Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In this study, the pore structure of magnesium potassium phosphate cement paste is investigated using
Received 26 June 2014 mercury intrusion porosimetry. Several mix proportions, obtained by changing the magnesia-to-phos-
Accepted 31 July 2014 phate molar ratio (M/P) and the water-to-cement mass ratio (W/C) of the material, are involved. It is
Available online 14 August 2014
found that lower W/C and longer material age make the porosity lower and the pore structure finer.
When the W/C is kept constant, both porosity and critical pore diameter are not monotonic functions
Keywords: of M/P, but the M/P of 6 gives the lowest porosity and the smallest critical pore diameter. Also, the
Magnesium potassium phosphate cement
M/P of 6 shows the highest compressive strength and the lowest intrinsic permeability. Based on the
Chemically bonded ceramics
Pore structure
experimental results, empirical models describing the relations between the properties and pore struc-
Compressive strength ture parameters (porosity / and critical pore diameter dc) of MKPC paste are developed. The compressive
2
Intrinsic permeability strength is inversely proportional to /, and the intrinsic permeability is directly proportional to dc /.
Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction only, but also the rate of this reaction is easier to be controlled
because KDP has smaller dissociation constant and lower solubility
Magnesia–phosphate cements (MPCs) are low-temperature than ADP. Due to these two advantages, MKPC seems to be more
high-strength materials formed by through-solution acid–based favored in recent years [3–6,18–20]. As frequently cited
reaction between dead burned magnesia and phosphate [1], and [11,18,21], the chemical reaction between MKPC and water can
also known as chemically bonded ceramics [2]. MPCs have been be written as
widely utilized in many engineering applications, including repair
MgO þ KH2 PO4 þ 5H2 O ! MgKPO4 6H2 O ð1Þ
and rehabilitation of civil structures [3], treatment of waste water
[4,5], stabilization of toxic matters and nuclear wastes [6–10], den- and this can be approximately assumed to be the sole reaction in a
tal and bone restorations [11,12], and so on. In civil engineering, MKPC paste [22].
MPCs are frequently used as repair materials for pavements and In the literature, most of the studies on MPCs seemed to directly
structures, as they set very fast and produce high strength patches focus on the engineering properties of MPCs-based materials, e.g.
with low permeability, little drying shrinkage and good durability setting time, fluidity and strength, to obtain optimized formula
[13–17]. Two types of MPCs appear the most frequently in both based on locally available raw materials [3,16–20], and a few
engineering practice and academic research, one uses ADP (ammo- investigated the reaction mechanisms of MPCs [23–26]. In the
nium dihydrogen phosphate) while the other uses KDP (potassium above-mentioned applications, trial-and-error strategy was nor-
dihydrogen phosphate) as the phosphate components. The former mally used, while the material, to the authors’ knowledge, can still
can be termed as MAPC, and the latter MKPC, as the main reaction not been effectively designed so far. To design the material, the
products in the two systems are magnesium ammonium phos- microstructure and its influence on the macroscopic engineering
phate (MAP) hexahydrate and magnesium potassium phosphate properties have to be fully studied. Pore structure is an effective
(MKP) hexahydrate, respectively. Compared with MAPC, MKPC representation of the microstructure, and the mechanical proper-
does not generate unpleasant odor when it reacts with water not ties as well as transport properties of a porous material are
strongly related to its pore structure. Therefore, it is imperative
⇑ Corresponding author. Tel.: +852 23588751. to study the pore structure of MPCs-based materials, for better
E-mail addresses: mhy1103@gmail.com (H. Ma), zongjin@ust.hk (Z. Li). understanding their performance.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.07.073
0261-3069/Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
498 H. Ma et al. / Materials and Design 64 (2014) 497–502
In the present study, the pore structure of MKPC paste is firstly The critical pore diameter, corresponding to the steepest point on a
examined by MIP (mercury intrusion porosimetry), in terms of cumulative porosity curve or the highest point on a logarithmic
porosity, pore size distribution and critical pore diameter, to see differential porosity curve [27,29], was also determined as an index
how the pore structure is affected by key material parameters, of the pore structure connectivity. It has been proven that the
including W/C (the water-to-cement mass ratio), M/P (the magne- critical pore diameter has strong relations with both diffusivity
sia-to-phosphate molar ratio) and the material age. Furthermore, and permeability of a porous material [30,31].
