FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Table 1:Total Achievable Mark by Students and Respective Weightage (Individual)- Laboratory

NO ELEMENTS TO ASSESS TOTAL MARKS WEIGHTAGE (%)

INDIVIDUAL IN-LAB ACTIVITIES ASSESSMENT
1 PUNCTUALITIY 5
2 DISCIPLINE (DRESS CODE,SAFETY SHOES,SAFETY
5
REGULATIONS)
4
3 KNOWLEDGE ON OPEN ENDED LABORATORY 5
4 LEADERSHIP SKILL & TEAMWORKING 5
5 INTERACTION 5
TOTAL 25 4

Table 2: Total Achievable Mark by Students and Respective Weightage (Group)- Laboratory Report

NO ELEMENTS TO ASSESS LEVEL OF OPENNESS

TOTAL WEIGHTAGE
0 1 2 3 MARKS (%)
REPORT ASSESSMENT
1 INTRODUCTION 5 5
2 BASIC CONCEPTS 5 5
3 SUMMARY OF PROCEDURES/ METHODS 5 5 10
4 ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF RESULT 5 5 5 15 6
5 DISCUSSION OF RESULT 5 5 5 5 20
6 CONCLUSION 5 5 5 5 20
7 ORGANIZATION 5 5 5 5 20
TOTAL 15 20 25 35 95 6

1
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Table 3:INDIVIDUAL IN LABORATORY-ACTIVITY ASSESSMENT (TEAMWORKING)

INDIVIDUAL IN LABORATORY-ACTIVITY ASSESSMENT
RUBRICS/Marks
NO ELEMENT
1 2 3 4 5
Between 5 to 10
More than 10 min. Up to 5 min. late Arrive on time but Arrive on time and
min. late which
late which affect which affect the not fully utilizing fully utilizing lab
affect the other
1 Punctuality the other group other group lab hours working hours working the
group members to
members to start members to start the task with other task with group
start performing
performing task performing task group members. members.
task
Conform to lab’s
Discipline (such Conform to lab’s Conform to lab’s
Does not wear Does not fully dress code,
as lab dress dress code, dress code,
dress code, safety conform to lab’s consistently clean
codes, safety consistently clean consistently clean
shoe, did not clean dress code, major up the equipment
2 shoe, safety up the equipment up the equipment
up the equipment flaws in safety and and nearly all lab
and all and nearly all lab without reminding
and did not follow seldom clean up regulation but with
laboratory regulation and and all regulation
lab procedures the equipment minor flaws in
regulations) safety and safety
safety
Able to design,
Not able to Able to design, Able to design,
Knowledge on Not able to explain conduct, testing,
explain, design and conduct and conduct, testing
the open- the experiment interpret and
3 conduct the explain the data and explain the
ended and the work explain the data
experimental work obtained but not data obtained and
laboratory assigned and the work
in the lab the work assigned the work assigned
assigned
Able to control, Able to control,
Able to control, Able to control,
Unable to control, lead and delivering lead and delivering
lead the group but lead and delivering
lead, fail to deliver the task to the the task to the
fail to deliver the the task to the
Leadership the task to the group efficiently group efficiently
task and does not group members
skill and group and does and usually does and serves as a
4 compromise and occasionally
team- not compromise to what is the best leader in managing
towards the helps the group to
working achieve the interest of the individual ideas
achieveme5nt achieve the
objectives of group towards the towards the
objectives of the objectives of the
experiments achievement of achievement of
experiments experiments
the objectives the objectives

Able to deliver
ideas ONLY with
Able to interact
Passive. Unable to constant Able to interact Able to interact
and deliver ideas
interact and prompting. and deliver ideas and deliver ideas
clearly,
deliver ideas and Interaction and with limited clarity, clearly, confidently
confidently, and
5 Interaction clearly, effectively delivery of ideas is confidence and and effectively at
effectively most of
and confidently in still not clear, not effectiveness to all times within the
the time to
to accomplish confident and not accomplish goals group to
accomplish goals
goals in the group effective to in the group accomplish goals
in the group
accomplish goals in
the group

