPMbI ero nosenenas H ztaror B03MO)!{HOCTb B HeKOTopbIX
CJIYlla5IX npencxaaunars, KaK CJlO)!{HTCHero M01'OlPlHKaB 1'0',1 IIJIH HIIOH
cHTyaIl.HH.
BceMH 3THMH HCCJle.ll.OBaHH5IMH
C03,l1,aeTC5IHOBa5I CHCTeMa rrOHHTHH,
B 3Ha1.f'HTeJIbHOHcrenenn ;Ima5I, lIeM Ta, ,()IT K0'l10POI.HnpHiBbIKJIH ,HCXOJ-
).(HTb asropsr, 'OCHOBbIBaBllIHeC5IIHa MeXaHHCTHlieCKOH KOHIl.errIl.HH. Flo-
H5ITHe nosezreaas, KaK pe3YJIbTaT KOM6HHaIl.HH OT.ll.eJIbHbIX perpnexrop-
HblX aK110B, 3aIMeH5IeTC5I3,l1,eCb .ll.pyrHM rrQHHMaHHe:M ero, B OCHOBe
xoroporo Jle)!{UT K'OIHll:err~H5ICJlO){{HbIX ,lI,H'HaMH1.fe'CKlIlX
1I3MeHeHH'd, see-
rzra 60JIee HJIH MeHee Il.eJIOCTHbIX, HOC5Illl.HX aa pa3HbIX aranax :pa3-
BHTHH HeO.ll.HHaKOBbIH CTPYKTYPHbIH xapaxrep, axerourax HeO,ll,HHaKO-
syio ,lI,H<p<pepeHIl.HpOBaI-:tHOCTb,
HO scerna .ll.HHaMH1.feCKHX.3Ta xoauen-
'96 A. P.JlYPHfl

IJ,II5I, KOTOpa51 B CPl13110JIOflUI 11 rrCI1XOHeBpOJIOrl1l1 BI1.l1.HMOnpaxo.aar

na CMeHY rrpl1MI1TI1BHOMY MeXaHI1CTl1qeCKOMY MI1POB033peHI1IO, eure He
pa3BI1JIaCb BO Bcei1: csoefi rrOJIHOTe,-HO npnxonsurae co scex CTOPOH
(cpI13HOJIOrH5111 HeBpO.ll.I1HaMI1Ka, reHeTH'-IeCKa51 H rraT~JI0rl1qeCKa51 ncn-
XOJIorl151) BbIBO.ll.bI C03.l1.alOT sneuaraenae, '-ITO Ml1pOBa51 rrCI1XOHeBpo-
,JI0rl151 rrepeacasaer cen-rac cepsesaua KPI13I1C, 113 xoroporo OH? Y)Ke
nanauaer BbIXO.ll.I1Tb.
COBepllIeHHO rrOH5ITHO, '-ITO B YCJIOBI151Xsanazmon HaYKI1, KOTOpa51
HaXO)J;I1TC5IB OKpY)KeHI1I1 l1.l1.eaJII1CTl1qeCKoi1:CPI1JIOCOCPHI1
11 11aorzra
CJIl1llIKOM MaJIO )J;YMaeT 0 rrpaBHJIbHOH, OCHOBaHHOHna Hay q H 0 i:1 cP11-
,JI 0 C 0 cP1111 MeTO)J;OJIOrl1l1,-B YCJIOBI151X3TOH HaYKI1 npeo.aoaeaae Me-
XaHI1CmQ,eCKI1X KOHIJ,errIJ,I1H
OQeHb '-IaCTO BbIJlI1BaeTC5I B peIJ,I1.l1.I1BbI
nnea-
JIHCTI1QeCKI1X nonxozoa K rrCI1XHKe. Ha xonrpecce, 0 KOTOPOM nner
pe-n., 3TOT rrpouecc 6bIJI Y.lI.l1BI1TeJIbHO 5lpKO 3aMeTeH. K Kpl1T11Ke Me-
XaHI1CTHi4>eCKIOJlO
rroztxona 'K rrOBe:,ll!e:HHIO rrpllcO'e.ll.l1lfiHJIliCb ,1I;OKJIa,lLbI
He~oToPbIX Y'-IeHbIX, xoropue, rrpHHI1Ma51 ll;eJIHlWM n05lCHeHI151 0 TOM,
QTO nCI1)QoArI151 ,lI:OJI)KHa 113YQaTb ll;eJIbHYIO JII1l.JHOCTb, C.lI.eJIaJIII 1I3
aroro COBepllIeHHO BbIXO)J;51w.l1eII3 npenenos nOJIO)KIITeJIbHoi1: HaJ:'KH
BbIBO.ll.bI.