the evolutions of compressive strength and intrinsic permeability The fresh pastes were also cast into cubic molds, with the side
of MKPC paste following increasing ages are measured, and their length of 40 mm, for the purpose of compressive strength mea-
relations with the pore structure are finally obtained in light of surement. Disk-shaped specimens were also prepared to deter-
mathematical fittings. mine the intrinsic permeability. All specimens were cured under
the same conditions as mentioned above. At the ages of 3, 7 and
2. Materials and experiments 28 days, compressive strengths were tested according to ASTM
C109, on a MTS 815 ROCK Mechanics machine [32], and the gas
In experiments, MKPC pastes were made from dead burnt mag- permeability coefficients were also tested according to the method
nesia powder (calcined under 1500 °C for 5 h) with a purity of used by Shi et al. [33] using nitrogen gas. The gas permeability
95.1%, powder KDP (chemical reagent) and deionized water. The coefficient was then transformed to intrinsic permeability of the
magnesia powder was supplied by Jinan Magnesia-Carbon Brick material as
Plant Co. Ltd., Shandong, China, and the KDP by Guangzhou Chem-
lk
ical Reagent Factory, Guangdong, China. Mix proportions involved j¼ ð3Þ
in the experiments, in terms of W/C and M/P, are listed in Table 1.
qg
In the table, the mixed pastes were named by character strings, of where j (m2) is the intrinsic permeability of the material, which is
which the former half indicates the W/C and the latter half indi- fluid independent, and k (m/s) is the nitrogen gas permeability
cates the M/P. For example, W15M04 indicates a paste with the coefficient. Besides, g (m/s2) denotes the gravitational acceleration,
W/C of 0.15 and the M/P of 4. In the mix proportions, W/C ranges q (kg/m3) and l (Pas) denote the density and dynamic viscosity of
from 0.15 to 0.5, and M/P from 4 to 12. For specimen preparation, nitrogen gas, respectively. It is worth noting that all tests were
powders were first weighted according to the M/P and dry-mixed, repeated for three times, and the average values are reported in
then mixed with a specific mass of water as calculated from the the present paper.
W/C. Note that the cement included magnesia and KDP only, and
retarder was not used, as the initial set times of all the listed mix-
tures were longer than 10 min due to the relatively low reactivity 3. Results
of the heavily calcined magnesia. The mixing procedure involved
firstly dry-mixing the powders for 1 min and then further mixing 3.1. Pore structure of MKPC paste
them with water for 3 min, in a vertical-axis planetary mixer.
The mixed fresh pastes were cast into plastic tubes with the 3.1.1. Influence of material age
diameter of 2 cm and then sealed by plastic sheets. The specimens Employing MIP results, the pore structure can be illustrated by
were de-molded and sealed in airtight plastic bags after 12 h, and two tools, i.e. the cumulative porosity curve describing the relation
placed at 25 ± 1 °C. At the ages of 3, 7 and 28 days, specimens were between the porosity and the logarithmic pore diameter, and the
taken out of the bags. After skin removed, the central portions of logarithmic differential porosity curve showing the slope changing
the specimens were sawn into small cuboids with the smallest of the cumulative porosity curve. The pore structure evolutions of
dimensions of 3–5 mm. The obtained cuboids were then vacuum- aged MKPC pastes are shown in Fig. 1, which takes the paste
dried to constant weight, and used as samples for pore structure W15M04 as an example. Comparing the cumulative porosity
measurement by MIP, as recommended by Ma [27]. The total curves (black), it can be seen that the porosity decreases continu-
porosity intruded by mercury was used as an index of porosity, ously with increasing ages. This is a certain result of the continuous
although it is normally slightly lower than the true porosity [28]. reaction between the cement components and water, which gener-
The pore size distribution was obtained in light of the well-known ates more and more solid phase. In addition, the cumulative poros-
Washburn equation, i.e. ity curves slightly move toward the small pore size direction,
showing the refinement of the pore structure. On each logarithmic
4c cos h
d¼ ð2Þ porosity curve (red), two peaks can be identified. The primary one
P corresponds to the critical pore diameter, and the secondary one
where d is the equivalent pore diameter, c is the surface tension of may be attributed to the consumed KDP particles in the chemical
mercury, h is the contact angle between the mercury and the pore reaction as shown in Eq. (1).
