Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Forensic Dent-Prelims
Forensic Dent-Prelims
HANS GROSS
FORENSIC SCIENCE ● Johann Baptist Gustav Gross
- The application of science to those criminal and ● A magistrate and law professor in Austria
civil laws that are enforced by police agencies in ● Known for his publications and for introducing
a criminal justice system. the word “criminalistics”
- Applied science ● In 1893, published a handbook for magistrates
- Often called “Criminalistics” that greatly influenced the practice of criminal
investigations.
Forensic science applies ALPHONSE BERTILLON (1853-1914)
● Chemistry
● Biology ● Father of criminal detection
● Physics ● Devised the first scientific system of personal
● Geology identification, using body measurements known
To CIVIL AND CRIMINAL LAW as anthropometry in 1879.
- Places physical evidence into a professional
discipline Anthropometry
● Literally, “the measure of man’”
The Development of ○ Quantifies human variability
FORENSIC SCIENCE ● What?
○ Physical measures
SIR ARTHUR CONAN DOYLE ○ Height, weight, reach, length, width depth,
circumference, surface area etc
○ strength , dexterity, range of motion.
● Popularized physical detection methods in a ● The limitation of this system was shown by its
crime scene inability to distinguish between two
● Sir Arthur Conan Doyle - developed the leavenworth, Kansas, penitentiary prisoners,
character Sherlock Holmes Will West & William West.
● 1887 published his first novel “A Study in Scarlet” ● The Bertillon system was eventually replaced by
● Had a considerable influence on popularizing the fingerprint system being developed by
scientific crime-detection methods Francis Galton, William Hershel, Edward Henry
& others in the late 1800s.
MATTHIEU ORFILA (1787-1853)
Forensic Anthropologists:
● Can determine whether found remains are of FORENSIC ENGINEERING
human or animal origin
● Used to analyze construction accidents, and the
● Reconstruct the skeleton from found remains
causes and origins of fires or explosions
● Provide an estimate of age, stature, and gender
● Involved in the investigation of transportation
● Can sometimes determine racial origin
related accidents, material failures, and
● Detect skeletal abnormalities and any trauma
structural failures
● Can provide information about the cause of
death
FORENSIC TOXICOLOGY
Forensic Odontologists:
● Perform two types of analyses involving the FORENSIC ANALYSIS
human dentition ● Can include organic and inorganic analytical
○ Identify human remains by comparing techniques
pre mortem and postmortem dental ○ Organic analysis of unknown
x-rays substances
○ Bite mark comparisons (Crime scene ■ Includes analytical techniques
marks to known bite marks) such as Chromatography,
UV-visible and infrared
spectrophotometry and Mass
Spectrometry
Forensic
ODONTOLOGY
● Forensic odontology is the application of
Childhood
dentistry in legal proceedings deriving from any
Primary teeth sprout from milk buds and temporary.
evidence that pertains to teeth.
Once they fall out, permanent teeth as seen on the
TEETH
other side appear.
● Hardest part of body attached to jaws. It serves
to help digest food, act as a defense
Adulthood
mechanism, etc. Teeth are made of crowns with
Permanent adult teeth come in when primary teeth fall
enamel surrounding a pulp.
out; they are permanent because they establish roots
inside the gums. Third molars come in around the mid
TEETH BASICS
teenage years.
Approximately 32 teeth in adult mouth
● Four types of teeth
○ Molars
○ Premolars
○ Canine
○ Incisors
DENTAL RESTORATIONS
● Crowns MASS DISASTER IDENTIFICATION
● Fillings
● Completed in the same manner as individual
● Root Canal
identification
● Bridge
● Organization of antemortem and postmortem
● Extractions
data is essential
GENERAL NEGLECTED GUM DISEASE ● Large scale problems can occur
IDENTIFICATION
● Postmortem description is generated
○ Radiographs taken
● Possible identities known?