MbI OCTaHOBI1MC5I3)J;eCb TOJIbKO na O.ll.HOM.lI.OKJIa.ll.e,npO'-ll1TaHHOM
na KOHrpecce-He3HaQIITeJIbHOM no CBoeMY Y)J;eJIbHOMY secy, HO CI1MO-
TOMaTII'-IHOM no CBoe:H CPOJIOCOCPCKOIi1:
YCTaHOBKe.
B noxaaae 0 nepasrx cpopMax cnoaraaaoro rrOBe.ll.eHI151Y perienxa,
Ill. G 10 JI e p (Buhler) TaK »ce, Ka;K 11 yxasannsre auure asropu, I1CXO-
.lI.HJIa 113 Kpl1TI1KI1 MeXaHI1CTI1l.JeCKOrOnoaxo.aa K rrCI1XOJIorl1l1; O.ll.HaKO,
3Ta Kpl1TI1Ka HarrpaBJI5IJIaCb 5ICHO Bblpa)KeHHbIM l1)J;eaJII1CTI1l.JeCKIIM
MII-
POB033peHI1eM 11 OTBO)J;I1JIa)J;aJIeKO OT rex OO.ll.JII1HHOHaYl.JHbIX 11 CTI1-
XI1i1:HO-.lI.IIaJIeKTl1'-1eCKI1XrrOJIO)KeHI1H, K KOTOPbIM rrpIIBO)J;I1JIHyxasauaue
HaMH Bblme asropsr. 510JIep I1C)QO.IJjHJlia
II13110nO, 1f110 noeeaeaae 4>eI-
,JIOBeKa xapaKTepII3yeTC5I He O)J;HI1M,.a )J;BYM5I5IBHO Bblpa)KeHHbIMH, HO
rJIy60Ko pa3JII1'-1HbIMI1 rrpI1HIJ,110aMII: noneneaae MaJIeHbKOro peoeaxa
MO)KHO CBeCTII K .lI.e5lTeJIbHOCTI1'-I11C110peaKT11BHOH; OHa aa l.JI1HaeTC5I
C BHemHeJlO paanpaaeeaaa H CBQI.IJjIITC5I
K MexaHH3MY OTBIeTHbIX ABHr
)K,eHIIH; O.ll.HaKO 6bIJIO 6bI OllII160'-lHbIM nosenenae B3pOCJIOro '-IeJIO-
sexa CBO)J;IITb K TaKOMY MeXaHI13MY; B HeM .lI.eHCTBYIOT11)J;PyrIIe CI1JIbI:
B3POCJIbI}I '-IeJIOBeK CTaBI1T nepezt C060H IJ,eJII111 ocyuiecraaser I1X. Ta-
xce nosenenae pesxo OTJII1'-1HOOT peaKTI1BHOrO, 11 GIOJIep Ha3bIBaeT
ero crrOHTaHHbIM. I1MeHHo B 3TOH COOHTaHHOCT'Hrrp05lBJI5IeTC5I cosep-
urenao .apyroa rrpI1HIJ,l1o' )K113He)J;e5l'r:eJIbHOCTH,crreIJ,l1cpl1'-1HbIHAJI5I '-Ie-
,JIOBeKa,H GIOJIep BI1)J;I1TB 3TOM BH)J;e rroseneans )J;ei1:CTBHeaKTHBHoro
Ha'-laJIa-«.lI.eHcTseHiloil .lI.YWII» (cdie wirkende Seele»); 3a.ll.al.JeI1CBOI1X
Ha6JIIO.lI.eHI1}! Ha)J; .lI.eTbMII OHa II C'-II1TaeT rrpOCJIe)KIIBaHl1e Toro MOMeH-
 ME)f{.D,YHAPO.D,HbIM KOHrPECC nCHXOJIorOB 97

'ra, xorna nOSlBJIHeTCSl9Ta ssrcmaa <pOpMa nCHXlItlJec~OIrl .ll!e!51TeJIbHOCTH

H peaKTHBHOe noseneaae OCJIO}!{HSleTC5ICnOHTaHHbIM 1.
