Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I. Questions
3. Explain the shareholder wealth maximization goal of the firm and how it can
be measured. Make an argument for why it is better goal than maximizing
profit.
Answer: The owner’s perspective holds that the only appropriate goal is to
maximize shareholder wealth. Progress of this goal can be measured using
the stock or share price and the amount of dividends. Moreover, the
competing viewpoint is from the stakeholders’ perspective, which emphasizes
social responsibility over profitability. This view maintains that managers must
maximize the total satisfaction of all stakeholders in a business. While strong
arguments speak in favor of both perspectives, financial practitioners and
academics now tend to believe that the manager’s primary responsibility and
goal should be to maximize shareholder wealth and give only secondary
consideration to other stakeholders’ welfare.
In addition, the invisible hand of market, acting through
compensation and the free price system, would ensure that only those
activities most efficient and beneficial to society as a whole would survive in
the long run. Thus, those same activities would also profit the individual
most. Because when companies try to implement a goal other than profit
maximization, their efforts tend to backfire. Consider the firm that tries to
maximize employment, the higher number of employees raises costs. Soon
the firm will find that its costs are too high to allow it to compete against
more efficient firms, especially in a global business environment. Therefore,
when the firm fails, all employees are let go and employment ends up being
minimized, not maximized.
4. Name and describe as many corporate stakeholders as you can.
Answer: A corporation is defined as type of business organization which has
huge number of stakeholders. So, a corporation has different type of
stakeholder, like, suppliers, owners, investors, creditors, communities, trade
unions, employees, government agencies, customers, and media.
Suppliers are people or businesses who sell goods to your business and
rely on you for revenue from the sale of those goods. It is an external
stakeholder, a secondary stakeholder and an indirect stakeholder.
Owner stakeholders are the owners of an organization. They supply
capital or equity to the business and have a say in how everything runs. It
can be describe as an internal, primary and direct stakeholder.
Investors can include owners but they can also be outside vendors who
typically have a right to accurate and timely information such as regular
financial statements. They may also have the right to approve or reject major
decisions like mergers and acquisitions and they also can contribute ideas and
give advice, bring connections, motivate and help promote and improve the
business image. It is an external, primary and direct stakeholder.
Creditors are the person or institutions who lend money to businesses,
and they could also have a secured interest in the company’s worth. Creditors
can also include banks, suppliers, and bondholders. Creditors are external,
secondary, and indirect stakeholder.
Communities also form part as an example of stakeholder because each
party (the business and the community) are mutually beneficial in different
ways like job creation, safety, economic development, health from
environmental development. Communities are external, secondary, and
indirect stakeholder.
Trade union also called labor union is an organization of workers in a
particular industry that exists to secure good improvements in pay, benefits,
safe working conditions, or social and political status through collective
bargaining. Trade union is an external, secondary, and indirect stakeholder.
Employees have a direct stake in the company because they interact
directly with customers, earn money to support themselves and give support
to the business operations as well. They can carry out managerial,
supervisory or other functions. They typically expect benefits like incentives,
career growth and job satisfaction. Employee is an internal, primary and
direct stakeholder.
Government agencies can also be thought of as a major stakeholder in a
business. They collect taxes from the company, its employees, and from
other spending the company does. A government agency is an external,
secondary and indirect stakeholder.
Customers are the people who buy business products. They expect to buy
the best quality from that business but a fair price. For a business doesn’t
exist without customers. Customers get products from businesses, and
because of that, they are interested in how a business performs. In addition,
customers are directly impacted by the product quality a business gives.
Customers are external, primary, and direct stakeholder.
Media can also be considered as an example of stakeholder because every
business nowadays needs media publication relationships to spread the word
about their brand, product, and services they offer. Media is an external,
secondary, and indirect stakeholder.
5. What conflicts of interest can arise between managers and stockholders?
Answer: Agency problem is the conflict of interest that can arise between
managers and stockholders. Theoretically, managers work for shareholders.
In reality, because shareholders aren’t involved in day-to-day firm activities,
managers control the firm. Managers might be tempted to operate the firm in
such a way as to benefit themselves more than the shareholders. That is why
corporate governance is the system of incentives and monitors that tries to
overcome this agency problem. Shareholders can align managers’ interest
with stockholder interests by making managers part owners of the firm.
Then, various monitors follow the firm and report on its activities.
6. What are the three types of financial management decisions? For each type
of decision, give an example of a business transaction that would be relevant.
Answer: The three types of financial management decisions are investment
decision, financial decision and dividend decision. Accordingly, there are two
types of investment these are long-term and short term. An example of long
term capital decision would be to buy machinery like crusher for production.
This is important as it affects the long term earnings of the firm. While short
term investment is related to levels of cash, inventories, etc. These decisions
affect day to day working of the business.
For financial decision, there are two main questions when looking at
the capital structure - 1) How much money do we need to borrow to buy this
long-term asset? 2) What are the least expensive sources of funds for the
firm? For example, since we are thinking of buying this new crusher, we need
to decide how we are going to afford this new machine. In this example, we
determined that if we cut back a little bit on labor and in other areas, we
would be able to afford the new machine. In regards to where the money will
come from, we do not take out loans to buy long-term assets. We borrow
from our company, and repay overtime.
For dividend decision, an example of a business transaction that would be
relevant is when a company is continuously paying the dividend at a normal
growth rate, earns huge profits for this year. Now the management has to
decide whether continue to pay dividend at normal rate or to pay at an
increasing rate? Why is this dilemma? The reason is that, if the management
decides to pay higher dividend, then it might be possible that next year, the
company will not achieve such higher growth rate, resulting the next year’s
dividend will be low as compared to last year’s. However, if the company
decides to stay on the normal rate of dividend then surplus amount of
retained earnings would remain idle which will result in over capitalization, if
no opportunity existing to utilize the funds.