○ Yes: comparison to antemortem data
■ Match strength determined
○ No: biological profile generated
DENTAL COMPARISON
● Dental records are useful in helping to identify
unknown persons who have been the victim of
foul play or who have been simply reported
missing.
Mass Identification
● Same process is used as individual identification
● Organization is crucial
● Family is asked to come identify the body, and
WHERE ARE BITE MARKS FOUND?
narrow down the pool of victims
● Impressions left on food, sin or other items left
DENTAL IDENTIFICATION at a scene.
○ Porous surface that absorb the impact
- The forensic dentist compares antemortem enough to make an impression
(before death ) records with postmortem (after ○ Impression vary
death) findings to determine if there is a positive ■ Depending on the pressure
match. applied, the impression will
show accordingly. The more
pressure there is, the more
detail to the bite.
● BITE MARKS:
○ It also includes the examination of bite
marks inflicted by humans and animals
in a variety of circumstances.
○ Example of bruising left from bite mark
○ Bites are common in violent crime and
child abuse
9/11
● At ground zero, among 973 victims identified in
● Example of bruising left from bite mark
the first year (with only one method), about
● Bites are common in violent crime and child
20% of victims were identified using dental
abuse
records
ASIAN TSUNAMI
● Around mid-March, (of some 800+ identified
bodies) 90% were identified by dental records ...
● If you post pictures of your loved ones on the
bulletin boards/web boards, choose a picture
FAMOUS CASES
with a broad smile so that your front teeth can
be seen. A better approach is to post dental
HIGH PROFILE CRIMES x-ray films and leave email/phone number of
● Ted Bundy was identified from a bite mark the dentist."
● John Wilkes Booth was identified by a “gold
plug” on the right side of his jaw
Computer Aided
FORENSIC ODONTOLOGY
● 3rd Bite Mark Analysis
● Automatic Dental COde matching
● Automatic Dental Identification System
System Architecture
● In order to obtain a dental impression the
Feature Extraction criminal/victim must provide consent.
↓ ● Most will give the impression on just a verbal
Atlas Registration request
↓ ● Some require search warrants to be obtained
Matching ● Once a request is granted the impressions are
↓ made and then cast in dental stone.
Retrieval
SUMMARY:
● History and status of forensic odontology
● Dental anatomy
● Main application applications
FORENSIC DENTISTRY
● Comparison to other forensic biometrics
● Famous cases
● Forensic Dentistry is a specialty that relates
● Computer-aided forensic odontology
dental evidence to investigation
● Analyses of bite marks had played a major role
in many cases
● Teeth marks may be left in dood, pencils or
other items left at crime scenes
● Bite marks can help eliminate or identify
suspects
b. Bite Marks on food stuff, assailants and Performed by a team in the ff manner:
on victims (self inflicted or inflicted by 1. Examination and recording of all details of an
another unknown body and living person
PROCESS OF IDENTIFICATION, DETERMINATION, AND A. Following methods are used:
a. Clinical examination- visual exams,
CONFIRMATION OF IDENTITY AGE DETERMINATION
x-rays, impressions, models and
photographs
IDENTIFICATION b. Microscopic examination- teeth and
● Identification is the establishment of a person's body tissues
individuality/identity c. Chemical examination - stains (blood,
● Required for legal and humanitarian reasons food, chemicals)
● Help in settlement of property, facilitate
remarriage of surviving spouse and allow Performed by a team in the ff manner:
cremation or burial of the body, according to 1. Examination and recording of all details of an
relevant religious and cultural customs unknown body and living person
● Traditional Methods: 2. Collection of information of a sinister character
○ Visually recognizing body from missing persons
○ Use of personal property such as 3. Matching of data obtained from the body with
clothing, jewelry, etc. the record of the missing person
● Visually identifying a burnt or decomposed
body can be a very traumatic experience for
relatives and friends, the better option of DETERMINATION AND CONFIRMATION OF
identification is for the forensic expert to IDENTITY
analyze physical features present in the body. ● Sassouni (1963) suggested 2 groups of
● Physical features are prone to change over techniques in determination and confirmation of
time, fingerprints are exceptions but like other identity individuals : Reconstructive group and
soft tissues, undergo post mortem change Comparative group
● Being the strongest structure present in the
body, dental hard tissues are resistant to post A. Reconstructive Group
mortem decomposition 1. Used on bodies with no trace as to their identity
● Moreover, most materials used by dentists for because their body appearance has been
restoring teeth are also resistant to post mortem altered by:
destruction a. Deterioration
● Therefore, the use of dental evidence is the b. Mutilation
method of choice in establishing the identity of c. Deliberate disfigurement
badly burnt, traumatized, decomposed and 2. Used on bodies with no trace as to their identity
skeletal remains. because their body appearance has been
altered .