MbI npHBeJIIH 9TOT AOKJIa.zr;ormoas He! H3-3a 'ern HaYlJHoi1: 3HaqH-
MOCTH; .MhI npHB.eJIH ero JlHlIlb KaK CHMnTOM, YKa3hIBalOUlHH na TO, KY-
,ZI.aMomeT 9BOJIIO~HOHHpOBaTb aanazna nCHX'OIJIOrH5I,pacrymas B OK-
pyacenaa 6yp}!{ya3HoH <pHJIOC0<pHH.
BbIcTyrrHBillHM a 60JIh:lIIHM )JjOKJla.rr.OM
na TeMy «Hayxa 0' JIHlJHOCTID>
H3BecTHbI'i1: HeMe~K'I1H nCHXOJIOr B. III r-e pir (W. Stern) YKa3aJI, lJTO
Ha1YKa 10 lJeJIOBe,QleCKOH
JIII14HIOCTHSlBJISleTC5IOOBepmleHHQ cne~H,<p,I1ilJHdii
HMeHHO B CllJIY uenocmoro, nCHX'o<pH3i'NeCKO-HeiffrpaJIbHOrO xapax-
Tep'a JrH4HOCTIH;'HMleHHloIB QlWIY 'POllO, QTO qeJIOBeK COICTOII1T
«He! TOJIbKIO
H3 <paKTOB, HO H lI3 B03MO}!{HOCTeH», a 9TH B03MO}!{HOCTH onpe.aeasror-
CSl .lJaCTO ero rJIy6i1HHbIMH «cnOHTaHHbIMH» YCTaHOBKaMH,-H3y.lJeHHe
JIHlJHOCTH .zr,OJI}!{HOHTTH 'COBeplIIeHHO HHbIMH nyT5IMH, lJeM re, KOTOPbl-
MH 06b1lJHO H.zr,eTBCSlKa51nayxa. «Der psychologishe Blick», nCHXOJIO-
rHlJeCKa51 MHTyaU.H5I-iO"f'HlO.zr,b Hie .lI.IOiJDK'Ha6bITb HCKJflOlJ'e!Ha H3 HH-
serrraps nCHXOJIOrHlJeCKHX MeTO,lIiOtB; JOHa OKa3bIBaeTC5I nacro B co-
cr05lHHiH .zr,aTb.zr,OCTaTOlJHO
a)l,9KBa-moe rrepsoe np:H6JIH}!{eHlfe K asy-rae-
MOMY ~eJIOMy; xY.ll.O}!{eCTBeHHbIe MeTo.zr,bI B nCHXOJIOrHH .zr,OJI}!{HbIrre-
pecrars TpaKTOBaTbC5I TaK IOTopBaHHO lOT HaYlJHbIX, KaK 9TO 6bIJIO
pant-me.
E,ZI.Ba JIH MO}!{HO npHH5ITb rronorinue YTBep}!{.lI.eHH5I 6e3 .!l.OCTaTOlJ-
HOH KpHTlIKH, ensa JIll OHH MoryT He BbI3BaTh uenoro pana caxux
onpeneaeaaux B03pa}!{eHHH COCTOPOHbI Ka)!{,ZI.OrOMaTeplIaJIHCTlIlJeCKH
MbICJI5Imero nClIXOJIOra. O.zr,HaKO, HX cyurecrsoaanae xapaxrepasyer
TO cneuarpaxecxoe COCT05lHHe, xoropoe nepeacaaaer ceasac sarranao-
eBponeHCKa51 nCHXOJIOr1I5I.
