Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Term Project
Final Report
Contents
1. Introduction
1.1 The Engineering Design Process
1.1.1 Recognition of need
1.1.2 Conceptualization and Creativity
1.1.3 Establishing Design Requirements
1.1.4 Preliminary Design
1.1.5 Detailed Design
2. Identification of need
2.1 The Need for Exercise
2.2 Background Research in Exercise Technology
2.2.1 Existing Machines and trends
2.3 Home Exercise Market
2.4 The Defined Need
3. Conceptualization Design
3.1 Initial Concepts
3.2.1 Evolution of Prismatic Mechanisms to Revolute Mechanisms
3.2 Refined Concepts
3.3 Feasibility Assessment
5. Preliminary Design
5.1 Decision Matrix for Design Selection
6. Second Preliminary Design
6.1 New Idea
7. Detailed Design
7.1 CAD Model
7.1.1 Parts of Mechanism
8. Working
9. Benchmarking
9.1 Benchmarking Table
10. Conclusion
ADVANCE EXERCISE MACHINE MECHANISAM Engineering Design & CAD
1. Introduction
This report uses the engineering design process applied to advance exercise machine. This
uses a person own weight as a source of resistance. The design process is used to take idea
from concept to computer aided design modeling.
The design process can be used to devise a system, component or process to meet desired
needs. Another definition of the design process is “The pro ess of appl i g the various
techniques and scientific principles for the purpose of defining a devise, a process or a
system in sufficient detail to permit its realization."
The first step in the engineering design process is the recognition of need. When a need is
given, it is usually brief and lacking detail. The design engineer must structure the problem
statement. There are different categories for each of the five different types of needs. The
first type of need is a formal request, also called a request for proposals. The second type is
an informal request, this is a suggestion or an implication from a potential customer. The
third type is when a need is felt to exist. The forth type of need is an assignment from a
supervisor. Finally, the fifth type is the need for a product for which market could be
developed.
Once a need is recognized, concepts immediately follow. A design engineer will start to
crudely synthesize and analyze the problem. This step is fun and frustrating and potentially
the most satisfying. Few facts exist about the phenomenon of creativity. Some believe it can
be taught, and others believe that it is inherited.
This step follows the feasibility assessment and will provide detailed task specifications for
the design. I feel that this step should follow the recognition of need since this will also help
determine the best concept. The list of requirements or specifications is important for
ADVANCE EXERCISE MACHINE MECHANISAM Engineering Design & CAD
communicating ideas to other engineering groups. It helps to save time and cost by
minimizing wasted pursuits.
This stage is the bridge between design concept and detailed design. If there is more than
one acceptable concept, an evaluation will be conducted. The cost will now become more
realistic and schematics, diagrams and layouts will be used. Also at this stage, some
computation and analysis will be done. A component-level literature search can also be
conducted.
The detailed design stage is an extension of the preliminary design stage. There is still some
synthesis and analysis occurring. Each part is evaluated to see if it meets the overall
requirements. Specifications are given for each component, this is usually done in detail
drawings.
2. Identification of Need
2.1 The Need for Exercise
The need for strength training is the first issue to consider. The surgeon general states that
daily activity for 35 to 40 minutes will improve overall health and quality of life. Some
examples of such aerobic activity include biking, walking, even working around the house or
yard work.
The effects of strength training go beyond just increasing strength. Several weeks of
strength training will reduce resting blood pressure, a 2 month program can reduce it by 4
mm Hg. It also causes fat reduction in two ways. First, strength training will burn calories
during the work out. Secondly, the after burn effect will burn more calories for hours after a
workout.
It is important to look specifically at the products available in the market. This will help save
time in the design process by not repeating work that has already been done. This can also
give ideas to improve and change existing designs.
- Resistance Machines
Weight Machines
A weight machine is an exercise machine used for weight training
that uses gravity as the primary source of resistance and a
combination of simple machines to convey that resistance to the
person using the machine. Each of the simple machines (pulley,
lever, wheel, incline) changes the mechanical advantage of the
overall machine relative to the weight.