PROCESS OF IDENTIFICATION 3. Also used to identify living individuals suffering
● Importance of Identification from loss of memory from:
○ Satisfy the relatives as to the fate of a. Attacks
their kinsman b. Shock
○ Satisfy the requirements for a death c. Old age
certificate 4. Uses of the following to bring out identification
○ To be able to search for the murderer a. Age
● Oral examination is in essential part of the ● Content of all available records should be
postmortem procedures transcribed onto the standard interpol
● A forensic dentist who conduct oral autopsy antemortem form which is color coded YELLOW.
should have adequate knowledge about
common postmortem findings such as
POST-MORTEM VS. ANTE-MORTEM DENTAL RECORDS
○ Rigor mortis
○ Livor mortis
○ Decomposition ● Features compared include tooth morphology
○ Postmortem artifacts and associated bony structures pathology and
● Rigor mortis may render the jaw and the use of restorations
mouth gags or intraoral myotomy is essential ● An individual with multiple dental treatment and
for jaw separation unusual features has a better likelihood of being
identified then someone with no extra ordinary
● Since teeth may be brittle in burden cases, prior dental characteristics
to examination, they need to be reinforced with ● Comparison should take into account quality
○ Cyanoacrylate cements rather than quantity
○ Polyvinyl acetate
○ Clear acrylic spray POST MORTEM FORM: PINK
● Access for radiology in incinerated bodies can ANTEMORTEM FORM: YELLOW
be obtained by removing tongue and contents
of floor mouth in a ‘tunneling’ fashion from
beneath the skin. WRITING A REPORT AND DRAWING CONCLUSION
● The status of each tooth whether intact, carious, ● Confirms identification: match each other
restored or missing should be carefully noted ● Probable identification: high level of
concordance between the two sets of data, but
● A thorough examination of soft tissue injuries, usually with no radiographic support
fracture and presence of foregin bodies is ● Possible identification: explainable identification
undertaken and a sample of hard and between the ante and post-mortem data
investigation. ● Insufficient information: available ante and
● All information pertaining to the body must be post-mortem data are insufficient
entered on to standard “interpol post-mortem ● Excludes identification: ante and post mortem
form” which is color-coded in pink data are clearly inconsistent
GUSTAFSON’S METHOD
AGE ESTIMATION IN CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS
● Based on morphological and histological
changes of the teeth. Accessed regressive
● Two events may be used →eruption and tooth
changes such as:
calcification
○ Amount of occlusal attrition (A)
● Various methods
○ Coronal secondary dentin deposition (S)
A.) Schowur and Massler’s Method:
○ Loss of periodontal attachment (P)
● Described 20 chronological
○ Cementum aposition at the root apex
stages of tooth development
(C)
starting from 4 months IU until
○ Root resorption at apex (R)
21 years of age
○ Dentin translucency (T)
● It is based on histological
● Each of regressive changes have seven grades
section which permits direct
(0, 0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3)
comparison with radiographs
● Age = 11.02 + (5.14A) + (2.3S) + (4.14P) + (3.71C) +
B.) Demijan’s Method:
(5.57R) + (8.98T)
● Made use of a foreign system
● Development of left side even mandibular teeth
DENTAL TRANSLUCENCY
was divided into 8 stages (A-H)
○ Each tooth assigned a “maturity score” ● Root dentin starts to become translucent during
and total maturity score of all teeth is the third decade of life beginning at the apex