HaXO.lI.5lCb B nOJIQ)IH~HlIH T5IrQa:i1:llieno Kp1I31Ica, npeono.resas Me-
xaHlICTHlJeCKlIe KOH~en~HH, OHa HMeHHO B CHJIY C11lIXlIHHoro xapaxre-
pa sroro npouecca .,ZI.aJIeKOHe scer.aa OKa3bIBaeTC5I B COCT05lHHH BbIH-
TlI 113 aroro Kp1I3Hca rr06e,lI;H'TM6M; II ecmr, C O,l(HOIHCTOPOHbI, MbI BH-
.lI.HM pan CHMnTOMOB, oeccnopao roaopsumx 0 TOM, lJTO B pe3YJIbTaTe
aroro KpH3Hca C03.l1.aeTC5IHOBa5l, .lI.lIHaMHlJeCKa5l, HO BnOJIHe OTBelJalO-
maa Tpe6oBaHH5IM HaYlJHOH MeTo.zr,OJIOrlIH KOH~err~1I5I,-TO B03pO)!{.lI.e-
HHe psna BlITaJflIC11HlJeCKlI:X H H,lJJeaJIllCTlIlJeCKlIX rrOCTpOeHHH: YKa3bI-
saer, ,lITO TaKasr orpOMfIlclli Ba}!{HOCTlI sanasa, KaK npeonoaeaae crapsrx,
OT)!{HBalOmlIX TOlJeK 3peH1I5I, MO}!{eT 6bITh npaBlIJIhHO paspeureua JIHlIIb
C IIiOMO:W:blOrJIY6ioKo np0.ll.YMaiIrHOH II <plIJIIO:CO<pCKHI
060cHiOBaHHO:H ,ZI.lI-
aJIeKTHlJeCKOH MeTO,Zl.OJIOrHH.
MHe XO'T'eJIOChKOHlJHTb 911<YT KpaT'Kli'H OlJ~P'K napaJIJIeJIH~H, KOTO-

13TH n03HUHH Bionep paasarsr B ee crarse «Zwei Grundtypen der Lebenspro-

zessen, Zeitschrift f. Psichologie Bd 108. H. sh.
7 HaYQHOe CJlOBO JI& 4.
 A. A. JJYPHf/

pue HeH36e)!{HO )I.OJI)KHbI nanpauraaarscs. B cenrscpe 1929 r. MHe'

npHllIJIOCb 6bITb aa Me)!{,lI.YHapO,lI.HOMnCHXOJIOrH4eCKOM xoarpecce B'
Aaepaxe; B ansape 1930 r.-4epe3 4eTblpe MeC5Il1.a-H npHcYTcTBO-
'BaJI aa I ct.eszte no noae.aenmo 4eJIOBeKa B Jlennnrpane.
Coeepuremro nOH5ITHtO, lf1'O Kam,lI.bI'M cne3)I. npe,lI.CTaBJIHeT xapax-
rep Toii CTpaHbI, B KOTOPOM OH coonpaerca, TOM HaYKH, KOTopaH ero
rnrraer. Ilpo IOl6a ct-eana, WCYI10pbI,e
MbI ceH4ac cpamrasaea, 1\'IO)!{HO
CKa3aTb 11 ropaano 60JIbllIe,e: Ka)!{)I.bIH li3 HHX npe,lI.CTaBJIHeT He TOJIb-
KO onpe,lI.eJIeHHYIO CTpaHY, HO orrpeneneaasnt 'COl1.HaJIbHbIHYKJIa,lI., on-
'p'e,lI.eJIeHHYIO 4aCTb ooapeaeanoro MHpa, Ha'WOHel1.--<onpe,lI.eJIeHHbIM
KJIaCC, C ccapaxrepusnra ,lI.JIH Hero YCTaHOBKaMH H H,lI.eOJIOrHeH. AMe-
pHKaHCKHH xonrpecc :npe)I.CTaBJIHeT HaYKY, KaK OHa pa3BHBaeTCH B Ka-
nHTaJIHCTH4eCKHX crpanaxsana.aa H AMepHI<H; BceCOlO3HbIH C'be3,lI. no
nOBe,lI.eHHIO 4eJIOBeKa-HaYKY, 'KaK OHa pacrer B crpaae CTpOIOll1.erOCH.