surface, and P is the applied pressure. As recommended in the liter- In MIP results, the pore size distribution curves can only be used
ature [27], 480 mN/m and 130° can be adopted for c and h, respec- for the purpose of qualitative comparison [28,34], as shown above.
tively, and thus d in lm can be obtained as a function of P in MPa. While the pore structures can be described quantitatively only in
Table 1
Mix proportions, porosities and critical pore diameters of MKPC pastes.
Fig. 1. Pore structure evolution of MKPC paste following increasing ages. Fig. 3. Comparison of the pore structures of MKPC pastes with the same W/C but
different M/P at the age of 3 days.
Fig. 5. Compressive strength evolutions of the MKPC pastes. Fig. 7. Intrinsic permeability evolutions of the MKPC pastes.
phase, the pore phase can significantly affect the strength as it 70 MPa as shown in Fig. 5, the intrinsic permeability varies from
breaks the connectivity of the solid phase [37–40]. All these trends 3 1018 m2 to 2 1015 m2, as shown in Fig. 7, covering 3
are consistent with those of porosities, i.e. the higher the porosity, orders of magnitude. As proven by researchers [42–47], transport
the lower the compressive strength, and vice versa. Since in the properties of a porous material are determined by not only poros-
pore structure parameters, porosity has the strongest relation with ity, but also the way in which the pores are connected.
compressive strength [41–43], a unique relation between com- Katz–Thompson equation [30] is a simple model relating the
pressive strength and porosity is possible to be found. intrinsic permeability of a porous medium to its pore structure,
The compressive strengths shown in Fig. 5 are plotted against and has been validated for many times. It can be expressed as
the corresponding porosities collected in Table 1, as shown in 2
Fig. 6. It is obvious that the compressive strength decreases follow- dc
j¼ ð6Þ
ing the increasing porosities in an inversely proportional way, and 226 F
through curve fitting, the relation can be obtained as where 226 is an analytical constant based on cylindrical pore shape
assumption, and F denotes the formation factor which is unitless.
f c ¼ 434=/ þ 4:29 ð5Þ
Since the formation factor can be related to the porosity as [48]
where fc is the compressive strength in MPa, and the coefficient of sD
determination R2 equals 0.948. F¼ ð7Þ
/
where sD is the diffusion tortuosity which is also unitless, Eq. (6)
3.3. Relation between intrinsic permeability and pore structure
can be re-written as
The evolutions of intrinsic permeability of MKPC pastes are 2
dc /
shown in Fig. 7. Contrary to the evolution of compressive j¼ ð8Þ
226 sD
strength, the intrinsic permeability decreases following increasing
ages in a decelerating manner, due to the filling of pores and the Combining some parameters, an equation which is consistent
refinement of the pore structure. When the M/P is kept constant, with the simple form given by Garboczi [45] can be derived as
higher W/C means higher permeability at the same age. When the
j ¼ b d2c / ð9Þ
W/C is kept constant, the M/P of 6 gives the lowest permeability,
which is followed by 8, 4 and 12 in an ascending order. By a sim- where b is a unitless parameter taking into account the pore phase
ple comparison, one may conclude that the higher the compres- connectivity, being 1 for straight and non-intersecting tubes while
sive strength, the lower the intrinsic permeability. However, smaller in other cases. As will be shown, b can approximately be
unlike compressive strength which varies from 10 MPa to treated as a constant for this material, thus it can be considered that
Fig. 8. The relation between intrinsic permeability and pore structure of MKPC
Fig. 6. The relation between compressive strength and porosity of MKPC paste. paste.