2
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Table 4: REPORT ASSESSMENT - WORKING AS A TEAM TO COME OUT WITH A COMPLETE REPORT
REPORT ASSESSMENT (TEAMWORK)
RUBRICS/Marks
NO ELEMENT
1 2 3 4 5
No information on Little information Some discussion on Discussion the
Some discussion on
purpose/objectives on purposes, purpose of work , purpose of work
purpose of work
1 Introduction of work, no objectives of work missing some with relevant
and no background
background and no background information background
information
information information background information
Able to design and
Able to identify the Able to discuss the Able to apply the Able to analyzes the
evaluate the basic
basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of
concepts of
respective respective respective respective
2 Basic concepts respective
laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through
laboratory through
formative test and formative test and formative test and formative test and
formative test and
lab report lab report lab report lab report
lab report
Able to design
Able to design, find Able to design, find
Unable to design Able to design the experiment, find
standard procedure Relevant standard
experiment and no experiment with relevant standard
Summary of and clear with procedure and
explanations on the little explanations procedure and
3 procedures/me precise clearly stated with
procedures of on the procedures sufficient
thods explanations on good explanations
conducting of conducting explanations of
conducting on conducting
experimental work experimental work conducting
experimental work experimental work
experimental work
Data collected is
Data collected was Data collected is relevant, related to
Data collected is Data collected is
Analysis and not relevant and relevant, related to the objectives,
relevant but not relevant and
4 interpretation not sufficient to the objectives and sufficient to analyze
sufficient to analyze sufficient to analyze
of data analyze and sufficient to analyze and accurate
and interpret and interpret
interpret and interpret interpretation of
data.
Result and
Discussion on
Description of discussion are
results is very Little discussion on
result is generally clearly stated,
difficult to follow, what result mean
No discussion on clear. Some through discussion
no discussion on and implications of
the meaning of discussion on what on what results
Discussion of the meaning of results. Enough
5 experimental results mean and mean and
result results and errors are made to
results and very implications of implications of
information is so be distracting, but
difficult to follow results. No results. Provide
inaccurate that some information is
significant errors consistently
makes the report accurate
are made accurate
unreliable
information
Conclusion is
Conclusion is good Conclusion is good
excellent and
Conclusion is and derived from and derived from
No attempt was derived from the
derived from the the collected and the collected and
made to conclude collected and
collected and analyzed data and analyzed data and
6 Conclusion and objectives of analyzed data and
analyzed data but it not from other not from other
the lab were not not from other
is not answering the sources but did not sources and directly
answered sources. Conclusion
objectives directly answering answer the
clearly answers the
the objectives. objectives
objectives.
Team showed
moderate cohesion, Team showed good Team showed great
Team slightly
interaction and cohesion, cohesion,
showed cohesion,
Team showed poor respect. Team interaction and interaction and
interaction and
cohesion, poor member did not respect. Team respect. Team
respect. Most work
interaction and share the tasks member shared member shared the
was done by only
poor respect. Only equally and did not the tasks equally tasks equally and
7 Organization one (1) member
one (1) person does utilize abilities of and utilize abilities utilize abilities of
team. Tasks were
all the tasks. Tasks each team of each team each team
not completed on
were not members. Tasks members. Tasks members. Tasks
time and with
completed. were completed on were completed on were completed on
unsatisfactory
time but with time with time and with good
results.
unsatisfactory satisfactory results. results.
results.