COl1.HaJIHCTH4eCKoro06ll1.eCTBa, II B 3110M-06a OIH'¥[npe)I.CTaBJI5IIOT )1.Ba.
rnyooxo pa3JIH4HbIX npanunna HaY4HOM opraaasaunn H naysnoro
'MbIllIJIeHH5I.
Hayxa He MO)!{eT He 6blTb 06ll1.eCTBeHHoM; OHa )I.OJI)!{Ha opraaase-
CIQf ytfH'rblBaTb 3a)I.a4H 06ll1.eCTBeHHlOHlKHi3HH,6bITb CB5I3aHHO;H
CHHMH ~
n03TOMY ona )I.OJI)!{Ha 6bITb HaYKoH, CTPOHll1.elicH nJIaHOBO. HaYKa-He
qaCTHOe )I.eJIo, H H3Y'lJeHHe 4eJIOBeKa ecrs TaKoH ace pusar CTpOHll1.erO-
C5I 06ll1.eCTBa, KaK pa3BHTHe HOBbIX ¢a6pHK H rrpaoopereane H'OiBbIX
MallIHH. TaKHe H,lI.eH JIe)!{aT B OCHOBe OpraHl-I3al1.HH HaYI~H. B uamev
COI03e, TaKHe H)I.eH 6bIJIH nOJI,0)KeHbI B OCHOBY aaurero ct.esna no no-
Be)IJeHHIO 4eJIOBeKa, 'KIOTIOP,bIH
npe)l.CTaBJI5IJI Ba)!{HreJHllme OeKTOp'bI 3T'0-
ro nJIaHOBOro HaY4Horo CTpOHTeJIbCTBa.
I1MeHHo 3TO npeacrasaaer nepsoe H xopeanoe pa3JIH4He Me)!{)I.Y
:HHM' H 'I1eM aMe!pUKaHCKHM WOHrpe.CCIOM;KOl'OPOMY MbI nOCBHTHJIH
nam 04epK. HenJIaHOBa51 H CJIY4aHHaH, OCHOBaHHaHna JIH4HOH HHHl1.Ha-
THBe H JIH4HOH KOHKypeHl1.HH, KanHTaJIHCTH4eCKaH cncrexa He MO)!{eT
ue )l.a'rb C110JIb»ce HlenJl(lHOBOH 11 CJIY4aHHoH, pacnanaiouieacx ua 0'1"-
,lI.eJIbHbIe 60JIee IfJIH MeHee H30JIHpOBaHHbIe H4eHKH, HaYKH; B CBOIO04e-
pens=-rasaa HaYKa HeH36e)!{HO zraer M03aH4HbIH H pa3,lI.p06JIeHHbIH
na )I.eC5ITKH 4aCTHblX np06JIeM C'be3)I.. I1MeHHo 3TO 6bIJIO ocorienno
HCHO BH)r,HO na aMepHKaHcKoM xoarpecce: re 450 )l.OKJIa)I.OB, xoropue
aa HeM 6bIJIH 3a'lHTaHbI, npe)I.craBJIHIOT He TOJIbKO COBepmeHHO pas-
'JlH4HYIO lleHHOCTb, HO H COBepllIeHHO «CJIY4aHHYIO» KOM6HHallHIO npo-
6JIeM.