plotted on a chronologic age conversion and advancing coronally
table. Separate maturity score and age ● Hence as age advances refractive index
conversion table for both sexes. between intratubular organic and extra tubular
C. Third Molar in Age Estimation inorganic material is equalized resulting in
● A valuable indicator in the age 16-23 years but increased translucency of the affected dentin
questionable now a days due to great variation zone
in genesis, position, morphology and time of ● Age= B0+B2X where B0-regression constant
formation ○ B1- regression coefficient
○ X-length of translucency
AGE ESTIMATION IN ADULTS
AGE ESTIMATION FROM INCREMENTAL LINES OF CEMENTUM
● From acellular cementum incremental lines
Challenging when compared to young aage group as
● Made use of mineralized unstained cross
numerous endogenous and exogenous factors, such as
sections of teeth
disease, nutrition, physical strain influence
A. Gustafson’s method
RADIOGRAPHIC METHOD
B. Dentin translucency
C. Age estimation from incremental lines of ● Used pulp size measurement of six teeth
cementum
D. Radiographic method
ODONTOMETRIC DIFFERENCE
AMINO ACID RECEMISATION
● Suggested a relationship between dentinal age
and extent of aspartic acid recemisation in
dentin
● Aspartic acid undergo rapid rate of
recemisation and get spontaneously converted
from L-Aspartic acid to D-Aspartic acid with
increasing age
● Comparing D-L ration can be estimated
● STEPS:
1. Visual examination
LIP PRINTS
2. Photography
a. Orientation photographs ● Examination of lip print-cheiloscopy
b. Close-up photographs ● Grooves and wrinkles visible on lips named as
3. Saliva swab: WBC and sloughed sulci, labiorum, rubrorum
epithelial cells, potential source of DNA ● Grooves are inheritable and supposed to be
4. Impression: vinyl polysiloxane individualistic → so material evidence left at a
5. Evidence collection from suspect: using crime scene similar to fingerprints
a signed and informed consents or a
court order (warrant) also include
Lip Prints Classified As
● A. Simple Wrinkles
photograph, two casts, bite registration
○ Straight line
in centric occlusion, and saliva swab
○ Curved line
from buccal vestibule.
○ Angled line
BITE MARK ANALYSIS AND COMPARISON ○ Sine shaped curve
● B. Compound Wrinkles
● Jaw movement ○ Bifurcated
● Flexibility of bitten tissue ○ Trifurcated
● Individual features of bite marks ○ Anomalous
● Metric analysis
● Computer software program ● II) Type 1 - clear cut vertical grooves that run
across the entire lip
CONCLUSION OF BITE MARK ANALYSIS ○ Type 1 - similar to type 1 but not cover
● Positive identification the entirely
● Possible identification ○ Type 2 - branched grooves
● Excludes identification ○ Type 3 - intercepted grooves
○ Type 4 - reticular grooves
INVESTIGATING ANIMAL BITES ○ Type 5 - grooves that can not be
morphologically differentiated
Characteristics of Some Vertebrate Dentition
● Invisible prints can be lifted using materials
● Fish → conical, homodont, heterodont or
such as aluminum powder, magnetic powder
polyphyodont
● Reptiles→ homodont conical or only tricuspid
LIP PRINTS: DISADVANTAGE
teeth
● Venomous snake → Single row palatal to this are ● Trauma, pathosis, surgical treatment can affect
two poison fangs containing canal or groove for the size and shape of the lip
venom release ● The zone of transition close to the vermillion
● Non- venomous snake → two rows of maxillary border is extremely mobile so prints produced
teeth may differ depending on pressure applied and
● Mammals → heterodont dentition, diphyodont its direction.
also have accessional teeth (permanent molar
emerge posterior to deciduous teeth)
● Carnivores →