Stack Machines
A stack machine also called a stack or rack has a set of massive
rectangular plates that are pierced by a vertical bar which has
holes drilled in it to accept a pin. Each of the plates has a
channel on its underside (or a hole through the middle, as
shown in the diagram) that aligns with one of the holes. When
the pin is inserted through the channel into the hole, all of the
plates above the pin rest upon it, and are lifted when the bar
rises. The plates below do not rise. This allows the same
machine to provide several levels of resistance over the same
range of motion with an adjustment that requires very little
force to accomplish in itself.
Plate-loaded machines
Plate-loaded machines (such as the Smith machine) use
standard barbell plates instead of captive stacks of plates.
They combine a bar-end on which to hang the plates with a
number of simple machines to convey the force to the user.
The plate-loaded machines will often have a very high
mechanical advantage, due to the need to make room for
large plates over a large range of motion following a path that
causes them to converge at one end or the other.
ADVANCE EXERCISE MACHINE MECHANISAM Engineering Design & CAD
Friction machines
Spring-loaded machines
Fan-loaded machines
Fluid-loaded machines
Bull worker
Hydraulic Equipment
Whole body vibration
Outdoor gym
Pneumatic exercise equipment
Solo flex
Stretch Trainer
- Endless-path machines
Stationary bicycles
A stationary bicycle (also known as exercise bicycle, exercise bike,
or exercycle) is a device with saddle, pedals, and some form of
handlebars arranged as on a bicycle, but used as exercise
equipment rather than transportation.
Elliptical machines
Elliptical (elliptical machines) are a combination of stair-climbing
and a treadmill. Generally it contains two tracks upon which the user
stands; when he or she moves his or her legs, they describe an elliptical
motion (hence the machine name). Some elliptical have magnetic
resistance controls that add difficulty to doing the motion.
Glider machines
This machine allows the user to stand on two separate foot pedals and
use their own muscles to create the movement. The stabilized movement can be likened to
that of a "swing set" for each leg.
Climbing machines
Also named stair-climbing machines, they work the user's legs as he/she pumps pedals up
and down, much like climbing stairs. Some climbing machines have handles to push and pull
to exercise the whole body.
"A ho e exercise achi e that uses a perso ’s ow weight as the source of resista ce.
This resistance must be variable for people of different strengths. This machine needs to
include eccentric exercises and the resistance of each exercise should be designed with the
strength curve in mind. The machine should be competitively priced for less than $300 and
offer a complete range of exercises."
3. Conceptualization Design
(Conceptualization of solutions)
The "Conceptualization of Solutions" Stage in the engineer design process. This Stage
Immediately follows the "identifications of need". This phase initiates the synthesis of the
solution.
While prismatic joints produce the desired motion in a conceptually simple way, these joints
have several drawbacks in application. They are relatively expensive to produce, and they
are prone to higher frictional forces and stick-slip motion. This led to a systematic attempt
to replace all prismatic joints with revolute joints. A prismatic joint can be replaced by
straight li e li kages su h as Watt’s four ar li kage. Ea h Watt’s linkage adds four more
re olute joi ts. The Watt’s mechanism is shown in Fig. CAD-2. The two rockers in this
linkage are of equal length and the midpoint of the coupler forms an approximately linear
coupler curve.
Figure CAD-1 shows a schematic of a fully prismatic linkage. This linkage has 1 revolute joint
a d pris ati joi ts. There are a total of li ks i ludi g the grou d li k. Grue ler’s
equation for planar linkages shows that there is 1 degree of freedom.
ADVANCE EXERCISE MACHINE MECHANISAM Engineering Design & CAD
The vertical prismatic joint is replaced usi g t o Watt’s four ar li kages, as sho i Fig.
CAD-3. This linkage has 11 revolute joints, 2 prismatic joints and 10 total links including
ground. This linkage does have a mobility of one.
Next, the adjustable prismatic joint is replaced with a single Watt linkage. One linkage is
used since this does not require keeping another link in constant orientation. This schematic
is shown in Fig. CAD-4. This linkage contains 1 prismatic joint and 15 revolute joints. There
are a total of 12 links including ground. The mobility of this linkage is also one.