7. What a goal should always motivate the action of a firm’s financial manager?
Answer: A goal that should always motivate the action of a firm’s financial
manager is to maximize the current market value of the equity of the firm
whether it’s publicly-traded or not.
I. QUESTIONS
1. Suppose you were the financial manager of a non-profit business (a not-for-profit
hospital). What kinds of goals do you think would be appropriate?
Answer: If I were supposed to be the financial manager of a non-profit-
business the kind of goals I think would be appropriate would be the revenue
minimization such as providing whatever goods and services are offered at the
lowest possible cost to society. A better approach might be to observe that even
a not-for-profit business has equity. Therefore, one answer is that the
appropriate goal I think is to maximize the value of the equity.
2. Evaluate the following statement: Managers should not focus on the current
stock value because doing so will lead to an overemphasis on short-term profits
at the expense of long-term profits.
Answer: The statement emphasized that executives or managers must strike a
balance between long-term corporate health management and communication
that may harm short-term benefits but align with growth goals over time. For
example, if a manager decides to add a new complementary business line, it may
hurt short-term earnings, but it will promote long-term growth. If these goals are
explained to investors in advance, they will help alleviate worries and possibly
reduce the negative impact on stocks.
5. What are some actions that stockholders can take to ensure that management's
and stockholders' interests are aligned?
Answer: Useful incentive tools that can help coordinate the interests of
shareholders and management include reasonable compensation plans, direct
shareholder intervention (including the firing of underperforming managers), and
the threat of acquisitions.
6. The president of Southern Tagalog Corporation (STC) made this statement in the
company's annual report: "STC's primary goal is to increase the value of our
common stockholder's equity". Later in the report, the following announcements
were made:
I. QUESTIONS
1. In a large corporation, what are the two distinct groups that report to the chief
financial officer? Which group is the focus of corporate finance?
Answer: In a large corporation, the two distinct groups that report to the chief
financial officer are the treasurer’s office and the controller’s officer. The
controller’s office handles cost and financial accounting, tax management, and
management information systems. While the treasurer’s office is responsible for
cash and credit management, capital budgeting and financial planning.
Therefore, the study of corporate finance is concentrated within the functions of
the treasurer’s office.
2. Can our goal of maximizing the value of the equity shares conflict with other
goals, such as avoiding unethical or illegal behavior? In particular, do you think
subjects like customer and employee safety, environment and general good of
society fit in this framework, or are they essentially ignored? Think of some
specific scenarios to illustrate your answer.
Answer: Either way it can be proven. At one extreme, we can argue that in a
market economy, all of these things have a price. This means that an optimal
level of ethical and or illegal behavior, which is explicitly included in the stock
valuation framework. At the other extreme, we can argue that these are non-
economic phenomena and are best dealt with through the political process. I
think of this specific scenario that illustrates my answer for example, a company
estimates that the cost of improving the security of one of its products is P40
million pesos. However, the company believes that improving product safety will
only save P30 million pesos for product liability aircraft.
3. Would our goal of maximizing the value of the equity shares be different if we
were thinking about financial management in a foreign country? Why or why
not?
Answer: The goal will be the same, but the best course of action to achieve this
goal may need to be adjusted to different social, political and economic climates.
4. Critics have charge that compensation to top managers in the United States is
simply too high and should be cut back. For example, focusing on large
corporations, Ray Irani of Occidental Petroleum has been one of the best-
compensated CEOs in the United States, earning about $54.4 million in 2007
alone and $550 million over the 2003-2007 period. Are such amounts excessive?
In answering, it might be helpful to recognize that superstar athletes such as
Roger Federer, top entertainers such as Justin Bieber and Manny Pacquiao and
many others at the top of their respective fields earn at least as much, if not a
great deal more.
Answer: The simplest answer is that, like all types of work, executives have a
market. Executive compensation is the price set by the market. The same goes
for athletes and artists. That said, one aspect of executive compensation is worth
commenting on. One of the main reasons for such rapid growth in executive
compensation is that companies are increasingly turning to share-based
compensation. This change is clearly consistent with efforts to better coordinate
the interests of shareholders and management. Accordingly, in recent years, the
stock price has skyrocketed so the management has been cleaned up. It is
sometimes argued that a large part of this reward is simply due to rising stock
prices, not management performance. Perhaps in the future, executive
compensation will only be used to reward differentiated performance-that is,
stock prices rise more than the overall market rise.
6. Distinguish the role of an external auditor from the role of an internal auditor.
Answer: The role of an external auditor examine the firm’s accounting systems
and comment on whether financial statements fairly represent the firm’s financial
position. While the role of an internal auditor examines issues related to
company business practices and risks and they also provide advice and other
consulting assistance to employees. In short, the two functions share one word
in their names, but are otherwise quite different. Larger organizations typically
have both functions, thereby ensuring that their records, processes, and financial
statements are closely examined at regular intervals.
7. Distinguish the functions of a controller from the functions of the treasurer.
Answer: The controller handles cost and financial accounting, tax management,
and management information systems. While the treasurer is responsible for
cash and credit management, capital budgeting and financial planning.
3. Regine is a financial manager who has discovered that her company is violating
environmental regulations. If her immediate superior is involved, her appropriate
action is to
Answer: C. Present the matter to the next higher managerial level.
6. A financial manager discovers a problem that could mislead users of the firm’s
financial data and has informed his/her immediate superior. He/she should
report the circumstances to the audit committee and/or the board of directors
only if
Answer: A. The immediate superior, who reports to the chief executive
officer, knows about the situation but refuses to correct it.