KOHe4HO, 3Ta «CJIY4aHHOCTb» 6bIJIa TOJIbKO Ka)!{Yll1.eHCH, H na ca-
MOM ,lI.eJI,ec'b'OO,lI.npe1:r.cTaBJI5IJIB nepBYIO 104epe,lI.b p'H)I. np06JIeM, CTH-
XHMHlO BbI)I.BHHyr'bIX oOOBpeMeHHbIMsranox '06ll1.eCTBeHH'OrO pa3BHTH5I,
.BQcflHTaHHe HaBbmOB H nCHXOJIOrHH xapaxrepa, nsynenae JIH"IHOCTH H
TeCrOJIOrHHCTHXHHHO 6bIJIH BbI,lI.BHHYTbI na nepssn! nJIaH ct.es.aa KaI<...
 ME}/{D,YHAPOD,HbIH KOHr?ECC nCI1XOJIorOB 99

KOJIll'leTBOM rrpe.n.CTaBJIe'HHbIX,mOKJIa.ll!OB,
TaK II Toli aynnropaeli, KOrrO-
pas OOOpaJIaCblHa 3TlIX aacenaaasx. O.n.HaKI()I,l{TO! cavoe sasoroe, aMe-
iPIIfK3JHCKHHcsean, .ll!aB OT'Ier 0 nponenanaux orr.n.'eJIbHbIMH rrCHXOJIOi-
raMH HCCJIe.n.OBaHll5lX,He cnenan onpenenenaon p a 6 a T sr: OH He CIIJIO-
TllJI Y'leHbIX BOKPyr xatorx-naoyzn, lI.e1I'TpaJIbHbIX rrp06JIeM, He .n.aJI
xaxnx HH6y.n.b oonmx YCTaHOBOK, H KOHeqHO He rrpOH3BeJI xaxoro HH-
6Y)l.b opraHll30BaHHoro c.n.BHra B pa3BllTllll HaYKll.
I1MeHHo 3THM OH OTJIH'IaJIC5II()ITGOBeTCKOf'O ci.es.aa no noseneumo
qeJIOBeKa, KOTOPbll1 6bIJI sees nponaxnyr e.n.HHoH MeTo.n.OJIOrH'IeCKOH
YCTaHOBKOHH J<OTOPbIHHMeHHO B CHJIYaroro 51BHJIC5I
MOlll.HbIM opraua-
3YIOllI.HM rpaxropox B pa3BJITlIlI COBeTcwOIt'IHa)TKl1.
COBpeMeHHa51 HaYKa .n.OllIJIa .n.o He06xo.n.HMOCTH 60JIbllIHX CHHTe-
THqeCKHX H3bICKaHHH, a 3TH CHHTeTH'IeCKHe H3bICKaHH5I ~Q)j{eT COBep-
llIHTb JIHllIb opraaaaoaaaaoe H rrJIaHOBOe HaY'IHOe HCCJIe.n.OBaHHe,
ncxoznnuee H3 llIHPOKllX H rrpaBHJIbHbIX MeTo.n.OJIOfHqeCKHXYCTaHOBOK.
K CO>KaJIeHHIO,06ll1.eCTBeHHbIH YKJIa.n. 3arra.n.a H AMepHKH He CO-
.n.eHCTByeT pa3BHTHIO TaKoro rrJIaHOBOro xapaxrepa HaYKH, ncxonsuica
as rrpaBHJIbHbIX H rro.n.JIHHHO-HaY'IHblX MeTo.n.OJIOrH'IeCKHX OCHOB; rpop-
Mbl 06ll1.eCTBeHHoH opraaaaauaa CTaB5IT non sonpoc nepsoe, npar-aa-
TH3M H BJIH5IHHe rrpHMHTHBHblX 'HJIH H.n.eaJI1HCTH'IeCKHX
KOHlI.enll.HH-
OCJIO)J{H5IIOT
sropoe. O.n.HaKO 3.n.eCbMbI BbIXO.n.HMH3 rrpezreaoa naurero
oxepxa, H .n.OJI)J{HbIycryrnrn, MeCTO COll.HOJIOry, OT xoroporo Mhl
6y.n.eM )J{)l.aTb aHaJIH3a cyneo sananaoa HaYl<H, pa3BHBalOllI.eHC5I ,B
YCJIOBH5IX KarrHTaJIHcruqeCKOH KYJIbTYPbl.

7*