Star Auto-Evaluation Report

Project:
Location:
Contract:
Engineer:
Filename: C:\ETAP 2050\CP_21_44_Coordination_Study_Rev2\CP_21_44_Coordination_Study.OTI
Date: 12-29-2021

Revision: Base
Configuration: Normal
Study Case: SM
Evaluation*: Protection& Coordination
Fault Type*: Phase& Ground
Rule: ETAP Default (ANSI/NEC)
Rule Reference: IEEE/ANSI and NEC Standards
Rule Description: Reference Standards:
NFPA 70 (NEC), IEEE Std 242, IEEE Std 446, IEEE Std C37.91, IEEE Std C37.96

* 1/2 cycle symmetrical short circuit current used for evaluation.

Evaluation Report: 606283818.xls Page 1 of 7

Evaluation Report: 606283818.xls Page 2 of 7
 Classification Zone ID Zone Type Device ID Type Condition
Alert Does not pass phase protective device evaluation
Alert Bus2 Bus No valid protective device found for some of Feeder(s)
Valid upstream or downstream protective device not found for
-
Bus2 Bus coordination
Warning Cable1 Cable
Alert No valid protective device found for some of load side feeder(s)
T1 Transformer
Pass Passed phase protective device evaluation

[General] Evaluation Report: 606283818.xls Page 3 of 7

 Protective Device Bus Protection Max Fault Reference
Bus ID 3Ph-Amps
Location Device ID Type Cont. Amp Condition kV
Bus Continuous Amp is not protected by
Bus2 Main Relay1 OCR-TOC Alert 709,8 13,8
main(s) or feeder(s)

[Bus Protection] Evaluation Report: 606283818.xls Page 4 of 7

Cable / Line Protective Device Cable Protection Max Fault Reference
ID Pickup Damage 3Ph-Amps kV
Location Device ID Type Ampacity Condition
Limit Curve Not considered for limit evaluation based
OCR-IOC - - Pass on rule setting
Trip curve
Cable protects the
is underutilized damage
due curve
to LT Pickup
(OC1) 50,3 A < 145,7 A = Ampacity x
Cable1 Source Relay1 LT Pickup (OC1) 50,3 80%A is within 182,1 A 15000 13,8
OCR- = Ampacity
Pass Warning Pass LT Pickup (OC1) 50,3 A is within max.
TOC
limit of 182,1 A = Ampacity x 100%
Trip curve protects the damage curve

[Cable | Line Protection] Evaluation Report: 606283818.xls Page 5 of 7

Transformer Protective Device Transformer Protection Max Fault Reference
ID Device Pickup Damage 3Ph-Amps kV
Location Type FLA Inrush Condition
ID Limit Curve Not considered for limit evaluation
Tripbased
curveon rule setting
is clear of Inrush
OCR-IOC - - Pass Pass
Trip curvePoint/Curve
protects the damage
LT Pickup (OC1)curve50,3 A is within
Primary Relay1 41,8 A = FLA
LT Pickup and 50,3
(OC1) 251 AA is= within
FLA x 14895 13,8
OCR- NEC 450.3 max.600% limit of 251 A = FLA
T1 Pass Pass Pass Pass Trip curvexis600%
clear of Inrush
TOC
Trip curvePoint/Curve
protects the damage
curve
No valid protective device found for
Secondary- SST-LT - Alert - Pass some
Trip of load
curve sidethe
protects feeder(s)
damage
CB3 22358 0,492
1 curve the damage
Trip curve protects
SST-ST - - - Pass
curve

[Transformer Protection] Evaluation Report: 606283818.xls Page 6 of 7

 Zone Upstream Downstream Max Fault Reference Coordination Amp Range
Zone ID Condition
Type PD PD Type Amp kV Status From To
between amp range of
3Ph 22358 0,492 Pass 539,8 22358 No zero sequence
539,8 A to 22358A fault
@
Bus2 Bus Relay1 CB3 Warning current for Relay1. Ground
L-G 22983 0,492 between
curves notamp range of
evaluated.
Pass 138,6 22983
138,6 A to 22983A @

[Coordination] Evaluation Report: 606283818.xls Page 7 of 7