3
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

LEVEL 0
REPORT ASSESSMENT (TEAMWORK)
RUBRICS/Marks
NO ELEMENT
1 2 3 4 5
No information on Little information Some discussion on Discussion the
Some discussion on
purpose/ objectives on purposes, purpose of work , purpose of work
purpose of work
1 Introduction of work, no objectives of work missing some with relevant
and no background
background and no background information background
information
information information background information
Able to design and
Able to identify the Able to discuss the Able to apply the Able to analyzes the
evaluate the basic
basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of
concepts of
respective respective respective respective
2 Basic concepts respective
laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through
laboratory through
formative test and formative test and formative test and formative test and
formative test and
lab report lab report lab report lab report
lab report
Able to design
Able to design, find Able to design, find
Unable to design Able to design the experiment, find
standard procedure Relevant standard
experiment and no experiment with relevant standard
Summary of and clear with procedure and
explanations on the little explanations procedure and
3 procedures/me precise clearly stated with
procedures of on the procedures sufficient
thods explanations on good explanations
conducting of conducting explanations of
conducting on conducting
experimental work experimental work conducting
experimental work experimental work
experimental work
Data collected is
Data collected was Data collected is relevant, related to
Data collected is Data collected is
Analysis and not relevant and relevant, related to the objectives,
relevant but not relevant and
4 interpretation not sufficient to the objectives and sufficient to analyze
sufficient to analyze sufficient to analyze
of data analyze and sufficient to analyze and accurate
and interpret and interpret
interpret and interpret interpretation of
data.
Result and
Discussion on
Description of discussion are
results is very Little discussion on
result is generally clearly stated,
difficult to follow, what result mean
No discussion on clear. Some through discussion
no discussion on and implications of
the meaning of discussion on what on what results
Discussion of the meaning of results. Enough
5 experimental results mean and mean and
result results and errors are made to
results and very implications of implications of
information is so be distracting, but
difficult to follow results. No results. Provide
inaccurate that some information is
significant errors consistently
makes the report accurate
are made accurate
unreliable
information
Conclusion is
Conclusion is good Conclusion is good
excellent and
Conclusion is and derived from and derived from
No attempt was derived from the
derived from the the collected and the collected and
made to conclude collected and
collected and analyzed data and analyzed data and
6 Conclusion and objectives of analyzed data and
analyzed data but it not from other not from other
the lab were not not from other
is not answering the sources but did not sources and directly
answered sources. Conclusion
objectives directly answering answer the
clearly answers the
the objectives. objectives
objectives.
Team showed
moderate cohesion, Team showed good Team showed great
Team slightly
interaction and cohesion, cohesion,
showed cohesion,
Team showed poor respect. Team interaction and interaction and
interaction and
cohesion, poor member did not respect. Team respect. Team
respect. Most work
interaction and share the tasks member shared member shared the
was done by only
poor respect. Only equally and did not the tasks equally tasks equally and
7 Organization one (1) member
one (1) person does utilize abilities of and utilize abilities utilize abilities of
team. Tasks were
all the tasks. Tasks each team of each team each team
not completed on
were not members. Tasks members. Tasks members. Tasks
time and with
completed. were completed on were completed on were completed on
unsatisfactory
time but with time with time and with good
results.
unsatisfactory satisfactory results. results.
results.