Each one of these linkages has one degree of freedom. Since, the platform link should
maintain a constant orientation. A prismatic joint would most likely be a linear bearing. This
would be more expensive to implement tha a li kage. Ho e er, t o Watt’s li kages are
complicated and add 10 revolute joints to the system. Other concepts of creating a vertical
motion for the platform must be considered. The horizontal prismatic joint can still be
created with a simple roller.
This concept also gives a linear vertical lift motion. The linkage is based on rotating a bevel
gear set to compress the scissors links and lift the platform. The input shaft must remain
vertically fixed relative to ground to maintain gear contact. Also, a method of adjusting the
resistance is not determined.
The second linkage concept is a four bar with two parallel rockers. A parallel four bar would
be a good choice to eliminate links and joints. The arced motion is not ideal for the feel of
the user, since the motion is not vertically linear. The radius of the arc depends on the
length of the rockers. This compromise is worth investigating. A schematic is shown in Fig.
CAD-7. In this concept, the four-bar linkage is used to elevate the person. The input is a
cable with a roller under the bottom link. As the cable is pulled, the linkage is forced to
move upwards.
The process of conceptualization led the first concepts toward a parallel linkage with a roller
to create two revolute joints. Clearly, during this step of the engineering design process,
there is synthesis and some analysis. Each time a problem is found or a new idea comes to
mind, the design engineer iterates on the concept.
rollers were further considered. One advantage of a radial cam is that its surface can be
shaped to control the mechanical advantage. This could be an advantage for designing a
resistance curve. There is still another potential problem with a linkage that uses a roller. As
the angle of the inclined surface that the roller follows is adjusted, the length of cable may
change. The cable length may need to be adjusted for different adjustments in the
resistance. Therefore, a new design consideration is that the roller must always start at the
same position.
5. Primarily Design
After a reasonable design concept has been developed, it must be analyzed to determine
more specific design issues. These can include coat, accuracy, and ease of handling, ease of
use, Manufacturing, motion, forces, and stresses. This step includes additional synthesis and
more extensive analysis. It is an iterative process that will refine the design. This step may
also reveal that a concept is too difficult to implement if, for example, the motion is
unacceptable, or internal forces are too extreme. In this case, the process will have to
return to the conceptualization stage. The concept that has been selected for further
development is a hydraulic cylinder linkage, four-bar linkage with a roller and an inclined
link to adjust the linkage movement.
CONCEPTS
Hydraulic Cylinder Four Bar Linkage Four Bar Linkage with
Linkage with Roller simple Lever Bar
SELECTION CRITERIA WEIGHT Rating Weighted Rating Weighted Rating Weighted
Score Score Score
I. Cost 20 2 0.40 3 0.60 5 0.10
II. Accuracy 15 3 0.45 2 0.30 4 0.60
III. Ease of handling 25 4 0.1 4 0.60 3 0.75
IV. Ease of use 20 3 0.60 3 0.60 3 0.60
V. Manufacturing 20 2 0.40 2 0.40 4 0.80
VI. Durability 15 2 0.30 3 0.45 3 0.45
VII. Portability 10 3 0.30 2 0.20 2 0.20
TOTAL
SCORE 2.55 3.15 3.50
Continue? NO NO YES
6. Secondary Design
By decision matrix we came to know that our first selection of mechanism for our project,
the four bar linkage with rollers would not be feasible for use. So by keeping in mind this the
additional brainstorming focused on overcoming these problems and on solving problems
with minimum number of parts.
L1 L2
lever
C
F o
n
n
ec
F+W to
r
Platform
The force (F) is applied by the user pushing up on the leverage bar. The equal and opposite
force is applied down on the platform. The weight of the person is also included in the
downward force. The motion of the platform as a result of the input force may seem
counter-intuitive. However, a simple summation of forces on the lever and platform proves
this to be a worthy idea. Figure CAD-15 displays the free-body diagrams.
L1 L2
Pivot
Lever
F T F
F+W T
Platform
Summing moments of lever bar and solving for T gives the following expression.
The vertical forces of the platform can now be found by summing forces in the vertical
direction.
As L1 approaches zero, the input force becomes infinitely large. Also, as L2 approaches
zero, the force becomes zero. In order for the input force to be equivalent to the weight,
L1 would be equal to L2.