H. Ma et al. / Materials and Design 64 (2014) 497–502 501
2 2
the permeability is determined by dc /. The dc / is thus termed as hydration products, and has a clear physical meaning. Once the
‘‘permeability determiner’’ in this paper. In Fig. 8, the intrinsic per- reaction kinetics of MKPC paste are solved, the degree of reaction
meability values shown in Fig. 7 are plotted against the permeabil- will be considered to define a parameter similar with the gel-space
2
ity determiner dc /. Using Eq. (9) to fit the data sets, b can be ratio, and a physically meaningful model will be developed to pre-
obtained as 3.09 104, with a coefficient of determination R2 as dict the compressive strength, as well as other mechanical proper-
high as 0.967. As shown in Fig. 4, a unique relation between dc ties. Strictly speaking, both the diffusion tortuosity sD in Eq. (8) and
and / does not exist, thus Eq. (9) cannot be further simplified to a the connectivity parameter b in Eq. (9) are pore-structure-depen-
mono-variable equation. dent parameters, rather than constants. However, as proven in a
numerical study, their values vary only in very limited ranges for
a specific type of porous medium [44]. Therefore, considering b
4. Discussion
as a constant will not bring significant errors, which can be proven
somewhat by the fitting shown in Fig. 8.
In the reaction between MPC and water, phosphate is dissolved
continuously in water, and the reaction occurs on the wetted sur-
face of magnesia particles. The reaction products grow around 5. Conclusions
magnesia particles and connect with each other, developing the
cementitious matrix [25]. According to this mechanism, pores orig- The pore structure of MKPC paste is firstly investigated in this
inally occupied by water will decrease undoubtedly in size and vol- study, and then its influences on the compressive strength and
ume following the reaction process. However, when phosphate intrinsic permeability are analyzed. Through this study, several
particles are consumed partially or completely, relatively large conclusions can be drawn as follows:
voids will be left. This hypothesis is sketched in Fig. 9, in light of
an algorithm developed for the microstructure simulation of MKPC (1) Lower W/C and longer age make the porosity lower while
paste [22]. As shown in Fig. 1, in a specific paste, the volume frac- the pore structure finer, which is totally a consequence of
tions of small pores decrease with increasing ages, but those of being expected and not surprising.
pores larger than several microns do not decrease obviously. This (2) When the W/C is kept constant, both porosity and critical pore
phenomenon could be attributed to the voids formed due to the diameter are not monotonic functions of M/P, but the M/P of 6
consumption of KDP, as shown in Fig. 9. gives the lowest porosity and the smallest critical pore diam-
It has been found that when the W/C is constant, the properties, eter. The M/P of 6 also shows the highest compressive
including porosity, critical pore diameter, compressive strength strength and the lowest intrinsic permeability. An optimum
and permeability, are all not monotonic functions of M/P. Similar M/P of MKPC-based material should depends on the chemical
phenomena were also reported by others [3,17,19], who found that composition of the dead burnt magnesia used as raw mate-
the compressive strength and flexural strength are not monotonic rial. Why such an optimum M/P exists cannot be explained
functions of M/P. The optimized M/P in terms of strengths distrib- until the reaction kinetics of this material are revealed.
uted in the range from 4 to 8, perhaps depending on the chemical (3) The compressive strength increases, while the intrinsic per-
composition of the magnesia. The reason of this phenomenon is meability decreases following increasing ages. Generally,
still not clear. Future study on the reaction kinetics of MKPC and higher porosity leads to lower compressive strength, while
water may help to understand it. lower porosity and smaller critical pore diameter result in
A central work of designing a MKPC-based material is to predict lower intrinsic permeability.
its properties based on the proportioning parameters or micro- (4) Two empirical models are developed to describe the relations
structure parameters. Eqs. (5) and (9) provide the ways of predict- between the properties and pore structure of MKPC paste,
ing properties from the pore structure, but valid property–time according to which, the compressive strength is inversely
relation models may be more straightforward and convenient to proportional to porosity (/), and the intrinsic permeability
2
use for design purpose. This is another reason why the reaction is directly proportional to a permeability determiner (dc /).
kinetics, which describe the time-dependency of the degree of
reaction, should be emphasized in future works. It is worth noting
that Eq. (5) is physically meaningless, but a purely empirical Acknowledgement
model. In the case of Portland cement based materials, the com-
pressive strength is directly proportional to the so-called gel-space The financial support from the Hong Kong Research Grants
ratio [41], which indicates the filling ratio of space by cement Council under 615810 is gratefully acknowledged.
502 H. Ma et al. / Materials and Design 64 (2014) 497–502