4
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

LEVEL 1
REPORT ASSESSMENT (TEAMWORK)
RUBRICS/Marks
NO ELEMENT
1 2 3 4 5
No information on Little information Some discussion on Discussion the
Some discussion on
purpose/ objectives on purposes, purpose of work , purpose of work
purpose of work
1 Introduction of work, no objectives of work missing some with relevant
and no background
background and no background information background
information
information information background information
Able to design and
Able to identify the Able to discuss the Able to apply the Able to analyzes the
evaluate the basic
basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of
concepts of
respective respective respective respective
2 Basic concepts respective
laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through
laboratory through
formative test and formative test and formative test and formative test and
formative test and
lab report lab report lab report lab report
lab report
Able to design
Able to design, find Able to design, find
Unable to design Able to design the experiment, find
standard procedure Relevant standard
experiment and no experiment with relevant standard
Summary of and clear with procedure and
explanations on the little explanations procedure and
3 procedures/me precise clearly stated with
procedures of on the procedures sufficient
thods explanations on good explanations
conducting of conducting explanations of
conducting on conducting
experimental work experimental work conducting
experimental work experimental work
experimental work
Data collected is
Data collected was Data collected is relevant, related to
Data collected is Data collected is
Analysis and not relevant and relevant, related to the objectives,
relevant but not relevant and
4 interpretation not sufficient to the objectives and sufficient to analyze
sufficient to analyze sufficient to analyze
of data analyze and sufficient to analyze and accurate
and interpret and interpret
interpret and interpret interpretation of
data.
Result and
Discussion on
Description of discussion are
results is very Little discussion on
result is generally clearly stated,
difficult to follow, what result mean
No discussion on clear. Some through discussion
no discussion on and implications of
the meaning of discussion on what on what results
Discussion of the meaning of results. Enough
5 experimental results mean and mean and
result results and errors are made to
results and very implications of implications of
information is so be distracting, but
difficult to follow results. No results. Provide
inaccurate that some information is
significant errors consistently
makes the report accurate
are made accurate
unreliable
information
Conclusion is
Conclusion is good Conclusion is good
excellent and
Conclusion is and derived from and derived from
No attempt was derived from the
derived from the the collected and the collected and
made to conclude collected and
collected and analyzed data and analyzed data and
6 Conclusion and objectives of analyzed data and
analyzed data but it not from other not from other
the lab were not not from other
is not answering the sources but did not sources and directly
answered sources. Conclusion
objectives directly answering answer the
clearly answers the
the objectives. objectives
objectives.
Team showed
moderate cohesion, Team showed good Team showed great
Team slightly
interaction and cohesion, cohesion,
showed cohesion,
Team showed poor respect. Team interaction and interaction and
interaction and
cohesion, poor member did not respect. Team respect. Team
respect. Most work
interaction and share the tasks member shared member shared the
was done by only
poor respect. Only equally and did not the tasks equally tasks equally and
7 Organization one (1) member
one (1) person does utilize abilities of and utilize abilities utilize abilities of
team. Tasks were
all the tasks. Tasks each team of each team each team
not completed on
were not members. Tasks members. Tasks members. Tasks
time and with
completed. were completed on were completed on were completed on
unsatisfactory
time but with time with time and with good
results.
unsatisfactory satisfactory results. results.
results.

5
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

LEVEL 2
REPORT ASSESSMENT (TEAMWORK)
RUBRICS/Marks
NO ELEMENT
1 2 3 4 5
No information on Little information Some discussion on Discussion the
Some discussion on
purpose/ objectives on purposes, purpose of work , purpose of work
purpose of work
1 Introduction of work, no objectives of work missing some with relevant
and no background
background and no background information background
information
information information background information
Able to design and
Able to identify the Able to discuss the Able to apply the Able to analyzes the
evaluate the basic
basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of
concepts of
respective respective respective respective
2 Basic concepts respective
laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through
laboratory through
formative test and formative test and formative test and formative test and
formative test and
lab report lab report lab report lab report
lab report
Able to design
Able to design, find Able to design, find
Unable to design Able to design the experiment, find
standard procedure Relevant standard
experiment and no experiment with relevant standard
Summary of and clear with procedure and
explanations on the little explanations procedure and
3 procedures/me precise clearly stated with
procedures of on the procedures sufficient
thods explanations on good explanations
conducting of conducting explanations of
conducting on conducting
experimental work experimental work conducting
experimental work experimental work
experimental work
Data collected is
Data collected was Data collected is relevant, related to
Data collected is Data collected is
Analysis and not relevant and relevant, related to the objectives,
relevant but not relevant and
4 interpretation not sufficient to the objectives and sufficient to analyze
sufficient to analyze sufficient to analyze
of result analyze and sufficient to analyze and accurate
and interpret and interpret
interpret and interpret interpretation of
data.
Result and
Discussion on
Description of discussion are
results is very Little discussion on
result is generally clearly stated,
difficult to follow, what result mean
No discussion on clear. Some through discussion
no discussion on and implications of
the meaning of discussion on what on what results
Discussion of the meaning of results. Enough
5 experimental results mean and mean and
result results and errors are made to
results and very implications of implications of
information is so be distracting, but
difficult to follow results. No results. Provide
inaccurate that some information is
significant errors consistently
makes the report accurate
are made accurate
unreliable
information
Conclusion is
Conclusion is good Conclusion is good
excellent and
Conclusion is and derived from and derived from
No attempt was derived from the
derived from the the collected and the collected and
made to conclude collected and
collected and analyzed data and analyzed data and
6 Conclusion and objectives of analyzed data and
analyzed data but it not from other not from other
the lab were not not from other
is not answering the sources but did not sources and directly
answered sources. Conclusion
objectives directly answering answer the
clearly answers the
the objectives. objectives
objectives.
Team showed
moderate cohesion, Team showed good Team showed great
Team slightly
interaction and cohesion, cohesion,
showed cohesion,
Team showed poor respect. Team interaction and interaction and
interaction and
cohesion, poor member did not respect. Team respect. Team
respect. Most work
interaction and share the tasks member shared member shared the
was done by only
poor respect. Only equally and did not the tasks equally tasks equally and
7 Organization one (1) member
one (1) person does utilize abilities of and utilize abilities utilize abilities of
team. Tasks were
all the tasks. Tasks each team of each team each team
not completed on
were not members. Tasks members. Tasks members. Tasks
time and with
completed. were completed on were completed on were completed on
unsatisfactory
time but with time with time and with good
results.
unsatisfactory satisfactory results. results.
results.