7. Detailed Design
After a preliminary design has been completed and accepted, detailed design must be
completed. This stage of the design process ultimately results in detailed drawings of a
tested design for manufacturing. This is inevitably an iterative process of design, testing and
redesign. The first iteration of this step is demonstrated with a modeling design and initial
test results.
- Link 1:
The link is the T shape main base frame link on which the whole weight of the machine will
act. It is basically consist of two members joint to form T shape link.
This is the transverse member of link 1 providing the horizontal support to the whole
system. Length of this member is 33.5in with cross-section height = 2in and width = 3in
- Link 2:
The vertical link providing rotating support to the link 3 and 4 by two revolute joints.
Figure CAD-23
- Link 3:
Provides the connection between link 2 and 6 connected by two revolute joints.
Figure CAD-25
ADVANCE EXERCISE MACHINE MECHANISAM Engineering Design & CAD
This horizontal link connected between the link 2 and 6 to provide the degree of motion.
Length link is 38in having two holes of 1in diameter at 36in center to center distance. The
cross-section height and width of this link is 1.50x1.50in.
Figure CAD-26
- Link 4:
The main link it help to push the weight of whole system by pulling down link 9.
Figure CAD-28
- Link 5:
The link for carring the weigth of the person and push it upwords and downwords according
to the position of link 9.
Figure CAD-30
This link has seat attached to it for carrying the load of the person laying on it. The length of
the link is 39in having cross-section height = 1.50in and with =3in.
Figure CAD-31
- Link 6:
The main frame of the system providing the connection between the other links.
Figure CAD-33
ADVANCE EXERCISE MACHINE MECHANISAM Engineering Design & CAD
Figure CAD-34
- Link: 7
Helps to provide the degree of motion to link 4 by moving the link 9.
Figure CAD-39
- Link 8:
The connecting link providing the connection between the link 7 and link 4.
Figure CAD-41
The length of the link is 8in having one hole at left side of 1in diameter and two holes on
right side of 0.75in diameter. The cross-section height of this link is 1.50in and width is 1in.
- Link 9:
The C channel shaped input link of the system in which two pairs of rollers mover to provide
the degree of motion.
.
Figure CAD-43
This link is povited at the little reight to center to the link 6 to create the moment in the
both directions.
Figure CAD-44
There is a plastic handle is attached to the left end of the link to provide the ease to the
user, so that it can easily graped for providing the input. When this link moves up the roller
set moves to right and when this link moves down then roller set moves to left.
8. Working
This machine use the person's own weight as a source of resistance. Person lay down on the
seat with hands in the up direction graping the plastic attached to the input link, by pulling
the input link in downword direction. Then input lever will apply the force on link 7 in
upword direction, this llink will pull up the link 4 and 8. When the upword force acts on the
link 4 it will also apply the force on the link 6 in the up direction, then this force will transfer
to the link 6 and will push the person up against his own weight acht downwords.
B
A
E
C
This eliminates the need of extra weight resistance and reduced the cost of system. As
demonstrated in the figure below,
ADVANCE EXERCISE MACHINE MECHANISAM Engineering Design & CAD
F
G
H
J
HOME FITNESS MULTI GYM V-Fit Herculean LFG2 Multi home gym system
WEIGHT BENCH PRESS Lay Flat Home Gym With Price Tag of 800$
INCLINE ARM CURL TRICEPS With Price Tag of 700$
CHEST LEG
With Price tag of 600$
ADVANCE EXERCISE MACHINE MECHANISAM Engineering Design & CAD
Engineering Requirements
(Competitor)
Ruggedness
Benchmark
Operation
Weight
Ease of
Shape
Cost
Size
Portable X X Weak
Requirements
Customer
Reliable x Moderate
Appealing x Weak
Inexpensive X x Strong
300-400$
Engineering Targets
10. Conclusion
This project has demonstrated the engineering design process as applied to the design of
e er ise a hi e that uses the perso ’s eight as a source of resistance. This mechanism is
designed to allow the user to adjust the mechanical advantage without resistance during
the adjustment. Also, the motion of the input link is relative to the user. This allows for
correct motion for the exercise. The design also implements techniques that simplify
manufacturing processes and assembly. For example, parallelogram linkage and linear
bearings which are relatively simple to fabricate and inexpensive are used.