6
FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

LEVEL 3
REPORT ASSESSMENT (TEAMWORK)
RUBRICS/Marks
NO ELEMENT
1 2 3 4 5
No information on Little information Some discussion on Discussion the
Some discussion on
purpose/ objectives on purposes, purpose of work , purpose of work
purpose of work
1 Introduction of work, no objectives of work missing some with relevant
and no background
background and no background information background
information
information information background information
Able to design and
Able to identify the Able to discuss the Able to apply the Able to analyzes the
evaluate the basic
basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of basic concepts of
concepts of
respective respective respective respective
2 Basic concepts respective
laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through laboratory through
laboratory through
formative test and formative test and formative test and formative test and
formative test and
lab report lab report lab report lab report
lab report
Able to design
Able to design, find Able to design, find
Unable to design Able to design the experiment, find
standard procedure Relevant standard
experiment and no experiment with relevant standard
Summary of and clear with procedure and
explanations on the little explanations procedure and
3 procedures/me precise clearly stated with
procedures of on the procedures sufficient
thods explanations on good explanations
conducting of conducting explanations of
conducting on conducting
experimental work experimental work conducting
experimental work experimental work
experimental work
Data collected is
Data collected was Data collected is relevant, related to
Data collected is Data collected is
Analysis and not relevant and relevant, related to the objectives,
relevant but not relevant and
4 interpretation not sufficient to the objectives and sufficient to analyze
sufficient to analyze sufficient to analyze
of result analyze and sufficient to analyze and accurate
and interpret and interpret
interpret and interpret interpretation of
data.
Result and
Discussion on
Description of discussion are
results is very Little discussion on
result is generally clearly stated,
difficult to follow, what result mean
No discussion on clear. Some through discussion
no discussion on and implications of
the meaning of discussion on what on what results
Discussion of the meaning of results. Enough
5 experimental results mean and mean and
result results and errors are made to
results and very implications of implications of
information is so be distracting, but
difficult to follow results. No results. Provide
inaccurate that some information is
significant errors consistently
makes the report accurate
are made accurate
unreliable
information
Conclusion is
Conclusion is good Conclusion is good
excellent and
Conclusion is and derived from and derived from
No attempt was derived from the
derived from the the collected and the collected and
made to conclude collected and
collected and analyzed data and analyzed data and
6 Conclusion and objectives of analyzed data and
analyzed data but it not from other not from other
the lab were not not from other
is not answering the sources but did not sources and directly
answered sources. Conclusion
objectives directly answering answer the
clearly answers the
the objectives. objectives
objectives.
Team showed
moderate cohesion, Team showed good Team showed great
Team slightly
interaction and cohesion, cohesion,
showed cohesion,
Team showed poor respect. Team interaction and interaction and
interaction and
cohesion, poor member did not respect. Team respect. Team
respect. Most work
interaction and share the tasks member shared the member shared the
was done by only
poor respect. Only equally and did not tasks equally and tasks equally and
7 Organization one (1) member
one (1) person does utilize abilities of utilize abilities of utilize abilities of
team. Tasks were
all the tasks. Tasks each team each team each team
not completed on
were not members. Tasks members. Tasks members. Tasks
time and with
completed. were completed on were completed on were completed on
unsatisfactory
time but with time with time and with good
results.
unsatisfactory satisfactory results. results.
results.